Peer Evaluation suggested template (not mandatory)

Name of evaluator: Casey Carrier Name of person being evaluated: Marian

Brief overview of the designed product, environment or service: Design Challenge ** push pull toy

Process and Presented Quality of Comment

Production Skill /Not communication and
presented design process

Satisfactory

Lacking or
Excellent

absent
Evidence is
presented that   Watched You-tube tutorials

demonstrates the Assessed existing solutions

critique of existing on Pinterest
solutions through
research and
exploration of their
nature.

In light of what is
known about   Researched how to make
functioning axels/wheels
existing solutions,
Investigating and Defining

and through survey, Made the design safe for

observation and/or the intended consumer (K-2
questioning, the students)
designer shows
evidence of research
and analysis of
user/consumer/
audience/participant
needs.

Evidence is
presented that   Used recycled materials to
ensure the design was
demonstrates sustainable
potential
consideration of
implications for
individuals, society
and the local and
global environment,
 now and in the
future.

The design of the

solution/product/   Weebly site contained
evidence of an identified
environment is problem, process and
presented as a solution
design brief.

An evaluative
selection of options   - The design is
adaptable and
and alternative allows room for
design choices is creativity
evidenced in the - Consideration for
student’s safety has occurred
documentation. This in the design
is achieved through process
an examination of
specifications and
assumptions that
may include the
manufacturing
process and risk
Generating and designing

assessment, as well
as cultural
considerations,
workability,
materials, aesthetics
etc.

A final design
specification is   Design in well-presented,
target market and price
presented that were considered
outlines purpose,
aesthetics,
characteristics,
target market,
cultural
considerations, price
and value for money
etc.

A final design is
presented.
 Design choices
demonstrate
 Opportunities are available
to creatively decorate the
innovative and design in different ways or
creative thinking even create different modes
and ideas. of transport (bus, car,
tractor etc)

The design is of high

quality and clearly  
responsive to the
needs identified in
the first phase of
investigation.
The final product has been
created to a high standard
and has clearly responded
to the identified issue.

A production plan
and timeline is  
presented, with any
ad hoc modifications
that were necessary
during the
Producing and implementing

production process.

A reflective,
production journal is   Website is well presented
and easy to navigate
presented,
documenting the
stages in the
production process
and its
management.

A product, process,
environment or   The blog is well organised
and clearly shows elements
service is presented that document the whole
and evaluated. design process .
 Evidence is
presented of  
insightful evaluation
and judgments,
completed against a
selection of criteria
Evaluating

for success.
Reflection and
evaluation of the
final product is
presented as well as
of the design
production process
itself.