Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Kerry S. Whitehead
Introduction
Todays students are no longer the people our educational system was designed to teach
(Prensky, 2001, p. 1). This quote accurately describes the digital native. Digital natives are
students that have grown up with technology. One of the many challenges that teachers face
today is how to reach the digital natives while still covering their subject curriculum and
preparing students for standardized testing. Teachers are trying to cover their material as they
always have while digital natives are craving the use of technology in the classroom (Thompson,
2013, p. 468). The question arises, how can the two worlds coexist? Some believe one way to
achieve this is through the blended learning classroom. The blended-learning classroom
combines face-to-face learning (teaching of old) and different forms of instructional technology
example, in Texas, the Student Success Initiative requires eighth-grade students to pass reading
and math State of Texas Assessment of Academic Readiness (STAAR) tests to be promoted to
high school. If there is such an emphasis on standardized testing, does blended learning have a
Past research does not adequately address how blending learning impacts standardized
testing in the middle school ELAR classroom. By exploring blended learning and standardized
testing, teachers can develop strategies and lessons that covers required material and meets the
needs of the digital native while preparing them to be productive, responsible adults.
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 3
According to Prensky (2001), a digital native is one that has been surrounded by
technology their entire lives (p. 1). The flip-side to the digital native is the digital immigrant.
The digital immigrant was introduced to the technology at some point in their lives. They have
learned to adapt but also maintain some degree of their past (Prensky, 2001). In todays
education world, the general student population represents the digital natives, and the
teachers/staff represent the digital immigrants. These are two different perspectives that are
trying to come together and coexist. The teachers are consumed with getting students ready for
the state assessments, and so the teachers focus becomes teacher-centered rather than student-
centered (Au, 2007). On the other hand, the students are looking for activities that are
Blended Learning
There had been research conducted to support that one way to reach the digital native is
through blended learning (Alijani, Kwun, & Yu, 2014). According to Patchan et al. (2016),
blended learning is considered to be a mixture of face-to-face time with an instructor and 30-
79% of content delivered through online components such as but not limited to discussions,
videos, and knowledge checks. One of the major benefits of blended learning is being able to
meet the different learning styles of students. Students learn at different paces. By teachers
being able to post videos to enhance learning slower students can review the videos multiple
times to make sure they master the content. The more advanced students can move through the
material quicker (Patchan et al., 2016). By having the students view videos outside of class, it
allows for more in-class time for collaboration and discussions (Chen, 2016). Another benefit to
blended learning that affects both the students and the teachers is immediate and targeted
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 4
feedback. As students complete knowledge checks, they receive immediate feedback to help
stop misconceptions early. The immediate feedback lets the students know what they missed and
why they missed what they missed. For teachers, it allows them to see what the students are
struggling with and allows the teacher to adjust face-to-face instruction to make it more efficient
and meaningful (Patchan et al., 2015). Collaboration, whether online or traditional, is a major
learning (Chen, 2016). Collaboration allows for students to communicate with each and teach
each other. For all of the benefits, there are some challenges to the blended learning classroom.
For teachers, a big challenge is the time creating blended learning lessons can take. The teachers
have to be willing to commit the time beforehand. Not only the time that is required to create the
lessons but if students are working at home, sometimes the teacher is not always available to the
students to answer questions that may arise (Longo, 2016). For students, a significant challenge
has been connectivity. In the current technological world, not all students have had access
Blended Learning in the English Language Arts and Reading (ELAR) Classroom
Research has shown that the United States is experiencing a crisis in reading achievement
(McKenna et al., 2012). Some of the statistics are staggering. According to a study of reading
attitudes, more than twenty-five percent of secondary students in the United States do not have
the skills to succeed (McKenna, Conradi, Lawrence, Jang, & Meyer, 2012). Another staggering
statistic has to do with struggling readers. As of 2007, more than eight million students in the
upper elementary/secondary level are considered struggling readers. One effect of being labeled
a struggling reader is that they are at risk of failing other subjects in school. Another effect of
being labeled a struggling reader is that students are in danger of dropping out of school, thus not
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 5
being prepared to be productive members of society (Sternberg, Kaplan, & Borck, 2007). There
have been very few studies regarding technology integration in the middle and high school
grades in regards to attitudes toward reading (McKenna et al., 2012). Most studies have been
about the cognitive areas of reading (McKenna et al., 2012). However, motivation and attitudes
toward reading influence reading achievement. Once students are in middle school, they do not
have much interest in reading. Most of the time the reading in class is teacher driven. Students
do not have a choice in what they read. Most of the reading that is done outside of class by
students today is on the Internet. In 2007, 93% of U.S. school-age children used the Internet on a
regular basis (McKenna et al., 2012). In light of so many children using the Internet, it only
makes sense for teachers to integrate technology into the English Language Arts and Reading
(ELAR) classroom to help motivate students and raise reading achievement. There are many
ways to integrate blended learning into the ELAR classroom. One of the most popular methods
is the use online literature circles (Falter Thomas, 2014). Traditional literature circles are
popular because they are peer groups that discuss the same piece of literature (Falter Thomas,
2014). Students can socialize and construct the meaning of the piece they are reading. By taking
the circle online, it adds a new dimension. Online literature circles help students become more
engaged, especially those who were normally quiet in a traditional literature circle. Online
literature circles gave students the freedom to participate outside of school (Day & Kroon, 2010).
Some students would participate even if they were out sick (Day & Kroon, 2010). There are
other ways that blended learning can be incorporated into the ELAR classroom. In a teacher
action research study, English curriculum was the focus. The blended learning group used an
online language arts program to practice their skills. The study focused on four grammar lessons
(Camahalan & Ruley, 2014). In each of the grammar lessons, the blended learning group
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 6
outperformed the traditional group (Camahalan & Ruley, 2014). Teachers can incorporate
activities and project that utilize the Internet to help increase writing skills and reading
achievement (Moran, Ferdig, Pearson, Wardrop, & Blomeyer, 2008). By utilizing different
technologies, students can demonstrate their mastery of various strategies such as but not limited
to navigating nonlinear format of websites, thinking critically about the validity of an online
source, and setting a purpose for reading (McKenna et al., 2012). Students also learn to
communicate effectively with their peers and their teacher (Falter Thomas, 2014).
English language learners (ELL) are fast becoming the largest population in schools
today (Watkins & Lindahl, 2010). In 2006, Texas was second to California for the number of
ELLs served, and Texas served 657,716 ELLs (Lpez, 2010). ELLs have many obstacles to
overcome when entering U.S. schools. ELLs come to U.S. schools with different experiences
(Watkins & Lindahl, 2010). They come to the U.S. with different degrees of English
proficiency; many are not accustomed to U.S. school routines because they may not have
participated much in the way of formal education (Watkins & Lindahl, 2010). In addition, ELLs
are trying to learn content that is not in their native language. There are virtually no
experimental studies showing how technology integration benefits ELLs (Lpez, 2010). Most of
the research conducted has focused on teacher and student perceptions of using technology in the
classroom (Lpez, 2010). There are many ways that teachers can create the blended
environment in the ELL classroom. In a study investigating iPod use for ELLs, Liu, Navarrete,
and Wivagg (2014) found that iPods can be used as resource tools and media creation tools. For
example, as a resource tool, they can be used as translation dictionaries that provide audio
pronunciation and images to help support vocabulary. As media creation tools, students use the
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 7
iPod to record their reading to improve fluency. Teachers can create lesson podcasts and upload
them to the iPods (Patten & Craig, 2007). Students have the ability to go back and listen as
many times as is necessary for them to master the content (Patten & Craig, 2007). Blogs are a
way to increase the ELLs writing abilities (Andrei, 2014). It helps instill confidence in the
student (Andrei, 2014). Wikis are a way to increase social interaction between students. Wikis
are websites that allow for collaboration. Wikis allow for students to construct their knowledge
while collaborating with their peers (Wiseman & Belknap, 2013). Wikis have many applications
in the ELL classroom, such as but not limited to, create a glossary of terms for a novel they are
reading in class, answer questions about the novel as a small-group, or complete an author study
for the novel they are reading (Wiseman & Belknap, 2013).
Standardized Testing
Standardized testing has been around for a long time. It started when Horace Mann
pushed for written essay exams in 1845. Standardized testing has continued to evolve over the
years. The first major education act was the National Defense Education Act of 1957, later
revised into the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA) in 1965. Through this law,
education accountability started to take shape. Schools that received Title I funds were required
to be accountable for the achievement of students. After many revisions, ESEA would later
become No Child Left Behind (NCLB) in 2002. One of the major tenets of NCLB was that any
school receiving federal funds must be held accountable in regards to student achievement
(Huddleston & Rockwell, 2015). As schools have become more accountable for student
standardized testing that has serious consequences tied to test results. These consequences can
directly affect students, teachers, schools, and even entire school districts (Jones & Egley, 2004).
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 8
Consequences can range from retention (affecting students) to major curriculum changes
(affecting teachers) to school ratings (affecting schools and districts) to major budget decisions
Texas had high-stakes testing long before NCLB became law. In 1984, Texas required
changes in the testing program. It was the first time in Texas that it was necessary that tests be
passed to graduate high school. In 1990, the tests were revised again, becoming more difficult.
It was in 1990 that Texas added assessments in grades 3 through 8 (Hursh, 2005). With the
passing of NCLB, Texas started the Student Success Initiative (SSI). SSI required students in
grades three, five, and eight to pass the reading and math Texas Assessment of Knowledge and
Skills (TAKS) to promote to the next grade (Huddleston & Rockwell, 2015). They had three
opportunities to pass the test. If on the third administration they did not pass they could be
retained in that grade level. How does this affect the teacher? Many believe that it causes the
teachers to begin to teach to the test (Assaf, 2008). In a case study conducted by Lori Czop
Assaf (2008), Marsha, the participant in the case study, had a major conflict between creating
real readers and ensuring her students were prepared for the state assessment. By the end of
the case study, Marsha was spending more time reviewing benchmark tests and preparing her
students for the state assessment (Assaf, 2008). In a qualitative study conducted in 67 Florida
school districts, 79.9% of the teachers surveyed felt that the Florida Comprehensive Assessment
Test (FCAT) was not improving the public schools in Florida (Jones & Egley, 2004). 23.3% of
the respondents felt that the FCAT forced them to teach to the test. Another complaint was that
the FCAT does not allow teachers to meet the needs of their students (Jones & Egley, 2004).
One component of teaching to the test is that instruction becomes teacher-centered with more in
the way of lectures (Au, 2007). Moreover, because of the more teacher-centered instruction
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 9
students are bored in school. Students want to participate in activities that are of more relevance
(Mora, 2011). In a study conducted by Richard Mora (2011), students expressed satisfaction
when they were engaged in instructional activities such as hands-on activities. However,
because students are faced with the possibility of retention if they do not pass their state
assessments, teachers feel the pressure to make sure they are prepared, which results in a
narrowing of the assessed curriculum. One of the consequences of students and educators being
pressured for students to perform on state assessments is the students ability to test (Hursh,
2005). Many studies have shown that high-stakes testing does not measure how much students
have learned but how well they have learned to test (Hursh, 2005).
Research Questions
1. How does the blended learning classroom differ from the traditional classroom
regarding reading test scores for seventh and eighth-grade English language arts
2. How does the blended-learning classroom influence reading test scores for the
Hypotheses Statements
The following hypotheses statements will be tested to answer the research questions:
1. Ha: There are significant differences in reading test scores for seventh and
H0: There is no difference in the reading test scores for seventh and eighth-grade
students in the middle school blended learning English language arts and reading
classroom.
2. Ha: There are significant differences in reading test scores for seventh and
H0: There is no difference in reading test scores for seventh and eighth-grade
This study will contribute to the current low number of studies that focus on standardized
testing the blended learning model in the middle school English language arts and reading
necessary to prepare our students for such a world. Through this study, administrators will see
the benefits of using a blended learning model in the ELAR classroom. Teachers might find that
by incorporating the blended learning model, they can meet the demands of high-stakes testing
while engaging students in meaningful and engaging activities that stimulate higher-order
thinking. Administrators and teachers might understand, through this study, that using a blended
learning model equips students with the necessary twenty-first century skills to be productive
Method
This qualitative study used a quasi-experimental design. The study participants were
selected according to selected English language arts and reading (ELAR) teachers. The study
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 11
lasted through the course of one school year. The researcher collected student assessment data
Participants
This research study was conducted using a quasi-experimental design because the
students were already scheduled into their English language arts and reading (ELAR) classes.
This study utilized two seventh-grade and two eighth-grade ELAR teachers. Each teacher had
two class periods in the study for a total of four seventh-grade classes and four eighth-grade
classes. The sample size of the study was 161 students. The classes were chosen because the
demographics for the control group and the treatment group were similar for each teacher. The
researcher first obtained permission to conduct the study by contacting the superintendent of the
school followed up with permission from the school principal. The researcher drafted consent
letters outlining the research study. These letters were distributed to teachers and students for
parents to sign.
Instrumentation
The main instrument used in this research study was the seventh-grade and eighth-grade
reading portion of the State of Texas Assessment of Academic Readiness (STAAR). STAAR is
used to determine how much the students have learned throughout the school year and whether
or not they can apply the skills they have learned. The reading portion of the STAAR measures
how the students have mastered comprehension skills using literary texts such as poetry, drama,
fiction, and literary nonfiction. The reading portion of the STAAR also measures the student's
mastery of informational texts using forms such as expository, persuasive, and procedural texts.
Media literacy skills are embedded in both the literary texts and the informational texts
(STAAR Reading Resources, 2017). The previous years STAAR scores were employed as the
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 12
pretest for this study. Those scores were compared to their current STAAR scores at the end of
the research study to answer the research questions. Both sets of STAAR scores were obtained
Design/Procedure
This research study utilized the experimental research design. The experimental design is
used to determine a cause-and-effect relationship between the two variables used in this study
(Creswell, 2015). This research design was appropriate because the researcher was trying to
determine if the blended learning environment had an effect on student state standardized test
scores. State standardized scores were collected at the beginning of the school year. The
students previous years scores were the baseline. The current years scores were compared to
The researcher studied two seventh-grade teachers and two eighth-grade, teachers. Each
teacher had a control group and a treatment group. Both groups followed the district curriculum.
The control group received traditional instruction such as but not limited to lecture, paper tests,
hand-written journals, and hand-written papers. The treatment group implemented the blended
learning environment that will employ activities such as but not limited to the use of a learning
management system, collaboration projects, blogging for journals and essays, and the use of peer
reviews of blogs.
All data were entered into a statistical program, Statistical Package for the Social
Sciences (SPSS), used for quantitative research. SPSS allowed the researchers to analyze the
data, answer the research questions, and test hypotheses (Creswell, 2015). A codebook was
Table 1
Variable Value
ID Student ID number
Gender 1 = Male 2 = Female
Grade 7 = 7th grade 8 = 8th grade
ESL 1 = No 2 = Yes
Teacher 1 = Teacher 1 2 =Teacher 2
3 = Teacher 3 4 = Teacher 4
Classroom 1 = Traditional 2 = Blended
STAAR1 Previous year STAAR score
STAAR2 Current year STAAR score
Once the data was inputted into SPSS, the researcher used descriptive and inferential
Data Analysis
The main sources of data used for the research project are the Reading State of Texas
Assessment of Academic Readiness (STAAR) for the current year and the previous year. Figure
1 shows the average score for the traditional classroom and the blended learning classroom.
Figure 1
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 14
Traditional 54% 87
Blended 63% 74
The data used was the current year STAAR scores. 161 students were studied for this project.
87 students were in the traditional learning classrooms, and 74 students were in the blended
learning classes. Each teacher in the study had a traditional classroom and a blended classroom.
Figure 2 shows the breakdown by teacher for the traditional and the blended classroom.
Figure 2
Figure 3 focused on the mean scores of the English as a second language (ESL) students.
Figure 3
Traditional 45% 26
Blended Learning 58% 20
Of the 161 students in the study, 46 were classified as ESL. Of the 46 ESL students, 26 were in
the traditional classroom, and 20 were in the blended learning classroom. Figure 4 shows the
breakdown for the different classrooms for the ESL population.
Figure 4
Introduction
A researcher has been given a task by the school principal to conduct research. The
researcher has started the research process and has completed the first three steps of the research
process, which includes identifying the problem, reviewing the literature, specifying the purpose
(Creswell, 2015). Now the data needs to be collected. However, which design should the
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 17
researcher choose? This report will provide some insight into different forms of quantitative
through trends and needs (Creswell, 2015). Quantitative research collects data with precise
measurements that test hypotheses statements (Johnson, & Christensen, 2000). This section of
the report will provide a scenario, advantages, and disadvantages of three different quantitative
research designs: correlational, causal-comparative, and experimental. This section will also
discuss survey design, and, how to ensure quality design and increase response rates.
Correlational Design
variables (Creswell, 2015). Therefore, no variables are manipulated. An example of this would
be a teacher desiring to see if there was a relationship between vocabulary development and
reading comprehension skills of middle school students. The teacher would administer a
vocabulary instrument to the students and would also administer a reading comprehension
instrument. Using different correlation statistics, the teacher would determine the relationship
between the two variables. If the students scored high on the vocabulary instrument and scored
high on the reading comprehension instrument, this would demonstrate a positive correlation. A
positive correlation is when the two variables move in the same direction (Creswell, 2015). An
correlation is when the two variables move in opposite directions (Creswell, 2015). One
advantage to correlational design is that the researcher can observe multiple variables in the same
study (Mertens, 1999). Another advantage is that correlational studies can be used as a
springboard for experimental studies. They can help in the generation of hypothesis statements
and gives the researcher a narrower direction for their experiment (Walker, 2005). One of the
biggest disadvantages is that correlational research can only determine the relationship between
Causal-comparative Design
(Johnson, & Christensen, 2000). The causal-comparative research design compares different
groups (independent variables) to a dependent variable (Creswell, 2015). As with the correlation
research design would be the comparing of middle school students that receive free or reduced
lunch (low socioeconomic status) to those that are not considered low socioeconomic status on
reading achievement scores. The purpose of this study would be to determine if there was an
association between socioeconomic status and reading achievement. One advantage of the
causal-comparative research design is the ability to conduct studies on issues that may have
disadvantage of this research design would be that since there is no manipulation of variable a
Experimental Design
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 19
The experimental design allows the researcher to determine if one variable has any
influence over another variable (Creswell, 2015). In the experimental design, the researcher has
the control group (no intervention) and a treatment group (intervention group). A researcher
wants to determine which teaching practice is best for increasing spelling scores in English
Language Arts middle school classrooms. The researcher would use random assignment to
create the groups. Both groups would be given the same spelling list each week. The teacher of
the control group would conduct different in-class activities with the students to help reinforce
the spelling words. The treatment group would be given the homework assignment of writing
the spelling words five times each. The teacher of the treatment group would also conduct in-
class activities to help reinforce the spelling words. Both groups would be given a spelling test
at the end of the week. The researcher would organize and analyze the results. An advantage of
using the experimental design is that it is considered the best in studying cause-and-effect
relationships (Creswell, 2015, 323). Another advantage to using experiments is that the
researcher can achieve more reliable results because the variables can be controlled (Walker,
2005). However, one of the disadvantages of using experiments is the ethical issues that can
arise (Creswell, 2015). Correlational and causal-comparative research designs are subject to
ethical issues also, but the experimental design is concerned the withdrawing of treatment or
Survey Design
The survey design method is another form of quantitative studies relationships (Creswell,
2015). Surveys are popular for situations such as but not limited to evaluation of programs,
making or changing policies (Fink, 2009). For a survey study to be effective and accurate, it
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 20
must be designed well (Fowler, 2009). Many steps go into designing a good survey. As with
other forms of research, the researcher must formulate the researcher questions or hypotheses
statements (Creswell, 2015). Once the researcher has decided on hypotheses statements, the
population to be studied must be identified. From there, the researcher must determine whether a
random population will be explored or whether a list of names will be obtained (Creswell, 2015).
The researcher will begin survey design and data collection at this point. The researcher will
need to decide if their survey is going to be cross-sectional (data collection at one point) or
longitudinal (data collection over a period). Cross-sectional studies are beneficial because they
can measure attitudes, beliefs, or practices. Longitudinal studies are beneficial because they
study, over time, either the same population or a different population that shares a common
characteristic. The researcher will determine the best way to collect the data. The researcher can
(Creswell, 2015). The researcher will either develop a survey instrument or locate one. If the
to make sure to create different types of questions. They should be sure to use clear language
and write questions that all respondents can answer. They should also conduct a pilot test to
make sure that questions have been constructed well (Creswell, 2015). The researchers will
administer the surveys, analyze the results and address the research questions or hypotheses that
the researcher developed. All of this will be dealt with in the report that the researcher writes.
Many things can be done to ensure a higher response rate on surveys. If the researcher is
going to carry out the surveys through the mail or the web, the researcher needs to notify the
participants ahead of time to let them know that they will be receiving a survey soon (Creswell,
weeks after the original survey has been sent out the researcher can send out a second survey. If
the researcher still has nonrespondents, a postcard can be sent to those nonrespondents two
weeks after the second survey has been sent out (Creswell, 2015). The researcher could give the
participants a choice between a paper survey or a web survey. Sometimes participants prefer one
over the other (Fink, 2009). The survey should not be too long for the participant to finish
promptly (Creswell, 2015). The researcher should study a problem of interest. The researcher
(Creswell, 2015). Sometimes one form does not sufficiently address the research questions, or
the researcher wants to present different perspectives in the study (Creswell, 2015). Because
mixed methods designs can be time-consuming, the researcher is sometimes asked to be part of a
research team (Creswell, 2015). There are different forms of mixed methods research designs.
The following sections will discuss the three types of designs: convergent, explanatory, and
exploratory sequential.
Convergent Design
The convergent design is where the researcher collects quantitative and qualitative data at
the same time (Creswell, 2015). The researcher gives each form equal importance. The
researcher wants to see if each form of data gives similar results. If the two forms do not give
similar results, then this causes a divergence. The researcher needs to go back to the databases
and explain why there was a discrepancy in the results. One advantage to using the convergent
design is that it utilizes the best aspects of quantitative and qualitative research designs
(Creswell, 2015). One drawback to using the convergent design is that it can be difficult to
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 22
merge the two databases and then have to go back and reanalyze the results if there is divergence
(Creswell, 2015).
The primary data collection method for the explanatory sequential design is quantitative.
It uses qualitative design to help explain the quantitative results (Creswell, 2015). The
researcher completes the quantitative research first and then uses the qualitative to explore
specific pieces of the quantitative research (Creswell, 2015). One advantage to using the
explanatory sequential design is that there is no merging of databases. Similar to the convergent
design it takes advantage of the best aspects of both quantitative and qualitative research
(Creswell, 2015). However, one of the major drawbacks to the explanatory sequential design is
on the qualitative side. The researcher has to determine which aspects of the quantitative
research will be followed up on in the qualitative phase (Creswell, 2015). The researcher has to
decide the participants to use and questions to ask. This cannot be accomplished until the
The exploratory sequential design also uses the quantitative and qualitative designs as the
explanatory sequential design. However, with the exploratory sequential design, the researcher
completes the qualitative research first (Creswell, 2015). The quantitative research is used to
explain the findings of the qualitative results. The qualitative research is completed on a small
sample, and the quantitative research is completed on a larger population (Creswell, 2015). One
advantage to using the exploratory sequential design is that the researcher is able to explore the
topic first. One disadvantage to using this design is that it is time-consuming on the part of the
Introduction
learning in the classroom. The researcher is unsure where to start. Should the researcher choose
design, which form should they use? This report will show the differences between quantitative
and qualitative research. It also discusses different forms of qualitative research. Finally, this
One of the first things researchers must do is decide what type of research is best to help
them with their problem (Creswell, 2015). Should they use quantitative or qualitative research?
This section of the report will show the similarities and differences between qualitative and
quantitative research. The structure of this section focuses on the six similarities and how they
The first step of the research process is identifying the research problem (Creswell,
2015). In quantitative studies, the research problem section sets up the research questions and
hypotheses to be explored (Fraenkel, & Wallen, 1993). In qualitative research, the research
problem section focuses on the importance of the study and allows the hypotheses emerge
throughout the study (Fraenkel, & Wallen, 1993). The second step of the research process is the
literature review (Creswell, 2015). In quantitative research, the literature review plays a major
role. It helps provide a rationale for the direction of the study. In qualitative research, the
literature review plays a minor role. For qualitative research, it helps document the need for
study (Creswell, 2015). The third step of the research process is specifying the purpose of the
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 24
study. For both quantitative and qualitative research, this step is the same. The purpose of both
forms of research is to state the overall objective of the study (Creswell, 2015). The fourth step
of the research process is collecting data. One way that both forms are similar is that they can
both use observations or interviews. However, quantitative research uses open-ended questions,
and qualitative research uses open-ended questions (Creswell, 2015). Quantitative research
focuses on the numerical data collection, and, quantitative research focuses on a narrative
description. When it comes to the sampling in data collection, quantitative research uses random
techniques and qualitative research uses purposeful sampling (Fraenkel, & Wallen, 1993). The
fifth step of the research process is analyzing and interpreting the data (Creswell, 2015). With
research, the researcher is looking for themes or patterns (Fraenkel, & Wallen, 1993).
Quantitative data analysis looks to confirm or deny the hypotheses statements that were
generated at the onset of the study (Johnson, & Christensen, 2000). Hypotheses statements are
not tested in qualitative research; they are developed throughout the study (Fraenkel, & Wallen,
1993). The sixth and final step of the research process is the reporting and evaluating of the
research (Creswell, 2015). Quantitative research reports are statistical reports whereas
qualitative research reports are narrative in nature (Johnson, & Christensen, 2000). If the reports
are published in journals, quantitative reports are generally ten to fifteen pages, and qualitative
reports are twenty to thirty pages in length (Johnson, & Christensen, 2000). In regards to
evaluating the research, conclusions are drawn at the end of the study in quantitative research.
However, in qualitative research, conclusions are drawn throughout the study (Fraenkel, &
Wallen, 1993).
the researcher's biases and thoughts (Creswell, 2015). In qualitative research, the researcher is in
direct contact with the components of the study, such as the participants, the situation, and the
phenomenon (Johnson & Christensen, 2000). Data is collected through items such as but not
limited to interviews and photographs (Creswell, 2015). This section of the report will provide a
scenario, advantages, and disadvantages of three different qualitative research designs: narrative,
Narrative Design
Researchers that conduct narrative research collect stories and write them in literary
format. Narrative research usually focuses on one subject. The researcher collects stories from
the subject describing individual experiences, and the researcher strives to find the meaning of
narrative research study would be a researcher wanting to understand the struggles and successes
a teacher experiences as they implement blended learning in the classroom. The researcher could
collect journal entries the teacher writes. The researcher can also conduct narrative interviews.
An advantage of using narrative research is that the subject being studied feels that their voice is
heard (Creswell, 2015). Because narrative research is so personal, the researcher and
participants create a close bond it brings the researcher closer to the topic being studied
(Creswell, 2015). One disadvantage of using the narrative research design is the validity of the
data (Flick, 2007). There is the possibility of obtaining fake data. Another disadvantage to
narrative research is at times participants are unable to tell their story. There is a possibility that
although the participant tells their story, their voice gets lost through restorying (Creswell, 2015).
Ethnographic Design
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 26
cultural group is a group of people that share the same beliefs, values, norms, and etcetera.
(Johnson & Christensen, 2000). Ethnographic research is one form of qualitative research.
Ethnographic research can study narrowly defined cultures such as but not limited to teachers,
students, or English language learners (ELL) or broadly defined groups such as schools or school
blended learning environment. The researcher wants to understand how the ELL students
responded to the blended learning environment. One advantage of using the ethnographic
research design is the researcher gains a more comprehensive perspective than with other
research designs (Fraenkel & Wallen, 1993). Researchers gain a deeper understanding of the
behaviors of a culture studied. This design is also well-suited for observing behaviors in the
over an extended period (Fraenkel & Wallen, 1993). Ethnographic research does have its
disadvantages. One of those disadvantages is that there is not an ability to make generalizations
because this research design focuses on one situation. Ethnographic research is dependent upon
the researchers observations and does not use statistical data, so it is hard to verify the results of
Case Study
The case study research design is a form of ethnographic research (Creswell, 2015). It
differs from an ethnographic study in the fact that instead of studying a group, a case study
studies one individual, classroom, or school, even district (Fraenkel & Wallen, 1993). It is not
looking to find cultural themes because it is focusing on one case (Creswell, 2015). An example
of a case study would be the study of a teacher that integrates technology on a regular basis into
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 27
their classroom. The researcher might examine why the teacher chooses to use technology, how
the teacher chooses what technology to use in the classroom, or how the teacher evaluates the
use of technology in the classroom. One advantage of using case study research is that the
researcher can study a phenomenon in-depth (Yin, 2009). The researcher can investigate the
case in its natural environment with no manipulation (Stake, 2010). Case study research has a
generalize to a wider population because it focuses on one situation (Yin, 2009). Another
disadvantage can be a particular case study is asked to serve too many purposes (Stake, 2010).
Action Research
(Airasian & Gay, 2003). Action research is similar to mixed-methods research design in that it
can use quantitative or qualitative methods for data collection (Creswell, 2015). There are
differences between action research and formal or traditional research. Action research is
conducted by teachers, principals or other educational personnel. They perform the research
with their students. Formal research, on the other hand, is conducted by university professors,
graduate students or scholars on specific groups of people that fit their particular research topic
(Airasian & Gay, 2003). Action research is focused on teacher practice. It has an insider
perspective because the teacher-researcher is looking at their practices. Formal research has an
outsider perspective (Airasian & Gay, 2003). Formal researchers are advancing knowledge in a
field of study. They have no relationship with the study participants (Creswell, 2015). The steps
that taken for action research are different from that of formal research. Action research uses a
spiraling technique. The researcher implements the plan and observes and reflects. If the
researcher has not achieved desired results, the researcher changes the plan, implements the new
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 28
plan, observes and reflects on the new plan. The researcher continues this until desired results
are achieved (Denzin, 2009). Whereas the formal researcher uses the following scientific
method steps: (1) identify the research problem, (2) review the literature, (3) specify the purpose,
(4) collect data, (5) analyze and interpret the data, and (6) report and evaluate the research
(Creswell, 2015).
There are numerous reasons a researcher would choose action research. With action research,
teacher-researchers have the ability to implement a plan and rework plans as often as they
needed. Teachers benefit directly from action research because they gain a deeper understanding
of teaching practices because they are the ones conducting the research (Airasian & Gay, 2003).
Schools can improve through action research. As teachers strive to improve their teaching
References
Airasian, P., & Gay, L. (2003). Educational research (1st ed.). Upper Saddle River: Prentice
Hall.
Alijani, G., Kwun, O., & Yu, Y. (2014). Effectiveness of blended learning in KIPP New Orleans'
Andrei, E. (2014). Digital technology in three middle school ESL language arts classrooms.
Camahalan, F., & Ruley, A. (2014). Blended learning and teaching writing: A teacher action
Chen, L. (2016). Impacts of flipped classroom in high school health education. Journal of
Day, D., & Kroon, S. (2010). Online literature circles rock! Organizing online literature circles
doi:10.1080/00940771.2010.11461753
Denzin, N. (2009). The Sage handbook of qualitative research (1st ed.). Thousand Oaks, Calif.:
Sage Publications.
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 30
Falter Thomas, A. (2014). An action research study involving motivating middle school students'
learning through online literature circles. Journal of Ethnographic & Qualitative Research,
9(1), 44-54.
Fink, A. (2009). How to conduct surveys (4th ed.). Los Angeles: SAGE.
Flick, U. (2007). An introduction to qualitative research (1st ed.). Los Angeles: SAGE
Publications.
Fowler, F. (2009). Survey Research Methods (4th ed.). Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications.
Fraenkel, J., & Wallen, N. (1993). How to design and evaluate research in education (1st ed.).
Hockly, N. (2011). The digital generation. ELT Journal, 65(3), 322-325. doi:/10.1093/elt/ccr041
Huddleston, A., & Rockwell, E. (2015). Assessment for the masses: A historical critique of high-
Hursh, D. (2005). The growth of highstakes testing in the USA: Accountability, markets and the
doi:10.1080/01411920500240767
Johnson, B., & Christensen, L. (2000). Educational research (1st ed.). Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
Jones, B., & Egley, R. (2004). Voices from the frontlines: Teachers' perceptions of high-stakes
Liu, M., Navarrete, C., & Wivagg, J. (2014). Potentials of mobile technology for K-12 education:
An investigation of iPod touch use for English language learners in the United States.
Longo, C. (2016). Changing the instructional model: Utilizing blended learning as a tool of
inquiry instruction in middle school science. Middle School Journal, 47(3), 33-40.
doi:10.1080/00940771.2016.1135098
Lpez, O. (2010). The digital learning classroom: Improving English language learners
McKenna, M., Conradi, K., Lawrence, C., Jang, B., & Meyer, J. (2012). Reading attitudes of
middle school students: Results of a U.S. survey. Reading Research Quarterly, 47(3), 283-
306. doi:10.1002/RRQ.021
Mertens, D. (1999). Research methods in education and psychology (1st ed.). Thousand Oaks,
Calif.: Sage.
Mora, R. (2011). "School is so boring": High-stakes testing and boredom at an urban middle
Moran, J., Ferdig, R., Pearson, P., Wardrop, J., & Blomeyer, R. (2008). Technology and reading
Patchan, M., Schunn, C., Sieg, W., & McLaughlin, D. (2015). The effect of blended instruction
doi:10.1080/1475939x.2015.1013977
Patten, K., & Craig, D. (2007). iPods and English-language learners: A great combination.
Prensky, M. (2001). Digital natives, digital immigrants Part 1. On The Horizon, 9(5), 1-6.
doi:10.1108/10748120110424816
THE EFFECTS OF BLENDED LEARNING ON MIDDLE SCHOOL 32
http://tea.texas.gov/student.assessment/staar/reading/
Stake, R. (2010). The art of case study research (1st ed.). Thousand Oaks, Calif.: Sage
Publications.
Sternberg, B., Kaplan, K., & Borck, J. (2007). Enhancing adolescent literacy achievement
416-420. doi:10.1598/rrq.42.3.6
Thompson, P. (2013). How digital native learners describe themselves. Education and
Walker, W. (2005). The strengths and weaknesses of research designs involving quantitative
doi:10.1177/136140960501000505.
Watkins, N., & Lindahl, K. (2010). Targeting content area literacy instruction to meet the needs
doi:10.1080/00940771.2010.11461718
Yin, R. (2009). Case study research (1st ed.). Los Angeles: SAGE Publications.