Project: Proposed Erection of Multiple-User General Industrial Development Compressing of 8-Storey

Ramp-up Factory Building (Total 108 Factory Units), A Temporary Ancillary Staff Canteen (Total 1 Unit)
And Other Ancillary Facilities on LOT 2853A PT MK7 at Tuas Bay Close (Tuas Planning Area)

Comparison between 8PTB15 & 16 PT Beam without and with Crane Load

1. 8PTB15 - PT Beam without Crane Load

a. Required Minimum Post-Tensioning Forces

Based on Stress Conditions Based on Minimum P/A

Type Left Center Right Left Center Right
kN kN kN kN kN kN
1 1121.58 6418.02 5140.38 3213.00 3213.00 3213.00
2 3024.67 4214.78 3110.95 3213.00 3213.00 3213.00
3 5123.09 6616.32 1472.85 3213.00 3213.00 3213.00

b. All Tendons

Span Force Total P/A

kN MPa
1 5803.08 1.54
2 4870.313 1.29
3 5822.15 1.54

c. Allowable Stress limit

Allowable Tensile Stress Calculated Tensile Allowable Compressive Calculated Compressive

Stress Stress Stress
4.782 N/mm2 3.77 N/mm2 13.5 N/mm2 8.35 N/mm2

2. 8PTB15 - PT BEAM WITH CRANE LOAD

a. Required Minimum Post-Tensioning Forces

Based on Stress Conditions Based on Minimum P/A

Type Left Center Right Left Center Right
kN kN kN kN kN kN
1 1116.43 6411.90 5149.71 3213.00 3213.00 3213.00
2 3174.57 4470.44 3579.89 3213.00 3213.00 3213.00
3 5530.75 6935.84 1703.05 3213.00 3213.00 3213.00

b. All Tendons

Span Force Total P/A

kN MPa
1 5803.08 1.54
2 4870.313 1.29
3 5822.15 1.54

c. Allowable Stress limit

Allowable Tensile Stress Calculated Tensile Allowable Compressive Calculated Compressive

Stress Stress Stress
4.782 N/mm2 4.18 N/mm2 13.5 N/mm2 9.11 N/mm2
3. 8PTB16 - PT BEAM WITHOUT CRANE LOAD
a. Required Minimum Post-Tensioning Forces

Based on Stress Conditions Based on Minimum P/A

Type Left Center Right Left Center Right
kN kN kN kN kN kN
1 0.00 2803.86 2602.72 1804.10 1804.10 1804.10
2 1231.82 1276.07 1283.71 1804.10 1804.10 1804.10
3 2596.20 2886.01 0.00 1804.10 1804.10 1804.10

b. All Tendons

Span Force Total P/A

kN MPa
1 3592.183 1.69
2 3013.038 1.42
3 3603.388 1.7

c. Allowable Stress limit

Allowable Tensile Stress Calculated Tensile Allowable Compressive Calculated Compressive

Stress Stress Stress
4.782 N/mm2 1.45 N/mm2 13.5 N/mm2 6.02 N/mm2

4. 8PTB16 - PT BEAM WITH CRANE LOAD

a. Required Minimum Post-Tensioning Forces

Based on Stress Conditions Based on Minimum P/A

Type Left Center Right Left Center Right
kN kN kN kN kN kN
1 0.00 2828.35 2685.51 1804.10 1804.10 1804.10
2 1399.60 1484.24 1747.73 1804.10 1804.10 1804.10
3 3072.24 3255.81 0.00 1804.10 1804.10 1804.10

b. All Tendons

Span Force Total P/A

kN MPa
1 3592.183 1.69
2 3013.038 1.42
3 3603.388 1.7

c. Allowable Stress limit

Allowable Tensile Stress Calculated Tensile Allowable Compressive Calculated Compressive

Stress Stress Stress
4.782 N/mm2 2.13 N/mm2 13.5 N/mm2 7.45 N/mm2