G:K>HI69:8>:C8>6EDAI>86$KDAJB:C'+$C'$'%%+$&+&&,(

B:BDGN6C9EGDB>H:>C6G:C9I6C9C>:IOH8=:

MEMORY AND PROMISE

IN ARENDT AND NIETZSCHE

K6C:HH6A:BB
JC>K:GH>9699>:<DEDGI6A:H!8=>A:

GZhjbZc

:hiZVgiXjadXdbeVgVZakVadgnZah^\c^XVYdfjZ6gZcYinC^ZiohX]Zdidg\VcVaVbZbdg^VnVaV
egdbZhVeVgVaVXdchi^ijX^cYZadedai^XdVhXdbdeVgVaVhVakV\jVgY^VYZaVa^WZgiVYnYZaVeajgVa^YVY
]jbVcV#

6WhigVXi

I]^hVgi^XaZ^ckZhi^\ViZhVcYXdbeVgZhi]ZkVajZVcYh^\c^XVcXZi]Vi6gZcYiVcYC^ZiohX]ZViig^WjiZ
idi]ZgdaZeaVnZYWnbZbdgnVcYWni]Zegdb^hZ^cXdchi^iji^c\i]Zeda^i^XVaVcY^chV[Z\jVgY^c\i]Z
[gZZYdbVcYeajgVa^ind[]jbVcVXi^dc#

E6A67G6H8A6K:6gZcYiC^ZiohX]ZEgdbZhVBZbdg^VDak^Yd

I]^hVgi^XaZXdbeVgZh6gZcYihVcYC^ZiohX]ZhXdcXZei^dchd[i]Zeda^i^XVa!cdi^cdgYZgidZb"
e]Vh^oZi]Z^gh^b^aVg^i^Zh^#Z#!i]Vi^ci]ZYZkVajVi^dcd[i]Zeda^i^XVai]ZnWdi]hZZdcZd[i]ZX]^Z[
egdWaZbhd[bdYZgc^in!WjigVi]Zgid^ckZhi^\ViZi]Z^gY^kZg\ZcXZl]Zc^iXdbZhidi]ZfjZhi^dc
d[]dlidgZ"ZhiVWa^h]i]ZkVajZd[i]Zeda^i^XVa#&I]Zbdhihig^`^c\Y^[[ZgZcXZWZilZZc6gZcYih
VcYC^ZiohX]ZhXdcXZei^dcd[i]Zeda^i^XVa^hi]Z^bedgiVcXZi]ViZVX]Viig^WjiZhidbZbdgnVcY
id[dg\Zi[jacZhh#L]^aZ6gZcYihlg^i^c\hdceda^i^XhVgZa^iZgVaan[jaad[gZ[ZgZcXZhidi]ZkVajZd[
bZbdgn^ceda^i^Xh!C^ZiohX]Zhlg^i^c\hVgZg^X]l^i]egV^hZ[dgi]Zk^gijZhd[[dg\Zi[jacZhh#
6gZcYihhigdc\Zbe]Vh^hdci]Z^bedgiVcXZd[bZbdgn^ceda^i^XhYZg^kZh[gdb]ZgZmeZg^ZcXZ
d[idiVa^iVg^Vc^hb#I]^hZmeZg^ZcXZXVccdiVcYh]djaYcdiWZ[dg\diiZc!VcYWZXVjhZ^iXVccdiWZ
[dg\diiZc!^il^aaValVnhgZbV^cl^i]jh#I]Zhjgk^kVad[i]ZbZbdgnd[idiVa^iVg^Vc^hb^hXgjX^Va[dg
6gZcYiWZXVjhZh]ZWZa^ZkZhi]Vii]Z[jijgZd[eda^i^XhYZeZcYhdc^i#Dci]ZXdcigVgn!^cC^ZiohX]Z!
i]Z[jijgZd[eda^i^XhgZhihcdidcandci]ZVW^a^ind[bZbdgn!WjiVahdVcYbdgZ^bedgiVciandci]Vid[
[dg\Zi[jacZhh#I]^h^hcdiidhj\\Zhii]ViidiVa^iVg^Vc^hbh]djaYWZ[dg\diiZc!WjigVi]Zg!i]Vi[dg\Z"
i[jacZhh^hcZZYZY^cdgYZgidegZhZgkZVbZbdgnd[i]ZeVhii]Vi^hk^iVaidi]Z[jijgZ#I]ZY^[[ZgZci
higViZ\^ZhegdedhZYWn6gZcYiVcYC^ZiohX]Z^cdgYZgidVYYgZhhi]ZfjZhi^dcd[]dlidegZhZgkZV
eVhii]Vi^hk^iVaidi]Z[jijgZVgZgZZXiZY^ci]Z^gY^[[ZgZciXdcXZei^dchd[i]Zegdb^hZ#
I]^h Vgi^XaZ WZ\^ch l^i] 6gZcYih cdi^dc d[ i]Z egdb^hZ VcY i]Zc ijgch id i]Vi d[ C^ZiohX]Z#
Id]ZgXgZY^i!6gZcYi]VhWgdj\]iWVX`i]ZXZcigVa^ind[i]Zegdb^hZ^cXdciZbedgVgneda^i^XVa
e]^adhde]n6gZcYi!&.*-/')("')-#>cI]Z=jbVc8dcY^i^dc!h]Z^cigdYjXZhi]Zegdb^hZVcY

& ;dgdi]ZgXdbeVg^hdchWZilZZc6gZcYihVcYC^ZiohX]ZhXdcXZei^dchd[i]Zeda^i^XVa!hZZ=dc^\!&..(06chZaa"EZVghdc!
&..)/)("))0K^aaV!&..+/-%"&%.VcY'%%%/'')"')+#

&+&
K6C:HH6A:BB

[dg\^kZcZhhVhgZbZY^Zh[dgi]Z^ggZkZgh^W^a^inVcYi]ZjcegZY^XiVW^a^ind[i]ZegdXZhhZhhiVgiZY
Wn]jbVcVXi^dc/
I]ZhZbdgVaegZXZeihPi]Zegdb^hZVcY[dg\^kZcZhhRVgZi]ZdcandcZhi]ViVgZcdiVeea^ZY
idVXi^dc[gdbi]Zdjih^YZ![gdbhdbZhjeedhZYan]^\]Zg[VXjaindg[gdbZmeZg^ZcXZhdji"
h^YZVXi^dchdlcgZVX]#I]ZnVg^hZ!dci]ZXdcigVgn!Y^gZXiandjid[i]Zl^aaida^kZid\Zi]Zg
l^i]di]Zgh^ci]ZbdYZd[VXi^c\VcYheZV`^c\#>[l^i]djiVXi^dcVcYheZZX]!l^i]djii]Z
Vgi^XjaVi^dcd[cViVa^in!lZldjaYWZYddbZYidhl^c\[dgZkZg^ci]ZZkZg"gZXjgg^c\XnXaZd[
WZXdb^c\!i]Zcl^i]djii]Z[VXjainidjcYdl]VilZ]VkZYdcZVcYidXdcigdaViaZVhieVg"
i^Vaani]ZegdXZhhZhi]Zn]VkZaZiaddhZ!lZldjaYWZi]Zk^Xi^bhd[VcVjidbVi^XcZXZhh^in
WZVg^c\Vaai]ZbVg`hd[i]Z^cZmdgVWaZaVlhl]^X]!VXXdgY^c\idi]ZcVijgVahX^ZcXZhWZ[dgZ
djgi^bZ!lZgZhjeedhZYidXdchi^ijiZi]ZdjihiVcY^c\X]VgVXiZg^hi^Xd[i]ZcVijgVaegdXZhh
6gZcYi!&.*-/')+#'
I]Z[VXjainidbV`ZVcY`ZZeegdb^hZhgZhedcYhidi]Z[gV^aind[]jbVcV[[V^gh6gZcYi!&.+-/
&+)#>ci]ZdXZVcd[jcXZgiV^cin!l]^X]^hi]Z[jijgZ!egdb^hZhhZgkZidhZijei]dhZ^haVcYh
d[hZXjg^ini]ViVhhjgZi]ZXdci^cj^inVcYi]ZYjgVW^a^ind[]jbVcgZaVi^dch]^eh6gZcYi!&.*-/
'))#I]Zegdb^hZhiVW^a^oZhi]ZldgaYd[]jbVcV[[V^ghVcYegdiZXih^i[gdbi]Zjc[dgZhZZVWaZ
XdchZfjZcXZhd[]jbVcVXi^dcZhhZci^VaanWZXVjhZ^i^hVbZX]Vc^hbi]ViXdcigdahi]Z[jijgZ#
6XXdgY^c\id6gZcYi!i]Zegdb^hZjcYZghiddYVhVbZX]Vc^hbd[XdcigdadkZgi]Z[jijgZa^ZhVii]Z
WVh^hd[ZkZgneda^ini]ViVg^hZhdjid[i]Zl^aaida^kZid\Zi]Zgl^i]di]Zgh^ci]ZbdYZd[VXi^dc
VcYheZZX]6gZcYi!&.*-/')+#(6hhjX]i]Zegdb^hZXdchi^ijiZhVW^aViZgVaXdbb^ibZciVcY
\jVgVciZZl]^X]W^cYheZdeaZid\Zi]Zgi]gdj\]VcV\gZZYejgedhZ#
8dcigdadkZgi]Z[jijgZhjXXZZYhYjZidVeVgi^XjaVg`^cYd[bZbdgn#;dg6gZcYi!i]Z[VXjaind[
egdb^hZ^hZhhZci^VaanV[VXjaind[bZbdgni]Vi]Vhi]ZedlZgidWg^c\VWdYnd[eZdeaZWVX`
idi]Z^gWZ\^cc^c\!i]Vi^h!WVX`idi]ZbdbZcil]Zci]ZnV\gZZYdcVcV^bVcYVejgedhZ#>c
i]^hhZchZ!i]Zegdb^hZ^hVgZb^cYZgi]Vi`ZZehdcWdcY^c\i]Z\gdjeid\Zi]ZgVcYa^c`^c\i]Z
^cY^k^YjVaWVX`idVeVhi[gdbl]^X]^iWZ\VcVcY[gdbl]^X]^iXVcWZ\^cV\V^c#I]^h^hl]n![dg
6gZcYi!i]Zegdb^hZ^hcdiVeea^ZYidVXi^dc[gdbi]Zdjih^YZWji^h^ihZa[VcVgi^XjaVi^dcd[cV"
iVa^in#I]Zegdb^hZZmZgX^hZhXdcigdadkZgi]Z[jijgZWnbZVchd[YgVl^c\i]Z[jijgZZkZg[jgi]Zg
^cidi]ZeVhi#>chdYd^c\!i]Zegdb^hZgZkZghZhi]Zdld[i^bZ#I]jh!^chiZVYd[WZ^c\Wdgc^cid
VcjcXZgiV^c[jijgZ!dcZ^hWdgc^cidVhZXjgZYeVhi#
6gZcYiegV^hZhi]Z]jbVcXVeVX^inidbV`Zegdb^hZhVcYidY^hedhZd[i]Z[jijgZVh^[^ilZgZ
eVhi!WZXVjhZh]ZhZZh^ci]ZaViiZgVeZdeaZhhdjgXZd[hdkZgZ^\cin#>i^h^bedgiVciidcdiZ
i]Vi6gZcYi^h\ZcZgVaan`cdlc[dg]ZgVci^"hdkZgZ^\cXdcXZei^dcd[eda^i^XhVXXdgY^c\idl]^X]
^[bZcl^h]idWZ[gZZ!^i^hegZX^hZanhdkZgZ^\cini]ZnbjhigZcdjcXZ6gZcYi!&.+-/&+*#
HdkZgZ^\cin]VhidWZgZ_ZXiZYWZXVjhZ^ihiVcYh[dgVl^aaedlZgdkZgdcZhZa[dgdkZgdi]Zghl]^X]
^h^chZeVgVWaZ[gdbk^daZcXZVcYYdb^cVi^dc#)>c]ZgY^hXjhh^dcd[i]Zegdb^hZ!]dlZkZg!6gZcYi

' ;dggZVhdchd[heVXZ6gZcYihcdi^dcd[[dg\^kZcZhhXVccdiWZY^hXjhhZY]ZgZ#DcbngZVY^c\d[[dg\^kZcZhh^c6gZcYi
hZZVahd;ddicdiZCd#',#
( HZZVahd6aaeda^i^XVaWjh^cZhh^h!VcYValVnh]VhWZZc!igVchVXiZYl^i]^cVcZaVWdgViZ[gVbZldg`d[i^ZhVcYWdcYh
[dgi]Z[jijgZhjX]VhaVlhVcYXdchi^iji^dch!igZVi^ZhVcYVaa^VcXZhVaad[l]^X]YZg^kZ^ci]ZaVhi^chiVcXZ[gdbi]Z
[VXjainidbV`ZVcYid`ZZeegdb^hZh^ci]Z[VXZd[i]ZZhhZci^VajcXZgiV^ci^Zhd[i]Z[jijgZ6gZcYi!&.+-/&+)#
) I]Z[VbdjhhdkZgZ^\cind[eda^i^XVaWdY^Zh]VhValVnhWZZcVc^aajh^dc!l]^X]!bdgZdkZg!XVcWZbV^ciV^cZYdcanWn

&+'
 B:BDGN6C9EGDB>H:>C6G:C9I6C9C>:IOH8=:

Zmea^X^ianjhZhi]ZiZgbhdkZgZ^\cin^cdgYZgidh^\c^[nZmVXiani]Zdeedh^iZ!cVbZan!i]Vii]Z
hdkZgZ^\cind[VWdYnd[eZdeaZ!WdjcYVcY`Zeiid\Zi]ZgWnVcV\gZZYejgedhZ[dgl]^X]VadcZ
egdb^hZhVcYXdcigVXihVgZkVa^YVcYW^cY^c\^hegZ[ZgVWaZidWZ^c\XdbeaZiZan[gZZ!jcWdjcYWn
Vcnegdb^hZVcYcdi`ZeiWnVcnejgedhZ6gZcYi!&.*-/')*#I]Vi]jbVchdkZgZ^\cinVcY
i]Zi]Z[VXjaind[bV`^c\egdb^hZhVgZXdccZXiZYidZVX]di]Zg^h^cVc^YZV6gZcYiiV`Zh
[gdbC^ZiohX]Z#>cV[VbdjheVhhV\Z[gdbDci]Z<ZcZVad\nd[BdgVah!C^ZiohX]ZcVbZhi]Z
egdb^hZl]^X]W^cYheZdeaZid\Zi]Zg^cV\gdjei]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aa<ZY~X]ic^hYZhL^aaZch
C^ZiohX]Z!&..)/(.#
6gZcYiVX`cdlaZY\Zhi]ViC^ZiohX]ZhVll^i]jcZfjVaZYXaVg^ini]ZXdccZXi^dcWZilZZc]jbVc
hdkZgZ^\cinVcYi]Z[VXjaind[bV`^c\egdb^hZh!l]^X]aZY]^bidVjc^fjZ^ch^\]i^cidi]ZgZaViZY"
cZhhd[]jbVceg^YZVcY]jbVcXdchX^ZcXZ6gZcYi!&.*-/')&#Jc[dgijcViZan![dg6gZcYi!i]^h
XdccZXi^dchgZbV^cZYjcgZaViZYl^i]VcYl^i]djiZ[[ZXijedc]^hX]^Z[XdcXZei!i]Zl^aaidedlZg!
VcYi]ZgZ[dgZVgZ[gZfjZciandkZgadd`ZYZkZcWnC^ZiohX]ZhX]daVgh6gZcYi!&.*-/')&#K^ZlZY
[gdbi]ZeZgheZXi^kZd[l^aaidedlZg!6gZcYiVg\jZhi]Vii]Zegdb^hZd[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVa
^cC^ZiohX]Z!l]^X]h]Z^YZci^ZhVhi]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aa!X]VgVXiZg^oZhi]Zl^aaedlZgd[i]Z
^hdaViZY^cY^k^YjVaVcYcdii]Zl^aaedlZgd[i]ZbVcnWdjcYid\Zi]Zg#I]ZgZ[dgZ!i]ZhdkZgZ^\cin
i]Vi^hVhhdX^ViZYl^i]i]Zeg^k^aZ\ZidbV`Zegdb^hZh^cC^ZiohX]Z^hcdidcan^c]ZgZcianVVcY
edhh^WanZkZcVci^"eda^i^XVa!WjiVahdcZXZhhVg^anZ\d^hi^XVcYjai^bViZanjc[gZZ#Dc6gZcYihVh"
hjbei^dci]Vi[gZZYdbVg^hZh[gdbi]ZedlZgd[i]ZLZgVi]Zgi]Vc[gdbi]Zl^aaedlZgd[i]Z
^hdaViZY^cY^k^YjVa!i]Z\jgZd[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVa^cC^ZiohX]ZWZXdbZhi]ZeVgVY^\bVi^X
ZmVbeaZd[V\Zcj^cZaVX`d[[gZZYdbgZhjaiVci[gdbVYZkVajVi^dcd[i]Zeda^i^XVa#*
>cdgYZgid_jY\Zi]ZbZg^id[6gZcYih^ciZgegZiVi^dcd[C^ZiohX]Z!^i^hcZXZhhVgnidgZijgcidi]Z
C^ZiohX]ZVciZmi!^ceVgi^XjaVg!idi]ZdeZc^c\hZXi^dchd[i]ZhZXdcYZhhVnd[Dci]Z<ZcZVad\n
d[BdgVah#I]ZfjZhi^dc^hcdih^beanl]Zi]Zg6gZcYihVeegdeg^Vi^dcd[C^ZiohX]Zhcdi^dcd[i]Z
egdb^hZ^hXdggZXi!WjibdgZh^\c^XVcian!l]Zi]ZgVY^[[ZgZcigZVY^c\d[C^ZiohX]Zb^\]iWZjhZ[ja
^cdgYZgidVYYgZhhhdbZegdWaZbh[djcY^c6gZcYihdlcVXXdjcid[egdb^h^c\#I]ZegdWaZbh
>hZZ^c6gZcYihVXXdjcid[i]Zegdb^hZVgZi]gZZ[daY#6aai]gZZgZkdakZVgdjcY]ZgYZc^i^dcd[
i]Zegdb^hZZmXajh^kZan^ciZgbhd[bZbdgn#;^ghi!]ZgjcYZghiVcY^c\d[i]Zegdb^hZ^ciZgbhd[
VXdbb^ibZciidi]ZeVhihiVcYh^ciZch^dcl^i]]ZgjcYZghiVcY^c\d[[gZZYdbVhi]ZedlZgid
WZ\^c6gZcYi!&.+-/&+*"&,&#6gZcYiVg\jZhXdggZXian!^cbnde^c^dc!i]ViZkZgnWZ\^cc^c\^hV
gZ"WZ\^cc^c\VcY]ZcXZgZfj^gZhVgZijgcidi]ZeVhii]Vi^ckdakZhV[dgbd[bZbdgnd[i]ZeVhi#
7jil]VigZbV^chjcXaZVg^h]dlVgZijgcidi]ZeVhiVadcZXVc\ZcZgViZVcZlWZ\^cc^c\!dg!^c

bZVchd[k^daZcXZ!i]Vi^h!l^i]ZhhZci^Vaancdc"eda^i^XVabZVch#JcYZg]jbVcXdcY^i^dch!l]^X]VgZYZiZgb^cZYWn
i]Z[VXii]VicdibVcWjibZca^kZdcZVgi]![gZZYdbVcYhdkZgZ^\cinVgZhda^iiaZ^YZci^XVai]Vii]ZnXVccdiZkZc
Zm^hih^bjaiVcZdjhan#L]ZgZbZcl^h]idWZhdkZgZ^\c!Vh^cY^k^YjVahdgVhdg\Vc^oZY\gdjeh!i]ZnbjhihjWb^iid
i]ZdeegZhh^dcd[i]Zl^aa!WZi]^h!i]Z^cY^k^YjVal^aal^i]l]^X]>[dgXZbnhZa[!dgi]Z\ZcZgVal^aad[Vcdg\Vc^oZY
\gdje#>[bZcl^h]idWZ[gZZ!^i^hegZX^hZanhdkZgZ^\cini]ZnbjhigZcdjcXZ#6gZcYi!&.+-/&+)"&+*#
* I]Zdi]ZgeVgVY^\bVi^XZmVbeaZd[V[dgbd[hdkZgZ^\cini]Vii]gZViZchi]Zeda^i^XVa!VXXdgY^c\id6gZcYi!^h[djcY^c
GdjhhZVjhcdi^dcd[i]Zegdb^hZ`cdlcVhi]Z\ZcZgVal^aa#L]^aZC^ZiohX]Zhcdi^dcd[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVa
gZZXihV[dgbd[k^daZcXZi]Z^cY^k^YjVaZmZgX^hZhV\V^chi^ihZa[!GdjhhZVjhcdi^dcd[i]Z\ZcZgVal^aagZZXih
V[dgbd[k^daZcXZhdbZZmZgX^hZdkZgdi]ZghDchdkZgZ^\cinVcYegdb^hZ^cC^ZiohX]ZVcYGdjhhZVj!hZZVahd
6chZaa"EZVghdc!&..&#;dg6gZcYi!Wdi]cdi^dchVgZ^c]ZgZcianingVcc^XVa6gZcYi!&.+-/&+)#>cXdcigVedh^i^dcid
C^ZiohX]ZVcYGdjhhZVj!6gZcYihZZh^c]ZgdlcXdcXZei^dcd[i]Zegdb^hZVcZmegZhh^dcd[i]Z[gZZYdbVcYi]Z
edlZgd[i]ZLZi]ViegdiZXihi]Zhe]ZgZd[eda^i^XhV\V^chii]Z[dgbhd[k^daZcXZVcYYdb^cVi^dc!l]^X]VgZ!^c
]Zgk^Zl!egZhZci^cC^ZiohX]ZhVcYGdjhhZVjhcdi^dcd[egdb^hZ#

&+(
K6C:HH6A:BB

di]ZgldgYh!]dli]ZeVhiXVcgZcZl^ihZa[Wn^ihZa[#;gdbi]ZeZgheZXi^kZd[bZbdgn!Vh6gZcYi
YZcZh^i!^ihZZbhi]ViVWZ\^cc^c\VcZl^hcZkZggZVaancZl!WjiValVnhdcanVgZijgcidVeVhi
i]VidcZ^cXgZVh^c\angZbZbWZgh#;dg6gZcYi!i]^hgZijgcidi]ZeVhi^hVgZijgcidi]ZWZ\^cc^c\
l]^X]VaadlhdcZidgZ"WZ\^cWZXVjhZl]VidcZgZijgchid^hZhhZci^Vaani]ZbZbdgnd[i]Z]jbVc
WZ^c\VhVWZ\^ccZg#H]ZXaV^bhi]ViWZXVjhZ]Z^hVWZ\^cc^c\!bVcXVcWZ\^c0idWZ]jbVc
VcYidWZ[gZZVgZdcZVcYi]ZhVbZ6gZcYi!&.+-/&+,#I]ZfjZhi^dcgZbV^ch!]dlZkZg!]dl
i]ZbZbdgnd[i]Z]jbVcWZ^c\VhVWZ\^ccZgXVcaZVYidi]ZVXijVaVXid[WZ\^cc^c\]dl
6gZcYiZck^hV\Zhi]ZigVch^i^dc[gdbbZbdgn!jcYZghiddYVhV]daY^c\dcidi]ZeVhi!idVXi^dc
jcYZghiddYVhi]ZhedciVcZdjhaZii^c\addhZd[egdXZhhZh^cid[jijgZ#
6hZXdcYegdWaZbVahdZbZg\Zh[gdb]ZgYZc^i^dcd[i]Zegdb^hZ^ciZgbhd[bZbdgn!cVbZan!
]ZgXaV^bi]Vii]Zegdb^hZcZZYhidWZ^chi^iji^dcVa^oZY!dg!^cdi]ZgldgYh!i]Vi[gZZYdbcZZYh
idWZ[djcYZY6gZcYi!&.+*/&)&"'&)#6gZcYiYZ[ZcYhi]ZXdci^c\ZcXnd[i]ZejWa^XgZVabWn
]daY^c\i]Vii]ZjcgZa^VW^a^ind[]jbVcVXi^dc^hi]Zeg^XZi]Vi]VhidWZeV^Y[dg[gZZYdbVcY
i]Vii]Z^bedhh^W^a^ind[egZY^Xi^c\i]ZXdchZfjZcXZhd[VXi^dc^hi]Zeg^XZi]Vi]VhidWZeV^Y[dg
eajgVa^in6gZcYi!&.*-/&,*"&-&#CZkZgi]ZaZhh!h]ZXdciZcYhi]Vi]jbVchXVccdia^kZid\Zi]Zg
l^i]djihdbZhiVW^a^o^c\bZVhjgZh#=ZcXZ!h]ZYZ[ZcYhi]Z^chi^iji^dcd[bZbdgnVhVbZVchid
hZXjgZi]ZedlZgd[i]Z\gdjeV\V^chii]ZjcXZgiV^ci^Zhd[i]Z[jijgZ#I]ZfjZhi^dc^hl]Zi]Zgi]^h
^chi^iji^dcVa^oZYegdiZXi^dccdidcanegZhZgkZh[gZZYdbVcYeajgVa^in!Wjih^bjaiVcZdjhani]gZViZch
i]ZbVhhjb^c\i]Vi^chi^iji^dcVa^oVi^dc^hZhhZci^VaanVbZX]Vc^hbd[XdcigdaY^gZXiZYV\V^chii]Z
jcgZa^VW^a^inVcYjcegZY^XiVW^a^ini]ViYZcZi]Z[gZZYdbVcYeajgVa^ind[]jbVcVXi^dc#
;^cVaan!Wj^aijedci]ZghiildfjZhi^dch^hVi]^gY#>hi]Zegdb^hZjcYZghiddY!dci]ZdcZ]VcY!
Vhi]ZYgVl^c\d[i]Z[jijgZ^cidi]ZeVhiVcY!dci]Zdi]Zg!Vhi]Z^chi^iji^dcVa^oVi^dcd[i]ZeVhi
dkZgi]Z[jijgZ!cdi^c]ZgZciank^daZciVcYi]jh^cXdc^Xil^i]6gZcYihXdcXZei^dcd[VXi^dcVcY
heZZX]Vhcdc"k^daZcXZ4;dg6gZcYi!in^c\i]Z[jijgZWVX`idi]ZeVhi^cdgYZgid\^kZhiVW^a^in
h]djaYWZi]ZgdaZd[Vji]dg^in6gZcYi!&.+-/.&"&)&#6ai]dj\]6gZcYideedhZhVji]dg^inid
k^daZcXZ!YdjWihbVnWZgV^hZYVhidl]Zi]Zgi]^hdeedh^i^dc^hcdijcYdcZ^c]Zg^YZVd[i]Z
egdb^hZ#>ciZgZhi^c\an!6gZcYiXdch^hiZcianZbeadnhZmegZhh^dchhjX]VhidbV`ZVegdb^hZ!
VcYid`ZZeVegdb^hZWjiYdZhcdiXdbbZcidc]ZgdlcjhZd[bZiVe]dghi]ViXaZVganWZadc\
idl]Vih]ZiZgbhi]ZgZVabd[bV`^c\6gZcYi!&.*-/&(+"&,)#I]ZbZiVe]dg^XZmegZhh^dch
d[XdbbdcaVc\jV\ZjhZYWn6gZcYied^ciidbVcjVaVXi^k^i^Zh/idbV`^c\!]daY^c\!`ZZe^c\0id
hdbZi]^c\dcZYdZhl^i]i]Z]VcYhgVi]Zgi]Vcl^i][VXjai^Zhd[i]Zb^cY#I]ZhZZmegZhh^dch
VahdgZkZVai]ZegZhZcXZd[[dgXZdkZgdcZhZa[VcYdkZgdi]Zgh/idegdb^hZbZVchid]daYdcid
hdbZi]^c\gVi]Zgi]VcidaZi^i\d0id`ZZehdbZi]^c\^cdcZhgb\g^e!gVi]Zgi]VcidaZi^iaddhZ0
idbV`ZdcZhZa[VcYdi]ZghgZbZbWZggVi]Zgi]Vc[dg\Zi0id[dgXZhdbZi]^c\^cidZm^hiZcXZi]Vi
ldjaYdi]Zgl^hZcdi]VkZdXXjggZY#7ZXVjhZ6gZcYiVg\jZhi]Vik^daZcXZ^hVihiV`Zl]ZcZkZg
i]Z\gVbbVgd[bV`^c\^hegd_ZXiZYdcidi]Vid[eda^i^Xh6gZcYi!&.*-/''%"'(%!^ihZZbhi]Vi
]ZgdlcYZc^i^dcd[i]ZbV`^c\d[egdb^hZh^hk^daZciVhdeedhZYidcdc"k^daZci#=ZcXZ!i]Z
fjZhi^dc^hd[]dlidXdjciZg"VXii]Zk^daZcXZ^ckdakZY^ci]ZbV`^c\d[egdb^hZhVii]ZbdbZci
d[i]Z[djcYVi^dcd[eda^i^XVaedlZg!VhlZaaVh^ci]ZhiVW^a^oVi^dcd[eda^i^XVaedlZg#
I]^hfjZhi^dca^ZhVii]Z]ZVgid[C^ZiohX]ZhXdcXZei^dcd[i]Zegdb^hZ#>cDci]Z<ZcZVad\nd[
BdgVah!C^ZiohX]ZVh`hl]Zi]Zgi]ZiVh`idWgZZYVcVc^bVal]^X]^hVWaZidbV`Zegdb^hZhYdZh
cdiXdchi^ijiZi]ZgZVaegdWaZbd[]jbVcWZ^c\h4C^ZiohX]Z!&..)/(-#=ZXdch^YZghi]^hiVh`
idWZVeVgVYdm^XVadcZWZXVjhZ^igZfj^gZhi]Z]jbVcVc^bVaidgZkZghZ^ihVc^bVacVijgZ#I]Z

&+)
 B:BDGN6C9EGDB>H:>C6G:C9I6C9C>:IOH8=:

]jbVcWZ^c\!V[dg\Zi[jaVc^bVa!]VhidWZXdbZi]Zdeedh^iZ!VgZa^VWaZdcZ#C^ZiohX]ZVhhdX^ViZh
i]Z[dg\Zi[jacZhhd[i]Z]jbVcVc^bVal^i]VhiViZd[gdWjhi]ZVai]i]Vi^hX]VgVXiZg^hi^Xd[V
hda^iVgnlVnd[a^[ZC^ZiohX]Z!&..)/(.#6XXdgY^c\id]^h\ZcZVad\^XVaY^hXdjghZ!]dlZkZg!i]Z
]jbVcVc^bVaXdjaYcdibV^ciV^c^ihVc^bVa[dg\Zi[jacZhhYjZid^ihgZaVi^kZ^c[Zg^dg^inXdbeVgZY
l^i]di]Zg[dgbhd[Vc^bVaa^[Z#>cdgYZgidhjgk^kZ]jbVch]VYidWZXdbZhdX^VaVcY\gdje"XdchX^djh
Vc^bVah#C^ZiohX]ZXdciZcYhi]Vii]^higVch[dgbVi^dclVhVXXdbea^h]ZYi]gdj\]i]Z^bedh^i^dc
d[VbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aa<ZY~X]ic^hYZhL^aaZchdci]Z[dg\Zi[jacZhhd[i]Z]jbVcVc^bVaVcY
i]Vii]ZaViiZgXd^cX^YZhl^i]i]Z^chi^iji^dcd[hdX^VaVcYeda^i^XVa[dgbhd[a^[Z#+
6ai]dj\]C^ZiohX]ZhZZbhideg^k^aZ\Zi]Za^[Z[dgbd[i]Zhda^iVgnVcY[dg\Zi[jaVc^bVaidi]Vid[
i]Z]ZgYVc^bVa!]ZVX`cdlaZY\Zhi]Vii]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aagZhedcYhidVcZZYd[a^[ZVcY
i]Vii]ZgZ[dgZ^iheda^i^XVa^chi^iji^dc^hcdidcancZXZhhVgn[dgi]ZegZhZgkVi^dcd[]jbVcVc^bVa
a^[Z!Wjii]Vi^ihVXXdbea^h]bZcihVgZVahdegV^hZldgi]n#,=dlZkZg!i]ZhjXXZhh[ja^chi^iji^dcd[
i]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aahZZbVaai]ZbdgZhjgeg^h^c\idi]ZdcZl]dPa^`ZC^ZiohX]ZRXVc[jaan
VeegZX^ViZi]ZXdjciZgkV^a^c\[dgXZ![dg\Zi[jacZhhC^ZiohX]Z!&..)/(-#;gdbi]ZeZgheZXi^kZ
d[[dg\Zi[jacZhh!i]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aadcanhdakZhi]ZegdWaZbd[Wg^c\^c\[dgi]VcVc^bVai]Vi
XVcbV`Zegdb^hZhidaVg\ZYZ\gZZC^ZiohX]Z!&..)/(-#>iegdk^YZhVhdaji^dcidi]ZfjZhi^dc
d[]dlhdX^Zi^ZhXVcWZ`Zeiid\Zi]Zg!]dl[dg\Zi[jaVcYhda^iVgnVc^bVahXVcWZbVYZidYZY^"
XViZi]ZbhZakZhl^aa^c\anidi]ZlZa[VgZd[hdX^ZinVcYd[i]ZhiViZ!Wjih^cXZ^i[V^ah^ckVadg^o^c\
Vc^bVa[dg\Zi[jacZhh!i]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aa^hcdiZci^iaZYidi]Zeg^k^aZ\Zd[bV`^c\egdb^hZh#
Dci]ZXdcigVgn!i]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aaXVgg^Zhi]Zg^h`d[egdYjX^c\Vc^c]ZgZcian^ggZhedch^WaZ
VcYYVc\ZgdjhVc^bVa/VcdkZg"WgZY]ZgYVc^bVa!idddWZY^ZciVcYiddiVbZ!VcVc^bVal]dhZ
egdb^hZhXVccdiWZigjhiZY#-6cY]ZcXZ![dgC^ZiohX]Z!i]ZfjZhi^dcgZbV^chd[]dlidWg^c\[dgi]
V[dgbd[bZbdgnVcYegdb^hZi]ViYZhe^iZ^ihWZ^c\Y^gZXiZYV\V^chi[dg\Zi[jacZhhgZXd\c^oZh

+ 6cYegZX^hZani]^hcZXZhhVg^an[dg\Zi[jaVc^bVa!^cl]db[dg\Zii^c\^hVhigZc\i]!gZegZhZci^c\V[dgbd[gdWjhi]ZVai]!
]VhWgZY[dg^ihZa[VXdjciZg"YZk^XZ!bZbdgn!l^i]i]Z]Zaed[l]^X][dg\Zi[jacZhhXVcWZhjheZcYZY^cXZgiV^cXVhZh!
cVbZan^ci]dhZXVhZhl]ZgZVegdb^hZ^hidWZbVYZ/XdchZfjZcian!^i^hWncdbZVchbZgZanVeVhh^kZ^cVW^a^in
idWZg^Yd[Vc^begZhh^dcdcXZ^i]VhbVYZ^ih^beVXi!cdg^h^i_jhi^cY^\Zhi^dcXVjhZYWn\^k^c\ndjgldgYdchdbZ
dXXVh^dcVcYcY^c\ndjXVccdiXdeZ!^chiZVY^i^hVcVXi^kZcdi"lVci^c\"id"aZi"\d!Vl^aaid`ZZedclVci^c\l]Vi
]VhWZZc!dchdbZdXXVh^dc!l^aaZY!VgZVabZbdgnd[i]Zl^aa<ZY~X]ic^hYZhL^aaZchC^ZiohX]Z!&..)/(.#
, C^ZiohX]Zhcdi^dcd[i]ZbZbdgnd[l^aa^h^ci]^hhZchZXdbeVgVWaZid]^hcdi^dcd[Vci^fjVg^Vc]^hidgnYZkZadeZY
^cDci]ZJhZVcY9^hVYkVciV\Zd[=^hidgn[dgA^[ZC^ZiohX]Z!&..,/,'",*#7di]VgZ[dgbhd[bZbdgni]ViVgZ
VYkVciV\Zdjh[dga^[ZWZXVjhZi]ZnegZhZgkZi]ZeVhi!i]Vi^h!i]ZigVY^i^dch!]VW^ih!gjaZhVcYcdgbhd[Vcn\^kZc
hdX^Zin#
- C^ZiohX]Z]daYhi]Vii]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aa^hYZh^\cZYid[VWg^XViZVc^YZci^inVcYid`ZZei]Z]jbVcVc^bVa^YZci^XVa
id^ihZa[!^YZci^XVaidVhdX^VaVcYX^k^a^oZYhZa[[dgXZYdc^i#7jiidijgci]Z]jbVcVc^bVa^cidhdbZi]^c\^YZci^XVa
VcY\ZcZgVaan^YZci^VWaZ^hVbZVchid\V^cbVhiZgndkZga^[ZVcY[jijgZa^[Z#I#L#6YdgcdVcYB#=dg`]Z^bZghZZ
^ci]^hegdXZhhd[^YZci^XVi^dcVgZZXi^dcd[i]ZY^VaZXi^Xd[Zca^\]iZcbZcil]^X]bVg`hi]ZXdjghZd[:jgdeZVc
X^k^a^oVi^dc/L]VilVhY^[[ZgZci^hZfjVa^oZY#I]Vi^hi]ZkZgY^Xil]^X]Xg^i^XVaanYZiZgb^cZhi]Za^b^ihd[edhh^WaZ
ZmeZg^ZcXZ#I]Z^YZci^ind[ZkZgni]^c\l^i]ZkZgni]^c\ZahZ^heV^Y[dg^ci]Vicdi]^c\bVnVii]ZhVbZi^bZWZ^YZci^XVa
l^i]^ihZa[#:ca^\]iZcbZciY^hhdakZhi]Z^c_jhi^XZd[i]ZdaY^cZfjVa^injcbZY^ViZYadgYh]^eVcYbVhiZgnWjiVi
i]ZhVbZi^bZeZgeZijViZh^i^cjc^kZghVabZY^Vi^dc!^ci]ZgZaVi^dcd[VcndcZZm^hiZciidVcndi]Zg#>iYdZhl]Vi
@^Zg`Z\VVgYegV^hZh]^hEgdiZhiVciZi]^X[dg!VcYl]Vi^ci]Z=ZgVXa^iZVcZe^XXnXaZ^hdcZd[i]Zeg^bVa^bV\Zhd[
bni]^XedlZg0^iZmX^hZhi]Z^cXdbbZchjgVWaZ#CdidcanVgZfjVa^i^ZhY^hhdakZY^ci]dj\]i!WjibZcVgZWgdj\]iid
VXijVaXdc[dgb^in=dg`]Z^bZgVcY6Ydgcd!'%%'/&'#C^ZiohX]Z!a^`Z6YdgcdVcY=dg`Z^bZgV[iZg]^b!gZ_ZXihi]Z
eda^i^Xhd[^YZci^in^c]ZgZciidi]ZegdXZhhd[hdX^Va^oVi^dcVcYX^k^a^oVi^dc#I]Zdeedh^iZk^Zl!cVbZan!i]ViC^ZiohX]Z
^hVegdedcZcid[Veda^i^Xhd[^YZci^in^h[djcY^c9dbWdlh`n!'%%%/'-(#DcC^ZiohX]ZVhVXg^i^Xd[i]Zeda^i^Xhd[
^YZci^in!hZZVahdHX]g^[i!'%%%/'.'#

&+*
K6C:HH6A:BB

^c[dg\Zi[jacZhhV[dgXZcZXZhhVgncdidcanidi]ZWZXdb^c\d[]jbVcVc^bVaa^[Z!WjiVahdidi]Z
Xdchi^iji^dcd[hdX^VaVcYeda^i^XVa[dgbhd[a^[Z#.
>i^h^ciZgZhi^c\idcdiZi]Vi^cC^ZiohX]ZhX]daVgh]^ei]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aa^heg^bVg^an`cdlc
[dgi]Zk^daZcXZVcYXgjZain^ckdakZY^c^ihbV`^c\#6gZcYi!^chiZVY!egV^hZhi]Z\gZVicZhhVcY
hdkZgZ^\cin l]^X] gZhjaih [gdb i]Z bV`^c\ VcY `ZZe^c\ d[ egdb^hZh! YZhe^iZ i]Z [VXi i]Vi
C^ZiohX]ZZbe]Vh^oZh]dlbjX]WaddYVcY]dggdga^ZhVii]ZWVh^hd[Vaa\ddYi]^c\C^ZiohX]Z!
&..)/)'/
=dlYdndj\^kZVbZbdgnidi]ZVc^bVa4=dlYdndj^begZhhhdbZi]^c\dci]^heVgian
Yjaa! eVgian ^Y^di^X! ^cViiZci^kZ b^cY! i]^h eZghdc^XVi^dc d[ [dg\Zi[jacZhh! hd i]Vi ^i l^aa
hi^X`4I]^hV\Z"daYfjZhi^dclVhcdigZhdakZYl^i]\ZciaZhdaji^dchVcYbZi]dYh!VhXVc
WZ^bV\^cZY0eZg]Vehi]ZgZ^hcdi]^c\bdgZiZgg^WaZVcYhigVc\Z^ci]Z]jbVcegZ]^hidgn
i]Vc^ihiZX]c^fjZd[bcZbdc^XhI]Z]jbVcWZ^c\lVhZkZcijVaanVWaZidgZiV^ckZdgh^m
>"Ydci"lVci"idh^c^ihbZbdgn^cXdccZXi^dcl^i]l]^X]Vegdb^hZ]VYWZZcbVYZ!^cdgYZg
idZc_dni]ZVYkVciV\Zhd[hdX^ZinVcYi]ZgZndjVgZL^i]i]ZV^Yd[i]^hhdgid[bZbdgn!
eZdeaZcVaanXVbZidgZVhdc6]!gZVhdc!hdaZbc^in!bVhiZg^c\d[Zbdi^dch!i]^hgZVaan
Y^hbVai]^c\XVaaZYgZZXi^dc!Vaai]ZhZeg^k^aZ\ZhVcYheaZcYdgh]jbVch]VkZ/l]ViVeg^XZ
]VYidWZeV^Y[dgi]Zb=dlbjX]WaddYVcY]dggdga^ZhVii]ZWVh^hd[Vaa\ddYi]^c\h
C^ZiohX]Z!&..)/)'
I]Vi6gZcYiYdZhcdiXdbbZcidci]Zk^daZcXZVcYXgjZain^c]ZgZciidi]ZbV`^c\d[i]ZbZbdgn
d[i]Zl^aa^cC^ZiohX]Z^hcdihjgeg^h^c\#6[iZgVaa!h]Z^YZci^Zhi]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aal^i]i]Z
l^aaedlZgd[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVaVcYdeedhZhi]ZaViiZghk^daZcXZidi]Zcdc"k^daZcXZd[i]Z
egdb^hZi]Vi`ZZehi]Z\gdjeWdjcYid\Zi]ZgVcYi]ViVg^hZhdjid[i]Zl^aaida^kZid\Zi]Zgl^i]
di]Zgh^ci]ZbdYZd[VXi^dcVcYheZZX]#
C^ZiohX]Z!^chiZVY!XaZVganY^hi^c\j^h]Zhi]Zegdb^hZd[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVaVhi]Vil]^X]
dkZgXdbZhi]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aa#I]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVa^hVcVjidcdbdjh!hjegV"Zi]^XVa
^cY^k^YjVa!l]dYZhZgkZhi]Zeg^k^aZ\ZidbV`Zegdb^hZhWZXVjhZ^i]Vh[gZZY^ihZa[[gdbi]Z
bdgVa^ind[XjhidbhC^ZiohX]Z!&..)/)%#>Vg\jZi]Vii]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVahdkZgXdb^c\d[
i]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aaYZeZcYhdcVgZijgcd[Vc^bVa[dg\Zi[jacZhhVhi]Vi[dgXZl]^X]Vaadlhi]Z
^cY^k^YjVaidil^hi[gZZ[gdbi]ZbdgVa^ind[Xjhidb#&%I]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVa[dg\Zihi]ZbdgVa
VcYeda^i^XVacdgbhd[hdX^Zin^ci]ZcVbZd[^ihdlchiVcYVgYd[kVajZC^ZiohX]Z!&..)/)%#
I]^h[dg\Zi[jacZhhgZZXihcdidcani]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVahdlcWZXdb^c\VcYhZa["dkZgXdb^c\!
WjibdgZdkZg!Xdcig^WjiZh!Vh>h]VaaVg\jZWZadl!idi]ZigVch[dgbVi^dcd[\^kZchdX^VaVcYeda^i^XVa
[dgbhd[a^[ZbdgVa^ind[Xjhidb#&&

. Dci]ZkVajZd[[dg\Zi[jacZhhVcYbZbdgn^ci]Z<gZZ`eda^h!hZZC^XdaZAdgZVjm&..,l]dh]dlhi]Vi^ci]Zeda^h
i]ZdVi]hZgkZhVhVbZVchV\V^chiY^hXdgYdcan^chd[VgVh^i^hi^ZYid[dg\Zi[jacZhhVhi]Vi[dgXZl]^X]Y^hhdakZh
i]ZbZbdgnd[b^hYZZYhVcY]VigZY#6XXdgY^c\idAdgZVjm!i]ZdVi]egdb^hZhV[Z\jVgYhi]ZhiVW^a^inVcY]Vgbdcn
d[i]Z<gZZ`eda^hWZXVjhZ^igZZXihVXdbb^ibZciid[dg\ZigVi]Zgi]VcidgZbZbWZg#Dc[dg\Zi[jacZhhVcYegdb^hZ
^cC^ZiohX]Z!hZZVahdHX]VVe'%%'#
&% >Wdggdli]ZiZgbil^hi^c\[gZZVhVhncdcnb[dgi]ZC^ZiohX]ZVciZgbzWZgl^cYjc\VcYHZaWhiWZgl^cYjc\
[gdbHVaa^h&..&#
&& Dci]Z^bedgiVcXZd[[dg\Zi[jacZhh[dgi]ZWZXdb^c\VcYdkZgXdb^c\d[]jbVcVc^bVaa^[Z!hZZHX]g^[i'%%&/),"+'#
HX]g^[iVg\jZhi]Vi^i^hi]ZZbe]Vh^hdcWZXdb^c\i]Vi^hVihiV`Z^ci]ZY^hXjhh^dc!Vii]ZdeZc^c\d[i]ZhZXdcY
ZhhVnd[i]Z<ZcZVad\nd[BdgVah!dci]ZVXi^kZ[dg\Zii^c\d[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVal]d]VhZVgcZYi]Zg^\]iid

&++
 B:BDGN6C9EGDB>H:>C6G:C9I6C9C>:IOH8=:

6gZcYih^YZci^XVi^dcd[i]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aal^i]i]Zl^aaedlZgd[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVa
^cC^ZiohX]Z^hegdWaZbVi^X#;^ghid[Vaa!i]^h^YZci^XVi^dc^\cdgZhi]Z[VXii]ViC^ZiohX]ZVXijVaan
gZ_ZXihi]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aaegZX^hZanWZXVjhZd[i]ZXgjZainVcYk^daZcXZ]ZYZiZXih^ci]Z
bZX]Vc^hbhd[^ihbV`^c\#HZXdcY!VcYeZg]VehbdgZ^bedgiVcian!]^hXdcXZei^dcd[i]Zegdb^hZ
d[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVaXdchi^ijiZhVXg^i^fjZd[i]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aai]Vi^h^c]ZgZcian
eda^i^XVa#>ihZZ`hiddkZgXdbZVeda^i^Xhd[k^daZcXZVcYYdb^cVi^dci]gdj\]i]ZXjai^kVi^dcd[
^cY^k^YjVa[gZZYdbVcYgZhedch^W^a^in#6gZcYihb^hgZVY^c\d[C^ZiohX]Z[V^ahidY^[[ZgZci^ViZWZilZZc
i]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aaVhVbZVchd[Ydb^cVi^dcVcYi]Zegdb^hZd[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVa
VhVbZVchd[[gZZYdbVcYgZhedch^W^a^in#&'
>cC^ZiohX]Z!i]ZXgjX^VafjZhi^dcd[i]Zegdb^hZ^hcdi!Vh6gZcYiXaV^bh!]dlid\ZcZgViZ!egZhZgkZ
VcYegdiZXii]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aai]Via^ZhVii]ZWVh^hd[eda^i^XVaedlZg!Wji^chiZVY!]dlid
XdjciZg"VXii]Zk^daZcXZVcYYdb^cVi^dcl]^X]YZcZi]Zeda^i^XVaegVXi^XZhd[^chi^iji^dchhjX]
Vhi]ZbdYZgchiViZ#I]^h^hcdiidhVni]ViC^ZiohX]ZdW_ZXihidi]ZcZZY[dgeda^i^XVa^chi^iji^dch
VhhjX]#Dci]ZXdcigVgn!]ZlZaXdbZhhigdc\^chi^iji^dch!&(Wji]ZWZa^ZkZhi]Vii]ZngZfj^gZV
XdjciZg"[dgXZl]^X]Xdci^cjdjhandkZgXdbZhi]Z^gWZ^c\[djcYZYdck^daZcXZVcYYdb^cVi^dc#;dg
]^b!i]Zegdb^hZd[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVa^hVXdjciZg"egdb^hZidi]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aal]^X]
egdiZXihi]Z[gZZYdbVcYeajgVa^ind[]jbVcVXi^dci]gdj\]i]ZegVXi^XZd[l]ViXdjaYWZXVaaZY
VcV\dc^hi^Xeda^i^Xhd[gZhedch^W^a^in#GZhedch^W^a^in^hV\dc^hi^X^ci]ZhZchZi]Vi^ihiVcYh[dgV
Xdci^cjdjhgZh^hiVcXZidi]Z^chi^iji^dcVa^oVi^dcd[[gZZYdb#>ci]^hk^Zl![gZZYdb^hcZ^i]Zgl]Vi
dcZ]VhWnk^gijZd[Vc^chi^ijiZYg^\]icdgl]VidcZ^h\^kZcWnk^gijZd[VbjijVaV\gZZbZci!Wji
ValVnhdcanl]VidcZ\]ih[dg!l]VidcZXdcfjZghC^ZiohX]Z!&..%/&%("&%)#
L]ViY^hi^c\j^h]Zhi]Zeda^i^XVakVajZd[i]ZV\dc^hi^Xhe^g^iZmZbea^ZY^ci]Zegdb^hZd[i]Z
hdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVa!VhdeedhZYidi]Zegdb^hZ^c6gZcYi!^hcdi^chi^iji^dcVa^oVi^dc/[dgC^ZiohX]Z!
i]Zegdb^hZ^h^c]ZgZcianXdjciZg"^chi^iji^dcVa#>ih[jcXi^dc^hidhjWb^ii]ZZhiVWa^h]ZYVji]dg^in
d[i]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aaVcY^ihbdgVaVcYeda^i^XVahiVcYVgYhidVXdci^cjdjhVcYgVY^XVaXg^i^"
fjZ#>i^hWnbZVchd[Xg^i^XVafjZhi^dc^c\!gVi]Zgi]VcWnbZVchd[ingVcc^XVahZa["Y^hX^ea^cZ!i]Vi
C^ZiohX]Z]deZhidVYkVcXZ]jbVchdkZgZ^\cinVcY\gZVicZhh#>i^hWZXVjhZd[i]^hV\dc^hi^Xhe^g^i
i]VihZkZgVaVji]dgh]VkZig^ZYidVhh^b^aViZC^ZiohX]ZidVcV\dc^hi^XXdcXZei^dcd[YZbdXgVXn#

bV`Zegdb^hZh/>i^hdcan^ci]ZXVhZd[i]^hZbVcX^eViZY^cY^k^YjVa;gZ^\ZldgYZcZi]^hbVhiZgd[i]Z[gZZl^aa
<B>>!'/=ZggYZh;gZ^ZcL^aaZcl]d^hXVeVWaZd[WZXdb^c\di]Zgi]Vc]ZlVhWn[dg\Zii^c\l]Vi]ZlVhi]Vi
egdb^h^c\WZXdbZhVegV^hZldgi]nVXid[gZhedch^W^a^inHX]g^[i!'%%&/*.#
&' C^ZiohX]Zhcdi^dcd[i]Zegdb^hZd[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVa^hXdbeVgVWaZidi]ZeVXiWZilZZc6WgV]VbVcY<dYVh
^i^hVgi^XjaViZYWn@^Zg`Z\VVgY^c;ZVgVcYIgZbWa^c\#L]^aZ6gZcYijhZhi]ZZmVbeaZd[i]ZeVXiWZilZZc6WgV]Vb
VcY<dY^cdgYZgidh]dli]ViigjZ[gZZYdb^hcZkZgi]Vid[i]Z^cY^k^YjVahl^aaWjiValVnhl]ViZbZg\Zhdjid[Vc
V\gZZbZcil^i]di]Zgh6gZcYi!&.*-/')(")!@^Zg`Z\VVgYijgchidi]Z\jgZd[6WgV]Vb^cdgYZgidh]dlZmVXian
i]Zdeedh^iZ/igjZ[gZZYdb^hedhh^WaZdcandci]ZWVh^hd[VcZhhZci^VaY^hV\gZZbZciWZilZZci]Z^cY^k^YjVaVcYi]Z
Zi]^XVaXdbbjc^in#IgjZ[gZZYdb^c@^Zg`Z\VVgYXVccdi!i]ZgZ[dgZ!WZVX]^ZkZYWni]ZbZVchd[eda^i^XhdgWni]Z
bZVchd[V\gZZbZciVcYXdchZchjhl^i]^cVcZi]^XVaXdbbjc^in!WjiValVnhdcani]gdj\]VcZmeZg^ZcXZd[[V^i]#
;V^i]^c@^Zg`Z\VVgY^hi]ZXVgg^Zgd[\Zcj^cZ[gZZYdb!l]ZgZ[gZZYdbhiVcYh[dgi]ZhigZc\i]idWgZV`l^i]i]ZZi]^XVa
Xdbbjc^in^ci]ZcVbZd[dcZhh^c\jaVggZhedch^W^a^in@^Zg`Z\VVgY!&.-*#I]Zk^gijZh@^Zg`Z\VVgYViig^WjiZhid
6WgV]VbVgZh^b^aVgidi]dhZC^ZiohX]ZViig^WjiZhidi]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVa/Wdi]hjheZcYi]ZZi]^XVa!^c6gZcYih
iZgbhi]ZedlZgd[i]ZLZ!^ci]ZcVbZd[^cY^k^YjVa[gZZYdbVhgZhedch^W^a^in#DcgZhedch^W^a^in^c@^Zg`Z\VVgY!hZZ
Vahd9Zgg^YV!&..'#
&( C^ZiohX]ZZbe]Vh^oZh![dgZmVbeaZ!i]Zl^aaidVji]dg^in!igVY^i^dcVcYhda^YVg^indkZgXZcijg^ZhYZc^c\GdbVceda^i^Xh
VheVgi^XjaVgana^[Z"Zc]VcX^c\C^ZiohX]Z!&..%/&%)"&%+#DcC^ZiohX]ZhgZkZgZcXZ[dgeda^i^XVa^chi^iji^dch!hZZ
=dc^\!&..(/+.",*#

&+,
K6C:HH6A:BB

L]^aZhdbZVg\jZi]ViVcV\dc^hi^XXdcXZei^dcd[eda^i^XVaVXi^dc^hZhhZci^Vaidi]Zeda^i^XVaa^[Z
l^i]^cVYZbdXgVXn!di]ZghVg\jZi]ViV\dc^hi^Xeda^i^XVaVXi^dcXVccdiWZ^chi^iji^dcVa^oZYVcY
]ZcXZValVnhdcanViiVX`heda^i^XVa^chi^iji^dch!l]Zi]ZgYZbdXgVi^Xdgcdi![gdbi]Zdjih^YZ
VcYi]Vi^i^hi]^hVci^"^chi^iji^dcVaVheZXid[C^ZiohX]ZhV\dc^hi^Xeda^i^Xhl]^X]^che^gZh]deZ
[dgVYZbdXgVXnnZiidXdbZC^ZiohX]Z!&.-+/(-)#&)
BdgZdkZg!i]Zegdb^hZd[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVa^h^bedgiVciidC^ZiohX]ZcdiWZXVjhZ^igZZXih
VXdbb^ibZcid[i]ZhZa[id^ihZa[i]Vi^h^c]ZgZcianVVcYbVnWZZkZcVci^eda^i^XVa!Wji!dci]Z
XdcigVgn!WZXVjhZ^ihiVcYh[dgi]ZXjai^kVi^dcd[V[gZZgZaVi^dcl^i]i]Zdi]Zgl]^X]ZmXZZYhi]Z
egd_ZXid[^cY^k^YjVahZa["gZVa^oVi^dc#H^cXZ6gZcYiXdc[jhZhC^ZiohX]Zhcdi^dcd[i]Zl^aaidedlZg
l^i]i]Vid[i]Z^cY^k^YjVahl^aa!h]ZiV`Zh]^hcdi^dcd[hdkZgZ^\cinidWZZci^gZanXdcXZgcZYl^i]
^cY^k^YjVahZa["gZVa^oVi^dc#&*I]jh!h]Z[V^ahidhZZWdi]i]Vii]Zegdb^hZd[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVa
gZZXihVegZdXXjeVi^dcl^i]i]ZXjai^kVi^dcd[[gZZYdbVhgZhedch^W^a^ini]VidkZgXdbZhi]Z`^cY
d[^cY^k^YjVa^hbl]^X]YZkVajZhi]Zeda^i^XVa!dci]ZdcZ]VcY!VcYi]VidkZgXdbZhi]Z`^cYd[
eda^i^Xhl]^X]YZkVajZhi]Z[gZZYdbVcYeajgVa^ind[]jbVcVXi^dc!dci]Zdi]Zg#
6gZcYihgZVY^c\d[C^ZiohX]Z^hine^XVad[Vc^ciZgegZiVi^dci]Vi^YZci^Zhi]Zegdb^hZd[i]ZhdkZ"
gZ^\c^cY^k^YjVaVhZhhZci^VaanV"hdX^VaVcYV"eda^i^XVaWZXVjhZ^iVeeZVgh^ci]Z[dgbd[Z\d^hbVcY
hda^ijYZ#&+>cgZVa^in!C^ZiohX]ZYZ[ZcYhZ\d^hbVcYhda^ijYZdcanWZXVjhZi]ZnVgZi]ZXdcY^i^dch
i]ViVaadli]Z]jbVcVc^bVaidhiVcY^cVgZaVi^dcidi]Zdi]Zgl]^X]^hcZ^i]Zg\gdjcYZYdc[dgXZ
VcY[ZVg!cdgdcgZhZcibZciVcYgZkZc\ZC^ZiohX]Z!&..*/.(".+#I]Zegdb^hZd[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c
^cY^k^YjVa^hVXVgg^Zgd[jca^b^iZYgZhedch^W^a^inWZXVjhZ^igZZXihVedlZgi]VigZhjaih[gdbi]Z
dkZgXdb^c\d[i]ZcZZYidYdb^cViZdi]Zgh#&,GZhedch^W^a^in^hi]Zeg^k^aZ\Zd[i]dhZl]d\^kZVcY
egdb^hZidi]Zdi]ZgVcYl]dhZZ^ci]^h\^[iVcY\^k^c\i]Z\gZViZhiZmiZch^dcd[i]Z^gedlZg#
>ciZgZhi^c\an!C^ZiohX]ZVhhdX^ViZhi]^h\^[i"\^k^c\l^i]VgZijgcd[Vc^bVa[dg\Zi[jacZhhC^ZiohX]Z!
&..*/,)",.#&-<^[i"\^k^c\^hVcZmXZhh^kZ!egdY^\VaVcYlVhiZ[ja[dgXZXdchi^ijiZYWni]Z^cY^k^YjVah

&) I]ZbVi^o^c\i]ZkVajZd[Vci^"^chi^iji^dcVaXjaijgZ[dgeda^i^Xh!7gdlcVg\jZhi]VieZgbVcZcigZh^hiVcXZidi]ZhiViZ
i]ViWdi]a^b^ihVcYZchjgZhi]ZYZbdXgVi^X[dgbWZXdbZhVbZVchd[hjhiV^c^c\YZbdXgVXn^chd[VgVh^i^hi]ZhiViZ
[dgbi]ViY^hhdakZhYZbdXgVXn#Dcani]gdj\]i]ZhiViZVgZi]ZeZdeaZXdchi^ijiZYVhVeZdeaZ0dcan^cgZh^hiVcXZid
i]ZhiViZYdi]ZeZdeaZgZbV^cVeZdeaZ7gdlc!'%%%/'%*"''(#DcV\dcVcYeda^i^Xh^cC^ZiohX]Z!hZZVahdK^aaV!
'%%%/'')"')+0=dc^\!&..(0=ViVW!&..*VcY'%%'/&('"&),VcY6XVbedgV!'%%(/(,)"(.%#>cXdcigVedh^i^dcid
i]ZVWdkZ!8dclVnVg\jZhi]Vii]ZV\dc^hi^Xhe^g^iYdZhcdieZgbZViZhdX^ZinVhVl]daZ!WjibZgZanYZcZhi]Z
Xdbbjc^ind[V\dc^hi^X[g^ZcYh[djcYZYWni]ZzWZgbZchX]8dclVn!&..,/(&!l]^X]^ihZa[hiVcYhVii]Ze^ccVXaZ
d[VengVb^YVa]^ZgVgX]nd[Zi]^XVaXdbbjc^i^Zh#>c8dclVnhk^Zl!V\dc^hb^hh^\c^XVci^chd[VgVh^i[jgi]Zghi]Z
hdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVahbdgVaeZg[ZXi^dc[dgVh^b^aVgk^Zl!hZZVahdDlZc!'%%'/&&("&(&#6\V^chi8dclVn!H^ZbZch
Xdck^cX^c\anVg\jZhi]ViV\dch]djaYcdiWZgZhig^XiZYidi]ZX^gXaZd[ZcZbn"[g^ZcYh[dgbZYVgdjcYi]ZdkZg]jbVc
8dclVn!&..,/')!Wji^hVXdchi^ijZcid[hdX^ZinVhVl]daZH^ZbZch!'%%'/-)#H^ZbZchYdZhcdi!]dlZkZg!
^YZci^[nV\dcVhVhigj\\aZ[dgVcYV\V^chigjaZ#GVi]Zg]ZhZZh^cV\dci]Zdg^\^cVcYi]ZbZVhjgZd[i]ZhdX^VaVcY
eda^i^XVa[dgbha^[ZVhlZaaVhd[Zi]^XVaaVlhH^ZbZch!'%%'/.&"&%+#;dgVc^ciZgegZiVi^dcd[V\dc^cC^ZiohX]ZVhV
Xdchi^ijZcid[hdX^VaVcYeda^i^XVa[dgbhd[a^[Z!hZZVahd<Zg]VgYi!&.-(/&&&"&((VcYH^ZbZch!'%%&/-%"&%+#
&* ;dgVcdi]Zg^chiVcXZd[i]^hXdc[jh^dc^c6gZcYi!hZZVahd/>cdi]ZgldgYh!l^aa!l^aa"edlZg!VcYl^aa"id"edlZgVgZ[dg
jhVabdhi^YZci^XVacdi^dch0i]ZhZVid[edlZg^hidjhi]Z[VXjaind[i]Zl^aaVh`cdlcVcYZmeZg^ZcXZYWnbVc^c]^h
^ciZgXdjghZl^i]]^bhZa[6gZcYi!&.+-/&+%#
&+ I]^hk^Zl^hcdidcan[djcY^c6gZcYiWjiVahd![dgZmVbeaZ!^cBVX>cingZ!&.-)#
&, Cdgg^hVg\jZhi]ViedlZg^ci]ZcdWaZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVa^hVejgZY^hX]Vg\Zd[k^iVa^inVcYedlZg!l]^X]YdZhcdi
]VkZVh^ihV^bi]ZYdb^cVi^dcd[i]Zb^cYhVcYhdjahd[di]ZghCdgg^h!&.-*/)#DchdkZgZ^\cin^cC^ZiohX]ZVh
VcdkZgXdb^c\d[Ydb^cVi^dc!hZZVahdBX>cingZ!&..,/("'&#
&- Dc\^[i"\^k^c\^cC^ZiohX]Z!hZZH]Ve^gd&..&!HX]g^[i&..*VcY&..+/&.,"'%*#Dci]ZgZaVi^dcWZilZZc\^[i"\^k^c\
VcY[dg\Zi[jacZhh!hZZ9Zgg^YV&..'V/&,"&-VcYHX]g^[i&..*/'%)!cd#&'#

&+-
 B:BDGN6C9EGDB>H:>C6G:C9I6C9C>:IOH8=:

[dg\Zii^c\d[^ihhZa[!l]^X]!^ci]ZldgYhd[OVgVi]jhigV!^hV\d^c\"jcYZg/>adkZ]^bl]dhZhdja
^hdkZg[jaahdi]Vi]Z[dg\Zih]^bhZa[VcYVaai]^c\hVgZ^c]^b/i]jhVaai]^c\hheZaa]^h\d^c\jcYZg
C^ZiohX]Z!&..*/&+#&.I]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVah[dg\Zi[jacZhh^hVcdkZgdl^c\d[i]ZhZa[i]Vi
gZb^cYhjhd[i]ZigV\^X]Zgdh\d^c\"jcYZgJciZg\Vc\Vhi]Z\d^c\"dkZgzWZg\Vc\idhdbZi]^c\
i]ViZmXZZYhi]Z]ZgdhhZa[C^ZiohX]Z!&..,/&**#'%7di]gZkZVai]ZigVXZhd[VgZijgcd[Vc^bVa
[dg\Zi[jacZhhVhi]Vi[dgXZl]^X]Y^hgjeihVcZXdcdbnd[hjgk^kVai]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aa^ci]Z
cVbZd[V\^k^c\WZndcYbZVhjgZhi]Zegdb^hZd[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVa#'&6XXdgY^c\an!i]Z
]^\]ed^cid[[gZZYdb^cC^ZiohX]Z^hValVnhV\d^c\"jcYZgd[i]ZhZa[WZ[dgZi]Zdi]ZggVi]Zg
i]VcVg^h^c\d[i]ZhZa[VWdkZi]Zdi]Zg#I]Zegdb^hZd[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVaViiV^chhjX]V
]^\]kVajZ[dgC^ZiohX]Zdcan^chd[VgVhi]Z[gZZYdb^iZmZbea^ZhhiVcYh[dgVgVY^XVaZmedhjgZ
d[i]ZhZa[idi]Zdi]Zgi]ViiV`Zhi]Z[dgbd[jca^b^iZYgZhedch^W^a^inVcYhZa["gZhedch^W^a^in#
>cDci]Z<ZcZVad\nd[BdgVah!C^ZiohX]Zh]dlhi]Vii]ZbV`^c\d[i]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aaXd^c"
X^YZhl^i]i]Z[dgXZYWgZZY^c\d[VeVgi^XjaVg`^cYd[Vc^bVa!cVbZan!VhdX^VaVcYX^k^a^oZYVc^bVa
i]Vi^h^c]ZgZciangZa^VWaZ!egZY^XiVWaZVcYZci^gZanYZkdiZYidi]Z\ddYd[hdX^Zin#;jgi]ZgbdgZ!
]ZbV^ciV^chi]Vii]Zk^daZcXZl]^X]X]VgVXiZg^oZhi]ZbV`^c\d[i]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aa^h^chZ"
eVgVWaZ[gdbV[dgbd[k^daZcXZY^gZXiZYV\V^chii]ZVc^bVa^ind[i]Z]jbVcVc^bVa!^ceVgi^XjaVg!
V\V^chi^ihVc^bVa[dg\Zi[jacZhh#''I]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aa!Vh6gZcYiXdggZXianhZZh!]jbVc^oZh
VcVc^bVaX]VgVXiZg^oZYWn[dg\Zi[jacZhh!dg!Vhh]Zejih^i!Y^hi^c\j^h]Zh]jbVch[gdbVc^bVa
a^[Z6gZcYi!&.*-/')&#;dg6gZcYi!i]ZY^hi^cXi^dcWZilZZc]jbVcVcYVc^bVaa^[Z^hXgjX^Va/^i
Xdchi^ijiZhi]ZXdcY^i^dcd[edhh^W^a^ind[eda^i^Xh!i]Vi^h!d[]jbVc[gZZYdbVcYVXi^dc#Di]Zgl^hZ!
Vh6gZcYicdiZh!lZldjaYWZYddbZYidhl^c\[dgZkZg^ci]ZZkZg"gZXjgg^c\XnXaZd[WZXdb^c\0
lZldjaYWZi]Zk^Xi^bhd[VcVjidbVi^XcZXZhh^in6gZcYi!&.*-/')&#
L]^aZ 6gZcYi WZa^ZkZh i]Vi V hZeVgVi^dc d[ ]jbVc [gdb Vc^bVa a^[Z ^h i]Z dcan lVn id egdiZXi
[gZZYdbVcYeajgVa^in!C^ZiohX]ZWZa^ZkZhZmVXiani]Zdeedh^iZ#=ZXdciZcYhi]Vii]^hhZeVgVi^dc
i]gZViZchi]Z[gZZYdbVcYeajgVa^ind[]jbVcVXi^dc#;dgC^ZiohX]Z!i]ZegdWaZb^hcdii]Zk^daZcXZ
d[i]ZVc^bVa![dg]ZXdch^YZghi]ZVc^bVaidWZ^c]ZgZcian^ccdXZci!Wji!^chiZVY!i]ZegdWaZb
a^Zhl^i]i]Zk^daZcXZi]Vi]jbVchY^gZXiV\V^chii]Z^gdlcVc^bVa^inVcYi]Z^gVc^bVa[dg\Zi[ja"
cZhh#'(H^cXZC^ZiohX]ZXdch^YZghVc^bVa[dg\Zi[jacZhhidWZZhhZci^Vaidi]ZZc]VcXZbZcid[

&. I]Zcdi^dcd[i]Z\^[i"\^k^c\k^gijZ^cC^ZiohX]Z]VhVhigdc\V[c^inl^i]7ViV^aaZhcdi^dcd[jcegdYjXi^kZZmeZcY^ijgZ#
>cWdi]Vji]dghlZVai]VeeZVghVhVcVXfj^h^i^dcidi]ZZmiZcii]ViedlZg^hVXfj^gZYWnVg^X]bVc!Wji^i^hZci^gZan
Y^gZXiZYidlVgYhadhh^ci]ZhZchZi]Vii]^hedlZg^hX]VgVXiZg^oZYVhedlZgidadhZ#>i^hdcani]gdj\]adhhi]Vi\adgn
VcY]dcdgVgZa^c`ZYidlZVai]#7ViV^aaZ!&.-*/&''#
'% I]Z]Zgd^X]jbVcWZ^c\YZhe^hZh]^h]Vee^cZhhVcY]^hjc]Vee^cZhh!]^hk^gijZhVcYk^XZh!VcY^c\ZcZgVai]Z
bZVhjg^c\d[i]^c\hWni]ZhiVcYVgYd[]^bhZa[=^hhigZc\i]a^Zh^c[dg\Zii^c\]^bhZa[C^ZiohX]Z!&..,/&**#
'& 6gZaVi^dcidi]Zdi]Zgi]Vi^h[gZZ[gdbYdb^cVi^dc^hVahdZmZbea^ZYWni]ZC^ZiohX]ZVc\jgZd[i]Z\Zc^jhd[
XjaijgZ/D[l]ViVXXdjci^h\Zc^jh^[^iYdZhcdiXdbbjc^XViZidi]ZdcZl]dXdciZbeaViZhVcYgZkZgZh^ihjX]
[gZZYdbVcYZaZkVi^dcd[[ZZa^c\i]VidcZcdadc\Zg]VhcZZYd[\Zc^jhGZcYZg^c\i]ZbhZakZhhjeZgjdjhh^X]
WZghh^\bVX]Zci]Vi^hi]Z\adgnd[i]Z\gZViC^ZiohX]Z!&.-+/'.-0&..%/&%-"&%.#=ViVWdW_ZXihidi]Z
k^Zli]Vii]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVa[dgZh]VYdlhC^ZiohX]ZhXgZVidgineZ#6XXdgY^c\id]^b!hjX]VXdccZXi^dc^hfj^iZ
egdWaZbVi^XWZXVjhZd[i]ZbZVc^c\d[hdkZgZ^\cin^ihiZmijVaVhhdX^Vi^dcl^i]bdgVa^in!VcYC^ZiohX]ZhXg^i^fjZ
d[bdYZgc^hi[gZZYdb=ViVW!&..*/(-#
'' :mVbeaZh[gdbC^ZiohX]ZhZVganVcYaViZldg`Xdcgbi]Vil]ViYZcZhi]Zeda^i^Xhd[i]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aa^hV
Xdci^cjZYXgjZainidVc^bVahC^ZiohX]Z!&..,/&+)#HZZVahd!higj\\a^c\X^k^a^oVi^dciVb^c\cZZYhZkZgn`^cY
d[^gdchVcYidgijgZidbV^ciV^c^ihZa[V\V^chiiZgg^WaZcZhhVcYWZVhi"d["egZncVijgZhC^ZiohX]Z!&.+-/)++#
'( L]ZgZVhk^daZcXZ]VhWZZcigVY^i^dcVaanViig^WjiZYidi]ZVc^bVa!C^ZiohX]ZViig^WjiZh^iidi]Z]jbVc!^ceVgi^XjaVg
idi]Zegd_ZXid[i]Z]jbVcVc^bVahX^k^a^oVi^dcVcYbdgVa^oVi^dc!Vegd_ZXiC^ZiohX]ZhhZZhXVgg^ZYdjii]gdj\]

&+.
K6C:HH6A:BB

]jbVcVc^bVaa^[Z![dg]^b!i]ZfjZhi^dc^h]dlidbV`ZVegdb^hZi]ViegdiZXihi]Z[gZZYdbVcY
eajgVa^ind[]jbVcVXi^dcl^i]djigZhi^c\dck^daZcXZVcYYdb^cVi^dcZmZgX^hZYdkZgi]Z]jbVc
Vc^bVahVc^bVaa^[Z#
Dci]^hgZVY^c\!l]Zci]Z]jbVcVc^bVaYZcZh^ihZa[V\V^chi^ihVc^bVa^inVcYVc^bVa[dg\Zi[ja"
cZhh!dgYZc^Zh^iVegdYjXi^kZgdaZ!XjaijgVaVcYeda^i^XVaa^[ZVhhjbZh[dgbhi]ViVgZWVhZYdc
Ydb^cVi^dcVcYZmead^iVi^dcd[]jbVchWn]jbVch#I]ZWgZZY^c\d[i]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aaVh
VcViiZbeiidigVchXZcYdgZmi^geViZVc^bVa^inVcYVc^bVa[dg\Zi[jacZhh^hVcZmVbeaZd[i]ZhZ
[dgbhd[Ydb^cVi^dc#8dcigVg^l^hZ!l]Zci]Z]jbVcVc^bVaZc\V\Zhl^i]^ihVc^bVa^inVcYVc^bVa
[dg\Zi[jacZhh!i]^h\^kZhg^hZid[dgbhd[XjaijgVaVcYeda^i^XVaa^[Zi]ViVgZgddiZY^ci]Zh^c\jaVg
]jbVcVc^bVahgZhedch^W^a^in#C^ZiohX]ZhXdcXZei^dcd[i]Zegdb^hZd[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVa
^hVcZmVbeaZd[V[dgbd[bZbdgni]Vi[gj^i[jaanZc\V\Zhl^i]i]Z]jbVcVc^bVahVc^bVa^in#
>ci]ZhdkZgZ^c\^cY^k^YjVa!bZbdgn^hcdi^bedhZYdci]Z]jbVcVc^bVah[dg\Zi[jacZhh#>chiZVY!i]Z
egdb^hZd[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVaedgigVnhi]Z[ZVijgZhd[Vc^bVa[dg\Zi[jacZhh#>ci]ZhdkZgZ^\c
^cY^k^YjVa!gZa^VW^a^inVcYegZY^XiVW^a^inVgZcdi[dgXZY!WjibVc^[Zhii]ZbhZakZh^ci]ZhdkZgZ^\c
^cY^k^YjVah^chi^cXid[gZhedch^W^a^inC^ZiohX]Z!&..)/)%#')C^ZiohX]ZhZZh^ci]Z[VXii]Vi
Vc^cY^k^YjVabjhiVXi^ci]ZcVbZd[^ihgZhedch^W^a^inVh^\ci]VihdkZgZ^\cinVcY\gZVicZhh
]VkZWZZcVX]^ZkZY#I]Z^cY^k^YjVah^chi^cXid[gZhedch^W^a^inh]djaYcdiWZXdc[jhZYl^i]^ihl^aa
edlZg/l]VibV`Zh[dghdkZgZ^\cin^cC^ZiohX]Z^hcdii]Z[VXii]Vii]Z^cY^k^YjVa^h[gZZVcYXdjaY
]VkZVXiZYdi]Zgl^hZ!Wjii]Vi^i^hhjW_ZXiidi]ZcZXZhh^ind[gZhedch^W^a^inVcY]ZcXZXdjaY
cdi]VkZVXiZYdi]Zgl^hZ#C^ZiohX]ZXdciZhihi]Z8]g^hi^Vc^YZVad[bdgVagZhedch^W^a^inl]^X]
gZhihdci]ZWZa^Z[i]Vi]jbVcVXi^dcgZhjaih[gdbi]Z^cY^k^YjVah[gZZYdbd[i]Zl^aaC^ZiohX]Z!
&.+-/+)"+*#<Zcj^cZgZhedch^W^a^in!^chiZVY!dXXjghl]Zck^ZlhhjX]Vhi]ZaViiZg]VkZWZZc
dkZgXdbZ#GZhedch^W^a^in^ci]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVa^hegdb^h^c\WZXVjhZ^i^h^bbdgVadgVbdgVa!
gVi]Zgi]ZcbdgVa0jcXdchX^djhgVi]Zgi]ZcXdchX^djh0^chi^cXi^kZgVi]Zgi]ZcgZZXiZY0cZXZhhVgn
gVi]Zgi]Zc[gZZ0V[dgbd[[dg\Zi[jacZhhgVi]Zgi]ZcV[dgbd[bZbdgn#'*
6XXdgY^c\idbn^ciZgegZiVi^dcd[C^ZiohX]Z!^i^hVb^hiV`Zidi]^c`i]Vii]Zegdb^hZXdchi^ijiZh
V[VXjain!VhZa["hj[X^ZciedlZg!Xjid[[[gdba^[Z#;dgC^ZiohX]Z!i]Zegdb^hZ^hV[dgXZd[a^[Z
i]Vi]VhidWZ^ckZhi^\ViZY[gdbi]ZeZgheZXi^kZd[a^[ZVhl^aaidedlZg#'+I]ZeZgheZXi^kZd[a^[Z
Vhl^aaidedlZggZkZVahi]Vii]Zegdb^hZ^hcdiV[dgbd[bZbdgn!Wji!dci]ZXdcigVgn!i]ViZkZgn
egdb^hZgZZXihVcVciV\dc^hi^X^ckdakZbZcid[bZbdgn[dgVcYV\V^chi[dg\Zi[jacZhh#>ci]^h
hZchZ!ZkZgnegdb^hZ^hcdih^beanV[dgbd[bZbdgnijgcZYidlVgYhi]ZeVhi!Vh6gZcYihj\\Zhih!
WjiVahdV[dgbd[[dg\Zi[jacZhhijgcZYidlVgYhi]Z[jijgZ#6XXdgY^c\an!C^ZiohX]ZY^hi^c\j^h]Zh

i]ZVhXZi^Xeg^Zhi/BdgVa^in^hVbZcV\Zg^Z0^ihegZb^hZ!i]Vi^gdcWVghVgZbdgZjhZ[jai]Vc[gZZYdb!ZkZc[dgi]Z
XVei^kZ0^ihdi]ZgegZb^hZ!i]Vii]ZgZVgZVc^bVaiVbZghl]dYdcdih]g^c`[gdb[g^\]i[jabZVch!l]d`cdl]dlid
]VcYaZgZY"]di^gdc#I]^h]dgg^XheZX^Zh!l]^X]VXXZeihWViiaZl^i]i]Zl^aYVc^bVa!XVaah^ihZa[eg^ZhiVhX^iZYWn
Cdgg^h!&.-*/."&&#Dci]ZgZhidgVi^dcd[Vc^bVak^daZcXZid^ihVbdgVa^ccdXZcXZ!hZZCdgg^h&.-*/."&&#
') I]ZegdjYgZVa^oVi^dcd[i]ZZmigVdgY^cVgneg^k^aZ\Zd[gZhedch^W^a^in!i]ZVlVgZcZhhd[i]^hgVgZ[gZZYdbVcYedlZgdkZg
]^bhZa[VcY]^hYZhi^cn!]VheZcZigViZY]^bidi]ZYZei]VcYWZXdbZVc^chi^cXi!]^hYdb^cVci^chi^cXiC^ZiohX]Z!
&..)/)%#
'* C^ZiohX]Z!\ZcZgVaanheZV`^c\!eg^k^aZ\Zhi]ZjcXdchX^djhdkZgXdchX^djhcZhh#Dci]ZZbZg\ZcXZd[XdchX^djhcZhh
VcY^ihgZaVi^dcidi]Z]jbVcVc^bVah]jbVc^oVi^dc!hdX^Va^oVi^dcVcYX^k^a^oVi^dc!hZZ^ceVgi^XjaVgC^ZiohX]Z!'%%&/
(%"('!(*!(,#
'+ 6XXdgY^c\an!VahdbZbdgn^cC^ZiohX]Zh]djaYcZ^i]ZgWZjcYZghiddYVhV[VXjain^ci]Z@Vci^VchZchZcdgVhVhZa["
hj[X^Zcidg\Vc#Dca^[ZVcYbZbdgn!hZZVahdHi^Z\aZg'%%&/*-",)#

&,%
 B:BDGN6C9EGDB>H:>C6G:C9I6C9C>:IOH8=:

WZilZZcild`^cYhd[egdb^hZh#I]Zghi`^cYd[egdb^hZ^cY^XViZhVk^Xidgnd[bZbdgndkZg
[dg\Zi[jacZhh#I]^hegdb^hZ^h!Vh^c6gZcYi!bVYZ^ci]ZcVbZd[i]ZeVhi#>i^h!a^`Zi]ZbZbdgn
d[i]Zl^aa!VbZVchidhiVW^a^oZVcYidhZXjgZi]ZXdci^cj^ind[i]ZeVhi!i]ZegZhZciVcYi]Z
[jijgZV\V^chii]ZjcXZgiV^ci^Zhd[i]Z[jijgZ#I]ZhZXdcY`^cYd[egdb^hZ^hZmZbea^ZYWni]Z
egdb^hZd[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVaVcYi]ZdkZg]jbVc#>i^cY^XViZhVk^Xidgnd[[dg\Zi[jacZhh
dkZgbZbdgn#I]^hegdb^hZ^hbVYZ^ci]ZcVbZd[i]Z[jijgZ#>i^hVbZVchcdidcanidWgZV`l^i]
i]ZeVhi!WjiVahdidgZkdaji^dc^oZi]ZegZhZci^ck^Zld[[jijgZa^[ZidXdbZ#6\V^chii]ZYVc\Zgh
^c]ZgZci^cVeda^i^Xhl]ZgZi]ZeVhiYdb^cViZhi]Z[jijgZ!i]^hegdb^hZlZaXdbZhi]ZgZijgcd[
Vc^bVa[dg\Zi[jacZhhVhi]Vi[dgXZl]^X]Y^hgjeihi]Z^YZci^inWZilZZceVhi!egZhZciVcY[jijgZ
^ci]ZcVbZd[i]Z[gZZVcYhedciVcZdjh\ZcZgVi^dcd[a^[Z#7di]`^cYhd[egdb^hZh"i]ZdcZhi]Vi
hiVW^a^oZVcYhZXjgZi]ZgjaZd[i]Z\gdjeVcYi]ZdcZhi]VigZkdaji^dc^oZ^i"VgZ!VXXdgY^c\id
C^ZiohX]Z!d[ZfjVakVajZid]jbVcVc^bVaa^[Z#9ZeZcY^c\dcl]Zi]Zga^[ZcZZYhidWZegZhZgkZY
dgl]Zi]Zga^[ZcZZYhidWZgZcZlZY!Z^i]Zgi]Zghidgi]ZhZXdcY`^cYd[egdb^hZegdiZXihi]Z
[gZZYdbVcYeajgVa^ind[]jbVcVXi^dc#
;gdbi]ZeZgheZXi^kZd[C^ZiohX]ZhXdcXZei^dcd[i]Zegdb^hZ!i]ZfjZhi^dchVYYgZhhZYVii]Z
WZ\^cc^c\id6gZcYihcdi^dcd[i]Zegdb^hZVg^hZ[gdbVc^chj[X^ZciXdch^YZgVi^dcd[i]ZkVajZd[
[dg\Zi[jacZhh#;^ghi![dg\Zi[jacZhhXdchi^ijiZhi]Zb^hh^c\a^c`WZilZZci]ZbZbdgnd[i]Z]jbVc
WZ^c\VhVWZ\^ccZgVcYi]ZVXijVaVXid[gZ"WZ\^cc^c\#',DcC^ZiohX]ZhVXXdjci!l]ViVaadlh
dcZidgZ"WZ\^c^h[dg\Zi[jacZhhWZXVjhZZkZgnVXi^dcgZfj^gZh[dg\Zi[jacZhhC^ZiohX]Z!&..,/
+'#;jgi]ZgbdgZ!l]ViegdiZXihi]Z[gZZYdbVcYeajgVa^ind[]jbVcVXi^dcV\V^chii]ZYVc\Zghd[
Vji]dg^in!i]Vi^h!d[Veda^i^XhYdb^cViZYWni]Z^chi^iji^dcd[i]ZeVhidkZgi]Z[jijgZ!^hVegdb^hZ
i]Vi`cdlh]dlidY^hgjeii]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aa^ci]ZcVbZd[i]Z[jijgZ#>cC^ZiohX]Z!hjX]
Vegdb^hZ]Vhi]ZedlZgidgZkdaji^dc^oZVc^chi^iji^dc^chjX]VlVni]Vii]ZaViiZgXVc^ihZa[
gZbV^c[V^i][jaidi]ZiVh`d[egdiZXi^c\VcYegZhZgk^c\i]Z[gZZYdbVcYeajgVa^ind[]jbVcVXi^dc#
AVhian!l]VigZYZZbhi]Z]jbVcVc^bVa[gdbi]Zk^daZcXZ^ckdakZY^ci]ZbV`^c\d[i]ZbZbdgn
d[i]Zl^aa^hVegdb^hZi]VideZchjeV[gZZVcYcdc"k^daZcigZaVi^dcidi]Zdi]Zg!VgZaVi^dci]Vi
YdZhcdihiVcYjcYZgi]ZgjaZd[i]Z]jbVcVc^bVah[dgXZYX^k^a^oVi^dcVcY]jbVc^oVi^dc#
;^cVaan!>ldjaYa^`ZidgZijgcidi]ZfjZhi^dcgV^hZYVii]ZWZ\^cc^c\!cVbZan!d[]dlidegZhZg"
kZi]Zhjgk^kVad[i]ZbZbdgnd[idiVa^iVg^Vc^hb^cVlVni]VihZXjgZhi]Z[jijgZd[eda^i^Xh!d[
]jbVc[gZZYdbVcYeajgVa^in#>cbnde^c^dc!Wdi]6gZcYiVcYC^ZiohX]Z]VkZVkVa^Yed^ciWZXVjhZ
Wdi]i]ZbZbdgnd[i]Zl^aaVcYi]Zegdb^hZd[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVaVgZcZZYZY^cdgYZgid
egZhZgkZi]ZbZbdgnd[idiVa^iVg^Vc^hb#Dci]ZdcZ]VcY!6gZcYi^hg^\]i^cVhhZgi^c\i]Vi^i^h
i]ZiVh`d[VYZbdXgVi^Xeda^inid\ZcZgViZ!egZhZgkZVcYegdiZXii]Zhjgk^kVad[i]ZbZbdgn
d[idiVa^iVg^Vc^hbWnbZVchd[^chi^ijiZY[dgbhd[bZbdgn#7ji!dci]Zdi]Zg]VcY!C^ZiohX]Z
eZghjVh^kZanh]dlhi]Vi^i^hi]Zegdb^hZd[i]ZhdkZgZ^\c^cY^k^YjVai]ViVaadlhjhidfjZhi^dc
i]Z^chi^iji^dchd[i]ZegZhZci^ci]Za^\]id[i]ZbZbdgnd[idiVa^iVg^Vc^hb!i]jhegdiZXi^c\jh
[gdbidiVa^iVg^Vc^hbhgZijgc#

', =dc^\Vg\jZhi]Vi[dg\^kZcZhh^c6gZcYi^hXdbeVgVWaZid[dg\Zi[jacZhh^cC^ZiohX]ZWZXVjhZWdi]VgZa^c`ZYidi]Z
VXid[WZ\^cc^c\=dc^\!&..(/-)"-,#>cXdcigVhiid=dc^\!>Vg\jZi]Vi[dg\^kZcZhh^c6gZcYi^ha^c`ZYidWZ\^cc^c\
cdiWZXVjhZ^i^hV[dgbd[[dg\Zi[jacZhh!Vh^cC^ZiohX]Z!Wji!dci]ZXdcigVgn!WZXVjhZ^i^hV[dgbd[bZbdgni]Vi
gZijgchidVWZ\^cc^c\l]^X]VaadlhdcZidgZ"WZ\^cdcZhZa[^ci]Z[jijgZ#Dci]ZgZaVi^dcWZilZZc[dg\Zi[jacZhhVcY
gZ"WZ\^cc^c\^cC^ZiohX]Z!hZZVahd8Vc^c\!&..%/&.%#

&,&
K6C:HH6A:BB

G:;:G:C8:H

6XVbedgV!8]g^hiV#'%%(#9Zbdh6\dc^hiZhGZYjm/GZZXi^dchdci]ZHigZ^id[Eda^i^XVa6\dc^hb#C^ZiohX]Z"HijY^Zc
('/(,)"(.%#
6chZaa"EZVghdc!@Z^i]#&..&#C^ZiohX]Z8dcigVGdjhhZVj#8VbWg^Y\Z/8VbWg^Y\ZJc^kZgh^inEgZhh#
6chZaa"EZVghdc!@Z^i]#&..)#6c>cigdYjXi^dcidC^ZiohX]ZVhVEda^i^XVaI]^c`Zg#8VbWg^Y\Z/8VbWg^Y\ZJc^kZgh^inEgZhh#
6gZcYi!=VccV]#&.*-#I]Z=jbVc8dcY^i^dc#8]^XV\d/Jc^kZgh^ind[8]^XV\dEgZhh#
6gZcYi!=VccV]#&.+*#DcGZkdaji^dc#AdcYdc/EZc\j^c7dd`h#
6gZcYi!=VccV]#&.+-#L]Vi^h6ji]dg^in4>c7ZilZZcEVhiVcY;jijgZ!ZY^iZYWn=#6gZcYi#AdcYdc/EZc\j^c7dd`h!
.&"&)&#
6gZcYi!=VccV]#&.+-#L]Vi^h;gZZYdb4>c7ZilZZcEVhiVcY;jijgZ!ZY^iZYWn=#6gZcYi#AdcYdc/EZc\j^c7dd`h!
&)("&,&#
7ViV^aaZ!<Zdg\Z#&.-*#I]Zcdi^dcd[ZmeZcY^ijgZ#>cK^h^dchd[:mXZhh!HZaZXiZYLg^i^c\h!&.',"&.(.!ZY^iZYWn6aaVc
HidZ`a#B^ccZhdiV/Jc^kZgh^ind[B^ccZhdiVEgZhh!&&+"&'.#
7gdlc!LZcYn#'%%%#C^ZiohX]Z[dgEda^i^Xh#>cL]nC^ZiohX]ZHi^aa4!ZY^iZYWn6aVc9#HX]g^[i#7Zg`ZaZnVcYAdh6c\ZaZh/
Jc^kZgh^ind[8Va^[dgc^VEgZhh!'%*"''(#
8Vc^c\!EZiZg#&..%#=dli]Z;VWaZWZXdbZhVLdgaY#>cAdd`^c\6[iZgC^ZiohX]Z!ZY^iZYWnAVlgZcXZ6#G^ZX`Zah#6aWVcn/
HiViZJc^kZgh^ind[CZlNdg`EgZhh!&,*"&.(#
8dclVn!9Vc^Za!L#&..,#C^ZiohX]ZVcYi]ZEda^i^XVa#;adgZcXZ!@N/GdjiaZY\Z#
9Zgg^YV!?VXfjZh#&..'#I]Z<^[id[9ZVi]#8]^XV\d/8]^XV\dJc^kZgh^inEgZhh#
9Zgg^YV!?VXfjZh#&..'V#<^kZcI^bZ/&#8djciZg[Z^iBdcZn#8]^XV\d/I]ZJc^kZgh^ind[8]^XV\dEgZhh#
9dbWdlh`n!9dc#'%%%#6GZhedchZid6aVcHX]g^[ihC^ZiohX]Z[dg9ZbdXgVXn4C^ZiohX]Z"HijY^Zc'./',-"'.%#
<Zg]VgYi!Kda`Zg#&.-(#Eg^co^eYZh<aZ^X]\Zl^X]ih#C^ZiohX]Z"HijY^Zc&'/&&&"&((#
=ViVW!AVlgZcXZ#&..*#6C^ZiohX]ZVc9Z[ZchZd[9ZbdXgVXn#8]^XV\d/DeZc8djgi#
=ViVW!AVlgZcXZ#'%%'#EgdheZXih[dgV9ZbdXgVi^X6\dc/L]nLZ8VcHi^aa7ZC^ZiohX]ZVch#>cI]Z?djgcVad[C^ZiohX]Z
HijY^Zh')/&('"&),#
=dc^\!7dcc^Z#&..(#Eda^i^XVaI]ZdgnVcYi]Z9^heaVXZbZcid[Eda^i^Xh#>i]VXVVcYAdcYdc/8dgcZaaJc^kZgh^inEgZhh#
=dg`]Z^bZg! BVm VcY 6Ydgcd! I]ZdYdg L# '%%'# 9^VaZXi^X d[ :ca^\]iZcbZci# CZl Ndg`/ I]Z 8dci^cjjb EjWa^h]^c\
8dbeVcn#
@^Zg`Z\VVgY!HdgZc#&.-*#;ZVgVcYIgZbWa^c\#AdcYdc/EZc\j^c7dd`h#
AdgZVjm!C^XdaZ#&..,#AV8^iY^k^hZ#AdjWa^ZZiaVbbd^gZY6i]cZh#EVg^h/EVndi#
BVX>cingZ!6aVhYV^g#&.-)#6[iZgK^gijZ#CdigZ9VbZ/CdigZ9VbZJc^kZgh^inEgZhh#
BX>cingZ!6aZm#&..,#I]ZHdkZgZ^\cind[?dn/C^ZiohX]ZhK^h^dcd[<gVcYEda^i^Xh#Idgdcid!7j[[Vad!AdcYdc/Jc^kZgh^ind[
IdgdcidEgZhh#
C^ZiohX]Z!;g^ZYg^X]#&.+-#I]ZL^aaidEdlZg!ZY^iZYWnLVaiZg@Vj[bVcc#IgVch#?#G#=daa^c\YVaZVcYLVaiZg@Vj[bVcc#
CZlNdg`/K^ciV\Z7dd`h#
C^ZiohX]Z!;g^ZYg^X]#&.-+#=jbVc!6aaIdd=jbVc#IgVch#?#G#=daa^c\YVaZ#8VbWg^Y\Z/8VbWg^Y\ZJc^kZgh^inEgZhh#
C^ZiohX]Z!;g^ZYg^X]#&..%#Il^a^\]id[i]Z>Ydah#IgVch#?#G#=daa^c\YVaZ#AdcYdc/EZc\j^c7dd`h#
C^ZiohX]Z!;g^ZYg^X]#&..)#Dci]Z<ZcZVad\nd[BdgVah#IgVch#8#9^Zi]Z#8VbWg^Y\Z/8VbWg^Y\ZJc^kZgh^inEgZhh#
C^ZiohX]Z! ;g^ZYg^X]# &..*# I]jh Hed`Z OVgVi]jhigV# IgVch# LVaiZg @Vj[bVcc# CZl Ndg`/ I]Z BdYZgc A^WgVgn! GVcYdb
=djhZ#
C^ZiohX]Z!;g^ZYg^X]#&..,#Jci^bZanBZY^iVi^dch#IgVch#G#?#=daa^c\YVaZ#8VbWg^Y\Z/8VbWg^Y\ZJc^kZgh^inEgZhh#
C^ZiohX]Z!;g^ZYg^X]#'%%&#I]Z<VnHX^ZcXZ#IgVch#?dhZe]^cZCVjX`]d[[#8VbWg^Y\Z/8VbWg^Y\ZJc^kZgh^inEgZhh#
Cdgg^h!BVg\di#&.-*#7ZVhihd[BdYZgc>bV\^cVi^dc!9Vgl^c!C^ZiohX]Z!@V[`V!:gchiVcYAVlgZcXZ#7Vai^bdgZ/I]Z?d]c
=de`^chJc^kZgh^inEgZhh#
DlZc!9Vk^Y#'%%'#:fjVa^in!9ZbdXgVXn!VcYHZa["GZheZXi/GZZXi^dchdcC^ZiohX]Zh6\dcVaEZg[ZXi^dc^hb#I]Z?djgcVa
d[C^ZiohX]ZHijY^Zh')/&&("&(&#
HVaa^h!?d]c#&..&#8gdhh^c\h#8]^XV\d/Jc^kZgh^ind[8]^XV\dEgZhh#
HX]VVe!HnWZ#'%%'#9^ZJc[~]^\`Z^iojkZg\ZhhZc#C^ZiohX]ZhJblZgijc\YZgLV]g]Z^ih[gV\Z#LgoWjg\/KZgaV\@c^\h]VjhZc
CZjbVcc<bW=#
HX]g^[i!6aVc9#'%%&#GZi]^c`^c\i]ZHjW_ZXi/Dg=dlDcZ7ZXdbZh"Di]Zgi]VcL]ViDcZ>h#>cC^ZiohX]ZhEdhibdgVa^hb!
:hhVnhdcC^ZiohX]ZhEgZajYZidE]^adhde]nh;jijgZ!ZY#G^X]VgYHX]VX]i#8VbWg^Y\Z/8VbWg^Y\ZJc^kZgh^inEgZhh!
),"+'#
HX]g^[i! 6aVc! 9# &..+# GZi]^c`^c\ :mX]Vc\Z/ Ad\^Xh d[ i]Z <^[i ^c 8^mdjh VcY C^ZiohX]Z# E]^adhde]n IdYVn Heg^c\/
&.,"'%*#
HX]g^[i!6aVc9#'%%%#GZhedchZid9dc9dbWdlh`n#C^ZiohX]Z"HijY^Zc'./'.&"'.,#

&,'
 B:BDGN6C9EGDB>H:>C6G:C9I6C9C>:IOH8=:

H^ZbZch!=ZgbVc#'%%&#6\dcVa8dc\jgVi^dch^ci]ZJcoZ^i\Zb~hhZ7ZigVX]ijc\Zc#C^ZiohX]Z"HijY^Zc(%/-%"&%+#
H^ZbZch!=ZgbVc#'%%'#6\dcVa8dbbjc^i^Zhd[IVhiZ/AVlVcY8dbbjc^in^cC^ZiohX]ZhE]^adhde]nd[IgVchkVajVi^dc#
I]Z?djgcVad[C^ZiohX]ZHijY^Zh')/-("&&'#
H]Ve^gd!<Vgn#&..&#6aXndcZ/C^ZiohX]Zdc<^[ih!Cd^hZVcYLdbZc#6aWVcn/HiViZJc^kZgh^ind[CZlNdg`EgZhh#
Hi^Z\aZg!7VgWVgV#'%%&#C^ZiohX]ZZiaVW^dad\^Z#EVg^h/EgZhhZJc^kZgh^iV^gZ;gVcXV^hZ#
K^aaV!9VcV#&..+#6gZcYiVcY=Z^YZ\\Zg#Eg^cXZidc!CZl?ZghZn/Eg^cXZidcJc^kZgh^inEgZhh!-%"&%.#
K^aaV!9VcV#'%%%#9ZbdXgVi^o^c\i]Z6\dc/C^ZiohX]Z!6gZcYi!VcYi]Z6\dc^hi^XIZcYZcXn^cGZXZciEda^i^XVaI]Zdgn#>c
L]nC^ZiohX]ZHi^aa4!ZY^iZYWn6aVc9#HX]g^[i#7Zg`ZaZnVcYAdh6c\ZaZh/Jc^kZgh^ind[8Va^[dgc^VEgZhh!'')"')+#

KVcZhhVAZbbZhE]9Zc;^adhd[VYZaVCZlHX]dda[dgHdX^VaGZhZVgX]YZCjZkVNdg`!:hiVYdhJc^Ydh#=Vh^Ydegd[ZhdgV
Z^ckZhi^\VYdgVZcaVh{gZVhYZadhd[VnX^ZcX^Vedai^XVZcCdgi]lZhiZgcJc^kZgh^in'%%'"'%%*niVbW^cZcZa:jgdeZVc
8daaZ\Z[dgA^WZgVa6gih!7Zga^c'%%)"'%%*#9ZhYZ'%%+Zhegd[ZhdgV^ckZhi^\VYdgVZcaVZhXjZaVYZ8^ZcX^VEdai^XVn
ZcZa>chi^ijidYZ=jbVc^YVYZhYZaVJc^kZgh^YVY9^Z\dEdgiVaZh!8]^aZ#6XijVabZciZZhi{XdbeaZbZciVcYdC^ZiohX]Zh
6c^bVaE]^adhde]n#Dc;dg\Zi[jacZhh!BZbdgnVcYi]Z7ZXdb^c\d[8jaijgZ!a^WgdfjZejWa^XVg{ZcZa'%%,_jcidV;dgY]Vb
Jc^kZgh^inEgZhh#
:"bV^a/KVcZhhV#aZbb5egd[#jYe#Xa
&,(