Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Nickel acetylacetonate was used as a precursor for the preparation of Ni/Al2O3 catalysts with metal content
between 0.4 and 3 wt %. The nature of the interactions between the metal complex and the support has been
investigated by X-ray photoelectron (XPS) and infrared (IR) spectroscopies. The spectral features point to
modifications of the precursor in the adsorbed state. IR results indicate that the interaction between acetylacetone
and the support involves coordinately unsaturated (cus) Al3+ sites, hydroxyls of the support surface, and
probably also basic oxygens. A model for these interactions is proposed. Monolayer coverage is achieved at
a Ni loading of about 0.8-1.0%. Piling in multilayers occurs at higher content.
Figure 5. XPS spectra of the C 1s peak of (a) Al2O3, (b) Al2O3 calcined
at 1200 C, (c) Hacac/Al2O3 and for Ni(acac)2/Al2O3 with (d) 0.4, (e)
1.0, (f) 1.6% Ni, and (g) pure Ni(acac)2.
TABLE 2: Binding Energies (BE, in eV) and Full Widths at Half-Maximum (fwhm Values in Brackets in eV)
C 1s Ni 2p3/2
sample C1 C2 C3 O 1s mp sat. Ct (%) (C2 + C3)/Ct
Ni(acac)2 284.8 286.8 290.0 531.7, 536.3 856.0 860.7 64.46 0.40
[2.68] [2.55] [4.30] [2.66], [2.18] [2.85] [6.78]
1.6% 284.8 286.7 288.8 530.9 856.0 861.7 20.10 0.28
[3.34] [2.29] [3.79] [3.12] [4.21] [6.19]
1.0% 284.8 286.4 289.0 530.9 856.3 862.1 19.02 0.31
[3.41] [2.15] [3.08] [3.14] [4.43] [5.50]
0.4% 284.8 286.5 289.0 530.9 855.8 861.6 16.88 0.31
[2.93] [2.34] [4.33] [3.09] [4.46] [6.44]
Hacac/Al2O3 284.8 286.7 289.1 531.0 11.60 0.30
[2.72] [2.30] [2.81] [3.22]
Al2O3a 284.8 286.3 289.3 530.9 11.88 0.31
[2.72] [2.21] [3.03] [3.15]
Al2O3 284.8 286.5 289.6 531.1 27.33 0.18
[2.59] [2.13] [2.99] [2.98]
a
C/Ni ratio determined after subtraction of blank (0.1% for Al2O3 + benzene).
Figure 6. O 1s peak of (a) Ni(acac)2 and of samples with nickel content Figure 7. Ni 2p3/2 peak of (a)/Ni(acac)2 and of Ni(acac)2/Al2O3 with
of (b) 1.6, (c) 1.0, and (d) 0.4% Ni. metal content of (b) 0.4, (c) 1.0, and (d) 1.6%.
progressive modification of the C 1s peak profile with increasing of the main peak (856 eV) was similar in all the samples and
amounts of complex is more evident when the total carbon (Ct in agreement with the values reported for Ni(acac)2 and assigned
in Table 1) and the surface carbon content (Table 2) of the to Ni(II).29-31 On the other hand, there was a difference in the
samples are considered. Indeed, the (C2 + C3)/Ct ratios, with BE of the satellite peak by about 1.0-1.4 eV between the pure
C2 standing for -C-O and C3 for -CdO, decreased from 0.40 and adsorbed complex. Also, the main peak and the satellite
(for nickel acac) to 0.28-0.31 for the impregnated samples.
peaks of the pure and adsorbed complex exhibited differences
As mentioned above, no good fit was obtained when the BE
in both the fwhm value and the peak profile. While an important
values obtained for pure Ni(acac)2 were imposed in the
increase of the fwhm of the main peak was observed between
decomposition of the peaks of the impregnated samples. It is
pure and supported Ni(acac)2, both a change of the peak profile
seen in Table 2 that there was no important change of the
and a decrease of the fwhm of the satellite peak were noticed.
binding energy of the C2 component of the C 1s peak, whereas
These changes again are consistent with a modification of the
for C3, a shift of about 1 eV between the pure and the supported
precursor after its adsorption on the support and perhaps also
precursor was observed. These observations are consistent with
a modification of the precursor when it is adsorbed on the with the formation of at least one different nickel species as
support. may be suspected from the asymmetry in the right-hand side
The BE and fwhm values of the O 1s peak are presented in of the peak.
Table 2. For the sake of illustration, Figure 6 shows the spectrum Surface Sites of the Support: IR Spectroscopy of Ad-
of the O 1s peak of a few samples. Pure Ni(acac)2 showed a sorbed Probe Molecules. The spectrum of the support out-
main peak at 531.7 eV and a weak one at 536.3 eV. In the gassed at 500 C showed three bands at 3752, 3734 (shoulder),
spectra of the impregnated samples, the second peak at 536.3 and 3690 cm-1. According to Knozinger and Ratnasamy,32 a
eV was absent while the main peak broadened and shifted by maximum of five different OH configurations can be expected
about 0.7 eV, indicating a decrease of the BE of oxygen-carbon for -alumina, ranging from basic terminal OH coordinated to
(C-O or CdO) and/or oxygen-nickel (in acac group). As for a single tetrahedral Al3+ ion to acidic bridging OH coordinated
the C 1s peak, these features point to a modification of Ni- to three Al3+ ions in octahedral insterstices, their actual
(acac)2 when it is supported on alumina. This hypothesis occurrence and proportions depending on the relative contribu-
assumes that a change of the charge around Ni would also occur. tions of the different crystal faces. The band at 3690 cm-1
The XPS spectra of the Ni 2p3/2 level of Ni(acac)2 and the (Figure 8a) probably corresponds to a type III configuration
impregnated samples (0.4, 1.0, and 1.6% Ni) are shown in Figure (OH linked to three Al3+ ions in octahedral position). A band
7, and the BE and fwhm values are given in Table 2. The BE at 3734 cm-1 in R-alumina has been assigned by Morterra et
6040 J. Phys. Chem. B, Vol. 103, No. 29, 1999 Molina et al.
Figure 8. Infrared spectra of R-alumina support after (a) outgassing overnight at 500 C, (b) adsorption of CO2, (c) outgassing at room temperature
(10-3 bar), (d) room temperature (10-5 bar) and outgassing at 10-5 bar for 20 min at (e) 100 C, (f) 200 C, and (g) 300 C.
al.33 to OH attached to Al in octahedral coordination and that In the OH stretching region (Figure 8, right), the adsorption
at 3750-3755 cm-1 to OH coordinated to a single tetrahedral of CO2 produced a clear perturbation of the high-frequency band
Al3+ ion. at 3752-3740 cm-1 and that at 3690 cm-1, with the appearance
The IR spectra after adsorption of CO2 at room temperature of a broad band centered at 3550 cm-1. These modifications
(100 mbar) and after outgassing at different temperatures on have been attributed to the formation of species A (hydrogen-
R-alumina previously heated under vacuum at 500 C for 14 h carbonate) involving isolated OH groups. Note also the simul-
are shown in Figure 8. Morterra et al.34 defined five species, taneous resurgence of the OH band and the diminution of those
A-E, characterized by bands at about 1655, 1440, and 1225 characterizing species A (at 1652, 1440, and 1227 cm-1) upon
cm-1 (species A); at 1570-1610) and 1350-1385 cm-1 (species outgassing.
B); at 1660-1675 and near 1345 cm-1 (species C); around 1710 Adsorption of ammonia and pyridine performed under similar
and 1310 cm-1 (species D); and above 1730 (1755 and 1810 conditions showed the complete disappearance of the OH bands.
cm-1) with a diffuse shoulder below 1300 cm-1 (species E). In the case of ammonia, two bands apprearing at 1625 and 1240
According to these assignments, the bands at 1652, 1440, cm-1 were assigned to the symmetrical and asymmetrical
and 1227 cm-1 would characterize surface hydrogen-carbonate deformation vibrations of ammonia coordinately held on un-
species (species A), the formation of which requires the presence completely coordinated Al3+, indicative of Lewis acidity.35,36
of tetrahedral Al.32 AlIV was observed in the 27Al MAS NMR
Two other bands could be distinguished near 3390 and 3220
spectrum, and small amounts of transition alumina were
cm-1. Morimoto et al.37 reported that such bands appear when
identified by XRD. The bands at 1606 and 1350 cm-1 may be
hydrogen bonding with hydroxyls is the only interaction with
assigned to species B (symmetrical and asymmetrical CO2
the surface. The spectra of adsorbed pyridine showed bands at
stretches of at least one monodentate species formed on basic
1614, 1595, 1578, 1491, 1449, and 1444 cm-1. According to
oxygens). The one at 1585 cm-1, which shows a similar
the results of Morterra et al.38 on R-alumina (containing small
evolution upon outgassing, is tentatively attributed to the same
amounts of -alumina), the bands at 1595 and 1614 cm-1 could
species. The shoulder near 1700 cm-1 probably corresponds to
species D, attributed to a bidentate carbonate. The formation be assigned to Py species coordinated to octahedral and
of this species is favored by a high dehydration degree.34 Figure tetrahedral Al sites, respectively. Those at 1449 and 1444 cm-1
8 also shows that species A and D are less important and less would indicate the presence of two types of Lewis sites with
stable than species B, since an outgassing at room temperature slightly different acid strengths. As for ammonia, these bands
(10-3 bar for 10 min and then at 10-5 bar for another 10 min) were barely observed after an outgassing at 150 C.
produced a significant loss of intensity of the corresponding Infrared Spectroscopy of the Adsorbed Complex. Pure
absorption bands, leaving those of species B relatively much metal acetylacetonates have been extensively investigated by
less affected. Species A and D were removed after an outgassing infrared spectroscopy, and the main spectral features have been
at 100 C for 20 min, while species B needed an outgassing compiled by Nakamoto.39 Alumina-supported Mn+(acac)n, un-
above 250 C to be totally eliminated. The formation of supported and supported Hacac, and Al(acac)3 have also been
monodentate species B (CO2 on basic oxygens) and their higher examined, recordings of pure metal complexes allowing band
resistance to evacuation indicate a relatively high basicity of assignment. The frequencies (in wavenumbers) of the absorption
these centers. bands of Al(III) and Ni(II) acetylacetonates taken from the
R-Alumina-Supported Ni Catalysts J. Phys. Chem. B, Vol. 103, No. 29, 1999 6041
vacuum, did not appear in the IR spectrum of Figure 10 probably (eq 3), and then only the IR OH stretching band should be
because of the rapid re-adsorption of water molecules that may perturbed, or that the chemical reaction proceeds without loss
interact via hydrogen bonding, contributing to the large absorp- of acac ligands (eq 4), and in that case the Al(acac) species
tion between 3700 and 3000 cm-1. Therefore, it cannot be should remain adsorbed on the support, which is consistent with
ascertained that these hydroxyls also react with the metal the very low amounts of Al found in the wash solution.
precursor, although both disappeared upon adsorption of probe The surface reaction between Ni-acac and surface OH groups
molecules. Beside, one may also expect that, owing to the high and between split acac ligands and cus Al3+ sites with enolate
thermal treatment to operate the -to-R phase transformation, configuration may be represented by the general reaction
some among the five types of hydroxyls observed by Knozinger
and Ratnasamy32 for -alumina may have been irreversibly lost,
since they were not observed for the R-alumina.
The shifts of the C 1s peaks noted in the impregnated samples
relative to the pure complex, suggesting a decrease of the BE
of oxygen-carbon (-C-O or -CdO) and/or nickel-oxygen
(of the acac ligands), the absence of the second peak of the O The formation of the enolate configuration is probably limited
1s level at 536.3 eV in the impregnated support (present in pure to the amount of the cus Al3+ available on the surface. The
Ni(acac)2), the broadening of the main peak and its shift by proton released could react with the acac groups in excess of
about 0.7 eV, and the modifications of the Ni 2p3/2 level equally the cus Al3+ available, forming Hacac, which at room temper-
point to changes of the metal complex in its adsorbed state. In ature remain adsorbed on the surface. As was suggested by van
addition, the appearance of new IR bands, which can only be Veen et al.,9 Hads could form a hydroxyl group with an O atom
due to the reaction of acac ligands with Al3+ species, implies that was coordinated to cus Al3+ before the adsorption. Mass
the split of the molecule and the reaction of the second acac spectrometric analyses of the gaseous effluent of a sample dried
group attached to Ni probably with surface OH groups (and/or at 120 C showed the presence of methane, acetone, and acac,
basic oxygens observed by IR-CO2) of the support. These besides CO, CO2, H2O, and traces of benzene. Since the carbon
observations and the formation of the enolate on Al3+ species analyses were performed on room temperature dried samples,
(IR band at 1290 cm-1), the color changes of the impregnated similar C/Ni ratios for the impregnated solids and the precursor
support, and the absence of Ni release upon exhaustive washing are not surprising. In reported studies, these ratios were
are in favor of an adsorption mechanism involving covalent established on samples previously heated or obtained by CVD
bonding rather than a physical adsorption via H-bonding or methods (at 200 C).
simple a precipitation. Monolayer Formation. The formation of a monolayer should
be in relation with the specific surface area and/or the number
If Ni-acac reacts with an OH group and/or a basic oxygen of sites available at the surface of the support. The structure
of the support (observed by IR-CO2), it may be expected that proposed for the adsorbed complex allows one to estimate the
the change of one acac ligand for one oxygen of the support monolayer (saturation) coverage on the R-Al2O3 from its specific
(with electronegativity of 3.5) will produce a modification of area (42 m2 g-1) and the packing of a molecule of the nickel
the charge around the nickel. Since the band shifts observed in complex. A value of 0.373 nm2 was established from the unit
the spectral region 1700-1200 cm-1 were not large, the overall cell parameters. To achieve monolayer coverage, 2.7 molecules
change of charge after reaction must not be very important, of Ni(acac)2 nm-2 (1.1 wt % of Ni) would theoretically be
inasmuch as the existence of other Ni species with BE nearly required. This value is consistent with the very low amount of
similar to those of Ni(acac)2 cannot be ruled out. This would Ni found in the wash solutions (Table 1) and the associated
be consistent with the results of Grim and Matienzo47 for color changes of the solids with 0.8-1.0 Ni %. In reported
inorganic and organometallic compounds of molybdenum, which studies, the area of the supported nickel species retaining one
exhibited similar BE values despite different oxidation states acac ligand was estimated to be 0.45 and 0.47 nm2, with a
of Mo. theoretical density of 2.2 (0.91% Ni) and 2.1 Ni atoms nm-2
As mentioned above, the carbon/metal ratio may provide an (0.87% Ni), respectively.7,22 Babich et al.6 reported values of
indication of the type of interaction mechanism.6,7,10,12 Lindblad 2.0 Ni atoms nm-2 for silica and 1.3 Ni atom nm-2 for
et al.7 showed that when solid Ni(acac)2 was vapor-phase- -alumina, which stayed unchanged after prolonged contact
deposited (VPD) on alumina pretreated at 200 and 800 C, the times or when an excess of the metal precursor was used at the
C/Ni ratios were about 5 and 8, respectively. Since the IR band preparation step. The difference between the values of the
of the isolated OH groups disappeared, the authors proposed literature and ours may be accounted for by the different choice
that an exchange reaction took place according to eq 4. Since of the predominant face considered for the calculation of the
in VPD the temperature (200 C) was near the decomposition packing of the precursor molecule. The theoretical density is
temperature of Ni(acac)2 (230 C), the loss of a ligand was thus in reasonable agreement with the results of the cited
favored over the associative adsorption, which may account for authors.7,22
a C/Ni ratio of 5. A C/Ni ratio of 8 would imply an additional In the dipping method (used in this work), mainly applied
reaction between acac ligands and Al3+ sites of alumina, the when the precursor interacts with the support, the metal uptake
formation of those sites being favored by calcination at high is governed by the concentration of the adsorption sites at the
temperature.31 Babich et al.6 determined, from TG-DSC mea- support surface.46,48 In pure alumina, both acidic and basic sites
surements, an acac/Ni ratio of 1.7 (C/Ni ) 8.4) and also were observed by IR spectroscopy. As the OH groups constitute
suggested that the precursor is covalently bonded to the support, reactive sites, an evaluation of the formation of a monolayer
Hacac evolving during chemisorption of Ni(acac)2 reacting with involving those sites can be made. The hydroxyl density of the
cus Al3+ ions on the alumina surface. support was 1.28 OH nm-2. Assuming that each OH participates
The absence of a significant difference of the C/Ni ratio of in a ligand exchange, they may account for 47 or 60% of the
the impregnated solids relative to that of the metal precursor theoretical Ni density calculated above, depending on the
(Table 1) indicates either that the complex is not decomposed packing value adopted. Obviously, sites other than the OH
R-Alumina-Supported Ni Catalysts J. Phys. Chem. B, Vol. 103, No. 29, 1999 6045
groups should be involved. It has been shown that the cus Al3+ monolayer coverage, (ii) the spectroscopic results, in particular
sites on alumina, whose number increases with increasing the IR data showing the reaction with OH groups of the support,
calcination temperature, also intervene in the adsorption process, the formation of Al(acac) species, and the absence of ring
although a precise figure cannot be easily determined.32 The opening of the organic moiety, and (iii) the C/Ni ratios, which
amphoteric character of both alumina and Ni(acac)2 leads us to are coherent with the stoichiometry of the overall reaction. It
admit that basic surface oxygens of the support could also take has been also established that the reaction between Hacac and
part in the adsorption process. Such sites were observed by IR alumina occurs by not only interaction with cus Al3+ but perhaps
spectroscopy of adsorbed CO2. Room-temperature CO2 adsorp- also with surface OH groups of the support.
tion measurements on alumina (made at the Department of A theoretical density of 2.7 molecules of Ni(acac)2 nm-2 has
Inorganic Chemistry (Prof. E. Vansant), U. I. T.; Antwerp) gave been estimated for the formation of a monolayer (around 0.8-
a total uptake of 2.61 cm3 g-1, half of it (8.4 1017 molecules 1% Ni), a value that is in qualitative agreement with the IR
CO2 m-2, or 0.84 molecule nm-2) representing chemisorbed observations but higher than values reported for similar catalysts.
CO2. Hence, the misfit between the OH density and the Ni For higher metal content, piling in multilayers is likely.
density (theoretical monolayer coverage) would represent the
contribution of the cus Al3+ and some basic sites. Acknowledgment. R.M. gratefully acknowledges Colcien-
From these considerations, it may be inferred that in the cias, Colombia, for a doctoral grant. The authors are indebted
systems with Ni loadings in excess of 1%, multilayers probably to Prof. E. Vansant, Universitaire Instellingen, Antwerpen, for
start piling up, with approximatively two layers for the sample the CO2 sorption measurements, and Prof. P. Grobet, Centrum
with 1.6% and three layers for that with 3% Ni. As seen above, voor Oppervlaktechemie en Katalyse, K.U. Leuven, for the
these multilayers remain on the surface even after exhaustive 27Al MAS NMR analysis.
(30) Nefedov, V. I.; Zhumadilov, E. K.; Baer, L. Zh. Neorg. Khim. 1978, (41) Dismukes, J. P.; Jones, L. H.; Bailar, J. C. J. Phys. Chem. 1961,
23, 2113. 65, 792.
(31) Baldy, A.; Durocher, A.; Rzehak, H.; Limouzin-Marie, Y. Bull. (42) Mitchel, M. B.; Chakravarthy, V. R.; White, M. G. Langmuir 1994,
Soc. Chim. Fr. 1981, 1-2, 67. 10, 4523.
(32) Knozinger, H.; Ratnasamy, P. Catal. ReV. Sci. Eng. 1978, 17, 31. (43) Kohler, S.; Reiche, M.; Frobel, C.; Baerns, M. In Studies in Surface
(33) Morterra, C.; Ghiotti, G.; Garrone, E.; Boccuzzi, F. J. Chem. Soc., Science and Catalysis; Elsevier: Amsterdam, 1995; Vol. 91, p 1009.
Faraday Trans. 1976, 72, 2722. (44) Agostini, G.; Ledoux, M. J.; Hilaire, L.; Maire, G. In Studies in
(34) Morterra, C.; Coluccia, S.; Ghiotti, G.; Zecchina, A. Z. Phys. Chem. Surface Science and Catalysis; Elsevier: Amsterdam, 1987; Vol. 31, p 569.
1977, 104, 275. (45) Klimov, O. V.; Fedotov, M. A.; Startsev, N. J. Catal. 1993, 139,
(35) Davydov, A. A. In Infrared Spectroscopy of Adsorbed Species 142.
on the Surface of Transition Metal Oxides; Rochester, C. H., Ed.; John
Wiley & Sons: Chichester, 1990. (46) Foger, K. In Catalysis, Science and Technology; Anderson J. R.,
(36) Knozinger, H. AdV. Catal. 1976, 25, 184. Boudart, M., Eds.; Springer-Verlag: Berlin, 1984; Vol. 6, p 227.
(37) Morimoto, T.; Yanai, H.; Nago, M. J. Phys. Chem. 1976, 80, 471. (47) Grim, S. M.; Matienzo, L. J. Inorg. Chem. 1975, 14, 1014.
(38) Morterra, C.; Coluccia, S.; Chiorino, A.; Boccuzzi, F. J. Catal. 1978, (48) Marcilly, C.; Franck, F. ReV. Inst. Fr. Pet. 1984, 39, 337.
54, 348. (49) Boitiaux, J. P.; Cosyns, J.; Vasudevan, S. In Studies in Surface
(39) Nakamoto, K. Infrared Spectra of Inorganic and Coordination Science and Catalysis; Elsevier: Amsterdam, 1983; Vol. 16, p 123.
Compounds; John Wiley & Sons: New York, London, 1963. (50) Rakai, A.; Tessier, D.; Bozon-Verduraz, F. New J. Chem. 1992,
(40) Djordjevic, C. Spectrochim. Acta 1961, 17, 448. 16, 869.