Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
INTRODUCTION
In recent years due to liberal economic policy of the Government many private banks
are coming into operation. The foreign joint venture banks are enjoying competitive
advantageous factors like highly skilled personnel, modern and advanced banking
technology, customer oriented modern banking services, management expertise and
global banking network.
Bank in general means an institution that deals with money. Concept of banking had
developed from the ancient history; with the effort of ancient Goldsmith who
practiced storing peoples gold and valuables. Bank was originated from French
word Banque. In the developing countries like Nepal, Banks play vital role for
domestic resource mobilization and economic development of a country. The first
commercial bank was Bank of England (1694), central bank of Britain. The first
commercial bank in Nepal is Nepal Bank Limited, which was, established in 1937
A.D. Commercial banks are the suppliers of finance for trade and industry and play a
vital role in the economic and financial life of the country. By investing the saving in
the productive areas they help in the capital formation.
According to Gillian and Soal,A sound banking system is important because of the
key roles it plays in the economy: intermediation, maturity, transformation,
facilitating payment flows, credit allocation, and maintaining financial discipline
among borrowers. Banks provide important positive externalities as gathering of
1
saving, allocation of resources and providers of liquidity and payment service.
Commercial Banks play the vital role in economic development of any nation. Capital
is the most important factor and foundation for not only the economic development
but also for the overall growth and prosperity of the nation.
Commercial banks perform different functions however some common functions listed
below.
Extension of Credit
2. Creating Money
One of the major functions of commercial banks that differentiate them from other
institutions is their ability to create money through lending and investing activities.
The power of commercial banking system to create money is of great economic
significance as it helps to create and elastic credit system that is necessary for
economic progress. It creates money through payment mechanism i.e. through
cheque, credit cards and debit cards. It also use pooling and saving tool to create
money.
The commercial bank efficiently arranges the amount of foreign exchange required
by business organizations. Moreover, the issue of letter of credit has facilitated
foreign trade transactions.
2
Nepal Bank Limited (NBL), a pioneer commercial bank is the oldest bank in the
history of modern banking system of Nepal. It was established on 30 Kartik 1994BS
(1937AD) in the technical assistance of Imperial Bank of India under "Nepal Bank
Act1993.
This marked the beginning of an era of formal banking in Nepal. Until then all
monetary transactions were carried out by private dealers and trading center. In that
era, very few understood or had confidence in the new concept of formal banking.
Raising equity shares were not easy and mobilization of deposits even more difficult.
This was evident when the bank floated equity shares worth NRs.25,00,000 but was
successfully only raise Rs.8,42,000 in 1994, has grown to Rs.38.04 crore as at 2060
Kartik. The total deposits for the first year was NRs.17,02,025 where current deposits
was about NRs.12,98,898 ; fixed was about NRs.3,88,964 and saving was
NRs.14,163. Loan disbursed and outstanding at the end of the first year was
1,985,000. From the very conception and its creation, Nepal Bank Limited was a joint
venture between the government and the private sectors. Out of 2500 equity shares of
NRs.100 face value 62.21% is owned by government and 37.79% by Public. It has
expanded its branches throughout the Kingdom including far remote areas having
very poor profitability and some of the parts having income not sufficient to meet
breakeven. The bank has given more priority to the service of common and poor class
people rather than to the profit and it has been able to achieve some objectives, which
were set at the time of its inception.
Accordingly, Nepal bank Limited was established to provide the services: to accept
deposits, to extend credit facilities for the promotion of trade, cottage industries and
agriculture, to render customer-related services, i.e. issue of bill of exchange, hundis
etc. to invest on government bond and securities, to carryout agency functions and to
act banker to the government.
OWNERSHIP STRUCTURE
The ownership structure of NBL has presented by the percentage of shares held by
respective shareholders.
3
Table 1.1
Ownership Percent
Government of Nepal 62.21
General Public
37.79
Fig:1.1
Diagrammatic Representation of Ownership Structure
NBL focuses on building the positive net worth and meeting minimum capital
requirement over the coming five years. It also focus on providing world class
business solutions and focus on increasing the sustainable profit.
4
Nabil Bank Limited was the first foreign joint venture bank of Nepal which started
its operation from 12th July, 1984 under a technical service agreement with Dubai
Bank Limited, Dubai. The bank is managed by a team of qualified and highly
experienced professionals. It represents a milestone in the banking history of Nepal as
it started an era of modern banking with customer satisfaction measured as a focal
objective while doing business. Pursuing its objective, Nabil provides a full range of
commercial banking services through its 51 points of representation across the nation
and over 170 reputed correspondent banks across the globe.
OWNERSHIP STRUCTURE
The ownership structure of Nabil Bank has presented by the percentage of shares held
by respective shareholders.
5
Figure 1.2 Diagrammatic Representation Of Ownership Structure
NB International Ltd.
30% ( Ireland)
Nepal Industrial
Development Corp.
50% (NIDC), Nepal
Other Institution Investors
4%
Other Promoters Group
10%
Public Shareholders
6%
The initial capital of Rs30million, Invested in 1984, has grown to Rs 1,314 million as
at mid-July 2003. During this period, the Bank has paid cash dividends totaling Rs
1,2768 million. Nabil Banks Capital Adequacy Ratio stood at 13.06% as at mid-July
2003 against the statutory minimum requirement of 10%. The Bank provides a
complete range of personal, commercial and corporate banking and related financial
services through its 15 branches and 2 counters- the largest number of branches
among any joint venture bank in Nepal. It also was the first to introduce consortium
finance in Nepal and has had the privilege of rendering comprehensive banking
services (including trade finance) to leading Government institutions. The Bank is a
major player in facilitating import export activities with modern and efficient Trade
Finance and International Trade support services, to large multinationals as well as
established business conglomerates in the private sector.
The increasing competition & global challenges indicate that 21st century will be full
of challenges in every field. To counter these challenges every bank should have a
clear, rigid & specific mission to achieve. Nabil bank has the mission To be the Bank
of 1st Choice.
The current situation has brought a cut throat competition in banking business.
Especially the joint venture private banks are concentrating their business in more
profitable area. In this context the NBL is in critical situation because it has to give
service to the remote people where financial benefits are low at the same time they
have weaknesses also in their management and operational activities.
In Nepal, the profitability rate, operating expenses and dividend distribution rate
among the shareholders has been found different in the financial performance of the
two joint venture banks in different period of time. The problem of the study will
ultimately find out the reasons about difference in financial performance. A
comparative analysis of financial performance of the banks would be highly
beneficial for pointing out their strength and weakness. Although joint venture banks
are considered efficient, but how far are they efficient? This question does emerge in
7
banking sector. At present we have twenty-six commercial banks. In spite of rapid
growth, some indicators show performance is not much encouraging towards the
service coverage. In such situation the study tries to analyze the present performance
of banks, which would give the answers of following queries:
iii. What are the problems and prospect associated to NBL and Nabil?
iv. What are the competitive liquidity, profitability, leverage and activities ratio
of the two banks?
The main objective of the bank is to collect deposits as much as possible from the
customer and to mobilize into the most profitable and preferable sector. The present
study is basically carried out in order to look into the comparative weaknesses and
inefficiencies of NBL and Nabil Bank with the help of the comparative analysis of
their financial statements. In Nepal many banks and financial companies have opened
up within a span of few years. Although joint venture banks have managed to perform
better than other local commercial banks within the short period of time, they have
been facing a neck competition against one another. Therefore, it is necessary to
analyze the profitability position of NBL and Nabil.
Thus the basic objective of this study is to analyze the financial performance of the
two banks by conducting a comparative study between NBL and NABIL through the
use of different ratios. The specific objectives of this study are as follows:-
i. To analyze the risk and return of NBL in comparison to Nabil.
ii. To evaluate financial ratios to calculate efficiencies, valuation, profitability,
Capital structure ratios.
iii. To analyze the liquidity position of the selected banks.
8
1.4 Significance of the study
This research study provides brief information about the comparative financial
performance between NBL and Nabil Bank Ltd. This comparative financial
performance analysis gives insight into the relative financial condition and
performance of these banks. This will provide guideline for improving its
performance to achieve the banks overall objectives and also to identify its hidden
weakness regarding financial administration. It also compels the management of
respective banks for self-assessment of what they have done in the past and guides
them in their future plan and programs.
Similarly, the study has also been carried out to fulfillment of the partial requirement
for the degree of Bachelor in Business Studies (BBS) to achieve the practical
knowledge of work, research skill and decision making skill for forth coming
professional life and this fieldwork may be useful for the library purpose so that any
student wanting to prepare a report can have some idea about it.
i. Further researcher
v. Library purpose
Chapter-1: Introduction
The first chapter of this study includes general background, statement of problems,
objectives of the study, significance of the study and limitation of the study.
This chapter reviews the existing literature on the concept of financial performance
analysis. It also includes a discussion of the conceptual framework, review of previous
related studies and research gap.
This chapter describes the research methodology employed in the study. It consists of
10
research design, types of data, Sources of data, population and sample, statistical and
financial tools used to analyze the data.
In this chapter collected and processed data are presented, and analyzed and interpreted
with using financial tools as well as present the findings of the research work.
Chapter-5: Discussion and Conclusion
In this chapter, discussion of whole study, conclusions and recommendation are
made.
At the end of the study, Bibliography and Appendices have also been incorporated.
11
CHAPTER-2
LITERATURE REVIEW
This chapter highlights and deals with the review of previous studies and the
conceptual framework on the topic. Review of literature is an essential part of all
studies. It provides the through understanding related to the present study by the
insight of previous research works and besides it avoids investigating problems that
have already been answered. In other word, it is the analysis of previous studies for
knowing the research in detail. The purpose of the literature review is to develop
some expertise in ones area, to see what new contribution can be made and to
review some idea for developing research design. This portion has been divided into
three parts:
i. Conceptual Review
The vertical and horizontal analysis could be done for the financial analysis. The
vertical analysis consists of financial Balance sheet, profit and loss Account of a
certain period time only, which is known as static analysis. Likewise, the horizontal
analysis consists of a series of statement relating to the number of years are reviewed
12
and analyzed. It is also known as dynamic analysis that measures the change of the
position or trend of the business over the number of years. In this study, the horizontal
analysis has been adopted to find out the financial indicator of the NBL and NABIL
over the period of FY 2013/2014 to 2016/2017.The steps of analysis are as follows.
1. Selection of the information relevant to the decision.
Ratio Analysis
Ratio analysis is the systematic use of financial information of the firms strength
and weakness as its historical performance, and current financial condition can be
determined.
After calculating various ratios, we need to compare with the certain standard and
draw out the conclusion of the result. The comparison classified by Weston and
Brigham into six types i.e.:
(i)Liquidity ratios (ii) Leverage ratios, (iii) Activity ratios (iv)profitability ratios
(v)Growth ratios and (vi)Valuation ratios .
In this study the following ratios are analyzed.
1. Profitability Ratio
2. Liquidity Ratio
13
3. Efficiency Ratio
5. Investment ratio
The details of the ratios will be discussed in detail in the next chapter.
Review of Previous work helps to identify issues on which researches were conducted
in the past. By providing information in these researches, it helps the researcher to
identify the issues that have remained untouched. In doing so, it prevents the
duplication in research work. Prior to the study, various report works have done in
different aspects of commercial banks such as lending policy, interest rate structure,
investment policy, resource mobilization, and capital structure etc. as well as several
researcher has found various studies regarding financial performance of commercial
banks. In this study only relevant subject matters are reviewed which are as follows:
Mr. Gurungs study on A Comparative financial study of NGBL and NIBL. In this
study, he has analyzed financial position of the banks measuring various ratios to
elaborate the financial performance. The liquidity, profitability and dividend payout
ratio of two banks are on favorable position. But NIBL seems to be slightly better
position in terms of liquidity, profitability and capital structure compared to the
NGBL. In this evidence he has concluded that the NIBL promises a better future than
NGBL.
14
than HBL. It has concluded that net profit to total assets ratio in case of HBL is found
better performance by utilizing overall resources but the generated profit is found
lower for the overall resources in three banks.
The review of the above mentioned bunch of research writes have definitely enriched
my vision to elaborate analysis, to come to the meaningful conclusion in realistic in
term and thereby come with few suggestions that help in improvement of commercial
banks
Research Gap refers to the areas of contradiction in a particular sector. The present
study tries to focus on financial performance of NBL and NABIL Bank Limited, it is
clear from the above review that there was no research work on comparative study of
these banks. This is the comparative study of commercial banks which were not
cleared in previous studies.
15
Chapter-3
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Among 31 commercial banks, Nepal Bank Limited and NABIL Bank Limited have
been selected for the present study. Financial statements of latest 5year have been
taken as sample for the comparative analysis of financial performance. The
recommendation and suggestions, which are derived from the study by taking the
above commercial banks as samples will be equally useful for the other commercial
16
banks in Nepal.
The research is based on primary as well as secondary data. Primary data collected
are personally collected through direct observation and interviews which have
conducted with the concerned staffs and customer of the concerned banks.
The secondary data are collected from annual reports of banks, broachers, balance
sheet and from the web-sites. All the secondary data are complied, processed and
tabulated in the time series as per the need and objectives of the study.
Ratio Analysis
Ratio analysis is one of the most commonly used techniques in the analysis of the
17
financial statement and evaluation of the managerial performance. Ratio analysis
points out the problems in any operational areas and provides a basis to recommend
corrective actions. Ratio analysis satisfies the interests of creditors, government
institutions and other to form their opinion or enable them to have guide line towards
effective decision- making.
Liquidity Ratio
Profitability Ratio
Valuation ratio
Liquidity Ratio
Liquidity Ratio reflects the short-term obligation of the firm. This ratio shows that
if firm need cash amount in short period without any notice, can firm fulfill its
need or how it manage the need.
Commercial banks need liquidity to meet loan demand and deposit withdrawals.
Liquidity is also needed for the purpose of meeting Cash Reserve Ratio (CRR) and
Statutory Liquidity Ratio (SLR) requirements prescribed by the central Bank. The
following ratios are calculated under the liquidity ratios.
a) Current Ratio
It is the ratio of total current assets to current liability. Lower current ratio creates
difficulties in meeting short run commitments as they mature. If the ratio is too high,
the bank has an excessive investment in current assets or is under utilizing short- term
18
credit.It can be computed by using formula method:
Current Liabilities
This ratio indicates the proportion of liquid assets to meet non-interest bearing
liabilities, which are free cost of source of NBL and RBB. This ratio is calculated
as:
Cash & bank balance to Non-interest Bearing Deposit Ratio= Cash & bank balance
Non-interest being deposit
19
an enterprise.
a) Loan and Advances to Total Deposit ratio:
Loan and advances are the major resources of investment to generate income in the
commercial banks. Deposits are used to grant loans and advances. Therefore, the
bank should manage its deposits efficiently. This ratio is calculated to determine the
utilization of deposits for profit generating purpose on the loans and advances. This
ratio is calculated as;
Loan and Advances to Total Deposit ratio= Loan and Advances
Total Deposit
b) Total Investment to Total Deposit Ratio
Investment is one of the major forms of credit created to earn return. It measures the
utilization of deposits in investment. Higher the ratio, better the utilization of collected
fund and generates regular income to the banks. This ratio is calculated as:
Total Investment to Total Deposit Ratio= Total Investment
Total Deposit
Leverage ratio shows the proportion of debt capital and equity capital. It shows the
long-term solvency of the firm. It judges the long-term financial position of the
firm. Hence the leverage ratios are calculated to measure the financial risk and the
firms ability if using debt for the benefit of shareholders. Following ratios are
calculated here:
a) Long term Debt to Net Worth (Shareholders equity) Ratio
It measures the proportion of long-term debt and equity used in the
capitalization of the banks. It is calculated as:
Long term Debt to Net worth Ratio= Long term Debt
Net Worth
20
b) Total Debt to Total Assets Ratio:
This ratio expresses the relationship between creditors fund and owners
capital. This ratio measures the share of the total assets financed by
outsider fund. This ratio is calculated as:
Total Assets
Total Assets
This ratio measures the proportion of interest bearing debt and owners fund. This
relationship describing the lenders contribution for each rupee of owners contribution
is called debt equity ratios .It is calculated as:
Net Worth
Profitability Ratio
This ratio measures the capacity of generating revenue and search for the
incomes of the firm. The operating efficiency of the bank and its ability to
ensure adequate return to its shareholders depends ultimately on the profit
earned by the bank. To measure the efficiency of the banks following
21
major profitability ratios are calculated.
This ratio measures the efficiency of the staff or cost paid for taking services from
staff to earning come by providing services to the customers.
c) Interest Income to Interest Expenses Ratio
This ratio measures the effective use of deposit to earn revenue in proportion of the
expense accrued on collected deposits. Bank has to pay interest on interest bearing
deposits and receive interest through its investment on loans, advances and others.
Valuation Ratios
These ratios result the overall performance of the bank measuring the combined effect
of risk and return. The valuation ratios indicate the market value of the firm as
compared to the book value and measure the stock price relative to earnings.The
following ratios are calculated.
Price earning Ratio is widely used by the security analyst to value the firms
performance as expected by investors. It shows how much investors are willing to
pay per dollar of reported profits. This ratio is calculated as:
Earning per share is calculated by dividing profit after tax by total number of common
shares outstanding.
22
b) Dividend Payout Ratio (DPR)
The Ratio measures the relationship between earnings belonging to the ordinary
shareholders and dividend paid to them. It can be calculated as:
The ratio measures the price; the outsiders are paying for each rupee reported by the
balance sheet of the banks. It can be calculated as:
The book value per share is net worth divided by the number of shares outstanding.
After reviewing the relevant Literatures and highlighting the Research Methodology
now the Analysis part of the research is gong to be undertaken.
23
24