Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Abstract-The quality of service provided rural electric cus- studies of the system, it is imperative that a program other
tomers can be improved with the accurate modeling and analy- than that used for transmission system power flow studies
sis of a distribution feeder. With the use of an analysis program
developed for a personal computer, it is possible for an engineer
be used. This paper will describe and demonstrate the
to solve existing feeder voltage profile and loss problems and to RDAP that satisfies this need [ 2 ] ,131.
plan feeder additions that will improve the quality of service to
the customers with reduced losses to the cooperative. This paper THERADIAL
DISTRIBUTION PROGRAM
ANALYSIS
describes the accurate model of a distribution feeder and its RDAP models all three phases of a radial system. Any
devices that are incorporated into a radial distribution analysis degree of unbalance caused by loading and/or line con-
program (RDAP) developed for the personal computer. An ex-
ample rural distribution feeder is modeled to demonstrate how figurations is taken into account. The data preparation
the program is used to solve typical design and operational utility provides the following functions:
problems.
Building feeder data files
computation of overhead and underground line
INTRODUCTION impedances and shunt admittances
allocation routine to scale loads to match a given
R
0
ADIAL. distribution systems are characterized by
having only one path for power to flow from the feeder demand.
source (distribution substation) to each customer. A typi- The analysis program has the following three analysis
cal distribution system will consist of one or more distri- routines:
bution substations with each substation consisting of one Radial flow
or more feeders. Each feeder will consist of one or more 0 motor starting
of the following components:
short circuit.
Three-phase primary main feeder
RADIAL
FLOW
three-phase, two-phase (V phase) and single-phase
laterals The radial power flow routine models all three phases
0 step-type voltage regulators of a system with the following attributes:
0 in-line transformers Segments
shunt capacitor banks Radially connected starting with a designated source
three-phase, two-phase, and single-phase spot and 0 may be lines, transformers, or switches (voltage regu-
distributed loads. lators are handled separately).
The loading of a distribution feeder is inherently unbal-
Load Locations
anced because of the large number of unequal single-phase
loads that must be served. An additional unbalance is Spot (at a node point)
introduced by the nonequilateral conductor spacing of the distributed (represented at the center if a line seg-
three-phase overhead and underground lines. ment).
Because of the nature of the distribution system, con- Load Input Data
ventional power flow programs used for transmission sys-
tem studies are not adequate. Such programs display poor kW and kVar
convergence characteristics for radial systems [ 11and make kW and power factor
the basic assumption of a perfectly balanced system. If a kVA and power factor
distribution engineer is to be able to perform accurate REA A and B factors (number of consumers and kW
hr) used with the distributed model only
Paper IPCSD 91-103, approved by the Rural Electric Power Commit- utilization factor (kW hr) used with the distributed
tee of the IEEE Industry Applications Society for presentation at the
1990 IEEE Rural Electric Power Committee Technical Conference.
model only.
Orlando, FL, April 29-May 1. Manuscript released for publication
September 17, 1991.
Load Connections
W. H. Kersting is with the College of Engineering, New Mexico State Either wye (any phase to neutral combination) or
.
University, Las Cruces, NM 88003.
W. H. Phillips is with WH Power Consultants, Las Cruces, NM 88003 delta (any phase to phase combination) configura-
IEEE Log Number 9108225. tions.
..
768 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS, VOL. 28, NO. 4, JULY / AUGUST 1992
TABLE I
IEEE 34 Bus RADIAL
REA DISTRIBUTION
SYSTEM
LINESECTIONDATA
BUS BUS LENGTH CONFIG.
A B (FT.) CODE
800 802 2580.0 301
802 806 1730.0 301
806 808 32230.0 301
808 810 5840.0 303
808 812 37500.0 301
812 814 29730.0 301
814 850 10.0 301
816 818 1710.0 302
816 824 10210.0 301
818 820 48150.0 302
820 822 13740.0 302
824 826 3030.0 303
824 828 840.0 301
828 830 20440.0 301
830 854 520.0 301
832 858 4900.0 301
832 888 0.0 55
834 860 2020.0 30 1
834 842 280.0 301
836 840 860.0 301
836 862 280.0 301
842 844 1350.0 301
844 846 3640.0 301
846 848 530.0 301
850 816 310.0 301
852 832 10.0 301
854 856 23330.0 303
854 852 36830.0 301
858 864 1620.0 302
858 834 5830.0 301
860 836 2680.0 301
Fig. 1. 34 bus circuit diagram. 862 838 4860.0 304
888 890 10560.0 300
as follows:
TABLE I1
2500 kVA IEEE 34 Bus RADIAL
REA DISTRIBUTION
SYSTEM
OVERHEAD
LINECONFIGURATIONS
115 delta-24.9 grounded-wye kV ~
150 kVA
24.9-4.16-wye kV
2 = 1.90 + j4.08%. The voltage regulator data for the feeder is shown in
Table VI:
Table I11 gives the shunt capacitor data for this feeder.
Table IV gives the spot load data for this system. DISTRIBUTION
FEEDER
ANALYSIS
Table V gives the line section distributed loads. This The IEEE 34 Radial REA distribution feeder will be
load data is given in number of customers (#) and kWH used to demonstrate how RDAP can be used to improve
and will be converted to kW and kVAr by RDAP using the performance of an existing feeder. Data for the test
the REA A and B Factors [6]. system is the based on actual data of a rural feeder in
~
770 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS, VOL. 28, NO. 4, JULY / AUGUST 1992
r -
KERSTING AND PHILLIPS: MODELING AND ANALYSIS OF RURAL ELECTRIC DISTRIBUTION FEEDERS 771
I 1 I
830 123.0853 AT -3.56 124.6769 AT -122.84 124.2147 AT 117.22 25.678
now 520.3, 493.3, and 493.3 kW. RDAP now shows the 854
856
123.0621 AT -3.57 124.6512
124.6434
AT
AT
-122.85
-122.86
124.1764 AT 117.21 25.777
30.195
following: 852
832
121.4229
125.2169
AT
AT
-4.32
-4.32
122.8463
123.6136
AT
AT
-123.45
-123.45
121.4433 AT
125.2377 AT
116.39
116.39
32.752
32.754
858 125.0389 AT -4.42 123.4046 AT -123.53 124.9239 AT 116.28 33.682
864 125.0387 AT -4.42 33.989
Substation input: 1507 kW and 754 kVAR 834
860
124.8324
124.7879
AT
AT
-4.53
-4.53
123.1650
123.1378
AT
AT
-123.63
-123.62
124.5615 AT
124.4985 AT
116.15
116.16
34.786
35.169
feeder power loss: 219.7 kW 836 124.7435 AT -4.53 123.1236 AT -123.63 124.4801 AT 116.16 35.677
772 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS, VOL. 28, NO. 4, JULY / AUGUST 1992
downstream from Bus 808 where the voltage has dropped IEEE 34 BUS RADIAL SYSTEM
b = 115.6 V).
A voltage regulator is installed at Bus 808 with Bus 824
designated as the load center, RDAP determines that the
R and X settings for the regulator should be R = 20 V,
and X = 10 V. WAR :
TOT z
266.7
266.710
.O 256.8
256.810
.O 251.0
251.040
.O 774.6
774.560
.O
These settings are based on the PT ratio of 120:l and KVA : 520.4 .O 497.6
497.558
.O 484.2
484.243
.O 1502.2
1502.180
.O
TOT : 520.385
CT rating of 100 A. The bandwidth was set at 2 V, and the PP : ,8587 .
0000 ,8565 ,0000 .E551 .0000 ,8568 .OOOO
desired voltage level set at 122 V. TOT : .8587 ,8565 ,8551 ,8568
.I .I .I
KVA : 59.852
profile is greatly improved. The voltages at Bus 824 are U p A C --(A-N)----(A-B)- --(B-N)----(B-C)- --(C-N)----(C-A)- ---HYE-----DELTA--
R-KVA: 250.0 .O 250.0 .O 250.0 .O 750.0 .O
TOT : 250.000 250.000 250.000 750.000
being held at 122 V as desired. Bus 890 continues to
A-WA: 268.4 270.3 270.8 809.5 .O
display the lowest voltages (114.4, 114.1, and 111.8). In TOT : 268.397 270.285 270.784 809.466
AT
-2.56
~
___________
IEEE 34 BUS
VOLTAGE REGULATOR DATA
RADIAL S Y S T M
---- DATE: 9-17-1991 AT 12: 4:12 HOURS --
__________--__---_______________________-------.------.----- W. H . Kersting (SM64pF89) was horn in Santa
VRG-ID( 1) CNCT-ID( 71 OPT( 2) FROU( 808) TO( 812) BDWIDTH(2.00 VOLTS)
........................................................................ Fe, NM. He received the B.S.E.E. degree from
PHASE LDCTR VOLT HOLD R-VOLT X-VOLT PT RATIO CT RATE TAP
1 0 122.000 20.0000 10.0000 120.00 100.00 11 New Mexico State University, Las Cruces, and
2 0 122.000 20.0000 10.0000 120.00 100.00 9 the M.S.E.E. degree from Illinois Institute of
_ _ _ _ ~ ~ ~ 0~ ~ _ _ _ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
3 122.000 20.0000 10.0000 120.00 100.00 10
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ~ ~ Technology.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
VRG-ID( 21 CNCT-ID( 7) OPT( 21 .
FROUl . 8521 TO1 832) BDWIDTHf2.00 VOLTS1
........................................................................ He joined the faculty at New Mexico State
PIWSE LDCTR VOLT HOLD R-VOLT X-VOLT PT RATIO CT RATE TAP
1 0 125.000 .OOOO .OOOO 120.00 100.00 7
University in 1962 and is currently Professor of
2
3
0
0
125.000
125.000
,0000
,0000
.OOOO
.OOOO
120.00
120.00
100.00
100.00
8
11
Electrical Engineering and Director of the Elec-
tric Utility Management Program there. Prior to
Fig. 8. Optimized system voltagc regulator data joining NMSU, hc was employed as a distrihu-
tion engineer by El Paso Electric Company.
Mr. Kersting is a member o f E t a Kappa Nu and Tau Beta Pi. He has
been an active member of the IEEE Power Engineering Societys Power
positions. This indicates that the feeder load can grow and Engineering Education Committee. serving as Chairman of the commit-
the regulators will continue to hold the voltages within tee and several subcommittees.
limits. As a matter of fact, RDAP was run with the loads
projected to grow at a 3% rate for 10 yr, and only at the
tenth year do the regulators finally hit their maximum tap
position. W. H. Phillips is a native of Las Cruces, NM. He
received the B.S.E.E. and M.S.E.E. degrees from
New Mexico State University in 1972 and 1979.
CONCLUSION He has worked in the planning and operations
The radial distribution analysis program has been used areas for electric utilities from 1972 to 1984,
both in the United States and overseas. He was
to demonstrate how an existing feeders performance can a researcher at NMSU from 1987 through 1Y88.
be improved. In the case studied, it was shown that the He is currently a partner in WH Power Consul-
overall voltage profile was improved and the feeder power tants.
losses reduced by relocating shunt capacitor banks and