Você está na página 1de 7

J. Cent. South Univ.

(2012) 19: 1346−1352


DOI: 10.1007/s11771-012-1148-5

Effect of exhaust gas recirculation and intake pre-heating on


performance and emission characteristics of dual fuel engines at part loads

A. Paykani1, R. Khoshbakhti Saray2, M. T. Shervani-Tabar3, A. Mohammadi-Kousha3


1. Department of Automotive Engineering, Iran University of Science and Technology,
Narmak, Tehran 1684613114, Iran;
2. Department of Mechanical Engineering, Sahand University of Technology, Sahand New City, Tabriz, Iran;
3. Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Tabriz, Tabriz, Iran
© Central South University Press and Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2012

Abstract: Achieving simultaneous reduction of NOx, CO and unburned hydrocarbon (UHC) emissions without compromising engine
performance at part loads is the current focus of dual fuel engine research. The present work focuses on an experimental investigation
conducted on a dual fuel (diesel–natural gas) engine to examine the simultaneous effect of inlet air pre-heating and exhaust gas
recirculation (EGR) ratio on performance and emission characteristics at part loads. The use of EGR at high levels seems to be
unable to improve the engine performance at part loads. However, it is shown that EGR combined with pre-heating of inlet air can
slightly increase thermal efficiency, resulting in reduced levels of both unburned hydrocarbon and NOx emissions. CO and UHC
emissions are reduced by 24% and 31%, respectively. The NOx emissions decrease by 21% because of the lower combustion
temperature due to the much inert gas brought by EGR and decreased oxygen concentration in the cylinder.

Key words: dual fuel engine; exhaust gas recirculation (EGR); emission; performance; venturi EGR system

and ignite the flame of the CNG in the combustion


1 Introduction chamber [4].
Dual fuel engine is one of the possible short-term
The concept of using alternative gaseous fuel in solutions to reduce emissions from traditional diesel
diesel engines has gained worldwide attention. engines, meanwhile, utilizing an alternative fuel like
Increasing fossil fuel prices and the deterioration to natural gas as primary fuel. It consequently results in not
environment have led to the search for alternative fuels only an interesting technology to meet future emission
since past several years. Natural gas is one such fuel regulations, but also a powerful solution to retrofit
available in large quantities in many parts of world at existing engines [5]. In this method, natural gas is
attractive prices. It is a clean burning fuel as compared to premixed with fresh air in the intake manifold, which
the conventional liquid fuels like diesel or gasoline. It then undergoes a multi-point ignition due to the
has a high octane number and therefore it is suitable for compression-ignition and combustion of a pilot diesel
engines with relatively high compression ratio [1−2]. Its fuel spray. Then, flame propagates through the premixed
self ignition temperature is 730 °C and it requires intense natural gas mixture. Thus, dual fuel operation with
source of energy to enable combustion, i.e. glow plug, natural gas fuel can yield a high thermal efficiency
spark plug or pilot liquid fuel. It mixes rapidly with air to almost comparable to the same engine operating on
form homogenous air fuel mixture for efficient diesel fuel at higher loads. However, engine performance
combustion inside engine cylinder and substantial and emissions suffer at low loads when operating in dual
reduction in harmful emissions [3]. There are two fuel mode [6−7]. During part load engine operation, the
methods for converting diesel engine to utilize natural fuel gas supply is reduced by means of a gas control
gas as the main fuel. The first method is to utilize valve. However, a simultaneous reduction of the air
compressed natural gas (CNG) fully in diesel engine supply decreases the air quantity induced. Hence, the
(known as the CNG dedicated conversion). In this compression pressure and the mean effective pressure of
method, the engine cylinder head should be changed to the engine decrease. This would finally lead to a drop in
implement an ignition system and a CNG injector. The power and efficiency. One reason for this is resulted from
second method is the dual-fuel conversion using CNG as overall very lean mixtures at low loads.
the main fuel and pilot diesel fuel to start combustion The lean mixtures ignite very hard and burn slowly [8].

Received date: 2011−07−20; Accepted date: 2011−09−26


Corresponding author: A. Paykani; PhD Candidate; Tel: +98−9397905698; E-mail: a.paykani@gmail.com
J. Cent. South Univ. (2012) 19: 1346−1352 1347
The use of exhaust gas recirculation has been suggested fuel engines at part loads. In order to meet future
to improve part load performance and emission emission standards, EGR must be done over wider range
characteristics of dual fuel engines. The exhaust gas of engine operation, and larger EGR ratio will be needed.
recirculation (EGR) may be used for improving part load Thus, utilizing a specific device to expand EGR area is
operation and reducing the exhaust emissions of NOx. necessary. In this work, the venturi type EGR system was
Introduction of EGR has combinations of some of these selected because it is rather effective for expanding the
effects [9]: 1) dilution effect, 2) chemical effect and 3) EGR range up to low engine load conditions.
thermal effect.
Numerous research works have been carried out to 2 Experimental
solve above mentioned issues [8]. Some researchers
investigate the effect of hot and cooled EGR on An experiment was carried out to investigate the
performance and emission characteristics of dual fuel effect of exhaust gas recirculation and pre-heating of the
engines at part loads. KUSAKA et al [3, 10] and inlet air on performance and emission characteristics of
DAISHO et al [11−12] studied experimentally the effect dual fuel engines at part loads. The engine used for the
of EGR on combustion and exhaust emission investigation was a single-cylinder, four-stroke, water
characteristics of dual fuel engines with the objective of cooled, indirect injection (Lister 8-1) dual fuel engine
improving their drawbacks at part loads. It was shown which was coupled to a direct current (D.C.)
that hot EGR with high ratios could improve dynamometer through a torque meter providing both
performance and emission characteristics of these torque and speed measurements. The technical
engines at part loads. ABD ALLA et al [13−15] specifications of the engine are given in Table 1, and the
conducted some experiments on a Ricardo E6 dual fuel schematic of the experimental setup is shown in Fig. 1.
engine to investigate the effect of pilot fuel quantity and Air flow rate was derived from the measured pressure
admission of high ratio of EGR gases on the performance drop across an orifice installed on a surge tank. Mass
and exhaust emissions of dual fuel engines at part loads. flow rates of diesel and natural gas fuels were measured
The results showed that both of the methods could by volumetric flow meters. Temperature of cooling water,
improve performance and emission characteristics except lubricating oil, inlet air and exhaust gas were also
for NOx emission when using larger amounts of pilot fuel. measured to ensure proper engine operating conditions.
PIROUZPANAH et al [16] conducted an experimental The engine is supplied with natural gas obtained from the
study to determine performance and emission local distribution network. The inlet and exhaust air
characteristics of an automotive direct injection temperatures were measured by K-type thermocouple
dual-fuelled diesel engine. Cooled EGR was used to made by Testo Co. Also, EGR line and an electric heater
resolve the poor light load performance of the engine. were designed and manufactured to enter different
The results showed that at part loads, the application of amounts of EGR to the intake charge. The exhaust
EGR could considerably reduce CO and unburned emissions, HC, CO, CO2 and NOx were measured by
hydrocarbon (UHC) emissions. PIROUZPANAH et al AVL 4000 exhaust gas analyzer.
[17−18] investigated theoretically the combustion
phenomenon of dual fuel engines at part loads and using 2.1 EGR system
hot EGR to improve the mentioned drawbacks. By The EGR system used with the test engine was the
employing this technique, it was found that, lower ratio type that exhaust gas was recirculated back into the inlet
of EGR considering its thermal and radical effects had
the positive effect on performance and emission Table 1 General specifications of Lister (8-1) dual fuel engine
parameters of dual fuel engines at part loads. Item Specification
KHOSHBAKHTI et al [19−20] investigated Type Four stroke
experimentally the emission and performance Number of cylinders 1
characteristics of a dual fuel engine operating on natural
Combustion system IDI
gas with pilot diesel injection. The results of their work
Bore/mm 114.1
showed that the ignition delay and combustion durations
shorten sufficiently by increasing EGR ratio and its Stroke/mm 139.7
temperature to a specified level. Also, CO and UHC Swept volume/L 1.43
emissions reduce whereas NOx emission increases but Compression ratio 17.5:1
not too much for low ratio of EGR. Max. power/(r·min ) −1
8/850
This work touches upon investigating the
Injection pressure/MPa 9.17
simultaneous effect of EGR and pre-heating of the inlet
air on performance and emission characteristics of dual Injection timing 20 CA BTDC
1348 J. Cent. South Univ. (2012) 19: 1346−1352

Fig. 1 Schematic diagram of experimental setup

manifold where it mixes with air and natural gas and gets drawn in:
diluted with the intake charge which in turn acts as a
=(14.532mp+16.684mNG)/ma (2)
diluents and reduces the peak combustion temperature
inside the combustion chamber. It includes a control The gas equivalence ratio,  gas, is defined as the
valve, pipes and venture, as shown in Fig. 1. To measure ratio of the mass of the stoichiometric amount of air
the amount of EGR, the EGR ratio [16] was considered: required for the combustion of the gaseous fuel to the
 I (CO 2 ) mass of the actual amount of air drawn in:
REGR  (1)
O (CO 2 ) gas=(16.684mNG)/ma (3)
where φI(CO2) and φO(CO2) are the volume fraction of where ma, mp and mNG are the mass flow rates of air, pilot
inlet CO2 and outlet CO2, respectively. and natural gas fuels, respectively.

2.2 Test conditions examined 3 Estimation of uncertainty


After starting the engine on diesel mode, different
performance and emission tests were conducted on the Any experimental measurement possesses a certain
engine at diesel mode to gain the base diesel engine amount of uncertainty. The uncertainty in any
performance and emission characteristics at different measurement may be due to either fixed or random errors.
loads. Later, the diesel was reduced and the rest of input As the fixed errors are repeatable in nature, they can be
energy was supplied by a venturi type mixer installed on
easily accounted for to get the true value of measurement.
the intake manifold which can introduce sufficient
However, random errors have to be estimated only
amount of natural gas fuel to operate engine in dual fuel
analytically. In this work, we repeated each measurement
mode in various load conditions. During engine tests at
five times. These repetitions have been used for the error
part loads, the amount of EGR which introduced to the
analysis of some of the parameters which were
engine increased progressively until the performance and
introduced in Table 2 as follows:
emission parameters were deteriorated. It is necessary to
mention that the amounts of pilot and natural gas fuels 1) Outlier excluding the unacceptable measured
were kept constant at each set of experiments to evaluate values;
the effect of EGR on the combustion, performance and 2) Standard deviation besides of the average values
emission parameters. to report each parameters error;
Total equivalence ratio, , is defined as the ratio of 3) Calculation of the uncertainty of the parameters
the mass of the stoichiometric amount of air required for (power, etc.) which contain various measured parameters
the combustion of both of the gaseous and the pilot using the error values calculated for each of the
diesel fuels to the mass of the actual amount of air measured values.
J. Cent. South Univ. (2012) 19: 1346−1352 1349
Table 2 Average uncertainties of some measured and calculated the mixture, widen its flammability limits and sustains
parameters flame propagation within relatively leaner mixtures [16].
No. Parameter Uncertainty/% The chemical effect is associated with the participation
1 Speed 1.1 of active free radicals present in exhaust gas to enhance
combustion by taking part in pre-ignition reactions.
2 Temperature 0.8
However, this effect causes an increase in thermal
3 Mass flow rate of air 1.7 efficiency. With more EGR substitution, the thermal
4 Mass flow rate of diesel 3.5 efficiency falls. This is due to the dilution effect of the
5 Mass flow rate of natural gas 4.1 EGR used, as it depleted the oxygen present in the
6 Oxides of nitrogen 2.2 combustion chamber [21].
7 Unburned hydrocarbons 2.9
8 Carbon monoxide 3.3
9 EGR ratio 5

4 Results and discussion

In order to study the effects of EGR combined with


intake preheating on performance and exhaust gas
emissions of a dual fuel engine at part loads, according to
Table 3, the experiments were conducted at a constant
engine speed of 730 r/min.

Table 3 Engine tests conditions for intake heating combined


Fig. 2 Variation of brake thermal efficiency with intake mixture
with EGR (Engine speed: 730 r/min, load: 1/5 full load, NG
temperature at constant EGR flow rates (Load: 1/5, NG fraction:
fraction: 75%)
75%)
Intake mixture
Case EGR ratio/%
temperature/K
Figure 3 represents the variation of oxides of
373 nitrogen with intake mixture temperature at constant
13.5 383 EGR flow rates. It can be observed that the NOx
403 emissions decrease as the EGR ratio increases. A
Constant EGR ratio and 425 possible reason is the reduction of oxygen available for
variations of intake combustion, and reduction of peak combustion
mixture temperature 373
temperature due to high specific heat capacity. On the
383
18.5 other hand, the NOx emissions reduce with increase in
420 intake mixture temperature, so, the optimum intake
440 temperature in which the minimum NOx can be achieved
13.5 is 410 K approximately. This can be explained by the
17.5 355 fact that the inert gas included in the recirculated exhaust
Constant intake mixture gas decreases the combustion temperature in spite of
temperature and 19
intake pre-heating. However, NOx emissions tend to
variations of 13.6
EGR ratio increase at high intake mixture temperatures. The
16.5 430 presence of radicals can help to initiate the combustion
19.5 process, especially with the increase of intake mixture
temperature due to mixing with exhaust gases. Although
4.1 Constant EGR percentage and variations of the diluents try to stop the reactions, the combined
intake mixture temperature effects of radicals and intake temperature are dominant.
Figure 2 shows the effects of pre-heating inlet air Hence, the NOx increases with increasing intake mixture
combined with EGR at 75% natural gas fraction and 15% temperature.
of full load. It is clear that remarkable improvements in The variation of unburned hydrocarbons with intake
thermal efficiency are obtained in this case. This is due mixture temperature at constant EGR flow rates is
to the increased intake temperature. The increase of depicted in Fig. 4. The UHC values are considerable for
intake temperatures will accelerate the reaction rates of high EGR ratios. It can be seen that increasing the intake
1350 J. Cent. South Univ. (2012) 19: 1346−1352

Fig. 3 Variation of NOx emission with intake mixture Fig. 5 Variation of carbon monoxide with intake mixture
temperature at constant EGR flow rates (Load: 1/5, NG fraction: temperature at constant EGR flow rates (Load: 1/5, NG fraction:
75%) 75%)

It is well known that duel fuel operation remarkably


produces little smoke emission. Moreover, combustion of
NG produces no particulates, so, the main source is pilot
injection of diesel. Since pilot injection of diesel is small
at low loads, less smoke is produced in this case. With
EGR substitution, there is trade-off of NOx and smoke
emission. With increasing EGR ratio, smoke opacity
increases. This is because of the decrease in the amount
of oxygen present in the combustion chamber with the
substitution of EGR. Therefore, the smoke is not taken
into account in the present work.

4.2 Constant intake mixture temperature and


Fig. 4 Variation of unburned hydrocarbon with intake mixture variations of EGR percentage
temperature at constant EGR flow rates (Load: 1/5, NG fraction: Figure 6 shows the variation of brake thermal
75%) efficiency with different EGR flow rates at constant
intake mixture temperatures. The brake thermal
mixture temperature has a beneficial effect in reducing efficiency decreases slightly with increasing EGR flow
unburned hydrocarbon emissions. One reason for this is rate at both constant intake temperatures. The reduction
that a portion of the unburned gases in the exhaust from
the previous cycle is recirculated and burned in the
succeeding cycle. On the other hand, increasing intake
mixture temperature decreases ignition delay and results
in improvements in combustion process. At low loads,
the flame cannot propagate successfully, which leads to
the increase in the UHC emissions.
The variation of carbon monoxide with intake
mixture temperature at constant EGR flow rates is shown
in Fig. 5. The CO variation follows a close trend with
increase in intake mixture temperature resulting in
decrease in CO emission. The main reason for this trend
is perhaps due to overcoming the positive effects of EGR
(i.e. thermal and radical effects) on its negative effects
(i.e. chemical effect) [22]. Also, the high EGR ratios Fig. 6 Variation of brake thermal efficiency with different EGR
create a hotter environment, which makes the flow rates at constant intake mixture temperatures (Load: 1/5,
combustion to improve. NG fraction: 75%)
J. Cent. South Univ. (2012) 19: 1346−1352 1351
in thermal efficiency is due to the EGR that results in
deficiency in oxygen concentration in combustion
process at part loads and larger replacement of air by
EGR. The higher specific heat capacity of both CO2 and
H2O and high flow rates of EGR reduce the average
combustion temperature in the combustion chamber,
resulting in the brake thermal efficiency to reduce.
Figure 7 depicts variation of oxides of nitrogen with
different EGR flow rates at constant intake mixture
temperatures. The NOx emissions reduce with increase in
EGR ratio at constant intake mixture temperatures. The
combustion temperature and local oxygen concentration
are dominant parameters for NOx formation. The
presence of inert gases in the combustion chamber
reduces the peak combustion temperature, and also it Fig. 8 Variation of unburned hydrocarbon with different EGR
replaces the oxygen in the combustion chamber. As a flow rates at constant intake mixture temperatures (Load: 1/5,
result of reduction in both parameters, the NOx decreases NG fraction: 75%)
with EGR. However, at high EGR ratio, NOx emissions
tend to increase. It can be due to the negative effects of
EGR that may overcome its positive effects.

Fig. 9 Variation of carbon monoxide with different EGR flow


rates at constant intake mixture temperatures (Load: 1/5, NG
fraction: 75%)
Fig. 7 Variation of oxides of nitrogen with different EGR flow
rates at constant intake mixture temperatures (Load: 1/5, NG combined with high intake mixture temperatures create a
fraction: 75%) hotter environment, which accelerates the reaction rates
of mixture and as a result, makes the combustion
The variation of unburned hydrocarbon with improved. However, CO emission tends to increase at
different EGR flow rates at constant intake mixture high EGR ratios. Also, this may be due to the partial
temperatures is shown in Fig. 8. It can be seen that, UHC replacement of oxygen in inlet air by inert gas, which
emissions are lower at high intake mixture temperatures, results in deficiency in oxygen concentration.
whereas increasing EGR ratio causes a drop in unburned
hydrocarbon emissions. One reason for this is that the 5 Conclusions
presence of radicals in the recirculated exhaust gases can
help to initiate the combustion process, especially with 1) Constant EGR ratios combined with variation of
the increase of intake charge temperature due to mixing intake mixture temperature can favorably increase brake
with exhaust gases. thermal efficiency; however, it can be observed that, by
The variation of carbon monoxide with different employing high ratio of EGR at a constant temperature,
EGR flow rates at constant intake mixture temperatures thermal efficiency deteriorates.
is depicted in Fig. 9. It is obvious that CO emission is 2) Reasonable ratio of EGR along with intake
lower at high intake mixture temperatures, while pre-heating decreases unburned hydrocarbons as well as
increasing EGR flow rate results in a decrease in carbon carbon monoxide emissions and reduces nitrogen oxides
monoxide emissions. This is due to the fact that the EGR due to the presence of higher levels of diluted gases.
1352 J. Cent. South Univ. (2012) 19: 1346−1352
3) Constant intake mixture temperatures combined H. Combustion and exhaust gas emissions characteristics of a diesel
with variation of EGR ratio result in large reductions in engine dual-fueled with natural gas [C]// The 4th international
symposium COMODIA. Kyoto, Japan, 1998: 555−660.
thermal efficiency and engine emissions.
[11] DAISHO Y, TAKAHASHI K, IWASHIRO Y, NAKAYAMA K R,
4) By employing low ratio of EGR in comparison SAITO T. Controlling combustion and exhaust emissions in a
with high ratio of EGR at a constant temperature, direct-injection diesel engine dual fueled with natural gas [J]. SAE
thermal and radical effects of EGR may overcome its Paper, 1995, 952436.
dilution effects and vice versa. [12] DAISHO Y, YAEO T, KOSEKI T, SAITO T, KIAHARA R.
Combustion and exhaust emissions in a direct-injection Diesel engine
5) From the above point of view, EGR combined
dual-fueled with natural gas [J]. SAE Paper, 1995, 950465.
with pre-heating of inlet air reduces NOx, unburned [13] ABD ALLA G H, SOLIMAN H A, BADR O A, ABD RABBOO M F.
hydrocarbon and CO emissions without deteriorating A Computational investigation of the effect of exhaust gas
engine thermal efficiency. recirculation on the performance of a dual fuel engine [J]. SAE Paper,
2000, 2000−01−2040.
Acknowledgement [14] ABD ALLA G H, SOLIMAN H A, BADR O A, ABD RABBOO M F.
Effect of diluents admissions and intake air temperature in
This research is financially supported by Tabriz Oil
exhaust gas recirculation on the emissions of an indirect injection
Refinery Company, Iran. dual fuel engine [J]. Energy Conversion and Management, 2001, 42:
1033−1045.
References [15] ABD ALLA G H, Using exhaust gas recirculation in internal
combustion engines [J]. Energy Conversion and Management, 2002,
43: 1027−1042.
[1] BAHR O, KARIM G A, LIU B. An examination of the flame spread
[16] PIROUZPANAH V, KHOSHBAKHTI SARAY R. Reduction of
limits in a dual fuel engine [J]. International Journal of Applied
emission in an automotive direct injection diesel engine dual-fueled
Thermal Engineering, 1999, 19(10): 1071−1080.
with natural gas by using variable exhaust gas recirculation [J]. Proc
[2] PIROUZPANAH V, KASHANI B O. Prediction of major pollutants
Instn Mech Engrs, Part D: J Automobile Engineering, 2003, 217:
emission in direct-injection dual-fuel diesel and natural gas engines
719−725.
[J]. SAE Paper, 1999, 990841.
[17] PIROUZPANAH V, KHOSHBAKHTI SARAY R, SOHRABI A,
[3] KUSAKA J, OKAMATO T, DAISHO Y, KIAHARA R, SAITO T.
NIAEI A. Comparison of thermal and radical effects of EGR gases
Combustion and exhaust gas emission characteristics of a diesel
on combustion process in dual fuel engines at part loads [J]. Energy
engine dual fueled with natural gas [J]. JSAE Review, 2000, 21:
Conversion and Management, 2007, 48: 1909−1918.
489−496.
[18] PIROUZPANAH V, KHOSHBAKHTI SARAY R. Enhancement of
[4] ABDELGHAFAR W A. Performance and emissions of a diesel
combustion process in dual fuel engines at part loads using exhaust
engine converted to dual diesel-CNG fuelling [J]. European Journal
gas recirculation [J]. Proc Instn Mech Engrs, Part D, J Automobile
of Scientific Research, 2011, 56(2): 279−293.
Engineering, 2007, 221: 877−888.
[5] SCARCELLI R. Lean-burn operation for natural gas/air mixtures:
[19] KHOSHBAKHTI S R. Enhancement of combustion process in dual
The dual fuel engines [D]. Roma, Italy: Mechanical Engineering,
fuel engines at part loads by using suitable techniques [J].
Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, 2007.
International Journal of Engineering, 2009, 22(1): 77−90.
[6] SATO T, SAITO T, DAISHO Y. Combustion and exhaust emission
[20] KHOSHBAKHTI S R, MOHAMMADI K A, PIROUZPANAH V. A
control in a dual-fuelled engine [J]. SAE Paper, 1993, 9305346.
new strategy for reduction of emissions and enhancement of
[7] WEAVER C S, TURNER S H. Dual fuel natural gas/Diesel engines:
performance characteristics of dual fuel engines at part loads [J].
Technology, performance and emissions [J]. SAE Paper, 1994,
International Journal of Engineering, 2010, 23(1): 87−104.
940548.
[21] PAPAGIANNAKIS R G, HOUNTALAS D T. Experimental
[8] SAHOO B B, SAHOO N, SAHA U K. Effect of engine parameters
investigations concerning the effect of natural gas percentage on
and type of gaseous fuel on the performance of dual-fuel gas Diesel
performance and emission of a DI dual fuel diesel engine [J]. Applied
engines–A critical review [J]. Renewable and Sustainable Energy
Thermal Engineering, 2003, 23: 353−365.
Reviews, 2009, 13(7): 1151−1184.
[22] HOSSEINZADEH A, KHOSHBAKHTI S R, SEYED MAHMOUDI
[9] SRINVASAN K K, KRISHNAN S R, QI Y, MIDKIFF C, YANG H.
S M. Comparison of thermal, radical and chemical effects of EGR
Analysis of diesel pilot-ignited natural gas low-temperature
gases using availability analysis in dual-fuel engines at part loads [J].
combustion with hot exhaust gas recirculation [J]. Combustion
Energy Conversion and Management, 2010, 51(11): 2321−2329.
Science and Technology, 2007, 179: 1737−1776.
[10] KUSAKA J, DAISHO Y, KIAHARA R, SAITO T, NAKAYAMA S (Edited by YANG Bing)

Você também pode gostar