SECTIONS HOME SEARCHSKIP TO CONTENTSKIP TO NAVIGATIONVIEW MOBILE VERSION

The New York Times

SUBSCRIBE NOW LOG IN SETTINGS

Ralph Northam, Twitter, Roy Halladay: Your Wednesday Briefing

NEW YORK TODAY

New York Today: Priorities for Next Mayor

CALIFORNIA TODAY
California Today: The Latino Education Crisis

THE DAILY
Listen to The Daily: Was Iowa Killing a Hate Crime?

With Virginia, Voters Give Democrats First Big Wins of the Trump Era
Ralph Northam: We Will Not Condone Hatred and Bigotry

NEWS ANALYSIS
Trumpism Without Trump: A Losing Formula in Swing-State Virginia

Phil Murphy Is Elected Governor of New Jersey, in a Lift for Democrats

Key Takeaways From Tuesdays Elections

De Blasio Coasts to Re-election, as Second-Term Challenges Await

Elections Roundup: Incumbents Fare Well in Boston, Detroit and Flint

Maine Voters Approve Medicaid Expansion, a Rebuke of Gov. LePage

Texas Gunman Once Escaped From Mental Health Facility

Surviving the Texas Church Shooting

Why the Tally of the Church Shootings Victims Included a Fetus

Trump, in China, Seeks Help Over a Nuclear North Korea

Trumps Striking Change in Tone on China

Trumps Visit to China: More Business Deals Than Trade Pacts

EDITORIAL
Virginia Rejects Your Hateful Politics, Mr. Trump

FRANK BRUNI
The G.O.P. Should Be Scared by Virginia
Loading...
HOME PAGE
U.S.

Why the Tally of the Church Shootings Victims Included a Fetus

By LAURIE GOODSTEINNOV. 8, 2017
Continue reading the main storyShare This Page
Share
Tweet
Email
More
Save
Photo

There are twenty-six crosses to represent those killed at the First Baptist Church
in Sutherland Springs, Tex. Credit Todd Heisler/The New York Times
Assessing the grim toll of the massacre in Sutherland Springs, Tex., sheriffs
deputies found 22 of the bodies inside the First Baptist Church, but by their
reasoning, one more victim died there inside the womb of Crystal Holcombe, who
was killed in the pews along with three of her five children.

Texas is one of at least 38 states with a law that recognizes a fetus in utero as a
potential crime victim separate from the mother, or where stiffer penalties apply
when crimes are committed against pregnant women. Federal law recognizes unborn
fetuses as separate victims of federal and military crimes.

The laws, some recent and others decades old, are another battle front in the long,
passionate political war over abortion and the question of when life begins. Anti-
abortion groups have lobbied for fetal homicide laws as part of a broader campaign
for personhood, hoping to persuade the public to regard prenatal life at any
stage of development as a human being deserving of legal rights and protection.

The federal Unborn Victims of Violence Act of 2004 took five years to get through
Congress. It gained momentum after the killing in California of Laci Peterson, who
was eight months pregnant. Her husband, Scott Peterson, was convicted in 2004 of
two counts of murder, one for his wife and one for the unborn child she was
carrying.

This has been a longstanding priority for us, and something we were instrumental
in pushing, said Jennifer Popik, director of federal legislation for National
Right to Life, an anti-abortion organization based in Washington. The principle
here is that theres two victims. For a family already invested in the child, for
the grandparents, this is a loss.

Continue reading the main story

RELATED COVERAGE

Youre Gonna Die: Survivors of the Texas Shooting Recall Terrifying Scene NOV. 7,
2017

Texas Gunman Once Escaped From Mental Health Facility NOV. 7, 2017
Ms. Popik said that she had not seen prosecutors hesitate to use the laws, even
though they have often been politically contentious. Prosecutors like to have this
in their toolbox, she said.

Abortion rights advocates have sometimes opposed fetal homicide laws out of
concerns that they could be used to lay the groundwork for criminalizing abortion.
But their stance has depended on exactly how the laws were worded.

NARAL Pro-Choice America, a national abortion rights group, supports laws that
create additional penalties for crimes against pregnant women, but it strongly
opposes crime-victim laws and personhood laws that designate a fetus as a
separate legal entity.

Kaylie Hanson Long, national communications director for NARAL Pro-Choice America,
said in a statement, We need tougher laws on the books that increase criminal
penalties for individuals who target pregnant women, and we stand with our allies
in support of meaningful legislation to prevent future acts of gun violence.

California Today
The news and stories that matter to Californians (and anyone else interested in the
state), delivered weekday mornings.

Sign Up
SEE SAMPLE PRIVACY POLICY OPT OUT OR CONTACT US ANYTIME
Ms. Holcombe was one of eight members of the Holcombe family who died in the
rampage, including her mother-in-law and father-in-law, a brother-in-law and a
niece. The baby she was expecting raises the count to nine. Her husband, John
Holcombe, was struck by shrapnel but survived.

Other than in the death toll, the Texas law on crimes against an unborn child will
not come into play in this case, because the gunman, Devin P. Kelley, was found
dead shortly after he fled the church.

Texas is one of many states with broad fetal homicide laws that define a human
being as including an unborn child at every stage of gestation from fertilization
until birth. The laws in some other states specify a viable fetus.

Carol Sanger, professor at Columbia Law School who has written extensively on
abortion, said that fetal homicide laws have not been a legal threat to Roe v.
Wade, the Supreme Court decision that legalized abortion. Fetal homicide laws are
criminal statutes, she noted, while Roe v. Wade concerns a constitutional right.

On that score, the Supreme Court decision prevails, Professor Sanger said.

Fetal homicide laws in some states include language specifying that they do not
apply to otherwise legal abortions.

Professor Sanger noted that the campaign to define life as starting at conception
was nonetheless making headway in government and elsewhere. A new strategic plan
proposed for the Department of Health and Human Services says the department will
serve and protect Americans at every stage of life, beginning at conception.

WRITE A COMMENT
The memorial at the World Trade Center in New York, Professor Sanger noted,
includes the words and her unborn child after the names of 10 pregnant women who
died in the terrorist attack of Sept. 11, 2001, and one who died in the 1993 attack
at the center.

It is part of a broader effort, she said, to acculturate us, to get us used to

thinking about prenatal life as being like a born person.

A version of this article appears in print on November 8, 2017, on Page A13 of the
New York edition with the headline: A Mass Shooting, a Tally of 26 Victims, and in
Texas, a Space for One More. Order Reprints| Today's Paper|Subscribe

Continue reading the main story

TRENDING

With Virginia, Voters Give Democrats First Big Wins of the Trump Era

The Interpreter: What Explains U.S. Mass Shootings? International Comparisons

Suggest an Answer

Op-Ed Columnist: The G.O.P. Should Be Scared by Virginia

Key Takeaways From Tuesdays Elections

Contributing Op-Ed Writer: Brave Enough to Be Angry

Cancer Doctors Cite Risks of Drinking Alcohol

Best of Late Night: Stephen Colbert Calls Out Trump for Not Hiring American Workers

Trumps Visit to China: More Business Deals Than Trade Pacts

Editorial: Virginia Rejects Your Hateful Politics, Mr. Trump

Op-Ed Columnist: Attention: Saudi Prince in a Hurry

View More Trending Stories

What's Next
Loading...
Go to Home Page
SITE INDEX THE NEW YORK TIMES

Site Index Navigation

NEWS

World
U.S.
Politics
N.Y.
Business
Tech
Science
Health
Sports
Education
Obituaries
Today's Paper
Corrections
OPINION

Today's Opinion
Op-Ed Columnists
Editorials
Op-Ed Contributors
Letters
Sunday Review
Video: Opinion
ARTS

Today's Arts
Art & Design
Books
Dance
Movies
Music
N.Y.C. Events Guide
Television
Theater
Video: Arts
LIVING

Automobiles
Crossword
Food
Education
Fashion & Style
Health
Jobs
Magazine
N.Y.C. Events Guide
Real Estate
T Magazine
Travel
Weddings & Celebrations
LISTINGS & MORE

Reader Center
Classifieds
Tools & Services
N.Y.C. Events Guide
Multimedia
Photography
Video
NYT Store
Times Journeys
Subscribe
Manage My Account
NYTCo
SUBSCRIBE

Home Delivery
Digital Subscriptions
Crossword
Email Newsletters
Alerts
Gift Subscriptions
Group Subscriptions
Education Rate
Mobile Applications
Replica Edition
Site Information Navigation
2017 The New York Times Company HomeSearchAccessibility concerns? Email us at
accessibility@nytimes.com. We would love to hear from you.Contact UsWork With
UsAdvertiseYour Ad ChoicesPrivacyTerms of ServiceTerms of SaleSite Information
Navigation
Site MapHelpSite FeedbackSubscriptions Go to the previous story Go to the next
story