PROCESS SELECTION

SCORE
ATTRIBUTES WEIGHT
P1 P2 P3
Economics
Total Capital Investment 4 3 5
Price of Raw Materials 5 5 5 3
Total Annual Production Cost 4 3 5

Manufacturability
Number of intensive equipment 5 3 4
Percent Yield 4 5 5 3
Number of equipment in the process 4 3 5

Sustainability
Availability of Raw Materials 3 5 5 4

Safety
Toxicological Rating 3 5 5 4

Environmental Impact
Environmental Hazards 3 5 5 4

TOTAL
LECTION
TRANSMUTED SCORE TOTAL SCORE
P1 P2 P3 P1 P2 P3

20 15 25
25 25 15 21.66667 18.33333 21.66667
20 15 25

20 12 16
20 20 12 18.66667 14.66667 16
16 12 20

15 15 12 15 15 12

15 15 12 15 15 12

15 15 12 15 15 12

85.33333 78 73.66667
 P1
ATTRIBUTES WORST BEST ECONOMICS
Economics 18.3333 21.6667
Manufacturability 14.6667 18.6667
Sustainability 12 15
Safety 12 15
Environmental Impact 12 15
1

ATTRIBUTES LEVEL OF IMPORTANCE SCORE

Economics 1 100
Manufacturability 3 21.43
Sustainability 5 10
Safety 2 40
Environmental Impact 4 20
TOTAL 191.43

ATTRIBUTES P1 P2
Economics 1 0
Manufacturability 1 0
Sustainability 0 1
Safety 1 1
Environmental Impact 1 1
TOTAL 1.9477615839 1.3656689129
CHOSEN PROCESS

Range:
0 compute (higher-current)/( 1
18.3333 21.6667
14.6667 16 18.6667
12 15
12 15
12 15
P1 P2 P1 P2
BEST MANUFACTURABILITY BEST SUSTAINABILITY BEST SAFETY BEST ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
21.6667 18.3333 21.6667 18.3333
18.6667 14.6667 18.6667 14.6667
15 15 15 15
15 15 15 15
15 15 15 15
3 5 2 4

WEIGHT
0.5223841613 100
0.1119469258 21.43
0.0522384161 10
0.2089536645 40
0.1044768323 20
1

P3
1
1
0.3333
0
0
0.8606958157
P1
*tie (Vote for level of importance)
 ATTRIBUTE P1 P2 P3 Score Weight
Economics 1 0 1 100 0.079365
Manufacturability 1 0 1 40 0.031746
Sustainability 0 1 0.3333 1000 0.793651
Safety 1 1 0 100 0.079365
Environmental Impact 1 1 0 20 0.015873

Overall 0.206349 0.888889 0.375635 1260 1

Choice P2
 SCORE
ATTRIBUTES SCORE
Zambales Surigao Laguna
Availability of Raw Material 5 5 0.1 5
Dwelling Time 5 5 4.12 4.56
Accessibility to Target Markets 5 1.79 0.24 5
Transportation Facilities 5 5 4 5
Water Source Quality and Quantity 4 5 4 3
Climatic Conditions 4 1.67 5 1.67
Utilities Costs and Availability 4 5 2.55 2.81
Construction Cost 3 3.38 3.89 5
Operating Labor 3 3.62 5 1.06
TOTAL
 TOTAL SCORE
Zambales Surigao Laguna
25 0.5 25
25 20.6 22.8
8.95 1.2 25
25 20 25
20 16 12
6.68 20 6.68
20 10.2 11.24
10.14 11.67 15
10.86 15 3.18
151.63 115.17 145.9
 1
L1
ATTRIBUTES WORST BEST AVAIL.
Availability of Raw Material 0.5 25
Dwelling Time 20.6 25
Accessibility to Target Markets 1.2 8.95
Transportation Facilities 20 25
Water Source Quality and Quantity 12 20
Climatic Conditions 6.68 6.68
Utilities Costs and Availability 10.2 20
Construction Cost 10.14 10.14
Operating Labor 3.18 10.86
1

ATTRIBUTES RANK SCORE

Availability of Raw Material
Dwelling Time
Accessibility to Target Markets
Transportation Facilities
Water Source Quality and Quantity
Climatic Conditions
Utilities Costs and Availability
Construction Cost
Operating Labor
1 100
2 79.4
6 36
3 59.4
4 47.4
8 19.18
5 37.2
7 25.86
9 16
TOTAL 420.44

ATTRIBUTES
Availability of Raw Material
Dwelling Time
Accessibility to Target Markets
Transportation Facilities
Water Source Quality and Quantity
Climatic Conditions
Utilities Costs and Availability
Construction Cost
Operating Labor
L1 L2
1 0
1 0
0.67 0
1 0
1 0.5
0 1
1 0
0 0.69
0.35 1
 1 1 1
L1 L3 L1 L1
BEST DWELL. BEST ACCESS. BEST TRANSPO. BEST WATER SOURCE
25 25 25 25
25 22.8 25 25
8.95 25 8.95 8.95
25 25 25 25
20 12 20 20
6.68 6.68 6.68 6.68
20 11.24 20 20
10.14 15 10.14 10.14
10.86 3.18 10.86 10.86
2 6 3 4

WEIGHT
0.237846066 100
0.1888497764 79.4
0.0856245838 36
0.1412805632 59.4
0.1127390353 47.4
0.0456188755 19.18
0.0884787366 37.2
0.0615069927 25.86
0.0380553706 16
1

L3 L1 L2
1 0.237846066 0
0.5 0.1888497764 0
1 0.0573684711 0
1 0.1412805632 0
0 0.1127390353 0.0563695176
0 0 0.0456188755
0.89 0.0884787366 0
1 0 0.0424398249
0 0.0133193797 0.0380553706
TOTAL 0.8398820284 0.1824835886
PLANT LOC CHOICE
 1
L2 L1 L3 L2
BEST CLIMATIC BEST UTIL. BEST CONS. BEST LABOR
0.5 25 25 0.5
20.6 25 22.8 20.6
1.2 8.95 25 1.2
20 25 25 20
16 20 12 16
20 6.68 6.68 20
10.2 20 11.24 10.2
11.67 10.14 15 11.67
15 10.86 3.18 15
8 5 7 9

L3
0.237846066
0.0944248882
0.0856245838
0.1412805632
0
0
0.0787460755
0.0615069927
0
0.6994291694
L1
 ATTRIBUTES L1 L2 L3 SCORE
Availability of Raw Material 1 0.56 0 100
Accessibility to Target Markets 0.1 0 1 76
Transportation Facilities 0.5 0 1 80
Water Source Quality and Quantity 0 1 0.72 12.5

Climatic Conditions 1 0.71 0 20

Utilities Costs and Availability 1 0 0.8 30

Construction Cost 0.25 0 1 16

Operating Labor 0.25 1 0 7.71

TOTAL
342.21
PLANT LOC CHOICE
WEIGHT L1 L2 L3
0.292218 0.292218 0.163642 0 100
0.222086 0.022209 0 0.222086 76
0.233775 0.116887 0 0.233775 80
0.036527 0 0.036527 0.0263 12.5

0.058444 0.058444 0.041495 0 84.6

0.087665 0.087665 0 0.070132 49.2

0.046755 0.011689 0 0.046755 16

0.02253 0.005633 0.02253 0 7.71

0.594744 0.264195 0.599047

L3
 SCORE TOTAL SCORE
ATTRIBUTES SCORE
P1 P2 P1
EQUIPMENT,UTILITY AND MAINTENANCE COST 5 5 4.46 25
ACID COST 4 3.41 5 13.64
WASTE GENERATION 4 5 2.85 20
TOTAL 58.64
TOTAL SCORE
P2
22.3
20
11.4
53.7
 ATTRIBUTES WORST
EQUIPMENT,UTILITY AND MAINTENANCE COST 22.3
ACID COST 13.64
WASTE GENERATION 11.4

ATTRIBUTES RANK
EQUIPMENT,UTILITY AND MAINTENANCE COST 1
ACID COST 2
WASTE GENERATION 3
TOTAL

ATTRIBUTES P1
EQUIPMENT,UTILITY AND MAINTENANCE COST 1
ACID COST 0
WASTE GENERATION 1
TOTAL
P1 P2 P2
BEST EUM COST BEST ACID COST BEST WG
25 22.3 25
13.64 20 13.64
20 11.4 20

SCORE WEIGHT
100 0.4440497336 100
68.2 0.3028419183 68.2
57 0.2531083481 57
225.2 1

P2 P1 P2
0 0.4440497336 0
1 0 0.3028419183
0 0.2531083481 0
0.6971580817 0.3028419183
CHOICE P1
 ATTRIBUTES P1 P2 SCORE
EQUIPMENT,UTILITY AND MAINTENANCE COST 1 0 100
ACID COST 0 1 68.2
WASTE GENERATION 1 0 57
225.2
WEIGHT P1 P2
0.44405 0.44405 0 100 10
0.302842 0 0.302842 68.2 70
0.253108 0.253108 0 57
1 0.697158 0.302842
CHOICE P1