Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Here are some of the usually committed errors in THE HUMAN PERSON AS AN EMBODIED SPIRIT
reasoning:
A. Hinduism
a. Appeal to pity (Argumentum ad - At the heart of Hinduism lies the idea of
misericordiam) human beings guest for absolute truth,
- a specific kind of appeal to emotion in so that ones soul and the Brahman or
which someone tries to win support for Atman (absolute soul) might become
an argument or idea by exploiting his of one.
her opponents feelings of pity or guilt. - For the Indians, God first created sound
b. Appeal to ignorance (Argumentum Ad and the universe arose from it. As the
ignorantiam) most sacred sound, The Aum (Om) is
- Whatever has not been proved false the root of the universe and everything
must be true, and vice versa. that exists and it continues to hold
c. Equivocation everything together.
- This is a logical chain of reasoning of a - According to Hinduism, human beings
term or a word several times; but giving have a dual nature: one is the spiritual
the particular word a different meaning and immortal essence (soul); the other
each time. Example: Human beings have is empirical life and character.
hands; the clock has hands. He is - Hindus generally believe that the soul is
drinking from the pitcher of water; he is eternal but is bound by the law of
a baseball pitcher. Karma (action) to the world of matter,
d. Composition which it can escape only after spiritual
- This infers that something is true of the progress through an endless series of
whole from the fact that it is true of births.
some part of the whole. The reverse of - Hinduism holds that humanitys life is a
his fallacy is division. continuous cycle (samsara).
e. Division - Also common to all Hindu thought are
- One reasons logically that something the four primary values namely:
true of a thing must also be the part of WEALTH, PLEASURE, DUTY and
all some of its parts. ENLIGHTENMENT.
f. Against the Person (Argumentum ad B. Buddhism
Hominem) - Siddhartha Gautama is the founder of
- This fallacy attempts to link the validity Buddhism.
of a premise to a characteristics or - Four Noble Truths that Gautama taught:
belief of the person advocating the (1) Life is full of suffering; (2) suffering
premise. is caused by passionate desires,
g. Appeal to force ( Argumentum ad baculum) lusts, cravings; (3) only as these are
- An argument where force,coercion, or obliterated, will suffering cease; (4)
the threat of force, is a given such eradication of desire may be
justification for a conclusion.
accomplished only by following the
Eightfold Path of earnest endeavor.
- The eightfold path steps are:
1. Right belief in and acceptance of the
Fourfold Truth
2. Right aspiration for ones self and
for others.
3. Right speech that harms no one.
4. Right conduct, motivated by
goodwill toward all human beings.
5. Right means of livelihood, or
earning ones living by honorable
means.
6. Right endeavor, or effort to direct
ones energies towards wise ends
7. Right mindfulness in choosing
topics for thought
8. Right meditation or concentration
to the point of complete absorption
in mystic ecstasy.
Prepared by: