Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
The Weekly Newspaper of New York’s Commercial Real Estate Industry $7.00
ppy Birthd
a
H To Us! ay
The Commercial Observer Turns 1!
➧ Our Big Look Back at Industry Power Brokers
➧ Prospective Tenants: How Right We Were
➧ Knakal on Why He Writes Concrete Thoughts
➧ Chandan Looks (Far) East for Next 12 Months
➧ And Steve Spinola Wishes Us Many More!
36
COACH
COGNIZANT
COLLABORATIVE
CONTEMPORARY
COUNSEL
CONFIDENCE COZEN
COURAGE
CELEBRATES O’CONNOR Ken Fisher, Land Use Lawyer
By Heather Holland
emissions. Now, thanks to a $100 LEED Gold certification for its exec- Vornado Subsidiary
million renovation that included utive offices in 230 Park, and reduc- Pitch
double-paned windows, a high-tech ing its overall energy consumption
CBRE: Mall Shoppers system to monitor energy use, and in the building by 30 percent.
better cleaning and trash disposal Monday owns buildings in Virgin- Vornado Realty is selling its sub-
to Rise Again in 2011 practices, Monday Properties has ia, Washington and New York. But sidiary, Merchandise Mart Properties
received LEED Gold certification for Manhattan’s coveted prewar build- Inc., for $1 billion in order to “simpli-
The return of the eternally undead 230 Park Avenue, Hani Salama, the ings pose the biggest greening chal- fy and prune” its holdings, reports
consumers to the suburban mall sig- firm’s vice president of operations, lenge, Brian Robin, chief operating Crain’s. The sale comes at an oppor-
nals that retail may rise again. told The Observer. It is the first pre- officer at Monday, said in an inter- tune time as the Mart has come out a
A CB Richard Ellis report re- war office tower in New York City to view. “Two-thirty had this terrific bit battered from the recession, and
leased Sept. 8 shows that shopping hit that mark. pop in that it’s one of our most im- it doesn’t quite fit the company’s core
center availability will begin to de- The 1.4 million–square–foot, top- portant assets,” he said. business of owning office and retail
cline next year. For once that means shelf building will belch 7,000 fewer Monday is in the process of in- properties in New York. This sum-
the boroughs may have it best, as tons of carbon a year—or about the troducing a monitoring system that mer, Cohen Bros. Realty Corp. offered
the report’s findings apply primar- amount of energy consumed by 300 will help building managers identify $1.25 billion for most of Mart’s as-
ily to mega-complexes in places like U.S. citizens every year. “These were where their buildings are wasting sets, but the deal fell through and the
Long Island, including Brooklyn and good changes,” said Mr. Salama. energy. Next the landlord will apply reason still remains unclear.
Queens, a CBRE spokesman said. They may have cost a little bit more its green thumb to 1440 Broadway,
New York—outer boroughs in- in the short-term, “but the plus out- an 85-year-old, 750,000-square-foot
cluded—is one of 14 markets that weighs the negative,” he added. building just south of Times Square. Meredith Hunt
saw a decline in the availability of The building’s largest tenant, ING,
retail space this year, meaning more which occupies more than 200,000 Meredith is shifting gears and
shops and stores opening up. That square feet, has undergone a green- $85 M. Mortgage looking farther east to find its new
puts the city a bit ahead of the real ing project of its own, receiving home, reports the New York Post.
estate curve, as across the coun- A subsidiary of Forest City En- The company began negotiating for
try retail availability is expected to terprises closed on an $85 million a large space at Hiro Plaza, where
decline starting in 2011. Shooting mortgage for its 312,000-square-foot the publisher already had offices,
ahead, however, are San Francisco, 2004. The company plans to invest property at 234 West 42nd Street, but it has now moved its gaze to the
Newark, Jacksonville, Cincinnati the $118 million in net proceeds to- reports The Real Deal. It’s a 10-year, Durst Organization’s nearby 205
and Trenton. ward 125 Park Avenue, which it fixed-rate mortgage, and new fi- East 42nd Street. The building has
Consumer spending was up 0.4 agreed to buy from Shorenstein nancing ensured an interest rate 375,000 square feet available, and
percent nationally in July, according Properties for $330 million, The that is 325 basis points lower than Meredith wants to consolidate in
to the Commerce Department, but Real Deal reported. that of the loan it replaced, increas- about 250,000 square feet.
only after three previous lackluster The sale comes just as the build- ing the cash flow generated by the
months. ing has scored a new tenant, For- property.
Still, we’re coming off “some of est Management, which signed a
the lowest points in retail sales his- 17,684-square-foot lease for 11 years,
tory,” the report’s author, CBRE The Commercial Observer reported $85 M. Sale
economist Abigail Marks, cautioned. last week. Since SL Green took over,
—Laura Kusisto occupancy in the building has in- Hearst’s Argonaut build-
creased to 99 percent, up from 86. ing at 224 57th Street sold
The sale is expected to close this for $85 million, reports
SL Green Sells Brim- fall. —Laura Kusisto The Real Deal. An in-
vestment group based
ming 19 West 44th in Beirut purchased
Monday’s Gem Grabs the 10-story build-
SL Green, the city’s largest office ing; the sale went
landlord, has agreed to sell 19 West
Green Gold into contract 183 Madison Deal?
44th Street for $123.2 million to June 23 and
Deka Immobilien, a German real es- New York’s golden landmark has closed August
tate investor. gone green. 26. The property at 183 Madison Av-
That’s nearly double the $67 The Helmsley Building may glitter enue is inches away from being con-
million that SL Green paid for the in the sun, but until recently it was tracted by a British group for near-
292,000-square-foot building in producing a dark cloud of carbon ly $75 million, putting the price at
about $300 per square foot, reports
the New York Post. Bidders for the
250,000-square-foot building had in-
STAT of the WEEK cluded Sitt Asset Management and
the Kaufman Organization.
Take-Off
N.Y.U. Condo Buy
The midtown class A average asking rent gained altitude for the third
straight month in August, the longest period of growth since the spring New York University purchased
of 2008. Though the increases were very slight for June and July, August a commercial condo on the third
saw an asking rent increase of just over 1 percent, closing the month at floor of the Silk Building, at 14 East
$65.05 per square foot. 4th Street, for $9.9 million. The
It now appears that midtown may have hit bottom in May of this year, school went into contract for the
with a figure of $64.18 a foot, though there are a lot of air pockets that 12,851-square-foot condo in March
could get in the way before making it to cruising altitude—office job cre- 2007, and closed Sept. 1. The deal
ation being first on the list. The midtown class A figure remains 34 percent is one of $200 million in purchases
off its record high set back in May 2008: $99.22 a foot (and still lower than made by the school this year, includ-
even the first quarter of this year). ing the Forbes building on Fifth Ave-
—Robert Sammons of Cassidy Turley nue and a 26-story dormitory build-
ing known as Founders Hall at 120
East 12th Street. The new purchase
will be used for back-office purposes
and for housing.
36TH STREET
1350 BROADWAY
Abundant natural light from windows on all four sides of our Pre-War Trophy,
on a pedestrian mall directly across from Macy’s flagship store. Recently
completed $53 million upgrade program, including a new entrance, lobby,
windows, elevators, restrooms, air-conditioned public corridors and upgraded
building systems. Steps to Penn Station, Port Authority, Grand Central Terminal,
PATH and 14 subway lines. Additional full floor of 11,075 sq.ft. and pre-built and
ready for move-in suites available from 2,200 – 4,000 sq.ft. Submetered electric
Actual View in all new suites above 2,500 sq.ft.
from 19th Floor
Thank you for giving us the opportunity to compete for your business.
Supervised by
the commercial
W&H10-1725 observer |1observer.com
1350 bway_obsv.indd September PM 5
14, 2010
9/10/10 4:35:07
the week in real estate
SEPTEMBER 7 - SEPTEMBER 14
Corigin Born feet of retail space. The space had been with-
out an agent for nearly a year and a half.
Corigin Holdings is forming in the stead
of the Coalco New York division, taking as-
sets associated with Coalco New York with Moinian vs. Related
it, reports GlobeSt. Corigin will focus on pri-
vate equity and commercial real estate, mak- Joseph Moinian is seeking financing from
ing two divisions, Corigin Real Estate Group SL Green in order to stop the Related Compa-
and Corigin Private Equity Group. Former nies from buying his mortgage at 3 Columbus
chairman of Coalco New York, Ryan Freed- Circle, foreclosing on the office tower, tearing
man, is the CEO and chairman for the newly it down and building a more modern tower in
launched real estate group. its place, the New York Post reports.
CWd^WjjWdjeCedjWka"<_\j^7l[dk[je<_h[?ibWdZ"8heeabod>[_]^jijej^[>Wcfjedi
Bank Building Returns Boomism Lives!
The Jarmulowsky Bank Building at the
111 Eighth
corner of Canal and Orchard streets returned
to the market for $37 million, an increase Owners of the
from the $25 million it sold for in 2005, re- building at 111
ports The Wall Street Journal. Central City Eighth Avenue
Brokerage Corp. is the brokerage marketing have put a fat $2
the 12-story, 60,000-square-foot property. billion price tag
Central City hopes to entice buyers by mar- on the property,
keting the property as an investment proper- hoping the market has improved enough that
ty for developers interested in converting the buyers are willing to pay prices not common
building into a hotel or condominium. since the boom earlier this decade, reports
The New York Times. The 15-story building
is nearly 3 million square feet, making it the
Toren Taps CPEX fourth-largest office building in New York
City. Tenants include Google, Nike USA and
The Toren, the downtown Brooklyn condo barnesandnoble.com. The outcome of this
Manhattan 881/888 Broadway 646 602 3000 abchome.com developed by BFC Partners, hired CPEX as venture may say a great deal on the current
exclusive leasing agent for its 13,000 square health of New York’s real estate market.
Bronx, NY 1055 Bronx River Ave 718 842 8770
A Celebration of Success.
600lex.slgreen.com
1971.
management, and interior
construction services, since
2011
forward to a bright future in
our 40th anniversary year of
212-944-4747
murrayhill.com
and beyond.
s cc
sucsu s es
cce
Succes
SUCCESS
SUCCESS CE
Su
SUCCESS
SS
cce
cce
cSeu s
Success
Succcess S
Su
ss
SUC
Su SUCCESS
ce
cce Success
in time for some seasonal pro-
Success
ss
ss Success
SUCCESS
SUCCESS
SUCCESS
success
Success crastination.
Success
The Oregon-based maker of
Success
Tax Planning
SuccessSuccess
Success Success Success
SuccessSuccess luxury fruit baskets has signed
Success
Success
IPOs
Success
Success
Success Audit
Success
Success
Success
a four-month lease at 155
SuccessSUCCESS
SuccessBusiness
Success Services Success
Success
Success
SUCCESS SUCCESS Success
Success
SUCCESS
Success Success
Success
Success
Fifth Avenue, in the Flatiron
district, Crain’s reports. The
pop-up store will open this
week, and includes 4,500 square feet on the likely Harry and David will stick around once
Charles Weinstein, CPA ground floor, a 4,800-square-foot basement the twinkle lights are turned off.
Chief Executive Officer and a 2,100-square-foot mezzanine. “Like most companies that focus on gifts
212.949.8700
Asking rent for a long-term lease on the rather than self purchases, [Harry & David]
Howard Cohen, CPA ground floor would be around $250 a square does most of [its] business in the fourth quar-
Chairman foot, according to Crain’s. ter, so it won’t be cost effective to pay New
732.287.1000 “Their things are specially geared toward York City rents the other eight months of the
holiday time,” said Robin Abrams, of Lansco year,” Meredith Schwartz, of Gifts & Decora-
www.eisneramper.com
Corp., who represented the landlord. tive Accessories magazine, told Crain’s. But
Those divine pears first came to New York Ms. Schwartz said she could see the retailer
EisnerAmper LLP City by mail from the Rosenburg brothers’ or- popping up again around Mother’s Day or Val-
Accountants & Advisors
chard in Oregon. But they didn’t sell well dur- entine’s Day.
Eisner LLP and Amper, Politziner & Mattia, LLP
have combined their accounting, tax and
ing last year’s lean holiday season. Sales were Ms. Abrams represented the landlord, the
advisory services practices. New York | New Jersey | Pennsylvania | Cayman Islands down 13 percent, though in general the com- Eretz Group, along with Melissa Rose in-
pany’s retail stores have fared slightly better house. Newmark Knight Frank Retail repre-
than the mail-order business. sented Harry & David.
Even if the pop-up store does well, it’s un-
10 September 14, 2010 observer.com | the commercial observer
FASTER
FORWARD
�
24/7 security bus lines and Metro North
�
Outstanding views �
Neighborhood amenities in Soho with 27K-Foot Deal
include national and
�
Will build-to-suit local retailers 250 Hudson Street staff by 30 percent, to nearly
The proliferation of bad 600 people, as of this month.
�
Convenient lobby news in corporate America It reportedly loves the Soho
newsstand/snackbar has proven good news for PR spot, which it moved into a
giant Edelman. The company year ago, because it allows
will take an additional 27,000 the staff to rub elbows with
For more information, please contact: square feet at 250 Hudson its bestest friend, the media.
Anthony Stapleton Street. “There are a lot of media com-
212.582.6688 Edelman’s clients include panies down here, and there’s
anthony@cogswellrealty.com Kraft, Apple, Starbucks, Wal- lots going on,” Robin Callif, Richard Ellis represented the
Mart and the Falkland Islands, the firm’s local chief of staff, tenant, along with Ken Mey-
Ross Jacobs to name a very few. It will occu- told Crain’s. erson. Landlord Jack Resnick
212.582.6688 py a total 168,000 square feet Asking rent was around & Sons was represented in-
ross@cogswellrealty.com in the building, which features $43 a square foot for the 14- house by Dennis Brady and
an environmentally friendly year deal, which is set to ex- Jonathan Dean.
cogswellrealty.com green roof that we can only as- pire along with the company’s
sume is good for PR. other leases. MORE LEASE BEAT
Edelman has increased its Mary Ann Tighe of CB ON PAGE 67
12 September 14, 2010 observer.com | the commercial observer
the commercial observer | observer.com September 14, 2010 13
law column
Relationship Driven.
Your Landlord
Execution Focused. Financially Challenged?
How to protect tenants, subtenants
At Meridian, we value our role as your expert
financing partner. That means understanding
and brokers
your business as well as your individual loan The scene: Midtown office of a midsize ad ment Affidavit? (Does that apply to commer-
transactions. agency. cial leases?) Well, there’s always a lien action …
The dramatis personae: Company’s VP for but who’s gonna pay for the litigation?”
operations, attorney and broker.
By leveraging our market insight and our
The discussions to this point: On the table
I
deep lending relationships, we consistently is a draft term sheet for a 15,000 rsf lease at a don’t think the above scenario is too far from
provide best-in-class financing solutions and rent which is 20 percent lower than tenant is reality in today’s troubled real estate market.
currently paying; also a $42 per rsf TI (tenant But what does it all mean?
seamless execution. improvement) allowance.
(We now listen in on the conver- Protecting Tenants, Subten-
Even in today’s complex market, Meridian sation …) ants and Brokers From Land-
offers the industry’s best loan products and lord Defaults
Tenant: You know that $48 rsf Here’s a topic that was not on
the ability to close your toughest transactions. rent is great, gonna save us a [boat] the radar screen 25 years ago
load of money over the next 10 years, but would have been considered
Please call us today to learn more about but I’ve been reading the trades and almost laughable if presented
our unique approach and to discuss your understand that [insert name of as part of a Continuing Ed pro-
financing needs. latest high-profile financially chal- gram or as suitable for a leasing
lenged landlord] is way deep under- law column. But here we are. It’s
water on a number of mortgages, 2010, and the market today is
and we’re concerned about getting still in the crapper; pockmarked
our TI money—hey, $600,000 ain’t Jeffrey Margolis with overextended landlords
chicken feed—and, for a our cor- who paid hyperinflated prices for
1 Battery Park Plaza New York, NY 10004 | 212 972 3600 | www.meridiancapital.com porate image, his ability to provide Guest Columnist properties with borrowed mon-
Class A building services—the lobby, ey, all having been predicated on
office cleaning, etc. That’s essential. ever increasing dollars per rsf.
A Year of Results...
Lawyer: Well, let’s make getting an SNDA a Well, then came Lehman Brothers and the
must here, and also we’ll look for an L/C on that worldwide financial debacle. Now with debt
TI work or an escrow. Maybe rent set-offs and service often far outstripping income, many
self-help too. … landlords are in trouble. Most talking real es-
Broker [gazing off into the distance, mo- tate heads predict continuing stormy seas for
mentarily caught up in his own thoughts about property owners who may be upside down in
the subject]: (to himself) Hmmm. I better fig- their current loans. This gloomy POV is sup-
ure out how I’m gonna make sure my six-fig- ported by recent numbers indicating that al-
ure commission gets paid ... especially as half most $46 billion in defaulted CMBS loans are
is due six months after signing. Gotta find that outstanding.
memo on this to all brokers from the compa- To be a bit Talmudic here (’tis the season, af-
ny’s new international HQ office in Saigon on ter all) we ask—rhetorically—what is the mean-
this. Try for an escrow? Commission in lieu of ing of all this for that advertising company in
488 7th Avenue Royal Oaks Townhomes 106 Ridge Street rent? Nah, that will never fly. Broker’s Entitle- our drama and others similarly situated? This
New York, New York Hollywood, Florida New York, NY
$28,800,000 $8,750,000 $5,350,000
PRESENTS
$15,000,000 $11,700,000
7-Year Commercial Real
Estate Mortgage Loan Permanent Loan
___________________ ___________________
Kite New Jersey, LLC 35 East 32nd Realty
NEW BATHROOMS
Peter Newman
Executive Managing Director
6th Floor pnewman@handler-re.com
10,000 rsf 646.597.6179
Scott Galin Principal
sgalin@handler-re.com
www.handler-re.com HANDS-ON REAL ESTATE
Address Square feet Tenant Tenant representative Landlord/sublandlord Landlord/sublandlord representative Submarket
1 11 Times Square 406,399 Proskauer Rose CBRE SJP Properties CBRE Times Square
1
2 1411 Broadway 385,759 Jones Apparel Group Inc. CBRE The Blackstone Group Equity Office Properties Penn Plaza/Garment
2
3 787 Seventh Ave. 352,418 Willkie Farr & Gallagher CBRE 787 Holdings CBRE Columbus Circle
2
4 55 E. 52nd St. 295,452 McKinsey & Co. CBRE Fisher Brothers Management Co. Fisher Brothers Management Co. Plaza District
5 620 Sixth Ave. 276,000 Service Employees International Union Newmark Knight Frank Jamestown Management Corp. Cushman & Wakefield Inc. Chelsea
6 200 Fifth Ave. 260,994 Tiffany & Co. Studley L&L Holding Co. CBRE Chelsea
7 777 Third Ave. 246,500 Avon Products CBRE/Cushman & Wakefield Inc. Sage Realty Corp. Jones Lang LaSalle Plaza District
2
8 125 W. 55th St. 201,700 Katz Media Group Inc. CBRE Boston Properties Inc. Boston Properties Inc. Columbus Circle
2
9 1 Broadway 199,240 Kenyon & Kenyon CBRE Logany Colliers International NY World Trade Center
3
10 450 W. 33rd St. 166,479 GMHC Cushman & Wakefield Inc. Broadway Partners Fund Manager Studley Penn Plaza/Garment
3
11 605 Third Ave. 130,740 United Nations Population Fund Colliers International NY Fisher Brothers Management Co. CBRE Grand Central
12 110 William St. 116,540 New York Liquidation Bureau Jones Lang LaSalle Swig Equities Swig Equities Insurance District
13 75 Varick St. 114,605 Horizon Media Newmark Knight Frank Trinity Church Real Estate Cushman & Wakefield Inc. Hudson Square
14 333 W. 34th St. 112,940 Metropolitan Transportation Authority NY Metropolitan Transportation Council SL Green Realty Corp. Cushman & Wakefield Inc. Penn Plaza/Garment
1
15 601 W. 26th St. 112,741 McGarryBowen CBRE SL Green Realty Corp. 601 West Associates Chelsea
16 399 Park Ave. 111,728 PineBridge Investments Studley Boston Properties Inc. CBRE Plaza District
1
17 260 Madison Ave. 110,000 McLaughlin & Stern Grubb & Ellis The Sapir Organization The Sapir Organization Grand Central
2
18 521 W. 57th St. 107,726 CBS Broadcasting Inc. CBS Corp. Himmel + Meringoff Properties Meringoff Properties Inc. Columbus Circle
4
19 26 Broadway 106,431 NYC School Construction Authority Newmark Knight Frank The Chetrit Group Newmark Knight Frank Financial District
20 127 W. 25th St. 104,500 Bowery Residents’ Committee Inc. Cassidy Turley 127 West 25th LLC Colliers International NY Chelsea
1
21 512 Seventh Ave. 101,855 G-III Apparel Group Ltd. Newmark Knight Frank The Chetrit Group Newmark Knight Frank Penn Plaza/Garment
2, 5
22 220 E. 42nd St. 100,602 WPIX-TV Channel 11 Cushman & Wakefield Inc. SL Green Realty Corp. SL Green Realty Corp. Grand Central
1
23 10 Hudson Square 97,000 Kirshenbaum Bond Senecal + Partners Studley Trinity Church Real Estate Trinity Church Real Estate Hudson Square
2
24 420 Lexington Ave. 87,944 New York Life Insurance Co. Cushman & Wakefield Inc. SL Green Realty Corp. SL Green Realty Corp. Grand Central
1
25 1 Penn Plaza 87,400 URS Corp. Studley Vornado Realty Trust Vornado Realty Trust Penn Plaza/Garment
3
26 750 Third Ave. 85,776 Reader’s Digest Association Inc. Cushman & Wakefield Inc. SL Green Realty Corp. CBRE Grand Central
2
27 1 Liberty Plaza 81,742 Royal Bank of Canada None Brookfield Properties Management None World Trade Center
2
28 666 Fifth Ave. 80,830 Vinson & Elkins CBRE Tishman Speyer Tishman Speyer Plaza District
2
29 250 Broadway 79,810 State of New York Direct Amtrust Realty Corp. USA Inc. Newmark Knight Frank City Hall
30 1411 Broadway 78,067 Jacques Moret Direct Swig Burris/Blackstone Group Cushman & Wakefield Inc. Penn Plaza/Garment
31 601 Lexington Ave. 76,862 Citadel Investment Group CBRE Boston Properties Inc. Jones Lang LaSalle Plaza District
4
32 3 World Financial Center 76,241 Royal Bank of Canada None Brookfield Properties Management None World Trade Center
33 77 Water St. 75,716 Lewis Brisbois Bisgaard & Smith CBRE/Studley 450 Seventh Ave. Associates Cushman & Wakefield Inc. Financial District
34 200 Park Ave. 75,574 Korn/Ferry International Cushman & Wakefield Inc. Tishman Speyer Tishman Speyer Grand Central
35 40 W. 57th St. 75,000 Elliott Associates Newmark Knight Frank The Lefrak Organization CBRE Plaza District
36 30 Rockefeller Plaza 74,600 Haynes and Boone CBRE Tishman Speyer Tishman Speyer Plaza District
2
37 529 Fifth Ave. 74,553 Citrin Cooperman & Co. CBRE Loeb Partners Realty Silverstein Properties Inc. Grand Central
3
38 2 World Financial Center 74,380 Nomura Holding America Inc. Cushman & Wakefield Inc. Brookfield Properties Management Jones Lang LaSalle World Trade Center
2
39 111 Eighth Ave. 71,302 XO Communications Jones Lang LaSalle Taconic Investment Partners CBRE Chelsea
40 1675 Broadway 69,422 Publicis Groupe Byrnam Wood Rudin Management Co. Rudin Management Co. Columbus Circle
41 345 Park Ave. 63,808 Piper Jaffray Jones Lang LaSalle Rudin Management Co. Rudin Management Co. Plaza District
42 55 E. 52nd St. 62,258 MF Global Holdings Jones Lang LaSalle Fisher Brothers Management Co. CBRE Plaza District
43 245 Park Ave. 59,714 Ares Capital Corp. Grubb & Ellis Brookfield Properties Management Brookfield Properties Management Grand Central
44 135 W. 50th St. 59,378 Jewish Board of Family and Children’s Services Cumulus Corp. UBS Realty Investors CBRE Columbus Circle
1
45 150 Varick St. 58,125 Wieden + Kennedy Inc. Studley Greiner-Maltz Co. Greiner-Maltz Co. Hudson Square
2
46 16 E. 34th St. 58,098 Charles Komar & Sons Inc. Centric Real Estate Advisors SL Green Realty Corp. SL Green Realty Corp. Murray Hill
2
47 352 Park Ave. South 58,000 NYC School Construction Authority Newmark Knight Frank MD Carlisle Realty Corp. Direct Gramercy Park
3
48 500-506 Seventh Ave. 57,818 Mount Sinai Hospital Newmark Knight Frank The Moinian Group CBRE Penn Plaza/Garment
49 125 Park Ave. 56,772 HMX Group Cushman & Wakefield Inc. Shorenstein Realty Services Newmark Knight Frank Grand Central
1
50 565 Fifth Ave. 56,311 Morvillo Abramowitz JDF Realty Inc. Kipp/Stawski Group CBRE Grand Central
This list includes leases with terms of more than two years. Deals are for new leases unless otherwise noted. 1-Renewal and expansion. 2-Renewal. 3-Sublease. 4-Expansion. 5-WPIX’s renewal at 220 E. 42nd St. is a long-term restructuring of the 104,243-square-foot renewal
signed in 2009. CoStar Group Inc., a provider of information services to the U.S. and U.K. commercial real estate industries, offers customers access via the Internet to the most comprehensive verified database of commercial real estate information in the United States and the
United Kingdom. For more information, visit www.costar.com or call (877) 7-COSTAR.
trials downtown, for No. 7 line station station possible at this location. Efforts
in the push for funding included a fact-
than five years. In addition, the pro-
visions would have been broadened
finding trip to Washington, D.C., in May to include interests held by family
2010, where REBNY representatives, members of a managing partner to be
T
he Real Estate Board of New as a place where people want to live sations with numerous high-level of- along with City Council Speaker Chris- taxed at the Carried Interest rates.
York (REBNY) wants to congrat- and work. ficials in the White House, including tine Quinn, met with the deputy chief This has been the third time that
ulate The Commercial Observer Over the past year, REBNY played Secretary of Homeland Security Ja- of staff to Vice President Joe Biden. The such a change has been proposed.
on its first anniversary. The Commer- a central role in two major issues af- net Napolitano, White House Deputy city has applied for these funds, and, if As the concerns in Washington grow
cial Observer has made a valuable fecting New York City: the proposed Chief of Staff James Messina and se- granted, they would be used to change about the federal deficit, we can ex-
contribution to the reporting of the Sept. 11 terror trials in Lower Man- nior presidential adviser David Axel- current design plans for the No. 7 line pect that another proposal to in-
real estate market and the real estate hattan and the push to restore and to rod. REBNY also launched a campaign extension, enabling a station to be built crease the Carried Interest tax rates
industry in New York City. secure funding for a sta- on the REBNY Action Center Web site in the future when sufficient funds be- will be introduced.
This weekly publication tion on the No. 7 subway that enabled its members, businesses come available. Without this redesign, In Albany, REBNY has introduced
has been a must-read for line extension. and residents in the impacted area and it would have been physically impos- 421a legislation that would revive
our members for its infor- When it was announced the public to contact their elected offi- sible to construct the station once the stalled projects, spur new develop-
mative and insightful arti- that the federal govern- cials urging them to move the trial. construction of the No. 7 line extension ment and create housing that would
cles and columns. ment would be holding As a result of REBNY’s efforts and is completed in 2013. be permanently affordable. These
In the spirit of firsts, the terror trials in Lower the support of other organizations, initiatives would serve as a catalyst
A
though REBNY is the old- Manhattan, REBNY rec- the federal government is reconsid- s our city and industry struggle for the economy by creating jobs and
est real estate trade asso- ognized the negative im- ering Lower Manhattan as a location with the continuing impacts of generating tax revenue, and would
ciation in New York, we are pact it would have on for the trials. the recession, REBNY has been help to address the city’s shortage of
approaching the first anni- the neighborhood, the REBNY spearheaded an effort to taking action in Washington and in Al- affordable housing.
versary of the first woman bany to revive our economy. At the be- Over the next year, REBNY will
chairman in our 114-year Steven Spinola country’s third-largest
business district, and re-
restore the No. 7 Subway station at
West 41st and 10th Avenue and to ginning of the summer, REBNY and its continue to be an advocate for actions
history, Mary Ann Tighe. Guest ceived numerous calls push for funding for its construction. members, along with our colleagues that are beneficial to our members
In this inaugural year, from members who were This station is a crucial infrastruc- at the Real Estate Roundtable, were and our industry. We look forward
REBNY continued its his- Columnist troubled by this decision. ture element in the successful com- successful in fighting the Carried In- to the high-quality and objective re-
torical mission—working REBNY urged federal offi- mercial and residential development terest proposal, which would have porting of The Commercial Observer
with the city and state to promote cials to move the trial to alternative of the growing neighborhood on the been devastating to the real estate to complement our efforts and bring
public policies that reduce the cost of locations in the Southern District, far West Side. industry and would have dramatical- awareness to relevant issues.
doing business, that encourage new and encouraged state and city offi- Understanding the importance of ly increased barriers to development
investment to grow our economy and cials to join in the effort. building the station while construc- during our struggling recovery. Steven Spinola is president of the
that enhance New York City’s appeal REBNY’s effort included conver- tion was already under way for the No. The Carried Interest proposal Real Estate Board of New York.
• Entire 5th Avenue blockfront of Ground & Second Floor window GROUND FLOOR: 10,440 SF • SECOND FLOOR: 13,532 SF
• Gateway between Lord & Taylor and Empire State Building LOWER LEVEL: 15,990 SF • LOWER LEVEL 2: 10,476 SF
• High traffic and visibility • Self contained HVAC system
• Private internal elevators • Loading docks REASONABLE DIVISIONS CONSIDERED
Asset Manager
HERITAGE
REALTY SERVICES, LLC.
212.750.6565 · www.ripcony.com
Peter Ripka: pripka@ripcony.com Andrew Mandell: amandell@ripcony.com Richard Skulnik: rskulnik@ripcony.com
®
Heritage_Job#26786
NY Observer_10”x6”_B/W
09/10/10_P1R
the commercial observer | observer.com September 14, 2010 19
THE LEAD INDICATOR
Anniversary Special
More
Not less
While others are cutting back,
we’re expanding our services
T
he emergence from recession in the growth or no growth? Economists, with
Happy First Anniversary! United States and Europe has been
lackluster. A year after the first issue
their meager macroeconomic forecasting
tools, continue to debate how to compel
of The Commercial Observer reached its a return to expansion. In Washington, the
select readership, headline measures of approaching election has turned many pol-
growth in the former show that the econo- iticians into economists in their own right.
my has slowed from its early, headier pace Worse yet, every economist is now an un-
of recovery. witting politician. Professors, be warned:
And while the Your academic assessment of the Bush tax
labor market has cuts might also signal your views on free
stanched the fright- speech, gays in the military, the burning of
ful job losses of sacred texts and your voting intentions in
late 2008 and early November.
2009, the American
I
economic engine has write this week’s column from the con-
yet to spur meaning- fines of a transpacific flight, making my
ful new job gains. Ba- way from the familiar surroundings and
Sam Chandan sic questions about quandaries of New York City for a week of
Grubb & Ellis NEW YORK the nation we will speaking engagements and meetings along
1177 Avenue of the Americas Columnist be in the 21st centu- the Asian Pacific Rim. However hectic the
New York, NY 10036 Member ® ry—embodied in the upcoming week’s schedule, it offers an op-
debates over health portunity to put our domestic mare’s nest
212.759.9700 | www.grubb-ellis.com
care legislation and the extension of expir- into a larger context.
REAL ESTATE BOARD OF NEW YORK
ing tax cuts—cloud the business outlook As it turns out, I am not the only one
and, until the opaque skies clear, hamper making an eastward sojourn. On the cover
investment. of The Wall Street Journal’s rather slight
And so there is talk of the potential for Asia edition, there is news of Governor
a double dip that might erase the mod- Schwarzenegger’s weeklong trade mis-
est gains of the past year. Will it be slow sion. Larry Summers, as well, was in the
20 September 14, 2010 observer.com | the commercial observer
10-0657 2rector tombstone_Layout 1 9/10/10 12:20 PM Page 1
neighborhood just last week. inence on the economic, political and military tainly not suggesting that we should abandon
There was a time, in the long days of the stage is greeted with a balance of awe and con- our stronger and unequivocal embrace of free
Cold War and more than a decade following sternation. Ongoing disputes over a host of is- markets. I only concede that growth can occur
the Sino-Soviet split, when only Nixon could sues, ranging from currency policy and a per- under different models.
go to China. Now, almost 40 years after the late sistent trade imbalance to engagement with Given the near certainty of a more regulat-
president’s historic meeting with Chairman North Korea and controls on the export of rare ed business and financial environment in the
Mao Zedong, the world’s attention —like the earth metals, have fueled perceptions in the United States, it is worth observing that Chi-
governor’s and former Treasury secretary’s— West that China will not acquiesce to our par- na’s most successful real estate market par-
ticular rule book. ticipants are those that have adapted to the
The currency question, in particular, has wondrous complexity of its regulatory envi-
Professors, be warned: Your aca- raised the ire of policy makers. The House ronment.
demic assessment of the Bush tax Ways and Means Committee will convene on With that in mind, there is hope for us yet.
cuts might also signal your views Wednesday and Thursday of this week to con- schandan@rcanalytics.com
sider the issue. And if a hard line on China
on free speech, gays in the military, resonates with voters, we will certainly hear Sam Chandan, Ph.D., is global chief economist
the burning of sacred texts and your more on this issue from Congress as Election and executive vice president of Real Capital
Day approaches. The testimony to watch will Analytics and an adjunct professor of real es-
voting intentions in November. be that of Treasury Secretary Geithner, sched- tate at Wharton.
uled for Thursday. The tenor of his comments
will undoubtedly prefigure the administra-
is turning ever more eastward. The U.S. econo- tion’s broader engagement strategy.
my returned to some measure of growth a year When thinking about our uncertain future,
ago, in the third quarter of 2009. But in order an acknowledgement of China’s current suc- For a complete archive of Sam Chan-
of magnitude, China has been at the helm of cess can be instructive. If nothing else, it tells dan’s Lead Indicator columns, go to Ob-
the global recovery. us that a highly controlled market economy server.com/the-lead-indicator.
In the United States, China’s growing prom- can still experience rapid growth. I am cer-
* Beautifully
walking
landscaped 38-acre campus with
trails, tennis, basketball and volleyball courts
* Terrazzo marble and smoked glass façade with 2-story atrium lobby
* Separate meeting house and video conference rooms
* State-of-the-art fitness center and Pilates, spin, yoga and
wellness classes; personal trainers are available
A Taste of Power
Sample the swagger! Our year in pointillist profiles
By Jotham Sederstrom managed by SL Green, touted as the firming a fact that exactly nobody bers of the U.N., they don’t trust million feet, while also working out
biggest owner of office buildings in in the industry hadn’t already fig- New Yorkers or fast-talking Ameri- tough deals for hitters like Dai-ichi,
Manhattan. ured out. “Whether they are or they cans, especially the brokers,” said Life Investment Properties, Vornado
O
ver the past 12 months, The “I can tell you already we’ve got a aren’t, this is our Hollywood.” Mr. Robinov, an executive managing and SL Greene, among others.
Commercial Observer has half-dozen prospects who are look- Depending on whom you ask, director at NAI Global who has been “For some reason, complicated
peeked into the boardrooms, ing at space for everything from Ms. Consolo may, in fact, be the nicknamed Mr. U.N. for the lengthy deals seem to find me,” said Mr. Hel-
cramped offices and tightly sched- 75,000 square feet to 250,000 square Elizabeth Taylor of the real estate roster of governments he has helped ler, 50. “It’s a good and a bad thing.”
uled conference rooms of the city’s feet solely because of our involve- set: brash but focused, prolific if a to acquire space near the United Na-
most influential real estate stars and ment, and that’s after two weeks,” bit unhinged, with a client roster tions Plaza. “I’ve been told that the
those closing in on that shorthand. said Mr. Durels, who has made a ca- that includes upscale tenants with plumbers take advantage of them, The First One
From the outspoken to the shy, and reer out of identifying distressed names like Versace, Salvatore Fer- the electricians take advantage of
from the megalomaniacal to the self- properties and determining how to ragamo, Yves Saint Laurent and Fen- them, the telephone company, the
Into the Pool
effacing, here’s a look back at some refurbish them. di, to name a few. None of that is to furniture people—everyone’s over-
of the high points of the past year, a say, however, that her critics would charging them. From April 13, 2010
representative sample, if you will, of agree with the depiction. “They trust me, and that means a Be it the meatpacking district,
Power Brokers. The Elizabeth Taylor “She’s a queen in her own mind,” lot.” where he inked one of the first deals
sniffed one real estate insider, who as the area was shedding its dry skin
of Retail criticized Ms. Consolo’s legendary as a bastion for butchers, or on Mul-
The Cultivator self-promotion, a skill that, like it or The Puzzle Solver berry Street, where he was the leas-
From Dec. 1, 2009 not, has led to reality TV and book ing agent for John Gotti’s former
From Sept. 15, 2009 If there was ever doubt about her offers as well as myriad on-air ap- From Feb. 23, 2010 social club, which he turned into a
Listening to Steve Durels ponder pivotal role at Prudential Douglas pearances. When it was announced last week boutique, Ben Fox has rested his
the challenges of renovating a dis- Elliman, a real estate firm bubbling that the coveted Drake Hotel site had reputation on an uncanny ability to
tressed building, you could hardly over with big names and bigger been sold for $305 million to the Cal- spin gold from silk.
be chided for mistaking the SL Green egos—think Dolly Lenz and Jacky The Ambassador ifornia-based investment firm CIM Indeed, at the age of 60, the Win-
leasing director for an interior deco- Teplitzky, to name a couple—Faith Group, mum, apparently, was the di- ick Realty president and longtime
rator. Hope Consolo was all but declaring From Jan. 5, 2010 rective. retail broker sniffs out emerging
“At the end of the day, this will her position at the top of the pile on Say what you will about dicta- But one day before word of the neighborhoods as well as, if not bet-
be an exercise in correcting those a recent rain-swept Monday after- torships—the human rights abuses, deal trickled down to The Wall Street
things about the building that were noon. censorship and religious intoler- Journal, the otherwise cool-as-a-cu-
done … imperfectly,” said Mr. Durels, “You know what, Hollywood has ance, for starters—they do make for cumber Studley powerhouse Woody
rather artfully. their stars, but truly fantastic tenants. Heller was struggling to contain his
Out-of-place lobby chandeliers, New York has The unconventional wisdom is glee over having brokered the deal
dreary old windows, demolished real estate, but one lesson real estate broker Gil on behalf of CIM. Indeed, reader, a
floors and bathrooms in disrepair— and every- Robinov has learned in a 40-year ca- faint smile seemed to cross his face
it was no wonder the beleaguered of- body in reer that has put him in close prox- while relaying the news to a report-
fice tower to which he was referring real estate imity to monarchies and autocracies, er.
has had such difficulty drawing ten- in New from Egypt and Iran to Saudi Arabia Combined with the Dec. 31 sale
ants, Mr. Durels sighed. York thinks and Uzbekistan—not to mention the of 515 Madison Avenue—a deal that
The building in such need of re- they’re a dreaded North Korea. faced more than a dozen obstacles
suscitation is 100 Church Street, star,” said Indeed, since 1992, when he over two years of negotiations—Mr.
the 21-story tower SL Green ac- Ms. Conso- snagged his first foreign client, Mr. Heller’s latest string of transactions
quired last month after lo, con- Robinov has represented 25 percent has positioned the Studley executive
the Sapir Organization of the 192 member governments managing director as a master at
defaulted on loan pay- of the U.N. In total, the native New closing eyebrow-furrowing deals.
ments to the real estate Yorker has leased an estimated 30 During his tenure at Studley,
getty; JB reed; shravan vidyarthi
investment trust. Among million square feet of office space to which began in 2003 and has includ-
real estate insiders, it’s Fortune 500 companies, major insti- ed the complicated sale of notes and
one of the most closely tutions and, most notably, foreign a mortgage at the Chrysler Building,
watched properties in a governments. Mr. Heller has closed more than $6.5
portfolio of 30 New York “The word ‘trust’ is very impor- billion in asset and note-sales trans-
City buildings currently tant because, in general, the mem- actions, totaling an estimated 33
Hi storic Building
Is Pleased To Announce
230 PA R K AVE NU E
Has Been Certified
L EED – EB G OL D
MONDAYRE.COM
230 PARK AVENUE, SUITE 500, NEW YORK, NY 10169 212.490.7100
1000 WILSON BOULEVARD, SUITE 700, ARLINGTON, VA 22209 703.284.0200
PIXABLE, INC.
Mr. Kesseler Mr. Siegel
137 VARICK STREET
ter than, any broker currently working in the at $150 million, was one of the largest in the
city, not to mention the youthful trailblazers city last year. It was sealed after a 12-month
he looks to for direction. search that included visits to 100 Church
Mr. Fox has represented retailers as var- Street, among other sites.
ied as Hard Rock Cafe, Starbucks, Dean & De- “I have this blue-ocean approach to my
Luca, Ann Taylor and Equinox, ushering each business,” said Mr. Kesseler. “About 70 per-
of them into neighborhoods once thought cent of the brokers compete for the same
undesirable but now considered chic. But business. They compete for the private-eq-
TrinityNYC.com among his accomplishments, Mr. Fox said uity business, the law firm business and the
212.602.0867 Availabilities updated weekly the 180,000-foot deal he secured for the AMC high-end private-sector business.
Movie Theatres chain on West 42nd Street “And, to me, that’s like fishing in a fleet of
ranks among his proudest real estate mo- 100 boats. I’d much rather fish in a fleet of
TRI-1639 Manfredi Pixable-NYO final.indd 1 9/3/10 12:09 PM
ments. In fact, it was the deal that turned four boats.”
Times Square into the family-friendly area it
is today.
“We’re there way before it ever even The Heat Seeker
shows up in The New York Times or The New
York Observer or New York magazine,” said From April 27, 2010
Mr. Fox. “We’re down there early and we’re Ken Siegel is a broker with a knack for
street urchins to an extent. We’re always on complicated deals and an unyielding loyal-
the street, always looking, always exploring. ty for Jones Lang LaSalle and its predeces-
A lot of us are looking for new markets.” sor, LaSalle Partners, one that has lasted for
23 years and counting. It’s no wonder that,
during an interview in April, he proclaimed,
The Dean of Commercial
Business
Class:
Grand Place Real Estate
“I grew up at this firm, so I admit I bleed JLL
blood.”
With help from headline-grabbing clients
Perfect Space
like the law firm Loeb & Loeb, Bank of Amer-
Made to Order From April 20, 2010 ica and the daytime television news show
When he isn’t reeling in 370-pound mako Good Morning America, Mr. Siegel has earned
sharks from his sport-fishing boat, Howard his reputation as a master puzzle solver.
Kesseler, an executive managing director “If I think about my niche in this market-
at Newmark Knight Frank, has been netting place, I would describe it as ‘Give me the
some of the biggest real estate deals in New tough ones,’ the kind of intricate, complex,
York. strategy-oriented, large, maybe even head-
Indeed, with education and health care quarters-type transactions,” he said. “That’s
widely perceived as two growth sectors at where I find my skill set can really add val-
a time when few industries are actually ex- ue.”
panding, Mr. Kesseler’s expertise in bro- With the Good Morning America deal in
kering deals on behalf of private and public particular, Mr. Siegel succeeded in prepar-
schools across the city has kept the New York ing a complex transaction for Disney at 1500
native—he lives with his wife and son near Broadway in less than two weeks. No easy
the Upper East Side—sailing against the eco- deal, it required an agreement for a complete
nomic tide. Recent transactions involving the and total structural renovation of what was
Rebecca School, the city’s Department of Ed- previously a multilevel movie theater.
Custom-built spaces, ucation and CUNY, among others, helped Mr. “It was as quick a deal as you would have
Kesseler earn a “Broker of the Year” award ever seen,” said Mr. Siegel of the lease at the
including free conference room, from Newmark in 2004, a win he repeated in New Amsterdam Theater. “It had bumps in
2005, 2008 and 2009. the road, but we did it in record time.”
in a newly renovated building But the deal that may have cemented Mr.
Kesseler’s reputation as a veritable dean of
just steps from Grand Central Station. real estate was a 203,770-square-foot lease on The Very Frequent Flier
behalf of the Claremont Preparatory School,
JB reed; marissa kaiser
Another Premium Property by 370 Lexington Avenue (at 41st.) NY, NY 10017 a tony private institution he expanded from From May 4, 2010
nearby 41 Broad Street to 25 Broadway, just Hurl a dart at a map, and chances are wher-
contact: Adam Weissleder or Jill Burrowes
steps from the bronze charging-bull sculp- ever it lands, Mitti Liebersohn, a Cushman &
212-370-9800 fax: 212-370-8109
•
ture in Lower Manhattan. The deal, valued Wakefield vice chairman, has inked a high-
SHERWOODEQUITIES info@370lexnyc.com 370lexnyc.com
•
WELCOMES
DENTSU HOLDINGS USA, INC.
AND ITS SUBSIDIARY INNOVATION INTERACTIVE
WHO HAS LEASED THE
ALSO AVAILABLE:
ENTIRE 5TH FLOOR OF 49,576 SF
ENTIRE 6TH FLOOR OF 49,608 SF
PARTIAL 21ST FLOOR OF 18,104 SF
WWW.32SIXTHAVE.COM
www.rudin.com
SoHo
Most conspicuous of his recent deals may Gary Eisenberg, a partner at Herrick Fein-
be a well-publicized 415,000-square-foot stein, whose clients have included Lehman
renewal on behalf of long-held client New Brothers and the investor J.E. Robert, said
York Life Insurance Co. Inked in December, he became observant later on in life after be-
the deal at 63 Madison Avenue is believed to coming convinced, while studying math and
have been the second largest of 2009. Weeks economics at Yale, that the religion itself was
later, Mr. Liebersohn tallied another deal slowly evaporating.
38 Greene St. 46-50 Greene Street for the insurance company when he inked a Should you presume, however, that Mr.
(corner of Grand St.) 200,000-square-foot lease in Mexico City for Eisenberg’s propensity for legal and financial
Entire 5th floor penthouse what will become the group’s Latin American
headquarters, he said.
Entire 2 floor 9,100 sq. ft.
nd
& roof, 6,500 sq. ft. “I love traveling around the country, I love
Entire 3rd floor, 6,500 sq. ft. being in touch with what’s going on in all the
markets and, to me, it’s just so much more in-
Partial 2nd floor 3,500 sq. ft.
teresting,” said Mr. Liebersohn.
Features:
• Class A, Art Deco building
• 42-story building, built in 1931
• Complete views of Midtown East
• Newly renovated lobby
• Direct access to the E and V
trains and multiple bus lines
• Two blocks from the 6 train
10
sure. That’s why they play the game.”
N
CE
212.742.2680
YEARS
The Interpreter
www.plynchassociates.com
From Aug. 17, 2010
Since 2006, the silver-haired Greg Kraut
albany buffalo new york city panama cit y, panama has dropped his knees into the steady tide
of foreign companies now seeking to ex-
pand in New York. Unlike the global con-
glomerates like Honda and Cadbury that fill The Broker Who Would Fill
BIG NAME
for itself on a realistic budget.
Pull Up a Chair
The Sit-Down every week got us into
corner offices throughout Manhattan
By Jotham Sederstrom
And how has that been going?
DD: Last night we had a brokers’ party, and
R
eal estate titans come in all shapes and he had to stay for the whole thing.
sizes, demeanors and personalities. Over JD: Douglas’ typical philosophy is the soon-
the past 12 months, however, The Com- er you show up, the sooner you can leave. I told
mercial Observer has learned firsthand that him the other evening that I was surprised to
they all share a visionary streak—and a pro- still be seeing him.
pensity to gab.
Here, below, are just a few examples
over the last year of what was said when we A Sport of It
stomped into Big Real Estate’s C-suites.
From Oct. 6, 2009
Since Peter Riguardi joined Jones Lang
The Cousins Durst LaSalle as the president of New York opera-
tions in 2002, his responsibilities have grown
From Sept. 15, 2009 significantly, both in terms of personnel and
The Durst Organization, one of the city’s the number of real estate transactions com-
oldest family-run real estate developers, is in pleted. The Commercial Observer spoke to Mr.
a state of transition. Co-president and chair- Riguardi in his sports-memorabilia-bedecked
office and learned not only about
the inner workings of JLL, but the
lifelong New Yorker’s devotion to
sports and how, exactly, they tie
into his role as a real estate chief.
REDUCED
APPLICATION FEE
OF $4,500
As well as a New Streamlined
Application Form
And, as always:
•Up to 80% LTV
•Supplemental Loans Available
After the First 12 Months
of the First Mortgage Loan
•$1-$3 Million, Up to $5 Million
in Certain Markets
There has never been a better time to apply for a small commercial
real estate loan at Arbor. While other firms no longer offer the
program, Arbor is more committed than ever. That’s because we
have been doing multifamily Small Loan Programs for more than a Growing Financial Partnerships
decade and are a top Fannie Mae DUS® Small Loan lender. At Arbor,
we take being your financial partner seriously and it shows. 1-800-ARBOR-10 • www.arbor.com
September 22, 2009 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00
September 29, 2009 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00
September 15, 2009 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00
Pr iS
View
em Su
ie e
re
From the
Center
ric Clark on Brookfield’s
war Chest, Lower
Manhattan and Putting
$1 B. in Debt to Bed
By JoThAM SeDerSTroM
770 Broadway
NY, NY 10003
212 653 8755
ddgpartners.com
investment development design construction
Tower Floors
of 15,000 sF available 1177 exceptional 3600 views
Grand lobby Premier address
Committed ownership
aVeNUe oF THe aMerICas
Base Floors
of 30,000 sF with 100,000 Contact roger silverstein or Jeremy Moss
contiguous sF available www.silversteinproperties.com or 212.732.9700 QUALITY. SERVICE. EXPERIENCE.
city-backed sublease deal with New edy award, so we brought them to Did you anticipate that there
York–based JetBlue, nobody was the 30 Rock stage and they got to see would be so many Europeans in-
more thrilled than David Brause, the some of the sets and some of the ac- terested in 34 Greene Street?
president of the 83-year-old fami- tors, which was exciting. And after Yes, because of where the euro
ly-owned realty company. Besides that, they went out for drinks in Long was. Plus, Europeans love Soho and
filling vacant space at the Brewster Island City and had a great evening. I cast-iron buildings and lofts. If you
building in Long Island City, Mr. think that kind of began the courting go to Europe now, the new ground-
Brause, 39, also played a small role of JetBlue to Long Island City. up development, the layouts of the
in the city’s bid to retain some 900 space is mainly lofts, and the lofts
airline jobs that would have other- originated here in the ’50s when the
wise flown to Florida. Home Runs industrial part of New York moved
out into the outer boroughs.
Tell me about your pitch to Jet- From April 27, 2010
Blue? All eyes seem to be on 200 Fifth Are you seeing a shift, with
We brought them over on the Wa- Avenue, the former Toy Building more Americans showing interest
and done, that’s important. ter Taxi from Manhattan to Queens and, as of last month, the new home in 34 Greene Street?
on a great beautiful summer day. to star chef Mario Batali’s highly an- Yes, but really it’s how the euro
How does that benefit Heritage We were the last neighborhood that ticipated food emporium Eataly and moves, or the dollar. That has a big
or, in general, any small, nimble they were touring in the day, so we Tiffany & Co. At the root of all the that’s not really what we wanted. We effect.
boutique? had a beautiful sunset over Manhat- excitement is David Levinson, the actually had a vision to animate the
When deals are far and few, it tan, and the views of Manhattan are chairman and CEO of L&L Holdings, space, and we wanted some kind of You appear to be very hands-on.
helps us make an instant decision. actually not great in Manhattan, but the privately held real estate invest- restaurant. It was really quite amaz- At this point, how do you stay busy
So if we like something, we go after they’re phenomenal in Long Island ment concern he formed with Rob- ing how this worked out because we at 34 Greene?
it—whether it’s a tenant or a build- City. ert Lapidus in 2000. actually had a vision very similar to
ing to buy. We’re looking at a prop- what Eataly is.
erty now in midtown, another one You pulled out all the stops, How did the Eataly deal take
to buy, on one of the major avenues. didn’t you? shape?
That’s going to be about $100 mil- Oh yeah, we did a whole market- They were in the market for a The History Buffer
lion. There isn’t a committee or any- ing presentation, the aerial view while, looking to develop something
thing. It simply meets our criteria, from the top of the beautiful build- in New York along the lines of what From May 4, 2010
so we’re going ahead with it. We buy ing, showing where we were in terms their financial partner had developed Veronica Mainetti, the 31-year-
two a year. of Court Square, Queens Plaza, Jack- in Turin and Japan. They had an Ital- old head of U.S. operations for the
son Avenue, where the BID was and ian connection, an operator that was Sorgente Group, has had a whirl-
where the Economic Development there, and somewhere along the line wind year, not least of all because of
Flying High activities had been in terms of the they hooked up with Mario Joe Bati- a well-publicized investment in the
$80 million that was being expend- anichCK to be the operator. Flatiron Building in 2009. Since put-
From April ed on the park. MetLife got involved. We had a lot of people looking at ting 34 Greene Street and its seven
13, 2010 Silver Cup Studios got involved. that retail space. A lot of them were elegant Soho condos on the market
When it was After they did a tour of the UN event operations, because that was in January, Ms. Mainetti has been
announced last Federal Credit building, they took a there; we had Cipriani 23. There engaged in selling the residential
month that jitney to Silver Cup Studios. It was were a lot of catering operations, units while also representing her fa-
Brause Real- the night after the Emmy Awards, and all the catering operations came ther’s real estate empire stateside.
ty had inked a and 30 Rock had won the best com- to us and wanted that location, but
october 6, 2009 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00
october 13, 2009 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00 october 20, 2009 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00
a real estate
Sport Real estate
heavies
Jones lang laSalle Prez Go Long
Peter riguardi on Big Deals in
Studley’s Mitchell Steir
By LySAnDRA ohRSTRoM
tenant
Mark weiss on Big Leases
and Big egos
By JoThAM SeDeRSTRoM
Shravan vidyarthi
Shravan vidyarthi
TRIPLE PLAY
VIEW FROM 7TH FLOOR TERRACE
77,000 SF ON
3 CONTIGUOUS FLOORS
PRIME PLAZA DISTRICT
7th FLOOR - 23,000 SF with expansive terrace
6th FLOOR - 27,000 SF
5th FLOOR - 27,000 SF
• 13.5’ Ceiling Height
• Spectacular Views of Central Park,
Fifth Avenue and Grand Army Plaza
Arthur Bocchi • VP, Leasing • 212.237.3122 • abocchi@paramount-group.com Lindsey Huenink • Manager, Leasing • 212-237-3153 • lhuenink@paramount-group.com
Member
38 September 14, 2010 observer.com | the commercial observer the commercial observer | observer.com September 14, 2010 39
THE sit-down One-Year Anniversary Special
It being finished, there’s just lit- derstand the depth of this organiza- estate industry, both during its ups you’re a broker, an invest-
tle things that I see, and it’s proba- tion from a geographic standpoint. and downs. By focusing on Man- ment sales owner, a prop-
bly only things I see. I’m just trying So of the roughly nine weeks, I’ve hattan properties and creating four erty owner or anyone. If
to better things constantly—I guess, been on the road five. I’ve traveled high-net-worth real estate funds, you think you’re right, do
just making sure that, after the par- through Asia, I’ve been to London, the 69-year-old mogul has come out it. Don’t let go. Do not go
ties, after the showings, that things I have to get to some other places on top. quietly into the night.
are still perfect. in Europe. I’ve been through South
America, up to Canada, and from the In the past couple of years,
A New Chief Pauses East Coast to the West Coast in the Murray Hill Properties has grown Jonathan Miller
United States. I haven’t hit every- in prominence. What do you attri-
From June 22, 2010 thing I’d like to hit, but this is real es- bute that heightened visibility to?
Appraises the
In April, former Centro Proper-
ties chief executive Glenn Rufrano
tate, and if you’re a principal in real
estate, you have to get out and kick
After 40 years, I’m an adult. Neil
and I built this business in 1971, and
Commercial
took the reins as Cushman & Wake- the bricks. it’s taken 40 years. About six years Market
field’s CEO. In the two months since, ago, we started several high-net-
the 60-year-old real estate veteran Have you identified anywhere worth individual funds, and that al-
has embarked on a global fact-find- that Cushman can be improved? lowed us to buy what you see up From Aug. 9, 2010
ing mission that has included visits I am still fact-finding, but the an- there on the wall. Up to that point, In 2005, Jonathan Miller made a es being paid on distressed real es-
to the firm’s offices in Europe, Asia, swer has to be yes. Any company that we were doing either one-offs or prediction on CNBC that, due to what tate snatched up from a developer
Canada and the United States. has come out of 2008 and 2009, and limited partnerships with individu- he saw as a growing endemic within in trouble. It’s interesting because
is alive—and Cushman is alive and als. You can only get so big by using the mortgage industry, a downturn after Lehman, which I see as the tip-
Congratulations are in order. we don’t have any debt problems— a single property with single inves- was on the way. Three years later, ping point, there was little activity.
How have you been spending your now needs to reevaluate itself and tors where, in contrast, once you get after the economy nose-dived, the The hedge funds and the groups that
first two months as chief execu- determine how it’s going to focus to starting a fund—and we’re now cable news network reran the clip— were forming distressed-asset strat-
tive officer at Cushman? its value over the next three to five running $265 million worth of high- this time in a segment looking back egies went out in 2009 to raise capi-
What I did at first was try to un- years. There isn’t a company in the net-worth individual funds—you re- on the experts who got it right. He tal to prepare for the onslaught of
world that isn’t going through that ally take off. made another bold prediction dur- acquiring all the distressed property
thought process right now. ing a conversation with The Com- that was going to become available.
You’ve attributed much of your mercial Observer. And over 2009 and the early part of
success to your own ‘stick-to-it- 2010, there was very little activity. It
Norman Sturner iveness,’ a phrase you might as What trends are you seeing in was very quiet.
well have coined. Has that ability the commercial real estate mar- And I think at some point a few
Rages Against the helped you during the recession? ket? months ago, with all the positive
Dying of the I think it’s a help in any-
thing you do. You’re not go-
I think what you’re seeing, be-
sides a whole lot of extend and pre-
news we saw in the U.S. housing
market, you started to see every-
Light ing to be able to print what I tend, is investors looking to acquire body coming out at the same time,
say, but when I put my teeth assets far less expensive than a few competing for the small amount of
in somebody’s tush, I hang years ago and then turning the prop- property out there. As a result, it ap-
From July 27, 2010 on. I don’t let go—some- erty around. What we’re seeing now pears that a lot of this property is be-
Along with Neil times to a fault. But I think is another bubble—rising rapidly. ing snatched up above what the re-
Siderow, Murray Hill ‘stick-to-it-iveness’ and the purposing of the property will yield.
Properties co-found- ability to keep your focus A bubble? In other words, you may win the
er Norman Sturner on what it is that you want I would call it a bubble; and I’m property, but the consumer’s situa-
has weathered nearly is extremely important, and not talking about individual unit tion hasn’t changed.
40 years in the real it doesn’t matter whether purchases. I’m talking about pric- jsederstrom@observer.com
october 27, 2009 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00 november 3, 2009 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00 november 10, 2009 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00
imperial Vu 10 to
Malkin holdings’ Fred Posniak on
Leasing at the higher end watch in
By JoThaM SeDeRSTRoM
’10 Cushman & wakefield’s Dale
Schlather Among the Busier
Brokers Going into next Year
BY JoThAm SeDeRSTRom
FirstService williams’ Mark Jaccom
and robert Freedman Talk Tenants,
Transition and Travel
by JoThAM SeDerSTroM
road warriors
Shravan vidyarthi
Shravan vidyarthi
Shravan vidyarthi
PREMIERE LOCATION.
ABOVE-STANDARD
PRE-BUILTS FULL FLOORS
of 8,000 rsf
779 rsf
1,500 rsf CONTIGUOUS BLOCK
2,800 rsf of 21,622 rsf
5,622 rsf
8,000 rsf
November 17, 2009 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00 november 24, 2009 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00 December 1, 2009 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00
PE FE FE
COMMERCIAL SPACE AT
15 EAST 26TH STREET
DN
PE PE PE PE
DN
UP
STAIR 'D' UP
FH
Madison Square Park
27TH STREET
26TH STREET
STAIR 'C' UP
DN
PE FE FE
MEN
W. 30 ST
idEAlly loCAtEd, mEtiCulouSly rEStorEd
W. 29 ST
This revitalized building on the park
provides a perfect working environment
W. 28 ST
in a neighborhood that combines
AV OF THE AMERICAS (6TH AV)
SQUARE
OA
W. 20 ST
For additional information, please contact exclusive build-
ing agents: W. 19 ST
“A full commission will be paid to the procuring broker who (i) consummates a sale, but only if, as and when title passes, or (ii) consummates a lease or sublease which has been executed by both the landlord and tenant, approved as
W. 16 ST
required, and duly consented by the overlandlord in the event of a sublease. This writing does not constitute, and shall not be construed as, an employment; and no commission shall be deemed earned, due or payable unless and until a
UNION
sale, lease or sublease (as the case may be) is fully consummated. Although all information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, such information has not been verified, and no ex-
SQUARE
press representation is made nor is any to be implied as to the accuracy thereof, and it is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing, or withdrawal without
PARK notice.”
W. 15 ST
means that Reader’s Di- they have less people, so, specific store expansion numbers,
gest can now terminate a, they need less space,” but are open to opportunities to se-
its lease obligations (oh, Mr. Schuman said. “B, cure prime space in outstanding lo-
the glories of Chapter there have been some cations.”
11). technological chang- Right now, Levi’s has four stores
That said, the firm’s es at WNET, and they in New York City: 1501 Broadway in
lease at 260 Madison need different studios. Times Square; 25 West 14th Street,
(pictured) reportedly ex- As a matter of fact, they between Fifth and Sixth avenues; 536
pires in 2012. So even if it just established a new Broadway in Soho; and 750 Lexing-
hadn’t filed for Chapter [about 5,000-square- ton Avenue, near 59th Street. Levi’s
11, it might still be look- foot] studio in Lincoln also recently signed a lease on West
ing for space in a market Center. That gives them erately priced denim wear that ap- 34th Street, near Herald Square.
that has swung dramati- some capacity that they peals to your mother. Afterword: Levi’s reached a deal
cally in favor of tenants. don’t need to have at But in this, the age of the frugal in February 2010 to open its fifth New
Cushman & Wakefield’s Mitchell Right now, Channel 13, also known 33rd Street.” shopper, Levi’s is apparently sens- York spot, a two-level store at 414
Konsker, who is working with Read- as WNET, produces public TV like “And, c, the space is now more ing an opportunity. The clothier is West 14th Street in trendy MePa.
er’s Digest, declined to comment for Worldfocus and Bill Moyers Journal than 10 years old, and they would said to be working with PBS Real Es-
this story. William Adler, a Reader’s in its 200,000-square-foot studios now like to upgrade it.” tate’s Laura Pomerantz to find new On Nov. 23, 2009, we reported …
Digest spokesman, would say only and offices within the 1.6 million– WNET’s existing lease expires in storefronts in Manhattan in which
that “we are looking at various op- square–foot media megalopolis at 2018. Mr. Schuman said that WNET to hawk its 501 Boyfriends, its Low Exactly What They
tions for meeting our space needs 450 West 33rd Street, the building is open to dividing the space. Skinny 531s and the like.
and haven’t made a final decision.” that Broadway Partners bought for “If the right deal presents itself to Ms. Pomerantz did not respond
Want
Afterword: Reader’s Digest’s edi- an astonishing $664 million in 2007. lease half the space, we will do that,” by press time, but a retail broker told
torial staff moved late last year into (The now struggling Broadway Part- Mr. Schuman said. “If the right deal us the firm is hotly pursuing a space Tiffany & Co., the retailer whose
the old Condé Nast space at 750 ners later tried to unload the build- presents itself to lease all of the on 14th Street in the meatpacking flagship store, packed as it is with
Third Avenue, according to the New ing, to no avail.) space, we will be just as happy to do district. precious metals and rare stones, ex-
York Post. The eyesore of a structure is also that, because that gives us the op- “I can tell you that our focus on erts a seemingly magnetic pull on
home to the Daily News, the Associ- portunity to start all over again.” potential retail expansion this year both Fifth Avenue tourist swarms
On Oct. 6, 2009, we reported … ated Press, and U.S. News & World Afterword: In August 2010, WNET has been on being opportunistic in and men seeking to please their bau-
Report. signed a 95,000-square-foot lease in the midst of the economic down- ble-headed brides, is looking for new
WNET Looks to Go To implement its real estate strat- Worldwide Plaza. turn,” said Jeff Beckman, a Levi’s office space.
egy, WNET has hired Studley’s kind- spokesman. “We have not set any The firm is working with brokers
Dark at 450 West ly executive vice president, Ira Schu- On Nov. 3, 2009, we reported … at Studley to find more than 200,000
33rd Street man, who is marketing the 200,000
square feet at an asking rent in Does This Storefront
square feet of office space, according
to an industry source. We imagine
the mid-$30s per square foot, and there are countless landlords slaver-
Channel 13 has hired a broker to searching for new offices of about
Make Me Look Fat? ing for the opportunity, what with
dispose of its cavernous offices on 100,000 square feet in size. the echoing vacancies now afflict-
the far West Side, and to find it new Why the new real estate strate- In the age of designer jeans, it’s ing the cavernous Manhattan office
offices that measure roughly half the gy? hard to get excited about Levi’s, market.
size of the old ones. “With the economic downturn, maker of sensibly crafted and mod- This could bode ill for both Ruben
December 8, 2009 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00 December 15, 2009 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00 December 22-29, 2009 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00
RETAIL SPECIA
L REPORT
Space
For rent Reflections Turn out the Lights
retail’s Challenge—
and Promise
PageS 10-20
On Retail ’09 Finally over—welcome, ’10!
Robert K. Futterman Talks ICSC,
Holiday Shopping and ➤ The 216 Biggest Spaces on the Market
What Happens in Vegas ➤ The Top Prospective Tenants
By JOTHAM SEDERSTROM ➤ The Largest CMBS Loans Maturing
➤ Scott A. Singer on the New Financing
Daniel M. Weiss PhotograPhy ©2009
Currently in over 3000 buildings, we’ve been driving energy cost savings for clients since 1978.
January 5, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00 January 12, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00
January 19, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00
Life at
REBNY AWARDS
The
SPECIAL
the Finally.
optimist
high
Mary ann Tighe becomes
First woman to Chair rebNY—
broker Cory Zelnik Now, to business!
on retail 2010:
end
bY JoThaM SeDerSTroM
Deals, Deals, Deals!
by JoTHaM seDersTroM pluS
More on the 2010
CB richard ellis’ rebNY honorees
Ben friedland on the
Priciest Leases
By JoThAM SeDerSTroM
Shravan vidyarthi
Shravan vidyarthi
January 26, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00
February 2, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00 February 9, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00
the top
street 1 World Trade Center 731 lexington avenue 1251 avenue of The
americas 1271 avenue of The americas 345 park avenue 645 fifth
twenty
avenue 1285 avenue of The americas 63 madison avenue 1230 ave-
nue of The americas 40 Worth street 200 park avenue 51 West 52nd
street 555 West 57th street 180 maiden lane 51 West 52nd street
leases
650 madison avenue 25 Broadway 1633 Broadway 55 Water street
555 West 57th street 1 World Trade Center 731 lexington avenue 1251
avenue of The americas 1271 avenue of The americas 345 park av-
of 2009
enue 645 fifth avenue 1285 avenue of The americas 63 madison av-
Jones Lang Lasalle’s
the CLoCk Is tICkIng ... enue 1230 avenue of The americas 40 Worth street 200 park avenue
Cynthia Wasserberger
new york’s
51 West 52nd street 555 West 57th street 180 maiden lane 51 West
On Hedge Funds, Corporate HQs 52nd street 650 madison avenue 25 Broadway 1633 Broadway 55
By JOtHaM sederstrOM Water street 555 West 57th street 1 World Trade Center 731 lexing-
aging Buildings ton avenue 1251 avenue of The americas 1271 avenue of The americas
By RoLand LI lane 51 West 52nd street 650 madison avenue 25 Broadway 1633
getty images
Broadway 55 Water street 555 West 57th street 1 World Trade Center
proprtyshark
212.594.2700 | slgreen.com
Join us:
The Massey Knakal Multifamily Summit
in conjunction with
This innovative day-long conference and GreenPearl Events
networking event that will offer analysis
and review of important topics such as
the state of the market, market trends, September 21st, 2010
financing, investment opportunities and
owner / operator secrets. The McGraw Hill Conference Center
Over 40 speakers will be joining us on September 21 at The McGraw Hill Conference Center, including:
Doug Bibby Ed Kalikow Richard Mack Joe Sitt Steven Spinola Ofer Yardeni
President President & CEO North America CEO Chairman and CEO President Managing Partner
National Multi The Kalikow Group Area Property Thor Equities Real Estate Stonehenge Partners
Housing Council Partners Board of New York
February 16, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $5.00 February 23, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00
March 2, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00
W W W. R G B C . C O M R O C K E F E L L E R C E N T E R WA L L ST R E E T C O R A L G A B L E S S A N J O S E 1-800-994-7422 Markets Move. Strength Endures. NEW YORK CITY’S LARGEST OWNER
OF COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE
March 16, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00
March 9, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00 march 23, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00
suite
adelaide
area Property Partners’
Lee neibart on 2010 investing
By JothaM sederstroM
212.594.2700 | slgreen.com
USE-Controller EMS The Verifier
2
FULL FLOORS
1
FABULOUS LOCATION
Actual photo of 15th floor
nine local golf courses deep sea fishing private swimming pool tons of shopping
Nestled in Long Island’s North Fork is a unique private community with luxury homes starting at $499,900.
Seeing is believing. Visit us at 4681 Sound Ave, Aquebogue, NY 11931. Models open 6 days 11-5 Wednesday by appointment. 631.722.5900
highlandsnorthfork.com
Complete offering terms are in an offering plan available from the sponsor. Marketing/ Sales For Builders / Developers.
© 2010 www.nuvurealestate.com
WWW.666FIFTHAVENUE.COM
Howard Fiddle
Zachary Freeman
Sinclair Li
Rima Shpolyansky
Stephen Siegel
212.984.8000.
W
hen I was told that this week regularly are: 1. Do I actually write properties. nancial Times as well as all of our
marks the one-year anni- the articles? 2. How do you find the This was not an unexpected re- great real estate trade publica-
versary of The Commercial time to write them? 3. Why do you sult (at least if you were actually tions.
Observer, I could not believe it. One write them? in the business and not a politician Beginning in the summer of
year, 50 columns and about 85,000 To understand my answers to without real-world experience). If 2007, when the credit crisis start-
words later, I am glad that I accept- these questions, it is helpful to un- you make anything more expensive, ed to tangibly be experienced,
ed Tom Aci- derstand what drives me. Let me try there is naturally less of that activ- uncertainty about current and
telli’s offer to provide some insight. ity. What was really eye-opening to future market conditions caused
to contrib- me was that after the tax was re- even the most seasoned partici-
I
ute to the have always been interested in pealed, tax collections from real es- pants in the market to question
paper with economics. Going back to my tate transactions, including capital- what was going on in our market-
my Concrete freshman year at the Wharton gains taxes, actually increased, as place. We saw an unprecedented
Thoughts School, I listened intently to classic transaction volume picked up signif- level of government intervention
column. I illustrations using guns and butter icantly. This was one of those “a-ha” as the crisis grew into the Great
would like or water and diamonds to explain moments for me. I wanted to under- Recession, which led to “issues”
to thank economic fundamentals in Samuel- stand more about how public policy for Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, GM,
so many of son’s Econ 101 textbook. impacted me, sitting at my desk each Chrysler, Lehman, Bear, AIG and a
you for your These theoretical relationships day, trying to sell buildings in New host of others. We saw TARP, TALF, to write my StreetWise blog. Then,
Robert Knakal kind words came vividly to life for me when I York City. PPIP and several rounds of “stimu- one year ago, Tom asked me to write
and support. saw the impact the dreaded “Cuo- This thirst for knowledge turned lus.” Within the past three years for The Commercial Observer, and I
Columnist Each week, I mo Tax” had on the investment sales me into a voracious reader. I wanted or so, we have witnessed a time in happily agreed to join what has been
receive sev- market. This tax was a New York to get my hands on everything pos- which there have never been (at a fantastic team to work with. Writ-
eral emails from readers with ques- State capital-gains tax that added an sible to broaden my knowledge and least during my 26-plus years of bro- ing had become a weekly habit.
tions, comments, story ideas and additional 10 percent tax to any in- understanding of the macroeco- kering property sales in the Big Ap- So let’s get back to the three fre-
feedback. I appreciate this input re- vestment property sale with a price nomic ramifications of public policy ple) closer ties between economics, quently asked questions.
gardless of whether readers support in excess of $1 million. I saw that this on commercial real estate sales. To politics and real estate.
my positions or dissent, presenting tax forced transaction volume to this day, I regularly read The Wall During this time, the frequency of Do I actually write this column?
counterpoints. dry up, as it simply became too ex- Street Journal, The Times, the Post, my periodic “Commentary” writings Yes, I write every word of these
Three of the questions I receive pensive for sellers to part with their Crain’s, Barron’s, Forbes and the Fi- to my clients increased and I began columns. My wife, Cynthia, who puts
March 30, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00 April 6, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00 april 13, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00
Fox on
The Prowl
sPeCIAL rePOrt
toP aCCountIng FIrMs
jb Reed
If you know your New York real estate, you should be able to figure
er.com/concrete-thoughts.
VISIT MARKSPANETH.COM FOR THE SOLUTION. 212.594.2700 | slgreen.com
Building owned by Kushner Properties | 2010 Marks Paneth & Shron LLP
OF COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE
Markets Move. Strength Endures. NEW YORK CITY’S LARGEST OWNER
OF COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE
april 20, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00 april 27, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00 May 4, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00
NYc
Veronica Mainetti
on Family Firm’s
new York Future
BY JothaM sederstroM
Payback time!
the Changing Cost-Benefit analysis of Building green By eugene giLLigan
a new Look
getty images
COLLIERS
INTERNATIONAL
New York’s global real estate firm.
212.594.2700 | slgreen.com
Global Expertise Markets Move. Strength Endures. NEW YORK CITY’S LARGEST OWNER
OF COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE
231 offices • 58 countries
joining so many others who admira- ideas for column topics, please feel founding partner of Massey Knakal
bly serve as advocates for our com- free to keep the suggestions coming. Realty services and in his career has
mercial real estate community. More rknakal@masseyknakal.com brokered the sale of more than 1,075 For the complete archive of Robert Knakal’s Concrete Thoughts col-
advocates are needed to influence properties, having a market value in umns, go to Observer.com/concrete-thoughts.
the perspectives of the people who Robert Knakal is the chairman and excess of $6.5 billion.
have the ability to affect our market-
place through regulatory or legisla-
tive changes.
Far too many of our policy mak-
ers and politicians have no private-
sector experience. Even more don’t
understand basic economic prin-
ciples. Unfortunately, getting re-
elected is the main objective for an
overwhelming majority of our elect-
ed officials, as opposed to trying to
make beneficial changes. Glaring
What a difference
examples of misguided initiatives
a year makes
time in which there have
never been (at least during
my 26-plus years of broker-
ing property sales in the Big
Apple) closer ties between
economics, politics and real
estate.
A stronger New York, a stronger company.
are seen in pending rent-regulation
reform, prevailing wages (which
caused the implosion of the Kings-
bridge Armory transaction in the Over the past 12 months, we’ve become a bigger, better firm.
Bronx), tax policy, entitlements,
union contracts, public-sector pen- We’ve added top talent and delivered real results for our clients.
sions—the list goes on and on. Each
of these things, in their own way, im-
pacts our real estate market. 7 offices in the Tri-state region
Through my writing, I attempt 1,600 employees
to create awareness of the policies
and issues affecting our industry. 22.6+ million square feet of leasing transactions annually
The more aware we all are of these $4.0 billion in projects under management
issues, the more likely it is that we
may be able to impact the perspec- 67 million square foot property and facility management portfolio
tive of a policy maker. Steve Spino- $1.75 billion investment sales transactions
la and the Real Estate Board of New
York do a terrific job of advocating
for our real estate community. I be-
lieve that each of us, in our own way,
should be ambassadors for our in-
dustry. If something is good for our
industry collectively, it is good for
each of us individually.
W
riting this column each week
is not easy, as I have not been
on a “work-related” deadline
since I had to be on time for exams in
college (hence, my enhanced admi-
ration for the journalists who cover
our real estate industry). Not easy,
but I believe it is beneficial to some
of the people in our industry, and it
is important to me personally. Much
of the research for the column pro-
vides a learning experience. Contin-
ually focusing on self-improvement
is a trait commonly found in highly
effective people, and here, the focus
cannot be avoided.
I am hopeful that today’s column 601 Lexington Avenue
provides some insight into the If, New York New York 10022
How and Why of my involvement + 1 212 812 5700
with The Commercial Observer. www.us.joneslanglasalle.com/ny
Thank you again for all of your sup-
port, and if you would like to share
Eight Million
New Yorks
Why the world’s biggest hotel
became just another thing
you might notice
By Emily Geminder In the remembered city, familiar- long occupied a curious place in the
I
n New York, the skyline sometimes ity becomes its own mythology. city’s margins.
recedes, but it never disappears With the recent thousand-foot-
T
entirely. Height, like money and plus skirmishes along New York’s he early part of the last cen-
power, is among the city’s eternally contested contour—developer Vor- tury was a heady time for city
recurring preoccupations, a kind of nado Realty Trust and cheerleaders dwellers. New York was lurch-
suspended totem of commerce, the of development on one side, defend- ing upward, metastasizing in plain
skyline’s residual tic. The skyline, af- ers of the Empire State Building’s view, quickening into a real estate
ter all, is not viscerally experienced solo reign on the other—the Ho- free-for-all of glass and steel, send-
so much as occasionally glimpsed tel Pennsylvania, which Vornado’s ing up hundreds of tall buildings
and secreted away, stowed as eight 1,216-foot 15 Penn Plaza will likely only to tear them down and replace
million portable New Yorks. We fer- displace, has mostly been lost in the them with taller ones. As the Empire
ry them across space and time, piece fray. Virtually all parties have more State Building was preparing to cast
them together according to lopsided or less unanimously conceded the aside a stocky old hotel of its own
memories, instinctively shield them 90-year-old structure as a pre-mor- (the Waldorf-Astoria would move pering Larkin Tower, which would brothers, who had already affixed
from change. Which is why we take tem footnote to the inevitable saga uptown), other contenders for the plunk 950,000 square feet of rent- their names to a bevy of major real
the skyline so personally: The re- of development. claim of world’s tallest building were able real estate on Eighth Avenue estate ventures, had a natural devel-
membered city follows rules more But the hotel, once the biggest in busily at work, among them Edward and 42nd Street, at once established opers’ predilection for superlative
impenetrable than any municipal the world (and whose switchboard, L. and John A. Larkin, a pair of ar- the brothers in the pantheon of mod- marketing. Two years before an-
zoning code, more persistent than when dialed, still belts out the old- chitect-developer brothers, who in ern-day Babelites and hastened the nouncing plans for the Larkin Tower,
a thousand landmark preservation est digits in New York—Glen Miller’s 1926 proposed a 110-story paean to competition’s skyward race. they filed suit against the Pennsylva-
commissions. rowdy “Pennsylvania 6-5000”), has the new order of gigantism. The ta- Biggest, tallest, best. The Larkin nia Railroad, alleging the railroad
May 11, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00 april
May20,
18,2010
2010 The
The Weekly
Weekly NeWspaper
NeWspaper ofof
NeWNeW york’s
york’s CommerCial
CommerCial real
real esTaTe
esTaTe iNdusTry
iNdusTry $7.00
$7.00 May 25, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00
The
tale of
PLus: the 50 Biggest Retail
IN NEW YORK REAL ESTATE spaces available in Manhattan Cushman & Wakefield’s
Brad Mendelson on
JB REED
June 15, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00
June 1, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00 June 8, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00
the Clowns in
Related president Jeff Blau on
developing the West Side Yard
BY JOTHAm SEDERSTROm
212.594.2700 | slgreen.com
212.594.2700 | slgreen.com
Markets Move. Strength Endures. NEW YORK CITY’S LARGEST OWNER
OF COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE
Markets Move. Strength Endures. NEW YORK CITY’S LARGEST OWNER
OF COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE
FEATURED TOPICS
➥ STATE OF NEW YORK CITY REAL ESTATE
➥ STATE OF CAPITAL MARKETS
➥ WHAT ARE THE OPPORTUNITIES?
SPEAkERS INCLUDE:
Keith barket, angelo Gordon richard leFrak, leFrak organization
Jeff blau, related companies richard mack, area
andrew Farkas, Island capital rob speyer, tishman speyer
Jon Gray, blackstone barry sternlicht, starwood capital
marc holliday, sl Green Jay sugarman, istar Financial
ron Kravit, cerberus *panelists subject to change
June 22-29, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00 July 13, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00
July 6, 2010 The Weekly NeWspaper of NeW york’s CommerCial real esTaTe iNdusTry $7.00
joe woolhead
brian letwin
Global Expertise
231 ofces • 58 countries Markets Move. Strength Endures. NEW YORK CITY’S LARGEST OWNER
OF COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE
BROWNMetro,
&Inc.BROWN
INSURANCE AND BONDING SPECIALISTS
By Heather
Holland REBNY (@REB-
NY) marks
T
ip-toe across the calendar.
this Tweet S t u y
Week, for tweet- Town’s Main
ers mulled more than Stakehold-
they gossiped. Some er Sets Auc-
made predictions, tion Date to Sell
some prepped for Massive Complex
events and others http://ow.ly/2BbHJ
asked thoughtful 12:39 PM Sep 8th via
questions, but all HootSuite
in all, things are on the in-
trospective side this time FYI: TRD Government
around. Brief, Cuomo settled last
month with Pinnacle Secu-
CB Richard Ellis (@ rity Group: http://ow.ly/2BbeS
cbrenyc) predicts rain in retail. 12:32 PM Sep 8th via HootSuite
RT @cbrecorp: Per CBRE Econometric Ad-
visors, U.S. Retail Availability Rate Expected Moving to the suburbs to raise a family?
to Start to Decline Early Next Year http://bit. Slow down and take a look at “Friends Don’t
ly/cXIGlv Let Friends Move to the Suburbs” http://
6:18 AM Sep 8th via TweetDeck ow.ly/2AFiT
9:00 PM Sep 7th via HootSuite
RT @cbrecorp: More than 1,000 CBRE
Professionals to Complete Rebuilding Proj-
ects in September for Those in Need http://
bit.ly/99SEe9 #CRE
7:13 AM Sep 7th via TweetDeck
Massey Knakal (@MasseyKnakal)
gives an update.
Featured Listing: 115 East 37th Street,
New York, NY- 1861 Murray Hill townhouse,
duplex unit could be delivered vacant http://
Cushman & Wakefield (@Cush- bit.ly/bkF3tm
Wake) gets its fill. 4:03 PM Sep 8th via web
The Broker Who Would Fill One World
Trade | The New York Observer http://t.co/ Featured Closing: 331 East 81st Street,
QWQqa0h via @AddThis New York, NY 10028 - a five-story mixed-use
10:21 AM Sep 8th via Tweet Button builing on UES http://bit.ly/cN5Dld
10:34 AM Sep 7th via web
1412 Broadway 35,000 Escada US Subco LLC n/a Jesse Rubens and Esther Zar of Murray Hill Properties brokered the 10-year deal.
48 West 37th Street 8,901 E & B Giftware LLC n/a David Levy and Joseph Friedman of Adams & Co. represented both the tenant and the landlord in the six-
year transaction.
Sperber, Denenberg & Kahan, David Levy and Joseph Friedman of Adams & Co. represented both the tenant and the landlord in the 10-year
48 West 37th Street 5,557 P.C. n/a transaction.
Elliot Warren of the Kaufman Organization represented the tenant in the two-year sublease, while Perry Mes-
56 West 22nd Street 5,000 Zemoga n/a mer of Colliers International repped the landlord.
540 Madison Avenue 3,000 Panco Management Boston Properties Jones Lang LaSalle represented both landlord and tenant in the three-year renewal.
Transwestern Invest-
126 East 56th Street 2,900 Goffe Capital Management ment Co. Alex Cohen of Cushman & Wakefield represented the tenant in the five-year deal.
90 Broad Street 2,495 National Book Foundation Swig Equities CBC Hunter Realty represented the tenant in the 10-year deal. Todd Koren repped the landlord in-house.
Andy Epstein of Easy Street Properties represented the tenant. Gabe Isaacs of Sierra Realty repped the
648 Broadway 2,300 Atheros n/a landlord.
149 Madison Avenue 1,907 Furniture Rental Associates Abramson Brothers CBC Hunter Realty represented the tenant. The landlord was repped in-house.
1123 Broadway 1,891 Sense Networks Inc. Kew Management Dan Schwartz of Winslow & Co. represented the tenant. The landlord was repped in-house.
Michael Chow of New York Commercial Realty Services represented the tenant in the five-year deal. Michael
459 Washington Street 1,600 C.A.C Industries, Inc. n/a Pligavko and Terrie Liu of Bosse Property represented the landlord.
July 20, 2010 THE WEEKLY NEWSPAPER OF NEW YORK’S COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE INDUSTRY $7.00 July 27, 2010 THE WEEKLY NEWSPAPER OF NEW YORK’S COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE INDUSTRY $7.00 August 3, 2010 THE WEEKLY NEWSPAPER OF NEW YORK’S COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE INDUSTRY $7.00
LEASE BEAT
Monster Deals
Suddenly, Several Leases
Of 100K-Plus Feet
BY WILLIAM ALDEN & LAURA KUSISTO
212.594.2700 | slgreen.com
212.594.2700 | slgreen.com
112 West 14th Street 1,500 One Light Ministry n/a Michael Chow of New York Commercial Realty Services represented the tenant in the one-year lease. Ber-
trand de Soultrait, also of New York Commercial Realty Services, repped the landlord.
1407 Broadway 1,446 Antex Knitting n/a Sommer Scafidi of the Kaufman Organization represented both landlord and tenant in the three-year lease.
1407 Broadway 1,424 Major Textiles Imports Inc. n/a Sommer Scafidi of the Kaufman Organization represented both landlord and tenant in the three-year lease.
1407 Broadway 1,410 Eurostyle International Inc. n/a Sommer Scafidi of the Kaufman Organization represented both landlord and tenant in the five-year lease.
299 Broadway 1,300 Gateway Management n/a GlenMark Realty represented the tenant in the five-year deal. Olmstead Properties repped the landlord.
291 Broadway 1,260 Geyneir and Associates n/a Nick Zervis and David Gomez of GlenMark Realty represented both the landlord and the tenant in the 10-
year deal.
270 Lafayette Street 1,250 Lauffer Wind Group n/a Lindsay Dukes of New York Commercial Realty Services represented the tenant in the five-year deal. Steve
Marvin of Olmstead Properties repped the landlord.
915 Broadway 1,250 Data Logix n/a GlenMark Realty represented the tenant in the three-year lease. John LiGreci of ABS Partners repped the
landlord.
405 Lexington Avenue 1,057 Oxford Analytica Tishman Speyer Waite Buckley of Vicus Partners represented the landlord in the four-year deal. The landlord was represent-
ed in-house.
648 Broadway 1,025 Patricia McMahon LTD n/a Gabe Isaacs of Sierra Realty represented both landlord and tenant.
291 Broadway 800 Lattice Engines n/a David Gomez of GlenMark Realty represented both landlord and tenant in the two-year lease.
August 10, 2010 THE WEEKLY NEWSPAPER OF NEW YORK’S COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE INDUSTRY $7.00 August 17, 2010 THE WEEKLY NEWSPAPER OF NEW YORK’S COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE INDUSTRY $7.00 August 24, 2010 THE WEEKLY NEWSPAPER OF NEW YORK’S COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE INDUSTRY $7.00
The
THE SIT-DOWN
THE SIT-DOWN
Everybody
Lawyers First Year Wants to Know
What This Man
You Call
Joseph Swingle, Grubb
& Ellis’ New Local Chief,
Talks Expansion, Hiring Has Planned
BY JOTHAM SEDERSTROM Anthony Orso of
Cantor Fitzgerald
The Top Firms, Players
BY JOTHAM SEDERSTROM
BY JOTHAM SEDERSTROM
Plus: Our New Law
Columnist on
Good-Guy Clauses
And! Sam Chandan on
A Busy Congress
SHRAVAN VIDYARTHI
212.594.2700 | slgreen.com
212.594.2700 | slgreen.com
1133 Broadway 611 Art & Advisory LLC Kew Management The landlord was represented in-house.
1133 Broadway 498 Hudson Wigs Kew Management The landlord was represented in-house.
1133 Broadway 432 Hugo & Marie LLC Kew Management The landlord was represented in-house.
1133 Broadway 390 Kaerensa A. Craft LCSW Kew Management The landlord was represented in-house.
1133 Broadway 245 David Brian Brown Kew Management The landlord was represented in-house.
1133 Broadway 138 Carley J. Beardsley Kew Management The landlord was represented in-house.
Associate Publisher,
for more information:
SHRAVAN VIDYARTHI
KATIE KHOURI
212.407.9382 or
Markets Move. Strength Endures.
212.594.2700 | slgreen.com
575 Fifth Avenue 13,000 Guess n/a Robert K. Futterman & Associates brokered the deal.
Noam Management Newmark Knight Frank represented the tenant in the 10-year deal. Sinvin Realty and JDF Realty repped the
24 East 21st Street 4,400 Al Mayass landlord.
James Famularo of New York Commercial Realty Services represented the tenant in the 10-year deal. Cosmo
649 Ninth Avenue 2,606 Michael Guerrieri n/a Montemurro of Winick Realty repped the landlord.
106 East 23rd Street 2,400 Lomography Abington Holding Winick Realty Group’s Steven E. Baker and Michael Gleicher represented the landlord.
Joseph Isa of Winick Realty Group represented the tenant in the 15-year deal. Gabe Whitman and Bill Abram-
48 West 8th Street 1,350 Brentwood Pharmacy n/a son of Buchbinder & Warren Realty Group repped the landlord.
Lafayette-Astor As-
740 Broadway 1,250 Financier Patisserie soc. Winick Realty represented the tenant. Newmark Knight Frank repped the landlord.
762 Madison Avenue 1,208 Gallerie Aesthetique n/a Bertrand de Soultrait of New York Commercial Realty Services represented the tenant in the 10-year deal.
Stuart Ellman of Judson Realty repped the landlord.
2282 Broadway 743 Sprint 221 West 82nd Street Cosmo Montemurro of Winick Realty represented the tenant. Ami Ziff of Time Equities repped the landlord.
• Custom Printing
OFFICE PRODUCTS
• Office Furniture
CERTIFIED WOMAN OWNED ENTERPRISE
• Advertising Specialties
212-279-7455 • www.jasonoffice.com
72 September 14, 2010 observer.com | the commercial observer
The Commercial Observer Classified
COmmerCial & residenTial real esTaTe - sales & leases + relaTed gOOds & serviCes
‘Green’ Glass
Best SERVICE! Best SELECTION! Best PRICE!
LONG ISLAND CITY .3900 ACRE EAst HAmpton
4-story loft elev bldg.
Deliv. Vacant. +/-12,500sf. $1.5m
Gabriel saffioti
100x170 ft. Dead end street. Wooded. 1 mile to
bay and restaurants, 4 miles to East
Hampton town. Reduced from $375,000
Under Glass
mFG. corP Great Neck Jaguar
gsaffioti@easternconsolidated.com less 15% to $318,750. 1-888-263-4158
646-658-7331 GREAt buy. 516-542-8967 GreatNeckJaguar.com
EASTERN CONSOLIDATED Permits Available
observer.com
32 Third Avenue 550 Thread Eyebrow Salon 115 E. 9th Street Re- Rafe Evans of Walker Malloy represented both landlord and tenant.
tail LLP
Union Square Asso- Robin Abrams of Lansco Corp. and Simon Dallimore of Dallimore and Co. represented the tenant in the 10-
1 Union Square West 500 Monsoon Accessorize USA Inc. ciates LLC year deal. William Abramson of Buchbinder & Warren Realty Group repped the landlord.
696 Lexington Avenue 400 Numero 28 Pizzeria n/a Robert K. Futterman & Associates represented the landlord.
Tim Parkkila of New York Commercial Realty Services represented the tenant in the five-year deal. Kelly Lin
188 Orchard Street 350 Dedegumo Watches n/a of Misrahi Realty repped the landlord.
2146 Nostrand Avenue 15,500 Dallas BBQ A&H Acquisitions Robert Greenstone of Greenstone Realty represented the tenant in the 20-year lease.
(Brooklyn)
7602-10 Main Street 14,000 TD Bank Zalkan Inc. Ripco Real Estate represented both landlord and tenant in the 20-year lease.
(Queens)
Chris Havens of Creative Real Estate Group represented the tenant in the two-year deal. The landlord was
215 Water Street (Brooklyn) 3,200 Toll Brothers Inc. Pearl Street Realty repped in-house.
www.durst.org