Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
srgrc
. .,. ,.,
~ ~,r, ,
i ~ ll
~ Y
~L~
~~~
Dear Clerk:
Respectfully,
CHRISTOPHER S. PORRINO
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF NEW JERSEY
By. ~ .(y,~..,~'r
Suzan e Davies
Deput Attorney General
v
~r 1~ ~"~ ~It y
7.i7~ t Y~
~ ~~~~
PRELIMINARY STATEMENT
under the common law right of access after this issue was raised
under the common law that were not available under OPRA.
Fennell called 911 to report that her husband had fired shots
OPRA request with a request under the common law, DCJ has
stated interest.
July 25, 2017
Page 4
Fennell stated that her husband was drunk and she heard her
"he's been drinking and he pushed me away and I'm like really
scared." Ibid.
the house and was in a wooded area behind his home. Id.
with Fennell. Id. While the SWAT team had Fennell surrounded,
with orders to put the gun down. Id. Fennell pointed the gun
at 6:52pm to report that her husband was drunk and that she had
scene. Id. "The scene was dark, and the weather was hot and
him and get him to cooperate, telling him that they were there
event." Id.
from Fennell, who had been lying under brush and leaves, he "sat
Officers commanded Fennell to show his hands and put the gun
officers. Id. Two .22 caliber casings from bullets fired from
Id. The Grand Jury voted "no bill" declining to indict the law
In response to item #2, DCJ provided two Call for Service Logs
from Little Egg Harbor Police Department and one from Ocean
July 25, 2017
Page 8
the common-law that were properly withheld under OPRA1: (1) CAD
Report from Ocean County; (2) CAD Abstract from Little Egg
for Fennell Phone; (6) Autopsy Report with photos; (7) NJSP
911 audio, unredacted; (13) NJSP Crime Scene Photos; and (14)
POINT I
enforcement agencies.
July 25, 2017
Page 10
105-06 (App. Div. 2015) held that UFRs were not subject to
officer's names for UFRs. As such, DCJ complied with the law as
July 11, 2017 holding that UFRs are not criminal investigatory
was provided the unredacted UFR. As such, this issue is now moot
15, N.J. (July 11, 2017) (slip op. at 31) The same
July 25, 2017
Page 11
fired shots within their home and had pushed her away as she took
the 911 call and responded to the home. See Lyndhurst, supra, 441
~~...
July 25, 2017
Page 12
DCJ under OPR.A, and Plaintiffs invoked the common-law for the
County; (2) CAD Abstract from Little Egg Harbor Township; (3)
with photos; (7) NJSP Ballistic Report and Receipts; (8) NJSP
audio; (13) NJSP Crime Scene Photos; (14) Crime Scene Log; and
investigation.
the Fennell home until the time the scene was cleared.
No. 076184 A-35-15, _ N.J. (July 11, 2017) (slip op. at 47).
' The fact that Plaintiff did not request investigative reports
and witness statements in the March 30, 2017 OPRA request at
issue in this matter is evidenced by Matthew Adams recent OPR.A
request, dated July 11, 2017, which seeks all witness statements
and police reports pertaining to the shooting of Patrick Fennell.
July 25, 2017
Page 15
common-law.
requests.
July 25, 2017
Page 16
CONCLUSION
For the reasons set forth above, the Order to Show Cause
Respectfully submitted,
CHRISTOPHER S. PORRINO
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF NEW JERSEY
By: ..
S e avies
Deputy ttorney General
CHRISTOPHER S. PORRINO
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF NEW JERSEY
Richard J. Hughes Justice Complex
25 Market Street
PO Box 112
Trenton, NJ 08625-0112
Attorney for State Defendants
LINDA FENNELL,
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
Plaintiff, LAW DIVISION - OCEAN COUNTY
DOCKET NO. OCN-L-1513-17
v.
C~.vil Action
TOWNSHIP OF LITTLE EGG
HARBOR ,
Et al.,
CERTIFICATION OF SERVICE
Defendants .
_ 1:5-2 to:
CHRISTOPHER S. PORRINO
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF NEW JERSEY
By. 1
Suzann avies
Deputy torney General
Dated. ~ ~~ j ~