Você está na página 1de 27

1 Matthew A.

Silverman (018919)
Jessica R. Kenney (026615)
2
McCarthy Holthus Levine
3 3636 North Central Avenue
Suite 1050
4 Phoenix, AZ 85012
5 (602) 230-8726

6 Attorneys for Movant,


Deutsche Bank National Trust Company, as Trustee in trust for the benefit of the
7 Certificateholders for Argent Securities Trust 2006-M2, Asset-Backed Pass-Through
Certificates, Series 2006-M2, its assignees and/or successors
8
9 UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT
10
FOR THE DISTRICT OF ARIZONA
11
PHOENIX DIVISION
12
13
In re:
) In Proceedings Under
14 )
Shelli Ayesha Veal, ) Chapter 13
15
Howard Richard Veal Jr, ) Case No. 2:09-bk-14808-RJH
16 )
Debtors. ) MOTION FOR RELIEF FROM
17
________________________________ ) AUTOMATIC STAY; SUPPORTING
18 Deutsche Bank National Trust Company, as MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND
Trustee in trust for the benefit of the
) AUTHORITIES
19
Certificateholders for Argent Securities Trust )
20 2006-M2, Asset-Backed Pass-Through )
Certificates, Series 2006-M2, its assignees )
21 and/or successors, )
22 Movant, )
)
23 v. )
24
Shelli Ayesha Veal, Howard Richard Veal Jr, )
25 Debtors; and Edward J. Maney , Chapter 13 )
Trustee, )
26
)
27 Respondents. )
28
)

29

File No. AZ-10-24882 1 Case No. 2:09-bk-14808-RJH


Motion For Relief From Automatic Stay
Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW Doc 118 Filed 03/31/10 Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12 Desc
Main Document Page 1 of 9
1 Deutsche Bank National Trust Company, as Trustee in trust for the benefit of the
2 Certificateholders for Argent Securities Trust 2006-M2, Asset-Backed Pass-Through
3 Certificates, Series 2006-M2 (Movant), by and through its undersigned attorney, moves for
4 termination of all stays and injunctions, pursuant to 11 U.S.C. 362(d), 11 U.S.C. 105,
5 Bankruptcy Rules 4001 and 9014 and Local Rule 4001, regarding the real property generally
6 described as 2910 East Windsong Drive, Phoenix, AZ 85048.
7 The relief requested in this Motion is proper for all of the reasons set forth in the
8 Memorandum of Points and Authorities attached hereto and incorporated herein by this
9 reference.
10 DATED: March 31, 2010
11
12 McCarthy Holthus Levine
13
By: /s/ Jessica R. Kenney
14
Jessica R. Kenney, Esq.
15 3636 North Central Avenue
Suite 1050
16 Phoenix, AZ 85012
17 Attorneys for Movant

18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29

File No. AZ-10-24882 2 Case No. 2:09-bk-14808-RJH


Motion For Relief From Automatic Stay
Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW Doc 118 Filed 03/31/10 Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12 Desc
Main Document Page 2 of 9
1 MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES
2
3 1. On or about 06/29/2009, Debtors filed a Voluntary Petition under Chapter 13 of the
4 Bankruptcy Code. Pursuant to 11 U.S.C. 362, the Petition stays the commencement or
5 continuation of any proceedings against the Debtors or any act to obtain possession of any
6 property of the Debtors or to enforce any lien against any property of the Debtors.
7 2. This Court has jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 1334. The filing of this Motion
8 commences a contested matter within the meaning of Bankruptcy Rule 9014. Pursuant to Local
9 Bankruptcy Code 4001(b), Movant sent notice to the Debtor's counsel.
10 3. On or about 06/14/2006, Argent Mortgage Company, LLC entered into a contract
11 with Shelli Veal and Howard Veal Jr wherein Debtors agreed to pay the amount of $2,678.82, or
12 more, on or before the first day of every month, beginning on or about 08/01/2006. The
13 obligation is evidenced by a Note and secured by a Deed of Trust. See Exhibit 1.
14 4. The Deed of Trust was timely and duly recorded and perfected in accordance with
15 Arizona law as Recorders No. 20060830548 in the office of the Maricopa County Recorder.
16 5. Deutsche Bank National Trust Company, as Trustee in trust for the benefit of the
17 Certificateholders for Argent Securities Trust 2006-M2, Asset-Backed Pass-Through
18 Certificates, Series 2006-M2 is now the holder of the Note that is Secured by the Deed of Trust
19 and is the real party in interest.
20 6. The original principal amount of the Note was $409,500.00, plus interest, costs and
21 attorneys' fees for collection. Currently, but for the defaults in acceleration, the monthly
22 payment pursuant to the Note would be $3,054.17.
23 7. The Debtors have failed to make monthly payments, beginning with the month of
24 11/01/2008, and all subsequent payments, costs, attorneys' fees, interest and accruing late
25 charges. Debtors have been in default for 17 months.
26
27 ///
28 ///
29

File No. AZ-10-24882 3 Case No. 2:09-bk-14808-RJH


Motion For Relief From Automatic Stay
Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW Doc 118 Filed 03/31/10 Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12 Desc
Main Document Page 3 of 9
1 8. As of 03/30/2010, the amount required to fully reinstate the Debtor's loan post-
2 petition is approximately $58,931.94 , itemized as follows:
3
4 Unpaid Principal Balance: $ 446,272.72
PRE-PETITION DELINQUENCIES:
5
Monthly Payments: 2 at $3,054.17 $ 6,108.34
6 (11/08 through 12/08)
Monthly Payments: 6 at $3,050.64 $ 18,303.84
7
(01/09 through 06/09)
8 Late Charges: $ 839.52
9 Property Inspections: $ 31.60
Appraisal Fee: $ 100.00
10 Miscellaneous: $ 30.00
11 Foreclosure Attorneys Fees & Costs: $ 2,648.85
Suspense: $ (118.50)
12
Total Pre-Petition Delinquencies: $ 27,943.65
13
POST-PETITION DELINQUENCIES:
14
Monthly Payments: 9 at $3,054.17 $ 27,487.53
15 ( 07/09 through 03/10 )
16 Escrow Advances: $ 2,700.76
Bankruptcy Attorney Fee: $ 650.00
17 Bankruptcy Filing Fee: $ 150.00
18 Total Post-Petition Delinquencies: $ 30,988.29

19 Total Delinquencies: $ 58,931.94


20
Total Amount Due to Secured Creditor: $ 505,204.66
21
22 9. Pursuant to the Note, Movant has declared the entire unpaid balance of principal and
23 accrued interest, plus all other amounts owed, to be immediately due and payable. As of
24 03/30/2010, the principal amount owing on the Note secured by the Trust Deed is $505,204.66.
25 10. Movant has performed all of its obligations required under the Note and Deed of
26 Trust, and all conditions precedent to the Debtors' performance there under have occurred.
27 MOVANT IS NOT RECEIVING ADEQUATE PROTECTION
28 11. Pursuant to 11 U.S.C. 362 subd. (d)(1), Movant is entitled to relief from the
29 automatic stay to enforce its lien for cause, including lack of adequate protection of any interest

File No. AZ-10-24882 4 Case No. 2:09-bk-14808-RJH


Motion For Relief From Automatic Stay
Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW Doc 118 Filed 03/31/10 Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12 Desc
Main Document Page 4 of 9
1 in the property. Movant is entitled to adequate protection for the present value of the collateral
2 in the form of monthly payments.
3 12. The Moving Party further seeks relief in order to, at its option, offer, provide and
4 enter into any potential forbearance agreement, loan modification, refinance agreement or other
5 loan workout/loss mitigation agreement. The Movant may contact the Debtor via telephone or
6 written correspondence to offer such an agreement. Any such agreement shall be non-recourse
7 unless included in a reaffirmation agreement.
8 13. Failure to make post-petition mortgage payments can constitute cause for lifting the
9 stay. The debtor has the burden of showing there is no cause to terminate the stay. In re Ellis,
10 60 B.R. 432 (9th Cir. BAP 1985). Where cause is shown, courts have no discretion, but must
11 grant relief. In re Ford, 36 B.R. 501 (Dt 1983). Movant has not been provided adequate
12 protection, inasmuch as monthly payments have been in default since 11/01/2008, as more fully
13 set forth in paragraph 8.
14 14. Movant is not adequately protected. Movant is not receiving regular monthly
15 payments, and is unfairly delayed from proceeding with the foreclosure of the subject Property.
16 Accordingly, relief from the automatic stay should be granted to Movant pursuant to 11 U.S.C.
17 362(d)(1).
18 15. Due to Debtor's default, Movant commenced foreclosure proceedings by recording
19 a Notice of Trustees Sale on 05/12/2009, and the foreclosure sale was scheduled for
20 08/12/2009. Due to the filing of the instant bankruptcy petition, Movant is stayed from
21 proceeding with the foreclosure.
22 16. Movant sent notice as required by Local Rule 4001-1(b).
23 CONCLUSION
24 1. Movants claim is in default and unpaid by the Debtors.
25 2. Movant's only form of redress is to look to the secured property.
26 3. Costs, attorneys' fees and interest continue to mount on Movant's claim,
27 thus completely eroding any and all equity that may be claimed by
28 Respondent.
29 4. This property is not required for any reorganization.

File No. AZ-10-24882 5 Case No. 2:09-bk-14808-RJH


Motion For Relief From Automatic Stay
Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW Doc 118 Filed 03/31/10 Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12 Desc
Main Document Page 5 of 9
1 5. Movant is not adequately protected.
2 6. Movant is a secured creditor who is at dangerous peril of becoming
3 undersecured as a result of the stays which enjoin Movant from
4 foreclosing its lien. Therefore, pursuant to 11 U.S.C. 362(d)(2), this
5 Motion should be granted to avoid further erosion of Movant's secured
6 lien position.
7 REQUEST FOR RELIEF
8 WHEREFORE, Movant requests that the Court enter its Order granting the
9 following relief:
10 A. Terminating all stays and injunctions including, but not limited to, the
11 automatic stays under Bankruptcy Code 362(a)(2) and 105 with respect to the property which
12 is described herein as to the Movant only;
13 B. For Movant's reasonable attorneys' fees and costs and interest herein
14 incurred and expended; and
15 C. For such other and further relief as the Court deems just and equitable.
16 DATED: March 31, 2010
17 McCarthy Holthus Levine
18
19 By:_/s/ Jessica R. Kenney ___
Jessica R. Kenney, Esq.
20 3636 North Central Avenue
21 Suite 1050
Phoenix, AZ 85012
22 Attorneys for Movant
23
24
25
26
27
28
29

File No. AZ-10-24882 6 Case No. 2:09-bk-14808-RJH


Motion For Relief From Automatic Stay
Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW Doc 118 Filed 03/31/10 Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12 Desc
Main Document Page 6 of 9
1 On 3/31/2010, I served the foregoing documents described as MOTION FOR RELIEF
2 FROM AUTOMATIC STAY; SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND
3 AUTHORITIES on the following individuals by electronic means through the Courts ECF
4 program:
5
COUNSEL FOR DEBTORS
6 John Joseph Volin
7 joe@volinlaw.com

8 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America that the foregoing
is true and correct.
9
10 /s/ Darco Turcu
11 Darco Turcu

12
On 3/31/2010, I served the foregoing documents described as MOTION FOR RELIEF
13
FROM AUTOMATIC STAY; SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND
14
AUTHORITIES, on the following individuals by depositing true copies thereof in the United
15
States mail at San Diego, California, enclosed in a sealed envelope, with postage paid,
16
addressed as follows:
17
COUNSEL FOR DEBTORS
18 John Joseph Volin
19 John Joseph Volin, P.C.
2033 E. Warner Road, #106
20 Tempe, AZ 85284
21
DEBTORS
22 Shelli Ayesha Veal
653 W. Raven Drive
23 Chandler, AZ 85286
24
Howard Richard Veal Jr
25 653 W. Raven Drive
Chandler, AZ 85286
26
27 ///

28 ///
29

File No. AZ-10-24882 7 Case No. 2:09-bk-14808-RJH


Motion For Relief From Automatic Stay
Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW Doc 118 Filed 03/31/10 Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12 Desc
Main Document Page 7 of 9
1 TRUSTEE
Edward J. Maney
2
P.O. Box 10434
3 Phoenix, AZ 85064
4 COUNSEL FOR TRUSTEE
5 Ronald L. Hoffbauer
Edward J. Maney, Chapter 13 Trustee
6 P.O. Box 10434
Phoenix, AZ 85064
7
8 UNITED STATES TRUSTEE
Office of the U.S. Trustee
9 230 North First Avenue, Suite 204
10 Phoenix, AZ 85003-1706

11 SPECIAL NOTICE
Maria Angela Tsagaris
12 Litton Loan Servicing
13 1544 Old Alabama Road
Roswell, GA 30076-2102
14
Wells Fargo Bank, N.A.
15
as Trustee for Option One Mortgage Loan Trust 2006-3
16 Asset-Backed Certificates, Series 2006-3
Malcolm & Cisneros, A Law Corporation
17 2112 Business Center Drive
18 Second Floor
Irvine, CA 92612
19
American Home Mortgage Servicing, Inc.
20 Attn: Managing Agent
21 4875 Belford Road, Suite 130
Jacksonville, FL 32256
22
Wells Fargo Bank, N.A.
23
Tiffany & Bosco, P.A.
24 2525 East Camelback Road Suite 300
Phoenix, AZ 85016
25
26 US Bank National Association
Tiffany & Bosco PA
27 2525 East Camelback Road, Suite 300
Phoenix, AZ 85016
28
29 ///

File No. AZ-10-24882 8 Case No. 2:09-bk-14808-RJH


Motion For Relief From Automatic Stay
Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW Doc 118 Filed 03/31/10 Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12 Desc
Main Document Page 8 of 9
1 MERS as nominee for the Bank of New York Mellon f/k/a The Bank of New York
Tiffany & Bosco P.A.
2
2525 East Camelback Road
3 Third Floor
Phoenix, AZ 85016
4
I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America that the foregoing
5 is true and correct.
6
/s/ David Fry
7 David Fry
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29

File No. AZ-10-24882 9 Case No. 2:09-bk-14808-RJH


Motion For Relief From Automatic Stay
Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW Doc 118 Filed 03/31/10 Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12 Desc
Main Document Page 9 of 9
Public Record EXHIBIT 1
Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW
Order: Non-Order Search Doc: MP:2006 00830548
Doc 118-1PageFiled
1 of 19
03/31/10 Created
Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12
By: lindaling Printed: 5/11/2009 9:10:05 AM PST
Desc Exhibit Page 1 of 18
Public Record

Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW
Order: Non-Order Search Doc: MP:2006 00830548
Doc 118-1PageFiled
2 of 19
03/31/10 Created
Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12
By: lindaling Printed: 5/11/2009 9:10:05 AM PST
Desc Exhibit Page 2 of 18
Public Record

Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW
Order: Non-Order Search Doc: MP:2006 00830548
Doc 118-1PageFiled
3 of 19
03/31/10 Created
Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12
By: lindaling Printed: 5/11/2009 9:10:05 AM PST
Desc Exhibit Page 3 of 18
Public Record

Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW
Order: Non-Order Search Doc: MP:2006 00830548
Doc 118-1PageFiled
4 of 19
03/31/10 Created
Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12
By: lindaling Printed: 5/11/2009 9:10:05 AM PST
Desc Exhibit Page 4 of 18
Public Record

Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW
Order: Non-Order Search Doc: MP:2006 00830548
Doc 118-1PageFiled
5 of 19
03/31/10 Created
Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12
By: lindaling Printed: 5/11/2009 9:10:05 AM PST
Desc Exhibit Page 5 of 18
Public Record

Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW
Order: Non-Order Search Doc: MP:2006 00830548
Doc 118-1PageFiled
6 of 19
03/31/10 Created
Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12
By: lindaling Printed: 5/11/2009 9:10:05 AM PST
Desc Exhibit Page 6 of 18
Public Record

Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW
Order: Non-Order Search Doc: MP:2006 00830548
Doc 118-1PageFiled
7 of 19
03/31/10 Created
Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12
By: lindaling Printed: 5/11/2009 9:10:05 AM PST
Desc Exhibit Page 7 of 18
Public Record

Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW
Order: Non-Order Search Doc: MP:2006 00830548
Doc 118-1PageFiled
8 of 19
03/31/10 Created
Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12
By: lindaling Printed: 5/11/2009 9:10:06 AM PST
Desc Exhibit Page 8 of 18
Public Record

Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW
Order: Non-Order Search Doc: MP:2006 00830548
Doc 118-1PageFiled
9 of 19
03/31/10 Created
Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12
By: lindaling Printed: 5/11/2009 9:10:06 AM PST
Desc Exhibit Page 9 of 18
Public Record

Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW
Order: Non-Order Search Doc: MP:2006 00830548
Doc 118-1PageFiled 03/31/10 Created
10 of 19
Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12
By: lindaling Printed: 5/11/2009 9:10:06 AM PST
Desc Exhibit Page 10 of 18
Public Record

Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW
Order: Non-Order Search Doc: MP:2006 00830548
Doc 118-1PageFiled 03/31/10 Created
11 of 19
Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12
By: lindaling Printed: 5/11/2009 9:10:06 AM PST
Desc Exhibit Page 11 of 18
Public Record

Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW
Order: Non-Order Search Doc: MP:2006 00830548
Doc 118-1PageFiled 03/31/10 Created
12 of 19
Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12
By: lindaling Printed: 5/11/2009 9:10:06 AM PST
Desc Exhibit Page 12 of 18
Public Record

Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW
Order: Non-Order Search Doc: MP:2006 00830548
Doc 118-1PageFiled 03/31/10 Created
13 of 19
Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12
By: lindaling Printed: 5/11/2009 9:10:06 AM PST
Desc Exhibit Page 13 of 18
Public Record

Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW
Order: Non-Order Search Doc: MP:2006 00830548
Doc 118-1PageFiled 03/31/10 Created
14 of 19
Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12
By: lindaling Printed: 5/11/2009 9:10:06 AM PST
Desc Exhibit Page 14 of 18
Public Record

Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW
Order: Non-Order Search Doc: MP:2006 00830548
Doc 118-1PageFiled 03/31/10 Created
15 of 19
Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12
By: lindaling Printed: 5/11/2009 9:10:06 AM PST
Desc Exhibit Page 15 of 18
Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW Doc 118-1 Filed 03/31/10 Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12
Desc Exhibit Page 16 of 18
Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW Doc 118-1 Filed 03/31/10 Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12
Desc Exhibit Page 17 of 18
Case 2:09-bk-14808-MCW Doc 118-1 Filed 03/31/10 Entered 03/31/10 07:17:12
Desc Exhibit Page 18 of 18