Appendix 1

target compounds test name Manufacturer compounds covered
Arsenic XRF Niton As

Arsenic Quantofix Macherey Nagel As3+/5+
Arsenic Quantofix Macherey Nagel As3+/5+
Arsenic Merckoquant Merck As3+/5+
Arsenic Merckoquant Merck As3+/5+
Barium XRF Niton Ba
Cadmium XRF Niton Cd
Cadmium CadmiumCheck Hybrivet Cd
Chromate Quantofix Macherey Nagel Cr042-
Chromate Merckoquant Merck Cr042-
Chromate Microquant Merck Cr042-
Chromate Aquaquant Merck Cr042-
Chromate ChromateCheck Hybrivet Cr042-
Chromate Aquaquant Merck Cr042-
Chromium XRF Niton Cr
Copper XRF Niton Cu
copper Quantofix Macherey Nagel Cu1+/2+
copper Merckoquant Merck Cu1+/2+
copper Aquaquant Merck Cu1+/2+
Copper CopperCheck Hybrivet Cu2+
cyanide Quantofix Macherey Nagel CN-
cyanide Merckoquant Merck CN-
cyanide Microquant Merck CN-
cyanide Aquaquant Merck CN-
cyanide Aquaquant Merck CN-
Lead XRF Niton Pb
Lead Leadcheck Hybrivet Pb
lead Merckoquant Merck Pb2+
Mercury XRF Niton Hg
Mercury MercuryCheck Hybrivet Hg
Nickel XRF Niton Ni
Nickel Quantofix Macherey Nagel Ni2+
Nickel Merckoquant Merck Ni2+
Nickel Microquant Merck Ni2+
Nickel NickelCheck Hybrivet Ni
Nickel Aquaquant Merck Ni2+
Zinc XRF Niton Zn
Zinc Quantofix Macherey Nagel Zn2+
Zinc Merckoquant Merck Zn2+
Zinc Aquaquant Merck Zn2+
Zinc Microquant Merck Zn2+
Flashpoint Setaflash Stanhope Seta ambient flash point
Heavy metals X-MET3000TXS+ Oxford Instruments Pb, As, Cr, Cu, Zn, Ni, Cd, Co, Se, Mo, H
Metals PTEA Wagtech all
Metals Alpha Innovx Pb, As, Cr, Cu, Zn, Ni, Cd, Co, Se, Mo, H
Wiithin desired range

Meets one of the criteria
Outside desired range
Price (ex VAT) Number of tests price per test capital spend also? detection limits
~ 20,000 Unlimited N/A yes 11mg/kg
45.20 100 0.45 no 0.1 mg/l
43.25 100 0.43 no 0.01mg/l
56.30 100 0.56 no 0.005mg/l
68.30 100 0.68 no 0.02mg/l
~ 20,000 Unlimited N/A yes 100 mg/kg
$39.95 8 no 0.001mg/kg
21.65 100 0.22 no 3 mg/l
49.90 100 0.50 no 3mg/l
128.00 300 0.43 no 0.2mg/l
71.80 300 0.24 no 0.01mg/l
$39.95 8 no 0.001mg/kg
159.00 150 1.06 no 0.2mg/l
13.50 100 0.14 no 10 mg/l
38.50 100 0.39 no 10mg/l
159.00 100 1.59 no 0.05mg/l
$24.95 8 no 0.001mg/kg
33.15 100 0.33 no 1 mg/l
91.40 100 0.91 no 1 mg/l
102.00 200 0.51 no 0.3mg/l
159.00 200 0.80 no 0.002mg/l
153.00 65 2.35 no 0.03mg/l
$49.95 6 no 400ppm
61.10 100 0.61 no 20 mg/l
$39.95 8 no 0.001mg/kg
16.30 100 0.16 no 10mg/l
41.70 100 0.42 no 10mg/l
121.00 300 0.40 no 0.5mg/l
$39.95 8 no 0.001mg/kg
159.00 125 1.27 no 0.02mg/l
24.50 100 0.25 no 2mg/l
61.50 100 0.62 no 10mg/l
159.00 120 1.33 no 0.1mg/l
102.00 100 1.02 no 0.1mg/l
3000 approx Unlimited yes ambient temperature
Cu, Zn, Ni, Cd, Co, Se, Mo, Hg, Sb,
12Ag,
hour
Babattery life yes 5 ppm
14,000.00 reagents 10ppb
Cu, Zn, Ni, Cd, Co, Se, Mo, Hg, Sb,
8 Ag,
hourBa
life yes
Detection range suitability for soils / Sample preparation requirements Reagent requirements
Up to % levels soil test Not necessary, but soil can be drie Plastic bags
0-3 mg/l liquid test buffering of sample supplied in kit
0-0.5mg/l liquid test buffering of sample supplied in kit
0-0.5mg/l liquid test buffering of sample supplied in kit
surface test supplied in kit
0-100mg/l liquid test buffering of sample supplied in kit
0-22mg/l liquid test disc preparation supplied in kit
0-0.22mg/l liquid test yes supplied in kit
3.6mg/l liquid test yes supplied in kit
0-300 mg/l liquid test
0-300mg/l liquid test supplied in kit
0.5mg/l liquid test yes supplied in kit
0-30 mg/l liquid test supplied in kit
0-5mg/l liquid test yes supplied in kit
soil test extractiion require supplied in kit
0-500mg/l liquid test buffering of sample supplied in kit
0-1000 mg/l liquid test
0-500mg/l liquid test supplied in kit
0-100 liquid test buffering of sample supplied in kit
0-250mg/ liquid test buffering of sample supplied in kit
0-5mg/l liquid test yes supplied in kit
0-300oC suitable some Gas bottle approximately
typically 5-30 ppm up t designed for soils none none
10-32ppb water-soil extraction yes extraction kit
up to % levels designed for soils none none
Time per test Portability Data Interpretation Shelf life
60 - 120 s hand portable X-ray fluorescnce Unlimited
10-20 seconds pocket size colour scale 2.5 years from manufacture
less than 1minute pocket size colour scale Approx 2years
1 minute pocket size colur scale Approx 2years
approx 1 minute pocket size colour scale Approx 2years
pocket size colour scale
10 minutes pocket size colour scale Approx 2years
1 minute pocket sized colour scale Approx 2years
less than 2 minutes Flight case size digital readout Unlimmited
10-120 seconds dependihandheld digital readout 5 year guarantee
10 minutes Flight case size LCD screen Approx 2years
10-120 seconds dependihandheld digital readout
target compounds test name Manufacturer
PRO SiteLAB UVF-3100 SiteLAB
RaPID Assay Total

PRO SDI
BTEX/TPH
DRO SiteLAB UVF-3100 SiteLAB
DRO SiteLAB TD-500 SiteLAB
DRO PetroFLAG Dexsil
Oils SiteLAB UVF-3100 SiteLAB
Oils SiteLAB TD-500 SiteLAB
Oils PetroFLAG Dexsil

Oil Oil test paper Macherey Nagel
Benzene Voyager Portable GC Photovac
PetroPRO Portable
Benzene Photovac
GC
Toluene Voyager Portable GC Photovac
PetroPRO Portable
Toluene Photovac
GC
Ethylbenzene Voyager Portable GC Photovac

PetroPRO Portable
Ethylbenzene Photovac
GC
Xylene Voyager Portable GC Photovac
PetroPRO Portable
Xylene Photovac
GC
PAH SiteLAB UVF-3100 SiteLAB
PAH SiteLAB TD-500 SiteLAB
PAH - 3-4-ring RaPID Assay PAH SDI
PAH - 5-6-ring RaPID Assay PAH SDI
PCB RaPID Assay PCB SDI
PCB Total PCB Cape Technology
Toxicity ROTAS Cybersense
pH Pocket pH meter Hanna Instruments
Extra rugged
pH Hanna Instruments
waterproof pH meter
pH Indicator papers Merck
pH Tritest Macherey Nagel
pH pH-Fix Macherey Nagel
pH Micro 500 pH meter Palin test
Organics Microsaic Systems

ChemPack
Hapsite ER Chemical
VOC's and Industrial chemicals Identification Inficon
Systems
Oils Soil test kit Hanby
soil Soil pH kit Palin test

Alkalinity Alkalinity test kit Hanna Instruments
Alkalinity LaMotte
total alkalinity direct r
Wiithin desired range

Meets one of the criteria
Outside desired range
compounds covered Price (ex VAT) Number of tests price per test
Using B-optics covers PRO

210.00 20 10.50
aromatics (C6 - C10)
C6 - C14 230.00 12 19.17
Using A-optics covers EDRO

210.00 20 10.50
PAH, Oil, tar (C16-C40) 210.00 20 10.50
Aromatics + Aliphatics C10 - C40 175.00 10 17.50
Using A-optics covers EDRO

210.00 20 10.50
PAH, Oil, tar (C16-C40) 210.00 20 10.50
Aromatics + Aliphatics C10 - C40 175.00 10 17.50

oil 24.95 100 0.2495
Cost of plastic
bags/headspace
VOCs - full speciation vial + 150 - 300 Unlimited N/A
for calibration and
carrier gases
Cost of plastic
bags/headspace
BTEX - full speciation vial + 150 - 300 Unlimited N/A
for calibration and
carrier gases
Cost of plastic
bags/headspace
for calibration and
carrier gases
Cost of plastic
bags/headspace
for calibration and
carrier gases
Cost of plastic
bags/headspace
for calibration and
carrier gases
Cost of plastic
bags/headspace
for calibration and
carrier gases
Cost of plastic
bags/headspace
for calibration and
carrier gases
Cost of plastic
bags/headspace
for calibration and
carrier gases
Using D-optics covers PAH

210.00 20 10.50
PAH, Oil, tar (C16-C40) 210.00 20 10.50
3 and 4-ring PAH (C13 - C20) 230.00 12 19.17
5 and 6-ring PAH (C18 - C22) 320.00 12 26.67
PCB - fully quantitative 230.00 12 19.17
PCB - semiquantitative 525.00 30 17.50
Broad screen toxicity 167.00 22 7.59
105.00 Unlimited
249.00 Unlimited
all 2.50 100 0.025

all 10.00 limited by the length of strip used. P
all 2.50 100 0.025
325.50 Unlimited
soil unlimted
VOCs - full speciation $75-95000 Unlimited
TPH in soils $900 15
soil 30.15 50 0.60

soil 28.00 110 0.25
Measures alaklinity as calcium
50 0.00
carbonate
suitability for soils /
Capital cost detection limits Detection range
sludges
10K 1 mg/kg No upper limit yes
4.9K 2 mg/kg No upper limit yes

9 mg/kg qualititative yes surface test
20K 10 mg/kg No upper limit yes (by headspace)
10 - 15K 11 mg/kg No upper limit yes (by headspace)

4.9K 20 mg/kg 0.2 - 5.0 mg/kg yes
4.9K 21 mg/kg 10 - 500 g/kg yes
4.9K 22 mg/kg Need to verify yes
1.8K 23 mg/kg Need to verify yes
Dependent on Dependent on
4.5K yes
compound compound
dependent on
pH1-14 yes
calibration
dependent on
pH1-14 yes
calibration
scales maybe require0-14 0-14 can be used for solid
no 0-11 0-11 can be used for solid
no 0-14 0-14 can be used for solid
pH1-14 ph1-14 leachate in soil
ppm
Dependent on
ppm yes
compound
Dependent on Dependent on
soil
compound compound
pH1-14 ph1-14 soil
3mg/l 0-300mg/l liquid test
4ppm 0-200ppm yes
Sample preparation requirements Reagent requirements Time per test Portability
Extraction kit + PRO

Weigh out sample, extract with 1 sample 5-10 min, 10
calibrator kit (reusable for 3 Portable
methanol, filter, dilute, analyse samples 1 hr
months) + methanol
Weigh out sample, extract with
All included in test kit 12 samples 2 hrs Portable
methanol, filter, dilute, analyse
Extraction kit + EDRO
calibrator kit (reusable for 3 Portable,
months) + methanol
Extraction kit + TPH
calibrator kit (reusable for 3 Pocket size
months) + methanol
Regagent test kit Pocket size
Extraction kit + TPH/oil
months) + methanol
Extraction kit + TPH
months) + methanol
Regagent test kit Pocket size
no none seconds pocket size
Place sample in bag or

headspace vial, vial can be Plastic bags or headspace
heated if required, pierce bag/vial vials, calibration gas made 10 min Portable
septum to automatically draw up to specification
sample

sample

sample

sample

sample
sample

sample

sample
Extraction kit + PAH

months) + methanol
Extraction kit + PAH
months) + methanol

All included in test kit 5 samples 1 hr Pocket size
Measure out sample by volume, Portable, use

All included in test kit 22 sample 1 hr
extract with water, filter, analyse with computer
Calibration and cleaning

Test leachate from sample solutions approxmately 15- 1-2minutes Pocket size
20 each
Test leachate from sample solutions approxmately 15- 1-2minutes handheld
20 each
none (some samples may require wnone 10 seconds pocket size
Test leachate from sample solutions approxmately 15- 1-2minutes handheld
20 each
some extraction maybe necessary 10minutes flight case size

10minutes Ruc-sack sized
measure sample by weight, All included in test kit (refills

5minutes flight case size
extract and analyse $250)
All included in test kit 1-2minutes flight case size
Test leachate from sample supplied in kit 10minutes Pocket size
extraction requires supplied in kit 10minutes Pocket size
Data Interpretation Shelf life
UV-fluorimeter gives result

Extraction kit unlimited, calibrator
in mg/kg, electronic data
kit 3 months
transfer possible
Photometer gives data in
12 months
mg/kg, print-out available
kit 3 months
transfer possible
UV-fluorimeter gives result Extraction kit unlimited, calibrator

in mg/kg kit 3 months

12 months
mg/kg
kit 3 months
transfer possible


12 months
mg/kg
colour change Approx 2years
Gaschromatography/photoi
onisation detector - gives
data in ppm in headspace. unlimited
Onboard data storage,
electronic transfer
electronic transfer
electronic transfer
electronic transfer
electronic transfer
electronic transfer
electronic transfer
electronic transfer

kit 3 months
transfer possible


12 months
12 months
12 months
Photometer gives > or < the

conc of the standard. No 12 months
electronic data transfer.
Luminometer gives result

as % luminescence
12 months
(none/moderate/severe
toxicity)
meter unlimited-probe and

Digital readout
calibration solution 12 months

Digital readout
colour scale Approx 2years

Digital readout
computer graph 12 month warranty

Digital readout unlimited
measured against coloured

12 months
standards
measured against coloured
12 months
standards
titration Approx 2years
titration 6months

Appendix 1

Enviado por

Dados do documento

Direitos autorais

Formatos disponíveis

Compartilhar este documento

Compartilhar ou incorporar documento

Opções de compartilhamento

Você considera este documento útil?

Este conteúdo é inapropriado?

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

Appendix 1

Enviado por

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

target compounds test name Manufacturer compounds covered

Arsenic XRF Niton As

Wiithin desired range

PRO SiteLAB UVF-3100 SiteLAB

RaPID Assay Total

DRO SiteLAB UVF-3100 SiteLAB

DRO SiteLAB TD-500 SiteLAB

DRO PetroFLAG Dexsil

Oils SiteLAB UVF-3100 SiteLAB

Oils SiteLAB TD-500 SiteLAB

Oils PetroFLAG Dexsil

Benzene Voyager Portable GC Photovac

Toluene Voyager Portable GC Photovac

Ethylbenzene Voyager Portable GC Photovac

Xylene Voyager Portable GC Photovac

PAH SiteLAB UVF-3100 SiteLAB

PAH SiteLAB TD-500 SiteLAB

PAH - 3-4-ring RaPID Assay PAH SDI

PAH - 5-6-ring RaPID Assay PAH SDI

PCB RaPID Assay PCB SDI

PCB Total PCB Cape Technology

Toxicity ROTAS Cybersense

pH Pocket pH meter Hanna Instruments

pH Micro 500 pH meter Palin test

Organics Microsaic Systems

Oils Soil test kit Hanby

soil Soil pH kit Palin test

Wiithin desired range

Using B-optics covers PRO

C6 - C14 230.00 12 19.17

Using A-optics covers EDRO

PAH, Oil, tar (C16-C40) 210.00 20 10.50

Aromatics + Aliphatics C10 - C40 175.00 10 17.50

Using A-optics covers EDRO

PAH, Oil, tar (C16-C40) 210.00 20 10.50

Aromatics + Aliphatics C10 - C40 175.00 10 17.50

Using D-optics covers PAH

PAH, Oil, tar (C16-C40) 210.00 20 10.50

3 and 4-ring PAH (C13 - C20) 230.00 12 19.17

5 and 6-ring PAH (C18 - C22) 320.00 12 26.67

PCB - fully quantitative 230.00 12 19.17

PCB - semiquantitative 525.00 30 17.50

Broad screen toxicity 167.00 22 7.59

all 2.50 100 0.025

TPH in soils $900 15

soil 30.15 50 0.60

10K 1 mg/kg No upper limit yes

4.9K 2 mg/kg No upper limit yes

10K 3 mg/kg No upper limit yes

4.7K 4 mg/kg No upper limit yes

0.9K 5 mg/kg No upper limit yes

10K 6 mg/kg No upper limit yes

4.7K 7 mg/kg No upper limit yes

0.9K 8 mg/kg No upper limit yes

20K 10 mg/kg No upper limit yes (by headspace)

10 - 15K 11 mg/kg No upper limit yes (by headspace)

20K 12 mg/kg No upper limit yes (by headspace)

10 - 15K 13 mg/kg No upper limit yes (by headspace)

20K 14 mg/kg No upper limit yes (by headspace)

20K 16 mg/kg No upper limit yes (by headspace)

10 - 15K 17 mg/kg No upper limit yes (by headspace)

10K 18 mg/kg No upper limit yes

4.7K 19 mg/kg No upper limit yes

4.9K 20 mg/kg 0.2 - 5.0 mg/kg yes