Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
asp
SUPREMECOURTOFINDIA
CaseStatus Status:PENDING
Statusof:WritPetition(Civil)259OF2017
MNSCORPSASSOCIATION.Vs.UNIONOFINDIA
Pet.Adv.:MR.SATYAMITRA
SubjectCategory:MATTERSPERTAININGTOARMEDFORCES&PARAMILITARYFORCES
Listed2timesearlierTherearenofurtherordersoflisting
Lastupdatedon03062017
Back
NIC
http://courtnic.nic.in/supremecourt/querycheck.asp 1/1
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
In the matter of
Versus
PAPER BOOK
In the matter of
Versus
INDEX
respondent.
dated nil.
respondent.
dated nil.
nil.
10. Annexure P-7
nil.
nil.
dated nil
30.04.04
30.03.2010
dated nil
nil
05.09.2016
05.09.2016
dated 17.02.2017
SYNOPSIS
Writ Petition (Civil) 744 of 2016 and Civil Appeal 7417 of 2010
where notices have been issued by this Honble Court. The Writ
Petition 806 of 2015 has been filed by the retired women officers
Service (MNS) branch and the Writ Petition 744 of 2016 has
Army. Both these petitions set out in considerable detail how the
use of stars and flag befitting the rank of Major General. She
Union has filed the Civil Appeal against the order of the Tribunal.
2. In Civil Appeal 7417 of 2010 this Court has made the following
by the
List the matter before the Hon'ble Court as per the Rules
with
3. In Writ Petition 806 of 2015 this Court has made the following
4. In Writ Petition 744 of 2016 this Court has made the following
2015.
5. This petition also follows in the same trend but deals with
shows that the officers of the MNS have always been treated as
was introduced between the pay of the officers of the MNS and
between Rs. 4,700 for the lower ranks upto Rs. 25,100 for the
higher ranks.
6. The other grievance set out in this petition relates to the time
reach the rank of Lt. Colonel. For example, in the Army Medical
Corps the officers would reach the rank of Lt. Colonel in 11 years
Corps, the Army Dental Corps, the Army Military Farms, the
Advocate Generals Branch, the Army Supply Corps and the Army
officers of the same rank in all the other branches of the regular
army. The principle is absolute: parity for the same rank in every
MNS are the officers of the regular army. Para 37 onwards deal
with how officers in the MNS have always been treated on par
with the other officers of the regular army of the same rank.
enactment of the Army Act 1950 and the Regulations and orders
55 demonstrates how the officers of the MNS are exactly like the
officers of the regular army in every respect. Para 59 onwards
of Europe and Canada treat MNS officers on par with all the
Para 95 onwards deals with the 7th Central Pay Commission pay
pay and the non treatment of the MNS as a distinct and separate
corps.
becoming a Republic.
22.07.1950 The Indian Army Act, 1911 stood repealed; and the
repealed.
titular rank.
Army.
MNS.
Commissioned Officers.
officers.
Pay Commission.
Commission.
VERSUS
Union of India
Ministry of Defence,
Government of India,
TO,
OF INDIA.
Nursing Service.
notion that nurses are somewhat inferior due the work they
do. They number around 4600 and are being treated unfairly
of the Army served in the MNS who all have dedicated their
filed a Writ Petition in this Court for protecting the rank and
could have a legal nexus with the issues involved in this Writ
short) has its origin from the Indian Military Nursing Service
(hereinafter called IMNS) which came into being with the Indian
the Allied Forces in the British Indian Army; the origins of the
India. These nurses in due course laid the foundation for the
and persons subject to the Indian Army Act, 1911. The said
Nursing Service).
2
(2) [***]
10. The Parliament repealed the Indian Army Act, 1911 and enacted
the Army Act, 1950; and by this repeal the Indian Military
which laid down the Terms and Conditions of Service for the
continuously.
status granted under the Army Act, 1950 in the regular Army
8
commission in the regular Army are liable for service in any part
12. With the coming into force of the Army Act, 1950 and issuance
Army Act, 1950 under Section 2(1)(a) of the Act. The service
promotion.
Sister - Lieutenant,
*Matron - Major
Matrons.
10
14. Since the creation of the MNS through Army Instruction 274/50;
like other officers of the regular Army serving in other Arms and
Section 10 of the Army Act, 1950, and the Act applies to them
Form of Oath
Form of Affirmation
17. That officers serving in all Arms and Services of the regular Army
18. Further, the Army Rules, 1954 are Statutory Rules made by the
The Section 193 of the Army Act, 1950 speaks about Publication
19. Neither the Army Act, 1950 nor the Army Rules, 1954 mention
20. The Section 2 of the Army Act, 1950 describes the person
is under Sub- Section (1) clause (a); and cannot be under any
of 1948);
forces;
Army.
(2) Every person subject to this Act under Cls. (a) to 2[(g)] of
service.
16
21. According to the above stated Section 2(2) of the Army Act,
1950, the Persons subject to the Act under Section 2 (1) clause
The Rule 16A of the Army Rules, 1954 had laid down the
manner provided in Section 2 (2) of the Act. The said Rules have
Regular Army. The persons subject to the Army Act, 1950 under
Section 2(1)(a) of the Act can only be retired from the regular
Section 2(2) of the Act. This leaves no manner of doubt that the
officers serving in the MNS are officers of the regular Army. The
in which they
whichever is earlier.
17
be
Service;
rank of Colonel;
22. The Rule 2(f) of the Army Rules, 1954, reads as under:
Thus under the Rule 2(f) of the Army Rules the Officers in
reads as under:
18
23. Further, the Army Rules, 1954 being Statutory Rules shall
Lieut.
Captain
Major
Lt. Colonel
Colonel
above.
Services.
25. However, the Section 12 of the Army Act, 1950 puts restrictions
behalf.
Act, 1950.
21
Further, the Army Act, 1950 applies to them under Section 2(1)
(a) of the Act. Further, the persons subject to the Army Act,
1950 under Section 2(1)(a) of the Act can only be retired from
the regular Army under Rule 16A of the Army Rules, 1954 as
doubt that the officers serving in the MNS are officers of the
Union in any part of the world, hence is part of the regular Army
said regulations stated that they will rank equally with male
officers of the same titular rank. The relevant parts of the 1962
Army, 1962; the Chief of Army Staff clarified the issue of saluting
the MNS officers through Army Order 501/63. The relevant parts
times.
29. That in the year 1973, the AO 501/63 was cancelled through
Army Order 353/73 and the Chief of the Army Staff again
23
with service caps will salute service officers senior to them and
return the salutes of junior officers and soldiers at all times. The
officers of the regular Army. True copy of the Army Order 353/73
Medical Services and the Surety. Before this date, there was no
31. That in the year 1977 the Government issued the Army
regular Army. All the present and past officers in the MNS
32. That with the creation of the MNS forming part of the Regular
the status, rank, duties etc for officers in the MNS in exercise of
the powers under the Army Act, 1950. On 15.03.1982, The Chief
of Army Staff through the Army Order 11/82; laid down the
and the earlier Army Order 120/73 on the subject was cancelled.
in honouring the women, the only all women Corps of the Army
that is the MNS was placed first among the Medical Services at
regular Army were placed first among the Medical Services. The
7. Medical Services
(a) MNS
(b) AMC
(c) ADC
33. The Government of India issued Regulations for the Army, 1987
includes the Army Reserve and the Territorial Army, when called
26
out on permanent service along with the Arms and all Services
the regular Army, (ii) the Army Reserve, and (iii) the Territorial
34. The persons subject to the Army Act, 1950 under Section 2(1)(a)
of the Act can only be retired from the regular Army under Rule
MNS are officers of the regular Army. Hence the Regulations for
58, 65, 66, 67, 75, 76, 77, 81, 105, 109, 255, 341, 618, 619,
of the regular Army. Both 1962 and 1987 Regulations laid down
that officers in the MNS would rank equally with male officers of
35. Further, the Para 255 of the Regulations for the Army, 1987
was further reiterated when the COAS through the Army Orders
Arms/ Services and Units of the Army. That the MNS is not
to any department.
3(xviii) of the Army Act, 1950 and MNS is a Corps of the Regular Army.
37. The report of the 5th Central Pay Commission 1997, accepted by
cadres.
38. Officers in the MNS have always been treated on par with the
xiii. Liability to serve in the Army, Navy and Air Force like
xxiii. Eligible for and also awarded with the same awards
substantive rank held the officer. The Army in general does not
Army; the General Service cadre officers of the Army are drawn
from the clerical staff and are employed in the clerical and
the Army Medical Corps officers are the doctors who are
employed in the health care; the Army Dental Corps officers are
the dentists of the Army entrusted with the dental hygiene and
care; the Army Intelligence Corps officers are responsible for the
vehicles; the Military Farms officers are the ones who are
Postal Service officers handles the postal mails; and the Judge
care of the animals dogs, horses etc. in the Army. None of these
go to the battle field and fight the enemy like the officers of the
Signals etc., but are granted the same status as the fighting
Arms officers.
40. It is an accepted fact that the officers of the Army do not form a
Arms and Arms Support, no matter they may all be drawing the
same salary, holding the same rank, wearing the same uniform
and serving the same employer with similar service benefits. The
Army titled Military Law Officer Training School AMC Centre &
even today.
33
point out to the MNS officers and others that they do not have
the rank and status of officers of the regular Army. In this book
Army Act, 1911 with Army Act 1950. Similar version of the
43. After the year 2000 an issue arose relating to medical officers
namely:
34
44. Based on this observation the central government and the Chief
in the statutes were not brought to the notice of the Court and
the fact that the Ordinance relied upon had been impliedly
have been correct prior to the Army Act, 1950 can no longer
changes that have taken place and have been set out in detail in
Court.
parties.
48. After the above observation by the Supreme Court, the Army
the Army made an order stripping the car flags and star plates
from the official cars used by the senior MNS officers of the
Service
49. That the order dated 30.04.04 by the Army stripping the car
flags and star plates from the official cars used by the senior
India & Ors., and the decision of the Armed Forces Tribunal
50. This case was also wrongly pleaded before the Tribunal by the
under:
under
starting with the Army Act, 1950 and various Army Instructions
officers and others that they do not have the rank and status of
(IAP) dealing with medical services issued by the Chief of the Air
erstwhile IMNS are nothing but the same organisation and the
self explanatory and explicit in all terms and removes the cloud
Sl MNS IMNS
No.
1. Officers of the MNS/ Other Subject to the IMNS
to the Army Act, 1950 and Indian Army Act, 1911 and
Army.
Army.
provided in Section 16 of
commissioning.
Rules, 1954.
1954.
combatants according to
Rules, 1954.
the MNS, like all other the Ordinance and the Rules
1950).
Services/ Arms.
army.
44
13. Officers of the MNS like all Liable to serve only with the
world.
the Army.
years.
male officers.
18. Only the persons subject to Rule 16A of the Army Rules,
the Army Act, 1950 under 1954 was not applicable to the
1954 as provided in
56. That the Army is trying to rewrite the military law to down grade
the officers of the MNS from being officers of the regular Army
stating that the officers of the MNS are not officers of the
Army Nursing Corps and they form an integral part of the Royal
Army. They wear the same uniforms, bear the same insignias
and ranks as officers of the regular army, salute and are saluted
60. This is the situation in the US as well. Recently, the head of the
61. As in the UK and the US so too in Nepal, the nursing officers are
like any other officer of the regular Army on par in every respect
and they wear the same uniform. This is also the situation in
47
62. That, India routinely trains the Army Officer Nurses from
Germany, UK, USA etc. Some of them like USA and UK got
separate branches for Army, Navy and Air Force. And in the
63. That the women officers of the MNS are also routinely required
staff who are placed under them. She handles combatant male
48
them the basic nursing skills. All these different roles, they have
commissioned ranks.
Island.
65. The officers of the MNS have served on the fringes of the battle
independence. The officers in the MNS are still caring for the
sick and wounded soldiers in the terrorist torn North and North
East to the field area bunkers just a stones throw away from the
Cambodia, and Sierra Leone etc. and with IPKF in Sri Lanka, also
training for the officers of the MNS. Every officer of every branch
of the Army gets weapon and arms training. This is true of all
are required to go near the battle front. The officers of the MNS
may be ordered
68. In India the officers of the MNS have been posted at J&K where
the reach of small arms fire from across the border. The Tangdar
the militants.
51
69. In Assam and other parts of the North East the officers of the
the officers of the MNS are posted in these disturbed areas. Not
only are the officers of the MNS required to work in the hospitals
and the said instruction or orders issued orally are for the sole
under:
ARTICLE 22
charge.
71. That the Medical personnel have the right to bear arms and may
72. That the Army in order to discriminate the officers in the MNS
them of the right to bear arms and use them in their own
Lt. Col. (then Major) Saroja Kumari Jhuthu an officer in the MNS.
73. Lt. Col. Jhithus illustrious career started with her being adjudged
the Best Shot during the Initial Nursing Officers Course in 1991
bronze medals for the Indian Army and made the Nation proud.
74. Lt.Col (Mrs) Birmati is another woman officer in the MNS who
rifle, 10 m air rifle and big bore events for the Indian Army. She
54
vogue for the MNS officers. However, the Indian Army trying
erase its own past by denying the contribution made by the MNS
officers in shooting.
75. The officers in the MNS often travel with persons from other
zones and insurgency areas thus facing the same level of threat
76. The Army found a novel way around by sending the officers in
(pages ... to ...); attachment plan for year 2016 MNS Officers
77. The distinction between combat and non combat officers of the
them. Not only are they required to serve in such places, but
78. That 5th CPC Report mentioned that the Army proposed to
grant the same pay scales to the MNS officers as for other
79. This clearly establishes the fact that the Army intended to
treat the women officers in the MNS at par with the officers
from other cadres of the Army at least till the year 1986 (4th
CPC); and wanted them to have the same pay scales as other
80. That Armys proposal to the 5th CPC for MNS (Para 147.40 of
entrants.
81. This shows that in the year 1996 the Army proposed the same
rank pay for all the officers serving in the MNS as applicable to
ranked officers.
82. That in the year 2008, the 6th Central Pay Commission had
83. That on the publication of the 6th CPC report, the Chief of
requested for lowering the Pay and Grade Pay of MNS officers.
is attached.
Army could have had the same basic pay as for the Doctors
60
and other officers way back in 1986 had the 4th CPC accepted
84. That the officers in the MNS had slightly lower Pay, than the
hitherto had no Rank Pay like the MNS officers. Para 147.41 of
85. The 6th CPC had considered the proposals of the Army the
the MNS officers on the same Pay Band and Grade Pay, as
starting scale
Pay Bands and Grade Pay to the officers in the MNS. However
other officers.
vis-a-vis AMC officers, the Chief of the Army Staff had alleged
upgradation of Basic Pay, Grade Pay and the hence the status
Doctors.
87. That, the doctors working in the Central Health Scheme has a
MNS and other Arms and Services of the Army. The doctors in
88. That the Government under pressure from the Army had
cadres;
pay to the Nursing Officers than the Doctors and other branch
90. That, the Command and Control in the Army always flowed
from the Army Act, 1950 and the Rules made thereunder; not
from the Pay band and Grade of its Officers. There are
for Lt Colonels in MNS had alleged that the officers in the MNS
stated that,
92. The Honble High Court of Delhi in its order dated 12.03.2010
America".
66
that,
combat in nature.
observed that,
93. That since the officers in the MNS are granted commissioned
rank they fall under the term combatants under this Rule
MNS are combatants just like all other officers of the regular
Army; though like other women officers in the Army they are
No. Educational
Qualification
68
Mechanical etc.
Engineers,
dissemination
General's Service
Branch
Corps Service
94. The 6th CPC in its report at Para 2.3.21 had recommended for
August 2008 is still valid and the said time bound promotions
commission commission
commission/
1 year
5 years
95. That the 7th CPC at Para 4.2.9 of its report mentioned about
the basic pay (pay in the pay band + grade pay) for the
1.1429)......
96. That the 7th CPC recommended a fitment factor of 2.57 times
reads as,
percent.
99. That the 7th CPC at Para 5.2.7 had given the fitment factor of
2.57 times of the basic pay as for the civilian employees. The
personnel only.
4600 MNS officers) is the same. Para 5.2.5 of the Report reads
as,
applied for arriving at the entry pay for the MNS officers. The
102. However, the 7th CPC had assured a minimum fitment factor of
Officers
Formula Formula
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
band 3)
band 4)
after Col
103. As seen from the above table, all ranks in the MNS except Lt
and Lt Col gets only less than the minimum assured 2.57
shows the figures arrived for the MNS officers of various ranks
2009. However, like all other women officers who are also
the MNS are also commissioned in to the regular Army and are
78
105. That the 7th CPC at Para 5.1.18 had recommended that the
106. As the 7th CPC had placed the women officers in the MNS on a
lower Pay Level the women officers in the MNS will not rank
of the Para 733 of the regulations which laid down the order
79
officers of the Army, Indian Navy and Indian Air Force. The
Engineers.
107. The lower Pay Levels also contradicts the provisions of the
regulations for the Army, 1987. The relevant portion reads as,
cadres;
108. Hence, the lower Pay Levels as recommended by the 7th CPC
other male and other women officers of the Army of the same
the 7th CPC and the Commission had considered only the
existing Grade Pay and Pay Band of the officers and had made
109. That the 7th CPC at Para 5.2.22 had made recommendations
110. That, the Army and 4th CPC had included the MNS officers as
part of the officers cadres of the Army. Para 147.39 of 5th CPC
111. The 5th CPC at Para 147.3 listed the MNS among the Cadre
112. The 6th CPC also included MNS among the officers cadres of
113. That at the 7th CPC had considered the MNS as separate from
the Defence Forces, the Para 1.20 of its report reads as,
83
the 7th CPC had deviated from that established position and
time.
116. That in the Army the status and pay of an officer is decided by
the substantive rank held the officer. The Army does not
duties. Hence in the case of the Army the pay is related to the
Hence in the Army the job is synonymous with the rank held
women officers serving in the MNS the equal pay for equal
rank is not justified. The Army had tried to set the records
correct by proposing to the 4th CPC, the same pay to the MNS
85
not accepted, the 5th pay commission also did not grant the
equal pay to the MNS officers as for other service officers. But
by the time of the 6th CPC the Army also started discriminating
equal pay as granted by the 6th CPC. The 6th CPC also was
officers in the MNS. The following table gives the actual job
No. Educational
Qualification
helicopters Arms
making etc.
communication Arms
equipments
Mechanical etc.
Engineers,
battle
dissemination
Police Service
Service
General's Service
88
Branch
Corps Service
canines etc.
only) Service
personnel
only)
AMC) personnel
89
officers from the Services stream and Arms/ support Arms are
decides the pay band and grade pay of an officer in the Indian
Army is his / her rank not his / her profession. The holding of
certain rank in the Army has been treated as the work and
equal pay has been extended to equal work and all the
been paid the same rank based pay, except for the women
officers in the MNS. That the equal pay for equal rank has
119. That the equal pay for equal rank has been denied by
be paid at the same Pay Levels like the other women officers
deciding the pay in the case of the women officers in the MNS
service benefits...
upon their rank. The criterion which decides the pay band and
his / her rank, not his / her profession. The holding of certain
rank in the Army has been treated as the work and equal pay
in the different Arms and Services of the Army has been paid
the same rank based pay, except for the women officers in the
MNS. That the equal pay for equal rank has been denied to
the women officers serving in the MNS and this job based
122. That the true typed copies of the extracts of the 7th Pay
them.
True typed copy of the extract of the relevant Paras of the 7th
123. That the petitioner has filed a petition in the High Court of
the Leave as prayed for was granted. The subject petition was
20
125. That the petitioner has not filed any other writ petition before
same is pending till date as the Union of India has not filed
126. That the Annexures filed along with the Writ Petition are true
127. That the petitioner did not have any alternate and efficacious
128. That the present Petition is being filed through the Vice
____to____).
94
129. That the present petitioners have not filed any other petition
130. That the petitioners have not filed any other writ petition
before this court or any other High Court or before the Honble
GROUNDS
Constitution.
Act, 1950.
the Army Act, 1950 and Rules made there under like
20.6.08.
97
through the Army Act, 1950 and the Rules made there
under.
to other professionals.
the Military Nursing Service will rank equally with the male
PRAYER
100
(b) For an order granting the same Military Service Pay and
September 2016.
101
Arms/Services.
Filed By
Drawn By:
Drawn on:
Filed on: