A TRULY GRITTY OLD WEST RPG

BY MATT SNYDER

PLAYTEST VERSION, THIRD DRAFT MARCH 6, 2002

Introduction
There comes a time when you got
to shoot or give up the gun.
D UST DEVILS is a role-playing game set in the dust-rid-
den Old West. Players portray gunslingers, gamblers,
cowboys and outlaws who must not only survive in a
rugged land, but conquer their own Devils, the dark
secrets that keep them from being honest decent folk.
Dust Devils asks, Can a no good sunnuvabitch make
right with his ugly, evil past and be a man the God-fearin
people of the West respect and admire? Or, will the Devil
get the best of him, and everyone see that hes a cheat, a liar
or a no-good killer.
Or, as we might say nowadays: Can a person reform his
or her dark past and become a hero, or will that past haunt
their actions until death?
Or, perhaps simpler: What does it take to be a hero in a
lawless place where its hard to just stay alive?
Or, simplest of all: Can a person change?
Dust Devils is a game in the tradition of films like The
Outlaw Josey Wales and the more current Unforgiven. In the
former, Josey Walesplayed by Clint Eastwoodis a real
sunnuvabitch, yet hes a hero. He doesnt reform his killin
ways. Indeed, he makes use of em right up to the end of the
film, at which point we know Josey Wales may be one hellu-
va gunfighter, but he aint the outlaw he used to be.
Unforgiven is very much the inverse (in fact, the inverse of
Westerns in general). William Munneyalso played by Clint
Eastwoodis an outlaw, and makes no bones that he was a
no good sunnuvabitch. In the movie, though, hes reformed.
I aint like that no more, he says. Yet, hes terrible at
reform. He cant farm, he can barely ride his old, sway-
backed horse, and he cant shoot worth a damn. Yet, when
he finally snaps after they kill his best friend from his wilder
days, Ned, hes no longer comical. He becomes a frightening
avenger. In the end, Munnys past comes up to haunt him
again as he shoots down five or six men, including his rival
Lil Bill, and scares away as many more. His legend lives on
that hes a "known thief and murderer, a man of notoriously
vicious and intemperate disposition. But is he really?
Thats the great issue in the movie, and its just the kind of
thing Dust Devils should facilitate for players.
Shoot or give up the gun. Which is it gonna be?
Both these movies exemplify Dust Devils premise, which is
the point of the Devil mechanic (see Devil below).
Characters
C HARACTERS have four attributes: Hand, Eye, Guts and
Heart. Players divide 13 points among the four
attributes for their character as they see fit.
Hand represents physical action, i.e. anything a character
does with his hands or body. Hand covers everything
from the brawn needed to knock a fella into next week to
the finesse required to rope an outlaw. (Hand is associat-
ed with the playing card suit of Spades.)
Eye measures a characters senses and intellect. Eye
might test a characters ability to sense a canyon
ambush or challenge his knowledge of Apache tradi-
tions. (Eye is associated with the suit of Diamonds.)
Guts reflects a characters vigor and health as well as his
courage and cool. It take Guts to take on the whole
Bolivian army, and it might take a lot of Guts to keep
your shootin hand steady with a .45 round in your
thigh. (Guts is associated with the suit of Clubs.)

1
 Finally, Heart gauges a characters social competence as well
as his heroicor perhaps villainousnature. Heart makes
the ladies swoon, and it sure comes in handy when youre
trying to convince the town to fight the railroads thugs.
(Naturally, Heart is associated with the suit of Hearts.)
Traits
I N ADDITION to the four attributes above, all player char-
acters have two figurative descriptive to highlight their
most obvious qualities. In true Western style, these are
written as similes. Tough as Nails or Dumb as a Post
and so on. When a character tries to overcome a conflict,
he earns an extra card in the Deal if he does so in a way
that emphasizes one of his two descriptors.
An example: Dylan Bang McCreedy is strong as an ox
and crazier n a shithouse rat. Should McCreedy need to
free himself from underneath his fallen horse, hed get an
extra card because using brute strength in this way
matches his Strong as an Ox descriptor perfectly.
Similarly, if ol Bang McCreedy decide to waltz into the
bank to rob the place with a lit stick of dynamite in each
hand, hed get a card for his next obviously crazy action
(and perhaps his last!).
Knacks
P LAYERSalso select a half dozen knacksskills at which
their characters are proficient. Knacks range from 1-4,
with 1 being a novice and 4 being an expert. Knacks can
be any suitably narrow skill. Examples include: Shootin,
Ropin, Readin n Writin, Rithmatic, Trappin,
Ambushin, Politickin, Safe Crackin, Ridin, Dancin
You get the idea.
Devil
F INALLY,every characters got a Devil. This is that ugly side
you dont want the preacher to know about. Devil is that
element youre trying to fight, good or bad.
A good example of a Devil is something that stays with a
character, no matter how often he tries to solve the prob-
lem. It could be that drinkin leads him to ruin, and he
just cant seem to turn it down. Or it might be that hes a
wanted man. Whether the character committed the crime
or not, the laws after him, and hes always looking over
his shoulder.

2
A poor example of a Devil is something the player might
be able to solve neatly in one or two sessions of play.
For example, it might be just too easy to say a characters
Devil is Get revenge on the sonnuvabitch that killed his
wife. Should he do just that, well, he might just as well
settle down and see what all this mail-order bride hub-
bub is all about.
A characters Devil may come into play as part of a con-
flict. When it does, the Devil may result in a modified num-
ber of cards for the Deal. For example, say characters Devil
is that hes a mean drunk. He might lose cards whenever
conflict involving liquor comes along. Say hes trying to
impress Sally at the saloon. Thanks to fifth of whiskey he
just downed, Sallys not as like to go upstairs with him,
least not without a couple dollars. The game master might
decide to deal two fewer cards in that case. Conversely, our
boy might earn a couple more cards in the Deal should he
need to walk across the same saloon during a firefight. A
little liquid courage never hurt the ol Guts attribute.
The Deal
W HENEVER players encounter conflict during play, the
Dealer (a.k.a. the game master) deals a number of
cards (from a traditional Poker deck, including Jokers) to
each character involved, possibly including his own non-
player characters or situation hands. Success hinges on
beatin the Dealer at his game, The highest Poker hand in
a conflict is the winner, and progressively better hands
indicate increasingly extraordinary success.
The number of cards dealt depends on the conflict. The
Dealer determines which two of his players four attribut-
es best applies in every situation, and he deals a number
of cards equal to the sum of those two attributes.
The Draw
P LAYERS can improve their characters hands with
Knacks. For each dealt hand, players can discard up
to a number of cards equal to the characters relevant
Knack rating. The player may choose to discard any
number or combination of cards, so long as he does not
exceed the limit dictated by his Knack rating. The Dealer
then deals to the player an equal number of new cards
from the deck. At least one card from the original dealt
hand must remain when players draw back part of their
hand. Characters without a relevant knack for a given
conflict may not draw additional cards, unless they spend
chips (see Stakes below).
Call
W HEN ALL players, including the Dealer, settle their
hands, the Dealer calls and everyone shows his hand.
For situations pitting character against character -- like
a shoot out -- highest hand between two sides (i.e. two
combatants) wins. Keep in mind that the dealer plays
non-player characters hands.
In situations pitting a player character against some
challengelike scaling a cliff face, for examplethe deal-
er sets a difficulty number for the encounter and draws
that number of cards. The dealer might also elect to make
situations more challenging with a draw difficulty, so
the situation can draw back cards just like a skilled char-
acter does. In these situations, the character must beat the
situation hand to overcome the conflict. So, in the case of
climbing a cliff, the player needs a better poker hand that
the situations dealt hand to scale the rock face.
Note: Just as in Poker, without a pair or better hand,
high card wins. Also note that Jokers act as Wild Cards.
Fastest Tongue in the West
I T WOULDNT BE the Old West without some tall tales to
spice things up. In every conflict situation, description
of the event falls on the single player with the highest sin-
gle card in his hand. In many cases, this will be the play-
er with the highest winning hand. However, even the low-
est poker hand may yield the Ace of Spades, for example.
The player who describes the hand takes into account
not only who wins and loses the conflict, but also
what poker hands they won or lost with. This should
color his description. Extraordinary handslike a Full
House (Three of a Kind coupled with Two of a Kind)
indicate dramatic and exceptional events, while winning a
hand with just a single high card indicates a relatively
mundane or routine success for the character.
Stakes
A T IMPORTANT DRAMATIC MOMENTS, the Dealer may
declare Stakes for a crucial conflict. This is the
reward players can earn should their character win the

3
 POKER HANDS 
1. ROYAL FLUSHThe five highest cards in
sequence and all of the same suit. For example,
10, J, Q, K, and A.
2. STRAIGHT FLUSHFive cards of the same suit in
sequence. For example: 5, 6, 7, 8, and
9. Ace can be counted as lowi.e. A, 2,
3, 4 and 5 but in this case the high card
will be the 5, not the A.
3. FOUR OF A KINDFour cards with identical face
values. For example, Q, Q, Q, Q.
4. FULL HOUSEThree cards of one rank and two
cards of a different rank. For example, J, J, J
and 9, 9. When comparing two or more Full
Houses in a hand, compare the rank of the three
matched cards. Highest of these wins.
5. FLUSHFive cards all of the same suit in any
order. For example, 3, 6, 7, 10 and Q.
6. STRAIGHTFive cards of mixed suits in
sequence. For example, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10.
7. THREE OF A KINDThree cards with equal rank.
For example, A, A, A.
8. TWO PAIRTwo cards of equal rank coupled
another set of two cards of equal rank (but dif-
ferent than the first). For example, A, A, 8,
8. When comparing two or more Two Pair in a
hand, the hand with the highest ranking pair
wins.
9. PAIRTwo cards with equal rank. For example,
5, 5.
10. HIGH CARDA hand with none of the above
combinations. When comparing such hands, the
hand with the highest single card wins.

C OMPARING SUITSSuits rank in the following
order from lowest to highest: Clubs, Diamonds,
Hearts, Spades.

W ILD CARDSJokers serve as Wild Cards, and
count as any card necessary to complete any of
the above combinations.
important challenge. The Dealer offers rewards as Chips;
players are encouraged to use actual poker chips to repre-
sent these. The Dealer generally sets Stakes at one Chip,
but he may offer two or three Chips for especially impor-
tant moments in game play.
The Dealer should offer Stakes for any situation that he
thinks will be a dramatic turning point in the game. For
example, should the players finally get into a shootout
with the notorious outlaw they chased from St. Louis to
Santa Fe, the Dealer should offer Stakes. Such dramatic
moments may also be more spontaneous. For example, a
character could show a love interest in a minor character.
Though the Dealer didn't expect it, he should react
accordingly and offer Stakes when the character tries to
sweet talk his newfound darling.
Also, the Dealer should offer Stakes any time a charac-
ter deals with his Devil in a substantive way. For exam-
ple, a character whose devil is massacred an Indian vil-
lage could earn stakes when he deals with that history
positivelyperhaps by successfully befriending an Indian
scout, even though the Heart based challenge would be
difficult due to fewer cards drawn as a result of his Devil.
When the Chips are Down
PLAYERS may spend earned Chips for the following:

Improve AttributesImproving an attribute costs a
number of Chips equal to twice the new rating.
Attributes cannot be higher than 5.

Improve or earn additional KnacksIncreasing a
Knack costs a number of Chips equal to the new
Knack rating. Knacks may be increased only one point
at a time. Purchasing a new Knack at Novice level (1)
costs 2 Chips. Characters may have a maximum num-
ber of Knacks equal to their Hand + Eye attribtues.

Assume narration of a handBy spending one
Chip, a player can assume the narration of one hand,
pre-empting narration by the player with the high card
as described in the rules above. Doing so allows the
player to reduce any damage to his character by one
point. Should another player or players attempt to do
the same, the players may bid for narrative control of
the scene. The player who spends more Chips narrates.

Receive extra cardPlayers can receive one extra
card in the Deal by spending one Chip. Players may
draw only one extra card per hand.

Draw additional cardPlayers may draw back one
additional card in the Draw. This is in addition to any
drawn cards for the character's Knacks. Players may
draw back only one additional card per hand. Note
that players must keep at least one card from the Deal
in their hand, which may preclude spending Chips in
this manner.
difficulty
He ran into some difficulty round Abilene way.
C HARACTERS who lose combat, conflicts or other haz-
ardous challenges lose attribute points. Compare the
hand that beat the character in the round. Subtract a
number of attribute points equal to the number of cards
in the winning hand. The player subtracts the points as
desired from the attributes related to the suits played.
An example: Lucky Luke Johnson isnt living up to
his name. A rival gunslinger shoots at him, playing three
of a kind in the hand to do it: the Five of Hearts, the Five
of Clubs, and the Five of Diamonds. Lucky loses three
points from his Heart (Hearts suit), Guts (Clubs suit)
and/or Eye (Diamonds suit). Luckys player subtracts the
three points of damage as he sees fit. He can subtract 3
from a single attribute, or subtract 1 point from all three
attributes if he chooses.
When Jokers constitute part of a hand, subtract damage
only from the suits played in other cards. In the above
example, if one of the gunslingers cards had been a Joker,
Lucky Luke would have subtracted 3 points from his
Heart (Hearts suit) and/or Guts (Clubs suit).
Its all right, Ma (Im only Bleedin)
I TS IMPORTANT to remember that while player lose attrib-
utes, the Difficulty inflicted may not be grievous. Its up
to the describing character to give his account of the
injury or reason for attribute loss. For example, if Luckys
player decided to subtract one point from each attribute
hit in the example above, the describing character might
say the gunslingers wild shot grazed Luckys forehead.
The blood trickling into his eyes explains him losing a
point of Eye. Getting shot at explains his reluctance to

4
carry on, which explains the loss of Guts, and the ugly
wound makes him a gruesome sight to everyone, hence the
loss of Heart. He may look a bit worse for the wear, but
maybe Luke is lucky after allthe wound could be worse.
Alternatively, the same hand could be described a bit
more comically. Say the describing player says the gun-
slingers wild shot knocks down a chandelier that falls on
poor Luckys head. The loss of a point in his three attrib-
utes is a reflection of his being a bit dazed by the event
(loss of Eye and Guts), not to mention more than a little
embarrassed (loss of Heart).
REcovery
C HARACTERS recover all damage to attributes at the end
of each game session. The Dealer may rule that dam-
age carries over into the next session if he thinks events
are unfinished or so closely tied that characters have little
chance for rest and recovery.
Characters may recover lost attribute points during the
course of a session. This requires the successful use of
Knacks, and the treatment must fit the description of the
damage. The difficulty (i.e., the number of cards the

5
Dealer deals to himself to challenge the character per-
forming the Knack) for recovering damage is equal to the
total amount of damage the character received. Success
usually indicates the character is back to his usual self,
An example: If the narration described the character's
damage as physical injury, he may need the help of Doc,
who might use his Doctorin' knack. However, if the narra-
tion described the damage as an embarrassing encounter
resulting in a loss of Heart and Guts for the character, the
solution for recovery may be a little lovin' from ol' Sally
upstairs in the saloon, or maybe just a shot or two of
whiskey downstairs to get back to his old self!
Dyin
We all got it comin, kid.
W HEN A CHARACTER reaches zero in any single
attribute, hes finally cashed in his chips and gone
to visit St. Peter or roast over the coals of Hell should his
Devil get the best of him after all.
Name:__________________ KNACKS TRAPPINGS
Occupation:_____________ Knack Rating ____________________
Chips:__________________ ____________________
1. _____________________ ______
____________________
2. _____________________ ______ ____________________
Attributes 3. _____________________ ______ ____________________
____________________
4. _____________________
5. _____________________
______
______
____________________
Hand Eye ____________________
6. _____________________ ______ ____________________
____________________
TRAITS ____________________

_______________________________ ____________________
____________________

_______________________________ ____________________
DEVIL
Guts Heart ________________________________________ QUOTE
________________________________________ ____________________
________________________________________ ____________________
DUST DEVILS charater sheet

Name:__________________ KNACKS TRAPPINGS

Occupation:_____________ Knack Rating ____________________
Chips:__________________ ____________________
1. _____________________ ______
____________________
2. _____________________ ______ ____________________
Attributes 3. _____________________ ______ ____________________
____________________
4. _____________________
5. _____________________
______
______
____________________
Hand Eye ____________________
6. _____________________ ______ ____________________
____________________
TRAITS ____________________

_______________________________ ____________________
____________________

_______________________________ ____________________
DEVIL
Guts Heart ________________________________________ QUOTE
________________________________________ ____________________
________________________________________ ____________________
DUST DEVILS charater sheet