Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
www.elsevier.com/locate/geomorph
Abstract
This paper focuses on origin, morphology and evolution of seven landslide dams in southeastern Sicily. These landforms are
part of a set of 146 landslides recently recognised in this area, which was hitherto considered to have little or no slope instability.
Southeastern Sicily consists of a plateau (the Hyblaean Mountains) incised by canyons and surrounded by lower lands. It is
underlain mostly by subhorizontal, moderately to well-lithified carbonate rocks. Relief is low. Several lines of evidence justify
the assumption of a seismic trigger for the landslides in this area: (1) the geo-climatic environment is not favourable to
landsliding, (2) low-angle basal shear surfaces are very frequent, (3) landslide distribution is consistent with the known
magnitude distance relationships for earthquake-induced landslides, (4) historical documents testify to earthquake-triggered
slope instability and (5) a specific landslide can be exactly dated. The phenomena illustrated here include six rock slides (one
with a debris-flow component) and one rock fall. Slip surfaces are mostly non-circular. Landslide volume ranges from about
50 103 to 34 106 m3. With reference to the Costa and Schuster [Geol. Soc. Am. Bull. 100 (1988) 1054] classification of
landslide dams, five cases belong to type II (spanning the entire valley), and two to type IV (failures from both valley sides, with
frontal or side contact between failed masses). With reference to Crozier and Pillans [Catena 18 (1991) 471] classification of
landslide lakes, all cases show a main valley lake while tributary valley, back and supra lakes are sporadically present. One
damming is attributable to the 1693 earthquake with certainty; another damming, to the same earthquake with high probability.
Three dams were reincised, one breached or reincised, one is slightly reincised and two more or less intact; correspondingly,
five silting up deposits were reincised, one is being reincised at present and two are still under formation. D 2002 Elsevier
Science B.V. All rights reserved.
0169-555X/02/$ - see front matter D 2002 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 1 6 9 - 5 5 5 X ( 0 2 ) 0 0 0 7 4 - 0
204 P.G. Nicoletti, M. Parise / Geomorphology 46 (2002) 203222
tended watershed and hydrologic regime. In general The most common types by far are type II (61%)
terms, landslide dams are more common in steep- and type III (28%); all other types account for 2 3%
walled and narrow valleys, because generally, these each.
possess higher landslide susceptibility and may be The types of landslides that form dams were also
easily blocked even by comparatively small debris examined: results show that dams derive commonly
masses. As concerns longevity, resistance to erosion is from rock and earth slumps and slides (50%), debris,
the key factor, and is favoured by materials consisting mud or earth flows (25%), rock or debris avalanches
of large and well-graded particles (Swanson et al., (19%), while sensitive-clay failures, and rock and
1985; Schuster and Costa, 1986; Schuster, 1993). earth falls account for the remaining 6%.
Landslide dams have been recognised all over the As concerns the triggering processes of dam-form-
world, and more or less detailed lists or descriptions ing landslides, rainfall and snowmelt account for
exist for many areas. Without pretending to compile an about 60%, earthquakes for about 30%, volcanic
exhaustive review, we may mention: the cases from the activity and other causes for the rest.
United States, Pakistan, Canada, Japan and China, Size of landslide dams varies in an enormous
collected in a book edited by Schuster (1986); the 38 range. There may be dams only 1 or 2 m high, and
landslide-dammed lakes, with a very broad age range, there is the 570-m-high dam emplaced across the
in a list from New Zealand (Adams, 1981); the Pleis- River Murgab (Tajikistan) by the 2 2.5 109-m3
tocene occurrences in the Argentine Cordillera, dis- Usoy rock slide/rock avalanche in 1911, behind which
cussed by Trauth and Strecker (1999); many cases from still extends a lake 500 m deep (Gaziev, 1984;
the Alps mentioned or described by Abele (1974), and Zolotarev et al., 1986). Also, the largest failure known
Eisbacher and Clague (1984); and the almost 100 cases on dry land, a prehistoric, 20 109-m3 rock ava-
from the Italian Alps, described by Pirocchi (1991). A lanche in SW Iran, dammed rivers. Along the R.
large catalogue of 463 cases from around the world has Seymareh (often spelled Saidmarreh), from which
been compiled by Costa and Schuster (1991). the landslide took its name, a lake almost 40 km long
Results of systematic analysis, concerning both and 130 m deep was formed, and a smaller lake was
geological and engineering aspects of the matter, are formed along the left-hand tributary Kashgan (Harri-
mostly contained in the papers by Schuster and Costa son and Falcon, 1938; Watson and Wright, 1967;
(1986), Costa and Schuster (1988), and Schuster Shoaei and Ghayoumian, 1997).
(1993, 2000). These authors proposed a classification Landslide dams may fail. We leave apart, for the
of landslide dams into six types (cf. Fig. 3 in Costa sake of brevity, the mechanisms of failure, for which
and Schuster, 1988) that will be used also in the reference can be made to the aforementioned papers
present paper: by Schuster and Costa (1986), Costa and Schuster
(1988) and Schuster (1993). In terms of hazard, dam
type I dams which do not span the valley from side failure represents the most hazardous process linked
to side; with landslide dams (Costa, 1988), the secondary
type II dams which do span the valley and may run hazardous process being backwater flooding. Of the
up the opposite slope; dams that failed, 89% did so within 1 year, and 11%
type III dams which span the valley and, in addition, lasted more. Cases of failure after 28, 40, and even
move considerably up- and downvalley; 131 years are cited in Schuster (1993). Catastrophic
type IV dams which are formed by contemporaneous flood waves may result if dam breaching progresses
failures from both valley sides, followed by quickly and a big mass of water is stored in the lake.
frontal or side contact between the two Backwater flooding may be a slow process, depending
masses; on the volume of basin and rate of inflow, but may
type V dams which are caused by multiple lobes of a cause further instability of valley sides and great
given landslide; economic losses.
type VI dams which occur when failure surface(s) Southeastern Sicily is a seismically active area,
extend(s) under the streambed, which is then and consists basically of a plateau incised by can-
raised when the landslide moves. yons. So, bearing in mind the reference picture out-
P.G. Nicoletti, M. Parise / Geomorphology 46 (2002) 203222 205
Fig. 1. Landslide dam (L) and lake-fill sediments (S) along an unnamed tributary of Fiume Irminio (dam no. 7 in the text), SE Sicily. The
sheer landslide scar is visible in the background. Note the subhorizontal rock stratification, which is typical of the considered territory. Cf.
with Fig. 10.
lined above, the presence of landslide dams is by no drainage basins averages only 0.025, indicating that
means exceptional (Fig. 1). However, so far, the relief is generally low. However, canyons are often
valuable clues provided by historical records had deeply incised, and their flanks, though not particu-
gone practically unobserved and only a pair of these larly high, may be steeply sloping. The plateau is
landforms had previously been mentioned in the surrounded by lower lands.
modern literature (ESE, 1951; Campisi, 1961), even In lithological terms (Fig. 2), moderately to well-
though without link to historical information. A re- lithified clastic carbonate rocks and marlstones under-
cent survey has revealed the certain existence of 7 lie most of the Hyblaean Mountains; thin claystone
landslide dams, dealt with here, and the possible layers are locally present. In the northern sector, these
existence of 12 more. materials are mantled by, or locally interbedded with,
Southeastern Sicily is among the four Italian extrusive basic rocks of both subaerial and submarine
regions where, according to a recent seismological origin. Around the Hyblaean Plateau medium- to fine-
study based on analysis of historical and instrumental grained, unlithified to moderately lithified clastic
seismicity (Boschi et al., 1995a), the probability of rocks crop out (Lentini, 1984, 1986; Beccaluva et
occurrence of crustal earthquakes with magnitude al., 1993; Grasso, 1997). Both in the Plateau and
equal to or greater than 5.9 is high. A better under- around it, dip of strata is generally in the range 0
standing of paleoseismic evidence would obviously 10j, and steeper only locally. Jointing is overall
help in managing the resulting hazard (Mc Calpin and moderate. Most of southeastern Sicily belongs to a
Nelson, 1996). To this aim, landslides, and above all foreland area, which accounts for this relatively uni-
landslide dams and lakes, with records of paleoearth- form and undisturbed geology.
quakes hopefully stored in their silting up deposits, Climate is typically Mediterranean, viz. hot-tem-
could be of great use. perate with dry summers. Annual precipitation ranges
from 400 mm in some coastal localities to 600 mm in
the outer rim of the Hyblaean Plateau and, gradually
2. Geologic and climatic setting of the area increasing, to 1000 1100 mm in two small, summit
areas inland (Adorni and Aureli, 1989). Almost 80%
The central plateau of southeastern Sicily, the of annual precipitation falls between October and
Hyblaean Mountains, attains its maximum elevation March, and rainstorms are frequent. The dammed
of 986 m about 40 km inland. Slopes are seldom of watersheds are small, so that streams are prone to
more than 200 250 m in relief, and relief ratio of the flash floods.
206
P.G. Nicoletti, M. Parise / Geomorphology 46 (2002) 203222
Fig. 2. Geologic sketch of SE Sicily (simplified after Lentini, 1984). The core of the area consists of a plateau attaining a maximum altitude of 986 m and radially incised by valleys
often showing a canyon morphology: these are the Hyblaean Mountains, in which most landslides lie. The territory surrounding the Hyblaean core presents hilly to plain morphology
and a limited landslide presence. Numbered sites are those dealt with in this paper. Seismogenic structures suggested by various scholars as being responsible for the main historical
earthquakes (Table 2) are shown in the inset. Whatever the case, landslides cannot be more than 100 km far away of seismogenic structures and, actually, distance is often much
smaller.
P.G. Nicoletti, M. Parise / Geomorphology 46 (2002) 203222 207
Table 1
Earthquake-triggered landslides in southeastern Sicily: typological distribution
Type Slide Lateral spread Fall Flow Multitypea Uncertain Total
n (%) 132 (90.4%), of which: 77 (52.7%) 3 (2.1%) 2 (1.4%) 1 (0.7%) 6 (4.1%) 2 (1.4%) 146 (100%)
upon circular surface, 43 (29.5%)
upon listric or planar or bi-planar
surface, 12 (8.2%) upon a surface
of complex or uncertain shape
a
Slope movements involving a combination of two or more types.
As it may be easily inferred from the description and the reasons for the attribution to seismic triggers
above, landslide susceptibility must be low, as long as are discussed.
static conditions are considered. In fact, literature on (1) Slide is by far the most common type (90%;
SE Sicily hardly mentions landslide activity (cf. Table 1).
reviews in Agnesi and Lucchesi, 1988; Nicoletti et (2) In most cases, the style of activity is multiple,
al., 1999a). However, historical sources provide evi- and very rarely complex or composite.
dence of some seismically induced instability. (3) The material is moderately to well-lithified rock
in 128 cases, poorly lithified to unlithified rock in the
remaining 18 cases (Fig. 2).
3. Landslides and earthquakes in southeastern (4) Slip surfaces of both circular and listric forms
Sicily are common. Listric surfaces, in particular, are fre-
quent in the larger landslides. A paramount point is
3.1. Landslide features that, whatever their shape, slip surfaces are commonly
of low angle. The ratio H/L between crown toe
A reconnaissance survey performed in southeastern height difference and planimetric length is shown in
Sicily identified with reasonable probability 146 land- Fig. 3: more than 70% of cases are inclined less than
slides, which could be attributed to seismic triggers 20j, and more than 90% less than 30j.
(distribution is shown in Fig. 2). Nearly all of them (5) Size is large (50 103 to 100 106 m3).
were previously unknown (Nicoletti et al., 1998, (6) Age is old.
1999a,b, 2000; Nicoletti and Catalano, 2000). (7) The present state of activity is dormant. Age
Landslide characteristics are now illustrated and state cause morphology to be often subdued.
(nomenclature follows Cruden and Varnes, 1996), Probably, they also explain, at least partly, why most
Fig. 3. Angular diagram of H/L ratios of the 141 cases in which data are available (of these, 129 are slides). Angular values (a = arctan H/L)
show the actual gradients. Note that more than 70% and 90% of cases are inclined less than 20j and 30j, respectively. Between brackets, L
values per unit H are also given.
208 P.G. Nicoletti, M. Parise / Geomorphology 46 (2002) 203222
3.2. Seismicity
209
210 P.G. Nicoletti, M. Parise / Geomorphology 46 (2002) 203222
(3) surficial/bedrock geology in the source area of S. Giuseppe (Fig. 5), and dammed the confluence
the landslide; between the cava itself (watershed: 0.6 km2), and an
(4) initial cause of the landslide; unnamed left tributary (watershed: 2.8 km2). Failures
(5) height, width, length, and volume of landslide affected slopes underlain by subhorizontally bedded
dam; limestone and marly limestone, with thick calcarenite
(6) length, width, depth, and volume of impound- layers at the top.
ment; The southern rock slide (no. 1) is 1.8 106 m3 in
(7) physical characteristics of geologic materials volume, is about 250 m long, about 500 m wide, and
making up the dam; an estimated 30 40 m thick. The inclination of the
(8) presence of seepage, piping, or slope failure on head is only slightly smaller than the inclination of the
faces of dam; source slope and no graben-like form is present, so that
(9) longevity of landslide dam and impoundment; this rock slide should possess a circular, low-curvature,
(10) mechanism of failure of landslide dam; slip surface. The northern rock slide (no. 2) volume is
(11) characteristics of the breach; 1 106 m3. It is about 300 m long and 400 m wide;
(12) estimation or measurement of peak discharge; displaced material is subhorizontally bedded, and is an
(13) attenuation of flood wave downstream. estimated 30 m thick. In this case, the presence of a
crest in the slide head indicates that a graben-like
Not all elements are yet known and in any case, structure formed as a consequence of displacement
several points, particularly, but not exclusively, the last along a listric slip surface. Secondary failures charac-
four, are hardly applicable to the dams dealt with terise the distal portion of both accumulations.
here. With reference to the aforementioned classifica-
Lakes were distinguished following the classifica- tions, this blockage belonged to the rare type IV, and
tion by Crozier and Pillans (1991): both lakes were main valley lakes.
Discontinuous terraces, which at least partly repre-
(1) back lakes, which are located between displaced sent remnants of lake-fill deposits after reincision, are
mass and back scarp; visible for a length of about 200 m in the Cava S.
(2) supra lakes, located in depressions on the Giuseppe, and for about 800 m in the unnamed
displaced mass; tributary (Fig. 5). Their maximum width is about 50
(3) main valley lakes, blocked by debris within the m. Waterfalls link the terraced segments of the two
same valley from which the slide originated; valleys to the segment that follows their confluence.
(4) tributary lakes, formed as the toe of the landslide Since terraces are located at different levels, and land-
blocked the exits of tributaries to the main valley. slides are and were suitable for reactivation, a multiple
sequence of damming infilling reincision may have
Due to the small extent of watersheds and the taken place. Because of possible reactivations, rural
precipitation regime, all lakes, except that in site no. settlements in both sites are at risk, including agricul-
5, are and were ephemeral in character. tural and some residential structures, plus a small
Italian site names, after 1:25 000 topographic maps, aqueduct at site no. 2. The blockage, totally reincised,
have been retained in the descriptions that follow. A has no more storing capability and presents no risk.
few definitions will help the reader: cava is a local term
for a narrow canyon with steeply inclined to subvertical 4.2. Dam no. 3
walls; fiume means river; rio and torrente indicate an
ephemeral stream; contrada is a term indicating a Dam no. 3 was caused by a rock slide of about
country area; costa indicates here a steep slope. 1.5 106 m3 emplaced at the confluence of Cava S.
Calogero (watershed: 5.6 km2) with its left-hand
4.1. Dam nos. 1 and 2 tributary Cava Carosello (watershed: 4.6 km2) (Fig. 5).
The landslide is now about 400 m long and 600 m
These landslide dams are described together since wide; maximum thickness is about 40 m. Also in this
they are located on the opposite valley sides of Cava case, the presence of graben-like structures suggests
212 P.G. Nicoletti, M. Parise / Geomorphology 46 (2002) 203222
Fig. 5. Geomorphological sketch of site nos. 1 to 3 (encircled numbers for location). Contour interval is 100 m.
P.G. Nicoletti, M. Parise / Geomorphology 46 (2002) 203222 213
that motion developed along a listric slip surface. reincision seems likely. There was a main valley
Secondary slope movements occurred along the accu- lake in Cava S. Calogero and a tributary valley
mulation toe. Geology is as in cases nos. 1 and 2. The lake in Cava Carosello.
displaced material still preserves subhorizontal bed- If landslide reactivation were to occur, there could
ding. be a degree of hazard for a rural settlement and a
The accumulation is not in contact with the oppo- Foresters hut located upon the rock-slide body, and
site valley side, but silting up deposits upstream from perhaps also an archaeological site of ancient tan-
the landslide body indicate that such a contact existed neries in the Cava Carosello (Ragonese, 1972, 1976
in the past; therefore, damming was of type II. 1977) could be at risk. No blockage failure can occur,
Discontinuous terraces, at least partly consisting of due to complete reincision.
silting up sediments, extend upstream from the dam-
ming site for about 1000 m in the Cava S. Calogero, 4.3. Dam no. 4
200 m in the Cava Carosello, and have a maximum
width of 40 50 m. The terraced valley segments end This blockage along the Torrente Pisciarello (water-
with waterfalls (Fig. 5). shed: 6 km2) was caused by a translational rock slide
Similarly to site nos. 1 and 2, and for the same (Fig. 6) involving a volume of 2 106 m3 of subhori-
reasons, a multiple sequence of damming infilling zontally bedded calcarenite and marly limestone. It
Fig. 6. Stereogram (year 1966) and section of landslide dam no. 4, in the Torrente Pisciarello valley. The planar slip surface of the landslide, as
well as the silting up deposits still in a comparatively early stage, can be readily appreciated. Average scale is about 1:30 000. Published by the
permission of the Italian Air Force (Concessione Aeronautica MilitareR.G.S. no. 207 del 23.06.1998).
214 P.G. Nicoletti, M. Parise / Geomorphology 46 (2002) 203222
had a heavy impact upon local economy because, apart New failures from the same source area, if occurring,
from destroying three mills and killing the occupants, may be hazardous for a hut and for agricultural
it interrupted the water supply to sugar cane planta- activity. As concerns the possibility of dam failure,
tions and a sugar factory downstream. This is likely to it can be observed that material is well-lithified rock
be the reason why, unlike other cases, this specific still retaining original structures (though fractured),
landslide was well remembered. It is documented in a the watershed is small, the outlet is only about 20 m
book of local history published by a reliable author (Di higher than the silting up sediments, and no seepage
Maria, 1745), who provides the following description or piping seems present; all in all, probability of
while dealing with the 11 January 1693 earthquake (p. failure seems low.
129 130, translation is ours): [the mountain] split
across and nearly half of it, after detaching rampa- 4.4. Dam no. 5
geously, plunged into the valley bed. . .and three mills
with all people inside remained beneath its portentous In this site, the Fiume Anapo was dammed by a
bulk. Notice in Fig. 6 the planar slip surface, fully rock fall coming from the northern valley flank (Fig.
justifying the sudden development described by Di 7). The event has not been dated with certainty, but
Maria. The landslide is further documented by archival the evidence provided by a historical source indicates
papers concerning the channel system soon built in that it occurred in 1693 (Boccone, 1697, p. 19; trans-
order to by-pass the blockage and take again the water lation is ours): Not far from the territory of Cassaro,
to plantations and factory (Gringeri Pantano, 1996), two very great rocks detached from two prominences
and by the plan of an aqueduct, drawn in 1887, which at the ends of two mountains, between which a river
specifically mentions the 1693 landslide (Gringeri streamed through a long valley. Both rocks plunged
Pantano et al., 2002). Since the detached mass is in down, and stopped in the defile of the valley and,
contact with the opposite slope of the canyon, this coming in contact to each other, clogged the passage
blockage is attributable to type II. of the water to such an extent that it, being unable to
The accumulation, about 250 m wide and 370 m flow out either underground or laterally, filled the
long, is about 60 m high above the valley bottom; it valley to the elevation of the rocks accumulated, and
retains subhorizontal bedding, even though the rock in then overflowed, leaving a lake 3 miles around and
it is highly fractured. The accumulation presents a considerably deep.
short outlet, presumably dug artificially, some 20 m The stereogram of Fig. 7 seems to show most of
above the valley bottom. Water flowing in it triggers the elements mentioned by Boccone. Cassaro is on the
erosion on the downstream portion of the blockage, left, two rock prominences across the Anapo valley
and the eroded materials are redeposited just down- are on the right, one rock fall which clogged the valley
stream from the dam (white elongated spot in Fig. 6). is clearly seen and, finally, the plain formed by the
Erosion also seems to have been responsible for the lake-fill deposits is evident. We add also that excava-
trigger of a secondary mass movement on the down- tions and borings made for founding the constructed
stream side of the accumulation. dam met many metres of lacustrine clay (ESE, 1951;
Silting up deposits are still accumulating and, so ENEL, unpublished stratigraphic data). However, the
far, extend almost 500 m upstream from the blockage. second rock fall is missing, but it may have been of
Their estimated maximum thickness is 20 25 m, and minor size and be no longer detectable; for example,
maximum width, just behind the accumulation, is the saddle marked by an arrow in Fig. 7 may have
about 80 m. Estimated volume of the deposited sedi- formed due to the failure of the part of the crest. In
ment is 0.18 106 m3. conclusion, the elements described by Boccone seem
According to local witnesses, the lacustrine basin, to be present here (and nowhere else in the area), so
also here a main valley lake, is subject to flooding that dating this landslide dam at 1693 seems a
following the major rainfall events (for example, reasonable inference.
during the 1995 1996 winter). According to Boccone, overtopping occurred soon
This landslide has reached the position of mini- after dam emplacement, but the dam (consisting of
mum potential energy, so that it cannot be reactivated. limestone blocks and boulders) must have lasted long,
P.G. Nicoletti, M. Parise / Geomorphology 46 (2002) 203222 215
Fig. 7. Stereogram (year 1966) and section of landslide dam no. 5, across the Fiume Anapo. The landscape shown seems to match satisfactorily
the description by Boccone (1697); a possible source for the second rock fall (not visible anymore; see main text) is shown by an arrow. The
blocky nature of rock-fall accumulation can be seen, together with the plain formed by the lake-fill deposits and the constructed dam built in
mid-XX century. Scale about 1:30 000. Published by the permission of the Italian Air Force (Concessione Aeronautica MilitareR.G.S. no. 207
del 23.06.1998).
so that a remarkable amount of sediments could be This rock fall is unlikely to move again, though
deposited. Much of blockage is now missing, and the minor settling due to undercutting is possible. How-
large blocks have been redeposited downstream (Fig. ever, the source slope seems to show symptoms of
7) indicating that the dam was reincised, but it is not instability and the possibility of new failures should be
known whether this occurred gradually, by retrogres- considered, particularly in seismic conditions. Ele-
sive erosion, or suddenly, by breaching. In any case, ments at risk would be the constructed dam, the service
part of the sediment body upstream was consequently building (presently not in use) and a secondary road.
removed, and the void was filled by a reservoir
constructed in mid-XX century. 4.5. Dam no. 6
The landslide involved calcarenite and calcirudite
and is presently about 200 m long and 200 m wide; This blockage across the Rio Amerillo (watershed:
the accumulation alone is about 150 m 200 m, and 12.1 km2) was caused by a rock slide (Figs. 8 and 9)
has an estimated volume of about 50 103 m3. that moved along a strongly listric slip surface, as is
The watershed area is by far the greatest among evidenced by the pronounced horst-and-graben mor-
those considered: 90 km2. Silting up deposits seem to phology. Estimated landslide volume is 34 106 m3.
extend upstream for about 800 m, with a maximum The affected slope is formed by an alternance of
width of about 200 m. The lake was basically a main subhorizontally bedded limestone and marly lime-
valley lake, which seems however also to have stone overlain by calcarenite, marly calcarenite and
flooded tributary valleys. calcareous marlstone. The displaced material is in
216 P.G. Nicoletti, M. Parise / Geomorphology 46 (2002) 203222
Fig. 8. Stereogram (year 1966) of site no. 6 in the Rio Amerillo valley. This strongly listric rock slide has perhaps also blocked a tributary
coming from right, but the real situation is not clear. Two more rock slides (L1 and L2) are visible, respectively, up- and downstream from
landslide dam no. 6. Scale about 1:30 000. Published by the permission of the Italian Air Force (Concessione Aeronautica MilitareR.G.S. no.
207 del 23.06.1998).
contact with the opposite slope, so determining also is more than 1000 m long, about 1200 m wide, and
here a blockage of type II. The landslide is about 1200 presumably 70 m thick. Displaced material still retains
m long and 1100 m wide; elevation difference subhorizontal bedding, but is more fractured than
between crown and toe is 230 m. The accumulation local bedrock.
P.G. Nicoletti, M. Parise / Geomorphology 46 (2002) 203222 217
Fig. 9. Geomorphological sketch and section of site no. 6. In the lower part of drawing, the Contrada Piano degli Angeli landslide (L1 in Fig. 8)
can be seen. Uncertain silting up deposits are marked with U. Contour interval is 100 m.
218 P.G. Nicoletti, M. Parise / Geomorphology 46 (2002) 203222
Fig. 10. Stereogram (year 1966) and section of landslide dam no. 7. Debris crossed the valley and ran up the base of opposite slope (note the
hummocky surface of debris mass): this was probably an embryonic rock avalanche and, in any case, a rapid, planar rock slide. Dammed basin
is not yet filled, and there is no outlet: probably no overtopping has ever occurred. Shadow emphasises the steep failure surface, which seems to
continue, though less steep, under the rotational rock slide (Rrs) contiguous to the SW. Evolution is complete in the planar rock slide, but tension
cracks (arrows) upslope of the scar indicate that future failures are possible. The rotational rock slide is far from stable, and has a considerable
potential for further development: rural estates with scattered houses are at risk, together with a railway, along the landslide toe, and a state road,
below the toe. Average scale is about 1:30 000. Published by the permission of the Italian Air Force (Concessione Aeronautica MilitareR.G.S.
no. 207 del 23.06.1998); security reasons prevent the provision of a more complete image.
P.G. Nicoletti, M. Parise / Geomorphology 46 (2002) 203222 219
The landslide dammed the Rio Amerillo, and limestone and marly limestone, (b) calcarenite and
perhaps one of its right-bank tributaries (the evidence calcirudite, and (c) calcarenite alternating with calca-
is not fully convincing). In the Rio Amerillo valley, reous marly sandy layers. All are subhorizontally
lake-fill deposits extend about 2000 m upstream from bedded. The landslide crown developed following
the blockage, have a maximum width of 200 m and an the boundary between (b) and (c). Overall, the land-
estimated maximum thickness of 40 m, so that esti- slide is about 800 m long and 1100 m wide, and the
mated volume is about 4.4 106 m3. Silting up of accumulation is about 550 m long and 1100 m wide.
lake was completed in an unknown time in the past, Maximum thickness is an estimated 60 70 m. The
and since then, a limited reincision of both the distal landslide dam bears no trace of a surficial outlet.
rim of the accumulation and the plain of silting up Blockage belongs to type II.
deposits has begun (Fig. 8). This was of course a The presence of a main valley lake is evident,
main valley lake, but a tributary lake may have but supra lakes and back lakes can form sporadi-
been also present. cally in the concavities between hummocks or be-
Nicoletti and Terranova (1998) presented a tenta- tween accumulation and back scarp. Silting up of
tive estimate of the duration of the lake in the Rio main valley lake is advanced, but not complete.
Amerillo valley. By comparing the volume of silting Deposits extend about 1000 m upstream (Fig. 10),
up sediments and average annual sediment yield, they have a maximum width of about 200 m and an
obtained a minimum duration of 6500 years. estimated maximum thickness of 60 m, so that esti-
The upstream portion of the lake-fill deposits in the mated volume of the sedimentary body is 2.2 106
Rio Amerillo is in contact with the displaced material m3. Also, this case was analysed by Nicoletti and
of another landslide that occurred on the same valley Terranova (1998) and the result was a minimum
flank (Contrada Piano degli Angeli landslide, L1 in duration of 5000 years. Since at Contrada Monte
Figs. 8 and 9; Nicoletti et al., 1998). the basin is not totally infilled, this figure represents
In this site, several estates are at risk, also including also a tentative dating for the occurrence of the land-
residential structures. Given the geomorphological slide.
configuration, a new damming seems unlikely. Sud- At this site, rectilinear cracks can be seen upslope
den failure of the dam can be excluded because no of the crown (shown by arrows in Fig. 10), indicating
storing capability remains. that the slope is still deforming and that future failures
are likely. Such cracks are presently about 150 m long
4.6. Dam no. 7 and several metres wide, and monitoring would obvi-
ously be opportune. In case of failure, some rural
This translational rock slide at Contrada Monte estates are at risk, also including residential structures,
completely dammed an unnamed left tributary (water- and a railway, clearly seen in the stereogram, may also
shed: 6.4 km2) of the Fiume Irminio (Fig. 10). It undergo damage. The possibility of a sudden dam
moved along a planar and steeply inclined slip sur- failure seems very remote, because the watershed is
face. Accumulation is hummocky, spans the entire small and the dam is large, flat and composed of well-
valley width and rests partly on the opposite slope lithified rock with very coarse to blocky grain size;
(see also Fig. 1). These characteristics, and in partic- moreover, the absence of an outlet suggests that no
ular the run up on the opposite valley side, which significant overtopping has ever occurred and, finally,
requires high velocity of the moving mass, suggest a this dam seems to have already withstood a very
complex mechanism in the occurrence of the land- prolonged testing.
slide, with a translational slide evolving into an
extremely rapid and presumably dry debris flow. This
could have been a rock avalanche, whose full devel- 5. Conclusions
opment was however prevented by the early impact
against the opposite slope. This study pointed out a peculiar aspect of land-
Rock-slide volume is about 14 106 m3. The sliding features in an area that was hitherto considered
failed slope consists, from the base upwards, of: (a) to be almost landslide-free. In the overall population
220 P.G. Nicoletti, M. Parise / Geomorphology 46 (2002) 203222
With CD-ROM, 2nd edn. Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica Harrison, J.V., Falcon, N.L., 1938. An ancient landslip at Saidmar-
Storia Geofisica Ambiente, Bologna, 644 pp. reh in southwestern Iran. Journal of Geology 46, 296 309.
Campisi, B., 1961. Note geologiche sulle regione di Cassibile e San Keefer, D.K., 1984. Landslides caused by earthquakes. Geological
Michele (Monti IbleiSicilia). Bollettino del Servizio Geologi- Society of America Bulletin 95, 406 421.
co dItalia 81, 287 312. Lentini, F., 1984. Carta geologica della Sicilia sud-orientale. Scale
Costa, J.E., 1988. Floods from dam failures. In: Baker, V.R., Ko- 1:100 000. University of Catania, Institute of Earth Sciences,
chel, C.R., Patton, P.C. (Eds.), Flood Geomorphology. Wiley, S.EL.CA., Florence.
New York, pp. 439 463. Lentini, F., 1986. Carta geologica del settore nord-orientale ibleo.
Costa, J.E., Schuster, R.L., 1988. The formation and failure of Scale 1:50 000. University of Catania, Institute of Earth Scien-
natural dams. Geological Society of America Bulletin 100, ces, S.EL.CA., Florence.
1054 1068. Mc Calpin, J.P., Nelson, A.R., 1996. Introduction to paleoseismol-
Costa, J.E., Schuster, R.L., 1991. Documented historical landslide ogy. In: Mc Calpin, J.P. (Ed.), Paleoseismology. Academic
dams from around the world. Open-File Report - U.S. Geolog- Press, San Diego, pp. 1 32.
ical Survey 91 329, 485 pp. Nicoletti, P.G., Catalano, E., 2000. Frane e sbarramenti fluviali di
Crozier, M.J., Pillans, B.J., 1991. Geomorphic events and landform antica origine sismica in Sicilia sud-orientaleIII Parte: ricog-
response in south-eastern Taranaki, New Zealand. Catena 18, nizione sul Foglio 274Siracusa. Bollettino della Societa Geo-
471 487. logica Italiana 119 (1), 97 104.
Cruden, D.M., Varnes, D.J., 1996. Landslide types and processes. Nicoletti, P.G., Terranova, O., 1998. Duration of lakes dammed by
In: Turner, A.K., Schuster, R.L. (Eds.), Landslides: Investigation old, earthquake-triggered landslides in southeastern Sicily. In:
and Mitigation. Transportation Research Board Spec. Rep., vol. Moore, D., Hungr, O. (Eds.), Proc. 8th International Congress
247. Nat. Res. Counc., Washington, DC, pp. 36 75. IAEG, Vancouver. Balkema, Rotterdam, pp. 2135 2142.
Di Maria, F., 1745. Ibla rediviva. Caltagirone. (Anastatic reprint Nicoletti, P.G., Parise, M., Scalzo, A., 1998. Ancient, earthquake-
edited by Gringeri Pantano, F., 1989. Edizioni Pro Loco, Avola, triggered landslides in SE Sicily. In: Moore, D., Hungr, O.
163 pp.). (Eds.), Proc. 8th International Congress IAEG, Vancouver. Bal-
Eisbacher, G.H., Clague, J.J., 1984. Destructive mass movements in kema, Rotterdam, pp. 2127 2133.
high mountains: hazard and management. Geological Survey of Nicoletti, P.G., Adorni, G., Scalzo, A., 1999a. Frane e sbarramenti
Canada Paper 84-16, Ottawa, 230 pp. fluviali di antica origine sismica in Sicilia sud-orientaleI Parte:
ESE, 1951. Impianto idroelettrico sullAnapo. Ente Siciliano per inquadramento generale e ricognizione sul Foglio 277Noto.
lElettricita. Bollettino dInformazioni 3, 5 33, Catania. Bollettino della Societa Geologica Italiana 118 (2), 461 477.
Finley, M.I., 1968. A History of Sicily. Ancient Sicily to the Arab Nicoletti, P.G., Adorni, G., Scalzo, A., 1999b. Frane e sbarramenti
Conquest. The Viking Press, New York, 226 pp. fluviali di antica origine sismica in Sicilia sud-orientaleII
Gasparini, P., Ferrari, G., 1997. Stima dei parametri sintetici: nuove Parte: ricognizione sul Foglio 276Ragusa. Bollettino della
elaborazioni. In: Boschi, E., Guidoboni, E., Ferrari, G., Valen- Societa Geologica Italiana 118 (3), 513 522.
sise, G., Gasparini, P. (Eds.), Catalogo dei forti terremoti in Nicoletti, P.G., Iovine, G., Catalano, E., 2000. Frane e sbarramenti
Italia dal 461 a.C. al 1990. With CD-ROM, 2nd edn. Istituto fluviali di antica origine sismica in Sicilia sud-orientaleIV
Nazionale di GeofisicaStoria Geofisica Ambiente, Bologna, Parte: ricognizione sul Foglio 273Caltagirone e conclusioni
pp. 56 64. generali. Bollettino della Societa Geologica Italiana 119 (2),
Gaziev, E., 1984. Study of Usoy landslide in Pamir. Proc. IV Int. 451 471.
Symp. on Landslides, Toronto, vol. 1, pp. 511 515. Pirocchi, A., 1991. Laghi di sbarramento per frana nelle Alpi: tipo-
Grasso, M., 1997. Carta geologica del settore centro-meridionale logia ed evoluzione. Atti 1j Convegno Nazionale dei Giovani
dellAltopiano Ibleo (provincia di Ragusa, Sicilia sud-orientale) Ricercatori in Geologia Applicata, Gargnano. Ricerca Scientif-
Scale 1:50 000. University of Catania, Institute of Geology and ica ed Educazione Permanente, University of Milan, Milan, pp.
Geophysics, S.EL.CA., Florence. 127 136, Suppl. 93.
Gringeri Pantano, F., 1996. La citta esagonale. Avola: lantico sito, Ragonese, B., 1972. Le Porte di Ponente e gli impianti artigianali
lo spazio urbano ricostruito. Sellerio, Palermo, 269 pp. nella valle del Carosello. Atti e Memorie dellIstituto per la
Gringeri Pantano, F., Nicoletti, P.G., Parise, M., 2002. Historical Storia e la Valorizzazione di Noto Antica 3, 97 114.
and geological evidence for seismic origin of newly recognised Ragonese, B., 1976 1977. Nuove acquisizioni sulle concerie della
landslides in south-eastern Sicily, and its significance in terms of Cava del Carosello. Atti e Memorie dellIstituto per la Storia e la
hazard. Environmental Management 29, 116 131. Valorizzazione di Noto Antica 7 8, 115 118.
Gruppo di Lavoro CPTI, 1999. Catalogo Parametrico dei Terremoti Richter, C.F., 1958. Elementary Seismology. Freeman, San Francis-
Italiani. Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica, Gruppo Nazionale per la co, 768 pp.
Difesa dai Terremoti, Storia Geofisica Ambiente, Servizio Sis- Schuster, R.L., 1986. Landslide Dams: Processes, Risk, and Miti-
mico Nazionale, Bologna. Available on line: http://emidius. gation. Geotechnical Spec. Publ., vol. 3. American Society of
itim.mi.cnr.it/CPTI/. Civil Engineering, New York, 164 pp.
Guidoboni, E., Comastri, A., Traina, G., 1994. Catalogue of Ancient Schuster, R.L., 1993. Landslide DamsA Worldwide Phenomenon.
Earthquakes in the Mediterranean Area up to the 10th Century. Proc. Annual Meet. Kansai Landslide Society, Osaka, pp. 1 23
Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica, Rome, 504 pp. 27 April.
222 P.G. Nicoletti, M. Parise / Geomorphology 46 (2002) 203222
Schuster, R.L., 2000. Dams built on pre-existing landslides. Pro- Swanson, F.J., Graham, R.L., Grant, G.E., 1985. Some effects of
ceedings GeoEng 2000, Int. Conf. on Geotechnical and Geo- slope movements on river channels. Proc. Int. Symp. on Ero-
logical Engineering, Melbourne, vol. 1. Technomic, Lancaster, sion, Debris Flow, and Disaster Prevention. Erosion Control
pp. 1537 1589. Engineering Society of Japan, Tsukuba, pp. 273 278.
Schuster, R.L., Costa, J.E., 1986. A perspective on landslide dams. Swanson, F.J., Oyagi, N., Tominaga, M., 1986. Landslide dams in
In: Schuster, R.L. (Ed.), Landslide Dams: Processes, Risk, and Japan. In: Schuster, R.L. (Ed.), Landslide Dams: Processes,
Mitigation. Geotechnical Spec. Publ., vol. 3. American Society Risk, and Mitigation. Geotechnical Spec. Publ., vol. 3. Ameri-
of Civil Engineering, New York, pp. 1 20. can Society of Civil Engineering, New York, pp. 131 145.
Shoaei, Z., Ghayoumian, J., 1997. Landslide dam in Iran, mecha- Trauth, M.H., Strecker, M.R., 1999. Formation of landslide-dammed
nism and history. In: Marinos, P.G., Koukis, G.C., Tsiambaos, lakes during a wet period between 40,000 and 25,000 yr B.P.
G.C., Stournaras, G.C. (Eds.), Proc. IAEG Congress on Engi- in northwestern Argentina. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology,
neering Geology and the Environment, Athens, vol. 2. Balkema, Palaeoecology 153, 277 287.
Rotterdam, pp. 1043 1047. Watson, R.A., Wright, H.E., 1967. The Saidmarreh landslide, Iran.
Sieberg, A., 1932. Erdbeben. In: Gutenberg, B. (Ed.), Handbuch der Geological Society of America, Special Paper 123, 115 139.
Geophysik, vol. 4. Borntraeger, Berlin, pp. 552 554. Zolotarev, G.S., Fedorenko, V.S., Vinnitchenko, S.M., 1986. An-
Sirovich, L., Pettenati, F., 1999. Seismotectonic outline of South- cient seismogenic and recent slides and slumps in Tadjikistan
Eastern Sicily: an evaluation of available options for the earth- (Central Asia). Proc. IAEG Int. Symp. on Engineering Geology
quake fault rupture scenario. Journal of Seismology 3, 213 233. Problems in Seismic Areas, Bari, vol. 2, pp. 149 157.