Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Milled zircon, d50 9 m, was fused with caustic soda pearls in open reaction vessels at
temperatures between 650 and 850 C. Fusion times of 1, 2, 4, 24, and 336 h (with intermittent
milling) were investigated. The fusion products were characterized by X-ray diffraction and by
wet-chemical analysis. For prolonged fusion times, the fusion products approached equilibrium
compositions. However, the phases Na2ZrSiO5 and Na4Zr2Si3O12 observed at 850 C did not form
at 650 C. Because these compounds do not hydrolyze completely in water, they limit the recovery
of alkali in the sodium silicate product stream. With short fusion times (2 h), a nonequilibrium
product spectrum is obtained. It is dominated by sodium zirconates and sodium silicates, allowing
reasonable zirconia yields and high alkali recovery in a sodium silicate product stream. This
allows efficient fusion of two moles of NaOH per mole of zircon at 850 C with a zirconia yield
of ca. 57% and an alkali recovery of ca. 78%.
Introduction
dilute mineral acids other than sulfuric. This facilitates (f) There are fewer effluent streams and less waste
the removal of impurities such as iron and radioactive to discard.
elements by leaching with hydrochloric acid. In this study we report on the optimization of the
Compared to conventional processes, advantageous alkali-fusion step of this process. The experiments
features of the De Wet process are as follows: described below were designed to provide an indication
(a) Fewer process steps are necessary to manufacture of the effect that fusion conditions have on the overall
acid zirconium sulfate tetrahydrate (AZST). product yields in terms of the simplified block diagram
shown in Figure 1. The zirconia yield and alkali (NaOH)
(b) A comparatively low-cost pigment-suitable zirconia
recovery in the sodium silicate are important process
with reduced radioactivity content can be made.
parameters that impact the commercial viability of the
(c) The alkali reactant can be recovered in the form overall process. The effect of the operating parameters
of a saleable, radioactivity-free, sodium silicate product such as fusion time and temperature and also reagent
stream. stoichiometry (NaOH/ZrSiO4 mole ratio) on these vari-
(d) Sulfuric acid economy in the manufacture of AZST. ables was determined.
The overall process requires less than 5% stoichiometric
excess of sulfuric acid.
Experimental Section
(e) Radioactivity is leached out of a solid phase instead
of using precipitation steps that require chemical ad- Commercial-grade zircon, mined at Richards Bay,
ditions and generate much waste. South Africa, was obtained from Ferro Industrial Prod-
Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., Vol. 42, No. 4, 2003 779
Table 1. Observed Phases in the XRD Spectra of the centrifugation. The hydrated silica was dried overnight
Products Obtained for 336-h Fusions in a drying oven at 90 C and calcined at 950 C to silica.
temp mol ratio of time The silica yield was calculated with respect to the silica
[C] NaOH/ZrSiO4 [h] phases observed in XRD in the zircon feed and reported as a percentage.
850 6:1 336 major phase: Na2ZrO3 The zirconium-containing residue remaining, follow-
minor phase: Na2SiO3 ing removal of the sodium silicate, was titrated with a
850 4:1 336 major phase: Na2ZrO3, Na2ZrSiO5, standardized 32% (m/m) analytical-grade HCl solution
Na2SiO3 to a pH 3.8. Repeated washing and centrifugation
850 2:1 336 major phase: Na2ZrSiO5 with a total of 250 mL of distilled water in 4-5 portions
minor phase: ZrSiO4, Na2ZrO3
trace phase: Na4Zr2Si3O12 removed water solubles, including NaCl. The residue
850 1:1 336 major phase: Na4Zr2Si3O12, ZrSiO4 consisted essentially of hydrous zirconia, silica, and
minor phase: Na2ZrSiO5 unreacted zircon. This was reacted with an excess
750 4:1 336 major phase: Na2ZrO3 amount of sulfuric acid (ca. 5% excess) to form AZST.
minor phase: Na2SiO3 Water and excess sulfuric acid were removed by evapo-
trace phase: Na2ZrSiO5 ration by first heating at 150 C and then at 350 C.
750 2:1 336 major phase: Na2ZrO3, ZrSiO4,
Na2ZrSiO5 The solids were allowed to cool to room temperature.
minor phase: Na2SiO3 AZST was dissolved in water and separated from the
750 1:1 336 major phase: Na2ZrSiO5, ZrSiO4 residue by centrifugation. AZST was then crystallized
minor phase: Na2ZrO3 overnight at 90 C by water evaporation and calcined
700 2:1 336 major phase: ZrSiO4, Na2ZrO3, to zirconia at 950 C. The yield was expressed as a
Na2ZrSiO5
percentage of the zirconia in the zircon feed.
minor phase: Na2SiO3
650 6:1 336 major phase: Na2SiO3, Na2ZrO3 The solids remaining after the AZST dissolution were
minor phase: Na4SiO4, ZrSiO4 dried at 90 C and then calcined at 950 C. All of the
650 4:1 336 major phase: ZrSiO4, Na2SiO3, calcined products (zirconia, silica, and residue) were
Na2ZrO3 collected, weighed, and submitted for elemental analy-
minor phase: Na4SiO4 sis. All of these fusion experiments were duplicated, and
650 2:1 336 major phase: ZrSiO4, Na2ZrO3
minor phase: Na2SiO3
in some instances there were with up to eight replica-
strong amorphous halo at ca. 2 ) 13 tions. The validity of the results was checked using
650 1:1 336 major phase: ZrSiO4 internal mass balances.
trace phase: Na2SiO3 XRD measurements between 0.8 and 10 2 were
600 2:1 336 major phase: ZrSiO4 obtained with a Siemens D-501 automated diffractome-
minor phase: Na2ZrO3, Na2SiO3 ter Cu KR (0.15418 nm) with the Soller slits at 2
(diffracted beam side), divergence slits at 1, and receiv-
ucts. A grade with a median particle size of d50 9 m ing slits at 0.05. A scintillation counter detector was
and with the following composition, as determined by used, over the range of 3-65 2 and at a step width of
X-ray fluorescence, was used: ZrO2 + HfO2, 65.7%; SiO2, 0.02, at a scan rate of 30 s/step.
33.6%; Ti, 738 ppm; Fe, 683 ppm; Ca, 666 ppm; P, 455
ppm; U, 331 ppm; Th, 144 ppm. Analytical-grade caustic Results and Discussion
soda, 98% sulfuric acid, and 32% hydrochloric acid were
used in all experiments. Extended Fusion Times. Long fusion times (336 h)
The fusion reactions were carried out in a model TPF were used in order to get an overview of the equilibrium
12/2 high-temperature oven. In each fusion experiment, fusion products that are likely to form. Table 1 lists the
36.6 g of zircon was fused with caustic. The NaOH/ main products identified in the XRD spectra. These data
ZrSiO4 mole ratio was varied from 1 to 6, and fusion were used to construct the simplified phase diagrams
temperatures of 600, 650, 700, 750, and 850 C were shown in Figure 2. The vertical dotted line in these
investigated. After the required fusion time, the oven ternary diagrams shows the locus of the NaOH/ZrSiO4
product was allowed to cool to room temperature. The reactant ratio used in this study. The phase diagram
fusion product was milled using a mortar and pestle to for 850 C is similar to the one accepted in the
homogenize the mixture and was fused again. All fusion literature16,17 that was constructed from results ob-
samples were characterized by X-ray diffraction (XRD) tained by fusing zircon with soda ash at temperatures
to identify the main compounds formed. above 1000 C.
The final fusion product was cooled and then weighed (a) Fusions at 850 C and 336 h. For fusions at 850
before leaching with water to remove the soluble C, the reaction products observed for a reagent ratio
silicates and unreacted sodium hydroxide. The liquids of 2:1 are consistent with the conversion of zircon
were separated from the solids using centrifugation. The according to the following reaction:
solid was dried in an evaporating oven.
The water leach was titrated with a standardized 32% ZrSiO4 + Na2O f Na2ZrSiO5 (I)
(m/m) analytical-grade HCl solution. Bromomethyl or-
ange was used as an indicator and a calibrated pH From a purely stoichiometric viewpoint, one could
meter (Mettler Delta 340) to determine the equivalence expect that the following reaction would be favored at
point at pH 3.8. This value provides an indication of a mole ratio of 4:1:
the alkali recoverable in the sodium silicate product
stream and was expressed as a percentage of the alkali ZrSiO4 + 2Na2O f Na2ZrO3 + Na2SiO3 (II)
used in the fusion.
The resulting hydrated silica was precipitated with However, the yields obtained and the XRD spectra
an ammonia and ammonium chloride solution by ad- recorded show that the products are better explained
justing the pH to 7. The sodium salts were then in terms of both reactions (I) and (II) occurring to
separated from the hydrated silica by washing and approximately the same extent. This implies that higher
780 Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., Vol. 42, No. 4, 2003
silicates must have formed as well: Figure 3. Effect of stoichiometry and fusion temperature on
yields. Fusions conducted for 336 h with intermediate milling.
ZrSiO4 + 3Na2O f Na2ZrO3 + Na4SiO4 (III)
From a practical point of view, short fusion times and (5) Blumenthal, W. B. Zirconium and Zirconium Compounds.
low reaction temperatures are preferred. The 2-h fusion In Kirk-Othmer Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology, 4th ed.;
results are, therefore, more relevant from a commercial Howe-Grant, M., Ed.; John Wiley: New York, 1998; Vol. 25, p 853.
(6) Nyman, H.; Hyde, B. G.; Andersson, S. Zircon, Anhydrite,
perspective. Figure 7 shows the zirconia yield per unit Scheelite and Some Related Structures Containing Bisdisphenoids.
of sodium hydroxide consumed. At a NaOH/ZrSiO4 ratio Acta Crystallogr. 1984, B40, 441.
of 2, the alkali-utilization efficiency of the 850 C, 2-h (7) Hyde, B. G.; Andersson, S. Inorganic Crystal Structures;
reaction is nearly the same as the 650 C, 336-h fusion. Wiley-Interscience: New York, 1989; pp 284, 285, and 338.
This is attributed to the nonequilibrium phases that are (8) Zeis, L. A.; Giesekke, E. W. Potential for Industrial Ap-
formed during the short fusion times. The 2-h reaction plications of Locally Produced Zirconium Chemicals. S. A. J. Chem.
1997, 50, 136.
at 850 C with a 2:1 stoichiometry also produces the (9) Hancock, J. D. A Review of Conventional and Novel
least alkali salt waste. However, a plant operating at Processes for the Extraction of Zirconia from Zircon. Miner. Sci.
these conditions would feature a significantly larger Eng. 1977, 1 (9), 25.
recycle stream and would have to be about 170% larger (10) Choi, H. S. Preparation of Pure Zirconyl Compounds from
in size than an equivalent plant (with the same output) Zircon Caustic Frit. Can. Min. Metall. Bull. 1965, 58, 193.
operating at the same conditions but with a stoichiom- (11) Menon, P. R.; Juneja, J. M.; Krishnan, T. S. Decomposition
of Zircon by Soda Ash Sintering Process. Bull. Am. Ceram. Soc.
etry of 6:1. 1980, 59b, 635.
(12) Choi, H. S.; Cross, H. Study of the Fritting Reaction of
Acknowledgment Zircon Sand with Sodium Hydroxide by using Differential Thermal
Analysis and X-ray Techniques. Can. Min. Metall. Bull. 1964, 57,
This paper is dedicated to the memory of our friend 966.
and mentor Dr. Willem De Wet, who passed away so (13) Ishibashi, S. Preparation of Zirconium Oxide from Zircon
unexpectedly. Financial support for this research from Sand of Formosa. J. Ceram. Soc. Jpn. 1951, 69, 138.
(14) Focke, W. W.; De Wet, W. J. Improved Sulphuric Acid
the THRIP program of the Department of Trade and Sulphation of Refractory Zirconia by Addition of Sodium Sulphate.
Industry and the National Research Foundation of S. A. I. Chem. Eng. J. 1999, 11, 29.
South Africa as well as Kumba and Xyris Technology (15) Barawy, K. A.; El Tawil, S. Z.; Francis, A. A. Alkali Fusion
CC is gratefully acknowledged. of Zircon Sand. Trans. Inst. Min. Metall., Sect. C 2000, 109, C49.
(16) DAns, J.; Loeffler, J. Examination of System Na2O-SiO2-
ZrO2. Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem. 1930, 191, 22.
Literature Cited (17) Sircar, A.; Brett, N. H. Phase Equilibria in Ternary
(1) Farnworth, E.; Jones, S. L.; McAlpine, I. The Production, Systems Containing Zirconia and Silica. IV. A Preliminary Study
Properties and uses of zirconium chemicals. In Speciality Inorganic of the System Na2O-ZrO2-SiO2. Trans. Br. Ceram. Soc. 1970,
Chemicals; Thompson, R., Ed.; Special Publication No. 40; Royal 69, 133.
Society of Chemistry: London, 1980; p 248. (18) Houchin, M. R.; Jenkins, D. H.; Sinha, H. N. Production
(2) Pearson, K. Grinding and Bearing It. A Zircon Market of High-Purity Zirconia from Zircon. Ceram. Bull. 1990, 69, 1706.
Insight. Ind. Miner. 1999, 380, 25. Received for review February 15, 2002
(3) Taylor, R. Zircon in Ceramics. Ind. Miner. 2001, 409, 69. Revised manuscript received October 12, 2002
(4) Nielsen, R.; Chang, T. W. Zirconium and Zirconium Com- Accepted October 12, 2002
pounds. In Ullmans Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemistry; VCH
Publishers: Weinheim, Germany, 1996; Vol. A28, p 543. IE020140C