Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
ABSTRACT INTRODUCTION
D
Pettitt, RW, Niemeyer, JD, Sexton, PJ, Lipetzky, A, and espite the lack of scientific evidence for the
Murray, SR. Do the noncaffeine ingredients of energy drinks performance-enhancing effects of energy drinks
affect metabolic responses to heavy exercise? J Strength Cond (EDs), their popularity is impressive, with Red
Res 27(7): 19941999, 2013Energy drinks (EDs) such as Bull (RB) reporting sales exceeding 500 million
Red Bull (RB) are marketed to enhance metabolism. Secondary
cases in a single year (16). Energy drinks are marketed to
boost energy or metabolism, and such marketing is persuasive
ingredients of EDs (e.g., taurine) have been purported to
among competitive athletes (16). For instance, one group (10)
improve time trial performance; however, little research exists
reported that 72.9% of the 203 athletes surveyed consumed
on how such secondary ingredients affect aerobic metabolism
EDs with the primary reason being to enhance energy dur-
during heavy exercise. The purpose of this study was to inves- ing practice. Thus, sales and survey findings indicate that
tigate the effect of the secondary ingredients of RB on aerobic EDs are used for a performance-enhancing benefit.
metabolism during and subsequent to heavy exercise. In double- The claims for the ergogenic effects of the secondary
blind, counterbalanced, and crossover fashion, 8 recreationally (i.e., noncaffeine) ingredients of EDs, such as taurine and
trained individuals completed a graded exercise test to deter- B vitamins, by manufacturers are ambiguous. For instance,
mine the gas exchange threshold (GET). Subjects returned on 2 Red Bull markets that its secondary ingredients boost energy
separate occasions and ingested either a 245 ml serving of RB (16). Such a claim would imply RB ingestion would positively
or a control (CTRL) drink with the equivalent caffeine before affect aerobic metabolism. To date, the literature on these
engaging in two 10-minute constant-load cycling bouts, at an secondary ingredients and exercising metabolism is limited.
intensity equivalent to GET, with 3 minutes of rest between The isolated effects of taurine can reportedly enhance vascular
reactivity (20) along with muscular contractility (1,13,26),
bouts. Accumulated liters of O2 (10 minutes) were higher for
whereas B vitamins may support aerobic metabolism directly
the first bout (17.1 6 3.5 L) vs. the second bout (16.7 6 3.5 L)
(25). Furthermore, when these secondary ingredients are stud-
but did not differ between drinks. Similarly, excess postexercise
ied in combination, investigators have reported enhanced
oxygen consumption was higher after the initial bout (RB mean,
cycling time trial performances (12,17); however, noncaffei-
2.6 6 0.85 L; CTRL mean, 2.9 6 0.90 L) vs. the second bout nated RB has been reported not to enhance exhaustive
(RB mean, 1.5 6 0.85 L; CTRL mean, 1.9 6 0.87 L) but did not performance (7). There is simply a paucity of research dem-
differ between drinks. No differences occurred between drinks onstrating any positive metabolic effects of the secondary in-
for measures of heart rate or rating of perceived exertion. These gredients during submaximal exercise.
results indicate that the secondary ingredients contained in a sin- Energy drinks also are marketed to enhance recovery (16);
gle serving of RB do not augment aerobic metabolism during or yet, there is little research on if (or how) EDs may influence
subsequent to heavy exercise. short-term postexercise metabolism. Caffeine, the primary
active ingredient of EDs, may enhance utilization of free
KEY WORDS EPOC, gas exchange threshold, oxygen uptake, fatty acids at lower levels of metabolic demand (22), thereby,
taurine augmenting the rate of return to resting postexercise homeo-
stasis. Such an effect from the secondary ingredients is
unknown. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to exam-
Address correspondence to Robert W. Pettitt, robert.pettitt@mnsu.edu. ine if the noncaffeinated ingredients of RB affected heavy
27(7)/19941999 exercise and postexercise metabolism using intensities
Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research corresponding heavy exercise (i.e., at or exceeding the gas
2013 National Strength and Conditioning Association exchange threshold [GET]) (6).
the TM
Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
the TM
Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Noncaffeine Ingredients and Exercise Metabolism
Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
the TM
Figure 4. Rating of perceived exertion (RPE) after the initial (filled bars)
and the second (open bars) cycling bouts in the Red Bull and control
drink trials.
Figure 2. Respiratory exchange ratio (RER) during and after exercise for time (F = 0.73, p = 0.58) were observed for heart rate. Sim-
the Red Bull and control drink trials. *Significant between-trial main effect ilarly, no differences in RPE occurred between the first bouts
(p , 0.05).
(z = 1.12, p = 0.26) or the second bouts (z = 1.57, p = 0.12)
(Figure 4).
Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Noncaffeine Ingredients and Exercise Metabolism
that the secondary ingredients for a single serving of RB do an ergogenic effect, although the precise mechanisms for
not augment EPOC subsequent to heavy exercise. The why remain unclear (12,17).
kinetics of the initial bout produced the expected increase In conclusion, athletes consume EDs not only before
on accumulated O2 and decrease in EPOC for the second major events but also for boosting energy during practice.
bouts (5,23). The ingestion of the secondary ingredients in The present study revealed that the secondary ingredients
RB did not seem to influence O2 kinetic differences between found in a single serving of RB had no augmenting affects on
the 2 bouts (Figure 1). aerobic metabolism during or subsequent to exercise inten-
A tendency for greater nonmetabolic CO2 production sities analogous to day-to-day practice (i.e., heavy exercise).
during and subsequent to exercise, as evidenced by higher Future research should examine different doses of the
RER values (Figure 2), was observed for the RB trial. Such secondary ingredients in EDs while controlling for differ-
a change occurred independent of changes in V O2 or heart ences in carbonation as a confounding variable possibly
rate (Figure 4). Greater hydrogen ion production and buff- influencing expired VCO2 values.
ering could have occurred presumably during the RB exer-
cise trial, exhibiting a deleterious effect on metabolism. Such ACKNOWLEDGMENT
differences, although statistically different, were negligible in Support was provided by the College of Graduate Studies
effect size. An equally plausible explanation for the RER and Research at Minnesota State University, Mankato.
findings may be that carbonation differed between the
2 drinks (i.e., excess carbonation in RB drink could have REFERENCES
inflated the expired VCO2 values). We regret this shortcom- 1. Bakker, AJ and Berg, HM. Effect of taurine on sarcoplasmic
ing of our procedures and encourage future investigators to reticulum function and force in skinned fast-twitch skeletal muscle
standardize carbonation to eliminate this as possible con- fibres of the rat. J Physiol 538: 185194, 2002.
founding variable. Finally, ingestion of the RB secondary 2. Baum, M and Weiss, M. The influence of a taurine containing drink
ingredients did not affect RPE (Figure 4), a finding consistent on cardiac parameters before and after exercise measured by
echocardiography. Amino Acids 20: 7582, 2001.
with a recent time trial study (17).
3. Beaver, WL, Wasserman, K, and Whipp, BJ. A new method for
Serving size for the secondary ingredients is acknowledged detecting anaerobic threshold by gas exchange. J Appl Physiol 60:
as a delimitation of our study. For instance, taurine may 20202027, 1986.
enhance vascular reactivity (20), thereby improving O2 deliv- 4. Borg, G. Perceived exertion as an indicator of somatic stress. Scan J
ery to exercising muscle; however, taurine found in a single Rehabil Med 2: 9298, 1970.
serving of RB (i.e., 1,000 mg) does not seem to augment O2 5. Burnley, M, Doust, JH, Carter, H, and Jones, AM. Effects of prior
exercise and recovery duration on oxygen uptake kinetics during
uptake during heavy exercise (Figure 1). Perhaps, higher heavy exercise in humans. Exp Physiol 86: 417425, 2001.
concentrations of taurine might augment efficiency. The sub- 6. Burnley, M and Jones, AM. Oxygen uptake kinetics as determinant
jects in the time trial studies investigating RB (12,17) ingested of sports performance. Eur J Sport Sci 7: 6379, 2007.
500 ml of RB, more than 2-times the volume consumed by the 7. Candow, DG, Kleisinger, AK, Grenier, S, and Dorsch, KD. Effect of
subjects in our study (i.e., .2,000 mg of taurine). Conversely, it sugar-free Red Bull energy drink on high-intensity run time-to-
exhaustion in young adults. J Strength Cond Res 23: 12711275, 2009.
is equally plausible that taurine only exerts an ergogenic effect
during exhaustive exercise. For instance, one group (2) having 8. Carter, H, Jones, AM, Barstow, TJ, Burnley, M, Williams, C, and
Doust, JH. Effect of endurance training on oxygen uptake kinetics
subjects perform an exhaustive GXT reported that RB inges- during treadmill running. J Appl Physiol 89: 17441752, 2000.
tion, with 1,000 mg of taurine, resulted in higher ventricular 9. Casaburi, R, Storer, TW, Ben-Dov, I, and Wasserman, K. Effect of
contractility before and after exercise, based on electrocardio- endurance training on possible determinants of VO2 during heavy
graphic measures of end diastolic volume. Conversely, others exercise. J Appl Physiol 62: 199207, 1987.
(7) have observed no performance enhancement from a con- 10. Froiland, K, Koszewski, W, Hingst, J, and Kopecky, L. Nutritional
supplement use among college athletes and their sources of
stant-speed exhaustive exercise bout. The disparity of results information. Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab 14: 104120, 2004.
may be explained simply by the unreliability of time trials and 11. Gaesser, GA and Poole, DC. The slow component of oxygen uptake
times for exhaustive exercise bouts (24). kinetics in humans. Exerc Sport Sci Rev 24: 3571, 1996.
12. Gei, K-R, Jester, I, Falke, W, Hamm, M, and Waag, K-L. The effect
PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS of a taurine-containing drink on performance in 10 endurance-
athletes. Amino Acids 7: 4556, 1994.
Based on the lack of prior scientific evidence, combined with
the results of this study, there is no justification to support 13. Goodman, CA, Horvath, D, Stathis, C, Mori, T, Croft, K,
Murphy, RM, and Hayes, A. Taurine supplementation increases
that a single serving of the secondary ingredients in RB skeletal muscle force production and protects muscle function
augments aerobic metabolism during or subsequent to heavy during and after high-frequency in vitro stimulation. J Appl Physiol
exercise. Indeed, athletes seeking a boost of energy for prac- 107: 144154, 2009.
tice (10) may obtain such benefits from beverages contain- 14. Graham, TE. Caffeine and exercise: metabolism, endurance and
performance. Sports Med 31: 785807, 2001.
ing similar amounts of caffeine (e.g., 80-mg caffeine from an
15. Graham, TE, Battram, DS, Dela, F, El-Sohemy, A, and Thong, FS.
8-oz cup of coffee). Conversely, if the athlete anticipates Does caffeine alter muscle carbohydrate and fat metabolism during
exercising to fatigue, such as a time trial, EDs may provide exercise? Appl Physiol Nutr Metab 33: 13111318, 2008.
the TM
Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
the TM
16. Gschwandtner, G. The powerful sales strategy behind Red Bull. 21. Pettitt, RW, Clark, IE, Ebner, SM, Sedgeman, DT, and Murray, SR.
Available at: www.sellingpower.com/article/display.asp?aid=SP2229597. Gas exchange threshold and VO2max testing for athletes: An
Accessed May 25th, 2009. update. J Strength Cond Res In press.
17. Ivy, JL, Kammer, L, Ding, Z, Wang, B, Bernard, JR, Liao, Y, and 22. Spriet, LL. Caffeine. In: Performance-Enhancing Substances in Sport
Hwang, J. Improved cycling time-trial performance after ingestion of and Exercise. M.S. Bahrke and C.E. Yesalis, eds. Champaign, IL:
an caffeine energy drink. Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab 19: 6178, Human Kinetics, 2002. pp. 267278.
2009. 23. Tordi, N, Perrey, S, Harvey, A, and Hughson, RL. Oxygen uptake
18. Jones, AM and Burnley, M. Oxygen uptake kinetics: An kinetics during two bouts of heavy cycling separated by fatiguing
underappreciated determinant of exercise performance. Int J Sports sprint exercise in humans. J Appl Physiol 94: 533541, 2003.
Physiol Perform 4: 524532, 2009. 24. Whipp, BJ and Ward, SA. Quantifying intervention-related
19. Miller, JM, Coyle, EF, Sherman, WM, Hagberg, JM, Costill, DL, improvements in exercise tolerance. Eur Respir J 33: 12541260, 2009.
Fink, WJ, Terblanche, SE, and Holloszy, JO. Effect of glycerol 25. Woolf, K and Manore, MM. B-vitamins and exercise: Does exercise
feeding on endurance and metabolism during prolonged exercise in alter requirements? Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab 16: 453484, 2006.
man. Med Sci Sports Exerc 15: 237242, 1983. 26. Yatabe, Y, Miyakawa, S, Ohmori, H, Mishima, H, and Adachi, T.
20. Nishida, S and Satoh, H. Vascular modulation of rat aorta by taurine. Effects of taurine administration on exercise. Adv Exp Med Biol 643:
Adv Exp Med Biol 643: 3746, 2009. 245252, 2009.
Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.