Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Abstract
The grammatical dual (abbreviated DU) seems to have played a prominent role in the development
of Indo-European languages which as a thesis may be proven by the dual character of the sky-god's
name *Dyeus.
However the standard Swadesh list (which starts with the words I, You, We, this, that,...) does not
include the most prominent dual pronouns and at least from a historical standpoint the standard list
seems to be incomplete.
In order to demonstrate the impact of the DU the Swadesh list should be extended by inserting the
three etymologically leading elements (specified in English): (1) the sky-god *Dyeus, (2) it (us
two) and (3) it (you two).
According to Jacob Grimm the duality it (us two, spoken Wit) and (3) it (you two, spoken
Git) is characterized by the trailing letter t.
On a local scale the corresponding sky-gods' names have been specified as Tuw, Tiw, respectively
Wuotan, Wden, Vut, Wda, etc...
In Latin and Greek the religious symbols of duality and the DU have been eliminated at an early
stage, but survived in the languages of the surrounding territories. Especially the old writings in the
border regions of the Roman Empire reveal characteristic symbols for duality and the DU.
Outside the borderlines of the Roman Empire the barbarian (modified) Swadesh List is ruled by the
dual (1) sky-god *Dyeus, (2) it (us two) and (3) it (you two).
Inside the Roman Empire the reconstructed DU in the Latin Swadesh list may demonstrate the
common symbolism of the IU-vowel combinations in Ju-piter, ius, iustitia, just, iugum, etcetera.
In both the official and the modified, barbarian Swadesh list the priority of the personal
pronouns of the 1st person singular respectively dual form had a considerable impact on language
and philosophy.
Most of the impact of the DU has been suppressed by the illiteracy of the barbarian people and the
absence of written documentation. This paper describes the concept of reconstructing the original
historical etymology.
A historical Overview of Duality versus Androcentrism
1 Shorter lists
The sky-god's names
There are two basic names for a sky-god's name in the Nordic languages, including the Dutch,
Frisian and English dialects who preserved their DU:
Tui, respectively Tiwas, Tiw or Tuw, etc.,
Wod, Wut, Wuotan or Vut, Wd, etc.
Strictly spoken both variants may be considered as equivalents of the basic idea of sky-god's name
*Dyeus. Tuw may be mirrored as Wut, Tiw as Wd. Obviously the spelling of Tuw had
been reversed to Wut or Wod.
There is no real evidence which of these two naming systems is the older or younger.
Both names Tiwas, Tiw, Tyr and Wod, Wuotan refer to the highest ranked deities in their
homelands. Tuesday refers to Tiwas, Tiw or Tuw and Wednesday to Woden or Vut, Wd,
etc..
Sometimes Woden is said to be Tiw's father2, whereas others say Woden dominated and may have
replaced an older predecessor Tiwas3.
Tiwas on the other hand is symbolized in the Tiwaz rune, The Tiwaz rune essentially represents the
dual character of the letter t, which according to Jacob Grimm symbolizes the duality in the DU-
elements it (us two) and (3) it (you two).
Tiwas, Tiw, Tr
According to Grimm Tiwas (especially as Ziu) represented Zeus.
(Tiw, Tr), he hardly does more than administer one of Wuotan's offices, yet is identical
in name with the first and highest god of the Greeks and Romans: and so all these god-
phenomena keep meeting and crossing one another. The Hellenic Hermes is pictured as
a youth, the Teutonic Wuotan as a patriarch:... 4
The Latinised name is rendered as Tius or Tio and also formally as Mars Thincsus. It is assumed
that Twaz was overtaken in popularity and in authority by both Odin and Thor at some point during
the Migration Age, as Odin shares his role as God of war5.
The Roman historians also compared Tr to Mercury, who is considered as a bi-faced dual
character. The bi-faced character of Hermes is illustrated by the Hermes of Roquepertuse.
2 Wuotan
3 Herkunft (in German Wikipedia)
4 Teutonic Mythology - page 165 - Jacob Grimm
5 Tyr
Wod, Wuotan, Vut, Wda
Jacob Grimm Teutonic Mythology Jacob Grimm specifies various names for Wden and
Wednesday, which may be summarized as follows:
Region / language Wden Wednesday Reference in Teutonic Mythology
(equivalent) (equivalent) (German Version)
Graubnden Vut Page 109/120
(Switzerland)
Frisia Wda Wansdey
Northern Frisia Wda Winsdei
Mecklenburg Wod Page 110/(121-122)
Westphalia Woudan Page 110/(121-122)
Wod is also found in Grimm's Teutonic Mythology, in which Wod is depicted as a wolves' leader:
Often of a dark night the airy hounds will bark on open heaths, in thickets, at cross-
roads. The countryman well knows their leader Wod, and pities the wayfarer that has
not reached his home yet; for Wod is often spiteful, seldom merciful6.
Wuotunc
Occasionally Wuotan, Oinn changed from a wise old man into an angry and wild warrior, which
seems to be rather unrealistic. Instead of a raging character (wut) I considered to correlate Wuotan
to wut as a personal pronoun of the 1 st person dual in Dutch respectively (wit 9) in old English.
Grimm's reference to the raging character was Wuotunc is10:
The form wuotunc seems not to differ in sense; an unprinted poem of the 13th century
says ' Wetunges her' apparently for the ' wiitende heer,' Herod's messengers of murder
are weterche, O.i. 19, 18 names the king himself gotewuoto. The form wuotunc seems
not to differ in sense; an unprinted poem of the 13th century says 'Wetunges her'
apparently for the 'wtende heer, 3 the host led as it were by Wuotan ; and Wuotunc is
likewise a man s name in OHG., Wdunc, Trad, patav. no. 19.
The former divinity was degraded into an evil, fiendish, bloodthirsty being, and appears
to live yet as a form of protestation or cursing in exclamations of the Low German
people, as in Westphalia: Woudan, Woudan! Firmenich 1, 257, 260; and in
Mecklenburg: Wod, Wod ! (see Suppl.).
Svetovid
In Svetovid's name (also spelled as Svantevit, Sveti Vid, Swantewit, Svetovit, Svatovit, witowit or
13) Sven an attribute such as saint Tovit (or Tevit, Towit respectively Tewit). The
similarity to Dyaus may be improved by assuming to replace the v by a u.
The forms Sventevith and Zvantewith show that the name derives from the word svt, meaning
"saint, holy". The second stem is sometimes reconstructed as vit="lord, ruler, winner".
Svetovid is the Slavic version of the neighbor Germanic sky-god Tuisco. The leading consonant
T in Tovit symbolizes the duality, which may have produced a 4-fold facial structure.
In the naming variant Vid instead of Tovit the sky-god directly relates to the personal pronoun
of the 1st person in dual (v = "the two of us")14.
According to Jacob Grimm:
Alone of Slavs, the Wends in Lneburg show a trace of naming after a god; dies Jovis
was with them Perendan, from Peren, Perun, thunder-god: apparently a mere imitation
of the German, as in all the other days they agree with the rest of the Slavs.[footnote #2]
The nett result of these considerations is, that, in Latin records dealing with Germany
and her gods, we are warranted in interpreting, with the greatest probability, Mercurius
as Wuotan, Jupiter as Donar, and Mars as Ziu. The gods of the days of the week
translated into German are an experiment on Tacitus's 'interpretatio Romana'.15
11 Svarog
12 A Paradise Made of Words
13 Source: Svantovit
14 The Sky-God Names and the (Correlating) Personal Pronouns
15 Jacob Grimm Teutonic Mythology Vol 1 (1882) page 130
in which footnote [#2] refers to the following text:
It is striking, that in O. Bohem. glossaries (Hanka 54. 165) Mercury, Venus and Saturn
are quoted in the order of their days of the week; and that any Slav deities that have
been identified with Latin ones are almost sure to be of the number of those that preside
over the week.
And whilst of the Slav gods, Svatovit answers to Mars (Ziu), Radigast to Mercury
(Wuotan), Perun to Jupiter (Donar), Lada (golden dame, zolota baba, in Hanusch
241, 35b) to Venus (Fria), and perhaps Sitivrat to Saturn;
The names of the planets are construed quite otherwise, Mars by Smrto-nos (letifer),
Mercury by Dobro-pan (good lord, or rather bonorum dator), Jupiter by Krale-moc
(rex potens), Venus by Ctitel (cupitor ? venerandus ?), Saturn by Hlado-let (famelicus,
or annonae caritatem afferens). Respecting Sitivrat I give details at the end of ch. XII.
days of the French days Roman God Germany English Slav Deity
week of the week (Greek God)
In Roman history the legally correct pedigree of the main deities lists: Saturn Jupiter Mars.
Mercury and Venus do not belong to the legally correct pedigree of the main deities. This concept of
legal and illegal ancestry may have played a mayor role in the philosophical concepts of the Greek
and Roman mythology and the corresponding Gallic/Germanic counterparts.
Historical records do not explain the role of the grammatical dual (abbreviated DU) in the
contradictions between the elements in the interpretatio Romana.
However the Names of the days of the week may play an essential role in understanding the impact
of the DU in philosophy, mythology and religion. The days of the week are remarkable stable and
well documented, which results in well-defined environments for studies.
Therefore another insight in the days of the week must be analyzed to see how far the interpretatio
Romana may have been correct or inprecise.
Interpreting the Days of the Week
The days of the week are quite illustrative and informative for the interpretation of the
Greek/Roman- respectively the Germanic mythology.
This concept merely contained the planets, which according to the Names of the days of the week
were visible with the naked eye. The system had been conceived and documented in the decaying
Roman Empire during Late Antiquity. In fact the days of the week covers both the pantheon of the
principal Greek/Roman and Germanic deities.
Without the help of Plato I would not have found the key elements so easily, because the planets all
seem to be equivalent. This concept must have been developed as early as the planet cult of Harran
with its 7 planets.
days of the French days Roman God Germany English Slav Deity
week of the week (Greek God)
In the second place, the primeval man was round, his back and sides forming a circle;
and he had four hands and four feet, one head with two faces, looking opposite ways,
set on a round neck and precisely alike; also four ears, two privy members, and the
remainder to correspond. He could walk upright as men now do, backwards or forwards
as he pleased, and he could also roll over and over at a great pace, turning on his four
hands and four feet, eight in all, like tumblers going over and over with their legs in the
air; this was when he wanted to run fast.
Now the sexes were three, and such as I have described them; because the sun, moon,
and earth are three; and the man was originally the child of the sun, the woman of the
earth, and the man-woman of the moon, which is made up of sun and earth, and they
were all round and moved round and round like their parents.21
From this description we may assume that originally all planets and their corresponding deities had
been designed as similar dual designs. Descriptions of the characteristic attributes for these deities
and their creatures required a grammatical dual (abbreviated DU).
Inside of the Roman Empire the DU disappeared. The dual however survived in the names of the
deities such as *Dyeus, Ziu, Zeus, IU-piter, Dieu, Dios,.... although the T- respectively Z- and D-
markers largely may be misunderstood.
21 Symposium_(Plato) - Translated in 1871. See also Symposium in Wikipedia, the free online encyclopedia.
The correlations between the sky-god and the personal pronouns
The androcentrism seems to be concentrated in the regions such as the Roman Empire and Hellas in
which the DU had been lost.
In The Hermetic Codex II - Bipolar Monotheism I found the strong correlation between the sky-
god's name and the personal pronouns of the 1st person singular. Samples of these correlations are:
22 In Germanic languages the dual therefore remained only in the first- and second-person pronouns and their
accompanying verb forms. Old English, Old Norse and the other old Germanic languages had dual marking only in
the personal pronouns, but not in the verbs. (The Nuclear Pillars of Symbolism)
Uuoden or Wuotan. Norse, in Germanic religion and mythology, the supreme god, who created the
first couple Ask and Embla from an ash (Old English sc)23, respectively alder24 tree.
Ash is a hardwood, tough and very strong but elastic, extensively used for making bows.
Alder is a hardwood, used in making furniture, cabinets, and other woodworking products25.
The Saxons were practicing pagans during at least their first five generations in England and
worshiped four principle deities: Woden, Thunor, Tiw, and Frigg26. Woden was married to Frigg
and their children were Thor, Balder and Tiw.
In Norse mythology, Ask and Embla (from Old Norse Askr ok Embla)male and
female respectivelywere the first two humans, created by the gods. The pair are
attested in both the Poetic Edda, compiled in the 13th century from earlier traditional
sources 27
According to chapter 9 of the Prose Edda book Gylfaginning, the three brothers Vili,
V, and Odin, are the creators of the first man and woman28.
In this derivation the dual symbol t of Wit (the personal pronoun for the first person dual (we
two) is missing.
The Slavic dual was fully operable at the time of Old Church Slavonic manuscript writings, and it
has been subsequently lost in most Slavic dialects in the historical period. 31
Frisian Tij ik
English Tue I
Old English Tw, Tg it (Wit) / it (Git) 33 ic, c, Y Tw, Tg (it, it)
Norse Ty, T-var ek
Old Norse T (?) vi (?) Ek (?) T (vi)
Icelandic Tr vi g Tr (vi)
Slavic Svan-tovit v ja Svantovit (v)
French Dieu je Dieu (je)
Provencal Diu iu Diu (iu)
Italian Dio io Dio (io)
Spanish Dios yo Dios (yo)
Portuguese Deus eu Deus (eu)
Sicilian Diu iu Diu (iu)
Romanian Zeu eu Zeu (eu)
Nmes (F.) Dou yiou Dou (yiou)
Savoye (Montagny) Dzeu dzou Dzeu (dzou)
Savoye (central) Dyu de Dyu (de)
Savoye Dyu, ze Dyu (ze)
(Bessans, Giettaz) Dzye, Dezyeu
Sardinian (Campidanese) Deu du Deu (du)
Walloon Diu, Dju, Di dji Diu (dji)
Villar-St-Pancrace Dou (?) iu Dou (yiou)
Eischemtitschu Ziisch iich Ziisch (iich)
Logudorese Sardinian du(s) do du(s) (do)
Rumantsch (sutsilvan) Dieu(s) jou Dieu(s) (jou)
Rumantsch (Surmiran) Dia ia Dia (ia)
Rumantsch (Grischun) Dieu jau Dieu (jau)
Rumantsch (Vallader) Diu eu, eau Diu (eau)
3: Table with the European names of the sky-god and the personal pronouns
(for the dual, respectively singular form)
32 The Sky-God Names and the (Correlating) Personal Pronouns
33 In Germanic languages the dual therefore remained only in the first- and second-person pronouns and their
accompanying verb forms. Old English, Old Norse and the other old Germanic languages had dual marking only in
the personal pronouns, but not in the verbs. (The Nuclear Pillars of Symbolism)
Searching a divine couple near the Magdeburg Brde
In order to find evidences for the philosophical impact of the DU I searched for sculptures of
divine couples outside the Roman Empire, which still may be carrying some of the DU's
symbolism. The DU may have survived a few centuries in the newly occupied territory
around Magdeburg, which had been occupied and christened 800 AD.
The extension of the Roman Empire was halted at the river Rhine, in which the borderline more or
less also marked a rather fertile region with an abundant population.
The Language Border between Flemish and French is concentrated in a belt of fertile soil, which is
named Loess.
In early societies the fertility resulted in intensive agriculture and large, relatively wealthy
populations. Locations with high population concentrations tend to form isoglosses.
Loess tends to develop into very rich soils. Under appropriate climatic conditions, it is
some of the most agriculturally productive terrain in the world.[29] 34.
The European loess-belt, which follows the northernmost mountain ridges of the Belgian Ardennes,
the Ruhr valley and the black soil region around Magdeburg, also more or less follows to the
Uerdinger ik/ich-isogloss.
In Eickendorf the black soil of the Magdeburg Brde had been marked as the most fertile soil of the
German agriculture, resulting in 1934 in a maximum quality number 100 35. The fertility of this soil
had been attributed to the loess-contents.
Around 800 AD Charlemagne extended his empire eastwards toward the Saxon fertility center,
occupied the region around the Magdeburg Brde, where part of a loess belt stretching along the
southeastern rim of the North German Plain, is noted for its very fertile Chernozem soils. And in
805 AD Charlemagne founded Magdeburg (Magadoburg as a Mighty Fortress), where Emperor
Otto I, the first Holy Roman Emperor, founder of the archbishopric of Magdeburg, was buried in
the town's cathedral after his death.
In Northern Germany, which never had been occupied by the Roman Empire the duality in
philosophy probably had been conserved for considerable periods of time.
In Magdeburg I found a sculpture, which originally had been titled Otto and his wife Editha, but
now is considered to represent the divine couple Christ and His Church.36
Hellweg patterns
In studying the European loess-belt I discovered a remarkable correlation between the areas which
are named Hellweg or in French Rue d'Enfer or Rue de l'Enfer and the loess-depots or other
fertile soils.
A number of areas located in an isolated loess-territory are carrying the name Hellweg although
no trading route is found to connect these locations to other trading stations. Therefore the name
Hellweg should not be understood to describe a real road. Instead the Hellweg may be thought to
identify a local loess-deposit or a section of the fertile European loess-belt37.
The divine couple (Emperor Otto and his wife Editha) in Magdeburg
Most traces for couples may be found in fertile regions, which allowed the emperors to concentrate
the early population in relatively large numbers and to create monumental sculptures as a proof for
the dual imperial couples from the DU-era.
One of the imperial couples which may have symbolized the androgynous divine couples in the
Middle Ages is the divine couple (probably Emperor Otto I and his wife Editha) at the Cathedral in
Magdeburg (dated ca. 1250 AD)
5: The divine couple (probably Emperor Otto I and his wife Editha) at the Cathedral in Magdeburg
dated ca. 1250 AD (own photograph)
Contents
Abstract.................................................................................................................................................1
A historical Overview of Duality versus Androcentrism ....................................................................2
The original and extended Swadesh Lists........................................................................................2
The impact of duality in philosophy...............................................................................................2
The sky-god's names.............................................................................................................................3
Tiwas, Tiw, Tr...........................................................................................................................3
Wod, Wuotan, Vut, Wda............................................................................................................4
Wuotunc.................................................................................................................................4
The Slav deities ...............................................................................................................................5
Svarog Zuarasici (up to 1068 AD)...........................................................................................5
Svetovid......................................................................................................................................5
Interpreting the Days of the Week........................................................................................................7
The planet cult of Harran (Roman: Carrhae) and Edessa................................................................7
The Greek & Roman planetary interpretation.................................................................................8
The Germanic planetary interpretation............................................................................................9
The Gallic planetary interpretation..................................................................................................9
The Reconstruction of the Slav planetary interpretation...............................................................10
The hermaphrodite character of Venus and Mercury.....................................................................11
The role of the grammatical dual .............................................................................................11
The character of Aphroditus .....................................................................................................12
The ancient concept of first Man........................................................................................................13
The correlations between the sky-god and the personal pronouns................................................14
The Slav personal pronoun for the first person dual.................................................................15
Linguistic correlations inside and outside the Roman Empire...........................................................16
Searching a divine couple near the Magdeburg Brde...................................................................17
Hellweg patterns............................................................................................................................17
The divine couple (Emperor Otto and his wife Editha) in Magdeburg.........................................18