Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
INDEX
1. INTRODUCTION.......................................................................................................7
1.1 PURPOSE OF THE MANUAL..................................................................................... 7
1.2 IMPLEMENTATION..................................................................................................... 7
1.3 UPDATING, AMENDMENT, CONTROL & DEROGATION ........................................ 7
2. DEFINITIONS ...........................................................................................................8
2.1 COMPLETION FLUID.................................................................................................. 8
2.2 PACKER FLUID .......................................................................................................... 8
2.3 NATURE OF COMPLETION FLUIDS AND PACKER FLUIDS .................................. 8
2.4 BRINE .......................................................................................................................... 8
2.5 PURPOSE OF THE COMPLETION FLUID ................................................................. 8
2.6 PURPOSE OF THE PACKER FLUID.......................................................................... 8
4. CALCULATION OF DENSITY..................................................................................16
4.1 DENSITY OF REFERENCE ........................................................................................ 16
4.2 THERMAL EXPANSION OF AQUEOUS COMPLETION FLUIDS ............................. 18
4.3 THERMAL EXPANSION OF OIL BASED COMPLETION FLUIDS ............................ 19
4.4 THERMAL EXPANSION OF EMULSIONS ................................................................. 20
4.5 CONTROL OF THE DENSITY OF THE COMPLETION FLUID .................................. 22
11. DISPLACEMENT......................................................................................................98
11.1 DISPLACEMENT OF THE COMPLETION FLUID IN THE WELL .............................. 98
11.2 DISPLACEMENT OPERATION AND WELL CLEAN UP ........................................... 99
11.2.1 CLEANING OF SURFACE EQUIPMENT AND CONDITIONING OF MUD.................... 99
11.2.2 SPACERS, PILLS AND CHEMICAL WASHERS ........................................................... 99
11.2.2.1 SIMPLE FIELD TEST TO VERIFY THE COMPATIBILITY OF SURFACTANTS
..................................................................................................................... 100
11.2.3 DISPLACING TECHNIQUES........................................................................................... 101
11.2.4 DIRECT AND REVERSE DISPLACEMENT ................................................................... 101
11.2.5 DISPLACEMENT OF BRINE........................................................................................... 102
11.3 A TWO STEP PROCEDURE (WITH SEAWATER FLUSH)........................................ 102
11.4 A ONE STEP PROCEDURE (WITHOUT SEAWATER FLUSH)................................. 103
1. INTRODUCTION
1.2 IMPLEMENTATION
The guideline and policies specified herein will be applicable to all Eni-E&P Division
and Affiliates, drilling and completion engineering activities.
All engineers engaged in Eni-E&P Division and Affiliates well control activities are
expected to make themselves familiar with the contents of this manual and be
responsible for compliance to its policies and procedures.
2. DEFINITIONS
2.4 BRINE
It is a water solution of salts.
It must be suitable to be left into the annulus of the well for all the productive life of
the well.
These fluids range from low-density gases such as nitrogen to high-density muds
and packer fluids.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 10 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
Weight Material Density Range (ppg) Density Range (kg/l) Acid Solubility
CaCO3 10-14 1.20-1.68 98%
FeCO3 10-18 1.20-2.16 90%
Barite 10-21 1.20-2.52 0%
Micromax (Mn3O4) 10-23 1.20-2.75 98%
Table 3-1 – Solids-Laden Completion Fluids
4. CALCULATION OF DENSITY
Where:
sg = specific gravity
In fact, the depth to be used in the calculation must be the depth at the top of the
level to be controlled, otherwise there is the risk of having a lower than required
safety of margin in that zone.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 17 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
129 + 30
sg = = 1.301 Kg/l
1222 / 10
This value of density, for example, is achievable with water based salt solutions of
CaCl2 (Calcium Chloride). The control of a level with the gradient of 1.056 Kg/cm2
/10 m but deeper (e.g. 2222m, formation pressure = 235 Kg/cm2) would lead to the
use of brine with a density:
235 + 30
sg = = 1.193 Kg/l
2222 / 10
obtainable with a salt solution of NaCl (Sodium Chloride) even though this density is
very close to the limit of density corresponding to the saturation of the salt.
Oil-based fluids have a density which depends on the density of both the organic
fluid component and of the brine component used to prepare emulsions, the latter of
which may have a high density. The resultant density of these fluids can be altered
by modifying the ratio of oil/brine. The values of density expressed in the preceding
examples, must be considered as those required in the well at certain conditions of
temperature and pressure. In APPENDIX - B, the values of density are reported,
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 18 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
weight
sg =
volume
In practice, the word “density” is used in the meaning of “specific gravity”. In this
manual, too, it is generally used the word “density”.
Figures from A.1 to A.5 in APPENDIX - A show the effects of temperature change on
the density of brines.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 19 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
The same values of the thermal expansion coefficient of these oils are reported in
Figure 4-2.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 20 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
G=(0.6⋅6.7+0.4⋅2.1)⋅10-4=4.9⋅10-4
To calculate the optimum density of the completion brine, the coefficient G can be
used in the following formula based on a linear static gradient of temperature:
where:
sg = density of the completion brine which must take into account the decrease of
density due to the increase of temperature in the well (Kg/l).
sgo= density of the same brine at the reference temperature indicated in the tables
(Kg/l)
T0= temperature (C°) at which the density d0 (Kg/l) is measured and reported in the
tables (usually 21°C, 70°F)
WHT = Well Head Temperature in circulating conditions (°C)
BHT = bottom hole temperature approximately taken as equal to the bottomhole
static temperature (°C)
The values of temperature are related to the conditions of circulation and should be
measured in the well; in the absence of this data it can be assumed that the tubing
head temperature is equal to the combined average value of temperature of the
static tubing head temperature and the SBHT; for a greater safety margin the tubing
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 21 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
WHT= 0.5⋅(70+30)⋅[(100+10)/100]=55°C
For the first of the examples seen in section 4.1, if reference temperature of the
charts is 21°C, we will have a density of preparation equal to:
The density in this case is practically identical (the difference is in the third decimal
figure) to the density measured at ambient temperature.
As regards the other example of section 4.1, we have:
sg = 1.193+0.5⋅2.11⋅10-4⋅(55+95-2⋅21)= 1.204 Kg/l @21°C
where:
BHT = 95°C,
WHT = 55°C,
Requested density at well conditions = 1.193 Kg/l (NaCl)
But the maximum density of NaCl solutions (at saturation) is 1.200 Kg/l and so
another salt must be used (for example CaCl2).
Similar calculations could be made for oils that, compared with water-based
solutions, have in general a greater effect of expansion with temperature; the same
can be said for emulsions, given the presence of oil in these systems. Because of
the great variety of oils which are commercially available, and the possibility of using
a wide range of oil/water ratios for the preparation of emulsions, it is not possible to
determine unequivocally the thermal expansion coefficients. Oil-based fluids are also
affected by the effect of pressure.
In these cases the density of the completion fluids to be prepared can be calculated
after determining this coefficient experimentally, but, in the case where it is not
possible to resort to laboratory tests, the value of density could be calculated in the
following manner. After preparing a fluid that, at the average temperature of the well
Tmed, (increased of the 10% for safety), has the necessary density to control the
formation pressure, it is allowed to cool down to ambient temperature.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 22 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
BHT + WHT
Ta = X1.1
2
Ta = Average well temperature
The measure of density of the cooled fluid will indicate the value to be achieved
during the preparation in the field, at the same temperature at which the density was
determined. By ambient temperature we mean the actual temperature of the brine in
the tanks resulting from the effects of the surrounding temperature. Thus this value
can vary by a few degrees from 0°C to over 30-40°C in hot environments. In these
situations, to carry out the control of the brine density, the value determined
experimentally shall be adjusted for the difference of temperature between the
environment and the reference values in the tables.
Each time that the density of the brine is determined, the temperature at which it was
measured must be recorded together with if possible the calculated at the reference
temperature (21°C, 70°F). Possible comparisons of densities determined at different
temperatures can be made only on the basis of values normalized to the reference
temperature.
FILTER
FLUID
LINE
(A) = Surface Filtration: the particle does not pass the restrictions of the pores of the filters
(B) = Internal impact: the particle as a result of inertia, leaves the main fluid stream and impacts on the
filter surface and stops;
(C) = Direct interception: the particle transported by the main fluid stream that passes very close to the
filter surface, collides and stops.
(D) = Settling: a particle with large dimensions settles if the fluid slows down;
(E) = Brownian motion: smaller particles are continuously in motion because of the thermal activity of the
molecules of the fluid and can collide, during their chaotic motion, with the walls of the filter.
Absolute filters mainly act according to the mechanism of direct impact visualized in
the cases (A), (B) and (C) in Figure 5-1. Particles, blocked in this way, can no longer
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 25 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
move unless the differential pressure on the filter or the direction of flow is changed.
Examples of this type of absolute filters are cartridges.
Nominal filters mainly act according to the other mechanisms visualized by cases
(D) and (E) in Figure 5-1. In these filters, the matrix is often incoherent and therefore
they can release the filtering material (referred to as break-out of the filter) or the
filtered solids. An example of this filter is the filter-press loaded with DE material
(Diatomaceous Earth).
Cartridges are classified as an absolute filter and are classical filtering systems (e.g.
car air filter) and essentially function with the surface mechanism. The filter cake
which is created however, rapidly raises the pressure drop across the membrane
and therefore this type of filter can not be used directly with very dirty fluids,
especially if they contain deformable solids which create filter cakes with low
permeability (e.g. clays). Cartridges are usually placed in appropriate vessels which
accommodate a certain quantity of cartridges (e.g. 16-24) in order to ensure an
adequate flow rate (each cartridge allows filtration at an average flowrate of 0.5 bpm
of clean water); once dirty, (on reaching a maximum working pressure differential of
30-40 psi), all the cartridges must be replaced (time for substitution: 15-20 min). In
order to avoid interruption of the filtration operations two vessels are usually
available so that one of them is used for the filtration while the other is being
cleaned. In order to ensure high efficiency in removing the solids, the cartridges
should hold back also smaller particles than those declared to be held back.
Therefore an absolute filter (e.g. of 10 µm) can remove also more than 90% of the
solids with a smaller diameter (e.g. of 2 µm). A nominal filter does not ensure the
removal of all the solids whose diameters are equal to the diameter of the filter
because of the hypothetical (since it is not sure they occur) releasing of material.
The degree of cleaning of the treated fluid is determined by the opening of the pores
of the absolute filter (e.g. of 10 µm) that has been used and by the β factor of the
same filter (e.g. a good absolute filter has a β ≥ 5000). The definition and the use of
this factor are necessary because also an absolute filter permits the passage of
some particles with a diameter equal to the opening of the filter. If, for example the
fluid inlet to be filtered contains 150 millions of particles per cm3 whose diameters
are larger than the diameter of the filter and the filtrate outlet contains only 15000
particles per cm3,, the β factor will be 10000 (=1.5⋅108/1.5⋅104). A filter (even if it is a
cartridge) with low value of β (e.g. β ≤ 100) must be considered as a nominal filter.
Because of this different selectivity the cartridges filters have definitely different
costs depending on their efficiency defined by the β factor.
Because of their high sensibility, efficiency and selectivity, the cartridge filtration
systems are protected with a DE system constituted by inert fossil material put on
some cloths of the filter-press (Figure 5-4). The filtering material DE is initially
inserted in the fluid to be filtered until it creates a filter cake against the bearing
cloths that constitute the centre of the functioning of the filter-press: the cake acts
like a filter and stops most of the suspended solids. In the phase of the formation of
the cake, the fluid circulates again through the filter-press until, in outlet, a clean fluid
is obtained. The cake is then fed with new inert material during the filtration phase of
the fluid in order to avoid that the hold back solids create a layer with low
permeability. The so filtrated fluid, is then sent to a unit characterized by cartridges
with absolute filters in order to ensure a good quality of the filtrate and providing the
removal of possible solids released by the DE filter. The filter of the DE unit does not
have a fixed range of filtration since its capability to stop solids depends on the type
of filtering material (inert) and on its settling on the cloths of the unit (filter-press);
however this filtering system is very efficient and is able even to block particles
whose diameters are close to 1-2µm).
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 26 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
The DE system may sometimes release inert material especially during the shocks
to which the filter cake is submitted due to sudden variations of the flowrate or
excessive vibrations of the plant; these materials released in small quantities, are
undeformable and create a filter cake with high permeability that is well supported by
the cartridges filtering unit. Once the filter-press has been filled up or the maximum
pressure differential has been reached on the cloths containing the material (100
psi), the created filter cake must be replaced and therefore it is necessary to stop the
filtration (if a second DE unit is not available, as it generally happens) and start from
the beginning all the phases of the operation (formation of the cake) with new
material (cleaning time 30-45 min).
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 27 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
The filtration should be performed until, in the fluid, there are only solids that can
pass freely through the pores of the rock without causing their plugging. It is well
known that, on average, particles with a diameter greater than 1/3 of the average
pore diameter may create a bridge effect: more particles with this diameter (1/3
dpores), passing at the same time through the pore may hamper each others getting
stuck between themselves and the walls of the pore, plugging it. Particles whose
diameter is greater than 1/6 of the average pore diameter may be dragged by the
fluids, essentially without plugging the pores.
Besides being a function of the granulometry of the particles, the bridging effect is a
function also of their concentration: high concentration of solids, even if with reduced
dimensions, may, anyhow, produce bridging effects, thus damaging the pores of the
rock because of their mechanical plugging. The limit of filtration should be carried up
to 1/3 (better if 1/6) of the average diameter of the pore of the rock, diameter (in µm)
which can be approximately described by the relationship:
where:
K= permeability of the liquid (mD)
Φ = porosity (fraction).
The value of permeability is related to brine because this is the type of fluid
subjected to filtration: it is well-known in fact that the value of permeability is not
constant and is a function of the fluid used for its determination; for example in oil
wells the wettability is a phenomenon to take into account, while in gas wells the
saturation of the rock has an important weight on permeability. In the following chart
some values are reported assuming a formation with a porosity equal to 25% (Φ
=0.25)
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 32 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
etc…) or the nature of the contamination which leads to the formation of colloids
able to pass through the filtering membranes ( e.g. presence of colloidal Iron
Hydroxide, etc…)
Due to the significant presence of suspended material in the emulsions (the droplets
of brine can disperse the light) it is not possible to use the same analytical technique
for these fluids; pure organic fluids (oils, gas oils, etc….) can be controlled by
Nephelometric measurements as well, previously adjusting the equipment, but
significant disturbances are to be expected owing to the coloration of the organic
phase.
Figure 5-6 – Correlation of Turbidimeter Response and ppm Solids from Gravimetric Analysis
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 34 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
Figure 5-7 - Quality of Filtrate: Measure of the NTU vs. Well Volume
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 35 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
2) Water may tend to wet the rock increasing water saturation and reducing relative
permeability to oil or gas. Filtrate invasion is normally termed water blockage. The
extent of oil productivity reduction depends on the degree of water saturation and
the radius of the affected area.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 36 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
3) Liquid filtrate may determine a viscous emulsion with the virgin reservoir oil;
stable emulsions appear to be associated with partially oil-wet systems. Viscosity
effects also include formation plugging by a high-viscosity treating fluid which, for
some reason, does not break and does not return to the well bore under the
available differential pressure.
4) It is also possible the formation of an organic solid called sludge, caused by the
contact of brine with the molecules of resin and/or asphaltene.
In a radial flow system, any reduction in permeability around the well bore results in
serious reduction of productivity or injectivity. In a linear flow situation, some
plugging of the face of the fracture can be tolerated due to the large area
represented by the faces of the fracture. However, plugging of the fracture itself
results in serious reduction in productivity or injectivity.
Clays are all constituted by silicate planes (tetrahedral) and aluminates (octahedron
with part of the aluminium substituted with magnesium) linked together and each
unit, constituted by two or three octahedral/tetrahedral planes exhibits on its external
walls (on the planes) negative charges (the trivalent Aluminium Al3+ has been, in
part substituted by Mg+2, bivalent) while on the edges there are positive charges; the
negative charges are preponderant giving a negative net charge to all the structure.
Among these units there are ions which are able to shield the charges of the
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 37 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
surfaces allowing the approaching and at the end the attraction. The distance
between clay layers is called C-spacing (Figure 6-1), distance variable with the type
of balancing ion and its concentration. Big or small ions but surrounded by many
molecules of water, that is to say highly solvated, attract many molecules of solvent
(that in this case is water), once entered in the zone among planes, even
maintaining integral their structure, move the planes away a bit making the C-
spacing increase; small ions and or less solvated are able to approach more planes
and therefore are considered stabilizing since the total structure appears more
compact.
Clay in contact with brine exchanges a significant number of ions up to reaching a
kind of dynamic balance: as many ions go out from the structure of the clay as many
ions enter again in it like a kind of endless run up. This phenomenon is called ionic
exchange. It is equal to 0.07-0.13 eq / 100g of dry smectite and measures the
number of equivalents of ions exchanged per unit of weight of the clay; for the
vermiculite the value is higher (0.1-0.2 eq/100g) being even more reactive. The
stronger the specific attractive action of the cation which enters between the planes
and the greater its concentration, the higher is the attraction between the different
planes (small C-spacing, compact structure). In fact, decreasing the salinity of the
solution, the number of ions entering the structure decreases (statistically
understandable since ion and structure must collide to interact) while initially the
number of ions going out from it does not change with the result that the number of
entrapped ions will tend to decrease searching a new configuration of balance, the
negative charge of the surface will not be shielded as it was before and the attractive
force will decrease allowing the planes to move away with consequent increase of
the C-spacing. This phenomenon is called swelling and is reversible: increasing
again the ionic concentration, the number of charges entrapped among the planes
will increase, the attractive force will have higher values again and the structure,
decreasing the C-spacing, will compact stabilizing itself (Figure 6-2).
Decreasing too much the salinity of the solution, the repulsive force between the
negatively charged planes becomes so strong that it disgregates the clay units, and
the different planes will tend to disperse in the fluid. Each plane, not electrically
balanced anymore, will repel the adjacent planes causing a state of dispersion
(Figure 6-3); this is for example obtainable putting small quantities of smectite in
distilled water that is a watery fluid without ions which could counterbalance the
surface charges. The state of dispersion is irreversible since an increase of salinity
obtainable adding solid salt or a brine very rich of salt in the dispersion, will cause
the flocculation of the clay, that is to say the layers will attract each others and the
small units, as soon as the minimum dimensions to decant have been achieved
(according the Stokes law) will reach the bottom of the container that contained the
dispersion, but the look, the shape and the layout of the units will be significantly
different from the initial neat state. Comparing the two states, the initial state and the
final one (after the swelling, the dispersion and the flocculation), would be like
comparing a building with the rubble gathered in an area after pulling down the
building.
In virgin formation, the degree of swelling of a clay particle is in equilibrium with the
type and concentration of salts in the connate water. Thus, clean formation water
used in workover operations should not disturb this balance.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 38 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
(C-Spacing increased) The negative charges, not The process is reversible and
shielded anymore, repel increasing the salinity of the fluid
each other and make the the conditions of equilibrium are
structural unit of the clay restored
move away
The brine which penetrates in the formation, should have a salinity (in terms of
quality and/ or quantity of ions) able to maintain the clays localized in the matrix and
inside the pores (in fact the clays often coat the inner part of the pores) where they
were before drilling and the only admitted phenomenon is the swelling. If the fluid is
not compatible and causes dispersion, the fluid lost in the formation will drag the
dispersed layers of clay causing the phenomenon of the dragging of fine particles;
these materials released in significant quantities (the rock often contains a certain
percentage of clay), will create bridges in the restrictions of the pores plugging them
and significantly jeopardizing the permeability of the rock which came in contact with
the not compatible brine. It is possible to place a series of the most common ions in
order that can stabilize the clay:
and therefore phenomena of dispersion are not to be expected using acids and
normal brines whose salinity is at least the 3% in weight (5% for NaCl, since Na+ is
the least stabilizing). If the formation water is particularly salty, the introduction in the
formation of brine with inadequate salinity may cause a shock of salinity to the clays
with a consequent and extremely serious effect of dispersion, as though the clay
burst because of the contact with the completion fluid.
Other clays like the illite (0.01-0.04 eq/100g as ion exchange), the chlorite (0.01-0.04
eq/100g), the attapulgite/sepiolite (0.0 1-0-035 eq/100g) and the
kaolinite/dictite/nacrite (0.003-0.015 eq/100g), are much less expandable and
sensitive to the salinity of the brine. However hybrid forms exist which may tend to
swell slightly, but the state of dispersion can not be reached.
The particles of clay may contribute to phenomena like the movement of fine
particles since they can be dragged by the watery fluid especially if the rock is water-
wet, in the case they are not well-anchored to the porous matrix. In fact the clays are
always sticking to the grains of the rock and plunged in the wetting fluid: they keep
still until the wetting phase keeps still, but as soon as the saturation of this phase
(e.g. water) increases and becomes mobile (e.g. production of formation water) it will
drag the fine particles which will be able to generate a damage due to the plugging
of the pores.
Clay dispersion is affected by pH. Scanning electron microscope studies have
confirmed the effect of pH on clay particle disturbance. Clay particles in core pore
spaces were significantly disturbed and thus made mobile in contact with 8 pH fluid.
This effect was more noticeable when contacted with 10 pH fluid. Virtually no
disturbance was noted when similar core samples were contacted with a 4 pH fluid.
This is due to the reduction of the stabilizing effect of the H+ ion and therefore
especially in case light brine is used, it is necessary to control and to adjust the pH
of the saline solution. However it is necessary to consider that some salts hinder
these manipulations of the pH values.
Phenomena of damage linked with the swelling/dispersion of fine materials may be
hindered by stabilizing products (cationic polymers used at the 1-2% in the brine)
that, introduced in the formation (it is necessary to pump cushions in the formation,
or make them be absorbed, to treat the zone nearest to the well), link tighter with
each other the clay planes and the fine particles to the grain surfaces.
The clay can be cemented in place using Zirconium Oxychloride which creates a
poly-nucleated cation that bond strongly the clay particles together. This system is
stable with HCl but is removed by HF.
It is usually impossible to restore the original permeability, when clay particles in
sandstones are rearranged or disturbed. Thus, formation damage due to clays must
be prevented rather than cured.
the productivity of the invaded level will turn out to be decreased. The more depleted
the level and the lower the permeability of the formation, the more severe the
phenomenon since the flow of hydrocarbons could be inadequate to expel the brine
rapidly from the pores of the rock. The phenomenon is obviously correlated also to
the trend of relative permeability water-hydrocarbon. For highly depleted reservoirs,
especially with low permeability (e.g. gradients<0.5 Kg/cm2/ 10m and K<10-20mD to
the brine), the phenomenon can be so severe as it hinders the flowing of the
hydrocarbon into the pores; this phenomenon is defined water blocking.
WATER BLOCKING
SAND
GRAIN
This kind of problem are faced and often solved by the use of surfactants (used with
concentrations of 0.2-1%), which, reducing the superficial tension of the fluid (from
70 dine/cm to around 20-21 dine/cm), let the formation gas or oil to displace the fluid
more easily.
Problems may arise if oil is a new phase in the formation; in dry gas reservoir
(methane) the introduction of a new phase allows the introduction of a new residual
saturation (oil) which will necessarily reduce the relative permeability of the gas; the
phenomenon may be not so serious, given the high mobility of the gas, but the
decision to use oil based completion fluids in mineralized formations must be
carefully evaluated and will depend on several factors such as the permeability of
the formation, the pressure gradient available for the clean up, the presence of a
organic phase released by oil based fluid used for drilling.
6.3.3.1 SLUDGE
It is also possible to have the formation of the sludge, an organic solid derived from
the collapse of the molecules of asphaltenes and/or resins contained in the oil and
this can be considered as a consequence of the salification (neutralization) of
particular functional groups caused by the metallic ion used for the preparation of the
brine; these solids precipitating within the pores of the rock cause damage to the
formation. It is not possible to give a more accurate explanation of this phenomenon,
given the uncertain composition of the oils, but the more these are heavier and
richer in resin/asphaltenes, the greater is the probability of reaction between these
large molecules and the metallic ions. Even the pH of the brine may play an
important role in the incompatibility between oil and the water-based completion fluid
since the various functional groups of the macromolecules dissolved in the oil are
salified or ionized by the variation of pH. In fact, a functional group which appears to
be charged at an acid pH (e.g.: amminic group -NR1R2H+) may become neutral at
elevated values of pH
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 43 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
− NR1 R 2 H + + OH − ↔ − NR1 R 2 + H 2 O
and therefore it may destabilize and lead to the precipitation of the molecule. The
acids or the brines with low pH may lead to salification reactions of the type
− NR1 R 2 + H + ↔ − NR1 R 2 H +
described above or set off complex reactions of polymerization or decomposition.
The drawbacks created by a negative interaction between oil and brine can be
avoided using particular surfactants (demulsifiers and anti-sludge agent) selected,
however, on the basis of empirical laboratory tests; another possibility is to change
the type of completion fluid and use an oil-based fluid.
Wells exhibit appreciable reduced productivity or injectivity and often require a large
number of costly remedial jobs.
Scale deposited slowly may be very hard and dense, and may be difficult to remove
with acid or other chemicals.
Scale precipitation also varies with calcium ion concentration (common ion effect-
such as from CaCI2), alkalinity of water (concentration of bicarbonate ion),
temperature, total salt concentration, contact time, and degree of agitation:
Also mixing of two incompatible waters (one with high bicarbonate ion content and
one with high concentration of Ca ion) will cause precipitation of CaCO3 scale.
• Both BaSO4 and SrSO4 are usually caused by commingling of two unlike
waters, one containing soluble salts of barium or strontium and the other
containing sulphate ions.
• For a given water salinity, BaSO4 scaling increases.
• With decreases in temperature as a result of decreasing BaSO4 solubility.
• Pressure drop may decrease the solubility of BaSO4
5 – Iron scales
Iron scales are frequently the result of corrosion products such as various iron
oxides and iron sulphide.
High salinity, acid gases (CO2 and H2S), oxygen, sulphate reducing bacteria (SRB),
give corrosion problems, each of these can react with iron in solution or with steel
surfaces to form a precipitate of iron oxide, iron sulphide, iron carbonate.
value of S.I.<0 indicate the under saturation and the impossibility to have
precipitation, the S.I.>0 indicate the possibility to have scale precipitation.
X-ray diffraction is the most used method for scale identification. Each crystalline
chemical compound in the scale diffracts X-rays in a characteristic manner.
Chemical analysis may also be used for scale identification. Samples of scale are
dissolved in specific chemical solution, based on type of scale (determined by
qualitative X-ray analysis). Chemical elements are then analysed by standard
analytics techniques.
WETTING PHASE
ROCK
GRAIN
NON
WETTING
PHASE
Many commercial surfactants appear to lose much of their surface activity above
50,000 ppm salt. To overcome this difficulty, it is sometimes desirable to pump a
preflush of solvent or relatively low salinity water, such as 1% KCI, ahead of the
surfactant treatment. The use of a solvent preflush may also reduce water
production, immediately following treatment. However, a solvent preflush should not
be used in dry gas wells.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 52 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
Fluids viscosified with polymers exhibit non-newtonian behaviour in which the shear
stress does not vary linearly with the shear rate and therefore for each shear rate
value, there is a different viscosity.
In order to completely describe the rheological behaviour of the fluid, it is necessary
to plot an experimental curve showing the viscosity trend for various ranges of
shear: a single value of viscosity, determined at a certain value of shear rate, cannot
describe this behaviour.
The viscosity is determined by means of particular instruments called viscosimeters
and the most commonly used are:
a) Capillary viscosimeter: it consists of a thin quartz tube through which
the fluid passes by gravitational effect; noting the tube diameter and fluid
density, from the time (t, seconds) which is required for a precise volume of
liquid to pass, the kinematic viscosity is calculated (ν = k·t [stokes], where k is
a constant of the instrument). The dynamic viscosity is obtained by multiplying
the kinematic viscosity by the value of density (η = ν·ρ [cps] or [mPa]). This
instrument is usable only for newtonian fluids, since it is not possible to apply
a prefixed shear rates to the fluid.
b) Rotational viscosimeter: the most well-known model is the Fann 35. A
cylinder (rotor) rotates externally and concentrically to a second fixed cylinder
(bob) which is dragged by the fluid movement in the annular space between
the two cylinders; from the drag force exerted on the bob (measured by a
dynamometer) the value of viscosity is obtained taking note of the rotational
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 53 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
speed of the rotor and some constants of the instrument (such as the rotor
and bob diameters and the response law of the dynamometer). It is possible to
measure the viscosity for various ranges of shear rate since different shear
rates can be applied and the corresponding shear stress to maintain motion
can be read.
Such viscosity is constant for newtonian fluids, whereas for non-newtonian fluids an
apparent viscosity is defined, given by the ratio σ / D (ηapp) which is a function of
the shear rate. Non-newtonian fluids are generally described by one or more values
of apparent viscosity corresponding to one or more shear rates (e.g. 1000 cps at 3s-1
and 10 cps at 511 s-1) or by equations (models) in common use; for example for
Ostwald’s type non-newtonian fluids:
Ostwald’s Law: σ = k ⋅ D n or η = σ / D = k ⋅ D n −1
The most commonly used non-newtonian fluids are the pseudoplastic fluids (flow
index, n<1) where the viscosity decreases with the increase in the shear rate. Such
phenomenon is due to the dispersion of the polymer molecules which tend to
change their structure with the variation in the shear rate: as the shear rate is
increased, the molecules stretch and as a consequence the apparent viscosity
decreases.
Fluids which exhibit a yield behave differently; when these fluids are in a state of rest
(gel state), it is necessary to apply a stress of a certain magnitude to put in motion
an immersed object. Once the fluid is in motion, the gel state disappears and it is no
longer necessary to apply an elevated stress to move the immersed object. Drilling
muds always have a yield since, if circulation is interrupted, they can maintain the
solids in suspension for a very long time in so far as the gel state can be regarded
as a state in which the fluid assumes an infinite viscosity. If the mud is maintained in
motion, the gel state does not appear and the drilling mud behaves as a fluid without
yield.
The model which describes the rheology of a fluid of this type can be expressed by a
modified power law by Ostwald ( σ = σo + k Dn) or by an analogous law which takes
into account the fact that a shear σ (σo>σ>0) can be applied to the fluid without
having flow (shear rate = 0, D = 0, even for σ not equal to zero). In this case, the
gelled fluid behaves as a solid (η = σ / D = σ / 0 = ∞, infinite viscosity) with high
deformation and maintains this property until the stress exceeds the threshold value
σo whereupon the force of the gel disappears and movement of the previously
gelled fluid occurs. The gel structure maintains in suspension those solids which
exert a stress σ < σo that is, light or small sized solids for which the preceding
correlation is valid.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 55 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
The viscosity of dilatant fluids on the other hand increases as the shear rate is
increased (n > 1). One of the most noted examples is demonstrated by wet sand that
offers resistance to motion under a person’s foot; some cement slurries also exhibit
a dilatant behaviour.
2 gd p2 ρ p − ρ f
Eq. 7.A vt = ⋅
36 µ
Eq. 7.B
vt = 9 ⋅
[d (ρ − ρ )]
p p f
12
[ρ ] f
12
where:
vt = velocity (cm/s)
g = 981 cm/s2
dp = diameter of the spherical particle (cm)
ρp, ρf = particle and fluid specific weights (g/cm3)
µ = fluid viscosity (poise)
Note: the equations reported above should not be applied for non-spherical particles
(e.g. metal cuttings produced during a milling operation of casing) but equations
which are applicable to different shapes of particles have still not yet been
developed. However, the use of these equations do allow an estimate of the velocity
of differently shaped particles as well as the comparison for the effect of different
dynamic conditions in the well regarding the carrying capacity of fluids.
Supposing that a solid body to be transported to surface has a certain density and
size (and assuming a spherical shape for simplicity), it is possible to evaluate, as a
function of the fluid viscosity and velocity and hence the conditions of turbulent or
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 56 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
laminar flow, its settling velocity and consequently its transport velocity. To evaluate
the viscosity of a non-newtonian fluid (for newtonian fluids the viscosity is constant),
it is necessary to know the well geometry (casing and tubing diameters) and the
circulation flow rate in order to evaluate the shear in the annulus and hence the
value of apparent viscosity of the fluid to be used in the Stoke’s law equation. The
flow regime (laminar or turbulent) is determined by Reynolds number: if the value in
the well is equal to or lower than a critical value (NRecrit) laminar flow exists, whereas
if the value is much higher than NRecrit the flow is turbulent (in the intermediate zone,
the flow condition is in transition between the two extremes).
Transition from laminar to turbulent flow for a newtonian fluid (NRe = Reynold’s
number)
Eq. 7.C ρ f ⋅ν f ⋅ d e
N Re crit =
µ
Transition from laminar to turbulent flow for a pseudoplastic fluid (NRe = Reynold’s
number)
n.
NRecrit
(consistency index)
1 2099
0.9 2158
0.8 2219
0.7 2280
0.6 2337
0.5 2381
In addition to the turbulence arising from flow in the annulus, the same particle may
be subject to a phenomenon of local turbulence which is capable of accelerating the
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 57 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
settling; the critical value of Reynolds number relative to the particle also depends
on the viscosity of the fluid and can be derived from Eq. 7.E.
Transition from laminar to turbolent flow for a newtonian fluid Nre = 2100 (NRe =
Reynold’s number)
Eq. 7.E de ⋅ vt ρ f
N Re, p =
µ
where:
vt = velocity (cm/s)
dp = diameter of the spherical particle (cm)
ρf = fluid specific weights (g/cm3)
µ = fluid viscosity (poise)
Figure 7-3 – Effect of Rheological Behaviour of the Fluid on NRecrit of a Settling Particle
The settling velocity under turbulent flow conditions does not depend on viscosity (it
depends only on Nre). Therefore, increasing the flow rate in a pipe, a fluid with a
higher viscosity will enter in turbulent flow later than a fluid with a lower viscosity but,
after the transition from laminar to turbulent flow conditions, the settling velocity of a
suspended particle will be independent of the viscosity.
The described equations have been used in order to obtain a simplified model of
transport which has allowed the following general observations to be made:
a) In turbulent flow conditions, the carrying capacity (given by the ratio
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 58 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
between the upward velocity of the solid and the fluid velocity in the annulus)
does not depend on fluid viscosity; that is, it does not depend on the quantity
of polymer used in the preparation of a viscosified brine but rather on the
circulation flow rate; this observation derives from the fact that fluid viscosity
does not appear in Eq. 7.B.
b) With viscosified brine (e.g. with HEC), the maximum carrying capacity
is observed at flow rates which correspond to laminar flow regime (since
viscosity is high, vt is a minimum in agreement with Eq. 7.A).
If completion fluids cannot be pumped at high flow rates in order to create a
turbulent flow conditions (i.e. lack of power in small rigs), their carrying capacity may
not be sufficient to remove the heaviest cuttings from the well because of their very
high settling velocity. In such situations, it is necessary to increase the viscosity (vt
decreases in accordance with Eq. 7.A and therefore the particles tend to remain
suspended and follow the direction of flow of the fluid) so that the carrying capacity
is increased to the extent of removing solids from the well.
At high flow rates, a low viscosity fluid such as brine is always able to transport most
of the solids without difficulty: for example, any gravel which remains inside the drill
string at the end of a gravel pack operation, can be easily removed with the
completion brine in reverse circulation.
Therefore, it is necessary to evaluate the use of polymers in operations which
require the transport of solids: if transport can be assured with only the completion
fluid in turbulent flow regime and the high flow rate does not cause any undesired
side-effect such as hole caving or high leak-off (loss of fluid in the formation caused
by the high bottomhole pressure differential), it is not recommended to use a
polymer. If the carrying capacity has to be increased through the use of polymers, it
is necessary to impose a laminar flow regime (by controlling the polymer quantity
and decreasing the velocity) to prevent the fluid from becoming excessively
weighted with cuttings at low flow rate.
Table 7-2 shows the optimum values calculated by the model for metal spheres (sg
= 7,5 g/cm3) with a diameter of 0,1 cm in 3% KCl and for 7” casing (ID = 6,3”) and 3-
1/2” string:
concentrations than those indicated in Table 7-2 (e.g. 65lb/1000 gals, i.e. 7.8 g/l)
satisfy the stated condition: the velocity of transport never reaches zero whatever
the circulation flow rate.
For example, at 60°C, the output plot of the model (Figure 7-4) leads to the
conclusion that the concentration of polymer of 60lb/1000gals (i.e. 7.2 g/l)
guarantees the transport of solids at any flow rate but at flow rates greater than 4,8
bpm, a decrease in the carrying capacity is observed since such the capacity is
governed exclusively by the turbulence regime (the curved line in the chart) which is
common to all fluids, even to non-viscosified brine.
Similar calculations (Figure 7-5), performed on sand particles in the same dynamic
system, lead to the conclusion that 50lb/1000gals (i.e. 6.0 g/l) of HEC are sufficient
to guarantee transport but the maximum applicable flow rate which takes advantage
of the fluid viscosity is lower, after which the transition from laminar to turbulent flow
regime occurs and the capacity falls again to the curve common to all polymer
concentrations in the same brine.
Figure 7-4 – Capacity to Transport 1mm Metal Spheres KCl 3% Viscosified with HEC
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 60 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
Furthermore, it can be observed that the turbulent flow regime is more efficient for
the transport of lighter particles such as sand. Therefore, in order to carry formation
sand to the surface, for example during underreaming operations, it is necessary to
avoid turbulent flow conditions, using lower flow rates and lower polymer
concentrations with respect to those calculated for metal cuttings, as indicated in
Table 7-3.
Obviously, utilizing polymer concentrations (as reported in Table 7-2) established for
the transport of metal spheres, the transport of sand will be assured (since sand is
lighter than metal spheres), but the maximum flow rates indicated in Table 7-2 must
be respected rather than those reported in Table 7-3 which refer to lower
concentrations of polymer.
Eq. 7.F 4Q
Vtb = 13.476
πd 2
Fluid velocity in an annulus:
Eq. 7.G 4Q
Van =13.476
π ⋅(D2 −d2)
Value of Reynolds number for a fluid pumped in a tubing (NRe = Reynold’s number):
where:
vtb = average velocity through tubing (ft/s)
van = average velocity through annulus (ft/s)
d = tubing diameter (OD, in)
D = casing diameter (ID, in)
ρ = specific weight of fluid (ppg)
Q = flow rate of fluid (bpm)
n’ = flow index of viscous fluid (n’ = n, dimensionless)
k’ = consistency index of viscous fluid (k’ = k [(3n + 1)/ n], lbfsn’/ft2)
[1 lbfsn’/ft2 = 47,88 Pa·s, Poise]
By applying Eq. 7.F-7.J and still assuming a casing with ID = 6,3” and a string with
OD = 3-1/2”, values of NRe and NRe(cr) for various polymer concentrations (HEC) in
3% KCl and at 50°C have been determined; these values are reported in Figure 7-6.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 62 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
From the Figure 7-6, it can be predicted that for polymer concentrations equal to
55lb/1000gals (i.e. 6.6 g/l), the maximum allowable flow rate to maintain a linear flow
regime is around 5,0bpm (against 5,4bpm as reported in Table 7-2), whereas for
polymer concentrations equal to 45lb/1000gals (i.e. 5.4 g/l), the maximum flow rate
is 3,1bpm (against 2,3bpm as reported in Table 7-3). The discrepancy between the
predictions of the two systems of equations can be found in the different way the
critical value of Reynolds number is calculated, as illustrated in Figure 7-7.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 63 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
Eq. 7.A-7.E have to be preferred since they predict lower limits of flow rates and
these equations are therefore used to establish the velocities for the transport of
solids in conditions of circulation.
In order to ensure a laminar flow regime at higher flow rates than those
recommended, it is necessary to increase polymer concentration which will result in
the use of a fluid having a very high capacity of transport which is capable of
carrying much heavier or larger cuttings to surface than is actually required;
moreover, the increase in cost for the greater use of the polymer needs to be taken
into account.
Whichever fluid is used (brine in turbulent flow or viscosified brine in laminar flow), it
is always a good practice during the circulation to displace pills which create a
different flow regime from the established one.
For example, with a simple brine the only practical flow regime is turbulence but in
this situation the settling velocity of the cuttings is at a maximum: the displacement
of a highly viscous pill (80-120lb/1000gals = 9.6-14.4 g/l of HEC according to the
temperature and flow rate and a volume equal to 100-150m of annulus) imposes a
laminar flow regime which is capable of carrying to surface the cuttings which remain
downhole. Similarly, if the flow regime during the operation is laminar as a result of
the use of viscosified brine and low flow rates, some cuttings can adhere to the wall
of the casing where the fluid velocity is zero (by definition of laminar flow) and
consequently the carrying capacity is zero. The displacement of a pill of non-viscous
brine (volume equal to 50-100m in the annulus) will induce turbulent flow conditions
which are capable of releasing these cuttings and subsequently transporting them to
surface through the action of the viscous fluid which follows in laminar flow and has
a high carrying capacity. When using viscosified salt solutions in laminar flow
conditions, it is possible to avoid the displacement of low viscosity pills if the
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 64 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
concentration of the polymer is not excessive, since the different flow regimes can
be achieved simply by varying the flow rate.
Another factor which negatively affects the recovery of metallic cuttings (metal
shavings produced during milling operations) is caused the magnetization of the
particles which then adhere more easily to the wall of the casing: even in this case,
the variations of flow regime should be beneficial.
The rate of rotation of the drill string can also affect the recovery of cuttings with
viscosified brine: although it is well-known that rotation assists in the recovery of
solids since it prevents the orientation of the particles according to their size less
than with respect to the direction of flow, high rates of rotation decrease the viscosity
of the viscous medium. The variations of flow rate established for the transition from
laminar to turbulent flow conditions are achieved more easily when assisted by
variations in the rate of rotation: the higher is the rate rotation the easier turbulent
conditions will be achieved.
The concepts presented above can be applied to other operations such as sand pills
used as an abrasive for the casing cleaning.
Milling and underreaming operations in front of pay zones should however be
executed with non-damaging drilling fluids specifically planned for these operations:
these fluids are called DIF, Drill-in-Fluids. Drilling in front of pay zones is in fact,
from the point of view of productivity, the most delicate and critical of all the drilling
phases: the use of unsuitable fluids can cause severe damage which may be
removed only by subsequent stimulation treatments, which may not necessarily be
successful.
environment which can be introduced to the brine during its preparation: the
contamination accelerates the degradation and therefore it is necessary to plan
for the addition of additives to XC in order to maintain a stable viscosity. When
polymers are added to an aqueous solution, they will tend to hydrate and once the
hydration is completed, the fluid will achieve its maximum value of viscosity. The
polymers chains will degrade with time and more rapidly when breakers are
added leaving an insoluble residue; consequently, it is necessary to use good
quality polymers with low residue in order to minimize the damage caused to the
formation.
e) Filter the viscosified fluid (DE filter + 10µm nominal cartridge) ensuring both the
removal of solids and fish eyes (fluids viscosified with XC are hard to filter).
Although this operation is always recommended, it may not be possible to perform
this continuously while using the fluid for underreaming operations as it will
become contaminated by large quantities of sand and clay; however, the
presence of these solids, if not removed, may cause severe formation damage;
f) Add the required additives in order to complete the preparation (e.g. biocide
and/or oxygen scavengers);
g) Add the breaker (when required) immediately prior to using the viscous fluid; for
the concentration, reference is made to charts and tables provided by Service
Companies or to ad hoc tests performed in the laboratory; nevertheless, it is
necessary to take into account some incompatibilities when selecting the breaker:
Enzymes lose their functionality in brines prepared with bivalent salts (calcium and
zinc) and where the pH of the solution is far from neutral;
Oxidants react with bromide ion (2Br - + Ox ==> Br2gas ; bromide is a toxic gas) and
therefore lose their effectiveness in brines prepared from NaBr, KBr, CaBr2 and
ZnBr2 (the reaction rate of the evolution of chlorine is extremely slow and practically
does not take place in chloride brines;
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 67 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
Oxidant breakers can react with other additives or contaminants that are easily
oxidised (e.g. alcohols and hydrocarbons);
Acids used as breakers (e.g. HCOOH or HCl), rather than reacting slowly with the
polymer (in terms of ten of minutes or hours), react very rapidly with any carbonates
contained in the rock, spending itself and losing any beneficial effect on the
decrease of viscosity;
If the breaking of the polymer does not occur within the planned period of time and if
the well is damaged (e.g. after inside casing gravel pack completion with the slurry
pack technique), it is possible to resort to matrix stimulations operations performed
by the injection of light salt solutions containing a high concentration of breaker;
such solutions must be compatible with the viscous fluid which is preventing
production. If it is possible to shut-in the well for a period of time (at least one
month), it is recommended to wait before performing a stimulation treatment: the
polymer may degrade by itself or by other mechanisms, restoring the productivity to
acceptable levels. Matrix stimulation treatments after polymer damage should
preferably be performed with the injection of weak acids which manage to penetrate
deep into the formation (retarding effect) rather than with aggressive acids which can
lead to the dissolving of large quantities of rock material.
Although it is possible to viscosify oil-based fluids, such operation is practically never
performed for completions since the polymers are very expensive and hard to treat
(e.g. reliable breakers are not available).
Emulsions which are prepared for completion operations already have a high
viscosity which can be modified by varying the ratio oil/brine since the greater the
proportion of the dispersed phase, the stability of the system permitting, the higher is
the viscosity: the addition of oil (external phase) decreases the viscosity of the
system (effect of dilution), whereas the increase in the aqueous phase (internal
phase) by increasing the number of suspended droplets, increases significantly the
viscosity. Emulsions are almost never used for underreaming operations since, if
loaded with shaly solids, they may be transformed irreversibly into damaging fluids
(shales are deformable solids) similar, at least in part, to drilling muds. Although it is
not recommended, the viscosity of oil-based completion fluids may be brought about
by proven procedures of the Service Companies (different surfactants are available
and only these Companies possess the necessary know-how to carry out
modifications of the systems; however, it would be prudent to have assistance from
a laboratory in order to avoid problems which have not been reported by these
Companies).
Consequently, the problem of the viscosifying of completion fluids can be restricted
to the viscosifying of salt solutions.
Polymer Type* Viscosity Filtration Suspension Acid Temp. Brine
Development Control Properties Solubility Stab. Tolerance
HEC NI Excellent Poor Poor Excellent 100-120°C Excellent
HEMC NI Excellent Poor Poor Good 100-120°C Excellent
CMC A Good Good Fair Poor 100-120°C Poor
XC-Polymer A Fair Poor Excellent Good 100-140°C Fair
PAC A Poor Good Poor Poor 100-150°C Poor
Starch NI Poor Good Poor Poor 100-120°C Good
Guar NI Excellent Poor Poor Fair 80-100°C Good
Polyacrylate A Poor Good Poor Insol. 140-170°C Poor
* NI = Non-Ionic A = Anionic
Table 7-4 - Characteristics of Water Soluble Polymers Used for Viscosity, Suspension or
Filtration Control; Temperature Stability is Dependent to the Salinity (Salt type and Conc.).
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 68 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
are used in colder weather or colder climates and have crystallization points ranging
from approximately -7°C to below -18°C.
At times, a crystallization point between those of summer and winter blends is
desirable. Special formulations are then used to prepare fluids that can be called
fall, spring or intermediate blends.
At first, it may seem practical to consistently formulate fluids having lower than
necessary, and therefore safe, crystallization points. Although this approach may be
easier, it is likely to be much more expensive. Generally, if a fluid with a lower
crystallization point is provided, the cost of the brine will be considerably higher than
necessary. This is just one of numerous factors to consider when selecting a fluid
that is both effective and economical.
The determination of the crystallization point of a salt solution is carried out by a
cooling cycle (until the appearance of the solid phase) followed by a heating cycle
(until the complete dissolving of the solid formed during the cooling cycle). Following
the trend of temperature as a function of time, when transitions of phase occur
(beginning of solidification/precipitation or end of dissolving), discontinuities are
observed (Figure 8-1). The faster the determination is made, the greater the
difference is between LCTD and FCTA. If the same measurement is carried out
more slowly, the two values will tend to approach one another and when the
difference is in the range of ±1°C, the LCTD and FCTA are assumed to be equal to
the TCT.
the productivity. In the simplest cases, it is just necessary to allow the bottomhole
temperature rise in order to remove the damage; where salt is precipitated (in the
case of solutions close to saturation) rather than the formation of ice, the solvent
(water) will be removed by the cleaning action and the redissolving will be
prevented, inducing permanent damage in the formation.
In Table 8-1 are shown the maximum density reachable with the most common salts
in water solutions. The table has been divided separating the salts which are used
for the preparation of brine in the range of density 1.1-1.2 kg/l (sodium, potassium
and ammonium chloride) and the other salts which can achieve higher densities: the
compatibility between salts in the same group is generally good, whereas the
compatibility between salts of different groups may be poor. The compatibility
among salts of the same section of Table 8-1 is usually good, but the
compatibility between two salts of different groups is not always good.
In the Tables from B.1 to B.7 in APPENDIX - B, preparation of single-salt solution
are shown.
NaCl, KCl and NH4Cl are fully compatible each other and so it is possible to prepare
all the blends of brine NaCl/KCl/NH4Cl. NaBr and KBr are two compatible salts (it is
possible to obtain NaBr/KBr brine blend). Although they are monovalent, they can
give elevated densities. Their compatibility with the chlorides (NaCl and KCl) is
complete and so it is possible to make heavy the solutions of chloride by preparing
NaCl/NaBr and KCl/KBr blends. The formulations of such brines are shown in
Tables B.9 and B.10 in APPENDIX - B.
The maximum attainable densities in water are reported in Table 8-1 for salts which
are commonly used in the field; the salt which does not contain halogen ions
(K2CO3) has been inserted at the end because it has a very different behaviour
compared with the other salts and it is rarely used (for convenience, the values of
the heat of dissolution are also reported).
contain iron fluids may create negative effects for some particular rock formation in
the presence of high carbonate and/or high sulphate ion concentration. Since the
fluids with significant zinc and calcium ion concentration in subterranean wells
containing carbonate or carbon dioxide result in precipitation of calcium and zinc
carbonates.
After studies, utilizing NaBr (1,52 kg/l), KBr (1,306 kg/l), KCl (1,17 kg/l), NaCl (1,19
kg/l) or their mixtures (density < 1.48 kg/l) as completion fluids, the precipitation
within reservoir rock and, therefore, to formation damage problems have been
partially resolved in place of calcium containing solutions.
But carbon dioxide or carbonate containing wells have been encountered which
require drilling and completion fluids mostly with densities of at least 1.68 – 2.40 kg/l.
For the operational requirements, the heavy completion fluids for use in sulphate
and/or carbonate containing wells have been developed in recently years.
One type of the calcium free high density completion fluids are composed by
mixtures of zinc bromide (ZnBr2), one or more alkali metal bromide (NaBr, KBr and
LiBr) and water. The brines can reach the densities up to about 2.46 kg/l, as showed
in the following:
• the density ZnBr2/NaBr in the range of 1,50 – 2,30, preferable 1,80 – 2,30 kg/l;
• the density ZnBr2/KBr in the range of 1.38 – 2.30, preferable 1,80 – 2,30 kg/l;
• the density ZnBr2/LiBr in the range of 1.62 – 2.16, preferable 1.80 – 2.16 kg/l.
The pH values of theses mixtures are about 1.0 to 7.5. These solutions can work
well with corrosion inhibitors to provide a less or non-corrosive environment for down
hole application.
The calcium free solutions may be prepared by mixing a zinc bromide/alkali metal
bromide base fluid with one or more monovalent alkali metal bromide solutions. The
zinc bromide /alkali metal bromide base fluids may be prepared:
1) by combining solid zinc bromide and water with a solid alkali metal bromide or an
aqueous solution;
2) by dissolving dry alkali metal bromide (s) in aqueous zinc bromide solutions.
iii
are also compatible with each other (it is possible to obtain a combination of
NaBr/KBr) and, even though monovalent, they can achieve high densities; their
compatibility with their respective chlorides (NaCl and KCl) is complete and it is
therefore possible to weight up chloride solutions by preparing mixtures of
NaCl/NaBr and KCl/KBr (in this latter case it is preferable not to exchange the cation
in order to maintain the degree of inhibition offered by potassium). The solutions
containing only calcium ions, CaCl2 CaBr2, and eventually zinc ions (ZnBr2) are
compatible with each other and can be mixed in a wide range of ratios. Because of
its high pH, K2CO3 is incompatible with all brines containing calcium, zinc and even
ammonium chloride (attention: ammonia gas is released).
It is particularly important to consider the change from low-medium density brines (≤
1.2 kg/l) to higher density brines which must overcome the transition from the use of
monovalent to bivalent ions. It is in fact possible that, because of the unexpected
existence of over-pressurized zones, it may be necessary to increase the weight of a
low density brine (under 1.2 kg/l) consisting of a monovalent salt above the density
limit which corresponds to its saturation, necessitating the use of bivalent salts. Such
operation is not always possible without destabilizing the entire system and causing
the precipitation of monovalent salt. The results of the addition of solid salts to NaCl
and CaCl2 solutions are reported in APPENDIX - B; it emerges from the tests that:
• the density of NaCl brine (1.18 kg/l) can be increased with KBr up to 1.32 kg/l;
• the density of CaCl2 brine (1.34 kg/l) can be increased with CaBr2 up to 1.49 kg/l.
V1 + V2 = Vf
where:
V1 = volume of one of the materials to be mixed together
sg1 = density of the above material
V2 = volume of the second material to be mixed
sg2 = density of the second material
Vf = total or sum of all volumes mixed together
sgf = density of the final fluid; it is the proportional average density of all
volumes mixed together
When working and formulating brine, the engineer will have to perform basic
calculations in order to increase or to cut brine densities. The following equations are
going to review these basic engineering calculations.
⎛ Vow * Wf ⎞
Wa = Vo⎜⎜ − Wo ⎟⎟
⎝ Vfw ⎠
Vfw
Vf = Vo *
Vow
where:
Wa = weight of salt to add
Vo = original volume of brine
Vow = original volume of water
Wf = final weight of salt
Vfw = final volume of water
Wo = original weight of salt
Vf = final volume of brine
Increase the density of a two salt brine with dry calcium bromide:
⎛ CoWf ⎞
Wa = Vo⎜⎜ − Wo ⎟⎟
⎝ Cf ⎠
⎛ CoBf ⎞
Ba = Vo⎜⎜ − Bo ⎟⎟
⎝ Cf ⎠
⎛ Co ⎞
Vf = Vo⎜⎜ ⎟⎟
⎝ Cf ⎠
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 76 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
where:
Co = original weight of CaCl2
Cf = final weight of CaCl2
Bo = original weight of CaBr2
Bf = final weight of CaBr2
Ba = CaBr2 to be added
Wa = water to be added
Vo = original volume of brine
Wf = final weight of salt
Wo = original weight of salt
Vf = final volume of brine
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 77 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
9.1 CORROSIVITY
Packer fluid used as completion fluids can be single, two or three mixtures due to
the fact that single salt brines have density limitations and mixture of salts are
needed to satisfy hydrostatic pressure requirements. The medium density ranges
from 8.4 to 19.2 lb/gal (1-2.3 g/cm3).
The most used brines are: KCl, NaCl, CaCl2, CaBr2 e ZnBr2.
Their corrosivity depends on temperature, contact time of the packer fluid with the
steel surface, brine composition and relative density, ratio between metal surface
area and brine volume and pH.
Generally the corrosivity increases with temperature and with acidity.
Mixtures of salts are more corrosive than the single salt brines; the brines which
contain the ZnBr2 have the highest corrosion rates since the pH of these solutions is
acidic.
Usually, corrosion inhibitors are used to protect the steel from corrosion. However
the high ion concentration of these fluids makes inhibition difficult due to limited
dispersibility and solubility of the most conventional inhibitors in these environments.
Moreover, corrosion inhibitors have been originally designed for use with carbon
steels rather than CRA materials and their efficiency has to be proven especially at
high temperature.
Brines used as packer fluids can be single –two – or three salt mixtures.
More recent products are the Formate Brines, introduced in the nineties.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 78 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
Higher penetration rates are expected in CaCl2 + CaBr2 + ZnBr2 blends: based on
laboratory tests, acid corrosion rate of carbon and low alloy steels, always referred
to uninhibited conditions, is of about 0.2 mm/y.
Addition of corrosion inhibitors, although their efficiency is uncertain in particular
after long term exposures, would lead to corrosion rates below those ones reported
here above.
Based on laboratory test results the following conclusions can be issued for acid
corrosion of carbon and low alloy steels in contact with halide based clear brines:
• corrosion rate at temperature below 100 °C is expected to be lower than 0.1 mm/y
(taken as acceptable limit) except for ZnBr2 or ZnBr2 containing blends;
• in CaCl2 + CaBr2 + ZnBr2 blends corrosion rate, in uninhibited conditions, is of about
0.2 mm/y;
• corrosion rate increases as temperature increases;
• corrosion rate increases as brine density increases;
• corrosion rate decreases as exposure time increases;
• corrosion rates can be mitigated by addition of corrosion inhibitor: however, the
inhibition efficiency is uncertain.
Concerning occurrence of stress corrosion cracking, in absence of oxygen the risk
seems to be negligible for low-medium temperatures. In laboratory tests [v]
performed in halide based brines, cracks have been observed only at high
temperature (260 °C) and on high strength steels.
Oxygen corrosion is a major concern for corrosion resistant alloys: risk of occurrence
of pitting corrosion depends on type of alloy and it increases as temperature
increases; pitting corrosion, especially at high temperature, can easily evolve into
chloride stress corrosion cracking.
Corrosion rates in aerated solutions appear to be much higher than 0.1 mm/y; this
condition is probably dominated by presence of dissolved oxygen and probably not
different from halide brines.
In de-aerated formate brines, corrosion rate of carbon and low alloy steels is
reported to be negligible in most cases, but with a few unexplained test results,
where extremely high corrosion rates, higher than 1 mm/y, were observed, also at
neutral to alkaline pH’s.
In summary, it seems that further investigations, possibly based on tests performed
by independent laboratories, to assess the true corrosivity of formate based clear
brines, are necessary.
Packer fluids:
• NaCl and sea water
• CaCl2
• NaBr
• NaCl/NaBr
• CaCl2/CaBr2
• ZnBr2/CaBr2
• CaCl2/CaBr2/ZnBr2
Evaluation criteria used to determine the packer fluid corrosivity is the following:
Localised corrosion
• low pitting intensity: 0-2
• moderate pitting intensity: 2-4
• severe pitting intensity: 4-6
Where, for pitting intensity, reference is made to an empiric scale from 0 to 6 where
‘0’ means: “no pitting” and ‘6’ means “large and diffuse pitting” [vi].
When mixtures of salts are present (in particular heavy brines) and at temperatures
higher than 150°C, addition of pH controller and corrosion inhibitor is recommended.
In presence of CaBr2/ZnBr2, SCC phenomena cannot be excluded.
In case of contamination of the packer fluid with CO2, corrosion rate can increase.
• If the tubing material is martensitic stainless steel:
Corrosion can be considered acceptable except for the following brines:
ZnBr2/CaBr2 , CaCl2/CaBr2 e CaCl2/CaBr2/ZnBr2 where risk of localised corrosion
(pitting and crevice) and SCC are foreseen.
• If the tubing material is duplex stainless steel:
In presence of NaCl, CaCl2 and NaBr uniform and localised corrosion is considered
acceptable up to temperature as high as 150°C. At T > 150°C the corrosion risk for
localised corrosion increases and it cannot be considered anymore acceptable.
In presence of ZnBr2/CaBr2 duplex 25%Cr is considered resistant, with and without
corrosion inhibitor; duplex 22%Cr presents SCC risk at T> 150°C. Below this
temperature the risk is acceptable.
• If the tubing material is superaustenitic stainless steel or based nickel alloy:
uniform and localised corrosion is acceptable.
9.2.1.1 BROMIDES
Bromides are generally acidic and have Bromine coupled with Zinc, Calcium or
Sodium to add weight with ZnBr2 being the heaviest and most acidic. Bromides are
generally classified as brines but are much more aggressive towards NBR and
HNBR than typical brines. The weight and pH of the pure solutions are shown in
Table 9-4.
9.2.1.2 FORMATES
Formates are generally basic and can be coupled with Sodium (NaCOOH),
Potassium (KCOOH) or Caesium (CsCOOH). Formates offer clean and solids-free
completion brine with better environmental characteristics than the Chlorides and
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 86 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
9.2.1.3 BRINES
Basic brines include saltwater and chlorides and are generally compatible with the
elastomers listed in Table 9-4. They can be buffered to be basic or acidic and
corrosion inhibitors are frequently added. Testing is advised if extra ingredients are
added.
9.2.1.6 DIESEL
Diesel is used to stimulate wells as well as for a general inexpensive completion fluid
that will sit on top of packers. Diesel will cause FEPM and EPDM to swell
significantly.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 87 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
10.3 PH CONTROL
10.3.1 DEFINITION OF PH
The water molecule (H2O) has the tendency to dissociate spontaneously into H+ ions
(hydrogen ions or simple protons) and OH− ions (hydroxyl ions):
H 2 O ⇔ H + + OH -
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 92 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
This is a reversible reaction and the equilibrium leads to the presence of 10-7
moles/litre of H+ ions and 10-7 moles/litre of OH− ions. The reaction is governed by
the equilibrium constant (K) which is given by the product of the concentration of the
produced ions with respect to the concentration of the reactant:
Kw =
[H ]⋅ [OH ]
+ −
[H 2 O]
[ ][ ]
K w = H + ⋅ OH − = 10 −14 mole 2 / l 2
The dissociation of water generates H+ ions and OH- in equal proportions and
therefore [H+] = [OH-]. Since [H+]⋅[OH-] = [H+]⋅[H+] = [H+]2 = 10-14 it follows that
[H+]=10-7 as stated above.
The pH is a measurement of the H+ ion concentration in a solution and it is
expressed as the negative logarithm to the base of ten of the hydrogen ion
concentration:
pH = − log 10 H + [ ]
Therefore, pure water has a
If a strong acid is added to water (e.g. HCl 10-4 mole/l), there will be an increase in
the hydrogen ion concentration and a decrease in the hydroxyl ion concentration:
The quantity of OH- ions will be given only by the dissociation of water, and hence
the equilibrium constant can be deduced with approximation:
[OH ] = K [H ] = 10
−
w
+ −14
/ 10 −4 = 10 −10 mole / l
Therefore, the pH of the solution will be equal to - log10⋅[10-4] = 4; this value, being
less than 7, indicates an acid environment.
If a strong base is added to water (i.e. NaOH 10-4 mole/l), there will be an increase in
the hydroxyl ions and a decrease in the proton concentration.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 93 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
The quantity of H+ ions will be given only by the dissociation of water and hence the
equilibrium constant can be deduced with approximation:
[H ] = K [OH ] = 10
+
w
− −14
/ 10 −4 = 10 −10 mole / l
The pH of the solution will therefore be equal to - log10⋅[10-10] = 10; this value being
greater than 7, indicates a base (or alkaline) environment.
An acid solution (having a pH less than 7) can be neutralized (that is to say the pH
can be brought back to 7) by a base which releases OH- ions which can react with
the H+ ions released by the acid.
Obviously, the opposite reasoning is also valid: an acid can neutralize a base
solution, by the reaction of the H+ ions with the OH- ions released in solution.
The concentrations have been expressed in mole/l: the number of moles is given by
the weight of the added material (100% pure) divided by the molecular weight of the
same material.
With weak acids/bases (that is, not totally dissociated and therefore governed in the
same way as water by their own equilibrium constants) and for concentrations of
strong acids/bases lower then 10-4 mole/l, the calculation becomes more complex,
but the concept of pH does not change.
but this does not necessarily mean that the salt is pure: for example, the salt used in
the field to prepare CaCl2 1.34 g/l, from the pH and density measurements,
contained a significant quantity of iron which lowered the pH through the formation of
Fe(OH)3 :
Fe +3 + 3H 2 O ⇒ Fe(OH ) 3( s. gel ) + 3H +
which is a colloidal and flocculent solid (as are almost all poorly soluble hydroxides)
that settles with difficulty and impedes the filtration operations.
In the case where the brine is found to be very rich in solids, modification of the pH
to values lower than neutrality (pH = 6-6.5) could dissolve a part of the material (if
made up of hydroxides or carbonates) which should not re-precipitate.
For all chlorinated and brominated brines containing sodium, potassium and calcium
ions, it is recommended to adjust the pH of the salt solution close to the value of
neutrality (and even better if the pH = 7.5-8); the modification, preferably made with
the hydroxide of the same cation (KOH for potassium salts, NaOH for sodium salts
and Ca(OH)2 for calcium salts) or with HCl (HBr, although preferable for brominated
salts, is rarely used), should be carried out after dissolving the salt but before
starting the filtration operations.
The quantities of the base/acid to be added vary exponentially (to the base 10)
according to the difference between the pH of the solution and pH = 7. Theoretically,
the quantities of the substances to add are as follows:
chemical to be
Molecular Weight
Initial pH added to 1m3 to quantity (g o ml)
(g/mole)
reach a pH =7
KOH (solid) 56 1 56 g
3 NaOH (solid) 40 40 g
Ca(OH)2 (solid) 74.1 74 g
KOH (solid) 56 1 5.6 g
4 NaOH (solid) 40 4.0 g
Ca(OH)2 (solid) 74.1 7.4 g
KOH (solid) 56 1 0.55 g
5 NaOH (solid) 40 0.39 g
Ca(OH)2 (solid) 74.1 0.73 g
chemical to be added
Molecular Weight
Initial pH to 1m3 to reach a pH quantity (g o ml)
(g/mole)
=7
HCl 37% (d=1.18 Kg/l) 36.5 0.09 ml
9 HCl 15% (d=1.07Kg/l) 36.5 0.23 ml
HCl 7.5% (d=1.03Kg/l) 36.5 0.47 ml
HCl 37% (d=1.18 Kg/l) 36.5 0.88 ml
10 HCl 15% (d=1.07Kg/l) 36.5 2.27 ml
HCl 7.5% (d=1.03Kg/l) 36.5 4.72 ml
HCl 37% (d=1.18 Kg/l) 36.5 8.8 ml
11 HCl 15% (d=1.07Kg/l) 36.5 22.7 ml
HCl 7.5% (d=1.03Kg/l) 36.5 47.2 ml
10.5 VISCOSIFICATION
The possible viscosification of the brine will be effected by the dispersion of polymer
in the filtered salt solution with a pH adjusted to 5-5.5. Some polymers may also
require the addition of particular substances since the yield in viscosity and the
rheological stability of the viscosified fluid may be affected by the contamination from
particular ions; an example is given by XC which requires the addition of Na2EDTA
(bisodium salt of ethylene-diamine-tetra-acetic acid) in order to complex (a process
through which an ion is removed from the solution) the bivalent ions (calcium and
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 96 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
magnesium). After a suitable period of agitation (at least 15 minutes after the last
addition), increasing the pH up to 8.5-9 will promote the hydration process. Where it
is dangerous to modify the pH of salt solutions, the brine (containing the dispersed
polymer at natural pH, or better, with a pH close to = 7) must be heated to at least at
45°-50° C by circulating through a choke (or using heaters, if available in the field) to
enable a faster and more complete hydration.
An incomplete hydration of the polymer can lead to overdosing which may hinder the
subsequent operations because of the occurrence of sudden and unexpected
increases in viscosity during circulation in the well (the circulating fluid is subject to
shear stresses and heating thus completing the hydration process). The viscosified
brine will then need to be passed through a shearing device or a choke to break the
fisheyes which may be present and then through the filtration equipment; it is
recommended to perform the filtration of both the brine and viscosified fluid to
ensure the quality of the filtered fluid.
The use of pre-hydrated polymers (in liquid form) is recommended only for the
heavier fluids since the dispersion of the polymer is obtained more quickly: the
hydration process should in any case be assisted by heating the brine and followed
by the operations of shearing and filtration. The pre-hydrated polymers are made up
of a polymer suspended in a solvent (the term pre-hydrated is therefore to be
considered incorrect): if the solvent is a hydrocarbon (even if pure), its use is not
recommended in dry gas wells since, when losses are encountered, a significant
quantity of oil is introduced into the formation which can reduce the permeability to
gas because of the effect of the irreducible saturation in oil; however, there are
polymers which are pre-hydrated in mutual solvent or even better, in glycols and
which can therefore be used in dry gas wells.
10.6 FILTRATION
The preliminary filtration of the fluid is always recommended even when the fluid is
viscosified for use in milling or underreaming operations: the fisheyes are in fact
highly deformable solids and are therefore damaging; obviously, the filtration
operations cannot be performed continuously during these operations because of
the significant amount of solids that enter the fluid. As already stated previously, a
fluid enriched with deformable solids can no longer be considered non-damaging:
the probability that solids removed from the formation and dispersed in the fluid may
cause a plugging of the pores in the rock is in fact very high; nevertheless, the
filtration of the underreaming fluid is recommended in order to avoid any damage
which may be caused by the presence of fisheyes (partially hydrated polymer). The
operations which are carried out in open hole (and include the possible drilling of the
pilot hole, milling of the casing and underreaming of the formation) are very delicate
since no subsequent improvement of the communication between the well and the
formation can be obtained through the execution of perforating tunnels. These
operations, which are performed in the productive zone of the formation (pay-zone),
should be performed using only non damaging fluids (called Drill-In Fluid). These
fluids have characteristics similar to a drilling mud, but have the capacity to
significantly decrease and sometimes completely avoid the damage. These fluids
are also often used during coring operations when it is necessary to take a
preserved sample of the formation and thus avoiding the invasion of the filtrate of a
common drilling mud. Drill-in Fluids are available as WBM as OBM.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 97 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
Obviously, it is not possible to cover the entire spectrum of the different situations
which may be encountered in the field, but it is recommended that the personnel
responsible for the preparation and the quality control of the brine are familiar, from
experience, with the type of additives that will be used: where this is not the case,
they should resort to the advice of personnel who are expert in the use of brines; this
will bring benefits in the growth of the know-how of the personnel responsible for the
preparation and the control of the completion brine, as well as for the results
obtained by the Company.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 98 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
11. DISPLACEMENT
Before going on with the present Section of this manual, it is suggested to refer to
the Completion Procedures Manual (STAP-P-1-M-7120 Sections 4.5 and 4.6).
If the cleaning operations are performed where a communication exists between the
well and the formation (e.g. in wells which have already produced and hence the
casings are already perforated), the fluids to be used for the cleaning must always
ensure the hydraulic control of the well and its density must higher enough to apply,
at the level of the open zones, a differential pressure in favour of the well towards
the formation.
Furthermore, in these wells which are already in communication with the mineralized
formation, it will be necessary to protect the rock and/or the tunnels against any
contamination which could be introduced by the loss of the pills in the formation and
which would consequently lead to a reduction in the future productivity from the well.
fluid in the hole and the fluid that will be used for displacement. The selected spacer
(s) must be compatible with adjacent fluids.
A pill is a mixture which is different from the fluid in the hole. Pills are used to provide
viscosity, to carry debris out of the hole, to neutralize the fluids and to prevent lost
circulation.
While chemical washers, formulated by surfactants or solvents to remove inorganic
or organic contaminants and residues, act for cleaning. Their annulus height should
be as a minimum 150 – 200 m at largest section.
To effect the maximum displacement efficiency and minimum interface
mixing/contamination, if possible, all fluids should be pumped in turbulent flowing
regime. Washing fluids could be pumped initially in direct circulation with a flow rate
at turbulent regime in annulus, except of high viscous pills which should be pumped
in laminar flow conditions: the variation of the flow regimes will guarantee a better
cleaning up degree as a turbulence will remove the residual solids while the high
viscous pills, in a laminar flow condition, will transport the removed solids to surface.
The correct flow rate to obtain the required flow regimes is to apply a minimum value
to get a turbulent flow with the low viscous fluids (oil and water) while the more
viscous pills will undoubtedly fall under laminar flow conditions (a flow rate of 3-4
bpm, i.e. 0,48 – 0,64 m3/min, for 7” casing with 3 ½” drill pipe should, for example,
always be able to ensure the flowing at both conditions).
It should be mentioned also that the behaviour of the surfactants (recommended
here for the cleaning up operations) is not consistent and can vary (from 0 to 100 %)
regarding to different mud systems (WBM and OBM) also because the additions
continuously polymers, co-polymers and surfactants, etc. make each mud a unique
system. It’s better to ascertain case by case the compatibility of the surfactants
through the laboratory tests (requiring a mud sample from the well site and send it to
the laboratory with a specific requirement of what the operations are planned in the
well and which kinds of product are expected to be used) or through the simple field
tests.
Both displacement procedures (direct and reverse) make use of spacers, chemical
washers and pills for effective hole cleaning up.
Loss rate Loss rate Loss severity Possible formation Cure methods
(bbl/h) (m3/h)
1 - 20 0.159 – 3,18 Seepage Porous and High viscous pills
permeable Acidizable fine-medium
granular
Acidizable fine-medium
fiber
20 - 50 3,18 – 7.95 Partial loss Unconsolidated Acidizable fine-coarse
sands and gravels granular
Small open fractures Acidizable fine-coarse
fiber
Acidizable fine-coarse
flake
50 - 100 7,95 – 15.9 Severe loss Long sections of Acidizable medium-
unconsolidated coarse granular
sands Acidizable medium-
Fractures coarse fiber
Acidizable medium-
coarse flake
> 500 > 79,5 Total Cavernous Acidizable gunk
Large fractures treatment
Table 12-1 – Losses Recognition
Until now, the cure methods used to reduce the fluid loss in thief zones can be
divided into two main classifications: one is to use viscous pills and another is to use
removable plugging materials, as will be discussed in next paragraph separately.
• HEC is compatible with most of the common used brine (univalent or/and
bivalent).
• It behaves an excellent ability of acid solubility. According to the testing results
and experiences, it suggests to make acid treatment immediately in order to
render the acid more effective.
• HEC is very sensitive to high shear rate and to terminal degradation. Its maximum
use temperature is about 95 - 120°C.
• HEC is very slow to develop viscosity in brines of density great than 1, 40 kg/l.
Even when heated, up to 5 hours mixing time may be required in order to reach
maximum viscosity. In certain brines containing for example zinc, HEC will not
yield even when heated or prehydrated. For the situations the zinc concentration
must be increased to a sufficiently high level, relative to the other salts, so that the
solution will solvate the prehydrated HEC. (Note: the minimum zinc concentration
is about 7, 5 – 9, 0 % by weight).
• Low viscous HEC fluids can cause permeability impairment.
• A viscosity breaker should be added to HEC viscous pill to enable it to backflow
out of the formation at the end of the job. Most breakers are used only for short
term jobs, while for long term jobs, HEC will be degraded thermally, for example,
it would be applications at very high temperatures (>135°C) or in low density brine
(1,40 kg/l).
and starches that suspend the salt particles, leaving a semi-permeable filter cake of
salt. The second step is an under-saturated fluid to dissolve the remaining salt.
The carbonate pills act by a mechanical plugging of pores: since the flow channels
are only partially obstructed by a non-deformable solid, they will allow some passage
of the fluid at very low flow rates, which becomes slower as the viscous fluid
penetrates the formation. The “sealing” effect will therefore not be perfect and the
formation will continue to absorb fluid slowly since the pore space which is not
completely plugged by the carbonate will remain to some extent open. This
phenomenon can be minimized by using the correct size of carbonate, the selection
of which is made based on the formation permeability and applying the concepts of
filtration which establish the degree of absolute filtration to be used in order to avoid
damage by plugging.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 109 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
Example n. 1.
One of the traditional criteria to select the average diameter of the plugging particle
should be more than or equal to 1/3 of the average diameter of the pore, i.e.
Bridging size Dbridge (µm) > or = 1/3 pore size Dpore (µm);
For pore size Dpori, one of the calculation methods can be: for example,
where K is the permeability (mD) to brine and φ is the porosity (%) of a rock
(hypothesis φ =25%).
Example n. 2.
ENI E&P accept another criterion based on the laboratory experimental works which
have demonstrated that optimized PSD in high permeability sands may be when the
mud contains CaCO3 sized from 7 times the average pore size diameter (7 x K1/2)
down to 1 micron, i.e.
Dpore (µm) = √K
PSD = 7 Dpore ∼ 1 (µm)
100
90 1/3 rule
x y 0
2,623249
80 7 factor rule 100 0,655812
0 0 1,311625
m 38,121 1,967437
70
76,241 100 2,623249
% fine than
60
50
x y 0
40 1,30103 50 0,325257
0 0 0,650515
30 m 38,431 0,975772
76,862 100 1,30103
20 1,561236
1,821442
10 2,341854
2,60206
0
1 10 100 1000
diameter (micron)
Figure 12-1 – An Example to Have a Correct PSD Based on Rock Permeability Data Using ENI
Criterion
Finally, commercially available CaCO3 products (usually 80-100 Kg/m3) are mixed
together to match such a distribution (Figure 12-2).
Mixture Kg/m3 %
Fine CaCO3 40,0 50,0
Medium CaCO3 24,0 30,0
Coarse CaCO3 16,0 20,0
TOTALE 80,0 Kg/m3
100
Mixture S % cum
90
target n.2 (%)
80
CaCO3 finer than (%)
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
1000 100 10 1
diameter (micron)
This process can be executed with software which is developed by ENI E&P division
and will be available in near future. In the mean time, if no software is available
neither from ENI nor from service companies, some optimizations obtained by ENI
software are reported on Table 12-2.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 111 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
Example n. 3.
Another example is taken from the field application in Angola. In Angola they use
different criteria for PSD selection depending on the type of thief formation (A and
B).
where K is the permeability (mD) of a rock and φ is the porosity (%) of a rock
(hypothesis φ =20%).
pH density
Salt Origin of Salt
( with electrode) (Kg/l) at 20°C
NH4Cl pure (analysis grade) 4,9 1,07
KCl pure (analysis grade) 6,3 1,161
NaCl pure (analysis grade) 7,1 1,185
KBr pure (analysis grade) 5,8 1,337
CaCl2 77-80% from the field 5,9 1,342
CaCl2 · 6H2O pure (analysis grade) 4,6 1,431
NaBr pure (analysis grade) 7,1 1,532
CaBr2 pure (analysis grade) 6,7 1,784
K2CO3 pure (analysis grade) 14,8 1,572
Table 13-1 – Value of pH and Density at 20°C Measured in Laboratory for Several Brines
The values of density and pH of the solutions, prepared from pure salts, can be
rather different from the values which are sometimes noted in the field. For example,
CaCl2 77-80% from the well site, used in the determination of the values of pH that
are reported in Table 13-1, has a pH close to that of a brine prepared from pure salt
(in general a value of pH = 9-10 is noted in the field), but the resultant density is
lower (-6%) with respect to the density of the solution prepared from pure salt; this
difference is attributable to the presence of contaminants which limit the solubility of
the salt.
The salt solutions of chlorides and bromides should have a pH value close to or just
below neutral (pH≤ 5-7) because of the hydrolysis reaction connected to the nature
of the cation contained in the salt; exceptions are:
• K2CO3 solutions which generate high values of pH (pH=13-14) since it is a very
soluble carbonate salt;
• ZnBr2 solutions since the salt leads to an acid reaction, registering low values of
pH (pH=4);
• NH4Cl solutions, inducing an acid reaction (pH≈5);
The cost of the brines is not detailed in this book.
Their cost can be related to several factors:
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 114 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
14. ENVIRONMENTAL
Environmental impact of drilling and completion fluids is evidenced and much
attention has been given in recent years. The concerns on environments, on safety
use, on disposal issue depend on where and when this kind of fluid to be used since
the interest, attention and local legislation are different. It is very important to follow
the individual regulatory agency aspects for onshore and offshore operations and to
update the information on the aspects. The rapid changes in the field are required to
keep informed which may be provided by publication, annual environmental report,
directives or government decrees. There are specific agencies which regulate and
enforce rules governing the use and discharge of these wastes. When dealing with
completion fluids, especially heavy brine, it is very important to be sure what
regulations are in effect for their use in a specific area.
Generally, during the completion program phase, it should be taken in consideration
the following aspects: local legislation, compatibility of products proposed with HSE,
possibility of disposal, etc. In the operation field, the considerations on HSE should
be arranged among operational company, local environment agency and fluid
service companies.
Fluid service companies must provide the data sheet and safety sheet of all products
programmed to use. So composition on hazardous ingredients, hazards
identification, first aid measures, fire fighting measures, handling/storage, exposure
control/personal protection, physical and chemical properties,
toxicological/ecological information, disposal considerations, transport information
and regulatory information, etc. of the products may be found on material safety data
sheet (MSDS).
In recent years, non toxic environmental friendly system and product as the
alternative, in order to make the operation more HSE compatible, have been
widespread used and have been received excellent results. For example, very
recently, brines containing ions which are compatible with the environment begin to
be used in the particular environment sensitive area. Formates (sodium formate,
potassium formate and caesium formate) match this requirement. The heavy zinc
based brine is being substituted by the formats or its mixture.
The object of this chapter is to give a basic concept, general considerations and
useful information before selecting or using a suitable solution for completion
operation. The details information and correct management on the systems and the
products, especially on high cost heavy brine, should be discussed and arranged
among operator, fluid service company and local environmental agency.
Acute LC50: A concentration of a substance expressed as parts per million per parts
of medium, that is lethal to 50 % of the test population of animals under specified
test condition.
Acute oral LD50: A single orally administered dose of a substance expressed as
milligram per kilogram of body weight, that is lethal to 50 % of the test population of
animals under specified test condition.
Acute toxicity: Any poisonous effect produced within a short period of time following
exposure, usually up to 24-96 hrs, resulting in severe biological harm and often
death.
Acute toxicity scale: There is a set of classifications used today related to the
typology of testing. Usually the hazard classification of environmental samples
according to their acute toxicity is based on toxicity unit (TU) values. TU can be
calculated as TU = 100 * (1/ LC50 or EC50), where LC50 and EC50 are expressed in
mg/l.
Non toxic: TU< 0,01
Low toxic: TU = 0,01 – 1
Toxic: TU = 1 – 10
Very toxic: TU = 11 – 100
Extremely toxic: TU > 100
Aerobic: Life or processes that depends on the presence of oxygen.
Alkalinity: The ability of solutions or aqueous suspensions to neutralize an acid.
Allergen: Any of a variety of materials that, as a result of coming into contact with
appropriate body tissues, after a latent period, indices a state of sensitivity and /or
harmful reaction.
Anaerobic: Life or processes that can occur in the absence of oxygen.
Auto ignition point: The minimum temperature required to initiate or cause self
combustion of a substance in the absence of a spark or flame.
Benthic region: The bottom layer of a body of water.
Bioaccumulation: The process whereby certain toxic substances collect in tissues,
thus posing a substantial hazard to human health or the environment.
Bioassay: Using living organisms to measure the effect of a substance, factor, or
condition.
Biodegradable: Any substance that decomposes through the action of
microorganisms.
Boiling point: The temperature at which the vapour pressure of a liquid is equal to
the pressure of the atmosphere.
Chronic: Long lasting or frequently recurring.
Chronic toxicity: The property of a substance or mixture of substances to cause
adverse effect on an organism upon repeated or continuous exposure over a period
of at least ½ the lifetime of that organism.
Chronic toxicity NOEC: No Observed Effect Concentration as the higher
concentration of compound which does not cause any effect on the organism.
COD: Chemical Oxygen Demand is a measure of the amount of oxygen required to
oxidize the organic matter in a waste sample. Results are reported in mg/l COD.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 117 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
KCl LD50 (oral):2600 mg/kg Salmo gairdneri: 96hrs LC50=2100 mg/l. Not regarded as a health hazard under
current legislation; Dust may irritate
respiratory or lungs.
NaCl LD50 (oral):3000 mg/kg Bluegill sunfish: 96hrs LC50>1000 mg/l; Not regarded as a health hazard under
Rainbow trout: 96hrs LC50>1000 mg/l. current legislation; Dust may irritate
respiratory or lungs.
ENI S.p.A.
CaCl2 LD50 (oral):1000 mg/kg Daphnia magna: 48 hrs LC50= 20-30 Hazards: Irritating to eyes, to skin and to Accordance
E & P Division
KBr LD50 (oral mouse): 3120 Fish: LC50>1000 mg/l Hazards: May cause eyes, skin and Must
mg/kg; LD50 (oral rat): respiratory tract irritation. May cause consult
3070 mg/kg; digestive tract irritation with nausea, state and
vomiting and diarrhea. Hygroscopic. May local
cause central nervous system depression. hazardous
wastes
regulations.
NaBr LD50 (oral):3500 mg/kg P. reticulata: 96hrs LC50=16000 mg/l; Not regards as a health hazard under Dispose of
STAP-P-1-M-20091
Daphnia magna: 48 hrs EC50=5800 current legislation. Dust may irritate on site
IDENTIFICATION CODE
CaBr2 LD50 (oral):4100 mg/kg OSPAR list/ substance pose little or no Hazards: Irritating to eyes, to skin and to According
A
ZnBr2 LD50 (oral): 1000 mg/kg Skeletonema costatum: 48 hrs EC50=6,6 Hazards: Harmful if swallowed or
mg/l. inhalation. Cause severe irritation or burns
121
K2CO3 LD50 (rat): 1870 mg/kg Hazards: Irritating to eyes, to skin and to
respiratory system. High pH value: 12.5;
salt Toxicological information Ecological information Hazards / Precaution Disposal
HCOONa LD50 (oral):3000 mg/kg (Rat); Fish: 96hrs LC50>1000 mg/l; Daphnia:
48 hrs EC0>1000 mg/l; Algae: 96 hrs
EC50=790 mg/l; Bacteria: 18 hrs
EC10=10600 mg/l.
86 % of biodegradability in 28 days,
OECD306.
ENI S.p.A.
HCOOK LD50 (oral, rat): 5500 mg/kg; LD50 Brown shrip: 96 hr LC50= 1300 mg/l; Hazards: Irritating to eyes to Accordance with
E & P Division
(oral mus): 11 200 mg/kg Skeletonema costatum: 72 hrs EC50= skin; Irritation to upper local or national
3700 mg/l in 75 % solution; Acartia legislation. The
S P E O
Table 14-2 – Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS) and HSE Considerations
REVISION
Data in tables from Table 15-1 to 15-8 have been extracted from catalogues of AVA, HALLIBURTON,
MI and BAKER HI and they may vary in future catalogues.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 128 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
A NaBr solution having a density of 12.5 lb/gal. was prepared by mixing 46.0 wt. % solid NaBr
and 54.0 wt. % water. A ZnBr2 / NaBr base fluid having a density of 17.5 lb/gal. was prepared by
combining 46.8 wt. % solid ZnBr2, 23.7 wt % solid NaBr and 29.5 wt. % water. Varying amounts of
ZnBr2 / NaBr base fluid (density = 17.5 lb/gal.) were then mixed with different amounts of NaBr
solution (density = 12.5 lb/gal.) in order to prepare different completion fluids in the density range of
13.0 to 17.5 lb/gal. The volumes of the base fluid and NaBr solution required to formulate these
different completion fluids, along with the respective densities and TCT of the completion fluids, are
given in the Table above.
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 156 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
APPENDIX - C. ABBREVIATIONS
BHT - Bottom Hole Temperature
CaBr2 - Calcium Bromide
CaCl2 - Calcium Chloride
CF - Caesium Formate
CF - Contact Factor
CMC - Carbossil Methyl Cellulose
DE - Diatomaceous Earth
DIF - Drill-in-Fluids
EPDM - Ethylene/Propylene Diene Elastomer
EU - Polyether Urethane Elastomer or Urethane
FCTA - First Crystal To Appear
FEPM - Tetrafluoroethylene Propylene Elastomer or Aflas™ or Fluoraz™
FFKM - Perfluorocarbon Elastomer or Kalrez™ or Chemraz™
FKM - Fluorocarbon Elastomer or Viton™ or Fluorel™
HCOOCs - Caesium Formate
HCOONa - Sodium Formate
HCOOK - Potassium Formate
HEC - Hydroxyethylcellulose
HEMC - Hydroxyethylmethylcellulose
HNBR - Hydrogenated Nitrile Elastomer
HSE - Health Safety Environment
HSN - Hydrogenated Nitrile Elastomer
KBr - Potassium Bromide
KCl - Potassium Chloride
KF - Potassium Formate
K2CO3 - Potassium Carbonate
LCTD - Last Crystal To Disappear (or Last Crystal To Dissolve)
MSDS - Material Safety Data Sheet
NaBr - Sodium Bromide
NaCl - Sodium Chloride
NACE - National Association of Corrosion Engineers
NBR - Acrylonitrile Butadiene Rubber or Nitrile or Buna-N
NF - Sodium Formate
NH4Cl - Ammonium Chloride
NTU - Nephelometric Turbidity Units
OBM - Oil-Based Muds
OSR - Oil Soluble Resins
PAA - Polyacrilamides
PAC - Poly Anionic Cellulose
PEEK - Polytheretherketone Elastomer
PPS - Polyphenylene Sulphide Elastomer or Ryton™
PTFE - Polytetrafluoroethylene Elastomer or Teflon™
SBHT - Static Bottom Hole Temperature
SRB - Sulphate Reducing Bacteria
SSC - Sulphide Stress Cracking
sg - specific gravity
TCT - True Crystallization Temperature
WBM - Water-Based Muds
WHT - Well Head Temperature
XC - Xanthan Gum
ZnBr2 - Zinc Bromide
S P E O IDENTIFICATION CODE PAG 167 OF 167
ENI S.p.A.
E & P Division REVISION
STAP-P-1-M-20091 A
APPENDIX - D. REFERENCES
i
E. Pitoni, “Nota sui fluidi di completamento”, Agosto 1995
ii
Baker Hughes – ElecTech - 2003
iii
United States Patent – Patent Number 4,941,982 – Jul. 17, 1990
iv
NACE Corrosion 02, paper 02067
v
NACE Corrosion 92, paper 46
vi
NACE Corrosion 99, paper n. 592
vii
Ray, T.W., Irby, R.I., “Elastomeric Material Considerations when Using Oil-base Drilling Fluids in
High Pressure / High Temperature (HP/HT) Environments.” Oilfield Engineering with Polymers
2001, London, UK. November 2001.
viii
ISO 3601-5:2002
ix
Halliburton – Seal Technology 101, 1st Edition