Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
R. Narayan Swamy
University of Sheffield, Sheffield, England
(Communicated by A. M. Neville)
ABSTRACT
Tests are reported to determine the Poisson's ratio of hardened paste, mortar
and concrete from longitudinal and torsional resonant frequencies and from
pulse velocity. It is shown that Poisson's ratio depends on the mix proportions,
the type of aggregate and its Poisson's ratio, and the aggregate volume content.
Pulse velocity Poisson's ratio is more consistent and greater than that obtained
from longitudinal and torsional resonant frequencies. The considerable scatter
found in Poisson's ratio values obtained from resonant frequency tests is shown
to be due to anlsotropy and the imperfectly elastic behaviour of the paste,
mortar and concrete.
559
560 Vol. I , No. 5
POISSON RATIO, DYNAMIC, CONCRETE
Introduction
Poisson's ratio is generally agreed to be the most difficult of the elas-
tic constants to measure. Its value is also normally not critical in engineer-
ing design and these two factors probably account for the limited amount of data
available on its experimental determination. A precise assessment of its value
is, however, necessary for multiaxial creep computations, in determining the
dynamic modulus from measurements of ultrasonic pulse velocity and in eval-
uating correction factors for the size and shape of the specimen vibrating in
longitudinal, flexural and torsional modes. Errors up to 30 per cent can be
introduced in the calculated values of dynamic modulus obtained from ultrasonic
pulse velocity by assuming a constant value of Poisson's ratio. A knowledge
of Poisson's ratio is also necessary to assess the spalling effects due to
thermal movements. Recent investigations have also shown that Poisson's ratio
has a significant role to play in studying the formation and propagation of
microcracks, and in studying the fracture mechanism of concrete (I, 2).
Experimental Program
The data reported here form part of an extensive investigation to study
the effects of the various constituents of concrete on the dynamic properties
of the composite material and, particularly, the effect of the presence of
relatively rigid aggregate inclusions in a cement paste matrix and in a mortar
matrix.
In the second series of tests Poisson's ratio was determined from the
longitudinal and torsional resonant frequencies. This series consisted of
tests on hardened pastes, mortars and concretes. The paste specimens had
water-cement ratios of 0.3, 0.4, 0.5 and 0.6. To control the shrinkage of
specimens with water-cement ratios of 0.5 and 0.6, additional specimens with
a plasticlsing grouting agent were also made. The tests on mortar consisted
of two water-cement ratios of 0.4 and 0.6, each water-cement ratio having
Vol. I , No. 5 561
POISSON RATIO, DYNAMIC, CONCRETE
sand contents of 20, ~0, 60 and 70 per cent by absolute volume. The concrete
specimens had a water-cement ratio of 0.6 with coarse aggregate contents of
20, ~0, 50, 60 and 70 per cent by absolute volume. Two types of aggregates
were used in this series - a crushed limestone and a crushed gravel, both
continuously graded with a maximum size of 19 mm (¼ in.).
Ordinary Portland cement (ASia[ type I) was used for all ~le three series
of tests. The cement for the first two series was obtained from one source,
while for the third series, it was obtained from a different source. No
attempt was made to blend the cement, but all the specimens in any one series
were made from a single delivery.
In the first and third series, and in the second series excepting the
paste specimens, the tests were conducted in the wet and dry condition. The
wet specimens were continuously cured under water underunoontrolled laboratory
conditions of temperature. For the dry conditions, the specimens cured under
water for fourteen days and hhen allowed to dry in a constant temperature and
humidity room at 68 ° and 65% Roll.
Testing.
The tests were carried out on 100 mm x 100 mm x 500 mm (4 in. x A in x
20 in) prisms and the strength properties of the concrete in hbe three series
were determined from control specimens. The prisms were excited to resonance
in the fundamental modes of longitudinal and torsional vibration and their
respective resonance frequencies were recorded. The specimens were tested
at various ages up ~o 56 days in both the wet and dry conditions.
The apparatus for the vibration tests (Figs. 1 and 2) consisted of a
test bench for the appropriate mode of vibration, a suitable pich-up device
and an electromagnetic vibrator with their control system. A 5VA low-distor-
tion oscillator was used with the exciter, the combined system providing an
8.91~ (2 ibf) thrust wi~h a frequency range of 5 H~ to 20 kH~ and a maximum
562 Vol. I , No. 5
POISSON RATIO, DYNAMIC, CONCRETE
FIG. I
Test set-up for longitudinal vibration
FIG. 2
Test set-up for torsional vibration
Vol. I , No. 5 563
POISSON RATIO, DYNAMIC, CONCRETE
displacement of 2.5 mm (0.1 in.) peak to peak. The vibration exciter had a
low fundamental frequency and negligible mass. The signal from the pick-up
was amplified and displayed by a Type C amplifier Telex oscilloscope. The
frequency was directly read on a digital counter with a crystal stability
of + I part in 106 and a system accuracy of -+ 0.005 per cent.
The longitudinal wave velocity through the test specimens was determined
with a well-known commercial ultrasonic pulse tester in which the individual
times of transmission could be measured to an accuracy of greater than one
per cent. A thin film of paraffin wax was used between the transducers and
the moulded faces of the specimens, and the reproducibility of the results
was found to be excellent. The time of propagation of the ultrasonic pulse
was determined across the centre of the section over the length of the prism,
and the mean of several observations was taken to compute the pulse velocity.
For laboratory specimens, the transmission times could be measured to within
-+ 0.2 microseconds.
Test Results
The dynamic moduli from the longitudinal and torsional modes of
vibration were determined from the well-established relationships between
elastic modulus and the mechanical resonance frequency (3,~,5). The
correction factor for lateral inertia for the fundamental longitud~-al
resonance is less than one half per cent and was neglected. The dy~Am4C
564 Vol. I , No. 5
POISSON RATIO, DYNAMIC, CONCRETE
E
2--7- i = ~ (I)
where E and ~ are the dynamic Young's and torsional modulus respectively.
The ultrasonic pulse velocity V is related to the dynamic longitudinal
elastic modulus E by the equation
where p is the &ensity. Poisson's ratio was obtained from equation (2)
from the measured values of E and V.
lines through the points for the paste without additive are shove. The
results for the paste without additive are generally consistent, but those
for the paste with additive show more scatter; nevertheless certain trends
are clearly evident. Poisson's ratio and differences due to age appear to
increase with water-cement ratio up to a value of 0.5. Poisson's ratio is
initially high, and decreases with increase in the strength and maturity of
the paste. The curve for 0.5 water-cement ratio without additive, however,
appears to rise at the beginning and then decrease more steeply than the rest;
with increase in age, the differences between curves for 0.5 and 0.6 for the
paste without additive become less and less.
Vol. I , No. 5 565
POISSON RATIO, DYNAMIC, CONCRETE
0'36'
0-28
0
n
0.26
U
$
< 024
z • "r-------------._ 0 3
0.22'
0'20
0
AGE IN DAYS
FIG. 3
Effect of water-cement ratio and age on the
dynamic Poisson's ratio of saturated ordinary
Portland cement paste without and with additive.
The slope of all the curves shows that Poisson's ratio is likely to
continue to change even after 28 days. The presence of an additive
increases the Poisson's ratio initially for the paste with 0.5 water-cement
ratio, but decreases it for the paste with 0.6 water-cement ratio. The
points for 0.6 with additive are well below those for 0.5 with additive.
SERIES I
030-
CONCRETE •
AGG./CEMENT 750
0.28"
WATER/CEMENT O,51
MORTAR MATRIX •
" 0.26"
WET
lI DRY
0.24-
~ 0.22- .
0
n \ •
\
_0 O.2O- "-
<
Z
~ oJg'
--A
0.16.
0,14 5~
0 ,~ 24 3~ 4b 48
AGE IN DAYS
FIG. 4
Typical variation of dynamic Poisson's ratio with
age of wet and dry concrete and its corresponding
mortar matrix.
conditions are also known to affect the static Poisson's ratio (II), and the
nature of the environment, such as corrosive atmosphere, similarly influences
the value of Poisson' s ratio (I0).
of about 0.33 (13), on the other hand, was found to produce concretes with a
higher Poisson's ratio than concrete with crushed gravel.
Anson (7) has shown that the static Poisson's ratio of concrete vC
is related to that of the paste v by the equation
P
Vc = Vp(l - Va)n = Vp Vnp (3)
where V a and V p represent the volume fraction of the total aggregate and of
cement pas~respectively. The constant n in equation (3) can be considered
as a measure of the degree of restraint imposed by the aggregate inclusion on
the lateral expansion of the matrix, and its value would depend on the stiff-
ness of the aggregate and its Poisson's ratio• For river gravel aggregates
with a Young's modulus of about 69kN/mm 2 (10.0 x 106 psi) and a Poisson's
ratio of 0.22, n is about 0.42 for Vp = 0.25 (14).
023-
O 22- !
o
0.21"
• • &|
O
4 & &
020
A O
El " ~l
SERIES I.
_o ol9 CONCRETE MORTAR MIX
| • •
WET DRY WET DRy
, • 28 DAYS • O • O
0-18'
o
• ,,• 56 DAYS
o • 9
m o.17- f • i o V D
m
oQ.
016-
_u
o
0"14
013
0'3 0:4 o:s & o:~ 0:8 o~
FIG. 5
Influence of water-cement ratio on the dynamic Poisson's
ratio of wet and dry concrete and its mortar matrix.
Vol. I , No. 5 569
POISSON RATIO, DYNAMIC, CONCRETE
content on the Poisson's ratio of wet and dry concrete and its mortar matrix.
There is considerable scatter to define a single relationship; the results,
however, show a trend. Leslie and Cheesman (15) found from tests on water-
saturated prisms that Poisson's ratio obtained from flexural and torsional
moduli decreased with increase in density - the values ranging from about
0.30 to 0.24 for densities of about ll20 to 2@20 kg/m 3 (70 to 150 lb/ft3).
The data given in Figs. 3, ~ and 5 show that the dynamic values of
Poisson's ratio are generally greater than the generally known static values
~ch, for most concretes, fall between 0.15 and 0°20 although other values
have also been reported. At high stresses or under conditions of rapidly
alternating loads, however, changes in the static value do occur. Probst
(16) has shown that, with repeated loading, Poisson's ratio shows a
consistent decrease. On the other hand, a marked increase in Poisson's
ratio at very high stresses has been observed by several investigators (1,
17, 18, 19, 2 0 ) . Similar results have also been reported in triaxial tests
on concrete cylinders. Gardner (21) has shown that Poisson's ratio changes
from about 0.10 at low stresses to about 0.25 for low values of triaxial
stresses. When Polsson's ratio is less than 0.50, there is a decrease in
the volume of the specimen subjected to compressive loading. At about 70
to 95 per cent of the failure load, increases in Poisson's ratio to over 0.50
have been measured (17, 18, 21). At this stage, the volume of the specimen
begins to increase, and this has been suggested as the long-term sustained
strength of concrete, and represents the beginning of hhe process of
disintegration and internal discontinuity (17, 19).
0"32
AGG./CEI~ENT WET DRY
0-30 4-0
8"O • 6
S E R I E S I.
ICRUSI,'IED GRAVEL I
(>28, "7.5 w •
L~ESTONE + x
SERIES 2.
_'0.26' GRAVEL • D
÷ AGE I - - 5 6 DAYS
÷
0-:)4
|,
0 x
!
m 0':~:~. %
n
• f3 & ~ve •
w v
IE # ; , t,,::',
<
Z • ': t~ 4,,.,
Ot8.
0"14 I
2"0 3'0 4:0 5b 8~0 7.C)
LONGITUDIB~L DYNAMIC MOOULUS X I0 6 p.$.i.
FIG. 6
Variation of dynamic Poisson's ratio with longitudinal
dynamic modulus of wet and dry' concrete.
030-
MORTAR MATRIX
WET DRY
028.
I o
o
• 026-
• 0
4-
l
0
W
0
o
•
•
A
V•
•
°t
A
•
SERIES I
o ( 0 4 W/~ S E R I E S 2 )
rr 0 2 4 " o W + x ( O 6 W/~ SERIES 2 )
• v • °°
A/1 AGE I - 56 DAYS
z
0 022-
• ~, ,g%+, o.,.,
n
020"
' i •
•
&l u
oi•
&O
J •
x ~/ I •
018- x • D
O
016"
OI4
0 i'o 2:o 3:o 4:o sb
LONGITUDINAL DYNAMIC MOOULUS X IO~ p+s+i
riG. 7
Variation of dynamic Poisson's ratio with longi~idinal
d~namic modulus of wet and dry mortar matrix.
ratio is less for both mortar and concrete in the dry condition than in their
wet condition. McCoy and Mather (23) also found a wide range of Poisscn's
ratio values for moist-cured limestone concrete tested under flexural and
torsional vibrations - from 0.11 to 0.33 at 14 days and from 0.13 to 0.39 at
180 days. Similar variations have been reported for static tests - showing
a slight increase with applied load and the strength of the concrete.
Krenchel (24) has reported values of Poisson's ratio of 0.15 to 0.18 for weak
concrete and of 0.17 to 0.25 for strong concrete of about 48 N/ram2 (7000 psi).
MORTAR MIX • A x ®
02'
28 DAY WET DRY WET DRY
28 DAY WET (CRUSHED GRAVEL)
O 21
8 DAY WET (CRUSHED GRAVEL)
_o02"
O 2~
Z
O
A @ • OX + + O O •
O25 O •
O A X + O
rl
+ +
• XX •
O.2,~ + o
022
+
II1@
022
O21
, A J
02O
30 4.0 5"0 60 70
-6
LONGITUDINAL DYNAMIC -MODULUS X IO PS I
FIGo 8
V a r i a t i o n o f p u l s e v e l o c i t y P o i s s o n ' s r a t i o ~rl'~h
longitudinal d~u~amic modulus of wet and dry concrete
and i t s m o r t a r m a t r i x .
the results sho~ the dependence of Poisson's ratio on the type of coarse and
fine aggregate.
If, however, the 28 day wet results alone are considered for a given
type of aggregate, the results show that an approximately linear variation
exists for both concrete and its mortar matrix for a wide range of
aggregate-cement and water-cement ratios. Simmons (22) also four~l slm~lar
linear relationships between pulse velocity Poisscn's ratio and the
longitudinal dynamic modulus.
SERIES 3
WET DRY WET DRY WET DRY
MORTAR MATRIX , a x ® + •
COI,K:RETE • o j J • ,
028"
AGG./CEMENT 40 60 7.5
• ~ AGE 28 DAYS
027:
_o
n,, 026-
v1
Z
0 025"
0
n
0.24"
o 023-
I..U
> • l
022
n 021
020
019
0 o.4 ols o~ o~ o8
WATER-- CEMENT PATIO
FIG. 9
Influence of water-cement ratio on pulse velocity
Poisson's ratio of concrete and its mortar matrix
for various aggregate contents.
AGG./CEMENT 40 60 75
CONCRETE • A ,
MOI~TAR MATRIX o A v
0 3(>
0
,~ 029
iX
ill
028
U3
cO
CL 027
o
>-
I'--
) 0,26"
d
w
> 025-
uJ
,,.n
_1
:D
a. 0.24-
021
4000 6000 8000 K3000
CUBE CRUSHING STRENGTH -- P.S.I.
FIG. I0
Influence of compressive strength on the pulse velocity
Poisson's ratio of wet concrete and its mortar matrix.
Vol. 1, No. 5 575
POISSON RATIO, DYNAMIC, CONCRETE
CONCRETE •
0"30" MORTAR MIX o
o 28 DAY WET
~ O,29.
"~ 0.28.
ul
a. 0-27.
>,.
t.-
U 028-
q
w
i,1
0.25.
/f @
O O
J
~ 0-24'
0.is o;m o.',7 o:ls 0:~ o:2o 0:21 o:22 o-'23 o.'24
DYNAMIC POISSON'S RATIO
FIG. 11
Comparison between dynamic Poisson's ratio and
pulse velocity Poisson's ratio.
× 4c
_ .--e .e
~c ~a
8
~-
./"r."
.~
_..~ .
.
. .
,
.
.
,~ 2c
Z_
_ _ ,:,, j 2c~- / ,~.--- .A •
k-
=7
O i , A ~ J i a
8 I 2 O B 16 24
AGE IN DAYS AGE IN DAYS
'_O 2C
x --e 03 W/C
• . --m 04 W/C
--v OS W/C
8 II- -II --~ o 6 w/c
IC ---v O5 W/C PASTE WITH ADDITIVE
---a O 6 W/C PASTE WITH ADOITIVE
FIG. 12
Typical dynamic Young' s modulus, flexural modulus
and torsional modulus for hardened paste.
Scatter of Te st Re sults.
dv E dE dG
E-2G ('-E --G) (l~)
Vol. I , No. 5 577
POISSON RATIO, DYNAMIC, CONCRETE
Equation (~) shows that errors of like sign in measuring both E and G tend
to cancel out each other, whereas errors of unlike sign are additive° In
the latter case, significant errors in ~ might result when multiplie& by
E/E-2@ which is of the order of @.0 to 5.0 for concrete. Assuming mean
values of E and @ of ~1.5 kN/mm 2 (6.0 x iO 6 psi) and 16.5 kN/mm 2 (2.4 x iO 6
psi) respectively, a variation of + 2 per cent from the mean values of E or
G would cause Poisson's ratio to vary by + i0 per cent.
Anisotropy of Concrete.
reported (23, 29). ~ith rock cores, instantaneous elastic relief of stress
and the resulting creep would certainly affect the measured elastic
properties; further, the drilling operation itself might set up an
asymmetrical orientation of structural elements that could lead to the
measurement of negative and time-dependent Poisson's ratio. The behaviour
of such cores may be considered analogous to the behaviour of a stopper
forced into the neck of a bottle (23).
Z~LE !l
Anisotropic Corre0tions__for D~fnamic ~oduli and Poisson's Ratio
Pursey and Cox (28) have outlined a me~hod of estimating the degree of
anisotropy whereby the true elastic properties of a material in its isotropic
form can be obtained from longitudinal and torsional tests on slightly
anisotropic specimens. Provided certain assumptions are made, the
corrections procedure applied to concrete can highlight the influence of
anisotropy on the results of elasticity measurements.
(~v --
: ( 7 l) (6)
The real isotropic constants may then be obtained from the following
equations (26)
E = E' (I - 0.40a~') (7)
G -- G' (i + 0.40c~' )
i + ,~' (8)
The results shown in Table I --nd the method given for dealing with
,n~ sotropy might appear to discredit the data given in this paper, and
inAeed, the dynamic method of determining Poisson's ratio. This is, of
course, not the case. The implication of Table i is that the value of
Pcisson's ratio determined from longitudinal and torsional resonant
frequency tests is inherently subject to error - firstly, due to the
ill-oon~itione~ nature of the mathematical relationship, and secondly, due
to the anisotropy of concrete. It is important to appreciate the
limitations of dynamic methods in evaluatimg Poisson's ratio, and to know
that anisotropio corrections are necessary to give a more realistic
assessment of the elastic constants. The results further show that errors
are bound to occur in computing one elastic constant from the experimental
determination of another elastic constant.
Vol. I , No. 5 581
POISSON RATIO, DYNAMIC, CONCRETE
Conclusions
Reference s
Acknowledgement
The author records his deep gratitude to Mr. @. Rigby who carried
out the tests and to Mr. K.L. Anand who helped with the computations.
The investigation is part of the project on fracture mechanism of
cementitious materials supported by the Science Research Council, England.