Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Background
~NTRODUCTION
* VF( = UL
Harmoiiic-Producing Load
(ZOkVA)
I
I
I
I
I I
I
(0.45kVA) I
I I 5th 7th High-Pass II
I Shunt Passive Filter(l0kVA) I
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ I L _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _2
In the beginning, shunt active filters were proposed to As is known, filtering characteristics of a shunt passive
suppress the harmonics generated by large rated thyristor filter partially depend on the source impedance, which is not
converters and inverters used in HVDC transmission sys- accurately known and is predominantly inductive. The
tems. However, they could not be realized in real power impedance of the shunt passive filter should be lower than the
systems because high-power high-speed switching devices source impedance at a turned frequency to provide the atten-
were unavailable in the 1970s. Then N. Mohan et al. [3] tuation required. Hence the higher the source impedance, the
presented a practical means for injecting the compensating better the filtering characteristics. However, the source
current, which was implemented by using naturally commu- impedance should exhibit a negligible amount of impedance
tated thyristor inverters with a specially designed passive at the fundamental frequency so that it does not cause any
circuit to reduce the fundamental voltage rating of the shunt appreciable fundamental voltage drop. These two require-
active filter. However, the thyristor inverters generate unde- ments, which contradict each other, can be satisfied only by
sirable high-order harmonics, which thus discourages their inserting an active impedance in series with the ac source.
practicability. Also, series and parallel resonances in the shunt passive
With remarkable development and advances in switching filter, which are partially caused by the inductive source
speed and capacity of power semiconductor devices in the impedance, can be eliminated by inserting an active
1980s, shunt active filters using PWM inverters have been impedance. The active impedance can be implemented by a
studied, with a focus on their practical applications in real series active filter using voltage-source PWM inverters.
power systems [4]-[ll]. At the same time, the following Hence a new approach, which combines the use of a shunt
problems of shunt active filters have been pointed out, delay- passive filter and a small rated series active filter, is the
ing their practical uses [5], [7]. answer to the question.
i) It is difficult to realize a large rated PWM inverter SYSTEM
CONFIGURATION
with rapid current response and low loss for use as a
main circuit of shunt active filters. Fig. 3 shows a system configuration of the proposed
ii) The initial cost is high as compared with that of shunt approach to harmonic compensation, which is an experimen-
passive filters, and shunt active filters are inferior in tal circuit developed in this paper. Fig. 4 shows a detailed
efficiency to shunt passive filters. circuit of a series active filter on a per-phase base. A passive
iii) Injected currents by shunt active filters may flow into filter consisting of a 5th- and 7th-tuned LC filter and a
shunt passive filters and capacitors connected on the high-pass filter is shunted with a three-phase six-pulse thyris-
power system [ 131. tor converter of rating 20 kVA, which is considered a typical
harmonic-producing load. The circuit constants of the shunt
A New Approach to Harmonic Compensation passive filter of rating 10 kVA are shown in Table I. Three
Conventional shunt passive and active filters have the single-phase voltage-source PWM inverters of rating 0.45
aforementioned problems, which make their practical appli- kVA are inserted in series with the source impedance through
cations difficult. Therefore a basic question is asked: Is three single-phase current transformers (CTs; turns ratio =
there an approach to solve the problems of shunt passive 1:20), thus forming a series active filter. A single-phase
filters and those of shunt active filters? diode rectifier of rating 50 VA is connected on the dc side of
PENG et al.: HARMONIC COMPENSATION IN POWER SYSTEMS 985
Source r - - - i Load
:CT
LmJI
I
L
I
I 1 I
Fig. 6. Equivalent circuit for fundamental frequency.
II 1
1
I I 1
Fig. 7. Equivalent circuit for harmonic frequencies.
.o
+ Vsh
Vc = iFZLh if K 9 z,, z,. (4)
Equation (4) implies that the voltage rating of the series
active filter is given as a vector sum of the first term on the
right side, which is inversely proportional to the quality
factor of the shunt passive filter, and the second term, which
is equal to the source harmonic voltage.
Filter Harmonic Voltage: VFh
2ol 1 K=O
(5)
V F=
~ -2FZLh if K % zs, 2., (6) .o
Equation (6) tells us that the source harmonic voltage does
not appear on the load side because it applies across the
series active filter.
FILTERING
CHARACTERISTICS 1
- 30
To illustrate filtering characteristics of the combined sys-
(b)
tem, reference is made to the equivalent circuit in Fig. 7. Fig. 8. Distribution factor against frequency. (a) L , = 2 % . (b) L , =
Application of the law of superposition to Fig. 7 makes the 5.6%.
following analysis easy. As a result, the absence or presence
of the series active filter produces distinct differences in Case of the Shunt Passive Filter. used Alone, i.e.,
filtering characteristics. K = 0: It is seen from Fig. 8 that the shunt passive filter
falls in parallel resonance with the source impedance at three
Harmonic Current Flowing from Load to Source
frequencies, because the shunt passive filter consists of two
Neglecting the harmonic voltage source on the source side LC filters and a high pass filter. For example, a parallel
in Fig. 7, the load harmonic current divides between the resonance appears at the 4th harmonic frequency in Fig. 8,
shunt passive filter and the source in proportion to the thus amplifying the load harmonic current by 22 dB ( = 13
admittance of the parallel branches, as shown in the term first times). It is difficult, however, to avoid the condition of
on the right side of (1). The ratio of the source harmonic parallel resonance for a cycloconverter, because it produces
current to the load current under the assumption of vsh = 0 harmonic currents having frequencies that vary with the
is given by output frequency.
Case of the Combined System, i.e., K = I or 2: The
(7) series active filter reduces the distribution factor for all the
frequencies as compared with the value obtained without it.
No amplification occurs in harmonic current at the three
The amplitude of (7) is called distribution factor. Figs. resonant frequencies, because the series active filter acts as a
8(a) and 8(b) show how the distribution factor against fre- damping resistance. The sharpest filtering of the 5th-, 7th-,
quency varies with resistance K for the source inductances and higher harmonics is obtained in K = 2.
Ls = 2% and 5.6% (200-V 20-kVA 50-Hz base), respec-
tively. Here the source resistance is neglected because it is Harmonic Current Flowing from Source to Shunt Passive
much less than the source reactance. Note that harmonic Filter
currents flowing into the source are amplified for all the Under the assumption of I L h = 0 in Fig. 7, a source
frequencies at which the distribution factor is more than 0 harmonic current flowing into the shunt passive filter is
dB . produced by the source harmonic voltage. The source har-
PENG er al.: HARMONIC COMPENSATION IN POWER SYSTEMS
2-
1-
0 I
0 5 10
Here, 2, = 2, 2, + +
K and Z , is a rated impedance,
i.e., 2 52 on a 200-V 20-kVA 50-Hz base. Figs. 9(a) and 9(b)
show how the ratio Z , / Z , against frequency varies with (13)
resistance K for L , = 2% and 5.6%, respectively.
Case of K = 0: For example, the shunt passive filter falls The reference output voltage given by (9) is compared with a
in series resonance with the source impedance at the 4th- triangle carrier, producing the PWM switching patterns.
harmonic frequency in Fig. 9(b). Even if a small amount of Here the frequency of the triangle carrier is 15 kHz. There-
harmonic voltage at the resonant frequency is included in the fore the series active filter operates as a controllable voltage
source voltage, the harmonic current flowing in the source source, while a conventional active filter operates as a con-
and the shunt passive filter will be excessive. The condition trollable current source. Hence a voltage-source PWM in-
of such a series resonance must be avoided, or overheating verter is suitable for the series active filter rather than a
and failure will occur in the shunt passive filter. current-source PWM inverter. The voltage-source PWM in-
Case of K = I or 2: The series active filter increases the verter used in the series active filter can be protected against
ratio Z , / Z o for all the frequencies, as compared with the overvoltage and overcurrent by the following means. All the
value obtained without it. No harmonic current flows into the power MOSFETs of the upper legs are turned off to release
source or the shunt passive filter at the three resonant fre- the dc capacitor from the secondary of the CTs, while those
quencies, because the series active filter acts as a blocking of the lower legs are turned on to short the secondary of the
resistance. CTs through the on-state power MOSFETs and diodes.
CONTROL
CIRCUIT OF A SMALL
DESIGN RATEDPASSIVE
FILTER
TO
.-
~
988 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS, VOL. 26. NO. 6. NOVEMBERIDECEMBER 1990
L, I V,: 25OV
is
1
ZF@ +iL
fiF:lOOA
1 hn~LW&J/rA~/nW$n
i
start
I 1 I Fig 11. Experimental waveforms in case of L , = 2 %
(b)
Fig. 10. Equivalent circuit for switching ripples of voltage and current. (a)
Equivalent circuit seen from PWM inverter. (b) Equivalent circuit for U,.
vc:mv
L -.
--yMww/M!d 1-
start
Fig. 13. Experimental waveforms In case of L , = 5.6%.
7I
lL:lOOA
In this paper, the combined system of a shunt passive filter
and a small rated series active filter was proposed, giving
both practical and economical points of view. The compensa-
tion principle applied to this system was quite different from
vc:20v
conventional shunt and series active power filters, thus suc-
L J d b p ? I- ceeding in better filtering characteristics and lower initial and
start running costs. The required rating of the series active filter is
Fig. 14. Experimental waveforms with no load (ir = 0 ) in case of L s =
mainly determined by the quality factor of the shunt passive
2%. filter. The quality factor of the shunt passive filter used in this
the voltage applied to the primary of the CTs was 2.5 V, so experiment was 14. Since it is 50-80 for a practical shunt
passive filter in power systems, the required rating of the
that the VA rating of the series active filter was
series active filter will be reduced to less than 1%, as
2.5V x 6 0 A x 3 = 450VA. compared with the rating of a three-phase six-pulse thyristor
converter or cycloconverter. It is believed that the combined
This was only 2.3%,as compared with that of the load, i.e.,
system is the most suitable to harmonic compensation for
20 kVA.
large rated thyristor converters and cycloconverters.
Fig. 13 shows the experimental waveforms in the case of
L , = 5.6%. Before the series active filter was started, a REFERENCES
parallel resonance at the 4th-harmonic frequency occurred in [ I ] H. Sasaki and T. Machida, A new method to eliminate ac harmonic
currents by magnetic compensation-Considerations on basic design,
the system. A small amount of the 4th-harmonic current IEEE Trans. Power Appl. Syst., vol. 90, no. 5 , p. 2009, 1971.
included in the load current was largely amplified. As a [2] L. Gyugyi and E. C . Strycula, Active ac power filters, is presented
result, severe distortion existed in the source current, is, and at IEEEIIAS Ann. Meeting, 1976, pp. 529.
[3] N . Mohan et al., Active filters for ac harmonic suppression,
the filter voltage, uF, which was not seen in Fig. 11. How- presented at IEEE/PES Winter Meeting, A77 026-8, 1977.
ever, no parallel resonance appeared after the series active [4] H . Kawahira, T. Nakamura, and S. Nakazawa, Active power
filter was started. filters, in Proc. JIEE IPEC-Tokyo, 1983, pp. 981.
[5] H . Akagi, A. Nabae, and S. Atoh, Control strategy of active power
Fig. 14 shows the experimental waveforms with no load in filters using multiple voltage-source PWM converters, IEEE Trans.
the case of L , = 2%.Although the source harmonic voltage Ind. Appl., vol. IA-22, no. 3, pp. 460, May/lune 1986.
990 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS. VOL. 26, NO. 6, NOVEMBERIDECEMBER 1990
K. Komatsugi and T. Imura, Harmonic current compensator com- Hirofumi Akagi (M87) was born in Okayama
posed of static power converter, presented at IEEE Power Elec- Prefecture, Japan, on August 19, 1951. He re-
tronics Specialist Conf.,1986, pp. 283. ceived the B.S degree from the Nagoya Institute
M. Takeda et al., Harmonic Current Compensation with Active of Technology, Nagoya, Japan, in 1974, and the
Filter, presented at IEEEIIAS Ann. Meeting, pp. 808, 1987. M S. and Ph.D. degrees from the Tokyo Institute
A. Nakajima et al., Development of Active Filter with Series of Technology, Tokyo, Japan, in 1976 and 1979,
Resonant Circuit presented at IEEE Power Electronics Specialist respectively, all in electrical engineering.
Conf.,pp. 1168, 1988. Since 1984 he has been an Associate Professor
r91 M. Kohata et al., Compensator for harmonics and reactive power at Nagaoka University of Technology, Japan. He is
using static induction thyristors, presented at European Conf. on engaged in research on ac motor drives, active
Power Electronics and Applications, 1987. power filters, and high-frequency inverters.
1101 F. Z. Peng, H. Akagi, and A. Nabae, A study of active power filter Dr Akagi is a member of the Institute of Electrical Engineers of Japan.
using quad-series voltage-source PWM converters for harmonic com-
pensation, presented at IEEE Power Electronics Specialist Conf.,
1987, pp. 204-212.
Y . Tanoue, F. Aoyama, and K. Terashima, 5-MVA flicker suppres-
sion equipment-A hybrid system of a passive filter and an active
filter using GTO thyristors, Toshiba Rev., vol. 43, no. 4, 1988.
H. Akagi, Y. Kanazawa, and A. Nabae, Instantaneous reactive
power compensators comprising switching devices without energy
storage components, IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. IA-20, pp, 625,
1984. Akira Nabae (M79-SM89-F90) was born in
F. Z. Peng, H. Akagi, and A. Nabae, Some considerations on an Ehime Prefecture, Japan, on September 13, 1924.
active power filter using quad-series voltage source PWM converters, He received the B.S degree from Tokyo Univer-
JIEE PE-86.154, 1986, (in Japanese). sity, Tokyo, Japan, in 1947, and the Dr. Eng.
degree from Wasada University, Japan, in 1987.
He joined Toshiba Corporation in 1951. From
Fang Zheng Peng was born in Hubei Province, 1951 to 1970 he was engaged in the research and
China. le received the B.S. degree from Wuhan development of rectifier and inverter technology at
University of Hydraulic and Electric Engineering, Tsurumi Works Engineering Department. From
China, in 1983. He received the M.E. and Ph.D. 1970 to 1978, he was involved in research and
degrees in electrical engineering from Nagaoka development of power electronics, especially ac
University of Technology, Japan, in 1987 and drive systems, at the Heavy Apparatus Engineering Laboratory. Also, from
1990, respectively. 1972 to 1978 he was a nonoccupied Lecturer of Wasada University, Japan.
He is now working for Toyo Electric Manufac- From 1978 to 1990 he was a Professor at Nagaoka University of Technol-
turing Company, Ltd. His research interests are ogy, Japan. Since 1990, he has been a Professor in the Electronics Engineer-
active power filters and hybrid systems of active ing Department at Tokyo Institute of Polytechnics, Japan. He is now
and passive filters. interested in energy conversion and control systems.
Dr. Peng is a member of the Institute of Electrical Engineers of Japan. Dr. Nabae is a member of the Institute of Electrical Engineers of Japan.