Journal of Asian and African Studies

http://jas.sagepub.com/

The Odyssey of the Ananda Marga: A Comparative Study

Narasingha P Sil
Journal of Asian and African Studies published online 20 December 2012
DOI: 10.1177/0021909612449127

The online version of this article can be found at:

http://jas.sagepub.com/content/early/2012/12/14/0021909612449127

Published by:

http://www.sagepublications.com

Additional services and information for Journal of Asian and African Studies can be found at:

Email Alerts: http://jas.sagepub.com/cgi/alerts

Subscriptions: http://jas.sagepub.com/subscriptions

Reprints: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.nav

Permissions: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav

>> OnlineFirst Version of Record - Dec 20, 2012

What is This?

Downloaded from jas.sagepub.com at WESTERN OREGON UNIVERSITY on January 7, 2013

449127
2012
JAS0010.1177/0021909612449127SilJournal of Asian and African Studies

Article
JAAS
Journal of Asian and African Studies

The Odyssey of the Ananda Marga: 0(0) 1­–13

© The Author(s) 2012
Reprints and permission:
A Comparative Study sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav
DOI: 10.1177/0021909612449127
jas.sagepub.com

Narasingha P Sil
Western Oregon University, USA

Abstract
This paper seeks to examine the ideology and theology of the Ananda Marga (Path of Bliss), a new radical
Hindu sect of postcolonial India, by comparing its odyssey with an almost radical Christian sect of Reformation
Europe, the Anabaptists. Like the Anabaptists, the Ananda Marga began as a movement of the common man.
Both were also millennial movements with lay leadership arising as responses to the social, cultural, and
economic crises of their respective historical times. Both sought to recover the pristine and authentic ethos
of their respective religious traditions and thus antagonized their respective governments. Consequently,
both endured persecution but both survived their ordeal by re-forming their ideology and theology under
competent leadership to emerge as peaceful, fruitful, and resourceful members of their societies.

Keywords
Ananda Marga, dharmarajya, geo-religion, gurukula, Gütergemeinschaft, Parama Purusa, tandava, kaushiki

Introduction
The Ananda Marga (Path of Bliss), constituting at once a minor sect outside of mainline Hindu
beliefs and practices and a social movement dedicated to the moral uplifting of the people, has had
a checkered history. Yet the sect survived its multiple trials and tribulations to become a global
movement. The odyssey of the Ananda Marga suggests tantalizing parallels with that of the
Anabaptists (originally the Swiss Brethren) of 16th century Europe.1 As apostates from the estab-
lished and powerful Roman Catholic and Protestant Churches, the Anabaptists suffered persecu-
tion from the very inception of their movement. The Ananda Marga followers endured periodic
brutal attacks by the Communist Party activists during 1967–1990. Both movements reacted with
violence temporarily, though achieved success at the end.
As typical religious sects, the Ananda Marga and the Anabaptists possess such features as vol-
untariness, expulsion, exclusivity, self-identification, elite status, merit, conscience, and legitima-
tion (Wilson, 1970: 28–35). Both may also be characterized as ‘revitalization’ and ‘apostolic’
movements (Bromley, 1998: 20–21) as well as chiliastic/messianic movements (Barkun, 1974).
Such movements arise in a disequilibrated society suffering from loss of authority in order to save

Corresponding author:
Narasingha P Sil, Western Oregon University, Monmouth, OR 97361, USA
Email: siln@wou.edu

Downloaded from jas.sagepub.com at WESTERN OREGON UNIVERSITY on January 7, 2013

2 Journal of Asian and African Studies 0(0)

it from inevitable disintegration. They tend to restore or resort to what they consider the pristine
glory of authentic religious/spiritual tradition. In formulating their ideal world, both movements
also represent a social regenerative piety rather than the traditional faith, ritualistic brahmnaical or
liturgical and institutional Episcopalian. They appear to be what may be considered ‘introversion-
ist’ sects who dissociate from their contemporary society and depend increasingly on their com-
munity and seek to retain a strong sense of their own sanctity. Their community life emphasizes
spiritual exercises that confer a ‘transcendent holiness’ upon them (Wilson, 1970: 118–119). In
other words, theirs is what Paul Heelas (2009) calls ‘spirituality of life’ – a practical spirituality for
the enhancement of the qualities of life while living in the present.
This comparatist exercise argues for an interesting point in respect to religious millennial move-
ments. Ananda Marga, starting as a religious sect, never had a coherent or cogent and strictly
scripturally based and rigorously argued theology, unlike the highly scholarly, albeit dogmatic,
writings of Anabaptist scholars and activists such as Conrad Grebel (1498–1526), Michael Sattler
(1490–1527), Felix Mantz (1498–1527), Hans Denck (1493–1527), Ludwig Hätzer (1500–1559)
and many others. And it is precisely for this lack of theological rigor that the Ananda Marga could
successfully expand itself to such a modernist, secular, socio-economic project while still main-
taining its activities under the rubric of its founder’s spiritual enterprise. Interestingly, even this
diversion of the sect’s original spiritual goal is not quite original with the Ananda Marga, it being
an imitation of the Ramakrishna Math and Mission, a pioneering spiritual-secular multinational
organization founded by the 19th-century religious leader Ramakrishna Paramahamsa’s (1836–
1886) distinguished disciple Swami Vivekananda (1863–1902; Sil, 1993, 1997).2
Anabaptism, the socio-religious movement of the Swiss Brethren, claiming to be a restoration
of authentic Apostolic Christianity, arose in a period of religious turmoil (the European
Reformations) and political instability (rise of nation states in defiance of the authority of the
Holy Roman Empire; see Bowsma, 1980: 215–246). The Swiss Brethren earned their nickname
Anabaptist (or Wiedertäufer, meaning ‘re-baptizers’), outlawed by the Codex Justinianus (529),
because they thought infant baptism no sacrament at all and that only the adult, capable of dis-
cretion and accountability, qualified for the ceremony as a symbol of regeneration.3 They, in fact,
‘preferred the name of Brüder (Brethren), in German-speaking areas, and Doopsgezinde (bap-
tism-minded) in the Low Countries’ (Weaver, 1987: 19). They denied the authority of the church
as an institution; theirs was a community of believers, a ‘gathered church.’ Believing themselves
to be saints on earth forming a Gemeinschaft der heilligen (community of the godly), and thus
assured of their salvation, the Anabaptists refused to conform to secular government, the govern-
ment for the ‘sinners.’ Hence they refused to bear arms, swear oaths in the court of law, or par-
ticipate in government. At the same time they believed that they should resist the forces of
secular power not by a show of violence but by forbearing all tribulations with fortitude and
courage.
The Anabaptists were keen on ‘imitating’ Christ in their everyday life.4 Simply put, their outlook
on their Christian identity was uncomplicated and unencumbered by the abstract theological ideas
of those of whom Menno Simons (1496–1561) called the ‘learned ones.’ A true Christian must seek
to realize his truth not in doctrine or exegesis but through praxis, through the experience of taking
up the cross of Christ and following him all through life to death. Within the Anabaptist ‘church,’
a strict sort of democracy and equality applied. Omnia sunt communia – ‘all things are common’
– was the motto of these people who believed in a strict communality of goods (Gütergemeinschaft)
described in the second chapter of the Act of Apostles. For the Anabaptists ‘it is not “faith alone”
which matters . . . but it is brotherhood . . . as the way to God’s kingdom’ (Friedman, 1944: 121).
Each believer was both priest to his fellow believer and missionary to the unbelievers.

Downloaded from jas.sagepub.com at WESTERN OREGON UNIVERSITY on January 7, 2013

Sil 3

The great majority of the Anabaptists were poor and uneducated, but nearly everybody was
convinced that the end of the world was at hand, that God was about to usher in the millennium or
thousand-year rule of the saints predicted in the Book of Revelation, and that, unlike the Catholics,
Calvinists, or Lutherans, they were God’s chosen people, the instruments of his inscrutable will.
The Nuremberg printer and itinerant bookseller Hans Hergot (d. 1527) had prophesized before his
execution in 1527 ‘the coming of the third age of the world, the rule of the Holy Spirit which would
eliminate all nobility, destroy the wealth of the monasteries, and inaugurate the age of the common
man’ (cited in Spitz, 1985: 173). The Anabaptists courted martyrdom and developed a theology of
suffering with the conviction that ‘suffering is the way, the door and the means to God.’ As one of
them put it, ‘a Christian without suffering is like an untrained doctor’ (cited in Littell, 2001: 132).
The Dutch Anabaptist martyr Janneken van Munstdorp wrote to her little daughter, also named
Janneken, on 10 August 1573 from her confinement in Antwerp, Belgium, prior to her execution at
the stake on 6 October: ‘Be not ashamed of us; it is . . . the narrow way which leads into eternal
life, for there shall no other way be found by which to be saved’ (Janz, 2008: 231).
Basing itself on the fundamental tenets of ancient Hindu tantrism, the Ananda Marga Pracharaka
Samgha (The Organization to Propagate the Path of Bliss) was founded by Prabhatranjan Sarkar alias
Shri Shri Anandamurti (1921–1990), an erstwhile clerk of the Indian Railways at Jamalpur, Bihar on
7 November 1955. The postwar and postindependence era of the Indian Republic was marked by an
atmosphere of anxiety, insecurity, and a sense of dislocation following industrialization and the
consequent breakdown of tradition and custom.5 This is what a follower of Ananda Marga described
as a ‘psycho-social crisis’ (Sunday, 1982; see also Sarkar, 1968b; Avadhuta, 1985: 41–43).
The Ananda Marga questions the spiritual base of traditional Hindu religion and practices.
Rituals, prayers, pilgrimages and the like, which have a pervasive influence on the average Indian,
are regarded by Sarkar as aspects of what he calls ‘geo-religion’ (earthy religion) or ‘pseudo-
religion’ (upadharma; Sarkar, 1982: 24–25; see also Anandamurti, 1985: 170–171). He is likewise
opposed to the various Hindu gods and goddesses whom he regards as ‘wholly created by human
beings, maintained by human beings’ (Sarkar, 1985: 27). While recognizing that ‘dharma is the
main current of human life,’ he seeks to offer a

comprehensive ideology which provides definite, clear-cut and bold directions for all aspects of human
life – from one’s personal daily routine, to one’s social activities and collective motivation, to the spiritual
inspiration which brings one closer and closer to God. (Anandamurti, 1985: 165–166)

This ideology – that is, theology – is predicated upon a belief in the existence of a Supreme
Consciousness or the Parama Purusa – the demiurge of the universe – to whom all human beings
must strive to return. Sadhana is thus ‘the process of returning home.’ And ‘it is a simple task. It
requires no scholarship, no knowledge, no intellectual faculty, no long and tedious lecturing’
(Sarkar, 1985: 17). All one needs is devotion, feeling of oneness with the people of the world, a
strictly moral life, and above all, a genuine master – sadguru. Sarkar admonished his adherents:
‘We should not forget even for a moment that this whole animate world is a large family in which
nature has not assigned any property to any particular individual’ (Sarkar, 1985: 130). In fact his
theory of society envisions a global family in which no hoarding but the accumulation of spiritual
wealth is encouraged (p. 132). The leader of the Ananda Marga exhorted his flock:

Today I extend my earnest request to all reasonably virtuous and moral fighters that they form a good,
well-disciplined sadbipra [perfect adept] society without further delay….These sadbipras will work for
the good of all countries, for the all-round emancipation of all humanity. (Sarkar, 1985: 162)

Downloaded from jas.sagepub.com at WESTERN OREGON UNIVERSITY on January 7, 2013

4 Journal of Asian and African Studies 0(0)

Yet neither the Ananda Marga nor the Anabaptists eschewed, albeit to an extent appeared to sub-
vert, the mainline scriptures of their respective faiths. In other words, the former belonged to Hindu
religion and the latter to Christianity, though both were seen as apostate or heretic by the main-
stream Hindus and Christians (Catholic as well as Protestant) and subjected to discrimination and
persecution (Wright, 1998: 95–114). But they considered themselves as the upholders of authentic
creed of their respective religions. As a distinguished Mennonite scholar maintains, the central
theme of Anabaptism – the church as a disciplined community of adult believers and followers of
Christ – ‘depicts an outlook running through the entire history of Christianity’ (Weaver, 1987: 113).
In fact, the cardinal creed of Anabaptism, adult or believer’s baptism is predicated squarely on the
New Testament Matthew 5: 19, Matthew 28, Mark 16, James 2 (Hübmaier, 1526, in Janz, 1982:
147–156). An erstwhile Benedictine monk turned Anabaptist and the formulator of the Anabaptist
creed at Schleitheim, Michael Sattler, stated at his trial following his arrest in May 1527:

Send for the most learned men and for the sacred books of the Bible in whatsoever language they may be
and let them confer with us in the Word of God. If they prove to us with the Holy Scripture that we err and
are in the wrong, we will gladly desist and recent. (Cited in Williams and Mergel, 1957: 141–142)

Nevertheless, the Anabaptists’ insistence on the right of interpretation of God’s Word tended to
isolate them. One scholar viewed Anabaptists’ emphasis on ‘the inspiration and authority of
Scripture, personal commitment to Christ, correct belief, separation of church and state, and high
personal and corporate morality’ as a variety of fundamentalism (Williams and Mergel, 1957: 115;
Weaver’s summary of the views of a leading Mennonite historian, John Horsch, 1951: 29–36).
In the Indian context, the Ananda Marga movement may be an echo of the 19th-century meas-
sianic movements of the primitive tribes such as the Mundas and the Santals of Chotanagpur in
north-eastern Madhya Pradesh (central provinces of India), the Oraons and the Gonds of Nagpur in
eastern Madhya Pradesh (central provinces), and the Lusheis and the Kacha Nagas of Assam and
the northeast frontier provinces (Fuchs, 1965). More importantly, the tradition of Hindu revivalism
of the late 19th century provided a direct inspiration and template for Sarkar’s sect. Hindu revival-
ists such as Swami Vivekananda (1863–1902), Balgangadhar Tilak (1856–1920), Sri Aurobindo
(1872–1950), Bipinchandra Pal (1858–1932), or Sahajananda Swami (Swaminarayan, 1781–1830)
had attempted ‘to blend religious with socio-economic values to foster a revived sense of commu-
nity and ultimately to espouse nationalism.’ The revivalists insisted on what they considered the
correct principles of dharma (religion) to regulate the individual’s social, political, and economic
responsibilities and the principles of karma (philosophy of activism) to enhance his willed actions.
Their larger concern was ‘to create a life-affirming orientation.’ At the same time, ‘like millennial
movements in Europe, the political character of Indian revivalism derived much from the impor-
tance of preparing for salvation’ (Anderson and Damle, 1987: 13–14; see also Williams, 1984). It
will not be out of place to note that the ochre (the color of gerua, the traditional outfit of a monk or
an ascetic) robe clad activists of the Ananda Marga harked back to the Sannyasi Rebellion (revolt
of the monks) in the 1770s.
Sarkar’s writings (especially 1985, 1986, and 1990) are replete with multiple injunctions and
instructions with a view to teaching the familiar tantric principles (see Gupta, Hoens, and Goudriaan,
1979; Urban, 2000, 2003). His definition of Practical Tantra as the way to harmonize spirituality
with worldly concerns echoes Swami Vivekananda’s concept of Practical Vedanta or Neo-Vedanta
that makes God-consciousness a useful tool for the material and moral upliftment of the people at
large (see the articles by Swami Gambhirananda, 129–142, Brahmachari Medhachaitanya, 169–
183, and Rabindrakumar Dasgupta, 184–197 in Lokeshwarananda, 1385 BE). Similarly, Sarkar’s

Downloaded from jas.sagepub.com at WESTERN OREGON UNIVERSITY on January 7, 2013

Sil 5

idea of the sadbipra, Marga’s dedicated activists, was derived from Bankimchandra Chattopadhyay’s
(1838–1894) imaginary militant-patriots, the santans (sons of Mother India) in his famous novel
Anandamath (The Abbey of Bliss, 1880–1882) or Vivekananda’s sannyasi social activists (ascetic
warriors; Sil, 2003: 22). Most importantly, the Ananda Marga adepts employed the Bhagavadgita
(the chapter on the philosophy of karma in the epic Mahabharata used by numerous religious
preachers and leaders as well as politicians and patriots of India before Sarkar) to legitimize their
reformulations, just as the Anabaptists relied on the Word of God, the Bible.
There is a marked disparity between the nature and intellectual contents of the theological foun-
dations of the two movements. Unlike the founders of Anabaptism, who were well-educated clas-
sical humanists, the founder of the Ananda Marga hailed from a humble background and was a
college dropout, whose writings and preachings are products of his personal education and enlight-
enment. Hence his theological writings contain an amazing amalgam of some scriptural insights
and much dubious hermeneutics, and even fanciful accounts passing for history. Reportedly an
initiated tantrika since 1939, Sarkar would like to invoke the efficacy of Tantra which he defines,
following the traditional tantric lingo, as ‘the fundamental spiritual science’ facilitating ‘the pro-
cess of transforming animality or latent divinity into the Supreme Divinity’ (Sarkar, 1985: 25–26;
see also Avadhuta, 1985: 30).
But his tantrism seems to comprehend both Vaisnava Tantra with its emphasis on Krishna and
kirtana and the Shaiva Tantra with its Shiva, yoga, tandava, and sadhana. Like all tantrikas, he
believes in the existence of Supreme Consciousness or a Parama Purusa who could be realized
through sadhana. This heterodox tantrism is a bit of a muddle in that it absorbs the practices
(achara) of two traditionally rival varieties of tantrikas. Then the Parama Purusa, the Supreme
Noumenon, is reduced, unwittingly, to an actual human being who is god-like. Sarkar makes Shiva
and Krishna historical as well as metaphysical entities – Shiva being devatmanam devata (God of
gods) and the ‘embodiment of Supreme Consciousness’ (Anandamurti, 1985: 37, 205), Krishna
having descended ‘from the universal body of the Supreme Entity’ (Anandamurti, 1981: 225). The
inevitable conclusion is that some superhuman beings are incarnations of God and this conclusion
is predicated upon the argument that people create gods out of those men on whom they depend in
all respects (Anandamurti, 1985: 41).
Sarkar’s preference for Tantra appears to be inspired by his belief that its scriptures not only
‘describe [the] qualities of an ideal guru’ who is ‘self-controlled . . . modest; soberly dressed; of
exemplary conduct; well-established in society; pure in body and mind; adept in both spiritual
theory and spiritual practice; superbly intelligent,’ but also endowed with ‘the qualities of an ideal
disciple: tranquil; modest and humble; of pure soul; having reverence; capable of receiving ideas
clearly; competent and ever ready to carry out the guru’s command’ (Sarkar, 1986: 79–80). This
emphasis on the qualities of a guru is typically tantric (Hoens, 1979: 74–80). Sarkar’s emphasis on
the rational and secular qualities of a spiritual mentor ultimately points to a distinct nexus between
guru and god. Having proclaimed ‘Brahma Himself is the Guru. There cannot be any special Guru’
(Sarkar, 1986: 78), he then goes to the extent of claiming that ‘it is [God] . . . who is teaching you
sadhana in the guise of Guru’ (Sarkar, 1985: 75).
Sarkar’s other weakness lies in his idiosyncratic interpretation of the history of ancient Bengal
and Hindu gods. He believes that Rahd, corresponding to the area of present West Bengal, had
existed eons before the birth of the Himalayas and was the cradle of human civilization (sabhyatar
adivindu). The historians of ancient Bengal, who never posited the existence of a pre-Vedic devel-
oped culture in the area, would be horrified by Sarkar’s claim for the primacy and centrality of
Bengali culture in the history of human civilization. At most, experts hold a cautious and modest
opinion that the Homo Alpinus that ‘forms the main element in the composition of the present

Downloaded from jas.sagepub.com at WESTERN OREGON UNIVERSITY on January 7, 2013

6 Journal of Asian and African Studies 0(0)

Bengalis . . . possessed a higher degree of civilization’ (Majumdar, 1974: 22; Sarkar, 1982; see also
Ghosh, 1948; Roy, 1966).
Sarkar also provides a thunderous account of Shiva. Oblivious of the concept of the Vedic Rudra
who became identified with the post-Vedic Shiva representing the abstract noumenon in the con-
crete world of transitory phenomena, he writes that Shiva was actually a human being called
Sadashiva (an appellation of Shiva favored by the Agama tantrikas of southern and eastern India
and a popular masculine name in Bengal, albeit spelt as ‘Sadashib’) who was born some 7,000
years ago. He was also ‘the first person to marry.’ With a view to ‘removing the distinctions among
the members of society,’ he took three wives: ‘Parvatii, a fiar-complexioned Aryan girl; and Kalii,
a dark-complexioned non-Aryan girl; and Gaunga, yellow-complexioned Mongolian girl.’ Shiva
and Parvati begat a son called Bhairava (actually another name of Shiva) who was an ‘ardent spiri-
tualist, a Tantric sadhaka’ (Anandamurti, 1985: 7–8, 47, 233, orthography as in original).6 Shiva
apparently visited Sarkar’s imagined paradise of Rahd to spread Shaiva dharma (Sarkar, 1962a: 6).
The validity or legitimacy of this account cannot be ascertained by any other means than sheer
faith. Further, Sarkar combines the two of the three principal divisions of tantrism – Vaisnava and
Shaiva – the former in its typical Bengali Vaisnava-Sahajiya variety with its erotic mysticism and
the latter with its esoteric spiritual exercises with a generous dose of the tantric metaphysical con-
cept of a cosmic entity in order to concoct the elixir of his Amritavani (Nectar of Speech).
Sarkar is silent on the most popular variety of Tantra – the Shakta Tantra. He has little to say
about the tantric dualism of Shiva and Shakti, the male and female principles. In fact his ethnic
home Bengal (though he was born and brought as an adolescent in the state of Bihar) has tradition-
ally been considered as an important center of the Shakta tantrikas, practicers of the Shakti cult
(cult of the Mother Goddess). His innovative tantrism without due reference and deference to
Shakti and yet his publicly proclaimed concerns for women’s liberation from social repression and
for elevating their status in society reveal his attempt to reconcile his contradictory project to
detach his new spirituality from traditional tantrism while aligning with the traditional tantric
emphasis on gender equality (Sarkar, 1985: 195; Prout Writers Group, 1986: 29–30). While his
personal bias for the history and culture of Bengal and his theology rooted in Tantra lead him to
exalt the position of women, his ambition to propagate a new religion prompts him to devalue the
status of the Mother Goddess in favor of the male gods, Shiva and Krishna. Thus he does not
appear to share the tantrikas’ ‘genuine awe for the female as the seat of reproduction, the source of
all life.’ On the contrary, he posits a new thesis that ‘the role of Purusa is foremost in all spheres’
and that ‘Prakriti only acts whatever extent the Purusa has authorized or authorizes her to act’
(Gupta, Hoens, and Goudriaan, 1979: 34 [also 33, 154ff]; Sarkar, 1984a: 3).
Although Sarkar’s sermons are generally conducted in Bengali and Hindi, he often uses English
to render them intelligible to non-Bengalis as well as to foreigners. For example, the following
furnishes a sample in this regard; it is how God is defined:

The supreme Entity, the Parama Purusa created everything. He is the generator: the first letter of generator
is G. He is the operator of everything: the first letter operator is O . . . He destroys, the first letter is D.
G-O-D. The word is God. (Sarkar, 1986: 28)

He also uses an idiosyncratic vocabulary. Thus the term atman (usually translated and understood
as individual soul) is rendered as ‘that which is omnitelepathic.’ Likewise, phrases such as ‘proto-
spiritualistic systaltic movement,’ ‘maximities,’ ‘laterite’ (meaning ‘derived from books’), ‘circ-
umrotarian universe,’ ‘subjective approach objective adjustment,’ ‘geosentiment,’ ‘geo-religion’
(meaning ‘narrow parochial sentiment and religion’), ‘spiritual pabula,’ or ‘macro-psychic

Downloaded from jas.sagepub.com at WESTERN OREGON UNIVERSITY on January 7, 2013

Sil 7

conation’ are frequently and frivolously used in a number of treatises and speechs of the Anandamurti
(Sarkar, 1982, 1984a, 1985).7 It is not easy to stomach Sarkar’s ‘neo-humanist philosophy’ with its
concern for ‘a direct link with the cosmological hub, a direct link with the existential nucleus of the
cosmological order’ (Sarkar, 1982: 109–110).
Though among the Anabaptists there were spiritualists and evangelical rationalists such as Hans
Denck, Ludwig Hätzer, Pilgrim Marpeck (d. 1556), Sebastian Franck (1499–1543), Kasper
Schwenckfeld (1490–1561), or Miguel Serveto (1511–1553), who arrived at their theological ideas
by the study of the sources and the patristic writers, there were also a great many of them who were
enthusiasts (Schwärmer), who held mystical and millenarian vision, men such as the Swabian fur-
rier Melchior Hoffman (1495–1543), the Haarlem baker Jan Matthys (d. 1534), the Leiden tailor
cum stage actor Jan Beukels or Bockelson (1509–1536), or the Moravian hatmaker Jakob Hutter,
among others. However, both the spiritualist-rationalists and the spiritualist-enthusiasts among the
Anabaptists emphasized the efficacy of ‘inner spirit’ rather than God’s Word. According to them,
revelation came neither from the Bible nor from such external rituals as water baptism or the sacra-
ments but from the illumination given to each man by God directly, speaking to him personally and
privately (Dipple, 2011: 257–298). All of them – mystics and militants alike – held an apocalyptic
vision of a new world built on the annihilation of the existing one of unbelievers and sinners.
Claiming that ‘the highest treasure of human beings . . . is their intellectual superiority,’ Sarker
distinguishes between right intellect and one that ‘is not moving on the right path.’ His ‘right intel-
lect’ amounts to recognizing the efficacy of devotion with a view to pleasing the Supreme
Consciousness. He thus exhorts his disciples that ‘learning or knowledge or any other asset is not
necessary except only two things – implicit faith and sincerity’ (Sarkar 1985: 68, 72–73). The
instruments to inspire devotion are sadhana and kirtana (congregational prayer through ecstatic
choral singing of divine glory accompanied by drums and cymbals and synchronized with rhyth-
mic bodily movements), which help to concentrate physical and psychic powers with a view to
‘getting inspiration from Parama Purusa’ (Sarkar, 1986: 155). Sarkar’s preachings in this respect
strongly resemble those of Sahajiya tantrikas of Bengal who believe that ‘the truth . . . can never
be known by the scholars for, what comes within the scope of our mind, can never be the absolute
truth’ (Dasgupta, 1962: 53, punctuations modified). Like some Anabaptists who emphasized inner
revelation, the Ananda Marga believe in sadhana, teaching the devotees how to ‘dive into this
wave of the Supreme’ (Sarkar, 1985: 31).
Since their inception, the Swiss Brethren were hounded by the Protestant reformers, not to men-
tion the Catholics. They were primarily harmless folk and their following constituted a tiny minor-
ity of very educated and conscientious pastors and scholars, while the vast majority of their
followers came from humbler stock. Especially during 1527–1533, nearly a thousand of them
perished in the Habsburg lands. The magisterial reformers as well as the Roman Catholics held the
Brethren in utter contempt for their beliefs in adult baptism and the Eucharist as well as their life-
style. The established churches, Catholic as well as Protestant, had always upheld the traditional
social order sustained by royal and hierarchical power and thus the individual autonomy and vol-
untarism supported by the Anabaptists were galling to the establishment monarchical as well as
clerical (see Pearce, 1993). Nicholas Lesse (fl. 1548–1550), a distinguished translator of Augustine’s
(354–430) A worke of the predestination of saintes (1550), declared: ‘[These] anabaptysts and
frewyl masters are so mych more daungerouse, as ther myschefe is cloked with a dobl face of holi-
ness ten tymes more religious . . . than were [th]e superstitious & arrogant papystes’ (cited in Euler,
2006: 212).
The sect also incurred the wrath of the Holy Roman Emperor Charles V (r. 1519–1555).
Persecuted from all sides, the Anabaptists turned defensive and eschatological. Two Anabaptist

Downloaded from jas.sagepub.com at WESTERN OREGON UNIVERSITY on January 7, 2013

8 Journal of Asian and African Studies 0(0)

leaders launched vigorous eschatological movements. Jakob Hutter, the ‘Hercules of the
Anabaptists,’ succeeded in gathering a large following in Moravia and, though he was executed by
the Austrian authorities, the Hutterites emerged for a time to be a powerful radical reformist sect to
reckon with. Another much more violent chiliastic organizer, Jan Beukels of Leiden, set up a New
Jerusalem in the nearby north German city of Münster. He proclaimed himself king in the fashion
of King David of Israel but was ultimately overpowered in June 1535 by the combined army of the
Catholic prince-bishop of the city Franz von Waldeck (1491–1553) and the imperial force.8 King
Jan met with a violent death, thus maligning the reputation of the Anabaptists until they recovered
from their beleaguered situation under the sober and sedulous leadership of another Dutchman
Menno Simons.
A follower of Hoffman, Menno emerged as the recognized leader of the Dutch Anabaptists fol-
lowing the end of Jan Beukels’s Münster madness of 1536. He had begun as an ordained priest of
the Church Universal at his hometown of Witmarsum since 1524 and begun to be concerned about
the efficacy of two major Catholic sacraments – infant baptism and Eucharist based on the theol-
ogy of transubstantiation – for which he found no scriptural imprimatur. However, ‘it was not
Menno’s doubts, but events related to Münster which finally compelled him to renounce the Roman
church’ (Weaver, 1987: 97). He quit his job and left the town in 1536, published an influential tract
The Foundation of the Christian Doctrine in 1539, got married, and relocated to Oldersum, became
quite prominent among the Melchiorite faction of the Anabaptists in the 1540s, and established
himself permanently at Wüstenfeld, between Lübeck and Hamburg in 1554, dying on 30 January
1561. His numerous tracts, especially The Foundation, ‘became one of his chief tools in the gather-
ing of the Melchiorites into a more unified and stable Anabaptist movement’ (Weaver, 1987: 98).
In fact, Menno’s name became synonymous with the newly organized and invigorated Anabaptist
movement in south Germany, Switzerland, and subsequently in the New World.
The Mennonite reforming sect, the Amish, led by the Swiss Mennonite Jacob Amman (c. 1656–
c. 1730), settled in Switzerland and the southern Rhine River region and subsequently migrated to
North America in the 18th century, settling in Pennsylvania. They remain a successful, peaceful,
and productive community retaining much of their traditional lifestyle, albeit adjusting to the tech-
nological and industrial society of their adopted country. However, another sect, the Baptists, an
off-shoot of the continental Reformation but founded by an English Separatist John Smyth (1570–
1612) in Amsterdam, grew to be a vast global congregation with over 41 million members in
150,000 congregations all over the world.
There may be several reasons why the Ananda Marga zealots did not quite succeed in enlisting
the support of the middle and upper classes of Indian society, especially West Bengal, until the last
decades of the past century. Their reputation in the 1970s and 1980s for preaching ‘power through
violence . . . mingled with ritual murder and mutilation’ (Naipaul, 1977: 62)9 kept them away from
the general rung of middle and upper-middle classes and failed to elicit government protection for
the sect. Especially Marga’s ideology is poised against both communism and capitalism, the for-
mer deemed as too repressive and oppressive and the latter too libertarian and anarchic (see Kumar,
1987: 15–16). No prominent political party of India in the 1970s and 1980s – Congress (I; Indira
Congress) or CPI (M; Communist Party of India, Marxist), or even BJP (Bharatiya Janata Party)
– was disposed to put up with another ideology that threatens to become a mass movement, particu-
larly in view of the social activities of the Marga in the rural areas. In fact, the government of Mrs
Indira Gandhi banned the sect during the Emergency Government (1975–1977) and incarcerated
Sarkar, but his conviction was overturned on 4 July 1978. Subsequently the ban was lifted by the
Supreme Court of India in 1996 and the sect was also recognized as a legitimate religious group in
the same year. Since the globalization and liberalization trend of India’s economy and the

Downloaded from jas.sagepub.com at WESTERN OREGON UNIVERSITY on January 7, 2013

Sil 9

consequent relaxation of political and cultural constraints, the Andna Marga has reaped the benefits
accruing from these developments to be shaped as a multinational organization.
However, the Ananda Marga movement redeemed itself in the 1980s and 1990s and even began
to earn global renown in respect of Sarkar’s theory of social cycles and of Progressive Utilization
of Resources (PROUT) popularized in the West, especially by an Indian professor of economics in
the United States (US), Dr Ravi Batra. The central theme of Proutism (announced since 1959) is
maximum utilization of all resources – physical and psychological – in order to build a new global
society that harmonizes technological and spiritual progress of mankind (Batra, 1980; Kumar,
1987). Especially Sarkar’s theory of social cycles (Sarkar, 1968a) that complements Proutism, was
utilized by Batra in his sensational blockbuster with its prophetic prognostication of an impending
global depression and messianic panacea to combat it (Batra, 1987).
Admittedly, the theory of human society and social cycles has little originality or historical valid-
ity, it being a restatement, with some adjustments, of the familiar Hindu cosmogonical calculations
and, more recently, in Vivekananda’s theory of social evolution (Sarkar, 1967).10 Nevertheless,
Batra’s analysis of Sarkar’s theory of Prout reveals some measure of economic and ecological con-
sciousness. In this era of wanton consumerism, the Marga’s emphasis on maximum utilization must
be welcomed as the right socio-economic creed, even though some critics, perhaps with some jus-
tification, have been skeptical about its validity (Williams, 1983: 157). Indeed, as an Ananda Marga
spokesman claims, the Prout movement ‘is established in over 160 countries around the world and
runs hundreds of schools, welfare centers and relief project’ (Kumar, 1987: Introduction: 1).

Conclusion
Both the Anabaptists and the Ananda Marga espouse an amalgam of millenary vision and social-
economic ameliorative mission. Even though the former appears to be an ‘introversionist’ sect that
depends on its community life and spiritual exercises that confer a ‘transcendent holiness’ upon its
members (Wilson, 1970: 118–119), it has learnt to cooperate and co-exist with the larger society
and as law-abiding citizens of their state. The Ananda Marga, however, has been able to align
themselves with the state by their increasing involvement in socio-economic and relief work
throughout the world. In a number of treatises and in numerous sermons, Sarkar unfailingly urged
his followers to be aware of universal love, spiritual upliftment, and to prepare for a relentless
endeavor to provide material comfort to all men and women of the world (Sarkar, 1962b, 1967,
1968b, 1973, 1984b). As he observed, ‘it is unwise to leave the world, to leave service to humanity
and to go to the Himalayas to attain the Supreme Consciousness – where will you go by leaving it?’
(Sarkar, 1985: 67; see also Sarkar, 1962, 1973, 1984b). The Ananda Marga began their educational
program, the Gurukula, on 7 September 1990 at Ananda Nagar in West Bengal. The Gurukula
boasts over a thousand schools all over India and even a few countries abroad. The sect’s other
venture, The Ananda Marga Association of Yoga (AMAY), was launched in 2006. To reiterate, the
Ananda Marga, much like the Anabaptists, is ‘spirituality of life,’ and indeed a sensible resolution
of the problem of hyper-individualistic esoteric sadhana preached by the Hindu and Christian
saints and sants by ‘interweaving symbols of social content into the network of interiorized wor-
ship’ (Goudriaan, 1979: 3–12; Gupta, Hoens, and Goudriaan, 1979: 29).
This comparatist study shows a few interesting features. First of all, the history of the Anabaptists
and the Ananda Marga defies neat categorization. Admittedly, both sects manifested a few features
of what Bromley has labeled New Religious Movement in that they organized themselves ‘as tight-
knit communities that distance themselves from a world they conclude[d] is corrupt and moribund’
(Bromley, 1998: 38). Both movements also sought to bring about some cohesion and renewal of

Downloaded from jas.sagepub.com at WESTERN OREGON UNIVERSITY on January 7, 2013

10 Journal of Asian and African Studies 0(0)

the traditional simple moral life and formulated their alternative paradigm of values. But while the
successors to the Anabaptists, the modern day Amish and some Baptists, have their distinct dress
code like the members of the Ananda Marga and maintain their sectarian lifestyle, they have thrived
by their adjustments and restructuring within their respective organizations to cooperate with the
state and by pursuing fruitful social and economic projects. Especially the Ananda Marga has suc-
ceeded tremendously in recent years as a truly global and multinational association that has earned
for their The Ananda Marga Universal Relief Team (AMURT, 1965) the recognition as an NGO
(non-governmental organization) by the United Nations in 1991. Indeed, both Bryan Wilson in
1979 and Chris Kang in 2000 observed with uncanny perspicacity that the Ananda Marga’s ethic
and ethos could be transferred to a wider public and that the sect possesses the potential to be
incorporated into the larger human collective (Wilson, 1979: 110–111; Kang, 2000: 23).

Acknowledgements
Earlier versions of this paper were published in 1988 in Quarterly Review of Historical Studies (Kolkata) and
Asian Culture Quarterly (Taipei; Sil, 1988, 1988–1989). All citations from Bengali sources appear in my
translation, unless otherwise stated.

Notes
  1. This study uses some materials for the Ananda Marga in Bengali that remain inaccessible to scholars in the
West. These were procured by the author from the Ananda Marga office, Eastern Bypass, Calcutta in September
1987 and have been used for the first time by this author in two earlier articles in 1988 (Sil, 1988, 1988–1989).
  2. Constraints of space do not allow a comparison between the Ananda Marga and the Ramakrishna Order
– this calls for a separate study.
  3. The best statement of the Anabaptist view of adult baptism remains Balthasar Hübmaier (c. 1480–1528),
a distinguished scholar of Ingolstadt and later a preacher of Waldshut (see Hübmaier, 1525: 65–98; see
also Foley, 1999).
 4. For a succinct scholarly estimate of the Anabaptist movement see Haude (2002: 237–256) and
MacCulloch (2003: 167–171, 204–212). For detailed accounts see Weaver (1987), Estep (1996) and
Goertz (1996). The Anabaptists split into three major groups: the Swiss and south German Anabaptists,
the Mennonites (after Menno Simons) in north Germany and Holland, and Hutterites (after Jakob Hutter,
c. 1500–1536) in Moravia.
  5. The debasement of traditional Indian culture is called apasanskriti in Sarkar (1982: 59).
  6. For a scholarly understanding of Shiva see Zimmer (1963, ch. 4: 123–188; Jones, 2004: 8414–8420).
  7. Sarkar often manufactures Sanskrit sounding words out of colloquial Bengali. The most glaring exam-
ples of this mongrel language are: ‘ajibanang bhatkapadam svaha’ (Sarkar, 1962: 25) and ‘shitkale
bhabedusna’ (Anandamurti, 1985: 47). The two Bengali words in italics appear in colloquial Bengali and
mean ‘food and clothing’ and ‘during winter’ respectively.
  8. For a credible biography of Jan Beukels, see Arthur (1999).
  9. For a very informative and balanced estimate of Ananda Marga’s alleged association with violence, see
Crovetto (2008).
10. For a brief but useful explanation of the Hindu cosmology and cosmogony, especially the Hindu concept
of the cosmic time, see Zimmer (1963: 11–19). See also Pargiter (1922: 175–179).

References
Anandamurti SS (1981) Namami Krishnasundaram [I Bow to the Beautiful Krishna], trans. Acharya Vijay-
ananda Avadhuta. Purulia: Ananda Marga Pracharaka Samgha.
Anandamurti SS (1985) Namah Shivaya Shantaya [I Bow to the Serene Shiva], trans. Acharya Vijayananda
Avadhuta et al. (2nd edition). Calcutta: Ananda Marga Pracharaka Samgha.

Downloaded from jas.sagepub.com at WESTERN OREGON UNIVERSITY on January 7, 2013

Sil 11

Anderson WK and Damle SD (1987) The Brotherhood in Saffron: The Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh and
Hindu Revivalism. New Delhi: Vistar Publications.
Arthur A (1999) The Tailor-King: The Rise and Fall of the Anabaptist Kingdom of Münster. New York:
Thomas Dunne Books.
Avadhuta S (1985) Sambhavami. Calcutta: Sevadharma Mission.
Barkun M (1974) Disaster and the Millennium. New York: Syracuse University Press.
Batra R (1980) Prout: The Alternative to Capitalism and Marxism. Lanham, MD: University Press of
America.
Batra R (1987) The Great Depression of 1990 (Revised edition). New York: Simon & Schuster.
Bowsma WJ (1980) Anxiety and the formation of early modern culture. In: Malament C (ed.) After the Ref-
ormation: Essays in Honor of J.H. Hexter. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press, 215–246.
Bromley DG (1998) The social construction of contested exit roles: Defectors, whistleblowers, and apostate.
In: Bromley DG (ed.) The Politics of Religious Apostasy: The Role of Apostates in the Transformation of
Religious Movements. Westport, CT: Praeger Publishers, 19–48.
Crovetto H (2008) Ananda Marga and the use of force. Nova Religio: The Journal of Alternative and Emer-
gent Religion 12(1): 25–56.
Dasgupta S (1962) Obscure Religious Cults (2nd edition). Calcutta: Firma KL Mukhopadhyay.
Dipple G (2011) The spiritualist Anabaptists. In: Roth JD, Stayer JM (eds) A Companion to Anabaptism and
Spiritualism. Leiden: EJ Brill, 257–298.
Estep WR (1996) The Anabaptist Story: An Introduction to Sixteenth-Century Anabaptism (3rd revised edi-
tion). Cambridge: Wm Eerdmans Publishing Co.
Euler C (2006) Couriers of the Gospel: England and Zurich, 1531–1558. Zürich: Theologische Verlag.
Foley T (1999) The Anabaptim of Balthasar Hubmaier. Anabaptism Today 22 (Autumn): 14–22.
Friedman R (1944) On Mennonite historiography and on individualism and brotherhood. Mennonite Quar-
terly Review 18(2): 117–122.
Fuchs S (1965) Messianic movements in primitive India. Asian Folklore Studies 24(1): 11–62.
Ghosh JC (1948) Bengali Literature. London: Oxford University Press.
Goertz H-J (1996) The Anabaptists. New York: Routledge.
Goudriaan T (1979) Introduction, history and philosophy. In: Gupta S, Hoens DJ, Goudriaan T (eds) Hindu
Tantrism. Leiden: EJ Brill, 3–12.
Gupta S, Hoens DJ and Goudriaan T (eds) (1979) Hindu Tantrism. Leiden: EJ Brill.
Haude S (2002) The Anabaptism. In: Pettegree A (ed.) The Reformation World. London: Routledge, 237–256.
Heelas P (2009) Spiritualities of Life: New Age Romanticism and Consumptive Capitalism. Hoboken, NJ:
Wiley.
Hoens DJ (1979) Transmission and fundamental constituents of the practice. In: Gupta S, Hoens DJ and
Goudriaan T (eds) Hindu Tantrism. Leiden: EJ Brill, 74–80.
Horsch J (1951) The background and heritage of the Mennonite church. Sword and Trumpet 19(1): 29–36.
Hübmaier B (1525) On the Christian baptism of believers. In: Estep WR (ed.) The Anabaptist Story: An
Introduction to Sixteenth-Century Anabaptism (3rd revised edition). Cambridge: Wm Eerdmans Publish-
ing Co, 65–98.
Janz DR (ed.) (1982) Three Reformation Catechism: Catholic, Anabaptist, Lutheran. Toronto: Edwin Mellen
Press.
Janz DR (ed.) (2008) A Reformation Reader: Primary Texts with Introductions (2nd edition). Minneapolis,
MN: Fortress Press.
Jones L (ed.-in-chief) (2004) Encyclopedia of Religion (Vol. 12). New York: Macmillan Reference.
Kang C (2000) Sarkar and the Buddha’s Four Noble Truths. Paper presented at the Australian Association for
the Study of Religions Annual Conference, Brisbane, 1–29 June.
Kumar J (ed.) (1987) New Aspects of Prout. Calcutta: Proutist Universal Publications.
Less(e) N (1550) Preface to Augustine, A Worke of the Predestination of the Saints, trans. Nicholas Lesse.
London: n. p.
Littell FH (2001) The Anabaptist View of Church. Paris, AR: The Baptist Standard Bearer, Inc.

Downloaded from jas.sagepub.com at WESTERN OREGON UNIVERSITY on January 7, 2013

12 Journal of Asian and African Studies 0(0)

Lokeshwarananda Swami (ed.) (1385 B.E./1384 B.E.) Chintanayak Vivekananda [Vivekananda the Intellec-
tual Leader]. Calcutta: Ramakrishna Mkission Institute of Culture.
MacCulloch D (2003) Reformation: Europe’s House Divided 1490–1700. London: Allen Lane.
Majumdar RC (1974) History of Medieval Bengal. Calcutta: G. Bharadwaj.
Naipaul VS (1977) India: A Wounded Civilization. New York: Vintage Press.
Pargiter FE (1922) Ancient Indian Historical Tradition. London: Oxford University Press.
Pearce M (1993) Fear of ‘Anabaptists’ in sixteenth-century England. Anabaptism Today 3(June): 17–22.
Prout Writers’ Group (1986) Spiritual Vision of Society. Manila: Universal Service Prout.
Roy S (1966) The Roots of Bengali Culture. Calcutta: Eureka Publishers.
Sarkar PR (1962a) Sabhyatar Adibindu: Rahd [Rahd: The Primeval Center of Civilization]. Kalikata: Ananda
Marga Pracharaka Samgha.
Sarkar PR (1962b) Great Universe: Discourse on Society. Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications.
Sarkar PR (1967) Human Society, Part II. Anandanagar: Proutist Universal.
Sarkar PR (1968a) Manuser Samaj I [Human Society]. Purulia: Ananda Marga Pracharaka Samgha.
Sarkar PR (1968b) Problem of the Day, trans., Nardeva Gupta. Purulia: Ananda Marga Pracharaka Samgha.
Sarkar PR (1973) Abhimat [Opinion]. Ananda Nagar: Ananda Marga Publications.
Sarkar PR (1982) Buddhir Mukti: Navyamanavatavad [Liberation of the Intellect: Neo-Humanism]. Calcutta:
Ananda Marga Pracharaka Samgha.
Sarkar PR (1984a) Ananda Sutram [The Blissful Verses] (Revised edition). Calcutta: Ananda Marga Pracha-
raka Samgha.
Sarkar PR (1984b) Idea and Ideology: A Collection of Speeches Delivered to Higher Tattvika Trainees from
27-5-59 to 5-6-59. Calcutta: A P Avadhuta.
Sarkar PR (1985) The Thoughts of P.R. Sarkar, ed. Avadhutika Anandamitra Acharya. Calcutta: Ananda
Marga Pracharaka Samgha.
Sarkar PR (1986) Light Comes, ed. Avadhutika Anandamitra Acharya and Acharya Vijayananda Avadhuta.
Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications.
Sarkar PR (1990) Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Practices, ed. Tarak. Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publica-
tions.
Sil NP (1993) Vivekānanda’s Rāmakrsna: An untold story of mythmaking and propaganda. Numen 40: 38–62.
Sil NP (1988) Anatomy of the Ananda Marga: Hindu Anabaptists. Asian Culture Quarterly 16(2): 1–18.
Sil NP (1988–89) The troubled world of the Ananda Marga: An examination. Quarterly Review of Historical
Studies 27(4): 3–19.
Sil NP (1997) Swami Vivekananda: A Reassessment. Selinsgrove: Susquehanna University Press.
Sil NP (2003) Vivekananda and Nietzsche as critics of western bourgeois civilization. Virginia Review of
Asian Studies 5: 1–23.
Spitz LW (1985) The Protestant Reformation, 1517–1559. St Louis, MO: CPH.
Sunday (1982) 16–22 May. Calcutta.
Urban H (2000) The cult of ecstasy: Tantrism, the new age, and the spiritual logic of late capitalism. History
of Religions 39(3): 268–304.
Urban H (2003) Tantra: Sex, Secrecy, Politics and Power. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Weaver JD (1987) Becoming Anabaptist: The Origin an Significance of Sixteenth-Century Anabaptism.
Scottdale: Herald Press.
Williams JR (1983) Review of Ravi Batra, Prout: Alternative to Capitalism and Marxism, Boston: University
Press of America, 1980 in Religious Studies Review 9(2): 157.
Williams GH and Mergel AM (eds) (1957) Spiritual and Anabaptist Writers. Philadelphia, PA: The West-
minster Press.
Williams R (1984) A New Face of Hinduism: The Swaminarayan Religion. Cambridge: Cambridge Univer-
sity Press.
Wilson BR (1970) Religious Sects: A Sociological Study. New York: McGraw Hill Book Co.
Wilson BR (1979) Contemporary Transformations of Religion. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Downloaded from jas.sagepub.com at WESTERN OREGON UNIVERSITY on January 7, 2013

Sil 13

Wright SA (1998) Exploring factors that shape the Apostate role. In: Bromley DG (ed.) The Politics of Reli-
gious Apostasy: The Role of Apostates in the Transformation of Religious Movements. Westport, CT:
Praeger Publishers, 95–114.
Zimmer H (1963) Myths and Symbols in Indian Art and Civilization, ed. Joseph Campbell. New York: Pan-
theon Books.

Narasingha P Sil, Professor Emeritus of History at Western Oregon University, has a number of publications
in his primary research field: History of Tudor England. His other research interest lies in the area of the
history of late colonial India, especially renascent Bengal. Among his numerous publications in the history
of Bengal the following appeared recently: Crazy in Love of God: Ramakrishna’s Caritas Divina (2009),
“Kali’s Child and Krishna’s Lover: An Anatomy of Ramakrishna’s Caritas Divina” (2009), and “The
Professor and the Paramahamsa: Martin Luther and Ramakrishna Compared” (2011). Sil’s Swami
Vivekananda: A Reassessment (1997) was selected by Choice as an “Outstanding Academic Book” in religion
for 1997.

Downloaded from jas.sagepub.com at WESTERN OREGON UNIVERSITY on January 7, 2013