action:

isekai wa tomo ni
mob psycho 100
darker than black
the irregular at magic highschool
Danmachi
Accel world (a slightly better sao)
Samurai Champloo
Cowboy Bebop
Angel Beats
Youjo Senki
Durarara
Berserk (1997 version)
Boku no hero academia
Campione
Code Geass
Dance in the vampire bund
Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood
Gate
Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash
Highschool of the dead
Kaze No Stigma
Kill la Kill
Absolute Duo
Mirai Nikki
Overlord
Noragami
One Punch Man
Gonna be the Twintail!
Princess Principal
Trinity seven
Attack on titan
Utawarerumono
Seiken Tsukai no world break
Tokyo Ravens
Madan no ou to vanadis
Akame ga kill
No game no life
Charlotte
Mondaji Tachi
Best show-Mob Psycho 100

Comedy

Amagi Brilliant Park

Ghost stories (only the dub)
Blood Lad
Boku wa tomodachi ga sukunai
Demi chan wa kataritai
Haiyore Nyaruko san
Hataraku Maou sama
Konosuba
Nichijou
Saiki Kusuo no Psi nan
Sekai Seifuku: Bouryaku no Zvezda
Outbreak Company
Best show: Amagi Briliant park
Romance

And you Never thought there were girls online?

Fruits of Grisaia (harem)
Princess Lover (harem)
Kanokon (harem)
Koi to uso
Masamune kun's revenge (harem)
Ookami-san to Shichinin no Nakama-tachi
Ore monogatari
Sankarea
Shomin sample (harem)
The world god only knows (harem)
Toradora
My Teen Romantic Comedy: SNAFU
Yuushibu (harem?)
Boku wa tomodachi ga sukunai (harem)
Gekkan shoujo Nozaki kun
High school dxd (if you want fanservice/harem)
Monster Musume (harem)
Best show: Toradora

Short series/movie

Wolf Children
Spirited away
Castlevania
The Berserk Golden age arc
Planetarium
Mahoutsukai no Yome: Hoshi Matsu Hito
Kimi no na wa
Best show: Wolf Children

Horror

Ajin
Gakkou Gurashi
Parasyte
Hellsing/Hellsing Ultimate
Jigoku Shoujo
Best show: Gakkou Gurashi

Slice Of Life

Isekai Shoukudo
Lucky Star
Gakkou Gurashi
Chuunibyou
Great Teacher Onizuka
Haibane Renmei
Inou-Battle wa Nichijou-kei no Naka de
Kobayashi's dragon maid
K-On
Himouto Umaru chan
Best Show: Gakkou Gurashi

Shows that I don't know where to put

Maouyuu Maou yuusha

Spice and wolf
Shokugeki no soma
Death Note
Classroom of the elite
Zankyou no terror
Log Horizon
Best show: Maouyuu Maou Yuusha (ignoring death note)

My top 15 recommendations

15 Samurai Champloo (exactly like cowboy Bebop, but I prefer this)

14 Grimgar of Fantasy and ash (very slow show, but I love it)
13 Overlord (a very good version of SAO)
12 Nichijou (great comedy)
11 No game, No life (probably the best trash show)
10 Parasyte (kind of more action/gore than horror, but it's still great)
9 Fruits of Grisaia (I'll probably replace this with the monogatari franchise when
I eventually finish it)
8 The world god only knows (best harem)
7 Darker than black (best pure action, but the third season chronologicaly ain't
great)
6 Toradora (Pure romance)
5 Kobayashi's dragon maid (The animation is second only to Mob psycho)
4 Amagi Brilliant Park (comedy's best first episode. I was laughing extremely hard
1 minute in)
3 Wolf Children (anime that brought me second closest to tears)
2 Gakkou Gurashi (seriously just watch it give it one episode)
1 Mob Psycho 100 (One punch man but better)