Landlaw Specialty Publishers Page 1 of 10 ae View Decision Archive Sense Repner(193-pte TOWN OF MONTAGUE ee No DONA ae 2008 DECISION Prunto che rvs of MLL 3, 5he Applian Clas E. Dodge 11, (Dodge is sale scan of i Agpoiing Au the Town Menta sending ‘Bf without py fore (3) essa sul nba polo Sugeno police pana, tors ek aon sn emisors esis on evr May 1, 200 sd eee The Appallat ad nly eps. A ering was elon Febuary 23,2009 an’ aes were minke Wk eaing Pot Hearing Bes weedy Mush 3, 205 fund on th documented it eid, by pest, 20 exhib, 1-7 and 88) and ‘Bear Selon, aes hearing, removed Chaves Dodge om the ak of Sergsart ard emt hin 2. To become Sent the Appt haw conpete oh poston, Heke Seger exam. He 3. ting he osning has of My 17, 200 he Appallantva of duty. print 9:00 Satan Fes Sone witha amber of ends Benson 9.00 p08 [3 en he 4-1he Aol ei tht consult se Bera eel that sty ar themdee eel th Se Police pb war over bers hla lesb beverage he ntpiflandiaw.com/eustomer/viewdesisions aspdid-4238 8/28/2012Landlaw Specialty Publishers Page 2 0f 10 5. On ay 1,208 Yul wa ten of hide, amples aa Palma for ‘umugue Pace Deparment Dodge urerioul greed © mest Ain Yul fe wie igh chen tbe Apel che Ya shome, (Teen) {6 Asamanged, Doge met MY he cl ih choo. When Pe apes ome Mrs Yul at Sebi sol Dodge hen hts bad sett i. Yl but eid we dana. The ‘Appelt ud Knew Me Yul sie lod The Appel and Ws Yu te separ aso th pking taf he lal hip coo One ere, Ms Vater the Applian tk ese) 1. Actringthe Appellant the pai egagedinconerston, Th Appel detrei ey ‘erg oe toge was beer eon he ta Te war a Fn he atthe dove ono an nt el where they seul nt be sean Thy Bad ced on he taf he tk Tesi Spun) 1 When Dade was ving the remote and anit ate, Mt Yok col rth a a inte feandof Des mer Yak gs he me bul hee an be Applian sive ome. When ke pan of mer sop Mr Ya dd not ble at Dodge hu pi base AMe'Sukuchy went ooking to De and Ms, Wa (Stoulony 9. Me, Yo weno the igh scl nd ui i’ car aes ping Me Yak Iecuesse dos of her ca Hower, rl dhe Appel and Me. VaR so he roe ot Radha 10. After Mt Yu car exe he pking at Dg hove hs along. dit road ut ofthe back of ‘hen held Dodge anes acal Camber Fane were ean in abi poste (Stale. thee ws ering Doge's 20am cre tata revise aang ih it preg ie nd Doge was worioobou nang Tesamon) 12 Ae Dg te Cumbran Farms with Mrs. Yl, Me. Yl nw Dds ec hei ot “Pape Ro othe High Sos ie Yk as Heading west Dag ud uke on thes of head Ne elds oa sop, ura hs ebierandand wen ae” Dade ond Mis Vall in etmek (Sulton) 13. Yul ple slo sit of Dodge's nd nou eof wo, sa hs wn be rosenger sel Me Yuka ere MY ner raed she Appts ack Mtge lover. Enver arf Does tack with eit pserge come of Yuk sew, VaR Ded pane Src Does cea sean tine (Sipulion & Tesimoy 14. Dig drove oth hgh seh parkag wile Ye! pve hs, Dodge wad o move is ‘hiesaifapuiowsy,tomoisapensblccemen afar veele ofa (Testimony & ‘Sipuaion anne), 15. Ate ih schon, Dodge was careful ptt pul is vec mote ps ease i ot ant ‘cause damage oe dont ese emia ene. Tesi) 16, When Dodge stopp his sci t thea the parking ot, Yl the at pe or he coger nto itcr Val ns yoling she Applian cite eke Dodge Held pe dtl mi ot thea nao eng “We st eto gen (Spain) 1. Yok! wong ne metal ra king the bt mi Dadge was bag out te wd Te {wate Haw au of he han oe Appa Yak eat Des ec whe mel Ba hlepeling Dede ota athe ctr Spon). 18 Th Appt eft ents tok ort fiction. Yak Ben paced Dodge abe {ie fought open cating hs Up During the ck essa oe ach Testor 19. tome point igh tack, Yul soles at Dade was "deo Dodge ese, "ing wit lion ws tke” Dodge ita tha ns ine "ellen tons ad tot Aloe was "ost nd cing” Alison then one om Dees ack and gpd ue the steahng fsa lng, apr clles ple (Sipuaon Tesoro) Fnpslladlaw.comn/customer/viendecisions.asp?did=4238 2872012Landlaw Specialty Publishers Page 3 of 10 20. Reser Ofer Dn Miner csp toh ea fhe ih sh Dag nd Yok a ict ph ol wton Mine ares However Mier aed non Yaka and Ibekad tnd he igh ehol fcr Mine hn procedee Yekl ame. (Spl). 21. Ofer Miner rose othe YR! me tec he taut the ws omen between she Sri ea ante sees of Yoke (Stun Tema) 22. Upon Ofc Mins aia tthe Va ame, und Dade sting o thighs ek ‘edge war peking on acl icpone Occ Minne he exunine dare Des tsk Of Mer do sterol hat Dodge aa ua edgy He mae tt De ws ‘palo Yat eens he hp repeating VI tame (Staton & Festina) 22, Moe ws aloo th howe Once nie, Mint akod Yul wheter ar Yak was hu. “tah oonsd i was Yuk a en wer ier sare oso wha happens Aner test yn sok anthng. Mie Ya ht es the Apellon m8 thr ot Mier ted ase ntising drape oh nto Vaks cw (Spun & Sinan 24, The Appl dn dito Mins tht tr kl fount Ape th Aon kl ait tim inthe moth ale rane hs cari Doar. Doda ep Nik Yak Eu "hlped at” Dodge opera abe “apa and st (Sipulaton &Teimeny) 25 Dodge equ hat Ofc Mint "hep the mate tinsel” Acca 0 Oe Min, ‘Dade be neta repo he cdo nls he whe, (Testo 2% Auta pin ner Dodge nar Yk ae whe Alton vas, Oe Mie ed ee ely {could ost er. Wale Alta euned acta fo Deneve ook fr bese inhaler ea Alison noid OK. Stpulten 8 Tesmon) 27. Aros i ous at Mie eal cpr the inet 0 Sa, illus Howes ei aad owen pon. When Ofer Mine th cng Se Cit Willa he sens albeen-apiine unt" Oe Miner's eaten iter an hee Ocer Mea ng ann een ng adem ema te ema 28 Othe ht inguin no Mentagu polio or aes OMT Yuk of arose th ovary lets nlaig he ler esa asl lelrts Vue comme aust Dade ‘db Alison Yl (Splton & Testor) 29, Yok cmd 0 worker hie cit, armed polo f fr As and deg, Se shi abl wkd une Dodge's ours 50, Mantgue Plc Offices ary Mace, Bly hu, le sight and itera 357 or 4D caer ‘ann we wk. Tesimon) 21. Assnting oad, arth em bean Yuk! ale" Doge ha temo ht be indo! ben pers and gon th YI the air wa done elo pars ‘olin In Dagestan ha men ben ¢mosndenaning Tenn fannie hat cares ie Yuk was ele sa pc ofc ifoet own Asoc {Sng tne! war rimrt he presen ater eeu valved Val bia man and ‘compromising stan wih Alton Val: Deeded Yl to at he ‘ha CTenlma) 538 Dest his revius meee arin Y's propensiy rvs, dsp sist hand spec asthe of Yuk olen acs Dede sd st ne and Yu ee hat eater Srormerly peso mater added” Yul wen ea wth ome ile ack ‘inn Doda ard Doge concede salon fave ce noting mre ha a pono at Bovge dot tlee Yoh ns eanger” estar) 34. Satusuetly, Acne Se Willan srs th hermes of Pace Dear were Sarco inion On or sto May 2,200, Se Waltume eto Dodges ere Dodo ae Innpy/landlawcom/customer/viewdecisions.asp?did-4238 8282012Landlaw Specialty Publishers Page 4 of 10 utd of tis hse reopen he damage src Sl Willan informe Dose that endo ieee now ieee Willan ene Deo ieee Pate. (Tesimeny te State) 55. nor stout May 25,200, 5g Bilin ama his eaten bean Vek and Dodge. Sat ills ba evn repo vo nen mang tbl an taper Ri, ese Dad oy benno Pace Cie Oyen. Aesorg to Sp Bigs, heeds “sapere without any mare acten hese by Che Oba, Bigs said Ce Bryan ‘aSatepltion Fr oeng eet arr Doge O'Bryan adie n esti hat he [hed Dodge ant direst tortor epred det of Dos of ayer {Desk Danas and U Mas eden Hones Oa oun Us bone ere "afore resneey) {wooter ember ofthe Deparment He infeed these oer ofcers because kre Oey woul "oprthe aro Chi! adhe kw hte Ch wold tats he mater re seo hn Iie innaton ame fe Sr Bing (esto) 57,01 vg 23, 200 te vo eer Montague ple ofes nome the Chie of Pol, Patek ‘yan ton nv ad secre aon Dodge and Yk Chet yn ina nea ‘Sechignioe, tant 13.4 Tesi) 28 The Chief Pace proche! Spt lings. The Chi ol Se. Blings fa ilings haem ‘hing nis oh be iedon old nt ave en lace lings spond ha sft oso ‘sath he fice al ay The Chat hen ol Salsa sa ser Serger Bling Pad a ‘Shion porte ein (Cosen), 138, Aerts conaaton, Sls mt wth te Dae an Yl in capa on resin Sa Blogs bmadtem th ty have speak othe Chie Tsinen 40-The partes woe lento th Chit ofc where Yul anit othe above fact regarding the Inc and eos um To ws. Yl is lcd on aos ve Tso Ext a 41, Yuki st hve eset arya ise a retin Sematary 24,2000, Se lings wena kis homed tok spe. (Testor. 42, Dodge id a want cob tte meson, Doda ys cing ad pst, He sed at "rs fr nt cooperating tenes fo conse easing hisaonsp th Hs who ‘ospepan athens (Tesimor) 48. Cae Bian sued en Ordering Dds copra withthe investgatn The Order to the Aosta ase verano om So Bilin St Bling ove ae Odo ‘eed rf rman th te Co nas nc aut rvs. The Ora rom CE Felth pate eet faring iy fu psec Dade under Came rule (esto EAB TO) 4, Afri one ppt a ivesiguon by Chef OB, Onde nd SL Biles ‘seis thence she lice of xcreee The he Apel poids veal sma of ‘he neler thread nthe caason of pyc! vine Terps Retna he Hh SEscaTR pips eisnce cies nas cs om ah Doe a Yas oe copa fas in he ead casey YaaTs aceon to Dodges eile he ik ate Siuaton & exe 7) 48 Dodge praca! phropaph ofthe cut ip he reed when psd by Vik. Dodge aio ced phtoeraps hea bi wie al eno he sarap ka oe i mus che Hihvoy (Hebe 7 Teme) 46. Chis tiga permits Dg tocontus working. Yet imately te te Ye ng ‘hn 200 Apu Acory odoed Dodge Be placed on pi ania ene. reve) 47 Foci pain sides the Apoining Aor ened plnan Yok! om -np/tandlaw com/customer'viewdesisions.asp2did~4238 2872012Landlaw Specialty Publishers Page S of 10 employes, Goad Ssecme {s-The Chil Seve Commision ure ups sso, eison ded Augist 2200, specks Noh. The Appar Autor ao ssp ewe Ofer Mined cing Serasnt Wills Serge Blings reed sto epemnd(Stpain abs, Bh Tiny ard Admiral note) 48 Arh coneavon fs She Polis init inlets made by Mr Yl pst Dodges Cha Park O'Bryan ed here fore unter of dps witout nnng he Ae ‘Aur fs eustence. Th, ain wou pir noon othe poling Athos he let Paice Imposed he mina pay perlite oa Che ole by sue aga Dodge (suman BARBS. {, Foes Chie of aie Paik OB then inposeda Fve-y suspension ese" it into esi ha a ro pd Ae ee ‘Seuven Ut BOS auoriy to dine Dodge mare sever (Tesinon) 50. Oration evidence a a a ino Dos tan ait hat pie toh inden had pubis rccucel Doge ee “net Cito! Pole Ua apa be “neous fd stern prt nea of te Apoining Att sects hs Wisin favor ge, Por toh sane o espa on, he Appoting Authors ha hela ering and spore eine guns every tne aes need he sons (ESD tha Testing) 5. Te Chie ht Dag athe ay ofa th et ano ine me ‘pone ident wisn cipiry ain ken The Chet ele at Doe as Super, ha oft mst etl sat sional a acting ago couple” Ta Chit ure nied. "hs th pry ear woud we mond fom Dodge's poe le Ina areas ar ‘cgaay aon ua im, These empes ae bt fn hat eet Cher ONS {avr tonne Dodge Testy & Exh 1) 52 The Appin Autoty fue 1 Doe the sary req sie of hewing an ashe ‘he equred sant edges eer ChilSrn,shrthe StePlo cont ltestosin (Splan Ean 8), 15, Meat, Dodge Red rinse sing he Fey spenson impos the Chi Come rth Apel reese the gevance ae be a wh he diary hei ‘elie he Apotng Auton. THe Appang Autry speed come te wo hears, (Sopautae Ese ‘4.0 Aus 23, 2000 ahosingcorsmoncd ene he Apel Aub. wo ars represented Dodge, Doge was he il opr pea eine and ce-exine "ese (Staion) 55. cyan tei ta tthe ine of tine Doe wae ntti into ave god Seen” inated tht tra numer gear Sergeant, Dade wa aly wang ndesand Stchadtotkes management le anda twas ugh mina ene ina sal Depa! in asa tow this ea aly case soon ke ante! erp, (an ether esr sch manplon by asabordate "bona ne (Tein) ‘56 Chan ofthe Bod of Selena Ear Vain tii at Chi of Pole ps a ‘nine sweaty suns eave he poet Raga re probe an peo Be Board (803), Hetty eed ha th Cre hd armed bth Yak ed Dodge te ‘unt posse fr tr voeemen nhs rset He we cenered ae cle ‘he'Su Poco fvesipze theater especial nite he Ch ke rete $n hs mater Ho rated the Cet tat ony he BUS woul keynes aon he iat ard he Chev ary ain eine or tomato spy tam ove th Sic Pole the Chet lisa roby is dace when he unacaly ims ately, “Sapeson on Dodge: orice and oman side we ror te oe ‘strato ome BOS. Tein) 47. Youten note members of he BOS i questo he Chie conser "hs asin fr of edge ecuse of his pte esen of Dodge hs mar. Te Che dd tedie Dodge as etext cet Poker aa Base Seinen mung a 19H (Teno) -gp:/landlaw.com/customer/viewdecisions asp?dig4238 8282012Lundlaw Specialty Publishers Page 6 of 10 58 Chea of Ha of Seaman, ver Voate expand hl teeing belo he ‘Apoming Auber. Dude led scnomleae he sercuanesoheeven ge tel reking miakes nd apologad Hawes Dodge oi seh th mater as meray "perma "Veen oie athe conse he cafe to ever porta nd pale as, ste hrs 91 el om s itso, Vaud xno Dns ht th HOS ad contend ‘Crmuting nb tad ada Sees Deas mean afimpeig me cores in ‘Mr Woudren eed hat Dg at fared om raplyng Sr porta Stes the fire (Testimony) 8 Vowen west a his ot as sn an crassa oh te. The ha ben ‘eveppa coverage ofthe dnt nthe flowy ptr There tn mack alk ie Town {pone hated pie senens nih ole Dsparen Alo he mane othe Bafurent ve been ne yt nee 2. ward Vouo fn ey cele wits tg fateght and cosets in bs demeanor sat {esimor, late much es testimony. However ia a theese Dodge andPasck Oman are credit As nes te Senne and eon ars Sing norte Thy aed el tuiony say facta noe ey wel ened ‘hough ther sources Ye when te estima lato ek own ete se of in. ‘nae, and poses cr en cad an bus ut unpre csp oso ane athe {et ih gee estima of Dodge and yan very ie weg (Tela) {61 After detain, the Apoieting Asher (805) ona ved 1 oven he ey “Saymlon ime ye Cet ans dete Doge parma an ees oe {Suing edursen ab raning. tampon ose hs soar igh Thx aes ‘le Tienda othe Agpting Aut has en placed ihe Appel He and ‘ste chaser (Spica ENB) (2 Subsea, adsiplinry rng was edb the Boutof Selectmen sais Chief Bean, trp te toh cone and oss nist, Aer te Rowing as cocude, Chil OByan rele. Testimony) 65. nhl exprnc as aol oer, Dodge knew oshosshav ny te fl sponses of ‘tol offers theyre the parl poring ou are te commision Orme He ‘Sou have been are fh heel of profes dent chia obpstons a ie ‘Daas ates tt te ere ines or put mos nmi Jato Uncen ge ‘eid at pc fcr mathe cs of wha tare und eeunsanes he ‘Seton Dodge avid hat Vuk atk coal te ensued asthe commision crn! ese {ai hi and Ms Yu (Ese 3 & Teno) {4 The Appt ha, pro his de ead he Paice Mana of es and etn fo the Pte ByarmentThe Manus ie Sal the aes rerpnnblies us ign of pale ofes and superior ofr (EDS, 3 Teen) CONCLUSION ‘The Respond di rove propondane of te viene ta here ut amet pon the ite of edoton nak fot pole sano pala. Js Cae leds ‘etnduct nich adtency fe the une aren impaing the fiery ofthe pic ‘nist ston Police Deere. Jobe Cals 46 tas Agp 11820) cng, Pole im Banton Cl Ser 39 Ma Ap Cx $89 1099, Th oa te Ca Saree ‘sin o eenine ter own Pd eben and vey pace eon repo The dipne areown .a, 0 Mas App, C2381 334 (198). The atin hee hee ‘ns raabl tation thea taken the Aoi Authors he ceumsanes hat ted hen be Appling Aube mae dc Town of Dechon Chal Senice {Commision 2 Ms. Ap. C904 C88). Isl eth oc ofr vluanly unde tn adore oa igh star of conduct ‘har that impon’ riya Te epee i Cou cig te Cou Apps Bs ald hat fy thir canbe bass or aig jus cause npn: sip on ce ‘ere The Coun sed “hos css each spl esa. Police ots mus cmp tenseesin acrdance withthe lave thatthe arson ofc nd Behave naar ht ng hor od ape! ‘up: landlaw.com/customer/viewdevisions.asp2did-~4238 ‘2872012Landiaw Specialty Publishers Page 7 of 10 ‘han pute dts fn enorcone pesonel. They ae euro do mor tan fala fom ince end Pole erred ino pb seve; rae ty compte rel Peston nace emsoynent ye pti they mpi ape tha hey wl tone auc wch cals quan tabi nd Sess prom ha fc ponies" try Gane Le Metta, Js 48 Ms. 790 (199) ng, Pole Camm’ Boston (Gh ese Commision, 2 Ms Ap CL 363711980, ndhe Lerner dessin the SC aimed he ny of Appeals Cou cases ping te dchree ti paleo ha bone taproot lo dg as Met uy Feta lode eto poles he SC mal erento re say Hao ak ged ‘romne inet nfrsemen Cases hse an scones he iphone lpn of ein ‘The Montague Paice otiy a Prades Manual aay etic aga to the Cade lotsa t Te "Law Enforcement Cae oh" gated th SIC: Arig toe Case of| ‘thc egared puntos Pte nd Proves Manali lowagoe Plc Deptet (ahh) Faligt alee the Code of bes sake a olan of he Avaeress of Dues” aregraph andr Sesion Raga Cont ‘hs nin ands alow fae he reo ad oer o be led the wl mane shally rete he coe ployment of Dodge we aril nr eon ate. One 5ST al tease mentor te publ concerns eet | space ofr remponds a ocured new kecmes ey uli ‘Bc opel ter comida nde ie polo ee valved, te mae ‘ees public and wii roe aso an elon of he Appling Aue Doe's ‘tunp chars the inlet ssmerel penal as este stp o wo pron ‘spent rofesinal aces Hs atempt however ha ese impo om ‘srs Mean Ya, Si Bilinge an Wiliams who al meio Spina lmaely Cet ‘Osan whe ree. ‘twee Reser ficues onthe sbviour crimes commit y Yalan Dade and Me {7a beng est nd ty Anaad Bary by meas a Jee neapon, dg. 2094 ‘inion sod mas datacian opal pope he pret ees of Doe, ner of Ticino areal veroahe. Tose pcs cesar cpr Famer vtie ona flew whic une nfs of lesb, wespaing shel rope nase er Fear eborcton oasis by temp fo vente spurge ke odes exe por udomen oghout by dking hui, cing Ms ruck rer and thor ‘Ning «ists wom ar tend thi, knoe ele jel Does never an topo ncte Alien Vahl af she ueny sapien osc ay ‘tap ate o Yu tt th ptt aur a Mis VL amend ofthe publ Dodges {eoped coverup ofthe mess hare sed ier Sepa othe vero he oe ope nah nis nien ans ahem ntadin bin eH amg cove the [ReGonupns tae ply bys inert and salt Chie ryan contin pays his fvoritsn fr Dad, ero alsa te iaveanton of ‘einen Tide te Pace Dyptment moral orld a fcr Bae ‘nary mar iiag Dade. Dade expel hs peferetal eamen the Chie cs rd hereby escape my ue ses spine ‘The Tom of Montague aston ate Hy hs elder and he fon-pestigaon. The Tov’ {ctl conldence nthe Palce Deprens ty © party efor ay Rasbeen etd an ‘ithe ronestens mo nthe et layed ot ‘The Appointing Aor ced property undrthe crmsanes fh nn dsp of [Appel Thre wa ruc een fr tainly he Appin Aa ne ‘Stans edt found ee Se slo anther case wih eso eeu tnd fasaty me Comission did sy te dss matey te Aoninting Rui, Fon of Dean ‘Cu Some Comms 31 Maz App Cx 94945) the belo i Coron tt Badge war een get lesion tho ater he Appling Aut. he Hes ac {ndthconlsneof av ma nth case woul cans ave ois moreso dpe Tee Derip ond incucing tornaton sachs ram lopment ‘np: landlaw com/customer/viewdesisions.asp?did~4238 8/28/2012Landlaw Specialty Publishers Page $ of 10 Wien smioing Cio con te i hn se he ere ai nt [Efisrcogine thal how te Anping Aus hast caso dicate he ewe” Waseem. sri, toa Apps 231,334 (1989), se win eau ofthe Commision ‘subse i jadgmam aut valence of dase aed on mai oy Smee SAtpning Ary fig Cori Cadre Cam 1 a Ap he Sees iia cases sh a, Sly Cambie Poe Deprun, Chil Senie Conision, ‘oD 98'sae sage Ociber 1, 2001 [14 MSR 172, Tne pase ae, Ihe ed balan “Apel who tad a open ke pet cen atte App has mt. rage 8 Toe freon eae is Sale veel am Apel who meee infermation an who. el” [Eldar comple hs es tne, he chow not I The preset eae ain Sat iri ea nen, eet i er icing the biel Dornan laser an a TU 8 ‘Ath Cis Senice Commision fun aS, is gover my peas anal be wed ina ‘name bat ats wey pose of Ci Servo Legation (ne. Pale Commision of aon Ca te Commision 22 Mass. Ap, C.364 (1980), Teor te Cv Seuce Commish ied. ple res fondu and hs enfrxmon ae ply mater ene ‘arto ital canoer ecten wre omental ped pubic foley. append ne Crisis each Hy a ag bg, Btn Police Deparment dei alin. App. C0 4081200) Ine ie and Pacetues Mansa (is be "Role as Sega” te des ab shigtons nee ee poston of hate ley delta. wndapte tha be Appelt Iseshed oy oh Man oming ese hiptsons ahi 2 fur undpte a he ‘peta competed randy sug he sto of sys. Dodge’ bein an dene ‘hing esptd hs niet sia te flow-up mene coverup. Vek os a "Gren ton to dg ahve we Se prefabs cheers peer ‘Dade aie ire ptr twan ls, Ya a role ae Sergent rape aor ond (tet ozo tes sven nen Ratan ote lee Sere sec ot he Manat he Sorgen sched wth ering crane wt he Dearne elon all cor and prt vlan toe supra He shale ede ‘penino inte paper slags ofthe Joes” odes proes isola spray olf Sergeant say is nse ta ‘bors propery vestige und eport pasbe llest and ome ars wh nara. Fv Doge ct ppt Generally polo ae cag ity be ence ea md Iboyetct and seve te publi tn ever op and pl hres. mas che {nein whe sitted reac Sie to et nde Heaton ad ensans tering Noe and ter stores ete serosa italy aay Ss. ‘gt the Applet nals acounae othe ston emione ofa der is ‘cousin which econ fo parental rein rol.” Dsge ea le th Law Fnforcent Cosa ths comin ie Montagne Poe Pca ical Nea ‘hh is Sea pied nie Das dels moved is cio of the rublie ay nayay m he esdetialare were ‘egtiosmig beara ann an stole the pe way cw of ei FE Srve tis tk oh ton "vis ppurent te ts domo fhe Appelt renin ese falar of icmp tahoe he station ropa Furthemare he Apel lear vote ear nd report e sasing poston Sc, Cel. secon TIA " Dodge ied calle and psec vdeo of he oes common his presume but he id scr to ile een harsh a ish net nesced ern defed ims {apres aati, Deda oie shar ea ton he pogo er ‘heen Hemmenaned ha te oc photograph nthe eve he Applian ones ma dete Ina He di chow ep he ce prevaing operant Tow cree fs ove ‘acon of eine Fates be wilde pote een ul sch ie se Was -ttp:/landlaw.conveustomer/viewdecisions.asp?did~4238, 82872012Landlaw Specialty Publishers Page 9 of 10 ordedto trons The fics to inumstnes hes ht Dad whe ied colt ied wpesere rj hi rdeavoydevidence, Dag ler sie uy ner» pole sro Sprain hs apr “The Apel ecu ts by sang tha be inated Min tell eth "if shed® At int in ‘hedles ofthe atelier he sergear dsp he canon dhe pols and Prose pp ny nh exe somone ase Ress fier Mine ha pra ase a {Ero ce Yak in e was gated ome compan. writen recor ofthe eves sel ‘So preenetie edo, The Appl as raqured eae eae es The eno thin hess re hat wo prt reoabl person conceive pong hon iolatd ne Mal rie olan wen Someone "ase Ins incite Dada asa prepay, prfenal wines, a a wpernce ian itm, and Horie woue cess Sted Hbaed maps mn gaion oat aoa proper: Inthe rsetcne,e Apel sid at Neko of stances flees in Yuk pst and he ‘pel exrsiod he kee rat hand Howevs, he Appel dk mote eset of {YU Hedi non Resowe Ore Mineo ake ret He diet ke cn Yas {tr dignd weed ope emmogneane Toe al tg ore dot ea vt ‘Therese eve he Appelt Rom soso rak of pols Sega snd moti {othe poston pote plan oral oft tov sed asus ov bya propndeane of he evidence hat the Appoint Auto ad usa ae te spina aon en nese. Teer is ped ‘demise By vate of he Cl Sene Comision (Len Chama Henderson Taya Gut, Conmisines on Mash 28, 2008 Mena 8 Sulla Be Sun, es Gun ‘One Manrh Pae Ste 120 Sponafisia Ma iat Mishel wits, 139 rsa Paso oi, Ma 2168 John Mira. sg Haman ett Dion ‘One Astaro Pace Boson a 108 Back hitp:Mandlawcom/customer/viewdecisions.asp?Uid=4238 sg2012Landiaw Specialty Publishers Page 10 of 10 hip: Mlandlaw:com/customer/viewdesisions.aspdid4238 282012