The document summarizes conversations with various Islamic scholars from different sects regarding the issues of music and pictures. It provides the views of over 20 scholars on whether music and pictures are allowed or forbidden in Islam. There was consensus among most scholars that music with instruments is forbidden, while music without instruments may be allowed with conditions. Views varied more on the issue of pictures, with most agreeing that pictures are allowed for identification purposes but forbidden for other uses.
Descrição original:
79
Título original
My Latest Letter to Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza Sahab the Great Un Biased Genuine Research Scholars Mirza
The document summarizes conversations with various Islamic scholars from different sects regarding the issues of music and pictures. It provides the views of over 20 scholars on whether music and pictures are allowed or forbidden in Islam. There was consensus among most scholars that music with instruments is forbidden, while music without instruments may be allowed with conditions. Views varied more on the issue of pictures, with most agreeing that pictures are allowed for identification purposes but forbidden for other uses.
The document summarizes conversations with various Islamic scholars from different sects regarding the issues of music and pictures. It provides the views of over 20 scholars on whether music and pictures are allowed or forbidden in Islam. There was consensus among most scholars that music with instruments is forbidden, while music without instruments may be allowed with conditions. Views varied more on the issue of pictures, with most agreeing that pictures are allowed for identification purposes but forbidden for other uses.
My latest letter to engineer muhammad ali mirza sahab the great un biased
genuine research scholars mirza_95@yahoo.com 0323-8556237
informing him about my recent telephonic conversations with top scholars of all sects regarding issues of music and pictures.I have requested engineer ali mirza bhaii sahab to please use the intelligence that ALLAH has blessed him with and give detailed lectures on these 2 topics.I have also requested him to deliver detailed lecture on banking and riba issues with their practical solution.MASHA ALLAH Ali bhaii is a grade 19 officer at nesom.A mechanical engineer by profession but he has been blessed by ALLAH.He has great knowledge of quran and ahadis.Any one can benefit from this great truthful unbiased and brave scholar/researcher(note:he is not a formal student of any madrassah and follows quran and sahih/hassan ahadees) Assalam u alaikum. My dear Muhammad ali mirza brother:I did a research/comparative study the issues of music and pictures. I have found out after talking to different grand scholars/researchers belonging to different sects that there are differences of opinion among scholars of same sects also. Sir i am sending you the replies of all scholars one by one,and i think that ALLAH has given you great intelligence and you are MASHA ALLAH really haqq parrast and brave researcher.I am very much hopeful that after reading all the views of scholars you will be in a much better position to prepare 2 deatiled lectures on the issues of music and pictures. Now please carefully read the views of scholars: syed azmat hussain shah gillani barelvi 0331-5008455 0321-5275251 moseeqi is harram li ghayrihi it is not harram li zaatihi.Had music been harram li zatihi then it could never have been allowed on the events of marriage,jihad and eid. He recommended book of imam e ghazzali and said that the ahadis are not so strong with regards to asnaad to prove the music as totally harram. About pictures he said that the condemned pictures mean statues.He however said that if someone makes a picture of a man with hands then probably it may be harram. Ghulam mustafa zaheer ahle hadees 0300-5482125 he said that all musical instruments are absolutely harram.Duff isnt a musical instrument.Recommended book of ibne qayyam and said that the view of ibne hazzam is rejected since it is shaadh,and he said that ahadis are very strong rather reached tawatur. He said that all pictures including modern day camera mobile pictures all harram.He said that even camera pictures are not AKS but these are also the pictures and get saved so harram absolutely. nadeem zaheer ahle hadees 0301-6603296 music with instruments is harram almost bil ijmaa.Musnad bazzar hadis is sahih which calls music instrument as a cursed voice. duff only permitted for young baby girls. He said that even if today all ulema of all sects claim that camera pictures are hallal even then they are all harram since no ijma is acceptable against quran and sahih ahadees. Mufti ejaz ahle hadees 0300-5337938 All music is harram li zatihi and all pictures are harram. Mufti asghar deobandi 0300-9218809 Music is harram li zatihi.Camera pictures are hallal but print out of such camera pictures is harram. Aftab Jawwadi shia 0300-5344736 There has been debate on definition of ghina/moseeqi and he said that all musical instruments are absolutely harram. Mufti imran barelvi 0300-8005189 He said that all music instruments are harram,and camera pictures even camera pictures in printed form are hallal. Dr abdul hameed azhar ahle hadees 0333-5156480 Music is harram li zatihi.Camera pictures are AKS like in mirror so allowed. Malik baqar shia 0334-2851214 music with instruments is absolutely harram. Only making statues is harram.All pictures are allowed. Ghulam mustafa noori barelvi 0300-6933481 Music is harram but camera pictures are allowed by recent fuqqaha. Mufti zakaria deobandi 0300-9482243 Music is absolutely harram. All kind of pictures are absolutely harram. Talib ur rahman shah ahle hadees 0321-5003499 Music is haraam li zatihi.Video is allowed since it doesnt have negative but it has dots on reel.Still photography is harram. Faisal khan barelvi 0321-5501977 Nothing is harram except few things which are categorically made harram in quran and sahih ahadees.There are few evils which make a thing harram. He said that although muhaddisin have always been very strict against all music instruments but he said that according to his view the use of an instrument makes it harram. He said that when rome was conquered a box was presented to the caliph containing pictures of AMBIA KARRAM.
He recommended books of javed ahmed ghamidi irshad ul haq asari tahir
maqdeesi ibne hazzam Nablisi. There was almost a consensus among all scholars that music without instruments is allowed with few conditions/sharrait. There was also almost a consensus among scholars except very few scholars that all music with instruments is absolutely harram and forbidden. Most of the scholars were of the view that music is absolutely harram since music is called music when it is played with instruments. There was almost a consensus among all scholars that in dire necessity like tabligh e deen propagation of religion passport identity card it is allowed to make pictures. There was almost a consensus among all scholars except very few that ahadis which curse music and pictures are sahih. There are many other grand scholars whom I tried to contact but couldnt since their mobiles were off.But majority of the above mentioned scholars are grand muftis/hadis scholars although I havent written mufti or muhaddis with few names but it doesnt mean they arent muftis or muhaddis.Except very few most of these scholars are senior grand muftis and grand muhaddisin.And even those who arent grand muftis or grand muhaddisin they are definitely experts in comparative study research and have a lot of study.