PHYSICS 191 and 209.

1 Experimental Physics I

Group/Team Work

Peer Evaluation Example :

Scale of 0 to 5 Waves in a Coaxial Cable
5 highest Hulk 0 Ironman 5
integer number only Batman 3 Superman
do not rate yourself
Additional Comments :
Hulk keeps on smashing the experimental
setup
Ironman has cool toys.

Submitted by : Superman

Score of a Laboratory Report of a Student :

Laboratory Report Grade x (average of peer evaluation score)
 PHYSICS 191 and 209.1 Experimental Physics I

Group/Team Work

Possible Assessment Criteria

attendance in meeting capacity to listen
responsiveness to feedback/criticism cooperative behavior
application of creative problem solving
appropriate level of engagement with task
 PHYSICS 191 and 209.1 Experimental Physics I

Group/Team Work

Your peer evaluation results are kept in absolute and complete confidence
by your Physics 191 Instructors. We shall neither confirm or deny to any
inquiries.

You will be allowed to examine the Presentation Assesstment result of

your Group. To enhance the confidentiality of peer evaluation, only the
average of your presentation scores will be released at the end of the
course.
 PHYSICS 191 and 209.1 Experimental Physics I

On Being A Scientist - A Guide To Responsible Conduct In Research

Authorship and The Allocation of Credit

The list of authors establishes accountability as well as credit.

When a paper is found to contain errors, whether caused by mistakes
or deceit, authors might wish to disavow responsibility, saying that they
were not involved in the part of the paper containing the errors or that
they had very little to do with the paper in general. However, an author
who is willing to take credit for a paper must also bear responsibility for
its errors or explain why he or she had no professional responsibility for
the material in question.
 PHYSICS 191 and 209.1 Experimental Physics I

Physics 191 and 192 Policy

You have a collective responsibility for the integrity of group

work submitted.

A final grade of 5.00 will be given to all the members of a

group that submits a plagiarized report.

The case will be submitted to the U.P. Student Disciplinary

Tribunal for appropriate action.