Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Sarah Rankin
I pledge
INTEGRATIVE REVIEW 2
Abstract
The goal of this integrative review is to evaluate the literature regarding hypertension awareness
in young adults who have received lifestyle education. Hypertension is a major health problem
for all ages and more recently, has become common among young adults. Lifestyle education is
often one of the first lines of treatment clinicians use to treat hypertension because it has been
research design is an integrative review. A literature search was conducted using the computer
based search engines PubMed and EBSCO. The search yielded 143 articles total and five of
those articles met the criteria for inclusion. The results and findings of the literature
demonstrated a lack of hypertension awareness among young adults along with a lack of lifestyle
education. Findings also showed a beneficial effect of lifestyle education programs as a way to
control hypertension. Limitations to this review include the novice researcher and the fact that it
is not an exhaustive review due to the imposed restriction of only using five articles. Findings
can be implemented into practice by encouraging young adults to see their primary care providers
at least once a year and tailoring lifestyle education to meet the specific needs of the young adult.
Future research should include evaluating young adults hypertension control when education has
An Integrative Review
The purpose of this integrative review is to gather literature that pertains to the use of life-
style education as a way to treat young adults with hypertension. Hypertension is a major health
problem that affects millions around the world and has become a major issue in young adults. Of
those diagnosed with hypertension in the United States, young adults have the lowest control
rates (Johnson, Warner, Bartels, & LaMantia, 2017; Johnson, Warner, LaMantia, & Bowers,
2016). Several factors contribute to this low control rate among young adults including a lack of
awareness of having hypertension. This is compounded by the fact that young adults are more
likely to be uninsured and less likely to have a primary care provider, decreasing the likelihood
they will be diagnosed with hypertension and receive education (Gooding, McGinty, Richmond,
Gillman, & Field, 2014). The researchers proposed PICO question is, in young adults how does
This research design is an integrative review done as a class assignment. Two computer-
based databases were used to find articles that fit the researchers criteria; PubMed and EBSCO.
Key terms used in the searches included, young adults, hypertension, and lifestyle
education. The PubMed search yielded 17 articles and the EBSCO search yielded 126 articles.
In order to maintain a contemporary approach to the issue, the search was limited to peer-
reviewed journal articles published in the last five years that were written in English. Articles
were selected that applied to the researchers PICO question, in young adults how does lifestyle
selected met the following inclusion criteria: young-adult age population, hypertension, and
INTEGRATIVE REVIEW 4
lifestyle education. Articles that did not meet the criteria were excluded from the integrative
review. After limiting the search criteria the researcher was able to locate five articles, two
qualitative and three quantitative that met the criteria for inclusion.
The findings and results of the five articles clearly identified a gap in young adults
receiving lifestyle education to help manage their hypertension (Ferrara et al., 2012; Gooding et
al., 2014; Johnson et al., 2014; Johnson et al., 2017; Johnson et al., 2016). A summary of all five
of the research articles can be found in Appendix 1. The researcher based the integrative review
off two major themes found within the research: hypertension awareness and documented
lifestyle education.
Hypertension Awareness
Four studies addressed the theme of young adults hypertension awareness (Gooding et
al., 2014; Johnson et al., 2014; Johnson et al., 2017; and Johnson et al., 2016). In a quantitative
study Gooding et al. (2014) evaluated hypertension awareness and control among young adults.
Gooding et al. were specifically interested in understanding the impact that young adults self-
perception of their health had on hypertension awareness and control. A sample of 13,512 young
Gooding et al. measured blood pressure, evaluated health insurance status, a recent
physical or check-up (within the last two years), and self rated health. The researchers only
assessed awareness of hypertension if the participant already had a diagnosis or they got an
elevated reading. The data collected was analyzed and three major statistical tests were used to
check for significance. Out of the 13,512 participants 3,303 were found to have hypertension,
INTEGRATIVE REVIEW 5
76% of those had uncontrolled hypertension (Gooding et al., 2014). Of those participants found
to have uncontrolled hypertension three-fourths were not aware that they even had hypertension.
Young adults who are not aware that they have hypertension cannot seek out treatment and get
Johnson et al. (2014) used a quantitative approach to evaluate different patient, provider,
and visit predictors that affect lifestyle education among young adults with hypertension. Data
for the study was manually abstracted electronic health records. Participants were ages 18-39
who met the Joint National Committee (JNC) 7 clinical criteria for hypertension. Their main
area of focus was whether or not the patient received lifestyle education after meeting the JNC
Through the random chart abstraction 500 young adults were selected to participate. Data
was analyzed and categorical variables were summarized using percentages, while continuous
variables were summarized using means. Overall it was found that 22% of participants did not
receive any lifestyle education or treatment (Johnson et al., 2014). This gap in teaching and
treatment that appears with the young adult population emphasizes a lack in hypertension
awareness.
Johnson et al. (2016) conducted a qualitative study in order to identify barriers specific to
hypertension control and treatment in young adults. Using focus groups 38 young adults ages
18-39 that had been diagnosed with hypertension were sampled. The main topic explored in the
focus groups was young adults feelings about their hypertension diagnosis.
Transcripts were coded and the data collected was analyzed. All participants were able to
give at least one example of a health complication associated with hypertension (i.e., heart attack,
INTEGRATIVE REVIEW 6
stroke, death). Johnson et al. (2016) used this data as the indicator of hypertension awareness in
their study. While this does show the participants had a good understanding of the consequences
of hypertension, it does not show that they are self-aware that these things (i.e., heart attack,
stroke, death) can happen to them. If patients are not self-aware and do not acknowledge that if
their hypertension goes untreated consequences can occur, they are less likely to follow lifestyle
Further research done by Johnson et al. (2017) also takes a qualitative approach but,
explores the providers perspectives on hypertension management in young adults. Data was
collected by conducting interviews with physicians and advanced practice providers who were
actively managing young adults with uncontrolled hypertension. A total of 16 questions on topics
related to treating young adults with hypertension were discussed in the interview.
Interview transcripts were coded and a data analysis was then performed. Many of the
physicians interviewed expressed their reluctance to diagnose young adults with hypertension
(Johnson et al., 2017). One reason for this reluctance includes a possible false hypertension
diagnosis. An elevated blood pressure reading can be caused by stress, white coat syndrome,
caffeine, alcohol, or tobacco use. This reluctance among physicians to diagnosis or even discuss
Three of the five articles specifically looked at lifestyle education as a way to treat
hypertension (Ferrara et al., 2012; Johnson et al., 2014; Johnson et al., 2016). Johnson et al.
(2014) found that 55% of the participants had at least one documented lifestyle education
experience after being diagnosed with hypertension. In a qualitative study performed by Johnson
INTEGRATIVE REVIEW 7
et al. (2016) a similar finding was also discovered regarding lifestyle education. What was most
alarming was that over 50% of the young adults who received handouts as education threw them
away as soon as they left the doctors office. This shows that young adults dont utilize the
Ferrara et al. (2012) examined the effects lifestyle education had on adults control of
hypertension. Collecting quantitative data with an experimental design Ferrara et al. examined
188 hypertensive patients that were randomly divided into two groups an Educational Care group
(EC) and a Usual Care group (UC). The EC group participated in small group meetings once a
month for three months. These meetings were run by doctors and well-trained dieticians.
After attending the educational sessions patients were seen at an outpatient clinic by
doctors and dieticians. At these visits they measured the participants blood pressure, weight,
body mass index, caloric intake, lipids, cholesterol, and protein intake. Data was analyzed using
Statistical Package for the Social Sciences; through the data analysis it was found that patients in
the EC group had statistically significant lower blood pressures than the UC group, even at the
two year follow up. The number of patients in the EC group performing physical activity
increased and reached statistical significance. These findings demonstrate the impact lifestyle
education can have on the control of blood pressure. While this study did not examine young
adults specifically the findings can be applied to the young adults population.
The findings of the integrative review address the use of lifestyle education as a
way to manage hypertension in young adults. For that reason, the integrative review findings
relate and support the researchers PICO question. The PICO question specifically looked at the
INTEGRATIVE REVIEW 8
effects that lifestyle education would have on young adults awareness of hypertension. Four of
the quantitative studies demonstrated that a statistically significant number of young adults lack
hypertension awareness (Gooding et al., 2014; Johnson et al., 2014, Johnson et al., 2017; Johnson
et al., 2016). If this population is not aware that they have hypertension it is unlikely they are
receiving treatment or making the proper lifestyle modifications to treat their disease. Johnson et
al. (2014) also showed that there is a gap in the number of young adults who even receive
lifestyle education once they are diagnosed with hypertension. Lifestyle modifications are often
clinicians first line of treatment when it comes to controlling hypertension, without proper
education young adults cannot take the first step in controlling their blood pressure. Ferrara et al.
(2012) demonstrated the impact that lifestyle education can have on the control of hypertension
in adults. These findings can be translated to the young adult population. For the young adults
who do receive education often times the material does not meet their specific needs or questions,
this was demonstrated in the two qualitative studies (Johnson et al., 2017; Johnson et al., 2016).
Tailoring lifestyle education to young adults specific needs will make it easier and more likely
for them to follow the guidelines in order to control their hypertension and help prevent future
health problems later in life. Nurses do a large amount of patient teaching; this is one area we
can help to improve and tailor the hypertension education to young adults.
The implications of the findings suggest that lifestyle education needs to be geared more
towards young adults specific needs and questions. In order for these young adults to receive
lifestyle education they must be aware of their hypertension in the first place. One way to do this
would be to encourage young adults to have a consistent primary care provider (PCP). This way,
even if they only go to their PCP when they are sick or once a year for a physical their records
will be in the same place and multiple elevated blood pressure readings are more likely to be
INTEGRATIVE REVIEW 9
caught. The researcher recommends future research should focus on how lifestyle education
specifically geared towards young adults affects their blood pressure control.
Limitations
There are various limitations acknowledged by the researcher that have affected this
integrative review. The integrative review is a class assignment being conducted by only one
novice researcher. The assignment criteria were limited to five journal articles written within the
Conclusion
By conducting this integrative review the researcher demonstrated the importance of first
identifying young adults with hypertension and then tailoring lifestyle education to meet their
needs. The researcher found a lack of consistent health care, as well as a lack of hypertension
awareness among young adults (Gooding et al., 2014; Johnson et al., 2014; Johnson et al., 2017;
and Johnson et al., 2016). The researcher also found that significant changes in blood pressure
Participation in lifestyle education programs has strong positive relationships in long term blood
pressure control. This integrative review demonstrates that young adults with hypertension are
not receiving the lifestyle education they need to control their disease. Nurses have the
opportunity to change hypertension awareness in young adults, first by making young adults
aware of their hypertension and then tailoring the lifestyle education to meet their needs. This
will help young adults have better control of their hypertension and improve their health
References
Ferrara, A.L., Pacioni, D., Fronzo, V.D., Russo, B.F., Staiano, L., Speranza, E., Gente, R.,
Gargiulo, F., & Ferrara, F. (2012). Lifestyle educational program strongly increases
10.111/jch.12016
Gooding, H.C., McGinty, S., Richmond, T.K., Gillman, M.W., & Field, A.E. (2014).
Hypertension awareness and control among young adults in the national longitudinal
study of adolescent health. Journal of General Internal Medicine 29(8), 1098-1104. doi:
10.1007/s11606-014-28909-x
Johnson, H.M., Olson, A.G., LaMantia, J.N., Kind, A.J., Pandhi, N., Mandonca, E.A., Craven,
M., & Smith, M.A. (2014). Documented lifestyle education among young adults with
10.1007/s11606-014-3059-7
Johnson, H.M., Warner, R.C., Bartels, C.M., & LaMantia, J.N. (2017). Theyre youngerits
2332-8
Johnson, H.M., Warner, R.C., LaMantia, J.N., & Bowers, B.J. (2016) I have to live like Im
Appendix 1
Quantitative and Qualitative Tables of Evidence
First Author Aldo L. Farrara (2012) Dr. at department of Clinical and Experimental Medicine at
(Year)/Qualifications Federico 2nd University of Naples (Naples, Italy)
Background/Problem Goal of normal BP level achieved in less than 25% of patients DX with HTN
Statement Evaluate whether an educational program dedicated to lifestyle changes to treat
hypertension would be useful in achieving better and long lasting results in the
control of BP levels
Lifestyle changes frequently considered stressful in daily life so they are harder to
maintain and implement
Conceptual/theoretical Quantitative? Experimental since they separated into two groups
Framework
Design/ Experimental (separated into two groups 1-educational care program 2-usual care
Method/Philosophical program
Underpinnings Educational care program met 3 times a month with doctors and well-trained
dieticians and spoke about different topics like: stress management, explaining the
relationship between sodium intake and hypertension and the importance of a low-
salt diet, recognition of high fat foods How different aspects of the diet can be
controlled/tailored to help treat and control their hypertension
Sample/ Setting/Ethical 188 hypertensive patients with stable blood pressure levels and drug therapy in the
Considerations previous six months
Randomly divided into 2 groups (educational care and usual care)
Followed at 3 moth intervals for 2 years
Major Variables Studied BP
(and their definition), if Body weight
appropriate BMI
Caloric intake
Lipids
Cholesterol
Protein intake
Measurement Tool/Data Follow-up physical exams with patients after educational courses
INTEGRATIVE REVIEW 12
Collection Method
Data Analysis SPSS was used to do a t test for unpaired data and a one-way analysis of variance
with Tukeys multiple comparisons
Findings/Discussion PTS in EC group significantly decreased their overall nutrient intake (specifically
decreased saturated fats and carbohydrates
Number of patients performing physical activity significantly increased in EC
groupreached statistical significance
EC group saw significant changes in BP
o Changes in BP at one year follow up were significantly related to changes in
body weight, BMI, Caloric intake, Lipids, Cholesterol, And Sodium
o At 2 year follow-up when they hadnt had education for a year still had lower
and better numbers
Appraisal/Worth to Educational programs to improve adherence to non-pharmacological treatment of
practice hypertension is a low-cost/effective way to improve outcomes and reduce the risks of
cardiovascular events. May even eliminate drug therapy
INTEGRATIVE REVIEW 13
First Author Holly C. Gooding (2014) division of adolescent and Young Adult medicine at Boston
(Year)/Qualifications Childrens Hospital and Department of pediatrics at Harvard medical school
Background/Problem Young adults are less likely than older adults to be aware that they have
Statement hypertension.
They are also less likely to be treated for hypertension compared to older adults. No
specific lit review, but reference some previous research in intro.
Aimed to describe rates of hypertension awareness and control using the National
Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health
Conceptual/theoretical Not stated
Framework
Design/ Cross-sectional study of 13,512 young adults
Method/Philosophical data collected from 4th wave of the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health
Underpinnings in 2007-2008
at the time participants were ages 24-32 years old
Extracted data
Sample/ Setting/Ethical 13,512 young adults participating in wave 4 of the National Longitudinal Study of
Considerations Adolescent Health in 2007-2008.
Informed consent was obtained during the first wave of the study
IRB approval was given by the institutional review board at the University of North
Carolina Chapel Hill and additional analyses were approved by the Bostons
Childrens hospital Office of Clinician Investigation
Major Variables Studied Blood pressure was measured by trained ADD Health field interviewers. Stated the
(and their definition), if type of BP cuff and measuring device (automatic) approved by British hypertension
appropriate society
Stated exactly how they measured the BPs step by step and with what instruments.
This allows you to easily replicate their study
Defined what blood pressure control was (systolic <140, diastolic < 90)
Awareness of hypertension was only assessed in those with uncontrolled
hypertension
Health Insurance status (uninsured, public insurance, or commercial insurance)
based on self report
Recent preventative care (reporting seeing a health care provider for a routine
INTEGRATIVE REVIEW 14
Data Analysis qualitative data analysis of the question content (coding) occurred
Findings/Discussion Clearly listed out variables that were being discussed in each paragraph and gave
samples of the transcripts within the paper.
1. Guidelines and young adults- all providers felt JNC guidelines were applicable to
young adults. 3-6 months of lifestyle modifications needed prior to medication
initiation
2. Reported spectrum of clinical care barriers
Psychosocial consequence of HTN diagnosis (sick identity for young
adults, anxiety, and fear)
A possible false HTN diagnosis (ADHD med and Birth control can
contribute to this)
Visit adherence (decreased visitor adherence among young adults)
Gender differences in BP management (Easier to achieve BP follow-up
among young women b/c of visits required for contraception or b/c visits
coordinated with other members of household, i.e. children)
Reluctant to start BP medication
Appraisal/Worth to Tailored interventions need to be put into place to treat the unique needs of young adults
practice diagnosed with hypertension
INTEGRATIVE REVIEW 19
Sample/ Setting/Ethical Young adults ages 18-39 diagnosed with hypertension in Wisconsin.
Considerations 38
Eligible pts were identified via medical health records and invited to participate in
the study by their primary health care provider, study recruitment flyers were also
placed in family medicine waiting areas allowing pts to directly contact the
researchers to participate in the study.
Received IRB approval by the University of Wisconsin-Madison Health Sciences
IRB. All participants reviewed an IRB-approved summary sheet about the research
and provided verbal consent. (IRB WAIVED WRITTEN CONSENT).
Study recruitment flyers were also placed in select waiting areas of family clinics.
Major Variables Studied . Four topics explored in focus groups
(and their definition), if 1. Emotions and reactions after an initial hypertension diagnosis
appropriate 2. Young adults knowledge about hypertension and future health risks
3. Young adults attitudes and barriers to hypertension lifestyle modifications
INTEGRATIVE REVIEW 20
Findings/Discussion Most were surprised and angry about diagnosis, expected to develop HTN at older age,
HTN diagnosis negatively altered their young personal identity, making them feel older
than their peers. Current HTN education materials do not address young adults health
questions.
Four topics explored in focus groups
1.Emotions and reactions after an initial hypertension diagnosis (surprised, scared,
angry) (concerned about negative stigma associated with HTN)(many had prior
experiences with family members who had HTN)
2. Young adults knowledge about hypertension and future health risks (all
participants able to give one complication, Less than half of the respondents
reported receiving HTN education, of those respondents who reported
receiving pamphlets/handout >50% threw them away
3. Young adults attitudes and barriers to hypertension lifestyle modifications
(have to act older than their biological age)
4. Cost-benefit analysis of adhering to blood pressure medication(HTN often
asymptomatic so they dont think they need meds)
5. Social media use among young adults for hypertension self-management
(last part of focus group addressed possible social media solutions to
improve HTN management- Respondents did not like this, concerned about
peers finding out)
DISSCUSSION:
Self-identity as young adult is negatively altered
Touch on all 4 of the topics that were discussed in the focus group and expand on
how they can benefit current practice
State changes that need to be made to improve practice
States strengths, but also states problems/weaknesses with in their study
INTEGRATIVE REVIEW 21
Appraisal/Worth to Need to target interventions when educating and treating young adults with HTN. May
practice have to do multiple education sessions and emphasize that it is ok to ask questions
High-light need for expanded team-based care to increase patient care provider
communication (to help improve practice and health outcomes)