)Human Rights Alert (NGO

Joseph Zernik, PhD "

PO Box 33407, Tel-Aviv, Israel " ,33407"
Fax: 077-3179186 Email: joseph.zernik@hra-ngo.org

][Bilingual record English below

Filed by fax on April 21, 2017 to: 02-6759648
_________________________________________________________________________
)(,";2003 )2)4((

.1:
( :'
('053625596 :
,33407 (:
(' :

.2:
(':
,1322/17
(:

(/:
)(1

.3:
((2003)
',(5917/97)
.
(
".
,
. ,"
"(2015,2010),(2013)
.
( 202017,:
" "
!
,
, , .
, """ , " ...
... , ' .
? " "
. , .
? ' , !

1/4

!
http://inproperinla.blogspot.co.il/2017/04/2017-04-20.html :
,
.,
"".
( ,
,.,

.
( .

. )"(

.,
.
,,,
,
. .
, "",
,.

.4)/(:
.,
)
,(.
",
,:
".
,
,,
.

: 21:;2017,
'

))RegulationsoftheCourtsInspectionofCourtFiles(2003);Form2(Regulation4(c

RequesttoInspectCourtFile

1.Requester'sDetails
a)Fullname: JosephZernik,PhD
b)IDNo: 053625596
c)Address: POBox33407,TelAviv
d)Telephone: None

2/4
2.CourtFileDetails
a)CourtFileNumber:
SupremeCourt,1322/17
b)Parties:
AnonymousvStateofIsrael
c)Records,whicharesubjectoftherequest:
(1)DulymadePublicationProhibitionDecree(gagorder)

3.PurposeandJustificationfortheInspection
a)InstantRequestisfiledpursuanttotheRegulationsoftheCourts,Inspectionof
CourtFiles(2003)andSupremeCourtdecisioninAssociationforCivilRightsin
IsraelvMinisterofJusticeetal(5917/97).
b)TheRequesterhasbeenengagedforyearsinacademicresearchregardingIT
systemsoftheIsraeliandUScourts,andadministrationofpublicaccesstocourt
records.Hisresearchonsuchsubjectshasbeenpublishedandpresentedin
internationalacademicconferencesintherelevantfields,subjecttointernational
expertreview.HisreportsonsuchsubjectshavebeenincorporatedintoUN
HumanRightsCouncilReportspertainingtotheUnitedStates(2010,2015)and
Israel(2013),followingtheCouncil'sProfessionalStaffreview.
c)TheRequestersApril20,2017publication,pertainingtoinstantcourtfile,
generatedwidespreadinterest:
Supreme Court Justice Uri Shoham fakes an Arrest Warrant on whistle-blower Shuki
Mishol!
The Regulations of Criminal Court Procedure and the Prisons Act prescribe a lawfully made
Arrest Warrant, identifying the prisoner and signed by a judge, for admission of a person to
prison. In contrast, Supreme Court Justice Uri Shoham issued an unsigned record, pertaining
to "Anonymous", "subject to editing and phrasing changes"... Roman Zadorov is also
confined with no Arrest Decree... First it was Roman Zadorov, on Sunday it will be Shuki
Mishol. Who is next? The Supreme Court declared a "Constitutional Revolution", founded on
the Base Law - Human Dignity and Liberty. At the same time the justices conduct the Court in
a manner befitting a dark regime. So what are we going to do? We accompany Shuki Mishol
on Sunday to Nitzan Prison, to ascertain the manner in which he is admitted to prison! One
may only hope that Prison Service Governor Ofra Klinger will conduct the matter in
compliance with the law, and not as a gulag commander.
Read the complete post: http://inproperinla.blogspot.co.il/2017/04/2017-04-21-
supreme-court-justice-uri.html
Likewise,publicationsbyothers,bothintheprintandbroadcast,pertainingto
instantcourtfile,havegeneratedsubstantialpublicinterest.However,in
retrospect,theRequesterdiscoveredthatinstantcourtfileismarkedinthe
SupremeCourtselectronicpublicaccesssystemsealed.
d)Atthesametime,itisobviousthattherecordsandregistrationsintheSupreme
CourtsITsystemarenotauthoritativebythemselves,sincetheSupremeCourtis
administeredinpapercourtfiles.Moreover,bothintheSupremeCourtandin
othercourtsIhaveencounterednumerousothercases,wherepublicaccesswas
deniedinITsystemswithnolawfulpublicationprohibitiondecree.
e)Instantcourtfilepertainstoakeywhistlebloweragainstgovernmentcorruption
andasocialprotestactivist.TheAppellant'smainprotestisagainstcorruptionof
3/4
 theTaxAuthorityandconductofthejusticeandlawenforcementsystem
pertainingtosuchcorruption.InamediainterviewSupremeCourtJusticeM.
Mazuz(thenformerAttorneyGeneral)describedthisaffairasclosesttoorganized
crimeinhighoffices.Healsoexpressedhisdisappointmentfromthemannerin
whichthescandalwasaddressedbythecourts.
Especiallyonsuchbackground,thecircumstancesnowcreated,wherecourt
processisconductedpurportedlyUnderSealandunderpurportedPublication
ProhibitionDecree,raisesevereconcernsofseriousviolationsoftheDefendants
rights,firstandforemosttherightforFairandPublicHearing.Such
circumstancesalsounderminepublictrustinthejusticesystem.
Furthermore,thefailuretopublishthepurportedgagordergeneratesvagueand
ambiguousconditions,whichlendthemselvestoarbitraryandcapricious
enforcement,raisingconcernsregardingFreedomofExpressionandFreedomof
thePressinIsrael.

4.RelationshipoftheRequestertotheCourtFile(directorindirect)
TheRequesterhasnodirectrelationshiptoinstantcourtfile.
TheRequesterknowsAppellantShukiMisholasaprotestactivist,particularlyin
relationshiptotheRuthDavidRonelFisherEranMalkascandal(sellingof
undercoverhighlevelpoliceinvestigationmaterialstoinvestigationsubjects,
includingorganizedcrimefigures).
TheRequesterhaspublishedmediareportsabroadregardingconductoftheIsraeli
courtsintheRafiRotemaffairanotherTaxAuthoritywhistleblower.Relativeto
Rotem,Israelimediawrote:Foradecade,thecourtshavebeenpersecutingajustice
crusader.
TheRequesterhasacademicinterestininstantcourtfile,relativetotheunusual
circumstances,pertainingtoHumanRights,FreedomofExpressionandFreedomof
thePress,andrelativetothemannerinwhichITsystemoftheSupremeCourtis
operated.

Date:April21,2017;Requesterssignature: _______________
JosephZernik,PhD

4/4