Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
org
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of the study was to evaluate pregnancy women (82%) underwent repeat testing, and 47 women (0.2% initially
outcomes of hypothyroidism that were identified in a population-based screened) were confirmed to have hypothyroidism. Perinatal outcomes
prenatal screening program. of women with treated overt hypothyroidism were similar to women with
euthyroidism. Higher rates of pregnancy-related hypertension were
STUDY DESIGN: This is a secondary analysis of a prospective prenatal
identified in the 182 women with unconfirmed hypothyroidism when
population-based study in which serum thyroid analytes were obtained
compared with women with euthyroidism (P < .001); however, this
from November 2000 to April 2003. Initial screening thresholds were
association was seen only in women with initial TSH >4.5 mU/L
intentionally inclusive (thyroid-stimulating hormone [TSH], >3.0 mU/
(adjusted odds ratio, 2.53; 95% confidence interval, 1.4e4.5).
L; free thyroxine, <0.9 ng/dL); those who screened positive were
referred for confirmatory testing in a hospital-based laboratory. Hy- CONCLUSION: The identification and treatment of overt hypothyroid-
pothyroidism was identified and treated if TSH level was >4.5 mU/L ism results in pregnancy outcomes similar to women with euthyroid-
and if fT4 level was <0.76 ng/dL. Perinatal outcomes in these women ism. Unconfirmed screening results suggestive of hypothyroidism
and those who screened positive but unconfirmed to have hypothy- portend pregnancy risks similar to women with subclinical hypothy-
roidism were compared with women with euthyroidism. Outcomes roidism, specifically preeclampsia; however, this increased risk was
were then analyzed according to initial TSH levels. seen only in women with initial TSH levels of >4.5 mU/L and suggests
that this is a more clinically relevant threshold than 3.0 mU/L.
RESULTS: A total of 26,518 women completed initial screening: 24,584
women (93%) were euthyroid, and 284 women (1%) had abnormal Key words: overt hypothyroidism, screening, subclinical
initial values that suggested hypothyroidism. Of those referred, 232 hypothyroidism
Cite this article as: Bryant SN, Nelson DB, McIntire DD, et al. An analysis of population-based prenatal screening for overt hypothyroidism. Am J Obstet Gynecol
2015;213:565.e1-6.
of thyroid analytes at Parkland Hospital initial analyte testing in the research rate, incidence of diabetes mellitus,
from November 2000 to April 2003. De- laboratory were the same that were used gestational hypertension, and severe
tails of patient identication and study during the original study by Casey et al6: preeclampsia. Gestational hypertension
design have been described previously.6,10 TSH >3.0 mU/L and fT4 <0.9 ng/dL. In was dened as persistent blood pressures
Briey, all women seeking prenatal care at concert, the hospital-based conrmatory of 140/90 mm Hg that occurred at 20
our institution underwent routine labo- threshold values were also consistent weeks of gestation, without evidence of
ratory blood testing at their rst visit. with those from the 2005 report, TSH proteinuria. Mild preeclampsia was
With the approval of the Institutional >4.5 mU/L and fT4 < 0.76 ng/dL for the diagnosed in hypertensive women who
Review Board of the University of Texas diagnosis and treatment of overt hypo- had 1 proteinuria determined by urine
Southwestern Medical Center and Park- thyroidism. Women who were identied dipstick analysis from a catheterized
land Hospital, excess serum from the to have overt thyrotoxicosis were sample as per protocol of our institution.
rubella screening sample was stored for excluded from this analysis. Severe preeclampsia was diagnosed in
thyroid analyte testing per research pro- Our service maintains a computerized hypertensive women with any of the
tocol. Chemiluminescent immunoassays database of selected obstetric and following: 2 proteinuria on a dipstick
were used to measure TSH and fT4 con- neonatal outcomes for all women who from a catheterized specimen, blood
centrations (Immulite 2000 Analyzer; deliver at Parkland in which nurses who pressure higher than 160/110 mm Hg,
Diagnostic Products Corporation, Los attend each delivery complete an ob- persistent headache, visual disturbances,
Angeles, CA) in a research laboratory. stetric data sheet. Before electronic right upper quadrant or epigastric pain,
TSH values outside of the referent ranges storage, research nurses assess the data serum creatinine 1.2 mg/mL, serum
(TSH >3.0 or <0.2 mU/L) prompted a for consistency and completeness. Infant aspartate transaminase levels more than
reex assay for fT4 levels. FT4 values outcome data were abstracted from twice the upper limit of normal, or
outside the referent range (fT4 <0.9 or discharge records and entered into a thrombocytopenia <100,000/mL.
>2.0 ng/dL) were considered abnormal. separate infant database. Results from Pearsons c2 Student t tests were used
These referent ranges were developed thyroid-related analyte serum levels de- for univariate 2-group comparisons.
during our previous studies; the analyt- termined in the aforementioned manner Logistic regression was applied to
ical sensitivity and coefcients of varia- were stored electronically and linked to examine the signicance of gestational
tion were published previously.6 the aforementioned perinatal and infant hypertension, severe preeclampsia, and
Women with abnormal thyroid ana- databases. This analysis was approved by eclampsia that were adjusted for any
lyte test results relative to these referent the Institutional Review Board of the differences accountable to age, race,
values were considered suggestive of University of Texas Southwestern Medi- parity, and body mass index. Statistical
either overt hypo- or hyperthyroidism cal Center at Dallas. computations were performed with SAS
and were referred for further evaluation Maternal and perinatal outcomes software (version 9.3; SAS Institute,
in the Obstetric Complications Clinic. were compared among 3 cohorts: (1) Cary, NC). A 2-tailed probability value of
On arrival, repeated conrmatory thy- women identied to be euthyroid on < .05 was deemed statistically signicant.
roid analyte testing was performed by initial screening, (2) women conrmed
the hospital-based laboratory. Women to have overt hypothyroidism and given R ESULTS
who were identied during this subse- treatment during pregnancy, and (3) During the study period from November
quent testing to have a conrmatory women who screened positive by the 2000 to April 2003, a total of 26,197
TSH levels >4.5 mU/L and fT4 <0.76 research laboratory but who were not women underwent thyroid analyte screen-
ng/dL were identied to have overt hy- conrmed to have overt hypothyroidism ing by the research laboratory. As shown
pothyroidism and were treated with after referral and repeat testing by the in Figure 1, a total of 24,584 women
thyroxine replacement according to the hospital laboratory. Logistic regression (93.8%) were identied to have euthy-
guidelines of the American College of was used to adjust for any differences roidism; 284 women (1%) were identi-
Obstetricians and Gynecologists.11 that were accountable to age, race, parity, ed to have abnormal values that
For the current study, we included and body mass index. After this last suggested hypothyroidism. Of these 284
women who were screened during their analysis, we sought to determine wheth- women who were referred for evalua-
initial prenatal visit as described earlier, er lowered screening TSH values were tion, 232 women (82%) continued pre-
at any gestational age, and who delivered clinically relevant. To do so, for this third natal care at our institution and attended
a singleton infant at Parkland Hospital cohort of women who screened positive repeat testing. As also shown in Figure 1,
who weighed at least 500 g. Gestational but were not conrmed to have overt 47 of these 232 women were conrmed
age at screening was established with the hypothyroidism, we analyzed pregnancy by the hospital laboratory to have overt
use of the obstetric estimate of gesta- outcomes after stratifying their initial hypothyroidism with both an abnormal
tional age recorded at delivery; the me- screening TSH values to either a TSH TSH level (>4.5 mU/L) and free T4 level
dian gestational age for all initial level of 3-4.5 mU/L or a level >4.5mU/L. (<0.76 ng/dL). Put another way, 2
screening was in the rst one-half of Outcomes of interest included gesta- per 1000 women who initially were
pregnancy. The screening thresholds for tional age at delivery, cesarean delivery screened were identied to have overt
TABLE 2
Obstetric complications
Treated overt Unconfirmed
hypothyroidism P value vs Euthyroidism P value vs hypothyroidism
Pregnancy outcome (n [ 47) euthyroidism (n [ 24,584) euthyroidism (n [ 183)
Gestational age at delivery, wka 39.6 1.5 .15 39.4 2.0 .33 39.2 2.5
30, n (%) 0 .50 232 (0.9) .33 3 (2)
32, n (%) 0 .39 376 (1.5) .47 4 (2)
36, n (%) 2 (4) .53 1608 (7) .07 18 (10)
40, n (%) 10 (21) .70 4678 (19) .97 35 (19)
Cesarean delivery, n (%) 11 (23) .97 5696 (23) .53 46 (25)
Gestational hypertension, n (%) 6 (13) .34 2161 (9) .005 27 (15)
Severe preeclampsia, n (%) 4 (9) .31 1285 (5) < .001 20 (11)
Eclampsia, n (%) 0 .79 36 (0.15) .001 2 (1.1)
Abruption, n (%) 0 .71 73 (0.3) .46 0
Diabetes mellitus, n (%)
Gestational 3 (6.4) .46 1034 (4.2) .63 9 (4.9)
Overt 1 (2.1) .17 144 (0.6) .95 1 (0.5)
a
Data are given as mean SD.
Bryant. Prenatal screening for hypothyroidism. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2015.