Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Paper
Cost cutting strategies
in HRM during
economic slowdown
Submitted By:
Sheikh Talha
RS1904 B25
10906035
Submitted to:
Miss. Chanjyot Kaur
LOVELY PROFESSIONAL
UNIVERSITY
Acknowledgement
I take this opportunity to present my vote of thanks to all those guidepost who really
acted as lightening pillars to enlighten our way throughout this project that has led to
successful and satisfactory completion of this study.
I’m highly thankful to Miss. Chanjyot Kaur for her active support, valuable time and
advice, whole-hearted guidance, sincere cooperation and pains-taking involvement
during the study and in completing the assignment of preparing the said project within
the time stipulated.
Lastly, I’m thankful to all those, particularly the various friends , who have been
instrumental in creating proper, healthy and conductive environment and including new
and fresh innovative ideas for us during the project, their help, it would have been
extremely difficult for us to prepare the project in a time bound framework.
SHEIKH TALHA
world economy will run at the full speed or the economic slowdown will appear to return
some balance into the economies of many countries in the world. To make things even
worse - the real economic slowdown did not appear for more than 20 years and the
companies did get fat a bit over the period. All the HR Processes in successful
organizations are set to support the growth of sales, volumes and net income, but they
are not ready to support the moments of cost cuts, lay offs and many other action
needed during the economic slowdown. The real HR Professional who remember the
times of the economic slowdown are very rare on the market. People working in Human
Resources are not aware of the real need to control and manage personnel expenses
• provide the business with the detailed analysis of benefit portfolio with the
potential cuts.
• provide the business with processes and procedures to decrease the number of
employees.
Introduction:
During Economic Slowdown downsizing has been a pervasive managerial practice for
the past three decades. Over the years, a firm's standard response to finding itself in
financial difficulty was to reduce its workforce. While there is ample evidence suggesting
that downsizing activities rarely return the widely anticipated benefits, there is also a
sobering understanding that downsized firms are forced to deal with the human, social,
Research shows clearly that the human consequences of layoffs are costly and
particularly devastating for individuals, their families, and entire communities. While
workforce reductions cannot always be avoided, there are compelling reasons why
last resort.
During an economic downturn a firm must carefully consider its options and assess the
layoffs as they relate to the actual cost-reduction stages of a firm. Indeed, it is critical for
cost-reduction stage that characterizes the firm's current business position and
environment. Thus, a firm needs to determine the expected duration of the business
where the firm is in its cost-cutting stage. A firm's cost-reduction stage, by definition,
expenditures successfully.
The purpose of this Term paper is to present a methodology that enables firms to
this, my term paper presents and discusses the framework of cost-reduction stages of a
firm coupled with creative modern-day human resource (HR) practices that firms
typically adopt.
Cost-reduction stages:
The framework comprises three timeframe-related phases. Each commands several
According to Vernon (2003), the first stage of the cost-reduction framework represents
activities. Most likely, the firm resorts to minor, moderate cost-reduction measures in
this early stage. These preliminary adjustments should enable the firm to shun
activity within a timeframe of four to six months. A firm experiences this stage because
slip and the resolute engagement in preliminary cost-reduction methods should allow
the firm to focus its operations in a cost-sensitive mode for a quick recovery.
The likelihood of success for short-range cost adjustments hinges on a number of
factors. First, senior management must be able to effectively articulate why the cost-
adjustment measures are necessary and the short time frame of the strategy.
Executives' ability to convey the message that the implementation of preliminary cost-
reduction measures at the present time will prevent future layoffs is critical. Second, the
HR Director's role is to communicate the decision(s) made by the executive board to the
Third, employees' flexibility in allowing the firm to modify cost structures increases the
chance of success for the planned cost alterations. In sum, a firm's capacity to
overcome a business downturn in the first stage will depend on the organization's ability
cost reductions. Some of the more popular approaches that have emerged are:
1. Hiring freeze
A hiring freeze constitutes a mild form of downsizing and reduces labor costs in the
short term. Some firms continue to hire new employees while cutting jobs at the same
time. While this practice may make sense in terms of supplying the firm with key
personnel, it also tends to send a confusing message to the rest of the workforce. In its
latest attempt to fight rising jet fuel costs and a weakening U.S. economy, American
2. Mandatory vacation
Implementing mandatory vacation involves requiring employees to use their accrued
vacation days or mandating that individuals take a number of unpaid vacation days
during a certain time period. While employees might not want to be told when and how
to use their entitlements, they will nonetheless appreciate the reaffirmed job security.
Chrysler LLC currently plans a corporate-wide shutdown of its U.S. operations during
the weeks of July 7 and July 14, 2008, with the intention of improving the automaker's
3. Reduced workweek
Firms sometimes resort to a reduced workweek. This may translate into the reduction
from 40 to 35 or fewer hours and thereby reduce the short-term payroll expenditures.
While most employees appreciate the idea of being able to spend more time with their
families, they may not always welcome a reduced paycheck. Also, employees may find
that the same amount of work still needs to be performed while they spend less time on
the job. Nucor Steel Corporation in South Carolina has avoided layoffs for 35 years by
reducing to two- and three-workday weeks for its employees during downturns .
Recently, workers at a St. Thomas automotive parts plant in the UK have voted to
reduce their work week rather than see 200 employees leave permanently .
reducing operational costs in the short term. Firms may decide on an across-the-board
(i.e., all employees) abolition or it may confine the cut to selected categories only (e.g.,
automotive firms, such as Visteon Corporation, General Motors, and Ford, slashed
5. Salary reduction
Salary reduction has been a standard practice for firms experiencing unexpected
financial pressure. Whereas salary reduction may mitigate financial concerns in the
short-run, extended salary reductions can affect employee morale and loyalty. Also,
while companywide salary reductions may prevent layoffs, there is a clear risk that top
performers will be encouraged to leave for competitors that offer superior compensation.
percent pay-cut to avoid layoffs. Prior to that, Intel announced that it had planned to cut
Temporary facility shutdowns occur when a work site closes for a designated period of
time, while some administrative functions are still performed. A shutdown allows
employees to have time off without using their vacation days. While the overall company
production decreases, the firm can achieve considerable cost savings while avoiding
layoffs. In 2008, Aleris International shut down its rolling mill production in Virginia in
order to align production with demand. The production for customers was phased out
Employees appreciate the opportunity to make a positive impact on their workplace and
environment. Firms frequently solicit cost-reduction ideas from employees who are often
effective when employees are able to make suggestions in the early stages of cost
executives still do not realize that employees are the best source of cost-reduction
ideas, in that workers on the job are in a prime position to identify and recognize waste.
Clearly, there are many HR practices and options that firms can adopt to reduce short-
term expenditures. While some firms have come up with fairly creative ideas, others
activity. If properly recognized and executed, the firm may be able to transition to mid-
range cost adjustments and thus prevent long-term layoffs and forced downsizing
HR Director must be able to articulate the underlying purpose and objectives of the
expenditure adjustments to the entire workforce. This should ensure buy-in and
could potentially alter employees' work environment. Thus, the HR department will play
reductions:
exceeds 6 months. While extended salary reductions can negatively affect employee
commitment and morale, advocates stress that employees would prefer a smaller
income temporarily rather than seeing their jobs disappear permanently. As with short-
substitute stock awards for variable cash payments. The U.S. firm 415 Production
offered an overall 5 percent pay cut or a four-day work week reflecting the appropriate
2. Voluntary sabbaticals
Voluntary sabbaticals, also called furloughs, allow salaried employees to take voluntary
leaves for a designated period of time. Companies may offer sabbaticals with
considerably reduced pay or no pay at all. Most firms continue to provide benefits during
sabbaticals. Sabbaticals enable firms to reduce their medium-term expenditure and act
as a potent method for avoiding downsizing-related layoffs. While employees may feel
motivated and re-energized upon their return, HR experts point out that medium-range
and long-term sabbaticals may cause employees to lose their leading-edge and return
with outdated skills. Interestingly, there is evidence suggesting that firms offer generous
sabbaticals during times of economic growth while companies refrain from this HR
practice during tough financial periods. In 2001, the consulting firm Accenture
announced that 800 employees qualified for a special voluntary sabbatical program,
while 600 employees were going to be laid off permanently. In 2001, one of Siemens'
divisions, Information and Communication Mobile, offered its German employees a one-
year 'time-out' at reduced pay without permanently eliminating the jobs . Siemens was
thus able to reduce costs without losing high-performing employees during difficult
economic times.
3. Employee lending
lending firm, lends an employee to another employer firm for a set period of time while
continuing to pay salary and providing benefits. The borrowing firm, which can be a
competitor, in return, reimburses the lending company for part or all of the salary. While
firm, some employees may not wish to work for a third-party. There is also the risk that
the borrowing firm may decide to hire the employee permanently once the contracted
period is lapsed. As a consequence, the lending firm would thus loose a critical
8 months with the intention of bringing them back to their original jobs at the end of that
period. The supplier reimbursed Texas Instruments for their staffers' salaries during the
4. Exit incentives
This option entails offering employees incentives to leave the firm in the form of optional
severance or early retirement. This strategy enables firms to better target jobs and units
in that it recognizes employees for their service and helps retain the remaining
employees. At the same time, exit incentives can be costly and can create an
entitlement mentality for the remaining workforce in the future . In 2007, technology-
outsourcing firm E.D.S. (Electronic Data Systems) offered extra retirement benefits to
medium-term expenditures. Unfortunately, similar to the first stage, too many firms
According to Vernon (2003), the third stage of the cost-reduction framework represents
downturn exceeding 12 months and beyond. This stage may be recognized through an
extended decline of current and projected customer demand and/or extremely volatile
expenditure adjustments on the part of the firm. It is in this phase that downsizing-
related layoffs are frequently inevitable. While permanent layoffs should always be seen
as a final resort, firms must try to avoid across-the-board, mass layoffs at all costs.
Companies who find themselves forced to engage in extensive layoffs must adopt
practices that instill loyalty and commitment in the remaining and exiting workforces .
Firms that are forced to embrace downsizing have shown to adopt various layoff-related
strategies and with various degree of success. It is beyond the purpose of this paper to
review and present the literature on the actual outcomes of downsizing. Essentially, the
primary goal in this third stage is to set the scene for the firm to be able to re-attract and
re-gain layoff victims in a post-downsizing phase. This, of course, is based on the
presumption that the economy will bounce back sufficiently and that the firm will be
1. Rehiring bonuses
It is not uncommon for firms to rehire laid-off employees. While some firms provide a
monetary rehiring bonus for veterans to return to the company within a specified period
of time, other companies hire previously laid off employees as external consultants. In
some cases, firms realize that they cut too many and/or the wrong employees, while in
other cases management decides to hire back after the economic downturn. Research
shows that employees and consultants frequently return to the downsized firm with
improved monetary rewards. Back in 2001 and after two rounds of layoffs, Charles
Schwab Corp. offered a $7,500 bonus for any previously downsized employee who was
Firms should make an effort to maintain friendly relations with laid-off victims. Modern-
day technology, including internet forums, 24-7 hotlines, e-mails, and mailings, provide
relationships . This is particularly important if firms intend to rehire the former employees
powerful method is an internal job fair, where firms host events in order to help place
and redeploy downsized employees within the company. The Ford Motor Company is
currently running internal job fairs in its plants to entice employees to find new careers
Layoffs, frequently called downsizing, describe the process in which companies remove
purpose of this practice is to reduce the organization’s burden of excess labor costs
The reasons why the company downsizes are related to dramatic changes
occurring in the environment. This may make the company lose a market share in its
industry or respond to fierce competition from its rivals resulting in the need for the
company to cut costs through altering its size to fit its market and customer base.
Globalization and the breakdown of trade barriers among nations and the emergence of
technology and automation have also necessitated the company to downsize. Thus, the
overriding rationale for downsizing by the company appears to be the need for survivial
Facing the threat of job loss and seeing others lose their jobs can be a traumatic and
bitter experience. This is one reason why many excellent companies do everything
possible to avoid layoffs. However, even the most employee-friendly companies may
therefore have to ensure that they develop appropriate and well thought-out plans
methods with the cost-reduction stage may prove to be a powerful method. While there
are many HR tools at an executive's disposal, each practice works most effectively
when implemented during its established time frame, or cost-reduction stage. At the
same time, the assumptions underlying the framework are somewhat simplistic and
Vernon (2003), at least six factors affecting the selection of a downsizing strategy need
to be considered:
• corporate culture, for example, the institutional values and anticipated effects of
cost cutting
• demographics, the location of the firm/demographics of employees the firm would
• labour market, specifically the state and condition of the labour market.
For instance, if the expected duration of an economic downturn is prolonged (i.e., factor
time) and, thus, the firm opts to engage in across-the-board layoffs, then there will be
the inevitable impact upon the firm's corporate culture, as mass layoffs have shown to
corporate culture) may prompt the firm to retain all its salaried employees if it has the
capacity to remain liquid during an economic downturn (i.e., factors budget and
resources).
For the company to practice effective and successful downsizing, the following steps
should be included:
Education
Planning
Communication
Education – The company needs to educate its employees on the needs of the
receptive to their needs and at the same time, it will help the management to design an
effective downsizing program. Education can also take the form of training the
employees to look beyond their existing roles and duties thus prepare them for taking
Reinforcement of the company goals and values – The company must ensure that the
vision, mission, goals and values of the organization are clearly articulated and
reinforced at every opportunity so that the employees embrace them. In the event of a
downsizing, workers will then better relate to the rationale of the downsizing. This has
to start with the leadership of the CEO and be reinforced by HR policies and practices
Honesty and dignity at all time – Employees should be treated with honesty and
dignity from the recruitment process through to eventual employment. If employees are
dealt with honesty, in the event of a downsizing, they will better understand the rationale
for this decision and thus develop a sense of wanting to overcome the problem with the
whatever way the company can support or assist him/her in his/her outplacement needs
(Greenspan, 2002).
Planning – In order for layoffs and downsizing for be effective, successful workforce
strategy, it must first understand the cost-reduction stage of characterizes its current
business position. This reveals how long the company needs to reduce expenditures
and takes into account the current economy and the duration of the economic downturn.
As the Japanese economy faces one of its worst financial crises in decades, it is
the concept of “lifetime employment” is important to the Japanese and has shaped their
cost by at the same time trying to maximize and preserve the highest number of jobs
possible. This is done through what is known as “koyochosei” meaning the “adjustment
overtime; reduction in the hours/days worked and the practice and internal
transfers through job rotation (to develop the skills of the worker) or transfers due
to a vacancy.
temporary leave. The objective of the temporary leave is to cut labor costs as the
transfer takes two forms, “zaiseki shukko” where the workers are temporarily
transferred by are still considered part of the original company and “iseki shukko”
where the workers are released to be employed by other companies. The latter
Only after the other alternatives have been used to adjust employment levels will
The salient features of the Japanese way to downsizing involve careful planning and
a gradual and systematic approach. Employees are consulted at all stages and
communication is open. Layoffs are considered as a last resort after all other
alternatives have been employed. Policies and programs are in place to minimize
Inventec Corporation
operations with production of calculators. For other 24 years, it has evolved into a
large environmentally friendly enterprise with ISO certifications and is currently one
approximately 4,000 dedicated employees, and its revenues are in excess of NT$46
Linkou, Taiwan. The reasons that forced Inventec Corp. to make this tough decision
decided to reduce personnel cost by laying off employees who worked on the assembly
lines.
They prepared very generous compensation packages, which included severance pay
based on years of service. For instance, employees who have worked over one year in
the company are eligible to receive at least ten months payment as compensation. The
longer their length of employment, the higher the compensation they can receive.
Currently, Inventec Corp is the only company that has offered this type of compensation
package in Taiwan. In addition, Inventec Corp. also surveyed employees’ opinions and
discussed it with them before announcing the layoff to obtain employees’ reaction to the
change. The company encouraged the employees to leave voluntarily and if they
wanted to transfer to other factories, management offered the necessary training and
development needed to successfully perform the new job. The most important purpose
of offering this assistance was to provide employees with opportunities that will promote
the global step of downsizing. Therefore, restructuring the organization and reducing
personnel and manufacturing costs are inevitable. Without properly controlling cost and
developing the proper action plans for this situation, the organization would have been
bankrupt. Inventec Corp. has chosen to reduce personnel costs by transferring their
assembly lines from Taiwan to China in order to stay competitive. With the careful
planning, Inventec Corp. received little complaints and protests when downsizing and
layoff.
Performance Management:
Another Alternative for cost
cutting
Performance management is the systematic process of planning work and setting
In times of global slowdown, managing performance has always been a major challenge
for the industry. The steps taken by Jet Airways and TATA automobile is an indicator of
a greater risk of social disturbances caused by it. The issue like talent shading and
identify how in times of slowdown, it is important for the HR department to come up with
alternate innovative strategies to ensure performances by all its emloyess, while still
keeping a check on the rising costs. The paper also discuss different ways of achieving
the above stated goals and also looks into some of the methods already adopted by
formulated to deliver the twin benefits of lowered cost as well as increased productivity,
compelled many organizations to tighten and control spending on their operation and
work
activities through all measures possible. The outlook of potential expenditure on their
human resources which often form a significant proportion of their respective resources
has even caused some organization and their recruitment and retention initiatives by
The likes of TCS, wipro and keane are either going slow on recruitment or are hiring
more number of trained hands,TCS,which recruits about 18000 employees every year,
has decided to make significant cuts in recruitment patterns every year, has decided to
tide over the current global economic crisis. The high-end pay packages have also
taken a backseat with investment banks withdrawing from the placement process. for
university(DU)graduates in2007 backed out from the process after its bankruptcy. As
the economic slowdown has also affected the use of credit cards, the BPO sector, call
company convergys laid off nearly 400 people after it closed on of its Mumbai centers.
Companies like patni, Fidelity and 24/7 are shedding low performers and will continue to
cut staff and freeze hiring. Kingfisher Airlines also stopped the intake of pilots till further
The knee-jerk reaction to a slowdown pressure often compels them to take steps like
downsizing and layoffs but these steps like downsizing and layoffs but these steps in
turn tend to negatively affect the organization’s overall long term strategy, also these
short sighted decisions carry the risk of ending all important dialogue with existing and
potential employees.
Hence, even in a slowdown, these organizations need to assess the impact of their
percentage of the salary or deleting a holiday gift program may cut expenses from the
bottom line .but they may also have a more significant longer term impact on profitability
decisions rather than decision taken in haste which impact the organization ‘s long term
backed by ways which eliminates waste while still retaining a motivated workforce.
The seven –steps strategy to enhance
performance during economic slowdown
are :
PRACTICES:
In general , a large number of companies invest in human capital practices that make
“softer” goals in mind-do not always add economic value when implemented in a
misguided way. Until employers align their human capital management Practices with
their, employees needs, they will continue to waste resources on strategies that
diminish, rather than increase, shareholder value. But rather than eliminating or
replacing these practices, all other employee related expenses like salaries, bonus or
other benefits allowances become the first to be targeted for cuts owing to their visibility
(i) Review all employee related expenses and assess those that do not make a
(ii) Survey employees to determine the benefits that have greatest value.
(iv) Build value by adding small high –impact benefits at a time when the rest of the
business world is cutting.
cuts cannot be underestimated ,As it is ,in today’s intellectual era, spending wisely,
holding employees accountable for performance and building a more positive workplace
Also, innovative ways to cut down cost without compromising an employee’s salaries or
learning and development should be taken up. For instance, sterlite technologies has
stopped all travel related to in-house meeting,and all meeting would be conducted via
conferencing.
Economy slowdown is generally marked by larger scale layoffs and recruitment freezing
across the organizations. Hence, the employees prefer to stick to the present employers
rather than switching to different jobs which are already scarce. Hence, retention for the
need to remain alert in order to retain top perform to ensure productivity in the times to
come. Hence, retention as such be treated as an ongoing process even during the
slowdowns.
(ii) Track turnover rates of these key employess separately from overall turnover figures.
(iii) Have senior executives talk individually with key employees to communicate the
employee’s value to the company.
(iv) Invest in proven retention practices including development opportunities for key
employees.
COMPONENTS
Conclusion:
This Term paper has demonstrated that the ability to correctly forecast the cost-
defer, and avoid downsizing-related layoffs. It appears as if the key lies in the alignment
of a firm's downsizing methods with the cost-reduction stage in which the firm finds
itself. While the introduced framework remains simplistic, it is nonetheless alleged that
implementing HR practices that are aligned with the six factors above should allow for a
are devastating for all parties and that permanent layoffs should be not be considered at
all costs.
Reference:
• http://hrguide.applezoom.com
• http://www.allbusiness.com/labor-employment/human-resources-personnel-
management
• http://www.scribd.com/doc/14477120/PERFORMANCE-MANAGEMENT-
DURING-ECONOMIC-SLOWDOWN
• http;//en.wikipedia.org/economic_slowdown