Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Research Article
Physiotherapy Practice Patterns for Management of
Patients Undergoing Thoracic Surgeries in India: A Survey
Copyright © 2016 Sagarika Sultanpuram et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attributio n
License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly
cited.
Aim. The aim of the current study is to determine the practice patterns of physiotherapists for patients undergoing thoracic surgeries
in India. Materials and Methodology. A cross-sectional survey was conducted across India in which 600 questionnaires were sent
in emails to physiotherapists. The questionnaire addressed assessment and treatment techniques of thoracic surgery. Results. A
total of 234 completed questionnaires were returned with a response rate of 39%, with the majority of responses received from
Telangana, Karnataka, and Andhra Pradesh. More than 90% of the responders practiced physical examination, chest expansion,
chest X-ray, ABG analysis, pulmonary function test, and SpO2 (oxygen saturation) as the assessment measures in both the pre- and
the postoperative phase. Breathing exercises, incentive spirometry, thoracic expansion exercises, coughing and huffing, positioning,
and modified postural drainage are found to be commonly used physiotherapy interventions, both pre- and postoperatively, with a
response rate of more than 90%. A response rate of more than 84.6% indicated that patients are made to dangle their lower limbs over
the edge of the bed on the 1st postoperative day. Mobilization, such as walking up to a chair, sit to stand exercises, and perambulation
within the patient’s room, was started on the 2nd postoperative day, as stated by more than 65% of the physiotherapists. Staircase
climbing was started on the 5th postoperative day. The most commonly used functional evaluation prior to discharge was 6-minute
walk test. This was, in fact, practiced by 77.4% of the physiotherapists in their clinical settings. Conclusion. The most predominantly
employed assessment measures included were physical examination, chest expansion, ABG analysis, pulmonary function test, chest
X-ray, SpO 2(oxygen saturation), peripheral muscle strength, and cardiopulmonary exercise. The physiotherapy interventions most
commonly used were breathing exercises, thoracic expansion exercises, incentive spirometry, and coughing and huffing techniques,
in both the pre- and the postoperative phase.
Maharashtra
Haryana
Jharkhand
Delhi
Karnataka
Gujrat
Punjab
Kerala
Andhra Pradesh
Bihar
upper abdominal surgery in India.
There is scarcity of retrievable literature regarding pre-
and postoperative assessment and treatment for patients
undergoing thoracic surgeries in India. The aim of the study
was to analyse current practice patterns among physiothera-
pists in pre- and postoperative assessment and treatment for Figure 1: Response rates from different states of India (𝑛 = 234).
patients undergoing thoracic surgeries in India.
3. Data Analysis
2. Study Procedure
Responses were numerically coded to allow for descriptive
A written approval was obtained from the Institutional Ethics summaries and frequency analysis of the data using SPSS
Committee and Scientific Committee of KMC, Mangalore. version 16. Frequency variables regarding assessment and
Upon approval by the committee, a list of hospitals where treatment for thoracic surgery patients were merged in order
thoracic surgeries are done was obtained from the NABH to create three responses: “always or frequently,” “some-
(National Accreditation Board of Hospitals and Health times,” and “rarely or never.”
Providers) and MCI (Medical Council of India) websites, and
a survey was conducted across India in which around 600 4. Result
questionnaires were sent via email to physiotherapists who A total of 600 questionnaires were mailed to physiotherapists
were involved in the management of patients undergoing all over India, of which 234 completed questionnaires were
thoracic surgery. returned. Data are reported as the number of respondents
This email included a hyperlink which directed the for each individual question, which varied throughout the
participants to a webpage with the Informed Consent Form survey. The physiotherapy profile is displayed in Table 1. The
and those consenting to participate could access the question- responses were received from 11 states, that is, Telangana,
naire. Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Bihar, Delhi, Gujarat, Haryana,
A period of 2 weeks was given to the physiotherapists to Jharkhand, Kerala, Maharashtra, and Punjab. This made for
fill in the questionnaire in an attempt to ensure good response a response rate of 42%. The majority of responders were
rate. If no response was obtained within the stipulated period, from Telangana (92, 39.35%), Karnataka (54, 23.1%), and
telephonic or email reminders were sent and the response was Andhra Pradesh (41, 17.5%) and the least responders were
awaited for another 2 weeks beyond which nonresponders from Jharkhand (1, 0.4%) and Bihar (1, 0.4%). Response rate
were excluded from the study. is given in Figure 1.
Surgery Research and Practice 3
100
90
6. Preoperative Physiotherapy Interventions
80 for Thoracic Surgery Patients
70
𝑛 = 217 [93.9 ]
30
50 (𝑛 = 204 [88.7
40 % ), huffing and coughing
10 ( % ),
0
60 The preoperative physiotherapy interventions included deep
breathing exercises (
and thoracic mobility exercises (𝑛 = 213 [91.0%]) of the
20 %]), active cycle of breathing exercises
𝑛 = 203 [86.7 %] ), incentive spirometry ( 𝑛 = 216 [92.3 ]
Chest X-ray
Barthel index
Cardiopulmonary exercise test 6
Chest expansion
SpO2
Pulmonary function test
oxygen saturation ( %
The frequencies with which different assessment measures 8. Postoperative Physiotherapy Interventions
were used preoperatively are given in Table 2 and Figure 2. for Thoracic Surgery Patients
A total of 99.14% of physiotherapists performed preop-
erative physiotherapy. Among them, 90% marked “always 8.1. Physiotherapy Interventions Used on the 1st Postoperative
or frequently.”
physical The various
examination ( assessment measures included
), chest expansion Day. The frequencies
techniques of various physiotherapy
used on postoperative day 1 are giventreatment
in Table 5
𝑛 = 218 [93.1 ]%
(𝑛 = 217 [92.7 %]), ABG analysis (𝑛 = 183 [78.2%]), and Figure 5. A total of 97.5% of the physiotherapists per-
pulmonary function test ( 𝑛 = 175 [74.7%]), chest X-ray (𝑛 = formed day 1 rehabilitation. Among them, more than 80%
215 [93.5 %]), oxygen saturation (𝑛 = 211 [90.1 %] ), periph- marked “always or frequently.” The treatment techniques
eral muscle strength (𝑛 = 175 [74.7 %]), cardiopulmonary included breathing exercises ( 𝑛 = 221 [94.4 %]), relaxation
4 Surgery Research and Practice
𝑛 = 159 [67.9 ] 𝑛 = 215 [91.8 ]
exercise test ( % ), 6 min and 12 min walk test techniques ( % ), thoracic expansion exercises
% ) of the % ), posi-
𝑛 = 138 [60.0 ] 𝑛 = 157 [70.4 ] 𝑛 = 193 [82.4 ] 𝑛 = 198 [84.6 ]
96 100
94 95
92 90
90
85
88
80
86
75
84
70
82
ABG analysis
Chest X-ray
Physical examination
SpO2
PFT
Chest expansion
Huffing and coughing
Breathing exercises
Incentive spirometry
Figure 3: Preoperative physiotherapy interventions for thoracic ( 𝑛 = 214 [91.4% ]), modified postural drainage 𝑛 (
surgery patients. 1 79 [ 76.4 ), upper extremities range of motion exercises
(𝑛 = 216 [92.3%]), lower extremities range of motion =
exercises (𝑛 = 211 [90.1%]), dangle (𝑛 = 174 [74.3%]),%]up
206 88%]), upper extremities range of motion exercises (𝑛 = to chair (𝑛 = 156 [66.6%]), sit to stand (𝑛 = 125 [53.4%]),
72 [73.5 %]), lower extremities range of motion walking in the room (𝑛 = 168 [71.7%]), and walking in the
(𝑛 = 201 [85.8 %]), and dangle (𝑛 = 198 [84.6%]). corridor (𝑛 = 86 [39.8%]).
exercises
8.2. Physiotherapy Interventions Used on the 2nd Postoper- 8.3. Physiotherapy Interventions Used on the 3rd Postoper-
ative Day. The frequencies with which different treatment ative Day. The frequencies with which different treatment
techniques were used on postoperative day 2 are given in techniques were used on postoperative day 3 are given in
Table 6 and Figure 6. A total of 97% of the physiotherapists Table 7 and Figure 7. A total of 98.6% of the physiother-
performed day 2 rehabilitation. More than 80% of the phys- apists performed day 3 rehabilitation. More than 80% of
iotherapists marked “always or frequently.” These methods the physiotherapists marked “always or frequently.” The
included breathing exercises (𝑛 = 228 [97.4 % ] ), relaxation t reat ment techniques included were breathing exercises (�
techniques (𝑛 = 217 [92.7 %]), thoracic expansion exercises 228 [97.4 %]), relaxation techniques (𝑛 = 216 [92.3%]),
(𝑛 = 217 [92.7%]), incentive spirometry (𝑛 = 217 [92.7%]), =
incentive spirometry (𝑛 = 226 [96.5%]), modified postural
coughing and huffing techniques𝑛( = 192 [82%]), per- drainage (𝑛 = 197 [84.1%]), upper extremities range of
cussion and vibrations (𝑛 = 156 [66.6 ), positioning motion exercises (𝑛 = 222 [94.8%]), lower extremities
%]
6 Surgery Research and Practice
200
); anda shuttle walk
Positioning
Incentive spirometry
Dangle
by
testan individual
employed 0.9% (𝑛(𝑛= =2 119
by [50.9%
Positioning
Modified postural drainage
Up to chair
Percussion and vibration
Incentive spirometry
Walking in room
Thoracic expansion exercises
Walking in corridor
Sit to stand
Dangle
Up to chair
Lower extremity range of motion
Breathing exercises
Incentive spirometry
Sit to stand
Staircase climbing
Dangle
this technique is employed in countries like Australia and of physiotherapists who administer the same exercises to
New Zealand which showed a response rate of 90.4% [7]. patients in countries like Australia and New Zealand (87.5%)
Peripheral muscle strength gradings were taken for [7] and the United Kingdom (70%) [6].
flexion, abduction, extension, and internal rotation of the Incentive spirometry is used to encourage sustained max-
shoulder joint as these are some actions of the muscles imal inspiration, promote reinflation of lung tissue, and pre-
which are divided during open thoracotomy. Postoperative vent or resolve atelectasis. Incentive spirometry involves deep
physiotherapy exercise programme was provided to prevent breathing through a device with visual feedback, thought to
or minimize shoulder dysfunction after thoracotomy [18]. In maximize accuracy of breathing technique and motivation
this study, 74.7% of the physiotherapists assessed peripheral [19]. The results showed that 93.9% of the physiotherapists
muscle strength in their clinical settings. practiced incentive spirometry as physiotherapy interven-
tions and this response rate is more than that indicated
11. Preoperative Physiotherapy Intervention in a similar study carried out in countries like the United
for Thoracic Surgery Patients Kingdom (37%) [6] and Australia and New Zealand (42.8%)
[7].
Our survey found that preoperative physiotherapy tech- Coughing and huffing techniques are used in clearing
niques include deep breathing exercises, incentive spirome- secretions from large airways. The rapid, forceful expulsion
try, thoracic mobility exercises, huffing and coughing tech- of air from the lungs helps remove secretions from the large
niques, and ACBT techniques (more than 90%). airways. In addition to mobilizing and expelling secretions,
Deep breathing exercises are taught to the patients in the high pressures generated during a cough may be an
the preoperative period. These can reduce the effects of an important factor in reexpanding lung tissue [20]. The current
altered breathing pattern after thoracotomy and can help to survey showed that 88.7% of physiotherapists practiced the
obtain full expansion of the chest wall during spontaneous coughing and huffing technique as a physiotherapy interven-
breathing. This is essential to help restore lung function tion. However, the response rate is lower than that reported
and to prevent subsequent chest deformity. A large inflating in countries like Australia and New Zealand (94.2%) and the
volume and transpulmonary pressure gradient is needed to United Kingdom (89%) [6, 7].
be maintained for several seconds in order to achieve lung Active cycle breathing exercises (ACBTs) are used in
reexpansion [19]. In this survey, 93.9% of physiotherapists improving pulmonary function and airway clearance. The
practiced the administration of deep breathing exercises to ACBTs are combinations of breathing control, thoracic
preoperative patients which is a higher percentage than that expansion control, and forced expiratory techniques (FET).
Surgery Research and Practice 11
Breathing control has been referred to as diaphragmatic physiotherapists employing the same technique in countries
breathing, or as gentle breathing using the lower chest. like Australia and New Zealand (90%) [7].
Thoracic expansion exercises are simply active inspirations Percussion is used to augment mobilization of secretions
with larger than normal breaths, followed by relaxed expi- by mechanically dislodging viscous or adherent mucus from
ration. This larger lung volume increases airflow through airways. Vibrations are used in conjunction with percussion
peripheral airways and collateral ventilation channels, which to help move secretions to larger airways. The air cushion
increases the gas volume available to mobilize secretions between the cupped hand and the chest wall generates the
during expiration [20]. According to this survey, 86.7% of typical hollow sound, transmits the energy to the underlying
the physiotherapists practiced these patterns regularly. The lung, and helps mobilize secretions. The atelectatic areas of
response rate is more than that from countries like Australia the lung can be reinflated and total lung/thorax compliance
and New Zealand (51.4%) and the United Kingdom [6, 7]. can be increased following percussion and vibration [8,
17]. In this survey, 66.6% of the physiotherapists practiced
12. Postoperative Physiotherapy Management percussion and vibration in their clinical settings.
for Thoracic Surgery Positioning is advised for promoting relaxation, reducing
postoperative pain, and causing lung expansion as also for
The results of our survey showed that predominantly the draining secretions. In pneumonectomy, the lateral position
same treatment techniques were employed postoperatively as is advised, as perfusion of the dependent lung is increased due
employed preoperatively. to gravitational changes though ventilation is more difficult.
Breathing exercises are used to improve the efficiency The prone position is advantageous whena large quantity of
of ventilation and gas exchange, increasing the excursion bronchial secretions is present in the segmentectomy [8]. In
of the diaphragm and easing the mobilization of secretions this study, the results showed that 60% of physiotherapists
[21]. Breathing exercises like localized breathing exercises, practiced positioning technique as an intervention in their
diaphragmatic breathing exercises, lateral basal expansion, clinical settings.
upper lateral expansion, and apical pectoral expansion exer- Modified postural drainage (bronchial drainage) is used
cises are important for treating thoracic surgery patients. for airway clearance by mobilizing secretions from different
These exercises help to counteract an abnormal breathing lung segments to the central airways by placing the patient in
pattern in the postoperative period [8]. According to our various positions so that gravity assists in draining secretions.
study, more than 95% of physiotherapists employ breathing Postural drainage attempts to use gravity to move secretions
exercises postoperatively and this is more than the response from peripheral airways to the larger bronchi, from which
rate reported by physiotherapists in Australia and New they are more easily expectorated [8]. A total of 89.2% of
Zealand (90%) [7]. the physiotherapists practice these patterns in their clinical
Incentive spirometry has the same effect as shown in settings as a physiotherapy intervention.
preoperative management. It is used primarily to prevent An upper limb exercise programme is commonly used to
alveolar collapse and atelectasis in postoperative patients prevent or minimize shoulder dysfunction and to maintain
[19]. In the current study, it was noted that more than 90% joint range of motion after thoracotomy. Active shoulder
of physiotherapists included spirometry as a physiotherapy exercises like flexion, abduction, external rotation and ele-
intervention which is a higher percentage when compared vation, shoulder shrugging, and progressive shoulder and
to the percentage of physiotherapists who employ spirometry thoracic cage exercises are commonly used after thoracic
as intervention in countries like Australia and New Zealand surgery. Shoulder strengthening exercises for flexion, exten-
(40%) [7]. The purpose of incentive spirometry is to increase sion, abduction, and external rotations are usually performed
the volume of air inspired. after thoracic surgery [18]. Upper limb exercises are practiced
Thoracic expansion exercises were given to improve the by 74.8% of physiotherapists. This is a lower percentage than
mobility of chest wall, trunk, and shoulder girdles. Exercises in Australia and New Zealand (93.5%) [7].
that combine stretching of these muscles with deep breathing Lower limb exercises like hip and knee flexion and
improve ventilation on that side of the chest. These exercises extension exercises and active leg, foot, and ankle exercises
are also used to reinforce or emphasize the depth of inspira- are taught to prevent circulatory problems like deep vein
tion or controlled expiration [21]. According to this survey, thrombosis and pulmonary embolism [21]. Thus, regular
the response rate of thoracic expansion exercises is 82.4% by activation of the muscle pumps to minimize circulatory stasis
physiotherapists in India. It is higher than the response rate and frequent body position changes is essential to reduce
reported in the United Kingdom (64.5%) [6]. risks [22]. In the current survey, it was seen that 85.8%
Coughing techniques enhance the clearance of retained of physiotherapists practiced these patterns in their clinical
bronchial secretions, thus preventing atelectasis and infec- settings.
tion. During a normal cough, airflow velocity varies in Mobilization in the upright position coordinated with
airways, creating high linear velocities, increased turbulence, breathing control and supported coughing maneuvers is
and high shearing forces within the airway. These forces shear encouraged in order to reduce atelectasis and impaired
secretions from the airway walls, propelling them towards mucociliary transport associated with surgery. Early mobi-
the larger airways and trachea which causes expelling of lization elicits cardiopulmonary responses, resulting in
secretions [20]. Coughing techniques are practiced by 80% enhancement of oxygen transport. These beneficial effects
of the physiotherapists which is lower than the percentage of are enhanced by improved chest wall motion, improved
12 Surgery Research and Practice
INFLAMMATION
BioMed
PPAR Research
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Research International
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Journal of
Obesity
Evidence-Based
Journal of Stem Cells Complementary and Journal of
Ophthalmology International
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Alternative Medicine Oncology
Hindawi Publishing Corporation Hindawi Publishing Corporation Hindawi Publishing Corporation Hindawi Publishing Corporation
http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Parkinson’s
Disease
Computational and
Mathematical Methods
in Medicine
Behavioural
Neurology
AIDS
Research and Treatment
Oxidative Medicine and
Cellular Longevity
Hindawi Publishing Corporation Hindawi Publishing Corporation Hindawi Publishing Corporation Hindawi Publishing Corporation Hindawi Publishing Corporation
http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014