Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
239
were the real reasons why alchemy drew sustained opposition
from the superiors of religious orders?
5See Marie-Louise von Franz, Aurora Consurgens (New York 1966) pp.
x-xiii and Robert Halleux, Les Textes Alchimiques ('Ihrnhout-Belgium 1979)
p. 105.
6See Thorndike, History 3.471-72.
7See Benedictus Maria Reichert, Vitae Fratrum Ordinis Praedicatorum
(Rome 1897) pp. 290-91.
8History (see note 2 above); 3.63, William of 'hmis; 3.132, Walter della
Flamma; 3.136, Thomas; 3.223, Philip.
9Acta capitulorum generalium ordinis Praedicatorum, ed. Benedictus
Reichert, 9 vols.(Rome 1898) 1.170, 238, 252; 2.65, 147,322,373, 446; 3.231.
THE FRANCISCAN S
The other mendicant order, the Franciscan, also had members
who manifested serious interest in alchemy. Elias of Cortone, who
succeeded Francis of Assisi as acting superior general of the Or
der in 1226 and as elected superior general from 1232 until
1239,16 pursued alchemy with enthusiasm. According to one biog
con," Speculum 7 (1932) 80-86. See also E. Brehm, Roger Bacons Place in
the History of Alchemy, Ambix 23 (1976) 53-58, and Guy-H Allard, Reac
tions de Trois Penseurs du XIIIe Sicle visvis LAlchimie," Cahiers Detudes
Mediuales 2 (1974) 97-106.
2fisee Thorndike, History 2, chap. 54, devoted to Bartholomew of Eng
land and also vol. 3, where he gives the following names: p. 174, Gerardus
Marionis; p. 223, Osbert de Pueblo and John of Apuleia. Singer, Alchemical,
(note 18 above) gives the following Franciscans: p. 172, Raymond Galfredus;
p. 196, Nicolas and Bernard; p. 287, Ferrarius; p. 301, Osbert.
29See Sancti Bonaventurae opera omnia, 9 vols. (Ad aquas claras
[Quaracchi] prope Florentiam, 1882 . . He discusses alchemy briey in
.).
7,
2,
2,
2,
P.
Quaest.
3
Opera) and also Lib. Dist. 47, Art. ad (4.978 in the Opera).
2,
2,
Quaest.
3
in the end reach everlasting death) and 9.466, Sermo de Sancto Andrea
Apostolo: . . appetitus auri et argenti inordinatus est occasio naufragandi"
.
(. . the unbridled desire for gold and silver the cause of shipwreck).
is
.
31La Chimie au Moyen-ge, vols. (Paris 1893) 2.77, Jai releve ces cita
3
tions avec dautant plus de soin qu'elles attestent au XIIIe siecle lexistence
CONCLUSION
Unfortunately it is not yet possible to account entirely for the
popularity of alchemy in the religious orders in the thirteenth
and fourteenth centuries. Its attraction surely went beyond the
mere desire to transmute base metals into gold and even beyond
its promise of restoring health and youth. This issue will not be
settled until the relationship between alchemy and Christian
mysticism has been claried. Although the surviving documents
provide ample evidence that alchemy was suspect in this period
and give some reasons for this, this issue too will remain clouded
until a better understanding of the surviving quasi-religious al
chemical texts is achieved.