Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Jarred Joyce
Prof. Batty
English 101
23 May 2017
A Misinterpreted Hero: Redefining Admirable Behavior within a Novel
The debate of good and evil has plagued philosophers for generations. This argument was
admirable person. Saints and heroes throughout literature lead virtuous lives and are therefore
admirable characters who many aim to emulate in some way. Their stories exists to inspire and
revitalize the lives of their audience. Likewise, the novel Still Water Saints by Alex Espinoza is
filled with stories that awaken the good in humanity and remind its readers of the power of
determination. Although some might say that Dario, a significant character from this novel, is not
an admirable mentor to Perla because of how he leaves her, I cannot help but to disagree. Dario
consistently emulates saint-like behavior by devoting himself to helping people overcome daily
problems, and find a purpose in life, despite having a polio virus slowly consume him.
by Zack Knorr, a Philosophy professor at Los Angeles Valley College, on the Greek concept of
virtue. He explained that according the ancient Greek perspective, virtues are the skills or traits
needed to fulfill ones telos or purpose in life. It was also clarified that one is virtuous if they
fulfill their telos (Knorr). With this in mind, it could be argued that Saints, who some of the best
examples of virtue, exhibit similar characteristics to any well-intentioned, righteous person. They
traversed the land standing for morality and their lives were so impactful that they continue to
inspire vicariously through the lessons they left behind. In a similar manner, Darios journey has
Joyce 2
the potential to motivate people struggling to detach themselves from whatever is holding them
back in life.
In the novel Still Water Saints, Dario shows his saint-like determination most
prominently by not allowing his polio virus to keep him from walking unaided. Polio, otherwise
known as poliomyelitis virus, is defined by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
(CDC) as a crippling and potentially deadly infectious disease [that]...can invade an infected
persons brain and spinal cord. In this book, Dario explains that he has a limp because Polio
shrank [his] leg (79 Espinoza). The average person today is likely to seek a prosthetic, cane or
some form of support for their daily travels. However, Dario has the mental fortitude and
determination to walk with his own physical strength. His response to this debilitating virus is
not only an example of saint-like determination, it is also an inspiration for anyone in what
seems like an unbearable situation to continue perusing their goals and fulfill their telos.
(Knorr)
Darios resolve is not his only virtuous characteristic. He is a devout healer spiritual
otherwise known as a curandero who found that his purpose in life was to help others. (71
Espinoza) His main goal is to travel to various cities and establish a Botanica to enrich the lives
of the citizens living nearby. The Botanica offers teas and other, more spiritual forms of restoring
balance and comfort in ones life. (81 Espinoza) Additionally, each storefront is operated by a
former customer who has a gift for helping others. Dario seems to instantly connect with these
individuals and share his passion for lending a helping hand. For example, during one of their
initial interactions he told Perla, You do have power. I saw it when you walked in. Shining blue
around your whole body. Why dont you let me help you? (78 Espinoza). It was clear from the
beginning of their relationship that he was being genuine. In their own way, each new employee
Joyce 3
starts by helping Dario organize and maintain the work place but ultimately finds that operating
the Botanica is their purpose in life. In Perlas instance, taking care of others also facilitated her
mental and emotional recovery from learning she was unable to have children.
Once Dario knowns that his new successor can manage the store on their own, he leaves
town in search of the next city that is in need of a Botanica and start the whole thing over
again. (83 Espinoza) This is where the counter argument of Dario being an unreliable mentor
could be expressed. However, I argue that he was done teaching his beneficiary by this point. In
the same way that a graduate student would leave their department and teachers behind to
navigate the corporate world utilizing the lessons once taught by their favorite professor, it is up
to Perla and those like her to properly direct their customers towards a more self-gratifying way
of life without referring to Dario first. The student would be unjustified in calling their favorite
teacher a bad mentor simply because they chose to not provide further assistance after
author Joseph Campbell and his diagram The Heros Journey, any Saint is also a hero of their
time (See Figure 1 on page 5). The diagram is an illustration of the common aspects in the stories
of most heroes. Its steps explain that a hero will cross a threshold into the unknown to face many
trials and temptations, eventually experiencing a transformation and atonement before returning
to their daily lives. (Figure 1) Darios journey, though incomplete, follows the diagram and is
validation that he is a hero to all of those who frequent his botanical stores. His story is cratered
with trials like battling disease, separating from family, and immigrating to a country where the
official language is not his native tongue. I consider the crisis he experienced to be the
poliomyelitis virus. Polio is unforgiving and debilitating yet it never deters him from reaching
Joyce 4
the next city and fulfilling his telos. As previously mentioned, Darios venture is incomplete. It
appears to end at the ninth step of diagram called the result. This is a reference to the results of
Dario accomplishing his most significant goal; establishing a Botanica in multiple cities to guide
and comfort the lives of whomever chooses to seek their assistance. The following step in the
diagram is the return. Unfortunately, the reader does not know where he goes after leaving Agua
Mansa so it is not possible to see him return to status quo or normalcy. However, considering that
Darios character fits the majority of the Hero diagram, I conclude that he must be a hero.
Despite Darios unique approach to mentoring, his saint-like behavior is critical to the
development of the entire novel. His willingness to give away something as valuable as a
storefront so that others can feel purposeful, allowed Perla to overcome her tragedy. Even after
his departure Perla continued to turn to his lessons for guidance and comfort when she needed
advice. Darios character reaches into the lives of the readers and inspires those who are limited
by medical ailments to persevere and remember that just because one is ill does not mean they
have no purpose. Just as your favorite hero provides comfort and security to all people, Darios
actions altered the mind state in Agua Mansa so that they could all lead a more fulfilling life and
(Figure
1: The
Heros
Journey
Diagram, Hardy)
Works Cited
Joyce 6
Anonymous. "What is Polio?" Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention, 15 Oct. 2014. Web. 10 May 2017.
Espinoza, Alex. Still Water Saints. New York: Random House, 2007. Print.
Hardy, Robert. "The 12 Steps of the Hero's Journey: A Crash Course In Structuring Compelling
Stories." The Filmmaker's Process. Flim Process LLC, 04 Jan. 2016. Web. 25 May 2017.
Knorr, Zack. "The Theory of Forms." Los Angeles Valley College, Valley Glen. 18 Feb. 2016.
Lecture.
Winkler, Matthew. What Makes a Hero? Ted Talk, Ted Ed: Lessons Worth Sharing. 9 May.
2017. Video Lesson.