Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
ScienceDirect
a
Iran University of Medical Sciences (IUMS), Tehran, Iran
b
Tehran University of Medical Sciences (TUMS), Tehran, Iran
c
Research Institute for Islamic & Complementary Medicine (RICM, IUMS), Tehran, Iran
Available online 13 May 2014
KEYWORDS Summary
Background: Premenstrual syndrome (PMS) may have negative effects on women’s health and
Royal Jelly;
sometimes need therapeutic non-pharmacological management.
Premenstrual
Objectives: To determine the effect of oral consumption of 1000 mg Royal Jelly capsule on
syndrome (PMS);
premenstrual syndrome.
Premenstrual Profile
Method: This is a randomized, triple-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trial, which was con-
2005
ducted in Tehran University of Medical Sciences female dormitories between December 2011
and October 2012. The study population comprised 110 medical sciences student with PMS,
whom were randomly assigned to an intervention or a control group. Each participant in the
intervention group took one Royal jelly capsule orally per day, starting on the first day of
menstruation and continued the same treatment daily throughout two consecutive menstrual
cycles, while participants in the intervention group took placebo capsules as same method.
The outcome measure in this study was PMS score as obtained through the Premenstrual Profile
2005.
Results: The mean of personal characteristics and baseline level of the premenstrual score
before intervention did not differ between groups. After two consecutive months consumption
of Royal Jelly, PMS score had decreased from 23.17 ± 17.43 to 11.42 ± 14.58 (mean change:
11.75; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 8.31—15.19) and in Placebo, PMS score changed from
21.48 ± 16.39 to 20.27 ± 15.76 (mean change: 1.20; 95% CI: −1.69 to 4.10). Also difference
between mean changes was significant (mean difference: 10.54; 95% CI: 6.10—14.98).
∗
Corresponding author. Tel.: +98 9124103935.
E-mail addresses: staavoni14@yahoo.com (S. Taavoni), barkhordari.f.sh@gmail.com (F. Barkhordari), sidagoush@yahoo.com
(A. Goushegir), haghani511@yahoo.com (H. Haghani).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ctim.2014.05.004
0965-2299/© 2014 Published by Elsevier Ltd.
602 S. Taavoni et al.
Conclusions: The results of the study have demonstrated that 2 months consumption of Royal
Jelly was effective in reducing PMS.
© 2014 Published by Elsevier Ltd.
Introduction
Jelly is also widely used in commercial medical products,
healthy foods and cosmetics in many count.ries,18,23 with
Premenstrual syndrome (PMS), which is a common disorder minimal risk of side effects.24 In two studies mixture of
among women during their reproductive years are charac- Royal Jelly, Pollen and Pistil extract had effect on those
terized by a range of cyclical physical and psychological suffering from premenstrual syndrome and menopausal
symptoms experienced during the premenstrual period1,2 symptoms.24,25 On the other hand another study showed that
Such as irritability, tension, fatigue, breast tenderness and Royal Jelly has no beneficial effect on the severity of PMS26
bloating.2 Also PMS could effect on family relationship, but little effects on human beings have been objectively
social and work behavior.3 shown, also no study published in the field of Royal Jelly
Symptoms and discomfort level vary from one to another, and PMS in Iran. Referring to all mentioned, objective of
vary from month to month and there may even be symptom- this study was to determine the effect of Royal Jelly on PMS
free months, also each woman reporting her own unique among Iranian University students.
syndrome1 and for some women, PMS may last until
the menopause.4 The causes of the PMS have not been
clearly elucidated5 but have been attributed to hormonal Materials and methods
change, neurotransmitters, prostaglandins, diet, drugs, and
lifestyle, so causal treatment is difficult.6 Although surveys This study is a randomized, triple-blind, placebo-controlled
have suggested that between 30% and 80% of women report trial. All the participants and investigator as well as statis-
PMS,7 in Iranian university students and at least with one tician were blind to the study groups until the analysis was
mild to severe PMS, PMS had been reported up to 98.2%.8 completed. The objective of study was to determine the
Many trials have been carried out to verify the effec- effect of Royal Jelly on PMS of Iranian Medical Sciences Stu-
tiveness of different interventions for the treatment of dents, who live in dorms of Tehran University of Medical
PMS. Therapeutic interventions for PMS vary from non- Sciences. Of 289 female students, whom underwent pre-
pharmacological management to psychotropic medications liminary screening for inclusion in the trial, then 110 were
and hormonal therapy.9 Regarding to variation of beliefs, recruited and finally 92 completed the protocol and were
there are some interest to use of non-pharmacological included in the analysis. The numbers of withdrawals are
and complementary therapy, whereas others are reluc- shown in Fig. 1, by using flow chart model of CONSORT
tant to use of them,10 since there has been considerable 2010.27 All the participants were volunteers, received infor-
public interest in the use of complementary and/or alterna- mation about the objective and method, and then signed in
tive products11—13 and many reproductive-aged women are informed consent. In this study all ethical points had been
turning to natural alternatives, such as non-pharmacologic considered and approved by the Ethics Committee of Tehran
therapies, which may be attempted before prescribing med- University of Medical Sciences, also had been registered in
ication include aerobic exercise, nutritional supplements, Iranian Registry of Clinical Trial, which is Primary Registry in
dietary adjustments, and psychological therapy.12,13 It is the WHO Registry Network set up with the help from the Min-
clear that any healthcare intervention should be safe for istry of Health and Medical Education (MOHME) and hosted
short- and long-term use and free from any side effects14 ; by Tehran University of Medical Sciences (TUMS).
therefore, nutritional supplement and herbal companies The inclusion criteria were as follows: age ‘‘between
should guarantee quality of their products.15 Referring to 18 and 35’’, not suffering from any systemic or genital
mentioned it is necessary to pay more attention to honey, diseases, regular menstrual cycles, have not been using anal-
which is well known in many cultures of the world, honey gesics or any kind of medication to overcome symptoms,
has long been used as a medicine16,17 and Royal Jelly, diagnosis of PMS according to accepted criteria in the ini-
which is one of nutritional supplements18 and a viscous tial screening questionnaire and daily rating of symptoms
substance secreted by the hypo pharyngeal and mandibu- severity using Premenstrual Profile 2005 questionnaire.28
lar glands of worker honey bees as an essential food for The exclusion criteria were as follows: participation in
the queen bee larva and the queen herself. Royal Jelly other trials, concomitant psychotherapy, pregnancy, drug
contains a considerable amount of proteins (12—15%), free dependence, concomitant serious medical condition, and
amino acids, lipids (3—7%), sugars (10—12%), and vitamins hypersensitivity to honey.
of very high biologic value,19,20 and Royal Jelly has been Two surveys were used in this study. The first was a
demonstrated to possess numerous functional properties demographics collection questionnaire which contained of
such as antibacterial activity, anti-inflammatory activity, personal information (including age, age at menarche, mar-
vasodilative and hypotensive activities, disinfectant action, ital status, and menstrual duration, consumption of caffeine
antioxidant activity, antihypercholesterolemic activity, anti- or junk food, and exercise). The second was the Premen-
tumor activity, and estrogenic activities.18,21—23 Biological strual Profile 2005, the questionnaire which is translated in
activities of Royal Jelly are mainly attributed to the bioac- Persian and had been used several times in other related
tive fatty acids, proteins and phenolic compounds.23 Royal studies in Iran.
Effect of Royal Jelly on premenstrual syndrome among Iranian medical sciences students 603
Excluded (n=179)
♦ Not meeting inclusion criteria (n=50)
♦ Declined to participate (n=129)
♦ Other reasons (n=0)
Randomized (n=110)
Allocation
Allocated to royal jelly (n=55) Allocated to placebo (n=55)
♦ Received allocated intervention (n=55) ♦ Received allocated intervention (n=55)
♦ Did not receive alloca ted intervention (n=0) ♦ Did not receive allocated intervention (n=0)
Follow-Up
Lost to follow-up (irregular use) (n=2) Lost to follow-up (irregular use) (n=5)
Analysis
Analysed (n=48) Analysed (n=44)
♦ Excluded from analysis (n=0) ♦ Excluded from analysis (n=0)
The Premenstrual Profile 2005 considers three factors, completion of the entire registration period of 2 months and
defined as: negative mood (markedly depressed mood, feel- one week, the average rating per day of both follicular peri-
ings of hopelessness or self-depreciating thoughts; marked ods (days 1—13) is compared with the average rating per
anxiety, tension, feeling of being ‘‘keyed up’’ or ‘‘on edge’’; day of both luteal periods (days 13 until the end of cycle).
marked affective labiality; persistent and marked anger or A luteal point’s average that surpasses the follicular point’s
irritability or increased interpersonal conflicts; decreased average with 50% of more should be considered an indica-
interest in usual activities; subjective sense of difficulty in tion of PMS. The Premenstrual Profile has been provisionally
concentrating; lethargy, easy fatigability, or marked lack of validated in a mixed nationality sample N = 20.27 In previ-
energy; a subjective change of being over whelmed or out of ous studies, which had done in Iran University of Medical
control), pain and discomfort (marked change in appetite, Sciences its face and content validity had been checked
over eating, or specific food cravings; hypersomnia or insom- by expert panel, and for its reliability, coefficient of cor-
nia; other physical symptoms, such as breast tenderness, relation between respond to questioner during morning and
headaches, joint or muscle pain, stomach/abdomen pain, then to the same questions in afternoon had been checked
backache), and bloating (breast swelling; a sensation of (0.85).29,30 Also in our study, validity had been checked in the
‘‘bloating’’; edema; weight gain). The Premenstrual Profile same way and reliability of questioner coefficient of correla-
requires the patient to register daily her overall perception tion in the morning and afternoon had been checked (0.84,
of the group of symptoms in each one of the three fac- 0.86).
tors, as well as to indicate if the symptoms are extreme or The outcome measure of study was premenstrual score
bad enough to prevent her from performing her daily tasks. as obtained through the Premenstrual Profile 2005. The pre-
Symptoms are scored according to the following instruc- menstrual score is the sum of symptoms’ score recorded by
tion: 0 — absent, 1 — noticeable but not disturbing, 2 — individuals during 7 days before the first day of each men-
interferes with normal activity, 3 — temporarily incapacitat- strual cycle. On completion of the study, two premenstrual
ing. The Premenstrual Profile is meant to gather data over scores had been obtained for every participant (once before
at least two menstrual cycles plus 1 week so that it will intervention and another one after 2 months intervention).
reflect the subjective changes in the three groups of symp- The mean score of every participant over the 2 months base-
toms during two ‘‘premenstrual cycles’’ that is, two entire line phase before treatment was compared to her mean
luteal phases and their returns to the follicular phase. After scores over the 2 months after the treatment.
604 S. Taavoni et al.
Group Pre intervention Post intervention Mean change (95% CI) Difference between
(mean ± SD) (mean ± SD) mean changes (95% CI)a
Royal Jelly 23.17 ± 17.43 11.42 ± 14.58 11.75 (8.31—15.19) 10.54 (6.10—14.98)
Placebo 21.48 ± 16.39 20.27 ± 15.76 1.20 (−1.69 to 4.10)
a 95% Confidence interval of the mean; if it excludes the value zero, the difference is statistically significant.
Effect of Royal Jelly on premenstrual syndrome among Iranian medical sciences students 605
18. Miyata T. Pharmacological basis of traditional medicines attending a specialist premenstrual syndrome clinic. J R Soc
and health supplements as curatives. J Pharmacol Sci Med 1993;89:199—201.
2007;103:127—31. 27. Moher D, Hopewell S, Schulz KF, et al., for the CONSORT Group.
19. Rembold H. Biologically active substances in royal jelly. Vitam CONSORT 2010 explanation and elaboration: updated guide-
Horm 1965;23:359—82. lines for reporting parallel group randomised trial. J Clin Epi
20. Mishima S, et al. Royal jelly has estrogenic effects in vitro and 2010;63:e1—37.
in vivo. J Ethnopharmacol 2005;101:215—20. 28. Campagne DM, Campagne G. The premenstrual syndrome
21. Fujii A. Pharmacological effect of royal jelly. Honey Bee Sci revisited. Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Bio 2007;130:
1998;16:97—104. 4—17.
22. Nagai T, Nagashima T, Myoda T, Inoue R. Preparation and 29. Pourmohsen M, Zoneamat Kermani A, Taavoni S, Hosseini F.
functional properties of extracts from bee bread. Nahrung Effect of combined calcium and vitamin E consumption on pre-
2004;48(3):226—9. menstrual syndrome. Iran J Nurs 2010;23(65):8—14.
23. Ramadan MF, Al-Ghamdi A. Bioactive compounds and health- 30. Pourmohsen M, Taavoni S, Zoneamat Kermani A, Hosseini
promoting properties of royal jelly: a review. J Funct Foods F. Evaluation the effect of vitamin E on premenstrual syn-
2012;4(1):39—52. drome. J Med Facul Guilan Univ Med Sci 2010;19(73):
24. Winther K, Hedman Ch. Assessment of the effects of the herbal 73—9.
remedy female on the symptoms of premenstrual syndrome: 31. Ito S, Nitta Y, Fukumitsu H, Soumiya H, Ikeno K, Nakamura T,
a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study. Curr Furukawa S. Antidepressant-like activity of 10-hydroxy-trans-2-
Therap Res 2002;63(5):344—53. decenoic acid, a unique unsaturated fatty acid of royal jelly, in
25. Georgiev B, Goudev AR, Manassiev N. Effects of an herbal med- stress-inducible depression-like mouse model. Evid-Base Com
ication containing bee products on menopausal symptoms and Alterna Med 2012:139—40.
cardiovascular risk markers: results of a pilot open-uncontrolled 32. Zaid, et al. The effects of tualang honey on female reproduc-
trial. Med Gen Med 2004;6(4):46. tive organs, tibia bone and hormonal profile in ovariectomised
26. Leather AT, Holland N, Andrews D, Studd W. A study of the rats-animal model for menopause. BMC Com Alterna Med
referral patterns and therapeutic experiences of 100 women 2010;10:82.