Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Introduction
Technological development, global warming and the In the biodiesel production from WCOs, both cata-
increase of the environmental pollution have directed lyzed and non-catalyzed alcoholysis reactions have
scientific research towards alternative and ecologically been employed. The homogeneously-catalyzed reaction
acceptable energy resources. One of them, biodiesel, is still most often used for the biodiesel production. Base-
which is a mixture of fatty acid alkyl esters (FAAE) de- catalyzed acoholysis is used for biodiesel synthesis from
rived from different renewable sources rich in triacyl- WCO with the lower content of FFA. Acid catalysts are
glycerols (TAG), has a great significance. The basic suitatable for the biodiesel production from WCOs with
feedstocks for industrial biodiesel production are edible the high FFA content since they simultaneously catalyze
vegetable oils but their usage is restricted by their con- esterification and the alcoholysis reaction [3]. Requiring
sumption in human nutrition and food industry, as well as stronger reaction conditions and longer time for comple-
by their high cost. In order to overcome these limitations, tition, acid-catalyzed methanolysis is less important than
the researchers and biodiesel manufacturers focus their the base-catalyzed reaction [4,5]. Two- step processes
attention on using low-cost feedstocks such as waste for the biodiesel production consisting of acid-catalyzed
cooking oil (WCO). esterification of FFA in WCO and base-catalyzed metha-
WCOs are promising feedstocks for the biodiesel pro- nolysis of the treated oil from the first step are promiss-
duction because of their lower price than that of pure ing for the biodiesel production from WCOs with the high
edible vegetable oils, relatively easy availability and pos- FFA content. The use of acid catalysts allows the FFA
sibility for solving their dumping problems and pollution conversion to alkyl esters, thus reducing the FFA content,
of the water and land resources [1]. An important fact is and the aloholysis of the treated oil over a base catalyst
that the use of WCO as a feedstock reduces the biodies- can be performed. A short review of one- and two-step
el production cost by about 60–70% [1]. Although there processes for FAAE synthesis from WCOs is given in
is a lack of information of the worldwide WCO production, Table 1.
Lam et al. [2] have reported that there is enough WCOs The knowledge of the alcoholysis reaction kinetics is
to be considered as a significant feedstock for the bio- fundamental for the process development and the reac-
diesel production. The biodiesel production from WCOs tor design, operation, scale-up, analysis and control. The
depends on their physico-chemical properties and primar- alcoholysis reaction kinetics is necessary for establish-
ily on their content of free fatty acids (FFAs) and water. ing the mathematical model describing the reaction rate
33
Advanced technologies 4(1) (2015) 33-41
and the product yield. In the studies of homogeneously second order followed by reversible second-order [33-
catalyzed methanolysis two stages are well-recognized. 37].
The initial heterogeneous stage is controlled by the mass The present paper deals with the KOH-catalyzed
transfer rate caused by the incomplete miscibility of the methanolysis of the WCO collected from food cooking
reactants, while the second, pseudo-homogeneous in a local household. The reaction was examined at a
stage is chemically controlled. methanol:WCO molar ratio of 6:1, the initial KOH amount
The kinetics of the methanolysis reaction of various of 1% (based on the oil weight) and moderate tempera-
oily feedstocks is described by different kinetic models. tures (30 oC to 60 oC). The main aim was to model the
Some of them are based on the stepwise reversible alco- reaction kinetics using simple irreversible reaction rate
holysis reaction [17,18] and include the side saponifica- laws like pseudo – first and – second order, and to se-
tion reactions [19]. Recently, the models that assume the lect the more appropriate one with respect of the good-
irreversible overall reaction have been more frueqently ness of fit and accuracy. Furthermore, the obtained ester
used because of their simplicity, no complex computa- product was purified and characterized in order to esti-
tion and good accuracy. The most often used reaction mate its quality for the use as biodiesel.
kinetic models are irreversible pseudo-first order [20-26]
or –second order [22,23,27-32] and irreversible pseudo-
34
Advanced technologies 4(1) (2015) 33-41
Theoretical background where XA is TAG conversion degree, Eqs. (2) and (3)
can be transformed into the following expressions, re-
For the purpose of modeling the kinetics of KOH-cat- spectively:
alyzed methanolysis of WCO, the following assumptions
are introduced: ..........................................................(5)
a) The methanolysis reaction is shown by the following
overall stoichiometric equation: and
........................................................(1) .........................................................(6)
where A is TAG, B is methanol, R is fatty acid methyl where cAo is the initial TAG concentration. Taking into ac-
esters (FAME) and S is glycerol. count the initial reaction condition ( t=0, xA=0 ), the inte-
It is considered that the overall reaction occurs in gration of Eqs. (5) and (6) gives the following equations,
one step, although it actualy occurs via three consecu- respectively:
tive reversible reactions where TAG stepwise converted
in glycerol and FAME. This assumption is proved by ..........................................................(7)
too small concentrations of mono- and diacylglycerols
(MAGs and DAGs, respectively) because of their much and
faster consumption rates in comparison to that of TAGs.
b) Because of the agitation intensity of the reaction .............................................................(8)
mixture, the reaction mixture is considered as a pseu-
do-homogeneous system without the mass transfer
limitation, so the overall process kinetics is chemically The reaction rate constants k1 and k2 can be estimated
controlled [38-40]. Also, the reaction mixture is perfectly from the slope of the linear dependence of and
mixed, ensuring its uniform composition.
c) The methanolysis reaction is an irreversible pseu- on t, respectively.
do–first- or –second order reaction with respect to TAG
[22,23,32]. Because of the excess of methanol and a low
product concentration in the early reaction period, the The significance of the model was statistically evaluated
reverse reactions are negligible. based on the mean relative percent deviation (MRPD)
d) The neutralization reaction of FFAs is ignorable and the coefficient of determination (R2) calculated by
because of their very low content (section 3.1). The sa- Eqs. (9) and (10), respectively:
ponification reaction is also negligible at the low initial
catalyst amount and reaction temperature. Vicente et ...........................................(9)
al. [41] showed that the saponification reactions were
insignificant because it accounted for a FAME yield loss
of no more than 3 mol% when the sunflower oil metha-
nolysis was carried out at 65 oC, using 1% of KOH and a ...................................................(10)
6:1 sunflower oil:methanol molar ratio. We expected the
FAME yield loss to be even lower for the reactions car-
ried out at lower temperatures. where XAp and XAa are predicted and experimental val-
ues of the TAG conversion degree, respectively, XAm is
According to the assumption (c), the TAG conversion the mean value of the TAG conversion degree (%) and n
rate can be expressed as irreversible pseudo-first order is the number of experimental runs.
or –second order kinetic law, respectively:
Materials and methods
........................................................(2)
Materials
and The used WCO was collected in a local household
from food cooking using the commercial sunflower oil.
........................................................(3) The oil was used for several times at the cooking tem-
perature of about 150 °C. The oil density and viscosity,
where k1 and k2 are reaction rate constants for the ir- determined at 20 oC, were 920 g/L and 108 mPa s, re-
reversible pseudo-first and –second order reaction, re- spectively. Having the acid value of 0.36 mg KOH/g, the
spectively, and CA is TAG concentration in the oil phase. WCO could be processed by the KOH-catalyzed metha-
Since: nolysis [42]. The iodine and saponification values of the
.............................................................(4) oil were 128 g I2/100 g and 184 mg KOH/g, respectively.
The water content of the WCO, measured by the cou-
35
Advanced technologies 4(1) (2015) 33-41
lometric Karl Fischer volumetric titration was 380 ppm separate to the ester layer and the water phase. At the
(0.38%), which was slightly above the limited value of end, the washed ester phase was dried using anhydrous
0.3% [42]. The fatty acid composition of the WCO was Na2SO4 that was removed by filtration. The final ester
determined by GC and GC-MS analysis [43]. The WCO product was characterized according to the biodiesel
consisted of palmitic (7.25%), stearic (3.47%), arachidic standard methods.
(0.15%), oleic (29.36%), linoleic (59.43%) and linolenic
(0.14%) acid. Methanol (99.5%) and KOH (pellets; 85%) Results and discussion
were from Zorka-Pharma (Serbia) and Lach-Ner (Czech
Republic), respectively. HCl (36%) and anhidrous Na2SO4 Analysis of methanolysis reactions
were purchased from Centrohem (Serbia) and Sigma Al- The change of the reaction mixture composition with
drich (USA). HPLC grade methanol and n-hexane were time at 30 oC is shown in Figure 1. Generally, two reac-
obtained from Promochem LGC (Germany), while iso- tion periods could be observed: the initial period during
propanol was from Carlo Erba (Italy). HPLC standards which the reaction was very fast, indicating no liquid-
for methyl esters and glycerides were obtained from liquid mass transfer limitation, followed by the second
Sigma Aldrich (USA). period, longer than the first one, where the composition
evolved slowly towards the reaction completition. Simul-
Equipment, reaction conditions and procedure taneously, with the increase of the FAME content during
The experiments were performed in a three-neck the reaction, the TAG content decreased. The shapes
glass flask (250 mL) equipped with a condenser and a of curves are typical for homogeneous base-catalyzed
magnetic stirrer. The agitation intensity was kept constant methanolysis of vegetable oils in the absence of mass
at 600 rpm in all experiments by using a voltage regula- transfer limitation in the initial reaction period. Depending
tor. The reactor was immersed in a glass chamber filled on the reaction temperature, the FAME content of above
with water circulating from a thermostated bath in order 98 % was achieved at all three reaction temperatures,
to maintain the reaction temperature at desired levels. but for different reaction times. In the present study, the
The methanolysis reaction of the WCO was carried out high FAME formation was obtained in a much shorter
at temperatures 30, 45 or 60 oC, the 6:1 methanol:WCO reaction time compared to the conversion degrees for
molar ratio and the KOH amount of 1% (based on the oil WCO in the previous studies (Table 1). The MAG and
weight) under atmospheric pressure. DAG concentrations slowly increased in the initial reac-
Methanol (10.14 g) and KOH (0.4596 g) were agitat- tion period, then decreased and stayed nearly constant
ed in the reactor at the desired temperature until the all at negligible levels up to the end of the reaction. These
catalyst amount was dissolved in methanol. The WCO very low concentrations verified the assumption (a). At
(45.96 g) was thermostated separately and added to the higher reaction temperatures (45 oC and 60 oC), the
reactor. As soon as the magnetic stirrer was turned on, same type of variations of TAG, MAG, DAG and FAME
the reaction was timed. During the reaction, the sam- concentrations were observed, provided that the FAME
ples (1 mL) were removed from the reaction mixture, im- formation was much faster than that at 30 oC. The posi-
mediately quenched by adding a required amount of the tive influence of the reaction temperature on the reaction
aqueous HCl solution (11% vol.) to neutralize the KOH rate was observed in the previous investigations of WCO
and then centrifuged (3500 rpm for 15 min). The upper layer methanolysis [7,9,10].
was withdrawn, dissolved in the isopropanol/n-hexane (5:4
v/v) mixture in a ratio 1:200 and filtered through a 0.45
μm Millipore filter. The obtained filtrate was utilized for
the HPLC analysis that gave contents of FAMEs, TAGs,
DAGs and MAGs in the ester/oil phase [33]. The conver-
sion degree of TAGs during the reaction was calculated
from the initial and actual (TAG0 and TAG, respectively)
content of TAGs (%) in the FAME/oil fraction as follows:
.....................................................(11)
36
Advanced technologies 4(1) (2015) 33-41
37
Advanced technologies 4(1) (2015) 33-41
The comparison of the kinetic model and the experi- Biodiesel properties
mental data is shown in Figure 4, where the variations The characteristics of the final FAME product obtained
of the TAG conversion degree with time are shown. The by the WCO methanolysis are given in Table 3. For com-
MRPD between the actual and predicted values of the parison, the characteristics of the esters obtained in the
TAG conversion degree at the temperatures of 30 oC, 45 oC previously reported studies of the homogeneous base-
and 60 oC were ±3.3%, ±2.4% and ±1.8%, respectively catalyzed alcoholysis of WCO, as well as the specifica-
for the irreversible pseudo-first order kinetic model and tion of the biodiesel standard quality, are also presented
±3.2%, ±0.36% and ±0.48%, respectively for the irre- in Table 3. The physico-chemical characteristics of the
versible pseudo-second order kinetic model. Lower val- biodiesel from WCO generally satisfied the EN 14214
ues of MRPD observed for the latter model confirmed its standard specifications. The exception was the iodine
slightly better accuracy in fitting the experimental data value, which was higher than the maximum value al-
than the former model. lowed by the European biodiesel standard EN14214. On
the other side, the USA ASTM D6751 standard does not
specify its value. Based on the new consideration, the
limitation of the iodine value does not seem to be neces-
sary [45].
38
Advanced technologies 4(1) (2015) 33-41
39
Advanced technologies 4(1) (2015) 33-41
40
Advanced technologies 4(1) (2015) 33-41
L. and the gaussian-like distribution of its wax alkanes, NEN, University of Graz and AGQM. 2008, http://
Journal of the American Oil Chemists' Society, 89 (2012) ec.europa.eu/energy/renewables/biofuels/doc/standard/
2165–2185. lot1.pdf (March, 2015)
[44] I. J. Stojković, I. B. Banković-Ilić, A. V. Veličković, J. M. [46] A. B. Chhetri, K. C. Watts, M. R. Islam, Waste cooking
Avramović, O. S. Stamenković, D. S. Povrenović, V. B. oil as an alternate feedstock for biodiesel production,
Veljković, Waste lard methanolysis catalyzed by potassium Energies 1 (2008) 3-18.
hydroxide at moderate temperatures, Submitted for
publication.
[45] O. Costenoble, M. Mittelbach, S. Schober, J. Fischer, J.
Haupt, Improvements needed for the biodiesel standard
EN 14214. EC project TREN/D2/44-LOT 1/S07.54676,
Izvod
41