c:~ s. (\,1f.

J0f) EXAM, 2009

Sl. No. C-DTN-J-MBA

LAW

Paper-I

ITime Allowed : Three Hours I IMaximu~--~arks : 300 I

INSTRUCTIONS

Each question is printed both

in English. •
Answers must be written in zum
specified in the Admission C'~,!"f ...a issued
to you, which must be st arly on the
cover of the answer- the space
provided for the pu marks will be
given for the ans tten in a medium
other than tha in the Admission
Certificate.

es s uld attempt Question Nos. 1

· ~are compulsory, and any three
"''>Vll".....,
maining questions selecting at least
uestion from each Section.

number of marks carried by each

question is indicated at the end of the
question.

t~ ~ : Ji~~n CfiT ~ ~qHH ~ m-~ <fi ~ '[N ~

~~I
 Section-A

1. Answer any three of the following (each

answer should be in about 200 words) :
2Qx3=60

{a) Differentiate between

Constitution' and 'Federal Government.
Based on judicial pronouncements
your perception of the workin
Constitution, comment on
India has a Federal Gov~~
Federal

(b) ((There is still versy whether

om prise a third

statement?
recent case

(c)

(d) How would you judge the constitutional

validity of an Amendment giVIng
primacy to the executive in the matter
of appointment of the judges of the
Supreme Court and High Courts?

C-DTN-J-MBA/42 2

________________________
..__ ._ -
 @Os-q)

1. Pll•=4f(1f{g(1 .q l) ~ iR ~ ~ ~ (~ ~
"Wr~ 200~-q~~): 20x3=60

(Cf1) 'qf{~€11~ ~' ~ 'qf{~l'.f)~ {"i{Cfll{' ~ ~

fu'~ <tl Rit 0> 1 ~ r Rl Cfl f4ortil ~ 3lfUR l:R ~ ~

(~) "~ ~ 31~ ~ ~ ~ fcf; CfflT ' ~

~Bfifq; ~ ~ ~ ~ Cfi1
ml"
~ ~ ROi<N1
cfil~Q. I

3;:q (1101 ;:~W-:0<'1~ ~ :Fir "'4141 (1l{j it ~ c€t

~ ~ ~ -ij Cf11441f<.iq;l Cfil 51tlG<11 ~ ~
~ cfa mfutnm ~"11"'4(11 Cfi1 3m ~
Wf)R~~?

C-DTN-J-MBA/42 3 ( P.T.O.

_j
2. (a) "By evolving the concept of
jurisdictional facts, the Courts have
broadened the power of judicial review
of administrative action."
Discuss this statement and compare
the extent of judicial review of
administrative action over jurisdictional
facts and ordinary facts.
(b) "The term 'freedom of speech
expression' in Article 19( 1)(a) h
held to include the right to
information and dissemina+-~

30

3. (a)

30
Spell out the object and reasons of
Part IV A of the Constitution of India.
Do you support this addition to the
Constitution of India? Give reasons and
also suggest some effective measures to
make these provisions more realistic
and operational. 30
C-DTN-J-MBA/42 4
 2. (ct;) "mtmftn <f'l-<fl cfi1 ~ Cflf'•H I CfiT ~ Cfl IB m ~
~ ~ l~lei41 ~ ~HIIBRCh Cflf4 if; <=lllmct> s;ffiaJUT
ctt ~ <F.T Af<11{ ~fum~ 1"
~ q;~ t« ~ cfilf~ 3fu: ~Cfl1fh11 <l~ <Jm
m'q"RUT o~ "Cl\ 5l~IIBf;p.fi ~ ~ ~lf~Cf> ~~
~ tftm cfa ¥R1 tlNtQ.I 30

4lf~AI sri)Tr it ~ ii ~ ~
fC4f<11<~ ~ ch'l~Q\1 Cfm m
7.JT ~ ~ ~ ~~
~:!~~ 19( 1)(a} cf;T 30

3. (C.fi) ''Pl~~l'ti ~ ~ ~ m :q '~'

~~~ ' :m~~~~Fnm

~ ~ -; 7 R~mlB:~;~~J~ ~
1

• ~ 3:ffi 1!? 3&~ ~ ~ cfa

~~'r\-Jrl!'±=T ~ ~t..T -q 3~(114 ~llll<?f~ ~ ~fi!q:,1ol

~ -slf<:"'Q.I 30

"ffi<f ifi m~ ~ \WT IV A ifi ~ 3fR Cf>l{on

q;l fu«tl( ~ ~l1~1~Q.I ~ -3m m\0 ~ Bfcr~ if
w~ ~ ~ CfiT Btl~ C.fiUt t? ~ ~
;:f;)ntQ. ~){ m~ tt ~ ~m cit :m~ ~
~ fifsh~kl1'=h ~ ~ ~ ~mcft ~ t!$1 l~t!\ I 30

C-DTN-J-MBA/42 5 [ P.T.O.
 4. Write short notes on/ Answer the following:
20x3=60
(a) Scope of the Right with regard to self-
incrimination
(b) Indian ombudsman-unfulfilled dream
(c) ('Powers of Election Commission are not
sufficient." Comment.

5. Answer any
answer should be in

(a) between
d judicial settlement' in
of the rules of International
so mention the relevant
ons regarding forum prorogatum •.
• umanitarian Law is no longer Geneva
and the Hague Law but transcends
these conventions to reach cosmic
stature and seek expression through
the United Nations and other
transnational instruments."
Discuss with reference to growth and
development of International Humani-
tarian Law in the present century.

C-DTN-J-MBA/42 6
 4. ~'tit m~ R01f01~i R1fi9Q>/Rk1R1fun1 ~ ~
~: 20x3=60

s. Rk1 fe1 f{g (1 -ij ~ fcF.;:tf m

~200~-it~ ~ 20x3=60
("~)

?.4 1ft '~ sih1~cq' if> ~ .q

wm~~ut Cf>T $ chl~Q> I

x~~""~"A.. fufu ~ ~ ~ mftrfu ;nft ~

' ~ ~SQ'(fi <g lR ~ .3fu ~ -m;: ~ 3-"R

~•-<Hft!\~ 34~~.oi1 ~ tiT~ it ~&lfffi cfit ~
-ij, ~ ~ ~ ~ ZVJi~>~~{ 3M~~ tl"
1:4d'lH ~1d l~l .q ~~<ftl~ cllchl4ct>ltl fufu ~
~ ~ fuctil~ CfiT $ ~ s;!. ~ lR ~
4{tf~W.I

C-DTN-J-MBA/42 7 ( P.T.O.
 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

(c) "A human rights violation 1s now

conceived as a violation not only of
those personally and directly aggrieved
but of everybody."
Examine critically the above statement
with reference to present scenario of our
country and rest of the world.
(d) '(In practice the relationship bctwe
International Law and Municipal
exists 1n the mixture of Intern 10n
Lav.· supremacy, Munici al
supremacy and a coordina o ~egal
system."
Cornment on the afo tement of
Edward Collins ntext of the
relationship bet ernational Law
and Municip

6. (a)

mention
qvrerence between <express recognition'
and 'implied recognition>. 30
Enumerate the rna1n features of
International Criminal Court. What
credit would you attribute to the
functioning of this Court? What are
the major drawbacks of this Court?
Discuss> in this context, the possible
amendments to the Regulations of the
International Criminal Court. 30

C-DTN-J-MBA/42 8
 (11) ,,~ ~~ * 3~€14 em ~ ~ ~~ ~
atfuilld ~ ~ ~ m-u 3~t41 it ~ it ~
~~it 3~~1 ~ ~ -ij ~~~I''

~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~dt:n1 ql{1~<q q)l ~~1<11

~ ~ Jq (htl ~ q:jT t1l•m.11::q 1 1r~ Cfi m~
t1G1Q\ I

6. (Cfi) ~ ~~.«; fuf'tffl Rf::q I(i

a:TVr ch) Ri1V. 1 ~ m .q,

~Mn-. ~~~Q,I m~ tf 'm~ ~l~dl' ~

~ ~1--'-1(11' ~ ~ 3F{R ~. chl~Q\1 30

~~ ~s ~1'41(.1·=1 ifl ~ m~~ fTHI~Q\1

~ ~ ~1'41(.1:q if> ~Cf)!'•~OI ;:f.r -~ ~ ~? ~
'"41'41c1'4 cRt ~ Cfifil;qf ~-qm ~? ~ ~~ .q
3li"(id~l'4 ~ ;:<qJ41d'4 $ f.:.R4~ .q -rrt:'1cl mn~
G1: ~ chlNi(( I 30

C-DTN-J-MBA/ 42 9 [ P.T.O.
7. {a) Would you support the idea of the
general review of the United Nations
Charter? Give reasons. Also give your
opinion about the continuity of the Veto
System'. What is the stand of India in
these respects? 30
(b) Explain critically the principle
)us cogens'. Distinguish between ~qu
Treaties' and 'Unequal Treaties'. G e
examples and also discuss the
features of Vienna Convention o ...... . . .~-­
Law of Treaties.

8. Write short notes on the fol ·

0. : 20x3=60
30

(a.) Sanctions of Inte

(b) Seas
(c) Manila De

C-DTN-J-MBA/42 10
 7. (q;) (fliT~.~~~~~ {lllOJI'""~ ~~
~ fcF.m: (f)J ~ ~? <muT ~ cfi1 NlQ\ I ~
"ift '~ Sl aII eft' ctT R{ct Hll ~ ~'U if :w:RT lRJ
01.ltti <fl ~~I ~~ .q \ffi(f (f)J <Fn ~ ~ t? 30

0. 30

8. f.l"lPcifulo 'R tifulr RUlfOJ~i 0 Pciful<!.h..._ 20x3=60

(q;) 3MHf~4 ~ cfil v . .,
('&) lOJ~IB~~ if 'q1$tfft ~:_~~

( TT) ll ;fh.11 liJ q 0 II , IA!HI'IIV

C-DTN-J-MBA/42 11 JS-1100
 C-DTN-J-MBA

~-'q"3{-l

>lRf ~ 3rf{ ~ 1frUT11 it ~~· -dllfSrr b-rr.:rT

~ >r<m- cr;r .q ~ "W l:J7Ulrr CfiT p:fff

3~ & 3"ff(-gRJcn ~ ~~~w

FcPrr ~ ra w 3 F[4 f@ ff lTfUTlf ~
'rrrMrrTT ~ fc.:t7j ~ YrR: q( citf ~

~rae ~ ~-"fl- q:;r:{ ~ m 'j+ifi{ fcn;:tf rft;r >rR7 ~

........ '3n<~/

Note : English verswn of the Instructions is

printed on the fran t cover of this
question paper.
 ... ,;. ., ~ .
.. t !

Sl. No. IC-DTN ..J-MBB I

LAW
Paper II

ITime Allowed : Three Hours I Maximum

Each question is printed b

in English.
Answers must he n the medium
specified in the A ·s Certificate issued
to you, which stated clearly mz tire
cover of th er-book in the space
prnvided urpose. No marks will be
gtven 'answers written in a medium ·
otlz r tit tlzat specified in the Admission
~....-,c~e.

idates should attempt Question Nos. 1

nd 5 which are compulsory, and any three
of the remaining questions selecting at least
one question from eaclr Section.
All questions carry equal marks.

641'1 ~: ~ff q;r ~ €4/ro?\ w rnrr-~ it N€9M rp;

rr{ fJtff ~I
 Section 'A'

1. Answer any three of the following (answer to each

question must not exceed 200 words). Support your
answer with the help of legal provisions and
decided cases. 20x3=6

(a) ·Although the requirements of mens

general throughout the criminal Jaw, ..tiJIE:te....a r
numerous exceptions to it'. Exp ·n
illustrations.

(b) 'Necessity knows

• ..
g1v1ng
illustrations.

(c) 'Volenti non fit il(u · <lefence for liability

in tort'. Illustr:· e answer with decided
cases.

(d)

~lain the ingredients of the offence of

criminal misappropriation of property and
distinguish this from criminal breach of trust.
A sees Z drop his purse with money in it.
A picks up the purse with the intention of
returning it to z1
but afterwards appropriates
it for his own use. Has A committed any
offence ? Discuss. 30

2 (Contd.)
1. MkiMfijcd ~~~~ t ~ GlNtl( I 9<441 ~
2oo~ran~arruq;~~~:q'~tt, ~~~
fccp,~~~~e~tttat ~~~~~cfllNitt:
20x3=
(q;) 'qoaf\4 31t~qict ~ Rfu ~ ~ ~
~4Cflctl ftt¥1trlf Gmr ~' (PliiM ~
a~q;:;u~ m
~, I '3~1~(01 tnT ~ m
cfnMq; I
(~) ·~~Cfidl ~ ..-ft fiffu - '111- .• 'iiHdf I
3~t~<ot ~ ~. ~ CSfTa" c:h1 MQII
(if) ·~~i1 ;tl;r ~ . ~ '=tf4{4 it~
~ stfd(m ~' 1 ~~~n+· * \3~1~<on· ~ ~
~~~ I
(ti) ~·~~~it"~;~u· en) fG1SC: ch)R;,~ 1 ~~iiil ~

~ ~*~'~'fiT em~
~~lftT.:r mor ~ ? .
2. ( ) ~ ~f4P141•1 iii ~ ~ tl'4~ct.1"
~~ cb\Niq; ~ \3ijCfll ~~~
~cftM~I
'Cf)' ~~Cfd 1 ~ fctl \cr' ~~ fiR: W ~ ~ fcfl
~ ~ '4f ~ I 'cti' ~ ~ ~ '«' CfiT ~ll~ ~
~ t ~ ~ ~' ~Pctlt=i ifR .q:, ~ ~~'ii<Wt
fiiM4lMd cg WIT~ I CM" 'q;' ~
*
CflT{
~ '3ftq,)
atq<IU ~ ~ ? :q:qf cfi'lMc:t I 30

C-DTN-J-MBB 3 (Contd.)
 (b) Distinguish between culpable homicide and
causing death by rash or negligent act.

her

3. (a) ·A statetncnt made in perfonnanc

privileged'. In the light of t
critically examine the tort of ef

X the famous critic while

criticising the o the famous
painter, wrote in spaper as follows :

re pots of paint hurled in

blic'. He afterwards wrote to
hatever he had written had been
said in the course of his duty and hoped
at 'lC would not allow this to interfere with
~...- ·r friendship. Y repJied and said 'Next time
eet you. I shall pun~h your nose damn hard.
I hope you will not allow this to interfere with
our friendship·.

What torts, if any, have they con1mitted and

what defences are available to them ?
20+10=30

C-DTN-J-MBB 4 (Contd.)
 {tcr) ~'"IHCf4'f1~ '3dl9&lq~ ~IDU"lfT~
cnr<-f ~ IDU ~ Cfltf(d 'fl~ ~ ~ ~ chl NtlJI 1
~ qfu ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '"lt%(0tt 'q)' ;r
\3f{Chl ~~qGI~~m.rr~ NHti:t;1 Cfi!~
~..,~<'11 qr, ~f4l~ mCfiRiG1 ~ ~~aMCfi< ~,
'"II&(~ .q ~ ~ m 3ftRra" Ff;m t, ~ ~~rr .....

m?
3. ( q;) 'Cfldoq ~ 3i 'jq I(1'1 if ~ 11m t;:i'~kr.:~::TT
n::lllll;....

9Tif mor ~, 1 ~ ~ % ~"

31 q 1 ttl q;r fl 111 C1l ::q '1 k&f Cf)

~ gru~ ~<-C1Cf) am: 'tr' ~ ~ gru"

. 311«loq'1J ~ '[(!: ~
-Hilt-:~~ I'(;R~ I :

eft 3fRciT if ~ ~ ~
~ I ~'Gf'~'~'q))~~~~
~· ~~~q:;Joq ~ Picf6~ ~<ft<l~
~ aft< ~ <fQ ~TT Cfl<(d 1 ~ fctl ~ GRT
~ltal if <iT{ €H1<"1 rrtf 3i l"t'~ll I '~' ~ !Jictlal
Wn~ '~~~ llt&i~ ~if~~~
~ ~ 4jCMil 111~~~ 1 1 ~ amrr ~ ~ ~ ~ IDU 3fr1
~;or I<t.l Gl fdl if mt.'1 t.'1 ~ ~ ~, I
~~ ~~~ 31q<£i<lf ~ ~, ~~ ~m-,
am~~CfiT~m~~-aq~~~?
20+10=30

C-DTN-1-MBB 5 (Contd.)
 (b) ~A master is not responsible for a wrongful act
unless it is done in the course of employment' .
Comment and explain the circumstance s when
wrongfu I acts are deemed to be done ••in the
course of employment". Refer to decided _,(:\.
cases. 30 ~'
4. (a) "The enforcement of any disability arisi
out of untouchabilit y is to be an
punishable in accordance with law". Conw~~IV§t
upon this statement and discuss i ~text
the scope of protection of c· . s Act,
1955. 20
(b) HDamnum sine injun· injuria sine
damnum are two di nciples of law".
Comment briefly 20
(c) List briefly t~l.ln~e ure to be followed by a
District R receipt of a complaint
ve goods under the Consumer
1986. 20

• Section 'B'
w.,.a~r any three of the following (answer to each
. . . ._.._estton must not exceed 200 words). Support your
nswer with legal provisions and decided cases.
20x3=60
(a) ·An invitation to treat is not an offer'. Explain.
(b) 'An attempt at ~eit which does not deceive
is not fraud'. Do you agree ?

C-DTN-J-MB B 6 (Contd.)
 Gl tt t"f ~ it ~ cr;r Cf'Cf) Nt d\ ~I< ~
( lS) '¥:11 ~ ct;
~ t", \ijGf oq;- fifl ~ CJ1T!f PiiflZ11'1 ~ r1t <I'"'~ ;r ~
lfln" ~· I flcqo n em MC( 3lR ~ q fd~ R14f em
ijii~ l~l( fcf; Nt'1it' ~ltSf'J_uf ~ '' H41"1"1 ~ G1(1'1'' ~
~ ~ 1!'R ;;mi,it 1 f4 f.l~ lllllffi" <~» ~<II <'II ~ -
~1Ptq I 30
«
4. (Cfi) "~'«<T ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ at4'ht~dt
Y4d'1 ~ ~ 3ftf<m' liT'U \it I((411, \if) ~
31~ t< ~:S'114 mm·,
I ~ ~ 'tR flcqof) ~m­
afR ~ ~ ~ mrq (Yf 3( ruCfil< r-.rr:J~Ja:h~I"J::r
"Di.

1955 ~qftfu~~4i1Ml( I
(~) "fil;:w I ~~~ afR t:inllliiPd'lll~
~ ~ c_ n. . ~,,
ttl Gl 1~?1 1~41d 'Q

20
(;r) ~ m~ 1986 ~ aralrr, , ~'~~~r
;m;r it; ~ ~.~~ efiT 9Tffi ~' fin;rr <i1l(ii
mr ~ Cflt4fctfu ct?r ~~ ~
20
1gq 'w'
S. · ~~ffi;r~Z1WGlM(( I ~m~-.;
41\f.:s:~~2oo ~ 3Tfirq; ~~ ~ m
~ :q'~o:, ~
~tirnt· aft"( f4Pt~~ ~ tT ij(?l4<11 ~ ~ ~ cfiT
4?1 Mtt : 20x3=60
(q;) '~Mttlrqqf't ~ etrr Pt+i~ot ~ ..,-m tmft
t"' I~ cfilM"" I
(~) 'gq"qf11 q)J ~ 941fl mg~R.a ;r ~' ~ ~
~ ~· I CfliT 3M' ~ fl~¥H1 ~ ?

C-DTN-J-MBB 7 (Contd.)
 (c) .. A cheque marked 'not negotiable ' ts
neverthele ss negotiable ". Comment.

(d) 'A quantum meruit. although a quasi contract.

arises out of a contract'. Comment.

6. (a) 'Informati on Technolog y - brought abo

Computers~ Internet arltl Cyberspac
posed new problems in j urisprudenc '. I
context of this statemen~ critic lly

o
ine
how far our existing laws e ~ient in
meeting these challenges . 30

(b) ·The essential chara f an agent is that

he is invested w· power to alter his
principars le 1 ns with third parties;
the principal u r a co-relative liability to
have his ations altered'. Discuss.
a contract with B to sell him
of cotton and afterwards discovers
t as acting as agent for C. Who is liable
to<fa for the price of the cotton? 20+ 10=30

'As an agreement is an essential ingredient in

a Partnership, it fol1ows that a minor cannot
enter into an agreement of Partnershi p'.
Critically examine this statement and discuss
the circumstan ces under which the Indian
Partnership Act permits a minor to participate
in the benefit of partnershi p. 30

C-DTN-J- MBB 8 (Contd.) l

J
 (~) " '~ m-
~ '6iq(Sf1tS4' R4~d ~' ~ ISfiCI'i~
.~ 'q<Sfltl4' mcrr
~,' 1 flcqoo cfil Niq; l
('Ef) 'fGla;ct ~ 3riiCI ~ J4<uN 31ef ~fi4GI ~' mm-
ttt4tM ~ ~fctGt ~ W « ~' I Qcqof)mcrr
cil)f;t~ I
6. (~) 'c:h~c(Y, ~co(~ ~ ~ ti ~ ~~( ffi1 '[ro ~sf
~~fflch) ~ fcrfu-~00 it~ ijJif4tl( w -
~' I ~~*~if, Biit(1l"i4411 ~~~
emM~ fcf> ~ i4l ra~· q)f e trFu ~ -..·..;;;llnr t
ret ttl~ 111 fcmF:rt ~ mm ~ •
(l.Cr) 'fcfim ~ q;r ~~ICI~~ ~~,.,_.,~.,.
. ~ ~ fffi£(1' ~ tr1ll ~ .llltiMI
J
~ q f(~ ~ ~ cfiT .....,... A"!rrlllr.::r-
mm ~; tti~Ch
~ ~ -m-d"Mcl;;~~

cfnMQ\ I
'q)' ~ '\.9' q;) ~ ~ ~ 'l.Cr' ~
~~:r'<tlK ~ t" afR CSf1G .q: 'en' ~ qcrr
\cr' ffi '11"' ~ tzq=i ~ ~ citt tR Cli11f
~ptr 1 Cf)q jij cfa 4l't~a ~ ~ 'Cf)' ~ m ~
~? , 20+10=30
'~ Cf}('R ~ t•fl ~ F<.l. ~ ~ 31 ~ Ict ~1:fCtl fl~ lCfl mm-
~' ~ ~ HCfi<1ct t ~ fcfi-31c:tl4f<fl 04Rn \it•n<=r<1 ~
ttMGI ~ rnr ~ ~ tictldl ~' I ~ ~ qrr
fl'11~"i4'11'{cfc:h q(l~OI cfilNtq ~ \R qf<f~f{p;(f
~ ~ chlM~ M'14l anftrr \it<d)q <fii4~GI<l
~' 31<:1<04~ oqfffi q;) \it•fl~tft ~ @1 it
~II Mc:;t ~ cfa 3t'j'1 Rt ~ ~ I 30

C-DTN-J-MBB 9 (Contd.)
 (b)

8.

(a) 'Contract of of
guarantee'.

(b) 'Specific offer'

(c) urchase' agreement.

C-DTN-J-MBB 10
 (lg) ,~, 3iR '(lutl:h 611Sh'i ~· tT 64~'11 <tiT,
~ 9CflR ij- ~ q(Sfl1J4 Mtqa 3lWM~'i ~ ctif¥4€1
t-, ijftft1~t:t attt ~ m1~ lmCflR1 ~ ~ CfiT
~ em N~t:t,
Ni'14i ~ ~ ~ ~C!h~l<1
~ ~ I ~ ~ cfiT ij~llfdl ~ ~
*
~RttQl 1

8.

C-DTN-JaMBB 11
 I C-DTN-J-MBB I

~T

«
--~- !n'1 fW;rr I 3/k 5 31 RCf tzf ~ I tS/1 cf?l r:n'ff if
g('ilq> ~if cm-it-Cfilf ~ ~rr "fJ/"fct>'< ~
'fiPr r:n-;ff iii ~ qJMQ 1

mit !n;:ff it ~ Hl/lrt ff I

Note : English version of the lnstn tctio ns is print ed on

the front cove r of this question paper.