Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
I agree music in the liturgy does give praise and thanks to God and does intensify and
enhance the words and actions of the rite. It supports the sung prayer of the people
who share in Christs priestly action through virtue of their baptism1. I will first look
perspective firstly in the Vatican, then in the United States of America, before briefly
liturgical music should be chosen and highlight some issues and obstacles that hinder
having one evaluation of the three judgments that is liturgically, pastorally and
The theological role of music in the post-modern era begins with the Second Vatican
1963 that brought reform to the Liturgy. It saw clearly the essential role of sacred
song and singing as a means to achieve the primary aim of participation that was
fully conscious and active, modified to the needs of today and leads to increasing
both physical and mental strength and energy in the faithful (SCL 112, 1, 14, 30; MS
15.2 It did away with the distinction between the low mass and the sung mass3. When
we refer to music and Liturgy we are talking about sacred music. The fathers said
there was no one sacred form of music, however the more music was connected with
1
Capra, Elio. Introduction to Liturgy, Lecture Notes (Melbourne CTC, 2014) 27 May
2
Vatican Translation, The Documents of Vatican II: With Notes and Index, (Strathfield NSW: St
Pauls Publications, 2009) 116, 96, 99
3
Gelineau, Joseph Liturgical Assembly, Liturgical Song (Pastoral Press: Portland, 2002) 82
Name: Peter Sheehan ID: 201317602 DL8000C 3
the liturgy the more holy it became (SCL112). The old four-hymn sandwich is gone
The only other Vatican document promulgated by the Sacred Congregation for Rites
was Musicam Sacram MS (Sacred Music) in 1967 two years before the New Order
of Mass was released. It was dealing with the Trindentine (Latin) Rite that was about
through the paschal mystery we are brought from defeat and despair to new life.
These documents plus the new Order of Mass, the General Instruction of the Roman
Missal (GIRM) and the Roman Missal were published in Latin. Translation was done
4
Breedlove, Jennifer K and Turner, Paul Liturgical Ministry Series: Guide for Music Ministers
2nd Ed. (Chicago: Liturgy Training Publications LTP, 2010) 38
5
Taylor, Dr. Paul. Introduction to Liturgy, Lecture Notes (Melbourne CTC, 2014) April 29
6
Foley, Edward A Lyrical Vision American Essays in Liturgy Ebook, (Minnesota, Liturgical
Press, 2009) 4%
7
Foley, Ibid, 30%
Name: Peter Sheehan ID: 201317602 DL8000C 4
The US bishops, in their commitment to liturgical and musical reforms especially the
celebration as priority (before the musical). It also emphasised the liturgy being an
attractive human experience (III). And identified three judgments to be made, based
on the principles of CSL, the musical, liturgical and pastoral8(III. C). It also
liturgical sequence.
There were several issues, Foley identifies, at this time. One issue that arose was the
emphasis on active participation, which meant the congregation were now the
musical subjects in the liturgy and the choir was no longer the main musical voice. A
key concern was getting a balance between the pastorally acceptable considering
the assembly, and the aesthetically pleasing the art and beauty of professional
liturgical music9.
Tied to this was the Gregorian chant was sung in Latin, written for specialists, was
not conducive to the congregation singing, (due somewhat to its complexity) and the
aim of the council fathers for the assembly to be fully and consciously participating.
8
Foley, Ibid, 19%
9
Foley, Ibid, 14%
Name: Peter Sheehan ID: 201317602 DL8000C 5
There were professional musicians who served at key cathedrals who were being
challenged by this and having to redefine themselves and their liturgical role.
A related tension was a 1965 debate about more contemporary forms of music for
high school and college students. Fr Godfrey Diekmann advocated the use of guitars
and folk music in Eucharistic liturgies with students. Students became effectively a
Special (Music) Group for whom music needs to be meaningful for the liturgy to
In 1966 the Friends of the English Liturgy published the Hymnal for Young
Christians. This included the song And theyll know we are Christians by our
Love by Peter Scholtes which became a classic of sorts its time11. It was certainly
a song I played on my guitar and sang in the late 70s and early 80s. Like me,
there were a lot of volunteer musicians who had no musical or liturgical training
There also arose a boom in the publishing industry of religious music, which Paul
Taylor refers to as the commercially driven cult of Liturgical Music12, with this
10
Foley, Ibid, 14%
11
Foley, Ibid, 33%
12
Taylor, Op. Cit., 29 April
Name: Peter Sheehan ID: 201317602 DL8000C 6
clear parallel in regard to the judgments and the MCW has expanded the discussion.
It also adds paragraphs on role descriptions for the congregation (MCW 34), the
choir (MCW 36) and the organist and other instrumentalists (MCW 37-38). William
Bauman says one of MCWs primary contributions was its distinction between
musical style and quality, with its acceptance of the folk music and ending of the
46)14. The most comprehensive document produced by the US bishops in 2007 was
Sing to the Lord: Music in Divine Worship which was a revision of both MCW
and Liturgical Music Today (LMT) from 1982. It further elaborates on the three
judgments but stresses a single evaluation. It also changed the original order to
why we sing.
think Taylor has it right as he emphasises the beauty of sung dialogue and the
expression of faith and praying, than the low and more monotone spoken voices15.
13
Foley, Op. Cit., 35%
14
Foley, Ibid, 48%
15
Taylor, Op. Cit., April 29
Name: Peter Sheehan ID: 201317602 DL8000C 7
Paul Taylor says when music is selected for liturgy we have things upside down. In
terms of importance the ministerial chants are first, then the mass settings and lastly
the celebration of the Mass, every care should be taken that singing by
the ministers and the people not be absent in celebrations that occur on
be sung by the Priest or the Deacon or a reader, with the people replying,
To this end the ICEL has produced The Revised ICEL Chant Mass. In Australia these
also Recommended Masses by Australian Composers and asked parishes to adopt the
16
Taylor, Op. Cit., April 29
17
The General Instruction Of The Roman Missal: Final Text With Application for Australia
(Strathfield NSW: St Pauls Publications, 2012) 26
18
Catholic Church in Australia ACBC National Liturgical Council Music Mass Settings
http://www.catholic.org.au/national-liturgical-council/music [Accessed 24 May 2014]
Name: Peter Sheehan ID: 201317602 DL8000C 8
The ACBC in 2009 produced, through the National Liturgical Musical Board
Liturgiam Authenticam. These were endorsed and approved and are now waiting
recognitio from the Congregation for Divine Worship. In this process it used sub-
Liturgical (refer Attachment A) that appear to have a different title and order of
the NLMB was not following the US document (STTL) it was a practical
convenience, more than anything else to consider the items on the list
Despite the obvious work in this area of liturgical music, I had never heard of this
until now, and I have been song leading with guitar for approximately 35 years. I
find this quite curious. I feel a sense of liturgical and musical disconnect has
19
Catholic Church in Australia ACBC National Liturgical Music Board Recommended Hymns and
songs approved by the ACBC http://www.catholic.org.au/national-liturgical-music-
board/recommended-hymns-and-songs-approved-by-the-acbc
20
Taylor, Paul Dr., e-mail message to author, 26 May, 2014
Name: Peter Sheehan ID: 201317602 DL8000C 9
All the judgments are part of the one question Is this particular piece of music
appropriate for use in the liturgy?21 Does it add delight and beauty to prayer?
Does it foster unity of minds? Does it confer greater solemnity? These are the
effects of sacred music identified by the council fathers22. Does it help people
enter more fully into communion with God and each other in Christ (STTL69)?
The primary liturgical instrument is the human voice, it too is the image and
likeness of God (STTL86). As St. Augustine says Singing is for one who loves.
It is personal23 and it is about a relationship of love with the God of love. Not all
pieces of music do this and the Liturgy does not usually ask or require this. When
making the evaluation, each of the judgments cant be applied in isolation and
In summary MCW says music has a ministerial role in helping faithful to express
and strengthen their faith; Prayer role in singing the Mass (parts); it unifies us to
one another and Christ; Other times it accompanies an action, words, or both
action and words. Liturgical music contributes to good celebrations (MCW 5).24
21
Unites States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) Sing to the Lord: Music in Divine
Worship 2007 (Washington DC: USCCB Publishing, 2008) 38
22
Vatican, Op. Cit., 42
23
USCCB, Op. Cit., 1
24
Archdiocese of Canberra and Goulburn Music in the Liturgy (Canberra: Liturgical Commission,
2004) http://www.cg.catholic.org.au/_uploads/rsfil/00056.pdf [Accessed 24 May 2014] 2
Name: Peter Sheehan ID: 201317602 DL8000C 10
This judgment asks whether the piece of music is in accord with the liturgical
rites structure and text. This requires the selector of music to be a Pastoral
musician who has a good working knowledge of the liturgical books especially
the Order of Mass and the GIRM and the Roman Missal.
The ICEL has provided chants, both solemn and simple, for every setting in the
takes on the importance of rites being sung more stars means more important:25 26
INTRODUCTORY RITES
Psalm ****
Gospel Acclamation *****
Profession of Faith *
General Intercessions **
25
Archdiocese of Canberra and Goulburn, Op. Cit., 5
26
Bishops Conference of England & Wales Singing the Mass Music Committee, 2007.
Name: Peter Sheehan ID: 201317602 DL8000C 11
Preparation of Gifts
Eucharistic Prayer
Communion Rite
Lords Prayer **
Doxology **
Lamb of God ***
Communion ****
Thanksgiving after Communion *
Concluding Rites
Blessing *
Recessional!! ! ! ! ! ! ***!!
A lot of praise and worship songs are excluded by the Priest because of the text,
even of songs composed by Catholic artists. When selecting songs the music needs
to be in accordance with the Liturgical cycle and season. For example, in Lent and
Advent there will be no Alleluia sung at the Gospel Acclamation. The mood will
Paul Taylor says ideally the Entrance and Communion Antiphons should be sung
as Antiphonal (back and forth) during the respective processionals rather than
The Responsorial Psalm refrain should ideally be sung by the assembly, even if the
verses are read by the lector/ reader. There are resources such as The Lyric
Psalter27 to aid in finding suitable sung responses. Ideally dialogues such as the
opening, closing and the Gospel and Preface Dialogues should be chanted (using
the ICEL vernacular recommended by the ACBC) by the Presider and the people.
For choice of hymns it is hard, for Song and Choir Leaders, to find songs that fit in
with the scripture readings and the Sunday theme which should be sought in the
Preface and the Collect prayers. In Australia our local song source is As One
Voice hymnals of Willow Publishing, who have recently released The Next
Generation.
Generally the entrance song uses a gathering theme, and the recessional a
sending theme. Br. Paul Skippen calls this mass structure GPBS (Gather,
and enjoyable engaging not entertaining. He says WE are the Church and when
and accepting of all people and be open to other styles of music. The lyrics must
27
Alonso, Tony & Haugen, Marty The Lyric Psalter: Year A Revised Grail Lectionary Psalms
(Chicago: GIA Publications, 2010)
28
Skippen, Paul Br. and Ogilvie, Gina Celebrate Often & Celebrate Well Seminar Notes,
http://gpbs.com.au (Traralgon: Lavalla Catholic College, 2014) 19 May
Name: Peter Sheehan ID: 201317602 DL8000C 13
This judgment asks Does this song or music piece serve the assembly at this
moment, in this situation?29 Will it draw them closer the holy mysteries, to Christ
Within Australian parishes today, there are a lot of multi-ethnic and multi-cultural
communities, such as Sri Lankan, Indian, Sudanese and Philippine, who have their
own music and traditions. The top three countries of birth of Casey residents (other
than Australia) in 2011 were United Kingdom (11,500 people), India (10,300
people) and Sri Lanka (7,600 people)31. Musicians from these countries who
STTL says other factors need to be considered such as the age, language and
education of the assembly. There is a widening gap between older members and
younger church goers. For example, between 1991 and 2011 the number of
Catholics over 75 has doubled and more than one in four Catholics are aged 55 or
over.32 Australians are better educated. The number of Catholics with a Post
Graduate degree has increased by a factor of five between 1991 and 2011 and 18%
29
Breedlove & Turner, Op. Cit., 39
30
USCCB, Op. Cit., 40
31
City of Casey Demographics http://www.casey.vic.gov.au/council/our-city/demographics
[Accessed 26 May 2014]
32
ACBC Pastoral Research Office Change over time in the Catholic population Issue 13, 25
October 2012.
33
ACBC Pastoral Research Office Educational Qualifications of Catholics Issue 16, 22
November 2012
Name: Peter Sheehan ID: 201317602 DL8000C 14
In the City of Casey 73 per cent of their 270,00 people follow a faith, and the
largest are Roman Catholic (70,700 people), Anglican (29,000 people), Islam
(13,900 people), Buddhism (9,900 people) and Uniting Church (7,900 people).
communicate a clear vision for the parish, their ability to get people to work
together, and a readiness to encourage parishioners to put their gifts and skills to
use for the good of the parish. It also found a high quality of celebration is
Accordingly the Pastoral judgment is keenly important and can overtake the other
judgments in determining the song choice. Favourite and popular songs are
selected, in a more protestant manner, due to the vigorous singing response of the
assembly.
34
ACBC Pastoral Research Office: Building Stronger Parishes What makes people feel they
belong September 2011
Name: Peter Sheehan ID: 201317602 DL8000C 15
This judgment asks Is this song or music piece good worthy technically,
artistically?36 The style of music must reflect ideals of true art and beauty,
therefore it must avoid the profane and promote a sense of the sacred, not be trite,
clich or cheap.
To do this, music and song leaders with next to no training in liturgy and music,
attempt to choose songs that fit in with at least the general liturgical moment and
be well known by the assembly so they can sing along. We dont do an entrance
who produce liturgical songs and mass settings such as Paul Taylor, John
Wilcock, Gina Ogilvie, Pat Keady, Rob Galea and Roby Curtis. An example given
by Paul Taylor, that was included mainly for Pastoral reasons was Here I am
Lord as it had wide pastoral currency despite it not having textual or musical
35
USCCB Sing to the Lord, Op. Cit., 40
36
Breedlove & Turner, Op. Cit., 39
37
Taylor, Paul Dr., e-mail message to author, 26 May, 2014
Name: Peter Sheehan ID: 201317602 DL8000C 16
The role of the music being sung is to encourage and support the assembly so they
sing. This means doing songs that are well known even if musically they are tiring
you. The aim is to build a repertoire of music, both new and old, that builds a
collective memory amongst the people. New songs and pieces, as well as
different Mass settings, need to be introduced patiently and slowly. The singers or
the choir can help this by singing harmonies to enrich the singing and sing those
parts the assembly cannot manage. Technically the music itself, the melody,
rhythm, pitch, note range and accompaniment style should foster prayerful
participation. The phrases, intervals and harmonies should not be difficult to sing
Once the assembly are singing well, you should step back from the microphone so
they can hear themselves. The volume of the instruments or singers should not be
so loud that the assembly cant hear themselves and are forced to listen because
A 2004 survey on Who goes when? concludes that Sunday evening masses, have
higher attendances but the people have less connection, are more educated,
younger and more come from outside the Parish; they prefer more contemporary
music as do Saturday evening masses. Early Sunday masses are attended by older
people, who prefer hymns and are more connected with the church38.
38
Dixon, Bob and Bond, Sharon Who goes when? Mass attenders and their usual Mass time A
report to the ACBC Pastoral Projects Office, November 2004
http://www.pro.catholic.org.au/researcharts#movingAway [Accessed 26 May 2014]
Name: Peter Sheehan ID: 201317602 DL8000C 17
What I have sought to demonstrate is that Sacred Music, whether it is for praise
and thanksgiving or to enhance the words and actions of the liturgical rite is not an
easy or by any means simple process. The judgments themselves are more like
guiding principles rather than science. They help clarify issues pertaining to song
selection for Liturgy. The process is convoluted by differing interests and factors
which include the nature of the assembly, the time the rite is held, who is attending,
the type of liturgical rite and who is presiding over the rite. I have focused on the
Eucharistic Rite but there are similar issues pastorally, liturgically and musically
The parish situation are so varied and unique they all require their own specific
the people and resources at the disposal of priests is usually somewhat finite,
I think we need to think bigger and always keep in mind the spirit of the liturgy
and attempt to best apply the major principles from CSL especially adaptations to
different cultures, especially the youth for they are the church of the future.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
ACBC Pastoral Research Office Change over time in the Catholic population
22 November 2012
Alonso, Tony & Haugen, Marty The Lyric Psalter: Year A Revised Grail
Bishops Conference of England & Wales Singing the Mass Leaflet, Music
Committee, 1997
Breedlove, JK and Turner, Paul Liturgical Ministry Series: Guide for Music
24 May 2014]
Name: Peter Sheehan ID: 201317602 DL8000C 19
May
Dixon, Bob and Bond, Sharon Who goes when? Mass attenders and their usual
2002
Skippen, Paul Br. and Ogilvie, Gina Celebrate Often & Celebrate Well Seminar
Taylor, Dr. Paul. Introduction to Liturgy, Lecture Notes, Melbourne CTC, 2014
The General Instruction Of The Roman Missal: Final Text With Application for
Unites States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) Sing to the Lord: Music
Vatican Translation, The Documents of Vatican II: With Notes and Index,
ATTACHMENT A
Scriptural
Apt for the season
Theologically robust
Thematically and linguistically coherent
In modern/classical language (rather than in archaic or
temporarily contemporary language)
In common possession and with likely appeal
With poetic power.
Music must properly support text being sung, with the proper
relationship of verbal and music accents etc.
Source: Catholic Church in Australia ACBC National Liturgical Music Board Recommended
board/recommended-hymns-and-songs-approved-by-the-acbc