Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
M a h m o u d E. EIDeeb, BDS, MS; M o h a m e d EIDeeb, BDS, DOS, MS; Abbas Tabibi, DDS, MS;
and James R. Jensen, DDS, MSD
The purpose of this study was to Periodontal tissue reaction to exper- MATERIALS AND
compare the clinical, radiographic, imentally produced perforations in METHODS
and histo[ogic changes that occur in dogs, ~"and monkeys, ~~'~ and the clini-
response to three of the most common- cal investigations of accidental root Four clogs of varying breeds, unse-
ly used materials to repair furcation perforations in humans ~'-:~' have been lected as to sex, ranging in age from
perforations. T h e results of the exper- studied. In general, all the investiga- one to three years, were used in this
iment showed that amalgam was supe- tors agree that the prognosis for root study. All the dogs had clinically and
rior to Cavit and calcium hydroxide as perforations in the apical and middle radiographically healthy periodon-
a sealing material of furcation perfora- third of the root is much better than tium. The experiments were per-
tions. The most severe reactions perforations in the cervical third of the formed on the mandibular and maxil-
occurred in the control group where root or in the floor of the pulp cham- lary premolars and molars with a total
the perforations were not filled. ber. They also recommend that perfo- of 64 perforations.
rations be filled immediately. Routine operating room sterility
INTRODUCTION AND T h e correction of perforations can was used. T h e dogs were premedicated
be achieved using either an intracoro- with atropine sulfate and aneslhetized
REVIEW OF THE
nal or surgical approach. T h e latter is with sodium nembutal. A rubber dam
LITERATURE not recommended for the repair of was applied, and entrance to the pull)
furcation perforations because the area chamber was achieved. T h e pulp was
In the practice of endodontics, occa- then extirpated, and the canals pre-
is usually surgically inaccessible, espe-
sionally procedural accidents are pared according to Weine. 2' Sterile
cially if the perforation was lingually
encountered that will affect the prog-
situated in a mandibular molar, or if it saline solution was used for irrigation
nosis of the root canal treatment. One as needed. T h e canals were dried with
is located in the trifurcation area of a
of these procedural accidents is endo- sterile paper points and filled to the
maxillary molar. Also, the surgical
dontic perforation. approach will usually lead to chronic level of the pulp chamber with Cavit,
Perforation of the floor or wall of pocket formation and periodontal fur- using a pressure syringe (Pulpdent
the pulp chamber, or of the root, Corporation, Brookline, Mass). T h e
cation involvement. :~'
sometimes occurs as a result of a The purpose of this study was to chamber was cleaned from all debris,
number of causes: misdirection of a compare the clinical, radiographic, then a no. 4 round bur was used to
bur in attempting to gain access to the and histologic changes that occur in perforate the furcation area. Care was
pulp chamber, during the placement of the periodontal tissues in response to taken to minimize traumatic injury to
posts and pins while searching for an three of the most commonly used the periodontium. The site of the
elusive root canal, or failure to follow materials to repair furcation perfora- perforation was cleaned and rinsed
the apical curvature during root canal with saline solution. Bleeding was con-
tions.
instrumentation.
459
Table 1 9 Evaluation of variables.
Cementum
Bone or dentin
S' * Inflammalion resorption New bone formation resorption Epithelium
0 None Less than I mmt None None None
1 Mild 1 to 1.9 mm Osteoblast bordering bony Extended less than Present in the
trabecule, but no evi- I mm furcation
dence of newly formed area
bone
2 Moderate 2 to 2.9 mm Evidence of newly formed Extended 1 to 1.9 N/A
bone mm
3 Severe 3 to 3.9 mm N/A: Extended 2 to 2.9 N/A
mm
4 N/A 4 mm or more N/A, Emended 3 mm or N/A
more
"'~ = sl~nllican, c; V = ~ a r l a b l c
+ ' J h c i~'rha:lli,m CXll w a s I h , r e l e r e n c e polnl Ic, all n l e a s u r c m f n t s
~N .\ = N,,~ , q , p l u a b l e
trolled by using a cotton pellet soaked code numbers and evaluated by an HISTOLOGIC
with epinephrine 1 : 1000. independent pathologist. OBSERVATIONS
The 64 teeth were apportioned into
four equal groups according to the Statistical a n a l y s i s o f the The different variables were statis-
material used to fill the perforation tically analyzed, and the significant
h i s t o l o g i c data
site. Amalgam, Cavit, and calcium difference of the comparisons of the
hydroxide were used to randomly fill Each histologic section was exam- different groups is presented in Ta-
the furcation perforations of three ined for the degree of inflammation, ble 4.
teeth in each quadrant. T h e fourth bone, cementum and dentin resorp-
tooth was used as a control, where the tion, new bone formation, and apical Group 1 (amalgam)
perforation sites were covered with a proliferation of the crevicular epitheli-
dry cotton pellet. The ocdusal prepa- um. T h e criteria for the evaluation of Inflammation. The microscopic
rations of all the teeth were filled with the aforementioned variables are pre- picture was generally characterized by
amalgam, and postoperative radio- sented in Table 1. The nonparametric mild to moderate chronic granuloma-
graphs were taken. Periodically dur- sign test was used to analyze the tous inflammation (Fig 2), consisting
ing the next three months, the teeth data. mainly of lymphocytes, histiocytes,
were examined clinically and radio- some plasma cells, and few scattered
graphically. polymorphonuclear leukocytes. The
RESULTS
After three months, the animals zone of inflammation was surrounded
were killed with intravenous injection Clinical and radiographic by striations of collagen fibers.
of saturated potassium chloride solu-
observations: Bone resorption. The resorption
tion. The teeth and surrounding struc:-
tures were taken out in block sections. was localized mainly to the area in
T h e clinical and radiographic
These were fixed in 10% formalin and proximity to the perforation site. No
results are summarized in Tables 2 evidence of wide involvement of the
prepared for histologic examination.
and 3. In the evaluation of the radio- medullary portion of bone was evi-
Longitudinal serial sections 4 #m thick
graphic results (Fig 1), a slight widen-
were cut in a mesiodistal direction, dent.
ing of the periodontal membrane was
stained with hematoxylin-eosin, and
considered normal. New bone formation. In six cases
examined by means of an ordinary
(37.5%), new bone had been elabo-
light microscope.
460
JOURNAL OF ENDODONTICS [ VOL 8, NO 10, OCTOBER 1982
Table 3 9 Radiographic results of total number of teeth with interradicular Group 3 (calcium hydroxide)
radiolucent areas.
Inflammation. In 12 cases (75%),
Observation
there was rather moderate chronic
period Group 1 Group 2 Group 3 Group 4
(months) Amalgam Cavit Calcium hydroxide Control inflammatory reaction (Fig 6). This
1 0 4 13 8 consisted mainly of histiocytes, lym-
2 2 5 14 8 phocytes, a n d some plasma cells.
3 2 7 14 8 Three sections showed severe, chronic
inflammatory cell infiltrate and few
scattered polymorphonuclear leuko-
cytes. Only one section was mildly
rated adjacent to the collagen fiber sections showed osteoblasts bordering infiltrated with chronic inflammatory
capsule. The rest of the specimen the bony trabeculae. cells. Granulomatous giant cells for-
showed osteoblasts hordering the bony eign hody reaction was evident in most
trabeculae in a linear arrangement Cementum and dentin resorption. of the cases.
Areas of diffuse cementum and dentin
(Fig 3).
resorption were noted in ten cases Bone resorption. The interradicu-
Cementum and dentin resorption. (62.5%). Repair of some of these areas lar crestal bone was considerably
In six cases (37.5%), localized resorp- with secondary cementum was seen. resorbed in all but one case. The bone
tion of small areas of cementum and was resorbed in a crater-like fashion
dentin was evident. Those were con- Epithelium. Granulomatous le- (Fig 7). The bone was resorbed along
eomitantly repaired hy cementoid and sions covered with stratified squamous the root surface forming a periodontal
epithelium were present in the bifur- pocket.
osteoid depositions.
cation areas of three teeth. The epithe-
Epithehum. Epithelium was not lium had begun to proliferate along New bone formation. The only
seen in the fun'cation area of any both sides of the root forming a peri- evidence of osteoblastie activity was
tooth. odontal pocket. seen in six cases (37.5%) where osteo-
Group 2 (Cavit)
461
JOURNAL OF ENDODONTICS I VOL 8, N O 10, O C T O B E R 1982
Group 4 (control)
462
JOURNAL OF ENDODONTICS I VOL 8, NO 10, OCTOBER 1982
Fig 4--Croup 2 ((2avit). PhohJmwrograph shows perJoration (P) Fz~ 5--Group Z (Cat.it). I~hol,rntcr, t,rr~ptl ~h,,w~ m/tammatr,r).
with moderate m/lammatory response composed of lymphocytes resp~m.se t,, peril,ration (P) in .Nrcati,m..'lh~cc3.s fi,rmatz,m (.4)
and plasma cells (I) and modest bone resorption. This response and m,derate hone re.~orptton (R) are seen (arrou,.~). B~,th
was szmzlar to that .seen m group 1, (Fig 2). (lI&E, or~'d rnag chronzc and acute tnflammatc~ry cell~ u'ere .,een m lh~s response.
X300). (tt&E, orzg mag X300).
463
JOURNAL OF ENDODONTICS I VOL 8, N O 10, O C T O B E R 1982
~, ,,, . ~ ~ ~, ~ .
464
JOURNAL OF ENDODONTICS ] VOL 8, NO 10, OCTOBER 1982
465
JOURNAL OF ENDODONTICS I VOL 8, NO 10, OCTOBER 1982
Dr. Mahmoud E. EIDeeb is assistant profes- 8. Bbaskar, S.N., and Rappaport, H.M. His- 19. Weissman, M.I. Unique sealing of an
sor, department of endodontics; Dr. Mohamed tologic evaluation of endodontic procedures in internal resorptive lesion of the bifurcation.
EIDeeb is assistant professor, department of oral dogs, Oral Surg 31(4):526-535, 1971. J Ga Dent Assoc 43:26-27, 1970.
and maxillofacial surgery; Dr. Tabibi is clinical 9. Jew, C.R. A histologic evaluation of peri- 20. Oswald J.B. Procedural accidents and
assistant professor, department of endodontics; odontal tissues adjacent to root perforations their repair. Dent Clin North Am 23(4):593-
and Dr. Jensen is associate dean and chairman, filled with Cavit. Thesis. Chicago, Loyola Uni- 616, 1979.
department of endodontics, Univeristy of Min- versity, 1979. 21. Weine, F.S. Endodontic therapy, ed 2. St.
nesota, School of Dentistry, 515 Delaware St 10. Schwartz, S.F. Treated perforations of Louis, C. V. Mosby Co, 1976, p 214-216.
SE, Minneapolis, 55455. Requests for reprints the pulp chamber floor; Histopathologic and 22. McGivern, B.F. Temporary filling
should be directed to Dr. Mahmoud E. Technological Study. Thesis. University of Tex- favored over alloy in retrograde root therapy.
EIDeeb. as Dental Branch at Houston, 1970. Clin Dent 2:5, 1974.
11. Seltzer, S.; Sinai, I.; and August, D. 23. Flanders, D.H., and others. Comparative
Periodontal effects of root perforations before histopathologic study of zinc-free amalgam and
References and during endodontic procedures. J Dent Res Cavit in connective tissue of the rat. J Endod
1. Euler, H. Perforation and paradontium. 49:332-339, 1970. 1:56-58, 1975.
Deutsche Monatsschritt fur Zahnheutund 12. Auslander, W.P., and Weinberg, G. 24. Defivanis, P., and Tabibi, A. A compara-
43:801-811, 1925. Anatomic repair of internal perforations with tive sealability study of different retrofilling
2. Kubler, A. Heilungsvorgange Nach Wur- indiun foil and silver amalgam, outline of a materials. Oral Surg 45(2):273-281, 1978.
zelperforationen. Schweizerische Monatsschrift method. NYJ Dent 39:454-457, 1969. 25. Finne, K., and others. Retrograde root
fur Zahnbeilkd 44:413-454, 1934. 13. Frank, A.L., and Weine, F.S. Nonsurgi- filling with amalgam and Cavit. Oral Surg
3. Lantz, B., and Persson, P.A. Experimental cal therapy for the perforative defect of internal 43:621-626, 1977.
root perforation in dog's teeth; a roentgen study. resorption. JADA 87:863-868, 1973. 26. Persson, G.; Lennartsson, B.; and Lund-
OdontoI Revy I6:238-257, 1965. 14. Harris, W.E. A simplified method of strom, I. Results of retrograde root-filling with
4. Lantz, B., and Persson, P.A. Periodontal treatment for endodontic perforations. J Endod special reference to amalgam and Cavit as root
tissue reactions after root perforations in dog's 2(5):126-134, 1976. filling materials. Swed Dent J 67:123-134,
teeth; a histologic study. Odontol Tedsk 75:209- 15. Leubke, R.G., and Dow, P.R. Correction 1974.
220, 1967. of an endodontic root perforation. Report of a 27. Pisano, J.V. A quantitative analysis of
5. Lantz, B., and Persson, P.A. Periodontal case. Oral Surg 17:98-101, 1964. microleakage in endodontic reverse fills. Thesis.
tissue reactions after surgical treatment of root 16. Nicholls, E. Treatment of traumatic per- Chicago, Loyola University, 1976.
perforation in dog's teeth; a histologic study. forations of the pulp cavity, Oral Surg 28. Sp/mgberg, L. Biological effects of root
Odontol Revy 21:51-62, 1970. 15(5):603-612, 1962. canal filling material. Reactions of bony tissue to
6. Ruchenstein, H. Les perforations radicu- 17. Riggans, J.W., Jr. The case history of a implanted root canal filling material in guinea
laires traitees au calxyl. Schweizerische Mon- root perforation and a method for its prevention. pigs. Odontol Tidsk 77:133-159, 1969.
atsschrift fur Zahnheikunde. 51(9):685-719, Dent Digest 77:275-279, 1971.
1941. 18. Stromberg, T.; Hasselgren, G.; and Berg-
7. Taatz, H., and Steifel, A. Zur Therapie stedt, H. Endodontic treatment of traumatic root
Von Zahnperforationen, Zahnaertztl Welt perforations in man: A clinical and roentgeno-
66:814-819, 1965. logical follow-up study. Sven Tandlak Tidskr
65:457-466, 1972.
466