Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Intercompany Accounting
Challenges in SAP ERP Financials
David Cohen
EY
1
What Well Cover
2
Intercompany Processes
3
Common Intercompany Issues
Long close cycle times and difficult reconciliation of IC processes
Highly manual and spreadsheet-based process
Manual No ability to adjust obsolescence, revaluation, PPV, or consumption
Processes variances for IC profit
Poor data quality and inconsistencies
Low accuracy of product costing
5
Intercompany Processes
6
Design Principles
7
Process Flow (Main Activities)
8
Key Enablers: Stock Transfer Order and
Goods-in-Transit Functionality
Stock Transfer Orders (STO) are used to move materials between
companies integrating both processes
Both companies need to implement Materials Management and
Purchasing (MM) and Sales and Distribution (SD)
Process is initiated by company that needs to receive the material
It is necessary to pay attention to fulfilling country statutory
requirements usually revenue recognition, transfer price, and
settlement of receivables/payables must be performed as if the
companies were independent
The additional usage of Goods-in-Transit improves the financial
controls of inventory ownership
9
Key Enabler: Goods-in-Transit Functionality
10
Intercompany Processes
11
Design Principles
12
Process Flow
13
Design Principles
SAP GAPs:
Full Processing of WHT in receiver side
Posting Payable Invoice to the correct cost object
15
Key Enabler: Resource-Related Billing
16
Example: Usage of WBS and RRB
WBS 123
Country A
Service Charges
Charges
Labor $2,000 Transferred to WBS 123 WBS 123
Fringe $1,000 Labor $500
Other Costs $3,000 Fringe $100 Labor $500
Other Costs $300 Fringe $100
Other Costs $300
17
Intercompany Processes
18
Design Principles
19
Process Flow
20
Key Enablers
Link Assets, Equipment, and Non-Valuated Material by serial
number
MM/SD are the drivers for shipping the asset and creating the
documentation
For some scenarios, Cost Centers can be used as an indirect
assignment of the location (country) of the equipment in order to
derive invoice and tax charges (e.g., IT charges to different
countries)
It will probably be necessary to develop custom reports to manage
end of lease and other management information
Potential GAP for different country taxes
Use combination of Vendor, Country, and other Sales Orders/
Billing characteristics to derive correct tax calculation
There is a need to keep synchronization between AM and MM
modules for quantity (i.e., asset disposal)
21
Intercompany Processes
22
Leading Practices
24
Option 1: SAP ICR (Intercompany Reconciliation)
Tool
Solution collects data from Accounts Receivable and Payable
invoice level detail and enables matching analysis during the
month. It can accommodate non-SAP data.
There is an opportunity to correct before month-end close,
reducing differences at month-end. Nevertheless, it is a batch
process.
There is a process for automatic and manual matching with
standard or customized rules for reconciliation and matching
ICR is an analysis tool. It does not correct the problem at the
source, but can initiate a dispute.
25
Option 1: SAP ICR (Intercompany Reconciliation)
Tool (cont.)
26
Option 1: SAP ICR (Intercompany Reconciliation)
Tool (cont.)
Communication (Email)
Workflow (Custom)
Dispute Case
27
Option 2: SAP BusinessObjects IC Reconciliation
Tool
How does it compare to SAP ERP ICR?
28
Option 2: SAP BusinessObjects IC Reconciliation
Tool (cont.)
The total of the invoices
The declaring companys invoices are compared to the is equal to the balance in
the child account
partners. The invoices are matched automatically:
The total of the
Have the same transaction reference invoices differs from
Uploaded data
Contain the same transaction amount the balance in the child
account
Unmatched invoices
(in Blue hyperlink)
Matched invoices
(in Black font)
29
Intercompany Processes
30
In-House Cash Concepts
Simulate an internal bank and use it to fulfill financial services to
group companies
It can provide services such as: Provision of FX, Interest Rate
Calculation, Liquidity Management, Intercompany Liability, Funding
Management, Centralized Management of Payables and Receivables
32
In-House Cash
Principles:
IHC is set up at the group headquarters
33
In-House Cash: How Does It Help?
Benefits:
Centralized payment and receivable transactions on a regional
or global level
Reduced cost and number of payment transactions, bank
account numbers, and bank fees
Surplus cash can be used for financing purposes; cash
resources are kept within the group
Better control of financial interest of subsidiaries
35
Intercompany Processes
36
Accounting 101: Intercompany Profit Elimination
Production Variances
Billing Currency
38
Leading Practices
40
Option 2: STO Updating ICP
Can use BAdI for changes in how values are calculated and
updated
42
Changes in Development
44
Leading Practices
45
Key Enabler: SAP Closing Cockpit
46
Key Enabler: SAP Closing Cockpit (cont.)
49
How Can HANA Improve IC Processes?
Physical Data
Data
Reports Warehouse Data Redundancy (Totals
Legal/External Management tables, Data Warehouse)
Accounting (FI) Accounting (CO) High Reconciliation effort
Totals tables Totals tables Low Flexibility
Higher Data Volume
Legal/External Management Profitability Analysis Market Segment Performance issues
Accounting (FI) Accounting (CO) (COPA) Data
Documents Documents Documents
No Data Redundancy
Easy Reconciliation
High Flexibility
Legal/External Management
Accounting (FI) Accounting (CO) Less Data Volume
Totals tables Totals tables High Performance
One-stop shop for all
Profitability Analysis Market Segment operational financial
One Unified Legal/External Management reporting
Accounting Accounting (FI) Accounting (CO) (COPA) Data
Document Documents Documents Documents Drilldown to atomic detail
51
Central Journal
Central Journal is an adoption scenario that enables implementing Simple Finance with
minimum disruption to existing systems
It provides real-time replication of financial information from diverse instances that are
harmonized into a Central Journal
Can provide consolidated financial and management reporting, central process execution and
transaction, planning, consolidation, and reporting based on the same (single source of truth)
data set
Consolidation Reporting
Finance data is copied from source systems
onto a Central Journal instance. Source
systems can remain in place and continue
with local transaction processing.
Real-time harmonized global financial
Central Journal
information on a HANA platform with atomic SAP Instance with
detail, allowing flexible reporting using robust Simple Finance
reporting tools
Single Uniform Global Data Model for external
(FI), internal (CO), and Profitability/Market
SAP ERP SAP ERP SAP R3 Non-
Segment (COPA) accounting 6.0 6.0 4.6 SAP
No reconciliation across instances
52
What Well Cover
53
Project Perspective
Advantages Disadvantages
56
Interim Stage: STO Integration
57
What Well Cover
58
Leading Practices
Systems
Single instance with consistent global template
Leverage dual posting (Seller AR and Buyer AP)
Use the matching and reconciliation functionality for AR/AP and GR/IR
Use ERP (SAP In-House Cash) netting functionality
SAP ERP 6.0 since Enhancement Pack 5 provides Goods in Transit visibility
Use workflow and IDocs where possible
Single point consolidation (avoid sub-consolidation) and leverage a tool (HFM, BPC, etc.)
59
Leading Practices (cont.)
Processes
Establish materiality thresholds for posting of IC transactions
Establish a detailed monthly calendar for IC tasks
Establish a Dispute Resolution Policy with a Committee that arbitrates disputes
Establish upfront approvals
Consider tax needs (provisioning, transfer pricing) when establishing timing of billing
(monthly, quarterly, annual) for corporate pass-downs
Establish policy on currency for transactions between entities with different currencies
for reconciliation and settlement
Document and communicate IC policies and procedures
People
Centralize IC accounting (where possible), but maintain a single point of contact for IC
transaction inquiries for each company
Document and train for specific roles and responsibilities, including handoffs
Train and provide job aids/contact information for all personnel involved in IC
transactions
Document review/approval/escalation points for IC transactions
60
What Well Cover
61
Where to Find More Information
62
7 Key Points to Take Home
63
Your Turn!
SAP and other SAP products and services mentioned herein as well as their respective logos are trademarks or registered trademarks of SAP SE (or
an SAP affiliate company) in Germany and other countries. All other product and service names mentioned are the trademarks of their respective
companies. Wellesley Information Services is neither owned nor controlled by SAP SE.
EY refers to the global organization and may refer to one or more of the member firms of Ernst & Young Global Limited, each of which is a
separate legal entity. Ernst & Young Global Limited, a UK company limited by guarantee, does not provide services to clients. Ernst & Young LLP
is an EY member firm serving clients in the US. For more information about our organization, please visit ey.com.
1401-118151
This material has been prepared for general informational purposes only and is not intended to be relied upon as accounting, tax, or other
professional advice. Please refer to your advisors for specific advice.
65
Wellesley Information Services, 20 Carematrix Drive, Dedham, MA 02026
Copyright 2015 Wellesley Information Services. All rights reserved.