Você está na página 1de 143

Ê   Ê 


c
c P  c c
c
c  
 c c


c
c 


 c 
 
 c 
 cc  
c
c 


 c 
 
 cc  
 c c
c
 c c c cc c
c c c  c c c c ccc c
c
c  c
 
cc
c
c
c  
c c
c
c c
 cc
c  c c ccc  c
c   c cccc c
c   c 
c  
c c 
c ccccc
c 
c
c  c cc cc c
c    c c   
cc ccc
c
c  
c c c  c
c c
 cc
c
 c cc cc c
c   c c cc cc  c
c
c  
c 
c
c
 c  c
 cc c
c
 c
c c
c 
 c cc ccc
c  c c c c
 
 cc  
 c cc c
c  c cc  cc c
c
c 
c c 
c
c 

cc  c c   c c
 cc
c c c 
c c  c
  c c c cc
c
cc c
 c ccPc c cc c c
c

c  
 c c c 
cc
 c 
c
c   c c  ccc c
c
cccccc
c c
 c


c
c
c ccccccc  c 
 ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc
c c ccccccccc cc c  c c  cPc c! c
 cc c
cccccccccccc c  c c
 
 cPc c! c
 ccccccccccccccccc
cccccccccccccc c
c cccccccc  c  c
ccccccccc c  c c
 c cc c" #c
c
c cccccccc  c

c  c
cc ccccccc  c  c
c cccccc
cc
 
 cc  c
c cccccccc


 c  c 
cc c  c
c ccccccPc
c c

 
c
c
c
c
c
cccccccc  c c 
 
 c
cccccccccccccccccccccP  c
cc   c c 
 
 c
c c
 c

 c c
 c


c

c c
cc 
 cc


 c  cc


c c 
 c
cc  
 c
cc 
 
 c
c
$c c  c
$ c 
c
 c 
c   c
 c 

 c c
 c  
 c


c
 c  
 c 
c 
c c    c c
c

c  
 c c

c 
c c 
c 
c  
c c
   c    c
$c 
c
 c  
 c 
 c
c 
c c 
 c c
c
 c 
 cc
c   c
c c  cc c

cc
 c 
 
c cc


c
 c c c

c cc c
c
$cc
c c cc  c
$ c
 c c ccc c
c
c

 c c 
 c
c c  c
$c   c c  
 ccc c
$c   c cc cc c
c  
 
c c

 c
$c 

c 
 c  c
 c  c  c
c  c  c
 c c c%  c cc c
 c    c c  
c c c 
  c c
cc
 c   c
c c   ccc c
 c  c cc ccc
 c P  c c ccccc
!cc c  
c c  c 
cPcP 
 c

c
 cc&c
P
c c
 c c  c c  c c  cc
 c
 

 c c c 
  
c   
c  c c c
"#c
c
c
c  
 c
 c   c c c cc c
!cccc   c c 'ccc c
!ccc cc cPc ccc"#c
c
$c 

c 
 c  c
 c  c


c
c c  c c c cc cc c
c  c cc cc c
c
$c 

c 
 c  c
 c  c


c
c  
c cc c c cc c
c 
c c 
c c   c Pc  c  c  c c
c
c
c ccccccc 
 
 c
c 
c 
 c   c
$c 
c cccc c
$c 
c  c c
c cc c
$c  c cccc c
c
c ccccccc
c c

c
$c  c cc cc c

c c
$c 
 c c  
c ccc
$c   c c  c c 
cccc
c
c

cc    c
$c    c c
 c
c cc c
c
c ccc
 cc   c
$c  c cccc
c c cccccc$cccc ! c c 
 c c c cc c" #c
c
c c c c  c
c c  c
$c P  c  
 c
ccc$ccccc
cc   c  
c c
c c c c $ cccc c c  c ccc
c c c c $cccc
c c c cc c
c c c c $ ccccc c c  c cc  c
c c c c $cccccc cP 
 c ccc
$cccc c c

c ccc" #c
$c c c   c (
c 

c c   c c  
c c
cc"#c
$c c c  c c
cPc c  c  c cc
c
c c c cccccc$ccccc
c
c  c c c c
c c c c $ cccccc  c cc ccc
c
c c ccccccc cccccc$cc   cc 
  c 
 c
c c c c $ ccc  c c cccc
c
c cccc c c
c ccccccccc$ccc) c c ccc c
c ccccccccc$cc c c*
c ccc
c c cccccc$c) c c  c cP  cPc c  c cc c
c c ccccc$c  c c    c Pc  c  c c c  cc
$  c  c cc c
c
c ccccc 
c c$ 
cc c
c ccccccccc$ccc
c$c c c ccc
c ccccccccc$cccc c  
 c cc  cc c
c ccccccccc$ccc
 c c  c  
 c c ccc
c
c cccccP  cc  c c
cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc$c ccccc 
 c c
 cP  c
c ccccccccccc $ c ( c c
c c c c !
c c

c ccc
c c c c !c c c c cc  c
!c cc cPc ccc"#c
c c c c !cc
c c c c cc  c"#cc
c c c c !ccc ccPc c   cc  cc
c
c c c $c 
c
c
 c
c c
c c c c !cc c
c c cc  c
c c c c !cc c
 c c cc cc c
c c c c !cc c c

ccc  cc c
c
c cccccc
 c 
 cc c   c$   c  c 
cc
c c ccccccccc   c
 c

c c
c c $c cccc c c  c cc c
c c $ccccc
 c  c c  c cc c
c c $c cccc 
 c c !  c cc c
c c $cccccc ccPc c  cc 
 c c
ccccccc$ cccccPc c cÊ  
Ê 
 
 
 
 

 
   c cc
c
c
c c c c

 c c  c
$c
c c c  c cc c
$c  c c
cccc
c
c c c
c  
 cc  c
cc 
 c
c
  
c
$c  c c c cc c
c
c   
 cc 
 c c
c c $c cc 
 c c !  c cc c
c c $c)  c ccPc c c c c c
c
c  
 cc 
 c
c  cc c c
c 
 c cc c
c   
c  cc

 c
c c $c cc
 c cc ccc ccc c
c c $cccc c c c cc c
c c   c cPc
c c  

 c
c c  c c c  c
c c    cc    c

c
c c ( c

c
c c $c cc  c c
cccc
c
c


ccc  cc
cc
c 
 
 c
cccc ccP c 
c
c 
 c


c
$c  c cPccc c
$c  c cccc c
c
c  
c  c
$c P  cc c  c
$ c c c c c  
ccc c
c
c 

cc 
c  c
$c c c

ccc c
c
c  cc 
c
$c   cc cccc
$c  c c
 c cc c
c
c 
 c ccc
c
$c   c c%
ccc c
$c  
 c c 
 c c c cc c
c
c

c

c c
c 
 
 c
c c c cccc  c
$c  c c  c cc c

c c
$c  c c
 c c

cPc c   c c c
 c
c
cc c ccccc

c  c c c  c c
 c

c
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc cc 
  c 
 c
c c c c cccc$c c c 
c  c c  
c cc c
$cc  c c cPc cc
c
c cccc 
 c c  c c  
 c c 
c   c c c
c
  c
$ c*
c  
c
 c c 
cc ccc
$c c
c c
c   c
c
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc)
 cc c c
c
$c c cc cc c
$c   c c
 c
ccc c
c
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc 
 c 
cc  
c c 

c c  c


$cc  c c cPc cc  c
$ccc  
 c c
c cc c
$c 
c c ccc c
c
c cccccccccccccc 
  c 
 
 c
c c c c ccccc$c  c c 
 c c 
 ccc c
$c
c cccc c
$cc cc ccc
c
c c cc
c 
 
 c c  c   c
c
ccc c c c
 
 c 
 
 c
c c c c cccc$cc  c
$c  
 c c  c
c c c ccccccccccccc$c
 c c  c
$ c c  c  
c   c c   
c  c
 c
$c c c c  c  c  c c c c c
c
$ c c
 c c c c cc c
ccc$c   cc c

cPc c  cc
  cc c

c c c  
 c 
 
 c
c
c c c c
  c
cc 
 
 c
c
c 
 
 c
c   c
c
 cc
c 
 
 c
c   c
c cc
$c  c c c  c ccc
$c  c c c cc c
c
c 
 
 c
c   c
c
 c


c
$c
  c cc c   ccccc
c
c
c


c 
c
c c  
c

cc  c$cc
c
$cP  c
$

 c c  c cc
c

c c
$c c
c c !c
c cc cc cc c
c c !c c c   c c
 
 c ccc
ccc$c
 c


c
c
c  
c


c
$cP  c c  c cc c
$c c c

c cc c
$c  c c

cPc c c c c c
c
cP  cc c


c
$c
 c c  c ccc
$c
cc c
c c
c ccc
$c c
c cc ccc
$c
c cc c
 cccc
c
c c c  c
c


c
c c c c ccccc$c c 
c c
c ccc
c
c


c c c

 c  
 c
$c) c

 c c 

cc cc c
$ccc c cccc c
c
c 
 
c c c   c
c  c


c
$c 
 c c  c   c 
 c
c c $ cc  c 
 
 c c 
c
c c $cc  c  
 c c 
 c 
 
 c
c
c 
 
 c c


c 
c  c
 c 
 c
$cc c cP c cc c
$c+ c c  
ccc  c
$c  c c 
c ccc" #c
c
c


c 
 c c
 c 
c
$cc
 
 c c c  c ccc
$c c 
 c cc
c   c cc c
c
c

 c c  
 c c  c
$cc  c
c ccccccccc$ c
c,c c c
 cc cc c
c
cccc$ 
 
 c c 
c c c

c
c 
 c
c
Pc 
 
 cc
 c c 
 c
c

 c c
c c  c
c c c c c c $cP  c  c
c c c c c c ccccc$ c c 
 c c c 
 c P  
c  
c
  c  ccc
c
c c c c c ccccc$c 
 c 
 c c
  c c
c cccc$ cccP c c  c ccc
c cccc$ccc  c cc c ccc
c
c
$c  c c   c c
 c
c ccc$ ccc 
 c c
 cccc
c ccc$cc   ! c c

ccc c

c c
c
$c 
 
 c c
 c c
c ccc$ cc- c- 
cc-c
c c !c c c  ccc c
c c !c  c
cc ccc cc c
c
)cc  c  
 cc c  c
c   c
c $c c
c  c  c c
c c $ cc! c cc ccc
c $c 

 c c   
c c 
 
c
c $c   
c
 c  cc 
c  c
c c $ c c c
c cc ccc c
c
c
 
 c
c $c  cc cccc c
c $c c  
 c
c $c  
 
 cc 
c
c c $ c c cc ccc
c
c  c  c
c $c  c c  
cccc
c
c
cc  
c  c  cc  c
c
c ccc c  
 cc  c
c
c c c $c  
 cc 
c c  
c
c c c c $ ccc  
 c c

c
c cc
c c c c c !c c c  c  cc c
c
c  cc  c
$c  
c  c
$c 
 cc c 
 
 c
$c
c  
c c  
c
c
c  c
c
$c 
 c

c
c c
 cc
c ccc$ c   c c
c cc c
ccccccccc$ccccccc c c   c cc c" #c
$c cc c   c c  cc c
 c
c ccc$ c c c c c  
c cc c
c ccc$cc c cc ccc
c
$c  c  c
c $ c ( c c  c  
c
c c !c c cc cc c
c
c $c  c  c
c   c
c c !c c c  
 c cc c
c c !c c c
 ccc c
c c !c c cPc cc c
c c !c  c cc ccc
c c !  c c cPc c  c c c c
c
$c( c c  c
c c c
 
 c 
c
c $ c !c cc  cc c
c

c c
$ c ( c  c c
 cc  c
 cc
  c  c
c $ c    c c ccccc
c
c 
 
 c c
 c 


 cc
 c c c


c
c
c c 


 c 
 
 c
c c c 

c c
 c  c c
 c c c c c
 c   c  
c 
c
c c c c  c 
c
c c c c $c 
 c c   c ccc
c c c c $c c 
 c c c
 
 c 
 c cc c
c c c c $c c c)
c cc c
c
c c c  c c
 c 


 c 
 cc
 c  c c
c c c c $c  c c

c cc c
c c c c $cc c)
c cccc
c
c c 
 
 c c


c
c  c
c 


 c
c c c   c c 
 
 cc 
 c
c c c 


 
c
cc c c c ccccccccc$c cccc
 c c
 c  c  c c ccc
cc c c c ccccccccc$ccccccc c c ccc c
c
c c c c  
 
 c c


c
c  c
c
c
 c 


 c
c c c c ccccccccc$c % c c
c c ccc c
c c c c ccccccccc$cc) c  c c 
c c cccc
c c c ccccc cccccc$c Pc c

c cc c
c
c c c c  c 


 cc   c
cc


c
c c c c c cccccc$c   c c

cccc
c
c c c  
 
 c c
 c


c
c c c c c c

c 
 
 cc 
c c
 c c
cc  c
c c c c  c


c
c c c c c cccccc$c c  c c) c  cc c
c c c c ccccccccc$c

 c  
cc cc  cc c
c c c c ccccccccc$c  c c c   c ccc
c
c  c


c
c c c cccccc$c  
 
 c
c c c c $ c c  c
c c c c $c 
 c c  c  c c 
 
 c
c c c c c !c  c c
c
c c c c c !  c c c
c c c c c !c  c c  c
!c c  c c
 
 c ccc
"#c
c c c c c !  c cP
cPc c c cc c
c
c cccc


c
c cc  c
c cccc


cc  
 c c  
c
c cccc


cc  
 c c  
c
c
c c c cccccc$c  c 
c c cc c

c cc
 c
c cccccccccccc$cP   cc c 
 
 c cc cc c
c
c cccc 
 cP
c
c c ccccccccc$c c  c c c cc cc c
c

c c
c cccc


c c
 c
c cccc  cc
c cccccccccccc$c 
 c c  c  c
c c ccccccccc$c 
 
 cc  c c
 cc  c
c c ccccccccc$c 

c c c 
 
 cc  c
c c ccccccccc$c
 c
c


c c  c
c c c cccccc$ c  c
c c c !c  c cc c   c ccc
c c c c c !c   c cc cc c
c c c c c !c  c c
 cc cc c
c c c c c    
   
c
c ccc 
c
c
c ccc cc
c c c cccccc$c  
c c
c cc c
c c ccccccccc$c c cc cc c
c ccc c  
cc
c c ccccccccc$c  
c c
c cc c
c ccc  
 cc
c c ccccccccc$c )  c   c  c c

c c  c  c c
c
c ccc  cc
c c c cccccc$cc c  c c
 
 c  ccc  c
c c ccccccccc$c  c  c cc c  cccc
c ccc

 cc
c c ccccccccc$c  c)  cc c c ccc
c ccc
  
cc  cc
c c c cccccc$c  c
 c c
  
c.c
 c  cc c
c c ccccccccc$c c c

cc c

c cc c
c c ccccccccc$c 
 cc c  c cc c
c ccc

 cc
c c ccccccccc$c   c c  c cc c
c c ccccccccc$c c c  c ccc
c ccc c c cc
c c ccccccccc$c 
c c  c cc c
c ccc


c c c
c c ccccccccc$c  c c
c  cc c
c ccc) c  c  c
c c ccccccccc$c
 c cc cc c
c  ccc


c c 
 ccc
c c ccccccccc$c c c 

c


c c  c cc c
c ccc 
 cc
c c ccccccccc$c 
c cc c ccc
c  ccc
 
 cc
c c ccccccccc$c c c c ccc
ccccc$c c c

c cc c" #c
c
c
c

 
cc  
 
c c
 
  c c


c
c

 
c c


c
c
c P  c  
 c 
 
 c
c
c

c c ccc c
c  c cccc c
c 

c cccc c
c  c ccccc
c

c c
c 
 
 c 
 c
c
c   
 c
c   c


c
c c !c   c  c 
c  
 c c c 
 
c
c c c  
c 
c cc c
ccc


c 
c
c  cc  
 c
c c !c 
c c
cccc
ccc
 c
c c
 cc  c
c c !ccc c 
c c c
ccc 
 c


c
c c !c 
c cc c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
 c c

c c
c
c

 c c c cc c

c c
  c c
 c c
Ê
  c
c


ccc

c

Ê      ! c


 !  cc
c
Ê  " ##$%&' $&#$($$c 
! 
c

p
  
Ê  

  !Ê   
 
"  
 
#
p $ 


 c

 
)c

ccc 
c c  c
 c  c c
 c 
c c
c
 c cc c
 
 c c c  c
c c c  


 cc  c
 c 
c
 c
 cc  
c c
c  c
c ! c
c 
 c
cc
 c
 c c c
 c   
c
 c  c
c  
c cc cc 
c 
 c c
 c
 
c c cc  cc
c 
 c  c  c
 c 
c c c
   
c
 c  c
c  
c cc c  c  c  c
c
 c c c
c c 
 c c
 c 
c c cc  c
 cc c
c   c
 cc 
c 
 c c
 c   c 
c

c c    
cc
c
 
c

   c c
 c
c c
 c
 c c  cc
 c c
 c c 
 c cc

 c  c 
 c 

c c

 cc
 c  c 
c  c) cc c
 ccc
 c  
 cc c   c  c cc c

c  c
 c
 
 cc c c
c 
cc
 c c c  
c c cccc
 c  
 c
c  c
 c  c
 c c c 
 c  cc 
 c
 ccc
 c c

 c  
 cc
   ccc  
 c c
 c 


 c c
 c cc
 c   c
 c c cc
 c

( c c c 
cc  
ccc cc  c
 c  
 cc
 c
  
c cc c  cc
 c c c  
c c c cc c c
 
c cc  
c  cc

c c c c c 
c
 c c  
c c
 c

c

c  c   c 
cc
 c c cc/ c c(  
c ccc
c

c
c
 c c cc c  cc
 c ccc
 c c c c
c c  
c
 c 


 c( cc c   c !  c
cc  cc


 c c
 c c 
 c c
 c c
c  c
c c c
  c
 
 c cc 
 cc  c
 c  
 c c  c
c c
 c c c c
 c

 c
c
 c c c
 c 
cP  c c  c c 
c  
c c
c
  c c  cc
 c c c  
c c c cc
c   c   c c
  c   c 
 c
c
c  
 c  c 
c  c
c c
 c cc  cc 
c
 c 
cP  c    c
c c  c
 c
 
 
c  cc
 c  c)  c c)  cc c cc  c  c
c
 c c

 c   c c   c c c   c 


 c c
 cc c c 


 c


c c  c  c c
 c   c 
ccc  c c  c 
cc
 c  c c c   c 
c
 c c
 c c c 
c c c   c


c
c c
 c
 c c
 c  c  cc   c c

c c
  
 cc c c  c cc! %

 

  
 
c
c
 c  cc  c
  c
 c c 
 c c

 c   c 
cc   cc c  
 c c
c
 c  c
c c 
c 
 c 
c
 c  c

c  c

c 
 cc c
 c c 


 c  c c cc
 c
  
c c

c c  c c  
c  c
 c  
c c  c
c c
 c
 c   c
 c  
 c
  c c
 cP  
ccc   c c
 c c

 c c c


 c 
  cc  cc
ccc   c 
c c
 c
 


 c   
c c
c
 c 
cP  c   c  cc
c
  c   c
 c  cc
 c  
c c  c  
c  c
c c
 c c
c
c 

c
 c cc

c  c
c 
c c
c
  cc  c
 c
  
 c c  c
c c
 c c c c  c( c
c 
 c c c  c

c c c


c c c c  c   c c c c  c c
 c  c c
 c
 cc c   cc  
c  c
 c  c
c  
c ccc
   c  c
c
c c 
 c cc  
 c  c c
 c 


 c c
 cc

 c c c
c

 c  c   c 
ccc  c

c
 c 


 c

  c 
 c c
 ccc c

c c  c c  
c  c  
c c
  c
c c
 c c   c
 c  
 c
  ccc
 c c c c
   c 
c c
 c 


 c c  c
 c 
 ccc 
 c c
  c
c c c c

c0 c c  c   c c c c  c c
 c
  c$
 c cc c  cc c   cc  
c  c
 c
  c
0cc  c
c  c

c  
c cc  c
cc
cc
 c c
c  
 cc
 c 
 c  c c
c c
 c 
 c  c  c

 c  
 c c  c
c c
 c c cc c c  cc c  c
cc
   c cc c
c
 c   c 
cc cc  c
  c c

 c
c 
 c cc c
c cc
c
 c  
c c c
 
 c c  c

 c c 
c c 


 c  
c
 c 
 c 
 
cc c
 c
  c
c cc 
cc  c
 
 c 
 
cc c
c
 c  
 c c
 c
c c
 c  c ccc
c
 c


 cc
 c ccc
  c    c
c
 c c 
 
cc
c
 
c
c

cc c
 c
c 
c
c
 c 


 c  c
 c 
cc
 c
 cccc
 


 c c
c
cc c
c

cc 
c
 c c
c  c ccc

c c c
 c 
 
c 
 c c
 c 


 cc  c
c  c
 c
  ccc
  
c
 c
 c
 c   c c
  cc
 c
 ccc c
c c ccc
c c
  c cc  


 c

 cc

c
 cccc c 
 cc
 c 
 cc c

c
c c 

c
 c  c
c
c
 c 
c c
 c 


 c$ c c
  c
ccc(cc  c c

( c
cc c

cc


c
  c
 c
 
c 
cc
 c 
 c c
 c
 


 c
cc
 c
c c
 c 
c
c  c
 c
c  


 c   c

 c
cc  c
c

c  
c
 c 
c c  c c
c c
 c
 
c
c
c
 c 


 cc
 c  
cc c
 c

cc 
 c
c  ccc c 
 ccc  cc


ccc  
 c
c
 c  
cc
 c 
c 
c c  cc
   c c 
c
c
 c
 


 c c
 c  c c c
c
 c 
 
 c c
 c 


 c
 c
 c 
 cc
c
 c 


 
c cc


ccc c

c
 c 
c
c
c  c
 c   c c 
 c  c
 c  
 c

c
 c
c c

c c

 c c 
c  cc c c
 c  
c c
 c c
 c$ c
c c ! c

 c
 c c 
c c 


 c  
c c
 c 
c 

c

 cc
 
c
c
 c  c c
 c

c c 


 cccc
   c  
c  c
 c

 c c
 ccc
c c
 c 
 c
 c c c
c 
 c
c
 c  c c
 c  cc

c 


 c$ c
c c c

 c 
 c 
cc  
cc 
 c c  c
cc c  c c

c

c
 c c cc c  cc
cc   c c  
 c ccc c
 c c


 c c 
 
c c
 c c c
 c c0cc
c c
 c c
 c 
  cc  0c cc 
 c c
 cc c
 c
 


 c c
c
 c c c c  c c
c c

c
 c
 


 c c c
c
  c c
 c 
 ccc  c c
 c !  cc

 c  cc 
 c c
 c  c

 c  cc   c    c

c
 c 
 c
cc c 
 c
c
c
c 
 c c
c
 ccc  c
c c cc
c c
c cc
 
c
c
 c 
cc 
 c 
 c cc cc  ccc


cc
c
   c c
c cc  c    c
  c
 c 
 c c c
 cc c 
 cc cc
c$ cc c c c  c

 c 
 c
c  ccccc  
cc 


 c  c

c
c cc
c 
cc

c
  cc
 c 
c% 
     
%
   
    
 
     %  c$ cc c c
c  c

( c c  cc



c
 c 
 c  c c c c  
cc c
 c
c
c
 c  c
c cc 
cc
c
c
c

c
 c cc  c
 c
c c

c
 c


 c c
 ccc
 c 


 ccc
c
c
 c  c c
 c
 
 c 
 
c c
 c 
 c c  c
ccc c c
cc  c
 
 c c
 c 


 c c   c
c
 c 
c cc
c c 
c
c
 c c


 cc c
ccc  c
c c   c  c   cc


cc c   cc 
c  c c cc 
cc c 
c


 c cc c c cc c


 c c
 cc c
 c 


 c c
 c   c c c  c cc   
cc  
c


 c c
 cc c c

 c 


 c c
 c 
 c 
 
c 
c c c 
 c c c  c
  c c  c  
 c c
 c  
c c c c 


 c 
c c
  
c
  c
  c c
 c 
 c c  c

 c c c
 c 


 c 
c c
 c c  c
 c
c c
  c c
  c

c
 c  
 c c  c
c cc ccc
cc  
c
 c

  c c
 c c 
c  c
 c!  c
ccc
c
 c c c
 c c c
 
 c
  
c
 c   c c
c c c 
cc cc

c
 c c c
c   c   cc c cc c  c
c cc
c  cc 
 cc

c   cc   c c cc  c


c cc c)c c  c ccc
   c ccc
 c 
c cc
c  c  cc
 c  c c  c c c

c  c  c
 c 
c

cc cc c   cc
 c 
c cc  c
c

c  c
 c  
c 
c c
 c
 c  c
c
c
 c  c  c
 c c
 
c c
 c  c
c   c
cc cc 
cc  cc  c

c  c 
 c   c
c
 c  c c ! c c
 c cc
 c
  
c  cc c   c
c c  cc c
 c c
c   c
c cc c   c
 c  c
cc  
c
   c  c  c

cc
c c

 cc 
c
c c
 c
 c c c 
 c
 cc 
c 
 c c
 c 
c c
 cc cc  c
c cc c

cc
c c c c   c cc 
c
cc  c  c1c 

cc c c 
cc
 c  
c c
 c 
c

c c
  
c c
 c  
c c
c  c cc cc c c  c c
  c c
  c$ 
c cc c  cc 
cc 
 c c
c c
 c
  ccc
c c
cccc
 c  c
c  
c c
 c  
c
cc c c c 
c c c 
 c
 /c ccc c  c  c
c
 
c  c  
c c
 c  c
c
c c   cc  c  c c c
 c
 c   c c  cc
c c   c cc c c c c
   c
c cc
c
c
  c c

c  c  cc cc
 c
   c ccc  c cc   c c c

 c
 c  cc
 c  c)  cc  
 c
c)  cc c cc
  c  c
c c c
c c c

c  c c
 cc  c c
 c

 
c c
 ccc
 c c c 
c 
c

c  c c
 c   c
 
c c
c  c c  
 cc

cc
 c
c c

cc c c
 c
 
 c
 c c c  c
c c
 c c
c
c c

cc
c  
 c


c
 c  
 cc
c  c c
 c  c c
 c   c 
c  c
c c cc
c  c c 
 c c
 c 
c c cc  c c  c 
c  c
 
 c c 
c
c
 c 


 c  c c
 c  
c c
 c  c
 c
 
cP  c
 c  c c
 c  c c
 
 cc  c  c c
 c
 c c c c   c c
 c c   c  cc  c c
 c
 
c c 
c 
 c  c
c
 c  c cc
  c c

c c
 c
   c 
c 
 cc 
  c 
c   c c  c
c c
 c c
 c  c
 c  
 c c c 
 c c
 c 
c c c
c c
  c c
c
 c c c  cc
c c 
 c c
 c  c  c
  c c
 c  
 cc
 c 


 cc

c c
 c
c

c  c
   c 
cc
c 
cc
c   c
 c    c c
 c  c
c  c c

c)c  c


c c
 c
 c 
c  c  
c  c  c  c
c c
c c

 c  
 cc
c c
 c
c  
c c  c
cc  c c
 c  ccc c 
 cc 
c c
 c
c

c   c 
cc
 c
 c c
c cP  c$ cccc

 c c   c c
 c 
 c
c
 cc
c
c  
c
 c
 c
c c
 c  cc  
c c
  c
c


c cc 

c c
c

 c cc
c 
c

c    c c
 cc  
ccc  
c

c
 c
 c c
 c 
 c

 cc  c c c
 c
 


 cc
c
 c

 c c 
 c

c  
c
c  cc
c
 c  c c
 c cc
 cc c c
c   c
cc
c c 
 c

ccc 
c
c
ccc

 c  cc
 c c
 
cc
 c
 c
c 

  c
cc c
c
c
cc
 c c cc
c
  c

) ccc
 c
c  c c c  cc
 c c  c
c
 
 c   c c
 c 
c c
  c c 
 c c
 c  c c c
 c
   cc cccc 
cc  c 
 c
 c
 c  
 c  c c

 c  c
cc cc c cc c  ccc c c   
c
 c
 
c c
 c  c
c c  c  c  c
c c
 c c c c  c
  c c
c c
 c 


 c  
 c c
c c c c 

c
c c c
c
  c
  c
c c
c 
c c c
 c
 c   cc
 c  
 c


c 
c
 c 
 
c c
 c 


 c  
 cc
 c c c c 
  
c
 c  c   c 
c  c0

c
 c$ 
 c c
 c 


 c
  c
 c    c c
 c  cc cc 
c 
 c
c c  c

c
 c  c  c
c
 c c

( cc c  c  c  c c c


c 
 cc c  
 c  c  
c
c  c
c cc ccc   cc
cc  c

 c
cc  c  cc
   c c
 c  
cc
c c cc  
c
c c c c
 
c
c

c c
   cc   cc    c c c
 
cc
 c( c c  c
c
 c
  c c
 c   c 
c
c  
 c
c
 cc 
  c c 
c 
 c
   c c
 c
c  cc
c)c  c  cc c
c
 cc

c c    c
 cc
c   c  c   c 
c
c 
cc
  c
c c
c  c 
c
cc c c
 c ! c cc

c cc
 c   c
c
 c
c 
c c

c c c
c c c   c

c
 c
 c cc
ccc 
 c
c   c
 c  
c c  
 c c c
cc

 c
c
 c 
 c c
 c  c

c
 c  
 cc c  c  
c  c c
 
  c  c   cc   c c
 c  c c
 c   c
 cc c c

c c
 c  c
c c
cc
c
 c c
 c 
c c
 c  c
c cc c
 c c 

cc   cc

  c  
 cc
 c

c
  cc
c   c c  
cc
cc cc
c
c c c c  c c c
 
c( cc
 c
 c c  
c
c 
c c
 c
c
 c  c cc c  c c
 c 
cc)  c c
   

 c  
cc c c
  c   cc c c
 c  c c  
c  c
 
c c
 c

 cc
 c  c c
 c 
 cc cc
 c
 c
 c   c c c c c c c

 
c c c

c
c
c  c
 c
  c 
c c 

c cc
c c c  c c
c c
 c   c c
 c cc c 
cc   ccc c

 
c c
 c  c
 c 
 c 
cc  
 c

cc
c
c  
 c
  c c
cc c
 c c  c
c  
 c  c

cc c c  
c  c
 c c
 cc cc  
c

  c c  c    c c  
 c   c c c
 c  c  c

   c$
cc cc" #c)  c c  
c c c  
c  c
 c
  
c c
 c c
 c  c c
 
c
 c   c
   c$ c c$c"#c
 c

c  c  cc  c c  c
c cc  
c c  c   c
 c c  c cc
 c c  c
 cc c
 c
c

c
 c c

 c
c

c
c

 c c  
c  c

 c$  c
c c c
 c   c c  cc 
c c c
 c c c c  cc
 c c
  c c
 c
c

c  c  c c 
c c c   c   c
c

 c
 c c c
c c  c c  
c  c  c
c$  c
c c
 c  c  
c c cc  c c  cc 
c c c
 c c  c
c
 c c 
c
c*  c c c  
c  c

 c$  c
c c cc

 c c c  c c c  cc c
 
cc
 c c 
  c c
 


 c  c c


c c  
c  cc  c 
 c c c
 c
cc  c c
 c c c  cc c c
 c c
c
c c
  
 c
 c  c c
 c 


 c  c
c cc   c
c  
c
c  c  c c
 c c
 c c cc
c
c   c
 c  
 c

   c c
 c    c c
 c  c

c   c c 



c
 c 
 cc cc
 c c c

   #

c
c

 c 
c

c
 c  
 c c  c
c c
 c c cc c  ccc
 c

  cc c  
c
 c 


 c( c 
 c c

c
 c


 cc

 c c
 c 


 cc c


cc
c
 c   c  cc

 c c
 c c 
 
cc

cc 
ccc
 c 
 c c
c
  c  c
  c

c
c c

cc cc c

c
c c
c  
cc
 


 c 
 c
   c
c
 cc c
 c 
cc
 c
c c
c


cc


c  c c
 c


 c 
cc  ccc


c
 c 
c
cc  c


 c  c ccc c c
 c 
c 
c c
 c
c

c
 c  c c
 c   c  
 c
 c  c  c  cc   c  c

c c    
cc
c 
c

% 
& ' 

 %  c  c

c c
c

Ê$*&$*++c

, Ê  


  c

(

c  c c  c c
 c 
 cc c c
c 
cc
 c c c
  
c c cPcc c! cc  c c
 c
cccc

c cc  c 
c
P  ccc  c
c

c

cc  cc
 c  c c
 c 
c
c
 c 
c

c
 
 c c  c
c c cc c cc
c  c

c
c c
 c c cc c
 cc c   c0
c
c cc
 c cc  
 c  c c
 c
 


 c c c0c 


cc  c c
 c  cc 
 c c
 c
 cc
c  ccc c
 c  c

cc 
 cc cc c
c cc

  c c
 c  
c c   c
 c 
 c c  c

Ê

  cc 
c

c 
c c
 c c  c

cc
 c 
c  c cc 
 c
cc
  
c c ccccccc   c
cc c
c
 c 
cc
 c

c c 
 c c  c

c
c c c c
 c
cc  c c
 c
 


 c

c
 cc 
c!c  cc 
 cc
c
c
c
c
c
c

P   

c

  cc


 c
P 
PP !"#$
 P 
 c

cc

PJ.:c

›c  c  c c c   cc c c  cc c 
c
 cccc   c cc !cc c c"c #c$c
 c  cc  %c !
c
& ccc c  c

c
 
c c  cc !c c  c  %c c  ccc
c 
cc
 c c c #c

  c
c c c  c c cccc'(c   cc

c )c 
cc
!c 
c !c'*(c  c c c cc 
c
' (c  c c ! cc c   cc c !c c   
c c
  cc c   c

The Factsc

c c
  c  c c cc c cc  c c  c 
c
c+ !  c,  c
c+c c   c

cc$ c   c  c-
.*-/c-. -/c-.-/c-."-/c-.0c 
c-.1c
cc c2 cc c
 c/ cc,  c
c+ c+ 
c  c c  %c/!c››c
3
 c c c  c  c c  
c c   c  cc
 
c  cc c cc c

ccc c c

c c
 
c !c

ccc c 
c !cc  c'"" *(c
 !c c 
cc cccc   c c !
c   c
  %c  cc c  c
c c
  c

2c/!c1c.c c
 
c  c c cc 
c c  cc
 c  cc c  cc c c  c
 cc c   
c
   c2c/!c*c.c c 
c
 
c  %c 
c c
  c c cc  cc c !c c c c ! c c 
c
! c 
 c
c c 
ccc c 
c c2c   cc
.c c  cc/c'+ (c !c c) c  c c 
cc
   &/ccc 
c c c
cc ccc   c1c.c
c  c1cc c c c   cc c c  c
!cc4  c
c 
c c c c cc+ !  c,  c
c+ c›c c c 
cc c
   c1c 
c*c.c 
c  c"c'c cc cÚhilippine Daily
Inquirerc 
c c   c1c 
c*c.c cc cLake Lanao Times c$ c
c c c

cc c
c c.5..c/ 4 cc  c**cc c c
2 cc c c$  cc4  c c

2c  ccc  c


c
  cccc c c cc
cc  cc ccc  c)c 
6c  c  !c

 c2c  c*cccc
c c  c  !c
(
)!c 
cc
!cc 
c
!c c c cc c
) c   c

$ c c c c  c


c c

cc c cc,  c
c+c
c c c

 c/c   cc c c


  c
c 
c ! 
cc
 c7 ! cc
cc c c c5 .c  cc c  c

 cc

/c*5 .c 
c 5..c  cc c  c
c 
c c! c 
c
 c  c   c  
c ! c ccc%c
  !c
 c

7 
c
c c cc8  ccccc  c
c
c  cc/ c*c c7 )
c c
cc2 c*"c c
$   ccc!  c
 c cc c c 
c c  cc
c c
   c  
c

/ c c c  c cc  cc c 


ccc   c cc c
 !c  c c  c c 
c  5c

'(c c/c  c*.cc   c   cc   c c 0c


 
c c  c c c-c c c c
cc c
!  cc c7  cc c  c 9
cc
 9 c c
  c
c
  c c 
c c
cc cc c  )+ c c
  c  
ccc c  cc ccc  c
 c cc c
 c cc 
c  c c 
!c !c c  c
c 
c

cc ccc
  c
!c:c   c c cc c
c

 c 
c !  :c

c c
'*(c+ c*cc7  c/c  c "cc9c  cc ccc  
c
  c:c c  c
 c cc ! c 
c cc c
7  cc c  cc c c 
c  :cc
cc
    c  ccc

  c

' (c7  c/c  c0 "cc9c  cc+   c.c1c 


c c
  cc c   c$c& c c+ c;   5c

! c
 
c c c  c c c c  cc c  c
!c c
  cc cc c cc c c
cc
 c

  c 
c c   c$ c  c   cc /227c c
 

cc ccc c  cc
 9 c c
  cc

 c!   cc c 
c c
cc cc c
!   c 
c c c c c c c cc c cc c
 
c  c/
c !c c
 
cc !  c c c c-c c
 cc c  cc
!c cc ccc  c  c
c c c  c   ccc  cc  c  c c! 
c
 cc c  cc ccc  c
 c cc 
c c
 ! cc c!  c 
cc    c$c+ c cc7/c0 "c

cc
  cc  cc5c

+  c c„on-profit Character of the Corporation Exemption from All


Taxes, Duties, Fees, Imposts and Other Charges by Government
and Governmental Instrumentalities c<c$ c c c c
-c 
c c
 c cc ccc  c  c
c c c  c   ccc  cc   c$c
  c c cc cc

 c 
c ! c 
cc
   c 
c   c   cc c c  
cc
+ c2 ccc/c c cc  c
 
c  5c

' (c8c c  cc c  c


 c cc ! c
c 
c  c cc ccc
  c
!cc
cc c c c c c 
c
 cc c7  cc c
  cc c c  c 
c c!  c
!  c 
c   c

'(c8c c c  c  c  c 


c c  cc c 
c
c c  c;  cc c c  c 
c
 c!  c !  c 
c   c

'(c8c cc
 c  !c  c 
c
 
c c
 c 
c  ! c cccc !c!
c &
ccc
  %c 
c) c 
c

'
(c8c c  c
 c cc 
c c c ! c

cc c7  cc c  cc c c
  c 
c c!  c !  c 
c   c
c c  c
c
cc c cc c!   c
 c = c 
c cc c  c'  c
 
( c

'(c2c  c**c1c 
 c  c  c .c  

c+ c c
  ! c' (c 
c'
(cc7/c0 "cc !c !c c c  cc
  cc  c
 c cc 
c c ! c
c:
  cc

  :cc c  c
c
cc  ccc   c

'"(c2c cc1c 
 c  c  c0c c9c c c7 c c
$ c
c c  
cc  c+ c.' (c  c
5c

+  c. cExemptions from Real Úroperty Tax c<c$ c  c c c c 5c

' (c7 c c


cc c7  cc c  cc ccc  c

c 
c c!  -
c cc  ccc  c c c c

c c
'0(c2c/!c*c1"c 
 c  c  c110c c ! 
c !c c
8 c›  c7  c> 
c'8›7>( c/!c c!c c> 
c c 9
c
c 5c

+  c* c/c8 c›  c7  c> 


cc  c 
cc c cc

 !c c
 c 
c c  c
c c

c
 c
 9
cc 

cc c c
cc c !c 5c

  c<c+   cc8  c


4  c<c+   cc›
c
<c c;   cc c  c
?c 
c   c/c
<c cc›  c7   c
<c ccc

$ c> 
c c  
cc c 
cc c  c 
cc cc
  cc c
 
c c c c
  c
 c
  cc cc c   cc cc c  -
c c

 cc c  c! c  c c! 
cc c c$c  c
c)  c c> 
c c & c c   cc c   c!  c
! cc  c$ c> 
c c c c ccc  c c c cc c
+   cc8  c

'1(c+ c.cc 
 c  c  c c

c4 c*1c10c c  

c
 c   
ccc+ c cc7/c0 "cc ! !c c c c
 c  cc c!   c  cc: ccc  c
 :c  c

c c  ! c 9!c 
cc+ c c
c c 5c

+  c c„on-profit Character of the CorporationcExemption from All Taxes, Duties,


Fees, Imposts and Other Charges by the Government and Government
Instrumentalities c<c$ c c c c-c 
c c
 c cc
 ccc  c  c c c c  c   ccc  cc
  cTo enable the Corporation to pay its indebtedness and obligations and in
furtherance and effective implementation of the policy enunciated in Section One of
this Act, the Corporation, including its subsidiaries, is hereby declared exempt from
the payment of all forms of taxes, duties, fees, imposts as well as costs and service
fees including filing fees, appeal bonds, supersedeas bonds, in any court or
administrative proceedings c'? c 
( c

c2c ccc 
 c  c  c ccc+ c*c
 c c c
 c ! c! 
cc!  -
cc
c  c
3  c+ c*c  c

5c

$ c 
cc c  c 
6c c4 cc8  cc c
  
cc c8 c›  c7  c> 
c'8›7>(c c c cc  c
 
cc  c  cc c c  c
 cc+ cc c c c

'(c cc+  c*ccc cc8  c1c"c c8›7>c


c7  c
 c.-" !c  %c c 
c
c  c ! c )
ccc

c/c*.c c  

ceffective from June 11, 1984 up to June 30, 1985 c/
c
 &  c8›7>c7  c  c-0c  

c c 
c c 
c
c  c
 ! cc   from July 1, 1985 onwards indefinitely c

'.(c2c   c1c0c 
c =c/&c ! 
c?  c
2
c  c c   c4 c.c1c c ! c
 !c c c 
c
c
  cc!  c 
c  c   c>c+ c*c  c!  c8›7>c c
cc:  c c 
6c
c  c
 c  
 :c

'(c2c c*c1c c8›7>c


c7  c  c1-1c c ! c !c
  %c c 
c
c  c ! ceffective as of March 10, 1987c' c
 c
 cc? 2 c ( c

c c
'*(c8 cc c4  
c

c2 c"c1c

 
cc c  c
8›7>c c/!c?  c+   c  c4   !c cconfirmedc 
c
approvedcc cc c 
c8›7>c7  c  c1-1 c

The Issuesc

$ c c ccc cc  ccc 


c c 
c c
 c c 
c 
c  c  c c c  cc c 
c cc
cc   c cc ! c 
c   c c c c c c) c
  cc  cc  c cc !
c
  cc c  cc
c   c

$ c  cc c c  cc  ccc  c c 
cc
)cc c 
c
c  c ! c 
!cc  cc  cc
 c c   c

  %cc ccc cc c  c c   c



ccc
 c 
c
c  c ! c! 
c
c/c*.c c  

c 
c7/c
0 "c c  

c 
cc !c   c
 c  c)c c&9 c
 
cc c cc c

cc  cc -  c  c3  c  c

cc
  c   cc c  c 
c   c c) c  c  c! c

cc 
c
c c  c

2c c c 


c 
%ccc c c  %c  cc
  cc c  c
c c
 cc 9
cc ccc c 
c

c  c c 
c 
cc c8›7>c7  c   
ccc c
  
cc?  c+  c4   !c c  c 
!c  c   cc
 c  cc c 
c ccccc   c c c7 !cc
„ational Úower Corporation vs cÚrovince of Albayc%c c cc 
cc
 !c c 
c 
c c
c+  c*ccc110c' ! 
c
/!c*c1"(cc 
c c8›7>c 
cc  cc+  c*ccc c c
8›7>cc! cc! 
c c c  
c c 
cc

cc cc
 c  cc 9 c !c cc
c cc c c
!  c c
 c  c
cc 
c  c  cc  c   c
c  c7 
c ! c c8›7>c7  c  c.-"c 
c-0c  c
c
c  cc c 
c c c
 c
! cc !c  c$c
 c  c c
  c 
c   c c 
c
c 
c! c c  c
  c?2c c c cc = ccc+ c*c c8›7>ccinter aliac
  c c 
6c
c  c
 c
c+ cc  cc  c

c 
ccc c 
c   c7 
c c   c c 
c8›7>c  c
c 
c 
c   c c   cc c  c  c c c c! c
  c'viz c c/!c4 cc8  c/ 
cc
c7
c c 
c c
4 cc8  c  c? / c@  c   (c  =!c c c8›7>cc
c c - c
c 
c 
c   cc    c 
c
c c  c
 &
c<c c  
c 
c c  c<cc
cc c
c 
c
 
cc c! c c !cc c
cc c8›7>c 
c c cc
  c

The Court's Rulingc

Úreliminary Issue5 Valid Restoration of Tax Exemptionsc

/ !c+ cccc c


 c c c  c   c 
!c
 cc  c+ c*c  c =
c 
c  
c c 
c

6c c4 cc8  cc  c c  cc
 !c   c›c
cc
   c c  %c c  c3 c c7
c ccc c
   c c/!c4 cc8  c 
c c/!c  cc8›7>c!
c

c c
8›7>c7  c  c.-"cc c
c   c cc ccc c
 ! c
 ccc c c c .c" c2c c c 
cc cc
8›7>c7  c  c-0c3 c@  fully restoredc c c  c cc cc
"cc cc c
 c 
c3 c c!
c c  ccc
 c
   c c4 cc8  c 
c c  cc c8›7> c$ c  c
  c

c 5c

* c$ c c c c!  c cc  cc c c c cc 
c

c  c
ccc c c c cc ccc+ c.c' (cc c
7 c c$ c
c c  

c

A c?2c c ! c


 c c c  cc  c!cc+ cc c
 5c

+  c c$ ccc c!   cc  c cc c c 


!c
c c 
c
c  c! 
cc!  c 
c  c  c  c  c

 c  5c

ccc

(c c 
cc c 
cc c  
cc c8 c›  c
7  c> 
c

   cc c 


5c

+  c* c$ c8 c›  c7  c> 


c 
c
cc110c c  

cc
  c =
c5c

' (crestore tax and/or duty exemptions withdrawn hereunder in whole or in partc

'(c  c c c 


c  ! cc c 
6c
c  c c c c 
c

'(c c
cc c  cc c 
6c
c  c

'
(c  c c
 cc 
cc  cc c  cc c 
6c
c
 c

' (c  c 
ccc c 
cc  c c  c cc c
! cc
 cc
 !c    cc  cccc cc c
  cc c 
c
c  cc    c  cc  c
 !c
 c cc
!c  c ! c    c 
c c c 
c
cc
 c! c  c 9!cc
 c c   c cc c
  c 
c c   c  cc c c! cc
 c
 cc
  c c cc   !c  c'  c 
(c

 c  c8›7>c7  c  c1-1c 


c c c  c ! c
c c  c   c4 c.c1 c/! c c  c c!
cc c
7
c ccc
 c   c c/!c+   cc8  c 
c c  c
8›7> c$c  c c
c 
c 
cc c/!c?  c
+   c4   !cc c cc c 
 c


!c c  c cc  ccc c c  %c c  cc
 c 
cc& c'-(c
c   c c  
c cc cc
 c  c!c8›7>c   c

7 
c  c! c ! c c c8›7>c!c c  - 
c
  c ! 
cc c c cc  c c  ccc  c
 
c
cc110c 
c?2c c7 
cc c8›7>c   c
 
cc  c c cc  
c  cc c c cc
grantc c  cc c 
!
cc c4 cc8  c 
c c 
 c/c

c  c
cccc

cc  c c  
cc c c
cc c
›
c c 
c c  c

 c  

c<ccc  c c8›7>c
  c<c 
c c 
c<ccc  c c4 cc8  c<c c! c
c c   c8cc c8›7>c7  c  c.-"c 
c-0c  c
c
cccc cAlbayc  cc c c 
c
5c

c c cc c8›7>c
cc  c 
 c  c  c110c
c c  
c
  cc:  
:c c   c>c cc
cc  c 
c 
c
 cc  c    c3  c cc ccc' ! cc
 
 c  c  c (c /227c
c 
cc )c c  c
 !  c&c

+c ! c  cc ! c   cAlbayc c c c



c 
c
 

ccMaceda vs cMacaraig, Jr c'  cccEn Bancc   c

c c8›7>c7  c  c.-"c 
c-0c  c 
5c

c c c8›7>c7  c  c.-"c 


c-0c c c c  c
cc   cc c
 &  cc+ c*c  c  c c  c c8›7>c
c 9 c c
  
c) cc c  cc: c 
cc c  c 
6c
 c4 cc8  :cA c 
c7  c
cc  cc  c c

cc c 
c c  c   c 
cc c4 cc
8  ccc c
 c =
cc  c c  c›c cc c c4 cc
8  cc!
c 
c ! 
c 
c   c

$ c  cc4 c c+  cc c


 !cc c8›7>c
7  c  c.-"c 
c-0cc  c ! 
cc c/!c4 cc
8  c/ 
c
c7
c c 
c4 cc8  c  c? c/ c@  c c  c
c8›7>c   c
c c    c 
cc 
c4 cc8  c c
 &
cc  c cc c   c/c   cc c 
c  c c c c
c c c 
c c!
c 
c  cc c
 c  cc  cc
8›7>c 
c4 cc8  c

4 c c+  c c 9 c    cc c  c„ational Úower Corporation


vs cÚrovince of Albayc  c cc 
c c
c  c  c110c c c
c c8›7>c c c  
c 
c & c c  cc c 
cc
 c 
c$cc 
c  c cc
c c8›7>c7  c  c.-"c 
c-
0cc !c c 
cc c 
c  cc 
c 
c   c c c
 
cc8›7>c'7  c  (c1-1c c
c cc c
 c 
cc c
2 cc c 
cc2 c"c1 c

3  c
c+ c*cc  c  c cc ccc    c
 

cc  

c  c  c110ccc  c

cc cc8›7>c
  c c c 
cc c: 
cc c  c 
6c c4 c
c8  :c$c  cas FIRB Resolutions „os. 10-85 and 1-86 were duly approved
by the Minister of Finance, hence they are valid and effective cTo this extent, this
decision modifies or supersedes the Court's earlier decision in Albay afore-referred
to c'  c 
(c

$  c cc cc& c c  %c c  c


 ccc
 c  c 
c 
cc8›7>c7  c  c.-"c 
c-0 c/! c

 cc?2c c c  c c c 
cc8›7>c7  c  c1-1c
  c cc4 c.c1 c4  cccc c  c  ccMaceda
vs cMacaraig, Jr creaffirmed  c
  ccAlbayc c?2c c !ccc
110c 
c  c c  c c 
c 
c c8›7>c7  c  c1-1c 
c c c
 c 
c  
c  c: 
c 
c   :c($ cccMacedac
c
c<c

$ ccc c c c+   cc cc2c  c11c



c/!c0c11c
 cc c c c c c 
cc c8›7>cc+ c*' (c'(c'(c

c'
(cc?  c2
c  c c c
 c
! cc !  c c

cc   c c3  c c c 
cc c 
c
?  c+   cc c  cc c+   cc8  c

c4 c .c c$ c

c c
?  c+   cc cc c 
c c c cc
c  cc
   c ccc c  c! cc c
  c    c


c 
c  cc c c c?2c c
c c 
c
! cc
!  c cc c8›7>c5cc

$ c  ccc)
 c
  c c
! cc !  c c c
  c c c 
cc-
! c c   c$ c cc c !c
 cc
c  c 
c c  c
cc!   cc cc
  c  !cc c   c$cc
cc c!!c  cc c
!  cc c
  cc c c c
 
!cc   c$ c
!cc c c 
cc  c 
c 
c   c 
c 
c
 c c c !  c c c  
c   cc  
c
+  = c  cc ! c c  c    c$c cc c c
 
cc  c
c
 9!c c !  c cc  c c
   c c  c c  c 
c c cc
c c &
c
 c 
c
 ccc c c  c

$ c    c cc c c c  c ! cc  c


c
 c 
c 
c 
c  
cc 
c8›7>c   c

›c !c c c  c

ccMacedac'c  cc  c
 c
  (c c c 9 c cc c c c cc c9 c c 
cc c

 !cc'cMaceda(c c c c c c   c    cc 


ponencia'sc   cc c -  c cc c  c c c

c  c c c c  ccc c c
c !c   c c
 
cc
cc   c 
cc c c  cc ponenciac 
cc c c
 cc c!  cc c  c›c cc c  c  
cc4 c c
+  ccc
 c c c )c !ccMacedac
c c c 
cc
 cc c c  cc cc c %c c  c c 
c
  c›c c c c  c  cdirectc<c  c<c c c
  c<c 
c c c  cc  c  c c cc c
  cc   cc c c cc cc  c c 
c
! c c -!c  c

7 
c c 
c cc11cc c
cc c c

c   cc c  c
! c 
c c c  c ! c
! 
c c  c
c7/c0 "cc cc c%c!   c  !c  c


c c 5cc

'/( c c
 c   c
c c 
c ! cc c  cc  c
 cc ccc c  c  c  c 
c 
6c

c

!  c

$c ! cc 9  c  cc  c›c c c


cc c !!c
 ! c   c c+ c.ccc c  

c+ c cc7/c
0 "c c  %c  cc !c c c c  c  cc c
!   c  cc ccc  c
 c 
c
  c$c  cc
 cc  c
c  cc c   ccc cc c›c
 c c c  c !
c c  %c -  c c c 9
c
c11ccc11 c> 
ccc c  c
c c:'(  cc
  c  cc 
c 
c cc c

c ccc  c c c
!  cc 

c/c c  c 
cc c 
cc
  c 
c
c c9
! cc c !c cc c) cccc   cc
 
c cc !c c  cc cc 

cc   ccc !  c
c c c !cc  c  c c c ! c  c ccc
c c   cc c c 
c!c 
c !c    cc
 c ! ! c
c c c  c c c   c c) c  cc c
  cc c c cc c   c cc 
c 
  c 
c

c  c
3  c  c cc c
cc 9 c c c 
c 
ccc c   c
c c c c 
c c  c c cc   c c c  cc c
   :c)c

Main Issue5cSubject Úroperties


Exempt From Realty Taxesc

/
cc c8›7>c7  c  c

c  cc c  c! c
 cc c  cc& c  cc) cc c  c+ c.c' (cc
 c7 c c$ c
cc0c c  

c   c  c cc
c  c+ 
c c
5c

Exemptions from Real Úroperty Tax c<c$ c  c c c c 5 c

' (c7 c c


cc c7  cc c  cc ccc  c

c 
c c!  -
c cc  ccc   c


c  c cc  c cc  cc c cc c
  
c  c c   c ccc c c! 
cc
 c
c  cc c   c  cc

ccc

$ c  ccc c ! c
  cc c ! c    c$ c
  cc& c c c cc c  c/!c››c3
 c c
 c cc!    c 
c  c  c c cc c 
c
c4
  c$  c  c!  c  c c
cc  c 
c


c
  c 
c cc c  c 
c =
cc c   cc c
  c cc!!c c c c  cc cc c c ccc
 c c!c c
  cc cc c cc c c
cc

 c
  c 
c c   c›c c c
cc7/c0 "cc
.c 
cc c c  %c-c   c c c  
c
!cc   c 
c c  cc 

cc
 c cc cc
  c  c 
c  c   cc  ccc   cc2c
c  c 
cc   c  cc cc

 c 
c ! c 
c
c   cc c  c cc  c 
c c!   c  c
 c  c c  
cc   c

 &  c c   c 


c cc' c c c c c(c c  cc
  cc 
c  c c 
c
cc !c cc
cc cc
+ c.cc  c c 
c+ c.c' (cc c7 c c$ c
c

/cc) c c  cccc c c !!c !cc cc  c


c c
c c c    cc   for the period from June 14, 1984 to
December 31, 1989 cA c cccc c cc c  c'c (cc
7  c/c  c10.c  (c9c c c, c;  c
ccc
c  %c -  c c c  c 9 c cc c c c c
 c 
cc  cc  c 
ccc0cc!c 
c
c c, c;  c
ccc  ! c'(c+ c" c$ c8cc>9c
›@c% c c!
c c
!c c 
c c  c c !c 
cc c
 c  c%c

„ullity of the Auction Sale


of Úetitioner's Úropertiesc

› c c c c c   c 


c ! c 
c c cc  %c
  c
c c 
cc 
%c  c  c c8›7>c
7  c  c.-"c-0c 
c1-1c  c
c c)
 c
  cc c
 
cc 
c  cipso jurec 
cc   c 
c c
c

c c
$ c   cc c c !c
c  c  c   c
& cc c
  cc 
c  cc 
c c 
c c  c  c &
c c!c
c ccc  c c 
c  c c  c›cc  c  c  c c
  c
& cc  cc  c$cc ccc+ c0"cc c7 c
 c$ c
cc ccc 
c c$  c c
=
cc c c c c 5c

+  c0" c„otice of delinquency in the payment of the real property tax c<cBc c
 c c cc c  c  c !c
& c c ccc
  c c
  c  c cc c cc c
c c c c

+c c c c c


 ccc c c   c
& c 
c c
  c c c c c c c c 
c   c c 
c  c c  cc c cc
c c cc
 cc c c c  c c)
 c c 
c c  c

& c c c c c
c c c c 
c c   c c c c
c c c c c 
c  cc c  c) c cc c!cc c

& c   cc c c ccc  cc
c c
c c
c c cc c
 cc c

/c  c
cc  c c cc c c c cc 
cc
 c c c cc cc  cc !c
&  c$ c
  ccc  c !c  cc  cc c  ccc

& c c cc !c c

8 c+ c1 cc c7 c c$ c


c c  

c  
c  c
c c  cc
   cc c  cc c
c c c  c
+ c1 c
cc 5c

+  c1 c/
   cc cc c c c c  c<c/ c c
 cc c ccc c cc
 c c ccc  c c

  c c c c c cc c  c
& c c cexcept real
property mentioned in subsection (a) of Section forty hereof cc c c c  c

c   c
 c 
c ccc c c c c

$ c c c c ! c  c  !c


c
cccc c
  
cc c 
c! cc,  c
c+c c*5 .c  c 
cc
 
c c  c c 5..c  c%%c  c**ccc cc 
c
cc 
c c c   cafterc c ! cc c cc c7 ! cc

cc c c 
c   cc  c c  cc c c cccc
  c2
  ccc
c  c c )
cc c c 
c
7 ! cc
c'c c!  c cc c  (c!cc
 
!c
c  c ccc  ccc c c  c cc   c
c c
ccc c cc 
%c  c ccc c
cc cc  %c   cc ccc  c)c 
6c
  c  !c
 c$ c 
%c --c  c c 
!c
! c 
c c c) c  ccc c! cc c 
c!c
 c c 9 c 
c
  c  c ! c 
c &  c
cc 
c

!cc c !!c
cc c 
 c c c c c
 c 
c ! cc) c  c  c c  cc c ! c c 
c
   c c 
c
c 
c c c c c c 
c c  cc c

 c c c c cc cc cc 
c c

Re5 Mr Justice Davide's Dissentc

4 c c3 c; c 


c cc!! !ccc !c2c c c
   cMaceda vs cMacaraigc%& 
c  c 9cc c
c
 cc„ational
Úower Corp cvs cAlbay c%'>  c cc   !c4 c c+  %cc

 ccMacedac c7  c.-"c 


c-0c  cc 
c cc c8›7>c

cc
cc c c c  cc  c/c  c ! c  c

c c
  c 
ccccc 
c  c 
cc4 c c? c
/ c;  cc ponenciac  c c cc ! c  c cccc
  c%(c

›c c  c4 c c;  %c1-"-* ponenciac c ! 


c
c c  cc c
c c 
c c:Macedac<c c›› :c$c c c
7  c% 
cc4 c c7
 c/ c c 
c
ccc c
 c   c 
c c8  c>
c7 !
c7 c>  c 
c
4  c ! 
cc cc cc

c c4cc7 
 cc
  c4 
cc 9cc c 
c   c 
c c   c c
 ! 
cc4 c c c/!c cc! c
!cc c 
c
7  c  c c !5c

 c/c ! c  cc c  c c c   c c  !cc c


 c ! c c
  c cc c c c  9 %c c c
!c c c c c
c  c c  cc ccc  c<c

 c 
c
  c+c  c c

c   cc   ccc cc


 c c

 cc
cc*c cc c
 c


 c 
cB+Cc cc c !c  c cc c cc c  cc
c  c

* c›cc c c c


c c! 
c c  c ! ccc
 c 
c

 c  c
cc  c

cA c c c cc


c 
c c  c c c  cc c   ccc
11cc c .c11c c  c  c   c 
cc c4 cc8  c
c  
cc c8›7>c' c7  c  c.-"c 
c-c0(c c
c+  c*ccc c
cc cc c8›7>c7  c  c.-"c 
c-
0c  cc ! c 
c 
c
cc c8›7>c ccc  c$ c8›7>c


cc  c %c c  c cc  crestoredc c

 cB
c/ 
 c  c0c c 
c4 c
c c
 cc c
 cc c c c› c>   !c   c 
cc c  cc c

&  cc c  cc &
c
  c cc c c  c

c c!  c  ! cc c c  cc c c cc!! 
c
c c cc
 cc c  c!  c c c  cc c/&c
  cc
cc c cc 
c 
 !cc !c
c
   c cc c
cB+C* c cc !c
c c c  cc c
cc c>  c  c c  c›c c cc c c
-
 
 !c  ! c4 c c
cc cc c!cc
/ 
 c0c  c  c c  c cc cc c c
c c1 c
c c:c c! !c c c  c c c 
cc c
  cc c )cc c c  cc c>   !c   :c c
cc c cc 
cc c 
c !  c
ccc c 
c
4 c
cc/ 
 c0c  c›c c cc c c 
c 
c
  c
c

" c$  ccc cc: cc


 c :c c8›7>c7  c  c.-
"c 
c-0c  c 
cc c4 cc8  c  c c  c  c
  

ccccc  c c  cc8›7> c$c cc c c
 cc 9!cc c! 
c c  c ! cc cc cc  cc
  cc c c  crestored c$c c  c c !cc c
 c
  c  
!c 
c !c 
c c  c  c c c


cc  c
 c
 c  c

0 cA c?2c c'  cc0(c c


cc 
c/&c c c  !c
c   c 
c !  c  c$c  c cc c
! 
cc c
  cc c c
! !c c cc c8›7>ccc cc?2c cc c

!  cc c !  c›
  c  c cc cc c 
c
/&c-
! !c c  c4  c?2c c c c
! !c c c
  cc c 
c c c 

c ccÚelaez vs cAuditor Generalc'"c+7/c
"0cD0"E( c

c c
1 c/ c c c c 
c 
c
 ccc c c c c
cc c  c
 ! c 
cc ccccc c   c

:4 
c c››:c c 
c   c c 
cc c )cc !c)  c
$c) c'JJ c
 c 
cF (c9cc c cJ c=c  
cc
! c
 c 
cJJ c;G-/&c 
c 
c c)
cJ c+  ccc
! c
  c$ c 9 c !cc cc ! ccc  ! c$cc
   c! c c c  - -c cc c! cMacedac
 c
B

c c 
c c c 
cc c   
c7  c c
c ! c c

cc: cc   c !: c

Epiloguec

F c  cc  !c c ! c ccc  cccc cc


 = c<c c c  cc)
 c c<c c  cc
!c c
   c 
c  ccc   cA ccAlbayc c
c c
) c8›7>c7  cc c c 
c
c c  
c  ccMacedac›c 
c

cc   c!cMacedac›› cA c c  cc    c   cc
! c ! cc  cccc  c c
cc c
 cc c c c
cccc  c 
c  c
 c
  c
c 
c
 cc c  c  c$cc
c caproposcc& c4 c
 c! cc cB
c+  c+  c5c

>c 
c cc c ccstare decisis c$ cc! c+ c*.c'c
 c c
(cc c c  c'suprac c*c  c(c 
c c cc
cc c  c c cc
 c   ccc c
c$ c
 c

cc c  c c 
c  c  c
  c›c
c c
!
cc c c c
c  cA c
cc  c c c  c   cc
Mahnich vs cSouthern S cS cCo c *cB + c0cc,  c
c"0c0c+ c c""c
'(c'suprac c* c  c(c  c c 
c c
c
 
cc c c
cc c c 
c cc c 

c 
c c 
c$ c c
  c cc c
cc c cc
   cA c

c cc c
  c 
c  cc c cc c  c c !cc+ c*.cc c
 c !  cc c  c!c  c c'+ c cB
c+  c *"cB + c
* (c%c

 cc c  c c


cc
c  ccCabagnot vs c
Comelecc%)  c c

c c c 
c5c

c c cA c 9 cc cc 


c ccc c c)
ccc
c 
c
c 
c 
c
cvolte facec c c c
 c c
 %c c 
c
 cc c

/c
 cc c -  c cc c c!cc 
c
cc c
 c ! c   c 
c  cc
 c  cc
c c
cc

 c  c &   c›c


c c
c ccc  c 
c
 c c 
c 
cc 
c 
c 
cc c ! 
ccc
  c c) c c  cc  ccc c/!c››c3
 c
 c c cc  c$c
c c8›7>c  c c

c
c
 c c cc c 
c  c 
!c c
- c c

c c ! c 
cc 
c c/

 c c  c!  c


 c!c  c c

cc c 
c! c c  cc c cc c
! cc !c  c   c$ c - !c &  ccc   c

cc c
 cc ! c  cc
c  c c c  cc
 c  c c cc  cc c 
 cc cc c: c
 cc c  c!c c
  cc cc c c
c c c
cc
 c
  c 
c c   :c

›c c 
c c+  cc c c c
cc cc  !c 
c
 !c c cc 
 ccc
 cc cc !c cc

c c
 c
 c 
c  c!cc
c  ccc
   c 
c    cInterest rei publicae ut finis sit litium c%c

A3?7?827?c c cc  c;7/ $? c


! cc  c 

5c

(c? 2› › ;c 


c 
c c ! cc !c 
c
!cc c
) c  cc  c

(c?,/7› ;c c c c



cc  c**cc 
c c ! c
c c  c c B,,c/ c@2›c

(c27?7› ;c c7 ! cc


cc,  c
c+cc/ ?,c c ! cc
 c c cc cc 
c c 
c

(c32,› ;c c 


c  c 
!c c
 c c c c
  c  cc  %c c 
c c cc c   c 
c c
 c  c9c  c

+2c27?7? c

„arvasa, C.J., Romero, Bellosillo, Melo, Úuno, Kapunan, Francisco, Hermosisima,


Jr. and Torres, Jr., JJ., concur.

Regalado and Mendoza, JJ., concur in the result.

cc

cc

cc


* +
*,!,!-c
cc

$ J.,
 !5c

›c ! c›c c)cc c )c c$ c  cc c c c'"(c c
 cMaceda vs cMacaraigc'1c+7/c11cDE(c  c›c& 
c)
c4 c
 c/  c+  ccc
 c cc c
c c c8›7>c
7  c  c.-"c 
c  c-0c 
c 
c c
 c c  c
 ! cc c  c c c' ( c›c cc c8›7>c
7  c  c1-1c

cc 
c  c c c  c ! cc c c
c  c
 cc?  c2
c  c c

/c   ccMaceda vs cMacaraigcc  c   c!! 


c›c c c
 
c c c
cc„ational Úower Corp cvs cAlbayc'0c+7/ccD.E(c

 !c
c8›7>c7  c  c.-"c 
c-0c cc c  !c c
c  c'+  cJ  ponente,cc c  cc8  cC J c   c
'cC J (c4 -3   c;  =c=c  c
 c>
c c
4

c 
c8  cJJ cc c  c cc c  (cc c
 c
' !c;  c 
c;G-/&cJJ c  cc  c 
c7 !
cJ c9c
c ( cBc c c 
c cc c  c


ccMaceda vs c
Macaraig c+  c';  cJ  ponentecc   c'cC J (c4 -
3   c8  c>
c4

c 
c7 !
cJJ c!(c
cc c
 c 
cc c   c8 c';  =c=c  c+  c 
c 
c

c c
 cJJ (c
 
c$cc cc
ccJustice Sarmiento in „ational
Úower Corporation vs cAlbayc'8  cC J c 
c
 cJ (c9cc cc c
 c 
c   c$c c  c  c  cc   c ! c

›c

›cc
 ccMacedac4 c c+  c
c c c c8›7>c7  c
 c.-"c 
c.0c  c c 
c
c   c c  cc 
c cc c8›7>c

!c c c c c!
c cc/ 
cc
c7
c ccc
 c   c cActing Ministerc'+   (cc8  c 
cActing Chairmanc
c c8›7>c c c  c c!
c cc  c? / c@  ccc c
   c c4 c'+   (cc8  c 
c  cc c8›7> c/c
  c  ccc
 c

+ c*cc  c  c110c
cc c cc 
ccc c
8›7>c5c

+  c* c/c8 c›  c7  c> 


cc  c 
cc c cc

 !c c
 c 
c c  c
c c

c
 c
 9
cc 

cc c c
cc c !c 5c

  c<c+   cc8  c


4  c<c+   cc›
c
 cc c  c?c

c   c/c
 cc›  c7   c
 ccc

$ c> 
c c  
cc c 
cc c  c 
cc cc
  cc c
 
c c c c
  c
 c
  cc cc c   cc cc c  
c c

 cc c  c! c  c c! 
cc c c$c  c
c)  c c> 
c c & c c   cc c   c!  c
! cc  c$ c> 
c c c c ccc  c c c cc c
+   cc8  c

+ cc  c! c c8›7>c c cc


c c 
c c c  c
  c 
c ! c  c c   
c   c›c
5c

+  c c/c 
c c c  c  c 
c ! c 
c &
c  
c

c! 
cc

 c  c c 
c  c 
c c c

 c
cc
  c!!c c  c cc c

cc c8 c
›  c7  c> 
c  c c  
c 
c   c

c  
c
c5c

 c cc

* c›   ccc c

c  c›  c7   c


c ccc  
 ccc c

 c$ c 
cc
c ccc  
 ccc*0c

" c, c$ c


c ccc  
 ccc*0c

0 c+ c c !cc<c

c?c !cH c/c

 c>2›c7 ! 
c
 c

 c4 -  c c

c  c

c+  c cc c   c

8c  ccccc c c8›7>cc c c cboardcc c   c


cc ccc c   ccc c$ c 
ccc
cc
 c  cc c+   cc8  c c c  c c 
c  c
 c c c c !c  

cc c &
c&c'cc 
cc
 c c )cc c  ci e c (c 
c c cc c )cc c
!c c&c
c c   cc c 
cc c 
c c 
c c
c   c/ c c c  cc c8›7>cc 
cc c c
 c<c c+   cc8  c<c 
c c
 c
ccc    cc
ci e c c cacting as suchc cc c  c c c c
 c 
c
Secretary of Financec cc 
c c c  cc c8›7> c  c7  c
 c.-"cc c 
c
cc !c c!
c cc/ 
cc
c7
c cc
c c   c cmerely Actingc4 c'+   (cc8  c 
c
/!c  cc c8›7>c 
cnot by thecboard itself c7  c  c-0c
 
cc  c c
!c cccc cboardc  c !c
!
cc c
 c 
c4 c'+   (cc8  c  c4 c c7
c
c4 c@  c
c  
c  cc  cc c c8›7> c

7  c  c.-"c 
c-0c  c   c  
c cc8›7>%c
c
c+ c*cc  c  c cc
5c

+  c* c$ c 
cc c  c 
6c c4 cc8  cc
  
cc c8 c›  c7  c> 
c 
c
c 
 c
  c  c110cc  c  
cc  c  cc c c  c

 cc+ cc  cc  c  c c cc  ! cc c
   c c 
c
c c c c c

/c  cc c c  c ! c


cc  c c cnewc! cc c
 ! c c c   c
  c  c cc cc c  c cc

  c 
cc  cc csuspendingc c  cc cc   c

$ c c! 
cc c 
cc+ c*cc  c  c cc  c c
 c  c ! cc   cc c  ! c/c c c  c  c c
 c  
c c 
c4 c
c   c !  c c
c c
  
c/ 
 c  c0cc c1 c c  ! ccc+ c1c
/ c@›››cc 
cc

c c 5c

'(c c c! !c c c  c c c 


cc c  cc c
 )cc c c4  cc c>   !c   c

>   c c 


c4 c  
c !  c c c
c c c


c   c c c c c>   !c   c 
c! c  c c
  c

3  c c! cc c4 c'+   (cc8  cc c cc cc
  c c  c
c c  c+ c*cc  c cc c 
c
! c
c c !  c  c›c ! ccc cc c cc4 c c=c
cc
 ccMaceda vs cMacaraig c

$ c  &
c  ! ccc+ c1c/ c@›››cc c1 cc
 

cc  ! ccc+ c*cc/ c@›cc c  cc
 cccc
c ccc 
cc    c›c & c cabsolutec
 )ccALL the Memberscc c>   !c   cc! c c   c$ c
 cc! c c  c !c  c cc c !  %c  c
 cc c c c
! 
c  cc ccc power to taxc c
 c! 
cc
! 
c›cc 
5c

c c
$ c cc  c c c
! 
cc c !  cc c  c  cc c
 c   c c cc   c$c c !  c  c cc
 c
c
c c cc
!  cc  c c cc  c c
c  cc c  c  c c !  c c cc  c'22,?Ic$ c
, cc$  c c››cD*Ec+ c00c c ( c

B
c+ c"c/ cJ›cc c1 cc c  c!  c
c  c! 
c c cc  c cc cc   c 
cc
c  cc) ccc  c c c c

cc  c+ c
"c/ cJcc c  cc ! c c c cc  c
!  ccc cc 
!c c c!
 c 
c  cc
! c c cc c cc c c cc  c
c 
c c c  c c 
c ! c 
cc c  c
!  cc c  c   cc  c+ c*cc c, c
;  c
ccc  c  c  c!  ccc
! c!c
  c
 c 
c c  c  cc
  c
cc c 
c
c c c c
c    c›c c
c c 
c  c

$ c cc  cc  cc c+  c  c 


cc c  c
!  cc cc c c  
cc c  c !  c
 cc ! cc
 cc c 
c
! c c  cc cc c
 c c 
cc
/ cJc+ c"cc c c c c'7BHc› ! c/ c c, c
DEc( c

c c
 c ! c c c4 c'+   (cc8  c c  c
c c
c  c!  ccc! c c c ! c 
c  
cc c  c
!  ccc c  cc   c c cc cc c c cc
! c c   c

››c

›c cccc8›7>c  c1-1cccc  c c c  c


 ! cc c c  c
 cc?  c2
c  c cc 
c
 =c c/&c

c1c   c0 c$ c 
c
  c9c  cc.c
4 c1 c8›7>c7  c  c1-1c c
cc*c c1c
c8›7>%c
c 
cc+ c*cc?2c  c cc   c
c c 5c

+  c* c$ c8 c›  c7  c> 


c 
c
c 
 c  c  c
110c c  

cc  c =
c5c

' (c7  c c 


6c
c  c
 c  
cc ccc c

ccc

$ c+   c4   !c 


cc"c2 c1c8›7>c7  c  c
1-1 c

B
c?2c  c c c8›7>c cc c  c c   c+ c*c
  c
c c
c!  cc c 
!c+ c'(cc
5c

+  c c$ ccc c!   cc  c cc c c 


!c
c c 
c
c  c! 
cc!  c 
c  c  c  c  c

 c  5c

ccc

'(c c 
cc c 
cc c  
cc c8 c
›  c7  c> 
c

c c
$ c c  ! cc+ c*cc  c  c110c   c&
c
c c c


c$ 9 c!  c c8›7>c c c  
c›c c  c
cc c c8›7>c7  c  c1-1c c
c 
c 
cc c
 
c!c/!c?  c+   c4   ! cAc c  c
8›7>c7  c  c1-1c
c c   c   c›cc c 
 c
 cc
c! c  c cc c7  c c c  cc c
 c ! cc c  c c c c! cc c   c

>c c c 


 c  c 
#c

›c   cc cc c c/c c c8›7>c7  c  c1-1c c 
c
 cc! c
c c1cc c 
c 
c 
cc  c
›c c 
cc cc4
cc c1c+  c"c/ c@›c(c
 !c cc c
c ccc c4  cc! c'+  c
c/ cJ@›››( c2 c! c c
c  c 
c 
c c  c
 ! c cc+ c*c'(c/ c@›cc c c›c
c  c
 c  c
  cc c 
 c  cc8›7>c7  c  c1-1c c
c
  c c !cc cc! c   cc c 
c/&c
c
 c   c !  c c cc+ c0c/ cJ@›››cc cc
c
5c

+  c0 c$ c c 


c c cc   c !  c c c
 cc! c 
c

›››c

7 cc+ c.' (cc7 c c$ c


c'  c  c0(c  c!
c
 
ccc ponenciacc c  cc& c  cc) cc c
 c c
cc  cc   c$ c c  c ! c! 
cc
 c 
c
c c !c c
 cc  c  c  c+ ccc c  c
  c
5c

$ ccc  cc!   c cc c c 


!c c
 cc c  cc
 c  c cc 
c c ! c
   c! 
cc cc!  -
cc
c c 
!c
 c
  c  c  c
  c

›c  !c  c  ! c"c


c c 5c

$ ccc 
c  c  c11c c c c c c c
 c
  c
c
  c
c c ! cc c  cc  c
 ccc  c  c  c 
c  

cc

c 
!  c

›c c cc? Ic c c  c

Úadilla and Vitug, JJ., concur.

c

-.. /-00c

 Ê Ê "c

  cc
c
,  , c   
c

c c
   # #
 
  
 

 # $%
 
 
 c


 )c



  c
 c c c
 c  c cc  c c
 c c   c  c

c 
 cc cc  c c  cc c
c   
c  c cc
 
 
c c c    c
c
cc  
cc!
c c
cc
 c
c cc
c
c c c ccc
ccc
 c 
 c c c

ccc
  c c
c cc  c c 
c$ c c  c  cc c

 /c
 c  c c  c c  ccc cc !
c c
cc  c
 c
 
 c c
c c  c c  c

cc c c  cc
c  c c
c 
 c  c  c c$ c
 c c c  
cc!

c c
cc
 c
c cc
c
 
c
c cc c
  ccc
 c 
 c
c c  c  cc
c c
c$c
 c+ c c  
c
c !
c c
ccc c c  c
c
c
 
c
c cc c
  cc
c
 c 
 c c  c  c c
cc c  c c  c
c$ c  cc  cc  c
c c c  c
  c
c  
cc!

c c
cc  c
c

c  c c  c c   c


 c 
 c cc c c  cc  c
 c c
 c   c
 c+ c
 cc   
  c  
 c
   
 c cc
 c c  
c  
c
 c   c  c
 c
 c c  c c   c  c

c
 c c cc c
  
c
  c c c   c   c  c cc
  
c c c
  cc cc  cc   c
 c c
c  
cc !
c c
cc
c
cc c
 c c c
c  cc cc c  c  c c
 c
   c 
c$cPc c!   cc   cc  c  c 
 c
 c
  c
%c c  c c
 c c   c   c  
c
  c c
 c
  c  c
 c c

c  c
 c c   c
c
 cc  c c 
 c
 c
c c
  c  
c

  c c c


 c   c c
 c c cc
 c c !
c c
c
c

c  
 c cc c c
c
 c 
 c cc  c c
 c   c
 
c c cc c  c c c cc  c 
c
c 
 c  
c c
 c
c
cc c  
cc c c  c
c
 c c c
c 
cc
  c c
 c c   c c  c c c
 c  
 c c c
c
 ! 
c
 c   c   c
   c  c

c cc  cc  c


   c c
c /c

 c cc  c 
c  
c
c
 
 c c 
 c
c c
 cc

c  c
c c  cc c

 c c   c c
 c 
c c
 c cc   
 c c
c  c c c
  c c
 c c  c c c  c
 c   c 
c$Pc c! c cc

c c
   c
 c   c c c
 c  cc c cc  c c
  cc  cc cc c  cc
c c  c 
 c
c 
c c  c
 
c c c
c  c
 c c

c
 c c c
 c   c  c

   c  c

c c  
c
 c  c cc 
cc cPc c!  c
cc
   c cc c cc  c
c  c c c c  cc


 c c
  c   cc
c
 cc c
c c  cc cPc c
!  c c
 c  c

c
 c  cc
c  c
 
cc

cc
  c c
 c

 c c
 c 
c c
 c c
cc
c  c ccc
  cc   c c
 c  
 c c
 c

 c cc  c 
c  c
 c
 c c  cc  c
c
 c ccc 
c  c

   
 cc
c
 c
cc
c
 c
   c
 c  
 c   cc
 cc
 c 
 c cc 
 c   c  c c
 c
 c 
 c
c  cc
c c
c
cc
 c  
 c c  cc  cc

c c
  c
c  cc 
 cc c
 c  c   cc  c
c
 cc 
 
c c c    c
c
cc  
cc !
c c
cc
 c
c
ccc
c c c cc

c
ccc
 c 
 c c c

cc
c  c c
c cc  c c 
c$ c c  c  cc cc

 c c   
 cc c
c  c c c c c
c
 cc c
 c
  c cc  c c  cc c  c
 c c
c c c
c   c
c
  c c 
 cc c0c
 c  c

c
c  c cc   cc
 c c
ccc
c
c  c
cc
c c c c
c c
 c c
c
  c

  0c  c cc c  c c c
 c
c
 c c c
 c c c c

c

c

 c c   c  c  cc


c
 c 
 
c c c
    c
c
 c   
c c
  cc c   c
c   c  
c
 c
  cc
 c  c c  cc cc 
c
 c  c   c  c c
 c
   
cc
c
 c  c   c c
 c

  c c
 cc c
  
c c
 c

 c cc
 c
c c c
ccc
cc

 c
c
 c  c  c   c c
 c

  cc
 c c   c
  c  c c 
 c c
 c c   c  cc 
 c

 c
c cc 
 
c c c    c
c
 c   
c 


cc  c
c
 c
c
 c  cc
 
c c

  /c  ccc 

 c

c   c

 c
c  c 

 c$

  /c cc!c

 c c
 c c c cc  c c 
cc c c
 c 
cc 
c c
 c
  c
   c
c
 c
c
 cc
c  
 c
 c  c  c  c c


/c   cc
c
 c 
c

cccc cc c  
c
c

c c  c 
 
cc  c cc   c  c c c
 c
c c   c

c
 c c
c c
 c  
ccc   c  c  c

c c
cc
 cc  
c c
 c    
c c
 c c

c
 c
  c cc c
c
c
 c c  c c  cc
 c

c c
c c
c
 c

c
c c
 c cc
c  
c
c  ccc c cc cc  c
c
 c cc
 c c
c ccc  cc    c   c

c
c
 c
 c  c cc
c c
  c c
 c
cc c   c
c c  c
 cc 
c c c c   c
  c
c c  c
ccc c   c
 ccc  c c
  c  c  c  c c cc
 c
c cc

c c
c
  c
  c c c  c c
  ccc 
  c c c c

  cc c c c 
c
c  c   c  
c

c c  c
  c c
cc  c c c  c c  c  cc
 c
cc
c
 c
  c c  c c 
c c  c
c c

c
  cc c c
c 
 cc

c c c c

c


c
 cc c c cc
  c

c

c
cc  
c c
c 
  cc
 c  
 c c c

cc c  c c

 c  
c c  c c
 c
c c
c
  cc
c c
c  
c

c
 c c c cccc
 c
 c

cc  c c c
cc cc
c c

c
 c  
c  
 c cc
cc
  c  
c

c
cc 
 c
c 
c c 
cc
 c c
c  
c c c c
cc  c
c c c
c  
c
 c c
c  c

 c c
c
 c c

c
c cc

c c
c 
 
c c
 c
cc c
 cc

c c
 
cc    cc c 
c c
 c
c c
c  c 
 
c
c c
c  
c
 c c
ccc

 c   c c
 c  
c c
 c
 ccc
c
 c 
c

c
  cc c c
 c c cccc
 c
 c
cc

  c
c c
/c
  c
c
c  c
 ccc c
c
 c  
c
 c  
cc c c c
c c

 c

c

c cc!
c
c

c
  c c  c c   cccc
   c
 c  c c c

c
/c
c
  c   
 c
c  
 c c
c
 c

c

c
  cc c c c cc c

 c

c
  cc c c c
 cc
 c
ccc
c  c
 c    
c c
  c
 c
c

cc  c

c c
 c
  ccc !
c
c  
c c  cc
cc
c
c

 c
c


c c
 c  
c  cc
 c c

c
 c c ccc
 c
 c
c c


c
  cc c  
c c
 c  
 c c
/c
c


c c  c
 c   c

cc
cc
 c
c c  c c


ccc cc

c  
 c c c c  cc  ccc
  
 c c cc 
c ccc!
c
ccc
  c
c c
cc c  c
c cc  c 
/c
  c

 c
 c  c
c

c   c c
 c
cc
 c
c cc
c c
c  c c  c c

c
  cc cc !
c
cc  c  
c
 c  cc
cc
c  
cc
  c c
 c
c
c cc
 c
c ccc( c c  c c
 c   c  
c c
c

 c
c
 c  c  c  cc c c
 c  c

c
 c    c

  c 
 c
 c c c 

c
 c
c
c  
cc !
c
cc
c( c c   c

cc!
c  
 cccc
c c  
c c
 c
 c c c
 c c  c
 c  
 c c cc  c c
 c
c
  cc c
 c  
 c c cc  cc
 c
 c
c c

c
cc c

c 
c
 c  
 c c  ccc c  c
 cc c
cc

c
c( c c   c

c
 c  
 c c
/c !
c

cccc  
 c  
cc 
c c
 
cc    c
   c
   c
 c c    
c c
 c ccc
c c
c c
 c
  
c
cc c  
 c  c( c
cc
 c

c cc 
c
cc c
 c  c c c c
c  c
 c   c c
 c
c

c
 c   c c
 c  c  
cc c cc c
 c   cc
c
 c c
 cc
c
  cc  c   c
  c  c c
c c
 c 
 c cc c
   c 
 cc
 c
ccc
c  c
 c c c c
 c
 cc c  c  cc   
c
c
 c  c cc
c
c c
 c
  c c   c c c  c( c  c  c

c
c c  c c

  cc !
c
cc

c
 c
c c  c c
c c  cc c


 c cc
  cc  cc  cc !
c c
cc c c
c
  c

c
cc !
c c
cc  c
c c c   c c
 c

c
c c c c
c

c
c

(

c  c
 c 
 c c   c c
 c 
c
 c c c
 c  c
cc
 c

c
 c c
c
 c 
 c
   c c 
c cc  c 
c
c

c c
  c c
cc c

 c  c

c
 c c c 
c c c
 c
  c c   c  c
c 
cc cc
  cc   c   c
  
c c c$ c ccc c
c,c c
 c c c cPc
cc!  /c 
 c c c

c   c cc c
% 
c
c c c c

c   ccc cc c   c
cc cc c cc c
 c 
 c c
 cc c  c
cccc
c)c
cc cc!cc!c  cc c  c c
c c c

cc cc cc cPc"# cc c c c c  c!  c
 cc  cc
c c cP  c cc cc cPc"#c cc
 c
  c c  c
c cc c  
c
c c
c
 c   c c 
c cc
 c
  c  c  c

 c
 c cc
c c c c
c
 c
 c c c
 c cc
 c c
  c c
 c  c  c  c c  
 c
c c
 c c
c  
c
  c

c  c
 c 
c 
cc
 c  c  c
c c

ccc c c
c c c
 
c
c  c
 c
c cc c
c  c  c$c
c
c
c
$ c
c c  c
 c 
 c

cc  c  
 cc  c c
 c0c
 

 cc   
c c
 c c 
 ccc c c c c
 c
  c   c c 
c  
c 
cc
 c  c c
ccc
 
c
cc
0cc
 c0  /c  c 
0cc cc c0
 cc  c c
  
 ccc 
ccc
 c 
 c c c  c
c cc
 0c c
 c$ c c  cc c c
 cc c c 
c

c c
c /c   c
c c c
 c
c
c c
 c c
  c)  c c
c
 cc 
c c
 ccc
 c  
c

c cc c c c  c


c  c c  c
 c
 c$ c c c c
 
c
c  c
 c

c cc c
c  c  c$c
c 
c$ c
c c c 

 c 
c

c
  c
c 
ccc
 cc c c  cc 
c
   c
 c  c 
c
c  c
 c c   c  c
c  c

c
 c c
c  
cc
 c
c c
ccc
 c 
 c 
  cc
 c  c  c  cc
c  
 c
  c
 c c c
 c c
  c


c c
c cc
c
c c

cc  c c
 c  c c c
c cc c
 cc c
 c 
c  cc 
 c
 
c
 c  cc  c
c
 c
  c  

cc
 c
c 
cc  
c
 c 
c 
 
c
 
c 
c
c

 c c c  
 c
c
 c  
 c  c c 
c cc
 c   c

   c ccc


c c
 c 
 c

cc
 c
c c
 c c   c c
  c
c
 c 
 c c
 c  c c 
 cc cc  ccc

 c c   
 cc c
c
 c  c   cc  c c  c

c  ! c$ 2c
 c 
c c c
  c
  c
c c   c c  c  c
 c

(   c
 c  c  c  cc   c  c
c 
c
c

  c

 c c


c c   c

$  
& # 
   
  % 

 

&  c  c

c
c
c
c
c

--001c

2 

   2 
2 

 Êc
 !  cc
c
  
 
 c 
! 
cc

D  $%  



 (
 
p
  
Ê  

   &  Ê  

D   


Ê  p $ )

&  (


c


c

 c  c 
 cc
c c  cc  
c c  
 c c
 c  c 
cc
 c
c
c
 c 
 
c
cc c c
 c 
 c cc 
c 
c
c
 c c
  c c 


cc  
c  c
cc  
 c c
 c c c c
   c c  cc 
 c( c c

c
c c
c

 c  cc
c cc
c c
 c c  ccc 
 c
c  
c
c c cc  c0  c   c  ccc%cPc cc
 
 c c 
 ccc  
 c
c 
 c c c
 c  c

 c
  cc  c c   
c
c cccc 
 c  c c  c
c
 cc 

cc  c 
c c c
c
 c
c c c  
c cc
 c
c c
c c
 cc  cc
 cc
  c  cc   c ccc
   cc  cc 
 cc 
 c  c  ! c  c$
ccc


c c  c
cc$c c c 
 c

c 
c c   c
 c
   c  c c 
c
  c  c
 c   c
 
 c 
 c
c0c

c c
( c
 c cc c c c c 
 c c  c
 c  c 
c
c
 c

c
 c
 c  c c
 c  c0 c  c
 
c

c
 c  cc cc
   c c
 c c  cc
c c

c cc 
 cc 
c c  c
c  c

 c cc

c cc 
c
 c c cc 
 c cc
 c c
cc 
c c
 c
  cc cc  c

cc 
c c c
 c c 
  0c
c
  c 
c  c
 c cc  c

c c c
c 
 c
 c
 

c cc

c
 c  
c c

c  cc 
 c cc c c 

c c  c


 c 
 c   c c 
 c
c c0
 c c
cc 
c 
cc
c   c
c
c
c  c cc  0c

 c
 c  c 
c

c

c
 c c c  c
 c   
c c

c c c
c c
 c
 

c
 c c c
 c  c 
 c0 c
 c  c
c


c
c
ccc  c
cc c c 
 c 
  cc
 c 
 c
c ccc   c c  
c c cc
 c
c cc

c 
c c
   c
 c   c  c c 
c
  c  c
 c   c
 
0c  c
  c c
 c 
c  c
  c0% c% c)  0c cc
 c
  c 
c cc

 
c0  c  c
c% ccc  c

c c c
 c

c
 c  c
0c

 

c
 c c  c

c cc0c
c 
c
 c c c  0c
  c c
 c  c cc
c  
c c$c 
c 
c cc 
 
c
0c 
c 
c c
 c) c  c 
0c
 cP  c c
c
c  cc
 c
 c   
c  c c cP c 
c c  c
c
 c  c
 
cc
c  c
cc cc  c
c cc   
c c
 c

c c  c c
 c  cc c 
c 
 cc 
 
c
cc c  c
c
 c

c

c
 c  c0cc 
c 
0c cP c 
c  c c
 c  c
 c


c

c
c
 c  

 c c
 c c 
c cc0c
c 
c
 c c c

 c 
 c c
 c c
cc 
c 
c  c 
cc   cc c c
 c
 c  cc  
c  c
 c    
c c cc  c c  0c  c

c  c

cc
 c
 c  c c
 c
c  c
 c  
 c
  ‘ !*‘ +, c

  
c c  cc  c
 c  c 
c   cc  c  
c
 c  c
0 c
 c c c c   c c  cc 
 c
cc

c 
c c
 c  c cc  c c
c
 c cc
c c
 c 
c  c  cc 
 c
  
c  cc c  
cc  c c
 cP  
0c

 c  c 
 c c  c cc
 c cc
 c
c
c 
c  c  c 
c c
  cc

 ccc 
c

c  
cc
  
c   c  c0
cc c  c c c
  c
cccc  c c  c
 c
c c  c c 
 c
  c c c

  
c c  
c  c c
 c
c c  cc
 c 
 c c  c
c c
 c c 
 0c  c 
c 
 c  c

c0  cc 
 c
   cc  c c
c  c  c c c c" c
 c c  c c

 c #c
 c c 
  c cc
 c   
c c
 c   c c
 c c  c c  c

c  c c
   c
 c
   c c cc c c c  cc 0c c
c
  c0 c c  c cc   c c c cc c  
c c  cc

 c   c c
 c c
 0c

 cc
c c c  c c  cc c cc 
c 
cc c cc
c
 
c c
cc   c c  c 
cc  
c
c c 
cc
c c
 c
c0 
 
 cc


 c  c  c
c
cc c  

c

c

 cc  c c  
c

c
 0c  c  
 c c
 c  c 
c

c
c
c c
c c

c c
  c  c c  c c

 #c  cc 
c 
cc 

c
c c c
 c 
 c

c
 c 
 
c0 c
 c  ccc 
c 
c
c
cc

 c
 c c  cc  ccc

 c c c  
 c
cc

c
 c
  c cc0  c  0c    
c c
cc  c c
 c c  c
  c  c c 
 c 0c c  cc c
cc
c
c
 c  c c

c 
c
c
c c
 c cc 
c
c cc


 c  c c
 c 

c

   c

c
c  c  
c
c
cc cc

 #c
c c
  c c
c
 
cc

(   c
 c  
c  c  cc  cc

c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c

-.1--3c

 ,
   
c (
 c c  
 
   , c

 (


c


 c  c 
cc  c

c
 c 
c
 c
 ! 
c  c 
c  
c  c 
c
c

c
 c

c c
 c

cc
  
c
 c c
c c 
 c c
 cc 
!
  c 
c cc  c c cc c  
c c
 c   c c

 c
c  c   cc
 c  
c c
 c c  c
c c c
 c  c
c c  cc cc
 c 
ccc
 c

c c c c  c
  c 
c   cc 
c  c 
c
 c 
c c
 c
 c
 c c 
!
  c 
c cc  c cc c  c c c c( c
    
 c
c  c 
cc

 c
c
 c  c  c0 cc
 c   c 
 c   
 c  c
 c
 c c
 c  c 
c c c 
 c  c 
c c
 c 
c
   c
c  
c  c
 c
 c
 c c  c
c  c c  c
 c c c  c c  c c  
c 
 c 
c
c
 c 
c c
c  c c
c
c  c
 ccc  c c c c
 c
 cc c

c c 
  c   c c
 c 
c    c  c c  cc  c
c
 c c
 c c   c  c c  c 
 c c c
 c  c

 c
  cc c
 c
 cc  c c
c c  c  
c
  c
cc
c

 c

 c 
c 
cc  cc   c c  c c c c!c
c c  c c c  c!c cc&c 
c!c c


cc  
 c0 cc c
c   cc cc  
cc 
c cc
 c 
 c c c  0c0 c c  c  
cc


cc 
 c c0c  cc  c
c cc
 c 
c    c
  c
 c

c c c
 c
 c

c cc0
c cc c c  
cc

 
 c c c   cc c  c
 cc
 c

c 
c c
 0cc c
 cc   c c
 c
c  cc c c
 c
 /c

c 
c cP  c c
cc c c
c 
c cc
cc c

c c

c
 cc

cc
 c 
c    c c
 c
c
 c
 c c
cc
 c

 c c"   c
 #c

c0c- c c  c 
cc

cc
cc
 c  c
 c 
c    cc
c0 c
 c  
c c c

 c c 
c  c  c
 
c c 
 c c c
 c  c

 c  c
 
 c

c cc 
 
  c
 c c  cc  c  c
 c  c 
c
  
c  c
c
c
c
c !cc  c cc c c  
cc
c
c

c0
 cc
 c c cc c c
c c 
 c
c
 c 
c c c  c
c  cc
 c  c
  cc c
 cc
c
 
 c c
 c 
c c
 c
c  cc c  cc 
 cc
 c

c 
c c c c
 c
 
c cc  c c  0c0 c c  c 
cc

 c  c 
c  c ccc 
c

c c
 c c c  cc  c
 c c

   c 
c
 c
 c c c
c
 c 
c

c  
c
c
 c  c c 
 c c
c
 c  c

 c  c c c c
c c 
 c cc
c
 c 
c
 c
c
 cc 
 c c
 c c c c
 c 
c cc  c
c  c c c
 c
c c c  c  c
c c / cc
 c c
 c  
c
  cc
 c c  c  c  c
 c  c 
c  
c  cc
 
 c
c
 c c  c
 cc 
 cc
 c 
c c c  c

c

cc
c c cc cc c c  
.c c cc
 c  cc c
c  cc  c
cc  c

cc
 c  c  c

c
  cc
 
 c c

 c
 c
c
c 
c0 c  c 
 c c
c c c  c c c0 c c  c 
cc

c
c c  c
 c c 
c  c
 ! 
c  c 
c  
c
  c  c
 c  c

c
 c

c c
 c cc c  
cc cc
 c c

c c 
 c
  
c cc 
c
c
 ccc  c
c c c
c c
c

c
    
 c
c  c 
cc 

cp 
    
  c!cc
 c 
c
 c  c c
 ! 
c 
c
c c
 c

c c cc c  
c c c  cc  c
c 

 cc
  c c
 c 
c

cc
 c

c c 
!  c
c  cc  c  c

 ! 
c
c

 c
c 
c c c
cc cc  c c c c  c
  
c
cc
c c c   c
c c c c
 c  c c
 c

c c
c
  
c
cc c  c

c
 c ! c  c c cc
c  c
c c
 c


c c
 c c c  cc     
 c c  c 
cc


c  c
c c cc 

 c c c
c
 c 
c  c c
 cc
 c
c
 c  c

 c  c0  c   c c

cc  cc
 c c
 c   c c
 c  c c c c
c c  c
c c
 c c

c
 c
 c   c
 c c
   c c  cc
c c  c  
c
  c
c c  c c c  
c  
c
c
 c
c cc  
c 

c
c

 c
 c
c c cc 
 c

 c
c c  
c
 
c 
c
c
   cc
 c   c c
 c

0 c c  c 
cc 

 c cc 


c  c c
 cc  c c c c 
c  c c
   c
0 c  cc
c c  c  
0c c
 c  c c 

c  
c
c
 c
c
 c   c0
c c
 c c
c
 c
 c   c0c   cc cc   c c
 c
c c

 ! 
c
c c
 c c
c
c
 c
 c   c  c  c c
 c c

   cc  c


c
 c c  c
   c c
c    
 c c  c 
cc 

(
c
c c c
c 
cc
 c

c c
 c c
   c c
c c
c c
 cc
cc
c c   cc

c 
cc
c
 c  c 
cc(
c
c  c
 c
c c
 c  c  ccc   c
c c c
c
 c


 c
  c   c  cc
 cc
cc c  
 c  c c
c 
c

c
  c
 cc cc cc
 c  c
  cc c c c


 c
  cc  c c c
 c 
cc
c   cc
c 1 c c  c 
cc 

c c
cp 
    
  
!c  c 
c c
 c 
 c c c c  c c
cc  cc
 c 
c
 c  c cc   c 

c c
 c  c 
c

 ! 
/c  
cc 
c c
 c 
c

c
cc
c 
c  c c c


c
cc
  c

c
 c c 
 c cc
c
 c c c  c c c
cc
c
 c

c  c
 c  c

 c  3c
 c c c
 c
 c  
c
c

 c c0 c


c
 
c c
c
 c
c
 c  c c   c c
 c  
c
"
 #ccc
 c 
 c c 
c c c
 0c c   c 
cc 

( c cc 

 c c
c  cc  c  c c
 c  c 
cc
 c
  c  c  c0(
c  
c
c
 cc

c
 c 
 c c c c  c c
c  
c
c
 c

cc cc c c c 
 c
cc   c
c  c

c
 
c c c  c  c
 c
c c
 c
cc  c

c
 c 
c
 
c ccc c    c cc c 

 c  c
c
 c
    
c  c c c 
 c c c
 c  c

 c  c c
 c

 c

c
 c
 cc 
c
  c c
 c

c c  cc  c c
c
 c
c c
 c
 c c  c c c 
 c  c
c
 
c c c  c c
 c cc
c

 c cc 
 c c  cc  c
c  c c  c c c
cc c
c
 c
  
c c  
c c c
 c
 cc   c  c
 c  c c
  
 c c
 c
cc
 cc
 c c
c c  c c
c c

c
 c
   c  cc
c
c  c c
 c

 c c
 c
c  
cc  c !
  c c c 
0c  c    c c
 c c   
 c c
 c  c
 
c
c c
c c
 c 
 c
 c 
 c

c
  cc c
   c c
 c
 
! c  c c c  
    
 c c  c 
c c

 c 
cc 
 c c

c
 c 
 c c
c c
c c  c c cc

cc

 c
 c c c
c c
 c 
c c  c c c c
c
 ! 
c
0c
c  c  c
 c ccc cc
cc
c c c
 c
 c

cc
 c

 0c0 c
c  c 
cc

  cc cc
c 
c cc cc
 c c c
 c  c 
cc
  c  c
0c  c c c
 c 
c    c  cP  c

c c c  c
 c
  
  
c c c
c c 
 c c
 c cc c c  
cc  c
 c 
 
 c

ccc  c c c
 cc 
c c
 c
   c
 c c cc  c  c c c
c ccc
 c
c c
 c 
c
 cc
 cc c cc  c  c
  c
c
 c
 
c

 cc
 c  c
 cc

 c
 ccc  
c c

c c  c
c c
c
 c   

 c c
 c c 
cc c    c  
c
 c
 c c 

c  cc
c
 cc
 c 
!
   c  c

 c
 c

cccc c
c
 cc c0c c c  c 
cc

c cc 
c c
c c
 ! 
c 
c c  c
c c 
cc
   c
c
 c  c 
c cc 
 c c
 c   c  c 
 c cc
 c 
c
c c c  c
cc
 c 
 c  c

c cc
c c 
 c
c

c 
c cc  c
c c c
 c
c
c
c c c c 
c c c
 c
 
c  c- c c  c 
cc

()


c
 c  c c
 c  c 
c
c c cc  cc

c(
c 
c

c
 ! 
c

c
c
c
c

-1-$%$45$&-1c

c c
 2 Ê  ÊÊ Ê  22, 
6  Ê Ê,    ÊÊ   2   
22   ,  ÊÊ   2  "   

 Ê,  22 ÊÊ      ÊÊ 


  Ê  2  
 Ê,  22c

  cc
c
Ê Ê   ÊÊ Ê Ê  ÊÊ c   
cc

Ê

 p +
& 
  
 
p
  
Ê  

   
   Ê  

D
  
 

Ê  

  

  
 
  c

27 
c

c
c c  cc  c c
 c c  
c  c c  c
 c  /c
 cc
 c

 c  c
c c
 c c

cc
 c  c cc  c
  cc
 c c  
c
c 
cc
 c  c
 c  c
c   c
 
 c
cc c c
 
c
c   c c c  c
 c 
c c
c
  c 

 c
 c  c  c
 c c  
c
c

 c  c

  c  c  c c  cc c 
c

 c
c   
c
  c 

c
 c c  
c  c c c  c c  c
  c  c cc
 c c  c  c   
c 

c
c


  c
c c c  c

  c   c 
c  c 
 c
 

cc  c 
c

c
 cc 
cc  c c  
 c
c
 c
 c
 
 cc
c c c c  
 c
cc
 c cc 
c
 c  c
c  c
 c  
c  c

 c
c cc c c
c  
 c c  c 
 c
c
 c c  c c  
c  c
 

 cc
 c 
c 
c c c c
 c  c  c 
 c c
c
 
 c  c

c  
c c
 c  
c c  
 c

  c  c

c
 cc  c  c
 c
  c

cc

 c 
 c
 c  c
c  
c
c  c  c
 c
 c c  
c 
c
c  c  c c 
c c  
c 
c
c
 cc
c
 c 
cc
 c  c
 c

c 
c c   c
   
c
 cc  c c
 c  c  c 
 c c
c 
 c  c
 c 
 c c

c
 c 
 c  c
c
 c c
c c  
 c
c
 c  
 c c   
c  ccc
 c
c   c 

c
  
 c c c 
 c

c cc c   


c 
c  cc
 c
cc c
 c c

c0
 c
 c  
c  cc c  c c
 
c
c   c 
 c c
c  c
 

 c
cc

  c  c
 c  
 c c  c c ccc
c
   
c  c
c  c
 
c c  cc c

   
c  c
c
 c
 c
cc c cc c  
c c  cc
c
c
 c c

  /c  c c c  c
c 

c
 c
   cc c c c  
c c

 c c
 c 
/c  c
 c
  c c
 c
 cc 
 c  c c 
c c
c 
c
 c   c
  
c
 c  
c
cc
 c
 c c c  c 

c c
  c

  c
c c
 c c   cc   
c 
c  c
c
   c c  
cc c

c 
 cc c   
c  c c
c cc
 c

 cc
 c

c  c
  cc c
 c   c
c  c cc c c

cc
 c
  c cc  c  cc
 c c  
c
c 
cc
 c  c

 c  c
c   c 
 c
c
c  c c c  c  c  
cc
  c  
 c c c  c c c
c c
 c
 cc
 c
  
 c cc c 

cc  c  
 c cc
c
  
c c c  c
 c  c 
c
 c   
 c c
 c
 

c c c

cc 
 c c
 c c  
c  c  c


c
c0c c  c
c   c c c  c
 c 
 c c
c  c
 

 cc c c  c  c


 c c  
c
0c

()


c
 c

 cc   c cc

  c c 
c
c c
 c
   
c 
c
c

c$ c c  c  
c c
c c
 c 
c c
 c   
c
 c 
 c  c c
 c  c cc  c


c
c  c 
c   c

 c c c c
 c
 c
c
 c  c
 c


c c c c( c
c   c

  c c
  c c,c 
 c   c

 c c  c c c
 c  c cc  c
 c

 c

...-c

 c   c c
 c

  c
c  c
c
c c
c
 c  c   c
  cc
cc c c
c
 c  c c
 c  c cc
c cc c
 c c c
 c  
c c
 c

  cc c c   c
c
 c
 c
  

c
c c
 c

  c
c
 c 
c

c 
cc
 c   
c c c
c
c 
 c c 
c  cc
c
 c c

c   
c  c  cc c

c
cc c
 
c  c
 c c  
c

c
c   c
 c 
c  c cc c
c  c 

 c

( c c c  cc
 c  /c
 c

c  cc

cc

c c
 c 
 
c  c c
 c c  
c
c  c  c

c

  /c 
 c

c
 c   
c  c c  cc
c
 c

 c 
 c c
 c &c 
c c 
c c
c  
c c  c 

 c

 c
  c
 
c c  c c c  c c 
c

 c 
 
c 
 c c 
 cc$c c
 c c  
c
c  
 c  c

c


cc
 
 
c1c$c  c 

 c  cc
 c  c
 
 cc c 

c
c
 c 
c
c
 c 
c c c c c c
 
c  c
 c 
c cc
 c c c c
c c
 cc
 c
  c c  c0
 


-
 
  
 
  %  %
%
  
 
    %     

 



%

 %

 
  %  
  


 



 
    

 
  %  
 cccc

 c
 c c

 cc
c   
c  cc
 c    
c c
 c
/c
c

c
 c  c c c
c  c
cc c 
 c
c 
c
 c

c c
  c
c
 c 
c
c
 c  c  cc cc 
c c
 c &c c
 
c  c  c 
cc  
 c cc 
 c
c  c c
 c 
 c

c  c

c  c c
c
 c
 c
 c

/c   c c
 c  c  cc
 c
  

 c c
 c  /c  c  c0
c  c 
c  cc  
c
c c  
c 
ccc c 
 c
c
 c c c
 c  c
 
c
 c
 cc$
c  c

 c
c  c
c
 cc c
c
 c c cc 
0 cc
c  
c c 
c cc 
cc   c  
c
 c
 cc c c

 c
 cc  c c  c c  c c
  c
 c 

 c c  cc


 c c  
 c c
 c c
c
  c  cc
c c c 

 c c
 c  
c
 c 

 c c  c


 cc  c
 c 
c 
 c

 c
c
 c  c  c  
c c  c
cc

c

  c 
c

cc
 c   c c
 c   
c  /c  c c 
 c
c 
 c c
 c 
cc  cc 
 c c c
 c
c
c c c
 c
 
c
c
   c
 c 
c c
c  
c  c 
 cc$ c   c
cc    c
c
0  c c
 c
cc
c c c 
c c
 c  c    
c c
c
0c
 cc c
c c
c
c 

 c 
 cc c
 c c  
c
c   c
  
c
 c  c c
 c  c   c  cc  c c
 c  c
 c
c c c

c
 c  cc
c   c c c
 c
 c
 
c
c
   c 
 c  c c
 c
c

c  c
 c c 

c
c
 c 
c c   c cc c  c c
 c c c
c c0 c  c
c
 c  cc c   c cc
 
c c
 c
P  
0c cc  c
 
c c
 c c c
 c 
cc
 c  c
c
 c
  c   
c  c
c  c  c c
c 
c
 c c
 c  
 c c 
 c

c cc
 c  
c
c c
 c  cc
   c c c c

cc  c c  c
 
c
  c

c(  c
 c  c c
 ccc cc
 c

c c
 c 
 cc   cc

  cc c c c


 cc 
 
 c c
 c


c  c 
cc
   c
 c
c  c   
c  /c c
c 
c 
c
  c
 c
 
c
c
   c 
 c c
c  
c c c  
c  c c
  c c c c

 c
 c  /c c
c
 cc
  c  c

c c
c
 c
  c
  cc cc 
c
 cc   cc

c c
 c 
 c

c

  c
c 
c
 cc
 c
c  c   
c  cc
c
  
 c c 
 c c  c  c  
c  c c
 c  c
c
 c  c c
 cc
c c   c c
c
 c c
c  c  c c

c  
 c c 
 c  c  c  c  c  
 c c  
cc

 c cc

c
 c c ! 
c  c 
 c c
c
c
 c
c
 c c
 c c  cc

c
 c  cc
 c  
c c
 c  cc
c c
c 
 c c  
c  c c
 cc
cc 
c cc !  c  c


c
 c c  
c
cc
c c
c
 c  c

 c
c
 c c  c  
 c
c c
 c  c c
c  c
  c
 c 
cc
 c 
c   c 
c c

  c

c
 c  c
c
c c  
 c c c c c c

cc  c c
 c 
 
c  c
cc c 
  c c c   c
c c  
c
 c  cc
c
  c c c 
 cc c c c  c

c c
c  
 c c c
  c c cc
c 

cc
 c  
 c
c  
c c c
cc
 
 c
 c
 c c
c  
c
c
 c   
 c c
c 

c c c


cc 
 c

cc
 c  c cc  c  cc
 c c  
c
c

cc
 c  c
 c  c
c   c 
 c
c0c c  c
c   c
 c c  c
 c 
 c c
c  c 

 cc c c  c  c

 c c  
c
0c

c  c
c  c  c
c c  
c c
c  
c c 
 cP
c

c
cc  c
c
 c
cc
c  
 c c 
 c

c c
 
c
 c 
cc c

 ccc

c0
ccc ! c  c

c   c
 cc    
c c
 c
c c c  c c
c c   
c  
c
 c c
 c


cc

c
 c
P  
cc c 
 c c
 c c  c c
 c
c c
c 
0c

  /cc
c

c
c  
 c  
c
 cc c c   ccc  c
c c
 c
c

cc c c c
 c c

 cc  c c 

c
 c c
  
c  c  c 
c  cc

c
 c   c
 c c    cc
 
 c
 c
c c
 c c  
c
c
c
 cc

c
 c  c c  c
c
c c
 c  c  c ccc
 c  c
 c &c 
c
  c c
 
c
 c  c cc c
c  
c  c  c    c c c c

c c
 c  cc
 c 

c
 c
c
  c
   c 
c
 c 
c
 c

c c c c c


 c  
c  c  c

c
 c
c  cc
 
 cc$c
  c

c
 c  cc
 c  c  c c  
c
c c c
 c  
c c
 c 
cc
 c c cc
 c  c
 c
 c
c  c
  cc

c
c
 c
 c
 c


c
 c

 cc c 

c
 c  c
 c
 
cc  c  cc 
c
c
 c 

c
 c c  c c
c cc
 $  %   Ê Ê
 $  c

c
 c 
 cc  c

 c
c  c
 cc  c


 cc
 c ! 
c


 c c
c

  c
c
 c  cc  c c
 c c  
c
c

c c c  c c


 cc 

c
   c c
 c  cc c
c
 cc
 c

 c c  
 c c 
 c c
c  
c c  cc
 c c

  cc
 c  cc
c  c c

  c  c  c c c

 c  cc  c c c  



c
c  cc
 c  
ccc 
c
 c
 c
 c   cc c c c  
cc c
 c  

 c cc
 c
   c  c  c 
c

c
  ccc c cc
 c 
c c c  cc
 
c c c
 c  ccc  c cc
c
cc c
 
c
c   c
 
 c c
c cc

  c 
c

c
 c  cc
   c c c
c

 
cc
 c
cc
 c

 c c
 c c c c  c
  /c
 cc
 c c
 c c cc c c c
 c 
c c
 c

c

P%c
 c  c  c  cc   c  c

c    
cc
c
 
c

$ 
 $  

  #. / Ê
&$  D
  c
  c

& 
  c
c c
c

-.%5$&10c

  8 !    8 !



  ! 
cc
c
2  " 
 ,7  2 
2 

 Ê 2 3  
Ê2    Ê Ê   c   
!  c

     


  
(
 c


&0
&  
 
 (


 c

cc

, 

c

 c  c
 c  c c
 c 
c c
c
 c cc 
cc
c c
 c c c cc
 c

 c c c
c c cc
c c

c c
  c 
 c  c
  c c
 c  c

  ! 
cP  cPc   c
c
  c c   c
c  c
 c  c   
!  c   
cc c
 c
 c
c 
cc

  ! 
/cc c 
 
c  
c c
 c c
 c
 cc  ccc
c 
c
 c  c   
!  c
1(    c
c
 c  c cc 
c  c  c
c
 c   c     c c
c
 c c  
 c
 c ! c 
c  cc 
 c
c
 c
   
cc c
 c c
c   c
 c c   
  c

 cc  c  cc c c


 c  c

+$›B,/$›2 c28c8/$+ c

$ c
!
c  cc c  cc c !!c cc
 cc5c

› c$ c c  c


c c   cc c c   c  cc c
7    c8  c c'78(c
 --  cc c  c
 
- 9cc c cc".. ..c

›› c$ c c  %c c c   c  c c 


c c78c> 
c
7  c  c*" cc/ c .c" c

››› c$ c c! ! c c c  


cc c  cc cc c
 
- 9cc4 c* c"c

›@ c$ c c 
c  cc".. ..c cc c  
cc c  cc   c
  c) c !c cc c !c
5 c

:'(c$ c c cc*.. ..c c c 


c c  5 c

:' (c c  c 


c ! cc c! ! c
 c

:'(c c   cc c


 c 
c
!c
 c

:'(c cc c c 


c 
c c  c
c c9c
 c 
cc0".. .. c

:'
(c ccc c   cc c !c
- 01 c cc c   c 
c

:' (c ccc 


 c!c c  c
c c   c  c

'*(c$ c c & c  c cc c c c..Kcc c
  cc cc 
cc  cc0".. ..c c c
  c c c
c ! c c  cc9 c ! !
cc c
) c  cc c   c
c 
c c  c  cc 
c
cc 
c   c

' (c$ c c c c c c


c c c
!cc
 
c 
c 
c 
c
cc 
 cc c c 
c
  c
c

'(c$ c c cc  cc c


!c c 
c
 cc c c c... ..cc c c 
cc c
! ! cc 
 ccc> 
c7  c  c "c  c
c1c

'"(c$ c cc 


c !cc c
!c c c
 
cc*.c
cc c
 cc c! ! c c

c c
'0(c$ c c  ccc  cc) cc c    cc
c

'1(c$ c c  c  !cc c  cc c c c c 


c
  c,  c  =c c!c c-! !c cc
! ! c c c ! 
cc4 c* c"cc c
7 ! cc
cc4 c2
 c c2&  c

:@ c$ c cc  cc*..c c


cc/ c*c"c 
c c c
  c  c
c & c   c

:@› c$ c cc c c0"c c 


!c ! cc c  cc c
 
- 9c 
!c  c c  "c

:@›› c$ cc c*1c0"c  c;


cF) c c
cc/9
! c
 c.c c c 
- 9cc4  c !cc cc c cc
... ..ccc 
!c ! cc c 
- 9ccc c

ccc 9c c cc7  c/c  c1c

:@››› c$ c c 


- 9ccc2= c> c

c c  cc c
-    ccc cc c!
c c c  c cc
c  cc
!cc c*.c" c c7  c/c1c c 
c

:›J c$ c c 


- 9ccc2= cc> c
cc2 cc
0"c c   cc c   cc c   c! ! c  
cc c
  c 
c c !cc c   cc c 
- 9c c c
+ ccc
 c

c c c c cc  cc00c
 c
!c  c;
cF) cc c   cc   c
cc c
 
- 9c

:J c$ c c  c  c ! cc  c c c c

cc  c
0c00cc8  cc00cc c  cc   cc c cc
 :c

Bc  c c 
c ccc c  c c c c cc  cc
c c ! cc c  c c!c c c cc c  cc
7  c/c  c1c c/ 
c/cc  c*.c" cc7  c/c .c c
! c 9c c c c cc

c c c c 
c 
c 
c

 
c 
c cc
c 
c cc c c c cc
 c c! !
cc 
 cc c   c   cc 
c
   c> 9cc c  c  c
 c cc   c›c c  c
  %c c ! cc cc 5c:$ c cc 
cc
 !c c c
 cc c  -  c cc!c c7  c/c  c1c c
 
cc c*.c" :c

$ c  c cc  c

$ c  ccc c !ccc c   


c> 9c c
, c c  

cc7  c/c  c1cc c*.c" c
c c 5 c

+? c* c$ c$  cc c  c cc   cc c c
 
cc c c  c 
cc c cc c  ccc
/ 
c/c 
c
cc c 
c ! c c c c ! 
cc c
+   cc8  c 9
! c 
c c & cc c !cc c!cc
 c+  c 
c ! c c

cc c c  c 
c ccc
9
! c c c
cc c   cc c  c c c cc
c  cc ! c
 c c   c 
c c cc c c

cc c
;  cc c  cc c cc c
 cc c  cc
  5c

c$ cc   c 
c) ccc c 
c ! c
c c c 
cc c+   cc8  c c   cc

 c c c

cc c$  cc c  c !c c cc c cc c c
  c 
c ! c c!ccc c c
 c 9
!
c 
c !=
c


c c c  c  ccc   cc

 c cc 
c c
c c c   c c
cc c  cc'(cobligations subsisting at

c c
the time of the approval of this Amendatory Act for which the applicant may directly
be liable to the government or to any of its branches or instrumentalities, or the
corporations owned or controlled by the Government, or to any citizen of the
Úhilippines, or to any association or corporation organized under the laws of the
Úhilippines, who may be willing to accept the same for such settlementc c

›cc

c 
c c
c c  cc c;  cc ccc
!  c
 cc  c c
 cc c    cc 9c c   %c
 c c  c
cc c   cc! c
c   cc c
   cc cc c ! cc    c  c   
cc c  &c›c
c & c c  c c c  cc   c & c c c
 ! c<ccc   cc

 c c c  
c c  c
c<cc csubsistingc c c cc c  cc7  c/c  c1c  c
 c cc c c  cc 9c c   c  c 
cc  cc c
!  -
c cc c ! c  cc cc!c c
 c cc c   cc 
c  
c/cc c*.c" cc
 c cc ! c c
cc  c c    c

›cc c c  %c   cc c c c   c  c c 


cc
 c 9cc/ c.c" c›c  c  c c  c

cc   cc
c cc  c cc c c  
c c! ! c c cc4 c* c
"c 
c  c c c  cc c cc c 
c  cc".. ..c
 cc c
cc  c 
c) cc   cc  c
cc
 
c   cB
c  c  c2c !cc c  ccRodriguez vs.
Development Bank of the Úhilippines 'cc ! c

›c c  c7


! =c 
c c  cc c 
c   c> 9cc c
  cc c  
cccc   c  c 
cc c 
c  cc
  c
c c c 
c
c 
cc c  c !   c
 cc 
c !  c7
! =c  
c cc  cc ccc
"... ..cc4 c*1c" c c c & c  c !c c... ..c
<c  cc c  c  c c  
cc 
c  
ccc  c c c" c
,  c7
! =c 
c c  c c c c
 cA c c  cc c
.... ..c  
c 
c7
! =c 
cc c c 
c 
!c  c
c c  ccc 9c c   c$ c> 9c 
c ccc  c c 
c
 
cc  cc   c 
c cc  
c c  c  cc 
cc
   c cc c cc"... ..c   !c ccc c  c
 
c  c c  ! cc7  c/c  c1c !c c cc c
 9c c   c 
cc7
! =c c c c cc c c c
 
c  cc c   c+c7
! =c
c c cc 
cc c
cc8c›  cc  cc c c> 9cc  cc 9c c
   cc  ccc c 
!c ! ccc c
c  cc
 ccc c  c 
!cc c  c
c  c c*.c" c
$c c c

cc c cc 
cc  cccc c

 c c 
cc c !c  5 c

›c cc c 
c c  c   c

cc c> 9cc c c cc
... ..cc c
 cc c !   c$ c  cc c  cc c
!
c  c  c
c
 
cc  c
c' c

 c
c
 
cc  ! ccc c cc csupra(c !ccc c
   cc
 c -   cc cc  c
c cc  c c
 cc c  cc c  cc c !
c  c 
c  c cc
 c c 9cc
c c  c   cc c 
c  c
 &  c c
c c

c c cc 5 c

: c c c 
cc c" c 
c   c c c


c c ! c!cc c" c$ c
 
c
 c c
cc  c c 9c c   cc  cc
 ! c!c c c/ 
c/c c 
c'+  c
*c7  c/c1( têñ.£îhqw⣠7  c/c1c c 
cc

c c
 c*.c" c$ c
 
c cc c
cc  c
 %c 9c c   cc  cc c c 
c
 c c*.c" :c

$ c  ccSabelino v. RFCc'; 7 c  c,-1.c+  c .c"(c 


ccc
 cc  c c c! ! c

 c!cc c 
cc
 %c 9c c   c  c  cc  c
ccc c
 cc7  c/c  c1 c c

3  c  %c cc  c c c cc7


! = c3  c  c
 c  
cc c 
c  c c c c'(cc  c c
  cc7  c/c1c 
c c 
!c  c  c  c
  
cc  c c  c c  cc c! ! c cc4 c
* c" cB

c 
!c c  cc c  c   c
> 9cc c  c'78(cc  %c  c   cc/ c .c" c
 c

cc  cc c ! cc c c  c c  c c
 
!c c  c 
cc  c  c4 c* c"c

cc
 ! c  c 
cc c   c c 
c c c 
c  c c c
obligation subsisting c c cc c  cc7  c/c  c1cc c*.c
" c

›c c c c 


c c 

cc  c c c c   cc c
 c c 
cc c  c> 9cc/ c .c" c c !  c c
  
c  c c 
c 
c> 9ccc
c c
c c
cc
!  c c c   c ! c c c 
c c cc c> 9cc
! c c  c  
cc  c c ! cc  cc c c  c

cc  c  c c  c c cc c  c c c  c 
cc
 c 
c 
c  c c  c) cc c   cc  c
c
 
cc c! ! c c  
c  c c  c 
cc7  c
/c1 c/ %c  c c c c   ccc c c
c   c
: c
cc
 
c   cc c c 
c cc cc
cc
 c cc  c  c 
cc
cc c  cc c c :c
c 9 c
  ! cc c 9c c   c
 c
  c cc

c
!c c 
c cc c 
c c  5c:8cc  c c c cc
  c 
cc
c   c 9 c
cc
 
c   c 
cc c c

c  c+ 
cc! c !cc c  cc cc)
c c
c c 
c   cc cc  c! c c cc c  cc c c
  :c'!  c7 
c  c0c*
c! cc7 ! c+ c4 c0c
" c ! c1c c&
cc8  c c c c >cc c"c0-
0 ( têñ.£îhqw⣠2c c c 
c  cA c c c ccc
   cccc c c 
c !c ! ! cc c  -
&
ccc  c$cc c
  c
 
cc c
 c cc
c 
c
  c
cc c   cc c c 
!ccc  c
 c   c !c
cc c cc   c   cc (c
c cc   ccc
c c 
cc  c ccc
c   c cc    cA  c c &  cc
cc
cc
 c 
c !c cc
 cc cc c)
  c›cc ccc
 cc 
 cc 
c$c  c  c c  
 cc c> 9c c, c
 c 
c c 
c c    cc 9c c   cc: ! c
!c c c cc c  ccc/:ccc c
c c ! c
 
c  cc   cc ccc c ccc  c

+ c c
cc  c c 
cc   c*cc c
cc
 
c 9cc
 ! ccc   cc c 9c c   c
c7  c
/c .cc ccc   c c/cc c 
c cc   cc
: ! c!c c c cc c  ccc/: c'+  c*(c

A3?7?827?c c)
! cc c ccc 
c c c

c c
Reyes, J.B.L., Act. C.J., Dizon, Makalintal, Zaldivar, Castro, Fernando, Teehankee,
Villamor and Makasiar, JJ., concur.

c

P   %&$.!
(c

### $
  cc
 c
$P$/0
-,",!1$."1
2+3

1,! 4 , 4. +2
5.
6!,+78 &9
 ::
P5
PP P P
0.*
,!+
!"
!+2+3
 +3
!4,;
,-+ ,;+<=:
#:#:#
$ 
 c

P   %'$.!
(c

     cc


 c
  
P 5 !"# $ /
$ ,!3,-; * ;,+7 -
-,",!1$."1

1,! 4 , 4. +5.
6!,+7
 !;3& 
 c

cc

J >c

$-c c  cc cccc c)


  Úeople vs.
Hernandezcc c c 9 c  c ! c c ccc c c c c c

c -   ccc c 
ccc
 c c ccc     c$c c
 c c  !c 
c c c cc c  c%c c9c cc c
 !- cc c 9
c 9cc -c cc
c> c  c c 
c
  c
c c   c
cc  c
c c  c 
c
 c 
c
  c  c !c  c c   cc c c
& c c9
c 
c ! cc ! c c  cc!cc cc c  c
&  cc

$ c c  ccc
 c›c c  cc8  c*1c.c+   c4c
8 c,
c c c? c c  
cc c   c c
cc
 c/ 
c,cc c  c> cc› ! cc c !cc c
  c
cc3 c  c+ = cc c7 ! c$ cccF =cc
> c. cc c  c  c.. c$ c  c
c
cc c
 c!
c 
c   c c
c
cc c  cc c
cc
+ c+  c c/ c c$  c+  c c8 
 
c7 c
/  c 
c/ cc c? !c4  & c c !!c+  c
? c c c7  c 
c? 
c   c 
c; !c3  cc c
 cc  cc
c 
c  c 
c
c !
c
c

!c c 
cc c 
cc  cc   c*cc   c.c
. c+  c? c c 9 cc 
c
c !c c c >›c
&  cc
$ c/  c4  cc  c c !c c  

cc c c

c c
cc c  c   c$ c !c!c8  c*c.c c
 c!cc c$ cL ! ccF =cc  c c c! c cc

c  c
 c
cc c+  
cc c  c  cc>! c;  c?
! 
c
 c$  &cc

2c c  c
 cc8  c*c.c+  c? c!c c
c c
 cchabeas corpusc  c'c c 
cc c   c c

cc4 c*c.(c !!c c c c

ccc c!cc
 !cc !c 5cc

' (c
cc  cc c  cc
 cc cc c  c9cc

'(c !
cc c c  cc c cccc c c
 c
cc  c ! c c

c  c c

c
 c
 cc

'(c

cc!cc  c 
cc

'
(c  
c 
c
 
cc c !cc c  c
cc c)
! cc

ccc !c  c
 
c c   cc  c  c'c

$ cc
c cc 
cc   c4 c"c.c 
c c c cc
 !cc4 c0c. c(c2c4 c"c.c c+ c;   c
c c
 

c ccc c 
ccc  c 
cc; 7 c  c*0ccAc

c c    cc    c
cccc+  c? %c-

c c c7  c 
c? 
c   c 
c 
c c&  c
+ 
c c!
c c c  %c  c
 cc cc cHernandez  !c
   - 
ccc!cc c - c ccHernandezc !
c

c 
c cc c
cas a necessary means for the
commission of rebellion,   c c c ! c+  c? cet al.c !
c

c 
c 
c
c
con the occasion, but not in furtherance, of
rebellion.c+ 
c  c c+ c;   c
c
!c  c c
 c c':
c ):(c !cc c  c !c c   c c
c!c  ccc  
ccc c 
c  cc/ cc
7 
c  c
c 
cc c) cc cHernandez  !c 
c c
c
 c':
c :(c !cc c! c c!ccc c!  cc
c!  c  c  
ccc cc  cc c  c  ! ccc
Hernandezc cc 
c 
ccc   cc
cc   cc

$ c  c  c 
cc c ! c c

cc4 c0c.c  c
c cc
cc7  cc c  c
 c)c! !c+  c? c 
c
 c   c c c  c

cc c !cc*cc
c c cc c
cc..... ..c'c+  c? (c 
c
*..... ..c'c c   (c    c$ c7  c 
c cc c
c
c )
 cc c c  

c  cc c  cc c c
 cc c  c 
c 
c cc cc !cc c ! c c
 
ccc   c8c4  cc ccc
c ! c! !c  cc
+  c? c 
ccc ! c! !c  cc c    cc

$ ccc

  c c c c c c  c 


c 
c ! 
cc
+  c? %c c; 7 c  c*0 cc

$ c  %c c 
c c c  
c ccc c !c5cc

' (c  
cHernandezc 
c
c cc c  
cc c c
 cc
 c4  cc 
c  c c  c c c c c c

c c
c/ ccc c7 
c  c
c  c c  c c
 
ccc  c-
ccc c!! 
cc c
+ c;   cc c ! c !cccc 
ccc c
!cc

c c
'(c
cHernandezc    c cc  c
cc   cc c c
   c cc ccc  cccc c
cc c
 cc c  cc c c::c cc!  cc c!  c
   cc

'(c  cHernandez c  !cc 9 c  c c c c  c



ccc c  ccc   cccccc   c
   cc

2c ccc  c'(c4  cc cc


c ! c  
!c
3  
= c$c'*(c4  c c c c
 c
c c -  
c?c›c c
 cc c )c c !c  c!
c cc  c 
c ! c  c
  c
c c & c ! c 
cc c c  c  
c  c
   c !cc  c c  c   c$c cc 
cc c c
 ccc !c !c c c 
c  !c c c
c c
0c8
cc ccc  c !c c 
 c  c  c
*cc c c ! cc  c!cc cc  = cHernandezcc
 !c c cc'/ c*-/(cc c7 
c  c
cc c  c c
:'( cc ccc c cc cc c c  =
ccc  c
'  c›cc$ c cc 
c  (c cc c  cc
c!  c   c  c
cc c  c
c c  cc cc
 c  ccc c 
c c c
cc c 
 :%cc›c
c !c c 
cc  cc !  c c  
cHernandez c
!c

 cc c  cc  c$ cc c


cc c c 
cc c  c
 !c  c c  c  c c ! cc
! cc

2c c 
cc cc  c
cc ) c c c c
Hernandezccc
c c 
ccc   cc  c
c c c
   c cc ccc  c 
c c c !c
cc c
  
c c!c c !cc  cc cc c

cc c cccc   c   cA cc4  cc
 cc c c c %c ! c  cc  c

cc c c
 c c c c  cc cc  c c  cc c c c
ccHernandezcc cc c !cc  cc c c  c

ccc c
c  cc c  
c  cc/ cc cc

c cc c !c  cc c )ccc c  5cc

$  cc c c - 


c c
  c c c -c/ cccc  c

c c c  
cc c  c c  c›c
c  cc 
cc
  c 
c cc c  c
c    c' !c cc
c c

 (c c !c   c
c c  cc c c  5c'(cc
 c cc  c c cc 
!c*....c 
cprision mayor, c c
 
!c 
c
 
!cc c
!c  c  cc
  c 
!c*c ccprision mayor, 
c'*(cc c cc
creclusion
temporalccc c 
cc
c
 
!cc c
!c
  c   cc c
cc c   cc !!  !c  c
the extreme penalty could not be imposedcc c3  c
c/ cc 
c
penalty would have to be meted outccceven in the absence of a single
aggravating circumstance. $c 
ccc
cccc c
 cc c c
c unfavorablecc c  cc

Bc c c 


c 
c/ cc c  
cc c ccfavoring  c
 ccc  !ccc c  cmore severec c cc
c c
 cc c   c c 
ccc  c
c     c›c c
cc
7
! =c  5cc

, c c
c  c c c c
cc
c
c c& c
  c    c  c  c'1"c
c
!c
c *(c  c 
c
    c c ccc  %c'››c c  c
c$ c
+ c
c?  c c*0 (cc

c  c
A c  c   cc c c cc  c  cc/ c1c'  c1"(cc c
+ c  c
c' c  ccc/ c(c c  

cc.c 
c c
c *c
!5cc

, c
 c
c  c  ccc    c c c c

c& cc c c c
cc c
cc 
c cc

c c c
c   c  c  c c cc

?c c c c c


 c c  c 
  c c
c
 c!  c cc!
c c  c c  c& c   c c
 c
c c& c
  c  c  
c  
  c c

 cc

 
c c  c c
c 
c
c  c  c c
   c c
cc  
 c'7
! =c  c c
  c
c$ c+ c@ c››c c*0 (cc


c cc/ cc
 cc c c&  c 
cc 
c  
 c
 !c ccc c  cc c!  c  ccc c 
c
c c  c cc
 cc 
c cc cc c   c  cc c
c !
c  c
cc     c$ c   cc 
c  ccc  c

c
 cccc
c  c  c ccc 
c/ c c›

cc
 c c ccc c  c  c c cc cc c c
 c!  c c c 
cc c cc 
c  cc!   c›c

 !c c c  cc c!  c  c ccc  c
ccc
 c 
c/ cc
c  c
cc c c cc  c c
  clowerc c c !! !  cc c   cc c  cc
c
     c$ c ccc   ccc  ccc
 c
  c
A ccc c c  c c  cc c! c c c 
cc

c c
   c c c cc 
c cc    c 
c
c  c›
c
c  !ccc c c
 
 cc c c cc c c
 cc c  cc c c c cc c c ccc c
!  c c cc cc c    c   cc c  c%cc

$ c ) cccc  c 
c
  c c c !cc cc
cc cHernandezc  c
!c
 c  !ccc c
 !cc  cc c c  c
cc c c  c
 c c c c   ccccc c c 

c  cc c
c c c   cc

$c  c
 cc cfiniscc c  c  %c! cc  ccc
  c&
ccc c
)
!
c$ ccc c ccc
c c c c
 c$ c%c !c  c
c c 9 -ccc c
cc c
& c  cc c  %c c c c
 ccc!c 
cc
 c cc c  c c c 9  cc

$ cc c c'c c cccc (c c c c


c ! c c
  c
 cc c ! c c  c ! 
!c c)   c !c
 c
c c  cc
c 
c  c 
c
c c

 ccc c
c c !!csimple rebellion c$ccHernandezc cc
 
5cc

›c c c


c cunder the allegations of the amended information ! c

 
-  c/
c@ c3  
=c c
c c 
c  c


c  c  cmere ingredients c c cc  c !
c
c
c 
c
 
c c c:   :c'(cc c   cc 
c  cc
  c c c cchargedcc c   
c  

c cc
   c c  cc c c cc  cc  c
c
c 
c  c c c c  c  c
cc ! c
 c 
c  c'*(c ccprision mayorc 
c c cc*3333c 
c cc
cc c ccccc
!cc 
c c    cc c
 c c 
c
 
c c c 
c  c c
&

c c
$ c cc  %c c c cc !
cc c c c
 cc cc
 c  c9c c  c cc c c cc c
c c
  c cc c 
cc c  c
cc c c
  cc   c c

c c c  c !cc  c7
cc c c
cHernandezc c c
 c

c ! c c  cc c c

c

c
cc c7 
c  c
5c c   cc

A c c  c !


cc c c !c c c
c 
6c
  c ! c

#c$ c 
cc  c c c c
! c  cc c  c c
cc c cc c  c> c
c› ! c 
c cc c !cc 
c c c  c ! c
 c

cc c 
c c  !cc c !cc c
& 
c  c'c$  cc!c   c ! cc cc cc
 !c ! c c 
c c
 cc c  c
  cc cc
 !
cc c c cc  
cc c 
 c
 
c
!c c
  c !  cc

›cc c 

c c c 
c
! c
c c  cc  %c
 cccpersonallyc
 !c c   cc  c  cc
 !c
c cc  c c  c 
cc  cc c
c/ c›››c  c*cc c c(c$cc c 
c
c  c cc
cc c 
 c
cc c)
! cc 9 cc c  c   cc
 !c c c c c   
c
 ccpersonallyc   !c c
 c 
c c!c
 c
cc c  c  c c
 c c  cc  c
c  c cc 
c c c  c c  c
 c 
ccc c 
c
! cc 
c!  c c  c c cc
  c!c c c c 
cc c  c !  cc4  c
   c 
c 
c
c c c!c
c c c  c c 
c
ccc cc c
c! cc cc  c c c
ccc

cc  cc 
cc
 c c! c  c cc  c
 c ! c c c c
c c c !  c 
cc

  c c c c c c



c c!cc  c›c c !cc c%c
  ccHernandezc c    cc  %c  c 
cc c ! c 
c
   c c c c c ! cc
c c

c c
 !!c c c cc c  ccc   c  cc c
cc c  
c c c c c>c c& c  5c; c c
 cccc  c  c c c cchabeas corpuscccc c
  c  cc  !c c!cc  cc
 !cc
 #cc

$ c c  c  c c 


c
! c c c c  cc9!c
 c  %c!cc  c c  c 
!c c 
c)
!  c$ c
! c)
cc! cc
c  c 
cc 
c 
 c$ c c
 c cc  cc9 c c)
cc !c c cc c

c
c  c !c c!cc  c c cc cc c 9 cc c 
 c
! c c2 c  c c 
c c

cc c cc
c c  c
)
cccc  c c9
c 
c  c cccc  !c
c ccc/ cc   c  c c c    c  cc

? c    cc  %c  c c!!cc cHernandezc !c c


 c ! c c-  c cc  c =!cc c  c c
 cc ! c c c c  c
cc  cc)cc c
 cc 
  cB
c  c c cc  c
c  c c
ccc& c!cc c c c  c c 
c
! c)cc

$  cc cc cc& c c/ c c!


ccc  c c


c c  c c  c  c cc c  cc cc

c  c
 !
cc c cc
c cccc c cc c
 !c  ccc c 
c
! cc
!cc c ! c ! c
c  c! c)  cc c c  c  c 
c
! c 
c
c
  c c!cc  c
cc
  ccc cc

$  c c 
ccc cc  c c c  cc cc  c& c
 c 
c c  cc   cc c 
c
! -

cc c
c
c c
 !c 
c c c ccc cc c   c
c
c cc ccc cc  
 c  c cc
& c
 cc  cccc

!c c ccc c
c)c
c !c   
c)
 c  c
!
cc
 c c ! c!c
 c  ccc c    ccc c c 
c c cc
c4  cc cc ! c c! cc  cc  5c c c c c c
c
ccc c   c
ccc! c)
cc! cc

c  c 
ccc 
cc c  c

c ccc cc  c›c
 9 cc
   c c c 
c
! c  c
c c  cc  c!c
c  c›  c  c c c !c c %c
  
c ! 
!c  c!cc c c  
c c c  c cc
 c)
! cmotu propriocc c c  c !c  c c  c  cc !
c›cc
c c  c cc c 
c cccc  c c c  

c
c
cc c c!cc c  c !c 
c  cccc c !cc
 9 cc c 
 c ! c cc

›cc cccc c c  c c c!! 


c cccccc
 c  cc c c c c    c 9!c c ccc
 cc
 cc c  cc 9!c  cc c ! c  c)c 
c
$ c   ccc c c c
cc c
c c c  c
 c  c
cc 
cc!c
  ccc cc

c c   c c  c c


cc c cc c  c
 cc c   cc c c%c 
cccc)
 c!
c

c c
c c
c cc c 
c! c!c ccc


c c  cc c  c>ccc
!c cc c  cc
! c c c c 
c c 

c c

c 
c
 c! cc

!c c
c  c 
cc c cc 
c 
ccc c
c c  c 
cc c

cc c c 
cc c c  cc c
cc/ cc   c

, cc c
c c c c   c cc cc ! c   cc c
! cccc c 9 c c  c c  c-c c)
 c c

c
ccc c  cc c  cc c! c   cc
 c  c cA c cc c c 
cc & c    cc 
c
 c
c c cc c   c c'; 7 c  c*0(ccc c›
 cc
 cc  c? cc  cmilieuc 
cc   c
   cc c  c
 c 
c c c+ 
c c  c 
c

c%c c
  cc  c
c ! c c c- 
cc  c? cc c
  c  c.-.c c c c  
c  c >›c c/ 
c,cc c
 cc4 cc.c c  c 9 cc
c 
c
 
cc  c
c c !cc 
c  cc - c -c c c! cc

›c c c cc c !cc  c  c c cc  c c c c
&   c&c& c c) c c  c  ccccc
 ! 

c 
c
cc c c  -
c  c  c c
cc  cc
c cc cc c 
c  c  cc  c c  c cc
c!cc  c c cc c  cc 
cc 
cc c cc
 c  c !cc
 cc   c c c cc ! c
  c9 !c!c9
 !c 
c 
c  cccc c

c c
 c  c
c c c   
c ! c c  c c ! c c
  ccc 
c ! c   ccc  c 
cc-
c  cc c
 cc c!!c   cc

›cc !cc! c  c  - 


c cccc  - cc  c c


c ccc  cc c  ccc  !c  c cc

 cc c c  c 


c c  c c c  c c
   c$  cc c   c
cc  c c cc  c  cc
  c c  c  ccc  c
 c 
c
c c c  cc c


c c 
c  cc cc c c   c =
c c c
 cc  ccc ! c c
 9 ccc  c$ cc cc
 cc  cc ! ccc c c  c c c cc 
c c c! c
 c 
c cc

c  c 
c    c3  c! c c
   c c
cc c =!c c  ccc  ccc  c
cc cc

A3?7?827?c cc    c c 


cc c
 c  
ccÚeople
vs. Hernandez,c c& 
c c
c ! c  c c c
? c 
c c c7  c 
c? 
c   cc c
c c !!c
 c  c c  c 
c  c  c 
cc  c  c c
c c c  cc! c$ c%c   c! cc  cc  c !c
  c cc   c c
!ccc  c  c

c
7?4/ ?cc c 
c
! ccc c cc  cc c
cc c
   c2 c  cc
cc 
c 
cc cc c  c c
 
!c  c
c 
cccc c  cfunctus oficio c c
  c cc cc

+2c27?7? cc

Cruz, Gancayco and Regalado, JJ., concur.

Medialdea, J., concurs in G.R. „o. 92164 but took no part in G.R. „o. 92163.

Cortes and Griño-Aquino, JJ., are on leave.

cc

cc


* +
*,!,!-c
cc

?#J., !5c

›c)cc ! cc
!c c cHernandezc
 cc c ccc
c c c c

c  c!
c c 
cc
c  c

c

 c 
c ! ccc c c  c c 
cc ! cc
   cc

›c 9 c  cc c c  c chabeas corpusc cc c c


 
 cc

3
c c› c
c c !
c  c c c cc7  c c
c
c  c c  c>c c› c !
c7  c
 
cc4
c 
c4  c8 
c4
c c cc
 cc c

c c
cc  c9 c$ c ! c c c 

cc 9 c c  cc c
c c  ccc c 
c  cc c 
c cc
/ ccc c7 
c  c
c$cc  c c  

cc c
› cc c c 
cc cA  cc/ c
cc c$ c
 cc

B
c c  
c  c   cc  c
c c4ccF c  c
 c  cc
cc  c!c c c
c  cc  c
  c c  c c 9! c!c c 
cc 
c4c  c c
 cc  c
c  c
cc !cc
  c> 
c c
AccHabeas Corpusc c c c  cc  c 
ccc c   c
 c c  
cc'  =c ccc/ c*c+7/c00 ( cc

›cc c chabeas corpusc


c
  cc c c c cc
c
c
c cc c c
cc c cc

$ cc  cc  c)


cc c c  c›cc  c c
c cc c

cc  c c
cc)
c cc ! c
 
c  %c   c3  cccc    cc

$ ccc  ccc    cc   c cc  c   c>c


  c c
 cc  cc c  cc c c
cc ccc
)
! ccc cc c)
! cc   c cc
  c c c  
c c
It may still be invoked though if the process, judgment or sentence proceeded from a
court or tribunal the jurisdiction of which may be assailed. Even if it had authority to
act at the outset, it is now the prevailing doctrine that a deprivation of constitutional
right, if shown to exist, would oust it of jurisdiction. In such a case, habeas corpus
could be relied upon to regain one's libertyc'  c c  c c+7/c (c
D? c  E cc

$ c cchabeas corpus  c  c 


cc c cc  %c
 c!cc  c c c  c
c c  c  cc c c
c c   c  c 
c c ccc  c 
c 
cc 
cc
c c c

c  cc-  cc  cc

A c ! c


c c c c  
c c cc c)
 c

c!c

ccccc 9!c!=  cc c!c  cc !c
! c c c c
 c c 
! cc

$ c cchabeas corpusc  cc c   c


c';   c cF c*c c
."(c ccchabeas corpusc !c c
  c cc  ! 
!c


 c
c ! c  c 
c  c  c  c$ c c 
c  c
c c-c  cc c c  cc ! c
 -its ability to cut through
barriers of form and procedural mazes-  c  c c  =
c 
c)  c
! 

ccc 
c  9 c'; c c cc> ccc 1c
+7/c*.(cD  c 
E cc

$ c   cc  ccccc 


cc c 9 ccc c
 c!c cc c  cc c cc ! c c cc
7  c 
cc cc  c 
!c c c cc
c
cc c
cc c 
cc c ! c 
c
c! 
c c
 cc   cc

›c

ccc

cc 9 c c cc7  c c  c  c'c
  ccreclusion perpetua(c c 
c  cc !  c>c/ c*-/cc
c c7 
c  c
c !cc  c  c*c  c 
cc !c
:   :cc?2c  c1cc"c c1 c?2c1c c   c

c c
/ c c' 
c c   
(cc c7 
c  c
c c: 
ccc
 c c 
c  c cc 
c  c 
c  
c
  :c3 !c cc

c c
 
cccc  cc cc !  cc   c
c c! cc
 -  !c c 
c
 c c:  c9cc :-c c c cc
7  cc4
 c$ c  
cc c  cc c  ccc c

!ccc
 c$ cAccHabeas Corpus  c 
cc c

c

P/$ J., !5c

›c)c c%c
cc! c c  c›c   !c c c c
c
!c c  c cc c 
cc
c cc  = c c
c c !  c c - cc   cc  c c  ccc
 c$ ccc   cc!  cc

›c cc    ccc 9 c cc›c c  c c !cc


  c  c   ccc c
  c c
cc c c

c  c c 
cc

›c ! cc c  c c c cc  ccc


  cc c c

 cc  c c!cc  cB
c c  c  ccc  c
  c c  c
cc c  c$ c
cc cc cc

8c c cc c   c   cc c


cc  c c3  
=cc
 c""c'"0(c c  cccc ccc  c9c c  c
 
cc
c c
c
cc cc c  cc

cc c cc  c 
c c c cc c  !cc c

cc  cc c c  ccc c  cc c c


 cc c -  c c 
c cc

+ 
cHernandezc c c c cc c  c›c c c   
cc & c
   c   c/ c  c 
c  c c
c  c   cc c
 c
/ cc  c c
 c -  
c  c c  c ) 
ccc
 cc

$
c 
c4 c!c c ccc c !  c c
c  c
  c*c  c !c c c cc  c 
cc  c
9 c
c  c!  c   c  c
cc  c3  c 
c/&c
!c c c !  c c   c 
cc*cc!c?  c2
c
1 c+ c  c  
c c cc  c 
cc
c 
c
cc
 c c cHernandezc
 c  c c !c c$ c c c
c  
ccccc  !c c  c   c
ccc c
 
 c$ c cc  c& c c cc c 
cc
  !c c   c
 c c
 cc 
!cc c  c
cc
  cc c! cc

8c c -   cc c3  


=c
 c!c c cc c
 cc c c ccccc ccc ! c  c? c
c c
  c c  c c c 
cc
cc
  c cc
 c
c   c  c c  cccc c cc c cc

c
c c c c+  cc  
c  cc

/
cc c  cc
!cc  cc cHernandez   cc !c
 c c9 !c !
cc c c  c
c:c c ccc
c c   c cc ccc  :c  cc 
c
 &  c 
c! c c c  cc   c$c
c c c
 c cc

cc$@-cc9 c!  c c  cc c
  c   c c cc c   c cc 9 c c  c
c

c c
3  cc c  cc c9 c c  cc c !
c c

!cc cc  c  c 


cc
c   c c9 !c
c  ccc   cc c cc c  c 
c   c c9 !c
 c c:c c cccc c%   c c%c ccc
   cc

$c ! cc  cc

$ c cc  ccc c  c$ c


!cc cc c c
 
c c c    c cc   c  c
c c
!cc c

c
cc c!cc 
cc  c!c c c9 ccc c

c
c 
cc    c  cc ccc c c  cc  cc
 c
cc  c 
c  c$ c  c c c c  cc    c
   c
 
!cc c9 c c cc - cc c
9 !cc
 cc cc c
cc   c$ c c c  c
!cc c !   c c cc c c 
cc  c c9 !cc  c c
!c  cc  c  c c   cc c  c c !cc
c  ! c   c 
c c cc c  c c
cc c ! !
cc
   cA c c 
c
cccc   c c cc  cc c
! c c c c cc  cc 
cc c   cA c c c
/ ccc c7 
c  c
cc  cc --c -  
c !  c$ c
9 !cc  c
!c c  c  9cc  c   c c c  c 
c
c cc c   cc

$ c cc c   c   cc c c  c


  c›c c

 
cc c c
! c
c c  cc  cc  ! c
  c  c c c 
cwas not entitled to bail c$ c  c c
c
c cccc c
cc c  
cwithout bailcc c  c c$ c
 cc!cc  c c   
c
 cc c+  c cA cc

c c  cc  
c c cc   
c
 c 
cc c -
9c+  cc ! cc

/ cc
c   c c cc cc c
 
c)
 c c
 c
cc !cc c c  c/cc
c  c cc c
 
cc c c 
c 
c ccc  c    c
8 
cc c c !!c c   c-  c c cduty of a trial
court is to throw it out.c2c c c c c 
c  c c 9 cccc
 c  cc

/c  cc c -   c 


c   c c
cc c+  cc
  c c
c  c 
cc c  cA  c c
! c
 ! c
c c+  cc !c cc cc  cc   cc c
ccc

c
cc   c3  c c)
! c c 
c c
c c
  c 
c c  c c  must follow the Supreme Court precedent.c
/c cc cc)
cc   cc! c 
cc c+  c
 c›cc  c  cc
c  c c c+ c;   c!ccc
cc& c c  c%c ) cc c   cc c  cc  c
c  c›c
c  c c c+ -;   c9!c c cc -
  c
cc c  c 9!cc c
cc c  cc c-
 c cc

$ c c c  !5cc

7 
ccc/ c c c

cc c c c c›c
cc  c

cc c c cc c ! c& c 
c$c$ c !c9 cc

c cc  c›cc c c c  c$  cc   ccc  cc
>   c c>   c',- "c c c1.c c+7/c(c%$ c
  c 9cc
  !c c!  c c   cc c cc cc c

c c
  c
c c
 ccc c c
  cc
cc c
)
  c›cc
 ! c c cc c c c c   !cc c c
c
  cc c    cc c cc  c$c  c  cc ! c
 c 
c 
ccc cc 9cc c c›c
 ccc c
! c 
c! c!c c! c)
 c! cc cA cc c c

c c
 c 
c   c
!cc c!c c  c 9cc
 c)
 c   c$ c  cc
 c 
cc %c'Ibidc.1 c$ ccc
 c,  cc  c c@  c0"c c"0cD 1Ec c
( c$ c !c
  ! cc ccc>   c c  = c c5c+c c!c c
   
cc ccc c > , c7  c 
c c  =
cc  c

5c%
! c; 
c  c
cc c 

c c c+  ccc

c 
ccc cc)
 c
 c c c c
cc c c
cccc c c  cc c)  c  c$  cc c c+  c
cc c
c c cc
c 9 c c ! c'Ibid c c
 > , c7  c9 ccc/  c ccc8c›  cc4  c'> c@›(c,-
*0 0c4 c*c0c* c+7/cc0 c'$!
c ccc/ c"c+7/c
**0cD1E c+ c c/  c ccc8c›  c* c+7/ccD0Ec 
c@-
 c+!c 
c4  c+  c› c c ,7c*"c+7/c"11cD E(cc

›c
c c c Spouses Úanlilio v. Úrosecutors Fernando de Leon, et al.c  c
 c    c›c c  cc c   c c  c  ccc c
-c  c cc  c 
cc
c c cc c
cc
 c ccc c 
cc c  cc

›c  c! c c c 


c 
c
!c
cc c  cc c
+  c c›c  
c  cc c c ! c
!c c !c 
cc
 c& c   c c c c &  cc  c  c cc
 
c›c cc  ccc& cc c cccc c  c
c c  cc  c c  c cthat the evidence would be submitted in due
timecc c c cc

$ c c   c 


c c  c  c cc c   c cc


 cB
c c 
cc  c c c   c cc c
  ! cc  c
cc  cc c- cc c   c$ c 
c
cccc   cc c cc
c c  c
cc c 
c
)  c c cc c c c  c
c cc cc)c


!c  c 
c c  c c 9  cc cc  
c
  c 
cc  c 
c  ccc  cc c!  ! c
? cc cc != c cc c  c 
c  ccc c  cc
 cc
    c c c c c  c- cc c   cc

$ c c cc  c  ccc c 


cc c   c  cc c
!
c c c c  c 
c
cc  c c c? c 
c 
c c
 c c 9
ccc cc c  cc cc!cc c
   c  c ccc! c!cc  c  cc c
 cc

›cSalonga v. Cruz Úaño,c c+7/c c'"(c c+  c+ ! c c !


c
c c cc c c!cc c  c   c c cc
 
c cc
c  c   c  
cc c!c! c 9 c

!c c
c cc cB
c+  cc c+  c 
c c!  c›c c
c  cc c
c!c c!c c3  ccc c  cc c
!cc
c!c c  !cc
cc

$ cccSalongac 
5cc

$ c cc c  c ! ccc  c c c ! c c
 c 
c  c c 
cc ccc c c 
c c
 cc cc c c   c 
c  cc c c c 
c c
c c c  cc c 
c   c  c'$c c4  cc+7/c
*c!c3 c c> c1c c*0( c$ c!cc c  c ! c

c  c
c c c! c 
cc
cc
c cc ! c c
 c
  c'+ c  c c2 
 c*"c+7/c*11(c3  cc
cc c c

 c c  cccc !c c c  c ! cc

cc
 c  cc 9!c c c c ! c cc   cc c/c
  c ! c  cc c c cc c+  c4 c cc
c c cc c!   cc
c 
c c cc  c!cc cc  c
cc c›cc   c   cc c cc c)
! c c c  c c
 cc   c c 
cc c cc!!c!c c c ccc   
c
 c c 
 cc cc c c c  c  cc cc  c
  c ccc c c  c cc c! cc c 
c/ !c  cc
c!   c cc
c cc c
  cc  c  c c c
  cc c


cc c !cc c
c !cc! c c 
c
c   c
 
cc c ! c
! cc c
!cccc c)
! c

!c c   cc c
!c
cc
 ! 
c c c  c c
)
! ccc cc c c
  cc c'+ c, c  c,  c+ / c
 c8  
=c*c+7/c ( c$ c)
! cc c   c
cc!ccc
 c cc c c c c
 c 
 c!c  ccc
!c
 ccc
c c c ! c cc c c!cc cc  c 
c
c
c›c c  !c c c)
 c  cccccc =!c 
c
c
! !c c! c+cc c c  c›c
c cc c
 c'id c c0-c0*(cc

>   cc c !!c›c 9 c  cc c cc c  cc c

c c c c !!c c   c$c  c

cc  cc
 c  c›c c c ! c
ccc cc c c
!
 cc
c c
! c c! c
cc c !!c
c›c  c
  c  c  cc c
   c  cc ! c c  cc c  c
ccc c
c c-   c$ c c 
c3  
=cc c
  
c+ c c c c
c cc c cc
cc
 !c
 cc c c c
c c 
c c c 
c
c c
 c !!c c c  c
c c
c/
cc; 7 c  c*0c c
 c c
c c
cc c  ccc c ccSalonga v. Cruz
Úatio, et al. (supra)c c c 
cc

$ ccccc c c  !c c;  cc!c c   c


 cc c   c›c c;  c c c c c c
 cc ccc c   c   c 9 c
cc c cc c
 c 9 c  c 
cc
c c 
ccc! cc c
 cc

›c   c cc;7/ $c c c 


cc27?7c c 
ccc
›+4›++c c
c cc c-  c cc

c

J., !5c

›ccc c  c 
cc c )cc c cc

›c   c c  c  c  c  cc Hernandezc


 c c c c  c
& cc c
c 
c   cc   c›c  cc
cc  c
  cc c c cc   c c  c/ c c 
c
/ c "cc c7 
c  c
c$cc c  cc  cc c ! c
 cc  ccc ! c  c›c c   c c  c cc/ c
 c' 
5c:7  cc› -3c
:(cc
c  c cc
/ c  cc covert actsc 
c ccriminal purposecc cc
!  c
c c c  cc   c$c/ c c  c c: c
 cc  cc
cc!c  c 
c 9!c c ! c c
;  c:' c c c c!c  (c:c c cc' c c
 c c cc  c)  (c !cc c !  cc 
c

c c
!  ccc c c cc c7  cc c  cc c c
  cc c
cc 
c  cc c 
c cc
!c c c
?  cc c, !  c cc  cc c cc !   :c/c
 c  c c/ c "c' 
5c:  cc7  cc›  :(c cc
c !cc cc  c  cc  cc c
c ccc
  cc 5c: ! !!cc c ! c c cc c;  c

!c cc!c c  c  !ccc

 !c c
cc c  c ccc c  c c
 
:c/ c  c
 cc  cgenerally?c2c  c c  c

ccc c:cpromote [ ], maintain [ ] or head [ ] a rebellion or
insurrection"cc  cc  c
cc  cc c  cby
public officers or employees?c  c c cc c ! c cc  c
  cc c
c  cc c c 
c c
   c cc
!
 cc c cc  c
c c7 
c  c
c 
cc c c
 
c
 !c c
cc 9!cc cc c  cc c)  c
c c  cc  cc

$ c
 c cc c c 
cc c cc   c c c  c c
 c 
c& cc c c  ccc -   c c c c c
cc
c cHernandezc
 c  c 
cc  c c c
   =
c c    cc
  c  cc c c  cc c c  c
 c 
c    cc  cc 
c
c ccc/ c
cc c7 
c  c
cc'c  cc 
c  c*c  (c  c
 ! c c   cc c cc'*(c
c   c$c cc c
 cc c  c c c
c c c c›c c c  cc 
!cc c

  c-  c c'/ cc c
c/ c**c7 
c
  c
ccc cc/ cc c
( cc

$ c-  c c   cc  c  c>c  c


cc cc
 c  cc  c cc c  cc  cc c cc! c
 cc)
 c
c  !c c c
 c
c!c
 cc! c c  c 
c ccc c›c c c c
c  c 
cc c!  c 
cc cc cc 
c c
!  c  c ! cc cc'cCaltex v. Úalomarcc+7/c*1c
D00E( c$c cc ! c c)
 c   cc c  c  c c
c c c cc c
 c c c c c! c  
c›c   cc cc
cc c  
c! c  c c c)
 c
 cc 
cc  c
 c  !c c c !c
 cc !c 
!c'  c 0c (c 
c
c  cc  c c  c
cc cc  c 
c c c

 cc c cc c 


c c c - !c c'  c c
  c""c+7/c0.1cD1Ec  c c,  c0"c+7/c*1.cD1"Ec; c c
 ccc 1c+7/c*.cD1E( c4  c c-  c c
  cc  cc !  c cc)
 c
c c c
   c$ c   !c cc cB
c+  cc c c)
 c
c c
   c 
c c c cc   c c  cc c  c
 
cc c  cc    cc c ! c 
cc c
 c ! c cc c c 
c c
 c c  c'> c ccc
  c 1cB+c 1*c, c?
c*
ccD0Ec4 9c cB + c cB+cc"c, c?
c
*
c*0.cD11Ec  c c c4 c   cc c00c8 c*
c c
DE( cc

›cc!
cc c+ c;   c c c-  c c
 cc
  c c c cc c c c cHernandez
 c c 
c
c/ cc 
c  cc c7 
c  c
c 
ccc cc
  c  c ccc  c cc  cc/ cc c c;  c
  c9  c›cc  c cc c
c  cHernandezc c
   c cc c 
c  c   =
c/
c !c cHernandezc

c  c

c cc   =
c & c  c  cc cHernandezc
 cc
 cc
cc
!c  c  c cc  c 
c c 
c
  cc/ cc' ! c  c c; c..c c.cD"0Ec  c c
7
! =c.1c c0"cD0.E( c$cc  cc c c c c& c

c c  c c cc
 c !  c
c  c    c
cc


c cHernandezc
 c c  !c   cc/ cc 
c
  ccc ! c
  c c c c& c
c c  c c
 c
 c  c
cc c;  c
c  c  c c

cc c
 cc   ! c !  c'c cc   ! c   cc c (cc c
  cc/ c c 
c "cc c7 
c  c
c c  
cc c
cc cHernandezc 
c & c   c$c  c c& c c  c
 c
c c cc c c !  c  c   cc cc c
 c 
cc cc 
cc   c4  c
 cc

8 c  c  cc cc& c c c c


 c c c;  c

c  cc
 cc cc c c c ! cc c7 
c  c

cc *c
c c c cc c 
c 
c c c c
  cc cHernandezc
 c c
cc  c c
cc
 c cc 
cc   cc c cc  cc c

c

cc c  cc c   cc

›c ! c   c c c ccc  cc c 


c c !!c c
 c cc c   c

c

m.J., !c 
c
 !5c

›c c 
cc cc    ccc c cc c c!
c

   cc c"0c !cc c c$ c c ! cc c
 c
 
cc c  ccÚeople vs. Hernandez,cc c""c'"0(c
c c c

  c c
cc
 c c    cc 
c
 cc cc 9 cc
  cc  
c 
c - 
c cc c c 
c
)
 cc

$cc
c c3  
=c
 c
cc c  
c c c -  !c
cc c c c cc c
cc c ccc
   cccc cc  c  c 
cc c   c$c c
 c›c c!c !cc c cc c )cc c c  c c
%3  
=c  c
!c
 c  !ccc c !cc  c
c c c  c
cc c c  c  c c c c
   ccccc c c 

c  cc c c c c
  :c' cc ( cc

$ c3  
=c
 c c 
c c cccc c 
cc c
cc"0c
!c c-
c  cc c39 c$ c ! cc
c cc c cc c c c c  c - !c  cc c -
 !c    cc c
 c
!c c  !  cc    c

cc =!c c cc c
 c
c;  cc  
cc
/ c c 
c "cc c7 
c  c
c 
c c & c  cc c
 ccc  c$ c
 c c!
c c cc›c   c c  cc c
  c  cc c3  
=c
 c c
c   cc

Ac c
 c  cc c ccc  cc cc›c   c c cc
c c c  c
c  c c

c c
c  c cc
  cc  cindispensablecc ccc  cc c c 
c

c c cc  c c  merely necessaryccc
   cc c

c c
cc  cc c  c$ c )cc ccc cc

!c  c 
c c cc3  
=c  c c c c  c
   
c c c   c cc!c  ccc c  cc c
 c c  !c  9!c c
c c

c c c c c
  c 
cc c

c
c c  cc c c cc
'/ c(cc c7 
c  c
c/cc c  cc3  
=c cc
  c 
cc c c  cc
!c cc
   cc cc
  c   cc ccc c  c  !ccc c c c
c c 9 c
c c c  c
cc c ccc c
 cc  c  c 
cc 

cc c  c c  c   cc

$ c   cc c
cc! c c   cc  
cc
   c  c  !cccc
 c$   c c c
cc
   cc ccc  cc    c c c  c
c c  cc c c cc  c   ccc
   cc c
cc  ccc c  cc c  c 
cc 
c c  c

c!c c  9!c cc c  cc c c c
c'/ c(cc c7 
c  c
cAc c
cc c

c ! c;  c c 
c cc c cc  c  c
  c

c
   c c cc  c 
c  c ! c 
c
cc c c!
 cc  c  ccc c
c ! c
 c  c cc c ccc c cc  c 
cc   c
  c c c   ccc
   cc!c c  c 
c c
   cc c

c c  cc c 
c cc   c$c   c
 c
c!c
!c 
c cc  c  c!  c
 c 
c c  c  c 
cc c  c 
c
c c c  !c
c c!cc  c c 
c c c  c c  c
   c
c !cc c   c>c
   c!c
c c 
c c
  cc c cc  c c !c c  c !c
 cc c
   cc c  c
cc c 
cc c cc  c c c
 c cc  c   ccc
   c›c c  c  c/ cc
c c7 
c  c
c
c   cc

$ c  cc cc


%c  cccc c c
cc =!c c cc
 c
 -
c!  cc !!c c  9cc!c  cc
 ccccc
c 9 c)
 c c c

c c c

 cc c   cc ccc  c 


c cc c
7 
c  c
c;   c c c
cc =!c c cc c
 c

c!  cc cc c  cc  c
c c
7 
c  c
cc c
c cc
%  c c cc c cc  c
$ c  ccc  c 
c c  c 
c !
ccc  cc c  c
c c  c
!c cc
%  cc c
 c
c 
c
cc
c  
cc c7 
c  c
cc c cc  c c  
c
c ccc c-
c  cc c".% c/cc
%  c c c
 
c  ccc   c !cc ccc c
 c cc c
c c9
 !c c  c   cc c
 cc c 
c c  c!ccc   c›c   c  c  c

c c c 
c cc c  c
cc c cc
cc
%c  c c
c  
cc  cc cc   c 
c cc

   cc ccc cc
%  c
c c  9! c


c c cc
c  c
 cc c  cc  c   cc

›ccc c  c c c c c c  c  


cc ccc›c 9 c
 cc c cc c )cc c
c   cc c3  
=c

 c

J., !c 
c
 !5cc

c  c
›ccc c )cc  c c ! 
c c
 cc  c
c
c c  
cc c  cc c 
c)
! cc c
!c
cc c cc  cc c
cc c   cc

›cc c c


!c
cc c  

cc c 
c)
! cc c
 cc!c  c c c  c
c c
 c  c c !!c
 c  c c  ccc   c &   habeas corpuscc c
 c 
c    cc  c c c 
cc
c c !
cc
 c  c c   c  ccc
c c

cc!cc  cc c
 
c)
! cc cc  %c c!cc  c›c c  c
 c  cc!c c cc  c 
c  c  c c
c

  cccc  c  ccc c 



cc  cc c c

! cc

›cc
  c c  cc
cc  cc c  cc!cc c

 
c 
c  c c7 ! c$ ccc c  c c c  c
'+ c c/ c›››cc 
c+ c c7 c( c  cc  cBc
c c cchabeas corpusc !c !c ccc c  cc
  c+ c c  c !
c'
c c c  (c
cc  ccc
 cccc c   ccc)
c c c cchabeas
corpusc'+ c"c'(c/ c@›››cc+ c*c7 c.*(cc! c
  cc!cc  c 
c !c

ccc  ccc c c  cc
cc c cc
c   c$   c c c & c c: c

!c!  cc c
:c cc c 
cc c 
c c
c'+ cc7 c.*( cc

/
! c c c
cc c ccc..... ..c
cc  cc
c c  c ccc  c

c4 c0c.c
cc
 c

c 
c

c cc  c
ccc c  cc c  c
' c  (c 
!c  c c 
c)
! cc  cc c
  
cc c
!c

ccc'  %(c    c  c
 c ccc 
cc
cc)
! cc c 
c  cc

cc

J., !c 
c
 !5cc

›c ! c c  c c3  
=cc
c 
c4 c c c

c  c
cc c 
cc c c 
cc c ccc)
 c c c

 cc

/c3  
=ccc  c c: ! !!cc c ! c c cc c
!  :c%cc  c: cc c &cc c 
c  c
 cc  c 
cc  cc  c
 ! cc c c
) c 
c cc  c 
c c! c  c 
c  c c c  cc
c 9 c :c&c  c
cc   cc c c   c cc c
ccc c cc   c$c c c  c c c 
c
c c c  ccc  c
ccc cc c
cc c
   c   c  c 
c
c !c c c  cc

›c c ! c c c c c 


c c c  cc c   c
+ c c c 
cc c!c  c  c c 

cc c
 c c  cc
c c c !c  cc c  ! c
   cc c  c c cc  cc c c

c'cc

/c c  c c!  c


c c  
c c cc c  c
 c c c  
 c cc  cc  cc

c c
›c
 c  c c c c )c
c c  
cc c  cc  cc
 c  c c›c 9 cc c c ccc7  cc4 c0c.c! 
c
 c  c: c  :cc c !cc c
cc..... ..c c
! 
cc  c$ c c c c!  cc: c  :cccc ccc
 c   c  c c c   c›c c  cc  c cc
  c c cc c c
c ! c c c  c  c c 
c
 c c  cc 
cc  c
 cc

cc

J.,
 !5c

›ccc c )cc c cc


c c c !ccÚeople vs.
Hernandez,cc c""c:  c
!c
 c  !ccc c
 !cc  cc c c  c
cc c c  c
 c c c c   ccccc c c 

c  cc c
c c c   :cc

›c
 c  cc c )cc c cc
c c c cc
& c c !!c c c cc  cc
c 
c  c
 
c
c"is to be read as charging simple rebellion." c

$ c  c  c  cc c


!
cc Hernandezc  cc c c c
'(c   c   c›c cHernandezc  ccc c
cc c
appealed casec c3  
=c
c c
cc c ccc c c
 cc  cc
c c 
c c 
cc cc c 
cc  c
  c c+  cc 
!c  c!  ccc cc  
c
Hernandezc
 c c c cc  c 
cc
c c 
c
 c
 cc  c›c c  c  cc c c 
c ccc

cc coriginal casec c  c c c c c   c
cc
 c cc 
c c  c  cc  c

c   cc

8  c c+  ccc cHernandezc  c c:!


- 9!:cc
 c cc  c  c c c 
cc
c c c  c›c
 c  c  cc c c 
c c c 
c c  ccc c

c cHernandez
 c'as case law(cc?  c2
c  c1cc 
c
 =c c/&c

c"c c1c'as statutory law(cc
c cc c ! c
c cthe crime of rebellion complexed with murder, and multiple frustrated
murder does not exist. c

/
c c 
!c  cunmistakable 
controlling  c !-  c
 ccc 
c
c cHernandezc
 - c c c
cc
 !c 
c c  cc c 
cc !c c c !!c c
  cc  c 
cc
c c  c 
c
 cThat
information is clearly a nullity and plainly void ab initio.c›c
c
cc c

cc  c/c c cc  c cc ! c!cc c! c c
c! c$ c  cc  c
c c  c  c c c 
c
c c c
 ccc c  c 
c/
c c c  c& cc c
 %c 
cc  c ccc  c  cc  c›c  cc
 c c c ccfatally defective,c  c
c
 c c   cc
 ! c c c c'(c  c'+  c c7 c.c7 cc( cc

›cc c cccccccc  != c c



c 
c c c  c

 c cc  !cc: =!:cc


   cc cc  c
 cc c$ c cc c centirely newcand properc ccc
 c   cc c c c
 cc c cc

c c
/27› ;,Ic›c cc;7/ $c c cFB/+3c c  cc  c 
c
27?7c c cc  c 
cc
c 
c  c 
c

cc c  c  c.-.c7$ccF =cc›+4›++? cc

 &  c c  c


c c

c    c 
c 
c c
  c 
cc

Úaras, J., concurs.

cc

c


* +
*,!,!-c

?#J., !5c

›c)cc ! cc
!c c cHernandezc
 cc c ccc
c c c c

c  c!
c c 
cc
c  c

c

 c 
c ! ccc c c  c c 
cc ! cc
   cc

›c 9 c  cc c c  c chabeas corpusc cc c c


 
 cc

3
c c› c
c c !
c  c c c cc7  c c
c
c  c c  c>c c› c !
c7  c
 
cc4
c 
c4  c8 
c4
c c cc
 cc c
cc  c9 c$ c ! c c c 

cc 9 c c  cc c
c c  ccc c 
c  cc c 
c cc
/ ccc c7 
c  c
c$cc  c c  

cc c
› cc c c 
cc cA  cc/ c
cc c$ c
 cc

B
c c  
c  c   cc  c
c c4ccF c  c
 c  cc
cc  c!c c c
c  cc  c
  c c  c c 9! c!c c 
cc 
c4c  c c
 cc  c
c  c
cc !cc
  c> 
c c
AccHabeas Corpusc c c c  cc  c 
ccc c   c
 c c  
cc'  =c ccc/ c*c+7/c00 ( cc

›cc c chabeas corpusc


c
  cc c c c cc
c
c
c cc c c
cc c cc

$ cc  cc  c)


cc c c  c›cc  c c
c cc c

cc  c c
cc)
c cc ! c
 
c  %c   c3  cccc    cc

$ ccc  ccc    cc   c cc  c   c>c


  c c
 cc  cc c  cc c c
cc ccc
)
! ccc cc c)
! cc   c cc
  c c c  
c c
It may still be invoked though if the process, judgment or sentence proceeded from a
court or tribunal the jurisdiction of which may be assailed. Even if it had authority to
act at the outset, it is now the prevailing doctrine that a deprivation of constitutional
right, if shown to exist, would oust it of jurisdiction. In such a case, habeas corpus
could be relied upon to regain one's libertyc'  c c  c c+7/c (c
D? c  E cc

c c
$ c cchabeas corpus  c  c 
cc c cc  %c
 c!cc  c c c  c
c c  c  cc c c
c c   c  c 
c c ccc  c 
c 
cc 
cc
c c c

c  cc-  cc  cc

A c ! c


c c c c  
c c cc c)
 c

c!c

ccccc 9!c!=  cc c!c  cc !c
! c c c c
 c c 
! cc

$ c cchabeas corpusc  cc c   c


c';   c cF c*c c
."(c ccchabeas corpusc !c c
  c cc  ! 
!c


 c
c ! c  c 
c  c  c  c$ c c 
c  c
c c-c  cc c c  cc ! c
 -its ability to cut through
barriers of form and procedural mazes-  c  c c  =
c 
c)  c
! 

ccc 
c  9 c'; c c cc> ccc 1c
+7/c*.(cD  c 
E cc

$ c   cc  ccccc 


cc c 9 ccc c
 c!c cc c  cc c cc ! c c cc
7  c 
cc cc  c 
!c c c cc
c
cc c
cc c 
cc c ! c 
c
c! 
c c
 cc   cc

›c

ccc

cc 9 c c cc7  c c  c  c'c
  ccreclusion perpetua(c c 
c  cc !  c>c/ c*-/cc
c c7 
c  c
c !cc  c  c*c  c 
cc !c
:   :cc?2c  c1cc"c c1 c?2c1c c   c

c c
/ c c' 
c c   
(cc c7 
c  c
c c: 
ccc
 c c 
c  c cc 
c  c 
c  
c
  :c3 !c cc
 
cccc  cc cc !  cc   c
c c! cc
 -  !c c 
c
 c c:  c9cc :-c c c cc
7  cc4
 c$ c  
cc c  cc c  ccc c

!ccc
 c$ cAccHabeas Corpus  c 
cc c

c

P/$ J., !5c

›c)c c%c
cc! c c  c›c   !c c c c
c
!c c  c cc c 
cc
c cc  = c c
c c !  c c - cc   cc  c c  ccc
 c$ ccc   cc!  cc

›c cc    ccc 9 c cc›c c  c c !cc


  c  c   ccc c
  c c
cc c c

c  c c 
cc

›c ! cc c  c c c cc  ccc


  cc c c

 cc  c c!cc  cB
c c  c  ccc  c
  c c  c
cc c  c$ c
cc cc cc

8c c cc c   c   cc c


cc  c c3  
=cc
 c""c'"0(c c  cccc ccc  c9c c  c
 
cc
c c
c
cc cc c  cc

cc c cc  c 
c c c cc c  !cc c

cc  cc c c  ccc c  cc c c


 cc c -  c c 
c cc

c c
+ 
cHernandezc c c c cc c  c›c c c   
cc & c
   c   c/ c  c 
c  c c
c  c   cc c
 c
/ cc  c c
 c -  
c  c c  c ) 
ccc
 cc

$
c 
c4 c!c c ccc c !  c c
c  c
  c*c  c !c c c cc  c 
cc  c
9 c
c  c!  c   c  c
cc  c3  c 
c/&c
!c c c !  c c   c 
cc*cc!c?  c2
c
1 c+ c  c  
c c cc  c 
cc
c 
c
cc
 c c cHernandezc
 c  c c !c c$ c c c
c  
ccccc  !c c  c   c
ccc c
 
 c$ c cc  c& c c cc c 
cc
  !c c   c
 c c
 cc 
!cc c  c
cc
  cc c! cc

8c c -   cc c3  


=c
 c!c c cc c
 cc c c ccccc ccc ! c  c? c
c c
  c c  c c c 
cc
cc
  c cc
 c
c   c  c c  cccc c cc c cc

c
c c c c+  cc  
c  cc

/
cc c  cc
!cc  cc cHernandez   cc !c
 c c9 !c !
cc c c  c
c:c c ccc
c c   c cc ccc  :c  cc 
c
 &  c 
c! c c c  cc   c$c
c c c
 c cc

cc$@-cc9 c!  c c  cc c
  c   c c cc c   c cc 9 c c  c
c
3  cc c  cc c9 c c  cc c !
c c

!cc cc  c  c 


cc
c   c c9 !c
c  ccc   cc c cc c  c 
c   c c9 !c
 c c:c c cccc c%   c c%c ccc
   cc

$c ! cc  cc

$ c cc  ccc c  c$ c


!cc cc c c
 
c c c    c cc   c  c
c c
!cc c

c
cc c!cc 
cc  c!c c c9 ccc c

c
c 
cc    c  cc ccc c c  cc  cc
 c
cc  c 
c  c$ c  c c c c  cc    c
   c
 
!cc c9 c c cc - cc c
9 !cc
 cc cc c
cc   c$ c c c  c
!cc c !   c c cc c c 
cc  c c9 !cc  c c
!c  cc  c  c c   cc c  c c !cc
c  ! c   c 
c c cc c  c c
cc c ! !
cc
   cA c c 
c
cccc   c c cc  cc c
! c c c c cc  cc 
cc c   cA c c c
/ ccc c7 
c  c
cc  cc --c -  
c !  c$ c
9 !cc  c
!c c  c  9cc  c   c c c  c 
c
c cc c   cc

$ c cc c   c   cc c c  c


  c›c c

 
cc c c
! c
c c  cc  cc  ! c
  c  c c c 
cwas not entitled to bail c$ c  c c
c
c cccc c
cc c  
cwithout bailcc c  c c$ c
 cc!cc  c c   
c
 cc c+  c cA cc

c c

c c  cc  
c c cc   
c
 c 
cc c -
9c+  cc ! cc

/ cc
c   c c cc cc c
 
c)
 c c
 c
cc !cc c c  c/cc
c  c cc c
 
cc c c 
c 
c ccc  c    c
8 
cc c c !!c c   c-  c c cduty of a trial
court is to throw it out.c2c c c c c 
c  c c 9 cccc
 c  cc

/c  cc c -   c 


c   c c
cc c+  cc
  c c
c  c 
cc c  cA  c c
! c
 ! c
c c+  cc !c cc cc  cc   cc c
ccc

c
cc   c3  c c)
! c c 
c c
c c
  c 
c c  c c  must follow the Supreme Court precedent.c
/c cc cc)
cc   cc! c 
cc c+  c
 c›cc  c  cc
c  c c c+ c;   c!ccc
cc& c c  c%c ) cc c   cc c  cc  c
c  c›c
c  c c c+ -;   c9!c c cc -
  c
cc c  c 9!cc c
cc c  cc c-
 c cc

$ c c c  !5cc

7 
ccc/ c c c

cc c c c c›c
cc  c

cc c c cc c ! c& c 
c$c$ c !c9 cc

c cc  c›cc c c c  c$  cc   ccc  cc
>   c c>   c',- "c c c1.c c+7/c(c%$ c
  c 9cc
  !c c!  c c   cc c cc cc c
  c
c c
 ccc c c
  cc
cc c
)
  c›cc
 ! c c cc c c c c   !cc c c
c
  cc c    cc c cc  c$c  c  cc ! c
 c 
c 
ccc cc 9cc c c›c
 ccc c
! c 
c! c!c c! c)
 c! cc cA cc c c

c c
 c 
c   c
!cc c!c c  c 9cc
 c)
 c   c$ c  cc
 c 
cc %c'Ibidc.1 c$ ccc
 c,  cc  c c@  c0"c c"0cD 1Ec c
( c$ c !c
  ! cc ccc>   c c  = c c5c+c c!c c
   
cc ccc c > , c7  c 
c c  =
cc  c

5c%
! c; 
c  c
cc c 

c c c+  ccc

c 
ccc cc)
 c
 c c c c
cc c c
cccc c c  cc c)  c  c$  cc c c+  c
cc c
c c cc
c 9 c c ! c'Ibid c c
 > , c7  c9 ccc/  c ccc8c›  cc4  c'> c@›(c,-
*0 0c4 c*c0c* c+7/cc0 c'$!
c ccc/ c"c+7/c
**0cD1E c+ c c/  c ccc8c›  c* c+7/ccD0Ec 
c@-
 c+!c 
c4  c+  c› c c ,7c*"c+7/c"11cD E(cc

›c
c c c Spouses Úanlilio v. Úrosecutors Fernando de Leon, et al.c  c
 c    c›c c  cc c   c c  c  ccc c
-c  c cc  c 
cc
c c cc c
cc
 c ccc c 
cc c  cc

›c  c! c c c 


c 
c
!c
cc c  cc c
+  c c›c  
c  cc c c ! c
!c c !c 
cc
 c& c   c c c c &  cc  c  c cc
 
c›c cc  ccc& cc c cccc c  c
c c  cc  c c  c cthat the evidence would be submitted in due
timecc c c cc

c  c
$ c c   c 
c c  c  c cc c   c cc


 cB
c c 
cc  c c c   c cc c
  ! cc  c
cc  cc c- cc c   c$ c 
c
cccc   cc c cc
c c  c
cc c 
c
)  c c cc c c c  c
c cc cc)c


!c  c 
c c  c c 9  cc cc  
c
  c 
cc  c 
c  ccc  cc c!  ! c
? cc cc != c cc c  c 
c  ccc c  cc
 cc
    c c c c c  c- cc c   cc

$ c c cc  c  ccc c 


cc c   c  cc c
!
c c c c  c 
c
cc  c c c? c 
c 
c c
 c c 9
ccc cc c  cc cc!cc c
   c  c ccc! c!cc  c  cc c
 cc

›cSalonga v. Cruz Úaño,c c+7/c c'"(c c+  c+ ! c c !


c
c c cc c c!cc c  c   c c cc
 
c cc
c  c   c  
cc c!c! c 9 c

!c c
c cc cB
c+  cc c+  c 
c c!  c›c c
c  cc c
c!c c!c c3  ccc c  cc c
!cc
c!c c  !cc
cc

$ cccSalongac 
5cc

$ c cc c  c ! ccc  c c c ! c c
 c 
c  c c 
cc ccc c c 
c c
 cc cc c c   c 
c  cc c c c 
c c
c c c  cc c 
c   c  c'$c c4  cc+7/c
*c!c3 c c> c1c c*0( c$ c!cc c  c ! c
c c c! c 
cc
cc
c cc ! c c
 c
  c'+ c  c c2 
 c*"c+7/c*11(c3  cc
cc c c

 c c  cccc !c c c  c ! cc

cc
 c  cc 9!c c c c ! c cc   cc c/c
  c ! c  cc c c cc c+  c4 c cc
c c cc c!   cc
c 
c c cc  c!cc cc  c
cc c›cc   c   cc c cc c)
! c c c  c c
 cc   c c 
cc c cc!!c!c c c ccc   
c
 c c 
 cc cc c c c  c  cc cc  c
  c ccc c c  c cc c! cc c 
c/ !c  cc
c!   c cc
c cc c
  cc  c  c c c
  cc c


cc c !cc c
c !cc! c c 
c
c   c
 
cc c ! c
! cc c
!cccc c)
! c

!c c   cc c
!c
cc
 ! 
c c c  c c
)
! ccc cc c c
  cc c'+ c, c  c,  c+ / c
 c8  
=c*c+7/c ( c$ c)
! cc c   c
cc!ccc
 c cc c c c c
 c 
 c!c  ccc
!c
 ccc
c c c ! c cc c c!cc cc  c 
c
c
c›c c  !c c c)
 c  cccccc =!c 
c
c
! !c c! c+cc c c  c›c
c cc c
 c'id c c0-c0*(cc

>   cc c !!c›c 9 c  cc c cc c  cc c

c c c c !!c c   c$c  c

cc  cc
 c  c›c c c ! c
ccc cc c c
!
 cc
c c
! c c! c
cc c !!c
c›c  c
  c  c  cc c
   c  cc ! c c  cc c  c
ccc c
c c-   c$ c c 
c3  
=cc c
  
c+ c c c c
c cc c cc
cc
 !c
 cc c c c
c c 
c c c 
c
c c
 c !!c c c  c
c c
c/
cc; 7 c  c*0c c

c c
 c c
c c
cc c  ccc c ccSalonga v. Cruz
Úatio, et al. (supra)c c c 
cc

$ ccccc c c  !c c;  cc!c c   c


 cc c   c›c c;  c c c c c c
 cc ccc c   c   c 9 c
cc c cc c
 c 9 c  c 
cc
c c 
ccc! cc c
 cc

›c   c cc;7/ $c c c 


cc27?7c c 
ccc
›+4›++c c
c cc c-  c cc

c

J., !5c

›ccc c  c 
cc c )cc c cc

›c   c c  c  c  c  cc Hernandezc


 c c c c  c
& cc c
c 
c   cc   c›c  cc
cc  c
  cc c c cc   c c  c/ c c 
c
/ c "cc c7 
c  c
c$cc c  cc  cc c ! c
 cc  ccc ! c  c›c c   c c  c cc/ c
 c' 
5c:7  cc› -3c
:(cc
c  c cc
/ c  cc covert actsc 
c ccriminal purposecc cc
!  c
c c c  cc   c$c/ c c  c c: c
 cc  cc
cc!c  c 
c 9!c c ! c c
;  c:' c c c c!c  (c:c c cc' c c
 c c cc  c)  (c !cc c !  cc 
c
!  ccc c c cc c7  cc c  cc c c
  cc c
cc 
c  cc c 
c cc
!c c c
?  cc c, !  c cc  cc c cc !   :c/c
 c  c c/ c "c' 
5c:  cc7  cc›  :(c cc
c !cc cc  c  cc  cc c
c ccc
  cc 5c: ! !!cc c ! c c cc c;  c

!c cc!c c  c  !ccc

 !c c
cc c  c ccc c  c c
 
:c/ c  c
 cc  cgenerally?c2c  c c  c

ccc c:cpromote [ ], maintain [ ] or head [ ] a rebellion or
insurrection"cc  cc  c
cc  cc c  cby
public officers or employees?c  c c cc c ! c cc  c
  cc c
c  cc c c 
c c
   c cc
!
 cc c cc  c
c c7 
c  c
c 
cc c c
 
c
 !c c
cc 9!cc cc c  cc c)  c
c c  cc  cc

$ c
 c cc c c 
cc c cc   c c c  c c
 c 
c& cc c c  ccc -   c c c c c
cc
c cHernandezc
 c  c 
cc  c c c
   =
c c    cc
  c  cc c c  cc c c  c
 c 
c    cc  cc 
c
c ccc/ c
cc c7 
c  c
cc'c  cc 
c  c*c  (c  c
 ! c c   cc c cc'*(c
c   c$c cc c
 cc c  c c c
c c c c›c c c  cc 
!cc c

  c-  c c'/ cc c
c/ c**c7 
c
  c
ccc cc/ cc c
( cc

c  c
$ c-  c c   cc  c  c>c  c
cc cc
 c  cc  c cc c  cc  cc c cc! c
 cc)
 c
c  !c c c
 c
c!c
 cc! c c  c 
c ccc c›c c c c
c  c 
cc c!  c 
cc cc cc 
c c
!  c  c ! cc cc'cCaltex v. Úalomarcc+7/c*1c
D00E( c$c cc ! c c)
 c   cc c  c  c c
c c c cc c
 c c c c c! c  
c›c   cc cc
cc c  
c! c  c c c)
 c
 cc 
cc  c
 c  !c c c !c
 cc !c 
!c'  c 0c (c 
c
c  cc  c c  c
cc cc  c 
c c c

 cc c cc c 


c c c - !c c'  c c
  c""c+7/c0.1cD1Ec  c c,  c0"c+7/c*1.cD1"Ec; c c
 ccc 1c+7/c*.cD1E( c4  c c-  c c
  cc  cc !  c cc)
 c
c c c
   c$ c   !c cc cB
c+  cc c c)
 c
c c
   c 
c c c cc   c c  cc c  c
 
cc c  cc    cc c ! c 
cc c
 c ! c cc c c 
c c
 c c  c'> c ccc
  c 1cB+c 1*c, c?
c*
ccD0Ec4 9c cB + c cB+cc"c, c?
c
*
c*0.cD11Ec  c c c4 c   cc c00c8 c*
c c
DE( cc

›cc!
cc c+ c;   c c c-  c c
 cc
  c c c cc c c c cHernandez
 c c 
c
c/ cc 
c  cc c7 
c  c
c 
ccc cc
  c  c ccc  c cc  cc/ cc c c;  c
  c9  c›cc  c cc c
c  cHernandezc c
   c cc c 
c  c   =
c/
c !c cHernandezc

c cc   =
c & c  c  cc cHernandezc
 cc
 cc
cc
!c  c  c cc  c 
c c 
c
  cc/ cc' ! c  c c; c..c c.cD"0Ec  c c
7
! =c.1c c0"cD0.E( c$cc  cc c c c c& c

c c  c c cc
 c !  c
c  c    c
cc


c cHernandezc
 c c  !c   cc/ cc 
c
  ccc ! c
  c c c c& c
c c  c c
 c
 c  c
cc c;  c
c  c  c c

cc c
 cc   ! c !  c'c cc   ! c   cc c (cc c
  cc/ c c 
c "cc c7 
c  c
c c  
cc c
cc cHernandezc 
c & c   c$c  c c& c c  c
 c
c c cc c c !  c  c   cc cc c
 c 
cc cc 
cc   c4  c
 cc

8 c  c  cc cc& c c c c


 c c c;  c

c  cc
 cc cc c c c ! cc c7 
c  c

cc *c
c c c cc c 
c 
c c c c
  cc cHernandezc
 c c
cc  c c
cc
 c cc 
cc   cc c cc  cc c

c

cc c  cc c   cc

›c ! c   c c c ccc  cc c 


c c !!c c
 c cc c   c

c

m.J., !c 
c
 !5c

c c
›c c 
cc cc    ccc c cc c c!
c

   cc c"0c !cc c c$ c c ! cc c
 c
 
cc c  ccÚeople vs. Hernandez,cc c""c'"0(c
c c c

  c c
cc
 c c    cc 
c
 cc cc 9 cc
  cc  
c 
c - 
c cc c c 
c
)
 cc

$cc
c c3  
=c
 c
cc c  
c c c -  !c
cc c c c cc c
cc c ccc
   cccc cc  c  c 
cc c   c$c c
 c›c c!c !cc c cc c )cc c c  c c
%3  
=c  c
!c
 c  !ccc c !cc  c
c c c  c
cc c c  c  c c c c
   ccccc c c 

c  cc c c c c
  :c' cc ( cc

$ c3  
=c
 c c 
c c cccc c 
cc c
cc"0c
!c c-
c  cc c39 c$ c ! cc
c cc c cc c c c c  c - !c  cc c -
 !c    cc c
 c
!c c  !  cc    c

cc =!c c cc c
 c
c;  cc  
cc
/ c c 
c "cc c7 
c  c
c 
c c & c  cc c
 ccc  c$ c
 c c!
c c cc›c   c c  cc c
  c  cc c3  
=c
 c c
c   cc

Ac c
 c  cc c ccc  cc cc›c   c c cc
c c c  c
c  c c

c c
c  c cc
  cc  cindispensablecc ccc  cc c c 
c

c c cc  c c  merely necessaryccc
   cc c
cc  cc c  c$ c )cc ccc cc

!c  c 
c c cc3  
=c  c c c c  c
   
c c c   c cc!c  ccc c  cc c
 c c  !c  9!c c
c c

c c c c c
  c 
cc c

c
c c  cc c c cc
'/ c(cc c7 
c  c
c/cc c  cc3  
=c cc
  c 
cc c c  cc
!c cc
   cc cc
  c   cc ccc c  c  !ccc c c c
c c 9 c
c c c  c
cc c ccc c
 cc  c  c 
cc 

cc c  c c  c   cc

$ c   cc c
cc! c c   cc  
cc
   c  c  !cccc
 c$   c c c
cc
   cc ccc  cc    c c c  c
c c  cc c c cc  c   ccc
   cc c
cc  ccc c  cc c  c 
cc 
c c  c

c!c c  9!c cc c  cc c c c
c'/ c(cc c7 
c  c
cAc c
cc c

c ! c;  c c 
c cc c cc  c  c
  c

c
   c c cc  c 
c  c ! c 
c
cc c c!
 cc  c  ccc c
c ! c
 c  c cc c ccc c cc  c 
cc   c
  c c c   ccc
   cc!c c  c 
c c
   cc c

c c  cc c 
c cc   c$c   c
 c
c!c
!c 
c cc  c  c!  c
 c 
c c  c  c 
cc c  c 
c
c c c  !c
c c!cc  c c 
c c c  c c  c
   c
c !cc c   c>c
   c!c
c c 
c c

c  c
  cc c cc  c c !c c  c !c
 cc c
   cc c  c
cc c 
cc c cc  c c c
 c cc  c   ccc
   c›c c  c  c/ cc
c c7 
c  c
c
c   cc

$ c  cc cc


%c  cccc c c
cc =!c c cc
 c
 -
c!  cc !!c c  9cc!c  cc
 ccccc
c 9 c)
 c c c

c c c

 cc c   cc ccc  c 


c cc c
7 
c  c
c;   c c c
cc =!c c cc c
 c

c!  cc cc c  cc  c
c c
7 
c  c
cc c
c cc
%  c c cc c cc  c
$ c  ccc  c 
c c  c 
c !
ccc  cc c  c
c c  c
!c cc
%  cc c
 c
c 
c
cc
c  
cc c7 
c  c
cc c cc  c c  
c
c ccc c-
c  cc c".% c/cc
%  c c c
 
c  ccc   c !cc ccc c
 c cc c
c c9
 !c c  c   cc c
 cc c 
c c  c!ccc   c›c   c  c  c

c c c 
c cc c  c
cc c cc
cc
%c  c c
c  
cc  cc cc   c 
c cc

   cc ccc cc
%  c
c c  9! c


c c cc
c  c
 cc c  cc  c   cc

›ccc c  c c c c c c  c  


cc ccc›c 9 c
 cc c cc c )cc c
c   cc c3  
=c

 c

J., !c 
c
 !5cc

›ccc c )cc  c c ! 


c c
 cc  c
c
c c  
cc c  cc c 
c)
! cc c
!c
cc c cc  cc c
cc c   cc

›cc c c


!c
cc c  

cc c 
c)
! cc c
 cc!c  c c c  c
c c
 c  c c !!c
 c  c c  ccc   c &   habeas corpuscc c
 c 
c    cc  c c c 
cc
c c !
cc
 c  c c   c  ccc
c c

cc!cc  cc c
 
c)
! cc cc  %c c!cc  c›c c  c
 c  cc!c c cc  c 
c  c  c c
c

  cccc  c  ccc c 



cc  cc c c

! cc

›cc
  c c  cc
cc  cc c  cc!cc c

 
c 
c  c c7 ! c$ ccc c  c c c  c
'+ c c/ c›››cc 
c+ c c7 c( c  cc  cBc
c c cchabeas corpusc !c !c ccc c  cc
  c+ c c  c !
c'
c c c  (c
cc  ccc
 cccc c   ccc)
c c c cchabeas
corpusc'+ c"c'(c/ c@›››cc+ c*c7 c.*(cc! c
  cc!cc  c 
c !c

ccc  ccc c c  cc
cc c cc
c   c$   c c c & c c: c

!c!  cc c
:c cc c 
cc c 
c c
c'+ cc7 c.*( cc

c c
/
! c c c
cc c ccc..... ..c
cc  cc
c c  c ccc  c

c4 c0c.c
cc
 c

c 
c

c cc  c
ccc c  cc c  c
' c  (c 
!c  c c 
c)
! cc  cc c
  
cc c
!c

ccc'  %(c    c  c
 c ccc 
cc
cc)
! cc c 
c  cc

cc

J., !c 
c
 !5cc

›c ! c c  c c3  
=cc
c 
c4 c c c

c  c
cc c 
cc c c 
cc c ccc)
 c c c

 cc

/c3  
=ccc  c c: ! !!cc c ! c c cc c
!  :c%cc  c: cc c &cc c 
c  c
 cc  c 
cc  cc  c
 ! cc c c
) c 
c cc  c 
c c! c  c 
c  c c c  cc
c 9 c :c&c  c
cc   cc c c   c cc c
ccc c cc   c$c c c  c c c 
c
c c c  ccc  c
ccc cc c
cc c
   c   c  c 
c
c !c c c  cc

›c c ! c c c c c 


c c c  cc c   c
+ c c c 
cc c!c  c  c c 

cc c
 c c  cc
c c c !c  cc c  ! c
   cc c  c c cc  cc c c

c'cc

/c c  c c!  c


c c  
c c cc c  c
 c c c  
 c cc  cc  cc

›c
 c  c c c c )c
c c  
cc c  cc  cc
 c  c c›c 9 cc c c ccc7  cc4 c0c.c! 
c
 c  c: c  :cc c !cc c
cc..... ..c c
! 
cc  c$ c c c c!  cc: c  :cccc ccc
 c   c  c c c   c›c c  cc  c cc
  c c cc c c
c ! c c c  c  c c 
c
 c c  cc 
cc  c
 cc

cc

J.,
 !5c

›ccc c )cc c cc


c c c !ccÚeople vs.
Hernandez,cc c""c:  c
!c
 c  !ccc c
 !cc  cc c c  c
cc c c  c
 c c c c   ccccc c c 

c  cc c
c c c   :cc

›c
 c  cc c )cc c cc
c c c cc
& c c !!c c c cc  cc
c 
c  c
 
c
c"is to be read as charging simple rebellion." c

$ c  c  c  cc c


!
cc Hernandezc  cc c c c
'(c   c   c›c cHernandezc  ccc c
cc c
appealed casec c3  
=c
c c
cc c ccc c c

c c
 cc  cc
c c 
c c 
cc cc c 
cc  c
  c c+  cc 
!c  c!  ccc cc  
c
Hernandezc
 c c c cc  c 
cc
c c 
c
 c
 cc  c›c c  c  cc c c 
c ccc

cc coriginal casec c  c c c c c   c
cc
 c cc 
c c  c  cc  c

c   cc

8  c c+  ccc cHernandezc  c c:!


- 9!:cc
 c cc  c  c c c 
cc
c c c  c›c
 c  c  cc c c 
c c c 
c c  ccc c

c cHernandez
 c'as case law(cc?  c2
c  c1cc 
c
 =c c/&c

c"c c1c'as statutory law(cc
c cc c ! c
c cthe crime of rebellion complexed with murder, and multiple frustrated
murder does not exist. c

/
c c 
!c  cunmistakable 
controlling  c !-  c
 ccc 
c
c cHernandezc
 - c c c
cc
 !c 
c c  cc c 
cc !c c c !!c c
  cc  c 
cc
c c  c 
c
 cThat
information is clearly a nullity and plainly void ab initio.c›c
c
cc c

cc  c/c c cc  c cc ! c!cc c! c c
c! c$ c  cc  c
c c  c  c c c 
c
c c c
 ccc c  c 
c/
c c c  c& cc c
 %c 
cc  c ccc  c  cc  c›c  cc
 c c c ccfatally defective,c  c
c
 c c   cc
 ! c c c c'(c  c'+  c c7 c.c7 cc( cc

›cc c cccccccc  != c c



c 
c c c  c

 c cc  !cc: =!:cc


   cc cc  c
 cc c$ c cc c centirely newcand properc ccc
 c   cc c c c
 cc c cc

/27› ;,Ic›c cc;7/ $c c cFB/+3c c  cc  c 


c
27?7c c cc  c 
cc
c 
c  c 
c

cc c  c  c.-.c7$ccF =cc›+4›++? cc

 &  c c  c


c c

c    c 
c 
c c
  c 
cc

Úaras, J., concurs.

c

P   ?&'%* ,4&)(c

 ,!3,-@!
3 42 !"!
3 422+3
 ,! -
 !" A !"?P:
 $   
$#  !" Ac

: /,!3
@!
3 42 !"!
3 4223

,! ;3,4"
!$ !": 44-. !
"
 +,!
6A !"/ !"/Ac

 ,!3
@!
3 42 !"!
3 4223

,! ;3,4"
!$$ !" 44-. !
"
Ac

c c
:P ,!3
@!
3 42 !"!
3 4223

,! ;3,4"
!PP !": 44-. !
"Ac

 /,!3
@!
3 42 !"!
3 422
3
 ,! ;3,4"
!#/#: !"
$  44-. !
"/Ac

$ ,!3
@!
3 42 !"!
3 4223

,! ;3,4"
!$/$  !"B 44-. !
"
  cc
 c
#BP !"# $ 
-,",!1$."1

2 !;3B. +2, -+!-+ !;
2 !,4  
 c

Rodolfo C. Úacampara for petitioners.

Tito M. Villaluna for respondents.

c

CJ.:c

$cc c cc  c c


cc c ccc8c›  cc4  c
> cJ›››c

c   c0c0c
!c  %c cc
 ! c
c c!
cc 9cc)
 c

  c  c c cc c


 
c   cc c4!c c
'    c  
cc c (cc c9!c cc c c

!
c  c c$ c> ! cc c*c01c

c c c  cc c
  -c c
c cc c cc c c+  c c c
! c c cc cc!  c c 
c ! c ! !  c 
c

   c 
cc 9 c c &
c  cc c cc c  ccc
 c9!c
!
ccc c c
5cc

ccc

 c$ cc  cc 


ccc c*01c c
 
c3›,?Jcc!c

c 9 c ! !  c 
c
 c 
c
   c   cc 9 c c &
c
  cc c
 c cc c  ccc c9!c
!
c c c
 c 
cc c cc c c 
c c c 
c ! c
 c ! 
c
c c;  c c  c 
c! c cc  c 
c
cc
  cc c cc  c c c c  c> 9c -+-cc 
c
!c 
c  
c c0..c c cc9 c c 
c9c cc  c
 !c  
c  cc c9!c  c cc ..c  cc c  c
 cc c 
c
 c c cc% 9cc c  cc c  cc c

!
cc
 ccc c  c   c".....cc
 cc9 c c9c
c 
c  c  
cc  c
c 
c
!c c c 
c 
cc 
c
ccc c  cc   c c'"(c
 c c
!
c9!c
c cc 
c 
cc   c
  c 
c & cc 9
c c   cc c  c !ccc
 cc cc c  c  
cc 
!c c 
cc c c 
!c
  ! c   
cc c c  cc

. c$ ccc cc c9 cc  c c9!c c


 
c3›,?J%c
 cc c 
c
 c c'"(c  c  cc   cc c !c  c**c
  c 
cc c c1c
c 
c c c*cc c 
!c c
  
ccc  ! c1c    c  c c   cc c  c
 
!c c c ccc c c! c cc c  c c  c

cc c cc c cc  cc 
c
 cc
 
c
3›,?J%c
cc  
c  c  cc c
 ! 
ccc
c
! c 
c c
 cc c  cc

c c
ccc

 c$ c
 
c3›,?Jcc c 
c c c 
c c c 
c ! c

 c ! 
cc c
 c
c  c c ccc c+  c
 c  c  
ccc c7 cc ! c ! c1- c/ c%>%c
  cc c 
c  cc
cc c9!c
!
c c
   c cc c cc c  c 
!c c c cc
c
 c  c  cc !c
c
!c c c00c  c c c  !c
 ccc **.*" ..cc c !c  c  cc1  ..c c cc
c/ c7 cc c c 

c   c c00c 
cc !! !  c  c
 !cc"1. ..c cc   c c00cc

ccc

' c*-c  (c

/ccc
c

c4 cc0c c
cc c !!c c c  c
c cc  c 
cc c
 c 
c  c 
cc cc
c cA9 %c  c/c'/c *c c  

cc7/c11*(c 
c c
 c ccc8c›  c cc)
c c c  c  c
c
cc

c4 c*1c0cc c 
ccc
c !c c c
  cc c  cc 
cc ccc cA9 %c  c
/ccc ccc c c
c !c c  
cc  c c 
c
  c
 ! c   5cc

/ c*10 cA  cc ccc  c


 ! cc  c  c !c  c
c ! !  cc !
cc cc c
 ! c
 c+c  cc ! !  cc
  ccc -c !c  c c  c c  cc
c c& -

c 
cc! 
cc cccc   cc

/ c*1 c$ ccc  c1*cc1c  c c    cc c& -

 cc

'(c/ c1 <$ c  cc ! !  cc c !ccc ccc c



 !  ccc &
cc c  cc c ! c 
c 
cc c
  cc c cc c c 
cc c  cA c ! !  cc

c c ccc/ c1c 
c**.c  ! c*c c   c

/ c**. ccccccccccc

›c  cc 
c
c c  cc c 
c c !c c c  c
c c
 ! cc c c   c 
cc c-   cc c
 !  cc

/ c**  c›c& -


c   c
 ! c c c! 
cc c
 
c

cc!c ! !  cc

/ c c  c 
c c )
c  c  c
c 
c
! c
c c
c


c c*1c0c
!c c  cc c!
c cc cc c
  c)
cc cA9 %c  c c2c  %c
cc 
 cc c 
c
c 
c
! cc+   c* c
0c 

c 
c c 
cc
cc c*1c0c 
c 
c cc
 c c  cc c  c c
cc 
c c   
c
c
c c
cc   cc

2c   c0c0c 


c
! c

c c  cc 9cc)
c

c
c cc 
 cc c   
c)
 c cA9 %c
  cc c   c! c)
c c
 ! cc
  c cc9- 
c
cc) cc9 cc
  c   cc  ccc c   c c ! ! c

!c cc
 c   %c ! !  c  cc9- 
c
cc) c c   c

c c
 c cc+ c-/cc cA9 %c  c/c c

 c
  c & cc".Kcc c  c
cc c/ c

  cc
c c  c  cc

›c c c  c 


c c !c ! cc 5c

›cc

$3?c,2A?7c2B7$c?77?c› c›+4›++› ;c$3?c,/› $›88+-c?$›$›2 ?7+%c


24,/› $c827c,/Lc28cB7›+›$›2 cc

››cc

$3?c,2A?7c2B7$c?77?c› c8/›,› ;c$2c2 +›?7c$3?c,?/7c


›+$› $›2 c>?$A?? c,/›4+c827c/4/;?+cB ?7c$3?c›@›,c2?c/ c
,/›4+c827c24? +/$›2 cB ?7c$3?cA27L4? %+c24? +/$›2 c
/$ cc

/cc

›c cc ! cc c  c ! c c c  cc c)
c
 c c  cc c c c cc 
cc ccc c c

cc
 ! c   c/ c*10c*1c1 c**.c 
c** c 
cc
c ccc cA9 %c  c/ c$ ccc c c
 c ! c!c 
c = c ! !  cc c cc cc  !cc 9 c
 c   c cc c cc c  ccc   c9!c

!
c$ c c  c c c c
cc c ccc
cc
 cca quoc c ! cc c c 
!c c 
cc c
  c  c

c

cc

›c c 
c ! cc c  c     c c 
c
! c
 
cc c c
c  c c cc  c
c c
A9 %c  c/c 
c c cc
 ! c 
cc!c
 ! !  cc c
c c c
c$ ccc c9 %c
  c  cc   cc  cc c  !cc)c

  cc
cc c9!c c!c
 c 
cc
  cc
 ! 
cc c  cc ! !  cc c   c c c cc
 ! c
c
 c c
cc  c
cc c ! cc  cc c   %c
  cc 9 c 
c c ! !  c  !cc c
cc c   c

ccc c ! cc c)
cc
)
  c c  cc

2c c c 


c c  c c9- 
c) c  c   c
  c
c ccc+ c"c 
c0cc cA9 %c
  c/cc
5cc

+? c" cExclusive right to compensation <$ c!c 


c 
 c! 
ccc
/cc c   cc cc c  c)c  !ccc  c c
 
c c c!c 
c 
 c !cc c   cc  c
     c
 
cc  cc9c ! c c   c
c c c

c 
c c c   cc 
c)c cc

+? c0 cJurisdiction <c$ cA9 %c  c c c  c


  c)
cc c 
c

c cc  c
c c
A9 %c  c/c) cc  cc c+  cc c

 c c c  cc4  c c8 cA c'c c""cD"0E(c  cc c

c c: c cc9 c ! c c   cc
 ! c
 cc 
c

c  c
 
cc c cc   c c c ! 
c 
c
)
 
cc c
A9 %c  c:c) cc  cc c+  c cc

 c  c c c c c c   c c ! ! c


 cc  c c
  cc c   c   cc   c
c cA9 %c  c
/c   c+ c-/cc c/c
c c

 c  cc  c c


  c  cc cc c &  cc  c c
cc cc
  c 
 c›c cccc c c   c 
c c  c

 c c  c 


c c c  c  c c  
cc  cc c

 
c c  c c cc = c8   cc
c c c  c

cc c!  c cc
 ! c
c c c
c

›c c !ccc  c cB


   cc, c› c>c c/ c
?
! 
c/!  cc 
cc cB cc c  c c4  c
, = c c  c c 
c/ c;   c4  ! cc c;+›+c, ! c
/ c   c 
c cc? c  cBc, c  c
 c8 c> ! c  
c camici curiae 
c   c
c c
   c  
cc

$ c cc c  
c cA?c 
cc c  cc   c*0c10c5cc

A  c c cc c)


c   cc9 cc ccc cc  ccc

c
c cA9 %c  c/cc   c  cc  c
 ccc c  cccc %c cc   c 
cc 9!c c

c  c

c
c cA9 %c  c/cc  c
 c  c c!cc cc cc c  c   !cc c9 %c!c

c cA9 %c  c/c 
c!cc c ! cc
c c
 c
cc! c
 ! c'  c c 
6c   (cc c   cc
 cc ! !  c'c  (cc c   cccc c   cc  c
 c c   c  ccc c c c c 
c  c

c cA9 %c  c/c 
c cc

cc
 ! cc c
 ! c c

$  c  c
 ! cccc  c c, = ccc cc c c
)
c   cc9 cc c cc  ccc
c c  c c c
c  c
 ! c'c  c
c cA9 %c  c/(c
c c ! ccc c cc ! !  cc c   c cc c c

c c/ c/!  c   c  c3 cc c c 
cc c
)
c   cc9- 
c)cc 
cc   cc 
 c
c+ c"cc cA9 %c  c/c c/ c> ! %cc
c c c cc  c3 c c c c cc c   cc  ccc

c  c c!cc cc   c   cc c  c



c
c c
A9 %c  c/ccc cc c ! cc
c c c
cc
! c
 ! cc c   cc cc ! !  cc c   c/ c
>%c 
cc c  c c cc/ c> ! c 
c

c c c c c


c c 
c

cc
c c/c c  cc ! c 
cc   c
   cc c 
c

cc
c c c
cc !c c cc
! c
 ! cc c ! cc 
c c  cc

2c/!c c1c  - cc


 
c   c = c8   c
c c
cc
cc c!
c c c  c   c 
c c cc
 
c  c›c c  cc+   c1c1cA?c

c c
 c c c c c   
c  c  c 
cc  !c c
  c  c c  ccc  cc

A?c
c c c ccc8c›  c c)
ccc c  cc

›c
c c

c c  %c cccc  c 
cc
 cA9 %c  c/cc c cc
 ! c'  c   c

c c

c (cc c c cc !c

c - c 
c'*"... ..(c
  c  c

cc9 c ccc cA9 %c  c/c
c  c cc  c  
 c›c cc ! c  
cc c
 c c c   c

cc 
c !ccc 
cc c cc
 c    c$ c c
c ! c!c 
c 9 c ! !  c

c
   c   cc c cc cc c c  ccc9 c c c
 &  ccc c  -c
c  !cc c
cc c   c
9!c
!
c+ 
cc c c cc   !c  ccc c
  cc ccc c  cc9 %c  c cc c cc

 ! c cc ccc c c


c c cc c   cc
! cc c c'> 
 c c, =c+! c4 c c› c1c c..( cc

›c c  c  c  c c  c c 


c c
 
c   c c
  c  c$ c !
c!c 
c 9 c ! !  c 
c
   c
   c c cc
c cc c cc c c c cc c
ccc c c
c   cc
 !  c$ ccc c c
cc
  cc cc c c  cc 
cc
c c
5cc

/ c** * c›c c 


c& - c cc c  
c   c
 ! c
c c
 
c 
cc c c 
 c 9 c  cc  c
   cc

/ c**. c›c c 


c& - c c
 ! ccc c !cc

cc!
c cc  c c c c c  c c  c 
c  c
 &  cc c cc c ! c 
cc c  c  c  cc

c  c   c  c c c c c ! c c
cc

›c  cc 
c
c c  cc c 
c c !c c c  c
c c
 ! cc c c   c 
cc c-   cc c
 !  cc

8  c/ c**0cet seq c c


c c c  cc c9
cc

 ! c c  
cc c cc

$ c  cc  
!c  c
c cA9 %c  c/c

 cc cc!!c


 ! c
c c c
c$ c  c c  c
 
cc c cc  c
cc c !c  cc
 ! c
  c
c c c !c
c c  c 
cc c
 ! c'c
  + c" ( c  cc! cc!  c c  c 
c cc

 c  cc c9 c 
cc   c3  c c   cc   c  c
 ! !  c ccc c   cc 
cc  c7  c
c c/cc
c 
cc c cc   c!cc c cc c   c'c  + c
0( cc

›c c
c
c c  c c c   cc   cc c
  c  cc cc c c !c c c
c9 cc)cc
9- 
cc9- !!  
c  cc c
cc)ccc
 cc c  c
c c   c'4 c c4 
= c00c c0( c2c c c 
c
 ! c  c
 

cc c c c
 cc c! c ccc! c›cc c

c    cc c cc c 
c)c  ccc c
 cc  c!c!c c cc
  cc  c'*"c  + c"*( cc

$ c  cc
 ! c
c c c
c c c
cc!c c  c
 c  c c
 
%c ! !  c 
c c  !c)c c c c c

 ! c 
cA c
c cA9 %c  c/c  cc c
 cc cc c
 
cc)
c   c c c
cc)cc
9- 
cc9- !!  
c 
c c   c c c
cc c

c  c
  c' c c/! c c;+›+cc+7/c .c c cAc c+7/c""c
4  c c8  = c c cAc0.c+7/c**( cc

$ c cc  c c c  ccc!=  cc cA9 %c


  cc cc?  c  ccc
 ! 
cc c c c 9 cc c c
c cA9 %c  c
/c

cc c ccc c  
cc  c c 
c   c

 !  cA c c/c



c c  c c!cc c cc c 
c
  cc c
cc c ccc 
c'0... ..(c c c
 c   ccc

c'*.. ..(c c 
c
 c   c c

c'+ cc*c 
c cA9 %c  c/(c 
c c

 c
  cc c".Kcc c c ! c   cc c cc c   c
c: c 
c  c  c    ccc 9 c c  cc c
  cc 
cc  c
  :c'+ c-/c›
( c›c c  c c
 c c c!cc c  
cc c 
c  c cc c

c

c cA9 %c  c/c 
cc c c! 
cc c
 cc

4  c
c cA9 %c  c/c  c  c
c
 c 
cc c   cc 
c c 
cc
 cc c   cc 9cc
   cc c
ccc   cc 
cc c
c c
 c
 ccc    cB
c c c
c c   cc c   c
 
cc
 cc cc c$ cA9 %c  c/c c  c
 
cc 
c cc c   cc9  c›cc c c ! c

!
cc! c  cc c9 cc c c ccc c 
c
 !cc
cc   cc)cc cccc   c'/!c c
Ac"c+7/c 1( cc

A?cc cc c& c cc  ccc c)


c   ccc cc
  cc
c  c c!cc cc cc c  c   !c
   cc c9 %c!c
c cA9 %c  c/c 
c!c
c c ! cc
c c c
cc! c
 ! c'  c c 
c
  (cc c   cc cc c ! !  cc  cc c   c
c  c c c   c   c  ccc c c c c

c  c
c cA9 %c  c/c 
c cc

c
c
 ! cc c ! c cc

›c
!cc c c cccc   c c c/c c *c
+7/c*c
c c c)
c9 c c c cc  cc  cc c
  c c
c c cc cA9 %c  c/ccc  c
c
 c c c ! c c cc! c
 ! cc c c
 cc cc c     cc

›c  G cA?c 
5cc

›c c  !c  cc?!  c c4=c  c !c c   cc


+ c0cc cA9 %c  c/cc c)
c9 %c!cc c

-c c cc c ! cc4 c c > , c7  c ! c 9!c
c cc
cc c c)
c9 c c c cc 
 cc
 c cc cc c    c 
cc 
c c  c

  ! cc  c
c cA9 %c  c/c c ! c c

 c  cc

/c  
ccc  c  c?!  c c  cc cc
 ! c
! c c 
c'
 
c (c   c c c 
cc 9c
  c
c cA9 %c  c, c 
cc c'  c  c
"cc c  c(c c !c 
c c c c c
c
c cc ccc8c›  c›cc !
cc  c c c c

 ! c    c
c c c
c  cc c   c c c

c c
c c c c  

c
c cA9 %c  c/c c
c
c c

c  c/c 
c
 
c c)
c  c c c
 cc c  cc  cc c   c c
c c cc c
  c, cc  cc  c c
 c c c ! c c c
c! c
 !  cA c  cc c  c c c
c   c
c cc cc 
cc c  %c !c  
cc c
cc
!c c  c c  c c
 
%c ! !  c 
c c  !c
)c 
cc !cc   c c  cc c
 ! c 
c c c  c
cc c  cc   c    c3 !c 9
cc cc c
  c 
c  cc  

cc!c c    c c c c
 c cc cc ) 
cc c  c c/ c
c c
cc+ c0c  &
cc c   c8 9 c> 9 c c  c
c
  c c ! c c !
c c cc!  c c c
  c c c  c 
c c  c  c c  c  cc c
  c

/ !c c
 cc c  cc?!  c c4=c  c'.c c"*(c
  cc
- c c 
c c
c 9  c  cc c   -
  cc

› c c c cc = c8   c  c 


c c 
c 
c c
 c c c

cc c  cc+   c1c1cc cc c
  c   c 
cc c 
c c 
c  cc

Ac ! 
cc c c  cc c !
cc ccccc
c


c4 cc0c  c cca quoc c c cc c
 
c
  c  c? c2 c, c@ c c/ c, = c, =c› c 
c
+ c4  =c
c c 
c cc  cc c7 ! c
2 c  ccc c c   cc, c 
c cc c  c c 
cc c
cc/!c*"c01c  c+ c4  =c c c


c c c c
 
cc  c' c.0-.1c  ( c+c ! c c

cc  c
  cc ccc ccc
c

c4 c*1c0c' c*-
**c  (cc c  ccc c cc c
  c c c c  c
c

c cA9 %c  c/c  c c 
cc c c cc
 c c 
cc !  c c 
cc   
c c c
 ! !  c 
c cc cc c 
cc c c 

cc c
 cc4 cc c c?  c+   c7  c+ cc c  c

c
2 cc01c c' c10c  ( cc

A?c
c c !c c c  c
c  
c c  c
c c
A9 %c  c/cc cc  
c cc!!c c c
  c c ! cc   c c   c!= cc c c c c c
 c ccc  c ! cc c
 
c c c  c
  !c  c
c c/ c3
c  c c   cc 
c c
c!  c c 
c ! cc c 
ccc ! !  c c
cc
  c!c
 c
c cA9 %c  ccc
 

c c  c cc   c$ c cc cc 
c c
 
cc!  cc c 9 cc cc  c c c cc cc c
 ! c c$ c  c
c   c c  

cc c  ccc
 c
! c3  c
c c  c c  cc c
c  c
 c  cc c  c
c
c cA9 %c  c/c
c
 c


cc c
 ! c c c c

cc c  cc

>cc

 cc c  cc c


 !cc cc
 cc !  cc
 c c  c$ cc  c   c 
c! c  cc c c
!   cc c) c c 
cc+ c"cc/ cc 
c+ c0cc
/ cJ›@cc c "cc 
ccc+ c0c1c 
ccc/ ccc

c  c
 c?,/7/$›2 c28c7› ›,?+c/ c+$/$?c2,››?+cc c1 c
c c  

c 
c c  
cc/ c*10c*11c*1c1 c
**.c**0c** c 
c** *cc c c c
cc". cc

$c  = c c "cc


  c 5cc

+  c" c$ ccc c) cc c c - !c 


c c c
c c c  c
c c c cc c+  c'/ c››( cc

+  c0 c$ c+  c c 


c cc c   cc9!c c 
c
c 
c c !  c c c  c 
 c 
c  c 
c  c
c 
c  cc
c 
cc !  c$ c+  c c
cc c
 c'/ cJ›@( cc

$ c1 cc 9  c 


c c+  cc: c c) cto
insure the dignity, welfare, and security of all the people "... regulate the use ... and
disposition of private property and equitably diffuse property ownership and profits
"   c  c 
censure adequate social services in, the field of
 c
healthc!cemployment, welfare and social security to guarantee the enjoyment
by the people of a decent standard of living" '+ c0c 
c1c/ c››c1 c
(c: cafford protection to labor, ... and regulate the relations between
workers and employers ..., and assure the rights of workers to ... just and humane
conditions of work" '+  cc/ c››c1 cc  c 
( cc

$ c !!c c!   cc cc c =


cc+ cc
c/ ccc c1 cc 
c - 
c c c
  cc c cc
/ c cc c c, c
c5cc

/ c cDeclaration of basic policy <$ c+  cshall afford protection to labor, promote
full employment,  c & c9c c ! 
cc c  cc
c

cregulate the relations between workers and employers. $ c+  c cassure
the rights of workers c -! = c  c ! !c cc  c 
c
just and humane conditions of work c'  c 
( cc

$ c   
c c c c  
cc c   
c
 cc c c c
c c c 
c 
cc c  c
cc/ c1 cc c c, c
c+ c"cc cA9 %c
  c/c'  cc camended by R.A. „o. 772 on June 20, 1952(c

 cc/ c1 cc c c, c
c c c 

cc c
  
ccc c c c
c c & c cc9c  cc
/!c .c".cc c c c 
 cc c) c  !c
c c
c c!cc c9 c c ! c c    c/ c1 cc c
c, c
c cc
c c!cc c9 c 
c   c 
c
c c c) c!   cc cc 
c c   ccc c
c c
cc

$ c!   cc c) c 



cc+ c0c1c 
ccc/ c››cc c
1 cc  c   cc ! c cc c  
c 
c 
cc
 c c4 c c7 c 9cc c  ccA c@! c+  c> 
cc
?
 c c>   cc   c &  c  
5cc

$ c c cc c> cc7!c cc


 c  c) cc c

cc  c cc  c c 
c c cc ) c 
c
 c 
cc   c c c ! c cc c  
cc c c2 %c
!cc  c  c 
c cc c c c c c
ccc 
c
  c 
c c
  c!c cc c
cc c c
 
c
c c ccc c' cB + c0*"c0 c1c,
c0 c  c
 
( cc

c c
›c  cc c
cc c c ! 

cc/ c1 cc c c, c

cc c c, c
c 
c c c
c
 c c c
c
c c
  
cc cc c9 c 
c    cc

$c/ ccc c c, c


c  c9c c 
 c  c  c
*c c  

c ! 
cc4 cc1ccc9c  ccc
   c
c c: c
cc c   c 
c   cc c
ccc
c 
!cc  !c c 
c ! c c c
  
cc cc :c'/ c*c, c
( cc

/ c.cc c c c


c  5c:›c  cc
cc c   cc
  cc ccc 
c c c - 9!c
c 

c!c 
c
) cc   c:cc

4 c  c/ c1.*cc c c c


c 9  c
 c  c:›c  cc

c c c ! c 


c c c c c c
cc cc c
  c 
c
 c !cc c   :cc

>  cc c  



cc c/c  c11*cc c*.c"*c+ c"c
c cA9 %c  c/c

5cc

+  c" c?  c!cc   -c$ c!c 


c 
 c! 
ccc/c
c c   cc cc c  c)c  !ccc  c c
 
c c c!c 
c 
 c !cc c   cc  c
     c
 
cc  cc9c ! c c   c
c c c

c 
c c c   cc 
c)c'  c 
( cc

?  c !c  cc c  c› 


cc9c
c c  c
 c  ccc  c c c 
 c 
ccc/c c  c
  cc) c  
c
c c› 
c!c 
c  !cc

c
!c c   cc c
 cc c   c 
c c  c c

cc c  c 
ccc c c c 
cc 
cc
!   cc

2 c c 
c  ! cc+ c"cc cA9 %c  c/c  c
*c c  

cc c/c  c11*cc c*.c"*c5cc

+  c" c?  c!cc   -c$ c!c 


c 
 c! 
ccc/c
c c   cc cc c  c)c  !ccc  c c
 
c c c!c 
c 
 c !cc c   cc  c
     c
 
cc  cc9c ! c c   c
c c c

c 
c c c   cc 
c) cc

?  c !c  cc c  c› 


cc9c
c c  c
 c  ccc  c c c 
 c 
ccc/c c  c
c) c  
c
c c› 
c!c 
c  !cc 
c
!c c
   cc c
 cc c    c+c c cc )
 c c
!cc c  cc c  cc cA9 %c  c, cc c  c
  c c 
cc
cc c c c   cc c'/c  

c
c c"cc7  c/c  c11*( c

/ c1 cc c c, c


c
 cc  c   cc 
c c
   ccc c c c
c   c 
c/ c1 c
5cc

/ c1 c?   cc    -cB c  c

c c   cc c
+  c›  c8
c
cc$ c c c   c 
cc  cc c c
   cc c   cc c   cc
 
cc  c  c

cc   c
 ! cc  cc c   ccc
 
 c$ c
  cc  c
cc$ c c c c  cc  c c


ccc+ c0cc c7 
c/
  c
c7  c/c
 
c?  c

c- c c  

c c/c  
c
2 c

c !-cc c  

c c/c  
c+c

c

c c
 c c  

c7  c/c  
c8- !c

c+-c c
 

c 
c c c c  c  c
 
cc c+ c
!c c
 
ccc  cc c  c
  cc
c 
c  c'  c
 
( cc

/c  -&


c/ c1 cc c c, c
c   c 
c c
+ c0cc c7 
c/
  c
c7 / c  c0c c  

c / c
 c0c c  

c7 / c  c0.c c  

c7 / c  c0c c  

c 
c
c c c c  c  c
 
cc c+ c'  !cc c;+›+c
c+++( cc

B 9 c+ c"cc cA9 %c  c/c c  &


c/ c1 cc
 c c, c
c
 cc  c  cc c   c  c c c
 c
cc   c&
cc

›cc  c   c c  c


c c c c
cc
 ! c !c
c ! !  ccc 
cc/ c1 cc c c, c
c/
c c

 ! c    c


c c c c
c  cc
 
cc c+ c


ccc c c, c
cc
 c c:+ :c c  !cc c
;  c+  c›  c+ cc c+ c+ c+ c'/ c01cDEc
D
Ec 
cD Ecc c c, c
( cc

8  c


c/ ccc c c c
c
cc c+  cc
c cc c cc c 
c

/ ccc c c c


c
5cc

/ c c
 c
c  !cc  !c c cc cc c
c c cc c ! c cc c   cc

$ cc!c c  c c c8


c7=c cc  c c,  c

5cc

/ ccc c c


cc c  c
 c c)
 c
c  !cc
  !c c cc ccc ccc)
%c ! c  c
$  c
c !cc   cc c c 
 cc c c
c  c$ c   cc   c 
cc ccc c cc cc
 c c cc c
 cc c   cc c 
c c c c%c   cc
   c  c    c c   c !  c c c c

c ccc cc  :c'0"c+7/c*1.c*1*-*1 cD1"E( cc

A?c
c c)
 c
cc c+  cc  c c  c c c
 c  c c'  c c  cc+7/c*1c*c c10 ( cc

$ c  &
ccc+ c"cc cA9 %c  c/c  c

c  cc c  

cc c/c  c11*cc c*.c"*c 
c
 c!cc  cc cc c
 
c  !cc)
c   cc c
  c

cc   c+ 
c+ c"c cc 

c !c
  cc c+  ccc c1.c  cc   c c c/c
 c' *c+7/c*(c cA?c
c c c)
c9 c c c cc
 cc  cc c   c c
c c cc cA9 %c
  c/ccc  c c
 c c c ! c c cc
!  c
 ! cc c c cc cc c     c+ 
c
   c  c 
cc4 c c$  9 c  
c/ c1cc c c

c c ! c cA9 %c  c/c   !c c0c !cc c
  cc@  c c4  cI c c'*c+7/c1*c c .0(c 
c c"c
  cc?!  c c4=c  c'.c c"*(cc 
cc c > , c
7   c+ 
c   c  c c
ccc c > , c7  c=c
4 9  cH
 c c8  
c 
c@  cc

c c
+ c cc   cc/ c1 cc c c, c
cc  c c -
   cc cc  ! cc+ c"cc cA9 %c  c/c c
 

c 
c
 cc  c  c  c   cc 
cc c c
c
c+ c"cc cA9 %c  c/c

cc!  c c 
c
/ c1 cc c) cc c  c   c

cc c  cc
   c@  c 
c?!  c   
c c c
 cc c   
c
 c' (c  cc  cc 
c
  c c c) c!   c 
cc
c c "c 
c1 c cc

›c
c c 
c 9  c c  ccc ccc c) cc c
/  c8
 cccc c c  ccc c/  c
B c &  c c  c  cc c/  c
cc c
A9 %c  c/c c c c ! c 
c cc2B7c
   cccc c   c/ c1cc c c c
c- -
c/ c1 cc c c, c
cc cc+ c"cc/ c››c 
c
+ c0cc/ cJ›@cc c "cc c 
cc+ c0c1c 
ccc
 c   cc c 
c+  c  cc/ c››cc c1 c cc

$ c
 c cc
  c c  cc c  cc c c!cc c
   c$ c!cc  cc!  
c  cc c
 c c  cc c
 c$c   c c   cc   cc c
ccc9 c !c
cc!cc c  cc   cc
c  c
 cc c cc
c   cc9 c ! c c
! cc  c  cc
!
c
!ccc
 c c
 
c9 c 
cc cc c!cc  c

cc c cc c  cc c9 c 
c c & c ccc  c
c
 c cc  c$ c
 cc  c
 c 
c   c
 ! cc!cc c ! cc c cc c   cc cc
c ! c ! cc
c  c  cc c cc c  c c 
c
 ccc9  c? cc c c c  cc 
cc-
  cc

›cc   c  c c!!c  cc c c) c!   cc c


c c  
cc ccc c c c
ccc c
  cc c cc - 9!ccc 
!c
  cc c 
 cc
 c
  c c 
c c  !c ! c   
cc

$ ccc  ccc ! !cc c c  cc

›cc  c cc


 c  c c 
c c c cc

$ c
cc+ c"cc cA9 %c  c/c 
cc/ c1 cc c
c, c
c c c!cc c  c c!c cc c

 
c!c    c+ c"cc cA9 %c  c/c 
c
/ c1 cc c c, c
c  c !  c   c c  c c 9c
c c  c  =-  c
 cc/
c+c  
cc110ccc
  cA cc c'  %c? 
 c@ c*c c c0(cc c
 c
 

cc  c c  cc cc c
 cc c›
 c
7  c c!   
c c  c 
c c   c
 c' !!c
c? cA %cc!cc1 c 
c7 c8 %c  cc.1(cc

c 
c  cc  c
! cc  c c 
c  c$ c
c
-  - c cc  - 
- -  ccc 

cc c
 !c c cc  - 
- c cc  c$ cc cc c
 c
cc
  cc %c c  c c cccc %c
9   c›ccc = c c ccccc %c9   c c cc c
 
c$c  c  ccc c c  c 
c  -
 c c c 1c  c
c c c8 c' c4 c".c c. .(c9
cc c
 c$ c c
  c c


cc 1c
!c c  cc c c 
c c cc

c c
/  c2 c c !c  c 
c !c   c cc
 c   ccc- c
 c$ c c c   c c 
c

  cc   c c
c
 c  cc c  c9 c c:  :c

c = cc  c !  c:  :cc:    :c›cc ccc
  c
!c 
c
 = c c$c cc cc c
!cA?c
 c  cc   c c& cc c5c:$ c  c cc c
  c 
c c  c  c c c c ! cc c cc c  cc
 9 c c  cc c  c c c c   c c  
cc
c  :c
$cc c c c
 c c9
c c/  c cA cc
!   
ccc 
c 
c
 ccc c 
cc/  c c

c cc0cc0 cc


 c    :cc c  cc c c  c c c ! c$ cc
c c c c %c c 
c  c c›c c
cc+ 9   c
: c  cc c c9 ccc! c  :cc

c

›ccc c c
 !cc !cc cc c cc c
!  cc

$ cc
c c  

cc/ ccc c c c
cc
c c
: c)
! ccc c
  cc 
c)
! cc cc c  c
cc cc c  c:cc

3  c  c c ! c c!c/ ccc c c c


c
 != c cc  c  c ccc c ! ! cc c3  c
:
c 
cc !  :cc cc c! cc c c   c c
cc c
! c 9 c c c !cc c 
c   c c  ! c c c
  ccc c c c  c c c c c
c c c  cc
  c c  cc

>c cc  c  c/ ccc c c c


c c
!c  c
c c/  cc  c 
c !=
c c   c c cc
 c  cc !  cc c cccc c c ! cc c
/  cc 
c c   cc

%$c/  
c3  c !  c
c c)
 c ! c c c
)
cc
 c c c cc c
 cc c  c c! c cc

 c c'$ c8
 c4
c, c c". -"c 1c
( c$ c
  c c  cc
c c ccc  c
 
cc c c
 c'/ 8 , c c/  c+ c cc "cB+c" ( cc

4 cc c! c 


cc c/  cc 9  c  c c  c
  c c c4  c
5c:›cc   c c c 
c
cc
 c
 c
  cc c c c cc'4 c c4
c›c c*1c
. (cc c - 
cc c c3! c c c 
c c: c
cc c c)
! c ccc'/

 cc4 c c.1c&
cc
 
c8 9 c c7  cc4 cc 1( c$c c   
cc
 c 
=cc
c c: c
c c cc c)
! c  c
   c3 c !  c c  c!  c3 c c c c  cc c  c:c
'$ c  cc c
 c c c ( c›c c ! ! cc c c3  c
8 c+ c:$ c c cc c)
 c ! cc c  cc c)
! :c'B + c
 c> c*1cB + cc !c2c c1(cc cc c   
cc
 c8 9 c 
c c7 c 9 c›c c cc c8 9 c
: cc  c  c  cc!cc c c ! cc cc 
c
c  c9 :cc

c c
›c
c c 
c c c   cc c   c
c+ c"cc c
A9 %c  c/cc/ c1 cc c c, c
cc 
cc

c   cc)c 
cc c  cc c9cc c  cc c
 cc c    c›cc  c 
cc  c    c+ c"cc c
A9 %c  c/c c  

cc/ c1 cc c c, c
c

 cc c cc   cc c   c 


ccc  cc
   c ! !  cc  !cc
c c  c
 c &
cc c cc c
 cc c  c c 
c cc c9  cB
c  c+ c"cc/ c
1 c c   c  c   cc c  c  cc c   c
 c
c   cc)cc9- 
c  cc c   c c  c

c
 !  c
c c c  c  c 
c  c

cc c c
c c c   cc

$ c c
ccc ! c c:  !c   :c›c c !  c ! ! c
c4 c c 
=c: c c c!cc c ! cc c c
 c  c
c c c  !c  c 
c  c c c  :c'A
c c
c;
c***c Acc 
=c$ c  cc c
 c c..( c c
 
=c 
c 5c:+  c c  cc)
! c c  
cc c
  ccc c ! ccc   c c 
c   
cc c c
 c c c   c  c:c'!c
cc, c 
c, ! c
*c3  
c, c7  c  c 1( cc

8 c c3  c


 
c cc
c!  c c c !  c

c
!cc c  c
 5c: c)
! c
c 
cc !  cc c
 c
cc c  c c  c
cc cc  c:c
'+ c c c c  c*cB+c*.c1( c/
cc c & c
  cc+! c c;  c'*11cB+cc*.-**c1*c,
c"c"*-c" (c
 c3  c
5cc

$ c! c
  cc cc
cc   c 
c

c
cc 9c

c c? c c c cc c  c
cc   cc c  c

!c!
 cc c   cc c  ccc cA c c cc c

  c
ccc c cc c cc c  
cc c
  c 
ccc!  c
cc!c cc

To make a rule of conduct applicable to an individual who but for such action would
be free from it is to legislate yet it is what the judges do whenever they determine
which of two competing principles of policy shall prevail.

ccc

›c
 cc cc
c ! ccc c  c c c
! ccc
  !c
c c
cc 
c c cc c
c  c !  c 
c
  c cc    c c 
c

c c  cc   !c
  c  cc  cc
  cc
ccc›c c cc  !c cc
cc c cc &  cc

$ c  c  c)c 


c ! c cc c c)
! c
cc !  c
c!
!! c
c cc  c  c)
! c
c !  c$ c= c c
cc cccc - 9!c c c
! ccc c

!    cc
 c  c$ c 
c> 9 c  c>  c c
> 9c c3  c c7 c c 
c>  c7
c9c7 c
+ c4 9 c8 !c 
c>  c3 
c,  c>c 
c c)cc ! c
  cc  c
c c cc ccc !  c-  c! c
c c cc
c c   ccc c  cc
cc   cc c
  cc cccc - 9!c cc c   c 
c
  cc c cc c  c c!  c cc)
 c cc
 cc cc)
 c ! c cc 
c c  cc


 c   c   c c  c9 cc c
 !
cc

c  c
2c c c 
c  c  c c
c  !c c> cc7!c 
c
 c   c  
!c c ccccc c c
! c8 c !c cc c
 cc c  cc4 
c c/= c
' cB+c 0c0(c;
c cA !c' 1*cB+c "(c?
c c› c' 1c
B+c1(cc!  
c c 
c
c
 c ! cc!cc
  c c 
cc c 
cc c
ccc!c c  c cc c
c ! c c cc cc
cc c cc c$  c
!c  cc
cc c/  c> cc7! c$  c!c  cc
 =
cc+ c*.c/ c›@cc c1 c c2 c c  -

-
c
  c  c cc c cc c/  c+  cc
c
c c c?  cA   cc

? c c
cc›
 c  cc cc c
 c)  
c
c c
 
cc/  c)
 c
ccc  
 cc c
> cc7!cc
 c)  
c' c c,  cc  c c$ 9c1 c c
*0.c*0-*0( c/
c  c)
 c
c  c c - 
cc+ c1cc7 c
1cc c"c7 cc c
 c c c cc+ ccc7 c1cc
 c0c7 
c7 cc c›ccc c 
c  cc c  c
c cc  cc c 
c  cc c  ccc ccc
 c  cc    c 
ccc    c 

cc cc
  cc

$ c & cc
 c)  
c  cc
ccc c> cc7! c$ c  c
c
 
cc)
 c
cc cB
c+  c 
cc c  c  c
  c  c cI ! c'"c c"-" ( cc

/! c c & c c  c c  


cc c  cc c c
8 !c'0 cB+c" 1(c c !cc c ! c & cc    c   c
c
 c c 9
cc c  cc>c c4  
c> 
cc?
 c
' cB+c*(c
!c c c & c c  c c c c ! c  c

cc  
c c  c c  

cc c - & c   cc c
  c -c c  

cc c 9c 
c c  cc

 - ! ! cc ! ! ccc c! !c cc

/!c c   c c
 c c  c c  
cc c  cc
  c c c'0c c.(cc c   c  ccc 
 c c
c! !c  c  cc9!c - 
!c cc c!c
 c c! c$ c  cc  c c ccc ! c c cc

/c  c c.cc c  cc, c c cI9c'cB+c"c10cc, c


c
 1c(c c3  c
c c  !c ! c c  cc
! c
  !c c!   cc
 c cc c c!c c ! c c
!cc c) cc c9!c  c$ c c!c ccc c
 c 

c c3  c c
 
c cc 0cc c  ccA c
 c3 c c c' ..cB+c 11-1cc, c
c1. (c  c c/  c+  c
c
c c!cc9 cc c) cc ccc!  
c
c ! cc c 
cc9!ccc 
!c !c'(c
 c

c  c  cc c    cc

$ c cc)
 c  c 
c c cc   cc c c c c c
 cc  c& c  c c  
c 
c! 
cc c/  c
cc)
 c
c'4 c c4
c c  c c4 c
.1cB+c c c, c
c "c+! c c;  c*11cB+c*.-**c1*c, c
c
"*c" ( cc

c c
›cc c c c> 9cc cc c ! c)
 c ! c
 
c c    c!ccc c  cc  c c4 c c
!c c
 cc  c& c c 
c c cc)
 c   c
$  cc!ccc c/  c 
c  cc   c

!c c c cc ccc 
cc c cc   cc
 c 
c c
 cc  c&  c$  c  c c  cc
  c)
 c  !c c
 cc   cc c 
c  c
& c 
c9!c/  c 
 cc

B 9 c c/  ccc c "c 


c1 c  cc
  c cc c+  cc c cc  c c 
cc
 cc c !  c   cc   c  cc

A3?7?827?c$3?c$7›/,c2B7$%+c27?7c28c›+4›++/,c›+c3?7?>Ic
7?@?7+?c/ c+?$c/+›?c/ c$3?c/+?c›+c7?4/ ?c$2c›$c827c
8B7$3?7c72??› ;+ c+32B,c/c;7?/$?7c/42B $c28c/4/;?+c>?c
?7??c› c8/@27c28c3?7?› c?$›$›2 ?7+c$3?c/I4? $+c/,7?/Ic
4/?c$2c$3?4cB7+B/ $c$2c$3?cA27L4? %+c24? +/$›2 c/$c
+3/,,c>?c?B$? c 2c2+$+ cc

+2c27?7? cc

Fernando, C.J., Teehankee, Úlana, Escolin, De la Fuente, Cuevas and Alampay JJ.,
concur. c

Concepcion, Jr., J., is on leave.c

Abad Santos and Relova, JJ., took no part. c

cc

cc

1.1!&/-033c

, Ê"  Ê   ,7


  
c c 8 , 
,7  
 
2 

    2Ê 


 
     8 9 ,2: ;-<

 
 c

cc


c

ccc

 c c  c c 
 c cc  c c
 c  c c 
c c  c

c  
c ccc cc c c c! c 

 c c c c
 cc 
 cc  c
 
 cc  
 cc
 c c
 c)  c  
 c
cc  c c
 c  c c
 c c c 
c c
 c
 c c)  c  
 c$)cc
 c c c
 
 cc  
 c
$
c c c c c cc 
 c$cc c c
    
 c c
  c 
cc 

 c 
c 
c cc  cc


c c

c  c
 cccc cc  
c  c
 c

 c
ccc 
 
c cc  c /c c$

c
00c
c00cc  c  c
cc c cc 
c 
c c

c c
 
c c  c c)  cc

c  c,c 2 c$  c
  cc  c
c 
c  c 
 
c ccc
   
 c
 c c  c  
c
c
 c 
c
c
 c 
c c
c
  
cc 
cc      
 c c   c 
cc 

  c c    cc


c
c
c
 cc c
 c c
 c
 c    
cc c2 cc c    
c 
c
 c
 
c 
c
 c c c c
 c
 c c c)  c
  
 c$)c  c
 cc
 c c
c c
 
cc 
c c
 c  c c
 c cc 
/c c
 
cc 
c c
 c c 
c c   c 
cc

  
c
 c  c

c
 c    
c c
c
 cc c

 c cc  
c
c c

c c
 c c  c  c2 c

  c c
  c  c
c  c
 c
c
 c
    
 c c   c 
cc 

  
c
c
 c)c c  cc  
 c
 c  
c
 c
 c 
 c
c
 c 
c c
 c   c cc    
c
 c
 c

c)  c 


c  c
c 
c c 
c  

 c
c
c   c
 c
 c c
 c  c c
 c c  c
c
    
 c c   c 
cc 

c
c 
c
 c c c  
c
c   c
 c 
c
c c

 c
 c
 c c c  c
c
 
c
c
 c
c c &c c c
 c
 c
c c
 c 
c c

 /c cc
 c 
c c
 cc cc
 c 
c c
 c 
   
 c c   c 
c c 

c  c


c 
 c c c
 c c)  c  cc  
 c

 c
cc  
c c

 cc

c c  cc


 
cc
 c

   
 c c   c 
cc 


cc  
 c 

 cc c
 c
c   cc  c
c  c c
 c
 cc
c
 c 
c  c
 c)c
c 
c

 c c 
c c
 c 
cc
c 
c
 c c 
c c
 c

 c c
 c 
c c  c
c
 
c
c
 c
c c &c c
 c  c
c c
 c 
cc

 /c cc
 c 
c c
c c    
cc
c 
cc ccc

cc
 c c   
 c  c c
 c

  c
 c c c 
c c
 c)c
  c
 c  c c
 cc
cc
c cc

c  c cc
 c   c
 c  c c
 c
cc   cc
 c
 c c)  c  
 cc   c   c
c 
c
 c c
 
c c
 c 
cc 
c
 c c 
c c
 c
 c
 
c c 
c c  c c)  c

c  c,c 2 c
$  c  c
c
 
c
c
 c
c c &c c c  c
c c
 c
 
cc
 c

 /c cc
 c 
c c c  c$c
  cc

 cc

 c c  cc  c
c
 c  c c 
c c  c
cc
'c  cc c  cc  cc   c c 
 c  c c
 c
)   
 c c
  c  
cc

)  c
c

    
 c   c  
cc  c

 c

 cc   c c
 c  c c c   c 
cc 

c c
cc
 c)c c c 
 c
c c c  c
cc 
c c c
 c c c
  c 
cc

c(  c
 c  
c c ! 
 cc c
c c
c c  c
 c
c c
 c  c
c
 c)c c   c 
cc 

cc
 c 
 c
  
cc
c c c cc c 
  c c

c
 c c
 c)c c   c 
c c 

c(
cc c cc   c 
  c c
c
 c   c 
c c  c

c(c
 c

  cc  
cc
 c   c c c  c  
c   c  
cc c



  c
c

c
 c)cc
c
 c
c 
 c   c
 c c
)  c  cc  
 c c)c cc c  c
c c

c c    c
 
 c
ccc c
 c c   c c
 c)cc
 c
 c c
  
 cc

cc

c  c
cc  cc 
 c   
c  
c
  cc  
c  cc 

c   c
c
c c
  cc 
c c c c
c  cc 

 cc


. 


cc  cc 
ccc
 c 
c
c c
 c c c  c c

c  cc
  
 cc  cc   c
c
 c  c c 
 c c cc
cc

c 
 c c cccc  cc

cc c  c 
cc c

 c  
c   c
 c c
 ccc
 c 
ccc
  c
c
 c  c c 
 c cc  cccc c
 c
 c c cc
 c

  
c c
c ccc



  c c

c ccc  c  c
 c
c c c c

cc  c


c 
c
 c
 c c  
 c c
 c)c
 c 
ccc
 c c)  c
  c

c

c
ccc 
 c
  
c
c
 c 
 c cc0 0cc cc
0c c  0c  c 
 c c c
 ccc

c
c c c  c
c0  0c c
c
0  0c  c 
 c c c cc

  c  c

c
c
 c 
 c c
 c

c c0 c  c  c
 c  c c
 c c
c   c ! 
 c c
 c)c
c c 
 c c
 c    
 c c   c 
cc 

 c  c c 
c
c  
 c
c
c
cc   c
c 
c c
 c  c


  cc
c cc



  /c
  c
c c
 ccc c
c
 c)c c
 c

 cc
c
 c
c c
 c c
 c c  
c c
c

 c  c 
 
c  c
cc

  c   c
 c c
c $c(  c
 cc c
c
 c cc
c

    
 c c   c 
cc

c
 c c c c c  c$!Pc c cc cc c
 c
 
c 
c
  c

c

c
  c c cc c cc
c

 c
 c  c c
 c /c c
 c
  /c cc

 c  c c  c 
c 
 c  
c

c c
 c 
 c

  
cc c
c 
c c  c c  c c
cc c

 cc  ccc  
 c
c c c c
c

c c

c    cc  c
c
 c c c
 c  c c   c



 cc  c c
c 
 c c c
 c 
 c
  
ccc

 c c c  c!cc cccc c  cc


ccc  c c c
 
cc  c
  c
  c
 c  c c
c
c c
ccc c
 c  c c c c
cc cc

c
 c  c c 
 c c$c

c
 c c c 
cc
 c

  
cc  c
 
 c 
c c
cc c
c
c
 c
  c   
 c
c c

c
 c  c c
 c
c0 0cc
 c

 c c  
 c c)cc
c c   cc
c
c
c
 
 c c  c
c
c ccc   c cc  cc
  c c  c

    
 c c   c 
c c 

 
c

  /c
c cc
  
c
c 
ccc c c
c

 c c c
 c)c c c 
c

cc

c  
c
 c c c cc c  
c
 c
 
c cc  c 
c c
 c 
c c0c
 c    
0c  c
 c
c
 cc c
 c c
 c
 c 
/c c
ccc



 c2c*cc


 c
P

c(
c
c c
c
 c c
c
 cc c
 c    
 c c   c  
cc

 c 
c c c  cc  c
 c c c c
 
/c
cc
 c
cc c
c c  c
c 
c
 c 
cc c c c cc

c c
 c 
c c
c   

    
 c c   c 
cc 

 c c c 
 c 
  c 
c
 c 
c
 c  c
c c c c 
 c c
 c
 c
c  c  cc
 c c 
 c c
 c 
c
c c
 c c  c c c c 
 c 
  c
 
c
 c 
c  c  c
 c 
 c c
 c
 c$c  c  cc c  cc

( c    
 c   c 
c c c

c  cc
 c  
c
 c c  
 c c)c
c  
 c 
c
c
0 c cc
 c c
0c c 
c

 c c ! 
 c c
 c
c
 c
c c
c 
    
 c c   c 
c c

cc  c c
c 
cc  c
c  c23%
1  
 
 


%
  2c-c
cc  
cc cc c ccc c$ cc

 c  c  c c ccc   c c


 c c

c  c c
c ccc


c c  c c  c
 c
cc  c
  cc
 c c
  c c c c

 cc
 c
 c
cc


c  c  cc
cc

  c c c c



 cc
 c
 c cc


c  c  cc
c c
 
c c
c
  c
c
 c  c
 cc c c

 c  c c

c
c
 cc
cc
 c
c
c 
c
c c
cc
 c c
cc

c
 c
c    cc c   c 
cc 

c c
 c
c cc  cc
 cc
 c c  
 c c)cc  c 
c
 cc  c  cc  cc  c
 
 c
c
c c   c
c c

c
c 
 c c     
 c c   c 
cc 

 c c  c
 ccc cc
 c 
 cc c  c
c


cc  
 c
cc c
 c   c
c c  c c c   c
 c
 

c
 c
 c cc
 c 
 cc

c
 c  cc  c c c.c c   c 
cc 

 c

 c c
 c
 cc

  cc 
c   
cc
 c c
 
 c c)ccc 

 c c
 c  c
c
c 
 c c cc c
c
 c)!)c c  cc  
 c  cc


c cP


 c c )

c
c!c
cc
 c  c  
cc
 
c

c c

cc
 c c c)  c
  
 cc c  
 c c
 c  c 
c c
 c

 c

   c 
c
c  
c
c
  c  cc  
 cc
c
   
c  
0 c c  c 
cc 

 c c$  c!c  c 
c

ccc

cc
 c c
 
 c c
 c)cc c  c
c

cc  c  


c
c

 cc 
c c
c

 c  
cc c
cc  c cc
  c
c 
 cc c
 c  c
c cc
  c cc

 c

 ccc

 
 c 
 cc c
 c

 cc
cc

 c c  c  c c


 c c 
c
c
 c

 c c  c c  c


c c 
  c 
c
 c
 c
c
 c
 c c
 c
  ccc c c
 c  
c cc
 c c
 c
 c c c
 

c cc c 

c c
c

 c c

 cc 
  c

  
cc
 c
 c c  c c 

cc c c
c  c c  c cc 
c
cc c
 c 
 c c c
 

   
 c c
  c 
cc 

 c  c c 



c c  c 
 cc
c c  
 c
c c
 c 
  cc c c 
c 
c
   
c c   
c
c c c
 c
 c
 cc

 c c c
 c c  c cc

›
!
%

 
%"
  

   
%

 

 

 !

 

 

  
   
%


% 
 

    
  


 .cc
c

 c
 c  c c  c 
 c
c
 c  c  c c
c c
 c c cc c
 c c
 c
c2c


 c c


c c
 c c$
c  cc

 c
  c  c
 c   cc c

c
 c)c  cc  
 c c

c c

c
c c c  c
c cc c 
 c
  
c
c c
c
 ! 
 c
  
cc

c
 c)cc 
 c c
c c cc
 c
 c  
c c
c

 c c

 c ! 
    
 c c   c 
cc 

  c

  cc 
 c  cc
 c  c c ! 

c c
 c c
c 
 c
c
 c
c 
c c
 cc c
 c cc   
 c  
c

  c c c cc


cc c
 cc c
  c    
c c
 c

  c

c

 c  c  c 


cc
c c 
   
 c c    c 
cc

c c
 c

  c c
c c
cc   

 cc
c c  c
c   c
c
  c
 c
 c cc   c c
c
c 
c
c
 cc c
 c
    
 c c   c 
cc 

 c

  c c
 c
c 
c c0c c    
c2 cc c
   
0c$
c!c
c!cc c 
 c  cc

c
 c c  c
  
 c c
c 
 c
  
c  c c  c 
c c  
c c
 c


  c
c
  c
c 
cc  c

c
cc c
 cc c
c
 c
   
cc c c  
cc 
 c


 c c
 c

  c
cc cc c


cc   c
 
c
 cc cc 
 c
  
cc  c
  c
 c
c c
 c   c c
c
 c
c 
c c c    
c
c

 cc c
 c c
c c
 cc   
c
c  c

c
cc
cc   c c

 c cc c
 c
 
c c
c 
cc   
c  c
 c cc
 
 cc 
c
 c 
c c
 c

  c

  cc c c  c
cc
 
c 
 c cc

c
 c
c c c
c 
 c

  
   
 c c   c 
cc 

c 
c  
cc
4  .  $   
cc 
c  
c
c

 c c c


c

c
 c 
 c c 
 cc c  c
 c c c c  c
c c c 
cc 
 cc
c   cc
c c  c
c c
cc c

c   

 c c 
 
c
c
 c  c c  c
c c
 c  c 
cc c
   c  c
     
 c c  c 
cc 

c  cc
c  c
 c
c cc   c cc ccc c
c

c
c cc  c    
c(  c cc
 
c
 c
 c
c
 cc c
 c
 cc    
cc
 c  c 
c
 c cc c
  cc c c 
c
ccc   c
 c cc 
    
 c c   c 
cc

  c
 c

c c   cc    
c
c 
cc 
 c  c

c
 c
  
cc c
c   c   c c
 c c   c
cc
 c
c
c 
c

 c    c cc c    
c  c

c
 c
c c  
c
 c c c
  
c
c
 c ccc 
 c

c
 c
cc
 c  
 
cc  c
c
c

c 
c
 c    c c
 c    
c ccc cc
 c c c4  
4  $ .ccc
 c c
c 
c c

c c
 c !c c

c

 c
 c c
 c cc  c
c
ccc
 c 
c c
 c c
c
 c  c

  c
cc  c
 c 
cc  c
 c  
cc1c c   c 
cc

c
 c

c c
c 
cc

c!c0  c 
 c c 
 c   cc
c  c
  
cc 
 c  
 c  c
c c 
c  
c
   c c
 
 c c  
 c c c 
 c
c  
cc
c  c c  c c
   

 0c3c c
  c 
cc

( c c cc c  cc c


 cc c  c
 c
cc c
%c,c
c   c c

cc

(  cc cc 
c c 
  c c
 cc cc
ccc
 c
cc 
 c
c  c
 c    c c
 c c
 ccc

c
c c
 c
  
   
 c c   c  
cc

 cc cc cc  c ccc   c 


c c
 
  c c
 ccc
cc
c  c  cc  c cc
c


cc
 c   ccc
c c
c
 c

     
 c c   c  
cc

 c  
c cc c c
c  c c c
c 
 cc
 c  c


c
c cc  cc 
 cc c
 c 
 c
  
c
c c c  c 
cc

c c
 c 
c

c  c   
cc
 c
 c ccc  
cc c
c
 c
 c

 c c
 c   c  cc
c
 c c
ccc  cc  cc 
c
 c c
 c c c c
c
 c  
ccc
c c
cc c

c
c0c  c
cc cc

c  c c
 c
c
 c$  
ccc  c c
 c  c$
 c
 c ccc  
c c
 cc c
c c
c c
 c
    c c
 c   
c c
 c c c
 c c cc
c

 c  

 c c
 c c$
c
 c ccc  
c
 c 
c

  c
 c
c
c   c

c  c c
 cc
c 
 c c
 c
 
 c

c
 c  c c
 c c
 c   c c
 c 
cc
c
 c c c c cc  c c
 c  c
c
 c c

c
 c
c
 cc c c
 c c  cc
 c c c  c
 c
 c c$
c

c c
 c
 cc cc c cc
 c cc
c c ccc cc c 
c cc
c
c

c$
ccc cc

 
 cc c
 c 
 c
  
c c

cc


 c  c c  c

c  
 c
c
cc   
c
  cc c  /c$c

c
 c
  
cc   cccc  
c

c
c  
c
c c$c

c cc c

 c
c
c$c

cc c
 c
 c
c
c 

cc$c

c
 c
  
cc
c
 c
 c cc
   
c cc 
c c c  c 
cc


cc c  
ccc c c
  cc c
 c
 c
c c%   cc-

c0
 c c  c c
c c  c
c
 c  
cc
$  c cc 
cc
 c cccc c
 c  c
c
 c  
c
 
c c   c c
 c

 c cc  c c
c
 c cc
 c
c c
 c    
c  cc
c c
 c c
  0cc
c c
cc

 c c

cc

 c cc   c  c c   c c


 c c 


c c
  c
c
 c  
cc c

c
  cc c 
c
 c
 c c
c
 c  
cc$ c
 cc c ccc%c
cc
 c c  c
c

cc c
c c  c$ c% c   c

 cc c  
c(ccc%ccc c
c c
 c
  
ccc  c c c
c c   

 c c c c
 c
 c$  c
 cc cc c c$cc
c  c


c   c c
 c
c c
 c c
c 
c c
c  c
c
c

 c  
ccc
 c c
 cc 
 cc   c cc  c

c
cc
 c c
 c cc
c cc
cc 
c
 c

c
  
ccc c  c
 c 
 c c c
 c cc

 c  ccc

 c
c
 c  
c c
 c  
 cc

c  c cc   cc
 c   c c

c 
 c
 c  c

cc c
c c
 c   
c c 
cc
c c
 c cc
c c c   c
c c c c
c  cc
 c c c

c  
cc c c
c

c 
 cc  
c
 cc%c c  c
c ccc ccc ccc

 c( c c

c c
 c c   c  c c
c c  c
c
 c  
c
c
 cc  cc
c c  c c
 c  
cc
c
 c c
  
c
c
c c
 c   c c
c
 c    cc  
c  c
  
cc c c  ccc c
  c
c
c
 c cc
 c  
c
c
 cc c
c
ccc
c c  
   
 c c   c 
cc

c c
c
 c
 c  
c c c ! 
 c
 c  
c c

  cc
  c
  c    
 c c   c  
cc

c 
 cc  
 c c
 c

  c c
c 
 c c c 
 c
c  
c
c c cc 
 c c
c
 c  cc 
c c
c
 
    
 c c
  c 
cc 

 c 
c    c
c c
 c  c 
 c c
 c)cc
c  c!cc

c  
c c  c
 cc

c  c c c


cc c   c 
cc 

cP c c cc


 c   c 
cc  c

c
c 
c   c


cc  c c
c

c 
 c
 c 
/c  
c c
 c
 
cc 

 c
c   c  
c  c c
 c cc
 c c
 c
c  c
c 
/c  
c  
c
c  c
 c
c
 c c
  c
 c   !!
 
c c c  c
  c
c
   c  
c c
c c
 c c c c  c c
 c
 c     c  c

cc

0
c c  
cc c c
c
 c  cc  c  c

 c 
 cc c 


c cc   !!
 
c
c c  c
  c
c   c
c0c

  c

c 
 c
 c 
/c  
c c
 c 
cc 

 c

c   c  
c c
 c c  
c
c c c
 c c c
cc

 c
c
c
 c 
c   c 
 c c c
 c c c  c

c

cc


 c c c 
cc   c c
  cc c
c
c
 c
cc
cc   c   c
 c
 c
 c

 c
c
c
c cc


cc 
 c

c
 c c c c   c c c
 c c



c

c
 c   c

 c  c 

 c c
 

 cc ccc c       
 c c   c 
cc 

 c 
c c
 c   c

 c c
cc
cc 
c

 
 c
 c
c
c  c  c
 c 
c c 
c  c
 c
 c 
 c c
 c c
c
c
 c  c c
 c c
 cc   c c  
 cc  
c
c
cc c

cc cc
c


 c
c  
c c 
c
c  
c  c c
c  c  c

 c 
c cc 
 c
 c c c
 c  c
  c c
 c
 c c c   c
c   c
 c  c c
 c c   c
 c
c 
c c
c c c

 c
c
 c c 
 cc
cc c
  
 c

 c
c
    
 c c   c 
cc 

c) c 
c
c(
cc

c
c cc
   
c c   c 
cc

  
cc
c  c   c 
c c  c

c c

c c   c( c  c   c 
c c c

c
c(
cc

c  
c
 c c c cc c  
c
 c 
c cc
 c 
c c
 c 
c c0c c    
0c  c
 c
c

 cc c
 c c c
 c 
/c c
ccc



 c2c*cc


 c
P

c(

c c
c
 c c
c cc c
 c
    
 c c
  c 
cc 

 c 
c c c  cc  c
 c c c c 
/c

cc
 c
cc c
c c  cc 
c
 c 
c
c c c c cc
c c
 c 
c c
c
   

    
 c c   c 
c c 

 c c c 
 c 
  c 
c
 c 
c  c  c

c c c c 
 c c
 c
 cc  c  cc

 c c 
 c c
 c 
cc c
 c c  c c c
c 
 c 
  c 
c
 c 
c  c  c
 c 
 c c

 c    
 c c   c 
cc

(
 c
 c c c c c c   c  
 c c
cc c
 c  c  
c
c
c c   c c c c c
 c  
c c
 

c c    
c  c
 c 
c c   c
 c
c
  c  
c c
 c c c
 c cc
 c 
c
c c
  c
c c c c
ccc    c c c  c
   
c  c 
cc   c
cc  c c
 c
 c

c cc    
cc
 c    c c
 c ccc  
c

c
 c  
c
c    
 c c   c 
cc

 c c

cc  
c c  
cc
c   c c
 c
 cc
  c  c  
ccc 
c
c
 c  
c cc
 c
c 
cc
c c  c 
c c
 c  
c c c
c c
 c  
cc 
/c 
c
cc
 ccc c
c
  
c c
c  c c
c  
c c
 c  !
    
 c c
  c 
cc 

) c 
c
 c  c c  c  c
 c
c
 c c
 c
 
cc 
c c   c
 cc c  c  
cc
c c
  c c
 c 
   
 c c   c 
cc 

c
 c

c c
 cc c
 c
 
cc

 /c c
 c c c
 
c c c  c
c  c
 c  c c
 c
c  c
 
/c   c
c   c
 c
 cc 
 c
 c
 c
c
  c
 c   c c  cc  c
c

c
c
 
c


c


c
 ccc c c 
cc  cc
 c
 
/c c 
 cc
c   c
 c  c 
c  

 c
c
 c cc
cc   c

c c
c
c
 c
 c 
cc  c
c
 c c    
cc

()


c
 c

 cc
c cc c 
c

c    
cc
c
 
c  c  c c
 c   
c 
c ccc cc
c  c c c  c c c
   c  c
c c

 
1
  c

c

cc

c c
'

.

$  4 $&   

c

00-*&+#-0-00c

   Ê c



  cc
c
!  , ;!,<
 Ê      
 
c   
c

c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c

0-c

! Ê c

  cc
c
!  , ;!,<c   
c

c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c

01c

2 

 Ê  ÊÊ  ;


2 Ê<c

  cc
c
!  , ;!,<c   
c

c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c

 0-Êc

 

 ,   Ê    "   2 Ê  




   Ê  2 !   Ê  
 9c

  c

c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c

.c

!2 
 c

  cc
c
!  , ;!,<c   
c

 "  " =2 Ê ,  Ê = Ê" 


!=   

 >Ê6 Ê= ,,=
  ,  2 
2 

 Ê" Ê2

&$*&$$$5/+ 44$+$

&$+$  Ê  
  
?$#$&+?+@*$&#%*%+/ , '?$
2 

 ,=
2 !2, Ê =,  Ê ,;,<
2   
=,Ê    
     Ê!=        
"     "   
 Ê; <2  
   =7
    2 2 
;7 <
Ê       =Ê  77 Ê 
7,  Ê ,
Ê7;7,<
2  7   Ê=  
 Ê" " 

Ê=     
Ê   Ê; Ê<2  ! Ê 7
 =   Ê   Ê  2 

2 

 Ê;Ê
<2   Ê    Ê=   Ê

c c
   2 
2 

 Ê;
<2  " ! 8 Ê=
Ê   2 Ê  "    2 
2 

 Ê;Ê
<2  
 Ê    "=6  ,  

Ê Ê=6   6 Ê  9   2 

2 

 Ê&$*&$$$5/8 Ê ,  !" =,  9


!  Ê
=  Ê    = "  
7Ê  "  "=  Ê  =   ! ÊÊ=
  "    =8  8
 !=c
  c

c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c

.-c

  9   !; ,


 ($&&Ê?$&A< 
,   ; ,
cP  !

c c

  cc
c
!  , ;!,<c   
c

c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c!c

.-0c

2 

 ,ÊÊ   c



  cc
c
!  , 2  :     
 
c   
c

c
ccccc cccc

, Ê 
c

cc c c


 c 
c  
c
c  c cc

()


c
 c 
c

c c
 c

 c c 
 cc ccPc c ccPc
 c  cc
 c

 c c ccPc c c c c 
 c

c c
 c

 c c 
 ccPc c  ccPc c c
cc c 
cc

cP
c
 c

 ccc c !!!cc  c 
c
 c c
cc cc

$c c   c
c  c c
 c 
 c c
c
c c
 c
 c
c c 
c c
 c    c
  
c c c 
 c 
c
c  c c c c cc

$c c  c


 c 
c
c c  c c
 c 
 c c c 
 cc

$c c 
c
c
 c  
c  
c
 c 
c
c c  c c
 c
 
 c c c 
 c c c  c c c ccc

$c c 
 c
c  c c
 c 
 c c
c
c c
 c
 cc
 c  cc 
c
c
 c  
c
 c 
c
c c
  c   c
 
cc  c
c
c  c

c  c
c

c


 c c   
 c



  c cc  c$Pc c  c c+c  
 cc cc
c
$Pc c cc cc 
 c$Pc c cc cc
  c


cc c
 c !  c c c$!  c c c
cc
c  
c
cc
c c  c c c cc
 c$%c
cc  c
c cc
 c(  c c c
 c c
 c c$( c cc
 c
 c cc  cc( cc  cc 

ccc  c$  c


c
c  c
 c  
 c
 c c   
 c c cc
 c c
   
 cc 
c  cc 
cc  c 
c
 
 cc
  c

( c  c
 c  
cc  c c
 c  c
 c c   
 cc

 c   c  c

  c

c  c 
cc
c   c  c  c c  c
 c c c
 c c
c
 c
  c
c 
c
 c c 
 c   c
c
 c   c 
c cc

c  c  c

 c c c c c   c
c 
cc  c
 
 c  
ccc
c  cc 
 c 
  c

cc 
 c c
 c 
c c

cc
 c 
c  
 c  c  c 
c


c
 c c 
 c
cc c  c c c
 cc c
c c c
 c
  c  c

c
 
c cc
c

ccc  c c
 c 
c

 
 cc
c

ccc c c 
 c c
 cc c
c c
cc


 c

c
 
c c 
 
c  c
 c  cc c
c 
 
c

cc  c


 c  c  c
 cc
 c 
cc c

 ccc
 
c  
 c c  c 
c

c  cc c
c 
 
cc cc
 cc
cc
 cc
   c
c
cc  
 c
cc c  c

c  
c
c
 c  
 c c
 c 


 c  cc    ccc
   c
c  c
 c
c c
 c c 
 c

c  c 
cc c
c c 
c
c
 c 
 c
 c c 
 c  c
   c
 c 
cc c
 c 


 c
c
 c c cc  
c

c  c


cc  c c  c c
c  cc
c c
 c
 c c c  
c
 c
 c  c  c

c
  c
c

c  c c


c c  c

c  c

  cc
 cc c c
 c c c
c
c 
 c

 c c  
 c c
 cc

 cc 


 c

c c
c  c 
c
 c


 c c
 c 


 c  
c
 cc c


c
 c 
c c
c  
cc  c c 


 cc  c
c
cc
   c c
 c  c 
c c
 c c

c  c



c 
 c c
 ccc cc

c
 c  c
c
c
 c 
cc
c c
c  c  c   cc  c  cc  c


 c c
 c 
c  c c
 c  
cc 
c
 c 
 
c c
 c  c
c c 
 cc
 cP  
c

c c  
 cc


 c

c  c 
c  c  cc 
 c c
 c 


 c  c
c

c 
 
c

c  c 


 cc
 c
 c 


 c  !c
 c 
 c

c
c 
 
cc
 c 
 c c
 cc
cc
c
c
 c

 
c c
 c 
c
c c  c c
 c
 c c
 c 
c
cc
c c
 c
  cc
 c c
cc
 c 
c c
 c
c c

c  c 
cc  cc c
c c
 cc c c


 c 
 
 c
c

c
 c 


 c

c  c 
cc  cc  c   c c
 c

 c
c c 
 c c
 
c   
c c


 c 
 
 c c

c c c c  c


 c 
c

c  c 


 cc  cc  c  c c
c 
 
cc
 c
 c  
 cc

c c
  c 
 
c
c  
 c 
 c

c  c 
cc  cc 
c
 cc
c   c
 c  c c
 c
 
 c c
 c
c
c c
 c  c
c c 
c c
 c    c

  
c c c 
 c  c
cc  c
c 

c
 c
c c  c c
 c 
 c
c  
c c c c  c c c c  c 


 c
c

 c 
c  c
 c  c c    c c
 cc  c
 c 
c
c
c
 c
c
c
c c c
c c
c c c
c c
c   cc
 c  c cc cc

 c cc c  c
 c c
 c c
 cc

c  c 
cc  cc  cc   c  ccc  cc
  
 c

c  c 


 cc c 
 
c c  cc 
c
 c 
c
 
c
 cc
c  c
c
 c  c 


cc  c  
 c c
 c
 


 cc
 c  c cc  
 c  c

c  c 
c
c  c c
 cc cc   c
 
cc 
 c
  c  
c c
 c 
c cc

c  c
 cc c c
 c 
c  c 
 c
c
cc c 
 c  c

 c  
cc  c  c
 c 
 
c c
 c   c c 
 cc

c  
 c   c

c  cc   c c
 cc c
c 
 
cc
c 
c c



c
c  c
 c
 c  
c  c c c c  c  c


c
c
 c  
c  
c
c 
c
 c 
c c 
 cc   c
 c
c
 

c c  c c c
c c  c

!  c c c


cc

c  c
c
c  c c  c 
 c c
 cc c
 c 


 c c

c 
 
c
c
 c  c)  c c  
c  c 
c
c
c
 c
 c c
 c  c    
c

c 
 c c
 cc c
 c 


 c  c c  
c 
 
c
c

 c 


 c  cc
 cc
c
 c  
c c
 c  c c
 
 
c
c c0
 c  c  c 
 
c c 
cccc
c
 


 0cc  c c

c
 c

 c c
 c 
c  c c
 c
  
c 
c
c 
 
c
c
 c  c  c 
 c c 
 c cc
 
 c c c
 cc c
cc  
c 
 
cc
 c
 
 cc
 c c c
 cP  
c

c   cc c   c

c
 c  c c
 c 


 c  c
 c c cc

c c 
 ccc c

c

c   cc c 
 c 
  c

c
c
 c 
c   c c c
  c

c  c  
 cc  c 
 c c
 cc c
c 
 
c
c cc
 cc
 c 
cc
c
 c 
 
c
c
 c  c

c  c 
 c c
 cc c
c 
 c
 c  c c
 c  c  c 
 c
c c
 cc
c
c 
 
cc
 c  c

  c

c  c 
c   c c 
 
c
c
 c  c  c
 c 


 cc
c
c 
 
cc c cc


 c c
 ccc
   c  c c
 c 


 c

c  c

c c
 cc c
c 
 
cc
c c 
 
cc
c

 c
 
 cc c 
 
c  c
 c c
 c c c c
 c$  c c c c  
c c c
 c 
 cc
  
c c
 c  c c
 c 


 c c
  cc c 
cc 
 c
c
 cc
 c

c c
 c  ccc
c 
c 
c

ccc c c
 cP  
c c c 
  c

ccc cc  c
cc 

cc
 c


 c c c
 
 

 cc c  
c   c  c

c
 c
 


 c 
c c

ccc  c

c  
c
c
 c  
 c c
c
 c  c


 c c
 c  c c
 c
 


 c c  c
c
 ccc    c  c c
 c 


 c

c   cc c  


c  c c c  cc c

cc   c
cc c
c
 c 


 cc

%c
cc

c  c 
c  cc
c
 c

 ccc c !!!c   c
 c


 cc
c  
cc 
 c 
  c  c c
c c  c
c
c c
c 
 c  c

c
 c  c c
 c c 
 cc
c
c 
c
c

c
 cc
  cc
c
c  c
 c c
c
c 
cc
c c  c
c

 c  
c

c c
c  c  
 c c c  c 
cc  c 

cc  c
c

 c  c c 
 c  c

cc c

c 
 c c
 cccc  
c
c 
 c$ c
 cc

 c 
cc  
c
 c c c
cc  
c c  
c$c
c


c
 c 


 c c c

ccc  c c

c c  
c
  c c
c c  cc
c  c c 
c
cc   cc c  
c

 c
 c  c
 c   
c c
 c

c  c cc
 
 c c
 c 


 c

 c
c 
 cc

c c

 c 
cc


 c 
 
 c  c ccc
  c c 
 c c
 cc   c


 c

cc

c  c 
c
  
c c
c  
cc
c c c 
  c  cc c
 c
cc
 
cc
 c  
c c c   c

c
c c
cc


c
c 

c c
c  cc
 c 
 c c
 c c 
 cc

c   c

c  c c

c 
 c c
 cc c
c c
cc  cc
 c 
cc

 c  c cc  
c
c c
c cc 
 c c


 c
 
 
 c  c  c
c  c  c  
 c
  c 
 
cc
 c

 
 c 
 
c  c
 c 
c c
c
 c   c
 cc
  c
 c c

 c

c  cc    c  c  c  c c


 c 


 c  c

 c
 cc c
c 
 
c
c c
 c  c c
 c  c
)  c c  c 
c
c
 c  c c 
 c  c
c  c
 c cc
  cc  cc 
cc

c 
 c c
 ccc
c 
 c
c 
 c$ c
 cc  c !
 c
c
c c c  c
c 
c  
c c c cc 
ccc c

c
 c c c
 cc  c 
c  
cc  c
 c c
 c cc cc

 c  
c  
c$ cc c
cc
c
 cc
 c
 c
  
 c c
 c 
c c 
 c  c
 ccc  c
c  c
 

c
c  c
 c  c

c
cc 
c  

‘ ‘c

c( c
 c 


 cccc c
 c ! c  c  c 
 c$ c

 ccc   c

c   cc cc


c 
c
 cc
c 
c
 c
c c  c c c  c c
c c  c 
 c
c
 cc
 cc  c  
 c c
 c 


 c
c 


cc  
 c  c

c   cc c c  


c c
 c 
 
c cc c 
 c   c
 c
 
c
c cc c c
c
cc
 c  c  c cc 

c 
 c
c
 c
 
 c
cc  
 c c
 c  
cc !  
c 
c
 c
  c c
 c 
cc  c  c
 c  
c
 
c  c

( c

c  c 
c   c
c 
 cc  c
 cc
c 
c
 c
c c
  c c c 
 c
c
 c  
c c c  c c c cc
c
 
 c
c  c c
 c 
 c c
 c
c   c
c
cc
  c
c c c  c c
 ccc  c
c  c cc c
 c

c c
 


 c   c 
 c
c c  c    c c
 ccc c
  
c
c
c  c  c

cc

c 
 c c
 cc
 c 
cc  c
 cc c c



 c 
 
 c
c
 c 
c

c
 c
c c c
 cc 
c c c
 c
cc cc  cc

c c c
c
 c  c
 cc
 c
c
 c

c   cc c   c
c 
c
 c 
c c 
 c  c

c
 c  c

c c c  c  c

c
 c  cc
 c c
 c  c  c c
 c
 
c  c 
c 
 cc c cc  cc
 c  c c
 c c 
 c

 c

c  c  c c 
 c c
 cc c cc    c c c



 c

c  c 


 c 
c c 
 cc
c 

c
c c  
c
c
 c 
 c
c  
c c
c  c

c  c  c c 
 c  cc  
c   c 
 c c
 ccc

 c 
 
c  c c
 c 


 c  c c cc  c

c  c 
cc  cc  c
 cc
c 
c
 c
c c  c
c
 c
  
c c c c c
c
 c

c   c c  cc   c
 cc
c
 
c
 c
c c  c c  c
 c  cc   c

  c

c c 
 c c
 cc
 c  c  
 c  c
 cc c
c
 
 
cc
 c
  c 
 
c
cc  
 c 
 c  c

 cc
c c
c
 c c

c c
 c  c c
 c 


 c
c cc 

 c
c
 c  c c
 c
 c c
 
 c
c c 
 
c

c c  
c
 c 
 
c c
 c 
c c 
 c  c
 cc c
c
 
 
c c
 c 
c   c
c
 c
 c c
 
 cc
   c
 c    c c
 c c 
 c c c
 c
 c  
c
 c 
  c  
c

c  c 
c c c  c

c

c
 c  
c  c  
c
 c
 c c
 c c

  c
cc

c 
 c c
 cc c
c
 cc
c
 c
 c c 
 
cc

 c  
cc 
c  cc
c
 c  c  cc


c cc
 c  c c
 c 


 c  c  
c
 c  c


c
 cc c
c 
 
c 
c
c c 
 
c

c    c c
 cc c
 c 
c  c 
c  c  
c  
c
c

c 
c 
c
c
cc c
c  c  c  c
 c
cc c
   c
c  c
c
 c  c  c

c  c 
c  cc
c
 c

 ccc c !!!c   c
 c


 cc
c  
cc 
 c 
  c

 
c

c c
c c 


 c


 c c 
c c   c
 cc
   c
c
 c  c

c c
 c 


 ccc

 c
c
 c  c c
P  
cccc
 c c
 c

 c c
 c
c c
 c  c  cc
 c  c  
c  c c
 c 


 c
 c


 c
 c c c  c

c

c
 c
  c  cc c c
c c

 
c
c
c   

 c

c  c  c c


 c 


 c  c c
 c  
ccc c

 c
  
c
c  c 


 c   ccc

 
c
cc c
  
c c
 c 


 c

c  c
 
c

  
c

 c  c c
 c 
cP  c$Pcc
 cc 
 c   
cc
 c
  
 c  
c
 c

Pc

c  cc c c   c
c 
c
c
 c  
cc 
c
c c
c  c
c
 c 
 c c c 
 c

c  c  
c  
cc
 c  c
c 
c
 c 
c c 
 c

c 
 c c
 cc c
c c
c
 c  c

c  c c c 


 c 
 
 c  c
 c  
 c c
 c  c
 c
 cc c
c 
 
‘!5‘c

c  c 
cc
 c
c
c  cc   cc c c c
 c
 cc
 cc
 c 
c

c

c

c  c  
c

 c c c c c c 

c   c
 c
cc
c
c  c
c
 c
 c
 c

 c  c  c
 c
 c  
c
  
cc
 c  c
c 
c
 c c c 
 cc   c
 cc
 c
c
c
  c
 c
cc
c 

cc 
c
c
c
 c  
c

c  c

 
cc
 c  c

c
  ccc 
c c
 ccc 
c
cc
   c c
 c  
c
c 
cc c 
 c c c
 c cc 
c
c 


 cc cc  c

 
c   c
 c    c c
 c
c

c  ccc c c
 c c  c c
 c 
c
cc c
c
c
 


 c
cc
c  
c  cc  
 c

 cc
c

  c


cc  c$c c !!!c 
cc  
c c
 c
 cPcc
 cc  c
 c  c  c
 c 
cc   c
c c c) c

c

c
 c

 c c   
 c  c 
c
c
 c

 c

c c

ccc

 c 
c   c)c  
c 
c

c  c c c
 c
 c c   
 c  c  c   c c
 c
  cc
 c 
c  c

c  c

 c

c c 
c  c
 c 
c  c c    c
c
 ccc  c c 
 c$ c
 cc c
 c 


 cc

  c  c
 c 
c 
 c  c  c 
 c c
 ccc

c c

 c  c
 c  
c c c  c c
c   ccc c
0
&
cc 
ccc

 c

c  c



c
 cc
  c
c
c
c
 cc 
 c c c
c 
c
 c 
c
c
c
 c  c 
c

 
c
cc 
  c 
c
 c   c c
 c 
c c
c  c c
    c c
 cc

c c c 
 c c
 cc
c 
 c$ cc 
 c c
 ccc
c
 c
 c 


 c

c  c 
 c c
 c  
 c c
 c 


 c  c
cc
 c
 
c c 
 c c  cc ccc  c c
 c
 c c
   
 c c
c c
c 
 c 
 c c
 cc c 
 c$ c
 c
c
c
c 
 c c
 cc$ c 
c

 c

( c  c
 c
 c c   
 c cc c 
c cc
 c

c c
   c
 cc c
c c c cc c   c c
 c  c cc c cc

 
  c
 c 
c 
c
c c c  c

c  c c
 c   c c 
 cc
c


c 
c c
 c 
c 
c

c
 c c c
 c cc 
 cc
  c
c

c
 c 
cc  cc  c c c   cc

 c 

 cc ccc


 c c  c
c c  c
 c
cc
 c c
c c 
c  c c
c
  c
c   
cc
c
c 

 c
c

c c

 c
c c c

cc c
  c
 c  cc  c cc  c c 
 c
 
c 
 c
 c
  c c c cc
 c c 
ccc  c 
c
c
 c c 
 c
 cc 
c
 c  cc 
 cc  c c   c cc 
c c 

c

 
c  c  c  c  cc   
c c   c
  c c 
c 
c
   c
 c  c c
 c
c 
c c c  c
c c 
cc c

c  c
 c  c
c
 c 
c   c c
 c  c ccc ccc

 c  c  c


 c c
 
ccc


c
  cc 
c
 

  c
  c   c   c
c
 c 

c

c
 c c c
 c
c

c 
c
 
 c
 c

 c
c  c c
  c c  c
c c c
 c
c c c
  c
!
 c
c   c    c
c
  ccc c c 
c c c
 c  c
c
 c c 
cc
 c  c 
c
c
 c 
c c ! 
c
 
c c
cc
c
 c  c  c 
c 
c c
cc
  c c 
c
c
 c
c
 
c

c  c c
c
c 
c
cc

 c 
cc
 c 
c 
c c
 cc c c  c
cc
c 
  c c   
c
 c
 c 
c   c
cc c  cc
c  c
c  c cc

 c  c

c
c
 c
c ! 
 c
cc cc 
 
 c  c
   c
c   
cc

ccccc  !c

c c
 c
c* c
  c  c cccccc
c c 
c
c cc
cc  !c
 
c  c c   
c c
c c

 cc c   cc c
    
ccc  c  c c c   ccc   
ccc   
c c
 c c
c  cc 
 
 c c  
cc
 c 
cc
 c

c c 
c
 c  cc 
 
 c
c c c
c
 c c  c
 c c
 c   
c
c c
 c c c    cc

c

 c
 c
  c
c
c

c  c 
c
c
c c  c c  c c
  cc

c
c c c  c c
c 
 c
 c 
cc
c cc
   c

c c
 c c
 
cc 
 c  c c
c   
 c 
c

c
 c 


 c

  c   c
 c
c
 
c c
 c 
c cc
c  c c  cc 
 c c
 c ccc cc c  c   c cc cc  c

  c  c
  c c  c c
 c c c
 c
 c

c
 c
 


 c  c 
 c
c
 c  c
 cc c  
c 
 
c
 c
 c  c

cc 
 c c
 ccc

 c  
 c

c
 c 
c c 
 c c  c
c  c
 c  c c
 c
 


 c  cc
c  c 
 c 
 c c
 cc c 
 c$ c

 cc
c  c 
 c c
 ccc  c c 
c  c  c c
 c
 


 c  c c

c   c) cPc  ccc   c
c
  c  cc 
 c 
c
c
 c  
c
c
 c 
c c  c c
  
c c 
c c
 c  c c
 c  
c
c
c 
c cc
c c
  cc
 c c  c   c  cc
 c
 c  c
c
  c
 c  cc 
 c c
 cc0$
 c c c 
 c 
 0c c


c
 c c  c c
 c  cc c 
 c c
 cc c 
 c

c c   c
c
 c  c
c
c

 
 c cc

 c  cc 
 c c  
c c 
c
c
 c 
c c  c c
 c
  
cc
c cc
  c c 
cc  c c
 c 


 c
  c c
 c  c c
 c c cc 
 c  
 c c
c c c   c c  c c  
!  c c 
  c  
 cc

 c  cc


c  c 
c
 c
 c 
c
c
c c c

c 
 c c
 cc c
c
 c
c 
 
cc
 c  c  c c

c
 c 
c 
 c  c c  c
c
 c c c c


 c 
 
 c

 c 
c  c cc
 c 
 cc c
   c 
 c 
 c
 c
  c  c c
 c c c


 c 
 
 cc

 c  c
 c 
c c
 c  c  c 
 c c
 cc c
 c  c

 c c
 cc c 
 
c
c
 c  c
c

c
 cc c
c
 c
  c  c
 c c c c c 
cc  ! 

 c
c
c 
c


 c
 cc
 c 
c  

c c
c c
c 
 c$ cc
 
 c c
c c
 cc
 c  c
c c
 cc  c 
 c c
 c
c c
 c  c  c
  c 
c
 c  c cc  c
  c%
c
 
 
 c
c  c
 c  c c c c c   c 


cc
  
c  c
 c  c c
 c 


 c  c
 c 
 c$ cc
 
 c c c c
cc
 c c c

c
 c cc cc 
cc c
 cc c
 
cc
  c
 
 c c cc    c   c
 ccc
  c
c  c
c c
c  c
 c 
 c

c
c
 c
 
 cc
 c c

 c
 c c c c c
c
 c
 
c
 c
c c  cc c  c

 c c c
 ccc cc  c 
 c
c c

c
 c 

c c c
 c
 
 cc  c   c
 c c  c c
 c 
 c

ccc
 c
  c c
 cc
   c

 c
 c  c cc c cc 

 c   c

)c
 c  c
 c
c 
c
 c 
 c 
 cc 
 c c
 cc
c
 c
 
 
c c  c c
 c   c 
c
 c c c 
 c  c c  c
 c
c c  c
 c
  c  c c
 c  c  c c c  c
c   c

c
 c 
 c c 
cc 
 c c
 ccc c   c

c  c
 c
c
 c 
 
c c  c c
 c   c 
cc
 cc
  c 
c
  cc 
 cc$ c
 cc 
c c  
 cc
c  c  c c

c
 c
 
 c
c
 c  
c c
c  
cc 
 
c
c
 c
 
c  c
 c 
c  
c  
 cc c
c
 c c c
 c  
c c
c
  
c
c c
c c
c
 c  c c
 c   c 
cc

( c
c 
c
 c c c
 c 


 c
c c

 c
c c 
 c 
cc
 c
c 
c
 c   c c c 
c

c( c


cc c 
cc
c c
 c  c


c
c
 c 
  c c c   c


c   cc
 c  c c
 c  
c 
c  c 
c c
 c  
c
  
cc 
c c
 c c c
c
c c
 c
 
c
c 
c
 c   c c

 c
c c 
 c

 c 
 cc  cc

 c  cc

 c  c c
 c 
c
c c
 c  cc c
 c   cc
 c 
c c
 c
 c cc
c
 c 
 c  c  c cc    c 
 c
 c

 c  
c c
 c  
c  c c
 c 
cc c
 c  
c

 c
c
 cc
c  cc
cc  c c
 c  c c
 c 
c c c 
c
 c
  c  c
 c 
c c c  c
 c   c
cc  c c  c

c c c   c
cc
  c c
 c
  
c  c
 c%
c c
c c
c
cc 
 c
c  c
 c 


 c
c c c
 c  c 
c c
 c   c
  
c
c c c  c
 c    c) c c
c c 
c
  c
c c 
c c c c c
 c c
 c 


 c
c

 c
 c 
  c

P%c
 c
 c c   
 c c  c
c 
c

c

c

-.$%$45$&-11-c



   2 
2 

 Ê
  
c c2Ê   ;+?+
%*%+/!$'?$&' +& %$' &#%,&%? <   
#+  #+B,5B Ê  #+4/$/$#+B 5B

 
 c

Ê 
 c
c %
  !%

› Ê 

   
$
c

  cc cc
  c
 c cc
 c 


 
c c
 c
!   cc

c
c
 c  
c
c c
 c cc
 c0   c
 
 0cc  c c  c c0  c  cc c 
c
c 
c
  c
c   c c cc  0c c
 c
c c c c
 cc0   0c

    
 c
c  c 
cc

ccc ccc 


c c  
 c c 
 cc c
 c
!   c
c
c  c
c
 c   
c  c cc
 c 
c c
c
 c c cc
c c  c  cc cP c  
cc  c 

 cc c

 c
c c 
c
 cP  
c  
c
c  c
 c   c
 
 c  c
 !  c 
 c 
ccc c cc 
c


c c c
c c  c
c   cc  cc
 c 
c c
c  c c c cc
c
 c 
 c c
c

c c
)   c 
c
 c  c  c    c  cc  c
2 cc  c c
 c  
c
c c
 c cc
 c
c c 
 c c
c 
 c
 cP  
c c
 c c
 c c c  c    c  
c   c c c
 c c c c

 c   c c 
cc
 c cc


c  ccc

 c  
c  c
 c 
 cc 
 c cc c  c c c
c
 
cc
 c c  c c 
c
 c
c c c  
c c

 c c  /c c
 c
 cc c
 cc  
c
c c
 c
    
 c c  c  
cc


cc
 c  c c
 c c  c
 c  c 
c
 
 c c  
c
c
 c c  c 
cc

$c 
c
 c cc c 

cc 

c c c
c 
c
c c

 
  c c  c 
cc

$c 
c
 c cc 

c cccc c


 
   
 c c  c 
c c

$c(
c
 cc c c c c  c c  c c c 
c

 c c
c c c
 c c

c
 c
!   c
cccc c


    
 c c  c 
cc

  c c cc c


 cc 
cc  c
c
 c c 
c
c
 c   
c c  cc  c
 c
c   c
c  c
 

 cccc 
 cc  ccc  c c

 c   c cc c cc



c  
c  c
 
c c
 c 
 c c 
 c
c  
c
c
 c cc
c c  
c
c
 c c
c  cc c 

 c c   c
  c cc  cc  c cc c )cPc

 c$
%c
c
cPc
cc

c
cc
c
%cc c)c
c
  c 

 c c
c  c c  
 c c
c c c
c
  c cc
 c
!   cc 

cc   c c  c 


c c 


cc c
cc  cc c 
 c c
 
cc
  
cc

 c  c c c
c
 c 
 c c
c)   c 
cc
   cc
 c c
 c ! c  c  c  c
c c 
c
c  c  c2 c  cc  c2 cc
  c c
 c* Pc*%cc   c 
 cc
  cc  c
c c c

c
c
cc
c

%cc
 c
 
c  c  cc c c
c  c
2 c  ccc  cc  cc  c2 cc  c
c
 c c
 c  
c
c c
 c c
c c c
 c c  /c
 c
 c
 cc c
 c  
c
c c
 c cc

cc

 c ! c  cc c  c2 cc  c c
 c
  

c   c 
 c c   
cc
 c
 c  c
 cc
 cc
  c  c  cc    c
 
c   c2 c 
 c
c c
c

cc
c

 c  c
c 
cc c  cc
 
 cc
 c cc

c
 c  
c2 c  cc   c  cc
c
c

 c
 c  
c c
 c  c c
 c c c  c
   c  
c   c2 c
 c c c cc c
 c
  c
c  c 
cc 

c c
cc c  c
c
 c  c c c
 c  c  
c

c2 c c  c
 cc  c   c  c


cc
c
 c  c
c 
c cccc 
 c
 c
P  
c c
 c  c c
 c c c  c    c  
c
   c2 c
 c c cc
c
c c
 cc  c
 c c
 cc
c c
 c* Pc*%cc
 c
 ccc c c
 c  c   c c  
c c
 
cc c 
 c   c2 c 
 c c
  c2 c
c2 c
 c c c
c 
cc 
 c

 cP  
c c
 c  c c
 c cc
c 
 cc
 c
 cc  
c     
 c c  c 
cc 

c  c  cc %Pcc%c


%
cc c

 c

cc
cc**cP  cc
 c  c
 c
 c   c2 c 
 c
 
 ccc c
c c  
c
  c c
 c c  /c c2 c c

cc
c
 c
  c
c  cc 
c c
 c   c c 
 c
 cP  
c
c
 c  c c
 c c
 c c 
 c  
c
   c2 c
 c c cc 
cc
 c cc
  
cP  
   
 c c  c 
cc 


c
 c  c 
c 
 c

 c
 c  c c
 c
 c$cc c c c c  c
c  c c c 
cc$c

c  c c  cc  c

c  c c c  c c


c c c
 c 
c c
 c


c c
 c c


c$ c
cccc c

 c$c
cc  c$ c
c  c  c
c  c  
c
c
  cc
 c

 c
  cc$c
c  cc
 c  c

 c c
 c
   
 c
c  c 
c c 

   c
 c 


 c c c
 c
c 
cc
c  
 c c 
 c c
c  c
 c


c c c
 c c

c
cccc c

 cc

c
cc  c
c  cc c
 c 
 c
c
 c
 c  c  cP  
c
  c( c   c
c
 
c
c ccc c c
 c c
  c

›› › 
   
6


 cc 
 c c$ c c
 c 


 c

c

c0 cc c

 c c
1   
cc c 
0-cc c

 ccc 


 c
cc 
c  
c


c
 
c   cc
 c 


 c cc 
 c cc c

 c c
 
.  c 


 cc
cc c

 c  c
c  
c
 c c c
 
 c c  c c  c 
 c
cc
  !cc
   c  
c 
 c  
 c c
 c c 
 1)
 c
c  
 cc c

 c  c  c


c  c   c  cc 
c
 
 c3c
cc
c
c c

c
 c 


 c 
 cc 
c  c
c
c cc 
cc
 c 
 c cc  c c
ccc 
 c

c
  c
c

 c


cccc c

 c c c  c 


cc 

c
 c c
cc
 c
!   c
cc   c c
 c 
c- ccc c


 c   c
c0
cc 
 0c
 c  
c
c c
 c ccc
0 
 c  c
c
 c   cc  
c c
 c 
 c
c 
 cc/ c  
c
c c c
c
 c  
c c
 c /0c c c c
 c
c
 c
c 
cc
  c   c0
 c  c c
 c  0cc  c0 c
 c c
  c
 c 
c c
 cc

c c c
 c c c  c c c
0c
 c c
c
 c
c 
c0 c
 c  c c"
c c
 #cc
 c c
c
 c
  ccc cc  
 c  c
 ccc
ccc c

 c   c
cc

c c
  c 
cc  
 c c 
 c 
cc
 c  cc c  c
c

 0 c
c  c 
cc

c( c
 c
cc   cc
c
c  
 c
cc c c

c
c c
c  c
 c
  
c
c c
 c c c
 c  c
  c c
 c   c c  
c
(
c
c cc c
c  c
 c
c
c cc  c  c c
 c 
 c c

 cP  
c c
 c   c c
 c 
 c

cc 
 cc
c  c
c
 c
 c 
 c  c
c0  
c
c c
 c 0c c   c
c 
 c   cc 
c
 c
c c
c  c
c
 c  
c
c c
 c
 c
c c
c0 c
 c 
 c c
 c c   cc
 c
   0c
c  cc
c c  c
c c  
c0 c c  c 
cc 

c 
 c c
 c
c
  c
c  c 
 cc c
 cc  c !
  
c  
cc   c
c c  cccc c c-c c

c ccc c

 cc
   c  


 c 
 cc  cc
c 
 
c

cc  c

$c c  c cc cc cc  c c


 c  
cc

ccc  c! c
c  c 
cc 

$ ccc  c 
c
 
c  c c c  
 c c cc
 c  c  c 
c c  c c
 c  c$
 c

ccc  c  c    c c c 
c
 c c c
 c 
    
 c c  c  
cc

 c c c  c c
c
 c

 c cc  cc
 c
  
c
   
 c c  c 
cc 

$c c  c c  c  


c
c 
 cc c  c
c  c
c
3 c c  c c
c  c
c  c c c
c

c


c   c
 c  
c
cc  c
cc 
 c c
c
  c  cc
 c
c

c  c     cc  c  c
  cc  c cc  c c
 c c  c c c c 
 cc
 c
   c 
c c
 c
c

c 
c
c

 c
 c c c c 
c
 c cc c
 c c  
c
  
cc   c
c c 


ccc c

 c  c


 
 c   c  c  c
 c   c  c
c 
c 
 c
  c
c c  c 
 c 
c


c   c  c c
 c  c c c 
 c
cc
c 
c
 cc 
 cc
  c  cc   c
 c
 
c
c
c c
 c 


 c
 c


c c
c
c 
cc   c c  c  c

c c
  c c 
c 
c
c c   c 
c

c$
cc


ccc  /c  c c
 c  c
c

c 
c

 cc
c c  c  cc  c
c 
cc  c
 c c c
 c
c  c c 

c
 c   c
c c   c
 c
   c

c›
 

 
 
 


 !  
 



 cc
   c
c c
 c  c

c cc
c!c
%
  
$  
    
 c c  c  
cc

  
c
c c   c
 
 c 
 c c cc ccc cc
c cc c c cc  
c
c c   c 
c c  cc
 c  cc  c c
 c 
 c c  c
 c  
c
c
c
 
ccc0  
!
 c 
 0c  c
 c   c
 
 c
 
 c
c c cc

c ccc c c

-c$ c c  c

c c
 
 c c0  
!
 c 
 0cc
 c cc
c cc

c 
cc c c c
 c
 c c  c 
cc 

"# c 
 cc
 c
c

ccc$c 

 c 
c
 
c c 
  c c
 c  c  
c c  c 
 c
 
 c
 c c  
c  
c  c
cc 
 cc c
c


 c$c  
c c
c  c
 c  
 c c c c
  
c  
cc

c  ccc cc$ c  c c  c 
cc

c 
c c
 c 
c 
c
 c  
c

c
 c
cccc c


 c  c



c c c c
c  c
 c  c c c  c
c
 c  
 c

cc
 c
c c
c c  c
c
c
c

cc  c 
 c
 c
 c cc
 cc  c

c
 c
  
c
ccc0  
!
 c 
 0c
 c 
c c
 c



 c 
 c
c
c c c cc
c  c

c
 c
c c
 c  c
c
 c c  c 
cc 

c
c  c
 c cc cc
 c 
c c cc
 
 c
c   c

c
 c  
c
c c 
c c
 c
 
 c
cc
c c  c  c
c
 c
c c
 c
c c
 c
c
 c
c
 c  c
c c
  c
 
 c
c
cc  c 
 c
  
c
c cc
 c
c  c  
c c c  c$ cc
ccc
c cc
c c

 c  c
 c
!   c
ccc c

 c
c c c

 c    c
c
 c  
cc 
cc
 cc  c

c  c c  c
c   c
 c
  
c
c
 c   c 
cc

c
 c 
c
cc
c c  c 
 c
 cP  
cc
c
c c
c
 c
c

c
 c  c  c
 c
c  c
  cc c 
c
cc

c
 c  c
 c
c c
c   c
c
c
c  c

c
c 
 c
cc  
 c c
c 
 c
 c 
c
P  
c c  c  
cc
 c c cc c
 c 
 c  c
 c 
 c
c 
 c cc  c     
 c c  c 
cc

c
c
 cc

c  c
 c


c 
 c 
cc 
  c
c 
c
 c
    
c c c c c  cc
 c
c  c
c
c c

cc   c

 c
 c c  ccc c  c
ccc0
c  0c   cc c


cc
 cc 
c c c  c 

 c c c  
c c
 c


c
  c 
 cc c  c  c c c c  c

c
c 
 c
 c
 c c c
 c
c
c
 c


c   c   c

c  c 
c c
. ! c
 c
c  c

c
c 
 c
 c c  
 c c
 c
c 
cc

c 
 cc c c
c   c

c  c
c c  c 
c c c
c
 c c  c0  c  cc c 
c
0c.  c  
c c  c


c
c  c
 c  c c c
 c
c 
c c c c0 
c
0c c
 


cc   
c c0  0c

c  c
 c  
c c 
c   c  c
 c   c c c 
c

 cc
 c 
 /c  c
 
 c c

 c

c   c c c  c   c


c
 c 
 /c c
 
    
 c
c  c 
 cc 

c
c c  c

c
 c
c   c  cc
c
 
 c
c 
 cc

c  c
c  c
ccc c

 cc


c 
c
 c c  c c
  
 c  
c c  c  cc  c c  c c
 cc c
 c
c cc 
 c c

c
 c  c 
  c c c  
c
c
 c


 c
c
 
c
c  cc
c
 c
 c    cc c  c
c
c ccc c


 c cc




c  c  c 
c 
! c 
c cc
  c c
c 
c
 
c
c 
cc c c  c c   cc  c
c c 
cc c
c 
c c cc  c
  cc  c c c
 cc
c  
 c
cc c
c c  c
c
 c  c c
 c* c* c*c1 c c  c 
cc 

c c
c
 c c
 c 
c c 
 c c$c c
 c 
c  c
c3  c c
 c
c  c
c
 c 
 
c c c  
c c  c  c0
c
 c 
c

c
 c
 c
c  c c
 c  
c
cc

c
 c c
c  c c c 
 c
c
 c
 c 
 c c
 cP  
c c  c c c c c c  


 c

 0cc  c c
c 
c cc  c 
cc 

 c
cc  c cc


c c 
 c
c c  c c
c  c 
 c
  c cc cc cc cc
c 
c  
c c
 c

cc c
c
 c
c   ccc c

 c-0
cc  c
c c

c


cc   c

  c cc
 c
cc
 c   c
c
 cP  
c c
 c
c

c c

 c c(c  c c  c- c  c  c


 c  c-- cc
 
c
 c  
c c 
 c  
 c
c  c cc
 c
c c
 cc
cc c

c
 cc  cc   c
 
 c- cc c
cc c cc
  c c
 c  
c
c
c  ccc  c c  c cc c  c-. c
 c 
ccc c

    
 c c   c 
cc


c c
 c  
c   cc 
 cc c   c   c
c c 
c
c
c c0  c
  0c
 c 
 c c c
c c  cc c cc

c  c  c
c c c

 c- c c  c 
cc 

c4
!7 .
1
     /
c-
 c c% c 
 c ccc
  c  c 
c 
! c 
c
cc  c c
c 
c
 
c
c 
c
c c c  c c  c c  cc  c c cc 
c c
c
 
c( c
 c


cc
c  c
 c* c* c*cc
c  
 c
 cc c

c
 c***c    cc 
c
 c


c
c
 cc

c
c
c

c
 c* c* c*c c  
c
 c 
c 
! c 
 c c
 c 
 cc
 c*
c c   c
 c
c

c   c 
c  c c
  c   c c
 c
 cc
 
 c c
 c* c* c*c  c 
cc

 c 
c  c   c
 c c cc
 c c 
c
cc
  c
 c   c

c
 c 
 cc 
  c cc   c

 c
 c
 c c c 
 c c c    cc

c
 c
   c 
c$ccc 
c
  c c
 c
c c  cc
c c

 c   c  c
c   cc  cc c c
cc
  
cc
c  c
cc c   cc$cc
 c  c
c cc
  c c
 c
c c
 c
 ccc 
c
c
c   c
 c c
 c 
cc c
 c* c* c*c
 cc 
 cc
 c
  cc0
ccc

c c  c   c

c
c 
 c

 c  c
c
c
c  c  c c cc cc
 c
c 
c
c
 c
 c
c
 cc c
 c  0cc
c
c c
 c
 cc0   c 
 cc
 c   c c c
 c c c
 c c cc 
 c c c c c c
 c
 c 
! cc 
c
c c c c 
c
c
 c c
 
 c c
 c  c c
 c
c
 c
c c
 0c
 c c
 c
 
cc0
ccc

c c  c   c

c
 c 
 c c

 c cc
 c 
cc    cc  c   c
 
 c

c
c
 c  cc

 c c  c c c c
 c
c

 c 
 cc
c   c
c
c 
0cc
cc c
 c
 cc
0 c  c cc   c c   c  c   
c  c
 
  cc
 c   
c cc c  c   c 
 c

 cc c c
c c   c c

c
 c 
 c c
 c  c
 c  c
 c
c c  0c  c
c 
c

c  c0
 c


 c c cc 
c 
 0cc   c


c0
 c c c 
c 
 cc c  c  

0c!c
 cc

c

c!cc0   
c  c c  cc   c


 c c 
c c c cc c
c  c  c 
 c

c c c
 c  c 
  c
 c 
 0 c c  c 
cc 

c c
( c  c

c
 c 
 cc  c
c c 
 ccc  c
  c c
 c  c  
c cc c  cc 

c c

 c)  c c   

 c c
 c
c  c 
c
c
 c 
 c
   cc
 
 c c
 c* c* c*c c c
cc  c!c

c
 c 
 
c   c!c

c
 c  ccc  c c
 c* c* c*c
cc  c
 c
c
 c 
 c   c  c
 c* c
c
c
 cccc  c c
 c  c

c
c  cc
c
c

 ! c 
 c


c
c

cc
c c
c 


 cc

c c
c  c
 c 
c   c ccc c   c
c
 c
 


 c c
 c
c

cc
 c 
c c
c  cc 
c
c
 cc   c0
c   0ccc
c
 c  c c
  c
  c  c
c c
c c0c  c  
cc
 c
  c 
c c c 
 ccc   c
c
 c c c c
 c
   
0c

c
cc  
cc  c
c
 c cc
  cc
 
c 
c  cc c  c

c
cc

 c c 
c  cc cc 
c c c c
 c


 c c c

cc
 c cc

c
c
 c
cc

c
c
c cc
 c  
c c
c  c c
c  c
   c
c c c-1 c c  c 
cc

c
 c c
 c
c c
 c  
c
cc c
 c  
c c 
 c

 c c
c 
cc c c c
 c  
c
c c
 c c
c cc
 c 
 c-3c  c cc c

c
 c  
 c c
 c
cc
 c
0 
 c c
 c cP  
c c c
  cc
c 
cc
 c
 cc  
c c c  
cc
c

c c 
c cc c
0c-  c  
 cc   c0 c
c
 c 
c c
 c  
c

c c
 c cc
 c 
 c c  
c  
c c
c 
 c
 cc
 c*
c c$*cc
 c    c c
 c c  /c c
c

   c  c
 c   c cc0( c 

c
   c c 
c
c
 c

 c cc  c c c c c c  c ccc
c 
 c
 c
  
cc c
 c cc
c c  cc   c
c
 cP  
c c

 c    
 c
c   c 
c c

c cc
c  c

c
 c


c  c  c c cc  c

c
c c c
c

 c
c c
 c 
 c
cc c

 c
cc c   c

c
c 
c c

 
  cc c
c  
c c    
c  c  c
 c
 c ccc c


 ccc 


 c 
 c c 
cc 
 c 
c   c0   
 cc
c c

 ccc  c  
  c   c c
c
1   c 
 c cc
 c

c 
 c c 
c
 c
 c cc  cc
  c!c/ cc c

 c c
1   cc c /cc    c c"c


#c
ccc c

 c
cc cc
1   c
c c
cc
cc
1   c
 c
  c

c 
c

c
cc
c c   c

c
c
c ccc c

 0c c c  c 


cc

 cc
    %8 .c-
 cc   c 
c  c
 c 
c c

 c
c c
 c
c c c  cc  c

c"# c  cc c c


c c c  c c c c  c c
  
cc
 c   c c
 c
c c c  cc c  c c
 
 
c
  c 
 c  
 c c 
 c cc
c  c$c c
 c
c
 c 
 c
c c
c 
 c  c 
c c
 
c c c
 c
c
c 
 c   c 
 c   cc  c c c 
c

c c c 
c 
 c 
 c c
cc  c
 
c c
 c cc
cc  c c  c$c c  c
 
c c
 
c
 c 
 c c  c c    c c
 cP  
c c

 c
c

c c c c c
 c

c c c

c c
c  c
 c


c
 c 
c
  c
 c  
 c
 c c
 c
c
c
 c


  c
  c
 c

c
c  cc c  c c
c cc
c
 c
c  c
 cc
c  
c
c c 
  
  c cc  ! c  c
c
c

 c
c( c  c

c  c
 c  c 


 c
 c
c
  
cc c
c
 c 

c

c
cc  c
 c
/c c   c
  c c   
 c
c
c 
 cc  c  c 
c c c

 c   
c 
 c c
 cP  
c c c c c   c 
c
c
 c c c c  c  c  
c
 c  
  c  cc
   c  
 c
c

c
 c c   c c 
cc
  
c  
 c c 
c
c
 c

cc
 c
c


   
 c
c  c 
cc 

c c
 c  c c
 c
cc  c  cc

  c
  c  c
 c


cc
 c

c cc
c  c  cc
  
  c  
 c
c c  
 cc 
c c c
  
c
 c c
c
c
c 
c c 
 c  
c c
  
 
c c  c c  c c
  c 
 c
  c
c
 c 
 c c
 c


c c
c c
  c 
 c

c c
c

 c c  c  
 c
c
 cc c

 cc

  c
   c  c c

 c
 c
c 
 c  

c

c
 c


c c
c ccc c


   c


c  
cc

c
 c 
 c
c   c  cc
 cc
   c 
c   
c  
c
c
 cc  c   c
 
 c 
 
c c
c

 cc
 c


c cc
c c0
 0c c c

  c
 c 
c

c
 c
  
cc
c  
cc  
c c
 
c

cc
 
c c 
 c  c
c
 c


 c
c
 
 c c
c
 c   cc
 c cc c
c
 c
 c   
 c

c  
cc c
c c  cc c   c
c c  c c cc
 c  c c 
 c c

c
 c  c c
 cc
 c  
c  
c
 c c c cc  c  
 c
   c c
c
   c c
 c c  
c
 
 c
  cc c c
 
cc

 c c c  c 


cc

c

 
c   c c cc c
 
!   c
c 
 cc
  c
  c



c
 c 
 c
  c c  c
c
c 

0
c
 c c
c
c
0c c
  c c0    cc c 
c
c 
c
   c

   c c c  c c
 c  
c
c c
  c2 c
c
   c c c c   c 
 0
c  cc c c  c   c
   c  c c
 c
c c c c
 c   c 
 
c
 c
 c c
 c

 
c c
 cc   c
 c  

c c c
   c c
c
   cc
cc  c 
c
 c  c
 c
c  cc   c
  c

c c  
 c  
c
c  
c c  c  c 
c.
 c 
 c  c c
 c
c c
   
c  c

››› '
  

-

  
 


cc  c

c
 c 
 c 
 cc 
 cc c
 c
c

c
 c  
c

c c
 c cc  c  c c
 c 
 c c
 P  
cc

 c
c
c  c
 cc cc 
 c c 
c c
 c  c c
 c
c


 c
c 
 c
 c 
 c  c
cc 
 cc  c c   cc
  c c 
 c c  
c

c
 c c
 
c c  c
c   c
0  c 
 0cc
 c  c c 


 c  c  c c

 c

c c
c
 c   c 
 c 
  c c
 c 
 c cc 

 c c c
 c  c c
  c 
c
 c


cc 
 c    
c c 

 cc
 c


c
 cc
 c  c
 c

c" # c  
c
c c
 c c
   
 cc 
c

ccc 
cc  c 
c 
 c
 cP  
c c
 c
  c c
 c 
c  c c  cc    c
c c c  
c
   c
 c c c c
 c   c c 
cc

  cc


c  c  
c
c c 
 c 
  c c  c 
c c 

c" # c 
 c 
 cc
 
 c c
 c  

c c
 c
 c 


cc c  
c c c
c
 c  
c c
 c
  c
c  c  
cc

c"#c
 c  c c
 c  c 

 cc 

   c

 cc  c
c

 cc 
   c c
 c  
c
c
c
 c cc
c
 
 
  cc  
c c c c 
 c

c  c

c 
 c  c
c
 c   cc  
c c
 c 
 c

c

c
 c 


 
c c
 c
c c c  
c 
 c c
c cc
  c
cc 

 c


c  c 

c
c c    
 c c  c 
cc 

c c

c c c c
 c
c  cc  c c
 c
 c
c c
 c
c
   c 
c c
 c

 c
 
 
 c" 
 c
  c c c  

 c c

 c
 c

ccc c
 c c c  c 
  c
c c c 
c c
  c c cc 
 c c 
 
c c
 c
c
cc
c   c 
 
c c 
c cc
 c    
c  c
c c
 c c c

c  c$ c
c
c c  c
c
c   c   

 c c  ! c cc 
 c c
 
 c 
c c
 c
 c

c  cc

c
c
 c
 c c
 c


c
 c
c c  
c
 c  c c
 c
 


 c c  c
c c c c 
cc c cc
  c 

c
   c  c c   c 
cc 
c c  
c c
 c
    
 c c   c 
c c

c  
 c  
 cc

c 
 c 
c!c
  c 
cc c
  
c
c
 c 
 c  
c!cc
c c  c c
c
 c

 c
  ccc
 c c  c

c
 c 
c c
 
 
c!c
  cc
 c
 c 
 c 
 
c
c
 c

c!c c

c c  

cc c c
c
 c  
c c
c c
c c c  c 
cc 

 c

c  
cc4
%%  
!7 .c1 
c c
c 
cc   
c3c

c/ cc c c
c cc   c 
 c
cc  c
 

 
cc c 
 c
 c c
 c
 c    
c c c  c c

  cc c

 c
c

c 
c  cc 
   0c  c 
c
c 
 c c  
c
c

   
 c c  c 
cc 

(
c  
c
ccc

 
c c 
 c c
 cc  c   c

 
 c 
 c
c c$

c0  
!
 c 
 0c c 
   c
 c
 c  
c 
 c
 c   
c  
cc

c
 c  
c
 c
0  c
 c  
 c c c c  
c  
0
 cc   c
 
cc

c c

cc
c c
 c 
c
c  c
 c 
c c
   
 c cc
 
c
   c c
 c  
c 
 c 

 c c 

c c
  c c 
cc  ccc c c c c c% c c
c c c( c 
 c
cc
 cc   
 c
ccc c c 
c
 cc c 
cc
c  

 c
c c  c c
 c
 
c  
c 
 c  c
c
 c
c 
c  
c
 c
c

c
c
c
 c
c

cc
  c   
c
 c c 
c   c

c
   c c
  c
c  
c  
c 
 c c

 ccc

 c c
c  c 
cc

c

 
c   c c cc c
  
 c c
 
cc
 c

!   c
   
 c c  c 
cc


c
 cP  
ccc
c
c

c
  c
   ccc  
 c
cc

c   c  
   !   
 cc
 c0 

c  0c c 
c
c  cc

  c  c
 c  c0  cc 
c
c

c
c  c
 
 c  c
 
c

c c  
c  cc c

0c.0c c 
 c c c

 ccc
  3
Ê 
c.c

(
c
 
c 
c
  c c c
c
 c  


c
  ccc/
/c
c
   c
c

c  
c

c  c  c
 c 
c

 
 c c  
c  c c  cc   c c( c
 
 c c c  
c   cc
 c  c c 
  c
 
 cc c c
c
c c    
c c
c
 c c  c c   c

c
c
c
c
 c  c c  c
c
 
c
c
 c

 c
 c  
c c  cc    c

c c  c 


c
 c c c
 c
c
c  
c$c 
 c  cc 
cc

  c     c


c  
c c
 c  c

c0 c
 
 c  
c
   c c 

cc 



c   c
c c  c c c

c  c

   
c  c 
 c c
 c cc c  c  c 0c.-  c
    
c c. !  c
  c  c   c c
 ccc  
cc c c  cc   c 
 c. cc
c c

c

  ccc 
 c  ccc    
c
c
 c

 cc c  cc 
 c
 c
c   c


c
 c 
 cc  cc  c   c
 c  c 
c c

c  
c c   c c  cc
c
c
 c
  
 ccc
cc  c.. c c  c 
cc

c  c  
c

c
 c
cc  


   c   c 
 cc   c c
c0 
 0 c
 cP  
cc 
 c c c c c

 c
   c
 c 
 c c
 c 0  c  cc c 
c
0cc 
 cc
 
 ccc   cc 
 c 
 c
 c 
  cc
 c 
 c  c c

 c  
c
c   c

cc 
 ccc   c

c  c
 c
  
c
c c
 c c
c c  c 
c c  c0  c  c
c c 
c
0c c
 c 
c0  0c  c c c


 c 
 c
 

cc0 
 c
c  c c  c    c
c c c  
c   cc

 c  0c  c  c c
c  
 cc 
 cc 
c c c  c
cc

c
 c
c
c  
    
 c c  c 
c c

  c
 c c0 
 /c  
 c 

 c  c c   
cc
 c c
 c ccc
   c c  c c c  c 
 c   
c
c 
 c
 cc c
c cc
 c
 c c c
 c
!   c
c
 c
 c
 c c0 
 0ccc
 c  cc  

c
c
 c  c

c c
  
c  
 c c
 c0 
 0  c0 
cc
 c cc



  cc c"#c
 cP  
c  c
  
 cc 
 c cc
 c  0c(
c
 
c  cccc  
 c c 
 cc  c0  c
  c  c c
 c 
c  c 
c 
 c c
 cP  
c c    c
c
c c 

cc
 ccc   c  ccc
c  
 c
 c

c c  
c  c c/ 
 / c
c c c
 cc c
cc
  c c
 c   c c
 c  
 c  c  c  c
 cc"c
 c
  c  
cc   c
c  
c
 c 
  #cc
  
c  c

  cc c
 c c c  cc 


c
 cc


 cc

 c 
c  c c
c
c
 c  0c.c

›0 '
  
  D

1
 

c  c 
c
c
 c
cc c
c  c
c 
 c
 cP  
c
 c  c    c 
 c c c(
c
 
cc   c c c   c
c 
 cc  c c
 c 
 
c c  cc
 c  
c

c
 c cc c 
cc c 

cc
c   cc   c

  c c
 c c  
  c
 c  
cc
 c   
 c c
  



 ccc 
    
 c c  c 
cc 

 c  c  c c
 cc  c
c
ccc c  
c
c
 c
  c  c
 c
!   c
c  c  c  c

( c  c c c c


c
c  c  
c c c
  c c  c c
c 
c    c
 c 
 c c
 
 
 c c c c  
 c  c c    c c   c ccc
  c c c 

c c c 
c c c  c c  c
 
 c   c
  c! c c  c 
cc 

c c  c
c  c
c3c c  c
  c
c
 
c
c c
ccc c  c c   
 c
 c
c

c c
 c 
 
c c 
  c c
 c  c c 
c  cc
  
 c. c
c  c 
cc

c 
c
 c 
c c
c  c
 c0 
cccÊ
  3
Ê 
c.1c


cc

 cc


c  c
cc c   c   cc
c
 


  c

c cc
c 
 c 
 c

cc
 
 c
c 
c   c 
c  c
 c c c
c  
c

c cc 

cc
c c 
 ccc

c c
 c

  
c( cc c c  c c  c 
c
 


cc   c c c 
ccc c c
c c
 c  c c   c  
c  c c

 c  c
 c
 
c c

c  
c

  ccc cc
 c c  c
 c   c  
c
 c   c
c  !   
 c
 c  c c 
c cc  cc

cc
 c

 c
  cc
 c 
 c c

c
 cc  c   c
 
 c 
 c

c c 
 c 
 c  
cc
c c

c
 
c c 
c 
c 

 c
c

 c  c c  c   c


c
c c
c c   c   c
 c  
c c
  cc
 c 
c
 c c  c
 c
 c.3 cc

c 
 c
0
 c
c 
c   c
 c c   c
c cc
  cc 
c
c
   
 c
 cc c
 c c  cc  c   c c
 c
 
 c   cc 
 c c 
c
c
 c c

c
 c 
c
c  c
c
    c
 c  
cc
c  
 c
 c0c.c

0 '
  ' 


c c
 c   
c  c  c
 c 


 c 

c0 ccc c c 
c

ccc  c  c
c  c  
ccc c   cc
 c

 c c
 c0c
0
c
c  c 
cc

(
cc cc
c  c
c c  cc


 c c
 c
cc
 c
c  c c
 
 ccc c

 
 c 
c  c c  c
c
 c  c
c

 c
 cP  
c c
 c  c
 c c c
 c
  
c c c c
c 
c    c  c    c  
c
   c c c  c
 c   c cc cP  
c c
 
c     c
 c 
 cc 
 c c c c  c
 c  c   
 
  
c
 c
   c 
 c  c
  cc
 c c  c


cc c

c
 cc  cc 
c  c
 c  cc
 c  
c

c c
 c  cc 
 c
cc c0 c   c
 c  c
c

 c
 c
 c c c c  
 c c c c c
 c

cc
c
c

c


c  c 
cc  
c  c  c
 c   cc
c
c c

 c
 c  cc   
c  c
c  cc c  
c  c
 c

c

c c
c c c c cc
!  
  c ccc
c c  c  0 c c  c 
cc

 c
cc
 c
c
cc

 c$0c
c
c

 c  
c
c c
 c
 cc 
 c c  c   cc 
 c
   0ccc 
c

 c 
 c c  

c0 c
cc c cc
 cc

!   c
0 
 c
c
 cc

 c
 c 
c

 c c
 c


    c

c

c
 c  
c

cc   c  ccc c


c  
c
   c
 c 


  cc  c


c  cc c c
 
cP  
c
c
c   c   c c  
     
 c c  c 
cc 

 c

 c ccc c
c cc
  c cc  c
c 

cc c
c 
c
 c

c c
 c
c
ccc c

 c c
c
cc c
c c

 c
 c  c
c    c c
 c   cc
c  
 c-c c c
c 
 
 c

c c  cc
 c


cc c c  cc   c  c
c
c

c
 c
 
 c

c( c 

c
 c
!   c
c  c
  c
  c    
c

0› $  



c   c cc c  c


 c 
c c
 
!   c
c c
c
  c
 c  c   cc  
 cc
c    
c  
c
c
 cc
 c 
 c c c   c c   c  c  c c
c
 c
 c%


c c   cc c  
 c  c
 c
  cP  
c
c
 c
c c c 
 c c 
c
c 
c 
c
 c  c
  
 c
 c c c c
 c  
c
c c
 c  c c
 c
   c 
  c c  c 
c c

$ cc
 c c c   c 
 c
 c

 c  
c
c c
 c c
$c

c
    c c
 c 
 cc
c 
 c
 c  
P  
c c
 c
 cc
c 
cc
 
 cc


c  c  c
 c 
 c c
  c  c$c

c
 c  c  c c 
 c$c

c cc c
  c  cc 
c
c c c  c 
cc

$cc
 c c c
 c  
c
c c
 c $c

c
 cc 
 c
c  c

 c  
 c c  cc c
c  c
c
c cc    c c
 c

 c c
 cP  
c c  c c
 c   c cc
 c 
 c  c

c  c

  
 c cc  c  c$c

c
 c  c  c
 cc$c

c cc c
  c  cc 
c
   
 c c  c  
cc

( c c  cc c    


cc
c
  c c cc  c c
 c
  
c
c
 c c c c c
 c   c 
 c   c
c


c
c
 c

    
 c c  c  
cc

P%c
 c 
  c  
 c c 
  c cc
c cc
  c
 c
 c c     c
c
 c 
cc c c
c c
 c 
c 
c
  c

#. / '

.


 
    %
  !% c
 %
  !%

$ 
 $    

  %
  !% c
 %
  !%

#.    .  c

c c  c 
cc  c

c c  c 
cc  c

-303%5$&-1c

, Êc

  cc
c
 ÊÊ    Êc   
c

Ê   
  
 
 D
 
 
 c

Ê2 9
c

 c 
 c
 c  
c
c
 c  c c
 
  cc
cc  c
c
 ccc 

 c0c
c 
c
 c 
c c
cc
 c  c c
 c c 0c
cc  c c 
cc
 c  c1c

c1c
c c
 c  c

c
c  c
 c 


 c
c

c0 ccc c c

c
ccc  c  c
c  c  
ccc c   cc
 c

 c c

 c0c   /c ccc


 c 
 c 
cc
 c  
c c

 c c

  cc 
 c

c  c c c


 c c
 
 c c
cc)  cc c cc  c

c c cc
c  c  c c
 c


c    cc

%c c

 c c c c c c cc*


! cc
 c  c   c  c*c*
c  c
c cc  c c
 cc 
cc
 c
 
 c c
ccc  c c c c c c 
c  c
c 
 cc 


c
cc

cc   
c 
c c
 c
 c  c
c c cc
 c 
c c
c  c c c c
 c  c 
c c  
c c
 c 
cc cc c

 cc  c 
c c  ! cc  c c
 c c 
cc c
 
cc
 c
c  c
! c  c  
 c c c c

 c c c
cc
 c 
c  c
c c


c c
c
c
c

c c cc c 
c 
  c c
c
 c
 
c c c 
 $ % cc

c c cc*
!

c c
 cc c  c   c  cc*c c
cc
 c c
 c 
c
 c 
c cc cc
 c 
 $ % 
c
c c c c c

 
c c
 c c  
 c   c 
c
c  
 c c  
c c c
 c
 
 
c 
 c cc c

 c   c c 
 
c c 
c 

 c c
cc c
 c
 
 c   c
 c  c

c

c  
c
cc c
 c c
 
c c
c c c cc  c
 c c c*
c
  cc cc  c c
 cc
 
c

cc
 c 
c cc c c c
 c c c
cc c

cc
 c 
c c  c

c
 c c c
 c cc*
! cc c  c   c
  cc*c

cc
 c 
c cc c c

c

 
 cc
 c


c
c
  c c1cc
 c 
 cc
 c  c c


c1c c
  c
c
 c  c c c c c c 
c
cc cc

 c  c c
 c
 c  c

 c c
c   
c c 
 cc c
 c  c c
 c  
c
 c
 c


c
 
 c 
 c    c
c   c

c
 c  
 c c
 c


c c
   c 
c0  c c  
c 
 0c

   c c  
 c c 
 cc c
c c
c c


 c  c

c

 c


c0 c c  
c  c  c  


 c c
 c   c 
0c

c
  c
 c  
c c
 c c 
 cc 
 c cccc
  
cc
 c c
 c
 c 
 c cc

ccc   c
c c

 c c  
 c) c c

c  c
c c c  c  


 cc

c
   /c  
 c c  
c c cc 
 cc c  
c
 c c
c  
c   c c   c

c

  c  c  c
 c 


 c    
c  

c

c0"# ccc c
 c 
c
ccc  c  c
c  c  
ccc c   cc
 c

 c
c
 c0c


c c c c
c

c
c
c
 c

c

c
 c 


 c  c 
c c


 c  c 
 c  cD c  cc
c c  c   
 c  c
 c


c c
   c  
cÊ
 c  c

 c c
 ccc
c c  ccc
  c  
c
c
 c
 c 
cc
 c cc
  c   c c
 c 
c
c
 c c  
c
  c

 c   c  cc
 c  c 
 c  c  
c c
 c


c 
c c0   cc
 c


 0c c
 cc c 


 c    
c0 
 c
 c
c c 0 c
  cc 
 c c
 c 
c

c
 c 


 c c
c 
c c  c
 c

 c
c c c
c  
 c
 c 
 c

c c
 ccc 
cc
 c c c
)  cc cc  c  c
c c  c
c

 cc c  c
c

  
 c
c
c c cc
 c)  c c   

 c  c
 cc c c
 c
 c 
c

 c  c
 c 


 c c
c   c  c
c  cc
 c

 c cc 
 
c
  c c c  cc
c c  c c c
  cc
 c 

cc
 c

c
c
  c
c  c c
 c

 c c  c
 c   c c
 c 


 c
 c

c
c c
 c 
c
 c  c
 
cc
 c  
c c
 ccc
 c
 c c
 c
 c  cc    c c
 c   ccc
c  
 cc
c

c  c

c c
 c
c  c
c
 c  c c
 cc
 cc c
 c c
 c 
c

 c
  cc
 c 
c  c c  c  c
 c 
c

c c
c c 
c
 c c
c
 c

 c cc


c  c
c
 c
 


 c    
c
 c  c c  c c c
 cc   c

 c

c c
 c   c cc

 cc
 c c
c
cc ccc

c  cc
c  
cc
 c  
c c
c c

cc  c
c
  c
cc  c  c  c
 c
c
c 
c  
! 
   




 
 !  %
 
  
 
  

 
 
  -    
  !

 


  
  
%"
 !

 
 

  

 
%
 
  
   
1
      

%"
   
  
 %c

ccccccccccccccccccccccc

c
c   c c
 c

 c % 
 
    
%
 

 
 
  
     
-

    
 

 


 %
.
 %  
  c

(
c
 c   c c
cc c
 ccc c
c
 c
c


c  c

 c1c
0c
c 
c
 c 
c c
c 
 
   
Ê0c1c
 
c
 c  c

c   c
 c  c c c c cc 
c c
 c 
 c c

c
c
 c

c

 cc
  c

c  
 cc
 c  
c  c c


c c  
cc
c c c c c
c  c c0c
 c  c c
 c c 0c c

c 

c c 

 c c
 c

 c c  
 c
 c
 c c 
cc

c
 c 
 ccc
 !  c   c  cc  c


c
$ c
c 
c
 c 
c c
c  
 c  c
 
!  c cc
 c
c
c
ccc
cc
 c  c c c c cc$c
c c  c

 c 
 cc

cc  c  
c  c c c c

 c c 
c c
 c 
 c

 c  c  
cc
c c  
c
c   c c


 cc
c c
 c  c c  cc
c
 c c
c c
 cc
cc
c
 c
 c  cc
 c
c c  cccc

ccc
 c  c c


c
  c

c
c c
 c

 cc c
 c c  c
 c
cc  c
c c
c
 c  
c  c c c c c
c 
c
 c cc
 ccc
c
c

cc  c  c


 c 
c c
 cc   c c
 c   cc   c
 c
c
 c 


 
c c  c
c c

   
/c
 cc

c
 c cc  c c
 c
 c  c  
cc0
 c
 

c
 c c

c
0c c

c  cc0   c
 c 
c
 c  
c c
 c 
 c c
 c  0c c
 c 
c c
cc

c

   c   c
c
 c 
c

c 
 cc

c c
 c c0 c
c c
  cc
 c

 c c
 c0c c 
 c1c c 
c c1c
c  c
 c  c c
 


 c  cc
c c
 c

 c c
 cc  c cc  c 
 c
c

 c  c  c  c
c
 c c  
c  c  
 c c c  
 c
c  c c
 c 
cc
 c   c  c c
  c c
 c
 c ccc
 

cc
 c 
 c cc 
cc
c
 c

 cc
c  
c
c 
c

   
cc c
c cD
!  Êc!  c
 c c cc 
 c  c
 cD
!c cc
cc  c c
  c
 c

 c c
 c
c$  c
c c c0c

c 
c
 c  c c 
c 
c  c  cc*!  0c

c

 cc cc  


 c  c
 c  
c

c
 c  c c
 cc
$ 
 cc
  cc   c
c
 c  
 c c c
 c  c
 c 
c  c

c
c 
cc
 c

 c c
 cc( c
  c  c

c
c
 cc c c 
c0 c
   cc
c 
cc  c 
c c  
c
c  c c
 c  c cc
 c
 c c
  0c1ccc0 
 c  c
c
 c  
0c c
 c 
 cc

c c

c 
cc
c

 c  c


c c  c c
c

 c cc  
c
c  c
 c

 c c cc  
c
c 
c  c  c  c


cc 
 cc

c c c    c c
 c 
 c c
 c c 
c c
cc
 c c  c c
 c
 c  c c c c

c   c 
cc c
 
cc  c c

c c c


 c
 
 c c
c 
c c


 ccc
c)
  0
 
D   c c(cc c   c
 c


cc 
  c c
 c

 c0c
c
c
  
c
 c c c 
 
cc
 c 
c c   0c  c


c  cc
c
 
 c c c0  c  c c
 c

c cc 
c

c
 c  c  c


 cc
 c 
 c c   cc

cc
c
cccc cc
 c cc
   c 


cc  c  
c c
 c c c
 c c c 
 
0c c


c
c  cc c c
 cc  
c c

c 
ccc
 c
c 

c
 c
 c  c  c 
 cc 
 c c
ccc
 c cc
c c 
 cc
 cc c
 cc

c 


 cc c0 cc
c  c  c
c  c  
ccc c   cc
c

 0c  c 
c 
c
  c  c
 c


cc 
c  c  c   c 
c cc
c
c
 c
 c  c c 
c  c  ccc)
c c c c
c
c c


c c c

c c0c
c
c  
c
 c  c c 
 
0c c c c
c  
c

 cc

c
 c c0c
 c 
c c   0c  c    c

c c c
c c
c 
c

c
 c c
c
c c c

c  c c
  cc   c

ccc c
 c  c cc   cc 
c
c 
cc
c c
 c

 c c
c
c c
 c   c c c
 c
cc c(  ccc
c c cc
 c

 
  
    
$      2

 

     



%  
      2c cc c

c cccc
cc(cc

'
  



  
› 
   
 
    
  #.
   
'
 
%
 

    !Ê&  8  92'

 

 
 
!  


  


 2 c

c


c c
cc  c c 
c   cc 
 c
   cc
c   cc
 c

 c  c  c  c  


 0 c

( c  c

c  c
c cc cc c

c  
 cc c

c  c
c c c
c c  c
c   c
c
 c
 c cc
 c 
 c c
cccc c c c
c
 c  c
  
 c c
 c 
 c
  cc
c c
 c
  c cc
 c 
 c
c  cccc
 c
 c  c c

c  c  c 
cc

c
 c

c

 c c
 c
c
c c
  c c
 cc
 c  c c c c c

( c c
c  c c
 c  c

  c c  cc c c


c

c  cc
 
 c cc


cc   c  


 cc
 c  c c
 c
cc c
 
cc
 c 


 c 
 c  cc  c c
 c  
 c
c
c
  c
 c

ccc
c c
 c
c c
 c


c c c
 c   
cc  
cc
 
 c  
 c   
c c  
 c c c
 cc
c

cc  c

c
 c 
 c
 c
 ccc  cc

c cc c
c
 c c
c 
c
 c 
 c c
cc
 c  c   
 c
 c c

c c
  c
c c  


 cc
 c  cc c
 c   
c
 
 c c  
c 
c c
c
  c

c 

 cc  c
 c c  
 cc   cc
 c    c c

c 
c
 c

 c  c  cc

c  c
c cc


cc cc  
c
c
 cc
c c
 c
cc c
 c c 
 c
%
  c
 c c c

cc c   c
cc  c
c c
c
 c c 
 c 
c c c c
   
c c
 c c 
 c    

   

 
! 



 %  
 
 
   
        
 

 
ccc
 c 
c c
c cc 
c
 cc c


c
c c
c
 c 
 c

cccc  c  c  cc
 c c
c c

 c


cc c c c  c c  c c c   c
cc! 

 
1
 

 
!


    
  
 

    !
 

cccc c

 c c  cc


 c 
 c

c  c
c
 c c
 c
c
c 
c
 c
 

c c c
% c
 c
c c
cccc c c c
c
 c

c c
c c
 c !

% c
 c
c c  ccc

c  c
c
 c   c
   c  c c 
c cc
 c 
 c

 c  
 c  c
c 
 cD  c  c  ccc
  

c c

 c

cc c
c
 c 
 c c  
cÊ
  c  c
ccc  c c
 c
  
cc
 c

 c c c c
ccc
 c

c
c

c
 c cc
 
c 

c
c c
 c c   cc
cc   c c
 c

 c

   
 c c 
c  c
c
 c  cc
 c  
 c c
 cc c c
 cc c c
c
  ccc   
c 
c 
c
  c c
  
 c

 cc  c
cc 
 c
  c c 
cc  c
 c

c
c c)  cc c 
c
 c
c c
c c c
 c c
!
 ( 
% c  c
 c c 
c
 c 
 c
c
c)  cc
c c  c
c c c

 c

 cc cc   c  
c
 c 
c  
 cc cc

 c  
 c  cc  
c
c
cc   
c 
c

cc c 
c
ccc  c
 c

c   c
c c

   cc  c
 c c c c
  c

( c
 c   ccc  
cc  c  
  c
 c


c c
 c

 
!  c c1c
c c c1ccc
 cc c
 c   
c
  c 
c
c
c cc c  
c c
 c 
c

c
 cc
  c
  
c 
c
cc

c

c

 c 
c c
 c  
ccc cccc cc
 c 
c c  cc


cc
 c
 c   c c  cc  c c 
 c
 c c
 c
  
 cc
c   c  
c c 
c  
 c  
 c  c
  
c
c
cc   
c 
c
c c
cc
 c c c  c c
 c
c c
 c
 
!  cc
c c
c  c

c
 c

c c
 cc c
 c c c c

c
 c c  c
cc 
c
c
c
 c   
c

 cc
 c cc   
c c  
 c c
 c
c c
 c c

c
c
 c  c
c c  cc
 c  
c) c
c
 c  cc  c


 cc
 c  
c 
 c c 
c c
c  c
 c c
c c c

  c
c 
 cc
c
c c  c
c
  c  c c
c c
 cc

 c 
 cc
cc
c
 c  c c 
c c c cc
c
c
c  c
c   cc(
c
 c c  c

c
cc 
c  c
 cc
  
 c c   c  
c c 
c  
 cc  
c  c
 c c
c c c

c  c
 c
c 
c
c
c  c c1c c
 c

c c
c
 
!  c1c c
cc 
c c  
c
c
c
c c  
 c c
c
  c

 c c


 c c   c

c c 
c 
c c c
 c cc
cc
 c cc  c
 c  cc
 c c 
 c
  c c c  
c
c
 c

 c 
 c c  c c c
c c 
c
c 
c  c
c c
c cc
c
c c c
c c
 c  c

 c
 
!  c c  c c
  c c c c
c 


cc
c
cc
cc

 c 
 c c  c
c c
c 
c
c c
c

c   cc

  c
c cc
 c  cc
cc  c cc cc
c


 c

c   c c c  


 c
 c c c c   
c  c

c

  cc
 c 

c c
 
c   c 
c c
 c  

 c c  c
c c


c  
 c   
/c  cc

c

  cc
c
 c c
cc
 
c

)  c
 c 
c cc


cc  c c
 c c

c
c  
c
 c 


 c
    
c

c
 c  
c c
 cc c   cc
c

 c
c
c c
   c
 c c
 c

  /c 

c
c c
 
c c c cc c

 
 cc
 c

 c

c
 c ccc

c  c cc cc c

  c
cc  
c c    c

 c
c c  c
 c
 cc
c cc  
c 
c c 
 c 
c
c
c
c 
c

c
 cc c 
cc
c  cc c c   c0c
  c
c
 c 


 0cc   cc
c 
  c



  ccc   c
c) c  
c
c
cc
 c c  
 c)c
c
c
ccc
c c  c
cc  c
cc c
cc 
c) c c
c
ccc
 c c
  c
c
ccc
c  
c  cc
c   c) c c
c  c
c c   c
c
c c
 
c  
c  
 cc c  c
c
 c c
c c c c
c
 cc
 c c  c cccc
cc 


cc 
 c
c  c
 c
cc
  
c c  c
  c) c c
c c c
 c
c c
 c c
c c c
 ccc c  c
c
c c  c c
 c c c c

cc
c c c
c
c
 c cc
 c
c  c   
c c c 


 c 
 c
 c
   c ccc 
c c cc
c

 c c
 c  
c 
c
 c c
 c  
c
 
c
    c
c
c
c  c
c c

c c
 c 


 c
c
c
c c
 c

c c c
 c c

c  
cc 
c c c   cc 
c
c  c
 c
 


 
c c
 c
cc c c  c

 c
 c  c c c
c
c  c  c
c c cc cc
c 
c
   
c  c  c  
c
 c c c  
c   c

 c 
c  c c   c

$ 
 $  

  & #. 
&   / $  


 c  c

Ê$*&$*++c


 
c

(
c 
cc
c c  
 c c
 c 
c c
 c  c c
 c 
cc c   c
 c
c c c 
c)  c
  c c c
c  c c
c

  c
c c c c
c  c  
c

c
 c 
 c c
 c 
c c

cc
 c  c c c c c  c

 c c  
c
cc
 c  
c

c
c cc 
 
c  c  c 
c

cc
 c  c c c


c c cc
 c

c c

 c 
 c c
 c  c  c  c c
c c
  c  c cc c
c 
c c 
c c
 c 


 c  c  c
c
 c 
c
 c


c
c c  c
 c
 c 

c 
c
c
c 
c 
c c 
 cc
c c
 c c
 
c
cc
 c 
 c c
ccc c c c
cccc
 c

c

 c 


 c    
cc

c ccc c c 
c
ccc  c
  c
c  c  
ccc c   cc
 c

 c c
 c c c  cc
c
c
  c cc
 c 


 c c c c

c
cc c
c
 c
c c
 c ! c  ccc ! c 
 cc
c  

 c c
   c 
 
c(  c
 c  
c cccc
c
cc
 c

c
 c
  c c
 c 
 cc cc
 c  c c c  c c
 c  
c c
   c 
 c   c c 


 c  c
 c   c
 c 
 c c
 cc 
 cc c cc  c
c  c
c
 c  
c

c c
 cc


cc
c
c c  c 
 c
 cc
c c c  c  c 
 c  c
 
 
 c 
c c   cc
c
c
cc  
c c
 c

 c c
    c  c   c
c  c
 c  c  
cc
 c


c c
c

c

c  c cc  c cc c   c c
 c  
c c


c  
c  c
c c
c c
c 
c  c 
 cc
c   c
c c
 c

 c
c
 c
cc 
c c c
c 

c  c 


 c  cc
  c cc
c
cc
cc 
c
c
c  
c c   cc
c

  c

 c 
c  c c
c 
c
c
 c 
 
c c
 c   
c c
 c
 cc c 
 cc  c c
c
 c

  ) . :
Ê.c c

c
 c  c c 
 c c c
c cc
 c 
 c
c c c
 c  ccc
 c

c c   c c
 c   c cc
 c c   c
 c  
c  c  ccc


 c  
c
c
 
 c c
 cc   cc
c  
 c c cc    
cc
 c  c
c
 c  c c
c 
 c  c  c    c 
cc  c c


c c
 cc  
c c
 c
cc 
 c
 c  c cc
c c

c 
 c
c
c

 c( c
 c c c

   ) . :
Ê.cc  c cc c 
c c c 
 c
c
 c
 c  
c
 c
 c
c c

c
 c 


 c    
cc
c c c
 c c

cc
cc

 c 
c  c  c c 
 cc
cc
c
 c

c

cc  c c
 c
 
c  c c 
 c  c

 cc
 cc c  
cc   
c  c c
cÊ  
$   
  c c
cc cD
!  Êcc c  c
 c  c
 c  c 
 c   c


cc
 c c  c

cc  

&c  c c
 c c cc
 c 
c
c  c
c c  cc 
cc
 c  
 c c
 c c 


 c
  c c
  
c
c c 
cc   

 cc 

 c0c c

Pc!
 c$c
 c (

cc(
 )c c


c
c)
c
P) %!'cc

c%c
c c


c ) %c)
c
%!'0cc c
c
 ccc  c

c c  c  c  
  c0 c
c  c c  cc
c  
 c  c

  c c c
c  c c
 cP  
c   c  c 
c c  c

  
c  
c
   c c
  c c c 
c
cc  
c

ccc
c
  c
c   
c
c c cc
 c c
c 
 c c
 c  
c$c c

  
c  
c c  c c  cc 
 c  c cc
 c 
 c
c  
!
!c c c  cc
c 
cc c c
c
 c  
c c
   
c
c c c 
c
 cP  
c   c  c 
cc
c  c c
c
  
cc  c  
c
c
c  0c 
  c c
 cc c
c
c

c
  cc c  
c c
 c c c 
c
 c0 c c
c  c c
 c 
c

c
  cc cc  c 
 ccc 
c

c c

c 
 c
 c 


 c  c
c   c
c
 c  
cc

 c c
 c
c
  0c


c c  c
   c

c
 c  c 
 c  c
c c cc
c
  
 c
c
 c
 
c

c
 c 


 c    
cc
c 
 c c  c
 c  
cc c c   ccc

 cc
c
c  c  
cc
 c 
 c
c
 c 
c c
c 
cc   cc
 c

 c


ccc
 c
c c
 c   
  c c  c c
c 
c  c c
 c  c
 c  c 
c 
 c c
 c
 c c 


 ccc
 c   c
 
 c

c
cc c  
cc c
 c

 c  c$ Ê
c
   cc c  c   c  c

c  c
cc c
c c 
 cc

 c   c c
c 
c
c 
c c 
c 
 c
  c  c
c c 
c

(  c c
 c  c c
 c


c c
 c c  
c c c c
 c
 
 c
 c c c c  c  cc
 c 
c c
c c

c
  c 
c
  c c
c c c c
cc 


 c 
 c  c
 c
 c !c  c  c   c c  c
c
c cc c
  c(
c 
  c  
c
c
c 
cc
 c   c   c
c c 
c


c c cc
 c 
 c 
cc

c c
  
c c
c c
 c
  c 
c 
c c
c c c c

c c c 
cc
c
 c 
c c c


c
c 
c c 
 cc
c   c  c

cc c c c 
  cc  c
c c c cc 
 c

 c c c cc
 c

c
 c


cc
c
 c

c c
 c 
cc

 c cc
c
c c    c
c
 c 
 c

c(
cc 
ccc c
 
c  c c cc cc c c c c 
 
 c  c
   c

c

c  c c

c  c
c c c c  
ccc c   c
   
cc c
c   c 
 c cc   ccc !
  

 c 
c  c c
 c

 c  c  c

cc cc
0 
 
 cc c c  cc  c
c
 c

c c
 c  
c0cc
Ê
&  $     c
c 
cccc c0
 c c c
 c  c c
   c 
c c cc   c
c"
 c  
#c  c c c 


 0c
 c c c c 
 c
cc c  c  cc c 


 c
 c
 ccc c  cc cP  c0c 
 cc


c 
c c
 c c
  c c c
c c
c
c
c c
cc 
 
 cc c c  
c
c
c
c c  c c
 c  c c
 c


cc  c  
 c c
 c 
 
 c

cc  
c
c
 c ccc c c c
c c c
c 

c
c c
 

 c
c
 c 
c

 c c
 c 
cc c c
c
 c
   c

c
 c  c
 c
c 
cccc  
 c c
 c
c c  c
)  c  c
 c  
c c cc  c c  c c
 c  c 
 
 c
c 
c
 c  c c c 
 c
cc c
c 
c c
 c 

 c

c
 c 
c
  cc


c
c
 c
 c
c
c cc
 
cc

cc 
c


 cc
c 
cc c0c

 c   c 
c  c c   c 
c  c
 c 
 c
c c 
 c

 c 
 c


c0
cc c
c  c 


 c

 c cc
c c
 
cc
c"
 #c 
0 c c
 c c c
 c
 
c 
c 
 c
0  c
 c c0  c
 
 0cc
 c  
 c 
c c c
 c c


c c  c c


c
c
c c c c c
 c c c 


 c
 
 cc c
c  cc
 c  c c c

 c

c  c 
 
 c
 c c  c 


 c 
 c  c c
 0c)c  cc
 c   c
 c 
 c
c
 c c    
c c
 cc
 c
 c  c c 
 c
0c
 c c cc c 
 c 
c/$
cc c
cc
 c


 c c  c


c

c c   ccc c  c 


c c
 c 


 
/c c

c  c
 c c c c
c

ccc c ccc
c c ccc c  cccc
c c cc c 
 c)  c0 cc  c 
c c 


 
cc c
cc
cc c

c
c 
cc 
c 
c
 cc 
 
 c c
 c


cc
 c  c cc
 c 
 c c c  /c  c c  cc ccc c
 cc c
0c  c c 
 c
 cc
c 
c c 
 cccc  c
   cc

c 
c0 c 

 c 
cc


 cc  
c
 c
 


 
c c 
 0c c  
 c c 
 c c
 c  c  c
0

c


 c c 
 cc c
c
 c 
c c c   c
 c

c c
 


 
0 c


c c  c
 c

c
c cc c  c 
cc
 c  c

cc
 
 c   cc
 c  c cc 
c0 c
c c cc 
 
 c
cc c
c 
c  c
cc   c  c
c 
 
 c  c  c c
 0 c  c
c c cc c 
 c c c cccc  c  c
 c
 c c 
c

 cc c  c
 c

c
cc c   
c c
 c
c  
 c
  c 
c
c
cc
 c  c c
 c 
c

$c

c)  
c  c
cc   c

c
 cc c $ c c 


 c

c

c c cc(cc c c c

c   c  c cc cccc cc ccc! c

c 
 c c
 cc c
 c 


 c  c

0 c cc 


 c  c c
 ccc
 c  c c

 c c 
cc c c
 cc 
ccc 
c
   cc
 c)  c c   

 c
c
 c 
c c   c c
  c
c  
0c

cc c  c c ccc c ! c c c)  c  cc
c ! c

cccc c c c  c

c
c c

c
c  c

c
 c( c c c c(c c  c
 c


c 

 c0c
c
cc 
 c c

ccc
cc
 c 
c cP

cc
 c
 c c c c ccc0c
c
 c  c c
 c
c 
c
 c
 
c
 c
cP

c



c c c ccc
 c


c 

 c0c
c
c c c cc
 c c
 c  c c 
c 
c
cc
 c  c c  c
c 
cc 
 0cc   c c   c
 c  c c
 c
c
  c
 c  c c
  c 
c

c c

 c c*  c 
ccc c  c
 c

 c c
 c
c  
c
c


c*  c 
c
c c 
c
 c  c c
 c
c

 c
c
c
)
c 
c



c c  c c c c
 c

 c c
 c
c  
c
c
c c  c

 c  c c 
c
cc
 c  c c
 c
cc
 c
 c
 c  c c c
 c
c  c   c c
 c 
cc
 c
c  c

c  c c c
 c  c c c c
 c  
 c

c
 c

c c  cc c c


 c  
c c
 c

c c c c  c c c c
c c
 c c cc
 c c
c

  c c
c c
 
c c(c c  c
 c

 c c
 c

c
 c

 c  c c  cc  c
c
 
c c
 c  c 
c  cc
 
 c

cc


 c ccc cc c

c c c cccc!c-
P  
c c c$c
c c c c  c

c c c  
 c c cc!c

cc
 c c c  c c
c c  c  c c c
cc 
c

c
 c 
 c
c
 c


c  cc

 c  c  ccc
c  cc
 c

 c0c

c
c
cc  c
 c  c c c
 c
c c  cc
 c

c c
0c c c
 c  c 
 c 
c  c 
c c
 c

c
 c c

c
c
 c  
  c 
 cc
 c c
  c c
c cc
c
 
cc
  c  c c c c  
c  c

c
  cc c c
  
 c c

c 
 c c
c
 c   c

 c  c

c c
c

 c

 c   c
  c
 c

c cc  cc


 cc
 c 
 c c
c
 c  
c
c c
 c
c

c
 c c c
 c c  cc(cc  c
 c


c  cc


 c0c
c 
c
c
 0c 
 cc
  c0   c
 c 
 c cc
 
c c

 c cc 
c c
c cc
0c
c  c c
 c
  c  c  c
c
 c

 c c
 cc c


cc  c c
 c  c 
c c c c* 
 c  cc  c

0  c  
c  c  c 
 cc" 
 c
c
 c 
 c cc
 
c c

 c c
 c
#c
c c cc
 c  c c
( c  c c
 c  c c
 c
c c  c
c
 c

 c c
 c
 c
c
 c 
 c c
 c
c c 
c
 c c   c
c
  c
 c 
 c c
 c


cc
 c c
cc c 
 c
c
 c
 c
c
cc
c c  c  c 
 cc c c c

c
 c
c cc
  cc  c
 c c c c  c( c c
 
c  c

c
  c  c c
c c c 
c

c 
 c
c  c
 c
c 
c 0c

cc c  c  c c
 
 c! c 
 c c  c

c c c)  cc(c c  ! c  c c
c c
 
c c(c
c c

!c 
c

c c
c
cc c cc c 


 c

cP  
c c)  c,ccc$ ccc c

c  c c c$ ccc c

ccc c

c cc$ cc

c! c
 c c c  c
 c c

c c c
c  c  c c
 c$ ccc c c c cc 
c$  c cc c c c
)  c$  c  cc c   c c
 c! c
c c c
 
c c  cc c c  c!   c  c c c

c! c   c c c

ccc c$ c

ccc  c$ c$c
c cc c  cc   cc$ cc
c c

ccc c 
 c c c  c
 c  c
cc c


 c c
c
c
c 
c0)  c
c  c

c
 c 
cc
c c 
 c
 ccc
c
 c
c  
c
c
 c 


 c
cc
 c
c cc


 c  c
c
cc c  
c
c
 c 


 cc c
c c  cc 
c c
cc
 c  c

c 
  c c
  cc 
c c  

cc
c
 c c c

 c 
 c c
 c c c  c c
 c


c c   c c c
 c

 
cc  c  
 c c
 c c  c 
 
 c

c


 cc c
 
ccc c
 c 
c c  


 
c c
 c
c c c
   c c
c   c
c c
 c  c  c c 
c
c c
 c
  c  0c

c c c  c$ c cc c!c


c
c

c c c

c
P c c  c,c)c c cc ccc cc c cc c c c

c cc
c

c c
c   c cc cccc c c
 cc c
c c c c c

c cc cccc ccc c
ccc c
c c c

c c ccc c ccc c c


 c c c
c c ccc c c  ccc c ccc cc
cc c
c c c

c
c

c c   c$  c cc cc

c
c

c c
 c c  
c c  cc c c

c1
c
 c$ c  cc c ! c

c cc c
c

c$ c  cc c c

2  " Ê cc


c
C .Ê$*$45$&-003Dcc
c
Ê     Ê 
 "Ê 2   
"
 Ê  2  , Ê 2 

c c
   2 Ê   
 Ê "
  Ê
  Ê

  Ê cc
c
2!)c
c
ccc

 c c  c c
  c  c  cc c
 c  c c 
c
 c c
c  
 cc$
c
c
 c
c c  c
   
c c
c c) c  cc

cc
 c c
  c c  c
c
c c
 c  " #c
c  c cc c
 c
  c c 
c$ cc
c "#c
c 
 ccccc
 c c c !c

 c
c
c   c cc
c  cc c c
 c c 
 c  " #c
 c  c c c
 c  c c 
c c
 c 
 
c c
c
cc

 c  c
 c c  c c
 c
c c  "#c
  c 
 c c

 c c
  c
 c 
 
c 
 c cc c



c c  
 c
c c cc c
 c cc
  cc
   c  cc
c c   c  cc  c
cc
c c 
!
 c  
c$&c c  c  
c$ &c c
 c c c  
c c
 c
  c c c c c
 c  c c  
c  c
c
 c


c 
 c c  c
c

c 
c

c
c
  
cc  c
cc  
c  c  
c c
 c
c
c
 c
c c
 c  c c$c
 c  c c
c
 c  c  c
c$c c "#c   
c
cc c c
 c
 c c 
 c

c
c  
c
c  c
 c  c cc
 "#c$c 
 c c cc c cc  c c
c  
 c  c

c
c
 c
 c c
c 
 
cc
c
c
 c  
 c$c
 c  c
c
 c
c c  c
c  cc  c
cc  
c
c


 c

 c
 cc
 c0
  1
0c  c cc 
 c c cc c cc
$c
 c 
 c c  c
c c
 c
c c  c c 
c
cc
 
 c c
 c 


 c  c
c 
c c 

"#c
c
cccc   
c  c
 c "#ccc
 c 

c
 c

c  
 c c c
c  c  c
 c  c
c c
 c
 


 c
c c  
c 
c
c 
c
 c c  c c  " #c
c
c c ccc !
c    cc c cc  c c c
  c  cc
 c c
 c c cc  c  c
 c
 c
c
 
c
 c  
 c  cc
  
c
 c c c c  c
 

c c  
 " #c
c
c  c cc
 c c   c
c  " #c  c
 c

 c  c

c 
c
c

c
 c 
c c
 c0
  1
0c  ccc
 c c c
 c
c c
c
 cc c
 c 
c c   c

c
 c
 " #c  c c
 
c

c
c  
 c c 
 c

c c
c  "c
c
 c
 cc  cc  c c
 c
c

 
cc
 c
  c c 
cc
c  
 c 
c 
 c
c
c c

cc
c c
 cc
c
 c
c
c c

" #cc
 c
 c c  
 c c
 c ! 
c  c c
 c 


 c
 c
c
 
c
c# $
%›
        # " #cc
  c

c
 c
/c  c
c
cc c
c   c cc c  
 c c
 
 c  c
c c
 c 
c
 
c
c
c
c c
 c  
c
c
c c

c c c  c c c  
c
c 

 c c 
 c
  c c  c c c 
c

 c 
c c 

c
c
 c
c  c c c
  " #c
c

c  cc
 c c   
 ccc  c c
 c
c 
cc
c " #c
c 
 ccc
c
 c
 c

c c
c

cc
 c  c  c
"#c )
c(
c c

cc c)Pc ) c
c

 
/c)
c$
c cc c())c
 c )
c0c
ccc '
0c
cc())ccc

c(c

c

 c c )
cc
P

 c
cc)
c 'c%c
c
cc

 
c%c

 c %c
c
"#c )
c(
c c

cc)Pc ) c
 
/c
)
cccP

c(ccc c

c

 c
c
PPc)
c 'cc )
cc
P

 c
c())cPc c )
c ccc

c(c
c
"#c )
c(
c c

cc c)Pc ) c
 c c
c )
ccP

 c
c())cc
 c c

 c  c )

c(c

 c %c c
c
)
c)
c 'cc
 c cc )
c
c())c

cc( )(cc 'c
'
 c
P
c

c c
c c )c
c
c
"#c )
c(
c c

cc c)Pc ) c
 c
cc cc )
ccP

 c
c

c%c c

'
 c
%c
' Pc c )
c 
cc c

 
 c c c c 
c
'
 c
c
" #c )
c(
c c

cc%Pc )
c
cc
   %c  c ) c 'c
'
 c
c
 
c  %cP c )
c '%
c
c
" #c )
c(
c c

cc c)Pc ) c

 
/c)
c$
c cc c)c

c


cc
'
c%c
 c cc
c cc

c c
 c0 )
cc

 c%c 0c *Pc
 c c )
c)
ccP
c

cc
$P
c$
c cc c())c
c
c
cc(

c

c

 c c )
cc
P

 c
c )

%cPcc c
Pc()%cc)
c 'c%c
c
cc

 
c%c

 c %c
c
"#c )
c(
c c

cc
PPc )
cPcc
)
c
 
 cc
c )P)c c
ccc
P

 c
c ) c
 
cc
'
 cc )
c
%
 cc )
c)
c 'c
c%cc
P

 c c
c )
ccP

 c
c
c
"#c )
c(
c c

cc c)Pc ) c )
c
 cc )
cc)
c 'cc
 
c
(c
c )
c   c) cP c

 cc  c
c
"#c )
c(
c c

cc
%Pc )
c
 c

(" #c
 c
c
c c
 c
c cc
c cc
 c
cc c
c c
 c
 c
c  c c
 c
c c  c

  !   c
c
( c  cc
 c 
 c
c
›  
 

    4 ;‘c
c
ccc c
/c 
 c  c$c c c
c 
c
 
 c c
  c
c   cc
c
 c 
c c
 c  
c 
  c
 
 c c'1  c!!c  c
c
c   c ccc c
 c
c c
 c c
 c c
 c c 

c cc  c  
c
  c /c
c  cc
 c  c c  
 cc c c c
  
c c c   c cc
c c ++?$&$?$&$$+
%%$&&+?##*/'&%?+$E$F+(#$?&$$*$&%$
;G<'##&&$%$+*'?$5+$&%$$&?+'&%?+$5/
?$&$$+%%$&&+?$+*$&%$$?##5$ 
!  "?+'&%?+$&$&+?$&$'c 
c 
c
 c
c

c   c ccc 
 c
c c c c  c
 c  c
 c 
 cc c
 c
 c
c  c  c  
c
c 
 cc c

 
 c c cc  c
 c

c 
 
cc  c c   cc
c c
 c  
c c  cc c c
 
c
c
 c
cc  c
 c
c
cc c
 c
c c
  c
c
 c
   c c
c  c cc  c
  c   

 cc

c c
  c
c
 c
 c
c  c  cc
 c
cc c
  
c
c 
c c
 c   c c
c  c$
c  c

c  c

c
 c0c c cc
 0c  cc 
 c c c
c  c
 
c
c  cc
 c
c cc
 c  
c
 c
 c  c

c$ c c  c


cc c  
c
" #c
c
c  c c c
 c 
c c c
/c  c
 c c
P  
c  c$c c c
c 
c 
 c cc 
 c
c
 
 c  c cc c c  c
 c 
 c c  c
c c
 c
 c  
c 
c c 
 c c
  c  c c
 c
c
c
c  
 c   c
c c
c
 c  c cc c c
 
c c
  c   c 
  c
  c &c
Ê$%+1 &%?+$ E@+?+/$E$4*+&$5/
/#@&?$&*$%+##@?$*&(+%$4/+4*$E5+$$
$H/+'&%?+$?$&$$E%$$+'+'/*$&%$;0G<'$
*$&%$;G<'?$&#&$%$+*'&?$*&$%$+%#$&/$&
5$?$+%4+&$%$+*&&$#+A$@+?++$&&+&+#H&++%+c
c
c
 c c cc  c

c  c
 c
cc
c  c  !
 

c
$ 2c c  c  
c$ &c c
 c
c 
 
cc
 c  c c
c  c c c
 c  c

c
c  
c
 c
cc c c
c
 c c  
c c
 c  c c c c c 
 c
  cc
  c  c
c
 
 c  cÊ 
 '1 !
c!!c
 
cc
  c  cc
c
  c
 c
c c c
 c
 c cc cc
 c  c c
 
c c  c  c  c 
c
 c
 c cc c
  cc  
c c c  cc   
c   
c
 c
c c
c
 cc

cc  c
c
 c  c c
c
  c
c
?$&$'E$??$%+/4/#$(/4/$E%$$?$4E+44&$
##@$'&?$*&(+%$&4+%+*#+/5/4&$?'+'/*$&%$
;0G<$E%$*?$&$'*&'$+#4$4$E$c
c
 
 c c8 ! '11
   

c!!c c
  c
  cc
c  c
c  
 c c 
 c
c
c c  
 c
 c cc  c
 c
c c c c  
!
 c c 
  c  
 c  
c c
c

c  
 c  c
 
 c  cc c c !
cc ! 
c 
cc
 
 c


 c c   c
c  c
 c 
 
c c
c  c
$
c  c

c c

c
cc
c  c c 
 c cc 
 c
c 
 c  c c
c c c   c
c  cc
c
c
 c 
 
c c
 cc
c( c c
c
/c 

 c c
c

c  c
c c
c
 
 c c 
 c  ccc c cc  c 
c
  c
 c
c c
c
 c 
 
c c
 cc  c

 c c
 c
 
 c
c  cc
c  
 c c 
 c
c c
c
 cc
cc  
cc
 c  c c 
 c c cc c c c

c c



 cc   c
c
›› '
2
  1
2$
  4 ;<=>c
c
 c0c c cc
 0c  cc
/c  cc
cc c  c
 c
 
cc  c
c 
c
c c 

c
c  
c c



 c 
 
 cc
 c cc
 c


c 
c c   c  c
c
c
c  
 c cc c cc
c
c c

c  cc  
 c
cc c 
 c c c 
c c c  c
c  cc  c  c c

 c
ccc  c
 c
c c
 c


c 
c c 
 c
c   c
c

 c 

" #c
c

cc c
 c  c

c
 c  c
 c
c c c c
c c  c
c
 c c
 c
 c  c
c$ c c  c
cc c
  
c
"#c
cc  
 c  c
 c c  c
c   c
 c0c
 c c
 0c  cc
c  c c
c
 c
 c
 cc
 c
 " #c
c
( c c c

cc c cc
c 
cc
c  
 c
c
c
 c c

 c 
 c c cc c c  c c
cc  c

c    
c
c
 c  
c$ &c cc c  
c c
 c  c


c  c
 c  cc
 cc  
 cc cc c cc

 c c
 c  c c c
  cc c c c
c   c
  c
cc c
 c
cc  
c  c
cc
c c
 c
 c
0c c cc
 0c  cc
 c  c c
c c  c
 
 c  c c c
 c

 c(
cc cc

c
cc c
 c
c    
c
c
 c  
c$ &c cc c  
c c
 c
  c

c  c
c  c
c
 c
 c  c
c  
 c
 c  c  
 c  c 
 c c
c
 c cc
 c
 c
  
cc
c    c
c
 c  

cc
 c0c c cc
 0c  ccc c c c
 c

cc  
c  c
c cc
 c  c
c 
c c 
 c


 c
c
ccc
 c  
 c
cc
 c  c c
 c

c c  c
 c  c &c  c
c  c
 c
c
c
 c  
c  ccc c  c
 c!c
 c c c
 c
)  c
c  cc
c c
c
c  
 c c c   cc c

 c 
 c
c
 c

 cc  cc  c c


 c
c
 
"#c  cc  c c c
 c c
 c
cc cc
 " #c  c   c c
 c  c
c

c c c 


c c  c c cc  c

cc
c c c
   c 
 
 c 

c
c
 c   
 c c
 c  c c
 c


 c c
 c 
 cc  c
c 
c
 c
 c

 c c
 c 
 c
 
c c   cc  c c
 c

"#c
c
c
c c
 c 
c 
c c   cc  c c
 c
c c  c  c0c
 c cc
 0c  c c  c
c
 c
c  c
 cc
c
c
 c
 cc 
 c 
c
cc
 c 
c  c c 
 c

c c

 c c cccc "#c  cc c c  
 c  c
 c  c
 c
" # c0c c cc
 0c  cc
/c  c c  c
c
 c
 c

c  c
c  c  c
 c
 c
c  c  c  c0c
 c cc
 0c  c c
c c
c c
 c  c  cc
 c 
c
c c 
 c c c
/c  c

c

c
 c
cc
0 
 c
c c c c  c
 c  c  c 
 cc c
 c
 c

c  c  0c c
 c  cc c 
 c c c c
c

c  cc
 cc
c
 c0   c c
c  c cc
  c
  c   

 cc  c
c
 c
 c
c  c
  0c  c
 c cc  c

c
 c
c
c0c c
  
c
c 
c c
 c   c c
c  0c
cc 
  cc
 
 c c
c c
 c  c c

cc c
 c0c c cc
 0c
  c
c c  c
c
 c  c
 c
 c
c  c  cc
c

c c
 c
c
c  
c
c
 c
c  c
 c
 c0c c
cc
 0c  c c
c c
c  c
c
c
 c  c
 c
 c0c c cc
 0c  cc
/c  c
c c
 c
c c
 c  c c c   c 
  c
 c  
 c
 c cc c
 c  c c c  c
 c  cc
 
 c $c c /c c  cc  c
cccc c c ccc
 c c cc
 c c 
 c  c

 c c  
c c c
 
c
 c  c c

 c  cc
 c
cc   c   c  
cccc
$
c  c
)  c  cc
c   c  
c
c  c c
 c  c
 c
 c0c c cc
 0c  c  cc   c
c
 c
c
  c
 c  c  c


 c  c
 c  c c

c 
 
 c c

c  
 cc

c
 c0c c cc
 0c  cc
/c  c c
 c
c
 cc
c
c c
 c

c c c
c

c
 c0c c cc
 0c  ccc c cc
   c   c
c
 c 
 c c
 c  c
c c

   
 c  "#cc

c c
cc
c c
cc
 c  c c
 c &c  c
c
cc
c  c  
 c

c c
c
 c
   
 c  c c
 c  c &c
 ! c
"#c
c
 c c c c c   c c
   c  c
cc    
c
c
&c c c  
c  c  c
 c c c  c c   "#cc c
 cc  c c
 c1
0

'1 !c$c c c
 c
 
 
c 
 c ccc   c
c  c 
 c c cc c
 c
Ê 0-"#$$E#$'$&(+%$$&#$$'
*&*$&+$;<$5$'E ?$&$?##5$#$(+$$$
%##$%$(#$$E$F+(#$$*$&%$;0G<'&
&$%$+*$&+($'&4?$#$&$E%?$'$&(+%$+%#+?$$&
#$$'*&*$&+$c
c
?$*?&$B#$&$E%?$'$&(+%$B4$?$*$&'&4%$'##

c c
+'$&(+%$+?$
?+#+**+$'&?$&'&'$$&$4$&+&
%+$&++%#+?$*$&'&4$&&$$&$5/ 
 
 cc
   c 

c
c c 

c  c 
cc
 c
  c  c c  
c
 c  c c c  c   c
  c c

c c 
c c  c  ccc
  c 
c c c c c
 c 
c  
c
c  c c
c
c 
c  c  c  cc  
c
 
c c  
c c 
 
c   
c c cc
 c

c c c cc
 c  cc  
 c c
 
c
 

 c 

c c
 c
 
c c c c c
 c  c c
 
c c c c c cc
 c  
c
  c c cccc
c 
 c
c
 c
 
c c c c
 c$&(+%$''&%?+$&$$'$#$*?$$#$&*?&+
$#$(++5&%+##?$&'&%?+$&$$$E%$*?$
$&Ê$%+1'?+$=c   c cc !c c

  cc  c  cc ! c  c  c
$  
c
 c c  c c 
c  
c 
cc c
  ccc   c  c c
 c c
c
 c   c

  cc c
 c   c c  c c
 c c c 
c  
 ccc" #c
c c c   c 
 cc
  c   c   c
 c
  c cc cc 
 c
c
 c
c c  c
 c
c c
   c  c c   cc
 cc  c  c  cc
  
 c c
c
  cc c 

c
c
" #cc 
c
 c0c
 c cc
 0c  ccc c cc   c 
 c c
 c 
c
c
 c c" #c
c
)  c
 c  c
c

c
 c
c c  c c  c 
c  c

c 
 c cc  c cc c c  c
 c c  c
c

c
 c c  c c
 c
c 
c
c  c&c c &c c
 c c c
  
c c
 c  c c c c c
 c  c c  
c
  c
c
 c

c 
 c c  c
c
››› p   

  

 D
 Dc
c
c  
c c
c  
c

c
 c0c c cc
 0c  cc
c c 
 c
cc  
 c  c c  c
 c
c 
c
 c  c c
 c
 
 
c c c
 c
 cPc
c  
c c cc   c
c c c
 c  c c
ccP  c  
  " #c
c
  
c
 c c  
cc
 c c c
 c    c
  cc
 c  c c  c  c c
c 
" #cc   c
 c c
 c 
c
 c c c
 cPc c
c   c c
 c 
c
" # cPc  c

c45 c cc c c  c
 c  c c


  ccc 
c 
 c
c  
 c  c c
 c

  c
 
c

c 
c c
c
c c   c  c c
 cPc
   c
c 
 cc   c
 c
 c c c
c  cc
cc
   c   cc  
 c c
 c  
c
c
c c  c
 cPcc
cc

 c  c  c c c
 
 c c 
c c c 
cc   cc
 c 
c  c
 
 c

c c

c c

  c 
c
c
 c 
c c c cc c  c
 
cc  c c 
 cc
cc 
c c
 c  c c
c
 cc 

c
 cPcc 
c   c
c  c  

 c   c
c
c
 c
c c  
cc
 c  c c c c


 c c  
c  
cc
 c 
c

c c
 c  c
 
 c c c

  ccc c 
 c
c
c
 c


 c c
45 c cc c c   cc
   c cc cc  
 c c

 cPc

c

 c  c cc
c  cc
 c  
 c
 c
c


  c  c c

c
 cPc  c
 c  
 c c  
cc

 c   c c
c
c
c c  c
c  
 c
c
cc
c

c c
c
 c 
 cc
c c c c c
c  c
 c  
c c
   c c
 cPcc
 c   c c
c
 c
c
 c  
 c c
c



 c cc  c c" #c
›0 '11 ?'11
  c
c

c c
 c  
 c c
 c0c c cc
 0c  cc 
 c c
cc c cc  c
c c
 c  
c c c  c
c
c c


c   c  c
 c c
 c0c c cc
 0c  c
 c c
 c

 c cc
c   cc
cc
c  
 cc
c  
 c c

c

 c
 c c
c c c
c
cc
c c c  c
cc c
  
c
c  c
c
c  cc  c 
 cc
c   " #c
c
)  cc   c c c
 c 
c
cc
 c
 cc 
c
  c
c c  
c   c
 cc
c  
 ccc
c   cc
 
 ccc 
c cc   c
cc
 c   c  cc c c
  c
cc
 c c  
cc   c c
 c
 ccc
 c
  c c
  c
 c
c  c
 c c c

 c
c   c
 c c  cc  c  
 cc   cc
 c cc
 
c c   cc  cc
 c  cc c
cc
 c c
  
c   
 c
 c  c

cc
c  
 c c c cc
  "c
c
 c
 cc  cc  c c
 c  
c
 c   c
c
c   " #c
c
0 Ê
  <@   4 ;=<Ac
c
c 
 c
cc
c  c 
 c c c
 c c
   
 c  c
c$c c c
Ê  -3# !      $#
/($'(&*&+(+#$$$E$4*+&+44+/&$$&
$E++'&%?+$&4/?$&$'$&5$&$?##% !5$%4$
*&'*&$(+#/&$$#$%44+%+'&%?+$?##5$
%%&$+44$+$#/%++##/?$&$$'%?
'&%?+$c  c  c 
c
 c   cc 
 c c
c c
 
c  c c
   
 c  c  c

 c  c
 c
 c  c
 c cc c
 c  c c
 c
 c c   c
  c
 c
 c  c$
c  c

c c
c c
c
c c
c

c c 
 c c cc c cc
  
 c
c
 c  c cP  c$c c" #ccc 
c
cc c c
c
   c c 
c c 
 c c cc c c
  c cc
 c
0 
c   c
 
 
c  0c c
 c0  
c  0c
 c  cc
 c
 c cP  c  
c
c  c c
 cc

 c  
c
c
 c  c c
" #c
c 
c

c c
 c  c cP  c
 
cc  c  
c
c  c c c c  c
c
c
  c c c  
c
c c 
c c 
 c c cc c c
 c  ccP  /c  c  c c
c c
$c  c
cc 
 c c
c
 c    c c
 c c c c

c
 c 
cc c c
 c 
cc  cc
c
c  cc
 ! c c 
c cc c  
c  c  c

c  c
c
 c c
 cc
cc
 c c+#+$'/##E$'
/+&$&$%&+*+#$(+$$5#+?$&%##$%$5//
?&+/@?$($&4+%+*#*&(+%+#&+#'&4@?+%??$
&$$+?$&$5/$E*&$#/$E$4*$c 
 c  c
 c
c c
 c c
c  c
c   c
c  c 
" #c
( c c c  c
c
c
 c  c    
c c
c 
c
 c
 c


 c c 
 c c cc c cc
 c  c
c
 c
%  c c
c 
cc
  
'

 

$  ›  $    "#cc  
 cc '

   

› 
  
 " #  cc
 c 
 c c cc c cc
c
c
c
c  
ccc
c

c  
 c
cc
   
 c 

 "#c  c  c c 
 c c
cc c cc
 c  c c
c)  c c  c c 
c c

c

c c c
 c
c c
c  
 c
cc

   
 c 

 c c
  c  c  
 cc c

c cc c " #c  c
c0
1
  0cc 
 c c cc
 c c c
c c
c  
 c  c
c c
c  
 c  c
 
c  
 cc    
c  c c
 c
 c
   
 c  "#c
c
 
   cc
 c  c cP  c$c c c
 c 
 c
 
 
 c

c

c
cc c c c  cc  ! c c 
c c
c c  
c  c  c

c  c
 c  cc c c c
cc
 c c cc
 c c 
 c  c 
 c c  
c
 c c
 
c
 c c c c
 c  cc
 c

cc   c   c  
"#c  c
c c  
 c  c
 c c c
 cc cc
 c!c

c c  c
 c
 c
c  
c c 
c cc c c c
 c  c
c c
 c  
c  cP  c  c c c
 c
c  cc c c
  cc cc
 c  c c
c
 cc c
c  cc
cc
 
cc
c  c   c
c
c   c  c c
 c 
c
 c
 c c
c c c
c c
    c

c  c
 c 
 c c

  /c
  c c  
cc c    c c
 

cc
c  cP  cc   c
c cc  c
c c  c  c
c  ! c  
c$ 46&c cc c  
c  c
c

 c c

cc   c
c cc
c c
 c  
c$ &c cc c  
c  c
  c

c

  /c
  c c   c

c
c c
 c c
 c c0 
 c  c   c  
 c c 
0c
c
c
P  c 
c c 
 c
cc
   
 c  c c
c
 c
c  cc
cc  c
c
 c
   
 c
  c c c  c  
c$ &c  c
c
 cc
 c

   
 c  cc c
c c 
c
c0 c
 c c
 0c c
c c c c
c c c
 c

c c  cc 
c
45 c c c
c c

  /c
  cc  c
 cP  
c
c
 c
  c c c
c c
c cc
c
   
 c  c
 
c  c  c c
 
c    c
cc  
c c  c 
cc
c   c
c  c 
 c  c   c  
 c c
 
c
cc
   
 c 

 "#c
0› 4 (
 $
  
$     c
c

 c  
c c
cc

c
 c 
 c c
 c c  c
c c

 c
c c  c c  
c
 c 


 c 
 c
c
 
c c 

c  c  c c
c

  ccc
 c
 c
cc 

c
 c
 c  
cc
"#c
c
)  c c c

c
  cc c  
 c c
 cc 
 c c c
 c c
 c 


 cc   c  c
 c  c c
c c

c   c  c c  
 c  c c
 c 
c
 c  c
  c c c  
 c  c
 c  c c c 
 c
c  c

c
c  c0c c cc
 0c  cc 
 c c cc c c  c
 c c c


 c c
c
c 
cc
 cc
 c 
c 
c
 c   c
c
 c
c c
c  
 c
c
  c
/c  cc
c
c
 c  c 
 c

c
cc
  
c
c  
c

 c c  "#cc cc' 
   Ê

 
D
c" #c

cc  c
c c

c
 c
 c
cc 

c
c
 c
 c   c c
 
c  
c

c
 c   c c
 c
c  c c
 c

c c

c  c c 
cc c
c 

cc  c
c c 
 cc

 c
 c
c
 c   
 c c  
c


c c  c  cc
 c c
c 

cccc 

c c
 c c  c  c  c c


c 

c
c 
c    c
 c
 c cc
  
cc
c  
c
 
c
c   c
 c  cc c  c
c 
c
c
c

c
 c 

c  cc c c
 
ccc

 c c
 c
  c c
 c

/c  c c

 c c  c  cc
c  
 cc
 c
c cc c  
 cccc
62   c
 c

c

 cc  c cc c 
c 
c
c


  c

c c
c
Ê  c
c

c  c