Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
)250$2'26&2175$726
12(6%6,&$6
(P JHUDO R FRQWUDWR © QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR ELODWHUDO GHFRUUHQWH GD FRQYHUJªQFLD GH PDQLIHVWD§µHV GH
YRQWDGHFRQWUDSRVWDV
&RPSUHFLV£RRVHPSUHOHPEUDGR&/9,6%(9,/48$VLQWHWL]DRLWHUGHIRUPD§£RGHXPFRQWUDWR
VDOLHQWDQGRRVVHXVUHIOH[RVSVTXLFRVGHFRQVWLWXL§£R
ߡ(XVLQWRPHLQFOLQDGRDFRPSUDUXPREMHFWRTXHYLHGRTXDOPHFRQY©PVHUSURSULHW¡ULR5HVLVWRRXFHGRORJRDRLPSXOVRGRGHVHMR
TXH PH DUUDVWD SDUD R REMHFWR GLVFXWR DV YDQWDJHQV H GHVYDQWDJHQV GD REWHQ§£R H DILQDO PLQKD YRQWDGH FHGHQGR VROLFLWD§£R GRV
PRWLYRV PDLV IRUWHV YDH D WUDGX]LUVH HP DFWR 6XSSRQKR TXH YHQFHX R GHVHMR GH SRVVXLU R REMHFWR HP TXHVW£R FRPH§R D H[WHUQDU D
PLQKD YROL§£R SURSRQGR D DOJX©P TXH SRVVXH R TXH HX DPELFLRQR TXH VH UHVROYD D PߞR FHGHU 1D PHQWH GHVVH DOJX©P VXVFLWDU¡ D
PLQKDSURSRVWDDVPHVPDVSKDVHVGDHODERUD§£RSV\FKLFDSRUTXHRSHQVDPHQWRSDVVRXHPPHXHVSULWRDW©TXHVXDYRQWDGHFRQYLUMDRX
Q£RSDUDRSRQWRHPTXHHVWDFLRQRXDPLQKD6HFRQYHUJLUVHU¡QRVVRVLQWHUHVVHVRXRTXHVHQRVDILJXUDWDOUHDOL]DUDPVHXHQFRQWUR
KDUP´QLFR DFKDPVH HP FRQJUXªQFLD DFWXDO 3DUD PLP HUD PDLV ºWLO QR PRPHQWR SRVVXLU R REMHFWR HP TXHVW£R GR TXH D VRPPD D
GHVHPEROVDURXRVHUYL§RDSUHVWDUSDUDRSRVVXLGRUGRREMHFWRHUDPDLVYDQWDMRVRGRTXHSRVVXORUHFHEHURTXHHXOKHRIHUHFLD&RP
DPDQLIHVWD§£RHPGLYHUJªQFLDGHQRVVDYRQWDGHLQLFLDVHRFRQWUDFWRߢ VLF
9ªVHFRPLVVRTXHRQDVFLPHQWRGHXPFRQWUDWRVHJXHXPYHUGDGHLURLWHURXSURFHVVRGHIRUPD§£R
FXMR LQFLR © FDUDFWHUL]DGR SHODV QHJRFLD§µHV RX WUDWDWLYDV SUHOLPLQDUHV ߚ GHQRPLQDGD IDVH GH
SXQWXD§£RߚDW©TXHDVSDUWHVFKHJDPDXPDSURSRVWDGHILQLWLYDVHJXLGDGDLPSUHVFLQGYHODFHLWD§£R
(PVQWHVHSRLVWHUDPRV
)$6('(38178$21(*2&,$(635(/,0,1$5(6
$ IDVH GH SXQWXD§£R FRQVRDQWH DQRWDPRV DFLPD FRQVLVWH QR SHURGR GH QHJRFLD§µHV SUHOLPLQDUHV
DQWHULRU IRUPD§£RGRFRQWUDWR
QHVWHPRPHQWRSU©YLRTXHDVSDUWHVGLVFXWHPSRQGHUDPUHIOHWHPID]HPF¡OFXORVHVWXGRVUHGLJHP
D PLQXWD GR FRQWUDWR HQILP FRQWHPSRUL]DP LQWHUHVVHV DQWDJ´QLFRV SDUD TXH SRVVDP FKHJDU D XPD
SURSRVWDILQDOHGHILQLWLYD
1R GL]HU GH *8,//(502 %25'$ ߡ0XFKDV YHFHV ODV WUDWDWLYDV FRQWUDFWXDOHV VH GHVHQYXHOYHQ D
WUDY©V GH XQ WLHPSR P¡V R PHQRV SURORQJDGR VHD SRUTXH HO QHJRFLR HV FRPSOHMR \ ODV SDUWHV TXLHUHQ
HVWXGLDUOR HQ WRGDV VXV FRQVHFXHQߓFLDV R SRUTXH TXLHQ OR ILUPD QR WLHQH SRGHUHV VXILFLHQWHV R SRU
FXDOTXLHURWURPRWLYRߢ
$ FDUDFWHUVWLFD E¡VLFD GHVWD IDVH © MXVWDPHQWH D Q£R YLQFXOD§£R GDV SDUWHV D XPD UHOD§£R MXUGLFD
REULJDFLRQDO
&RPRGHVWDFD&$5/</(3233
ߡ$SULQFLSDOFDUDFWHUVWLFDGHVWDIDVHGHQHJRFLD§µHVSUHOLPLQDUHV©DQ£RREULJDWRULHGDGH,VWRSRUTXHUHDOL]DUQHJRFLD§µHV©XPGLUHLWR
FRQFHGLGRSHORRUGHQDPHQWRGHQDWXUH]DFRQVWLWXFLRQDOTXHDXWRUL]DDOLYUHFHOHEUD§£RGHQHJ³FLRVMXUGLFRV2SWDUSHODFHOHEUD§£RRX
Q£R©XPGLUHLWRTXHDVVLVWHDFDGDXPGRVQHJRFLDQWHV(VWHGLUHLWRYROWDVHDGL]HU©FDGDYH]PDLVOLPLWDGROLPLWD§£RHVWDGLUHWDPHQWH
SURSRUFLRQDODRLQFUHPHQWRGDERDI©REMHWLYDQDVUHOD§µHVMXUGLFDV1£RFHOHEUDURQHJ³FLRMXUGLFR©XPGLUHLWRTXHDVVLVWHDRWUDWDQWH
GHVGHTXHDMDGHQWURGRVOLPLWHVGDERDI©HQ£RYLROHDFRQILDQ§DDOKHLDߢ
(VWD©HPQRVVDRSLQL£RXPDGDVPDLVVHQVYHLVGLIHUHQ§DVDRVHSURSXJQDUSRUXPDQRYDYLV£RGD
WHRULDJHUDOGRVFRQWUDWRV
'HIDWRQLQJX©P©REULJDGRDFRQWUDWDU
7RGDYLDDRVHGDULQFLRDXPSURFHGLPHQWRQHJRFLDW³ULR©SUHFLVRREVHUYDUVHPSUHVHDGHSHQGHU
GDVFLUFXQVW¢QFLDVGRFDVRFRQFUHWRM¡Q£RVHIRUPRXXPDOHJWLPDH[SHFWDWLYDGHFRQWUDWDU
'L]HUSRUWDQWRTXHK¡GLUHLWRVXEMHWLYRGHQ£RFRQWUDWDUQ£RTXHUGL]HUTXHRVGDQRVGDGHFRUUHQWHV
Q£RGHYDPVHULQGHQL]DGRVGHSHQGHQGRGDFLUFXQVW¢QFLDGRFDVRFRQFUHWRQDSHUVSHFWLYDGRSULQFSLR
GDERDI©REMHWLYD
$SHQDV D WWXOR H[HPSOLILFDWLYR SRGHPRV SHQVDU QD LGHLD GH UHSDUD§£R GRV SUHMX]RV GD SDUWH TXH
HIHWLYRX JDVWRV QD FHUWH]D GD FHOHEUD§£R GR QHJ³FLR VH WRGRV RV LQGFLRV GD QHJRFLD§£R LDP QHVVH
VHQWLGR
2XWURLPSRUWDQWHSRQWRGHYHDLQGDVHUUHVVDOWDGR
(VVHVDWRVSUHSDUDW³ULRVFDUDFWHUVWLFRVGDIDVHGHSXQWXD§£RQ£RVHLGHQWLILFDPFRPRGHQRPLQDGR
FRQWUDWRSUHOLPLQDUDH[HPSORGHXPDSURPHVVDGHFRPSUDHYHQGDߓ
$ SURPHVVD GH FRQWUDWR WDPE©P GHQRPLQDGD SU©FRQWUDWR RX FRQWUDWR SUHOLPLQDU © DTXHOH QHJ³FLR
MXUGLFR TXH WHP SRU REMHWR D REULJD§£R GH ID]HU XP FRQWUDWR GHILQLWLYR 2 H[HPSOR PDLV FRPXP © R
FRPSURPLVVRGHYHQGDRTXDOFRPRVHVDEHSRGHLQFOXVLYHJHUDUGLUHLWRUHDO
&XLGDVH GH PRGDOLGDGH FRQWUDWXDO TXH GHYHU¡ FRQWHU WRGRV RV UHTXLVLWRV HVVHQFLDLV DR FRQWUDWR
GHILQLWLYR FRP H[FH§£R GD IRUPD H FXMR UHJUDPHQWR HQFRQWUDVH QRV DUWV D GR &³GLJR GH
&ODUR TXH SDFWXDQGRVH R FRQWUDWR SUHOLPLQDU D UHVSRQVDELOL]D§£R GR LQIUDWRU VHU¡ PXLWR PDLV
IDFLOLWDGDSRUM¡H[LVWLUSUHYLDPHQWHXPWWXORTXHVHUYLU¡GHEDVHDRSOHLWRGDSDUWHSUHMXGLFDGDSHOR
LQDGLPSOHPHQWRGDRXWUD
&DVR Q£R VHMD FHOHEUDGD D SURPHVVD D SDUWH SUHMXGLFDGD SRGHU¡ RXWURVVLP EXVFDU D FRPSHQVD§£R
GHYLGDSURYDQGRQRFDVRDRFRUUªQFLDGHXPDOHJWLPDH[SHFWDWLYDGHSDFWXD§£RFRPEDVHQDERDI©
REMHWLYDJHUDQGRSUHMX]RVTXHGHYHPVHUUHSDUDGRV
3523267$'(&2175$7$5
$SURSRVWDWDPE©PGHQRPLQDGDSROLFLWD§£RFRQVLVWHQDRIHUWDGHFRQWUDWDUTXHXPDSDUWHID] RXWUD
FRP YLVWDV FHOHEUD§£R GH GHWHUPLQDGR QHJ³FLR GD DTXHOH TXH DSUHVHQWD D RIHUWD © FKDPDGR GH
SURSRQHQWHRIHUWDQWHRXSROLFLWDQWH
7UDWDVH GH XPD GHFODUD§£R UHFHSWFLD GH YRQWDGH TXH SDUD YDOHU H WHU IRU§D YLQFXODQWH GHYHU¡ VHU
V©ULD H FRQFUHWD DLQGD TXH YHUEDO 0HUDV FRQMHFWXUDV RX GHFODUD§µHV MRFRVDV Q£R WUDGX]HP SURSRVWD
MXULGLFDPHQWHY¡OLGDHH[LJYHO
'DPHVPDIRUPDDVHULHGDGHGDSURSRVWDGHYHVHUDQDOLVDGDFRPEDVWDQWHFXLGDGRSDUDTXHHODQ£R
VHMDFRQIXQGLGDFRPXPDVLPSOHVRIHUWDGHQHJRFLD§µHVSUHOLPLQDUHV
2&³GLJR&LYLODRGLVFRUUHUVREUHRWHPDQD6H§£R,,GR&DSWXOR,GR7WXOR9'D)RUPD§£RGRV
&RQWUDWRV HPERUD Q£R KDMD HOHQFDGR RV VHXV HOHPHQWRV FRQVWLWXWLYRV GLVFLSOLQRXD QRV VHJXLQWHV
WHUPRV
ߡ$UW $ SURSRVWD GH FRQWUDWR REULJD R SURSRQHQWH VH R FRQWU¡ULR Q£R UHVXOWDU GRV WHUPRV GHOD GD QDWXUH]D GR QHJ³FLR RX GDV
FLUFXQVW¢QFLDVGRFDVRߢ
2EVHUYHVHSRUWDQWRTXHDSURSRVWDGHFRQWUDWDUREULJDRSURSRQHQWHRXSROLFLWDQWHTXHQ£RSRGHU¡
YROWDUDWU¡VUHVVDOYDGDVDSHQDVDVH[FH§µHVFDSLWXODGDVQDSU³SULDOHLDUWVH
&XLGDVHQRFDVRGRGHQRPLQDGRSULQFSLRGDYLQFXOD§£RRXGDREULJDWRߓULHGDGHGDSURSRVWDGLUHWUL]
QRUPDWLYDXPELOLFDOPHQWHOLJDGDDRGRJPDGDVHJXUDQ§DMXUGLFD
'D DQ¡OLVH GHVVH GLVSRVLWLYR FRQFOXPRV TXH R OHJLVODGRU UHFRQKHFH D SHUGD GD HILF¡FLD FRJHQWH GD
RIHUWDQDVVHJXLQWHVVLWXD§µHV
DVHRFRQWU¡ULRDQ£RREULJDWRULHGDGHUHVXOWDUGRVWHUPRVGHODPHVPDߚ©RFDVRGHRSURSRQHQWHVDOLHQWDUTXDQGRGDVXDGHFODUD§£R
GHYRQWDGHRIHUWDTXHUHVHUYDRGLUHLWRGHUHWUDWDUVHRXDUUHSHQGHUVHGHFRQFOXLURQHJ³FLR7DOSRVVLELOLGDGHHQWUHWDQWRQ£RH[LVWLU¡
QDVRIHUWDVIHLWDVDRFRQVXPLGRUQDIRUPDGD/HLQ&'&
E VH R FRQWU¡ULR D Q£R REULJDWRULHGDGH UHVXOWDU GD QDWXUH]D GR QHJ³FLR ߚ FLWHVH R H[HPSOR VHJXLQGR R SHQVDPHQWR GH &$5/26
52%(572 *21$/9(6 ߡGDV FKDPDGDV SURSRVWDV DEHUWDV DR SºEOLFR TXH VH FRQVLGHUDP OLPLWDGDV DR HVWRTXH H[LVWHQWHߢ
3RGHPRVSHQVDUWDPE©PFRPRXPH[HPSORGRGLDDGLDTXDQGRVHRIHUHFHFDURQDHPVXDPRWRDSHVVRDVGHXPJUXSRFRQWUDWRGH
WUDQVSRUWHJUDWXLWRHPTXHDRIHUWDVRPHQWHSRGHVHUFRQVLGHUDGDY¡OLGDDRSULPHLURTXHDFHLWDUSHODLPSRVVLELOLGDGHI¡WLFDGHFDUUHJDU
PDLVGHXPQRYHFXOR
F VH R FRQWU¡ULR D Q£R REULJDWRULHGDGH UHVXOWDU GDV FLUFXQVW¢QFLDV GR FDVR ߚ QHVVH FDVR RSWRX R OHJLVODGRU SRU DGRWDU XPD GLF§£R
JHQ©ULFDVHQ£RDEVWUDWDTXHGDU¡DRMXL]DOLEHUGDGHQHFHVV¡ULDSDUDDIHULUQRFDVRFRQFUHWRHUHVSHLWDGRRSULQFSLRGDUD]RDELOLGDGH
VLWXD§£RHPTXHDSURSRVWDQ£RSRGHULDVHUFRQVLGHUDGDREULJDW³ULD
&RPSOHPHQWDQGRHVVHUROGHH[FH§µHVRFRGLILFDGRUFXLGRXDLQGDGHPHQFLRQDUKLS³WHVHVGHSHUGD
GHIRU§DYLQFXODQWHGDSURSRVWDSRUIRU§DGRGHFXUVRGHODSVRWHPSRUDOHQWUHDSURSRVWDHDDFHLWD§£R
RSUD]RGHYDOLGDGHGDSURSRVWD
3UD]RGHYDOLGDGHGDSURSRVWD
'LVSµHRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLO
ߡ$UW'HL[DGHVHUREULJDW³ULDDSURSRVWD
, ߚ VH IHLWD VHP SUD]R D SHVVRD SUHVHQWH Q£R IRL LPHGLDWDPHQWH DFHLWD &RQVLGHUDVH WDPE©P SUHVHQWH D SHVVRD TXH FRQWUDWD SRU
WHOHIRQHRXSRUPHLRGHFRPXQLFD§£RVHPHOKDQWH
,,ߚVHIHLWDVHPSUD]RDSHVVRDDXVHQWHWLYHUGHFRUULGRWHPSRVXILFLHQWHSDUDFKHJDUDUHVSRVWDDRFRQKHFLPHQWRGRSURSRQHQWH
,,,ߚVHIHLWDDSHVVRDDXVHQWHQ£RWLYHUVLGRH[SHGLGDDUHVSRVWDGHQWURGRSUD]RGDGR
,9ߚVHDQWHVGHODRXVLPXOWDQHDPHQWHFKHJDUDRFRQKHFLPHQWRGDRXWUDSDUWHDUHWUDWD§£RGRSURSRQHQWHߢ
3DUDTXHHQWHQGDPRVWDLVVLWXD§µHV©SUHFLVRGHILQLURTXHVHHQWHQGHSRUߡSHVVRDSUHVHQWHߢHߡSHVVRD
DXVHQWHߢ
3UHVHQWHVV£RDVSHVVRDVTXHPDQWªPFRQWDWRGLUHWRHVLPXOW¢QHRXPDFRPDRXWUDDH[HPSORGDTXHODV
TXHWUDWDPGRQHJ³FLRSHVVRDOPHQWHRXTXHXWLOL]DPPHLRGHWUDQVPLVV£RLPHGLDWDGDYRQWDGHFRPRR
WHOHIRQH SRU H[HPSOR 2EVHUYHVH TXH HP WDLV FDVRV R DFHLWDQWH WRPD FLªQFLD GD RIHUWD TXDVH QR
PHVPRLQVWDQWHHPTXHHOD©HPLWLGD
$XVHQWHV SRU VXD YH] V£R DTXHODV SHVVRDV TXH Q£R PDQWªP FRQWDWR GLUHWR H LPHGLDWR HQWUH VL FDVR
GDTXHODVTXHFRQWUDWDPSRUPHLRGHFDUWDRXWHOHJUDPDFRUUHVSRQGªQFLDHSLVWRODU
1HVVD OLQKD GH UDFLRFQLR SRGHUHPRV FRQVLGHUDU PXWDWLV PXWDQGLV HQWUH SUHVHQWHV R FRQWUDWR
FHOHEUDGR HOHWURQLFDPHQWH HP XP FKDW VDODV YLUWXDLV GH FRPXQLFD§£R KDMD YLVWD TXH DV SDUWHV
HQYROYLGDV PDQWªP FRQWDWR GLUHWR HQWUH VL TXDQGR GH VXD IRUPD§£R H SRU RXWUR ODGR HQWUH DXVHQWHV
DTXHOHIRUPDGRSRUPHLRGRHQYLRGHPHQVDJHPHOHWU´QLFDHPDLOSRLVQHVVHFDVRPHGHLDXPODSVR
GHWHPSRHQWUHDHPLVV£RGDRIHUWDHDUHVSRVWD
7HFLGDV WDLV FRQVLGHUD§µHV UHWRUQDUHPRV DQ¡OLVH GR DUW VRE FRPHQWR R TXDO HQXPHUD DV
VHJXLQWHVKLS³WHVHVGHSHUGDGDHILF¡FLDREULJDW³ULDGDSURSRVWD
D VH IHLWD VHP SUD]R D SHVVRD SUHVHQWH Q£R IRL LPHGLDWDPHQWH DFHLWD ߚ RUD VH VH WUDWD GH SHVVRDV SUHVHQWHV LQIHUHVH GD TXH D
UHVSRVWDRXDFHLWD§£RGHYHVHULPHGLDWDVRESHQDGHSHUGDGHHILF¡FLDGDRIHUWD1RWHVHTXHROHJLVODGRUVDOLHQWDFRQVLGHUDUWDPE©P
SUHVHQWHDSHVVRDTXHFRQWUDWDSRUWHOHIRQHRXRXWURPHLRGHFRPXQLFD§£RVHPHOKDQWHRPHQFLRQDGRFKDWSRUH[HPSOR
EVHIHLWDVHPSUD]RDSHVVRDDXVHQWHWLYHUGHFRUULGRWHPSRVXILFLHQWHSDUDFKHJDUDUHVSRVWDDRFRQKHFLPHQWRGRSURSRQHQWHߚQHVWH
FDVRDSURSRVWD©HQYLDGDVHPUHIHUªQFLDDSUD]RHGHFRUUHWHPSRVXILFLHQWHSDUDDPDQLIHVWD§£RGRDFHLWDQWHTXHRGHL[DWUDQVFRUUHU
LQDOELV,QWHUHVVDQWHQRWDUTXHROHJLVODGRUDRUHIHULUVHDߡWHPSRVXILFLHQWHߢFRQVDJURXXPDH[SUHVV£RTXHHQFHUUDFRQFHLWRDEHUWR
RXLQGHWHUPLQDGRFDEHQGRSRUWDQWRDRMXOJDGRUVHPSUHGHDFRUGRFRPRSULQFSLRGDUD]RDELOLGDGHDSOLFDUGDPHOKRUIRUPDDQRUPDDR
FDVRFRQFUHWR&RPRSDU¢PHWURSRGHRMXL]SRUH[HPSORFRQVLGHUDUߡVXILFLHQWHߢRSHURGRGHWHPSRGHQWURGRTXDOKDELWXDOPHQWHHP
FRQWUDWRVGDTXHODQDWXUH]DFRVWXPDVHHPLWLUDUHVSRVWD
F VH IHLWD D SHVVRD DXVHQWH Q£R WLYHU VLGR H[SHGLGD D UHVSRVWD GHQWUR GR SUD]R GDGR ߚ QHVVD KLS³WHVH D SURSRVWD © IHLWD D SHVVRD
DXVHQWH FRP GHILQL§£R GH SUD]R H D DFHLWD§£R Q£R © H[SHGLGD GHQWUR GR SUD]R GDGR ([HPSOR &DLR HQYLD FRUUHVSRQGªQFLD D 7FLR
SURSRQGROKHDFHOHEUD§£RGHGHWHUPLQDGRFRQWUDWRFRQVLJQDQGRQDSU³SULDFDUWDRSUD]RGHVHLVPHVHVSDUDDUHVSRVWDDFHLWD§£R
3DVVDPVHRVVHLVPHVHVHDUHVSRVWDQ£R©H[SHGLGD'HWDOIRUPDSHUGHDSURSRVWDDVXDREULJDWRULHGDGH
GVHDQWHVGHODDSURSRVWDRXVLPXOWDQHDPHQWHFKHJDUDRFRQKHFLPHQWRGDRXWUDSDUWHDUHWUDWD§£RGRSURSRQHQWHߚDTXLDQWHVGD
SURSRVWDRXMXQWRFRPHODFKHJDDRFRQKHFLPHQWRGDRXWUDSDUWHDUHWUDWD§£RRXRDUUHSHQGLPHQWRGRSURSRQHQWHFDVRHPTXHDRIHUWD
SHUGHU¡WDPE©PDVXDREULJDWRULHGDGH
)RUD GHVVDV KLS³WHVHV DUWV VHJXQGD SDUWH H SRUWDQWR D SURSRVWD REULJD R SURSRQHQWH H
GHYHU¡VHUGHYLGDPHQWHFXPSULGDFDVRKDMDDFRQVHTXHQWHDFHLWD§£R
$RIHUWDDRSºEOLFR
2 &³GLJR &LYLO GH FXLGRX DLQGD GH UHJXODU QR DUW D RIHUWD DR SºEOLFR FRQVLVWHQWH QD
SURSRVWDGHFRQWUDWDUIHLWDDXPDFROHWLYLGDGH
1HVVH VHQWLGR GLVS´V TXH ߡD RIHUWD DR SºEOLFR HTXLYDOH D SURSRVWD TXDQGR HQFHUUD RV UHTXLVLWRV
HVVHQFLDLVDRFRQWUDWRVDOYRVHRFRQWU¡ULRUHVXOWDUGDVFLUFXQVW¢QFLDVRXGRVXVRVߢ
9ªVH SRUWDQWR TXH HVWD PRGDOLGDGH GH RIHUWD Q£R VH GLIHUHQFLD HVVHQFLDOPHQWH GDV GHPDLV
VLQJXODUL]DQGRVHDSHQDVSRUVHGLULJLUDXPQºPHURLQGHWHUPLQDGRGHSHVVRDV
$GHPDLV GHVGH TXH VHMD IHLWD REVHUYDQGRVH RV UHTXLVLWRV JHUDLV GH YDOLGDGH GD SURSRVWD WRUQDVH
REULJDW³ULD UHVVDOYDGD D KLS³WHVH GH DV FLUFXQVW¢QFLDV RX RV XVRV GHVFDUDFWHUL]DUHPQD FRPR RIHUWD
,PDJLQHVHSRUH[HPSORTXHHPXPDGHWHUPLQDGDORFDOLGDGHPXLWRGLVWDQWHVHMDVHFXODURFRVWXPHGH
DQXQFLDU SURGXWRV HP DOWD YR] DSHQDV FRPR W©FQLFD SXEOLFLW¡ULD SDUD DWUDLU FOLHQWHV EDUUDFD GR
DQXQFLDQWH VHQGR TXH D SURSRVWD GHILQLWLYD VRPHQWH © IHLWD SHOR YHQGHGRU DS³V D HVFROKD GR EHP
SUHWHQGLGR
)LQDOPHQWH YDOH QRWDU TXH R PHVPR GLVSRVLWLYR GH OHL DGPLWH D UHYRJD§£R GD SURSRVWD VH IRU IHLWD
SHODPHVPDYLDGHGLYXOJD§£RHGHVGHTXHHVVDIDFXOGDGHKDMDVLGRUHVVDOYDGDQDSU³SULDRIHUWD&RP
LVVRTXHUVHGL]HUTXHVHRSURSRQHQWHQ£RUHVHUYRXDIDFXOGDGHGHUHYRJD§£RGDQGRLQFOXVLYHFLªQFLD
GHOD RXWUDSDUWHQ£RSRGHU¡H[HUFªOD
+¡HQWUHWDQWRXPSHFXOLDUWLSRGHRIHUWDFRPXPQRVGLDVGHKRMHHTXHPHUHFHDQRVVDUHGREUDGD
DWHQ§£RDTXHODRSHUDGDSRUDSDUHOKRVDXWRP¡WLFRVGHYHQGDGHSURGXWRV
6REUH R WHPD PDQLIHVWDVH FRP SURSULHGDGH &$,2 05,2 FLWDQGR R SHQVDPHQWR GH )5$1
0$57,16
ߡ&RQVWLWXL DLQGD WLSR SHFXOLDU GH RIHUWD D TXH UHVXOWD GR SURFHVVR W©FQLFR FRP D DGR§£R GH DSDUHOKRV DXWRP¡WLFRV QRV TXDLV D
PHUFDGRULD©H[SRVWDHDIL[DGRRSUH§RIRUPDQGRVHRFRQWUDWRFRPDLQWURGX§£RGHPRHGDHPXPDUDQKXUDRXWURVFRQWUDWRVDO©PGD
FRPSUDHYHQGDFHOHEUDPVHSHORPHVPRVLVWHPDFRPRRWUDQVSRUWHHPWUHPVXEWHUU¢QHRSRXVDGDHPPRW©LV PDUJHPGDVHVWUDGDV
YHQGDGHMRUQDLVHWF2DSDUHOKRDXWRP¡WLFR©TXHUHSUHVHQWDQRFDVRRSURSRQHQWHRREODWR©RSºEOLFRHPJHUDOߢ
(PQRVVRVHQWLUHVWDHVSHFLDOIRUPDGHFRQWUDWD§£RWSLFDGDVRFLHGDGHHPTXHYLYHPRV©SDVVYHO
GH FRQFUHWL]D§£R QD PHGLGD HP TXH VH UHFRQKHFH MXULGLFLGDGH DWXD§£R GR DSDUDWR PHF¢QLFR R TXDO
H[HUFHULDXPDIXQ§£RVHPHOKDQWH GRQºQFLR
1£R FRQFHEHPRV SRUWDQWR TXH R PHFDQLVPR HOHWU´QLFR RX PHF¢QLFR VHMD DGPLWLGR FRPR
ߡUHSUHVHQWDQWHߢ GD HPSUHVD RX GR HPSUHV¡ULR TXH R LQVWDORX XPD YH] TXH SRGHUHV GH UHSUHVHQWD§£R
GHPDQGDULDPXPDPDUJHPGHYROXQߓWDULVPRHGLVFHUQLPHQWRGHTXHQ£RGLVSµH
0DVVHPGºYLGDDP¡TXLQDVHUYHFRPRWUDQVPLVVRUGDYRQWDGHGRFRPHUFLDQWHTXHIL[DRSUH§RDV
FRQGL§µHVHLQVWUX§µHVGHYHQGDHDLQGDDVVLPDQXQFLDRXGHYHDQXQFLDUDJDUDQWLDGRUHFHELPHQWRGR
SURGXWRRXDGHYROX§£RGRSUH§RSDJR
3RULVVRTXDQGRFRORFDPRVXPDPRHGDHPXPDP¡TXLQDGHUHIULJHUDQWHVDFHLWDPRVXPDSURSRVWDGH
FRQWUDWDU IRUPXODGD SHOR YHQGHGRU GDV PHUFDGRULDV SRU PHLR GH XP PHFDQLVPR WUDQVPLVVRU GD VXD
YRQWDGH
2XWURV DVSHFWRV DFHUFD GD SURSRVWD IHLWD DR SºEOLFR FRQVXPLGRU VHU£R YLVWRV DLQGD QHVWH FDSWXOR
TXDQGRWUDWDUPRVGRWHPD OX]GR'LUHLWRGR&RQVXPLGRU
&RQVHTXªQFLDVMXUGLFDVGDPRUWHGRSURSRQHQWH
)LQDOPHQWHFXPSUHQRVLQGDJDUTXDLVVHU£RDVFRQVHTXªQFLDVMXUGLFDVGDPRUWHGRSURSRQHQWHDQWHV
GDFHOHEUD§£RGRFRQWUDWRRXVHMDDQWHVTXHRDFHLWDQWHSRVVDDTXLHVFHUFRPDRIHUWD
1£R WHPRV GºYLGD GH TXH VH D SURSRVWD IHLWD SXGHU VHU FXPSULGD D SRVWHULRUL SRU Q£R VH UHIHULU D
SUHVWD§£R LQIXQJYHO SHUVRQDOVVLPD D VXD REULJDWRULHGDGH SHUGXUDU¡ UHIOHWLQGRVH QRV EHQV
FRPSRQHQWHVGRHVS³OLRGHVGHTXHVHMDSOHQDPHQWHY¡OLGD
6H HQWUHWDQWR R SURSRQHQWH YLHU D IDOLU DQWHV GD DFHLWD§£R GD SURSRVWD FRQFRUGDPRV FRP R FXOWR
'$5&< %(6621( QR VHQWLGR GH TXH WDO FLUFXQVW¢QFLD Q£R R SULYDULD GD FDSDFLGDGH SDUD FRQWUDWDU
HPERUDRVFRQWUDWRVTXHFHOHEUHQ£RVHMDPRSRQYHLV PDVVDIDOLGDQ£RSRGHQGRSRUWDQWRSUHMXGLFDU
RVVHXVFUHGRUHV$GYLUWDVHDSHQDVTXHSRGHU¡RSURSRQHQWHIDOLGRHQFRQWUDUQDVXSHUYHQLªQFLDGH
VXD IDOªQFLD UD]£R SDUD UHYRJDU D SURSRVWD H SRU RXWUR ODGR SRGHU¡ R SU³SULR DFHLWDQWH GHVLVWLU VH
DQWHYHU SUHMX]R DR QHJ³FLR RX FDVR M¡ WHQKD DFHLWDGR LQVFLHQWH GD TXHEUD SRGHU¡ GHVOLJDUVH
SRVWHULRUPHQWHGRFRQWUDWR
$$&(,7$2
$DFHLWD§£R©DDTXLHVFªQFLDDXPDSURSRVWDIRUPXODGD
7UDWDVHGDPDQLIHVWD§£RGHYRQWDGHFRQFRUGDQWHGRDFHLWDQWHRXREODWRTXHDGHUH SURSRVWDTXHOKH
IRUDDSUHVHQWDGD
&RPR VH WUDWD GH DWXD§£R GD YRQWDGH KXPDQD GHYHU¡ VHU H[WHUQDGD VHP YFLRV GH FRQVHQWLPHQWR ߚ
FRPRRHUURRGRORDOHV£RRXDFRD§£RߚVRESHQDGHRQHJ³FLRYLUDVHUDQXODGR
3UHVVXSµHGDPHVPDIRUPDDSOHQDFDSDFLGDGHGRDJHQWHVHQ£RIRURFDVRGHHVWDUUHSUHVHQWDGRRX
DVVLVWLGRQDIRUPDGDOHJLVOD§£RFLYLOHPYLJRU
&XPSUHQRV REVHUYDU TXH VH D DFHLWD§£R IRU IHLWD IRUD GR SUD]R FRP DGL§µHV UHVWUL§µHV RX
PRGLILFD§µHV LPSRUWDU¡ HP QRYD SURSRVWD 2X VHMD FDVR D DTXLHVFªQFLD Q£R VHMD LQWHJUDO PDV IHLWD
LQWHPSHVWLYDPHQWHRXFRPDOWHUD§µHVUHVWULWLYDVRXDPSOLDWLYDVFRQYHUWHUVH¡HPFRQWUDSURSRVWDQRV
WHUPRVGRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLO
1HVVD PHVPD OLQKD VH D DFHLWD§£R SRU FLUFXQVW¢QFLD LPSUHYLVWD FKHJDU WDUGH DR FRQKHFLPHQWR GR
SURSRQHQWHHVWHGHYHU¡FRPXQLFDURIDWRLPHGLDWDPHQWHDRDFHLWDQWHVRESHQDGHUHVSRQGHUSRUSHUGDVH
GDQRVDUW
,QWHUHVVDQWHHVWDºOWLPDKLS³WHVH
2UHIHULGRGLVSRVLWLYRLPSµHDRSURSRQHQWH OX]GDVXSHULRUUHJUDGHERDI©REMHWLYDDLQGDTXHQD
IDVHSU©FRQWUDWXDORGHYHUGHLQIRUPDUDR DFHLWDQWHTXH D VXD PDQLIHVWD§£R GH YRQWDGHFKHJRX DRVHX
FRQKHFLPHQWRWDUGLDPHQWHVRESHQDGHHPVHRPLWLQGRYLUDVHUUHVSRQVDELOL]DGR
,PDJLQHVH SRU H[HPSOR TXH 6RX]D KRXYHVVH HQYLDGR D )ULP XPD SURSRVWD SDUD D YHQGD GH XPD
WRQHODGDGHEDQDQDVGDWHUUD)ULPHQW£RGHQWURGRSUD]RDVVLQDGRUHVSRQGHDTXLHVFHQGRFRPDRIHUWD
2FRUUH TXH SRU FLUFXQVW¢QFLD LPSUHYLVWD D FDUWD © H[WUDYLDGD H VRPHQWH FKHJD V P£RV GR
SURSRQHQWHYHQGHGRU 6RX]D VHWH GLDV DS³V R ILQDO GR SUD]R GH UHVSRVWD M¡ WHQGR LQFOXVLYH VH
FRPSURPHWLGR D YHQGHU DV EDQDQDV D XP WHUFHLUR *HUDOGR 'HYHU¡ SRLV QHVWH FDVR FRPXQLFDU
LPHGLDWDPHQWHD)ULPRUHFHELPHQWRWDUGLRGDVXDUHVSRVWDVRESHQDGHVHUFLYLOPHQWHUHVSRQVDELOL]DGR
SHORVGDQRVGDUHVXOWDQWHV
7UDWDVHVHPGºYLGDGHQRUPDFODUDHGHLQHJ¡YHOMXVWL§DTXHVHDILQDFRPRSULQFSLRGDHWLFLGDGH
YDORUL]DGRSHORFRGLILFDGRU
)LQDOPHQWHYDOHVDOLHQWDUTXHDDFHLWD§£RSRGHU¡VHUH[SUHVVDRXW¡FLWDFRQVRDQWHVHSRGHFRQFOXLUGD
DQ¡OLVHGRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLO
ߡ$UW6HRQHJ³FLR IRUGDTXHOHVHPTXHQ£RVHMDFRVWXPHDDFHLWD§£RH[SUHVVDRXR SURSRQHQWHDWLYHUGLVSHQVDGRUHSXWDUVH¡
FRQFOXGRRFRQWUDWRQ£RFKHJDQGRDWHPSRDUHFXVDߢ
1HVVHVFDVRVRFRVWXPHQHJRFLDORXDW©PHVPRDGLVSHQVDGRSURSRQHQWHID]HPFRPTXHVHDGPLWDD
DFHLWD§£RW¡FLWDVHQ£RFKHJDUDRDFHLWDQWHDQWHVGDFRQFOXV£RGRQHJ³FLRDUHFXVDGRSURSRQHQWH
'LILFXOGDGHK¡WRGDYLDQDIL[D§£RGRPRPHQWRHPTXHVHUHSXWDFHOHEUDGRRFRQWUDWRSRUVHWUDWDUGH
DFHLWD§£R W¡FLWD (QWUHWDQWR GHVGH TXH KDMD SURYD QHVVH VHQWLGR LQFLR GH DWRV H[HFXW³ULRV SRU
H[HPSORRSROLFLWDQWHQ£RSRGHU¡PDLVVHUHWUDWDU
)250$2'26&2175$726(175($86(17(6
,PSRUWDQWHTXHVW£RDVHUHQIUHQWDGDGL]UHVSHLWR IRUPD§£RGRFRQWUDWRHQWUHDXVHQWHVHVSHFLDOPHQWHR
SDFWXDGRPHGLDQWHFRUUHVSRQGªQFLDHSLVWRODU
$OL¡VFRPRFDUHFHPRVGHXPDGLVFLSOLQDHVSHFILFDGRVFRQWUDWRVHOHWU´QLFRVDPDW©ULDDTXLH[SRVWD
SRGHU¡PXWDWLVPXWDQGLVVHUDGDSWDGD TXHOHVQHJ³FLRVSDFWXDGRVSRUHPDLO
)XQGDPHQWDOPHQWHDGRXWULQDFULRXGXDVWHRULDVH[SOLFDWLYDVDUHVSHLWRGDIRUPD§£RGRFRQWUDWRHQWUH
DXVHQWHV
DWHRULDGDFRJQL§£RߚSDUDRVDGHSWRVGHVVDOLQKDGHSHQVDPHQߓWRRFRQWUDWRHQWUHDXVHQWHVVRPHQWHVHFRQVLGHUDULDIRUPDGRTXDQGRD
UHVSRVWDGRDFHLWDQWHFKHJDVVHDRFRQKHFLPHQWRGRSURSRQHQWH
EWHRULDGDDJQL§£RGLVSHQVDVHTXHDUHVSRVWDFKHJXHDRFRQKHFLPHQWRGRSURSRQHQWH
E VXEWHRULDGDGHFODUD§£RSURSULDPHQWHGLWDߚRFRQWUDWRVHIRUPDULDQRPRPHQWRHPTXHRDFHLWDQWHRXREODWRUHGLJHGDWLORJUDID
RXGLJLWDDVXDUHVSRVWD3HFDSRUVHUH[WUHPDPHQWHLQVHJXUDGDGDDGLILFXOGDGHHPVHSUHFLVDURLQVWDQWHGDUHVSRVWD
E VXEWHRULDGDH[SHGL§£RߚFRQVLGHUDIRUPDGRRFRQWUDWRQRPRPHQWRHPTXHDUHVSRVWD©H[SHGLGD
E VXEWHRULDGDUHFHS§£RߚUHSXWDFHOHEUDGRRQHJ³FLRQRLQVWDQWHHPTXHRSURSRQHQWHUHFHEHDUHVSRVWD'LVSHQVDFRPRYLPRV
VXD OHLWXUD 7UDWDVH GH XPD VXEWHRULD PDLV VHJXUD GR TXH DV GHPDLV SRLV D VXD FRPSURYD§£R © PHQRV GLILFXOWRVD SRGHQGR VHU
SURYDGDSRUH[HPSORSRUPHLRGR$5DYLVRGHUHFHELPHQWRQDVFRUUHVSRQGªQFLDV
0DVDILQDOTXDOVHULDDWHRULDDGRWDGDSHORQRVVRGLUHLWRSRVLWLYR"
&/9,6 %(9,/48$ DXWRU GR SURMHWR GR &³GLJR &LYLO GH HUD QLWLGDPHQWH DGHSWR GD
VXEWHRULDGDH[SHGL§£RSRUUHSXW¡ODߡDPDLVUD]R¡YHOHDPDLVMXUGLFDߢ
3RU LVVR ERD SDUWH GD GRXWULQD EUDVLOHLUD GHEUX§DQGRVH VREUH R DUW GR &³GLJR UHYRJDGR
FRQFOXDWUDWDUVHGHGLVSRVLWLYRDILQDGRFRPRSHQVDPHQWRGH%(9,/48$
ߡ$UWFDSXW2VFRQWUDWRVSRUFRUUHVSRQGªQFLDHSLVWRODURXWHOHJU¡ILFDWRUQDPVHSHUIHLWRVGHVGHTXHDDFHLWD§£R©H[SHGLGDߢ
JULIDPRV
1DPHVPDOLQKDVHFRWHMDUPRVHVVHGLVSRVLWLYRFRPRFRUUHVSRQGHQWHGR&³GLJRHPYLJRUWHUHPRVD
QWLGDLPSUHVV£RGHTXHIRLDGRWDGDDYHUWHQWHWH³ULFDGDH[SHGL§£R
ߡ$UW2VFRQWUDWRVHQWUHDXVHQWHVWRUQDPVHSHUIHLWRVGHVGHTXHDDFHLWD§£R©H[SHGLGDH[FHWR
,ߚQRFDVRGRDUWLJRDQWHFHGHQWH
,,ߚVHRSURSRQHQWHVHKRXYHUFRPSURPHWLGRDHVSHUDUUHVSRVWD
,,,ߚVHHODQ£RFKHJDUQRSUD]RFRQYHQFLRQDGRߢJULIDPRV
1RWHVH HQWUHWDQWR TXH R UHIHULGR GLVSRVLWLYR HQXPHUD VLWXD§µHV HP TXH R FRQWUDWR Q£R VH UHSXWDU¡
FHOHEUDGRQR FDVR GR DUW VH R SURSRQHQWH VH KRXYHU FRPSURPHWLGR D HVSHUDU D UHVSRVWD QHVWD
KLS³WHVHRSU³SULRSROLFLWDQWHFRPSURPHWHXVHDDJXDUGDUDPDQLIHVWD§£RGRREODWRRXILQDOPHQWHVHD
UHVSRVWDQ£RFKHJDUQRSUD]RDVVLQDGRSHORSROLFLWDQWH
2FRUUHTXHVHREVHUYDUPRVDUHVVDOYDFRQVWDQWHQRLQFLVR,GHVVHDUWLJRTXHID]UHPLVV£RDRDUW
FKHJDUHPRV LQDUUHG¡YHOFRQFOXV£RGHTXHDDFHLWD§£RQ£RVHUHSXWDU¡H[LVWHQWHVHDQWHVGHODRXFRP
HODFKHJDUDRSURSRQHQWHDUHWUDWD§£RGRDFHLWDQWH
$WHQWHVH SDUD HVVD H[SUHVV£R ߡVH DQWHV GHOD RX FRP HOD &+(*$5 DR SURSRQHQWH D UHWUDWD§£R GR
DFHLWDQWHߢ
2UDDRID]HUWDOUHIHUªQFLDRSU³SULROHJLVODGRUDFDERXSRUQHJDUDIRU§DFRQFOXVLYDGDH[SHGL§£R
SDUDUHFRQKHFHUTXHHQTXDQWRQ£RWLYHUKDYLGRD5(&(32RFRQWUDWRQ£RVHUHSXWDU¡SHUIHLWRSRLV
DQWHVGRUHFHELPHQWRGDUHVSRVWDRXVLPXOWDQHDPHQWHDHVWDSRGHU¡YLURDUUHSHQGLPHQWRGRDFHLWDQWH
'DGDDDPSOLWXGHGDUHVVDOYDFRQVWDQWHQRDUWTXHDGPLWHFRPRYLPRVDUHWUDWD§£RGRDFHLWDQWH
DW© TXH D UHVSRVWD VHMD UHFHELGD SHOR SURSRQHQWH HQWHQGHPRV TXH R QRVVR &³GLJR &LYLO DGRWRX D
VXEWHRULDGDUHFHS§£RHQ£RDGDH[SHGL§£R
(VVH©RHQWHQGLPHQWRWDPE©PGH&$5/2652%(572*21$/9(6
ߡ2DUWGR&³GLJR&LYLODFROKHXH[SUHVVDPHQWHDWHRULDGDH[SHGL§£RDRDILUPDUTXHRVFRQWUDWRVHQWUHDXVHQWHVWRUQDPVHSHUIHLWRV
GHVGHTXHDDFHLWD§£R©H[SHGLGD(QWUHWDQWRHVWDEHOHFHXWUªVH[FH§µHVDQRFDVRGHKDYHUUHWUDWD§£RGRDFHLWDQWHEVHRSURSRQHQWH
VH KRXYHU FRPSURPHWLGR D HVSHUDU UHVSRVWD H F VHHOD Q£R FKHJDU QR SUD]R FRQYHQFLRQDGR 2UD VH VHPSUH © SHUPLWLGD D UHWUDWD§£R
DQWHVGHDUHVSRVWDFKHJDU VP£RVGRSURSRQHQWHHVHDLQGDQ£RVHUHSXWDFRQFOXGRRFRQWUDWRQDKLS³WHVHGHDUHVSRVWDQ£RFKHJDU
QRSUD]RFRQYHQFLRQDGRQDUHDOLGDGHRUHIHULGRGLSORPDILOLRXVH WHRULDGDUHFHS§£RHQ£R GDH[SHGL§£Rߢ
$3523267$12&',*2'('()(6$'2&21680,'25
(PERUD Q£R VHMD REMHWR HVSHFILFR GH QRVVD REUD Q£R SRGHUDPRV QRV IXUWDU GH WHFHU EUHYHV
FRQVLGHUD§µHV DFHUFD GD RIHUWD DR SºEOLFR IHLWD QR ¢PELWR GR 'LUHLWR GR &RQVXPLGRU SRU VH WUDWDU GH
WHPDDWXDOHGRVPDLVSDOSLWDQWHV
2 &³GLJR GH 'HIHVD GR &RQVXPLGRU ߚ /HL Q GH ߚ UHJXOD QR &DSWXOR 9 'DV
3U¡WLFDV&RPHUFLDLV6H§£R,,DRIHUWDIHLWDDRPHUFDGRGHFRQVXPRDUWVD
/RJRQRDUWROHJLVODGRUFXLGRXGHHVWDEHOHFHUFRPQLWLGH]TXHDVSURSRVWDVIHLWDVDRFRQVXPLGRU
VHU£R LQIRUPDGDV SHOR SULQFSLR GD YLQFXOD§£R R TXH VLJQLILFD GL]HU TXH WHU£R VHPSUH XPD FDUJD GH
REULJDWRULHGDGHPDLVDFHQWXDGDGRTXHDVRIHUWDVHPJHUDOUHJXODGDVSHOR&³GLJR&LYLO
ߡ$UW7RGDLQIRUPD§£RRXSXEOLFLGDGHVXILFLHQWHPHQWHSUHFLVDYHLFXODGDSRUTXDOTXHUIRUPDRXPHLRGHFRPXQLFD§£RFRPUHOD§£RD
SURGXWRVHVHUYL§RVRIHUHFLGRVRXDSUHVHQWDGRVREULJDRIRUQHFHGRUTXHDIL]HUYHLFXODURXGHODVHXWLOL]DUHLQWHJUDRFRQWUDWRTXHYLHUD
VHUFHOHEUDGRߢ
'HYHU¡ DGHPDLV VHU IHLWD HP OQJXD SRUWXJXHVD DUW H FRP LQIRUPD§µHV FODUDV SUHFLVDV H
RVWHQVLYDV
$GHPDLVWRUQDQGRHIHWLYDDWXWHODGRFRQVXPLGRURDUWSUHFHLWXDTXHVHRIRUQHFHGRUGHSURGXWRV
RX VHUYL§RV UHFXVDU FXPSULPHQWR RIHUWD DSUHVHQWD§£R RX SXEOLFLGDGH R FRQVXPLGRU SRGHU¡
DOWHUQDWLYDPHQWHH VXDHVFROKD
DH[LJLURFXPSULPHQWRIRU§DGRGDREULJD§£RQRVWHUPRVGDRIHUWDDSUHVHQWD§£RRXSXEOLFLGDGHߚQHVWHFDVRODQ§DQGRP£RVREUHWXGR
GRVPHLRVMXGLFLDLVGHWXWHODHVSHFILFDSRVWRV VXDGLVSRVL§£R
EDFHLWDURXWURSURGXWRRXSUHVWD§£RGHVHUYL§RHTXLYDOHQWHߚWUDWDVHGHXPDIDFXOGDGHGRFRQVXPLGRUHQ£RXPGLUHLWRGRIRUQHFHGRU
FUHVFLQGLURFRQWUDWRFRPGLUHLWR UHVWLWXL§£RGDTXDQWLDHYHQWXDOPHQWHDQWHFLSDGDPRQHWDULDPHQWHDWXDOL]DGDHDSHUGDVHGDQRVߚ
WUDWDVHHPYHUGDGHGHUHVROX§£RGHFRQWUDWRSRULQDGLPSOHPHQWRDEULQGRVHDRFRQVXPLGRUDSRVVLELOLGDGHGHSOHLWHDUDFRPSHQVD§£R
GHYLGDDWXDOL]DGDVHJXQGRRVQGLFHVRILFLDLVHPYLJRU
&RP LVVR YHPRV TXH D OHJLVOD§£R FRQVXPHULVWD LPSULPLX XPD HIHWLYD WXWHOD QR SODQR SURFHVVXDO
LQFOXVLYHGRVGLUHLWRVGRVFRQVXPLGRUHVDILQDQGRVHDVVLPFRPDQRVVD/HL)XQGDPHQWDO
/8*$5'$)250$2'2&2175$72
)LQDOPHQWHFXPSUHQRVOHPEUDUDRQRVVRDPLJROHLWRUTXHQRVWHUPRVGRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLOR
FRQWUDWRUHSXWDVHFHOHEUDGRQROXJDUHPTXHIRLSURSRVWR
7DO UHJUD ORQJH GH VHU GHVQHFHVV¡ULD DILJXUDVH ºWLO HVSHFLDOPHQWH TXDQGR VXUJLUHP TXHVWµHV
DWLQHQWHV FRPSHWªQFLDRXTXDQGRRMXL]WLYHUGHDQDOLVDUXVRVHFRVWXPHVGROXJDURQGHRQHJ³FLRIRUD
SDFWXDGR
&ODUR HVW¡ HQWUHWDQWR TXH QR FDVR GD FRQWUDWD§£R HOHWU´QLFD SHOD ,QWHUQHW QHP VHPSUH HVWD UHJUD
SRGHU¡VHUDSOLFDGDFRPDGHYLGDVHJXUDQ§DFRQVLGHUDQGRVHDIUHTXHQWHGLILFXOGDGHGHVHSUHFLVDUR
ORFDOGHRQGHSDUWLXDSURSRVWD
;9
'$6(67,38/$(6&2175$78$,6(0
5(/$2$7(5&(,526
,1752'82
$ UHJUD JHUDO © TXH RV FRQWUDWRV V³ GHYHP JHUDU HIHLWRV HQWUH DV SU³SULDV SDUWHV FRQWUDWDQWHV Q£R
GL]HQGRUHVSHLWRDSULRULDWHUFHLURVHVWUDQKRV UHOD§£RMXUGLFDFRQWUDWXDO
$VVLPSRUH[HPSOR9DOGLUQ£RWHPQDGDDYHUFRPRFRQWUDWRFHOHEUDGRHQWUH)ORULVYDOGRH%DUERVD
Q£RSRGHQGRH[LJLUSDUDVLRPHVPRFRQWHºGRFRQWUDWXDO
7RGDYLD FRPR WRGD UHJUD SDUHFH FRPSRUWDU XPD H[FH§£R H WDOYH] HVWD UHJUD WDPE©P FRPSRUWH
H[FH§µHVQ£R©GLIHUHQWHFRPRSULQFSLRGDUHODWLYLGDGHVXEMHWLYDGRVHIHLWRVGRFRQWUDWR
1RV SU³[LPRV W³SLFRV DERUGDUHPRV WUªV PRGDOLGDGHV GH HVWLSXOD§µHV FRQWUDWXDLV UHODFLRQDGDV FRP
WHUFHLURVDVDEHU
DHVWLSXOD§£RHPIDYRUGHWHUFHLUR
ESURPHVVDGHIDWRGHWHUFHLUR
FFRQWUDWRFRPSHVVRDDGHFODUDU
9DPRVDHODV
(67,38/$2(0)$925'(7(5&(,52
3RU PHLR GD HVWLSXOD§£R HP IDYRU GH WHUFHLUR DWR GH QDWXUH]D HVVHQFLDOPHQWH FRQWUDWXDO XPD SDUWH
FRQYHQFLRQD FRP R GHYHGRU TXH HVWH GHYHU¡ UHDOL]DU GHWHUPLQDGD SUHVWD§£R HP EHQHIFLR GH RXWUHP
DOKHLR UHOD§£RMXUGLFDEDVH
1R &³GLJR &LYLO EUDVLOHLUR D PDW©ULD © WUDWDGD GH IRUPD VXFLQWD FRQVRDQWH VH SRGH REVHUYDU GRV
VHJXLQWHVGLVSRVLWLYRV
ߡ'D(VWLSXOD§£RHP)DYRUGH7HUFHLUR
$UW2TXHHVWLSXODHPIDYRUGHWHUFHLURSRGHH[LJLURFXPSULPHQWRGDREULJD§£R
3DU¡JUDIR ºQLFR $R WHUFHLUR HP IDYRU GH TXHP VH HVWLSXORX D REULJD§£R WDPE©P © SHUPLWLGR H[LJLOD ILFDQGR WRGDYLD VXMHLWR V
FRQGL§µHVHQRUPDVGRFRQWUDWRVHDHOHDQXLUHRHVWLSXODQWHQ£RRLQRYDUQRVWHUPRVGRDUW
$UW6HDRWHUFHLURHPIDYRUGHTXHPVHIH]RFRQWUDWRVHGHL[DURGLUHLWRGHUHFODPDUOKHDH[HFX§£RQ£RSRGHU¡RHVWLSXODQWH
H[RQHUDURGHYHGRU
$UW2HVWLSXODQWHSRGHUHVHUYDUVHRGLUHLWRGHVXEVWLWXLURWHUFHLURGHVLJQDGRQRFRQWUDWRLQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWHGDVXDDQXªQFLDHGD
GRRXWURFRQWUDWDQWH
3DU¡JUDIRºQLFR$VXEVWLWXL§£RSRGHVHUIHLWDSRUDWRHQWUHYLYRVRXSRUGLVSRVL§£RGHºOWLPDYRQWDGHߢ
1RGL]HUGRFXOWR&$,205,2DHVWLSXOD§£RHPIDYRUGHWHUFHLURߡRULJLQDVHGDGHFODUD§£RDFRUGH
GRHVWLSXODQWHHGRSURPLWHQWHFRPDILQDOLGDGHGHLQVWLWXLUXPLXULVYLQFXOXPPDVFRPDSHFXOLDULGDGH
GHHVWDEHOHFHUREULJD§£RGHRGHYHGRUSUHVWDUHPEHQHIFLRGHXPDWHUFHLUDSHVVRDDTXDOQ£RREVWDQWH
VHUHVWUDQKDDRFRQWUDWRVHWRUQDFUHGRUDGRSURPLWHQWHߢ
1HVVDPRGDOLGDGHFRQWUDWXDOHVSHFLDODVSDUWHVV£RFKDPDGDVGHHVWLSXODQWHߚDTXHOHTXHHVWDEHOHFH
D REULJD§£R ߚ H SURPLWHQWH RX GHYHGRU ߚ DTXHOH TXH VH FRPSURPHWH D UHDOL]¡OD -¡ R WHUFHLUR RX
EHQHILFL¡ULR©RGHVWLQDW¡ULRILQDOGDREULJD§£RSDFWXDGD
2 H[HPSOR PDLV FRPXP GHVWD ILJXUD MXUGLFD © R VHJXUR GH YLGD 1HVWH FDVR FRQVXPDGR R ULVFR
SUHYLVWR QD DS³OLFH D VHJXUDGRUD FRQIRUPH HVWLSXODGR FRP R VHJXUDGR GHYHU¡ SDJDU DR WHUFHLUR
EHQHILFL¡ULRRYDORUGHYLGRDWWXORGHLQGHQL]D§£R
OYDUR9LOOD§D$]HYHGROHPEUDQRVRXWURH[HPSOR
ߡ7DPE©P H[LVWH D HVWLSXOD§£R RUD FRJLWDGD TXDQGR XP SDL HVWLSXODQWH SRU H[HPSOR GHWHUPLQD D XPD HPSUHVD SURPLWHQWH RX
GHYHGRUD GH TXH © DFLRQLVWDTXH SURPHWD SDJDU DVHXILOKREHQHILFL¡ULR RX WHUFHLUR RV GLYLGHQGRVFRUUHVSRQGHQWHV D VXDV D§µHV QD
©SRFD HP TXH IRUHP GHYLGRV %DVWD TXH HVVD HPSUHVD FRQFRUGH SRU VHXV OHJWLPRV GLULJHQWHV FRP WDO HVWLSXOD§£R SDUD TXH HVWHMD
DSHUIHL§RDGRRFRQWUDWRHPIDYRUGHWHUFHLURSRUTXHGHVVDDYHQ§DQ£RWRPDSDUWHߢ
3HUFHEHVH FRP LVVR TXH R WHUFHLUR HVWUDQKR DR QHJ³FLR VHU¡ SRU HOH DIHWDGR VLWXD§£R HVWD TXH
H[FHSFLRQDDUHJUDJHUDOGDUHODWLYLGDGHGRVHIHLWRVGRFRQWUDWR
$VVLPDQXLQGRREHQHILFL¡ULRFRPDVߡFRQGL§µHVHQRUPDVGRFRQWUDWRߢRTXHGHYHVHUIHLWRGHIRUPD
H[SUHVVD RX VHMD DVVXPLQGR DV REULJD§µHV GHOH GHFRUUHQWHV LQFRUSRUD DR VHX SDWULP´QLR MXUGLFR R
GLUHLWRGHH[LJLUDSUHVWD§£RRTXHVHLQIHUHGDLQWHUSUHWD§£RFRQMXQWDGRPHQFLRQDGRGLVSRVLWLYRFRPR
DUW
'HVVDIRUPDDO³JLFDGHߡTXHPSRGHRPDLVSRGHRPHQRVߢGHYHVHUߡWHPSHUDGDߢFRPDREVHUY¢QFLD
GR GLUHLWR DGTXLULGR SRLV VH © O³JLFR TXH TXHP HVWLSXOD XPD REULJD§£R HP IDYRU GH WHUFHLUR SRVVD
MXVWDPHQWH SRU VHU R FRQWUDWDQWH PRGLILFDU R FRQWUDWR WDQWR QR VHX FRQWHºGR TXDQWR DR GHVWLQDW¡ULR
WDPE©P © LPSUHVFLQGYHO FRPSUHHQGHU TXH D H[RQHUD§£R GR GHYHGRU PHGLDQWH XPD UHPLVV£R SRU
H[HPSORQ£RSRGHU¡RIHQGHUGLUHLWRGREHQHILFL¡ULR
1HVVHVHQWLGRDIDFXOGDGHGHVXEVWLWXL§£RGHVWHGHYHVHUHPQRVVRVHQWLUUHJLVWUDGDH[SOLFLWDPHQWHQR
FRQWUDWRFRPRHVWDEHOHFHRDUWGR&&
1HVVHSDUWLFXODUDYXOWDDFUWLFDGDGRXWULQD SUHYLV£ROHJDOQRTXHGL]UHVSHLWRDDXVªQFLDGHXPD
GLVWLQ§£R TXDQWR RQHURVLGDGH GD DYHQ§D HP UHOD§£R DR WHUFHLUR SRLV QDGD LPSHGH TXH HVVH DVVXPD
REULJD§µHVSDUDWHUGLUHLWRDREHQHIFLRHVWLSXODGR
RTXHPHQFLRQD/9$529,//$$OHPEUDQGRRVDXGRVR6,/9,252'5,*8(6
ߡ$S³V PRVWUDU D IDOWD GH KDUPRQLD QR &³GLJR DQWHULRU YDOHQGR D FUWLFD WDPE©P SDUD R QRYR HQWUH HVVHV DUWLJRV TXH WUDWDP GD
HVWLSXOD§£RHVWXGDGDGHPRQVWUD6LOYLR5RGULJXHVTXHIDOWRXDROHJLVODGRUEUDVLOHLURGLIHUHQFLDUHQWUHHVWLSXOD§£RDWWXORJUDWXLWRHDWWXOR
RQHURVR HOXFLGDQGR TXH QR WRFDQWH DR SDU¡JUDIR ºQLFR GR DUW SDU¡JUDIR ºQLFR GR DUW GR QRYR &³GLJR FRORFDPVH DR
WHUFHLUR DR ODGR GDV YDQWDJHQV TXH OKH V£R FRQFHGLGDV REULJD§µHV &DVR R EHQHILFL¡ULR DVVXPD HVWDV HP UD]£R GRV EHQHIFLRV
RIHUHFLGRVFRQFUHWL]DVHRQHJ³FLRVHPTXHH[LVWDTXDOTXHUSRVVLELOLGDGHGHUHYRJD§£RRXPRGLILFD§£RSHORHVWLSXODQWHVHPTXHFRP
LVVR FRQFRUGH R WHUFHLUR )D] YHU DLQGD HVVH SURIHVVRU TXH DQWH R DUW DUW GR QRYR &³GLJR VH D HVWLSXOD§£R IRU D WWXOR
JUDWXLWRRHVWLSXODQWHߝV³Q£RDSRGHUHYRJDUVHH[SUHVVDPHQWHDEULXP£RGHVVHGLUHLWRDRFRQIHULUDRWHUFHLURDSUHUURJDWLYDGHH[LJLUR
FXPSULPHQWRGDSURPHVVDߞVHIRUDWWXORRQHURVRߝQ£RVHFRPSUHHQGHDH[RQHUD§£RGRREULJDGRRXVXEVWLWXL§£RGRWHUFHLURߞRXDLQGD
RXWUDPRGLILFD§£RFRQWUDWXDOHQWHQGRߝSRLVLVVRHQYROYHULDXPSUHMX]RSDUDHVWHºOWLPRVHPTXDOTXHUFDXVDTXHRMXVWLILFDVVHߞ
3520(66$'()$72'(7(5&(,52
$O©P GD SUHYLV£R OHJDO GD HVWLSXOD§£R HP IDYRU GH WHUFHLUR DGPLWH R &³GLJR &LYLO EUDVLOHLUR D
SRVVLELOLGDGH GH HVWDEHOHFLPHQWR GH XPD GHFODUD§£R GH YRQWDGH QD DILUPD§£R GD UHDOL]D§£R GH XP DWR
SRUWHUFHLUR
$H[SUHVV£RߡIDWRGHWHUFHLURߢFRQVDJUDGDQRWH[WRFRGLILFDGRQRVSDUHFHXPWDQWRLPSU³SULDWHQGR
HPYLVWDTXHVHWUDWDGDSU¡WLFDIXWXUDGHXPDFRQGXWDKXPDQDHQ£RGHXPIDWRGHFRLVDRXDQLPDO
7UDWDVHSRUWDQWRGHXPQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRHPTXHDSUHVWD§£RDFHUWDGDQ£R©H[LJLGDGRHVWLSXODQWH
PDVVLPGHXPWHUFHLURHVWUDQKR UHOD§£RMXUGLFDREULJDFLRQDORTXHWDPE©PIOH[LELOL]DRSULQFSLRGD
UHODWLYLGDGHVXEMHWLYDGRVHIHLWRVGRFRQWUDWR
1DWXUH]DMXUGLFD
8PWHPDSRXFRWUDWDGRQDGRXWULQDHVSHFLDOL]DGD©DQDWXUH]DMXUGLFDGDSURPHVVDGHIDWRGHWHUFHLUR
(PQRVVRHQWHQGHUSDUHFHQRVEDVWDQWHFODURTXHVHWUDWDGHXPQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRVXEPHWLGRDXPIDWRU
HILFDFLDO RX VHMD FRP XP HOHPHQWR DFLGHQWDO TXH OLPLWD Q£R R GHELWXPD UHOD§£R REULJDFLRQDO HP VL
PHVPRPDVVLPDREOLJDWLRDUHVSRQVDELOLGDGHFLYLOSHORGHVFXPSULPHQWRGRFRQWUDWR
([SOLTXHPRVPHOKRU
6H&DLRSURPHWHD7FLRTXHR3URIHVVRU*HUDOGRLU¡PLQLVWUDUDXODVHPXPFXUVRSUHSDUDW³ULRSDUD
FRQFXUVRVFDVRRLOXVWUHSURSHGHXWDQ£RUHDOL]HWDOWDUHID©³EYLRTXHQ£RWHQGRSDUWLFLSDGRGDDYHQ§D
Q£RSRGHU¡VHUFRPSHOLGRDID]ªOR
2 QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR SRU©P H[LVWLX © Y¡OLGR H HILFD] SDUD YLQFXODU RV VXMHLWRV FRQWUDWDQWHV H Q£R
REYLDPHQWHRWHUFHLURPRWLYRSRUTXHHVWDEHOHFHRFDSXWGRDUWGR&&TXHDTXHOHߡTXHWLYHU
SURPHWLGRIDWRGHWHUFHLURUHVSRQGHU¡SRUSHUGDVHGDQRVTXDQGRHVWHQ£RRH[HFXWDUߢ
'LIHUHQWH VLWXD§£R KDYHU¡ WRGDYLD TXDQGR R WHUFHLUR QRPLQDGR RULJLQDOPHQWH SHOR HVWLSXODQWH VH
FRPSURPHWHU GLUHWDPHQWH SUHVWD§£R SRLV D D REULJD§£R VHU¡ SU³SULD GHOH FRQIRUPH VH YHULILFD GR
DUW
ߡ$UW1HQKXPDREULJD§£RKDYHU¡SDUDTXHPVHFRPSURPHWHUSRURXWUHPVHHVWHGHSRLVGHVHWHUREULJDGRIDOWDU SUHVWD§£Rߢ
1DGDLPSHGHREYLDPHQWHSRUIRU§DGDDXWRQRPLDGDYRQWDGHTXHVHHVWDEHOH§DXPDUHVSRQVDELOLGDGH
VROLG¡ULDGRHVWLSXODQWHRULJLQDOPDVLVVRGHSHQGHU¡SRUFHUWRGHPDQLIHVWD§£RH[SUHVVDQHVVHVHQWLGR
SRUDSOLFD§£RGDUHJUDGRDUWGR&&
([FOXV£RGHUHVSRQVDELOLGDGH
$LQGDVREUHDSURPHVVDGHIDWRGHWHUFHLURR&³GLJR&LYLOEUDVLOHLURGHWURX[HXPDLQRYD§£R
DRSUHYHUXPDKLS³WHVHGHH[FOXV£RGHUHVSRQVDELOLGDGHFLYLOGRHVWLSXODQWHSDUDRGHVFXPSULPHQWRGD
REULJD§£RSHORWHUFHLUR
RTXHSUHFHLWXDRSDU¡JUDIRºQLFRGRDUWHVWDEHOHFHQGRTXHDߡUHVSRQVDELOLGDGHQ£RH[LVWLU¡VH
RWHUFHLURIRUF´QMXJHGRSURPLWHQWHGHSHQGHQGRGDVXDDQXªQFLDRDWRDVHUSUDWLFDGRHGHVGHTXHSHOR
UHJLPHGRFDVDPHQWRDLQGHQL]D§£RGHDOJXPPRGRYHQKDDUHFDLUVREUHRVVHXVEHQVߢ
&2175$72&203(662$$'(&/$5$5
7HPRVDLQGDRGHQRPLQDGRFRQWUDWRFRPSHVVRDDGHFODUDU
7UDWDVHGHILJXUDFRQWUDWXDOFRQVDJUDGDSHOR&³GLJR&LYLOYLJHQWHTXHDUHJXORXDSDUWLUGRVHXDUW
VHPHTXLYDOHQWHQDOHJLVOD§£RFRGLILFDGDDQWHULRU
ߡ'R&RQWUDWRFRP3HVVRDD'HFODUDU
$UW1RPRPHQWRGDFRQFOXV£RGRFRQWUDWRSRGHXPDGDVSDUWHVUHVHUYDUVHDIDFXOGDGHGHLQGLFDUDSHVVRDTXHGHYHDGTXLULURV
GLUHLWRVHDVVXPLUDVREULJD§µHVGHOHGHFRUUHQWHVߢ
7UDGX] HP YHUGDGH WDPE©P XPD SURPHVVD GH SUHVWD§£R GH IDWR GH WHUFHLUR TXH WLWXODUL]DU¡ RV
GLUHLWRVHREULJD§µHVGHFRUUHQWHVGRQHJ³FLRFDVRDFHLWHDLQGLFD§£RUHDOL]DGDRTXHVHGDU¡H[WXQF
FHOHEUD§£RGRQHJ³FLRDUW
$UHVSHLWRGRWHPD25/$1'2*20(6SUHOHFLRQD
ߡ7UDWDVH GH FRQWUDWR QR TXDO VH LQWURGX] D FO¡XVXOD HVSHFLDO SUR DPLFR HOLJHQGR RX SUR DPLFR HOHFWR SHOD TXDO XPD GDV SDUWHV VH
UHVHUYDDIDFXOGDGHGHQRPHDUTXHPDVVXPDDSRVL§£RGHFRQWUDWDQWH$SHVVRDGHVLJQDGDWRPDQDUHOD§£RFRQWUDWXDOROXJDUGDSDUWH
TXH D QRPHRX WDO FRPR VH HOD SU³SULD KRXYHVVH FHOHEUDGR R FRQWUDWR 2 GHVLJQDQWH VDL GD UHOD§£R VHP GHL[DU YHVWJLRV (P VXPD R
FRQWUDHQWHLQSURSULRQRPHLDWHUFHLURWLWXODUGRFRQWUDWRߢ
1RGL]HUGH-21(6),*8(,5'2$/9(6SRUPHLRGHVWHQHJ³FLR
ߡUHVHUYDVHDXPGRVFRQWUDWDQWHVQRQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRFHOHEUDGRSHODFO¡XVXODSURDPLFRHOLJHQGRDLQGLFD§£RGHRXWUDSHVVRDTXHR
VXEVWLWXD QD UHOD§£R FRQWUDWXDO DGTXLULQGR RV GLUHLWRV H DVVXPLQGR DV REULJD§µHV GHOH GHFRUUHQWHV &DVR Q£R H[HUFLWH D FO¡XVXOD RX R
LQGLFDGR UHFXVH D QRPHD§£R RX VHMD LQVROYHQWH GLVVR GHVFRQKHFHQGR D RXWUD SDUWH SHUPDQHFH R FRQWUDWR VRPHQWH HILFD] HQWUH RV
FRQWUDWDQWHVRULJLQ¡ULRVDUWߢ
2SUD]RSDUDDFRPXQLFD§£RGDLQGLFD§£RGRWHUFHLUR©GHFLQFRGLDVVHRXWURODSVRQ£RVHHVWLSXORX
DUW
7UDWDVH D QRVVR YHU GH SUD]R GHFDGHQFLDO FRQWUDWXDOPHQWH HVWLSXODGR GHQWUR GR TXDO R FRQWUDHQWH
H[HUFHU¡FDVRTXHLUDRGLUHLWRSRWHVWDWLYRGHLQGLFD§£R
GHQRWDUTXHRSDU¡JUDIRºQLFRGRUHIHULGRDUWH[LJHTXHDDFHLWD§£RGRWHUFHLURGHYDREVHUYDUD
PHVPDIRUPDTXHDVSDUWHVXVDUDPSDUDRFRQWUDWR$VVLPVHDDFHLWD§£RGDSURSRVWDGHFRQWUDWDUIRL
H[SUHVVD SRU HVFULWR D DTXLHVFªQFLD GR WHUFHLUR LQGLFDGR Q£R SRGHU¡ VHU W¡FLWD R TXH GHYH VHU
REVHUYDGR QR FDVR FRQFUHWR SRLV R VLOªQFLR GR WHUFHLUR Q£R VHU¡ QHFHVVDULDPHQWH LQWHUSUHWDGR FRPR
DFHLWD§£R
$SU³SULDOHLHQWUHWDQWRUHVVDOYDKLS³WHVHVHPTXHRFRQWUDWRVHU¡HILFD]DSHQDVHQWUHRVFRQWUDWDQWHV
RULJLQ¡ULRVDUWVH
DVHQ£RKRXYHULQGLFD§£RGHSHVVRDRXVHRQRPHDGRVHUHFXVDUDDFHLW¡OD
EVHDSHVVRDQRPHDGDHUDLQVROYHQWHHDRXWUDSHVVRDRGHVFRQKHFLDQRPRPHQWRGDDFHLWD§£R
FVHDSHVVRDDQRPHDUHUDLQFDSD]RXLQVROYHQWHQRPRPHQWRGDQRPHD§£R
&ODUR HVW¡ SRUWDQWR TXH R FRQWUDWR FRP SHVVRD D GHFODUDU © XP QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR TXH HQYROYH FHUWD
PDUJHPGHULVFRWDQWRSDUDRVFRQWUDWDQWHVRULJLQ¡ULRVFRPRSDUDRWHUFHLURTXHDFHLWDDLQGLFD§£R
6/9,29(126$DOL¡VOHPEUDVHUFRPXPDRFRUUªQFLDGHVWDILJXUDߡQRVFRPSURPLVVRVGHFRPSUDH
YHQGD GH LP³YHLV QRV TXDLV R SURPLVV¡ULR FRPSUDGRU DWULEXLVH D IDFXOGDGH GH LQGLFDU WHUFHLUR SDUD
ILJXUDUQDHVFULWXUDGHILQLWLYDߢ
1£RVHGHYHFRQIXQGLURFRQWUDWRFRPSHVVRDDGHFODUDUFRPDILJXUDMXUGLFDGDFHVV£R GHSRVL§£R
FRQWUDWXDO
6REUH HVVD PRGDOLGDGH GH FHVV£R WDPE©P GHQRPLQDGD FHVV£R GR FRQWUDWR M¡ YLPRV TXH GH IRUPD
GLIHUHQWHGRTXHRFRUUHQDFHVV£RGHFU©GLWRRXGHG©ELWRQHVWHFDVRRFHGHQWHWUDQVIHUHDVXDSU³SULD
SRVL§£R FRQWUDߓWXDO FRPSUHHQGHQGR FU©GLWRV H G©ELWRV D XP WHUFHLUR FHVVLRQ¡ULR TXH SDVVDU¡ D
VXEVWLWXORQDUHOD§£RMXUGLFDRULJLQ¡ULD
2V LQVWLWXWRV Q£R GHYHP VHU FRQIXQGLGRV KDMD YLVWD TXH QR FRQWUDWR FRP SHVVRD D GHFODUDU D
IDFXOGDGH GH LQGLFD§£R M¡ YHP SUHYLVWD RULJLQDULDPHQWH SRGHQGR LQFOXVLYH QXQFD VHU H[HUFLGD QD
FHVV£RGDSRVL§£RGHFRQWUDWRSRUVXDYH]Q£RRFRUUHQHFHVVDULDPHQWHHVWLSXOD§£RSU©YLDGDIDFXOGDGH
GHVXEVWLWXL§£R
$VVLPRWHUFHLURHPERUDQ£RYLQFXODGRRULJLQDULDPHQWH UHOD§£RFRQWUDWXDOSRGHU¡H[SHULPHQWDURV
VHXVHIHLWRVFDVRDFHLWHDQRPHD§£RLQGLFDGD
2EVHUYDVH SRUWDQWR QHVVH FDVR TXH R HVSHFWUR HILFDFLDO GR QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR ILUPDGR HQWUH RV
FRQWUDHQWHVLQLFLDLVLQFLGLU¡HPVXD³UELWDMXUGLFDGHDWXD§£RPLWLJDQGRVHGHVVDIRUPDRSULQFSLRGD
UHODWLYLGDGHGRVHIHLWRVGRFRQWUDWR
;9,
&2175$7235(/,0,1$5
&21&(,72(,167,787266,0,/$5(6
&RQFHLWXDU XP LQVWLWXWR MXUGLFR QXQFD © XPD WDUHID GHILQLWLYD KDYHQGR VHPSUH D SRVVLELOLGDGH GH
GLYHUJªQFLDVSDUDDIL[D§£RGRVOLPLWHVGHVHQWLGRHVLJQLILFDGRGHFDGDSDODYUD
6HPFDLUQDWHQWD§£RGDVFRQFHLWXD§µHVGLJUHVVLYDVFRPSUHHQGHPRVRFRQWUDWRSUHOLPLQDUFRPRXPD
DYHQ§D DWUDY©V GD TXDO DV SDUWHV FULDP HP IDYRU GH XPD RX PDLV GHODV D IDFXOGDGH GH H[LJLU R
FXPSULPHQWR GH XP FRQWUDWR DSHQDV SURMHWDGR 7UDWDVH SRUWDQWR GH XP QHJ³FLR MXUߓGLFR TXH WHP SRU
REMHWRDREULJD§£RGHID]HUXPFRQWUDWRGHILQLWLYRߓ
2H[HPSORPDLVFRPXPGHVVHWLSRGHSURPHVVD©DGHFRPSUDHYHQGDSURPHVVDGHFRPSUDHYHQGD
DTXDOTXDQGRGHYLGDPHQWHUHJLVWUDGDQR&DUW³ULRGH,P³YHLV SURGX]HILF¡FLD UHDO IDFXOWDQGRDR
SURPLWHQWH FRPSUDGRU VH IRU QHFHVV¡ULR UHFRUUHU D§£R GH DGMXGLFD§£R FRPSXOV³ULD SDUD D FRQFUHߓ
WL]D§£RGRVHXGLUHLWR
7DOILJXUDM¡HUDFRQKHFLGDLQFOXVLYHQR'LUHLWR5RPDQRSRLVRSDFWXPGHFRQWUDKHQGRFRPSUHHQGLD
RSDFWXPGHPXWXDQGRHRSDFWXPGHFRPPRGDQGRHQWUHRXWURV
(VVD SRVVLELOLGDGH GH H[LJªQFLD GD HILF¡FLD LPHGLDWD GH XP FRQWUDWR LQILHUL© WDPE©P GHQRPLQDGD
GRXWULQDULDPHQWHSU©FRQWUDWRSURPHVVDGHFRQWUDWRRXFRPSURPLVVRQ£RGHYHQGRVHUFRQIXQGLGRFRP
RQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRDLQGDQ£RFHOHEUDGRFXMDHILF¡FLDVHSUHWHQGHH[LJLU
&RPRREVHUYD2UODQGR*RPHV
ߡ7UDWDVH GH ILJXUDV GLVWLQWDV GR UHVSHFWLYR FRQWUDWR GHILQLWLYR KDYHQGR HQWUHWDQWR TXHP FRQWHVWH D LQGHSHQGªQFLD GRV GRLV 6RE D
LQIOXªQFLD GR 'LUHLWR IUDQFªV VHJXQGR D TXDO D SURPHVVD GH YHQGD ߚ TXH © FRQWUDWR SUHOLPLQDU QR HQWHQGLPHQWR JHUDO ߚ YDOH YHQGD
TXDQGRKDMDFRQVHQWLPHQWRGDVGXDVSDUWHVVREUHDFRLVDHRSUH§RPXLWRVDXWRUHVQHJDPDDXWRQRPLDGRSU©FRQWUDWR3HQVDPRXWURV
TXHVHFRQVLVWHHPFULDUDREULJD§£RGHFHOHEUDURFRQWUDWRGHILQLWLYR©VXS©UIOXRSRUTXHVHDOJX©PSURPHWHXREULJDUVHHPGLDFHUWR
REULJDGRHVWDU¡QHVVHGLDFRPRVHQHOHKRXYHVVHFRQWUDGRDREULJD§£R([LJLUTXHQRYDPHQWHVHREULJXH©DGPLWLUFRPRGL]LDPFHUWRV
FDQRQLVWDVXPFLUFXLWXVLQXWLOLVߢ
7DPE©P Q£R VH GHYH FRORFDU QD PHVPD W¡EXD DV FKDPDGDV QHJRFLD§µHV SUHOLPLQDUHV H R FRQWUDWR
SUHOLPLQDU
'HIDWRDVQHJRFLD§µHVSUHOLPLQDUHVߚDRFRQWU¡ULRGRLQVWLWXWRDTXLDQDOLVDGRߚQ£RJHUDPGLUHLWRV
FRQWUDWD§£R SUHWHQGLGD SRGHQGRVH IDODU QR P¡[LPR HP XPD UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH FLYLO SU©FRQWUDWXDO
FXMRVGDQRVV£RSDVVYHLVGHLQGHQL]D§£R
1$785(=$-85',&$
2 FRQWUDWR SUHOLPLQDU © XP QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR QD PHGLGD HP TXH FRQVLVWH HP XPD GHFODUD§£R GH
YRQWDGH HPLWLGD HP REHGLªQFLD DRV VHXV SUHVVXSRVWRV GH H[LVWªQFLD YDOLGDGH H HILF¡FLD FRP R
SURS³VLWRGHSURGX]LUHIHLWRVDGPLWLGRVSHORRUGHQDPHQWRMXUGLFRSUHWHQGLGRVSHORDJHQWH
'DQ£R©GHVHHVWUDQKDUTXHGLVSRQKDRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLOEUDVLOHLURLQYHUELV
ߡ$UW2FRQWUDWRSUHOLPLQDUH[FHWRTXDQWR IRUPDGHYHFRQWHUWRGRVRVUHTXLVLWRVHVVHQFLDLVDRFRQWUDWRDVHUFHOHEUDGRߢ
,VVR SRUTXH FRPR QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR TXH © R FRQWUDWR SUHOLPLQDU WDPE©P VH VXEPHWH D WRGRV RV
UHTXLVLWRVHVVHQFLDLVGRFRQWUDWRDVHUSDFWXDGR
$H[FOXV£RGDIRUPDVHG¡SRUXPDRS§£ROHJLVODWLYDGHPRGRDIDFLOLWDUHHVWLPXODUDXWLOL]D§£RGR
LQVWLWXWR FRPR RUGLQDULDPHQWH VH SURFHGH SRU H[HPSOR TXDQGR R FRQWUDWR GHILQLWLYR H[LJH D HVFULWXUD
SºEOLFDHRVUHTXLVLWRVGRFRQWUDWRSUHOLPLQDUV£RVDWLVIHLWRVFRPDODYUDWXUDHPLQVWUXPHQWRSDUWLFXODU
1DGD LPSHGH SRU©P TXH R FRQWUDWR GHILQLWLYR FRQWHQKD PDLV FO¡XVXODV GR TXH DV SDFWXDGDV QR
FRQWUDWRSUHOLPLQDUTXHGHPDQHLUDDOJXPDVHGHVQDWXUDFRPWDOSRVVLELOLGDGH&RPHIHLWRDUHJUDOHJDO
GHYHVHULQWHUSUHWDGDFRPUD]RDELOLGDGHSDUDVHHQWHQGHUTXHDH[LJªQFLD©VRPHQWHTXDQWRDRVUHTXLVLWRV
HVVHQFLDLV HQWHQGDVH RV HOHPHQWRV GH H[LVWªQFLD H YDOLGDGH GR QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR H Q£R TXDQWR DR
LQWHLURFRQWHºGRGRSDFWXDGR
&/$66,),&$2
7RGDFODVVLILFD§£R©YDUL¡YHOGHDFRUGRFRPDYLV£RPHWRGRO³JLFDGHFDGDDXWRU
(P QRVVD FRPSUHHQV£R GHYHPRV FODVVLILFDU RV FRQWUDWRV SUHOLPLQDUHV GH DFRUGR FRP D VXD
H[LJLELOLGDGHUHWUDWDELOLGDGHHRQHURVLGDGH
1DFODVVLILFD§£RSULP¡ULDSHUFHEHPRVTXHRSU©FRQWUDWRSRGHVHUXQLODWHUDORXELODWHUDO
1HVWDSULPHLUDIRUPDDIDFXOGDGHGHH[LJLURFXPSULPHQWRUHVHUYDVHºQLFDHH[FOXVLYDPHQWHDXPD
GDVSDUWHVVHQGRTXHDRXWUDFRQWUDLXPDREULJD§£RFXMRDGLPSOHPHQWRILFDVXERUGLQDGR YRQWDGHGD
TXHSRGHH[LJLOR
'HVWDTXHVHTXHDSHFXOLDULGDGHGHFULDUREULJD§£RDRWDODQWHGHXPDºQLFDSDUWHQ£RUHWLUDDQDWXUH]D
FRQWUDWXDO GHVWD SURPHVVD XPD YH] TXH HOD VRPHQWH VH DSHUIHL§RD FRP R DFRUGR GH YRQWDGHV 6£R
H[HPSORVGHWDLVFRQWUDWRVSUHOLPLQDUHVXQLODWHUDLVDRS§£RGHFRPSUDDYHQGDDFRQWHQWRHDSURPHVVD
GHGRD§£R3DUDKLS³WHVHVFRPRHVVDV©TXHIRLFRQFHELGRRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLOGHDVDEHU
ߡ$UW6HDSURPHVVDGHFRQWUDWRIRUXQLODWHUDORFUHGRUVRESHQDGHILFDUDPHVPDVHPHIHLWRGHYHU¡PDQLIHVWDUVHQRSUD]RQHOD
SUHYLVWRRXLQH[LVWLQGRHVWHQRTXHOKHIRUUD]RDYHOPHQWHDVVLQDGRSHORGHYHGRUߢ
&RPR REVHUYD 6/9,2 9(126$ ߡTXHP SURPHWH GDU ID]HU RX Q£R ID]HU DOJR Q£R SRGH ILFDU
LQGHILQLGDPHQWH YLQFXODGR 6H Q£R KRXYH SUD]R QD SURPHVVD FXMR GHFXUVR SRU VL V³ GHVREULJD R
SURPLWHQWH GHYH HVWH FRQFHGHU XP SUD]R SDUD TXH R LQWHUHVVDGR VH PDQLIHVWH (P Y¡ULDV VLWXD§µHV
SU¡WLFDV D SURPHVVD XQLODWHUDO © XWLOL]DGD FRPR SRU H[HPSOR QD RS§£R TXH VH G¡ D XP FUHGRU SDUD
DOLHQDUXPGHWHUPLQDGREHPߢ
-¡ QR FRQWUDWR SUHOLPLQDU ELODWHUDO FDGD SDUWH SRGH H[LJLU GD RXWUD D H[HFX§£R GR FRQWUDWR TXH
SURMHWDUDPHPWRGDDVXDH[WHQV£RHHIHLWRV
$ SURPHVVD GH YHQGD © R H[HPSOR PDLV KDELWXDO GH WDO HVS©FLH GH DYHQ§D SRLV QHOD WDQWR R
SURPLWHQWH YHQGHGRU TXDQWR R SURPLWHQWH FRPSUDGRU SRGHP H[LJLU D UHDOL]D§£R GR QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR
SURPHWLGRDVDEHUDYHQGDGREHPQRVWHUPRVHPTXHIRLSDFWXDGRDLQGDTXHFRPFRQGL§£RUHVROXWLYD
GDDYHQ§D
3RUFHUWRQ£RKDYHULDVHQWLGRHPHVWDEHOHFHUFO¡XVXODGHDUUHSHQGLPHQWRQRVFRQWUDWRVSUHOLPLQDUHV
XQLODWHUDLVXPDYH]TXHDSHQDVDYRQWDGHGHXPGRVSU©FRQWUDWDQWHV©UHOHYDQWHSDUDDUHDOL]D§£RRX
Q£RGRSU©FRQWUDWR
1DV IRUPDV ELODWHUDLV SRU©P © UHOHYDQWVVLPR VDEHU VH K¡ SRVVLELOLGDGH GH DUUHSHQGLPHQWR RX
LUUHWUDWDELOLGDGH SRLV QHVWH ºOWLPR FDVR QD SURPHVVD GH YHQGD R GLUHLWR SRVLWLYR SRGH FRQVLGHUDU
LQFOXVLYHXPGLUHLWRUHDO
(VSHFLILFDPHQWHVREUHRFRQWUDWRSUHOLPLQDUGHFRPSUDHYHQGDDGRXWULQDID]LDGLVWLQ§£RHQWUHGXDV
PRGDOLGDGHVRFRQWUDWRSUHOLPLQDUSU³SULRTXHUHSUHVHQWDULDPHUDSURPHVVDHRLPSU³SULRFRQWUDWRHP
IRUPD§£R TXH YDOH SRU VL PHVPR (P QRVVD RSLQL£R SRU IRU§D GD DWXDO GLVFLSOLQD SRVLWLYDGD WDO
FODVVLILFD§£RSHUGHXRVHQWLGRSUDJP¡WLFR
3RU ILP UHJLVWUHVH FRPR R ID] 25/$1'2 *20(6 TXH D SURPHVVD SRGH VHU RQHURVD RX
JUDWXLWD SRLV QDGD LPSHGH TXH VH SDFWXH R SDJDPHQWR GH XPD UHWULEXL§£R XP SUªPLR SRU H[HPSOR
FRPRFRQWUDߓSUHVWD§£RVLPSOHVPHQWHSHORH[HUFFLRGRGLUHLWRSRWHVWDWLYRGHUHDOL]D§£RGRFRQWUDWRQDV
SURPHVVDV XQLODWHUDLV RX GR GLUHLWR VXEMHWLYR GH H[LJLU D FRQWUDWD§£R QRV SU©FRQWUDWRV ELODWHUDLV
LQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWHGRVHIHLWRVSHFXQL¡ULRVGRFRQWUDWRGHILQLWLYR
787(/$(63(&),&$
&RPRXPSDFWXPGHFRQWUDKHQGRDREULJD§£RGHID]HUHVWDEHOHFLGDQRFRQWUDWRSUHOLPLQDUGHYHHP
UHJUDVHUREMHWRGDWXWHODSUHYLVWDQRVDUWVDGR&3&RTXHQRVSDUHFHXPLPSHUDWLYRGD
EXVFDSRUXPDPDLRUHIHWLYLGDGHGDVUHOD§µHVMXUGLFDVGH'LUHLWR0DWHULDODLQGDTXHHPGHWULPHQWRGD
YLV£RPDLVWUDGLFLRQDOGR'LUHLWRGDV2EULJD§µHVFRQIRUPHM¡H[SOLFLWDPRVDQWHULRUPHQWH
;9,,
9&,265(',%,75,26
&21&(,72(&$5$&7(567,&$6
2V YFLRV UHGLELW³ULRV SRU GHILQL§£R V£R GHIHLWRV RFXOWRV TXH GLPLQXHP R YDORU RX SUHMXGLFDP D
XWLOL]D§£RGDFRLVDUHFHELGDSRUIRU§DGHXPFRQWUDWRFRPXWDWLYRDUWGR&&
2 SULQFLSDO DVSHFWR D VHU FRQVLGHUDGR © SUHFLVDPHQWH SRUWDQWR R IDWR GH HVWH YFLR VHU RFXOWR
UHF´QGLWRRXVHMDQ£RDSDUHQWH
6HIRUDSDUHQWHQ£RVHWUDWDU¡GHYFLRUHGLELW³ULR
&$,205,2DRGHILQLORDILUPDWUDWDUVHGHߡXPGHIHLWRRFXOWRGHTXH©SRUWDGRUDDFRLVDREMHWR
GHFRQWUDWRFRPXWDWLYRTXHDWRUQDLPSU³SULDDRXVRDTXHVHGHVWLQDRXOKHSUHMXGLFDVHQVLYHOPHQWHR
YDORUߢ
(PDLVDGLDQWHDUUHPDWDߡ1£RVHDSUR[LPDRQWRORJLFDPHQWHRFRQFHLWRGHYFLRUHGLELW³ULRGDLGHLD
GHUHVSRQVDELOLGDGHFLYLO1£RVHGHL[DSHUWXUEDUDVXDQR§£RFRPDLQGDJD§£RGDFRQGXWDGRFRQWUDHQWH
RXDSXUD§£RGDVXDFXOSDTXHLQIOXLU¡FRQWXGRQDJUDGXD§£RGRVUHVSHFWLYRVHIHLWRVVHPDSDUHFHUFRPR
HOHPHQWDUGHVXDFDUDFWHUL]D§£Rߢ
(VVHQFLDOPHQWHRYFLRUHGLELW³ULRDSUR[LPDVHPXLWRPDLVGHXPDFDXVDGHGLVVROX§£RFRQWUDWXDOGR
TXHSURSULDPHQWHGRVLVWHPDGHUHVSRQVDELOLGDGHFLYLOPXLWRHPERUDDSDUWHSUHMXGLFDGDWHQKDRGLUHLWR
GHVHUGHYLGDPHQWHLQGHQL]DGD
([HPSORWSLFRGHDSOLFD§£RGDWHRULDRFRUUHU¡TXDQGR6LPSOFLRDRFRPSUDUXPUHO³JLRGHFREUHGD
PDUFD 6FXEL[ LJQRUD TXH HOH © SRUWDGRU GH XP GHIHLWR RFXOWR ߚ XPD FRQH[£R HTXLYRFDGD GH VXDV
HQJUHQDJHQVYJߚTXHSUHMXGLFDDVXDXWLOL]D§£R
1RWHVHRXWURVVLPTXHHVVHGHIHLWRGHYHU¡DFRPSDQKDUDFRLVDTXDQGRGDVXDWUDGL§£R
6LPSRUTXHVHRYFLR©SRVWHULRU DTXLVL§£RGDFRLVDRXVHMDVHDFDXVDGRGHIHLWRRSHURXVHM¡
TXDQGRDUHVHVWDYDHPSRGHUGRDGTXLUHQWHSRUP¡XWLOL]D§£RRXGHVGLDHVWHQDGDSRGHU¡SOHLWHDU
1HVVHGLDSDV£RSRGHUDPRVDVVLPHOHQFDURVVHJXLQWHVHOHPHQWRVFDUDFWHUL]DGRUHVRXUHTXLVLWRVGR
YFLRUHGLELW³ULR
DDH[LVWªQFLDGHXPFRQWUDWRFRPXWDWLYRWUDQVODWLYRGDSRVVHHGDSURSULHGDGHGDFRLVD
EXPGHIHLWRRFXOWRH[LVWHQWHQRPRPHQWRGDWUDGL§£R
FDGLPLQXL§£RGRYDORUHFRQ´PLFRRXRSUHMX]R DGHTXDGDXWLOL]D§£RGDFRLVD
$GYHUWLPRVPDLVXPD YH] TXHYFLR UHGLELW³ULR H HUUR SRVWR VHMDP FRQFHLWRV PXLWR SU³[LPRV Q£R
GHYHPVHUFRQIXQGLGRV
&216(481&,$6-85',&$6'$9(5,),&$2'(9&,265(',%,75,26
(DILQDOGHFRQWDVYHULILFDGDDLQFLGªQFLDGHYFLRUHGLELW³ULRTXDLVVHULDPDVVXDVFRQVHTXªQFLDV
MXUGLFDV"
$UHVSRVWDQ£R©GLIFLO
$WHRUGRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLODEUHPVHSDUDRDGTXLUHQWHGXDVSRVVLELOLGDGHV
DUHMHLWDUDFRLVDUHGLELQGRRFRQWUDWRYLDD§£RUHGLELW³ULD
EUHFODPDURDEDWLPHQWRQRSUH§RYLDD§£RHVWLPDW³ULDRXTXDQWLPLQRULV
$ SULPHLUD VROX§£R © D PDLV GU¡VWLFD 2 DOLHQDW¡ULR LQVDWLVIHLWR SHOD FRQVWDWD§£R GR YFLR SURSµH
GHQWUR GR SUD]R GHFDGHQFLDO SUHYLVWR HP OHL XPD D§£R UHGLELW³ULD FXMR REMHWR © SUHFLVDPHQWH R
GHVID]LPHQWR GR FRQWUDWR H D GHYROX§£R GR SUH§R SDJR SRGHQGR LQFOXVLYH SOHLWHDU R SDJDPHQWR GDV
SHUGDVHGDQRV
1RVHJXQGRFDVRSUHIHUHRDGTXLUHQWHWDPE©PGHQWURGRSUD]RGHFDGHQFLDOGDOHLSURSRUD§£RSDUD
SOHLWHDURDEDWLPHQWRRXGHVFRQWRQRSUH§RHPIDFHGRGHIHLWRYHULILFDGR7DOD§£RGHQRPLQDVHD§£R
HVWLPDW³ULDRXTXDQWLPLQRULV
7DQWRDD§£RUHGLELW³ULDTXDQWRDD§£RTXDQWLPLQRULVV£RHVS©FLHVGDVGHQRPLQDGDVD§µHV HGLOFLDV
H[LVWLQGR HQWUH DPEDV XPD UHOD§£R GH DOWHUQDWLYLGDGH RX VHMD XP FRQFXUVR GH D§µHV R DGTXLUHQWH
VRPHQWHSRGHU¡SURPRYHUXPDRXRXWUDYLVWRTXHFRPSRUWDPSHGLGRVH[FOXGHQWHVHQWUHVLHOHFWDXQD
YLDQRQGDWXUUHJUHVVXVDGDOWHUDP
'LVFRUUHQGRVREUHRWHPDQRSODQRSURFHVVXDO-0'($558'$$/9,0DS³VFULWLFDUDH[SUHVV£R
ߡFRQFXUVRGHD§µHVߢSRQWLILFD
ߡ'HY¡ULDVIRUPDVSRGHVHDSUHVHQWDURFRQFXUVRGHD§µHV&RPRSRUH[HPSORYHMDPRVDVD§µHVTXHFDEHPDRFRPSUDGRUGHFRLVD
UHFHELGDFRPYFLRRXGHIHLWRRFXOWRTXHDWRUQHPLPSU³SULDDRXVRGHVWLQDGR(VWDVH[LVWHPSDUDDVDWLVID§£RGRGLUHLWRGRFRPSUDGRU
(QWUHWDQWRSHORDUWGR&&SRGHRDGTXLUHQWHRXPRYHUD§£RUHGLELW³ULDHQMHLWDQGRDFRLVDHUHVFLQGLQGRRFRQWUDWRRXHQW£R
UHFODPDUDEDWLPHQWRQRSUH§Rߢ
2EVHUYHVHRXWURVVLPTXHQRVWHUPRVGRDUWVHRDOLHQDQWHFRQKHFLDRYFLRRXGHIHLWRRFXOWR
GDFRLVDGHYHU¡UHVWLWXLURTXHUHFHEHXFRPSHUGDVHGDQRVPDVVHQ£RRFRQKHFLDDSHQDVUHVWLWXLU¡R
YDORUUHFHELGRPDLVDVGHVSHVDVGRFRQWUDWR
7UDWDVH SRLV GH XP GLVSRVLWLYR TXH JXDUGD QWLPD FRQH[£R FRP D QR§£R M¡ WUDEDOKDGD GH ERDI©
REMHWLYD $ TXHEUD GR GHYHU GH OHDOGDGH FRQVLVWHQWH QD DOLHQD§£R GH FRLVD TXH VDEH VHU GHIHLWXRVD
VXMHLWDSRLVRDOLHQDQWHDSDJDUDWWXORLQGHQL]DW³ULRSHUGDVHGDQRV SDUWHDGYHUVD&DVRHQWUHWDQWR
GHVFRQKH§DRGHIHLWRDSHQDVUHVWLWXLU¡RVWDWXVTXRDQWHGHYROYHQGRRSUH§RSDJRPDLVDVGHVSHVDVGR
FRQWUDWR
5HJLVWUHVH LQFOXVLYH TXH R &³GLJR &LYLO YLJHQWH Q£R UHQRYRX D QRUPD SURLELWLYD GH DGPLVV£R GDV
D§µHVHGLOFLDVTXDQGRDFRLVDIRVVHDGTXLULGDHPKDVWDSºEOLFD&&ߡ$UW6HDFRLVDIRL
YHQGLGD HP KDVWD SºEOLFD Q£R FDEH D D§£R UHGLELW³ULD QHP D GH SHGLU DEDWLPHQWR QR SUH§Rߢ Q£R
WUD]HQGRTXDOTXHUQRUPDHTXLYDOHQWHQRTXHFRQVWLWXLXXPDYDQ§RDW©SHODGLILFXOGDGHGHFDUDFWHUL]D§£R
TXHVHYHULILFDQDSU¡WLFDMXGLFLDO
3RVWR LVVR SDVVHPRV D HQIUHQWDU XP LPSRUWDQWH DVSHFWR UHIHUHQWH V D§µHV HGLOFLDV TXDO © R SUD]R
SDUDDVXDSURSRVLWXUD"
35$=23$5$$352326,785$'$6$(6(',/&,$6
3ULPHLUDPHQWHIULVHVHTXHSRUVHWUDWDUGHD§µHVTXHWªPSRUFRQWHºGRQLWLGDPHQWHRH[HUFFLRGH
GLUHLWRVSRWHVWDWLYRVRVSUD]RVHPTXHVW£RV£RGHFDGHQFLDLVHQ£RSUHVFULFLRQDLV
ߡ$UW2DGTXLUHQWHGHFDLGRGLUHLWRGHREWHUDUHGLEL§£RRXDEDWLPHQWRQRSUH§RQRSUD]RGHWULQWDGLDVVHDFRLVDIRUP³YHOHGHXP
DQRVHIRULP³YHOFRQWDGRGDHQWUHJDHIHWLYDVHM¡HVWDYDQDSRVVHRSUD]RFRQWDVHGDDOLHQD§£RUHGX]LGR PHWDGH
hz4XDQGRRYFLRSRUVXDQDWXUH]DV³SXGHUVHUFRQKHFLGRPDLVWDUGHRSUD]RFRQWDUVH¡GRPRPHQWRHPTXHGHOHWLYHUFLªQFLDDW©
RSUD]RP¡[LPRGHFHQWRHRLWHQWDGLDVHPVHWUDWDQGRGHEHQVP³YHLVHGHXPDQRSDUDRVLP³YHLV
hz7UDWDQGRVHGHYHQGDGHDQLPDLVRVSUD]RVGHJDUDQWLDSRUYFLRVRFXOWRVVHU£RRVHVWDEHOHFLGRVHPOHLHVSHߓFLDORXQDIDOWDGHVWD
SHORVXVRVORFDLVDSOLFDQGRVHRGLVSRVWRQRSDU¡JUDIRDQWHFHGHQWHVHQ£RKRXYHUUHJUDVGLVFLSOLQDQGRDPDW©ULDߢ
&³GLJR&LYLOGH
ߡ$UW3UHVFUHYH
h z (P TXLQ]H GLDV FRQWDGRV GD WUDGL§£R GD FRLVD D D§£R SDUD KDYHU DEDWLPHQWR GR SUH§R GD FRLVD P³YHO UHFHELGD FRP YFLR
UHGLELW³ULRRXSDUDUHVFLQGLURFRQWUDWRHUHDYHURSUH§RSDJRPDLVSHUGDVHGDQRV
,9ߚDD§£RSDUDKDYHURDEDWLPHQWRGRSUH§RGDFRLVDLP³YHOUHFHELGDFRPYFLRUHGLELW³ULRRXSDUDUHVFLQGLURFRQWUDWRFRPXWDWLYRH
KDYHURSUH§RSDJRPDLVSHUGDVHGDQRVFRQWDGRRSUD]RGDWUDGL§£RGDFRLVDߢ
&RQFOXLVHSRLVTXHRSUD]RGHFDGHQFLDOSDUDRDMXL]DPHQWRGDD§£RUHGLELW³ULDRXGDD§£RTXDQWL
PLQRULVDXPHQWRXGHSDUDGLDVߚQRFDVRGHEHQVP³YHLVߚHGHPHVHVSDUDDQRߚQRFDVR
GHEHQVLP³YHLV(QWUHWDQWRFDVRRDGTXLUHQWHM¡HVWLYHVVHQDSRVVHGDFRLVDRSUD]R©FRQWDGRDSDUWLU
GDDOLHQD§£RSHODPHWDGH
(VWDºOWLPDFLUFXQVW¢QFLDSRUVXDYH]Q£RSUHYLVWDQR&³GLJRDQWHULRUGHYHVHUUHDO§DGDSRUPHLRGH
XPH[HPSORSDUDTXHQ£RSDLUHPGºYLGDVQDPHQWHGHQRVVRDWHQWROHLWRU
,PDJLQHVHTXH-XFDHVWLYHVVHQDSRVVHGHXPDID]HQGDSHUWHQFHQWHD&KLFRK¡DQRVQDTXDOLGDGH
GH DUUHQGDW¡ULR 5HVROYH HQW£R FRPSU¡OD 2UD HP WDO FDVR VH YLHU D SHUFHEHU D H[LVWªQFLD GH YFLR
UHGLELW³ULRGHIHLWRRFXOWRWHU¡RSUD]RGHXPDQRUHGX]LGR PHWDGHPHVHVSRUWDQWRDFRQWDUGD
GDWDGRUHJLVWURGRWWXORGHWUDQVIHUªQFLDQRFDUW³ULRGHLP³YHLVGDWDGDDOLHQD§£RIRUPDOSDUDSURSRU
D D§£R HGLOFLD 2 PHVPR UDFLRFQLR VH DSOLFD VH VH WUDWDU GH EHQV P³YHLV RSHUDQGRVH WRGDYLD D
UHGX§£RGHSUD]RGHSDUDGLDV
0DVDILQDOGHFRQWDVTXDOVHULDRUHDOPRWLYRSDUDTXHVHSURFHGHVVHDHVVDFRQWDJHPGRSUD]RSHOD
PHWDGH"
$MXVWLILFDWLYD©TXHXPDYH]TXHRDGTXLUHQWHM¡HVWDYDQDSRVVHGREHPROHJLVODGRUHQWHQGHXTXH
HOHM¡GLVSRULDGHWHPSRPDLRUSDUDDGHWHF§£RGRGHIHLWRUD]£RSHODTXDORSUD]RVHULDFRQWDGRSHOD
PHWDGH
(VVD H[SOLFD§£R WRGDYLD QHP VHPSUH FRQYHQFH RX VH DILJXUD MXVWD SRLV VH R DGTXLUHQWH HVWLYHU QD
SRVVHGREHPDSHQDVXPGLDDQWHVGRDWRGHDOLHQD§£RVXSRUWDU¡DSHUGDGHPHWDGHGRSUD]R
LVVRPHVPR
6HJXQGRRGLVSRVLWLYRVREFRPHQWREDVWDDVLPSOHVߡSRVVHߢGDFRLVDDQWHULRU WUDGL§£RSDUDTXHVH
SURFHGD UHGX§£RGRSUD]R(XPDYH]TXHQ£RVHHVWLSXORXFULW©ULRREMHWLYRSDUDFRQWDJHPGHVVHODSVR
WHPSRUDOXPEUHYHSHURGRTXHVHMDDQWHULRU DOLHQD§£RM¡MXVWLILFDULDDVXDSHUGDSRUPHWDGH
7DOVLWXD§£RQ£RQRVSDUHFHMXVWDHGHYHHPQRVVRVHQWLUVHUGHYLGDPHQWHDIHULGDSHORMXL]FDVRD
FDVRVHJXQGRRERPVHQVRTXHVHHVSHUDGRMXOJDGRUFDXWHORVR
,QWHUHVVDQWHDLQGDREVHUYDUDGLF§£RGRhzGRDUWLJRVREFRPHQWRM¡WUDQVFULWR
ߡhz4XDQGRRYFLRSRUVXDQDWXUH]DV³SXGHUVHUFRQKHFLGRPDLVWDUGHRSUD]RFRQWDUVH¡GRPRPHQWRHPTXHGHOHWLYHUFLªQFLDDW©
RSUD]RP¡[LPRGHFHQWRHRLWHQWDGLDVHPVHWUDWDQGRGHEHQVP³YHLVHGHXPDQRSDUDRVLP³YHLVߢ
&XLGRXVHDTXLGHUHJXODUDVLWXD§£RPXLWRFRPXPGHRYFLRUHGLELW³ULRDSHQDVVHUGHWHFWDGRDS³VD
WUDGL§£RRXFRPRTXHUROHJLVODGRUߡVHUFRQKHFLGRPDLVWDUGHߢKLS³WHVHHPTXHRSUD]RVHU¡FRQWDGRD
SDUWLUGRPRPHQWRHPTXHRDGTXLUHQWHWLYHUFLªQFLDGRGHIHLWRWHUPRDTXRDW©RSUD]RP¡[LPRGH
GLDVVHDFRLVDIRUP³YHOHGHXPDQRVHIRULP³YHO
6DOLHQWHVHHVWHSRQWRWDOSUD]RVRPHQWHFRUUHU¡DSDUWLUGRPRPHQWRHPTXHRGRQRGDFRLVDGHWHFWDU
RYFLRRTXDOREYLDPHQWHQ£RSRGHU¡GHFRUUHUGHP¡XWLOL]D§£RHVLPVHUDQWHULRU WUDGL§£RGDFRLVD
,ߚWULQWDGLDVWUDWDQGRVHGHIRUQHFLPHQWRGHVHUYL§RHGHSURGXWRQ£RGXU¡YHLV
,,ߚQRYHQWDGLDVWUDWDQGRVHGHIRUQHFLPHQWRGHVHUYL§RHGHSURGXWRGXU¡YHLV
hz7UDWDQGRVHGHYFLRRFXOWRRSUD]RGHFDGHQߓFLDOLQLFLDVHQRPRPHQWRHPTXHILFDUHYLGHQFLDGRRGHIHLWRߢJULIDPRV
(P VH WUDWDQGR HQWUHWDQWR GH YHQGD GH DQLPDLV R h z GR DUW GR && SUHYª TXH RV SUD]RV GH
JDUDQWLD VHU£R RV HVWDEHOHFLGRV HP OHL HVSHFLDO RX QD IDOWD GHVWD SHORV XVRV ORFDLV DSOLFDQGRVH R
GLVSRVWRQRSDU¡JUDIRDQWHFHGHQWHVHQ£RKRXYHUUHJUDGLVFLSOLQDQGRDPDW©ULD9ªVHSRUWDQWRWUDWDUVH
GH UHJUD VXSOHWLYD FXMD ILQDOLGDGH © HYLWDU HYHQWXDLV OLWJLRV TXDQGR R YFLR UHGLELW³ULR LQFLGLU HP
DQLPDOREMHWRGHFRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGD
2XWUR LPSRUWDQWH DVSHFWR DERUGDGR SHOR &³GLJR &LYLO YLJHQWH H GHVFRQKHFLGR SHOD OHJLVOD§£R
DQWHULRU GHYH VHU UHVVDOWDGR D SUHYLVLELOLGDGH QRUPDWLYD GD VXVSHQV£R GR SUD]R GH JDUDQWLD OHJDO
HQTXDQWRHVWLYHUHPFXUVRDJDUDQWLDFRQWUDWXDO
( W£R LQWHUHVVDQWH © D GLF§£R GHVWH GLVSRVLWLYR TXH HP QRVVR VHQWLU QD IDOWD GH UHJUD VHPHOKDQWH
SRGHU¡VHUDSOLFDGRVXEVLGLDULDPHQWH VUHOD§µHVGHFRQVXPR
1HVVHSRQWRHVWDPRVDWUDWDUGDUHJUDSUHYLVWDQRDUW
ߡ$UW 1£R FRUUHU£R RV SUD]RV GR DUWLJR DQWHFHGHQWH QD FRQVW¢QFLD GH FO¡XVXOD GH JDUDQWLD PDV R DGTXLUHQWH GHYH GHQXQFLDU R
GHIHLWRDRDOLHQDQWHQRVWULQWDGLDVVHJXLQWHVDRVHXGHVFREULPHQWRVRESHQDGHGHFDGªQFLDߢ
&RPHQWDQGRHVWHGLVSRVLWLYR-21(6),*8(,5'2$/9(6REVHUYRX
ߡ&O¡XVXODGHJDUDQWLD©FDXVDREVWDWLYDGHGHFDGªQFLDHFRPRFO¡XVXODFRQWUDWXDOSHODTXDORDOLHQDQWHDFREHUWDDLQGHQLGDGHGDFRLVD©
FRPSOHPHQWDUGDJDUDQWLDREULJDW³ULDHOHJDODTXHUHVSRQGH1£RH[FOXLSRUWDQWRDJDUDQWLDOHJDO2SULPHLURUHODW³ULRDRSURMHWRGH
DXWRULDGR'HSXWDGR(UQDQL6DW\URM¡UHJLVWUDYDQ£RVHKDYHUߝFRPRFRQIXQGLURIDWRGHQ£RFRUUHUSUD]RQDFRQVW¢QFLDGDFO¡XVXODGH
JDUDQWLDFRPDREULJD§£RTXHWHPRDGTXLUHQWHGHGHQXQFLDURGHIHLWRGDFRLVDDRDOLHQDQWHW£RORJRRYHULILTXH7UDWDVHFRPRVHYª
GH FRQVDJUD§£R MXUGLFD GH XP GHYHU GH SURELGDGH H ERDI© WDO FRPR DQXQFLDGR QR DUW 1£R © SRU HVWDU DPSDUDGR SHOR SUD]R GH
JDUDQWLD TXH R FRPSUDGRU GHYD VH SUHYDOHFHU GHVVD VLWXD§£R SDUD DEVWHUVH GH GDU FLªQFLD LPHGLDWD GR YFLR YHULILFDGR QD FRLVD
DGTXLULGDߢ
(PYHUGDGHRTXHROHJLVODGRUIH]Q£RVHPWHPSRIRLVROXFLRߓQDUDGHOLFDGDVLWXD§£RFRQVLVWHQWHQR
IDWRGHFRH[LVWLUHPGXDVPRGDOLGDGHVGHJDUDQWLDDOHJDOHDFRQWUDWXDO,VVRRFRUUHFRPIUHTXªQFLDQR
¢PELWRGRPHUFDGRGHFRQVXPR2LQGLYGXRFRPSUDSRUH[HPSORXPDWHOHYLV£RGHGHWHUPLQDGDPDUFD
FRP JDUDQWLDFRQWUDWXDOGH DQRV 6HP SUHMX]R GH WDO FO¡XVXOD HQWUHWDQWR JR]DU¡ WDPE©P GD JDUDQWLD
OHJDOJHQ©ULFD SUHYLVWD SHOR &³GLJR GH 'HIHVD GR &RQVXPLGRU SDUD R FDVR GH VH YHULILFDU GHIHLWR QR
SURGXWRDGTXLULGRDUW
3RLVEHP
(PWDOFLUFXQVW¢QFLDHQTXDQWRHVWLYHUHPFXUVRRSUD]RGHJDUDQWLDFRQWUDWXDODJDUDQWLDOHJDOHVWDU¡
VREUHVWDGDSDUDOLVDGDRXVHMDQ£RFRUUHU¡SUD]RGHFDGHQFLDODOJXPHPGHVIDYRUGRDGTXLUHQWH
7RGDYLD YHULILFDGR R GHIHLWR R DGTXLUHQWH SRU LPSHUDWLYR GD ERDI© REMHWLYD GHYHU¡ GHQXQFL¡OR
QRWLFL¡ORDRDOLHQDQWHQRVGLDVVHJXLQWHVDRGHVFREULPHQWRVRESHQDGHGHFDGªQFLD
&RPLVVRFRQFOXPRVTXHFDVRRDOLHQDW¡ULRGHVFXPSUDHVVHGHYHUGHLQIRUPD§£RSHUGHU¡RGLUHLWR
JDUDQWLDOHJDO
&RQVWDWHVH SRUWDQWR PDLV XPD YH] FRPR WRGD D DQ¡OLVH KHUPHQªXWLFD GR QRYR GLSORPD
HVSHFLDOPHQWHQDVHDUDFRQWUDWXDOHQFRQWUDVHSURIXQGDPHQWHLQIOXHQFLDGDSHORSULQFSLRGDERDI©FXMD
QR§£RYDOHVHPSUHDSHQDVHUUHFRUGDGD
ߡ(QTXDQWRSULQFSLRQRUPDWLYRDERDI©VXUJHFRPRXPFULW©ULRQRUWHDGRUGHFRPSRUWDPHQWRVLPSRQGR VSDUWHVXPDFRQGXWDTXHSRVVD
YDORUDUVHFRPRKRQHVWDFRUUHWDHOHDO3UHWHQGHFRPWDOI³UPXODH[SULPLUVHDLGHLDGHTXHQ£R©OHJWLPRGHIUDXGDUDTXHODFRQILDQ§D
TXH FRQVWLWXL D EDVH LPSUHVFLQGYHO GDV UHOD§µHV KXPDQDV WRUQDQGRVH SRU LVVR QHFHVV¡ULR TXH RV FRQWUDWDQWHV DWXHP WDO FRPR GHYH
HVSHUDUVHTXHRID§DTXDOTXHUSHVVRDTXHSDUWLFLSHFRUUHWDPHQWHQRWU¡ILFRMXUGLFR1RTXHYDLLPSOLFDGDDH[LJªQFLDIXQGDPHQWDOGH
TXHFDGDXPDGDVSDUWHVGDUHOD§£RQHJRFLDOWRPHHPFRQVLGHUD§£RRVLQWHUHVVHVOHJWLPRVGDRXWUDߢ
(VVDEHOVVLPDSDVVDJHPGRSHQVDPHQWRGH$/0(12'(6KDUPRQL]DVHSHUIHLWDPHQWHFRPDLGHLD
HVSRVDGDRDGTXLUHQWHDJHGHPDQHLUDOHDOH©WLFDDRFRPXQLFDUDRDOLHQDQWHRGHIHLWRGDFRLVDGHQWUR
GRSUD]RHVWLSXODGRHPOHL
2 VHX VLOªQFLR RXWURVVLP SRGHU¡ LQGLFDU LQWHQ§£R GH SUHMXGLFDU RX P¡I© PRUPHQWH HP VH
FRQVLGHUDQGRTXHRVHIHLWRVGDQRVRVSURYHQLHQWHVGRYFLRSRGHU£RHPYLUWXGHGRVHXFRPSRUWDPHQWR
RPLVVLYRVHDJUDYDU
9&,265(',%,75,26(2&',*2'('()(6$'2&21680,'25
)LQDOPHQWHFXPSUHQRVWHFHUEUHYHVFRQVLGHUD§µHVDFHUFDGRVYFLRVUHGLELW³ULRVHRQRVVR&³GLJR
GH'HIHVDGR&RQVXPLGRU/HLQ
$SURWH§£RGLVSHQVDGDSHOR&'&DRFRQVXPLGRU©PXLWRPDLVDPSODGRTXHDTXHODSUHYLVWDQR&³GLJR
&LYLO
,VVR SRUTXH D OHL FRQVXPHULVWD Q£R FXLGD GH GLIHUHQFLDU RV YFLRV DSDUHQWHV GRV UHGLELW³ULRV
FRQVDJUDQGRWRGDYLDXPHILFD]VLVWHPDSURWHWLYRTXHLU¡WXWHODURVGLUHLWRVGDSDUWHKLSRVVXILFLHQWHQD
UHOD§£RGHFRQVXPRLQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWHGDQDWXUH]DGRGHIHLWRHPWHODDUWVHV
1HVVHPHVPRVHQWLGR-26)(51$1'26,02REVHUYDTXH
ߡ2&³GLJRGH'HIHVDGR&RQVXPLGRULQRYRXDRHQIDWL]DURIDWRGHRYFLRVHUGHTXDOLGDGHRXTXDQWLGDGH2IDWRGHRYFLRVHURFXOWRRX
DSDUHQWHUHDOPHQWHJHUDSRXFDVGLIHUHQ§DVQDUHOD§£RGHFRQVXPRHVXDVFRQVHTXªQFLDVOLPLWDPVH TXHVW£RGRVSUD]RVSDUDH[HUFFLR
GRGLUHLWRGHUHFODPDUSHORVYFLRVDUW&³GLJRGH'HIHVDGR&RQVXPLGRUߢ
-¡6/9,29(126$FRPPDHVWULDSRQWLILFD
ߡ6HP VRPEUD GH GºYLGD © QR ¢PELWR GR FRQVXPLGRU TXH DYXOWDU¡ GH LPSRUW¢QFLD D JDUDQWLD SHORV SURGXWRV RX SHORV VHUYL§RV -¡
UHVVDOWDPRVTXHRIRUQHFHGRUWHPRGHYHUGHLQIRUPDURFRQVXPLGRUDFHUFDGDVTXDOLGDGHVGRSURGXWRRXVHUYL§REHPFRPRDGYHUWLOR
GRVULVFRV(QWUHDVUHJUDVGHSURJUDPDTXHWUD]DOHL/HLQ©UHFRQKHFLGDDYXOQHUDELOLGDGHGRFRQVXPLGRUQRPHUFDGRGH
FRQVXPRߢ
(PDLVDGLDQWHDUUHPDWD
ߡ H[LVWH XP DODUJDPHQWR GD UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH OHJDO GR IRUQHFHGRU DWHQGHQGR DR GLQDPLVPR H IRUPD GDV SU¡WLFDV GH FRP©UFLR 2
IRUQHFHGRU UHVSRQVDELOL]DVH Q£R VRPHQWH SHOR SURGXWR HP VL TXH FRORFD QR PHUFDGR FRPR WDPE©P SHOD LPDJHP TXH GLYXOJD GHVVH
SURGXWRVHQGRREULJDGRDUHVSHLWDUVXDYHUDFLGDGHߢ
$VVLPIRU§RVRFRQYLUTXHVHPGºYLGDDJUDQGHYDQWDJHPGRVLVWHPDLQDXJXUDGRSHOR&'&FRQVLVWH
QDDPSOLD§£RGDUHVSRQVDELOLGDGHGRIRUQHFHGRUSHORYFLRGRSURGXWRRXVHUYL§R
7UDWDVHHPYHUGDGHGHXPDIRUPDREMHWLYDGHUHVSRQVDELOLGDGHFLYLOߚRTXHIDYRUHFHDGHIHVDGR
FRQVXPLGRU ߚ FRPSDUWLOKDGD VROLGDULDPHQWH SRU WRGRV DTXHOHV TXH SDUWLFLSDP GD FDGHLD FDXVDO GH
FRQVXPR
;9,,,
(9,&2
12(6&21&(,78$,6
(YLF§£R©XPDILJXUDMXUGLFDTXHQRVUHPHWH LGHLDGHߡSHUGDߢ
$VVLP FRPR RV YFLRV UHGLELW³ULRV D SURWH§£R FRQWUD VHXV HIHLWRV QDGD PDLV © GR TXH XPD JDUDQWLD
FRQWUDWXDOGRVFRQWUDWRVRQHURVRV
1RWHVHSRUWDQWRTXHDVXDSUHYLV£ROHJDOGHFRUUHHVSHFLDOPHQWHGDQHFHVVLGDGHGHVHUHVJXDUGDUR
DGTXLUHQWHGHXPDHYHQWXDODOLHQD§£RDQRQGRPLQRRXVHMDDOLHQD§£RGHFRLVDQ£RSHUWHQFHQWHDRDOLHߓ
QDQWH
6RERSULVPDKLVW³ULFRHVVHSHFXOLDULQVWLWXWRMXUGLFRWHPLQGLVFXWYHOUDL]URPDQD
1DVFHX GDV IRUPDOLGDGHV GD PDQFLSDWLR RX GH QHJ³FLR PHQRV IRUPDO GHQRPLQDGR VWLSXODWLR 6H R
DGTXLUHQWHSHODPDQFLSDWLRYLHVVHDVHUGHPDQGDGRSRUWHUFHLURDQWHVGHRFRUUHUDXVXFDSL£RSRGHULD
FKDPDURYHQGHGRUDILPGHTXHHOHVHDSUHVHQWDVVHHPMX]RSDUDDVVLVWLORHGHIHQGªORQDOLGH6HR
YHQGHGRU VH UHFXVDVVH D FRPSDUHFHU RX VH PHVPR FRPSDUHFHQGR R DGTXLUHQWH VH YLVVH SULYDGR GD
FRLVDWHULDHVWHºOWLPRDGHQRPLQDGDDFWLRDXFWRULWDWLVSDUDREWHURGREURGRSUH§RTXHKDYLDSDJRQR
QHJ³FLR
9ªVH SRUWDQWR GHVVDV EUHYHV QR§µHV FRQFHLWXDLV LQWURGXW³ULDV TXH GD HYLF§£R SDUWLFLSDP WUªV
SHUVRQDJHQVIXQGDPHQWDLV
DDOLHQDQWH
EDGTXLUHQWHHYLFWR
FWHUFHLURHYLFWRU
6HQGR DVVLP FDVR R DGTXLUHQWH YHQKD D SHUGHU D FRLVD DGTXLULGD SDUD R WHUFHLURUHLYLQGLFDQWH
HYLFWRUTXHSURYDRVHXOHJWLPRHDQWHULRUGLUHLWR SURSULHGDGHGDFRLVDSRGHU¡YROWDUVHFRQWUDR
DOLHQDQWHSDUDKDYHUGHVWHDMXVWDFRPSHQVD§£RSHORSUHMXߓ]RVRIULGR
2VIXQGDPHQWRVGHWDOLPSRUWDQWHHMXVWDJDUDQWLDVHPRVWUDPHYLGHQWHV
([SOLFLWHPRQRV
)81'$0(1726-85',&26
7RUQDVHQHVVHGLDSDV£RLQGLVFXWYHORFDU¡WHUHVVHQFLDOPHQWHJDUDQWLVWDGDHYLF§£R
'HIDWRPHVPRTXHDQDOLV¡VVHPRVRLQVWLWXWRVREXPD³WLFDHVWULWDPHQWHSDWULPRQLDOLVWDWHUDPRVSRU
FHUWR TXH R SULQFSLR JHUDO GD SURLEL§£R GR HQULTXHFLPHQWR VHP FDXVD M¡ OHJLWLPDULD VRFLDO H
MXULGLFDPHQWHDVXDXWLOL]D§£R
$ILQDOGHFRQWDVHODVRPHQWH©FDEYHOQRVFRQWUDWRVRQHURVRVHPTXHRVߡ´QXVߢGDDYHQ§DGHYHPVHU
GLYLGLGRVHQWUHRVFRQWUDWDQWHVSDUDTXHSRVVDPREWHURVSURYHLWRVGHVHMDGRVHDSHUGDGREHPVHP
TXHVHEXVFDVVHUHSDUDUDVFRLVDVDRVWDWXVTXRDQWHLPSRUWDULDHPORFXSOHWDPHQWRVHPFRQWUDSUHVWD§£R
GRDOLHQDQWH
7RGDYLDOLPLWDUQRVHPRVDHVVD³WLFDGHFHUWDIRUPDVLPSOLVWD
3RUFHUWRPDLVXPDYH]GHYHPRVIULVDUDRQRVVRDWHQWROHLWRUTXHWRGDVHVVDVQR§µHVYªPSURIXQGDH
XPELOLFDOPHQWHLQIRUPDGDVHLQߓIOXHQFLDGDVSRUXPSULQFSLRPDLRURGDERDI©REMHWLYD
,VVRPHVPR
$ RFRUUªQFLD GD HYLF§£R Q£R GHL[D GH WUDGX]LU QD HVPDJDGRUD PDLRULD GDV VLWXD§µHV XPD DIURQWD D
HVVHSULQFSLREDVLODUGDVUHOD§µHVMXUGLFDVHHPHVSHFLDOQDPRGHUQLGDGHGDVUHOD§µHVFRQWUDWXDLV
SHODLQHJ¡YHOTXHEUDGDOHDOGDGHTXHGHYHSDXWDUWRGDHTXDOTXHUUHOD§£RQHJRFLDO
$VVLPQ£RWHPRVGºYLGDDJDUDQWLDGDHYLF§£RJXDUGDQWLPDFRQH[LGDGHFRPRSULQFSLRGDERDI©
LQIRUPDGRUGHWRGRR'LUHLWR3ULYDGR
3RULVVRPHVPRHDWWXORGHH[HPSOR©TXHQ£RVHSRGHU¡IDODUGHHYLF§£RVHRDUUHPDWDQWHVDELD
TXHDFRLVDHUDDOKHLDRXOLWLJLRVDQDIRUPDGRDUWGR&&
5(48,6,726
(PQRVVR&³GLJR&LYLODHYLF§£R©GLVFLSOLQDGDDSDUWLUGRVHXDUW
ߡ$UW1RVFRQWUDWRVRQHURVRVRDOLHQDQWHUHVSRQGHSHODHYLF§£R6XEVLVWHHVWDJDUDQWLDDLQGDTXHDDTXLVL§£RVHWHQKDUHDOL]DGRHP
KDVWDSºEOLFDߢ
$SULPHLUDSDUWHGRGLVSRVLWLYRGHL[DEHPFODURTXHPUHVSRQGHSHORVULVFRVRDOLHQDQWH
(SDUDTXHDVXDUHVSRQVDELOLGDGHVHPDQLIHVWHWUªVUHTXLVLWRVGHYHPVHUFRQMXJDGRV
DDTXLVL§£RGHXPEHP
ESHUGDGDSRVVHRXGDSURSULHGDGH
FSUROD§£RGHVHQWHQ§DMXGLFLDORXH[HFX§£RGHDWRDGPLQLVWUDWLYR
$QDOLVHPRVFDGDXPGHOHVVHSDUDGDPHQWH
$TXLVL§£RGHXPEHP
3DUDTXHDHYLF§£RVHRSHUH©SUHFLVRVHYHULILFDUTXDOIRLDPDQHLUDSHODTXDOREHPIRLDGTXLULGR
,VVR SRUTXH SDUD FDUDFWHUL]DU D HYLF§£R WDO DTXLVL§£R GHYH SUHFHGHU FURQRORJLFDPHQWH SHUGD GD
FRLVD
6HQGRGHWDOIRUPDUHOHYDQWHHVWDDTXLVL§£RSRGHVHGDUSRUGXDVPDQHLUDVTXDLVVHMDPDFHOHEUD§£R
GH XP FRQWUDWR RQHURVR WUDQVODWLYR GD SRVVH RX SURSULHGDGH GD FRLVD RX D VXD DTXLVL§£R HP KDVWD
SºEOLFD
([SOLTXHPRVHVWDVGXDVKLS³WHVHVGHRFRUUªQFLD
&RQWUDWRVRQHURVRV
$ SULPHLUD REVHUYD§£R D VHU IHLWD © TXH VH HQFRQWUDP IRUD GD SURWH§£R FRQWUD RV HIHLWRV GD HYLF§£R
WRGRVRVFRQWUDWRVJUDWXLWRVWUDVODWLYRVGHSRVVHHSURSULHGDGHGHEHQV
$VVLP SRU H[HPSOR Q£R K¡ TXH VH IDODU GR LQVWLWXWR QRV FRQWUDWRV GH GRD§£R VLPSOHV RX FRPRGDWR
XPDYH]TXHRV´QXVSDWULPRQLDLVIRUDPLPSRVWRVDSHQDVSDUDXPDGDVSDUWHVSDFWXDQWHV
4XDQGRVHIDODHPULVFRVGDHYLF§£RFRQFHS§£RGRXWULQ¡ULDWUDGLFLRQDOID]PHQ§£RVHPSUHDRFRQWUDWR
GHFRPSUDHYHQGD
(QWUHWDQWR © LPSRUWDQWH IULVDU TXH D HYLF§£R M¡ SRGHU¡ RSHUDUVH FRP D SHUGD GD VLPSOHV SRVVH GD
FRLVDQ£RVHQGRDGHPDLVXPDILJXUDH[FOXVLYDGHWDOILJXUDFRQWUDWXDO
1HVVHVHQWLGR+(50$12)/9,20217$1,1,'(&$6752H'$1,/2)/9,20217$1,1,
'(&$6752FLWDQGRSHQVDPHQWRGH&$,205,2DVVHYHUDPTXH
ߡ(PTXHSHVHTXDVHWRGRVRV&³GLJRVGRPXQGRGLVFLSOLQDUHPDHYLF§£RGHQWURGDVUHJUDVUHODWLYDVDRFRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGDR
TXH DOL¡V D W©FQLFD OHJLVODWLYD GR %UDVLO Q£R VHJXLX SRLV WUDWRX GR DVVXQWR GHQWUR GR FDSWXOR UHIHUHQWH V GLVSRVL§µHV JHUDLV GRV
FRQWUDWRVRIDWR©TXHHVWDJDUDQWLDQ£RILFDDGVWULWDDSHQDVDHVWDILJXUDFRQWUDWXDOߢ
$OL¡VDSU³SULDVLWXD§£RGDDTXLVL§£RHPKDVWDSºEOLFDQ£RWHPSURSULDPHQWHQDWXUH]DGHߡFRQWUDWR
GHFRPSUDHYHQGDߢ
$TXLVL§£RHPKDVWDSºEOLFD
$QWHV GD YLJªQFLD GR &³GLJR &LYLO GH KDYLD DFHVD FRQWURY©UVLD GRXWULQ¡ULD H MXULVSUXGHQFLDO
DFHUFD GD SRVVLELOLGDGH GH VH IDODU QD SURWH§£R FRQWUD RV ULVFRV GD HYLF§£R TXDQGR R EHP IRVVH
DGTXLULGRHPKDVWDSºEOLFD
3HODPRGLILFD§£ROHJLVODWLYDWDODVSHFWRQ£RFRPSRUWDPDLVTXDLVTXHUGºYLGDV
3RU FHUWR QRVVR OHLWRU M¡ GHYH WHU REVHUYDGR TXH R DUW GR && WHYH XPD SDUWH ILQDO
DFUHVFHQWDGDSHORFRGLILFDGRUGHTXHDW©HQW£RQ£RH[LVWLDQDOHLDQWHULRUߡVXEVLVWHHVWDJDUDQWLD
DLQGDTXHDDTXLVL§£RVHWHQKDUHDOL]DGRHPKDVWDSºEOLFDߢ
,PDJLQHVHSRUH[HPSORTXH&DUORVKDMDDUUHPDWDGRGHWHUPLQDGREHPP³YHORXLP³YHOHPOHLO£RRX
SUD§DUHVSHFWLYDPHQWH6HDS³VDDUUHPDWD§£RHDH[SHGL§£RGDLPSUHVFLQGYHOFDUWDFRPSUREDW³ULD
GRVHXQRYRGLUHLWRGHSURSULHGDGHYLHUDVHUGHPDQGDGRHPVHGHGHD§£RUHLYLQGLFDW³ULDSURSRVWD
SRU$GROIRHVXFXPELUSRGHU¡H[HUFHURVHXGLUHLWRGHUHJUHVVRIUXWRGDJDUDQWLDGDHYLF§£RFRQWUDR
GHYHGRUGHFXMRSDWULP´QLRVHRULJLQRXREHPOHYDGR KDVWD
1HVVHFDVRRDUUHPDWDQWH&DUORVXPDYH]OLWLJDQGRFRPRWHUFHLUR$GROIRVREUHDFRLVDDGTXLULGD
HP KDVWD SºEOLFD GHYH YDOHUVH GD GHQXQߓFLD§£R GD OLGH FRPR PHLR GH H[HUFFLR GH VXD SUHWHQV£R
UHJUHVVLYDDUW,GR&3&
LVVRPHVPR
4XDQGR &DUORV DUUHPDWRX R EHP R IH] HP VHGH GH H[HFX§£R SDUD YLDELOL]DU TXH RV FUHGRUHV GR
GHYHGRUH[HFXWDGR IRVVHP VDWLVIHLWRV 2UD VH R DUUHPDWDQWH YLHU D SHUGHU D FRLVD FRQFOXPRV TXH R
GHYHGRUORFXSOHWRXVHLQGHYLGDPHQWHSRUKDYHUSURSLFLDGRDKDVWDGHXPEHPDSDUHQWHPHQWHVHXPDV
TXHGHIDWRQ£ROKHSHUWHQFLD(PWDOFDVRRYDORUSDJRSRU&DUORVFDUDFWHUL]DULDSDJDPHQWRLQGHYLGR
FDEHQGRDRPHVPRSRUIRU§DGDVHJXQGDSDUWHGHVWHGLVSRVLWLYRYROWDUVHFRQWUDRH[HFXWDGRGHYHGRU
SDUDH[HUFHURGLUHLWRTXHGDHYLF§£ROKHUHVXOWD
1HVVDOLQKDTXHVW£REDVWDQWHLQWHUHVVDQWH©VDEHUTXHP©RUHVSRQV¡YHOSRUWDOSDJDPHQWR
'LVVHUWDQGR VREUH R WHPD )5(',( 628=$ ',',(5 -5 HP H[FHOHQWH REUD DTXL WUDQVFULWD DW©
PHVPRQRVURGDS©VREVHUYD
ߡ5HVWDVDEHUTXHPVHU¡RUHVSRQV¡YHOSHORSDJDPHQWRGRVSUHMX]RVGRDUUHPDWDQWHHYLFWR"
6HJXQGR GHPRQVWUD $UDNHQ GH $VVLV TXH WUD§RX EHOR SDLQHO GD FRQWURY©UVLD D GRXWULQD EUDVLOHLUD DGRWRX R SHQVDPHQWR GH /LHEPDQ
FDEHULDSUHWHQV£RUHJUHVVLYDHPIDFHGRGHYHGRUTXHVHHQULTXHFHXLQGHYLGDPHQWHVHQGRHOHLQVROYHQWHSRGHULDRDUUHPDWDQWHYROWDUVH
FRQWUD R FUHGRUH[HTXHQWH TXH PXLWR HPERUD WLYHVVH R GLUHLWR DR SDJDPHQWR Q£R R WLQKD D VHU SDJR SHOD DOLHQD§£R GH EHP GH
WHUFHLUR
9DLDO©P$UDNHQGH$VVLVߚHRDFRPSDQKDPRV5HFRQKHFHRDXWRUDSDUWLUGHSHQVDPHQWRGH:LODUGGH&DVWUR9LOODUTXHWDPE©PR
(VWDGRSRGHVHUUHVSRQVDELOL]DGRSHORVSUHMX]RVVRIULGRVSHORDUUHPDWDQWHHPUD]£RGDHYLF§£R9HMDPRVRVHXSHQVDPHQWRFRPRTXDO
FRQFRUGDPRVLQWHJUDOPHQWH
ߝ$TXL©SUHFLVRFRQVLGHUDUDXQLGDGHGRSRGHUMXULVGLFLRQDO$RVXEURJDUDYRQWDGHGRH[HFXWDGRDLQVW¢QFLDVGRH[HTXHQWHRXYHLFXODU
D D§£R GHVWH QD HVIHUD MXUGLFD GR REULJDGR FRQIRUPH R ¢QJXOR GD DQ¡OLVH H D XP V³ WHPSR GHFLGLU R GRPQLR D IDYRU GH WHUFHLUR R
(VWDGR DVVXPH R ULVFR GH HQWUHJDU FRP XPD P£R R TXH HP VHJXLGD UHWLUDU¡ FRP D RXWUD 'D UHVXOWD R GHYHU HVWDWDO GH LQGHQL]DU R
HYLFWR$GHPDLVDLQVHU§£RGR(VWDGRQRQHJ³FLRGHDUUHPDWD§£RDXWRUL]DLPSXWDUOKHUHVSRQVDELOLGDGHSHORGDQRSRUYHQWXUDFDXVDGRD
WHUFHLUR'HVWHPRGRR(VWDGRUHVSRQGHU¡VROLGDULDPHQWHFRPDVSDUWHVGDUHOD§£RSURFHVVXDOSHODHYLF§£RGRDUUHPDWDQWHߞ ߢ
6RPHQWHQHVVHDVSHFWRILQDOQ£RFRQFRUGDPRVGDWDYHQLDFRPRQRVVRHVSHWDFXODUSURFHVVXDOLVWD
$ SRVVLELOLGDGH GH VH UHFRQKHFHU OHJLWLPLGDGH SDVVLYD DR FUHGRUH[HTXHQWH QD GHPDQGD UHJUHVVLYD
SURSRVWDSHORHYLFWRHPHVPRDR(VWDGRQRVSDUHFHH[DJHUDGD
1RSULPHLURFDVRDSHQDVDGPLWLUDPRVDVXDFRQGL§£RGHU©XVHHVWLYHVVHDJLQGRDUGLORVDPHQWH&DVR
Q£RKRXYHVVHSURFHGLGRGHIRUPDLQVLGLRVDDVXDERDI©VHULDHPQRVVRVHQWLUMXVWLILFDWLYDVXILFLHQWH
SDUD H[FOXOR GD OLGH PRUPHQWH SRUTXH HP WRGD DUUHPDWD§£R H[LVWH SDUD R DUUHPDWDQWH XPD ¡OHD GH
ULVFR VHPHOKDQWH RX PDLRU RFRUUHQWH QRV FRQWUDWRV HP JHUDO 3DUD R FUHGRUH[HTXHQWH SRXFR LPSRUWD
TXDO©REHPTXHLU¡VHUH[SURSULDGRSDUDVDWLVID]HUVHXFU©GLWRSRLV©DUHOD§£RMXUGLFDREULJDFLRQDO
TXHRYLQFXODYDDRGHYHGRUTXHTXHUYHUFXPSULGDHIRLMXVWDPHQWHSHORLQDGLPSOHPHQWRGRU©XTXH
WHYHGHVHYDOHUGRDSDUDWRMXGLFLDOSDUDUHFHEHUVXDSUHVWD§£R
1DPHVPDOLQKDWDPE©PQ£RDGPLWLPRVDUHVSRQVDELOLGDGHGR(VWDGRPRUPHQWHHPVHFRQVLGHUDQGR
D KLS³WHVH GH WRGR R WU¢PLWH SURFHVVXDO ߚ GD FRQVWUL§£R SHQKRUD KDVWD SºEOLFD ߚ WLYHU VLGR
GHYLGDPHQWH REHGHFLGR H FRQGX]LGR $ILQDO QDGD PDLV IH] R (VWDGR GR TXH FXPSULU XP GHYHU
FRQVWLWXFLRQDOPHQWHLPSRVWRTXH©RGHDSUHFLDUWRGDOHV£RRXDPHD§DGHOHV£RDGLUHLWRDUWz;;;9
GD&)
$VVLP © LPSRUWDQWH SHUFHEHU TXH VH KRXYH H[SURSULD§£R GH EHQV GR GHYHGRU LVVR RFRUUHX SRU VXD
ºQLFDHH[FOXVLYDUHVSRQVDELOLGDGHSHORTXHDPSOLDUR¢PELWRGHJDUDQWLDFRQWUDRVULVFRVGDHYLF§£R
VHPQRUPDOHJDODXWRUL]DGRUDVRDFRPRXPVXSHUGLPHQVLRQDPHQWRGRLQVWLWXWR
%DVWD SHQVDU SRU H[HPSOR QD H[HFX§£R GH XP FU©GLWR WUDEDOKLVWD FRQWUD DOJXQV GRV GHYHGRUHV
FRQWXPD]HV GH WDLV YHUEDV TXH VLPSOHVPHQWH IHFKDP DV SRUWDV H QDGD SDJDP SRXFR FRQWULEXLQGR SDUD
VROX§£R GR OLWJLR D SRQWR GH GHL[DU LU SUD§D RX OHLO£R VHXV EHQV 1HVVH FDVR R DUUHPDWDQWH YLUDU¡
FUHGRU SHOD HYLF§£R GR HPSUHJDGR H GR (VWDGR" 1£R QRV SDUHFH UD]R¡YHO WDO VROX§£R SHOR TXH
FRQVLGHUDPRVVHPDPHQRUVRPEUDGHGºYLGDTXHWRGDDUHVSRQVDELOLGDGH©GRGHYHGRUH[SURSULDGR
)D]VHPLVWHUUHJLVWUDUSRUILPTXHHPERUDRH[HPSORPDLVHYLGHQWHGHDTXLVL§£RHPKDVWDSºEOLFD
VHMDDDUUHPDWD§£RDSUHYLV£RQ£RVHOLPLWDDHODSRGHQGRVHUSHUIHLWDPHQWHDSOLF¡YHOSDUDRFDVRSRU
H[HPSORGHXPDDGMXGLFD§£R
3HUGDGDSRVVHRXGDSURSULHGDGH
1RWHVH SRUWDQWR TXH R SUHMXGLFDGR TXDQGR FRQVXPDGD D SHUGD GR EHP H FRQVHTXHQWHPHQWH D
HYLF§£R©RDGTXLUHQWHWDPE©PGHQRPLQDGRHYLFWR
(PDLVHPQRVVRVHQWLUEDVWDTXHVHSHUFDDSRVVHGDTXLORTXHOHJLWLPDPHQWHVHWUDQVIHULXDRHYLFWR
LQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWH GH D VHQWHQ§D WUDQVLWDU HP MXOJDGR RX GD WUDQVIHUªQFLD GR GRPQLR SDUD TXH HVWH
SRVVDID]HUYDOHURVHXGLUHLWRFRQWUDRDOLHQDQWH
3UROD§£RGHVHQWHQ§DMXGLFLDORXH[HFX§£RGHDWRDGPLQLVWUDWLYR
(VVH©XPSRQWRTXHWDPE©PGHYHVHUEHPGHVWDFDGRHFRPSUHHQGLGR
7UDGLFLRQDOPHQWH D GRXWULQD FRVWXPD UHIHULU TXH D HYLF§£R GHFRUUH GH XPD VHQWHQ§D MXGLFLDO TXH
UHFRQKHFHGLUHLWRDQWHULRUGHWHUFHLURVREUHDFRLVD
1HVVHVHQWLGRYHMDHVWDGHILQL§£RGH25/$1'2*20(6ߡ'¡VHHYLF§£RTXDQGRRDGTXLUHQWHYHPD
SHUGHUDSURSULHGDGHRXSRVVHGDFRLVDHPYLUWXGHGHVHQWHQ§DMXGLFLDOTXHUHFRQKHFHDRXWUHPGLUHLWR
DQWHULRUVREUHHODߢ
1DPHVPDOLQKDSDUD%(9,/48$DHYLF§£RFRQVLVWHߡQDSHUGDWRWDORXSDUFLDOGDSRVVHGHXPD
FRLVDHPYLUWXGHGHVHQWHQ§DTXHDJDUDQWHDDOJX©PTXHDHODWLQKDGLUHLWRDQWHULRUߢ
'HIDWRFRPRUHJUDJHUDOSRGHPRVDILUPDUTXHRHYLFWRVXFXPEHDQWHRHYLFWRUQRERMRGHXPDD§£R
UHLYLQGLFDW³ULDHPTXHHVWHºOWLPRIRUPXODDVXDSUHWHQV£RGHGLUHLWRUHDOHPIDFHGDFRLVDTXHDFDED
SRUVHUDFROKLGD
(QWUHWDQWR QDGD LPSHGH TXH D SHUGD GR EHP VH Gª SRU IRU§D GH XP DWR DGPLQLVWUDWLYR FRPR SRU
H[HPSORXPDDSUHHQV£RSROLFLDO
,PDJLQHVHSRUH[HPSORTXH/HRGHJ¡ULRHVWHMDJXLDQGRRVHXYHFXORUHF©PFRPSUDGRHVHMDSDUDGR
SRUXPDEOLW]SROLFLDO$S³VDSUHVHQWDUVHXVGRFXPHQWRVRSROLFLDOYHULILFDTXHRDXWRP³YHOFRQGX]LGR
KDYLDVLGRURXEDGR6LWXD§£RH[WUHPDPHQWHGHVDJUDG¡YHOHGHVFRQFHUWDQWHPRUPHQWHSRUTXH/HRGHJ¡ULR
GHQDGDVDELD(PVHJXLGDRYHFXOR©DSUHHQGLGRRSHUDQGRVHSRUFRQVHTXªQFLDDSHUGDGDSRVVHH
SRVWHULRUPHQWH GD SURSULHGDGH GR EHP 1HVVH FRQWH[WR QDGD LPSHGH TXH R HYLFWR /HRGHJ¡ULR VHP
TXHKRXYHVVHVLGRSURODWDGDQHQKXPDVHQWHQ§DLQJUHVVHGHLPHGLDWRFRPD§£RMXGLFLDOSDUDKDYHUGR
DOLHQDQWHGRYHFXORDMXVWDFRPSHQVD§£RSRUVXDSHUGD
3RUWDQWR FRQFOXPRV TXH D VHQWHQ§D QHP VHPSUH © LQGLVSHQV¡YHO SDUD TXH VH FRQVXPH R ULVFR
GHFRUUHQWHGDHYLF§£R
1HVVHVHQWLGR©RSHQVDPHQWRGH6/9,29(126$ߡ'HVWDUWHWHPRVDFRPSDQKDGRVHPUHEX§RVHVVD
FRUUHQWHMXULVSUXGHQFLDOTXHHQWHQGHVHUDDSUHHQV£RDGPLQLVWUDWLYDQHVVDVSUHPLVVDVHTXLYDOHQWHDXPD
GHFLV£RMXGLFLDOGHQWURGRHVSULWRGRLQVWLWXWRߢ &ODURHVW¡HQWUHWDQWRTXHHVVHDWRDGPLQLVWUDWLYR
GHYHVHUILUPHREDVWDQWHSDUDLPSOLFDUHIHWLYDSHUGDGDSRVVHRXGDSURSULHGDGHRXWURERPH[HPSOR
VHULDDDSUHHQV£RGHSURGXWRVSRUILVFDLVGDDOI¢QGHJD
5HJLVWUHVH SRU©P TXH Q£R © XPD OLPLWD§£R GR GLUHLWR GH SURߓSULHGDGH DGYLQGD GR (VWDGR TXH
HQVHMDU¡ D HYLF§£R PDV VLP D GHWHUPLQD§£R GD SHUGD GD SURSULHGDGH RX GD SRVVH GD FRLVD 2
WRPEDPHQWRSRUH[HPSORHPTXHSHVHSRGHUUHGX]LURVGLUHLWRVGRSURSULHW¡ULR©KLS³WHVHDVVHQWDGDGH
Q£RFDELPHQWRGRLQVWLWXWR
',5(,726'2(9,&72
1HVVD OLQKD GH LQWHOHF§£R REVHUYDVH TXH R HYLFWR DR H[HUFHU R VHX GLUHLWR UHVXOWDQWH GD HYLF§£R
IRUPXODU¡HPIDFHGRDOLHQDQWHXPDSUHWHQV£RWLSLFDPHQWHLQGHQL]DW³ULD
3RGHU¡ SOHLWHDU SRLV VDOYR HVWLSXOD§£R HP FRQWU¡ULR DO©P GD UHVWLWXL§£R LQWHJUDO GR SUH§R RX GDV
TXDQWLDVTXHSDJRXDUWGR&&
DDLQGHQL]D§£RGRVIUXWRVTXHWLYHUVLGRREULJDGRDUHVWLWXLU
EDLQGHQL]D§£RSHODVGHVSHVDVGRVFRQWUDWRVHSHORVSUHMX]RVTXHGLUHWDPHQWHUHVXOWDUHPGDHYLF§£R
FDVFXVWDVMXGLFLDLVHRVKRQRU¡ULRVGRDGYRJDGRSRUHOHFRQVߓWLWXGR
9DOH QRWDU TXH D REULJD§£R SUHYLVWD QHVWH DUWLJR VXEVLVWH SDUD R DOLHQDQWH DLQGD TXH D FRLVD HVWHMD
GHWHULRUDGDH[FHWRVHWLYHUKDYLGRGRORGRDGTXLUHQWHDUW2XVHMDVHDFRLVDDOLHQDGDQ£RHVWDYD
HP SHUIHLWR HVWDGR GH FRQVHUYD§£R RX HVWDYD SDUFLDOPHQWH GHVWUXGD H R HYLFWR YHP D SHUGªOD DLQGD
DVVLPWHU¡GLUHLWR UHVWLWXL§£RLQWHJUDOQDIRUPDGRDUW3HUGHU¡HQWUHWDQWRHVVHGLUHLWRVHDWXRX
GRORVDPHQWH GDQGR FDXVD GHWHULRUD§£R (P WDO FDVR Q£R WHU¡ GLUHLWR FRPSHQVD§£R LQWHJUDO
DEUDQJHQWHGDVSHUGDVHGDQRV
$GHPDLVFDVRRHYLFWRM¡WHQKDVLGRFRPSHQVDGRSHODVGHWHULRUD§µHVRDOLHQDQWHSRGHU¡REYLDPHQWH
GHGX]LURYDORUGHVVDVYDQWDJHQVGDTXDQWLDTXHWHULDGHUHVWLWXLUOKHDWHRUGRDUWGR&&
(63&,(6'((9,&2727$/(3$5&,$/
1DPHGLGDHPTXHLPSOLTXHDSHUGDFRPSOHWDGDSURSULHGDGHRXDSHQDVGHIUD§£RGHODDHYLF§£RVHU¡
FKDPDGDGHWRWDORXSDUFLDOUHVSHFWLYDPHQWH
(QWUHWDQWRYDOHQRWDUTXHVHMDWRWDORXSDUFLDORSUH§RDVHUUHVWLWXGRVHU¡RGRYDORUGDFRLVDQD
©SRFDHPTXHVHHYHQFHXVHSHUGHXHSURSRUFLRQDODRGHVIDOTXHVRIULGRQRFDVRGHHYLF§£RSDUFLDOQD
IRUPDGRSDU¡JUDIRºQLFRGRDUWGR&&
(P FDVR GH HYLF§£R SDUFLDO RX VHMD GH SHUGD Q£R LQWHJUDO GD FRLVD DOLHQDGD SRU H[HPSOR D
UHLYLQGLFD§£R GH SDUWH GH OLYURV GH XPD ELEOLRWHFD GH SDUWH GH XP WHUUHQR DGTXLULGR RX GH DOJXQV
DQLPDLV GHXPD ID]HQGDFRPSUDGD GH ߡSRUWHLUDIHFKDGDߢ SRGHU¡ RHYLFWR RSWDU HQWUH D GLVVROX§£RGR
FRQWUDWR RX D UHVWLWXL§£R GD SDUWH GR SUH§R FRUUHVSRQGHQWH DR GHVIDOTXH VRIULGR &DVR Q£R VHMD
FRQVLGHU¡YHODHYLF§£RFLUFXQVW¢QFLDTXHGHYHU¡VHUDIHULGDSHORMXL]LQFRQFUHWRWHU¡GLUHLWRDSHQDV
LQGHQL]D§£R DUW 7UDWDVH FRPR VH SRGH YHU GH XPD KLS³WHVH GH FRQFXUVR GH GLUHLWRV RX
SUHWHQVµHVQ£RSRGHQGRSRU³EYLDVUD]µHVRHYLFWRFXPXODUDPERVRVSHGLGRV
$OHLQ£RHVWDEHOHFHHVSHFLILFDPHQWHTXDO©RSUD]RSDUDDGHGX§£RHPMX]RGHVWDSRVWXOD§£RQHPD
VXDQDWXUH]D
$SULPHLUDLPSUHVV£R©TXHVHWUDWDGHXPDD§£RHGLOFLDHSRULVVRGHYHULDVHUDSOLFDGRRPHVPR
SUD]RGHFDGHQFLDOGRDUWGR&&
7RGDYLDDVVLPQ£RSHQVDPRV
'H IDWR Q£R QRV SDUHFH PXLWR W©FQLFR DGPLWLU QR VLVWHPD FRGLILFDGR FLYLO D IL[D§£R GH SUD]RV
GHFDGHQFLDLVSRUDQDORJLD
7RGDYLDDLQGDTXHLVVRQ£RVHMD³ELFH©SUHFLVRDQDOLVDURTXHVHSUHWHQGHGHGX]LUHPMX]RTXDQGR
UHDOL]DGDDHYLF§£R
$SRVWXOD§£RTXHVHID]TXDQGRRFRUUHQWHDHYLF§£RQ£R©GHGHVID]LPHQWRGRQHJ³FLRߚSRVWXOD§£R
FRQVWLWXWLYDQHJDWLYDTXHDWUDLXPSUD]RGHQDWXUH]DGHFDGHQFLDOߚPDVVLPGDVXDGLVVROX§£RSRUIDWR
SRVWHULRUFRPDVPHQFLRQDGDVLQGHQL]D§µHVFRUUHVSRQGHQWHVSURSRUFLRQDLVQRFDVRGHHYLF§£RSDUFLDO
$VVLP R TXH VH WHP HIHWLYDPHQWH © XPD SUHWHQV£R H SRU LVVR R SUD]R GHYHU¡ VHU FRQVLGHUDGR
SUHVFULFLRQDO
(TXDO©RSUD]R"
$SULPHLUDWHQWD§£RGDPHVPDIRUPDSHODLQH[LVWªQFLDGHXPDSUHYLV£RGLVFLSOLQDGRUDHVSHFILFD©
LQYRFDURFDSXWGRDUWGR&&SDUDUHFRQKHFHURSUD]RGHGH]DQRV
7RGDYLDDVVLPWDPE©PQ£RSHQVDPRV
'HQRYRFRQVLGHUDPRVUHOHYDQWVVLPRYHULILFDUTXDO©DQDWXUH]DGDSRVWXOD§£RGHGX]LGDHPMX]R
(QHVVHFDVRFRQVWDWDPRVTXHQRILQDOGDVFRQWDVRTXHVHYHULILFD©XPDSUHWHQV£R GHUHSDUD§£R
FLYLOSRLVRDOLHQDQWHRXGHYHGRUH[SURSULDGRQRFDVRGDKDVWDSºEOLFDDFDERXSRUJHUDUXPGDQRQR
SDWULP´QLRGRDGTXLUHQWHHYLFWRSRUVXEPHWHUXPEHPTXHQ£RHUDVHXPDVVLPGRWHUFHLURHYLFWRU
(9,&2($872120,$'$9217$'(ߚ$&/868/$'(12(9,&2
$QRVVDDWHQ§£RHQWUHWDQWRGHYHU¡UHGREUDUTXDQGRSDVVDUPRVDDQDOLVDURWRUPHQWRVRWHPDUHIHUHQWH
H[FOXV£R GLPLQXL§£RRXDRDXPHQWRGDJDUDQWLDGHFRUUHQWHGDHYLF§£R
'HIDWRHVVDJDUDQWLDSRGHU¡GHQWURGR¢PELWRGDDXWRQRPLDGDYRQWDGHVRIUHUH[WHQV£RRXUHWUD§£R
SRGHQGRDW©PHVPRVHUVXSULPLGDQRVWHUPRVGRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLO
ߡ$UW3RGHPDVSDUWHVSRUFO¡XVXODH[SUHVVDUHIRU§DUGLPLQXLURXH[FOXLUDUHVSRQVDELOLGDGHSHODHYLF§£Rߢ
'HORJRFRQVWDWDPRVTXHHVVDSRVVLELOLGDGHVHPSUHGHFRUUHU¡GHFO¡XVXODH[SUHVVDQXQFDSRGHQGR
SRLVVHULPSOFLWDFRQVRDQWHGHIOXLFODUDPHQWHGDSULPHLUDSDUWHGRGLVSRVLWLYR
$VVLP VH DV SDUWHV UHVROYHUHP DXPHQWDU H[WHQV£R GD JDUDQWLD R GLUHLWR GR DGTXLUHQWH ߚ
HVWDEHOHFHQGR XPD PXOWD FDVR VH FRQVXPH D SHUGD SRU H[HPSOR ߚ DEDWHU D JDUDQWLD GH LQGHQL]D§£R
SHORV HYHQWXDLV IUXWRV UHVWLWXGRV GLPLQXL§£R GD JDUDQWLD RX EHP DVVLP H[FOXUHP WRWDOPHQWH D
UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH SHOD HYLF§£R VRPHQWH SRGHU£R ID]ªOR SRU FO¡XVXOD H[SUHVVD FRQVWDQWH GR FRQWUDWR
ILUPDGR
GHVHVDOLHQWDURXWURVVLPTXHH[LVWHXPDKLS³WHVHGHH[FOXV£ROHJDOGDJDUDQWLDTXH©DPHQFLRQDGD
SUHYLV£ROHJDOGRDUWGR&³GLJRTXHSUREHRDGTXLUHQWHGHGHPDQGDUSHODHYLF§£RVHVDELDTXHD
FRLVDHUDDOKHLDRXOLWLJLRVD
7UDWDVH FRPR M¡ GLWR GH XP GLVSRVLWLYR XPELOLFDOPHQWH OLJDGR DR VXSHULRU SULQFSLR GD ERDI©
REMHWLYDXPDYH]TXHQ£RVHDILJXUDMXVWRTXHRDOLHQDW¡ULRDGTXLUHQWHSRVVDSOHLWHDUFRPSHQVD§£RSRU
XP GDQR FRQVFLHQWHPHQWH VRIULGR 6H VDELD SRLV TXH D FRLVD HUD DOKHLD GH WHUFHLUR RX OLWLJLRVD HUD
REMHWRGHGLVSXWDMXGLFLDOQ£RGHYHULDFRQWUDWDU
0DVDWHQ§£R
$LQGD TXH WHQGR KDYLGR D H[FOXV£R FRQYHQFLRQDO GD JDUDQWLD DUW VH D HYLF§£R VH RSHUDU R
HYLFWRWHU¡RGLUHLWRGHUHFHEHUSHORPHQRVRSUH§RTXHSDJRXSHODFRLVDHYLFWDVHQ£RWLYHUVDELGRGR
ULVFR GDHYLF§£R RXWHQGR VLGR GHOH LQIRUPDGR Q£R R DVVXPLX FRQIRUPH HVWDEHOHFLGR H[SUHVVDPHQWH
SHORDUWGR&&
9DOH GL]HU PHVPR TXH QR FRQWUDWR FRQVWH D FO¡XVXOD ߡR DOLHQDQWH Q£R UHVSRQGH SHORV ULVFRV GD
HYLF§£Rߢ DLQGD DVVLP R HYLFWR ߚ D TXHP Q£R KRXYHVVH VLGR QRWLFLDGR R ULVFR GH SHUGD RX PHVPR
LQIRUPDGRTXHQ£RWHQKDDVVXPLGRHVVHULVFRߚWHU¡DRPHQRVRGLUHLWRGHUHFHEHURSUH§RSDJR1£R
WHU¡SRUWDQWRGLUHLWR LQGHQL]D§£RSHORVIUXWRVUHVWLWXGRVEHQIHLWRULDVRXRXWUDVGHVSHVDVDVVLVWLQGR
OKHDSHQDVRGLUHLWRGHKDYHUGHYROWDDTXDQWLDTXHSDJRXSHODFRLVDTXHVHHYHQFHX
&RP LVVR IRU§RVR FRQYLU TXH R DOLHQDQWH DSHQDV VH H[RQHUDU¡ WRWDOPHQWH GD UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH SHORV
ULVFRVGDHYLF§£RFDVRID§DFRQVWDUGRFRQWUDWRDFO¡XVXODH[FOXGHQWHGDJDUDQWLDHDO©PGLVVRGªDR
DGTXLUHQWHDHIHWLYDFLªQFLDGRULVFRGHSHUGDGDFRLVDHGHTXHDVVXPHHVVHULVFRQDTXHOHDWR
$VVLP FRPSDWLELOL]DQGR DV UHJUDV GRV DUWV H WHPRV TXH KDYHQGR HIHWLYDPHQWH R
FRQKHFLPHQWRGRVULVFRVVHMDSHODLQIRUPD§£RGLUHWDHH[SUHVVDGRDOLHQDQWHDUWVHMDSRURXWURV
PHLRVDGPLVVYHLVHP'LUHLWRSRUVDEHUTXHDFRLVDHUDDOKHLDRXOLWLJLRVDQRWHVHTXHRDUWQ£R
OLPLWDDIRUPDGHFLHQWLILFD§£RQ£RSRGHU¡RDGTXLUHQWHGHPDQGDUSHODHYLF§£R
1RWHVHSRUWDQWRTXHDFRQWURY©UVLDSRGHU¡LQVWDXUDUVHHPIXQ§£RGDSURYDGRFRQKHFLPHQWRHIHWLYR
GRVULVFRVH[LVWHQWHVGDSRVVLELOLGDGHGHSHUGDGDFRLVD
&RPHQWDQGR HVWD ºOWLPD KLS³WHVH /9$52 9,//$$ $=(9('2 FLWDQGR GRXWULQD GH $512/'2
:$/'SRQGHUDTXH
ߡVHRDGTXLUHQWHVDEHGRYFLRTXHPDFXODRGLUHLWRGRDOLHQDQWHUHODWLYDPHQWHDRREMHWRTXHOKH©WUDQVPLWLGRHH[FOXLH[SUHVVDPHQWHD
UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH GH TXHP DOLHQRX D HVVD PHVPD FRLVD © FODUR TXH R DGTXLUHQWH HVW¡ DGTXLULQGR EHP OLWLJLRVR 1HVVH FDVR R FRQWUDWR
DSUHVHQWDVHFRPQDWXUH]DDOHDW³ULDSRLVRFRUUHQGRDHYLF§£RQDGDSRGHU¡RDGTXLUHQWHUHFODPDUGRDOLHQDQWHߢ
;,;
(;7,12'2&2175$72
,1752'82
(PERUD D OHJLVOD§£R PXLWDV YH]HV VH YDOKD LQGLVWLQWDPHQWH GH GHQRPLQD§µHV GLVWLQWDV H[WLQ§£R
UHVLOL§£RUHVROX§£RHUHVFLV£RFRPRVLQ´QLPDVGHIHQGHPRVXPPDLRUULJRUWHUPLQRO³JLFR
$VVLPTXDQGRHVWLYHUPRVIDODQGRGRJªQHURXWLOL]DUHPRVDVH[SUHVVµHVߡH[WLQ§£RߢߡGLVVROX§£RߢRX
ߡGHVID]LPHQWRߢ GR FRQWUDWR SRU FRQVLGHU¡ODV HTXLYDOHQWHV YDOHQGR GHVWDFDU TXH D SULPHLUD © D
FRQVDJUDGDQR&DSWXOR,,GR7WXOR9ߡ'RV&RQWUDWRVHP*HUDOߢGRWH[WRFRGLILFDGR
7RGDYLD QD DQ¡OLVH GDV PRGDOLGDGHV H[WLQWLYDV SRVWHULRUHV Q£R QHFHVVDULDPHQWH FRQFHELGDV QR
FRQWUDWR YHULILFDUHPRV FRPR GLWR FDXVDV DQWHULRUHV FRQWHPSRU¢QHDV RX VXSHUYHQLHQWHV VXD
FHOHEUD§£R
4XDQWR V FDXVDV DQWHULRUHV H FRQWHPSRU¢QHDV XWLOL]DUHPRV D H[SUHVV£R JHQ©ULFD H[WLQ§£R HPERUD
FRPR YHUHPRV DFHLWHPRV D XWLOL]D§£R HP GHWHUPLQDGDV PRGDOLGDGHV GH RXWUDV H[SUHVVµHV R TXH
VHPSUHH[SOLFLWDUHPRV
5HDOL]DGRV RV HVFODUHFLPHQWRV WHUPLQRO³JLFRV SDVVHPRV D HQIUHQWDU FDGD XPD GHVVDV PRGDOLGDGHV
H[WLQWLYDVGRFRQWUDWR
(;7,121$785$/'2&2175$72
6RE D GHQRPLQD§£R ߡH[WLQ§£R QDWXUDO GR FRQWUDWRߢ UHXQLPRV WRGDV DV VLWXD§µHV I¡WLFDV HP TXH D
UHOD§£R FRQWUDWXDO VH GLVVROYH SHOD YHULILFD§£R GH XPD FLUFXQVW¢QFLD SUHYLVWD SHODV SDUWHV H WLGD FRPR
UD]RDYHOPHQWHHVSHUDGD
$H[HPSOLILFD§£RPDLV³EYLD©LQGXELWDYHOPHQWHDGRUHJXODUFXPSULPHQWRGRFRQWUDWRPDVQ£RVH
OLPLWD D HOD XPD YH] TXH SRU IRU§D GD GLVFLSOLQD QRUPDWLYD GR QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR SRGHP DV SDUWHV
HVWDEHOHFHU HOHPHQWRV GH HILF¡FLD TXH OLPLWDP D SURGX§£R GH HIHLWRV GR FRQWUDWR SRVVLELOLWDQGR VXD
H[WLQ§£R
(QIUHQWHPRVQRVSU³[LPRVVXEW³SLFRVFDGDXPDGHVWDVIRUPDVGHH[WLQ§£RQDWXUDOGRFRQWUDWR
&XPSULPHQWRGRFRQWUDWRRXH[DXVW£RGRVHXREMHWR
2FRQWUDWR©IHLWRSDUDVHUFXPSULGR
(VVD P¡[LPD DSDUHQWHPHQWH W£R ³EYLD GHYH VHU H[SOLFLWDGD SDUD UHJLVWUDU D IRUPD HVSHUDGD GH
H[WLQ§£RGRFRQWUDWRUHDOL]DQGRVHRVHXFRQWHºGR
5HDOL]DGDDSUHVWD§£RQDIRUPDFRPRSDFWXDGDH[WLQJXHVHH[QXQFDUHOD§£RFRQWUDWXDOKDYLGDHQWUH
DVSDUWHV
&RPHIHLWRFXPSULGDDSUHVWD§£RPXLWDVYH]HVM¡VHHQFRQWUDH[DXULGRRREMHWRGRFRQWUDWRRFDVR
SRU H[HPSOR GD YHQGD GH XP EHP P³YHO HP TXH FRP R SDJDPHQWR GR SUH§R H D HQWUHJD GD FRLVD
FRQVXPDGDHVW¡DREULJD§£RH[WLQJXLQGRVHRYQFXORFRQWUDWXDO
$YLVXDOL]D§£RGHWDLVH[HPSORVVHPRVWUDEHPPDLVI¡FLOQRVFRQWUDWRVLQVWDQW¢QHRVVHMDGHH[HFX§£R
LPHGLDWDVHMDGHH[HFX§£RGLIHULGD
1RVFRQWUDWRVGHGXUD§£RSRUVXDYH]DWHQGªQFLD©DLQGHWHUPLQD§£RGRSUD]RHPERUDQHPVHPSUHD
OHLWXUD GDV FO¡XVXODV FRQWUDWXDLV SHUPLWD GL]HU GH SURQWR VH R FXPSULPHQWR LPHGLDWR GD SUHVWD§£R
LPSRUWDU¡DH[WLQ§£RGRYQFXOR
7DO UHJLVWUR VH LPSµH SDUD DILUPDU TXH R VLOªQFLR Q£R LPSRUWD SRU VL V³ HP XPD UHJUD DEVROXWD GH
LQGHWHUPLQD§£R SUD]DO ,VVR SRUTXH D SUHVWD§£R SRGH VLJQLILFDU D H[DXVW£R GR REMHWR GR QHJ³FLR
RFRUUHQWH TXDQGR K¡ XPD HYLGHQWH OLPLWD§£R QDWXUDO RX MXUGLFD QD SRVVLELOLGDGH GH FXPSULPHQWR 3RU
H[HPSOR TXDQGR VH FHOHEUD XP FRQWUDWR GH SUHVWD§£R GH VHUYL§R SDUD XPD VLWXD§£R H[FHSFLRQDO RX
HPHUJHQFLDOYJRIRUQHFLPHQWRGHFROFKµHVSDUDGHVDߓEULJDGRVSRUXPDHQFKHQWHOLPLWDGRREYLDPHQWH
DR QºPHUR GH SHVVRDV QHFHVVLWDGDV DLQGD TXH GHVFRQKHFLGR RX RIHUHFH XP SURGXWR QR FRP©UFLR
OLPLWDGRDRHVWRTXHH[LVWHQWH
1HVVHFDPSRVHJXLQGRDVUHJUDVSDUDDFHOHEUD§£RGRQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRSRGHPDVSDUWHVHVWDEHOHFHU
FO¡XVXODVQRFDPSRGDHILF¡FLDTXHWDPE©PLPSRUWDU£RHPXPDH[WLQ§£RQDWXUDOGRFRQWUDWR
9HULILFD§£RGHIDWRUHVHILFDFLDLV
$V SDUWHV FHOHEUDQWHV GH XP FRQWUDWR SRGHP HVWDEHOHFHU HOHPHQWRV OLPLWDGRUHV GD VXD GXUD§£R
FRQFHEHQGRSUHYLDPHQWHSRUWDQWRDVXDH[WLQ§£R
,VVRSRUTXHRFXPSULPHQWRGRFRQWUDWRHPWDLVVLWXD§µHVHVW¡LQWLPDPHQWHOLJDGRDHVWHIDWRHILFDFLDO
UHODFLRQDGRDRGHFXUVRGRWHPSRRX RFRUUªQFLDGHXPHYHQWRIXWXURHLQFHUWR
9HQFLPHQWRGRWHUPR
8PD GDV KLS³WHVHV SDUD D H[WLQ§£R GH XP FRQWUDWR LQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWH GH VHX UHJXODU HRX LQWHJUDO
FXPSULPHQWR©RDGYHQWRGHXPWHUPR
3RGHP DV SDUWHV SRU H[HPSOR FHOHEUDU FRQWUDWRV VHP D SUHIL[D§£R GH XP SUD]R 2 H[HPSOR PDLV
GLG¡WLFR©SRUFHUWRRFRQWUDWRGHHPSUHJRTXHSRUIRU§DGRSULQFSLRGDFRQWLQXLGDGHGDUHOD§£RGH
HPSUHJR SUHVXPHVH VHPSUH GH GXUD§£R LQGHWHUPLQDGD PRWLYR SHOR TXDO SDUD VHU H[WLQWR LPSµH HP
UHJUDDFRQFHVV£RGHXPDYLVRSU©YLR
2XWURV FRQWUDWRV SRU©P SRGHP VHU FHOHEUDGRV ߚ H FRPXPHQWH R V£R ߚ FRP D HVWLSXOD§£R GH XP
WHUPRHPERUDQDGDLPSH§DTXHVHMDPIHLWRVVHPOLPLWD§£RWHPSRUDORFDVRSRUH[HPSORGHFRQWUDWRV
GHDVVLVWªQFLDW©FQLFD
,PSOHPHQWRGHFRQGL§£RUHVROXWLYD
$O©P GH XP HYHQWR FHUWR TXDQWR RFRUUªQFLD FRPR © R FDVR GR WHUPR SRGHP DV SDUWHV HVWLSXODU
TXHUHQGRTXHDGXUD§£RGRFRQWUDWRVHMDOLPLWDGD RFRUUªQFLDGHXPHYHQWRIXWXURHLQFHUWRDFRQGL§£R
7UDWDVHQRFDVRGRLPSOHPHQWRGHXPDFRQGL§£RUHVROXWLYD
$VVLPFDVRVHMDFHOHEUDGRXPFRQWUDWRFXMDHILF¡FLDHVWHMDVXEPHWLGDDXPDFRQGL§£RRLPSOHPHQWR
GHWDOHYHQWRJHUDU¡DVXDH[WLQ§£RDXWRP¡WLFD
2 H[HPSOR FRPXPHQWH FLWDGR GH FRQGL§£R UHVROXWLYD RFRUUH TXDQGR QR SU³SULR FRQWUDWR © SUHYLVWD
FO¡XVXOD QR VHQWLGR GH TXH HP RFRUUHQGR R LQDGLPSOHPHQWR SRU SDUWH GH TXDOTXHU GRV FRQWUDWDQWHV R
YQFXOR MXUGLFR HVWDU¡ H[WLQWR (VWD © VHP VRPEUD GH GºYLGD D VLWXD§£R PDLV OHPEUDGD QD GRXWULQD
HVSHFLDOL]DGD HPERUD GHYDPRV DGYHUWLU TXH R IDWR FRQFUHWL]DGRU GHVWD SUHYLV£R QHJRFLDO OKH ©
VXSHUYHQLHQWHRLQDGLPSOHPHQWR
2XWUR H[HPSOR LQWHUHVVDQWH GH LPSOHPHQWR GH FRQGL§£R UHVROXWLYD © R SDFWR GH UHWURYHQGD FO¡XVXOD
HVSHFLDO FRPSUD H YHQGD TXH JDUDQWH DR YHQGHGRU R GLUHLWR GH UHFREUDU D FRLVD LP³YHO QR SUD]R
GHFDGHQFLDOGHWUªVDQRVUHVWLWXLQGRRSUH§RUHFHELGRHGHVHPEROVDQGRDVGHVSHVDVGRFRPSUDGRUQD
IRUPDGRVDUWVDGR&&
)UXVWUD§£RGDFRQGL§£RVXVSHQVLYD
(PERUDQ£RVHMDWHFQLFDPHQWHXPDKLS³WHVHGHH[WLQ§£RQDWXUDOGRFRQWUDWRSDUHFHQRVTXHQDEXVFD
SHODFRPSOHWXGHTXHDQLPDDUHGD§£RGHVWDREUDYDOHDSHQDOHPEUDUDLQGDTXHSRUH[WUHPRDSHJRDR
ULJRU DFDGªPLFR TXH D IUXVWUD§£R GD FRQGL§£R VXVSHQVLYD SRGH WDPE©P JHUDU D H[WLQ§£R FRQWUDWXDO D
GHSHQGHUGDIRUPDFRPRYHQKDLQVHULGDQRQHJ³FLRMXUGLFR
3RU FHUWR VH SRU H[HPSOR -RUJH HVWDEHOHFH TXH YDL HQWUHJDU GHWHUPLQDGR EHP D ,XUL VH JDQKDU QD
ORWHULD HQTXDQWR Q£R VH UHDOL]DU WDO IDWR R FRQWUDWR HPERUD H[LVWHQWH H Y¡OLGR Q£R SURGX] HIHLWRV
HVWDQGR VXVSHQVD VXD H[HFX§£R 5HDOL]DQGRVH HVVH HYHQWR LQFHUWR GHYHU¡ SURGX]LU WRGRV RV HIHLWRV
SDFWXDGRV 7RGDYLD VH D ORWHULD PHQFLRQDGD GHL[DU GH H[LVWLU Q£R K¡ FRPR LPDJLQDU TXH DV SDUWHV
HVWHMDP YLQFXODGDV LQGHILQLGDPHQWH SHOR TXH SRU H[FH§£R WHUHPRV D H[WLQ§£R GR FRQWUDWR SHOD
LPSRVVLELOLGDGHMXUGLFDGHVXDH[HFX§£R
(PERUDSRXFRXVXDOQ£RFRQVLGHUDPRVHTXLYRFDGDFKDPDUHVVDPRGDOLGDGHGHH[WLQ§£REHPFRPRD
DQWHULRUGHUHVROX§£RFRQWUDWXDOHPERUDFRPRYHUHPRVDH[SUHVV£RVHMDUHVHUYDGDKDELWXDOPHQWHSDUD
FDXVDVVXSHUYHQLHQWHVDVDEHUKLS³WHVHVGHLQH[HFX§£RIDOWRVDGHVFXPSULPHQWRFRQWUDWXDO
&RPSUHHQGLGDV DV VLWXD§µHV GH H[WLQ§£R QDWXUDO GR FRQWUDWR SDVVHPRV D HQIUHQWDU DV KLS³WHVHV GH
H[WLQ§£RGRFRQWUDWRVHPRFXPSULPHQWRGRTXDQWRSDFWXDGR
'LYLGDPRV SRU©P WDLV PRGDOLGDGHV HP GRLV JUDQGHV JUXSRV WRPDQGR SRU SDU¢PHWUR XP FULW©ULR
WHPSRUDODVDEHUGHXPODGRFDXVDVDQWHULRUHVRXFRQWHPSRU¢QHDV IRUPD§£RGRFRQWUDWRHGHRXWUR
FDXVDVVXSHUYHQLHQWHV FHOHEUD§£RGDDYHQ§D
&$86$6$17(5,25(628&217(03251($6)250$2'2&2175$72
3DUWLQGRVHGDSUHPLVVDGHTXHRREMHWLYRDOPHMDGRSHODVSDUWHVQ£RIRLFXPSULGRVHMDUHDOL]DQGRD
SUHVWD§£RVHMDFXPSULQGRRVIDWRUHVHILFDFLDLVGRQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRWRGDH[WLQ§£RFRQWUDWXDOSRVWHULRU
QHVWHVWHUPRVGHYHVHUFRQVLGHUDGDDQRUPDO
(VWDߡPRUWHQ£RQDWXUDOߢSRU©PSRGHWHUVXDUDL]HPFDXVDVDQWHULRUHVRXFRQWHPSRU¢QHDV IRUPD§£R
GRFRQWUDWRRTXHQ£ROKHUHWLUDDFDUDFWHUL]D§£RGHXPDH[WLQ§£RSRVWHULRUKDMDYLVWDTXHVHSDUWHGD
FRQFHS§£RGHH[LVWªQFLDMXUGLFDGDDYHQ§D
&RQKH§DPRVSRUWDQWRTXDLVV£RWDLVFDXVDV
1XOLGDGHRXDQXODELOLGDGH
$RFRUUªQFLDGHQXOLGDGHߚVHMDDEVROXWDVHMDUHODWLYDߚQRQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRFRQWUDWXDO©XPDWSLFD
KLS³WHVHTXHSRGHVHUDQWHULRU SU³SULDFHOHEUD§£RPDVTXHDFRQWDPLQDGHWDOIRUPDTXHLPSRVVLELOLWD
DSURGX§£RY¡OLGDGHHIHLWRV
$QXOLGDGH©XPDVDQ§£RSHODRIHQVDDGHWHUPLQDGRVUHTXLVLWRVOHJDLVTXHLPSµHDQ£RSURGX§£RGH
HIHLWRVMXUGLFRVHPIXQ§£RGRGHIHLWRTXHFDUUHJDHPVHX¢PDJR
&RPR VDQ§£R SHOR GHVFXPSULPHQWR GRV SUHVVXSRVWRV GH YDOLGDGH GR QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR R 'LUHLWR
DGPLWH H LPSµH R UHFRQKHFLPHQWR GD GHFODUD§£R GH QXOLGDGH REMHWLYDQGR UHVWLWXLU D QRUPDOLGDGH H D
VHJXUDQ§DGDVUHOD§µHVVRFLRMXUGLFDV
(VWD QXOLGDGH VRIUH JUDGD§µHV GH DFRUGR FRP R WLSR GH HOHPHQWR YLRODGR SRGHQGR VHU DEVROXWD RX
UHODWLYDQDPHGLGDHPTXHGHFRUUDGDLQIULQJªQFLDGHQRUPDVGHRUGHPSºEOLFDRXGHQRUPDVMXUGLFDV
SURWHWRUDVGHLQWHUHVVHVSUHSRQGHUDQWHPHQWHSULYDGRV
2LPSRUWDQWHDGHVWDFDUSRU©P©TXHSDUWLQGRGRSUHVVXSRVWRTXHRQHJ³FLRHIHWLYDPHQWHH[LVWLXD
VXD H[WLQ§£R VH G¡ SHOR UHFRQKHFLPHQWR MXGLFLDO GD QXOLGDGH H DQXODELOLGDGH GHVID]HQGRVH TXDOTXHU
YQFXORFRQWUDWXDOH[LVWHQWHHQWUHDVSDUWHV
5HGLEL§£R
8P IHQ´PHQR DQWHULRU FHOHEUD§£R GR FRQWUDWR PDV TXH WDPE©P SRGH JHUDU D VXD H[WLQ§£R © D
UHGLEL§£R
$ H[SUHVV£R ߡSRGHߢ © DTXL XWLOL]DGD HP VHX VHQWLGR W©FQLFR TXDO VHMD D GH IDFXOGDGH SRLV QHP
VHPSUH D RFRUUªQFLD GH XP YFLR UHGLELW³ULR HQWHQGLGR FRPR R GHIHLWR RFXOWR TXH GLPLQXL R YDORU RX
SUHMXGLFDDXWLOL]D§£RGDFRLVDUHFHELGDSRUIRU§DGHXPFRQWUDWRFRPXWDWLYRLPSRUWDU¡QDH[WLQ§£RGR
FRQWUDWR SRGHQGR VLP JHUDU XPD UHYLV£R GH VXDV SUHVWD§µHV FRP R DEDWLPHQWR GR SUH§R
FRUUHVSRQGHQWH
&RPR YLPRV HP FDSWXOR DQWHULRU D UHGD§£R GR DUW GR &³GLJR &LYLO EUDVLOHLUR JDUDQWH DR
DGTXLUHQWHGHFRLVDGHIHLWXRVDDIDFXOGDGHGHUHGLELURFRQWUDWRߚOHLDVHH[WLQJXLORSHORYFLRRFXOWR
GDFRLVDߚRXUHFODPDUUHGX§£RQRSUH§RSDFWXDGR
/RJRWUDWDVHGHXPDKLS³WHVHGHH[WLQ§£RFRQWUDWXDOSRUFDXVDDQWHULRU VXDFHOHEUD§£RXPDYH]TXH
VHRYFLRRXGHIHLWRIRUGHFRUUHQWHGDXWLOL]D§£RSRVWHULRUSHORDGTXLUHQWHHQ£RSHODVXDSUHH[LVWªQFLD
DLQGDTXHRFXOWDQ£RK¡FRPRVHLQYRFDUDJDUDQWLD
'LUHLWRGHDUUHSHQGLPHQWR
$ O³JLFD GD FHOHEUD§£R GH XP FRQWUDWR © QR VHQWLGR GH TXH DV SDUWHV DR HVWDEHOHFªOR M¡ WHQKDP D
FRQYLF§£RGHTXHTXHUHPHIHWLYDPHQWHDSUHVWD§£RSDFWXDGD
7RGDYLD FRPR PHGLGD H[FHSFLRQDO © SRVVYHO HP GHWHUPLQDGDV DYHQ§DV TXH DV SDUWHV SDFWXHP
FRQWHPSRUDQHDPHQWH FHOHEUD§£R GR QHJ³FLR XP GLUHLWR GH DUUHSHQGHUVH FRPR D HVWDEHOHFHU XP
ߡSHURGRGHFDUªQFLDߢHPTXH©SRVVYHOVHGHVID]HURFRQWUDWRVHPPDLRUHV´QXV
'DGDDH[FHSFLRQDOLGDGHGHWDOPHGLGDSDUHFHQRVUD]R¡YHODILUPDUTXHWDOGLUHLWRVRPHQWHSRGHVHU
UHFRQKHFLGRVHSUHYLVWRH[SUHVVDPHQWHHPUHVSHLWRDRSULQFSLRGDDXWRQRPLDGDYRQWDGH
3DUDWDLVVLWXD§µHVSRGHPDVSDUWHVHVWDEHOHFHUDUUDVSHQLWHQFLDLVQDIRUPDFRPRSUHYLVWRQRDUW
GR&&LQYHUELV
ߡ$UW6HQRFRQWUDWRIRUHVWLSXODGRRGLUHLWRGHDUUHSHQGLPHQWRSDUDTXDOTXHUGDVSDUWHVDVDUUDVRXVLQDOWHU£RIXQ§£RXQLFDPHQWH
LQGHQL]DW³ULD1HVWHFDVRTXHPDVGHXSHUGªODV¡HPEHQHIFLRGDRXWUDSDUWHHTXHPDVUHFHEHXGHYROYªODV¡PDLVRHTXLYDOHQWH(P
DPERVRVFDVRVQ£RKDYHU¡GLUHLWRDLQGHQL]D§£RVXSOHPHQWDUߢJULIRVQRVVRV
5HJLVWUHVH QR SDUWLFXODU TXH QDV UHOD§µHV GH FRQVXPR R DUW GR &'& FRQIHUH DR FRQVXPLGRU
LQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWHGHSUHYLV£RFRQWUDWXDORGLUHLWRSRWHVWDWLYRGHGHVLVWLUGDFRPSUDUHDOL]DGDIRUDGR
HVWDEHOHFLPHQWRQRSUD]RGHVHWHGLDV 7UDWDVHGRGHQRPLQDGRSUD]RGHUHIOH[£R
&$86$6683(59(1,(17(6)250$2'2&2175$72
4XDQGR PHQFLRQDPRV D RFRUUªQFLD GH FDXVDV VXSHUYHQLHQWHV IRUPD§£R GR FRQWUDWR SDUWLPRV GR
SUHVVXSRVWRGHTXHHOHVHFRQFUHWL]RXGHIRUPDSOHQDFRPRQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRQRVSODQRVGDH[LVWªQFLD
YDOLGDGHHHILF¡FLD
$VVLP FHOHEUDGR SDUD VHU FXPSULGR VHP YFLRV RX SUHYLV£R GH DUUHSHQGLPHQWR VXD GLVVROX§£R
SRVWHULRUSRGHVHGDUSRUGLYHUVDVIRUPDVTXHYDULDPGHVGHDPDQLIHVWD§£RH[SUHVVDGDYRQWDGHDW©RV
HIHLWRVH[WLQWLYRVGRHYHQWXDOLQDGLPSOHPHQWRRXGDPRUWHGHXPGRVFRQWUDWDQWHV
(QIUHQWHPRVFDGDXPDGHVWDVPRGDOLGDGHV
5HVLOL§£R
$H[SUHVV£RߡUHVLOL§£RߢXWLOL]DGDH[SUHVVDPHQWHGHIRUPDW©FQLFDSHOR&³GLJR&LYLOYLJHQWHHPVHX
DUW DSHUIHL§RDQGRDUHGD§£ROHJDOFRGLILFDGDRXWURUDRPLVVDUHIHUHVH H[WLQ§£RGRFRQWUDWR
SRULQLFLDWLYDGHXPDRXDPEDVDVSDUWHV
5HJLVWUHVHSRUWDQWRGHORJRTXHWDOH[WLQ§£RQ£RVHRSHUDUHWURDWLYDPHQWHSURGX]LQGRVHXVHIHLWRV
H[QXQF$VVLPQRVFRQWUDWRVGHWUDWRVXFHVVLYRQ£RVHUHVWLWXHPDVSUHVWD§µHVFXPSULGDVDPHQRVTXH
DVSDUWHVDVVLPRHVWDEHOH§DP
(PYHUGDGHSDUWLQGRGDFRQFHS§£RGHTXHRFRQWUDWRJHUDXPYQFXORMXUGLFRREULJDW³ULR VSDUWHVD
FRQFOXV£RO³JLFD©TXHDPHVPDPDQLIHVWD§£RFRQMXQWDGDYRQWDGHSRVVDH[WLQJXLOR
$VVLP VHQGR WHPRV TXH D UHJUD QR GLUHLWR EUDVLOHLUR © TXH D UHVLOL§£R VHMD ELODWHUDO GLVWUDWR
HPERUD VH SRVVD IDODU HP FDVRV SHUPLWLGRV H[SUHVVD RX LPSOLFLWDPHQWH SHOD OHL HP XPD PDQLIHVWD§£R
XQLODWHUDOGHYRQWDGHH[WLQWLYDGRFRQWUDWR
&RPSUHHQGDPRVHVWDVGXDVHVS©FLHV
%LODWHUDOGLVWUDWR
$UHVLOL§£RELODWHUDO©FKDPDGDSHODGRXWULQDHSHORSU³SULRWH[WRFRGLILFDGRGHGLVWUDWR
6HIRLDDXWRQRPLDGDYRQWDGHTXHHVWDEHOHFHXDUHOD§£RFRQWUDWXDO©³EYLRTXHHVWDPHVPDDXWRQRPLD
SRGHU¡ GHVID]ªOD QD IRUPD FRPR SDFWXDGR SRVVLYHOPHQWH FHOHEUDQGR XP QRYR QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR TXH
HVWDEHOHFHRILPGRYQFXORFRQWUDWXDOGLVFLSOLQDQGRDVFRQVHTXªQFLDVMXUGLFDVGHVWHIDWR
$VVLPSRUH[HPSORVHDHPSUHVD;WHPXPFRQWUDWRGHSUHVWD§£RGHVHUYL§RVFRPXPHVFULW³ULRGH
DGYRFDFLD FHOHEUDGR SRU WHPSR LQGHWHUPLQDGR DV SDUWHV SRGHP GH FRPXP DFRUGR H[WLQJXLOR
HVWDEHOHFHQGRDVLQGHQL]D§µHVTXHDFKDUHPFDEYHLVSRUWDOURPSLPHQWRFRQWUDWXDO
(GHTXHIRUPDGHYHVHGDUWDOH[WLQ§£R"
D)RUPD
(VWDEHOHFHH[SUHVVDPHQWHRDUW
ߡ$UW2GLVWUDWRID]VHSHODPHVPDIRUPDH[LJLGDSDUDRFRQWUDWRߢ
6H©GDVXEVW¢QFLDGRQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRXPDGHWHUPLQDGDIRUPDVRPHQWHSRUWDOVROHQLGDGH©TXHVH
SRGHFRQVLGHUDUY¡OLGRRGLVWUDWR
$VVLPSRUH[HPSORVHSRUIRU§DGDUHJUDGRDUWGR&& DOHLREULJDRUHJLVWURSRU
HVFULWXUDSºEOLFDGHXPGHWHUPLQDGRFRQWUDWRSDUDVXDYDOLGDGHQ£RSRGHU£RDVSDUWHVGHVID]ªORSRU
LQVWUXPHQWRSDUWLFXODU'DPHVPDIRUPDVHVHJXQGRRDUWGR&& DILDQ§DVRPHQWHSRGH
GDUVHSRUHVFULWRVHXGLVWUDWRQ£RSRGHU¡VHUIHLWRRUDOPHQWH
,VVR Q£R LPSOLFD GL]HU SRU©P TXH VH R FRQWUDWR IRL HVWDEHOHFLGR SRU XPD GHWHUPLQDGD IRUPD Q£R
LPSRVWDSHODOHLHOHWDPE©PWHQKDGHVHJXLUWDOIRUPDOLGDGHSDUDVHUH[WLQWR
E4XLWD§£R
8PGDGRUHOHYDQWHVHUHIHUHDRLQVWLWXWRGDTXLWD§£R
'HIDWRHVWDEHOHFLDRDUWGR&&
ߡ$UW2GLVWUDWRID]VHSHODPHVPDIRUPDTXHRFRQWUDWR0DVDTXLWD§£RYDOHTXDOTXHUTXHVHMDDVXDIRUPDߢ
8PDOHLWXUDDSUHVVDGDSRGHULDOHYDU FRQFOXV£RGHTXHFRPDUHWLUDGDGDPHQ§£R TXLWD§£RQRM¡
WUDQVFULWRDUWGR&&HVWDWDPE©PGHYHULDVHJXLUDPHQFLRQDGDUHJUDGHIRUPD
$REVHUYD§£R©FRPRGLWRDSUHVVDGDHHTXLYRFDGD
(P YHUGDGH Q£R KRXYH PRGLILFD§£R GD GLVFLSOLQD GD TXLWD§£R QRV FRQWUDWRV PDV VLP DSHQDV XP
DSHUIHL§RDPHQWR GD W©FQLFD OHJLVODWLYD SDVVDQGR R LQVWLWXWR D VHU GLVFLSOLQDGR HP GLVSRVLWLYR SU³SULR
UHODFLRQDGR SURYDGRSDJDPHQWRPDQWLGDDFRQFHS§£RGHOLEHUGDGHGHIRUPD
8QLODWHUDO
3DUWLQGRVH GD FRQFHS§£R WUDGLFLRQDO GR SULQFSLR GD IRU§D REULJDW³ULD GRV FRQWUDWRV SDFWD VXQW
VHUYDQGD©O³JLFRTXHDH[WLQ§£RXQLODWHUDOGRFRQWUDWRSRUPHUDPDQLIHVWD§£RGHYRQWDGHQ£RSRGHULD
VHUEHPYLVWD
(PYHUGDGHHVVDYLV£RHVSHFILFDFRQWLQXDY¡OLGDSRLVVHULDLO³JLFRߚRXQRPQLPRDWHQWDW³ULR
VHJXUDQ§D GH XPD HVWLSXOD§£R FRQWUDWXDO ߚ LPDJLQDU TXH WRGD FRQWUDWD§£R SXGHVVH VHU VLPSOHVPHQWH
GHVIHLWDDRDOYHGULRGHXPDGDVSDUWHV
1HVVD OLQKD DGPLWHVH SRUWDQWR D UHVLOL§£R XQLODWHUDO VRPHQWH FRP DXWRUL]D§£R OHJDO H[SUHVVD RX
LPSOFLWDSHODQDWXUH]DGDDYHQ§DHVHPSUHFRPDSU©YLDFRPXQLFD§£R RXWUDSDUWH
RTXHVHLQIHUHGRFDSXWGRDUWGR&&VHPHTXLYDOHQWHQDFRGLILFD§£RDQWHULRU
ߡ$UW$UHVLOL§£RXQLODWHUDOQRVFDVRVHPTXHDOHLH[SUHVVDRXLPSOLFLWDPHQWHRSHUPLWDRSHUDPHGLDQWHGHQºQFLDQRWLILFDGD RXWUD
SDUWHߢ
(P XP FRQWUDWR GH SUHVWD§£R GH VHUYL§RV SDFWXDGR HQWUH XP SURIHVVRU GH HGXFD§£R IVLFD H XPD
DFDGHPLDGHJLQ¡VWLFDWDPE©PSRGHSUHYHUXPDFO¡XVXODUHVLOLW³ULDPRUPHQWHHPVHFRQVLGHUDQGRTXHD
UHOD§£RFRQWUDWXDOQ£RGHYHVHUYRFDFLRQDGD HWHUQLGDGH
9DOHDFUHVFHQWDUDLQGDTXHRDWRMXUGLFRSHORTXDOVHRSHUDDUHVLOL§£RXQLODWHUDO©ߡGHQºQFLDߢ
ߡ'HQXQFLDU XP FRQWUDWRߢ SRUWDQWR HP 'LUHLWR &LYLO WUDGX] D LGHLD GH ߡUHVLOLU R QHJ³FLR
XQLODWHUDOPHQWHߢ
D/LPLWD§£RWHPSRUDO
1DVUHOD§µHVFLYLVHPJHUDOTXHDGPLWDPDUHVLOL§£RXQLODWHUDOQ£RVHSURSXJQDLQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWHGH
SU©YLDFRPXQLFD§£RSHODPDLVDPSODSRVVLELOLGDGHGDH[WLQ§£RLPHGLDWDGRFRQWUDWR
,VVRSRUTXHDSDUWHFRQWU¡ULDSRGHWHUUHDOL]DGRYXOWRVRVLQYHVWLPHQWRVQDSHUVSHFWLYDGDFRQWLQXLGDGH
GRYQFXORFRQWUDWXDOQ£RVHQGRUD]R¡YHOQHPFRPSDWYHOFRPDERDI©REMHWLYDTXHDQLPDWRGDDDWXDO
FRGLILFD§£RFLYLOTXHWDLVJDVWRVSHUPDQH§DPLUUHVVDUFLGRV
'DQGRXPH[HPSORSDUDPHOKRUYLVXDOL]DUDKLS³WHVHLPDJLQHVHXPFRQWUDWRGHSUHVWD§£RGHVHUYL§RV
GHDVVLVWªQFLDW©FQLFDHPTXHDHPSUHVDSUHVWDGRUDLQYLVWDQDDTXLVL§£RGHHTXLSDPHQWRVHVSHFLDOL]DGRV
SDUDRPDTXLߓQ¡ULRGDWRPDGRUD2UDVHUHSHQWLQDPHQWHHVWDºOWLPDGHFLGHURPSHURYQFXORFRQWUDWXDO
SRUWHUSH[HQFRQWUDGRRXWUDHPSUHVDTXHSRVVDOKHSUHVWDURVHUYL§RILFDULDDRXWUDSDUWHߡDYHU
QDYLRVߢ"
(P RXWUD OLQKD VH SRU IRU§D GD PDLRU SURWH§£R TXH OKH G¡ D OHJLVOD§£R FRQVXPHULVWD SUHWHQGH XP
FRQVXPLGRUGHVID]HUXPFRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGDSRUQ£RWHUPDLVFRQGL§µHVGHFXPSULURSDFWXDGR
GHYHRYHQGHGRUDFHLWDUWDOIDWRVHPTXDOTXHUUHVVDUFLPHQWRSHODVGHVSHVDVIHLWDV"
FODURTXHQ£RM¡KDYHQGRLQFOXVLYHIDUWDMXULVSUXGªQFLDQDFLRQDOVREUHDPDW©ULDPHVPRDSOLFDQGR
UHJUDVDQWHULRUHVDRDWXDO&³GLJR&LYLOEUDVLOHLUR
3HQVDQGR HP WDLV VLWXD§µHV IRL H[SOLFLWDGD D UHJUD GR SDU¡JUDIR ºQLFR GR PHQFLRQDGR DUW LQ
YHUELV ߡ3DU¡JUDIR ºQLFR 6H SRU©P GDGD D QDWXUH]D GR FRQWUDWR XPD GDV SDUWHV KRXYHU IHLWR
LQYHVWLPHQWRV FRQVLGHU¡YHLV SDUD D VXD H[HFX§£R D GHQºQFLD XQLODWHUDO V³ SURGX]LU¡ HIHLWR GHSRLV GH
WUDQVFRUULGRSUD]RFRPSDWYHOFRPDQDWXUH]DHRYXOWRGRVLQYHVWLPHQWRVߢ
)ULVHVHHQWUHWDQWRTXHDFRPSHQVD§£RGDVGHVSHVDVHIHWXDGDVSHODSDUWHTXHQ£RGHVIH]RFRQWUDWR
GHYHU¡VHUMXVWDHIL[DGDVHJXQGRFULW©ULRVFRPSDWYHLVFRPRVSULQFSLRVGDIXQ§£RVRFLDOGRFRQWUDWRH
GDGLJQLGDGHGDSHVVRDKXPDQD
3RU WDLV UD]µHV Q£R YHPRV FRP ERQV ROKRV DV UHJUDV GH ߡILGHOL]D§£R FRQWUDWXDOߢ XWLOL]DGDV SHODV
HPSUHVDV GH WHOHIRQLD FHOXODU UHVXOWDQGR QD LPSRVL§£R GH SHVDGDV PXOWDV DR FRQVXPLGRU TXH SUHWHQGD
UHVLOLURFRQWUDWRHVSHFLDOPHQWHTXDQGRRP³YHOVXEMHWLYRGDUHVLOL§£RIRUDLQVDWLVID§£RFRPRVHUYL§R
IRUQHFLGR
(PWDOKLS³WHVHHVWDUHIHULGDW©FQLFDGHVXERUGLQD§£RFRQWUDWXDODILJXUDVHQRVLQMXVWDHLOHJWLPDXPD
YH]TXHUHWLUDGRFRQVXPLGRURGLUHLWRGHHVFROKDTXDQWR PHOKRUFRQFHVVLRQ¡ULDTXHSRVVDVHUYLUOKH
IHULQGR LQFOXVLYH WRGR R VLVWHPD GH SULYDWL]D§£R H D SU³SULD &RQVWLWXL§£R )HGHUDO TXH DSRQWD D OLYUH
FRQFRUUªQFLDFRPRRSULQFSLRE¡VLFRGDHFRQRPLD
E)RUPDVHVSHFLDLV
$OJXPDVPRGDOLGDGHVFRQWUDWXDLVSHUPLWHPDUHVLOL§£RXQLODWHUDOWRPDQGRVHHPFRQVLGHUD§£RFHUWDV
SHFXOLDULGDGHVXWLOL]DQGRGRXWULQDHOHJLVOD§£RQRPHVHVSHFLDLVSDUDFDUDFWHUL]¡OD
'HQWUHHVVDVIRUPDVHVSHFLDLVGHVWDFDPRVDUHYRJD§£RDUHQºQFLDHRUHVJDWH
E5HYRJD§£R
$ UHYRJD§£R FRQVLVWH HP XPD PRGDOLGDGH GH GHVID]LPHQWR GH GHWHUPLQDGRV QHJ³FLRV MXUGLFRV SRU
LQLFLDWLYDGHXPDGDVSDUWHVLVRODGDPHQWH
RH[HPSORGDUHVLOL§£RXQLODWHUDOPHQWHIHLWDQRVFRQWUDWRVGHPDQGDWRDUWVDGR&&
HGRD§£RDUWVDGR&&
(VSHFLILFDPHQWH VREUH R PDQGDWR YDOH UHJLVWUDU TXH © SRVVYHO R HVWDEHOHFLPHQWR GH FO¡XVXOD
UHVWULWLYDGDVXDUHVLOL§£ROHLDVHFO¡XVXODGHLUUHYRJDELOLGDGHQDIRUPDGRDUW
'LVWLQJXLQGRUHYRJD§£RGHGHQºQFLDDILUPD25/$1'2*20(6TXH
ߡHVWD SµH ILP GLUHWDPHQWH UHOD§£R REULJDFLRQDO HQTXDQWR DTXHOD H[WLQJXH R FRQWUDWR H V³ FRPR FRQVHTXªQFLD PHGLDWD D UHOD§£R
ID]HQGRFHVVDUH[WXQFRXH[QXQFRVHIHLWRVGRQHJ³FLR
2 DWR GH UHYRJD§£R UHTXHU FXPSULPHQWR SHOR SU³SULR VXMHLWR TXH SUDWLFRX R DWR TXH VH UHYRJD H GHYH GHVWLQDUVH D LPSHGLU TXH HVWH
SURGX]D VHXV HIHLWRV SU³SULRV &RQWXGR R YRF¡EXOR UHYRJD§£R © HPSUHJDGR HP VHQWLGR PDLV DPSOR 7DO FRPR D GHQºQFLD FRQVLVWH D
UHYRJD§£RQXPDGHFODUD§£RUHFHSWFLDGHYRQWDGHTXHRSHUDH[WUDMXGLߓFLDOPHQWHHFRPRHOD©GLUHLWRSRWHVWDWLYR
2V FRQWUDWRV HVWLSXODGRV QR SUHVVXSRVWR GD FRQILDQ§D UHFSURFD HQWUH DV SDUWHV SRGHP UHVLOLUVH DGQXWXP PHGLDQWH UHYRJD§£R (VW¡
QHVWH FDVR R PDQGDWR $ OHL DXWRUL]D R PDQGDQWH D UHYRJ¡OR SRQGROKH WHUPR D WRGR WHPSR SRU VLPSOHV GHFODUD§£R GH YRQWDGH H
LQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWHGHDYLVRSU©YLR
2XWURV FRQWUDWRV FRPSRUWDP HVVH PRGR GH UHVLOL§£R VHP HVVD OLEHUGDGH $ GRD§£R SRU H[HPSOR SRGH VHU UHYRJDGD PDV R SRGHU GH
UHYRJD§£RQ£RVHH[HUFHOLYUHPHQWHHVWDQGRFRQGLFLRQDGRDFDXVDVSHFXOLDUHV1HVWHFDVRDUHYRJD§£RFRQIXQGHVHFRPDUHVROX§£R
SRUTXHGHSHQGHGHFRQGL§£RUHVROXWLYDDVHUDSUHFLDGDSHORMXL]ߢ
E5HQºQFLD
&RPR D RXWUD IDFH GD PRHGD FRPSUHHQGHPRV TXH R VHQWLGR TXH VH G¡ DR YRF¡EXOR ߡUHQºQFLDߢ HP
PDW©ULD GH H[WLQ§£R FRQWUDWXDO QDGD PDLV © GR TXH D UHVLOL§£R FRQWUDWXDO SRU LQLFLDWLYD XQLODWHUDO GR
VXMHLWRSDVVLYRGDUHOD§£RREULJDFLRQDOVHQGRWDPE©PHVSHFLDOPHQWHDSOLF¡YHODDOJXPDVPRGDOLGDGHV
FRQWUDWXDLV
R FDVR SRU H[HPSOR WDPE©P QR FRQWUDWR GH PDQGDWR GD UHQºQFLD GR PDQGDW¡ULR QD IRUPD
GHWHUPLQDGDQRDUWGR&&TXHWDPE©PSUHYªOLPLWD§µHVDRVHXH[HUFFLR
1RHQVLQDPHQWRGH25/$1'2*20(6
ߡ3RVWRTXHVHMDXQLODWHUDODUHQºQFLDSHUWHQFH FDWHJRULDGRVQHJ³FLRVH[WLQWLYRVDSUHVHQWDQGRVHQRUPDOPHQWHFRPRFRPSRUWDPHQWR
DEGLFDWLYR GHVWLQDGR D H[WLQJXLU XPD UHOD§£R MXUGLFD SHOD DXWRHOLPLQD§£R GH XP GRV VHXV VXMHLWRV R DWLYR 1R GLUHLWR GDV REULJD§µHV D
UHPLVV£RGDGYLGD©DILJXUDPDLVFDUDFWHUVWLFDGDUHQºQFLD1RPDQGDWRWDQWRRPDQGDQWHSRGHGHVYLQFXODUVHGRFRQWUDWRUHYRJDQGR
RVSRGHUHVGRPDQGDW¡ULRFRPRHVWHFRPDPHVPDOLEHUGDGHGHD§£RVHOLEHUDUHQXQFLDQGRRV([HUFHGHVWHPRGRRSRGHUGHUHVLOLU
XQLODWHUDOPHQWH R FRQWUDWRSHORTXHLQGHIHULPRVDSRVWXOD§£RGR LWHP ߝDߞ GD LQDXJXUDO 'HYHQRWLILFDU VXD LQWHQ§£R DR PDQGDQWH H HP
FHUWRVFDVRVDJXDUGDUVXEVWLWXWR'DUHQºQFLDGLVWLQJXHPVHRVQHJ³FLRVRPLVVLYRVFRPRRUHSºGLRߢ
E5HVJDWH
([HPSORFO¡VVLFRHGLIXQGLGRGHUHVJDWHHQFRQWU¡YDPRVQR&³GLJR&LYLODQWHULRUTXDQGRSUHFHLWXDYD
DFHUFD GR LQVWLWXWR GD HQILWHXVH GLUHLWR UHDO QD FRLVD DOKHLD Q£R PDLV GLVFLSOLQDGR SHOD FRGLILFD§£R
QDFLRQDO
$OL¡VREVHUYDDHVVHUHVSHLWR3$%/2672/=(*$*/,$12TXH
ߡ'DGR R VHX FDU¡WHU GH SHUSHWXLGDGH H SRU LPLWDU R GLUHLWR GH SURSULHGDGH VHP VªOR R QRYR &³GLJR &LYLO FRUUHWDPHQWH S´V ILP
HQILWHXVHVXEVWLWXLQGRDSHORGLUHLWRUHDOGHVXSHUIFLHPDLVGLQ¢PLFRHGHFDU¡WHUWHPSRU¡ULRߢ
7UDGX]LD SRLV HVWH UHVJDWH R H[HUFFLR GH XP GLUHLWR SRWHVWDWLYR HQW£R SUHYLVWR QR DUW GR
&&FRPDVHJXLQWHUHGD§£R
ߡ$UW7RGRVRVDIRUDPHQWRVLQFOXVLYHRVFRQVWLWXGRVDQWHULRUPHQWHDHVWH&³GLJRVDOYRDFRUGRHQWUHDVSDUWHVV£RUHVJDW¡YHLV
GH]DQRVGHSRLVGHFRQVWLWXGRVPHGLDQWHSDJDPHQWRGHXPODXGªPLRTXHVHU¡GHGRLVHPHLRSRUFHQWRVREUHRYDORUDWXDOGD
SURSULHGDGH SOHQD H GH GH] SHQVµHV DQXDLV SHOR IRUHLUR TXH Q£R SRGHU¡ QR VHX FRQWUDWR UHQXQFLDU DR GLUHLWR GH UHVJDWH QHP
FRQWUDULDUDVGLVSRVL§µHVLPSHUDWLYDVGHVWH&DSWXORߢ
1D DWXDO FRGLILFD§£R FRQWXGR D H[SUHVV£R VRPHQWH © XWLOL]DGD HP RXWUR FRQWH[WR PDLV
HVSHFLILFDPHQWH QR H[HUFFLR GD UHWURYHQGD UHIHULQGRVH DR UHWRUQR GR EHP DR YHQGHGRU FRQIRUPH VH
YHULILFDGHXPDVLPSOHVOHLWXUDGRVDUWVH
ߡ$UW2YHQGHGRUGHFRLVDLP³YHOSRGHUHVHUYDUVHRGLUHLWRGHUHFREU¡ODQRSUD]RP¡[LPRGHGHFDGªQFLDGHWUªVDQRVUHVWLWXLQGRR
SUH§R UHFHELGR H UHHPEROVDQGR DV GHVSHVDV GR FRPSUDGRU LQFOXVLYH DV TXH GXUDQWH R SHURGR GH UHVJDWH VH HIHWXDUDP FRP D VXD
DXWRUL]D§£RHVFULWDRXSDUDDUHDOL]D§£RGHEHQIHLWRULDVQHFHVV¡ULDV
$UW 6H R FRPSUDGRU VH UHFXVDU D UHFHEHU DV TXDQWLDV D TXH ID] MXV R YHQGHGRU SDUD H[HUFHU R GLUHLWR GH UHVJDWH DV GHSRVLWDU¡
MXGLFLDOPHQWHߢJULIRVQRVVRV
$UHWURYHQGDHPYHUGDGH©XPDFO¡XVXODHVSHFLDO FRPSUDHYHQGDTXHOLPLWDDVXDHILF¡FLDXPD
YH]TXHVXEPHWHRQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRDXPDFRQGL§£RUHVROXWLYDH[SUHVVDVHQGRFRQVLGHUDGRSRUQ³VXPD
PRGDOLGDGHGHH[WLQ§£RQDWXUDOGRFRQWUDWR
1DDQWHULRUKLS³WHVHGDHQILWHXVHSRUWDQWRHVSHFLDOPHQWHTXDQGRGHFRUUHQWHGHXPFRQWUDWRILUPDGR
HQWUH DV SDUWHV RX QD VLWXD§£R DWXDOPHQWH SUHYLVWD GD UHWURYHQGD SRGHPRV REVHUYDU HVSHFLDLV
PRGDOLGDGHVGHUHVLOL§£R PDQLIHVWDGDVSRUPHLRGRGLUHLWRGHUHVJDWH
5HVROX§£R
(PERUDDOHJLVOD§£RFRGLILFDGDSRUYH]HVXWLOL]HDH[SUHVV£RHPRXWURVVHQWLGRV RIDWR©TXHD
WHRULD JHUDO GRV FRQWUDWRV UHVHUYD SDUD R YRF¡EXOR ߡUHVROX§£Rߢ R VLJQLILFDGR GH H[WLQ§£R FRQWUDWXDO
IXQGDPHQWDGDQRGHVFXPSULPHQWRGRSDFWXDGR
6HRFRQWUDWR©IHLWRSDUDVHUFXPSULGRDQ£RUHDOL]D§£RGDSUHVWD§£RFRPRSDFWXDGDSRGHHQVHMDU
VLPDSULRULDFULW©ULRGDSDUWHOHVDGDSRUVXDSURYRFD§£RRGHVID]LPHQWRGDUHOD§£RREULJDFLRQDO
$H[SUHVV£RߡSRGHߢ©DTXLPDLVXPDYH]XWLOL]DGDHPVHXVHQWLGRW©FQLFRSRLVQDQRYDYLV£RTXHVH
SURSXJQD SDUD R GLUHLWR REULJDFLRQDO GHYHVH VHPSUH SUHVWLJLDU D WXWHOD HVSHFILFD GD REULJD§£R FDVR
VHMD SRVVYHO D SUHVWD§£R H DLQGD KDMD LQWHUHVVH QHOD SHOD SDUWH OHVDGD UHDOL]DQGRVH D LQWHQ§£R
GHFODUDGDDRVHFHOHEUDUDDYHQ§D
$OJXPDVSDODYUDVVREUHDYROXQWDULHGDGHGDLQH[HFX§£R
3DUD HIHLWR GH UHVROX§£R GR FRQWUDWR SRXFR LPSRUWD VH D LQH[HFX§£R VH GHX YROXQW¡ULD RX
LQYROXQWDULDPHQWH
'HIDWR VHMDSHODUHFXVDߚ MXVWLILFDGD RX Q£Rߚ GR GHYHGRU VHMD SRU IDWRV DOKHLRV VXD YRQWDGH
FRPRSRUH[HPSORQRFDVRIRUWXLWRRXGHIRU§DPDLRUVHPSUHVHU¡SRVVYHODRLQWHUHVVDGRSDUWHOHVDGD
SHORGHVFXPSULPHQWRSHGLUDUHVROX§£RGRFRQWUDWRH[WLQJXLQGRVHRYQFXORFRQWUDWXDO
1HFHVV¡ULRVHID]SRU©PYHULILFDUVHK¡UD]RDELOLGDGHQRLQFXPSULPHQWRSDUDHIHLWRGHYHULILFD§£RGD
UHVSRQVDELOLGDGHFLYLOSRUWDODWRSHORTXHUHPHWHPRVWDOGLVFXVV£RSDUDXPFDSWXORSU³SULR
2 WHPD GR GHVFXPSULPHQWR GR FRQWUDWR HQVHMDQGR D VXD UHVROX§£R GHVSHUWD QD UHDOLGDGH Y¡ULRV
WHPDVDFHVV³ULRVFRPR©RFDVRSRUH[HPSORQRVFRQWUDWRVELODWHUDLVHPTXHRLQDGLPSOHPHQWRGHXPD
SDUWH DXWRUL]D R Q£R FXPSULPHQWR GH SUHVWD§£R FRUUHVSRQGHQWH SHOD RXWUD FDUDFWHUL]DQGR D H[FH§£R
VXEVWDQFLDOGRFRQWUDWRQ£RFXPSULGRH[FHSWLRQRQDGLPSOHWLFRQWUDFWXV
'DPHVPDPDQHLUDDUHVROX§£RGRFRQWUDWRSRGHGHFRUUHUGDLPSRVVLELOLGDGHGHVHXFXPSULPHQWRSRU
RQHURVLGDGH H[FHVVLYD HP YLUWXGH GH DFRQWHFLPHQWRV H[WUDRUGLQ¡ULRV H LPSUHYLVWRV WHPD DOL¡V TXH
SRGHHQVHMDULQFOXVLYHDUHGLVFXVV£RGDVVXDVSUHVWD§µHVMXVWDPHQWHSDUDHYLWDUDVXDH[WLQ§£R
'DGDDLPSRUW¢QFLDGHVVHVGRLVºOWLPRVDVSHFWRVGLVFLSOLQDGRVH[SUHVVDPHQWHSHOR&³GLJR&LYLOGH
ߚ R VHJXQGR LQFOXVLYH GH IRUPD LQRYDGRUD ߚ SRU XPD TXHVW£R PHWRGRO³JLFD YDPRV WUDW¡ORV
WDPE©PHPFDSWXORVDXW´QRPRV
&O¡XVXODUHVROXW³ULDH[SUHVVDRXW¡FLWD
$V SDUWHV SRGHP SUHYHU QR SU³SULR FRQWHºGR GR FRQWUDWR TXH FDVR KDMD GHVFXPSULPHQWR VHU¡ HOH
FRQVLGHUDGRH[WLQWR
7UDWDVH GD FKDPDGD ߡFO¡XVXOD UHVROXWLYD RX UHVROXW³ULD H[SUHVVDߢ RX ߡSDFWR FRPLVV³ULR
H[SUHVVRߢ TXHJHUDHIHLWRGLVVROXW³ULRGDUHOD§£RFRQWUDWXDO
4XDQGR FRQWXGR DV SDUWHV QHP VHTXHU FRJLWDUDP DFHUFD GR LQDGLPߓSOHPHQWR FRQWUDWXDO IDODVH GH
PDQHLUDGLVWLQWDQDSUHH[LVWªQFLDGHXPDFO¡XߓVXODUHVROXW³ULDW¡FLWD SRLVHPWRGRFRQWUDWRELODWHUDO
SRU IRU§D GD LQWHUGHߓSHQGªQFLD GDV REULJD§µHV R GHVFXPSULPHQWR FXOSRVR SRU XPD GDV SDUWHV GHYH
FRQVWLWXLUMXVWDFDXVDSDUDDUHVROX§£RGRFRQWUDWRXPDYH]TXHVHXP©FDXVDGRRXWURGHL[DQGRVHGH
FXPSULURSULPHLURSHUGHULDRVHQWLGRRFXPSULPHQWRGRVHJXQGR
7DOLQVWLWXWRHVW¡SUHYLVWRH[SUHVVDPHQWHQR&³GLJR&LYLOEUDVLOHLURHVSHFLILFDPHQWHQRVHXDUW
ߡ$UW$FO¡XVXODUHVROXWLYDH[SUHVVDRSHUDGHSOHQRGLUHLWRDW¡FLWDGHSHQGHGHLQWHUSHOD§£RMXGLFLDOߢ
$SODXGLPRVDQRYDGLVFLSOLQDOHJDOSRLVH[SOLFLWRXWUDWDUVHGHXPDFO¡XVXODUHVROXWLYDPRGLILFDQGR
DH[SUHVV£RDQWHULRUFRQGL§£RUHVROXWLYDFRQVWDQWHGRSDU¡JUDIRºQLFRGRDUWGR&&RTXH
QRVVRDPDLVW©FQLFRSHODGLILFXOGDGHGHVHLPDJLQDUXPHOHPHQWROLPLWDGRUGDHILF¡FLDLPSOLFLWDPHQWH
FRQWLGDHPXPQHJ³FLRMXUGLFR
(SRUTXHQ£RVHLQFOXLUGHQWURGDYLV£RHVTXHP¡WLFDDTXLSURSXJQDGDWDODVVXQWRQDSDUWHUHIHUHQWH
H[WLQ§£RQDWXUDOGRFRQWUDWRKDMDYLVWDTXHIRUDPDVSU³SULDVSDUWHVTXHM¡DQWHYLUDPWDOSRVVLELOLGDGH"
-XVWDPHQWH SRUTXH QD YLV£R ©WLFD TXH GHIHQGHPRV SDUD DV UHOD§µHV FRQWUDWXDLV Q£R QRV SDUHFH
DFHLW¡YHO LPDJLQDU TXH SHOD ERDI© REMHWLYD DOJX©P SDFWXH XPD UHOD§£R FRQWUDWXDO M¡ FRP D ILUPH
LQWHQ§£RGHQ£RFXPSULOD
$ FRQFHS§£R GD FO¡XVXOD UHVROXW³ULD H[SUHVVD GHYH VHU DFHLWD Q£R SHOD LGHLD GH TXH R FRQWUDWR IRL
FHOHEUDGR SDUD Q£R VHU FXPSULGR PDV VLP MXVWDPHQWH SRU XPD TXHVW£R GH FDXWHOD QR FDVR GH
LQDGLPSOHPHQWR HP IXQ§£R GH HYHQWXDLV VLWXD§µHV VXSHUYHQLHQWHV R TXH VH PRVWUD PDLV HYLGHQWH QRV
FRQWUDWRVGHH[HFX§£RGLIHULGDRXGHGXUD§£R
3RU WDLV IXQGDPHQWRV GLYHUJLPRV QHVWH SDUWLFXODU GR GLOHWR DPLJR &$5/26 52%(572
*21$/9(6TXHHOHQFDDFO¡XVXODUHVROXWLYDH[SUHVVDFRPRXPDFDXVDFRQWHPSRU¢QHD IRUPD§£RGR
FRQWUDWR (PYHUGDGHHPERUDFRQFHELGDQDFHOHEUD§£RGDDYHQ§DDFDXVDVRPHQWHVHPDWHULDOL]D
ߚHGHIRUPDVHPSUHLQGHVHMDGDHPERUDDGPLWLGDߚFRPRGHVFXPSULPHQWRGDREULJD§£RSDFWXDGD
5HVROX§£RSUHVVXSµHLQDGLPSOHPHQWRGHDOJRH[LJYHO
(LQDGLPSOHPHQWR©DOJRTXHQXQFDSRGHVHUFRQVLGHUDGRQRUPDORXFRQWHPSRU¢QHRDRFRQWUDWR
3RULVVRPHVPRDH[SUHVV£RߡGHSOHQRGLUHLWRߢGHYHVHULQWHUSUHWDGDFRPDGHYLGDUHVVDOYDSRLVHOD
Q£RTXHUGL]HUTXHRFRUUHQGRRLQDGLPSOHPHQWRRFRQWUDWRHVW¡DXWRPDWLFDPHQWHH[WLQWR
3HQVDUGHVVDIRUPDVHULDSUHVWLJLDURLQDGLPSOHQWHRTXH©LQDGPLVVYHO
$VVLPRTXHVHGHYHWHUHPPHQWH©TXHRFRUUHQGRRLQDGLPSOHPHQWRDSDUWHOHVDGDWHPRGLUHLWRGH
H[LJLU R VHX FXPSULPHQWR KDMD YLVWD TXH D WXWHOD HVSHFILFD GDV REULJD§µHVGHYH VHUDUHJUDHP QRVVR
RUGHQDPHQWR RX Q£R VHQGR PDLV SRVVYHO D SUHVWD§£R RX Q£R KDYHQGR PDLV LQWHUHVVH HP VHX
FXPSULPHQWRDGHFODUD§£RMXGLFLDOGDVXDUHVROX§£R
(VVD©DOLQKDGRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLOEUDVLOHLUR
ߡ$UW$SDUWHOHVDGDSHORLQDGLPSOHPHQWRSRGHSHGLUDUHVROX§£RGRFRQWUDWRVHQ£RSUHIHULUH[LJLUOKHRFXPSULPHQWRFDEHQGRHP
TXDOTXHUGRVFDVRVLQGHQL]D§£RSRUSHUGDVHGDQRVߢ
'HVVD IRUPD KDYHQGR R LQDGLPSOHPHQWR H RSWDQGR D SDUWH OHVDGD SHOD UHVROX§£R GXDV VLWXD§µHV
SRGHU£RDGYLU
D +¡ FO¡XVXOD UHVROXW³ULD H[SUHVVD QHVVH FDVR XPD PDQLIHVWD§£R MXGLFLDO WHU¡ HIHLWR PHUDPHQWH GHFODUDW³ULR RSHUDQGRVH H[ WXQF $
SURYRFD§£R GR (VWDGR-XL] VRPHQWH VH ID] QHFHVV¡ULD SDUD DVVHJXUDU XPD FHUWH]D MXUGLFD R TXH © HP HVVªQFLD D ILQDOLGDGH GH
TXDOTXHUSRVWXOD§£RGHQDWXUH]DGHFODUDW³ULD$GHPDLVSRGHPVHFXPXODUSUHWHQVµHVSRVWXOD§µHVFRQGHQDW³ULDVDRH[LJLUUHVWLWXL§£R
GHSDUFHODVSDJDVGHYROX§£RGHEHQVHLQGHQL]D§£RSHODH[WLQ§£RGRFRQWUDWR
E 1£R K¡ FO¡XVXOD UHVROXW³ULD H[SUHVVD QHVVH FDVR HQWHQGHVH VHU LPSUHVFLQGYHO D LQWHUSHOD§£R MXGLFLDO SDUD GHVFRQVWLWXLU R YQFXOR
FRQWUDWXDOXPDYH]TXHQ£R©UD]R¡YHOVHLPDJLQDUTXHHPXPFRQWUDWRVLQDODJP¡WLFRXPDGDVSDUWHVWHQKDGHFRQWLQXDUDFXPSULUD
VXDSUHVWD§£RVHDRXWUDVHDEVW©PGHWDOPLVWHU$ILQDOLGDGHGHWDOLQWHUSHOD§£R©MXVWDPHQWHFLHQWLILFDUDSDUWHFRQWU¡ULDGDLQWHQ§£R
GHFRQVLGHUDUUHVROYLGRRFRQWUDWRSRGHQGRVHUVXSULGDSRURXWUDIRUPDGHFLHQWLILFD§£R
5HVVDOWHVHTXHHPERUDLQDGLPSOHQWHRGHYHGRUQ£RVHSRGHWROHUDUTXHRFUHGRUTXHLUDUHVROYHUR
FRQWUDWRUHDYHQGREHQVDOLHQDGRVHPSUHVWD§µHVVHPDGHYROX§£RFRPDVGHYLGDVFRPSHQVD§µHVGDV
SDUFHODVSDJDV1HVVHVHQWLGRHVWDEHOHFHR&³GLJRGH'HIHVDGR&RQVXPLGRU
ߡ$UW 1RV FRQWUDWRV GH FRPSUD H YHQGD GH P³YHLV RX LP³YHLV PHGLDQWH SDJDPHQWR HP SUHVWD§µHV EHP FRPR QDV DOLHQD§µHV
ILGXFL¡ULDV HP JDUDQWLD FRQVLGHUDPVH QXODV GH SOHQR GLUHLWR DV FO¡XVXODV TXH HVWDEHOH§DP D SHUGD WRWDO GDV SUHVWD§µHV SDJDV HP
EHQHIFLRGRFUHGRUTXHHPUD]£RGRLQDGLPSOHPHQWRSOHLWHDUDUHVROX§£RGRFRQWUDWRHDUHWRPDGDGRSURGXWRDOLHQDGR
hz9HWDGR
hz1RVFRQWUDWRVGRVLVWHPDGHFRQV³UFLRGHSURGXWRVGXU¡YHLVDFRPSHQVD§£RRXDUHVWLWXL§£RGDVSDUFHODVTXLWDGDVQDIRUPDGHVWH
DUWLJR WHU¡ GHVFRQWDGD DO©P GD YDQWDJHP HFRQ´PLFD DXIHULGD FRP D IUXL§£R RV SUHMX]RV TXH R GHVLVWHQWH RX LQDGLPSOHQWH FDXVDU DR
JUXSR
hz2VFRQWUDWRVGHTXHWUDWDRFDSXWGHVWHDUWLJRVHU£RH[SUHVVRVHPPRHGDFRUUHQWHQDFLRQDOߢ
5HJLVWUHVH DLQGD TXH QR FDPSR GD GLVFLSOLQD OHJDO RX GD DXWRQRPLD GD YRQWDGH © SRVVYHO R
HVWDEHOHFLPHQWR GH UHJUDV SDUD D SXUJD§£R GD PRUD DIDVWDQGR D UHVROX§£R FRQWUDWXDO R TXH GHYH VHU
DQDOLVDGRQRFDVRFRQFUHWREHPFRPRVHUDGPLVVYHOSRUH[FH§£RTXHDUHVROX§£RGRFRQWUDWRVHGª
SRULQLFLDWLYDGDTXHOHTXHQ£RFRQVHJXLXDGLPSOLOR
5HVFLV£R
6HK¡XPDPRGDOLGDGHGHH[WLQ§£RFRQWUDWXDOHPTXHVHFRQVWDWDSURIXQGDLPSUHFLV£RWHUPLQRO³JLFDH
GHVYLRVWHRU©WLFRVQ£RK¡PHQRUGºYLGDGHTXH©ߡUHVFLV£Rߢ
'RSRQWRGHYLVWDJUDPDWLFDODH[SUHVV£RHQFRQWUDDVVHJXLQWHVDFHS§µHV
%DVHDGD QRV HQVLQDPHQWRV GH 0(66,1(2 SRU©P ERD SDUWH GD GRXWULQD FLYLOLVWD EUDVLOHLUD
HVSHFLDOL]DGD LGHQWLILFDRWHUPRUHVFLV£RWHFQLFDPHQWHFRPRDIRUPDGHH[WLQ§£RGHFRQWUDWRVHP
TXHWHQKDRFRUULGROHV£RRXFHOHEUDGRVVREHVWDGRGHSHULJR
2EVHUYDQGRWDOFRQIXV£RUHJLVWUD6/9,29(126$TXH
ߡUHVFLV£R©SDODYUDTXHWUD]HQWUHQ³VDQR§£RGHH[WLQ§£RGDUHOD§£RFRQWUDWXDOSRUFXOSD2ULJLQDOPHQWHYLQKDOLJDGDW£RV³DRLQVWLWXWR
GD OHV£R 1R HQWDQWR JHUDOPHQWH TXDQGR XPD SDUWH LPSXWD RXWUD R GHVFXPSULPHQWR GH XP FRQWUDWR SHGH D UHVFLV£R HP MX]R H D
VHQWHQ§DGHFUHWDD2VLQWHUHVVDGRVQRHQWDQWRXVDPFRPIUHTXªQFLDRWHUPRFRPRPHVPRVHQWLGRGHUHVLOLULVWR©WHUPLQDUDDYHQ§D
GHFRPXPDFRUGRGLVWUDWDURTXHIRLFRQWUDWDGR1DGDLPSHGHTXHDVVLPVHXWLOL]HQXPFRVWXPHDUUDLJDGRHPQRVVRVQHJ³FLRVߢ
(SRUPDLVFRQWUDGLW³ULRTXHSRVVDSDUHFHURSU³SULR&³GLJR&LYLOGHXWLOL]DDH[SUHVV£RHP
GLYHUVRVFRQWH[WRVVHPXPHOHPHQWRFRPXPTXHRVXQD
0,*8(/ 0$5,$ '( 6(53$ /23(6 DS³V UHJLVWUDU D FRQIXV£R WHUPLQRO³JLFD H[LVWHQWH SUHIHUH
FRQFOXLUTXHHPQRVVR'LUHLWRDUHVFLV£RGHYHGHIDWRVHUWUDWDGDFRPRFDXVDH[WLQWLYDGRFRQWUDWRHP
FDVRGHQXOLGDGHVHJXLQGRDOLQKDGR&³GLJR&LYLOIUDQFªV
$VVLPQDSULPHLUDDFHS§£RUHVFLV£RVHULDXPDFDXVDVXSHUYHQLHQWH IRUPD§£RGRFRQWUDWR(PERUD
LPSUHFLVDWUDWDVHGDIRUPDPDLVXWLOL]DGDQDSU¡WLFDPRWLYRSHORTXDOSUHIHULPRVPHWRGRORJLFDPHQWH
WUDWDUQHVWHW³SLFRRLQVWLWXWR7RGDYLDSDUDTXHQ£RVHMDPRVDFXVDGRVGHFROLGLUDVFODVVLILFD§µHVIHLWDV
HVFODUHFHPRVTXHVHXWLOL]DGDQRVHQWLGRFO¡VVLFRGHFDXVDH[WLQWLYDGRFRQWUDWRHPFDVRGHQXOLGDGH
UHVFLV£RREYLDPHQWHVHU¡XPDFDXVDDQWHULRURXFRQWHPSRU¢QHD IRUPD§£RGRFRQWUDWR
0RUWHGRFRQWUDWDQWH
3RUILPID]VHPLVWHUWHFHUDOJXPDVFRQVLGHUD§µHVDFHUFDGRVHIHLWRVGDPRUWHGHXPGRVFRQWUDWDQWHV
SDUDDUHOD§£RMXUGLFDREULJDFLRQDO
&RPRREVHUYD25/$1'2*20(6
ߡ(QWUH DV FDXVDV GH H[WLQ§£R GRV FRQWUDWRV D PRUWH GH XP GRV FRQWUDWDQWHV RFXSD OXJDU SDUWH 6XD LQFOXV£R QRV RXWURV PRGRV GH
GLVVROX§£RQ£RWHPUHDOPHQWHFDELPHQWR1£R©SRVVYHODILUPDUVHTXHUHVROYHRFRQWUDWR6HPGºYLGDLPSRVVLELOLWDVXDH[HFX§£RRX
ID]FHVV¡ODGHILQLWLYDPHQWHPDVDULJRUQ£RSRGHVHUFRQVLGHUDGDLQH[HFX§£RLQYROXQW¡ULDSRUTXHVHXVHIHLWRVQ£RVHLJXDODPDRVGR
FDVRIRUWXLWR1£RVHMXVWLILFDWDPE©PHQTXDGU¡ODHQWUHDVFDXVDVGHUHVLOL§£RFRPRSURFHGHDGRXWULQDIUDQFHVDSRLVDUHVLOL§£RVH
FDUDFWHUL]DSRUVHUFRQVHTXªQFLDGHPDQLIHVWD§£RGDYRQWDGHGHXPRXGRVGRLVFRQWUDWDQWHVߢ
'HIDWRDPRUWHGHXPDGDVSDUWHVVRPHQWHFRQVWLWXLFDXVDGHGLVVROX§£RGRFRQWUDWRQDTXHODVDYHQ§DV
SHUVRQDOVVLPDV FRQWUDGDV MXVWDPHQWH HP IXQ§£R GD SHVVRD GR FRQWUDWDQWH LQWXLWX SHUVRQDH
HTXLSDUDQGRVH LQFDSDFLGDGHVXSHUYHQLHQWH 6RPHQWH QHVWHV FDVRV SRGHVHU DSOLFDGR R EURFDUGR
ODWLQRPRUVRPQLDVROYLW
0HVPRDVVLPRSHUDQGRVHDH[WLQ§£RGDDYHQ§DWHU¡SURGX]LGRVHXVHIHLWRVQRUPDOPHQWHDW©RHYHQWR
PRUWHQ£RWHQGRSRUWDQWRHIHLWRUHWURDWLYRH[WXQFPDVVLPREYLDPHQWHH[QXQFRTXHVHWRUQDPDLV
HYLGHQWHQRVFRQWUDWRVGHH[HFX§£RFRQWLQXDGDRXSHUL³GLFD
1DV GHPDLV VLWXD§µHV I¡WLFDV DV REULJD§µHV FRQWUDWXDLV EHP FRPR RV GLUHLWRV FRUUHVSRQGHQWHV
WUDQVPLWHPVHDRVKHUGHLURVGRGHFXMXV
&DVRIRUWXLWRRXIRU§DPDLRU
$SHQDVFRPDILQDOLGDGHGHGDUFRPSOHWXGH QRVVDFODVVLILFD§£RGHYHPRVOHPEUDUTXHKLS³WHVHVGH
FDVRIRUWXLWRRXIRU§DPDLRUWDPE©PHQVHMDPDH[WLQ§£RGRFRQWUDWR
$ PDW©ULD M¡ IRL SRU Q³V WUDWDGD DQWHULRUPHQWH PDV © LPSRUWDQWH UHDILUPDU TXH DPEDV DV KLS³WHVHV
IRUDPFRQGHQVDGDVHPFRQFHLWRºQLFRFRQIRUPHVHSRGHYHULILFDUGRDUWGR&&
ߡ$UW2GHYHGRUQ£RUHVSRQGHSHORVSUHMX]RVUHVXOWDQWHVGHFDVRIRUWXLWRRXIRU§DPDLRUVHH[SUHVVDPHQWHQ£RVHKRXYHUSRUHOHV
UHVSRQVDELOL]DGR
3DU¡JUDIRºQLFR2FDVRIRUWXLWRRXGHIRU§DPDLRUYHULILFDVHQRIDWRQHFHVV¡ULRFXMRVHIHLWRVQ£RHUDSRVVYHOHYLWDURXLPSHGLUߢ
+¡ SURIXQGD GLYHUJªQFLD QD HYHQWXDO GLVWLQ§£R FRQFHLWXDO HQWUH RV GRLV LQVWLWXWRV 6HP LQWHQ§£R GH
GLULPLOD LGHQWLILFDPRV QD IRU§D PDLRU D FDUDFWHUVWLFD GD LQHYLWDELOLGDGH H QR FDVR IRUWXLWR D QRWD
GLVWLQWLYDGDLPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH
1£R K¡ GLIHUHQ§D SUDJP¡WLFD SRU©P HQWUH RV LQVWLWXWRV TXH RFRUUHQGR QD YLJªQFLD GH XPD UHOD§£R
FRQWUDWXDODFDEDU£RSRUH[WLQJXLODVHP´QXV VSDUWHV
9DOHUHJLVWUDULQFOXVLYHDWWXORGHFXULRVLGDGHTXHDOJXPDVPRGDOLGDGHVFRQWUDWXDLVH[SUHVVDPHQWH
HOHQFDPDIRU§DPDLRUFRPRFDXVDH[WLQWLYD RTXHHPYHUGDGH©SHUIHLWDPHQWHGLVSHQV¡YHOWHQGR
HPYLVWDRSU³SULRVHQWLGRGRLQVWLWXWR
;;
(;&(2'(&2175$7212&8035,'2
&216,'(5$(6,1,&,$,6
8P WHPD H[WUHPDPHQWH UHOHYDQWH HP VHGH GH GLVFXVV£R VREUH H[WLQ§£R FRQWUDWXDO © D DSOLFD§£R GD
ߡH[FH§£RGHFRQWUDWRQ£RFXPSULGRߢH[FHSWLRQRQDGLPSOHWLFRQWUDFWXV
7UDWDVH GH LQVWLWXWR GH JUDQGH DSOLFDELOLGDGH SU¡WLFD TXH GDGD D VXD LPSRUW¢QFLD MXULVSUXGHQFLDO
PHUHFHVHUWUDWDGRHPFDSWXORSU³SULR
$PDW©ULDHVW¡GLVFLSOLQDGDQRVDUWVHGR&&TXHHVWLSXODP
ߡ6H§£R,,,
'D([FH§£RGH&RQWUDWRQ£R&XPSULGR
$UW1RVFRQWUDWRVELODWHUDLVQHQKXPGRVFRQWUDWDQWHVDQWHVGHFXPSULGDDVXDREULJD§£RSRGHH[LJLURLPSOHPHQWRGDGRRXWUR
$UW 6H GHSRLV GH FRQFOXGR R FRQWUDWR VREUHߓYLHU D XPD GDV SDUWHV FRQWUDWDQWHV GLPLQXL§£R HP VHX SDWULP´QLR FDSD] GH
FRPSURPHWHURXWRUQDUGXYLGRVDDSUHVWD§£RSHODTXDOVHREULJRXSRGHDRXWUDUHFXVDUVH SUHVWD§£RTXHOKHLQFXPEHDW©TXHDTXHOD
VDWLVID§DDTXHOKHFRPSHWHRXGªJDUDQWLDEDVWDQWHGHVDWLVID]ªODߢ
&RPSUHHQGDPRVVLVWHPDWLFDPHQWHRWHPDDSDUWLUGDHQXQFLD§£RGHVHXFRQFHLWR
&21&(,72(1$785(=$-85',&$
&RQVLVWHDߡH[FH§£RGHFRQWUDWRQ£RFXPSULGRߢHPXPPHLRGHGHIHVDSHORTXDODSDUWHGHPDQGDGD
SHODH[HFX§£RGHXPFRQWUDWRSRGHDUJXLUTXHGHL[RXGHFXPSULORSHORIDWRGDRXWUDDLQGDWDPE©PQ£R
WHUVDWLVIHLWRDSUHVWD§£RFRUUHVSRQGHQWH
&RPR VH LQIHUH WDO H[FH§£R VRPHQWH SRGH VHU DSOLFDGD QRV FKDPDGRV FRQWUDWRV ELODWHUDLV
VLQDODJP¡WLFRVRXGHSUHVWD§µHVFRUUHODWDVHPTXHVHWHPXPDSURGX§£RVLPXOW¢QHDGHSUHVWD§µHVSDUD
WRGRVRVFRQWUDWDQWHVSHODGHSHQGªQFLDUHFSURFDGDVREULJD§µHV
7UDWDVHSRUWDQWRGHXPDH[FH§£RVXEVWDQFLDOSDUDOLVDQGRDSUHWHQV£RGRDXWRUGHH[LJLUDSUHVWD§£R
SDFWXDGD DQWH D DOHJD§£R GR U©X GH Q£R KDYHU SHUFHELGR D FRQWUDSUHVWD§£R GHYLGD 1£R VH GLVFXWH D
SULRULRFRQWHºGRGRFRQWUDWRQHPVHQHJDDH[LVWªQFLDGDREULJD§£RRXVHSUHWHQGHH[WLQJXLODVHQGR
XPDFRQWHVWD§£RDSHQDVGRSRQWRGHYLVWDGDH[LJLELOLGDGH
6REUH DV H[FH§µHV VXEVWDQFLDLV GLVVHUWD )5(',( ',',(5 -5 DTXL WUDQVFULWR LQFOXVLYH FRP VXDV
UHIHUªQFLDVHPURGDS©
ߡ$H[FH§£RVXEVWDQFLDOSDUDVHUFRQKHFLGDSHORMXL]SUHFLVDVHUH[HUFLGDSHORGHPDQGDGR1£RSRGHGHUHJUDRPDJLVWUDGRFRQKHFHU
H[ RIILFLR GHVVD H[FH§£R 1£R DOHJDGD D H[FH§£R VXEVWDQFLDO QR PRPHQWR GD FRQWHVWD§£R RFRUUH D SUHFOXV£R VDOYR VH D OHL
H[SUHVVDPHQWHSHUPLWLUDDOHJD§£RDTXDOTXHUWHPSRRTXH©UDURH[SUHVFUL§£RDUWGR&&$H[FH§£RRSHUDQRSODQRGD
HILF¡FLD Q£RSUHWHQGHRGHPDQGDGRH[WLQJXLUDSUHWHQV£RFRQWUDVLH[HUFLGDPDVDSHQDVUHWLUDUOKHDHILF¡FLD4XHPH[FHWXDQ£R
QHJDDHILF¡FLDEXVFDQHXWUDOL]¡ODRXUHWDUG¡OD $H[FH§£RFRPRUHYHUVRGDSUHWHQV£RSUHVFUHYHQRPHVPRSUD]RGHVWDDUW
GR && 6£R H[FH§µHV VXEVWDQFLDLV SRU H[HPSOR D SUHVFUL§£R R GLUHLWR GH UHWHQ§£R H D H[FH§£R GH FRQWUDWR Q£R
FXPSULGRߢ
7UDWDVH WDPE©P GH XP LQVWUXPHQWR EDVWDQWH ºWLO SDUD IRU§DU R GHYHGRU D FXPSULU D VXD REULJD§£R
XPDYH]TXHDUHFXVDGHSDJDPHQWRGDREULJD§£RSRGHFRPSHOLORDWDOILP
5HJLVWUHVH DLQGD FRP 6,/9,2 52'5,*8(6 TXH D ߡH[FHSWLR QRQ DGLPSOHWL FRQWUDFWXV SRGH VHU
LQYRFDGD TXDOTXHU TXH VHMD D FDXVD JHUDGRUD GR LQDGLPSOHPHQWR GR FRQWUDWR 4XHU D UHFXVD GH
FXPSULPHQWRVHIXQGHQDP¡YRQWDGHGRFRQWUDWDQWHTXHUQDIRU§DPDLRURXQRFDVRIRUWXLWRHPDPEDVDV
KLS³WHVHVDRXWUDSDUWHSRGHDGX]LUDH[FH§£R3RUTXHWHQGRXPDSUHVWD§£RVXDFDXVDQDRXWUDGHL[DQGR
DTXHODGHVHUFXPSULGDVHMDTXDOIRURPRWLYRFHVVDGHH[LJLUDFDXVDGHFXPSULPHQWRGDVHJXQGDߢ
3RUILP©SRVVYHOIDODUHPH[FH§£RGRFRQWUDWRSDUFLDOPHQWHFXPSULGRH[FHSWLRQRQULWHDGLPSOHWL
FRQWUDFWXVߚQRFDVRGHXPDGDVSDUWHVWHUFXPSULGRDSHQDVHPSDUWHRXGHIRUPDLPSHUIHLWDDVXD
REULJD§£RTXDQGRVHFRPSURPHWHUDDFXPSULODLQWHJUDOPHQWHߚPDVHPYHUGDGHDVXDFRQFHS§£RHVW¡
DEUDQJLGDQDSULPHLUD
(/(0(1726&$5$&7(5,=$'25(6
3DUDIDFLOLWDUDFRPSUHHQV£RGRLQVWLWXWRGHVWULQFKHPRVTXDLVV£RRVHOHPHQWRVQHFHVV¡ULRVSDUDVXD
FDUDFWHUL]D§£R
D ([LVWªQFLD GH XP FRQWUDWR ELODWHUDO ߚ $ H[FHSWLR QRQ DGLPSOHWL FRQWUDFWXV HP VHQWLGR SU³SULR VRPHQWH SRGH VHU LQYRFDGD HP
FRQWUDWRVRQGHK¡XPDGHSHQGªQFLDUHFSURFDGDVREULJD§µHVHPTXHXPD©DFDXVDGHVHUGDRXWUDQ£RVHQGRDSOLF¡YHODSULRULSDUD
RXWUDVUHOD§µHVMXUGLFDV
E'HPDQGDGHXPDGDVSDUWHVSHORFXPSULPHQWRGRSDFWXDGRߚ6RPHQWHK¡VHQWLGRQDLQYRFD§£RGHXPDH[FH§£RVXEVWDQFLDOGHIHVD
HPVHQWLGRPDWHULDOVHK¡XPDSURYRFD§£RH[LJLQGRVHRFXPSULPHQWRSRLVQDLQ©UFLDGDVSDUWHVQ£RK¡TXHIDODUHPGHIHVD
F 3U©YLR GHVFXPSULPHQWR GD SUHVWD§£R SHOD SDUWH GHPDQGDQWH ߚ MXVWDPHQWH R SU©YLR GHVFXPSULPHQWR SHOD SDUWH GHPDQGDQWH TXH
DXWRUL]DRH[FLSLHQWHDVHYDOHUGDH[FHSWLRQRQDGLPSOHWLFRQWUDFWXVXPDYH]TXHWHQGRKDYLGRFXPSULPHQWRGDSUHVWD§£RQDIRUPD
FRPR SDFWXDGD D GHPDQGD SHOR VHX FXPSULPHQWR FRQVWLWXL R UHJXODU H[HUFFLR GH XP GLUHLWR SRWHVWDWLYR 5HVVDOWHVH TXH VH R
GHVFXPSULPHQWRIRLGHWHUFHLURHQ£RGDSDUWHFRQWUDWDQWHQ£RK¡FRPRLQYRFDUDH[FH§£R
5(675,2$3/,&$2'2,167,7872
$ GLVFLSOLQD OHJDO GD H[FHSWLR QRQ DGLPSOHWL FRQWUDFWXV QDGD GLVSXQKD VREUH D SRVVLELOLGDGH GH
UHVWUL§£R LQYRFD§£RGRLQVWLWXWR
1DGDLPSHGHSRU©PTXHSDUWLQGRVHGHVLWXD§µHVI¡WLFDVHPTXHDVSDUWHVHVWHMDPHPLJXDOGDGHRXD
UHVWUL§£RVHMDIHLWDHPLQWHUHVVHGDFROHWLYLGDGHVHMDHODUHDOL]DGD
RSRVLFLRQDPHQWRSRUH[HPSORGH&$5/2652%(572*21$/9(6
ߡ&RPRGHFRUUªQFLDGRSULQFSLRGDDXWRQRPLDGDYRQWDGHDGPLWHVHDYDOLGDGHGHFO¡XVXODFRQWUDWXDOTXHUHVWULQMDRGLUHLWRGHDVSDUWHV
VHXWLOL]DUHPGRDOXGLGRDUW7UDWDVHGDFO¡XVXODVROYHHWUHSHWHSHODTXDOREULJDVHRFRQWUDWDQWHDFXPSULUDVXDREULJD§£RPHVPR
GLDQWHGRGHVFXPSULPHQWRGDGRRXWURUHVLJQDQGRVHDSRVWHULRUPHQWHYROWDUVHFRQWUDHVWHSDUDSHGLURFXPSULPHQWRRXDVSHUGDVH
GDQRV,PSRUWDHPUHQºQFLDDRGLUHLWRGHRSRUDH[FH§£RGRFRQWUDWRQ£RFXPSULGR1£R©PXLWRFRPXPVHQGRHQFRQWUDGDHPDOJXQV
FRQWUDWRVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVSDUDSURWHJHUD$GPLQLVWUD§£R1DVUHOD§µHVGHFRQVXPRGHYHVHUHYLWDGDHPUD]£RGDFRPLQD§£RGHQXOLGDGH
DWRGDFO¡XVXODTXHFRORTXHRFRQVXPLGRUHPGHVYDQWDJHPH[DJHUDGD&'&DUWߢ
*$5$17,$'(&8035,0(172
&RPRYLVWRDH[FHSWLRQRQDGLPSOHWLFRQWUDFWXVSUHVVXSµHRGHVFXPSULPHQWRGDDYHQ§D
7RGDYLDFHOHEUDGRRFRQWUDWRVHKRXYHUIXQGDGRUHFHLRGHVHXIXWXURGHVFXPSULPHQWRSRUIRU§DGD
GLPLQXL§£R SRVWHULRU GR SDWULP´QLR GD SDUWH FRQWU¡ULD © SUHFLVR TXH VH ID§D DOJR SDUD UHVJXDUGDU R
LQWHUHVVHGRVFRQWUDHQWHV
3DUDLVVRSUHYªRDUWGR&&
ߡ$UW 6H GHSRLV GH FRQFOXGR R FRQWUDWR VREUHYLHU D XPD GDV SDUWHV FRQWUDWDQWHV GLPLQXL§£R HP VHX SDWULP´QLR FDSD] GH
FRPSURPHWHURXWRUQDUGXYLGRVDDSUHVWD§£RSHODTXDOVHREULJRXSRGHDRXWUDUHFXVDUVH SUHVWD§£RTXHOKHLQFXPEHDW©TXHDTXHOD
VDWLVID§DDTXHOKHFRPSHWHRXGªJDUDQWLDEDVWDQWHGHVDWLVID]ªODߢ
7UDWDVHGHXPDIRUPDGHSURWH§£RDRVLQWHUHVVHVGDTXHOHTXHSRUIRU§DGDUHOD§£RREULJDFLRQDOHVW¡
DGVWULWRDRFXPSULPHQWRGDSUHVWD§£RDQWHVGDSDUWHFRQWU¡ULDFRQVWLWXLQGRVHVHPDPHQRUGºYLGDHP
PHGLGDGDVPDLVMXVWDV
([HPSOLILFDQGRDPDW©ULDREVHUYD&$5/2652%(572*21$/9(6
ߡ3URFXUDVHDFDXWHODURVLQWHUHVVHVGRTXHGHYHSDJDUHPSULPHLUROXJDUSURWHJHQGRRFRQWUDDOWHUD§µHVGDVLWXD§£RSDWULPRQLDOGRRXWUR
FRQWUDWDQWH $XWRUL]DVH SRU H[HPSOR R YHQGHGRU D Q£R HQWUHJDU D PHUFDGRULD YHQGLGD VH DOJXP IDWR VXSHUYHQLHQWH FHOHEUD§£R GR
FRQWUDWRDFDUUHWDUGLPLQXL§£RFRQVLGHU¡YHOQRSDWULP´QLRGRFRPSUDGRUFDSD]GHWRUQDUGXYLGRVRRSRVWHULRUDGLPSOHPHQWRGHVXDSDUWH
QDDYHQ§DSRGHQGRDTXHOHQHVWHFDVRUHFODPDURSUH§RGHLPHGLDWRRXH[LJLUJDUDQWLDVXILFLHQWH
1DKLS³WHVHPHQFLRQDGDQ£RSRGHU¡RFRPSUDGRUH[LJLUGRYHQGHGRUDHQWUHJDGDPHUFDGRULDHQTXDQWRQ£RFXPSULUDVXDREULJD§£RGH
HIHWXDU R SDJDPHQWR GR SUH§R RX RIHUHFHU JDUDQWLD EDVWDQWH SDUD VDWLVID]ªOD 6H SURPRYHU D§£R MXGLFLDO SDUD HVVH ILP SRGHU¡ DTXHOH
RSRUDH[FH§£RGRFRQWUDWRQ£RFXPSULGRߢ
'DQGR RXWUR H[HPSOR LPDJLQHVH TXH DOJX©P FRQWUDWH D EDQGD ߡ&5221(56 ,1 &21&(57ߢ SDUD
ID]HUXPVKRZGHILQDOGHDQRHPXPDGHWHUPLQDGDFDVDGHHVSHW¡FXORVQRLQWHULRUGD%DKLD3RUIRU§D
GH XPD HQFKHQWH SRU©P R ORFDO ILFRX LQWHUGLWDGR SRU Y¡ULRV PHVHV JHUDQGR YLVYHO H VXEVWDQFLDO
SUHMX]R SDUD VHX SURSULHW¡ULR 2UD VHU¡ TXH YDOH D SHQD FRUUHU R ULVFR GH VH GHVORFDU SDUD D FLGDGH
ID]HUDDSUHVHQWD§£RHQ£RUHFHEHUDFRQWUDSUHVWD§£R"FODURTXHQ£RPRWLYRSHORTXDOGHYHRUHIHULGR
FRQMXQWRPXVLFDOH[LJLUJDUDQWLDVGRFXPSULPHQWRDQWHVGHVHDYHQWXUDUSHODVHVWUDGDVGDYLGD
$(;&(2'2&2175$7212&8035,'2($$'0,1,675$23%/,&$
3RUILPYDOHWHFHUDOJXPDVFRQVLGHUD§µHVVREUHDSRVVLELOLGDGHGHLQYRFD§£RGDH[FH§£RGRFRQWUDWR
Q£RFXPSULGRHPVHGHGHFRQWUDWRVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRV
1£RK¡DPHQRUGºYLGDGHTXHLVVRSRGHVHUIHLWRXQLODWHUDOPHQWHSHOD$GPLQLVWUD§£RPDVDSHUJXQWD
TXHVHID]©VHRSDUWLFXODUWDPE©PJR]DULDGHVVDSUHUURJDWLYD
,VVRSRUTXHHVWDEHOHFLGRRFRQWUDWRFRPD$GPLQLVWUD§£R3ºEOLFDRFRQWUDWDGRDVVXPHRSDSHOGHVHX
FRODERUDGRU DJLQGR FRPR WDO QR LQWHUHVVH GD FRPXQLGDGH TXH Q£R SRGH ILFDU SUHMXGLFDGD SHOD
SDUDOLVD§£RQDVXDH[HFX§£R
1DREVHUYD§£RGH0$5,$6</9,$=$1(//$',3,(752HVVD
ߡGRXWULQDVRIUHKRMHDOJXPDEUDQGDPHQWRSRLVM¡VHDFHLWDTXHDH[FHSWLRQRQDGLPSOHWLFRQWUDFWXVVHMDLQYRFDGDSHORSDUWLFXODUFRQWUD
D$GPLQLVWUD§£RHPERUDVHPDPHVPDDPSOLWXGHTXHDSUHVHQWDQRGLUHLWRSULYDGR1HVWHRVLQWHUHVVHVGDVSDUWHVV£RHTXLYDOHQWHVHVH
FRORFDP QR PHVPR S© GH LJXDOGDGH QR FRQWUDWR DGPLQLVWUDWLYR RV LQWHUHVVHV GDV SDUWHV V£R GLYHUVRV GHYHQGR HP GHWHUPLQDGDV
FLUFXQVW¢QFLDV SUHYDOHFHU R LQWHUHVVH SºEOLFR TXH LQFXPEH HP SULQFSLR $GPLQLVWUD§£R SURWHJHU 3RU LVVR R SDUWLFXODU GHYH FRPR
UHJUDGDUFRQWLQXLGDGHDRFRQWUDWRHYLWDQGRGHVSRQWHVXDSDUDOLVDUDH[HFX§£RGRFRQWUDWRM¡TXHDUHVFLV£RXQLODWHUDO©SUHUURJDWLYD
GD$GPLQLVWUD§£RRTXHRSDUWLFXODUSRGHHGHYHID]HUDW©PHVPRSDUDDFDXWHODUVHXVLQWHUHVVHV©SOHLWHDUDUHVFLV£RDGPLQLVWUDWLYDRX
MXGLFLDOPHQWHDJXDUGDQGRTXHHODVHMDGHIHULGDߢ
FODUR TXH HP FHUWDV VLWXD§µHV D FRQWLQXLGDGH GD SUHVWD§£R GHYH VHU YHULILFDGD GH DFRUGR FRP R
SULQFSLR GD UD]RDELOLGDGH SURSRUFLRQDOLGDGH SRLV SRGH LPSRVVLELOLWDU D H[HFX§£R GR FRQWUDWR RX
FDXVDUDRFRQWUDWDGRXPGHVHTXLOEULRHFRQ´PLFRGHWDOPRQWDTXHQ£RVHULDUDߓ]R¡YHOH[LJLUTXHIRVVHHOH
VXSRUWDGR SHOD GHVSURSRU§£R HQWUH HVVH VDFULIFLR H R LQWHUHVVH SºEOLFR D DWLQJLU SHOD H[HFX§£R GR
FRQWUDWR
$VVLPSDUHFHQRVSRUH[HPSORTXHDVSUHYLVµHVGRDUW;9H;9,GD/HLGH/LFLWD§µHV/HLQ
SRGHPDXWRUL]DUH[FHSFLRQDOPHQWHVHPWURFDGLOKRDDSOLFD§£RGDH[FH§£RGRFRQWUDWRQ£R
FXPSULGR
$W©SRUTXHQHVVDPHVPDOLQKDGHUDFLRFQLRWDPE©PQ£RVHDILJXUDMXVWRTXHR(VWDGRVHEHQHILFLH
FXVWDGRSDUWLFXODU
;;,
7(25,$'$,035(9,62(5(62/82325
21(526,'$'((;&(66,9$
,1752'82
$SHQDV SRU XPD TXHVW£R GH ULJRU WHUPLQRO³JLFR SDUHFHQRV UHOHYDQWH H[SOLFLWDU D GLIHUHQ§D HQWUH
7HRULDGD,PSUHYLV£R5HVROX§£RSRU2QHURVLGDGH([FHVVLYDH&O¡XVXOD5HEXV6LF6WDQWLEXV
$ߡ7HRULDGD,PSUHYLV£Rߢ©RVXEVWUDWRWH³ULFRTXHSHUPLWHUHGLVFXWLURVSUHFHLWRVFRQWLGRVHPXPD
UHOD§£RFRQWUDWXDOHPIDFHGDRFRUUªQFLDGHDFRQWHFLPHQWRVQRYRVLPSUHYLVYHLVSHODVSDUWHVHDHODV
Q£RLPSXW¡YHLV
7UDWDVH HP QRVVR SHQVDU GH XPD DSOLFD§£R GLUHWD GR SULQFSLR GD ERDI© SRLV DV SDUWHV GHYHP
EXVFDU QR FRQWUDWR DOFDQ§DU DV SUHVWD§µHV TXH RULJLQDOPHQWH VH FRPSURPHWHUDP GD IRUPD FRPR VH
REULJDUDP
-¡ D H[SUHVV£R ߡ&O¡XVXOD 5HEXV 6LF 6WDQWLEXVߢ UHPRQWD FRPR YLVWR D WHPSRV LPHPRULDLV 0HVPR
VHQGR HP YHUGDGH EDVWDQWH DQWHULRU FURQRORJLFDPHQWH FRQFHS§£R GD 7HRULD GD ,PSUHYLV£R VXD
ILQDOLGDGHDFDEDSRUVHUHYHODUXPDDSOLFD§£RGHODQRUHFRQKHFLPHQWRSUHWRULDQRQRVHQWLGRGHTXHHP
WRGR FRQWUDWR GH SUHVWD§µHV VXFHVVLYDV KDYHU¡ VHPSUH XPD FO¡XVXOD LPSOFLWD GH TXH D FRQYHQ§£R Q£R
SHUPDQHFH HP YLJRU VH DV FRLVDV Q£R SHUPDQHFHUHP UHEXV VLF VWDQWLEXV FRPR HUDP QR PRPHQWR GD
FHOHEUD§£R7DOFRQVWUX§£RWH³ULFDLQFOXVLYHIRLXPDGDVUHVSRQV¡YHLVSHODFRQVDJUD§£RMXULVSUXGHQFLDO
GDFRUUH§£RPRQHW¡ULDQRSDVDLQGDQD©SRFDHPTXHRWH[WRFRGLILFDGRSUHVWLJLDYDRQRPLQDOLVPR
3RU ILP TXDQGR VH IDOD HP ߡ5HVROX§£R SRU 2QHURVLGDGH ([FHVVLYDߢ H[SUHVV£R XWLOL]DGD SHOD DWXDO
FRGLILFD§£RFLYLOEUDVLOHLUDDUWVDGR&&VHPFRUUHVSRQGHQWHQDDQWHULRUM¡VHHVW¡D
LQYRFDU D H[WLQ§£R ߡUHVROX§£Rߢ GR FRQWUDWR HP IXQ§£R GR GHVFXPSULPHQWR LQYROXQW¡ULR SHOD RQHURߓ
VLGDGHH[FHVVLYDJHUDGDSRUFLUFXQVW¢QFLDVVXSHUYHQLHQWHV
$O©P GLVVR FRPR YHUHPRV D H[SUHVV£R ߡWHRULD GD RQHURVLGDGH H[FHVVLYDߢ HPERUD FDOFDGD HP
IXQGDPHQWRVVHPHOKDQWHVQ£RFRUUHVSRQGHH[DWDPHQWH WHRULDGDLPSUHYLV£RSRUHVWDUPDLVIRFDGDQD
TXHVW£RGDGHVSURSRU§£RGRTXHSURSULDPHQWHQDLPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH
(/(0(17263$5$$3/,&$%,/,'$'('$7(25,$'$,035(9,62
&RPR M¡ VH REVHUYRX HVWD WHRULD LQWHUHVVD PDLV DRV FRQWUDWRV GH H[HFX§£R FRQWLQXDGD RX GH WUDWR
VXFHVVLYR RX VHMD GH P©GLR RX ORQJR SUD]R EHP FRPR RV GH H[HFX§£R GLIHULGD VHQGR LQºWLO SDUD RV
FRQWUDWRVGHH[HFX§£RLPHGLDWD
3RGHPRV QHVVD OLQKD GH LQWHOHF§£R GHFRPSRU HVVD LPSRUWDQWH FRQVWUX§£R GRJP¡WLFD QRV VHJXLQWHV
HOHPHQWRV
DVXSHUYHQLªQFLDGHFLUFXQVW¢QFLDLPSUHYLVYHOߚFODURHVW¡DVVLPTXHVHDRQHURVLGDGHH[FHVVLYDLPSRVWDDXPDGDVSDUWHVLQVHULUVHQD
¡OHDGHSUHYLV£RFRQWUDWXDOQ£RVHSRGHU¡HPWDOFDVRSUHWHQGHUVHPXGDURVWHUPRVGDDYHQ§DKDMDYLVWDTXHQDYLGDQHJRFLDOQDGD
LPSHGHTXHXPDGDVSDUWHVWHQKDIHLWRXPߡPDXQHJ³FLRߢ
E DOWHUD§£R GD EDVH HFRQ´PLFD REMHWLYD GR FRQWUDWR ߚ D RFRUUªQFLD GD FLUFXQVW¢QFLD VXSHUYHQLHQWH DOWHUD D EDODQ§D HFRQ´PLFD GR
FRQWUDWRLPSRQGRDXPDRXDDPEDVDVSDUWHVRQHURVLGDGHH[FHVVLYD
FRQHURVLGDGHH[FHVVLYDߚFRQVHTXHQFLDOPHQWHXPDRXDW©PHVPRDPEDVDVSDUWHVH[SHULPHQWDPXPDXPHQWRQDJUDYLGDGHHFRQ´PLFD
GDSUHVWD§£RDTXHVHREULJRX&RPLVVRSRGHPRVFRQFOXLUFRQVRDQWHDQRWDPRVOLQKDVDFLPDTXHDWHRULDGDLPSUHYLV£RQ£RSUHVVXSµH
QHFHVVDULDPHQWH HQULTXHFLPHQWR GH XPD SDUWH HP GHWULPHQWR GR HPSREUHFLPHQWR GD RXWUD ,VVR SRUTXH QD VXSHUYHQLªQFLD GD
FLUFXQVW¢QFLDQ£RHVSHUDGDSRGHU¡KDYHUGHWHUPLQDGDRQHURVLGDGHSDUDDPEDVDVSDUWHVVHPTXHFRPLVVRVHDIDVWHDDSOLFD§£RGD
WHRULD
7(25,$'$,035(9,62/(62
1£R VH FRQIXQGH RXWURVVLP D DSOLFD§£R GD WHRULD GD LPSUHYLV£R FRP R YFLR GD OHV£R DUW GR
&& HPERUD QHVWH WDPE©P VH YHULILTXH D H[LVWªQFLD GH GHVSURSRU§£R PDQLIHVWD HQWUH DV SUHVWD§µHV
SDFWXDGDVFRQVRDQWHVHSRGHREVHUYDUGDDQ¡OLVHGRPHQFLRQDGRGLVSRVLWLYROHJDO
ߡ$UW 2FRUUH D OHV£R TXDQGR XPD SHVVRD VRE SUHPHQWH QHFHVVLGDGH RX SRU LQH[SHULªQFLD VH REULJD D SUHVWD§£R PDQLIHVWDPHQWH
GHVSURSRUFLRQDODRYDORUGDSUHVWD§£RRSRVWDߢ
3RGHVH DVVLP FRQFHLWXDU D OHV£R FRPR R SUHMX]R UHVXOWDQWH GD GHVSURSRU§£R H[LVWHQWH HQWUH DV
SUHVWD§µHV GH XP GHWHUPLQDGR QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR HP IDFH GR DEXVR GD LQH[SHULªQFLD QHFHVVLGDGH
HFRQ´PLFDRXOHYLDQGDGHGHXPGRVGHFODUDQWHV
'HFRPSµHVHSRLVHVWHGHIHLWRHPGRLVHOHPHQWRV
DREMHWLYRRXPDWHULDOߚGHVSURSRU§£RGDVSUHVWD§µHVDYHQ§DGDV
E VXEMHWLYR LPDWHULDO RX DQPLFR ߚ D SUHPHQWH QHFHVVLGDGH D LQH[SHULªQFLD H D OHYLDQGDGH GD SDUWH OHVDGD YDOHQGR GHVWDFDU TXH
WUDGLFLRQDOPHQWHVHDFUHVFHQWDDQR§£RGRGRORGHDSURYHLWDPHQWRGDSDUWHEHQHILFLDGDHPERUDRWH[WRGR&³GLJR&LYLOGHDHOH
Q£RID§DPHQ§£RH[SUHVVDVHQGRHPQRVVRHQWHQGHUGHVSLFLHQGR
$ WHRULD GD LPSUHYLV£R SRU VXD YH] SUHVVXSµH D H[LVWªQFLD GH XP FRQWUDWR Y¡OLGR GH H[HFX§£R
FRQWLQXDGD RX GLIHULGD TXHSRU FLUFXQVW¢QFLDVXSHUߓYHQLHQWH RQHUD H[FHVVLYDPHQWHR GHYHGRU1£R K¡
SRLVDTXLIXQGR GHDEXVRGH SRGHU HFRQ´PLFR FRPR RFRUUH QD OHV£R PDV VLP DOWHUD§£R GD VXD EDVH
REMHWLYD SRU IDWR SRVWHULRU LPSUHYLVYHO &DVR VH WUDWH GH VLWXD§£R SUHYLVYHO H GH FRQVHTXªQFLDV
FDOFXO¡YHLV GHQWUR GD ¡OHD HFRQ´PLFD RUGLQ¡ULD DLQGD TXH LPSRVVLELOLWHR FXPSULPHQWR GD REULJD§£R
SULQFLSDO Q£R K¡ IDODU HP DSOLFD§£R GD WHRULD VRE DQ¡OLVH QHP PXLWR PHQRV SUHWHQGHUVH D UHYLV£R
MXGLFLDOGRFRQWUDWR
7(25,$'$,035(9,62,1$',03/(0(172)2578,72&$62)2578,7228
)25$0$,25
(PERUD PXLWR SU³[LPRV FDEH GLVWLQJXLU D WHRULD GD LPSUHYLV£R GR GHQRPLQDGR LQDGLPSOHPHQWR
IRUWXLWR
$ WHRULD GD LPSUHYLV£R SRU VXD YH] HQVHMD XPD UHYLV£R GRV WHUPRV GR FRQWUDWR SRGHQGR JHUDU QD
UHSDFWXD§£RXPGHYHUGHUHVVDUFLUSDUFHODVSDJDVRXJDVWRVIHLWRVEHPFRPRDW©PHVPRGHLQGHQL]DU
SHODH[WLQ§£RGDDYHQ§D
7UDWDQGR GD DSOLFD§£R GD WHRULD $GPLQLVWUD§£R 3ºEOLFD H ID]HQGR D GLVWLQ§£R SDUD D IRU§D PDLRU
REVHUYD0$5,$6</9,$=$1(/ߓ/$',3,(752
ߡ1HVWDHVW£RSUHVHQWHVRVPHVPRVHOHPHQWRVIDWRHVWUDQKR YRQWDGHGDVSDUWHVLQHYLW¡YHOLPSUHYLVYHODGLIHUHQ§DHVW¡HPTXHQD
WHRULDGDLPSUHYLV£RRFRUUHDSHQDVXPGHVHTXLOEULRHFRQ´PLFRTXHQ£RLPSHGHDH[HFX§£RGRFRQWUDWRHQDIRU§DPDLRUYHULILFDVHD
LPSRVVLELOLGDGHDEVROXWDGHGDUSURVVHJXLPHQWRDRFRQWUDWR$VFRQVHTXªQFLDVV£RWDPE©PGLYHUVDVQRSULPHLURFDVRD$GPLQLVWUD§£R
SRGHDSOLFDUDWHRULDGDLPSUHYLV£RUHYHQGRDVFO¡XVXODVILQDQFHLUDVGRFRQWUDWRSDUDSHUPLWLUDVXDFRQWLQXLGDGHVHHVWDIRUFRQYHQLHQWH
SDUD R LQWHUHVVH SºEOLFR QR VHJXQGR FDVR DPEDV DV SDUWHV V£R OLEHUDGDV VHP TXDOTXHU UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH SRU LQDGLPSOHPHQWR FRPR
FRQVHTXªQFLDGDQRUPDGRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLO3HOD/HLQDIRU§DPDLRUFRQVWLWXLXPGRVIXQGDPHQWRVSDUDDUHVFLV£RGR
FRQWUDWRDUW;9,,WHQGRHVWDHIHLWRPHUDPHQWHGHFODUDW³ULRGHXPDVLWXD§£RGHIDWRLPSHGLWLYDGDH[HFX§£Rߢ
7UDWDVHSRUWDQWRGHGRLVLQVWLWXWRVGLYHUVRVTXHQ£RGHYHPVHUFRQIXQGLGRV
$7(25,$'$,035(9,6212&',*2'('()(6$'2&21680,'25
'LIHUHQWHPHQWH GR &³GLJR GH %HYLO¡TXD TXH Q£R FXLGRX GD PDW©ULD R &³GLJR GH 'HIHVD GR
&RQVXPLGRU HP VHX DUW z 9 LQRYRX DR FRQVDJUDU HVVD WHRULD FRP QRYR PDWL] DR DGPLWLU TXH R
FRQVXPLGRUSXGHVVHSOHLWHDUDUHYLV£RGRFRQWUDWRVHFLUFXQVW¢QFLDVXSHUYHQLHQWHGHVHTXLOLEUDVVHDEDVH
REMHWLYDGRFRQWUDWRLPSRQGROKHSUHVWD§£RH[FHVVLYDPHQWHRQHURVD
9ªVHSRLVGDDQ¡OLVHGHVWHGLVSRVLWLYRTXHDPROGXUDMXUGLFDGDGDSHOROHJLVODGRUDHVWDWHRULD©
SHFXOLDUQDPHGLGDHPTXHSHUPLWHDUHYLV£RFRQWUDWXDOLQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWHGHRIDWRVXSHUYHQLHQWHVHU
LPSUHYLVYHO
,VVRPHVPR
2&'&Q£RH[LJLXDLPSUHYLVLELOLGDGHSDUDTXHVHSXGHVVHUHGLVFXWLURVWHUPRVGRFRQWUDWRUD]£RSRU
TXH D GRXWULQD H D MXULVSUXGªQFLD HVSHFLDOL]DGDV SUHIHUHP D GHQRPLQ¡OD WHRULD GD RQHURVLGDGH
H[FHVVLYD
(DILQDOFRPRVHWUDWRXGDWHRULDGDLPSUHYLV£RQR&³GLJR&LYLOEUDVLOHLUR"
&RPRLPSUHYLV£RSURSULDPHQWHGLWDRXFRPRRQHURVLGDGHH[FHVVLYD"
RTXHYHUHPRVQRSU³[LPRW³SLFR
$7(25,$'$,035(9,6212&',*2&,9,/'(
2DWXDO&³GLJR&LYLOSRUVXDYH]FXLGRXGHUHJXODUDPDW©ULDQRVVHJXLQWHVWHUPRV
ߡ6H§£R,9
'D5HVROX§£RSRU2QHURVLGDGH([FHVVLYD
$UW1RVFRQWUDWRVGHH[HFX§£RFRQWLQXDGDRXGLIHULGDVHDSUHVWD§£RGHXPDGDVSDUWHVVHWRUQDUH[FHVVLYDPHQWHRQHURVDFRP
H[WUHPD YDQWDJHP SDUD D RXWUD HP YLUWXGH GH DFRQWHFLPHQWRV H[WUDRUGLQ¡ULRV H LPSUHYLVYHLV SRGHU¡ R GHYHGRU SHGLU D UHVROX§£R GR
FRQWUDWR2VHIHLWRVGDVHQWHQ§DTXHDGHFUHWDUUHWURDJLU£R GDWDGDFLWD§£R
$UW$UHVROX§£RSRGHU¡VHUHYLWDGDRIHUHFHQGRVHRU©XDPRGLILFDUHTXLWDWLYDPHQWHDVFRQGL§µHVGRFRQWUDWR
$UW 6H QR FRQWUDWR DV REULJD§µHV FRXEHUHP D DSHQDV XPD GDV SDUWHV SRGHU¡ HOD SOHLWHDU TXH D VXD SUHVWD§£R VHMD UHGX]LGD RX
DOWHUDGRRPRGRGHH[HFXW¡ODDILPGHHYLWDUDRQHURVLGDGHH[FHVVLYDߢ
'LDQWHGRVWHUPRVGDQRYDOHLDOJXPDVFRQVLGHUD§µHVSRGHPVHUWHFLGDV
$SOLFDELOLGDGHGRLQVWLWXWR
3ULPHLUDPHQWHQRWDPRVTXHDGLF§£RGRDUWID]SUHVXPLUTXHDWHRULDDGRWDGDSHORFRGLILFDGRU
H[LJHSDUDDVXDFRQILJXUD§£RTXHGDVXSHUYHQLªQFLDGRHYHQWRH[WUDRUGLQ¡ULRH LPSUHYLVYHOGHFRUUD
HQULTXHFLPHQWRVHPFDXVDSDUDXPDSDUWHHPGHWULPHQWRGDRXWUD
-¡ FULWLFDPRV OLQKDV DWU¡V D LPSURSULHGDGH GH VH FRQVLGHUDU TXH D LPSUHYLV£R H[LMD UHOD§£R FDXVDO
HQWUHHQULTXHFLPHQWRHHPSREUHFLPHQWRGHXPDSDUWHHRXWUDXPDYH]TXHRIDWRSRVWHULRUSRGHU¡RQHUDU
DDPEDVFDVRHPTXHDLQGDDVVLPDWHRULDQ£RSRGHULDGHL[DUGHVHUDSOLFDGD
,QWHUHVVDQWHQRWDUWDPE©PTXHRQRYRGLSORPDH[LJHDO©PGDLPSUHYLVLELOLGDGHDH[WUDRUGLQDULHGDGH
GR HYHQWR RX VHMD GHYHU¡ VHU H[FHSFLRQDO HVFDSDQGR DVVLP GR FXUVR QRUPDO H RUGLQ¡ULR GRV
DFRQWHFLPHQWRV GD YLGD $OL¡V SRU VH WUDWDU GH FO¡XVXOD JHUDO GHYHU¡ R MXL] HIHWLYDU D VXD FRQFUH§£R
DWHQWR VFDUDFWHUVWLFDVGRFDVRFRQFUHWR
1HVVD OLQKD R GHYHGRU ߚ H[FHVVLYDPHQWH RQHUDGR ߚ SRGHU¡ QRV WHUPRV GR DUW SOHLWHDU D
UHVROX§£R RX VHMD R GHVID]LPHQWR GR FRQWUDWR FDVR HP TXH RV HIHLWRV GD VHQWHQ§D UHWURDJLU£R DR
PRPHQWRGDFLWD§£R
$UHVSHLWRGHVWHºOWLPRDVSHFWRSRQWLILFD-26'(2/,9(,5$$6&(162
ߡ2DUWGLVSµHTXHRVHIHLWRVGDVHQWHQ§DTXHGHFUHWDUDUHVROX§£RUHWURDJLU£R GDWDGDFLWD§£R&RPSUHHQGHVHSRLVDVHQWHQ§D
YHULILFDQHVVHFDVRTXHKDYLDUHDOPHQWHIXQGDPHQWRSDUDDUHVROX§£RGRFRQWUDWR0DVSRGHSHUJXQWDUVHVHVHU¡HVVDDºQLFDVROX§£R
SRVVYHO 8PD YH] TXH D DFWXD§£R WDPE©P SRGH VHU H[WUDMXGLFLDO RV HIHLWRV SRGHU£R UHWURDJLU GDWD GD LQWHUSHOD§£R GLULJLGD SRU XPD
SDUWH RXWUDXPDYH]YHULILFDGRTXHKDYLDUHDOPHQWHIXQGDPHQWRSDUDDUHVROX§£RGRFRQWUDWR
1DUHDOLGDGHDTXHOHWUHFKRGRDUWTXHWUDGX]DQWHVGHPDLVQDGDDUHDOLGDGHSURFHVVXDOFRPXPV³FRQIXQGH6HVHQ£RTXLVHVVH
HVWDEHOHFHUXPDVROX§£RHVSHFLDOSDUDHVWDKLS³WHVHPDLVYDOLDR&³GLJRWHURPLWLGRTXDOTXHUUHIHUªQFLD UHWURDF§£R0DLVXPDYH]D
URXSDߓJHPSURFHVVXDOHPOHLVVXEVWDQWLYDVUHYHODVHGHVORFDGDHQRFLYDߢ VLF
5HYLVLELOLGDGHGRFRQWUDWR
2DUWLJRVXEVHTXHQWHSRUVXDYH]DEUHDSRVVLELOLGDGHGHVHHYLWDUDUHVROX§£RVHRU©XRIHUHFHUVHD
PRGLILFDUHTXLWDWLYDPHQWHDVFRQGL§µHVGRFRQWUDWR
1RWDVHSRUWDQWRGDOHLWXUDGHVWHGLVSRVLWLYRTXHDUHYLV£RGRFRQWUDWRQRVWHUPRVGRDWXDO&³GLJR
&LYLO©XPDVLPSOHVIDFXOGDGHGRGHPDQGDGRRTXHVHQRVDILJXUDXPHVFDQFDUDGRDEVXUGR
&RPR FRQFHEHU TXH D UHYLV£R GD EDVH HFRQ´PLFD GR FRQWUDWR ILTXH DR DOYHGULR GH DSHQDV XPD GDV
SDUWHV"
$QHJDWLYDGHVVDYLDߚGHIHULGDH[DWDPHQWH SDUWHTXHHPJHUDOJR]DGHPDLRUSRGHUHFRQ´PLFRߚ
SRGH VLJQLILFDU QD SU¡WLFD TXH DR DXWRU GD D§£R GHYHGRU RQHUDGR SHOR HYHQWR LPSUHYLVYHO FDLED
DSHQDV SOHLWHDU D UHVROX§£R GR FRQWUDWR RX VHMD D GLVVROX§£R GR QHJ³FLR R TXH SRGHU¡ Q£R OKH
LQWHUHVVDURXDW©PHVPRVHUOKHDLQGDPDLVSUHMXGLFLDO
3RULVVR VXVWHQWDPRVD LQHJ¡YHO SRVVLELOLGDGH OX] GRV SULQFSLRV GD GLJQLGDGHGD SHVVRD KXPDQD
GRGHYHGRUHGDHIHWLYLGDGHGRSURFHVVRGHRMXL]VHPSUHWHQGHUVXEVWLWXLUVH YRQWDGHGDVSDUWHV
SURODWDUVHQWHQ§DUHYLVLRQDOFRUUHWLYDGDVEDVHVHFRQ´PLFDVGRQHJ³FLRPHVPRFRPDRSRVL§£RGRU©X
FUHGRU
7DO HQWHQGLPHQWR LQFOXVLYH SDUHFHQRV UHVSDOGDGR SRU XPD SUHYLV£R HVSHFILFD GH DSOLFD§£R GH WDO
WHRULDHPUHOD§£RDRSDJDPHQWRGDSUHVWD§£RGHYLGDSRUIRU§DGDUHOD§£RMXUGLFDREULJDFLRQDO
7UDWDVHGRDUWGR&&VHPHTXLYDOHQWHQDFRGLILFD§£RDQWHULRUTXHHVWDEHOHFH
ߡ$UW4XDQGRSRUPRWLYRVLPSUHYLVYHLVVREUHYLHUGHVSURSRU§£RPDQLIHVWDHQWUHRYDORUGDSUHVWD§£RGHYLGDHRGRPRPHQWRGHVXD
H[HFX§£RSRGHU¡RMXL]FRUULJLORDSHGLGRGDSDUWHGHPRGRTXHDVVHJXUHTXDQWRSRVVYHORYDORUUHDOGDSUHVWD§£Rߢ
$LQGD QHVVD OLQKD YDOH GHVWDFDU TXH D /HL Q GH GH DJRVWR GH TXH GLVSµH VREUH R
SDWULP´QLRGHDIHWD§£RGHLQFRUSRUD§µHVLPRELOL¡ULDV/HWUDGH&U©GLWR,PRELOL¡ULR&©GXODGH&U©GLWR
,PRELOL¡ULR&©GXODGH&U©GLWR%DQF¡ULRDOWHUDQGRR'HFUHWROHLQGHzGHRXWXEURGHDV
/HLVQGHGHGH]HPEURGHGHGHMXOKRGHHGHGHMDQHLURGH
H GDQGR RXWUDV SURYLGªQFLDV DFDERX SRU HVWDEHOHFHU UHJUDV SURFHGLPHQWDLV SDUD D KLS³WHVH GH
D§£RTXHYLVHUHGLVFXWLUREULJD§µHVGHFRUUHQWHVGHHPSU©VWLPRILQDQFLDPHQWRRXDOLHQD§£RLPRELOL¡ULRV
QRUPDFRPSDWYHOFRPDLGHLDGHTXHRVXMHLWRSDVVLYRGDREULJD§£RGHYHFRQVLJQDURYDORUTXHHQWHQGH
GHYLGRGHPRQVWUDQGRDVXDERDI©HDQLPXVVROYHQGL
6REUHRWHPDYDOHGHVWDFDULQFOXVLYHSRUILPTXHR(QXQFLDGRQGR&RQVHOKRGD-XVWL§D)HGHUDO
WUDWDHVSHFLILFDPHQWHGRWHPDQRVWHUPRVDTXLSURSRVWRV
$SOLFD§£RGDWHRULDQRVFRQWUDWRVXQLODWHUDLV
)LQDOPHQWHRDUWFRQVDJUDUHJUDHVSHFILFDDRVFRQWUDWRVXQLODWHUDLVRXVHMDDTXHOHVTXHLPSµHP
REULJD§µHVDSHQDVSDUDXPDGDVSDUWHV1HVWHFDVRSDUDHYLWDUDRQHURVLGDGHH[FHVVLYDߚYHMDTXHD
QRUPDWHPFXQKRDFDXWHODW³ULRߚRGHYHGRUSRGHU¡SXJQDUSHODUHGX§£RGDSUHVWD§£RRXDDOWHUD§£RGR
PRGRGHH[HFXW¡OD
2UDVHSDUWLPRVGDSUHPLVVDGHTXHRFRGLILFDGRURSWRXSHODUHIHUªQFLD LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGHWHPVH
TXH QD KLS³WHVH RFRUULGR R HYHQWR LQHVSHUDGR GHVWH R GHYHGRU SRGHU¡ SOHLWHDU D PLQLPL]D§£R GDV
FRQVHߓTXªQFLDV GDQRVDV QRV WHUPRV DQWHULRUPHQWH PHQFLRQDGRV R FDVR SRU H[HPSOR GH DOJX©P VH
FRPSURPHWHUSRUPHLRGHXPFRQWUDWRGHGRD§£RFRQWUDWRXQLODWHUDODIRUQHFHUVDFDVGHFHUHDLVHP
XPGHWHUPLQDGRGLDDXPDIDPOLDFDUHQWHTXHUHVLGHHPXPDORQJQTXDFRPXQLGDGHFXMRºQLFRDFHVVR©
XPDHVWUDGDYLFLQDO6HXPHYHQWRLQHVSHUDGRGLILFXOWDUVREUHPDQHLUDDSUHVWD§£RXPDJUDYHHURV£RQD
HVWUDGDSRUH[HPSORRGHYHGRUSRGHU¡SXJQDUSHORHQYLRGRFHUHDOSHODYLDIOXYLDOHPGLDVVHJXLGRV
VHJXQGRDGLVSRQLELOLGDGHGRVEDUFRVGHWUDQVSRUWHGDUHJL£R
9ªVHFRPLVVRTXHDQRUPDVREFRPHQWRDILQDVHFRPRVGLWDPHVFRQVWLWXFLRQDLVGHYDORUL]D§£RGD
SHVVRDKXPDQDVHJXQGRXPDSHUVSHFWLYDVRFLDOL]DGRUDGRFRQWUDWR
;;,,
&2175$726$73,&26
,1752'82
-¡ WLYHPRV RSRUWXQLGDGH GH PHQFLRQDU TXH R FRQWUDWR SULQFLSDO HVS©FLH GH QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR © VHP
GºYLGDXPDGDVPDLVLPSRUWDQWHVILJXUDVMXUGLFDVGR'LUHLWR&LYLO
1DPHVPDOLQKDGHFRPSDUD§£RRFRQWUDWRHVW¡SDUDRFLYLOLVWDFRPRRFULPHHVW¡SDUDRSHQDOLVWD
2FRUUHTXHGLIHUHQWHPHQWHGRGHOLWRTXHH[LJHVXEVXQ§£RDXPWLSRSHQDOSUHYLDPHQWHGHOLQHDGRQD
OHLWLSLFLGDGHRFRQWUDWRVHDSUHVHQWDGHYDULDGDVIRUPDVFRPLQFRQW¡YHLVPDWL]HV
&RP LVVR TXHUHPRV GL]HU TXH SRU VHU IUXWR GD OLYUH DXWRQRPLD GD YRQWDGH Q£R SRGHULD R
OHJLVODGRU FRQFHEHU DQWHFLSDGDPHQWH WRGRV RV WLSRV GH FRQWUDWRV PROGDQGR SU©YLRV VWDQGDUGV OHJDLV
XPDYH]TXHVHPSUHH[LVWLULDPGHWHUPLQDGRVFRQWUDWRVQ£RSUHYLVWRVHPOHLߚRVGHQRPLQDGRVFRQWUDWRV
DWSLFRV7RPHPVHDWWXORGHH[HPSORRFRQWUDWRGHIDFWRULQJRXRGHKRVSHGDJHP
9DOHQRHQWDQWRPHQFLRQDUTXHR'LUHLWR5RPDQRSULQFLSDOIRQWHKLVW³ULFDGR'LUHLWRRFLGHQWDOSRU
VXD SU³SULD QDWXUH]D IRUPDOLVWD Q£R VH DGHTXRX DR VLVWHPD GRV FRQWUDWRV DWSLFRV H LQRPLQDGRV
FRQVRDQWHVHSRGHREVHUYDUGDGRXWULQDGRFXOWR(%(57&+$0281
ߡ&DUDFWHUL]DYD R GLUHLWR URPDQR GDV REULJD§µHV D WLSLFLGDGH FRQWUDWXDO GLIHUHQWHPHQWH GR TXH VXFHGH QR DWXDO GLUHLWR FLYLO RV URPDQRV
HQWHQGLDP TXH DSHQDV FHUWRV QHJ³FLRV HUDP LG´QHRV SDUD FRQILJXUDU UHOD§µHV FRQWUDWXDLV H GHPDUFDYDP RV OLPLWHV GH FDGD WLSR GH
FRQWUDWRFRPWDOIL[LGH]TXHDO©PGHOHVQ£RHUDPSRVVYHLVTXDLVTXHUH[WHQVµHV$SU¡WLFDHQWUHWDQWRH[LJLDDFULD§£RGHQRYDVILJXUDV
FRQWUDWXDLVTXHR]HORVLVWHP¡WLFRHDUJLGDVLPHWULDGRMXVFLYLOHQ£RSRGLDPUHFRQKHFHU&RPRVHPSUHVXFHGHXIRLRSUHWRUTXHVHP
DVDGPLWLUHPVHXV©GLWRVQHPOKHVFRQFHGHUI³UPXODVWLSRSURWHJHXDVSRU©PFRPD§µHVDWUDY©VGHGHFUHWRVߢ
2 'LUHLWR &LYLO DWXDO SRU VXD YH] DGPLWH D H[LVWªQFLD GHVWDV ILJXUDV MXUGLFDV FRQWUDWRV DWSLFRV H
LQRPLQDGRVFRQVRDQWHYHUHPRVQRGHFRUUHUGHVWHFDSWXOR
&2175$72673,&26($73,&26
3RU FRQWUDWRVWSLFRV HQWHQGDPVH DTXHOHV TXH WªP SUHYLVLELOLGDGH OHJDO RX VHMD TXH V£R UHJXODGRV
SHOR'LUHLWR3RVLWLYRFRPRDFRPSUDHYHQGDDGRD§£RDORFD§£RRGHS³VLWRRVHJXURRFRPRGDWRR
PºWXRHWF6£RSRUWDQWRILJXUDVFRPDVVHQWRQDOHJLVOD§£RHPYLJRU
-¡ RV FRQWUDWRV DWSLFRV SRU VXD YH] V£R DTXHOHV Q£R UHJXODGRV HP OHL FRPR SRU H[HPSOR RV
FRQWUDWRVGHKRVSHGDJHPIDFWRULQJHHQJLQHHULQJ GHQWUHWDQWRVRXWURV
8PDERDGHILQL§£RGHFRQWUDWRDWSLFR©GDGDSRU*,6(/'$+,521$.$
ߡ$ VHX WXUQR SRUWDQWRFRQWUDWRDWSLFR© DTXHOH Q£RGLVFLSOLQDGRSHORRUGHQDPHQWR MXUGLFR HPERUDOFLWR SHOR IDWRGHUHVWDU VXMHLWR V
QRUPDVJHUDLVGRFRQWUDWRHQ£RFRQWUDULDUDOHLQHPRVERQVFRVWXPHVQHPRVSULQFSLRVJHUDLVGRGLUHLWRߢ
$SURYHLWDQGR WDO OLQKD GH SHQVDPHQWR FRQFOXPRV TXH WRGR H TXDOTXHU FRQWUDWR DWSLFR HPERUD
GHFRUUHQWH GD DXWRQRPLD SULYDGD H GD OLYUHLQLFLDWLYD GHYHU¡ UHVSHLWDU RV SDU¢PHWURV GH PDWL]
FRQVWLWXFLRQDOIL[DGRVSHORVSULQFSLRVGDIXQ§£RVRFLDOGRFRQWUDWRHGDERDI©
$OL¡VHVVDLGHLDGHVROLGDULVPRFRQWUDWXDO©EHPQWLGDQRSHQVDPHQWRGH3$8/252%(5721$/,1
ߡ$LGHLDGHXPDUHOD§£RFRQWUDWXDOVROLG¡ULDSUHVVXSµHVREUHWXGRRH[LVWLUGDFRQFRUUªQFLDHQ£RGD
RSRVL§£RQRTXHWDQJHDRVLQWHUHVVHVHQYROYLGRVDSURS³VLWRGHXPILPFRPXPHGHXPDLQGLVSHQV¡YHO
PHGLGDGHFRRSHUD§£RHQWUHDVSDUWHVߢ
(PDLVDGLDQWH
ߡ1DDWXDOLGDGHDIDVWDQGRVHGRVSDGUµHVUHOLJLRVRVHVWULWRVHGDVFDVXVWLFDVKLS³WHVHVRIHUHFLGDVSHOR&³GLJR&LYLOEHPFRPRGDSU³SULD
&DUWD &RQVWLWXFLRQDO EUDVLOHLUD © IDFWYHO VH H[WUDLU XP VHQWLGR GR TXH VHMD FRQWUDWD§£R VROLG¡ULD PRVWUDQGRVH LPSHUDWLYD D OHLWXUD GR
&³GLJR&LYLOHDLQWHUSUHWD§£RGRVFRQWUDWRV OX]GD&DUWD6RERSULVPDFRQVWLWXFLRQDO©SRVVYHOVXVWHQWDUTXHLQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWHGD
HVFROKDLGHRO³JLFDTXHVHID§DDPHOKRUGHVFUL§£RGDVROLGDULHGDGHGHYHHVWDUYROWDGD YHUWLFDOL]D§£RGRVLQWHUHVVHVGRKRPHPHILFD]R
VXILFLHQWHSDUDDQLTXLODUDVGHVLJXDOGDGHVVXEMHWLYDVHUHJLRQDLVFRQILJXUDQGRVHFRPRLQGLVVRFL¡YHLVDVROLGDULHGDGHHDLJXDOGDGHߢ
1HVVD OLQKD SRGHPRV FRQFOXLU TXH DV GLVSRVL§µHV QRUPDWLYDV FRQVWDQWHV QRV DUWV H GR
&³GLJR&LYLOLPSUHVFLQGYHLVSDUDDQRYDFRQFHS§£RGRVFRQWUDWRVQDPRGHUQLGDGHV£R SHUIHLWDPHQWH
DSOLF¡YHLVDRVFRQWUDWRVDWSLFRV
ߡ$UW$OLEHUGDGHGHFRQWUDWDUVHU¡H[HUFLGDHPUD]£RHQRVOLPLWHVGDIXQ§£RVRFLDOGRFRQWUDWR
$UW2VFRQWUDWDQWHVV£RREULJDGRVDJXDUGDUDVVLPQDFRQFOXV£RGRFRQWUDWRFRPRHPVXDH[HFX§£RRVSULQFSLRVGHSURELGDGHH
ERDI©ߢ
$ UHVSHLWR GHVWH IHQ´PHQR GH VRFLDOL]D§£R MXUGLFD GDV UHOD§µHV FRQWUDWXDLV WDPE©P QRWDGD FRPR
YLVWRQR¢PELWRGRV FRQWUDWRVDWSLFRVYDOHUHIHULU RXWUDSUHOH§£R GH*,6(/'$ +,521$.$ FLWDQGR
7(3(',12
ߡ*XVWDYR7HSHGLQR EHPREVHUYDTXHDLQVHU§£RGDIXQ§£RVRFLDOFRPRXPGRVPHJDSULQFSLRVFRQVWLWXFLRQDLVߚHQWUHRVGLUHLWRVH
DV JDUDQWLDV IXQGDPHQWDLV ߚ WHYH R HVFRSR GH HOHYDU D GHWHUPLQD§£R GH VHX DWHQGLPHQWR DR SDWDPDU GH UHJUD IXQGDPHQWDO DSWD D
LQVWUXPHQWDOL]DU WRGR R WHFLGR FRQVWLWXFLRQDO H SRU YLD GH FRQVHTXªQFLD WRGDV DV QRUPDV LQIUDFRQVWLWXFLRQDLV FULDQGR XP SDU¢PHWUR
LQWHUSUHWDWLYRGRRUGHQDPHQWRMXUGLFRߢ
'LVWLQ§£RGRVFRQWUDWRVQRPLQDGRVHLQRPLQDGRV
8PDLPSRUWDQWHREVHUYD§£RVREUHRWHPD©DGLVWLQ§£RHQWUHFRQWUDWRVWSLFRVHDWSLFRVHRVFRQWUDWRV
QRPLQDGRVHLQRPLQDGRV
'H IDWR XWLOL]DVH D H[SUHVV£RߡFRQWUDWRV QRPLQDGRVߢ TXDQGR WDLV FRQWUDWRV WLYHUHP WHUPLQRORJLD RX
QRPHQFODWXUD GHILQLGD $VVLP VHQGR FRQFOXLVH IDFLOPHQWH SRUWDQWR TXH SRU XPD TXHVW£R O³JLFD RV
FRQWUDWRVWSLFRVSRUVHUHPREMHWRGHSUHYLV£ROHJLVODWLYDV£RWDPE©PQRPLQDGRV
1RV H[HPSORV GH FRQWUDWRV DWSLFRV TXH PHQFLRQDPRV DW© DJRUD WRGRV SRVVXHP XPD QRPHQFODWXUD
FRUUHQWH H VRFLDOPHQWH DGPLWLGD UD]£R SRU TXH SRGHUDPRV HP QRVVR SHQVDU FRQVLGHU¡ORV WDPE©P
QRPLQDGRV
1DGD LPSHGH HQWUHWDQWR TXH DV SDUWHV FRQMXJXHP SUHVWD§µHV GH GLYHUVRV FRQWUDWRV RX FULHP XPD
ILJXUD FRQWUDWXDO FRPSOHWDPHQWH QRYD VHJXQGR D DXWRQRPLD GH VXDV YRQWDGHV LQH[LVWLQGR SRU
FRQVHTXªQFLD QRPHQ MXULV SDUD HVWD QRYD PRGDOLGDGH QHJRFLDO (P WDO FDVR WHUDPRV D VLP XP
FRQWUDWRDWSLFRLQRPLQDGR
9HPRVSRUWDQWRTXHQ£R©FRUUHWRHVWDEHOHFHUVHXPDVLQRQPLDHQWUHHVVDVH[SUHVVµHVPXLWRHPERUD
Q£RLQFRUUDPRVHPHUURDRDILUPDUTXHHPJHUDORVFRQWUDWRVWSLFRVV£RQRPLQDGRVDRSDVVRTXHRV
DWSLFRVSRGHPQ£RRVHU
1HVVH GLDSDV£R FRQFOXPRV FRP D OL§£R GH /9$52 9,//$$ $=(9('2 FLWDQGR UHVSHLW¡YHO
GRXWULQDLWDOLDQDQRVHQWLGRGHTXH
ߡ$VVLPTXDQGRIDODPRVHPFRQWUDWRWSLFRPLQLVWUDQJHOR3LUDLQR/HWRFRPDVSDODYUDVGH6DFFRTXHUHPRVGL]HUߝFRQWUDWR TXH VH
LQVHUH HP XPD ILJXUD TXH WHP XPD GLVFLSOLQD OHJDO SDUWLFXODUߞ 3RU RXWUR ODGR © FRQWUDWR DWSLFR DTXHOH TXH Q£R SRVVXL XPD GLVFLSOLQD
OHJLVODWLYD SRVVXLQGR XPD ߝFDXVD QRYD H GLYHUVD UHODWLYDPHQWH DR GLVFLSOLQDGR SHOD OHLߞ 2V FRQWUDWRV WSLFRV UHFHEHP GR RUGHQDPHQWR
MXUGLFRXPDUHJXODPHQWD§£RSDUWLFXODUHDSUHVHQWDPVHFRPXPQRPHDRSDVVRTXHRVDWSLFRVHPERUDSRVVDPWHUXPQRPHFDUHFHP
GHGLVFLSOLQDSDUWLFXODUQ£RSRGHQGRDUHJXODPHQWD§£RGRVLQWHUHVVHVGRVFRQWUDWDQWHVFRQWUDULDUDOHLDRUGHPSºEOLFDRVERQVFRVWXPHV
HRVSULQFSLRVJHUDLVGRGLUHLWRߢ
&ODVVLILFD§£RGRVFRQWUDWRVDWSLFRV
&XPSUHQRVPHQFLRQDUDLQGDTXHHPQRVVRVHQWLUHVHJXQGRGRXWULQDGH25/$1'2*20(6
RVFRQWUDWRVDWSLFRVFRPSRUWDPXPDVXEWLSLILFD§£R
DFRQWUDWRVDWSLFRVSURSULDPHQWHGLWRVߚV£RDTXHOHVFULDGRVRXߡLQYHQWDGRVߢSHODVSU³SULDVSDUWHVTXHFXLGDPGHFHOHEUDUXPQHJ³FLR
MXUGLFR LQWHLUDPHQWH QRYR FRP FDUDFWHUVWLFDV HVSHFILFDV H VHP VLPLODU QR GLUHLWR SRVLWLYR 6£R IUXWR GD DXWRQRPLD SULYDGD OLPLWDGD
FRPR YLPRV SHORV SULQFSLRV VXSHULRUHV GH QGROH FRQVWLWXFLRQDO GD IXQ§£R VRFLDO GR FRQWUDWR H GD GLJQLGDGH GD SHVVRD KXPDQD HVWH
ºOWLPRFRPSUHHQVLYRGDQHFHVVLGDGHGHREVHUY¢QFLDGDERDI©REMHWLYDQDUHOD§£RQHJRFLDO
EFRQWUDWRVDWSLFRVPLVWRVߚV£RDTXHOHVIRUPDGRVSHODFRQMXJD§£RGHSUHVWD§µHVWSLFDVGHRXWURVFRQWUDWRVH[LVWHQWHV3URYªPSRLVGD
IXV£RGHHOHPHQWRVGHRXWURVFRQWUDWRVSRVLWLYDGRVUHVXOWDQGRHPXPDILJXUDQRYDGRWDGDGHDXWRQRPLDMXUGLFDHXQLGDGHVLVWªPLFD
RFDVRGRFRQWUDWRGHKRVSHGDJHPTXHGHFRUUHGDFRQMXJD§£RGHHOHPHQWRVGHRXWURVFRQWUDWRVFRPRDORFD§£RRGHS³VLWRDFRPSUDH
YHQGDHWF
'LVFLSOLQDMXUGLFDGRVFRQWUDWRVDWSLFRV
2PDLRUSUREOHPDQRTXHWDQJHDRVFRQWUDWRVDWSLFRV©DVXDGLVFLSOLQDMXUGLFD
,QH[LVWLQGR UHJUD OHJDO HVSHFILFD H VHJXQGR R SHQVDPHQWR GR FLYLOLVWD EDLDQR 25/$1'2
*20(6 WUªVVROX§µHVV£RDSUHVHQWDGDVSHODGRXWULQD
DWHRULDGDFRPELQD§£R
EWHRULDGDDEVRU§£R
FWHRULDGDDSOLFD§£RDQDO³JLFD
&RQIRUPH D SULPHLUD WHRULD R KHUPHQHXWD DR DQDOLVDU XP FRQWUDWR DWSLFR GHYHU¡ GHFRPS´OR
DSOLFDQGR SDUD FDGD SDUWH VXD D UHJUD OHJDO FRUUHVSRQGHQWH DR WLSR GH FRQWUDWR TXH OKH © VLPLODU 2X
VHMDQRFRQWUDWRGHKRVSHGDJHPGHYHULDPVHUFRPELQDGDVDVUHJUDVOHJDLVGDORFD§£RGRGHS³VLWRHGD
FRPSUD H YHQGD SDUD VROXFLRQDU TXDOTXHU TXHVW£R GH QDWXUH]D LQWHUSUHWDWLYD &RQVRDQWH EHP REVHUYRX
25/$1'2*20(6DPDLRUFUWLFDTXHVHSRGHID]HUDHVWDWHRULD©QRVHQWLGRGHTXHQ£RVHDILJXUD
YHUGDGHLUDDLGHLDGHTXHRFRQWUDWRDWSLFRGHQWURGHVXDXQLGDGHVLVWªPLFDUHVXOWDGDVLPSOHVVRPDGH
RXWUDVILJXUDVFRQWUDWXDLV(DUUHPDWD
ߡ(PUHVXPRRLVRODPHQWRGHHOHPHQWRVSDUWLFXODUHVGHXPFRQWUDWRHGRVUHVSHFWLYRVHIHLWRVMXUGLFRVQ£RSRGHVHUIHLWRVHPSUHMX]RGH
VXDHVWUXWXUD$GHPDLVDVUHJUDVSDUFLDLVGHFRQWUDWRVFXMRVHOHPHQWRVV£RDSURYHLWDGRVQDIRUPD§£RGRVFRQWUDWRVPLVWRVFKRFDPVH
SRUYH]HVWRUQDQGRVHLPSRVVYHOQHVWHFDVRDFRPELQD§£Rߢ
'HIDWRQ£RYHPRVFRPERQVROKRVHVWDVROX§£RGRXWULQ¡ULDXPDYH]TXHHPVHQGRDGRWDGDQHJDUVH
LDP DXWRQRPLD H LGHQWLGDGH RQWRO³JLFD H IXQFLRQDO DR FRQWUDWR DWSLFR DILJXUDQGRVH SRLV FRPR XPD
VROX§£RH[WUHPDPHQWHVLPSOLVWD
2V DGHSWRV GD VHJXQGD WHRULD SRU VXD YH] VXVWHQWDP TXH HP WRGR FRQWUDWR DWSLFR H[LVWH DOJXP
HOHPHQWR SUHSRQGHUDQWH RX LQIOXHQWH HP IDFH GRV RXWURV UD]£R SRU TXH FXOPLQDULD SRU DEVRUYªORV
$VVLPVHHPGHWHUPLQDGR FRQWUDWR DWSLFR DSUHVWD§£R SUHSRQGHUDQWH ©D GHGHS³VLWR HQWUHJDUFRLVD
P³YHO SDUD JXDUGDU H GHYROYHU DV UHJUDV GHVWH ºOWLPR FRQWUDWR GHYHU£R SUHYDOHFHU HP GHWULPHQWR GH
TXDOTXHURXWUD
1£R FRQYHQFH HQWUHWDQWR D LGHLD GH TXH HP GHWHUPLQDGR FRQWUDWR XP HOHPHQWR VHMD SUHSRQGHUDQWH
HPIDFHGRRXWUR7RGRVV£RVHPGºYLGDLJXDOPHQWHLPSRUWDQWHVSDUDDIRUPD§£RGRFRQWUDWRDWSLFR
Q£RKDYHQGRUD]µHVSURSULDPHQWHFLHQWILFDVSDUDVHFRQFOXLUTXHXPDSUHVWD§£RSUHIHUHDRXWUD
&RPDGHYLGDYªQLDSRUWDQWRDIDVWDPRVHVWDVHJXQGDYHUWHQWHGHSHQVDPHQWR
'HIHQGHVHILQDOPHQWHDWHRULDGDDSOLFD§£RDQDO³JLFDVHJXQGRDTXDORLQW©USUHWHGHYHU¡XWLOL]DUDV
UHJUDVOHJDLVUHIHUHQWHVDRFRQWUDWRWSLFRPDLVVHPHOKDQWHV TXHOHVREDQ¡OLVH&XLGDVHGHPHFDQLVPR
WDPE©P LQVDWLVIDW³ULR QD PHGLGD HP TXH Q£R UHVROYH SOHQDPHQWH D GHOLFDGD TXHVW£R UHIHUHQWH DR
LQVWUXPHQWR LQWHUSUHWDWLYR PDLV SUHFLVR D VHU XWLOL]DGR XPD YH] TXH FRPR GLWR DFLPD Q£R VH SRGHU¡
DILUPDUTXHGHWHUPLQDGRHOHPHQWRGRFRQWUDWRDWSLFR©PDLVSUHSRQGHUDQWHDSRQWRGHVHUYLUFRPRHOR
FRPRXWURFRQWUDWRWSLFR$GHPDLVSRGHU¡RFRUUHUGHQ£RVHHQFRQWUDUFRQWUDWRGRWDGRGHVHPHOKDQ§D
VXILFLHQWHSDUDMXVWLILFDURUHFXUVRGDDQDORJLD
&RQVLGHUDQGR SRLV D GLILFXOGDGH GH VH DSRQWDU FULW©ULR VHJXUR GH LQWHUSUHWD§£R FRQFRUGDPRV FRP
3('523$,6'(9$6&21&(/26HPH[FHOHQWHWUDWDGRVREUHRWHPDQRVHQWLGRGHTXHQRVFRQWUDWRV
DWSLFRV R LQW©USUHWH FRQWD PXLWR PDLV FRP DV SU³SULDV HVWLSXOD§µHV FRQWUDWXDLV GR TXH FRP R GLUHLWR
SRVLWLYRߡ1RVFRQWUDWRVDWSLFRVRLQW©USUHWHWHPGHFRQWDUPDLVFRPDVHVWLSXOD§µHVQHJRFLDLVHSRGH
FRQWDUPHQRVFRPRGLUHLWRGLVSRVLWLYRߢ
(DGLDQWH
ߡ7DO FRPR QRV FRQWUDWRV WSLFRV R FRQWHºGR GRV FRQWUDWRV DWSLFRV UHVXOWD SULPDFLDOPHQWH GD VXD LQWHUSUHWD§£R H HVWD © IHLWD DFLPD GH
WXGRSHODLQWHUSUHWD§£RGDVHVWLSXOD§µHVQHJRFLDLVTXHOKHG£RYLGDHHPTXHVHPDWHULDOL]DP
$V HVWLSXOD§µHV QHJRFLDLV TXH IRUPDP R FRQWUDWR FRQVWLWXHP D SULPHLUD PDW©ULD GLVSRQYHO SDUD D VXD LQWHUSUHWD§£R ( © D TXH R
LQW©USUHWH YDL UHFROKHU HP SULPHLUD OLQKD D H[SUHVV£R GD YRQWDGH QHJRFLDO H © D TXH YDL WDPE©P QXPD SULPHLUD OLQKD DMXL]DU VREUH D
WLSLFLGDGHRXDWLSLFLGDGHGRFRQWUDWR$VHVWLSXOD§µHVQHJRFLDLVQ£RHVJRWDPFRQWXGRRFDPSRGHH[SUHVV£RGDYRQWDGHQHJRFLDO4XDQGR
RVFRQWUDWRVFHOHEUDGRVV£RWSLFRVDVSDUWHVSRGHPUHGX]LUDPXLWRSRXFRDPDW©ULDGDVVXDVHVWLSXOD§µHVRVWLSRVIRUQHFHPLQMXQWLYDRX
GLVSRVLWLYDPHQWH XPD GLVFLSOLQD TXDVH VXILFLHQWH 2V FRQWUDWRV DWSLFRV DR FRQWU¡ULR Q£R WªP PRGHORV UHJXODWLYRV TXH GLVSHQVHP RX
VXEVWLWXDPDVHVWLSXOD§µHVQHJRFLDLV$VVLPRVFRQWUDWDQWHVGHXPDFRPSUDHYHQGDQ£RSUHFLVDPHPSULQFSLRGHGHFODUDUPDLVGRTXH
DLGHQWLILFD§£RGDFRLVDYHQGLGDHRPRQWDQWHGRSUH§RRWLSRIRUQHFHWXGRRPDLVHPSULQFSLRQHFHVV¡ULRFRPRGLVFLSOLQDGRFRQWUDWR-¡
SDUD RV FRQWUDWDQWHV GH XP FRQWUDWR DWSLFR © QHFHVV¡ULR HVWLSXODU QDV GHFODUD§µHV QHJRFLDLV TXH IRUPD R FRQWUDWR D GLVFLSOLQD HP
SULQFSLRFRPSOHWDGRFRQWUDWRߢ
$VVLPVHQGRHQWHQGHPRVTXHDLQWHUSUHWD§£RGHXPFRQWUDWRDWSLFRGHYHU¡VHUGLUHFLRQDGDVHJXQGR
DVHVWLSXOD§µHVGR SU³SULR QHJ³FLRH VHPSUH VHJXQGR RV FRQGLFLRQDPHQWRV GH RUGHP SºEOLFD GLWDGRV
SHOD&RQVWLWXL§£R)HGHUDO
(VWHQGHPRVSRUWDQWRDRVDWSLFRVDOºFLGDREVHUYD§£RIHLWDSRU)/9,27$578&(DUHVSHLWRGRV
FRQWUDWRV WSLFRV QD DWXDO SHUVSHFWLYD FLYLOFRQVWLWXFLRQDO ߡ1HVVD QRYD HVWUXWXUD R FRQWUDWR WSLFR
LQVWLWXWR GR 'LUHLWR 3ULYDGR YHP VRIUHQGR XPD V©ULH GH DOWHUD§µHV FRQFHLWXDLV H D DQWLJD YLV£R GH
DXWRQRPLDSOHQDGDYRQWDGHSHUGHHVSD§RSDUDXPDHODERUD§£RPDLVYROWDGDSDUDDUHDOLGDGHVRFLDOGRV
HQYROYLGRVQDUHOD§£RQHJRFLDOߢ
3RVWRLVVRSDVVDUHPRVDDQDOLVDURWHPDVRED³WLFDGDOHJLVOD§£RHPYLJRU
26&2175$726$73,&2612&',*2&,9,/%5$6,/(,52
2&³GLJR&LYLOGHQ£RFRQVDJURXGLVSRVLWLYRDOJXPSDUDRVFRQWUDWRVDWSLFRV
2&³GLJR&LYLOGHSRUVXDYH]SRVWRQ£RKDMDGHGLFDGRVH§£RRXFDSWXORHVSHFILFRSDUDDVXD
GLVFLSOLQDIH]OKHH[SUHVVDPHQ§£RHPVHXDUW
ߡ$UWOFLWR VSDUWHVHVWLSXODUFRQWUDWRVDWSLFRVREVHUYDGDVDVQRUPDVJHUDLVIL[DGDVQHVWH&³GLJRߢ
9ªVH SRUWDQWR TXH R OHJLVODGRU UHPHWHX D GLVFLSOLQD GR WHPD V GLVSRVL§µHV JHUDLV GRV FRQWUDWRV
FRQVWDQWHVQRVDUWVD
GHVHQRWDUDH[LVWªQFLDGHSURSRVWDOHJLVODWLYDSDUDDOWHUD§£RGHVWHGLVSRVLWLYRVHJXQGRDGRXWULQD
GR HPLQHQWH 3URIHVVRU 9,//$$ FRQVRDQWH VH SRGH REVHUYDU GD DQ¡OLVH GR FXOWR 'HV -21(6
),*8(,5'2$/9(6DUHVSHLWRGHVWHGLVSRVLWLYRGHOHL
ߡ6XVWHQWRXR3URIOYDUR9LOOD§DHPUHOHYDQWHFRQWULEXL§£RFUWLFDDRWH[WRGRSURMHWRGR&&GHDSUHVHQWDGD 5HODWRULD*HUDOQR
VHQWLGR GH TXH ߝRV FRQWUDWRV DWSLFRV Q£R SRGHP VHU UHJLGRV SHODV QRUPDV GRV FRQWUDWRV WSLFRV SULQFLSDOPHQWH GRV PLVWRV SRLV D
FRQWUDWD§£RV³VHH[WLQJXHDS³VFXPSULGDVWRGDVDVREULJD§µHVFRQWUDWDGDV2FRQWUDWRIRUPDXPWRGRXQRHLQGLYLVYHOߞߢ
(PUD]£RGLVVRIRUDVXJHULGDDVHJXLQWHDOWHUD§£ROHJLVODWLYD
ߡ$UWOFLWR VSDUWHVHVWLSXODUFRQWUDWRVDWSLFRVUHVJXDUGDGRVDRUGHPSºEOLFDRVERQVFRVWXPHVHRVSULQFSLRVJHUDLVGHGLUHLWR
HVSHFLDOPHQWHRSULQFSLRGHTXHVXDVREULJD§µHVV£RLQGLYLVYHLVIRUPDQGRXPV³WRGRߢ
&RQWXGRRUHODW³ULRGR'HSXWDGR9,&(17($558'$QD&RPLVV£RGH&RQVWLWXL§£RH-XVWL§DFXLGRX
GHUHIXWDUDSURSRVWDGHDOWHUD§£ROHJLVODWLYDVRERVHJXLQWHDUJXPHQWR
ߡ$UW $R SHUPLWLU D HVWLSXOD§£R GH FRQWUDWRV DWSLFRV H GHWHUPLQDU TXH RV PHVPRV GHYHU£R REVHUYDU DV QRUPDV JHUDLV IL[DGDV QR
&³GLJR TXH SUHFRQL]DP D ERDI© RV ERQV FRVWXPHV D SUHVHUYD§£R GD RUGHP SºEOLFD H RV SULQFSLRV JHUDLV GH GLUHLWR R GLVSRVLWLYR M¡
LPSHGHDHVWLSXOD§£RGHFRQWUDWRVDWSLFRVTXHQ£RDWHQGDPDTXHOHVSUHVVXSRVWRV
3HODPDQXWHQ§£RGRWH[WRߢ
'HQRVVDSDUWHHPERUDSRVVDSDUHFHUTXHROHJLVODGRUQ£RDYDQ§RXPXLWRDVVLPQ£RSHQVDPRV
'DGD D QDWXUH]D GHVWHV FRQWUDWRV DILJXUDVH GH FHUWD IRUPD LPSU³SULR TXH VH SUHWHQGD HVJRWDU VXD
GLVFLSOLQD VHQGR PDLV UD]R¡YHO SRUWDQWR TXH VH GHL[H R VHX WUDWDPHQWR DR VDERU GD DXWRQRPLD GD
YRQWDGHGDVSDUWHVVHPSUHOLPLWDGDSHODVEDOL]DVFRQVWLWXFLRQDLVDFLPDPHQFLRQDGDV
3HQVDPRVSRLVVHUSHUIHLWDPHQWHSRVVYHOTXHVHDGPLWDDDSOLFD§£RGDVQRUPDVJHUDLVGDWHRULDJHUDO
GRV FRQWUDWRV VHPSUH HP REVHUY¢QFLD GRV OLPLWHV GH FRQWUDWD§£R GHOLQHDGRV HP QRVVD &RQVWLWXL§£R
)HGHUDO
2 TXH Q£R SRGHUDPRV © QHJDU D VXD LPSRUW¢QFLD PXLWR EHP QRWDGD SHOR PDJLVWUDO )5$1&(6&2
0(66,1(2 ߡ,O FRQWUDWWR LQQRPLQDWR ¨ OߞLQGL]LR SL¹ VLJQLILFDWLYR FKH OD YLWD JLXULGLFD QRQ VL
IRVVLOL]]D LQ IRUPH LPPXWDELOL H FKH DO FRQWUDULR HVVD ¨ LQ SHUHQQH PRYLPHQWR H LQ FRQVWDQWH
HYROX]LRQHߢ
81,2'(&2175$72628&2175$726&2/,*$'26
&RPR DUUHPDWH GHVWH FDSWXOR DFUHGLWDPRV TXH GHYH VHU IHLWD XPD LPSRUWDQWH DGYHUWªQFLD Q£R
SRGHPRV FRQIXQGLU R FRQWUDWR DWSLFR FRP D XQL£R RX FROLJD§£R GH FRQWUDWRV LQVWLWXWR MXUGLFR GH
QDWXUH]DFRPSOHWDPHQWHGLVWLQWD
2 FRQWUDWR DWSLFR FRPR YLVWR D GHVSHLWR GH FDUHFHU GH SUHYLVLELOLGDGH OHJDO IRUPD XPD XQLGDGH
QHJRFLDO DXW´QRPD GLIHUHQWHPHQWH GD FROLJD§£R GH FRQWUDWRV HP TXH WHPRV Y¡ULRV QHJ³FLRV MXUGLFRV
FRQMXJDGRVXQLGRVHQWUHVL
1HVWD ºOWLPD KLS³WHVH Q£R VH SRGHU¡ UHFRQKHFHU FDU¡WHU GH XQLGDGH VLVWªPLFD QHP PXLWR PHQRV
LGHQWLILF¡ORFRPXPFRQWUDWRDWSLFRXQLGDGHFRQWUDWXDO,VVRSRUTXHQ£RVHHVW¡GLDQWHGHXPDºQLFD
ILJXUDPDVVLPGHY¡ULDVSOXUDOLGDGHFRQWUDWXDO
7DODVSHFWRIRUDPXLWREHPREVHUYDGRSRU0(66,1(2
ߡ,OIHQRPHQRGHOFROOHJDPHQWRRFRQQHVVLRQHIUDFRQWUDWWLVLK TXDQGRXQFRQWUDWWRSUHVHQWLXQFHUWRQHVVRFRQXQDOWURGXSOLFLW VLD
FKH LO QHVVR DEELD FRPH SXQWR GL ULIHULPHQWR LO SULPR FRQWUDWWR VLD FKH DEELD FXPH SXQWR GL ULIHULPHQWR LO VHFRQGR 7DO TXDOLILFD]LRQH
SURYYLVRULDDYU ELVRJQRGLVYLOXSSRPDVHUYHSHUXPSULPRRULHQWDPHQWR
,OSUREOHPDFKHTXLVRUJHGHOODSOXUDOLW RXQLW GLFDXVDHTXLQGLGHOODGXDOLW RSOXUDOLW GLFRQWUDWWL¨LGHQWLFRDTXHOORYDJOLDWRVRSUD
DSURSRVLWRGHOFRQWUDWWRLQQRPLQDWRFDSLWROR;,,,hFRQGLIIHUHQ]DFKHߚPHQWUHLQTXHOFDVRSUHQGHULOLHYRLOIHQRPHQRGHOODGXDOLW
R SOXUDOLW FKH ߚ FRPH DEELDPR QRWDWR ߚ K LO SULPR H QHFHVVDULR SUHVXSSRVWR SHUFK© SRVVD GDUVL FROOHJDPHQWR IUD FRQWUDWWL L
FRQWUDWWLFRPHߝPRQDGLߞߢ
$ GHVSHLWR GH Q£R KDYHU SUHYLV£R OHJDO HVSHFILFD D UHVSHLWR GLVVR © LQHJ¡YHO TXH R IHQ´PHQR GD
FROLJD§£RFRQWUDWXDOSRGHU¡H[LVWLUVHJXQGRDDXWRQRPLDFRQGLFLRQDGDGDYRQWDGHGDVSDUWHV
6LWXD§£R PXLWR FRPXP TXH EHP H[HPSOLILFD D FROLJD§£R GH FRQWUDWRV HQFRQWUDPRV QDV DYHQ§DV
ILUPDGDV HQWUH GRQRV GH SRVWRV GH FRPEXVWYHO H RV GLVWULEXLGRUHV GH GHULYDGRV GH SHWU³OHR
)UHTXHQWHPHQWH DV SDUWHV HQYROYLGDV FHOHEUDP VLPXOWDQHDPHQWH Y¡ULRV FRQWUDWRV FROLJDGRV SRGHQGR
HOHV ILJXUDU QR PHVPR LQVWUXPHQWR RX Q£R $VVLP V£R FHOHEUDGRV FRQWUDWRV GH IRUQHFLPHQWR GH
FRPEXVWYHOFRPRGDWRGDVERPEDVORFD§£RGHHTXLSDPHQWRVHWF7RGRVHOHVMXULGLFDPHQWHYLQFXODGRV
GDQGRFDXVDDXPDFRPSOH[DUHOD§£RMXUGLFDYLQFXODWLYDGDVSDUWHVFRQWUDWDQWHV
(P WHUPRV GH FODVVLILFD§£R VHJXQGR GRXWULQD GH (11(&&(586 UHIHULGD SRU 25/$1'2
*20(6 DXQL£RHQWUHFRQWUDWRVSRGHU¡GDUVHGDVVHJXLQWHVIRUPDV
DXQL£RPHUDPHQWHH[WHUQD
EXQL£RFRPGHSHQGªQFLD
FXQL£RDOWHUQDWLYD
(PWRGDVHODVUHSLWDVHQ£RH[LVWHDIRUPD§£RGHXPFRQWUDWRºQLFRPDVVLPDFRQMXJD§£RGHPDLVGH
XPFRQWUDWR
1R SULPHLUR FDVR WHPVH DSHQDV XPD YLQFXOD§£R PHUDPHQWH GRFXPHQWDO 2V FRQWUDWRV Q£R JXDUGDP
YQFXOR GH IXQFLRQDOLGDGH VLVWªPLFD HQWUH VL PDV DSHQDV V£R FRQVLJQDGRV QR PHVPR LQVWUXPHQWR (P
OLQJXDJHP VLPSOHV H FRORTXLDO FRP D SHUPLVV£R GR QRVVR FDUR OHLWRU H VHP SUHVFLQGLUPRV GR DPRU
W©FQLFDGLUDPRVTXHRVFRQWUDWRVFRPSDUWLOKDPRPHVPROXJDURPHVPRSDSHO'HIDWRQ£RVHWUDWDULD
SURSULDPHQWHGHXPDXQL£RGHFRQWUDWRVPDVDSHQDVGHXPFRPSDUWLOKDPHQWRGHLQVWUXPHQWR
$OL¡V M¡ WLYHPRV RSRUWXQLGDGH GH DGYHUWLU TXH Q£R VH SRGH FRQIXQGLU R FRQWUDWR HQTXDQWR DFRUGR
QHJRFLDO GH YRQWDGHV FXMR QºFOHR © R FRQVHQWLPHQWR GDV SDUWHV FRQWUDWDQWHV FRP R PHUR LQVWUXPHQWR
FRQWUDWXDORGRFXPHQWRTXHFRQFUHWL]DQDUHDOLGDGHH[WHUQDDYRQWDGHGDVSDUWHV1HVVHVHQWLGRDXQL£R
PHUDPHQWHH[WHUQD©LQHTXLYRFDPHQWHVXSHUILFLDO
1R VHJXQGR FDVR RV FRQWUDWRV FROLJDGRV JXDUGDP XPD QWLPD YLQFXOD§£R GH GHSHQGªQFLD HQWUH VL
FRPRRFRUUHQRVFRQWUDWRVILUPDGRVFRPGRQRVGHSRVWRVGHJDVROLQDPHQFLRQDGRVOLQKDVDFLPDRXQD
KLS³WHVHGHFRQWUDWRVSRUH[HPSORGHHPSU©VWLPRߚPºWXRRXFRPRGDWRILUPDGRVHQWUHHPSUHJDGRH
HPSUHJDGRU QR FXUVR GR FRQWUDWR GH HPSUHJR H D HVWH YLQFXODGR 2V FRQWUDWRV XQHPVH IRUPDQGR XPD
HVS©FLHGHEORFRFRQWUDWXDOFDSLODUL]DGRHQWUHVL$LPSUHVV£RTXHVHWHP©TXHVHWUDWDGHXPFRQWUDWR
PLVWR PDV WDO LPDJHP VH GHVID] DR SURFHGHUPRV FRP XPD DQ¡OLVH GH IXQGR H FRQFOXLUPRV SHOD
H[LVWªQFLDGHDXWRQRPLDMXUGLFDHQWUHDVGLYHUVDVILJXUDVYLQFXODGDV
%HPDSURS³VLWRQHVVHSDUWLFXODUV£RDVSDODYUDVGRJUDQGHPHVWUH25/$1'2*20(6
ߡ$ GHSHQGªQFLD SRGH VHU UHFSURFD RX Q£R 1D SULPHLUD IRUPD GRLV FRQWUDWRV FRPSOHWRV HPERUD DXW´QRPRV FRQGLFLRQDPVH
UHFLSURFDPHQWHHPVXDH[LVWªQFLDHYDOLGDGH&DGDTXDO©DFDXVDGRRXWURIRUPDQGRXPDXQLGDGHHFRQ´PLFD(QILPDLQWHQ§£RGDV
SDUWHV©TXHXPQ£RH[LVWDVHPRRXWUR$FROLJD§£RGRVFRQWUDWRVSRGHVHUQHFHVV¡ULDRXYROXQW¡ULD$FROLJD§£RQHFHVV¡ULDWDPE©P
FKDPDGDJHQ©WLFD©LPSRVWDSHODOHLFRPRTXHH[LVWHHQWUHRFRQWUDWRGHWUDQVSRUWHD©UHRHRGHVHJXURGHSDVVDJHLUR4XDQGRGHFRUUH
GDYRQWDGHGRVLQWHUHVVDGRVFRPRVHYHULILFDRUGLQDULDPHQWHGL]VHYROXQW¡ULD9LVWRTXHQHVVDXQL£RGHFRQWUDWRVK¡UHFLSURFLGDGHRV
GRLVVHH[WLQJXHPDRPHVPRWHPSRDGLVVROX§£RGHXPLPSOLFDDGRRXWURߢ
(ILQDOPHQWHDXQL£RDOWHUQDWLYD©DTXHODHPTXHRVFRQWUDWRVV£RH[FOXGHQWHVHQWUHVLSUHYDOHFHQGR
XP HP OXJDU GR RXWUR FDVR GHWHUPLQDGR DFRQWHFLPHQWR RX FLUFXQVW¢QFLD SUHYLVWD SHODV SDUWHV VH
LPSOHPHQWHRFDVRSRUH[HPSORGHXPFRQWUDWRGHGRD§£RFXMDHILF¡FLDHVWHMDFRQGLFLRQDGDDXP
GHWHUPLQDGRHYHQWRVHUDSURYDGRHPXPFRQFXUVRYJHVWDEHOHFHQGRVHTXHFDVRHOHQ£RVHUHDOL]H
DFHVV£RGREHPVHU¡FRQVLGHUDGDFRPRXPPHURFRQWUDWRGHFRPRGDWR7DPE©PQHVWHFDVRHQWHQGHPRV
TXH VH WUDWD GH XPD XQL£R DSDUHQWH FRP YHLR GH VXSHUILFLDOLGDGH YLVWR TXH GH IDWR DSHQDV XP GRV
FRQWUDWRVSUHYDOHFHU¡
(PFRQFOXV£RIULVHVHTXHSRVWRQ£RKRXYHVVHVLGRGLVFLSOLQDGDHPVH§£RHVSHFILFDGRDWXDO&³GLJR
&LYLOSRUPDQLIHVWDGHVQHFHVVLGDGHIRU§D©FRQYLUTXHDFROLJD§£RGHFRQWUDWRV©SHUIHLWDPHQWHSRVVYHO
HPQRVVRGLUHLWRSRVLWLYR
;;,,,
&2035$(9(1'$
&21&(,72(3$57(6
$ GHILQL§£R GR FRQWUDWR GH FRPSUD H YHQGD © H[WUHPDPHQWH VLPSOHV GLVSHQVDQGR JUDQGH HVIRU§R
LQWHOHFWXDO WUDGX] R QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR HP TXH VH SUHWHQGH D DTXLVL§£R GD SURSULHGDGH GH GHWHUPLQDGD
FRLVDPHGLDQWHRSDJDPHQWRGHXPSUH§R
7UDWDVH SRLV GH XP QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR ELODWHUDO SHOR TXDO XPD GDV SDUWHV YHQGHGRUD VH REULJD D
WUDQVIHULUDSURSULHGDGHGHXPDFRLVDP³YHORXLP³YHO RXWUDFRPSUDGRUDPHGLDQWHRSDJDPHQWRGH
XPDTXDQWLDHPGLQKHLURSUH§R
1£R©RXWUDDOL¡VDGLF§£ROHJDOGRQRVVRSU³SULR&³GLJR&LYLOTXHGLVSµH
ߡ$UW3HORFRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGDXPGRVFRQWUDWDQWHVVHREULJDDWUDQVIHULURGRPQLRGHFHUWDFRLVDHRRXWURDSDJDUOKH
FHUWRSUH§RHPGLQKHLURߢ
1RWDVHSRUWDQWRDH[LVWªQFLDGHGRLVDWRUHVIXQGDPHQWDLVQHVWHFHQ¡ULRMXUGLFRRYHQGHGRUTXHVH
REULJD WUDQVIHUªQFLDGRGRPQLRHRFRPSUDGRUTXHVHREULJDDRSDJDPHQWRGRSUH§R
GH VDOLHQWDU HQWUHWDQWR TXH QR VLVWHPD MXUGLFR EUDVLOHLUR R FRQWUDWR GH FRPSUD H YHQGD SURGX]
DSHQDVHIHLWRVMXUGLFRVREULJDFLRQDLVQ£RRSHUDQGRGHSHUVLDWUDQVIHUªQFLDGDSURSULHGDGHVHQ£RD
VLPSOHVREULJD§£RGHID]ªOR
&RP LVVR TXHUHPRVGL]HU TXH FHOHEUDGR R FRQWUDWRGH FRPSUDH YHQGDDV SDUWHV DLQGD Q£R SRGHP
FRQVLGHUDUVHGRQDVGRSUH§RYHQGHGRURXGDFRLVDFRPSUDGRUVHQ£RDW©TXHVHRSHUHDWUDGL§£RGD
FRLVDYHQGLGDHPERUDM¡VHMDPWLWXODUHVGRGLUHLWRGHH[LJLUDVXDSUHVWD§£R
2XVHMDDWUDQVIHUªQFLDGHSURSULHGDGHQRGLUHLWRSRVLWLYREUDVLOHLURUHVXOWDGDFRQVWLWXL§£RGRWWXOR
FRQWUDWRHGHXPDSRVWHULRUVROHQLGDGHPRGRߚWUDGL§£RGREHPP³YHOUHJLVWURGREHPLP³YHO3RU
H[HPSORVH&DLRFHOHEURXFRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGDFRP6LOYLRYHQGHGRUHQTXDQWRQ£RVHRSHUDUR
UHJLVWURGRWWXORFRQVWLWXWLYRQRFDUW³ULRGHLP³YHLVRSULPHLURQ£RSRGHU¡VHUUHSXWDGRGRQRGDFRLVD
6REHVWHDVSHFWRGHPRQVWUDQGRDQDWXUH]DMXUGLFDREULJDFLRQDOGRFRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGDHUD
EDVWDQWHFODURR$QWHSURMHWRGR&³GLJRGH2EULJD§µHVGHDXWRULDGRJUDQGH&$,205,2'$6,/9$
3(5(,5$TXHHPVHXDUWGLVSXQKD
ߡ2FRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGDFRQVWLWXLRWWXORFDXVDOGDWUDQVIHUªQFLDGHGRPQLRDTXDOVHRSHUDSHODWUDGL§£RRXSHODWUDQVFUL§£RQR
UHJLVWUR GD VHGH GRLP³YHO H Q£R SRGH VHU REVWDGD SHOD PRUWH GR YHQGHGRU QHP SRU DWR HPDQDGR GHVWH RX GH WHUFHLUR VDOYR FDVR GH
GºYLGDOHYDQWDGDSHUDQWHRRILFLDOGRUHJLVWURRXSRUHOHSU³SULRߢ JULIRVQRVVRV
&ODUR HVW¡ ILQDOPHQWH TXH DV SDUWHV HQYROYLGDV QHVWH FRQWUDWR GHYHP VHU GRWDGDV GRV UHTXLVLWRV GH
FDSDFLGDGHHOHJLWLPLGDGHLQGLVSHQV¡YHLVSDUDDSHUIHLWDYDOLGDGHQ£RVRPHQWHGDDYHQ§DHPTXHVW£R
PDVWDPE©PGHTXDOTXHUQHJ³FLRMXUGLFR
&$5$&7(567,&$6
7UDWDVHHPVQWHVHGHXPQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRELODWHUDOHVLQDODJP¡WLFRHPUHJUDFRQVHQVXDOFRPXWDWLYR
RXDOHDW³ULRDXWRUL]DGRUGDWUDQVIHUªQFLDGHSURSULHGDGHGHH[HFX§£RLQVWDQW¢QHDRXGLIHULGD HQWUH
RXWUDVFDUDFWHUVWLFDV
1HVVHVHQWLGR©FRQYHQLHQWHOHPEUDUTXHQRVGLDVTXHFRUUHPDFRPSUDHYHQGD©FRVWXPHLUDPHQWH
SDFWXDGDVREDIRUPDGHFRQWUDWRGHDGHV£R
XP FRQWUDWR ELODWHUDO QD VXD IRUPD§£R SRLV H[LJH D FRQMXJD§£R GDV YRQWDGHV FRQWUDSRVWDV GR
YHQGHGRUHGRFRPSUDGRUDVTXDLVTXDQGRKDUPRQL]DGDVIRUPDPRFRQVHQWLPHQWRQºFOHRGRUHIHULGR
QHJ³FLR 6RE RXWUR HQIRTXH © FRQVLGHUDGR ELODWHUDO SRU JHUDU RX SURGX]LU GLUHLWRV H REULJD§µHV SDUD
DPEDVDVSDUWHVHQYROYLGDVQDDYHQ§D
7HPRVDVVLPVRERFULW©ULRHPLQHQWHPHQWHFLHQWILFRTXHRFRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGD©ELODWHUDOQD
VXDIRUPD§£RHTXDQWRDRVVHXVHIHLWRV
1HVVDPHVPDOLQKDGDVXDQVLWDELODWHUDOLGDGHUHVXOWDDFRQVHTXHQWHFDUDFWHUVWLFDGDH[LVWªQFLDGR
VLQDODJPDHQWUHDVSUHVWD§µHVSDFWXDGDV)DODVHSRLVTXH©XPFRQWUDWRELODWHUDOHVLQDODJP¡WLFR
(RTXHYLULDDVHUSRLVRVLQDODJPD"
(PQRVVRVHQWLURVLQDODJPDFDUDFWHUVWLFDLPDQHQWHDRVFRQWUDWRVELODWHUDLVWUDGX]LULDDUHOD§£RRX
QH[RGHFDXVDOLGDGHUHFLSURFLGDGHHQWUHDVSUHVWD§µHVRSRVWDVSDFWXDGDV$VVLPDSUHVWD§£RGHYLGD
SHORYHQGHGRUWUDQVIHULUDSURSULHGDGHGDFRLVDVHULDFRUUHODWDUHFSURFDRXFRUUHVSHFWLYDSRUIRU§D
GRVLQDODJPD HPIDFH GD SUHVWD§£R GR FRPSUDGRU SDJDU RSUH§R+¡ FRPR VH Yª HQWUHDPEDVXPD
LQHTXYRFDUHOD§£RGHUHFLSURFLGDGHRSUH§RVRPHQWH©GHYLGRSRUTXHDFRLVDWDPE©PR©HYLFHYHUVD
$O©PGHELODWHUDO©HPJHUDOFRQVHQVXDORXVHMDWRUQDVHSHUIHLWRTXDQGRDVSDUWHVFRQYHQFLRQDPD
UHVSHLWRGRSUH§RHGDFRLVDDVHUYHQGLGD9DOHGL]HURFRQWUDWRVHIRUPDSHORVLPSOHVFRQVHQWLPHQWR
LQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWHGDHQWUHJDGREHP
9HMDQHVVHSRQWRRQRVVRUHJUDPHQWROHJDO
ߡ$UW$FRPSUDHYHQGDTXDQGRSXUDFRQVLGHUDUVH¡REULJDW³ULDHSHUIHLWDGHVGHTXHDVSDUWHVDFRUGDUHPQRREMHWRHQRSUH§Rߢ
'DOHLWXUDGRVXSUDPHQFLRQDGRGLVSRVLWLYR©SRVVYHOH[WUDLURVHOHPHQWRVHVVHQFLDLVGRFRQWUDWRGH
FRPSUDHYHQGDFRQVHQWLPHQWRFRLVDHSUH§RRTXHHVPLX§DUHPRVQRSU³[LPRW³SLFR
DLQGDHVS©FLHGHQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRRQHURVRSRGHQGRVHUFRPXWDWLYRRXDOHDW³ULR
RQHURVRSRUTXHWUDGX]SDUDFDGDSDUWHRH[SHULPHQWRGHXPJDQKRRXEHQHIFLRHDFRQVHTXHQWH
GLPLQXL§£RSDWULPRQLDORYHQGHGRUVHEHQHILFLDFRPRSUH§RHSHUGHDFRLVDRFRPSUDGRUVHEHQHILFLD
FRPDFRLVDHSHUGHRSUH§R
9DOH UHJLVWUDU TXH VRPHQWH QRV FRQWUDWRV RQHURVRV © TXH R DOLHQDQWH UHVSRQGHU¡ SHORV ULVFRV GD
HYLF§£R QD IRUPD GR DUW GR && EHP FRPR SHORV YFLRV UHGLELW³ULRV DEULQGRVH DR
DGTXLUHQWHQHVWHFDVRDSRVVLELOLGDGHGHUHMHLWDUDFRLVDUHGLELQGRRFRQWUDWRYLDD§£RUHGLELW³ULDRX
UHFODPDURDEDWLPHQWRQRSUH§RYLDD§£RHVWLPDW³ULDRXTXDQWLPLQRULV
5HVVDOWHVH SRU©P TXH QD IRUPD GR DUW GR && QDV ߡFRLVDV YHQGLGDV FRQMXQWDPHQWH R
GHIHLWR RFXOWR GH XPD Q£R DXWRUL]D D UHMHL§£R GH WRGDVߢ 7DO UHJUD HP QRVVR HQWHQGLPHQWR GHYH VHU
WHPSHUDGDHPIXQ§£RGDXWLOLGDGHGDFRLVDFROHWLYD(PVHWUDWDQGRGHXPDXQLYHUVDOLGDGHSRUH[HPSOR
XPDELEOLRWHFDRXXPDFROH§£RGHVHORVFXMRYDORUHPVHXFRQMXQWRSRGHVXSHUDURYDORUGHFDGDXP
GRVLWHQVVRPDGRVLQGLYLGXDOPHQWHFRQVLGHUDGRVRXQDKLS³WHVHGHDDXVªQFLDGHXPLQXWLOL]DURXID]HU
SHUGHU R VHQWLGR GD DTXLVL§£R GRV GHPDLV H[ SDU GH EULQFRV FDUWDV GH EDUDOKR HWF VHP TXH VHMDP
FRQVLGHUDGRVSRULVVRPHUDVSDUWHVLQWHJUDQWHVDUHJUDOHJDOSRGHQ£RID]HUVHQWLGRVHDSOLFDGD
1HVVD OLQKD SRGHU¡ VHU FRPXWDWLYR VH DV SUHVWD§µHV GDV SDUWHV IRUHP FHUWDV RX DOHDW³ULR VH Q£R
KRXYHUFHUWH]DTXDQWR RFRUUªQFLDGHXPDGDVSUHVWD§µHV$HVVHUHVSHLWRFRPDEVROXWDSURSULHGDGH
6/9,29(126$SRQWLILFD
ߡ©FRQWUDWRJHUDOPHQWHFRPXWDWLYRSRUTXHQRPRPHQWRGHVXDFRQFOXV£RDVSDUWHVFRQKHFHPRFRQWHºGRGHVXDSUHVWD§£R$GPLWHVHD
FRPSUD H YHQGD DOHDW³ULD TXDQGR XPD GDV SDUWHV SRGH Q£R FRQKHFHU GH LQFLR R FRQWHºGR GH VXD SUHVWD§£R R TXH Q£R VXSULPH RV
IXQGDPHQWRVE¡VLFRVGRQHJ³FLRߢ
([HPSORGHFRQWUDWRDOHDW³ULR©DFRPSUDHYHQGDGHXPDVDIUDGHVRMD
3RGHPRV DLQGD GL]HU TXH © XP FRQWUDWR DXWRUL]DGRU GD WUDQVIHUªQFLD GH SURSULHGDGH 6REUH HVVD
FDUDFWHUVWLFD M¡ GLVFRUUHPRV DFLPD TXDQGR PHQFLRQDPRV TXH D REULJD§£R SULQFLSDO GR YHQGHGRU ©
WUDQVIHULURGRPQLRGDFRLVDDRSDVVRTXHDGRFRPSUDGRU©RSUH§R)ULVHVHPDLVXPDYH]TXHHVVH
HIHLWRWUDQVODWLYR©FRQVHTXªQFLDGRFRQWUDWRHVRPHQWHVHFRQFUHWL]DSRUPHLRGDWUDGL§£RP³YHLVH
GRUHJLVWURLP³YHLV 2EVHUYHVH SRU©P TXHD FRPSUDH YHQGD © QDFODVVLILFD§£R GRVFRQWUDWRV
UHFLSURFDPHQWHFRQVLGHUDGRVXPFRQWUDWRSULQFLSDOHGHILQLWLYR
2FRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGDSRGHDLQGDVHGDUWDQWRQDPRGDOLGDGHSDULW¡ULDTXDQWRQDGHDGHV£RD
GHSHQGHUGHDVSDUWHVHVWDUHPHPLJXDLVFRQGL§µHVGHQHJRFLD§£RHVWDEHOHFHQGROLYUHPHQWHDVFO¡XVXODV
FRQWUDWXDLVQDIDVHGHSXQWXD§£RRXVHXPGRVSDFWXDQWHVSUHGHWHUPLQDRXVHMDLPSµHDVFO¡XVXODVGR
QHJ³FLRMXUGLFRUHVSHFWLYDPHQWH
QHJ³FLRMXUGLFRGHDPSODXWLOL]D§£RFRPRM¡GLWRSHORTXH©LQYRFDGRHPTXDVHWRGRVRVWLSRVGH
UHOD§µHV FRQWUDWXDLV FLYLV FRPHUFLDLV FRQVXPHULVWDV H DGPLQLVWUDWLYRV VDOYR DV WUDEDOKLVWDV SRLV
QHVWDPRGDOLGDGH©DIRU§DGHWUDEDOKRRXVHMDHPºOWLPDDQ¡OLVHRSU³SULRWUDEDOKDGRUTXH©RREMHWR
GDUHOD§£RMXUGLFDGHGLUHLWRPDWHULDO
7UDWDVH DLQGD GH XP FRQWUDWR TXH SRGH GDUVH WDQWR GH IRUPD OLYUH RX VHMD Q£R VROHQH RX D
FRQWUDULRVHQVXFRPULJRUIRUPDOFRQWUDWRVROHQHTXDQGRHQYROYDEHQVLP³YHLVDWHRUGRDUWGR
&&
4XDQWR GHVLJQD§£RWUDWDVHSRU³EYLRGHXPFRQWUDWRQRPLQDGRHSHODH[LVWªQFLDGHXPDGLVFLSOLQD
OHJDOHVSHFILFDGHXPFRQWUDWRWSLFR
2 FRQWUDWR GH FRPSUD H YHQGD © WDPE©P XP FRQWUDWR LPSHVVRDO SRLV V³ LQWHUHVVD R UHVXOWDGR GD
DWLYLGDGH FRQWUDWDGD LQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWH GH TXHP VHMD D SHVVRD TXH LU¡ UHDOL]¡OD 'HVVD IRUPD
IDOHFHQGR R FRPSUDGRU RX YHQGHGRU DQWHV GD WUDGL§£R GD FRLVD RX GD WUDQVFUL§£R UHJLVWUR GD
WUDQVIHUªQFLDSRGHDSURYLGªQFLDVHUH[LJLGDGRVHXHVS³OLR
WDPE©P XP FRQWUDWR FDXVDO TXH SRGH VHU LQYDOLGDGR TXDQGR R VHX PRWLYR GHWHUPLQDQWH IRU
LQH[LVWHQWHLOFLWRRXLPRUDO
0HVPR WUDWDQGRVH GH FRQWUDWR TXH HQYROYH QRUPDOPHQWH GXDV SHVVRDV © FRQVLGHUDGR XP FRQWUDWR
LQGLYLGXDOSRLVVHUHIHUHDXPDHVWLSXOD§£RHQWUHSHVVRDVGHWHUPLQDGDVDLQGDTXHHPQºPHURHOHYDGR
PDVFRQVLGHUDGDVLQGLYLGXDOPHQWH
3HOD IXQ§£R HFRQ´PLFD HVWDEHOHFH XPD WURFD YLVWR TXH VH FDUDFWHUL]D SHOD SHUPXWD GH XWLOLGDGHV
HFRQ´PLFDVVHQGRXPDGHODVRGLQKHLUR
)LQDOPHQWH © XP FRQWUDWR LQVWDQW¢QHR SHOR IDWR GH VHXV HIHLWRV VHUHP SURGX]LGRV GH XPD V³ YH]
SRGHQGRVHUGHH[HFX§£RLPHGLDWDߚTXDQGRVHFRQVXPDQRPRPHQWRGDFHOHEUD§£RFRPDHQWUHJDGR
EHPP³YHORXUHJLVWURGRFRQWUDWRGHWUDQVIHUªQFLDGHEHPLP³YHOߚRXGLIHULGDߚTXDQGRDVSDUWHV
IL[DPSUD]RSDUDDVXDH[LJLELOLGDGHRXFXPSULPHQWR
(/(0(1726(66(1&,$,6
$LQGD TXH RV UHTXLVLWRV SODQRV GH H[LVWªQFLD H YDOLGDGH GRV QHJ³FLRV MXUGLFRV VHMDP LPDQHQWHV D
WRGDV DV HVS©FLHV FRQWUDWXDLV PHUHFHPHOHVQR FRQWUDWR GHFRPSUD H YHQGD DOJXPDV HVSHFLILFD§µHVH
PLQXGªQFLDV
'H IDWR GD OHLWXUD GR PHQFLRQDGR DUW GR && FRPR YLVWR © SRVVYHO H[WUDLU RV
HOHPHQWRVHVVHQFLDLVHVSHFILFRVGDFRPSUDHYHQGDDVDEHU
DRFRQVHQWLPHQWRVHXQºFOHR
ERSUH§R
FDFRLVD
$QDOLVHPRVVHSDUDGDPHQWHFDGDXPGHVVHVUHTXLVLWRV
2FRQVHQWLPHQWR
6XSHUDGD D IDVH GDV WUDWDWLYDV SUHOLPLQDUHV DR ILUPDUHP DV SDUWHV VHX FRQVHQWLPHQWR D UHVSHLWR GR
SUH§RHGDFRLVDDVHUYHQGLGDRFRQWUDWRUHSXWDVHIRUPDGRLQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWHGHIRUPDSUHYLDPHQWH
HVWDEHOHFLGDHPOHL
1RWHVHHQWUHWDQWRTXHHPQRVVRVLVWHPDVHRFRQWUDWRYHUVDUVREUHLP³YHOTXHVXSODQWHRWHWRGH
VDO¡ULRV PQLPRV FRQVLGHUDVH LQGLVSHQV¡YHO D ODYUDWXUD GR DWR HP HVFULWXUD SºEOLFD VRE SHQD GH
QXOLGDGHDEVROXWD
1HVVHVHQWLGRRDUWGRQRVVR&³GLJR&LYLO
ߡ$UW 1£R GLVSRQGR D OHL HP FRQWU¡ULR D HVFULWXUD SºEOLFD © HVVHQFLDO YDOLGDGH GRV QHJ³FLRV MXUGLFRV TXH YLVHP FRQVWLWXL§£R
WUDQVIHUªQFLDPRGLILFD§£RRXUHQºQFLDGHGLUHLWRVUHDLVVREUHLP³YHLVGHYDORUVXSHULRUDWULQWDYH]HVRPDLRUVDO¡ULRPQLPRYLJHQWHQR
3DVߢ
1£R VHFRQIXQGD RXWURVVLPD H[LJªQFLD GDIRUPD SºEOLFD GR FRQWUDWRGHILQLWLYRGH FRPSUDH YHQGD
FRP D GR FRQWUDWR SUHOLPLQDU GH SURPHVVD M¡ TXH SDUD HVWH ºOWLPR D OHL WDPE©P DGPLWLX D IRUPD
SDUWLFXODUDUWFDEHQGRQRVOHPEUDUTXHߡXPDGDVYDQWDJHQVGDSURPHVVDGHFRPSUDHYHQGD©
H[DWDPHQWHDSRVVLELOLGDGHGHVXDIRUPDOL]D§£RVHPRVULJRUHVGRLQVWUXPHQWRSºEOLFRߢ
$FRLVD
3RU³EYLDUD]£RREHPREMHWRGRFRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGDGHYHU¡VHUFRLVDSDVVYHOGHFLUFXOD§£R
QRFRP©UFLRMXUGLFRDFRLVDQ£RSRGHVHUEHPIRUDGRFRP©UFLRVHMDSRUGLVSRVL§£RGHOHLFRQWUDWRRX
SRUVXDSU³SULDQDWXUH]DFHUWDHGHWHUPLQDGDRXGHWHUPLQ¡YHORTXHDIDVWDSRUFRQVHTXªQFLDWRGRV
RV LQWHUHVVHV Q£R VXVFHWYHLV GH DIHUL§£R RX YDORU HFRQ´PLFR HVVHQFLDO FRPR D KRQUD R QRPH D
LQWHJULGDGHIVLFDDYLGDHWF
)L[DGD WDO SUHPLVVD ILFD FODUR TXH XPD TXDQWLGDGH LQLPDJLQ¡YHO GH REMHWRV SRGH WUDQVIHULUVH SRU
PHLRGDFRPSUDHYHQGDRTXHLQFOXVLYHDO©PGHGHPRQVWUDUSURJUHVVRFXOWXUDOHHVSLULWXDOHPORQJR
SHURGRGD$QWLJXLGDGHRVEHQVFLUFXODYDPHVSHFLDOPHQWHSRUIRU§DGDVJXHUUDVHEDWDOKDVIDYRUHFHH
HVWLPXODDHFRQRPLD
'HVQHFHVV¡ULRQRWDUDLQGDTXHREHPߚSDVVYHOGHWUDQVIHUªQFLDߚGHYHU¡VHUGHSURSULHGDGHGR
YHQGHGRU VRE SHQD GH R QHJ³FLR VHU QXOR SRU IDOWD GH SRVVLELOLGDGH MXUGLFD SRU FDUDFWHUL]DU D
LQGHVHM¡YHODOLHQD§£RDQRQGRPLQR$SHQDVSRUH[FH§£RSRGHPRVDGPLWLUTXHDFRLVDYHQGLGDSRVVD
VHUDOKHLDGHVGHTXHRYHQGHGRUDDGTXLUDDQWHVGHRFRPSUDGRUVRIUHUDSHUGD
1RWHVHHQWUHWDQWRTXHVHRREMHWRGRQHJ³FLRIRUHPGLUHLWRVߚHQ£RFRLVDVߚPDLVW©FQLFRVHULD
GHQRPLQ¡ORFRQWUDWRGHFHVV£RGHGLUHLWRVHPYH]GHFRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGD
1DWULOKDGHSHQVDPHQWRGH3$%/2672/=(*$*/,$12ߡUHSXWDPRVPDLVDSURSULDGDDXWLOL]D§£R
GDSDODYUDDOLHQD§£RSDUDFDUDFWHUL]DUDWUDQVIHUªQFLDGHFRLVDVGHXPWLWXODUSDUDRRXWURUHVHUYDQGRD
H[SUHVV£RFHVV£RSDUDRVGLUHLWRVHPJHUDOߢ
RFDVRGDFHVV£RRQHURVDGRGLUHLWRKHUHGLW¡ULRRXGHTXRWDVGHGHWHUPLQDGDVRFLHGDGH
3RVWRLVVRSRGHPRVREVHUYDUTXHR&³GLJR&LYLOHPVHXDUW DGPLWHTXHDFRPSUDHYHQGD
WHQKDSRUREMHWRFRLVDVDWXDLVRXIXWXUDV
3RUFRLVDDWXDOHQWHQGHVHRREMHWRH[LVWHQWHHGLVSRQYHODRWHPSRGDFHOHEUD§£RGRQHJ³FLRDFRLVD
IXWXUD SRU VXD YH] © DTXHOD TXH SRVWR DLQGD Q£R WHQKD H[LVWªQFLD UHDO © GH SRWHQFLDO RFRUUªQFLD
,PDJLQHVH SRU H[HPSOR D FRPSUD GH XPD VDIUD GH FDFDX TXH DLQGD Q£R IRL SODQWDGD (P WDO FDVR R
FRQWUDWR ILFDU¡ VHP HIHLWR VH D FRLVD Q£R YLHU D H[LVWLU FRQVRDQWH SUHYLVWR QR PHVPR GLVSRVLWLYR
UHVVDOYDGDDKLS³WHVHGHDVSDUWHVWHUHPSUHWHQGLGRSDFWXDUFRQWUDWRDOHDW³ULR
2OHJLVODGRUFXLGRXDLQGDGHHVWDEHOHFHUTXHFDVRDYHQGDVHUHDOL]H YLVWDGHDPRVWUDSURW³WLSRVRX
PRGHORVHQWHQGHUVH¡TXHRYHQGHGRUDVVHJXUDWHUDFRLVDDVTXDOLGDGHVTXHDHODFRUUHVSRQGHPDUW
7UDWDVHGHUHJUDFODUDM¡H[LVWHQWHQRFDPSRGR'LUHLWRGR&RQVXPLGRUHDJRUDGHILQLWLYDPHQWH
LPSODQWDGDSDUDRVFRQWUDWRVFLYLVHPJHUDO
2UDVHRTXHVHSUHWHQGHXFRPDHGL§£RGRQRYRGLSORPDGHQWUHRXWUDVILQDOLGDGHVIRLDEXVFDGD
FRQFUHWL]D§£RGRLGHDO©WLFRQRSODQRMXUGLFRQDGDPDLVMXVWRTXH OX]GRSULQFSLRGDERDI©REMHWLYD
DSDUWHYHQGHGRUDYHQKDDFXPSULURVHXGHYHUGHOHDOGDGHFRQWUDWXDOFRPDP¡[LPDGLOLJªQFLD
(VVD SUHYLV£R OHJDO WHP TXH YHU DOL¡V FRP RV SULQFSLRV GD HWLFLGDGH H VRFLDOLGDGH FXMR FRQWHºGR
QDGDPDLVID]GRTXHUHODWLYL]DUDIUXL§£RGHXPGLUHLWRVXEMHWLYRߡUHFRQKHFHQGRVHߢVHJXQGR0,*8(/
5($/( ߡTXH HVWH GHYH VHU H[HUFLGR HP EHQHIFLR GD SHVVRD PDV VHPSUH UHVSHLWDGRV RV ILQV ©WLFR
VRFLDLVGDFRPXQLGDGHDTXHRVHXWLWXODUSHUWHQFH1£RK¡HPVXPDGLUHLWRVLQGLYLGXDLVDEVROXWRVXPD
YH]TXHRGLUHLWRGHFDGDXPDFDEDRQGHRGHRXWUHPFRPH§Dߢ
3RULVVRPHVPRFXPSUHQRVOHPEUDUTXHKDYHQGRFRQWUDGL§£RRXGLIHUHQ§DHQWUHDPDQHLUDSHODTXDO
VHGHVFUHYHXDFRLVDQRFRQWUDWRHDDPRVWUDSURW³WLSRPRGHORSUHYDOHFHU¡TXDOTXHUGHVWHVºOWLPRVXPD
YH]TXHVHSUHVXPHWHQKDRFRPSUDGRUVHRULHQWDGRSHORREMHWRDSUHVHQWDGRSDUDDHIHWLYD§£RGDFRPSUD
1R FDPSR GR 'LUHLWR GR &RQVXPLGRU GHYHU¡ SUHYDOHFHU D RIHUWD D SXEOLFLGDGH RX R DQºQFLR IHLWR
SHOR IRUQHFHGRU GR SURGXWR RX VHUYL§R FDEHQGR DR FRQVXPLGRU FRPSUDGRU DOWHUQDWLYDPHQWH H VXD
HVFROKDH[LJLURFXPSULPHQWRIRU§DGRGDREULJD§£RQRVWHUPRVGDRIHUWDDSUHVHQWD§£RRXSXEOLFLGDGH
DFHLWDU RXWUR SURGXWR RX SUHVWD§£R GH VHUYL§R HTXLYDOHQWH RX ILQDOPHQWH UHVFLQGLU R FRQWUDWR FRP
GLUHLWR UHVWLWXL§£RGDTXDQWLDHYHQWXDOPHQWHDQWHFLSDGDPRQHWDULDPHQWHDWXDOL]DGDHDSHUGDVHGDQRV
DUWGR&'&
1RGL]HUGH9$6&21&(//26(%(1-$0,1
ߡ$SDUFHULDHQWUHR'LUHLWRHDFRPXQLFD§£RPHUFDGRO³JLFDFRPRFRQVXPLGRUHYROXLXGHXPDSURWH§£RH[WUDFRQWUDWXDOIU¡JLOSDUDXPD
WXWHODHIHWLYDQDIDVHGDIRUPD§£RGRFRQWUDWRHDSDUWLUGHVWDSDUDXPUHJLPHHVSHFLDOGHH[HFX§£RGRGRFXPHQWRFRQWUDWXDOQHVWD
ºOWLPD FRQFHS§£R TXH DV PHQVDJHQV PHUFDGRO³JLFDV HP SDUWLFXODU D SXEOLFLGDGH JDQKDP IRU§D REULJDW³ULD WUDQVIRUPDQGRVH D
FRPXQLFD§£RSXEOLFLW¡ULDHPDXWªQWLFRVHUYL§RLQIRUPDWLYRHPEHQHIFLRGRVFRQVXPLGRUHVߢ
)RU§D©FRQYLUSRUWDQWRTXHRVLVWHPDSURWHWLYRGR&³GLJRGH'HIHVDGR&RQVXPLGRU©PDLVDPSOR
GRTXHRILJXUDGRQR&³GLJR&LYLOEUDVLOHLUR
2SUH§R
2 SUH§R © XP SUHVVXSRVWR H[LVWHQFLDO RX HOHPHQWR FRQVWLWXWLYR HVSHFILFR GR FRQWUDWR GH FRPSUD H
YHQGD
&XLGRXRFRGLILFDGRUGHGLVSHQVDUFLQFRDUWLJRVSDUDUHJXODURSUH§RQRFRQWUDWRVREHVWXGRDUWV
D
(PSULQFSLRRSUH§RGHYHU¡VHUIL[DGRSHODVSU³SULDVSDUWHVVHJXQGRDDXWRQRPLDGHVXDVYRQWDGHV
(QWHQGHPRV FRQWXGR TXH D DXWRQRPLD GD YRQWDGH QR FDVR HVSHFILFR Q£R © DEVROXWD XPD YH] TXH R
SUH§R GHYH REVHUYDU R SULQFSLR GD HTXLYDOªQFLD PDWHULDO GDV SUHVWD§µHV EHP FRPR GHYH VHU
FRQVLGHUDGR V©ULR QR VHQWLGR GH Q£R QILPR SRLV HP FDVR FRQWU¡ULR FRQILJXUDUVHLD XPD GRD§£R
VLPXODGD
1£R K¡ ³ELFH SRU©P D TXH R SUH§R VHMD LQGLFDGR SRU WHUFHLUR D VHU GHVLJQDGR SHORV SU³SULRV
FRQWUDHQWHV(VWHWHUFHLURDWXDULDFRPR¡UELWURHVSHFLDOPHQWHQRPHDGRSDUDUHDOL]DUDIL[D§£RGDTXDQWLD
DVHUSDJDSHORFRPSUDGRU(VSHUDVHSRUWDQWRGHVWHVXMHLWROLVXUDHERPVHQVRQRFXPSULPHQWRGRVHX
HQFDUJR
1D KLS³WHVH HQWUHWDQWR GH R WHUFHLUR Q£R DFHLWDU D LQFXPEªQFLD ILFDU¡ VHP HIHLWR R FRQWUDWR
UHVVDOYDGDDKLS³WHVHGHRVFRQWUDWDQWHVGHVLJQDUHPRXWUDSHVVRDDUW
(PQRVVRSHQVDUFDVRRWHUFHLURGHQHJXHHDVSDUWHVQ£RLQGLTXHPVXEVWLWXWRFRQFOXPRVQ£RVHUFDVR
GH VLPSOHV LQHILF¡FLD GR FRQWUDWR PDV IXQGDPHQWDOPHQWH GH LQH[LVWªQFLD SRU DXVªQFLD GH UHTXLVLWR
HVSHFILFRSUH§RFRQVRDQWHPHQFLRQDGROLQKDVDFLPD
1DGDLPSHGHRXWURVVLPTXHVHGHL[HDIL[D§£RGRSUH§R WD[DGHPHUFDGRRXGHEROVDHPFHUWRH
GHWHUPLQDGRGLDHOXJDUDUW
6REUHHVVDSRVVLELOLGDGHSRQGHUDFRPSUHFLV£R6/9,2'(6$/929(126$TXH
ߡVH QD GDWD IL[DGD KRXYHU RFRUULGR RVFLOD§£R GH SUH§R OHYDUVH¡ HP FRQWD R SUH§R P©GLR VH R FRQWUDWR Q£R HVWLSXODU GLIHUHQWHPHQWH
FRPR SRU H[HPSOR R SUH§R PDLV DOWR RX PDLV EDL[R GR GLD R SUH§R GH GHWHUPLQDGR KRU¡ULR R SUH§R GH DEHUWXUD RX HQFHUUDPHQWR GR
PHUFDGRRXGRSUHJ£RHWFߢ
'H IDWR DV SDUWHV WªP SOHQD OLEHUGDGH GH SURFHGHU V GHYLGDV DOWHUD§µHV H DGDSWD§µHV HP IDFH GR
QGLFHRXFULW©ULRHVFROKLGRVHQ£RKRXYHUSRUFHUWRUD]£RVXSHULRUTXHOLPLWHHVVDIDFXOGDGH
1HVVDPHVPDOLQKDSRGHU£RDVSDUWHVVHUYLUVHGHQGLFHVRXSDU¢PHWURVREMHWLYRVSDUDDIL[D§£RGR
SUH§RGHVGHTXHQ£RVHMDPDEXVLYRVRXH[WRUVLYRV
,QWHUHVVDQWH QRWDU DLQGD TXH R DUW GR &³GLJR DGPLWH D XWLOL]D§£R GR FRVWXPH SUDHWHU OHJHP
VHJXQGR DV YHQGDV KDELWXDLV GD SDUWH YHQGHGRUD HP FDU¡WHU VXSOHWLYR FDVR R FRQWUDWR VHMD
FRQYHQFLRQDGRVHPIL[D§£RGHSUH§RRXGHFULW©ULRVSDUDDVXDGHWHUPLQD§£RHQ£RKRXYHUWDEHODPHQWR
RILFLDO
$WWXORGHUHYLV£ROHPEUHPRQRVQDWULOKDGHSHQVDPHQWRGRLQVXSHU¡YHO125%(572%2%%,2TXH
ߡXPH[HPSORTXDVHTXHLQGLVFXWLGRGHIRQWHUHFRQKHFLGD©UHSUHVHQWDGRSHORFRVWXPH1HVWHFDVRFRPHIHLWRHVWDPRVGLDQWHGHUHJUDV
SURGX]LGDV SHOD YLGD VRFLDO H[WHUQDPHQWH DR RUGHQDPHQWR MXUGLFR GR (VWDGR H SRU HVWH ºOWLPR DFROKLGDV QXP VHJXQGR PRPHQWR FRPR
QRUPDVMXUGLFDVߢ
7DO UHJUD VHP FRUUHVSRQGHQWH QR &³GLJR DQWHULRU DILJXUDVHQRV PXLWR ºWLO SRLV SHUPLWH D
VXEVLVWªQFLDGRFRQWUDWRSDFWXDGR
)ULVHVH SRU ILP TXH Q£R KDYHQGR DFRUGR QHVWD KLS³WHVH SRU WHU KDYLGR GLYHUVLGDGH GH SUH§R
SUHYDOHFHU¡RWHUPRP©GLRRXVHMDRYDORUP©GLRUHVXOWDQWHGRVSUH§RVSUDWLFDGRVSHORYHQGHGRUQRV
ºOWLPRVWHPSRVQDIRUPDGRSDU¡JUDIRºQLFRGRPHQFLRQDGRDUW
&XPSUHQRVDGYHUWLUDLQGDTXHDOHLUHSXWDQXORGHSOHQRGLUHLWRRFRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGDTXDQGR
VHGHL[HDRH[FOXVLYRDUEWULRGHXPDGDVSDUWHVDIL[D§£RGRSUH§RDUW7UDWDVHGHUHJUDFODUD
TXHGHFRUUHGDSURLEL§£ROHJDOGDVFO¡XVXODVRXFRQGL§µHVSXUDPHQWHSRWHVWDWLYDVUHSXWDGDVLOFLWDVSRU
WUDGX]LUHPXPDDUELWU¡ULDPDQLIHVWD§£RGDYRQWDGHKXPDQD
SUHFLVR TXH VH REVHUYH DLQGD TXH VH SRU XP ODGR D OHL YHGD R HVWDEHOHFLPHQWR GH FRQGL§£R TXH
GHULYHH[FOXVLYDPHQWHGRFDSULFKRGHXPDGDVSDUWHVWDOQ£RRFRUUHQDFKDPDGDYHQGDDFRQWHQWRSDFWR
DFHVV³ULR TXH G¡ GLUHLWR DR FRPSUDGRU GH H[SHULPHQWDU D FRLVD DQWHV GH DFHLW¡OD XPD YH] TXH D VXD
FDXVDQ£R©RDUEWULRPDVVLPDVDWLVID§£RGRDGTXLUHQWHRTXH©SOHQDPHQWHDGPLWLGRSRUOHL
3RU ILP YDOH OHPEUDU TXH QD IRUPD GR DUW Q£R VHQGR ߡD YHQGD D FU©GLWR R YHQGHGRU Q£R ©
REULJDGRDHQWUHJDUDFRLVDDQWHVGHUHFHEHURSUH§Rߢ7DOUHJUD©DPDLVSHUIHLWDWUDGX§£RGDH[FHSWLR
QRQ DGLPSOHWL FRQWUDFWXV H[FH§£R GH FRQWUDWR Q£R FXPSULGR WSLFD GRV FRQWUDWRV ELODWHUDLV H
UHYHOD TXH GDGR TXH QHP VHPSUH D VLPXOWDQHLGDGH GH SUHVWD§µHV © DOFDQ§¡YHO HPERUD VHPSUH
UHFRPHQG¡YHOK¡JUDQGHLPSRUW¢QFLDQRHVWDEHOHFLPHQWRGHJDUDQWLDVSDUDRFXPSULPHQWRGRSDFWXDGR
'(63(6$6&202&2175$72'(&2035$(9(1'$
2 FRQWUDWR GH FRPSUD FRPR M¡ VH H[SOLFLWRX WHP DSHQDV HIHLWRV REULJDFLRQDLV Q£R LPSRUWDQGR GH
IRUPDLPHGLDWDQDWUDQVIHUªQFLDGDSURSULHGDGH
3DUD HVVH ILP QHFHVV¡ULD VH ID] D HQWUHJD GR EHP RX VHMD D VXD WUDGL§£R QR FDVR GH EHQV P³YHLV
7UDWDQGRVHGH EHQV LP³YHLVD SURSULHGDGH VRPHQWHVH WUDQVIHULU¡ VHVHJXLQGRVH DRWWXOR FRQWUDWR
RFRUUHURUHJLVWURLPRELOL¡ULR
7DLVDWRVQRWDGDPHQWHRUHJLVWURLPSRUWDPHPFXVWRV
(TXHPGHYHDUFDUFRPHOHV"
$UHVSRVWDHVW¡QRDUWGR&&TXHSUHFHLWXDLQYHUELV
ߡ$UW6DOYRFO¡XVXODHPFRQWU¡ULRILFDU£RDVGHVSHVDVGHHVFULWXUDHUHJLVWURDFDUJRGRFRPSUDGRUHDFDUJRGRYHQGHGRUDVGD
WUDGL§£Rߢ
1HVVH VHQWLGR © LPSRUWDQWH H[SOLFLWDU WDPE©P TXH R ߡYHQGHGRU VDOYR FRQYHQ§£R HP FRQWU¡ULR
UHVSRQGHSRUWRGRVRVG©ELWRVTXHJUDYHPDFRLVDDW©RPRPHQWRGDWUDGL§£RߢQDIRUPDGRDUWGR
&&
3RU PDLV ³EYLD TXH SDUH§D D UHJUD D VXD H[SOLFLWD§£R SHOD YLD OHJLVODWLYD VH PRVWUD EDVWDQWH
FRQYHQLHQWHXPDYH]TXHUHVROYHRVFRVWXPHLURVFRQIOLWRVVREUHTXHP©UHVSRQV¡YHOSHORSDJDPHQWRGH
GYLGDV FRQWUDGDV SRVWHULRUPHQWH FHOHEUD§£R GR QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR GH FRPSUD H YHQGD PDV DQWHV GD
WUDQVIHUªQFLDGDSURSULHGDGH
(PQRVVRVHQWLUWDPE©PK¡GHVHDSOLFDUDUHJUDQRFDVRGDWUDQVIHUªQFLDLPRELOL¡ULDSRUFRQWDGH
XPD DGHTXDGD H UHFRPHQG¡YHO LQWHUSUHWD§£R H[WHQVLYD GD SDODYUD ߡWUDGL§£Rߢ M¡ TXH SRU FRQWD GR
GLIXQGLGRDG¡JLRRQGHK¡DPHVPDUD]£RGHYHKDYHURPHVPRGLUHLWR
5(63216$%,/,'$'(&,9,/3(/265,6&26'$&2,6$
7UDWDVH DJRUD GH HQIUHQWDUPRV R LQVWLJDQWH WHPD UHIHUHQWH UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH FLYLO SHOR ULVFR GH D
FRLVDSHUHFHUSRUFDVRIRUWXLWRRXIRU§DPDLRU
&RPRVDEHPRVDUHJUDJHUDOGRQRVVRVLVWHPD©QRVHQWLGRGHTXHDWUDQVIHUªQFLDGDSURSULHGDGHGD
FRLVDYHQGLGDVRPHQWHVHRSHUDTXDQGRGDVXDWUDGL§£RRXUHJLVWUR$W©TXHVHFRQVXPHSRLVTXDOTXHU
GHVVHV DWRVDFRLVDFRQWLQXD MXULGLFDPHQWH YLQFXODGDDR YHQGHGRU XPDYH] TXH DLQGD Q£RVDLX GR VHX
¢PELWRGHGRPQLR
3RLVEHP
3DUWLQGRVH GHVVD SUHPLVVD © IRU§RVR FRQYLU TXH D UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH SHOD LQWHJULGDGH GD FRLVD HP
IDFHGRULVFRGHSHUHFLPHQWRSRUFDVRIRUWXLWRRXGHIRU§DPDLRUFRUUHSRUFRQWDGRDOLHQDQWH$SOLFDVH
RGRJPDGRUHVSHULWGRPLQRDFRLVDSHUHFHSDUDRGRQR
1HVVHVHQWLGRGLVSµHQRVVR&³GLJR&LYLO
ߡ$UW$W©RPRPHQWRGDWUDGL§£RRVULVFRVGDFRLVDFRUUHPSRUFRQWDGRYHQGHGRUHRVGRSUH§RSRUFRQWDGRFRPSUDGRUߢ
7DO UHJUD D SDU GH H[WUHPDPHQWH FODUD DILJXUDVH LPSRUWDQWH QD PHGLGD HP TXH HVSDQFD TXDOTXHU
GºYLGDUHIHUHQWH UHVSRQVDELOLGDGHSHODSHUGDRXGHWHULRUD§£RGDFRLVD
&ODURHVW¡HQWUHWDQWRTXHVHDFRLVDSHUHFHXRXVHGHWHULRURXSRUFXOSDGRSU³SULRFRPSUDGRUDUFDU¡
HVWHFRPDVFRQVHTXªQFLDVMXUGLFDVGRVHXSU³SULRDWR
1D PHVPD OLQKD h z FRUUHU£R WDPE©P SRU FRQWD GR FRPSUDGRU RV ULVFRV GDV UHIHULGDV FRLVDV VH
HVWLYHUHPPRUDGHDVUHFHEHUTXDQGRSRVWDV VXDGLVSRVL§£RQRWHPSROXJDUHPRGRDMXVWDGRVRTXH©
SHUIHLWDPHQWHFRPSDWYHOFRPDUHJUDGRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLO
9HPRVSRUWDQWRTXHDPRUDGRFRPSUDGRUWDPE©POKH©GHVIDYRU¡YHOQDPHGLGDHPTXHOKHLPSµH
UHVSRQVDELOLGDGHSHORVULVFRVSHQGHQWHVVREUHDFRLVD
$LQGDQRFDPSRGDUHVSRQVDELOLGDGHTXHVW£RLQWHUHVVDQWHGL]UHVSHLWRDFRLVDVHQWUHJXHVIRUDGRORFDO
GHFRQFUHWL]D§£RGRQHJ³FLR
'HIDWRDUHJUDJHUDO©GHTXHDߡWUDGL§£RGDFRLVDYHQGLGDQDIDOWDGHHVWLSXOD§£RH[SUHVVDGDUVH¡
QROXJDURQGHHODVHHQFRQWUDYDDRWHPSRGDYHQGDߢDUWGR&&
7RGDYLDQDGDLPSHGHTXHDVSDUWHVHVWDEHOH§DPTXHDWUDGL§£RVHMDIHLWDHPOXJDUGLYHUVR
1HVVHFDVRGHTXHPVHU£RRVULVFRVSRUHYHQWXDOSHUHFLPHQWRRXGHWHULRUD§£RGDFRLVD"
6REUHRWHPDGLVSµHDQRVVDOHL
ߡ$UW 6H D FRLVD IRU H[SHGLGD SDUD OXJDU GLYHUVR SRU RUGHP GR FRPSUDGRU SRU VXD FRQWD FRUUHU£R RV ULVFRV XPD YH] HQWUHJXH D
TXHPKDMDGHWUDQVSRUW¡ODVDOYRVHGDVLQVWUX§µHVGHOHVHDIDVWDURYHQGHGRUߢ
&ODUR HVW¡ TXH VH D FRLVD © H[SHGLGD SDUD OXJDU GLYHUVR RX © HQWUHJXH D WHUFHLUR SDUD TXH VHMD R
SRUWDGRUDPEDVDVVLWXD§µHVSRUGHWHUPLQD§£RGRFRPSUDGRUHVWHSDVVDU¡DDVVXPLUDUHVSRQVDELOLGDGH
SHODVXDLQWHJULGDGHDW©FKHJDUDRVHXORFDOGHGHVWLQR(PFDVRFRPRHVWHLQWHUHVVDDFHOHEUD§£RGHXP
FRQWUDWRGHVHJXURSDUDSUHYHQLURDGTXLUHQWHGHHYHQWXDLVSUHMX]RV
$VVLPSRUH[HPSORVH0DULQDFRPSUDUHYLVWDVUDUDVGRFROHFLRQDGRU0DLFRQHHVWHDVHQWUHJDDXP
SRUWDGRU RX DR VHUYL§R GH FRUUHLRV FRQIRUPH LQVWUX§µHV H[SUHVVDV GD FRPSUDGRUD Q£R DUFDU¡ R
YHQGHGRUFRPRVULVFRVGHHYHQWXDOSHUGDRXGHWHULRUD§£RGDFRLVD
6H HQWUHWDQWR R YHQGHGRU PHVPR GLDQWH GD RUGHP UHFHELGD DIDVWDVH GHOD ID] UHWRUQDU SDUD VL D
DVVXQ§£RGRULVFR
$HVVHUHVSHLWRFRPSHUFXFLªQFLDSRQWLILFD&$,205,2
ߡ6HSRU©PRYHQGHGRUFRQWUDULDUDVLQVWUX§µHVGRDGTXLUHQWHVXSRUWDRVULVFRVRFRUULGRVGXUDQWHRWUDQVSRUWHSRUTXHDVVLPSURFHGHQGR
DJH FRPR PDQGDW¡ULR LQILHO &O³YLV %HYLO¡TXD 1£R VH HVFXVDU¡ FRP D DOHJD§£R GH TXH SURFXURX VHU ºWLO DR FRPSUDGRU PHGLDQWH D
DGR§£R GH PHLR PDLV HILFLHQWH H PDLV U¡SLGR WUDQVSRUWH D©UHR HP YH] GH WHUUHVWUH SRU H[HPSOR SRUTXH Q£R VH WUDWD GH DSXUDU XPD
SRVVYHOLQWHQ§£RGHEHPVHUYLU'HL[DQGRGHVHJXLUDVLQVWUX§µHVGRFRPSUDGRUWRPRXDVLRULVFRGDFRLVDDW©DVXDHIHWLYDHQWUHJDH
GHVWD VRUWH D SHVVRD TXH D WUDQVSRUWRX GHL[D GH VHU XP UHSUHVHQWDQWH GR DGTXLUHQWH $ WUDGL§£R ILFD SRLV DGLDGD DW© D FKHJDGD DR
GHVWLQRߢ
7UDWDVH SRUWDQWR GH XPD KLS³WHVH GH UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH FLYLO FRQWUDWXDO SRLV GHVFXPSULQGR R
YHQGHGRU DV LQVWUX§µHV H[SUHVVDV GR FRPSUDGRU LPSµHVHOKH DUFDU FRP DV FRQVHTXªQFLDV GDQRVDV GR
VHXFRPSRUWDPHQWR
(QWHQGHPRVDLQGDTXHQRFDVRGDFKDPDGDߡWUDGL§£RVLPE³OLFDߢRXߡWUDGL§£RILFWDߢHQWHQGLGDFRPRD
VXEVWLWXL§£RGDHQWUHJDPDWHULDOGREHPSHORDWRLQGLFDWLYRGRSURS³VLWRGHWUDQVPLWLUDSRVVHRXSHOD
HQWUHJD GH FRLVD TXH UHSUHVHQWH D WUDQVIHULGD R UHVSHLWR ERDI© REMHWLYD LPSµH FRQVLGHUDU TXH D
ILQDOLGDGHGHFODUDGDHVW¡FRQVXPDGDSHORTXHDSURSULHGDGHGREHPVHDSHUIHL§RRXVHQGRFRQVLGHUDGD
OHJWLPD
GH UHVVDOWDU DLQGD TXH R &³GLJR G¡ DR YHQGHGRU SRGHUHV SDUD VREUHVWDU SDUDOLVDU D HQWUHJD GD
FRLVDDW©TXHRFRPSUDGRUOKHGªJDUDQWLDFDX§£RGHSDJDUQRWHPSRDMXVWDGRFDVRHVWHºOWLPRKDMD
FDGR HP LQVROYªQFLD DUW 'LVWR VH GHSUHHQGH D QRVVR YHU TXH HVWD JDUDQWLD SRGHU¡ VHU UHDO RX
SHVVRDOILGHMXVV³ULDDGHSHQGHUGRTXDQWRFRQYHQFLRQDGRHQWUHDVSU³SULDVSDUWHV
&RP HVVH H[SHGLHQWH R OHJLVODGRU SUHWHQGH HYLWDU TXH R DOLHQDQWH VHMD SUHMXGLFDGR FDVR RSHUH D
WUDQVIHUªQFLD GR EHP VHP R FRUUHVSRQGHQWH UHFHELPHQWR GR SUH§R (P RXWUDV SDODYUDV HYLWD R
HQULTXHFLPHQWRVHPFDXVD
48(67(6(63(&,$,65()(5(17(6&2035$(9(1'$
1HVWHSRQWRGDREUDOHYDUHPRVRQRVVRFDUROHLWRUDWRPDUFRQWDWRFRPLQVWLJDQWHVTXHVWµHVUHODWLYDV
DR FRQWUDWR GH FRPSUD H YHQGD TXH PXLWR WªP DJX§DGR D FXULRVLGDGH GRV MXULVWDV H GHVSHUWDGR DFHVDV
SROªPLFDVQDMXULVSUXGªQFLD
9HQGDDGHVFHQGHQWH
2 DUW GR &³GLJR &LYLO GH GLVSXQKD TXH ߡRV DVFHQGHQWHV Q£R SRGHP YHQGHU DRV
GHVFHQGHQWHVVHPTXHRVRXWURVGHVFHQGHQWHVH[SUHVVDPHQWHFRQVLQWDPߢ
(VWH GLVSRVLWLYR HP YHUGDGH FULDYD XPD UHVWUL§£R YHQGD D GHVFHQGHQWHV TXH Q£R JR]DULDP GH
OHJLWLPLGDGH SDUD ILJXUDU FRPR DGTXLUHQWHV QHVWH WLSR GH FRQWUDWR (VWDULDP SRLV QHVVH FRQWH[WR
LPSHGLGRVGHFHOHEUDUHVWHQHJ³FLRDLQGDTXHIRVVHPSHUIHLWDPHQWHFDSD]HVVHRVGHPDLVGHVFHQGHQWHV
Q£RKRXYHVVHPH[SUHVVDGRDVXDDTXLHVFªQFLD
(PYHUGDGHRTXHYLVRXDQRVVDOHLQHVWHSDUWLFXODUIRLH[DWDPHQWHUHVJXDUGDUDOHJWLPDGRVGHPDLV
GHVFHQGHQWHVTXHQ£RSDUWLFLSDVVHPGDUHIHULGDYHQGD
2IDWR©TXHDOHLDPDQW©PDGRWDQGRDLQGDSURYLGªQFLDVWXWHODUHVHPIDFHGHVWDSRU§£RSDWULPRQLDO
(XPDGHVVDVPHGLGDVGHSURWH§£R OHJWLPD©SUHFLVDPHQWHDQHFHVVLGDGHGHVHFROKHUDDQXªQFLD
GRVGHPDLVKHUGHLURVQHFHVV¡ULRVSUHIHUHQFLDLVSDUDTXHVHSRVVDUHSXWDUY¡OLGDDUHIHULGDYHQGD
$FHVDFRQWURY©UVLDHQWUHWDQWRLQVWDORXVHQDMXULVSUXGªQFLDDFHUFDGRJUDXGDUHIHULGDߡLQYDOLGDGHߢ
GHFRUUHQWHGDYLROD§£RGHVWHSUHFHLWRDQWHVGDHQWUDGDHPYLJRUGR&³GLJR&LYLOGH
+DYLDGºYLGDVHDKLS³WHVHWUDWDYDGHQXOLGDGHDEVROXWDSRUDIURQWDDH[SUHVVRGLVSRVLWLYROHJDORX
GHPHUDDQXODELOLGDGH
2FRUUHTXHIORUHVFHXQDGRXWULQDHQDMXULVSUXGªQFLDFRUUHQWHGLYHUVDTXHVXIUDJDYDDDQXODELOLGDGHGR
QHJ³FLRVREFRPHQWR
1HVVHVHQWLGROHLDVHSUHOH§£RGH$512/'2:$/'
ߡ6HJXQGRDPHOKRUMXULVSUXGªQFLDWDOYHQGDIHLWDVHPRFRQVHQWLPHQWRGHTXHPGHGLUHLWR©DQXO¡YHOHQ£RQXODGHSOHQRGLUHLWR6ºPXOD
HDQXOLGDGHSRGHVHUGHFODUDGDHPD§£RPRYLGDFRQWUDRDVFHQGHQWHDLQGDHPYLGDGHVWHߚ5(MXOJDGRSHOR67)QHVWH
YSߢ
'H IDWR D FRUUHQWH GD DQXODELOLGDGH PXLWR PDLV UD]R¡YHO VROXFLRQD FRP PXLWR PDLV HILF¡FLD H
XWLOLGDGHDSUREOHP¡WLFDTXHVW£RUHIHUHQWH YHQGDHQWUHDVFHQGHQWHVHGHVFHQGHQWHV
,VVRSRUTXHFDVRIRVVHVHJXLGDDWHVHGDQXOLGDGHDEVROXWDDOJXQVLQWUDQVSRQYHLVVHQ£RHVGUº[XORV
REVW¡FXORVVXUJLULDPDH[HPSORGDLPSUHVFULWLELOLGDGHGRYFLRHDLQGDGDSRVVLELOLGDGHGHRQHJ³FLR
VHULPSXJQDGRSRUTXDOTXHUSHVVRDRXDW©PHVPRWHUDQXOLGDGHUHFRQKHFLGDSHORMXL]GHRIFLR
$GHPDLVVHJXLQGRVHHVVDFRUUHQWHHVWDUVHLDLPSHGLQGRSRUYLDREOTXDTXHRVGHPDLVKHUGHLURV
SXGHVVHP SRVWHULRUPHQWH FKDQFHODU R DWR XPD YH] TXH FRPR VH VDEH R QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR QXOR Q£R
DGPLWHFRQILUPD§£R
3RU LVVR D MXULVSUXGªQFLD GR 6XSHULRU 7ULEXQDO GH -XVWL§D FRP LQHJ¡YHO DFHUWR DGRWRX HVWD ºOWLPD
YHUWHQWHGHSHQVDPHQWRPDLVFRQVHQW¢QHDFRPRQRVVRVLVWHPDMXUGLFR
1HVVH FRQWH[WR R 6XSUHPR 7ULEXQDO )HGHUDO KDYLD HGLWDGR D 6ºPXOD FDQFHODQGR D DQWHULRU
6ºPXODFXMRWHRU©RVHJXLQWH
6ºPXODQߚߡ$D§£RSDUDDQXODUYHQGDGHDVFHQGHQWHDGHVFHQGHQWHVHPFRQVHQWLPHQWRGRVGHPDLVSUHVFUHYHHPYLQWHDQRV
FRQWDGRVGDGDWDGRDWRUHYRJDGDD6ºPXODQߢ
&RPRVHYªDGHVSHLWRGHKDYHUVHJXLGRDOLQKDGDDQXODELOLGDGHDQRVVD6XSUHPD&RUWHDFDERXSRU
DGPLWLUXPLQFRPSUHHQVYHOSUD]RYLQWHQ¡ULRSDUDTXHVHSXGHVVHLPSXJQDURDWRYLFLDGR(VVHORQJR
SUD]RDSDUGHIDYRUHFHUDVHQVD§£RGHLQVHJXUDQ§DMXUGLFDQ£RVHKDUPRQL]DFRPRQRVVRVLVWHPDGH
QXOLGDGHV YLJHQWH TXH FRPR VH VDEH DGRWD FXUWRV SUD]RV GHFDGHQFLDLV SDUD D DQXOD§£R GR QHJ³FLR
MXUGLFRYLGHSRUH[HPSORRDUWGR&&
2&³GLJR&LYLOGHSRUVXDYH]YLVDQGRFRORFDUXPILP FRQWURY©UVLDGLVS´VHPVHXDUW
TXH
ߡ$UW DQXO¡YHO D YHQGD GH DVFHQGHQWH D GHVFHQGHQWH VDOYR VH RV RXWURV GHVFHQGHQWHV H R F´QMXJH GR DOLHQDQWH H[SUHVVDPHQWH
KRXYHUHPFRQVHQWLGR
3DU¡JUDIRºQLFR(PDPERVRVFDVRVGLVSHQVDVHRFRQVHQWLPHQWRGRF´QMXJHVHRUHJLPHGHEHQVIRURGDVHSDUD§£RREULJDW³ULDߢ
JULIDPRV
2EVHUYHVHGHORJRDUHIHUªQFLDIHLWDDRF´QMXJHGRDOLHQDQWHRTXDOTXDQGRQ£RFDVDGRQRUHJLPH
GDVHSDUD§£RREULJDW³ULDGHEHQVWDPE©PGHYHU¡DQXLUQDYHQGD
7DOFLUFXQVW¢QFLDVHMXVWLILFDSHORIDWRGHR&³GLJR&LYLOGHWHUHULJLGRRF´QMXJH FRQGL§£RGH
KHUGHLURQHFHVV¡ULR
(QWUHWDQWR QD KLS³WHVH GH VHU FDVDGR HP UHJLPH GH VHSDUD§£R REULJDW³ULD SRU Q£R WHU LQWHUHVVH
MXUGLFRUHFRQKHFLGRSRUOHLQRSDWULP´QLRGRDOLHQDQWHQ£RSUHFLVDU¡FRQVHQWLU
2EVHUYHDLQGDQRVVRFDURDPLJROHLWRUTXHRYLJHQWH&³GLJR&LYLOGLULPLQGRTXDOTXHUFRQWURY©UVLD
©FODURDRGL]HUTXHDFRPSUDHYHQGDGHDVFHQGHQWHDGHVFHQGHQWHQ£RDSHQDVGRSDLDRILOKRPDVGR
DY´DRQHWRHWF©DQXO¡YHO
3´VVHSRUWHUUDDVVLPDFRUUHQWHPLQRULW¡ULDTXHVXVWHQWDYDDWHVHGDQXOLGDGHDEVROXWD
0DVFXPSUHQRVVDOLHQWDUTXHHPQRVVRVHQWLUDDQWLJD6ºPXODGR67)SHUGHXDVXDHILF¡FLDSRU
IRU§D GR DUW GR &³GLJR &LYLO YLJHQWH VHP FRUUHVSRQGHQWH QD FRGLILFD§£R DQWHULRU TXH
WUDQVFUHYHPRVLQYHUELV
ߡ$UW 4XDQGR D OHL GLVSXVHU TXH GHWHUPLQDGR DWR © DQXO¡YHO VHP HVWDEHOHFHU SUD]R SDUD SOHLWHDUVH D DQXOD§£R VHU¡ HVWH GH GRLV
DQRVDFRQWDUGDGDWDGDFRQFOXV£RGRDWRߢ
9ªVHFRPLVVRTXHXPDYH]Q£RSUHYLVWRRSUD]RGHFDGHQFLDOGHDQXOD§£RHVWHVHU¡GHGRLVDQRVH
Q£RPDLVGHYLQWH
)LQDOPHQWHWHQKDPRVDLQGDHPPHQWHTXHDUHVWUL§£RQHJRFLDOVREFRPHQWRQ£RVHDSOLFD VGRD§µHV
TXHVHVXEPHWHPDRXWURUHJUDPHQWRQHPDRXWURVDWRVMXUGLFRVFRPRSRUH[HPSORRGHFRQFHVV£RGH
XPD JDUDQWLD UHDO XPD KLSRWHFD IHLWD SRU DVFHQGHQWH HP SURO GH XP GHVFHQGHQWH VHX ,VVR SRUTXH
WUDWDQGRVH GH QRUPD UHVWULWLYD GR GLUHLWR GH SURSULHGDGH GR DOLHQDQWH DUW Q£R SRGHU¡ VHU
DQDOLVDGD H[WHQVLYDPHQWH QDGD LPSHGLQGR TXH VH SRVVD HYHQWXDOPHQWH LPSXJQDU R DWR FRP IXOFUR HP
RXWURVGHIHLWRVGRQHJ³FLRSUHYLVWRVHPOHL
6LWXD§µHVHVSHFLDLVUHIHUHQWHV IDOWDGHOHJLWLPLGDGHSDUDDFRPSUDHYHQGD
-¡WLYHPRVRSRUWXQLGDGHGHGLVFRUUHUDFHUFDGDVGLIHUHQ§DVH[LVWHQWHVHQWUHFDSDFLGDGHHOHJLWLPLGDGH
'HIDWRQHPWRGDSHVVRDFDSD]SRGHHVWDUOHJLWLPDGDSDUDDSU¡WLFDGHXPGHWHUPLQDGRDWRMXUGLFR
KDMDYLVWDTXHDOHJLWLPD§£RWUDGX]XPDFDSDFLGDGHHVSHFILFD
$VVLP SRGHPRV SHUFHEHU TXH D LOHJLWLPLGDGH WUDGX] XP LPSHGLPHQWR HVSHFILFR SDUD D SU¡WLFD GH
GHWHUPLQDGRDWRRXQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRHPUD]£RGHXPLQWHUHVVHVXSHULRUTXHVHTXHUWXWHODU
1HVVH FRQWH[WR DV SHVVRDV UHIHULGDV QR DUW V£R FRQVLGHUDGDV SHOR OHJLVODGRU FDUHQWHV GH
OHJLWLPLGDGHSDUDDFRPSUDGHGHWHUPLQDGRVEHQVDLQGDTXHHPKDVWDSºEOLFDHFDVRVHMDHIHWXDGDVHU¡
FRQVLGHUDGDQXODGHSOHQRGLUHLWR
$VVLPRVWXWRUHVFXUDGRUHVWHVWDPHQWHLURVHDGPLQLVWUDGRUHVQ£RSRGHU£RDGTXLULURVEHQVFRQILDGRV
VXDJXDUGDLQFLVR,
2VVHUYLGRUHVSºEOLFRVHPJHUDOߚHQRWHVHTXHROHJLVODGRUIRLPDLVW©FQLFRHSUHFLVRDRVHUHIHULUD
ߡVHUYLGRUߢHPOXJDUGHߡIXQFLRQ¡ULRߢSºEOLFRDEUDQJHQGRSRUWDQWRQ£RVRPHQWHRVHVWDWXW¡ULRVHIHWLYRV
PDV GD PHVPD IRUPD RV H[HUFHQWHV GH FDUJR HP FRPLVV£R FRQWUDWDGRV WHPSRUDULDPHQWH HP UHJLPH
HVSHFLDO GH GLUHLWR DGPLQLVWUDWLYR 5('$ H RV FHOHWLVWDV ߚ WDPE©P Q£R SRGHU£R DGTXLULU EHQV RX
GLUHLWRV GD SHVVRD MXUGLFD D TXH VHUYLUHP RX TXH HVWHMDP VRE VXD DGPLQLVWUD§£R GLUHWD RX LQGLUHWD
LQFLVR,,
1D PHVPD OLQKD RV MX]HV VHFUHW¡ULRV GH WULEXQDLV DUELWUDGRUHV SHULWRV H RXWURV VHUYHQWX¡ULRV RX
DX[LOLDUHV GD MXVWL§D Q£R SRGHU£R DGTXLULU EHQV RX GLUHLWRV VREUH TXH VH OLWLJDU HP WULEXQDO MX]R RX
FRQVHOKRQROXJDURQGHVHUYLUHPRXDTXHHVWHQGHUDVXDDXWRULGDGHLQFLVR,,,1RWHVHWRGDYLDTXHR
DUW UHVVDOYD TXH HVWD SURLEL§£R ߡQ£R FRPSUHHQGH RV FDVRV GH FRPSUD H YHQGD RX FHVV£R HQWUH
FRHUGHLURVRXHPSDJDPHQWRGHGYLGDRXSDUDJDUDQWLDGHEHQVM¡SHUWHQFHQWHVDSHVVRDVGHVLJQDGDVQR
UHIHULGRLQFLVRߢRTXHQRVSDUHFHGHXPDMXVWL§DHYLGHQWHXPDYH]TXHDUHOD§£RMXUGLFDVXEPHWLGDHP
MX]RQ£RWHPTXDOTXHUYLQFXOD§£RGLUHWDRXLQGLUHWDFRPRPºQXVSºEOLFRH[HUFLGR
$OL¡V YDOH UHJLVWUDU TXH HP QRVVR VHQWLU D SURLEL§£R SUHYLVWD QR LQFLVR ,,, DWLQJH SRU O³JLFD
LQWHUSUHWD§£R LQWHUSRVWDV SHVVRDV TXH DWXDQGR QR LQWHUHVVH HVSºULR GH XP GRV DJHQWHV SºEOLFRV
PHQFLRQDGRV SUHWHQGD DGTXLULU R EHP SDUD UHSDVV¡OR GHSRLV 7UDWDUVHLD QR FDVR GH LQHTXYRFD
VLPXOD§£RSDGHFHQWHWDPE©PGRYFLRGHQXOLGDGHDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLO
)LQDOPHQWH D SURLEL§£R HVWHQGHVH DRV OHLORHLURV H VHXV SUHSRVWRV QR TXH WDQJH DRV EHQV GH FXMD
YHQGDHVWHMDPHQFDUUHJDGRV
5HJLVWUHVH ILQDOPHQWH TXH DV SURLEL§µHV SUHYLVWDV QHVWH DUWLJR HVWHQGHPVH WDPE©P FHVV£R GH
FU©GLWR
2EVHUYHVH TXH R &³GLJR &LYLO GH Q£R UHSHWLX D GLF§£R GR DUW ,, GR &³GLJR &LYLO
DQWHULRUTXHSURLELDDRPDQGDW¡ULRDGTXLULUEHQVGRPDQGDQWH &RUUHWDDQRVVRYHUDQRYDOHLSRLV
QDGDLPSHGLULDTXHRPDQGDW¡ULRVDWLVID]HQGRWRGDVDVFRQGL§µHVDSUHVHQWDGDVSHORPDQGDQWHHHPS©
GHLJXDOGDGHFRPWHUFHLURYLHVVHDFRPSUDUREHP
&XLGDVHDOL¡VGDSHFXOLDUILJXUDGRDXWRFRQWUDWRRXGRFRQWUDWRFRQVLJRPHVPRSRUIRU§DGRTXDOQD
ODYUDWXUD GD WWXOR GH WUDQVIHUªQFLD ILJXUDU¡ XPD ºQLFD SHVVRD PDQGDW¡ULR 7DO VRPHQWH © SRVVYHO
FRPRVHVDEHSRUTXHWDPE©PDWXDQRLQWHUHVVHGRPDQGDQWH
1DGDLPSHGH DGHPDLV TXHR SU³SULR PDQGDQWH FRPSDUH§D DR DWRHSDUWLFLSH GD VXDGRFXPHQWD§£R
MXQWDPHQWHFRPRVHXSURFXUDGRUDJRUDSDUWHDXW´QRPDQRQHJ³FLRMXUGLFR
9HQGDDFRQG´PLQR
3DUDDFRPSUHHQV£RGHVWHW³SLFRID]VHQHFHVV¡ULRWUDQVFUHYHUPRVRDUWGR&&
ߡ$UW 1£R SRGH XP FRQG´PLQR HP FRLVD LQGLYLVYHO YHQGHU D VXD SDUWH D HVWUDQKRV VH RXWUR FRQVRUWH D TXLVHU WDQWR SRU WDQWR 2
FRQG´PLQR D TXHP Q£R VH GHU FRQKHFLPHQWR GD YHQGD SRGHU¡ GHSRVLWDQGR R SUH§R KDYHU SDUD VL D SDUWH YHQGLGD D HVWUDQKRV VH R
UHTXHUHUQRSUD]RGHFHQWRHRLWHQWDGLDVVRESHQDGHGHFDGªQFLD
3DU¡JUDIRºQLFR6HQGRPXLWRVRVFRQG´PLQRVSUHIHULU¡RTXHWLYHUEHQIHLWRULDVGHPDLRUYDORUHQDIDOWDGHEHQIHLWRULDVRGHTXLQK£R
PDLRU6HDVSDUWHVIRUHPLJXDLVKDYHU£RDSDUWHYHQGLGDRVFRPSURSULHW¡ULRVTXHDTXLVHUHPGHSRVLWDQGRSUHYLDPHQWHRSUH§Rߢ
7UDWDVHGHQRUPDUHIHUHQWHDSHQDVDRFRQGRPQLRGHFRLVDLQGLYLVYHOFRQGLFLRQDQWHGDIDFXOGDGHGH
DOLHQD§£RSRUGHWHUPLQDUDRFRQG´PLQRDOLHQDQWHDQHFHVVLGDGHGHFRQIHULUDRVHXFRQVRUWHGLUHLWRGH
SUHIHUªQFLDHP IDFH GD IUD§£R DOLHQDGD RX VHMD R GLUHLWR GH SUHYDOHFHU R VHX LQWHUHVVH HP DGTXLULU R
EHPVHVXDSURSRVWDHVWLYHUHPLJXDLVFRQGL§µHV VGRVGHPDLVLQWHUHVVDGRV
3RUGHILQL§£RRFRQGRPQLRWUDGX]DFRH[LVWªQFLDGHY¡ULRVSURSULHW¡ULRVTXHGHWªPGLUHLWRUHDOVREUH
DPHVPDFRLVDKDYHQGRHQWUHVLDGLYLV£RLGHDOVHJXQGRVXDVUHVSHFWLYDVIUD§µHV
1RFDVRVREDQ¡OLVHDFRLVDREMHWRGRGLUHLWRUHDOGRVFRPSURSULHW¡ULRVQ£R©SDVVYHOGHGLYLV£R
UD]£R SRU TXH SUHWHQGHX R OHJLVODGRU LPSULPLU D REULJDWRULHGDGH GH VH GDU SULPD]LD D FDGD XP GRV
FRQVRUWHVQRFDVRGHKDYHUHYHQWXDODOLHQD§£RGHSDUWHGRFRQGRPQLR
0DVQRWHVHTXHVHJXQGRH[SUHVVDGLF§£ROHJDOHVVHGLUHLWRGHSUHIHUªQFLDߚTXHWHPHILF¡FLDUHDO
ߚGHYHU¡VHUH[HUFLGRSHORFRQG´PLQRLQWHUHVVDGRHPS©GHLJXDOGDGHFRPRVWHUFHLURVTXHSUHWHQGDP
DGTXLULUDUHIHULGDTXRWD
$VVLPVHRFRQG´PLQR%DFLOGHVDQXQFLRXDYHQGDGHVXDSDUWHSHORSUH§RGH5%DGMDH
+LJXLWD ߚ WDPE©P FRSURSULHW¡ULRV ߚ GHYHU£R SDJDU R UHIHULGR YDORU Q£R WHQGR GLUHLWR D DEDWLPHQWR
SUHIHULQGRHQWUHWDQWRDXPHYHQWXDOWHUFHLURTXHWDPE©PGHPRQVWUHLQWHUHVVHQDDTXLVL§£RGDFRLVD
&RPRDOHLQ£RHVSHFLILFDRPRGRSHORTXDOVHGHYDGDUFLªQFLDDRVGHPDLVFRQVRUWHVHQWHQGHPRVTXH
WDOFRPXQLFD§£RSRGHU¡VHRSHUDUSRUPHLRGHQRWLILFD§£RMXGLFLDORXH[WUDMXGLFLDODVVLQDQGRVHSUD]R
GHPDQLIHVWD§£RVRESHQDGHRVLOªQFLRGRQRWLILFDGRVHULQWHUSUHWDGRFRPRUHFXVD
9DOHREVHUYDURXWURVVLPTXHDYLROD§£RGHVWHGLUHLWRGHSUHIHUªQFLDGLIHUHQWHPHQWHGRTXHVHRSHUD
FRP D FO¡XVXOD HVSHFLDO GR FRQWUDWR GH FRPSUD H YHQGD DUWV JHUD HILF¡FLD UHDO H
FRQVHTXHQWHPHQWHRSRQLELOLGDGHHUJDRPQHVQDPHVPDOLQKDGRVDUWVDGD/HLQGH
/HL GR ,QTXLOLQDWR FRQVRDQWH VH SRGH REVHUYDU QD VHJXQGD SDUWH GR GLVSRVLWLYR ߡR
FRQG´PLQRDTXHPQ£RVHGHUFRQKHFLPHQWRGDYHQGDSRGHU¡GHSRVLWDQGRRSUH§RKDYHUSDUDVLDSDUWH
YHQGLGDDHVWUDQKRVVHRUHTXHUHUQRSUD]RGHFHQWRHRLWHQWDGLDVVRESHQDGHGHFDGªQFLDߢGHVWDTXHV
QRVVRV
7UDWDVHGHXPSUHFHLWREDVWDQWHDGHTXDGRGDGDDSHFXOLDULGDGHGDLQGLYLVLELOLGDGHGDFRLVDWHQGRR
SURS³VLWR GH HYLWDU R LQJUHVVR QD FRPXQK£R GH SHVVRDV HVWUDQKDV R TXH SRGH JHUDU FRQVWUDQJLPHQWRV
HYLW¡YHLVFRPRVLPSOHVH[HUFFLRGRGLUHLWRGHSUHIHUªQFLD
(VVD IDFXOGDGH UHLYLQGLFDW³ULD SRUWDQWR GHFRUUHQWH GH XP GLUHLWR GH QDWXUH]D SRWHVWDWLYD VRPHQWH
VHU¡OHJLWLPDPHQWHH[HUFLGDVHRUHVSHFWLYRSUH§RKRXYHUVLGRGHSRVLWDGRUHVSHLWDGRRSUD]RP¡[LPR
SDUDRVHXH[HUFFLRGLDV
(DSDUWLUGHTXDQGRVHFRQWDHVVHSUD]R"
$SHUJXQWD©SHUWLQHQWHSHORIDWRGHTXHRSU³SULRGLVSRVLWLYROHJDOVHUHIHUH FLUFXQVW¢QFLDGHTXHR
FRQG´PLQRQ£RWHYHFRQKHFLPHQWRGDYHQGD
$UHVSRVWD³EYLD©GHTXHRSUD]RFRPH§DDIOXLUDSDUWLUGHWDOFRQKHFLPHQWRTXHVHSUHVXPHTXDQGR
HIHWLYDGRRUHJLVWURGRWWXORWUDQVODWLYR
&DVR HQWUHWDQWR FRQFRUUD PDLV GH XP FRQG´PLQR LQWHUHVVDGR DV VHJXLQWHV UHJUDV GHYHU£R VHU
REVHUYDGDV
DSUHIHULU¡RTXHWLYHUEHQIHLWRULDVGHPDLRUYDORU
EQDIDOWDGHEHQIHLWRULDVRFRQG´PLQRGHTXLQK£RPDLRU
FVHDVSDUWHVIRUHPLJXDLVWHU£RGLUHLWR SDUWHYHQGLGDRVFRPSURSULHW¡ULRVTXHDTXLVHUHPGHSRVLWDQGRSUHYLDPHQWHRSUH§R
&RQFRUGDPRV RXWURVVLP FRP D REVHUYD§£R GH 1(/621 1(5< -81,25 H 526$ 0$5,$ '(
$1'5$'( 1(5< QR VHQWLGR GH TXH D UHJUD VRE HVWXGR LPSRVLWLYD GR GLUHLWR GH SUHIHUªQFLD
DSOLFDVHWDPE©PDRFRHUGHLURTXHSUHWHQGDDOLHQDUDVXDTXRWDKHUHGLW¡ULDXPDYH]TXHFRPRVHVDEH
DKHUDQ§D©FRQVLGHUDGDFRLVDXQLYHUVDOHLQGLYLVYHODW©VHXOWLPDUDSDUWLOKD
ߡ(P TXH SHVH D FRQWURY©UVLD H[LVWHQWH VREUH R WHPD PHUHFH VHU SUHVWLJLDGR R HQWHQGLPHQWR VHJXQGR R TXDO D YHQGD H D FHVV£R GH
GLUHLWRV KHUHGLW¡ULRV HP VH WUDWDQGR GH EHP LQGLYLVYHO VH VXERUGLQDP UHJUD GR && TXH UHFODPD VHMD GDGD SUHIHUªQFLD DR
FRQG´PLQRFRHUGHLUR(POLQKDGHSULQFSLRDRULHQWD§£ROHJDO©QRVHQWLGRGHHYLWDURLQJUHVVRGHHVWUDQKRQRFRQGRPQLRSUHVHUYDQGRR
GHIXWXURVOLWJLRVHLQFRQYHQLHQWHV$LQWHUSUHWD§£RPHUDPHQWHOLWHUDOGHYHFHGHUSDVVRTXDQGRFROLGHQWHFRPRXWURVP©WRGRVH[HJ©WLFRV
GH PDLRU UREXVWH] H FLHQWLILFLGDGHߢ 67- 5(VS %$ '-8 S 5HO 0LQ 6¡OYLR GH )LJXHLUHGR 7HL[HLUD Y X
MXOJDGRHPk7XUPD
9HQGDHQWUHF´QMXJHVHHQWUHFRPSDQKHLURV
1HVVD RUGHP GH LGHLDV D GHSHQGHU GR UHJLPH GH EHQV HVFROKLGR RV FRQVRUWHV SRGHP PDQWHU
SDWULP´QLRSU³SULRHVHSDUDGRDH[HPSORGRTXHRFRUUHQDFRPXQK£RSDUFLDOQDVHSDUD§£RWRWDOHQD
SDUWLFLSD§£RILQDOQRVDTXHVWRV
(PWDLVFDVRVQDGDLPSHGHTXHXPGRVF´QMXJHVDOLHQHDRRXWUREHPSU³SULRQ£RUHSUHVHQWDQGRWDO
DWRQHJRFLDODRPHQRVHPWHVHEXUODDRVLVWHPDOHJDOHPYLJRU
1HVVHVHQWLGRHVFRLPDQGRTXDOTXHUGºYLGDGLVSµHRDUWGR&&
ߡ$UWOFLWDDFRPSUDHYHQGDHQWUHF´QMXJHVFRPUHOD§£RDEHQVH[FOXGRVGDFRPXQK£Rߢ
$OL¡V GHYHPRV EDQLU GH YH] D IDOVD SHUVSHFWLYD GD H[LVWªQFLD GH SUHVXQ§£R GH IUDXGH QRV DWRV
FHOHEUDGRV HQWUH SHVVRDV FDVDGDV FRPR WUDQVSDUHFH GD DQ¡OLVH GR FRQWURYHUWLGR DUW GR &³GLJR
&LYLO
3RU ³EYLR R FRQWUDWR GH FRPSUD H YHQGD QR UHJLPH GD FRPXQK£R XQLYHUVDO GH EHQV FDUHFHULD GH
HILF¡FLDRXXWLOLGDGHVRFLDOXPDYH]TXHDGTXLULGRREHPSDVVDULDDLQWHJUDURSDWULP´QLRFRPXP
1R TXH WDQJH DRV FRPSDQKHLURV REVHUYDPRV TXH D PHVPD UHJUD SRU LVRQRPLD FRQVWLWXFLRQDO VH
DSOLFDGHYHQGRVHUHVVDOWDUTXHDWHRUGRDUW RUHJLPHDGRWDGR©RGDFRPXQK£RSDUFLDOGH
EHQV
9(1'$$'&25386(9(1'$$'0(1685$0
3DUDEHPFRPSUHHQGHUPRVHVWHWHPDPLVWHUVHID]WUDQVFUHYHUPRVRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLO
ߡ$UW 6H QD YHQGD GH XP LP³YHO VH HVWLSXODU R SUH§R SRU PHGLGD GH H[WHQV£R RX VH GHWHUPLQDU D UHVSHFWLYD ¡UHD H HVWD Q£R
FRUUHVSRQGHUHPTXDOTXHUGRVFDVRV VGLPHQVµHVGDGDVRFRPSUDGRUWHU¡RGLUHLWRGHH[LJLURFRPSOHPHQWRGD¡UHDHQ£RVHQGRLVVR
SRVVYHORGHUHFODPDUDUHVROX§£RGRFRQWUDWRRXDEDWLPHQWRSURSRUFLRQDODRSUH§R
h z 3UHVXPHVH TXH D UHIHUªQFLD V GLPHQVµHV IRL VLPSOHVPHQWH HQXQFLDWLYD TXDQGR D GLIHUHQ§D HQFRQWUDGD Q£R H[FHGHU GH XP
YLJ©VLPRGD¡UHDWRWDOHQXQFLDGDUHVVDOYDGRDRFRPSUDGRURGLUHLWRGHSURYDUTXHHPWDLVFLUFXQVW¢QFLDVQ£RWHULDUHDOL]DGRRQHJ³FLR
hz6HHPYH]GHIDOWDKRXYHUH[FHVVRHRYHQGHGRUSURYDUTXHWLQKDPRWLYRVSDUDLJQRUDUDPHGLGDH[DWDGD¡UHDYHQGLGDFDEHU¡DR
FRPSUDGRU VXDHVFROKDFRPSOHWDURYDORUFRUUHVSRQGHQWHDRSUH§RRXGHYROYHURH[FHVVR
hz1£RKDYHU¡FRPSOHPHQWRGH¡UHDQHPGHYROX§£RGHH[FHVVRVHRLP³YHOIRUYHQGLGRFRPRFRLVDFHUWDHGLVFULPLQDGDWHQGRVLGR
DSHQDV HQXQFLDWLYD D UHIHUªQFLD V VXDV GLPHQVµHV DLQGD TXH Q£R FRQVWH GH PRGR H[SUHVVR WHU VLGR D YHQGD ߝDG FRUSXVߞߢ JULIRV
QRVVRV
6XEOLQKDPRV FRPR SRGH QRWDU R QRVVR FDUR OHLWRU DV GXDV HVS©FLHV GH YHQGD WUDWDGDV QHVWH LWHP D
YHQGD SRU PHGLGD GH H[WHQV£R ߚ DG PHQVXUDP ߚ D SULPHLUD H D YHQGD SRU UHIHUªQFLD PHUDPHQWH
HQXQFLDWLYDߚDGFRUSXVDVHJXQGD
1RSULPHLURFDVRRDOLHQDQWHFXLGDGHHVSHFLILFDURXGLVFULPLQDUD¡UHDYHQGLGDRXRSU³SULRSUH§R
SRULQGLFD§£RGHPHGLGD([LP³YHOGHKHFWDUHVFRPPHWURVGHIUHQWHPHWURVGHIXQGRQD
ODWHUDO FRQWJXR DR LP³YHO GR VHQKRU DR QRUWH 2X HQW£R R LP³YHO GH KHFWDUHV VHU¡
DOLHQDGRRQHURVDPHQWHSDJDQGRVHUHDLVSRUKHFWDUH
2TXHWHPRVSRLVDTXL©XPDYHQGDHVSHFLILFDGDRILFLDOPHQWHFHUWDHVHJXUD(PJHUDODVVLPGHYH
FRQVWDU QDV HVFULWXUDV SºEOLFDV GH DOLHQD§£R LQGLVSHQV¡YHLV SDUD DV YHQGDV GH LP³YHLV FXMR YDORU
XOWUDSDVVHRVWULQWDVDO¡ULRVPQLPRVDUWGR&³G&LYLO
(P WDO FDVR VH IRL HVWLSXODGR R SUH§R SRU PHGLGD GH H[WHQV£R RX GHWHUPLQDGD D UHVSHFWLYD ¡UHD D
YHQGD©GHQRPLQDGDDGPHQVXUDPHFDVRD¡UHDQ£RFRUUHVSRQGDHPTXDOTXHUGRVFDVRV VGLPHQVµHV
GDGDVRFRPSUDGRUWHU¡RGLUHLWR
DGHH[LJLURFRPSOHPHQWRGD¡UHDHQ£RVHQGRLVVRSRVVYHO
ERGHUHFODPDUDUHVROX§£RGRFRQWUDWRRXSHGLURDEDWLPHQWRSURSRUFLRQDOQRSUH§R
7RGDYLD XP SRQWR GHYH ILFDU EHP FODUR WDLV GLUHLWRV VRPHQWH H[LVWLU£R VH VH WUDWDU GH YHQGD DG
PHQVXUDP
(PSULPHLURSODQRFRPRVHSRGHYHUROHJLVODGRUDEUHDSRVVLELOLGDGHGHRFRPSUDGRUSUHMXGLFDGR
SOHLWHDURFRPSOHPHQWRGD¡UHDYHQGLGDYLDD§£RH[HPSWRHQ£RVHQGRLVVRSRVVYHOߚDWHQWHEHP
SDUDHVWDH[SUHVV£RߚSRGHU¡SHGLURGHVID]LPHQWRGRFRQWUDWRFRPHYHQWXDLVSHUGDVHGDQRVRXR
PHURDEDWLPHQWRQRSUH§RFDVRTXHLUDILFDUFRPRLP³YHOGHPHWUDJHPPHQRUGRTXHDGHFODUDGDSHOR
DOLHQDQWH
(PERUD KDMD HQWHQGLPHQWR QR VHQWLGR GH TXH R DGTXLUHQWH SRVVD LQJUHVVDU GH LPHGLDWR FRP D§£R GH
UHVROX§£R GR FRQWUDWR SDUD SHGLU R VHX GHVID]LPHQWR RX D§£R GH DEDWLPHQWR GR SUH§R GD YHQGD
VXVWHQWDPRVTXHSRUH[SUHVVDGHWHUPLQD§£ROHJDOEDVWDOHURFDSXWGRDUWLJRVREFRPHQWRHVWHVGRLV
SHGLGRVVRPHQWHVHULDPYL¡YHLVFDVRVHDILJXUHLPSRVVYHORFRPSOHPHQWRGD¡UHD
&ODUR HVW¡ HQWUHWDQWR TXH IRUPXODGR R SHGLGR GH FRPSOHPHQWR R DXWRU DGTXLUHQWH SUHMXGLFDGR
SRGHU¡FXPXO¡ORFRPRSHGLGRGHUHVROX§£RGRFRQWUDWRRXDEDWLPHQWRQRSUH§RHVWHVH[FOXGHQWHVHQWUH
VL FDUDFWHUL]DQGR DTXHOH IHQ´PHQR TXH D GRXWULQD SURFHVVXDO GHQRPLQRX GH FXPXOD§£R HYHQWXDO GH
SHGLGRV 2 TXH Q£R VH DGPLWH REYLDPHQWH © TXH QD PHVPD GHPDQGD VH SRVWXOH R GHVID]LPHQWR GR
QHJ³FLRHVLPXOWDQHDPHQWHRDEDWLPHQWRQRSUH§RSRUPDQLIHVWDIDOWDGHFRPSDWLELOLGDGHO³JLFD
8UJH DVVLQDODU HQWUHWDQWR TXH VH D GLIHUHQ§D HQWUH D GLPHQV£R UHDO GR LP³YHO H D VXD GLPHQV£R
GHFODUDGDQDHVFULWXUDIRULJXDORXLQIHULRUDGD¡UHDWRWDOSUHVXPHVHTXHDVUHIHUªQFLDV V
GLPHQVµHVIRUDPPHUDPHQWHHQXQFLDWLYDVQ£RDVVLVWLQGRSRLVDRFRPSUDGRUGLUHLWRDOJXPUHVVDOYDQGR
VHOKH D KLS³WHVH ߚ GLVSµH R h z GR DUW ߚ GH SURYDU TXH HP WDLV FLUFXQVW¢QFLDV Q£R WHULD
FHOHEUDGRRQHJ³FLR
$ GHVSHLWR GH UHFRQKHFHUPRV QHVWD ºOWLPD SDUWH GR GLVSRVLWLYR HP HVWXGR XP DFHQWXDGR JUDX GH
VXEMHWLYLGDGH UHSXWDPRV UD]R¡YHO D SUHRFXSD§£R GR OHJLVODGRU TXH GHVVD PDQHLUD UHVJXDUGDULD R
FRPSUDGRU HVSHFLDOPHQWH TXDQGR DTXHOD GLIHUHQ§D IRU GH YDORU VLJQLILFDWLYR $GHPDLV GDGD D
LPSUHFLV£RGRQRVVRVLVWHPDUHJLVWU¡ULRWDOPDUJHPGHHUUR©GHSRVVYHORFRUUªQFLDSU¡WLFD
&XPSUHQRV DLQGD QRWDU TXH R &³GLJR &LYLO GH DYDQ§RX QR WUDWDPHQWR GHVWD PDW©ULD VH
FRPSDUDUPRVDVVXDVQRUPDVFRPDVFRQVWDQWHVQR&³GLJRGH
3UHYLXSRUH[HPSORDIDFWYHOKLS³WHVHGHRFRUUHURLQYHUVRRXVHMDRH[FHVVRGH¡UHDDRLQY©VGH
VXDIDOWD(PRXWUDVSDODYUDVRTXHID]HUVHRYHQGHGRUDS³VDWUDGL§£RUHJLVWURYHULILFRXTXHDOLHQRX
PDLVGRTXHGHFODURX"
25/$1'2*20(6HPGRXWULQDDQWHULRUDRDWXDO&³GLJRSRQWLILFDYDTXHߡVHD¡UHDGRLP³YHOWLYHU
GLPHQVµHVPDLRUHV GR TXHDVGHFODUDGDVDRFRPSUDGRU DSURYHLWD R H[FHVVR SRLVDRYHQGHGRU Q£RVH
SHUPLWH TXH SRU HVVD UD]£R SOHLWHLH D UHVROX§£R GR FRQWUDWR QHP TXH SUHWHQGD D VXSOHPHQWD§£R GR
SUH§R (QWUHWDQWR HP DOJXPDV OHJLVOD§µHV VH OKHV DVVHJXUD H[SUHVVDPHQWH HVVH GLUHLWR HQWHQGHQGR
DOJXQV HVFULWRUHV TXH D VROX§£R © DSOLF¡YHO HQWUH Q³V H RXWURV TXH FDEH D D§£R GH DQXOD§£R SRU
HUURߢ
1RVLVWHPDRUDYLJHQWHUHVSRQGHQRVRhzQRVHQWLGRGHTXHHPWDOFLUFXQVW¢QFLDVHRYHQGHGRU
FRPSURYDUTXHWLQKDPRWLYRVSDUDLJQRUDUDPHGLGDH[DWDGD¡UHDYHQGLGDIDFXOWDVHDRFRPSUDGRUH
VXDHVFROKDFRPSOHWDURYDORUFRUUHVSRQGHQWHDRSUH§RRXGHYROYHURH[FHVVR
3RGHUVHLDDUJXPHQWDUHPXPSODQRFUWLFRGHSHUVSHFWLYDTXHGLUHLWRDOJXPDVVLVWLULDDRYHQGHGRU
XPDYH]TXHVHSUHVXPHTXHGHYHULDFRQKHFHUDTXLORTXHOKHSHUWHQFHFDEHQGROKHDUFDUFRPR´QXVGH
DOLHQDUSDUFHODPDLRUGRVHXSDWULP´QLR
(QWUHWDQWRRPQLPRGHH[SHULªQFLDSU¡WLFDQRVG¡FRQWDGDLPHQVDGLYHUVLGDGHJHRJU¡ILFDGHQRVVR
SDV GH SURSRU§µHV FRQWLQHQWDLV R TXH GLILFXOWD VREUHPDQHLUD D SHUIHLWD PHQVXUD§£R GRV LP³YHLV
XUEDQRVHUXUDLVHVSHFLDOPHQWHQD]RQDUXUDOHHPIDFHGHSHVVRDVGHEDL[RSRGHUDTXLVLWLYR1HPWRGRV
WªPODPHQWDYHOPHQWHFRQGL§µHVILQDQFHLUDVGHFXVWHDURWUDEDOKRGHXPHQJHQKHLURDJULPHQVRU(DOLH
VH D LVVR R IDWR GH TXH QRVVR VLVWHPD GH 5HJLVWURV 3ºEOLFRV © HP PXLWRV (VWDGRV H[FHVVLYDPHQWH
EXURFU¡WLFRHIUHTXHQWHPHQWHSRXFRSUHFLVR
3RU WDLV UD]µHV FRQFOXPRV SHOD UD]RDELOLGDGH GR UHIHULGR GLVSRVLWLYR TXH JDUDQWH DR YHQGHGRU R
GLUHLWR GH MXVWLILFDU D VXD LJQRU¢QFLD HP IDFH GD GLPHQV£R H[DWD GD ¡UHD FDEHQGR HQWUHWDQWR DR
FRPSUDGRUDIDFXOGDGHGHHVFROKHUVHFRPSOHPHQWDRSUH§RRXGHYROYHD¡UHDH[FHGHQWH
)LQDOPHQWH VH DV UHIHUªQFLDV GD ¡UHD IRUDP PHUDPHQWH HQXQFLDWLYDV RX VHMD VHP GHVFUL§£R RX VXD
HVSHFLILFD§£RSRUSUH§RGHWHUPLQDGRUHSXWDVHDYHQGDDGFRUSXVPHVPRTXHWDOH[SUHVV£RQ£RFRQVWH
GRFRUSRGDHVFULWXUDGHYHQGD3ULYLOHJLDVHDVVLPRFRQWHºGRHPYH]GRPHURIRUPDOLVPR
4XDQWR DR SUD]R SDUD R H[HUFFLR GDV D§µHV VXSUDUUHIHULGDV GLVSµH R OHJLVODGRU TXH VHU¡ GH XP
DQR DFRQWDUGRUHJLVWURGRWWXORWHQGRLQHTXYRFDQDWXUH]DGHFDGHQFLDOSRUVHWUDWDUGHH[HUFFLR
GHGLUHLWRSRWHVWDWLYRDLQGDTXHVHDGPLWDDSRVWHUJD§£RGRVHXGLHVDTXR
7DOUHVVDOYD©IHLWDSHORSDU¡JUDIRºQLFRGRDUWTXHSUHFHLWXDTXHVHKRXYHUDWUDVRQDLPLVV£RGH
SRVVHGR LP³YHO DWULEXYHO DRDOLHQDQWH D SDUWLUGHOD © TXHIOXLU¡ R SUD]R GHGHFDGªQFLD 1HVWHFDVR
FRPSUHHQGHVHTXHRSUD]RFRPHFHDIOXLUGDSRVVHHIHWLYDHQ£RGRPHURUHJLVWURSRUFRQVLGHUDUPRV
TXHVRPHQWHDSDUWLUGDLPLVV£RSRGHRDGTXLUHQWHYHULILFDURLP³YHOHGHWHFWDURGHIHLWR
&/868/$6(63(&,$,6283$&726$&(665,26&2035$(9(1'$
(PTXHFRQVLVWHPDVFO¡XVXODVHVSHFLDLVRXSDFWRVDFHVV³ULRV FRPSUDHYHQGD"
1DGDPDLVGRTXHHOHPHQWRVDFLGHQWDLVGRFRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGDTXHQ£RDIHWDPDSULRULDVXD
H[LVWªQFLD RX YDOLGDGH PDV VLP R FDPSR GD HILF¡FLD GR QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR SUHWHQGLGR H FHOHEUDGR
VXERUGLQDQGRVHXVHIHLWRVHPJHUDODHYHQWRVIXWXURVHLQFHUWRV
2 YLJHQWH &³GLJR &LYLO EUDVLOHLUR SUHYLX H[SUHVVDPHQWH QD UHIHULGD 6H§£R ,, ߡ'DV &O¡XVXODV
(VSHFLDLV &RPSUDH9HQGDߢGR&DSWXOR,ߡ'D&RPSUDH9HQGDߢGR7WXOR9,ߡ'DV9¡ULDV(VS©FLHV
GH &RQWUDWRߢ GR /LYUR , ߡ'R 'LUHLWR GDV 2EULJD§µHVߢ GD 3DUWH (VSHFLDO FLQFR PRGDOLGDGHV GH
FO¡XVXODV HVSHFLDLV VHQGR TXDWUR SUHYLVWDV QDFRGLILFD§£RDQWHULRUUHWURYHQGD YHQGD D FRQWHQWR H
YHQGD VXMHLWD SURYD SUHHPS§£R RX SUHIHUªQFLD H YHQGD FRP UHVHUYD GH GRPQLR H XPD VHP
FRUUHVSRQGHQWHQR&&DVDEHUDYHQGDVREUHGRFXPHQWRV
$QDOLVHPRVSRLVFDGDXPDGHVVDVFO¡XVXODVVHSDUDGDPHQWH
5HWURYHQGD
$ FO¡XVXOD GH UHWURYHQGD WDPE©P FKDPDGD GH FO¡XVXODGLUHLWR GH UHWUDWR RX SDFWXP GH
UHWURYHQGHQGR©XPSDFWRDFHVV³ULRDGMHWR FRPSUDHYHQGDSRUPHLRGRTXDORYHQGHGRUUHVJXDUGDD
SUHUURJDWLYDGHUHVROYHURQHJ³FLRUHVWLWXLQGRRSUH§RUHFHELGRHUHHPEROVDQGRDVGHVSHVDVIHLWDVSHOR
FRPSUDGRU
7UDWDVHSRUWDQWRGHXPDFRQGL§£RUHVROXWLYDH[SUHVVDTXHVXEPHWHRQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRGDFRPSUDH
YHQGD D HYHQWR IXWXUR H LQFHUWR VHJXQGR R LQWHUHVVH GR YHQGHGRU HP UHDYHU D FRLVD DOLDGR DR
RIHUHFLPHQWRGRYDORUDGHTXDGRSDUDUHVWLWXL§£RHUHHPEROVR
4XDQWRDRVHJXQGRSRU©PDOJXPDVFRQVLGHUD§µHVVHID]HPQHFHVV¡ULDV
'H IDWR R YDORU DGHTXDGR SDUD D UHWURYHQGD QD IRUPD GR DUW GR && TXH SRGHPRV
FKDPDU GH ߡMXVWR SUH§Rߢ GHYH FRUUHVSRQGHU D WRGRV RV JDVWRV HPSUHHQGLGRV SHOR FRPSUDGRU
GHYLGDPHQWH DWXDOL]DGRV VHMD SDUD D DTXLVL§£R GR EHP VHMD SDUD D UHDOL]D§£R GH EHQIHLWRULDV
QHFHVV¡ULDV
3DUHFHQRV O³JLFR TXH EHQIHLWRULDV ºWHLV H YROXSWX¡ULDV GHYHP HVWDU IRUD GHVWH SUH§R VDOYR VH
UHDOL]DGDV FRP DXWRUL]D§£R GR YHQGHGRU Q£R VRPHQWH SRU IRU§D GD DXVªQFLD GH SUHYLV£R OHJDO PDV
WDPE©P HP UHVSHLWR DR SULQFSLR GD ERDI© REMHWLYD XPD YH] TXH GDGD D SUHYLV£R FRQWUDWXDO GD
SRVVLELOLGDGHGHUHWURYHQGDWDLVGLVSªQGLRVSRGHPVHUHQFDUDGRVFRPRXPDWHQWDWLYDGRFRPSUDGRUGH
LQYLDELOL]DURH[HUFFLRGDSUHUURJDWLYD
'HIDWRQ£RSRGHPRVGHL[DUGHWHUHPPHQWHTXHDUHWURYHQGDQ£RFRQVWLWXLXPDQRYDDOLHQD§£RPDV
VLPRGHVID]LPHQWRGRQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRRULJLQDOSHODRFRUUªQFLDGDFRQGL§£RUHVROXWLYDHVWDEHOHFLGDDE
LQLWLR
-XVWDPHQWHSRULVVR©LPSRUWDQWHWDPE©PWHUUHGREUDGRFXLGDGRQDDQ¡OLVHGDVLWXD§£RI¡WLFDHPTXHVH
DOHJD XPD UHWURYHQGD SRLV Q£R © GLIFLO LPDJLQDU TXH SRVVD VHU XWLOL]DGD ODPHQWDYHOPHQWH FRPR XP
LQVWUXPHQWRGHIUDXGHRH[HPSORGHXPDVLPXOD§£RGHFRPSUDHYHQGDFRPFO¡XVXODGHUHWURYHQGD
SDUDPDVFDUDUXPHPSU©VWLPRXVXU¡ULRHPTXHRLP³YHOWHQKDVLGRFRORFDGRFRPRJDUDQWLD
LPSRUWDQWH UHVVDOWDU TXH WDLV VLWXD§µHV VLPXODW³ULDV WUDGX]HP KLS³WHVHV GH QXOLGDGH DEVROXWD
SHUPLWLQGRDRPDJLVWUDGRDW©PHVPRRVHXUHFRQKHFLPHQWRGHRIFLRDUWGR&&
5HJLVWUHVHHQWUHWDQWRTXHDXWLOLGDGHSU¡WLFDGDFO¡XVXODGHUHWURYHQGDFDGDYH]PDLVVHHVYDLSRU
IRU§D GD GLVVHPLQD§£R GD SURPHVVD FRPSURPLVVR GH FRPSUD H YHQGD D VHU HVWXGDGD DTXL QD SDUWH
UHIHUHQWHD'LUHLWRV5HDLV
1HVVDOLQKDGHSHQVDPHQWRREVHUYD9(126$
ߡ'RLVV£RRVSRQWRVIXQGDPHQWDLVGDFO¡XVXODSRUWDQWRVRPHQWHVHGHIHUH FRPSUDHYHQGDGHLP³YHLVHVHXSUD]RQ£RSRGHXOWUDSDVVDU
RV WUªV DQRV +RXYH TXHP QR SDVVDGR GHIHQGHVVH VXD XWLOL]D§£R SDUD RV P³YHLV VHP VXFHVVR FRQWXGR 2 IDWR GH RV P³YHLV VH
WUDQVIHULUHPVHPPDLRUHVIRUPDOLGDGHVSHODWUDGL§£RVHPPDLRUSXEOLFLGDGHSDUDFDXWHODGHWHUFHLURVEHPFRPRRVWHUPRVSHUHPSW³ULRV
GDOHLQ£RSHUPLWHPRXWUDFRQFOXV£R6HHVWDEHOHFLGDDUHWURYHQGDQDDOLHQD§£RGHEHPP³YHODTXHVW£RILFDU¡QRFDPSRQHJRFLDOGD
DXWRQRPLD GH YRQWDGH FRQWUDWXDO VXERUGLQDQGRVH DRV SULQFSLRV REULJDFLRQDLV HP JHUDO GHVYLQFXODQGRVH GD DSOLFD§£R GDV QRUPDV GR
&³GLJRRUDH[DPLQDGDV
6DELGRGDLPSRUW¢QFLDGDVYHQGDVLPRELOL¡ULDVSDUDRSDWULP´QLRGRVFRQWUDWDQWHVUHVXOWDH[WUHPDPHQWHLQFRQYHQLHQWHHVVDFO¡XVXODFXMD
IUDQFD XWLOLGDGH IDFLOPHQWH SHUFHELGD © PDVFDUDU HPSU©VWLPRV RQ]HQ¡ULRV RX FDPXIODU QHJ³FLRV Q£R SHUIHLWDPHQWH WUDQVSDUHQWHV
*HUDOPHQWH D LQVHU§£R GHVVH SDFWR QD YHQGD GH LP³YHO SURFXUD DWHQGHU D GLILFXOGDGHV HFRQ´PLFDV GR YHQGHGRU TXH DV HQWHQGH
SDVVDJHLUDV6HHUDºWLOQRSDVVDGRSDUDJDUDQWLURSDJDPHQWRSRUSDUWHGRYHQGHGRUQDVYHQGDVDSUD]RRFRPSURPLVVRGHFRPSUDH
YHQGDVXEVWLWXLXDFRPDPSODYDQWDJHPVHSXOWDQGRGHILQLWLYDPHQWHDXWLOLGDGHGDUHWURYHQGDߢ
3RUVXDFRQGL§£RGHFO¡XVXODDFHVV³ULDDQXOLGDGHGRSDFWXPGHUHWURYHQGHQGRQ£RDIHWDDYDOLGDGH
GRFRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGD
8PSRQWRUHOHYDQWVVLPRDVHUGHVWDFDGRSRLV©DTXHVW£RGDQDWXUH]DMXUGLFDGDFO¡XVXOD
3RU ³EYLR K¡ FRQVHQVR GRXWULQ¡ULR GH TXH WDO FO¡XVXOD WHP QDWXUH]D MXUGLFD REULJDFLRQDO Q£R
SRVVXLQGR HILF¡FLD UHDO GH IRUPD GLVWLQWD SRUWDQWR GD SURPHVVD LUUHWUDW¡YHO GH FRPSUD H YHQGD
GHYLGDPHQWHUHJLVWUDGD
7RGDYLD HP TXH SHVH WDO FLUFXQVW¢QFLD R GLUHLWR SRVLWLYR UHFRQKHFH XPD RSRQLELOLGDGH
WUDQVLQGLYLGXDOPXLWRSU³[LPDGDFRQFHS§£RHUJDRPQHVWSLFDGRVGLUHLWRVUHDLV
'HIDWRFRQILUDVHRDUWGR&&
ߡ$UW2GLUHLWRGHUHWUDWRTXH©FHVVYHOHWUDQVPLVVYHODKHUGHLURVHOHJDW¡ULRVSRGHU¡VHUH[HUFLGRFRQWUDRWHUFHLURDGTXLUHQWHߢ
3DUHFHQRVUHOHYDQWHUHJLVWUDUSRU©PXPHOHPHQWRGLIHUHQFLDGRUGDYLJHQWHGLVSRVL§£ROHJDOSDUDD
QRUPDHTXLYDOHQWHUHYRJDGDTXHFRQVWDYDGRDUWGR&&QRVVHJXLQWHVWHUPRV
ߡ$UW1DUHWURYHQGDRYHQGHGRUFRQVHUYDDVXDD§£RFRQWUDRVWHUFHLURVDGTXLUHQWHVGDFRLVDUHWURYHQGLGDDLQGD TXH HOHV Q£R
FRQKHFHVVHPDFO¡XVXODGHUHWUDWRߢ
2 QRYR WH[WR OHJDO VXSULPH FRPR YLVWR D SUHYLV£R H[SUHVVD GH GLVSHQVDELOLGDGH GH FRQKHFLPHQWR
SHORWHUFHLURGDFO¡XVXODGHUHWURYHQGDSDUDDVXDH[LJLELOLGDGH
'HVWDUWH SRGHUDPRV FRQFOXLU TXH KRMH R UHWUDWR VRPHQWH SRGHU¡ VHU H[HUFLGR VH R WHUFHLUR WLYHU
FRQKHFLPHQWRGDFO¡XVXOD
$VVLPSHQVDPRVSHORIDWRGHVRDUH[WUHPDPHQWHLQFRHUHQWHTXHXP&³GLJRTXHSUHVWLJLDHQRUPHPHQWH
DERDI©QRWDGDPHQWHQDVXDPRGDOLGDGHREMHWLYDYHQKDDGHVSUH]¡ODMXVWDPHQWHHPXPLQVWLWXWRTXH
FRPRM¡DSRQWDGRWHPHQVHMDGRDVLPXOD§£RGHQHJ³FLRVMXUGLFRV
(PFRQFOXV£RWHPRVTXH OX]GRSULQFSLRGDERDI©REMHWLYDHWDPE©PHPDWHQ§£RDRHVWDGRGH
LQRFªQFLD GR WHUFHLUR TXH SRGHPRV WUDGX]LU QD H[SUHVV£R ERDI© VXEMHWLYD R SDFWR GH UHWURYHQGD
VRPHQWHSRGHU¡VHUH[HUFLGRFDVRVHWHQKDUHDOL]DGRRUHJLVWURGDFO¡XVXODRXVHIRUDGDGDFLªQFLDGLUHWD
DRSUHWHQVRLQWHUHVVDGRQDDTXLVL§£RGDFRLVD
)HLWDVWDLVREVHUYD§µHVVRPHQWHQRVFXPSUHUHVVDOWDUWDPE©PTXHRYLJHQWHGLVSRVLWLYROHJDOSµHILP
SROªPLFD VREUH D WUDQVPLVVLELOLGDGH GR GLUHLWR GH UHWUDWR SURLELQGR D FHVV£R GHVVH GLUHLWR SRU DWR
LQWHU YLYRV SRLV DSHQDV DGPLWH D VXD WUDQVPLVV£R SDUD KHUGHLURV H OHJDW¡ULRV R TXH SUHVVXSµH R
IDOHFLPHQWRGRYHQGHGRURULJLQDO
&DVR R EHP DLQGD SHUWHQ§D DR FRPSUDGRU H HVWH Q£R FXPSUD HVSRQWDQHDPHQWH D FO¡XVXOD SDFWXDGD
SRGHU¡ R YHQGHGRU H[LJLU MXGLFLDOPHQWH R VHX DGLPSOHPHQWR QD IRUPD GR DUW GR && VHP
HTXLYDOHQWHQR&&TXHSUHFHLWXDLQYHUELV
ߡ$UW6HRFRPSUDGRUVHUHFXVDUDUHFHEHUDVTXDQWLDVDTXHID]MXVRYHQGHGRUSDUDH[HUFHURGLUHLWRGHUHVJDWHDVGHSRVLWDU¡
MXGLFLDOPHQWH
3DU¡JUDIRºQLFR9HULILFDGDDLQVXILFLªQFLDGRGHS³VLWRMXGLFLDOQ£RVHU¡RYHQGHGRUUHVWLWXGRQRGRPQLRGDFRLVDDW©HHQTXDQWRQ£RIRU
LQWHJUDOPHQWHSDJRRFRPSUDGRUߢ
5HVVDOWHVHDSDUWHILQDOGRSDU¡JUDIRºQLFRGHVWDFDQGRDLGHLDGRߡMXVWRSUH§RߢTXHDTXLGHIHQGHPRV
Q£RVHQGRHVWUDQKRDILUPDUTXHDOLGHSRGHU¡VHFRQFHQWUDUDSHQDVQDIL[D§£RGRYDORUDGHTXDGRSDUDD
UHWURYHQGD
6HDFRLVDYLHUDSHUHFHUVHPFXOSDH[WLQJXHVHRGLUHLWRGHUHVJDWHXPDYH]TXHKRXYHSHUGDGREHP
SDUDRFRPSUDGRUVHPTXDOTXHULQGHQL]D§£R SDUWHDGYHUVDYDOHQGRDUHJUDGHTXHDFRLVDSHUHFHSDUD
VHXGRQRUHVSHULWGRPLQR2XWURVVLPHQWHQGHPRVTXHSRUIRU§DGRPHVPRSULQFSLRVHRLP³YHOVH
GHWHULRUDU Q£R WHU¡ R YHQGHGRU GLUHLWR UHGX§£R SURSRUFLRQDO GR SUH§R GHYHQGR UHVWLWXOR
LQWHJUDOPHQWHDRFRPSUDGRU
1DPHVPDOLQKDHSHORPHVPRIXQGDPHQWRRFRPSUDGRUHQTXDQWRGHWLYHUDSURSULHGDGHVREFRQGL§£R
UHVROXWLYDWHU¡GLUHLWRDRVIUXWRVHUHQGLPHQWRVGRLP³YHOMXVWDPHQWHSHODVXDFRQGL§£RGHSURSULHW¡ULR
3RU ILP QD IRUPD GR DUW GR && VH ߡD GXDV RX PDLV SHVVRDV FRXEHU R GLUHLWR GH UHWUDWR
VREUHRPHVPRLP³YHOHV³XPDRH[HUFHUSRGHU¡RFRPSUDGRULQWLPDUDVRXWUDVSDUDQHOHDFRUGDUHP
SUHYDOHFHQGRRSDFWRHPIDYRUGHTXHPKDMDHIHWXDGRRGHS³VLWRFRQWDQWRTXHVHMDLQWHJUDOߢ
$UHJUDIDFLOLWDDFRPSUHHQV£RGRLQVWLWXWRGDUHWURYHQGDFRQMXQWDHVXDILQDOLGDGH
'HIDWRJDUDQWLGRRGLUHLWRDGXDVRXPDLVSHVVRDVRLGHDOVHULDTXHHODVSRVWXODVVHPFRQMXQWDPHQWH
SRU Q£R KDYHU SUHYDOªQFLD GR GLUHLWR GH XPD HP IDFH GDV RXWUDV 7RGDYLD FRPR RV LQWHUHVVHV
LQGLYLGXDLV V£R YDUL¡YHLV DJLX EHP R OHJLVODGRU DR SUHYHU TXH FDVR Q£R KDMD PDQLIHVWD§£R FRQMXQWD
SUHYDOHFHU¡DTXHOHTXHSULPHLURSURYRFRXUHDOL]DQGRRGHS³VLWRGHVGHTXHLQWHJUDO2 ³EYLR SRU©P
GHYHVHUUHVVDOWDGRVRPHQWHVHU¡JDUDQWLGRRGLUHLWRFRPRSDJDPHQWRWRWDOQ£RKDYHQGRTXHVHIDODUHP
UHWURYHQGDSDUFLDO
6H KRXYHU GLVFXVV£R VREUH R MXVWR YDORU UHDO§DVH D LPSRUW¢QFLD GD FRPXQLFD§£R DRV GHPDLV
LQWHUHVVDGRV SRLV HVWHV SRGHU£R TXHUHQGR H[HUFHU WDPE©P R GLUHLWR GH UHWUDWR ID]HQGR D VLP R
GHS³VLWRGRYDORUDGHTXDGR
$ SHUJXQWD TXH Q£R TXHU FDODU © H VH WRGRV UHDOL]DUHP VLPXOWDQHDPHQWH R GHS³VLWR DGHTXDGR
H[HUFLWDQGRRVHXGLUHLWR"
$OHLQ£RWUD]DUHVSRVWDVHQGRLQWXLWLYRUHVSRQGHUTXHQ£RVHQGRSRVVYHOGHOLPLWDUTXHPHIHWLYRXD
PHGLGDHPSULPHLUROXJDURTXHQDPDLRUSDUWHGDVYH]HV©UHODWLYDPHQWHI¡FLOGHFRPSURYDUVHMDSHOD
JXLDGHGHS³VLWREDQF¡ULRVHMDSHORSURWRFRORGHSHWL§£RMXGLFLDORXH[WUDMXGLFLDOPHQWHVHMDUD]R¡YHO
HVWDEHOHFHUXPFRQGRPQLRVREUHRLP³YHO
(VHREHPLP³YHOYHQGLGRFRPDFO¡XVXODGHUHWURYHQGDSHUWHQFLDRULJLQDOPHQWHDXPDFROHWLYLGDGH
HP FRQGRPQLR PDV D VXD DOLHQD§£R Q£R IRL UHDOL]DGD QR PHVPR DWR RX FRP FO¡XVXOD GH UHWURYHQGD
FRQMXQWD"
2 YLJHQWH &³GLJR &LYLO EUDVLOHLUR VLOHQFLRX VREUH D TXHVW£R PDV HP QRVVR HQWHQGLPHQWR Q£R K¡
PXGDQ§DGHRULHQWD§£RXPDYH]TXHDUHJUD©FRPSDWYHOFRPRVSULQFSLRVGRFRQGRPQLR
9HQGDDFRQWHQWRHVXMHLWD SURYDSRUH[SHULPHQWD§£R
$ 6XEVH§£R ,, GD 6H§£R GHVWLQDGD V FO¡XVXODV HVSHFLDLV FRPSUD H YHQGD UHºQH GRLV LQVWLWXWRV
MXUGLFRVDQ¡ORJRVDVDEHUDYHQGDDFRQWHQWRHDYHQGDVXMHLWDDSURYD
$PEDVDVFO¡XVXODVVHUHIHUHPDYHQGDVUHDOL]DGDVVREFRQGL§£RVXVSHQVLYDYDOHGL]HUDRDJUDGRGR
FRPSUDGRURX DGHTXD§£RGREHP ILQDOLGDGHGHVHMDGD
LQWHUHVVDQWH UHVVDOWDU TXH QD FRGLILFD§£R UHYRJDGD DPEDV DV PRGDOLGDGHV HVWDYDP SUHYLVWDV QR
PHVPRGLVSRVLWLYRTXDOVHMDRDUWTXHSUHFHLWXDYDLSVLVOLWWHULV
ߡ$UW$YHQGDDFRQWHQWRUHSXWDUVH¡IHLWDVREFRQGL§£RVXVSHQVLYDVHQRFRQWUDWRQ£RVHOKHWLYHUGDGRH[SUHVVDPHQWHRFDU¡WHU
GHFRQGL§£RUHVROXWLYD
3DU¡JUDIRºQLFR1HVWDHVS©FLHGHYHQGDVHFODVVLILFDDGRVJªQHURVTXHVHFRVWXPDPSURYDUPHGLUSHVDURXH[SHULPHQWDUDQWHVGH
DFHLWRVߢ
$ FRGLILFD§£R YLJHQWH SRU VXD YH] GHVWULQFKD RV LQVWLWXWRV H[SOLFLWDQGR TXH GR SRQWR GH YLVWD
W©FQLFRDKLS³WHVH©SURSULDPHQWHGHFRQGL§£RVXVSHQVLYDXPDYH]TXHVXMHLWDDHYHQWRIXWXURHLQFHUWR
1HVVDOLQKDSRUWDQWRDYHQGDDFRQWHQWRWDPE©PFRQKHFLGDFRPRYHQGDDGJXVWXPRXFRPSDFWXP
GLVSOLFHQWLDH©DTXHODTXHVHUHDOL]DVREDFRQGL§£RVXVSHQVLYDGHV³VHWRUQDUSHUIHLWDHREULJDW³ULD
DS³VGHFODUD§£RGRFRPSUDGRUGHTXHDFRLVDRVDWLVID]
$TXLPHUHFHGHVWDTXHDQDWXUH]DVXEMHWLYDGRDWRUHYHODGRUGRFRQWHQWDPHQWRTXHGHYHVHUHQFDUDGD
FRPRXPDFRQGL§£RSRWHVWDWLYDVLPSOHVHQ£RSXUDPHQWHSRWHVWDWLYDXPDYH]TXHRSDFWRDFHVV³ULRG¡
GLUHLWRDRFRPSUDGRUGHH[SHULPHQWDUDFRLVDDQWHVGHDFHLW¡ODQ£RVHQGRDVXDFRQFHS§£RRDUEWULRGR
SRWHQFLDODGTXLUHQWHPDVVLPDVXDVDWLVID§£R
-¡QDYHQGDVXMHLWDDSURYDDFRQGL§£RVXVSHQVLYDUHVLGHQRDWHQGLPHQWRGDVTXDOLGDGHVDVVHJXUDGDV
SHORYHQGHGRUHQDLGRQHLGDGHSDUDRILPDTXHVHGHVWLQD
1HVVD VHJXQGD PRGDOLGDGH R FDPSR GH VXEMHWLYLGDGH HPERUD H[LVWHQWH © PHQRU XPD YH] TXH ©
DGPLVVYHOIDODUHPGHPRQVWUD§£RREMHWLYDGDVTXDOLGDGHVHLGRQHLGDGHSDUDRVILQVH[SHULPHQWD§£R
'HVVD IRUPD HQWHQGHPRV TXH SDUD D YHQGD VXMHLWD SURYD D UHFXVD GR FRPSUDGRU Q£R SRGH VHU
LQMXVWLILFDGDPRWLYRSHORTXDODSODXGLPRVDH[SOLFLWD§£RGDPRGDOLGDGHDQ¡ORJD
5HVVDOWHVH QR SDUWLFXODU TXH HP DPEDV DV IRUPDV R QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR HPERUD H[LVWHQWH H Y¡OLGR
VRPHQWHSURGX]LU¡RVVHXVHIHLWRVDS³VDGHFODUD§£RGRFRPSUDGRU$VVLPVHQGR©LQVWLWXWRGLVWLQWRGR
GLUHLWR GH DUUHSHQGLPHQWR TXH WDPE©P © XPD SUHUURJDWLYD H[FHSFLRQDO QDV UHOD§µHV FRQWUDWXDLV VDOYR
QDV UHOD§µHV GH FRQVXPR HP TXH R DUW GR &'& FRQIHUH DR FRQVXPLGRU R GLUHLWR SRWHVWDWLYR GH
GHVLVWLUGDFRPSUDUHDOL]DGDIRUDGRHVWDEHOHFLPHQWRQRSUD]RGHVHWHGLDV
5HFRQKHFLGD D QDWXUH]D MXUGLFD GH FRQGL§£R VXVSHQVLYD GHVWDV GXDV PRGDOLGDGHV GH FO¡XVXODV
HVSHFLDLVGXDVFRQVHTXªQFLDVO³JLFDVVHLPSµHP
D HQTXDQWR Q£R DGYLHU D PDQLIHVWD§£R FRQFRUGDQWH GR DGTXLUHQWH H D GHVSHLWR GH KDYHU RFRUULGR D WUDGL§£R R GRPQLR FRQWLQXD FRP R
DOLHQDQWHTXHVRIUHDVSHUGDVDGYLQGDVGRIRUWXLWR
EQ£RWHQGRDGTXLULGRRGRPQLRRFRPSUDGRUDQWHVGDRFRUUªQFLDGDFRQGL§£R©PHURFRPRGDW¡ULROLPLWDQGRVHSRUWDOFLUFXQVW¢QFLD V
VXDVREULJD§µHVDUWGR&& SHORTXHDSRVVHTXHH[HUFH©SUHF¡ULD
$OHLQ£RHVWDEHOHFHSUD]RSDUDTXHRFRPSUDGRUVHPDQLIHVWHGHFODUDQGRVXDVDWLVID§£RSHVVRDOFRP
REHPRXDDGHTXD§£RGHVWHSDUDDVILQDOLGDGHVSUHWHQGLGDV
$VVLP VHQGR Q£R KDYHQGR SUHYLV£R FRQWUDWXDO HVSHFILFD HVFULWD RX YHUEDO WHP R YHQGHGRU D
SUHUURJDWLYD GH LQWLP¡OR MXGLFLDO RX H[WUDMXGLFLDOPHQWH SDUD TXH VH YHULILTXH D RFRUUªQFLD RX Q£R GD
FRQGL§£R
(VHRFRPSUDGRUVLOHQFLDU"
3RUH[HPSORVH0DUOLYHQGHXP'9'SDUD&OHLGHFRPDFRQGL§£RVXVSHQVLYDGHTXHHVWDJRVWHGR
VHXFRQWHºGRQ£RIL[DQGRSUD]RSDUDWDOPDQLIHVWD§£RGHYHFRPXQLF¡ODMXGLFLDORXH[WUDMXGLFLDOPHQWH
SDUDTXHRID§DQRSUD]RLPSURUURJ¡YHOGH;GLDVVRESHQDGHFDUDFWHUL]DUWDFLWDPHQWHRDJUDGR$W©
SRUTXH RV SULQFSLRV GD UD]RDELOLGDGH H GD VHJXUDQ§D MXUGLFD QRV RULHQWDP QR VHQWLGR GH TXH HVWH
FRPSRUWDPHQWR RPLVVLYR DOLDGR VXEVLVWªQFLD GD SRVVH VREUH D FRLVD ILUPD D LGHLD GH TXH KRXYH D
VDWLVID§£RRXRDWHQGLPHQWRGDH[SHFWDWLYDGRFRPSUDGRUHPIDFHGDFRLVD
3UHHPS§£RRXSUHIHUªQFLD
&HOHEUDGRXPQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRGHFRPSUDHYHQGDHHPVHJXLGDDWUDQVPLVV£RGDSURSULHGDGHSHOD
WUDGL§£RRXUHJLVWURRQRUPDO©TXHQ£RKDMDPDLVTXDOTXHUYLQFXOD§£RHQWUHRVFRQWUDWDQWHV
7RGDYLDSRGHPRVSDFWXDQWHVHVWDEHOHFHUXPDFO¡XVXODTXHREULJXHRFRPSUDGRUGHFRLVDP³YHORX
LP³YHO QR FDVR GH SUHWHQGHU YHQGªOD RX G¡OD HP SDJDPHQWR D RIHUHFªOD D TXHP OKH YHQGHX
RULJLQDOPHQWHSDUDTXHHVWHWHQKDDSUHIHUªQFLDHPUHDGTXLULODHPLJXDOGDGHGHFRQGL§µHVFRPTXHP
WDPE©PHVW¡LQWHUHVVDGRHPLQFRUSRU¡ODHPVHXSDWULP´QLR
D FO¡XVXOD GH SUHHPS§£R WDPE©P FKDPDGD GH FO¡XVXOD GH SUHIHUªQFLD SUHOD§£R RX SDFWXP
SURWLPLVHRVGLVFLSOLQDGDSHORVDUWVDGR&&
7UDWDVHGHXPSDFWRGHFRUUHQWHXQLFDPHQWHGDDXWRQRPLDGDYRQWDGHHHVWLSXODGRHYLGHQWHPHQWHHP
IDYRU GR DOLHQDQWH DTXL FKDPDGR SUHIHUHQWH SUHVWLJLDQGR R VHX GHVHMR HYHQWXDO GH UHWRPDU R EHP TXH
RXWURUDOKHSHUWHQFHX
3DUDTXHRGLUHLWRGHSUHHPS§£RVHMDH[HUFLGRRYHQGHGRUVRESHQDGHSHUGDGDVXDSUHIHUªQFLDHVW¡
ߡREULJDGRDSDJDUHPFRQGL§µHVLJXDLVRSUH§RHQFRQWUDGRRXRDMXVWDGRߢDUWGR&&,VVR
TXHUGL]HUTXHSDUDUHDGTXLULUREHPRYHQGHGRURULJLQ¡ULRGHYHLJXDODUDVFRQGL§µHVRIHUHFLGDVSRU
WHUFHLURVWDQWRQRTXHVHUHIHUHDRYDORUSHFXQL¡ULRSUH§RTXDQWRHPUHOD§£R VYDQWDJHQVRIHUHFLGDV
3RU LVVR R FXPSULPHQWR GD FO¡XVXOD TXH VH DVVHPHOKD D XPD FRQGL§£R UHVROXWLYD Q£R VH
LGHQWLILFDQGR SRLV VH WUDWD GH XPD QRYD DTXLVL§£R SRWHQFLDOPHQWH FRP YDORU GLIHUHQFLDGR H Q£R XP
UHWRUQRDRVWDWXVTXRDQWHGHSHQGHQHFHVVDULDPHQWHGHGXDVFLUFXQVW¢QFLDVDVDEHU
D LQWHUHVVH GR FRPSUDGRU HP VH GHVID]HU GR LP³YHO SRU FRPSUD H YHQGD RX GD§£R HP SDJDPHQWR QHJ³FLRV MXUGLFRV HPLQHQWHPHQWH
RQHURVRV
E GHVHMR GR YHQGHGRU RULJLQDO HP UHDGTXLULU R EHP WHQGR FRQGL§µHV GH RIHUHFHU DV PHVPDV FRQGL§µHV GH WHUFHLURV Q£R EDVWD D
PDQLIHVWD§£RGHYRQWDGHVHQGRLPSUHVFLQGYHOWDOLJXDOGDGHVRESHQDGHSUHMXGLFDURFRPSUDGRURULJLQDORUDDOLHQDQWH
6HPDSUHVHQ§DVLPXOW¢QHDGHVVHVGRLVUHTXLVLWRVQ£RK¡FRPRIDODUHPSUHOD§£R
(TXDO©RSUD]RGRGLUHLWRGHSUHIHUªQFLD"
(VWD©XPDSHUJXQWDLQWHUHVVDQWHH[FHOHQWHSDUDID]HUHPSURYDVVHPFRQVXOWD OHJLVOD§£RXPDYH]
TXHDUHVSRVWDFRPSRUWDGHVGREUDPHQWRV
,VVRSRUTXHDFO¡XVXODHVSHFLDOGHSUHIHUªQFLDQRFRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGDWHU¡VHPSUHOLPLWD§£R
WHPSRUDOFXMRSUD]RILFDU¡DFULW©ULRGDVSDUWHVQ£RSRGHQGRQDIRUPDGRSDU¡JUDIRºQLFRGRDUW
GR&&VHPFRUUHVSRQGHQWHQR&&H[FHGHUFHQWRHRLWHQWDGLDVVHDFRLVDIRUP³YHO
RXGRLVDQRVVHLP³YHO
1£R K¡ GLUHLWR GH SUHIHUªQFLD VREUH SDUWH GR EHP P³YHO RX LP³YHO DLQGD TXH HVWDEHOHFLGR HP
EHQHIFLRGHGXDVRXPDLVSHVVRDV
1HVWD KLS³WHVH R SUD]R GH YDOLGDGH GD FO¡XVXOD © R PHVPR PDV R SUD]R GHFDGHQFLDO FRUUHU¡ SDUD
FDGDSUHIHUHQWHDSDUWLUGHVXDFLHQWLILFD§£RSRGHQGRRGLUHLWRFDGXFDUSRUWDQWRSDUDXQVHQ£RSDUD
RXWURV
RTXHVHLQIHUHGRDUWGR&&
ߡ$UW4XDQGRRGLUHLWRGHSUHHPS§£RIRUHVWLSXODGRDIDYRUGHGRLVRXPDLVLQGLYGXRVHPFRPXPV³SRGHVHUH[HUFLGRHPUHOD§£R
FRLVDQRVHXWRGR6HDOJXPDGDVSHVVRDVDTXHPHOHWRTXHSHUGHURXQ£RH[HUFHURVHXGLUHLWRSRGHU£RDVGHPDLVXWLOL]¡ORQDIRUPD
VREUHGLWDߢ
1RTXHWDQJHDRVVHXVHIHLWRVDYLROD§£RGHVWDFO¡XVXODHVSHFLDOGRFRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGDQ£R
JHUDHILF¡FLDUHDOPDVVLPVHUHVROYHQDYHOKDI³UPXODGDVSHUGDVHGDQRVSRUH[SUHVVDGLF§£ROHJDO
$VVLP VH R FRPSUDGRU Q£R WLYHU DIURQWDGR FLHQWLILFDGR R YHQGHGRU HVWDEHOHFH R DUW GR
&&LQYHUELV
ߡ$UW5HVSRQGHU¡SRUSHUGDVHGDQRVRFRPSUDGRUVHDOLHQDUDFRLVDVHPWHUGDGRDRYHQGHGRUFLªQFLDGRSUH§RHGDVYDQWDJHQV
TXHSRUHODOKHRIHUHFHP5HVSRQGHU¡VROLGDULDPHQWHRDGTXLUHQWHVHWLYHUSURFHGLGRGHP¡I©ߢ
GH ODPHQWDU TXH QHVWH DVSHFWR Q£R WHQKD VLGR SUHYLVWD TXDOTXHU PRGDOLGDGH GH WXWHOD HVSHFILFD
SDUD R GHVFXPSULPHQWR SRLV D UHJUD FRQWUDWXDO HP VLWXD§µHV FRPRWDLV © QRUPDOPHQWHYLROHQWDGDSRU
TXHPWHPFRQGL§µHVGHDEXVDUGRSRGHULRHFRQ´PLFR
(VWH©XPHOHPHQWRLQFOXVLYHTXHGLIHUHQFLDWDOFO¡XVXODHVSHFLDO FRPSUDHYHQGDFRPRGLUHLWRGH
SUHIHUªQFLDGRORFDW¡ULRQRFRQWUDWRGHORFD§£RLPRELOL¡ULD
'HIDWRQDIRUPDGRVDUWVDGD/HLQWHPRORFDW¡ULRߡSUHIHUªQFLDSDUDDGTXLULUR
LP³YHO ORFDGR HP LJXDOGDGH GH FRQGL§µHV FRP WHUFHLURV GHYHQGR R ORFDGRU GDUOKH FRQKHFLPHQWR GR
QHJ³FLRPHGLDQWHQRWLILFD§£RMXGLFLDOH[WUDMXGLFLDORXRXWURPHLRGHFLªQFLDLQHTXYRFDߢ
(VWHGLUHLWRGHSUHIHUªQFLDGHFRUUHQHFHVVDULDPHQWHGHSUHFHLWROHJDOHQ£RPHUDPHQWHGDDXWRQRPLD
GDYRQWDGHFRPRRSDFWRDFHVV³ULRDTXLWUDWDGR
$VVLP DO©P GD SRVVLELOLGDGH GH SHUGDV H GDQRV R GLUHLWR GH SUHIHUªQFLD GR ORFDW¡ULR SRGHU¡ WHU
HILF¡FLDUHDOFRPDSRVVLELOLGDGHGHWXWHODHVSHFILFDߡGHVGHTXHRFRQWUDWRGHORFD§£RHVWHMDDYHUEDGR
SHORPHQRVWULQWDGLDVDQWHVGDDOLHQD§£RMXQWR PDWUFXODGRLP³YHOߢ
9DOH GHVWDFDU WDPE©P TXH R GLUHLWR GH SUHIHUªQFLD TXDQGR HVWDEHOHFLGR QHVWD FO¡XVXOD HVSHFLDO GH
FRPSUDHYHQGD©FRQVLGHUDGRSHUVRQDOVVLPRRXVHMDQ£RVHWUDQVPLWHQHPSRUDWRLQWHU YLYRV QHP
PRUWLV FDXVD R TXH © REMHWR GH QRUPD HVSHFILFD D VDEHU R DUW GR && ߡ2 GLUHLWR GH
SUHIHUªQFLDQ£RVHSRGHFHGHUQHPSDVVDDRVKHUGHLURVߢ
3RU ILP GH IRUPD H[FHSFLRQDO D OHL HVWDEHOHFH XP GLUHLWR GH SUHIHUªQFLD GH QDWXUH]D REULJDFLRQDO
PDVTXHQ£RGHFRUUHGHXPFRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGDHVLPGDH[SURSULD§£RSDUDILQVGHQHFHVVLGDGH
RXXWLOLGDGHSºEOLFD
(PGLUHLWRDGPLQLVWUDWLYRIDODVHHPUHWURFHVV£R
(P FDVRV TXH WDLV VH ߡD FRLVD H[SURSULDGD SDUD ILQV GH QHFHVVLGDGH RX XWLOLGDGH SºEOLFD RX SRU
LQWHUHVVHVRFLDOQ£RWLYHURGHVWLQRSDUDTXHVHGHVDSURSULRXRXQ£RIRUXWLOL]DGDHPREUDVRXVHUYL§RV
SºEOLFRV FDEHU¡ DR H[SURSULDGR GLUHLWR GH SUHIHUªQFLD SHOR SUH§R DWXDO GD FRLVDߢ DUW GR
&&
7UDWDVHGHPHGLGDGDVPDLVVDOXWDUHVSRLVRGHVYLRGDILQDOLGDGHRULJLQ¡ULDGRDWRGD$GPLQLVWUD§£R
3ºEOLFDGHYHHQVHMDURGLUHLWRGHRDGPLQLVWUDGRUHDYHURVHXEHPVHPSUHMX]RGRLQWHUHVVHSºEOLFR
TXH UHFHEHU¡ R YDORU HIHWLYR SHOR SUH§R DWXDO GD FRLVD PDW©ULD TXH UHQGH LQºPHURV GHVGREUDPHQWRV H
FRQWURY©UVLDVQDVHDUDHVSHFILFDGR'LUHLWR$GPLQLVWUDWLYR
9HQGDFRPUHVHUYDGHGRPQLR
7UDWDVHGHXPDFO¡XVXODQ£RSUHYLVWDRULJLQDULDPHQWHQDFRGLILFD§£RFLYLOUHYRJDGDVHQGRSRUWDQWR
XPD QRYLGDGH GR &³GLJR &LYLO GH HPERUD R LQVWLWXWR M¡ IRVVH FRQKHFLGR QR FDPSR GR GLUHLWR
SURFHVVXDO
3RU PHLR GHVWH FRQWUDWR FRP WDO FRQGL§£R VXVSHQVLYD WUDQVIHUHVH DR DGTXLUHQWH DSHQDV D SRVVH GD
FRLVDDOLHQDGDFRQVHUYDQGRRYHQGHGRURGRPQLRVREUHHODDW©OKHVHUSDJRDWRWDOLGDGHGRSUH§R
1HVVDVFLUFXQVW¢QFLDVDTXLWD§£RGRSUH§RHVWLSXODGRHQVHMDDDXWRP¡WLFDWUDQVIHUªQFLDGRGRPQLRR
TXHQ£RH[LJLU¡PDLVTXDOTXHUDWRXPDYH]TXHPDWHULDOPHQWHM¡RFRUUHXDWUDGL§£R
3RULVVRPHVPRHVWDQGRM¡RFRPSUDGRUQDSRVVHGLUHWDGREHPP³YHO©HOHRJXDUGL£RGRPHVPR
VHQGR R UHVSRQV¡YHO SHORV ULVFRV GD FRLVD PRWLYR SHOR TXDO VRD UD]R¡YHO D UHJUD GR DUW GR
&&TXHGLVSµH
ߡ$UW $ WUDQVIHUªQFLD GH SURSULHGDGH DR FRPSUDGRU G¡VH QR PRPHQWR HP TXH R SUH§R HVWHMD LQWHJUDOPHQWH SDJR 7RGDYLD SHORV
ULVFRVGDFRLVDUHVSRQGHRFRPSUDGRUDSDUWLUGHTXDQGROKHIRLHQWUHJXHߢ
3DUHFHQRV HYLGHQWH TXH D LGHLD GH GLVFLSOLQDU WDO PRGDOLGDGH GH FRPSUD H YHQGD VXEPHWLGD D
FRQGL§£R VXVSHQVLYD WHP SRU ILQDOLGDGH LQFHQWLYDU R FU©GLWR DR FRQVXPR GH EHQV P³YHLV
SURSRUFLRQDQGR PDLRU JDUDQWLD DR YHQGHGRU PXLWR HPERUD D DOLHQD§£R ILGXFL¡ULD DILJXUHVHQRV PXLWR
PDLVGLQ¢PLFD
3RULVVRPHVPRK¡DSUHRFXSD§£RGHVHH[SOLFLWDUDOHJLWLPLGDGHGHLQVWLWXL§µHVILQDQFHLUDVSDUDQD
FRQGL§£RGHFHVVLRQ¡ULDVGRFU©GLWRRULJLQDOGRYHQGHGRUH[HUFHURVGLUHLWRVHSUHWHQVµHVGHFRUUHQWHV
GRFRQWUDWRDEHQHIFLRGRVHXFU©GLWRH[FOXGDDFRQFRUUªQFLDGHTXDOTXHURXWUR
HVWDDUHJUDGRDUWGR&&
ߡ$UW6HRYHQGHGRUUHFHEHURSDJDPHQWR YLVWDRXSRVWHULRUPHQWHPHGLDQWHILQDQFLDPHQWRGHLQVWLWXL§£RGRPHUFDGRGHFDSLWDLV
DHVWDFDEHU¡H[HUFHURVGLUHLWRVHD§µHVGHFRUUHQWHVGRFRQWUDWRDEHQHIFLRGHTXDOTXHURXWUR$RSHUD§£RILQDQFHLUDHDUHVSHFWLYD
FLªQFLDGRFRPSUDGRUFRQVWDU£RGRUHJLVWURGRFRQWUDWRߢ
1R TXH GL] UHVSHLWR YDOLGDGH IRUPDO GH WDO FO¡XVXOD HVWDEHOHFH D OHL TXH D IRUPD GHYH VHU
QHFHVVDULDPHQWHHVFULWDHSDUDYDOHUFRQWUDWHUFHLURVSUHFLVDVHUUHJLVWUDGDHPFDUW³ULRSU³SULRDVDEHU
R&DUW³ULRGH7WXORVH'RFXPHQWRVQRGRPLFOLRGRFRPSUDGRU
6RPHQWH SRGHP VHU REMHWR GD YHQGD FRP UHVHUYD GH GRPQLR FRLVDV P³YHLV GH QDWXUH]D GXU¡YHO
VXVFHWYHO GH FDUDFWHUL]D§£R SHUIHLWD KDYHQGR UHVWUL§£R OHJDO QHVVH VHQWLGR QR DUW GR &&
EXVFDQGRHYLWDUGLVWºUELRVQDLGHQWLILFD§£RGREHPVHQGRHVWDEHOHFLGDLQFOXVLYHUHJUDGHKHUPHQªXWLFD
FRQWUDWXDOSDUDH[SOLFDUTXHQDGºYLGDGHFLGHVHHPIDYRUGRWHUFHLURDGTXLUHQWHGHERDI©
(VHRFRPSUDGRUWRUQDUVHLQDGLPSOHQWH"
%HP WUDWDQGRVH GH XPD YHQGD FRP FRQGL§£R VXVSHQVLYD HP SULPHLUR OXJDU GHYH R YHQGHGRU
FRQVWLWXLU R FRPSUDGRU IRUPDOPHQWH HP PRUD VHMD SHOR SURWHVWR GR WWXOR VHMD SRU LQWHUSHOD§£R
MXGLFLDO YDOHQGR GHVWDFDU TXH WDO DWR © HVVHQFLDO DW© PHVPR SRUTXH HQVHMD D SRVVLELOLGDGH GH
SXUJD§£RGDPRUDSHORDGTXLUHQWH
$SDUWLUGDRDUW GR&³GLJR&LYLOGHRIHUHFHGXDVRS§µHVDRYHQGHGRU
DH[LJLURSDJDPHQWRGDVREULJD§µHVYHQFLGDVHYLQFHQGDVVHPSUHMX]RGDSUHWHQV£RLQGHQL]DW³ULDFRPSUHHQGLGDQDH[SUHVV£RߡHRPDLV
TXHOKHIRUGHYLGRߢFRQWLGDQDOHLRX
EUHDYHUDFRLVDFRPDDSUHHQV£RHGHS³VLWRGDFRLVDXPDYH]TXHRFRPSUDGRUQ£RWHPPDLVMXVWRWWXORDUHVSDOGDUDVXDSRVVHPRWLYR
SHORTXDOK¡DSRVVLELOLGDGHLQFOXVLYHGHFRQFHVV£RGHRUGHPOLPLQDUSDUDLPSHGLUTXHRFRPSUDGRUDOLHQHHVFRQGDRXGHWHULRUHDFRLVD
LQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWHGDERDI©GHWHUFHLURV
6HRYHQGHGRUHVFROKHUDVHJXQGDRS§£RHVWDEHOHFHRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLO
ߡ$UW1DVHJXQGDKLS³WHVHGRDUWLJRDQWHFHGHQWH©IDFXOWDGRDRYHQGHGRUUHWHUDVSUHVWD§µHVSDJDVDW©RQHFHVV¡ULRSDUDFREULUD
GHSUHFLD§£RGDFRLVDDVGHVSHVDVIHLWDVHRPDLVTXHGHGLUHLWROKHIRUGHYLGR2H[FHGHQWHVHU¡GHYROYLGRDRFRPSUDGRUHRTXHIDOWDU
OKHVHU¡FREUDGRWXGRQDIRUPDGDOHLSURFHVVXDOߢ
3RUILPSHUJXQWDVHTXDO©DGLIHUHQ§DGDYHQGDFRPUHVHUYDGHGRPQLRSDUDDDOLHQD§£RILGXFL¡ULD
HPJDUDQWLD"
6HJXQGR$512/'2:$/'DDOLHQD§£RILGXFL¡ULDHPJDUDQWLDߡ©WRGRQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRHPTXHXPD
GDVSDUWHVILGXFLDQWHDOLHQDDSURSULHGDGHGHXPDFRLVDP³YHODRILQDQFLDGRUILGXFL¡ULRDW©TXHVH
H[WLQJDRFRQWUDWRSHORSDJDPHQWRRXSHODLQH[HFX§£Rߢ
7UDWDVHSRUWDQWRGHQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRELODWHUDOQRTXDOVHSUHWHQGHDWUDQVIHUªQFLDGDSURSULHGDGHGH
XPD FRLVD DR FUHGRU FRP D ILQDOLGDGH GH JDUDQWLU XP SDJDPHQWR 9DOH GL]HU R GHYHGRU ILGXFLDQWH
SHUPDQHFH FRPR SRVVXLGRU GLUHWR DR SDVVR TXH R FUHGRU ILGXFL¡ULR GHW©P D SRVVH LQGLUHWD H D
SURSULHGDGHUHVROºYHOGDFRLVDDW©RDGLPSOHPHQWRGDGYLGD
1HVVHDVSHFWR©SRVVYHOFRQVWDWDUDVHPHOKDQ§DQDFLUFXQVW¢QFLDI¡WLFDGHTXHK¡DWUDQVIHUªQFLDGD
SRVVHGLUHWDGREHPSDUDRVXMHLWRTXHSUHWHQGHREWHURVHXGRPQLR
1R PDLV SRU©P K¡ PDLV GLIHUHQ§DV GR TXH VHPHOKDQ§DV SRGHQGR RV HOHPHQWRV GH GLYHUJªQFLD VHU
DVVLPUHVXPLGRV
D1DYHQGDFRPUHVHUYDGHGRPQLRK¡XPDYHQGDFRPFRQGL§£RVXVSHQVLYDTXDOVHMDRHYHQWRIXWXURHLQFHUWRGRSDJDPHQWRGRSUH§R
SHORFRPSUDGRUHPERUDDSRVVHGLUHWDGREHPM¡VHMDWUDQVIHULGDQDDOLHQD§£RILGXFL¡ULDK¡XPDߡYHQGDߢSDUDDHQWLGDGHILQDQFLDGRUD
FRPFRQGL§£RUHVROXWLYDRSDJDPHQWRGDGYLGDFRQVROLGDULDDSURSULHGDGHQRSRVVXLGRUGLUHWR
E $ YHQGD FRP UHVHUYD GH GRPQLR SRGH VHU IHLWD GLUHWDPHQWH HQWUH FRPSUDGRU H YHQGHGRU HQTXDQWR QD DOLHQD§£R ILGXFL¡ULD K¡ D
SUHVHQ§DLQGLVSHQV¡YHOGHXPILQDQFLDGRU
F$YHQGDFRPUHVHUYDGHGRPQLRVHUHVWULQJHDEHQVP³YHLVHQTXDQWRDDOLHQD§£RILGXFL¡ULDSRGHVHUDSOLFDGDLJXDOPHQWHHPYHQGDGH
LP³YHODUWGD/HLQ
2IDWRSRU©P©TXHFRPDGLVVHPLQD§£RGDDOLHQD§£RILGXFL¡ULDRHVSD§RUHVHUYDGRSDUDDYHQGD
FRP UHVHUYD GH GRPQLR WHP GLPLQXGR HPERUD DLQGD VHMD ILJXUD FRQWUDWXDO EDVWDQWH XWLOL]DGD
QRWDGDPHQWHQDDTXLVL§£RGHHOHWURGRP©VWLFRV
9HQGDVREUHGRFXPHQWRV
$YHQGDVREUHGRFXPHQWRVFRPRPRGDOLGDGHHVSHFLDOGHFRPSUDHYHQGDQ£RHQFRQWUDYDSUHYLV£RQR
&³GLJR&LYLOGHVHQGRXPDQRYLGDGHGDFRGLILFD§£RLQDXJXUDGDHP
7UDWDVH SRU©P GH LQVWLWXWR K¡ PXLWR FRQKHFLGR QRWDGDPHQWH QR FRP©UFLR PDUWLPR WHQGR SRU
ILQDOLGDGHDJLOL]DUDGLQ¢PLFDFRQWUDWXDOGHIRUPDDSRVVLELOLWDUDFRQFOXV£RGRQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRVHPTXH
VH WHQKD GH SURFHGHU DQ¡OLVH GD FRLVD TXH FRPXPHQWH HVW¡ QD GHWHQ§£R GH WHUFHLURV FRPR SRU
H[HPSORXPWUDQVSRUWDGRURXXPGHSRVLW¡ULR
&RQVLVWHQDIRUPDGRDUWGR&&HPXPDFRPSUDHYHQGDHPTXHߡDWUDGL§£RGDFRLVD©
VXEVWLWXGDSHODHQWUHJDGRVHXWWXORUHSUHVHQWDWLYRHGRVRXWURVGRFXPHQWRVH[LJLGRVSHORFRQWUDWRRX
QRVLOªQFLRGHVWHSHORVXVRVߢ
6DOLHQWHVHDPHQ§£RDRVXVRVIRQWHQRUPDWLYDUHOHYDQWVVLPDQRPHLRFRPHUFLDORTXHM¡GHVWDFDD
VXDLPSRUW¢QFLDQDGLVVHPLQD§£RGRLQVWLWXWR
2FULW©ULRGHVHJXUDQ§DGHVWDIRUPDFRQWUDWXDOUHVLGHQDFLUFXQVW¢QFLDSUHYLVWDQRSDU¡JUDIRºQLFRGR
PHQFLRQDGRDUWLJRGHTXH6(HQFRQWUDQGRߡDGRFXPHQWD§£RHPRUGHPQ£RSRGHRFRPSUDGRUUHFXVDUR
SDJDPHQWRDSUHWH[WRGHGHIHLWRGHTXDOLGDGHRXGRHVWDGRGDFRLVDYHQGLGDVDOYRVHRGHIHLWRM¡KRXYHU
VLGR FRPSURYDGRߢ KLS³WHVH ºOWLPD HP TXH GHYH VHU IHLWD D UHVVDOYD SHOR FRPSUDGRU XPD YH] TXH
FRQKHFHQGRHOHRGHIHLWRHPHVPRDVVLPDGTXLULQGRREHPDSUHVXQ§£R©GHTXHRGHVHMDYDQRHVWDGR
HPTXHVHHQFRQWUDYD
8P H[HPSOR PXLWR FRPXP RFRUUH QD YHQGD GH PHUFDGRULD DLQGD HP WUDQVSRUWH GHSRVLWDGD HP
DUPD]©P RX SHQGHQWH GH OLEHUD§£R QD DOI¢QGHJD HP TXH R YHQGHGRU HQWUHJD DR FRPSUDGRU R WWXOR
ZDUUDQW RX RXWUR GRFXPHQWR K¡ELO DR UHFHELPHQWR GD FRLVD TXH FRPR VH SHUFHEH HP WDLV FDVRV VH
HQFRQWUDFRPWHUFHLURV
&RPRK¡DLPSRVVLELOLGDGHGHVHREVWDURSDJDPHQWRDSUHWH[WRGHGHIHLWRQDFRLVDVHRGRFXPHQWRD
HVWDUHIHUHQWHHQFRQWUDVHHPRUGHPRTXHID]HUVHREHPHQWUHJXHFRQWLYHUXPYFLRRFXOWR"
$PHVPDFRQGXWDDVHWHUHPTXDOTXHURXWUDPRGDOLGDGHGHFRPSUDHYHQGDߚUHVSRQGHPRVQ³Vߚ
SRLV©³EYLRTXHWDOFO¡XVXODHVSHFLDOWHPSRUILWRVRPHQWHIDFLOLWDUDFRQVXPD§£RGDWUDQVIHUªQFLDGH
GRPQLR VHP DJXDUGDU D WUDGL§£R H Q£R OHVLRQDU R FRPSUDGRU VHQGR DSOLF¡YHO SRUWDQWR WRGD D
GLVFLSOLQDGHWXWHODHPIDFHGRVYFLRVUHGLELW³ULRV OX]GRSULQFSLRGDERDI©REMHWLYD
1HVVHVHQWLGRREVHUYD&$5/2652%(572*21$/9(6TXHDߡHQWUHJDGRVGRFXPHQWRVJHUDSRLV
SUHVXQ§£RGHTXHDFRLVDFRQVHUYDDVTXDOLGDGHVQHOHVDSRQWDGDVQ£RSRGHQGRRFRPSUDGRUFRQGLFLRQDU
R SDJDPHQWR UHDOL]D§£R GH YLVWRULD SDUD FRQVWDWD§£R GH LQH[LVWªQFLD GH GHIHLWRV RFXOWRV YFLRV
UHGLELW³ULRV RX DSDUHQWHV &RPR REVHUYD 3DXOR /XL] 1HWWR /´ER RFRUUH HP UHOD§£R DR FRPSUDGRU
DSUR[LPD§£RFRPRHVTXHPDVROYHHWUHSHWHSULPHLURSDJXHGHSRLVUHFODPHPXLWRXWLOL]DGRQRGLUHLWR
ILVFDO 2 FRPSUDGRU SDJD FRQWUD D HQWUHJD GR GRFXPHQWR UHSUHVHQWDWLYR H UHFODPD FRQWUD R YHQGHGRU
VREUHYFLRRXGHIHLWRGDFRLVDߢ
(VHGHIDWRREHPQ£RIRUHQWUHJXH"
&RPRDSURSULHGDGHM¡VHWUDQVIHULXGHYHVHLQJUHVVDUFRPDPHGLGDSRVVHVV³ULDRXSHWLW³ULDFDEYHO
HPIDFHGRDOLHQDQWHD§£RUHLYLQGLFDW³ULDSRUH[HPSOR
2SDJDPHQWRGHYLGRSHORFRPSUDGRUFRPRGLWRSHODPHUDHQWUHJDGRWWXORUHSUHVHQWDWLYRRXRXWURV
GRFXPHQWRVH[LJLGRVQRFRQWUDWRRXSHORVXVRVGRFRP©UFLRVHU¡HIHWXDGRQDGDWDHQROXJDUGHHQWUHJD
GRVGRFXPHQWRVVDOYRFRQYHQ§£RHPVHQWLGRFRQWU¡ULRQDIRUPDGRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLO
1HVWHWLSRGHQHJ³FLRMXUGLFR©H[WUHPDPHQWHUHFRPHQG¡YHODHVWLSXOD§£RGHXPVHJXURFXMRV´QXV
Q£RIRUDPHVTXHFLGRVSHORYLJHQWH&³GLJR&LYLOEUDVLOHLURDRHVWDEHOHFHUHPVHXDUW
ߡ$UW6HHQWUHRVGRFXPHQWRVHQWUHJXHVDRFRPSUDGRUILJXUDUDS³OLFHGHVHJXURTXHFXEUDRVULVFRVGRWUDQVSRUWHFRUUHPHVWHV
FRQWDGRFRPSUDGRUVDOYRVHDRVHUFRQFOXGRRFRQWUDWRWLYHVVHRYHQGHGRUFLªQFLDGDSHUGDRXDYDULDGDFRLVDߢ
$GLVSRVL§£ROHJDOWHPSRUILQDOLGDGHVDQFLRQDUDP¡I©GRYHQGHGRUTXHM¡WLQKDFLªQFLDGDSHUGDRX
DYDULD GD FRLVD H PHVPR DVVLP FHOHEURX R QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR ³EYLR SRU©P TXH R WUDQVFULWR
GLVSRVLWLYR © HP YHUGDGH XPD UHJUD GH UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH FLYLO SRLV GH IDWR R SDJDPHQWR GD
FRQWUDWD§£R GR VHJXUR © FXVWHDGR RULJLQDOPHQWH SHOR FRPSUDGRU DSHQDV VHQGR SRVVYHO LQYRFDU R
GLVSRVLWLYR GHSRLV GH VH FRQVWDWDU TXH R QHJ³FLR M¡ FHOHEUDGR H FRQVXPDGR FRP D HQWUHJD GRV
GRFXPHQWRVQ£RSRGHULDWªORVLGRSHODSHUGDRXDYDULDGDFRLVDRTXHVRPHQWHSRGHVHUFRQVWDWDGR
SRVWHULRUPHQWH
3RUILPWDPE©PVHSUHYªDDWXD§£RGHHVWDEHOHFLPHQWRVEDQF¡ULRVQHVWHWLSRGHUHOD§£RQHJRFLDO
DUHJUDGRDUWGR&&
ߡ$UW(VWLSXODGRRSDJDPHQWRSRULQWHUP©GLRGHHVWDEHOHFLPHQWREDQF¡ULRFDEHU¡DHVWHHIHWX¡ORFRQWUDDHQWUHJDGRVGRFXPHQWRV
VHPREULJD§£RGHYHULILFDUDFRLVDYHQGLGDSHODTXDOQ£RUHVSRQGH
3DU¡JUDIRºQLFR1HVVHFDVRVRPHQWHDS³VDUHFXVDGRHVWDEHOHFLPHQWREDQF¡ULRDHIHWXDURSDJDPHQWRSRGHU¡RYHQGHGRUSUHWHQGªOR
GLUHWDPHQWHGRFRPSUDGRUߢ
1RWHVWHPXQKRDXWRUL]DGRGH6/9,29(126$
ߡ(VVVDPRGDOLGDGH©UHJXODGDSHOR&³GLJRLWDOLDQR3UHPLVVDRUGLQ¡ULDGDYHQGDFRQWUDGRFXPHQWRV©TXHDFRLVDHQFRQWUHVHQDSRVVH
GHXPWHUFHLURHPQRPHHSRUFRQWDGRYHQGHGRU2FRUUHFRPIUHTXªQFLDQDFRPSUDHYHQGDLQWHUQDFLRQDOSRUQ³VM¡H[DPLQDGD6XD
XWLOLGDGHPDLRUDFHQWXDVHTXDQGRXPRXDPERVRVFRQWUDWDQWHVVHHQFRQWUDPHPORFDOGLYHUVRGDPHUFDGRULDQRPRPHQWRGDFRQFOXV£R
GRFRQWUDWR+¡VHPGºYLGDDLQWHUIHUªQFLDGRVSULQFSLRVGRVWWXORVGHFU©GLWRQRFRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGD(VVHQHJ³FLRWHPOXJDU
TXDQGRHVVHVGRFXPHQWRVUHSUHVHQWDPDSU³SULDFRLVDFRPRRFRUUHHPDOJXQVWWXORVGHFU©GLWRߢ
;;,9
752&$283(5087$
'(120,1$2(&21&(,72
7URFD RX SHUPXWD V£R H[SUHVVµHV HTXLYDOHQWHV TXH FRQWªP XPD JUDQGH TXDQWLGDGH GH VLQ´QLPRV
F¢PELRHVFDPERFRPXWD§£RSHUPXWD§£R$W©DSDODYUDߡPºWXRߢ©HOHQFDGDQHVWHURO
$EVWUDGDHVWDºOWLPDSDODYUDTXHWHPXPVHQWLGRSU³SULRQRFDPSRGR'LUHLWRTXDOTXHUXPDGHODV
SRGH VHU XWLOL]DGD LQGLVWLQWDPHQWH HPERUD SRU ³EYLR VHMDP SUHIHUYHLV DV DGRWDGDV SHOR &³GLJR TXH
G£RQRPHDHVWHFDSWXORRTXHSUHVWLJLDUHPRVQDPHGLGDGRSRVVYHOHGRHVWLORUHGDFLRQDO
7UDWDVH GH XPD GDV PRGDOLGDGHV FRQWUDWXDLV GH PDLV DQWLJD XWLOL]D§£R PHVPR DQWHV GR
GHVHQYROYLPHQWRGDFRPSUHHQV£RGRVLVWHPDQRUPDWLYRPRGHUQRFRQVLVWLQGRVHXFRQFHLWRHPVQWHVH
HP XPQHJ³FLR MXUGLFR HP TXH DV SDUWHV VH REULJDP D HQWUHJDU UHFLSURFDPHQWH FRLVDV TXH Q£R VHMDP
GLQKHLUR
$SUR[LPLGDGHGHWDOPRGDOLGDGHFRQWUDWXDOFRPRFRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGD©HYLGHQWHSRLVDILQDO
GHFRQWDVRTXH©XPDWURFDVHQ£RXPDFRPSUDTXHVHSDJDFRPEHPHPYH]GHSHFºQLD"
)L[DGRVHXFRQFHLWRHQXQFLHPRVVXDVSULQFLSDLVFDUDFWHUVWLFDV
&$5$&7(567,&$6
4XDQWR QDWXUH]DGDREULJD§£RWUDWDVHGHXPFRQWUDWRELODWHUDOQDPHGLGDHPTXHLPSOLFDGLUHLWRVH
REULJD§µHVSDUDDPERVRVFRQWUDWDQWHV1DGDLPSHGHSRU©PTXHVHDSUHVHQWHQDPRGDOLGDGHSOXULODWHUDO
RX PXOWLODWHUDO FDVR FRQFRUUDP PDLV GH GRLV FRQWUDWDQWHV FRP REULJD§µHV GHVGH TXH VHMD DVVLP
HVWDEHOHFLGR SHOD DXWRQRPLD GD YRQWDGH H[ 0DULQD WURFD D ILJXULQKD [ FRP 1DWK¡OLD HP
FRQWUDSUHVWD§£R ILJXULQKD \ GH &DURO TXH SRU VXD YH] UHFHEHU¡ D ILJXULQKD ] GH TXH 1DWK¡OLD HUD
GHWHQWRUD
'D PHVPD IRUPD D WURFD © XP FRQWUDWR RQHURVR 0HVPR Q£R KDYHQGR D HQWUHJD GH SHFºQLD QHVWD
PRGDOLGDGH FRQWUDWXDO LVVR Q£R D WRUQD XP FRQWUDWR JUDWXLWR 'H IDWR QD SHUPXWD D FDGD EHQHIFLR
UHFHELGR FRUUHVSRQGH XP VDFULIFLR SDWULPRQLDO VHQGR DSOLF¡YHLV WRGDV DV SHFXOLDULGDGHV GH WDO
FDUDFWHUVWLFDSRUH[HPSORDH[FH§£RGRFRQWUDWRQ£RFXPSULGR
$V REULJD§µHV GHYHP HTXLYDOHUVH MXULGLFDPHQWH FRQKHFHQGR RV FRQWUDWDQWHV DE LQLWLR DV VXDV
UHVSHFWLYDV SUHVWD§µHV SHOR TXH VH IDOD HP XP FRQWUDWR FRPXWDWLYR 7DO FRUUHVSRQGªQFLD Q£R VHU¡
QHFHVVDULDPHQWH HFRQ´PLFD D GHSHQGHU GD DXWRQRPLD GD YRQWDGH GDV SDUWHV FRQIRUPH HVPLX§DUHPRV
QHVVHFDSWXOR
3HODVVXDVSU³SULDVSHFXOLDULGDGHVDWURFDRXSHUPXWDHPUHJUDSUHVVXSµHTXHDVSDUWHVHVWHMDPHP
LJXDLVFRQGL§µHVGHQHJRFLD§£RHVWDEHOHFHQGROLYUHPHQWHDVFO¡XVXODVFRQWUDWXDLVQDIDVHGHSXQWXD§£R
FRQVLGHUDQGRVHDVVLPXPFRQWUDWRSDULW¡ULR
XPWSLFRFRQWUDWRFLYLOTXHTXDQWR IRUPD©FODVVLILFDGRDSULRULFRPRQ£RVROHQHDPHQRVTXH
HQYROYDSRUH[FH§£REHQVLP³YHLVHPTXHFRQIRUPHSUHFHLWXDGRSHORDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLOKDYHU¡
D LPSUHVFLQGLELOLGDGH GR UHJLVWUR SDUD D YDOLGDGH GD HVWLSXOD§£R FRQWUDWXDO H FRQVHQVXDO WDO TXDO D
FRPSUDHYHQGDQDPHGLGDHPTXHVHFRQFUHWL]DFRPDVLPSOHVGHFODUD§£RGHYRQWDGHSURGX]LQGRGH
LPHGLDWR VHXV HIHLWRV MXUGLFRV REULJDFLRQDLV VHP RSHUDU GH SHU VL D WUDQVIHUªQFLD GD SURSULHGDGH
VHQ£RDVLPSOHVREULJD§£RGHID]ªOR
4XDQWR GHVLJQD§£R SRU ³EYLR TXH VH WUDWD GH XP FRQWUDWR QRPLQDGR H SHOD H[LVWªQFLD GH XPD
GLVFLSOLQDOHJDOHVSHFILFDGHXPFRQWUDWRWSLFR
2 FRQWUDWR GH WURFD RX SHUPXWD DVVLP FRPR R GH FRPSUD H YHQGD Q£R © FHOHEUDGR HP IXQ§£R GD
SHVVRDGRFRQWUDWDQWHPDVVLPSHODFLUFXQVW¢QFLDI¡WLFDGHTXHPGLVSµHGDVFRLVDVGHVWLQDGDVDVHURV
REMHWRVGDUHOD§£RFRQWUDWXDO$VVLPVHQGRSRGHVHUFRQVLGHUDGRFRQWUDWRLPSHVVRDO TXH ©DTXHOH HP
TXHVRPHQWHLQWHUHVVDRUHVXOWDGRGDDWLYLGDGHFRQWUDWDGDLQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWHGHTXHPVHMDDSHVVRDTXH
LU¡UHDOL]¡OD3RUH[HPSORVHXPGRVSHUPXWDQWHVYLHUDIDOHFHUDQWHVGDHQWUHJDGDFRLVDSRGHU¡VHU
H[LJLGRGRHVS³OLRRFXPSULPHQWRGDSUHVWD§£R
0HVPR WUDWDQGRVH GH FRQWUDWR TXH HQYROYH QRUPDOPHQWH GXDV SHVVRDV © FRQVLGHUDGR XP FRQWUDWR
LQGLYLGXDOSRLVVHUHIHUHDXPDHVWLSXOD§£RHQWUHSHVVRDVGHWHUPLQDGDVDLQGDTXHHPQºPHURHOHYDGR
PDVFRQVLGHUDGDVLQGLYLGXDOPHQWH
4XDQWRDRWHPSRDWURFDRXSHUPXWD©XPFRQWUDWRLQVWDQW¢QHRM¡TXHVHXVHIHLWRVV£RSURGX]LGRVGH
XPDV³YH]SRGHQGRPDWHULDOL]DUVHWDQWRFRPRXPFRQWUDWRGHH[HFX§£RLPHGLDWD TXDQWR GHH[HFX§£R
GLIHULGD D GHSHQGHU GD VLWXD§£R I¡WLFD HP TXH D SURGX§£R FRQFHQWUDGD GH HIHLWRV VH Gª LSVR IDFWR
DYHQ§DRXHPGDWDSRVWHULRU FHOHEUD§£RHPIXQ§£RGDLQVHU§£RGHXPWHUPROLPLWDGRUGDVXDHILF¡FLD
7UDWDVH DLQGD HP IXQ§£R GR PRWLYR GHWHUPLQDQWH GR QHJ³FLR GH XP FRQWUDWRFDXVDO TXH SRGH VHU
GHFODUDGRLQY¡OLGRVHDFDXVDGRQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRIRUFRQVLGHUDGDLQH[LVWHQWHLOFLWDRXLPRUDO
1DFODVVLILFD§£RSHODIXQ§£RHFRQ´PLFDDW©SHODVXDGHQRPLQD§£RM¡VHLQIHUHWUDWDUVHGHXPFRQWUDWR
HPTXHK¡SHUPXWDGHXWLOLGDGHVHFRQ´PLFDV
3RU ILP WRPDQGR R FULW©ULR FODVVLILFDW³ULR GRV FRQWUDWRV UHFLSURFDPHQWH FRQVLGHUDGRV FRQILUPDPRV
VHUXPFRQWUDWRSULQFLSDOFRPH[LVWªQFLDDXW´QRPDLQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWHGHRXWUREHPFRPRGHILQLWLYR
3(5087$'(9$/25(6'(6,*8$,6
&RPR SDUHFH ³EYLR VRPHQWH GH IRUPD H[FHSFLRQDO © TXH RV EHQV SHUPXWDGRV WHU£R H[DWDPHQWH R
PHVPRYDORUHFRQ´PLFR
3RU LVVR Q£R © UDUR TXH XPD GDV SDUWHV FRPSRQKD D VXD SUHVWD§£R FRP SHFºQLD R TXH GHFRUUH GR
H[HUFFLRGDDXWRQRPLDLQGLYLGXDOGDYRQWDGH
'RH[SRVWRVXVFLWDPRVDVHJXLQWHTXHVW£RTXDQGRDFRQWUDSUHVWD§£RSHOREHPRIHUWDGRHPWURFDIRU
SDUFLDOPHQWHHPGLQKHLURHVWDU¡GHVYLUWXDGDDSHUPXWD"
3DUDUHVSRQGHU©SUHFLVRDQDOLVDUDQDWXUH]DGRFRQWUDWRGHSHUPXWDHPTXHK¡VDOGRDVDWLVID]HUSRLV
DGHSHQGHUGRHQIRTXHTXHVHYLVOXPEUHSRGHVHWHUHIHWLYDPHQWHXPDSHUPXWDH[DWURFDGHXPDFDVD
SRUXPDSDUWDPHQWRFRPSOHPHQWDQGRDGLIHUHQ§DHPGLQKHLURRXXPDFRPSUDHYHQGDFRPSDJDPHQWR
SDUFLDOPHQWHLQQDWXUDH[DYHQGDGHXPDID]HQGDFRPRUHFHELPHQWRGHXPDSDUWDPHQWRFRPRSDUWH
GRSDJDPHQWR
6HJXQGRDGRXWULQDGH(GXDUGR(VSQROD ©SRVVYHOYLVXDOL]DUWUªVWHRULDV
D YHULILFD§£R GH TXDO R PDLRU YDORU H[DWR VH GD FRLVD RX GR VDOGR FDUDFWHUL]DQGRVH REMHWLYDPHQWH QR SULPHLUR FDVR D SHUPXWD H QR
VHJXQGRDFRPSUDHYHQGD
EYHULILFD§£RGDHIHWLYDLQWHQ§£RGDVSDUWHVDSUHFLDGDGHDFRUGRFRPDVFLUFXQVW¢QFLDV
FFRQVLGHUD§£RGDSHUPXWDFRPRUHJUDJHUDOSDUDDHQWUHJDUHFSURFDGHEHQVSHUPXWDFRPVDOGRDQ£RVHUTXHDLPSRUW¢QFLDSDJD
FRPRVDOGRVHMDGHWDOPDQHLUDVXSHULRU FRLVDREMHWRGRFRQWUDWRTXHLQGXELWDYHOPHQWHRSDJDPHQWRHPGLQKHLURGHYHVHUFRQVLGHUDGR
RREMHWRSULQFLSDO
1DVSDODYUDVGRM¡OHPEUDGR('8$5'2(6312/$©ߡHVWDºOWLPDDRSLQL£RGRPLQDQWHFRPDTXDO
VHFRQIRUPDPRVSULQFSLRVUHJXODGRUHVGDPDW©ULDQRVY¡ULRVVLVWHPDVOHJLVODWLYRV7HPUD]£R+HQULGH
3DJH TXDQGR DGYHUWH TXH HP PDW©ULD GH SHUPXWD FRP VDOGR Q£R H[LVWH FULW©ULR IL[R TXH SHUPLWD GL]HU
LQYDULDYHOPHQWHVHRFDVR©GHYHQGDRXGHWURFDRXGHYHQGDHWURFDJHPLQDGDV2TXH©FHUWR©TXHDV
OHJLVOD§µHVPRGHUQDVVDOYRDOJXPDFRPRDSRUWXJXHVD Q£RVHSURQXQFLDPSRUDOJXPDGDVVROX§µHV
DGPLWLGDV SHOD GRXWULQD GH RQGH VH GHSUHHQGH TXH D SHUPXWD FRP VDOGR HP GLQKHLUR Q£R GHL[D GH VHU
SHUPXWDVDOYRPDQLIHVWD§£RVLQFHUDGDVSDUWHVQRXWURVHQWLGR3DUDHYLWDUFRQWURY©UVLDVR&³GLJR&LYLO
DOHP£R OLPLWRXVH D GHFODUDU TXH SHUPXWD VH DSOLFDP DV GLVSRVL§µHV FRUUHVSRQGHQWHV GD FRPSUD H
YHQGDDUWߢQRTXHߚDFUHVFHQWDPRVQ³VߚIRLVHJXLGRSHOR&³GLJR&LYLOEUDVLOHLURDUWGR
&&FRPDVGHYLGDVDGDSWD§µHV
$VVLPVHQGRUHJLVWUDPRVTXHRSDU¢PHWURGHߡPDLVGDPHWDGHGRYDORUߢFRPRTXDOTXHURXWURSRU
Q£RWHUSUHYLV£ROHJDOHVSHFILFDGHYHVHUDSOLFDGRGHDFRUGRFRPRSULQFSLRGDUD]RDELOLGDGHPRWLYR
SHORTXDO©SRVVYHOVLPWRPDURXWURSDU¢PHWURQRFDVRFRQFUHWRDGHSHQGHUGDVFLUFXQVW¢QFLDVI¡WLFDV
',6&,3/,1$-85',&$
$GLVFLSOLQDMXUGLFDGDWURFDRXSHUPXWDQ£RPHUHFHXPDLRUHVGHWDOKDPHQWRVGROHJLVODGRU
'HIDWRGDGDDVHPHOKDQ§DH[LVWHQWHHQWUHRFRQWUDWRGHFRPSUDHYHQGDHDWURFDRXSHUPXWDWRGDD
GLVFLSOLQD QRUPDWLYD DSOLF¡YHO DR SULPHLUR SRGHU¡ VHU LQYRFDGD PXWDWLV PXWDQGLV VHJXQGD D
VDEHUDVUHJUDVVREUHYFLRVUHGLELW³ULRVHYLF§£RHWF
5HVVDOWHVH SRU©P TXH GDGDV DV SHFXOLDULGDGHV GHVWD PRGDOLGDGH FRQWUDWXDO QRWDGDPHQWH D
LQH[LVWªQFLDGHXPߡSUH§RߢSHOREHPWURFDGRQDRFRUUªQFLDGHXPYFLRUHGLELW³ULRSRUH[HPSORQ£R
KDYHU¡ D RS§£R GH H[LJLU HQWUH D VROX§£R GR FRQWUDWR RX R DEDWLPHQWR GR SUH§R FRQFHQWUDQGRVH DV
RS§µHVQDH[WLQ§£RGDDYHQ§D
2 &³GLJR &LYLO EUDVLOHLUR GH UHVHUYRX SRU LVVR UHIHULGD ILJXUD FRQWUDWXDO DSHQDV XP ºQLFR
DUWLJRTXHWHPSRUILQDOLGDGHID]HUDVDGDSWD§µHV VVXDVSHFXOLDULGDGHVDVVLPSUHFHLWXDQGR
ߡ$UW$SOLFDPVH WURFDDVGLVSRVL§µHVUHIHUHQWHV FRPSUDHYHQGDFRPDVVHJXLQWHVPRGLILFD§µHV
,ߚVDOYRGLVSRVL§£RHPFRQWU¡ULRFDGDXPGRVFRQWUDWDQWHVSDJDU¡SRUPHWDGHDVGHVSHVDVFRPRLQVWUXPHQWRGDWURFD
,,ߚ©DQXO¡YHODWURFDGHYDORUHVGHVLJXDLVHQWUHDVFHQGHQWHVHGHVFHQGHQWHVVHPFRQVHQWLPHQWRGRVRXWURVGHVFHQGHQWHVHGRF´QMXJH
GRDOLHQDQWHߢ
1DSULPHLUDUHVVDOYDFRPRQ£RVHWHPSURSULDPHQWHGHIRUPDLVRODGDXPFRPSUDGRUHXPGHYHGRU
PDVVLPGRLVVXMHLWRVTXHUHFHEHPHHQWUHJDPSUHVWD§µHVQ£RSHFXQL¡ULDVXPDVROX§£RVDORP´QLFDIRL
DGRWDGDSDUDRHVWDEHOHFLPHQWRGDVGHVSHVDVGRQHJ³FLRMXUGLFR7DOUHJUDREYLDPHQWH©GHDSOLFD§£R
VXSOHWLYD QD DXVªQFLD GH HVWLSXOD§£R FRQWUDWXDO HVSHFILFD GHFRUUHQWH GD DXWRQRPLD GD YRQWDGH GDV
SDUWHV
-¡ D VHJXQGD UHVVDOYD WDPE©P H[LVWHQWH QD FRGLILFD§£R DQWHULRU IRL ߡDWXDOL]DGDߢ QR YLJHQWH &³GLJR
&LYLO SDVVDQGR GH FDVR GH QXOLGDGH SDUD DQXODELOLGDGH DFRPSDQKDQGR SRUWDQWR D M¡ PHQFLRQDGD
PRGLILFD§£RGDGLVFLSOLQDGDYHQGDGHDVFHQGHQWHDGHVFHQGHQWHDUWGR&&
6REUHRWHPDREVHUYD&$5/2652%(572*21$/9(6
ߡ6H RV YDORUHV V£R GHVLJXDLV H R REMHWR TXH SHUWHQFH DR DVFHQGHQWH © PDLV YDOLRVR RV GHPDLV GHVFHQGHQWHV GHYHP VHU RXYLGRV H
FRQVHQWLU H[SUHVVDPHQWH SHODV PHVPDV UD]µHV TXH MXVWLILFDP D QHFHVVLGDGH GH WDO FRQVHQWLPHQWR QD YHQGD GH DVFHQGHQWH SDUD
GHVFHQGHQWHDUW6HRVYDORUHVV£RLJXDLVQ£RK¡QHFHVVLGDGHGDUHIHULGDDQXªQFLDSHODLPSRVVLELOLGDGHGHKDYHUSUHMX]RSDUDRV
GHPDLVGHVFHQGHQWHV(HPERUDR&³GLJRQ£RPHQFLRQHWDPE©PVHU¡GLVSHQV¡YHOWDODQXªQFLDVHREHPUHFHELGRSHORDVFHQGHQWHQD
WURFDWLYHUYDORUVXSHULRUDRSRUHOHHQWUHJXHSRLVKDYHU¡QDKLS³WHVHDXPHQWRGHVHXSDWULP´QLRQ£RWHQGRRVGHPDLVGHVFHQGHQWHV
OHJWLPRLQWHUHVVHSDUDGLVFRUGDUGRQHJ³FLRߢ
9ªVHSRUWDQWRQHVWHSRQWRDLQHTXYRFDSUHRFXSD§£RGROHJLVODGRUGHSURWH§£RGDOHJWLPD
;;9
&2175$72(67,0$75,2
&21&(,72(3$57(6
0XLWR VH GLVFXWLX HP GRXWULQD D UHVSHLWR GD QDWXUH]D GR FRQWUDWR HVWLPDW³ULR ILUPDQGRVH DR ILQDO
GHVWD WRUPHQWD GRXWULQ¡ULD D WHVH GHIHQVLYD GH VXD DXWRQRPLD MXUGLFD FRQVRDQWH DVVHYHUD R FXOWR
:$/',5,2%8/*$5(//,
ߡ$V GLVFXVVµHV YHULILFDGDV HP WRUQR GD QDWXUH]D MXUGLFD GR FRQWUDWR HVWLPDW³ULR FRPSUD H YHQGD VRE FRQGL§£R UHVROXWLYD GHS³VLWR
RIHUWDILUPHGHYHQGDHVS©FLHGHFRPLVV£RRXPHVPRXPWLSRGHVRFLHGDGHSHUGHUDPPXLWRGDVXDLPSRUW¢QFLDDS³VDWLSLILFD§£RTXH
OKHIRLGDGDSHOR&³GLJR&LYLO,WDOLDQRGHߢ
'H IDWR R &³GLJR LWDOLDQR FXLGRX GH WLSLILF¡OR WUD]HQGR GLVFLSOLQD SU³SULD QRV DUWV
FRQFHLWXDQGRRGDVHJXLQWHIRUPD
ߡ$UW3HORFRQWUDWRHVWLPDW³ULRHQWUHJDXPDSDUWHXPDRXPDLVFRLVDVP³YHLV RXWUDHHVWDVHREULJDDSDJDURSUH§RDQ£RVHU
TXHUHVWLWXDDFRLVDQRSUD]RHVWDEHOHFLGRߢ
6HJXLGRGHIRUPDPXLWRSU³[LPDTXDQWR VXDGLF§£ROHJDOSHOR&³GLJR&LYLOEUDVLOHLUR
ߡ$UW3HORFRQWUDWRHVWLPDW³ULRRFRQVLJQDQWHHQWUHJDEHQVP³YHLVDRFRQVLJQDW¡ULRTXHILFDDXWRUL]DGRDYHQGªORVSDJDQGR TXHOH
RSUH§RDMXVWDGRVDOYRVHSUHIHULUQRSUD]RHVWDEHOHFLGRUHVWLWXLUOKHDFRLVDFRQVLJQDGDߢ
&RPIXQGDPHQWRQHVVHVGLVSRVLWLYRVOHJDLVILFDI¡FLOFRQFHLWXDUPRVRFRQWUDWRFRQVLJQDW³ULRFRPRXP
QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR SRU PHLR GR TXDO XPD GDV SDUWHV FRQVLJQDQWH WUDQVIHUH D RXWUR FRQVLJQDW¡ULR EHQV
P³YHLVDILPGHTXHRVYHQGDVHJXQGRXPSUH§RSUHYLDPHQWHHVWLSXODGRRXVLPSOHVPHQWHRVUHVWLWXDDR
SU³SULRFRQVLJQDQWH
(QXQFLDGRV HVW£R WDPE©P RV VXMHLWRV GD UHOD§£R FRQWUDWXDO TXDLV VHMDP R FRQVLJQDQWH WLWXODU GR
EHP H R FRQVLJQDW¡ULR UHVSRQV¡YHO SHOD YHQGD RX UHVWLWXL§£R GD FRLVD GHYHQGR VHU UHVHUYDGD D
H[SUHVV£RߡFRQVLJQDGRߢSDUDREHPREMHWRGRQHJ³FLRMXUGLFR
5HVVDOWHVHTXHHPERUDKDMDLGHQWLGDGHWHUPLQRO³JLFDRFRQWUDWRHVWLPDW³ULRYHQGDSRUFRQVLJQD§£R
Q£RVHFRQIXQGHFRPDFRQVLJQD§£RHPSDJDPHQWRTXH©HPYHUGDGHXPLQVWLWXWRMXUGLFRFRORFDGR
GLVSRVL§£RGRGHYHGRUSDUDTXHDQWHRREVW¡FXORDRUHFHELPHQWRFULDGRSHORFUHGRURXTXDLVTXHURXWUDV
FLUFXQVW¢QFLDVLPSHGLWLYDVGRSDJDPHQWRH[HU§DSRUGHS³VLWRGDFRLVDGHYLGDRGLUHLWRGHDGLPSOLUD
SUHVWD§£ROLEHUDQGRVHGROLDPHREULJDFLRQDO
$ PDW©ULD HPERUD M¡ FRQKHFLGD GD GRXWULQD H MXULVSUXGªQFLD EUDVLOHLUD EHP FRPR QD KLVW³ULD GR
'LUHLWR VRPHQWHYHLRDVHUFRGLILFDGDFRPRDGYHQWRGR&³GLJR&LYLOGHSRLVR&³GLJRGH
VLOHQFLRXVREUHRLQVWLWXWR
1$785(=$-85',&$
2ULJLQDOPHQWHKDYLDEDVWDQWHSROªPLFDDFHUFDGDQDWXUH]DMXUGLFDGRFRQWUDWRHVWLPDW³ULRYHQGDHP
FRQVLJQD§£RRTXHSRUFHUWRGHFRUULDGDIDOWDGHXPDGLVFLSOLQDFRGLILFDGD
5HVVDOWHVHSRU©PTXHDDXWRQRPLDGDYHQGDSRUFRQVLJQD§£RSDUDDFRPSUDHYHQGDM¡YLQKDVHQGR
VXVWHQWDGD DQWHV PHVPR GD SRVLWLYD§£R SHOR YLJHQWH &³GLJR &LYLO EUDVLOHLUR TXH D UHFRQKHFH FRPR
IRUPDFRQWUDWXDOWSLFDHQRPLQDGD
(VWDPRGDOLGDGHFRQWUDWXDOSRULVVRPHVPRGHYHVHUGLIHUHQFLDGDGHDOJXPDVHVS©FLHVDQ¡ORJDVFRP
DVTXDLVQ£RVHGHYHFRQIXQGLUQRWDGDPHQWHFRPRUHFRQKHFLPHQWRGHVXDDXWRQRPLD
6DOLHQWDQGRDVVXDVSHFXOLDULGDGHVQD,-RUQDGDGH'LUHLWR&LYLOSURPRYLGDSHOR&HQWURGH(VWXGRV
-XGLFL¡ULRV GR &RQVHOKR GD -XVWL§D )HGHUDO DSURYRXVH R (QXQFLDGR Q UHIHUHQWH DR FRQWUDWR
HVWLPDW³ULRQRVVHJXLQWHVWHUPRV
ߡ(181&,$'2 1 ߚ 1R FRQWUDWR HVWLPDW³ULR DUW R FRQVLJQDQWH WUDQVIHUH DR FRQVLJQDW¡ULR WHPSRUDULDPHQWH R SRGHU GH
DOLHQD§£RGDFRLVDFRQVLJQDGDFRPRS§£RGHSDJDPHQWRGRSUH§RGHHVWLPDRXVXDUHVWLWXL§£RDRILQDOGRSUH§RDMXVWDGRߢ
1RWHVHSRLVTXHRFRQVLJQDW¡ULRIDU¡MXVDXPDSDUFHODGRSUH§RGDYHQGDTXHGHYHU¡SHODQDWXUH]D
PHVPD GR FRQWUDWR VHU IL[DGR SHOR SU³SULR FRQVLJQDQWH ([HPSOR M¡ PHQFLRQDGR © R GD HGLWRUD TXH
WUDQVIHUHDROLYUHLURGHWHUPLQDGDTXDQWLGDGHGHOLYURVHVWLSXODQGRRSUH§RGHYHQGDHRSHURGRGHQWUR
GRTXDORVH[HPSODUHVGHYHPVHUYHQGLGRVRXVLPSOHVPHQWHFDVRLVVRQ£RRFRUUDVHU£RUHVWLWXGRVDR
FRQVLJQDQWH 2XWUD KLS³WHVH VHULD D GH XPD GLVWULEXLGRUD GH EHELGDV WUDQVIHULU HP FRQVLJQD§£R D XPD
HPSUHVD RUJDQL]DGRUD GH IHVWDV FHUWD TXDQWLGDGH GH HQJUDGDGRV GH UHIULJHUDQWH 2 TXH IRU YHQGLGR ©
FRPSXWDGRFRPROXFURSDUDDPEDVDVSDUWHVRTXHQ£RIRU©GHYROYLGRDRFRQVLJQDQWH
(PUHVXPRWHUDPRVRVHJXLQWHTXDGUR
2 REMHWR GHVWH FRQWUDWR FRPR YLVWR © OLPLWDGR D EHQV P³YHLV Q£R KDYHQGR SHUPLVVLELOLGDGH OHJDO
SDUD TXH VH SDFWXH R FRQWUDWR WHQGR SRU REMHWR LP³YHLV SRLV LVVR GHVYLUWXDULD D QDWXUH]D PHVPD GD
DYHQ§D
(PERUD D OHL DSRQWH QR VHQWLGR GH TXH D FRLVD P³YHO GHYD VHU YHQGLGD D WHUFHLUR RX VH LVVR Q£R
RFRUUHUUHVWLWXGDDRFRQVLJQDQWHQDGDLPSHGHTXHRSU³SULRFRQVLJQDW¡ULRDFRPSUHSDJDQGRRYDORU
HVWLSXODGR 7DLV SRVVLELOLGDGHV V£R FRQIHULGDV IDFXOWDWLYDPHQWH D HOH Q£R SRGHQGR HP QRVVR VHQWLU R
FRQVLJQDQWHLPSRUDDTXLVL§£RSHORFRQVLJQDW¡ULRSRUIRU§DGDLQHJ¡YHODEXVLYLGDGHFRQWLGDHPFO¡XVXOD
GHVWHMDH]
)LQDOPHQWHFXPSUHQRVDGYHUWLUTXHFDVRRFRQWUDWRQ£RHVWLSXOHSUD]RSDUDDYHQGDRXDUHVWLWXL§£R
GR EHP SRGHU¡ R FRQVLJQDQWH QRWLILFDU R FRQVLJQDW¡ULR IL[DQGROKH SUD]R SDUD D QHFHVV¡ULD
GHYROX§£R
&$5$&7(567,&$6
2FRQWUDWRHVWLPDW³ULRFRPRYLVWRHPERUDFRQKHFLGRQDSU¡WLFDQHJRFLDOK¡PXLWRWHPSRSRUWDQWR
QRPLQDGR WRUQRXVH WSLFR QR &³GLJR &LYLO GH DUWV VHQGR GRWDGR GDV VHJXLQWHV
FDUDFWHUVWLFDV
DUHDOߚSRLVDHQWUHJDGDFRLVDDRFRQVLJQDW¡ULR©YHUGDGHLURHOHPHQWRFRQVWLWXWLYRRXH[LVWHQFLDOGRFRQWUDWR(PRXWUDVSDODYUDVDVVLP
FRPRRFRUUHQRSHQKRUHQRGHS³VLWRHQTXDQWRQ£RRSHUDGDDWUDQVIHUªQFLDGDSRVVHRFRQWUDWRQ£RVHFRQVLGHUDIRUPDGR
EELODWHUDOߚLPSµHGLUHLWRVHGHYHUHVSDUDDPEDVDVSDUWHV$REULJD§£RSUHFSXDGRFRQVLJQDQWH©UHPXQHUDURFRQVLJQDW¡ULRHRGHYHU
MXUGLFRSULQFLSDOGHVWHºOWLPR©HIHWLYDUDYHQGDGDFRLVD1RSU³[LPRW³SLFRWUDUHPRVPDLVGHWDOKHVHVSHFILFRVVREUHHVWHDVVXQWR
F RQHURVR ߚ SRLV DPEDV DV SDUWHV HP OLQKD GH SULQFSLR H[SHULPHQWDP UHFLSURFDPHQWH VDFULIFLRV SDWULPRQLDLV H EHQHIFLRV
FRUUHVSRQGHQWHV
GFRPXWDWLYRߚXPDYH]TXHDVSUHVWD§µHVLPSRVWDV VSDUWHVV£RFHUWDVHGHWHUPLQDGDVQRSU³SULRFRQWUDWR
HGHGXUD§£RSUD]RGHWHUPLQDGRRXQ£RߚHPJHUDOQRSU³SULRFRQWUDWRM¡VHHVWDEHOHFHRSUD]RGHQWURGRTXDOGHYHRFRQVLJQDW¡ULR
HIHWLYDUDYHQGDGRVEHQVRXGHYROYªORV(QWUHWDQWRYLPRVOLQKDVDFLPDTXHFDVRQ£RVHSDFWXHHVWHSUD]RSRGHU¡RFRQVLJQDQWHD
TXDOTXHUWHPSRQRWLILFDUDSDUWHDGYHUVDSDUDTXHUHDOL]HDGHYROX§£RGDTXLORTXHUHFHEHX
I©ILGXFL¡ULRߚRXVHMD©XPFRQWUDWRSDFWXDGRHPFRQILDQ§DSRLVRFRQVLJQDQWHVXMHLWDVHDWUDQVIHULUFRLVDVVXDVDRFRQVLJQDW¡ULRVHP
DFRQVHTXHQWHWUDQVOD§£RGRGRPQLRHHPFDU¡WHUSRWHQFLDOPHQWHWHPSRU¡ULR
$ SULRUL WUDWDVH GH XP FRQWUDWR SDULW¡ULR HP TXH DV SDUWHV HP LJXDLV FRQGL§µHV GH QHJRFLD§£R
HVWDEHOHFHPOLYUHPHQWHDVFO¡XVXODVFRQWUDWXDLVQDIDVHGHSXQWXD§£RPDVWDPE©PSRGHPDQLIHVWDUVHQD
PRGDOLGDGHGHXPߡFRQWUDWRGHDGHV£RߢFRQWUDWRHPTXHXPGRVSDFWXDQWHVSUHGHWHUPLQDDVFO¡XVXODVGR
QHJ³FLRMXUGLFR([5LFDUGRSDVVDD-RUJHOLYUHLURY¡ULRVOLYURVGDVXDHGLWRUDLQIRUPDQGRRSUD]R
RYDORUSUHWHQGLGRFRPFDGDREUDHDW©DPDUJHPGHOXFURDFHLW¡YHOWHQGR-RUJHDSHQDVDDOWHUQDWLYDGH
FRQWUDWDURXQ£R
7UDWDVH GH PRGDOLGDGH FRQWUDWXDO DPSODPHQWH GLIXQGLGD QD SU¡WLFD WDQWR QDV UHOD§µHV FLYLV TXDQWR
FRPHUFLDLV
(PERUDVHMDFRPRYLVWRXPFRQWUDWRUHDOQ£RK¡DLPSUHVFLQGLELOLGDGHGHXPDIRUPDHVSHFILFDSDUD
DYDOLGDGHGDHVWLSXOD§£RFRQWUDWXDOSHORTXH©FRQVLGHUDGRXPFRQWUDWRQ£RVROHQH
7UDWDVHDLQGDHHPUHJUDGHXPFRQWUDWRLPSHVVRDOSRLVVRPHQWHLQWHUHVVDRUHVXOWDGRGDDWLYLGDGH
FRQWUDWDGD LQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWH GH TXHP VHMD D SHVVRD TXH LU¡ UHDOL]¡OD R TXH LPSRUWD HP SRGHU VHU
H[HFXWDGRSRURXWUHP
1D PHVPD OLQKD GD PDLRULD GDV ILJXUDV FRQWUDWXDLV QRPLQDGDV GR &³GLJR &LYLO GH R FRQWUDWR
HVWLPDW³ULR©XPFRQWUDWRFDXVDOYLQFXODGRSRUWDQWR FDXVDTXHRGHWHUPLQRXSRGHQGRVHUGHFODUDGR
LQY¡OLGRVHHVWDIRUFRQVLGHUDGDLQH[LVWHQWHLOFLWDRXLPRUDO
3HOD IXQ§£R HFRQ´PLFD WUDWDVH GH XP FRQWUDWR GH DWLYLGDGH FDUDFWHUL]DGR SHOD SUHVWD§£R GH XPD
FRQGXWDPHGLDQWHDTXDOVHSRGHFRQVHJXLUXPDXWLOLGDGHHFRQ´PLFDWDLVFRPRRVFRQWUDWRVGHHPSUHJR
SUHVWD§£RGHVHUYL§RVHPSUHLWDGDPDQGDWRDJªQFLDHFRUUHWDJHP
3RU ILP FRPR © HYLGHQWH WUDWDVH GH XP FRQWUDWR SULQFLSDO FRP H[LVWªQFLD DXW´QRPD
LQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWH GH RXWUR H GHILQLWLYR SRLV Q£R GHSHQGH GH TXDOTXHU RXWUD DYHQ§D Q£R VHQGR
SUHSDUDW³ULRSDUDDFRPSUDHYHQGD
;;9,
'2$2
&21&(,72(3$57(6
6REUH R FRQFHLWR GH GRD§£R PXLWR LQFLVLYD QR FDVR HP HVWXGR © D GLF§£R GR &³GLJR &LYLO GH
3RUWXJDO HP TXH VH SRGH REVHUYDU QLWLGDPHQWH R PHQFLRQDGR DQLPXV GRQDQGL WSLFR GR FRQWUDWR GH
GRD§£R
ߡ$UWߚ'RD§£R©RFRQWUDWRSHORTXDOXPDSHVVRDSRUHVSULWRGHOLEHUDOLGDGHH FXVWDGRVHXSDWULP´QLRGLVSµHJUDWXLWDPHQWH
GHXPDFRLVDRXGHXPGLUHLWRRXDVVXPHXPDREULJD§£RHPEHQHILFLRGRRXWURFRQWUDHQWH
1£RK¡GRD§£RQDUHQºQFLDDGLUHLWRVHQRUHSºGLRGHKHUDQ§DRXOHJDGRQHPW£RSRXFRQRVGRQDWLYRVFRQIRUPHVDRVXVRVVRFLDLVߢ
JULIRVQRVVRV
1HVVHPHVPRGLDSDV£RPDVFRPUHGD§£RPDLVFRQFLVDSUHFHLWXDRQRVVR&³GLJR&LYLO
ߡ$UW&RQVLGHUDVHGRD§£RRFRQWUDWRHPTXHXPDSHVVRDSRUOLEHUDOLGDGHWUDQVIHUHGRVHXSDWULP´QLREHQVRXYDQWDJHQVSDUDRGH
RXWUDߢJULIRQRVVR
9DOH VDOLHQWDU QHVWH SRQWR TXH R QRVVR OHJLVODGRU GLIHUHQWHPHQWH GR SRUWXJXªV Q£R FRQVLGHURX
GRD§£R DߡDVVXQ§£R GH XPDREULJD§£Rߢߚ DFHUWDGDPHQWH DR QRVVR YHU ߚSRLV HP QRVVRVLVWHPDWDO
VLWXD§£RMXUGLFDVXEVXPHVHPHOKRUHPRXWURVLQVWLWXWRVMXUGLFRVWSLFRVGDWHRULDJHUDOGDVREULJD§µHV
FRPRDDVVXQ§£RGHGYLGDRXDQRYD§£RVXEMHWLYDSDVVLYDFXMDILQDOLGDGHGL]PDLVUHVSHLWRFRPDLGHLD
GHDGLPSOHPHQWRDQLPXVVROYHQGLGRTXHFRPDGHPHUDOLEHUDOLGDGH
$VVLP VHQGR M¡ SRGHPRV FRQFHLWXDU GRD§£R FRPR XP QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR ILUPDGR HQWUH GRLV VXMHLWRV
GRDGRUHGRQDW¡ULRSRUIRU§DGRTXDORSULPHLURWUDQVIHUHEHQVP³YHLVRXLP³YHLVSDUDRSDWULP´QLR
GRVHJXQGRDQLPDGRSHORVLPSOHVSURS³VLWRGHEHQHILFªQFLDRXOLEHUDOLGDGH
'XDV V£R DV SDUWHV SRUWDQWR GD GRD§£R D VDEHU R GRDGRU TXH © DTXHOH TXH WUDQVIHUH R EHP H R
GRQDW¡ULRTXH©DTXHOHTXHUHFHEHREHQHIFLR
(TXDLVV£RDVFDUDFWHUVWLFDVE¡VLFDVGHVVHFRQWUDWR"
RTXHYHUHPRVQRSU³[LPRW³SLFR
&$5$&7(567,&$6
&RPRVHYªGRM¡WUDQVFULWRDUWGR&&WUDWDVHDGRD§£RGHXPFRQWUDWRWSLFRHQRPLQDGR
FXMDSULQFLSDOFDUDFWHUVWLFD©DXQLODWHUDOLGDGHLPSRQGRREULJD§£RDSHQDVSDUDRGRDGRU
(PHVPRTXHVHWUDWHGHGRD§£RRQHURVDߚDTXHODJUDYDGDFRPXPHQFDUJRߚDLQGDDVVLPHPQRVVR
SHQVDPHQWRDFDUDFWHUVWLFDGDXQLODWHUDOLGDGHSHUVLVWLULDXPDYH]TXHR´QXVTXHVHLPSµHDRGRQDW¡ULR
Q£RWHPRSHVRGDFRQWUDSUHVWD§£RDSRQWRGHGHVYLUWXDUDQDWXUH]DGRFRQWUDWR
R FDVR GR VXMHLWR TXH GRD XPD JUDQGH ID]HQGD D %HQHYDO LPSRQGR D HVWH R HQFDUJR Q£R D
FRQWUDSUHVWD§£RGHSDJDUXPDSHQV£RDXPDVHQKRUDLGRVDWLDGRGRDGRUDW©TXHHODFRPSOHWHDQRV
1RWHVHTXHQHVWHFDVRR´QXVDVVXPLGRSRU%HQHYDOGHYHU¡VHUFXPSULGRHPEHQHIFLRGHOHPHVPRH
Q£RWHPRPDWL]GHXPDFRQWUDSUHVWD§£RREULJDFLRQDORXVHMDHOHGRQDW¡ULRQ£RHVW¡SDJDQGRDSHQV£R
FRPRSUHVVXSRVWRSDUDRUHFHELPHQWRGDFRLVDQRWDWSLFDGDELODWHUDOLGDGHVLQDODJP¡WLFD
( WDQWR © DVVLP TXH ߚ D GHVSHLWR GH R GRDGRU SRGHU UHYRJDU R QHJ³FLR VH R HQFDUJR IRU
GHVFXPSULGR ߚGHVGHRGLDGDFHOHEUD§£RGRDWRRGRQDW¡ULRM¡DGTXLUHDSURSULHGDGHGDFRLVD
DLQGD TXH Q£R WHQKD HIHWLYDGR R SDJDPHQWR GHYLGR DUW GR && 7HPRV DVVLP TXH R FRQWUDWR GH
GRD§£RVRPHQWHLPSµHREULJD§£RQRVHQWLGRW©FQLFRHVWULWRGRWHUPRSDUDXPDGDVSDUWHVߚRGRDGRU
ߚQ£RGHVYLUWXDQGRHVWDXQLODWHUDOLGDGHDH[LVWªQFLDGHRQHURVLGDGHGRD§£RFRPHQFDUJR
1HVVH PHVPR VHQWLGR FRQFOXL 6/9,2 9(126$ ߡ TXDQGR LPSRVWR HQFDUJR GRD§£R Q£R VH
GHVYLUWXDDXQLODWHUDOLGDGHߢ
$O©P GD XQLODWHUDOLGDGH D GRD§£R FDUDFWHUL]DVH SRU VHU HVVHQFLDOPHQWH IRUPDO FRQVRDQWH VH
GHSUHHQGHGDDQ¡OLVHGRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLO
ߡ$UW$GRD§£RIDUVH¡SRUHVFULWXUDSºEOLFDRXLQVWUXPHQWRSDUWLFXODUߢJULIRVQRVVRV
(QWUHWDQWR SRGHU¡ VHU VLPSOHVPHQWH FRQVHQVXDO YHUEDO FDVR WHQKD SRU REMHWR EHQV P³YHLV GH
SHTXHQRYDORUVHOKHVHJXLUGHLPHGLDWRDWUDGL§£RFRQIRUPHFRQVWDGRSDU¡JUDIRºQLFRGRPHQFLRQDGR
DUW RFDVRSRUH[HPSORGRDPLJRTXHGRDXPDFDQHWDDRRXWURHQWUHJDQGRDGHLPHGLDWR
2EVHUYHVH HQWUHWDQWR TXH R OHJLVODGRU Q£R FXLGRX GH HVWDEHOHFHU FULW©ULRV SDUD D PHQVXUD§£R GR
FRQFHLWR GH ߡSHTXHQR YDORUߢ 7UDWDVH SRLV GH XP FRQFHLWR DEHUWR RX LQGHWHUPLQDGR TXH GHYHU¡ VHU
SUHHQFKLGRSHORMXL]QRFDVRFRQFUHWRK¡TXHPFRQVLGHUHߡSHTXHQRYDORUߢDTXHOHTXHQ£RVXSODQWHR
WHWRGHXPVDO¡ULRPQLPRHPERUDDTXHVW£RQ£RVHMDSDFILFD
9DOHOHPEUDUHQWUHWDQWRTXHHPQRVVRVLVWHPDVHRFRQWUDWRYHUVDUVREUHLP³YHOTXHVXSODQWHRWHWR
GHVDO¡ULRV PQLPRVFRQVLGHUDVH LQGLVSHQV¡YHO DODYUDWXUD GR DWRHPHVFULWXUD SºEOLFD RXVHMDD
VROHQLGDGHGDIRUPDVRESHQDGHQXOLGDGHDEVROXWD
1HVVHVHQWLGRRM¡PHQFLRQDGRDUWGRQRVVR&³GLJR&LYLO
ߡ$UW 1£R GLVSRQGR D OHL HP FRQWU¡ULR D HVFULWXUD SºEOLFD © HVVHQFLDO YDOLGDGH GRV QHJ³FLRV MXUGLFRV TXH YLVHP FRQVWLWXL§£R
WUDQVIHUªQFLDPRGLILFD§£RRXUHQºQFLDGHGLUHLWRVUHDLVVREUHLP³YHLVGHYDORUVXSHULRUDWULQWDYH]HVRPDLRUVDO¡ULRPQLPRYLJHQWHQR
3DVߢ
2XWUD LPSRUWDQWH QRWD FDUDFWHUVWLFD GD GRD§£R © D RFRUUªQFLD GR DQLPXV GRQDQGL TXH SRGH VHU
HQWHQGLGD FRPR R ¢QLPR RX SURS³VLWR GH EHQHILFLDU SDWULPRQLDOPHQWH R GHVWLQDW¡ULR GD YRQWDGH GR
GRDGRU
(VWH DQLPXV GRQDQGL Q£R SRGH VHU FRQIXQGLGR FRP D VLPSOHV UHQºQFLD DEGLFDWLYD RX VHMD DTXHOD
PDQLIHVWD§£R QHJRFLDO SRU PHLR GD TXDO R GHFODUDQWH VLPSOHVPHQWH VH GHVSRMD GH XP EHP GR VHX
SDWULP´QLR VHP EHQHILFL¡ULR FHUWR RX GHWHUPLQDGR 1RWHVH DVVLP TXH HVWH WLSR GH GHFODUD§£R GH
YRQWDGH RSHUD D H[WLQ§£R GH XP GLUHLWR FRPR QD KLS³WHVH HP TXH RߡSURSULHW¡ULR DEDQGRQD R LP³YHO
TXDQGRRFUHGRUUHPLWHRFU©GLWRTXDQGRRFUHGRUUHQXQFLD ILDQ§DRX KLSRWHFDTXDQGRRGHYHGRU
UHQXQFLDDRSUD]RFRQFHGLGRDRVHXIDYRUTXDQGRRGHYHGRUUHQXQFLD SUHVFUL§£Rߢ
(P WRGDV HVVDV VLWXD§µHV SRLV Q£R H[LVWH XPD WUDQVIHUªQFLD SDWULPRQLDO YROXQW¡ULD EHQ©ILFD D
GHWHUPLQDGDSHVVRD
&DVRHQWUHWDQWRVHWUDWHGHUHQºQFLDWUDQVODWLYDSRVWRJXDUGHGLVWLQ§£RRQWRO³JLFDFRPRFRQWUDWRVRE
H[DPHDVXDVHPHOKDQ§DHILFDFLDOHPIDFHGDGRD§£R©PXLWRJUDQGHSRLVQHVWHFDVRK¡SHVVRDVTXHVH
EHQHILFLDPGRDWRH[+ROO\YHLURVUHQXQFLD VXDTXRWDGDKHUDQ§DHPIDYRUGRVHXLUP£R3HGUR7UDWD
VHGHFHVV£RGHGLUHLWRVFRPQDWXUH]DGHUHQºQFLDWUDQVODWLYD
1HVVDPHVPDOLQKDQ£RVHGHYHFRQIXQGLURDQLPXVGRQDQGLFRPRVROYHQGLHPTXHDSDUWHSUHWHQGH
VROYHUXPG©ELWRFXPSULUXPDREULJD§£R
1£R©RXWUDDOL¡VDGLDJQRVHGLIHUHQFLDOHQWUHDGRD§£RHDGD§£RHPSDJDPHQWRDUWVDGR
&&IRUPDHVSHFLDOGHSDJDPHQWR
)LQDOPHQWH VDOLHQWDQGR DGYHUWªQFLD IHLWD TXDQGR HQIUHQWDPRV R FRQWUDWR GH FRPSUD H YHQGD VH R
REMHWRGRQHJ³FLRIRUHPGLUHLWRVߚHQ£RFRLVDVߚPDLVW©FQLFRVHU¡FKDP¡ORGHFRQWUDWRGHFHVV£R
JUDWXLWDGHGLUHLWRVHPYH]GHFRQWUDWRGHGRD§£RRH[HPSORGDFHVV£RJUDWXLWDGRGLUHLWRKHUHGLW¡ULR
RXGHTXRWDVGHXPDGHWHUPLQDGDVRFLHGDGH
$ FODVVLILFD§£R TXDQWR FRPXWDWLYLGDGH RX DOHDWRULHGDGH © LQDSOLF¡YHO DR FRQWUDWR GH GRD§£R QD
PRGDOLGDGHGHGRD§£RVLPSOHVWHQGRHPYLVWDDVXDFDUDFWHUVWLFDGHXQLODWHUDOLGDGHTXDQWRDRVHIHLWRV
3HORVPHVPRVIXQGDPHQWRVQ£RK¡IDODUHPHTXD§£RILQDQFHLUDGRFRQWUDWRRXFRQWUDWRHYROXWLYREHP
FRPRHPIXQ§£RHFRQ´PLFDGRFRQWUDWR
(PERUDJUDWXLWRHPJHUDO©XPFRQWUDWRGHDGHV£RXPDYH]TXHDRGRQDW¡ULRVRPHQWHFDEHDQXLURX
Q£R OLEHUDOLGDGHGRGRDGRUQ£RSRGHQGRGLVFXWLURVVHXVWHUPRV
1D FODVVLILFD§£R GRV FRQWUDWRV TXDQWR GLVFLSOLQD MXUGLFD © FRQWUDWR DPSODPHQWH XWLOL]DGR QDV
UHOD§µHVFLYLVQ£RVHQGRPXLWRFRPXPQDVFRPHUFLDLVFRQVXPHULVWDVHDGPLQLVWUDWLYDVQHPDSOLF¡YHO
SDUDDVUHOD§µHVWUDEDOKLVWDV
7UDWDVH DLQGD GH XP FRQWUDWR LPSHVVRDO HQWHQGLGR FRPR DTXHOH HP TXH VRPHQWH LQWHUHVVD R
UHVXOWDGR GD DWLYLGDGH FRQWUDWDGD LQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWH GH TXHP VHMD D SHVVRD TXH LU¡ UHDOL]¡OD H
LQGLYLGXDOUHIHULQGRVHDXPDHVWLSXOD§£RHQWUHSHVVRDVGHWHUPLQDGDV
1R TXH GL] UHVSHLWR DR WHPSR D IRUPD KDELWXDO © GH FRQWUDWD§£R H H[HFX§£R LPHGLDWDV PDV QDGD
LPSHGH TXH D DXWRQRPLD GD YRQWDGH GRV FRQWUDWDQWHV QR SDUWLFXODU GR GRDGRU D HVWDEHOH§D VRE D
PRGDOLGDGHLQVWDQW¢QHDFRPH[HFX§£RGLIHULGDRXH[FHSFLRQDOPHQWHFRPGXUD§£ROLPLWD§£RWHPSRUDO
3RU ILP WUDWDVH GH XP ߡFRQWUDWR SULQFLSDOߢ H D SULRUL ߡGHILQLWLYRߢ HPERUD KDMD TXHP DGPLWD
SRVVYHO D FHOHEUD§£R GH XPD SURPHVVD GH GRD§£R FRQWUDWR SUHOLPLQDU TXH WHP SRU ILQDOLGDGH
MXVWDPHQWHDFHOHEUD§£RGHXPFRQWUDWRGHILQLWLYR
$&(,7$2'$'2$2
$R DSUHVHQWDU D SURSRVWD GH GRD§£R HVSHUDVH TXH R GRQDW¡ULR H[SUHVVDPHQWH PDQLIHVWHVH
DTXLHVFHQGRRXUHSXGLDQGRDRIHUWDGRGRDGRU
&RPR M¡ DVVHYHUDPRV SRU VHU QHJ³FLR ELODWHUDO QD RULJHP H XQLODWHUDO QRV HIHLWRV VRPHQWH DS³V
KDYHUDDFHLWD§£RGRGRQDW¡ULRRFRQVHQWLPHQWRVHIRUPDGDQGRRULJHPDRFRQWUDWR
7DOPDQLIHVWD§£RH[SUHVVDSRGHVHUWDQWRQDPRGDOLGDGHHVFULWDTXDQWRYHUEDORXPHVPRJHVWXDO
(QWUHWDQWR SRGH DFRQWHFHU TXH R GRDGRU SRU FDXWHOD FXLGH GH DVVLQDUOKH SUD]R GH PDQLIHVWD§£R D
WHRUGRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLOVRESHQDGRVHXVLOªQFLRWUDGX]LUDFHLWD§£RWUDWDQGRVHGHGRD§£RSXUD
ߡ$UW2GRDGRUSRGHIL[DUSUD]RDRGRQDW¡ULRSDUDGHFODUDUVHDFHLWDRXQ£RDOLEHUDOLGDGH'HVGHTXHRGRQDW¡ULRFLHQWHGRSUD]R
Q£RID§DGHQWURGHOHDGHFODUD§£RHQWHQGHUVH¡TXHDFHLWRXVHDGRD§£RQ£RIRUVXMHLWDDHQFDUJRߢJULIDPRV
1£R GHYHPRV RXWURVVLP FRQIXQGLU HVWD PRGDOLGDGH GH DFHLWD§£R SUHVXPLGD GHFRUUHQWH GH XPD
DEVWHQ§£RGRGRQDW¡ULRVLOªQFLRFRPDKLS³WHVHHPTXHSRVWRQ£RKDMDH[SUHVVDPHQWHDTXLHVFLGRQHP
WHQKD VLGR HVWLSXODGR R SUD]R SDUD PDQLIHVWD§£R UHDOL]D R GRQDW¡ULR DWRV FRPSDWYHLV FRP D LGHLD GH
DFHLWDUSURYLGHQFLRXDOLPSH]DGREHPGRDGRSDJRXWULEXWRVUHIHUHQWHVDHOHUHDOL]RXRU§DPHQWRVSDUD
DVXDPHOKRULDHWFFDVRHPTXHHVWDUDPRVGLDQWHGHXPDPRGDOLGDGHGHDFHLWD§£RW¡FLWDSHUIHLWDPHQWH
SRVVYHOHPQRVVRVHQWLU
1HVVHPHVPRVHQWLGRREVHUYD'$5&<%(6621(
ߡ&XPSUHLQLFLDOPHQWHWHUVHHPYLVWDTXHRVLOªQFLRQ£RSRGHVHUFRQIXQGLGRFRPDPDQLIHVWD§£RW¡FLWDRXLPSOFLWD9LYDQWHDGYHUWHTXH
ߝDYR]GRVLOªQFLRFRPSUHHQGHRVLOªQFLRGHSDODYUDVHGHIDWRVLVWR©DLQD§£Rߞ$VVLPTXDQGR0DVV©GL]TXHTXHPJXDUGDVLOªQFLRQ£R
GL]Q£RPDVWDPE©PQ£RGL]VLPGHYHVHHQWHQGHUTXHDDEVWHQ§£RGHSDODYUDVGHYHVHUDFRPSDQKDGDGDDEVWHQ§£RGHDWRVRXIDWRV
SRUTXH GH RXWUR PRGR D PDQLIHVWD§£R W¡FLWD LVWR © D TXH VH LQIHULVVH GH DWRV RX IDWRV TXH Q£R FRPSRUWDVVHP RXWUD H[SOLFD§£R
FDUDFWHUL]DUVHLD (QW£R R VLOªQFLR VRPHQWH VH FRQILJXUD TXDQGR KDMD DEVWHQ§£R FRPSOHWD WDQWR GH SDODYUDV FRPR GH DWRV RX
IDWRVߢ
$VVLPVHQGRFKHJDPRV FRQFOXV£RGHTXHDDFHLWD§£RSRGHU¡VHUH[SUHVVDW¡FLWDRXSUHVXPLGDDUW
GR&&
1RWHVH HQWUHWDQWR TXH GH IRUPD H[FHSFLRQDO D OHL GLVSHQVD D FDSDFLGDGH GR DFHLWDQWH FRPR
UHTXLVLWRLQDIDVW¡YHOGHYDOLGDGH
6REUHDFDSDFLGDGHRDWRQHJRFLDOGHPDQGDSDUDVHUY¡OLGRDFRQFRUUªQFLDGHXPDJHQWHHPLVVRUGH
YRQWDGHFDSD]HOHJLWLPDGR'HVGHTXHVHMDSOHQDPHQWHFDSD]SRGHU¡DSHVVRDIVLFDRXMXUGLFDߚSDUD
HVWD ºOWLPD H[LJLQGRVH QDWXUDOPHQWH R UHJLVWUR GRV VHXV DWRV FRQVWLWXWLYRV ߚ SUDWLFDU DWRV H FHOHEUDU
QHJ³FLRVHPJHUDOQD³UELWDMXUGLFD
,QGLVFXWYHO©SRLVDQHFHVVLGDGHGHTXHRGRDGRUVHMDSHVVRDFDSD]Q£RREVWDQWHSRVVDPFRQFRUUHU
LPSHGLPHQWRV HVSHFILFRV HP GHWHUPLQDGDV VLWXD§µHV FDUDFWHUL]DQGR R TXH D GRXWULQD FKDPRX GH
LOHJLWLPLGDGH FRPR D KLS³WHVH GR VXMHLWR FDVDGR TXH PHVPR FDSD] SUHWHQGD GRDU XP EHP VXD
FRQFXELQD
$ OHL SHUPLWH HQWUHWDQWR HVSHFLILFDPHQWH QR TXH WDQJH DR GRQDW¡ULR TXH SRVVDP VHU EHQHILFLDGDV
SHVVRDVDEVROXWDPHQWHLQFDSD]HVDUWGR&&RXDW©PHVPRRSU³SULRQDVFLWXURDUWGR
&&RTXHUHIRU§DQHVWHºOWLPRFDVRDWHVHVXVWHQWDGDSHORVDGHSWRVGDWHRULDFRQFHSFLRQLVWDQR
VHQWLGRGHTXHRQDVFLWXURM¡VHULDFRQVLGHUDGRSHVVRDHQ£RPHURߡHQWHSRWHQFLDOߢFRPH[SHFWDWLYDGH
GLUHLWRV
&RQILUDPVHDSURS³VLWRRVPHQFLRQDGRVGLVSRVLWLYRV
ߡ$UW$GRD§£RIHLWDDRQDVFLWXURYDOHU¡VHQGRDFHLWDSHORVHXUHSUHVHQWDQWHOHJDO
$UW6HRGRQDW¡ULRIRUDEVROXWDPHQWHLQFDSD]GLVSHQVDVHDDFHLWD§£RGHVGHTXHVHWUDWHGHGRD§£RSXUDߢ
$ LGHLD GH GLVSHQVD GD DFHLWD§£R GR DEVROXWDPHQWH LQFDSD] © QD YHUGDGH D FRUUH§£R GH XPD
LPSURSULHGDGH W©FQLFD GR WH[WR HTXLYDOHQWH GR && TXH GL]LD TXH DV SHVVRDV TXH Q£R SXGHVVHP
FRQWUDWDU SRGHULDP Q£R REVWDQWH DFHLWDU GRD§µHV SXUDV (P YHUGDGH R TXH RFRUUH © XPD PRGDOLGDGH
HVSHFLDOGHDFHLWD§£RSUHVXPLGDXPDYH]TXHVHQGRDGRD§£RSXUDRXVHMDVHPTXDOTXHUHQFDUJRQ£R
K¡TXDOTXHUSUHMX]RSDUDRLQFDSD]
³EYLRTXHVHDGRD§£RLPSRUWDUHPTXDOTXHU´QXVDRGRQDW¡ULRLQFDSD]RGLVSRVLWLYROHJDOQ£R©
DSOLF¡YHOVHQGRDGRD§£RQXODGHSOHQRGLUHLWR
&ODUR HVW¡ HQWUHWDQWR TXH HP OLQKD GH UHJUD JHUDO QR FDVR GR DEVROXWDPHQWH LQFDSD] GHYHU¡ HVWDU
GHYLGDPHQWHUHSUHVHQWDGRSDUDDYDOLGDGHGRDWRGDGRD§£RRPHVPRYDOHQGRSDUDRQDVFLWXUR1HVWD
KLS³WHVHSRGHUVHLDIDODUWDPE©PHPFXUDWHOD TXDQGROKHIDOWDURVHXUHSUHVHQWDQWHOHJDO
$ UHVSHLWR GR QDVFLWXUR HQWUHWDQWR YDOH QRWDU TXH FDVR Q£R QDV§D FRP YLGD D HVWLSXOD§£R QHJRFLDO
TXHGDU¡SUHMXGLFDGDHVHPHIHLWRSHUPDQHFHQGRREHPQRSDWULP´QLRGRGRDGRU
3RU ILP DLQGD VREUH R WHPD GD DFHLWD§£R © LQWHUHVVDQWH GHVWDFDU DLQGD QHVWD OLQKD D LQGLFD§£R
GRXWULQ¡ULDHMXULVSUXGHQFLDOIHLWDSRU1(/6211(5<-5H526$0$5,$'($1'5$'(1(5<QR
VHQWLGR GH TXH D GRD§£R SRU UHSUHVHQWDQWH YROXQW¡ULR SURFXUDGRU VRPHQWH VHULD SRVVYHO FRP D
LQGLFD§£RH[SOFLWDGRGRQDW¡ULR
ߡ3DUD D YDOLGDGH GD HVFULWXUD GH GRD§£R UHDOL]DGD SRU SURFXUDGRU Q£R EDVWDP SRGHUHV SDUD D OLEHUDOLGDGH GH PRGR JHQ©ULFR
LQGLVSHQV¡YHODPHQ§£RGRGRQDW¡ULREHPFRPRRREMHWRUHVSHFWLYR1RPHVPRVHQWLGR5757ߢ
&RQFRUGDPRV FRP HVVH SHQVDPHQWR XPD YH] TXH UHIRU§D R SULQFSLR GD VHJXUDQ§D MXUGLFD QDV
UHOD§µHVQHJRFLDLVHYLWDQGRTXHEUDGDERDI©REMHWLYDSRUSDUWHGRPDQGDW¡ULR
'2$20257,6&$86$
'HOLFDGR SUREOHPD GL] UHVSHLWR DGPLVVLELOLGDGH GD GRD§£R PRUWLV FDXVD DTXHOD HP TXH R
GLVSRQHQWH SUHYª D WUDQVIHUªQFLD GH EHPQV GR VHX SDWULP´QLR D WWXOR JUDWXLWR SDUD GHSRLV GD VXD
PRUWH
$QDOLVDQGRGHWLGDPHQWHHVWDILJXUDVRPRVSRUVXDLQDGPLVVLELOLGDGH
,VVR SRUTXH VH DWHQWDUPRV SDUD R QRVVR VLVWHPD VXFHVV³ULR GH QRUPDV FRQFOXLUHPRV TXH SDUD R
DWHQGLPHQWRGHVWHWLSRGHGHVLGHUDWRROHJLVODGRUSUHYLXXPLQVWLWXWRMXUGLFRHVSHFILFRRWHVWDPHQWR
7UDWDVH SRLV HVWH ºOWLPR GH QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR XQLODWHUDO HVVHQFLDOPHQWH UHYRJ¡YHO H
HVSHFLDOPHQWH VROHQH SHOR TXDO R DXWRU GD KHUDQ§D WHVWDGRU GLVSµH DFHUFD GD WUDQVPLVVLELOLGDGH GRV
VHXVEHQVSDUDGHSRLVGDVXDPRUWH
3RGHU¡IXQGDPHQWDOPHQWHQDIRUPDGDOHLFLYLODGRWDUXPDGDVVHJXLQWHVIRUPDV
7HVWDPHQWRVRUGLQ¡ULRVDUWGR&&
,ߚRSºEOLFR
,,ߚRFHUUDGR
,,,ߚRSDUWLFXODU
7HVWDPHQWRVHVSHFLDLVDUWVHGR&&
,ߚRPDUWLPR
,,ߚRDHURQ¡XWLFR
,,,ߚRPLOLWDU
1RWHVHDGHPDLVTXHGRDUWDRDUWGHSDUDPRQRVFRPXPDH[DXVWLYDUHJXODPHQWD§£RGD
VXFHVV£R WHVWDPHQW¡ULD VREUHWXGR SRU PHLR GH QRUPDV FRJHQWHV H GH RUGHP SºEOLFD UHIHUHQWHV Q£R
DSHQDV HODERUD§£RFRPRWDPE©P H[HFX§£RGRWHVWDPHQWRWXGROHYDQGRDFUHUTXHHPQRVVR'LUHLWR
3RVLWLYRDWUDQVPLVVLELOLGDGHGRSDWULP´QLRSRVWPRUWHPVRPHQWHSRGHU¡VHGDUSRUHVWDYLDHPSUROGD
VHJXUDQ§DHGRUHVSHLWR ºOWLPDYRQWDGHGRWHVWDGRU
&RQFOXPRV SRLV SHOD LQDGPLVVLELOLGDGH GD GRD§£R SDUD GHSRLV GD PRUWH GR GRDGRU ILJXUD TXH
LQFOXVLYH FDUHFH GH SUHYLVLELOLGDGH OHJDO VHQGR R OHJDGR ߚ GLVSRVL§£R WHVWDPHQW¡ULD D WWXOR
VLQJXODU SHOD TXDO R WHVWDGRU GHL[D SHVVRD HVWUDQKD RX Q£R VXFHVV£R OHJWLPD XP RX PDLV REMHWRV
LQGLYLGXDOL]DGRVRXTXDQWLDHPSHFºQLDߚSUHYLVWRQRVDUWVDGR&&DILJXUDMXUGLFD
PDLVSU³[LPDGDQR§£RGHߡGRD§£RSRVWPRUWHPߢ
'2$2,12),&,26$
$GHQRPLQDGDGRD§£RLQRILFLRVD©DTXHODTXHWUDGX]YLROD§£RGDOHJWLPDGRVKHUGHLURVQHFHVV¡ULRV
3RU KHUGHLURV QHFHVV¡ULRV HQWHQGDVH DTXHOD FODVVH GH VXFHVVRUHV TXH WªP SRU IRU§D GH OHL GLUHLWR
SDUWHOHJWLPDGDKHUDQ§D
2TXHROHJLVODGRUSUHWHQGHXDRUHVJXDUGDURGLUHLWRGHVWDFDWHJRULDGHKHUGHLURVIRLSUHFLVDPHQWH
GDUOKHV FHUWR FRQIRUWR SDWULPRQLDO LPSHGLQGR TXH R DXWRU GD KHUDQ§D GLVSRQKD WRWDOPHQWH GR VHX
SDWULP´QLR
'H QRVVD SDUWH WHPRV VLQFHUDV GºYLGDV D UHVSHLWR GD HILF¡FLD VRFLDO H MXVWL§D GHVWD QRUPD
SUHVHUYDGRUD GD OHJWLPD D TXDO QD JUDQGH PDLRULD GDV YH]HV DFDED SRU LQFHQWLYDU LQWHUPLQ¡YHLV
EULJDVMXGLFLDLVTXDQGRQ£RDSU³SULDGLVF³UGLDRXDW©PHVPRDLQGROªQFLD3RGHULDWDOYH]ROHJLVODGRU
UHVJXDUGDUDQHFHVVLGDGHGDSUHVHUYD§£RGDOHJWLPDDSHQDVHQTXDQWRRVKHUGHLURVIRVVHPPHQRUHVRX
FDVRSDGHFHVVHPGHDOJXPDFDXVDGHLQFDSDFLGDGHVLWXD§µHVTXHMXVWLILFDULDPDUHVWUL§£R IDFXOGDGHGH
GLVSRVL§£RGRDXWRUGDKHUDQ§D0DVHVWHQGHUDSURWH§£RSDWULPRQLDODSHVVRDVPDLRUHVHFDSD]HVHP
QRVVRVHQWLU©GHPDLV
'HTXDOTXHUIRUPDRQRVVR'LUHLWR3RVLWLYRPDQWHYHDSUHVHUYD§£RGDOHJWLPDFLUFXQVW¢QFLDTXHVH
UHIOHWH QR ¢PELWR GR 'LUHLWR &RQWUDWXDO HVSHFLDOPHQWH QD GRD§£R FRQVRDQWH SRGHPRV REVHUYDU GD
DQ¡OLVHGRVDUWVHGR&³GLJR&LYLO
ߡ$UW$GRD§£RGHDVFHQGHQWHVDGHVFHQGHQWHVRXGHXPF´QMXJHDRXWURLPSRUWDDGLDQWDPHQWRGRTXHOKHVFDEHSRUKHUDQ§D
$UW 1XOD © WDPE©P D GRD§£R TXDQWR SDUWH TXH H[FHGHU GH TXH R GRDGRU QR PRPHQWR GD OLEHUDOLGDGH SRGHULD GLVSRU HP
WHVWDPHQWRߢ
2TXHROHJLVODGRUTXHULPSHGLU©SRLVTXHRGRDGRUGLVSRQKDJUDWXLWDPHQWHGHPDLVGDPHWDGHGD
VXD KHUDQ§D FRP YLROD§£R GD OHJWLPD GRV KHUGHLURV QHFHVV¡ULRV $ FRQWUDULR VHQVX VH R DWR GH
OLEHUDOLGDGH Q£R DWLQJLU R GLUHLWR GHVWD FDWHJRULD GH KHUGHLURV VHU¡ UHSXWDGR Y¡OLGR 9DOH OHPEUDU
LQFOXVLYH TXH SDUD HIHLWR GHVWH F¡OFXOR GHYHU¡ VH FRQVLGHUDU R YDORU GR SDWULP´QLR GR GLVSRQHQWH
TXDQGRGDDOLHQD§£R
3DUDIDFLOLWDURHQWHQGLPHQWRGRQRVVRHVWLPDGROHLWRUXPH[HPSORLU¡LOXVWUDUDKLS³WHVH
,PDJLQHPRVTXH&ODXGLR$GULDQRVHMDWLWXODUGHXPSDWULP´QLRDYDOLDGRHPUHDLV9LºYRWHP
WUªV ILOKRV +XJXLQKR =H]LQKR H /XL]LQKR 7RGRV FRPR VDEHPRV KHUGHLURV QHFHVV¡ULRV 3RLV EHP
,PDJLQHPRV TXH &ODXGLR UHVROYD GRDU GR VHX SDWULP´QLR SDUD XP WHUFHLUR 1£R KDYHULD
SUREOHPD SRLV HVWD TXRWD VDLULD GD VXD SDUWH GLVSRQYHO 1D PHVPD OLQKD SRGHULD WDPE©P GRDU HVWH
YDORU SDUD XP GRV KHUGHLURV QHFHVV¡ULRV R TXDO LQFOXVLYH SRGHULD M¡ UHFHEHU D WWXOR GH
DGLDQWDPHQWR D VXD SDUWH QD OHJWLPD 2 TXH R WHVWDGRU Q£R SRGHULD VHULD GRDU D SDUWH
GLVSRQYHO XPD TXRWD TXH XOWUDSDVVDVVH RV FRUUHVSRQGHQWHV OHJWLPD GRV RXWURV
KHUGHLURVQHFHVV¡ULRV
6HLVVRRFRUUHVVHDGRD§£RQRTXHFRQFHUQHDHVVHH[FHVVRVHULDFRQVLGHUDGDQXODDWHRUGRDUW
GR&³GLJR&LYLO
,PSRUWDQWH DVSHFWR D VHU FRQVLGHUDGR GL] UHVSHLWR QDWXUH]D GHVWD LQYDOLGDGH R DWR VHULD UHSXWDGR
QXORQXOLGDGHDEVROXWDRXDQXO¡YHOQXOLGDGHUHODWLYD"
-XULVSUXGªQFLDDQWHULRU HQWUDGDHPYLJRUGR&³GLJR&LYLOGHDWULEXDDQDWXUH]DDQXODW³ULDDR
DWRDGPLWLQGRSUD]RGHYLQWHDQRVSDUDRH[HUFFLRGDD§£RMXGLFLDOFRUUHVSRQGHQWH
1HVVHVHQWLGRFRQILUDVHRVHJXLQWHDF³UG£RGR6XSHULRU7ULEXQDOGH-XVWL§DGDODYUDGR0LQ58<
526$'2'($*8,$5-5
ߡ9(1'$'($6&(1'(17(3$5$'(6&(1'(17(,QWHUSRVWDSHVVRD$QXOD§£R3UHVFUL§£R'DWDLQLFLDO'RD§£RLQRILFLRVDߚ$
SUHVFUL§£RGDD§£RGHDQXOD§£RGHYHQGDGHDVFHQGHQWHSDUDGHVFHQGHQWHSRULQWHUSRVWDSHVVRD©GHTXDWURDQRVHFRUUHDSDUWLUGDGDWD
GD DEHUWXUD GD VXFHVV£R 'LIHUHQWHPHQWH D SUHVFUL§£R GD D§£R GH QXOLGDGH SHOD YHQGD GLUHWD GH DVFHQGHQWH D GHVFHQGHQWH VHP R
FRQVHQWLPHQWRGRVGHPDLV©GHYLQWHDQRVHIOXLGHVGHDGDWDGRDWRGHDOLHQD§£Rߚ$SUHVFUL§£RGDD§£R GHDQXOD§£RGHGRD§£R
LQRILFLRVD©GHYLQWHDQRVFRUUHQGRRSUD]RGDGDWDGDSU¡WLFDGRDWRGHDOLHQD§£R$UWVHGR&&LYLO3ULPHLUR
UHFXUVR Q£R FRQKHFLGR FRQKHFLPHQWR SDUFLDO GR VHJXQGR H VHX SURYLPHQWR WDPE©P SDUFLDOߢ 67- 5HFXUVR (VSHFLDO
5HO0LQ5X\5RVDGRGH$JXLDUGDWDGDGHFLV£Rk7XUPD
9ªVH SRUWDQWR TXH R QRUWH MXULVSUXGHQFLDO ILUPDGR DQWHV GD HQWUDGD HP YLJRU GR &³GLJR &LYLO GH
HUDQRVHQWLGRGHFRQVLGHUDUGHQDWXUH]DDQXODW³ULDHFRPSUD]RGHYLQWHDQRVDFRQWDUGRDWRGH
GRD§£RDD§£RMXGLFLDOGHLQYDOLGDGHGDGRD§£RLQRILFLRVD
2UDPHVPRVHSHUVLVWLUHVWHSRVLFLRQDPHQWRIRU§RVRVHU¡FRQFOXLUTXHRSUD]RGDDQXODW³ULDWHULDVLGR
UHGX]LGRSDUDGRLVDQRVDWHRUGRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLO
ߡ$UW 4XDQGR D OHL GLVSXVHU TXH GHWHUPLQDGR DWR © DQXO¡YHO VHP HVWDEHOHFHU SUD]R SDUD SOHLWHDUVH D DQXOD§£R VHU¡ HVWH GH GRLV
DQRVDFRQWDUGDGDWDGDFRQFOXV£RGRDWRߢ
7HPRVHQWUHWDQWRDOJXPDVGºYLGDVDUHVSHLWRGDQDWXUH]DDQXODW³ULDGHVWHSUD]R
,VVR SRUTXH D SDU GH DV UHJUDV SUHVHUYDGRUDV GD OHJWLPD WHUHP QDWXUH]D SºEOLFD H FRJHQWH
LQGLVFXWYHO R IDWR © TXH R &³GLJR &LYLO DR UHIHULU D H[SUHVV£R ߡ© QXORߢ FXOPLQD SRU UHPHWHU R
LQW©USUHWH LQDIDVW¡YHOFRQFOXV£RGHTXHVHWUDWDGHQXOLGDGHDEVROXWDHQ£RPHUDDQXODELOLGDGH
$OL¡V XP SRQWR GLJQR GH HORJLR QR QRYR GLSORPD © H[DWDPHQWH HVWH FXLGDU GH WUD§DU XPD GLDJQRVH
OLQJXVWLFDGLIHUHQFLDOPDLVQWLGDHQWUHRVLQVWLWXWRVMXUGLFRVGDQXOLGDGHHGDDQXODELOLGDGH
1RWHVH SRUWDQWR TXH TXDQGR R OHJLVODGRU TXLV PHQFLRQDU D KLS³WHVH GH DQXODELOLGDGH WUDWRX GH VHU
H[SOFLWR FRPR © R FDVR SRU H[HPSOR GDV UHJUDV GRV DUWV H DRV
TXDLVUHPHWHPRVROHLWRU
(FRPRVHVDEHQ£RKDYHQGRSUD]RGHFDGHQFLDOHVSHFILFRGHDQXODELOLGDGHHVWHVHU¡GHGRLVDQRVD
WHRUGRDUW
7DLVDUJXPHQWRVSRUWDQWRVHULDPVXILFLHQWHVHPQRVVRVHQWLUSDUDFKHJDUPRV LQDIDVW¡YHOFRQFOXV£R
GHTXHDGRD§£RLQRILFLRVDSRUWUDGX]LUDIURQWDDQRUPDVGHRUGHPSºEOLFDHVHJXQGRDVQRUPDVOHJDLV
GRSU³SULR&³GLJR&LYLO©QXODGHSOHQRGLUHLWR
0DV D HVWH DUJXPHQWR SRGHUVHLD FRQWUDSRU RXWUR SRU VHU LPSUHVFULWYHO D DUJXL§£R GD QXOLGDGH
DEVROXWDLVVRQ£RJHUDULDLQVHJXUDQ§DMXUGLFDDQWHDSRVVLELOLGDGHGHVHSRGHUDWDFDURDWRDTXDOTXHU
WHPSR"
'HIDWRRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLOGLVSµHTXHRDWRQXORQ£RFRQYDOHVFHSHORGHFXUVRGRWHPSR
0DVRVHIHLWRVSDWULPRQLDLVGHFRUUHQWHVGDGHFODUD§£RGHLQYDOLGDGHVLPSRGHPSUHVFUHYHU
$GHFODUD§£RGHQXOLGDGHDEVROXWDGDGRD§£RLQRILFLRVDDWHRUGHVWHPHQFLRQDGRGLVSRVLWLYRGHOHL
Q£RVHVXEPHWHDSUD]RDOJXPHPERUDRSHGLGRGLULJLGR UHLYLQGLFD§£RGDFRLVDSUHWHQV£RGHQDWXUH]D
UHDO RX R SDJDPHQWR GDV SHUGDV H GDQRV SUHWHQV£R GH QDWXUH]D SHVVRDO IRUPXODGR SHOR KHUGHLUR
SUHMXGLFDGRVXEPHWHVHDRSUD]RSUHVFULFLRQDOJHUDOSDUDSUHWHQVµHVSHVVRDLVRXUHDLVGHGH]DQRVQD
IRUPDGRDUWGR&&
'LDQWHGHWRGRRH[SRVWRHSRULQH[LVWLUMXULVSUXGªQFLDPDFL§DQRV7ULEXQDLV6XSHULRUHVDUHVSHLWRGR
WHPD OX]GR&³GLJR&LYLOGXDVFRUUHQWHVGHSHQVDPHQWRSRGHU£RVHUIRUPDGDV
D D TXH FRQVLGHUD D GRD§£R LQRILFLRVD XPQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRDQXO¡YHO H FXMR SUD]R GHFDGHQFLDO SDUD D D§£R FRUUHVSRQGHQWH VHULD GH GRLV
DQRVDUW
EDTXHFRQVLGHUDDGRD§£RLQRILFLRVDQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRQXORVHQGRLPSUHVFULWYHORSHGLGRGHFODUDW³ULRGDQXOLGDGHHPVLHSUHVFULWYHOHP
GH]DQRVDSUHWHQV£RUHDOGHUHLYLQGLFD§£RGREHPGRDGRRXDSUHWHQV£RSHVVRDOGHSHUGDVHGDQRV
(PQRVVRVHQWLUK¡GHSUHYDOHFHUDVHJXQGDOLQKDGHSHQVDPHQWR
'2$281,9(56$/
2XWUD IRUPD GH GRD§£R SURLELGD HP QRVVR VLVWHPD © D GHQRPLQDGD GRD§£R XQLYHUVDO DTXHOD TXH
FRPSUHHQGHWRGRRSDWULP´QLRGRGRDGRUVHPUHVHUYDPQLPDGHSDUWHSDUDDVXDPDQWHQ§D
1HVVHVHQWLGRGLVSµHRDUWGRQRVVR&³GLJR&LYLO
ߡ$UWQXODDGRD§£RGHWRGRVRVEHQVVHPUHVHUYDGHSDUWHRXUHQGDVXILFLHQWHSDUDDVXEVLVWªQFLDGRGRDGRUߢ
&XLGDVH HP QRVVR VHQWLU GH LQHTXYRFD KLS³WHVH GH QXOLGDGH DEVROXWD SRU WUDGX]LU YLROD§£R GH
SUHFHLWRFRJHQWHGHRUGHPSºEOLFDTXHYLVDDUHVJXDUGDUUHQGLPHQWRPQLPRSDUDDH[LVWªQFLDGLJQDGR
GRDGRU
(YLWDPRV LQFOXVLYH HPSUHJDU R WHUPR ߡVXEVLVWªQFLDߢ HP VHX VHQWLGR OLWHUDO XPD YH] TXH HVVH
GLVSRVLWLYRGHYHVHULQWHUSUHWDGRFRQMXQWDPHQWHFRPRFRPDQGRFRQVWLWXFLRQDOTXHSUHYªDGLJQLGDGHGD
SHVVRDKXPDQDFRPRXPGRVYDORUHVIXQGDPHQWDLVQR(VWDGR'HPRFU¡WLFRGH'LUHLWR
(VHPGºYLGDߡYLYHUGLJQDPHQWH©PXLWRPDLVGRTXHVLPSOHVPHQWHVXEVLVWLUߢ
6REUH D GLJQLGDGH GD SHVVRD KXPDQD SULQFSLR IXQGDPHQWDO WDQWDV YH]HV UHIHULGR QHVWD REUD
OHPEUHPRQRVGDVEULOKDQWHVSDODYUDVGH&$127,/+2
ߡ3HUDQWH DV H[SHULªQFLDV KLVW³ULFDV GD DQLTXLOD§£R GR VHU KXPDQR LQTXLVL§£R HVFUDYDWXUD QD]LVPR VWDOLQLVPR SROSRWLVPR JHQRFGLRV
©WQLFRVDGLJQLGDGHGDSHVVRDKXPDQDFRPREDVHGDUHSºEOLFDVLJQLILFDVHPWUDQVFHQGªQFLDVRXPHWDIVLFDVRUHFRQKHFLPHQWRGRKRPR
QRXPHQRQ RX VHMD GR LQGLYGXR FRPR OLPLWH H IXQGDPHQWR GR GRPQLR SROWLFR GD 5HSºEOLFD 1HVWH VHQWLGR D 5HSºEOLFD © XPD
RUJDQL]D§£RSROWLFDTXHVHUYHRKRPHPQ£R©RKRPHPTXHVHUYHRVDSDUHOKRVSROWLFRRUJDQL]DW³ULRVߢ
(PYHUGDGHDSUHRFXSD§£RGROHJLVODGRU©H[WUHPDPHQWHMXVWLILF¡YHO6HSHUPLWLGRIRVVHDGRD§£RGH
WRGR R SDWULP´QLR GR GLVSRQHQWH HVWDUVHLD DLQGD TXH SRU YLD REOTXD RSRUWXQL]DQGRVH TXH HVWH
PHVPR GRDGRU SRVWHULRUPHQWH SXGHVVH EDWHU V SRUWDV GH XP SDUHQWH YLD D§£R GH DOLPHQWRV RX GR
SU³SULR(VWDGRSRUPHLRGRVLVWHPDGH6HJXULGDGH6RFLDO
*DUDQWHVHDVVLPDSURWH§£RDXPSDWULP´QLRPQLPRGRLQGLYGXRFRPRXPDWXWHODLQGLVSHQV¡YHOD
XPDYLGDGLJQDGDTXDOQ£RSRGHU¡DEULUP£RHPKLS³WHVHDOJXPD
3RGHU¡ HQWUHWDQWR R MXL] OX] GR SULQFSLR GD FRQVHUYD§£R GRV QHJ³FLRV MXUGLFRV UHFRQKHFHU D
QXOLGDGH PHUDPHQWH SDUFLDO GD GRD§£R SDUD FRQVHUY¡OD QR TXH WDQJH DR TXDQWXP H[FHGHQWH GR
UHQGLPHQWRE¡VLFRQHFHVV¡ULR PDQWHQ§DGRGRDGRU$GPLWHVHSRUWDQWRHPQRVVRVHQWLUTXHVHRSHUHD
UHGX§£RGDOLEHUDOLGDGHFRPRRFRUUHQDGRD§£RLQRILFLRVDSDUDTXHVHSRVVDSUHVHUYDUDYLGDGLJQDGR
GRDGRU
2EYLDPHQWHDUHVWUL§£R GRD§£RVHDIHUHQRPRPHQWRGDVXDFHOHEUD§£RQ£RKDYHQGRTXHIDODUHP
QXOLGDGHGHGRD§£RVHSRVWHULRUPHQWHVHPQHQKXPDYLQFXOD§£RGLUHWDFRPRUHIHULGRFRQWUDWRYHPR
GRDGRUDFDLUQDSHQºULD
1£R©GHPDLVOHPEUDUQHVVHSRQWRTXHFDVRRGRDGRUWHQKDKHUGHLURVQHFHVV¡ULRVGHYHU¡VHVXMHLWDU
UHVWUL§£RGRDUWDFLPDDQDOLVDGR
3520(66$'('2$23$&780'('21$1'2
(QIUHQWDUHPRVDTXLXPGRVPDLVWRUPHQWRVRVHLQWHUHVVDQWHVSUREOHPDVUHIHUHQWHV GRD§£R3RGHULD
HVWHFRQWUDWRVHUREMHWRGHXPDSURPHVVD"
$ SURPHVVD GH FRQWUDWR WDPE©P GHQRPLQDGD SU©FRQWUDWR RX FRQWUDWR SUHOLPLQDU © DTXHOH QHJ³FLR
MXUGLFR TXH WHP SRU REMHWR D REULJD§£R GH ID]HU XP FRQWUDWR GHILQLWLYR 2 H[HPSOR PDLV FRPXP © R
FRPSURPLVVRGHYHQGDRTXDOFRPRVHVDEHSRGHLQFOXVLYHJHUDUGLUHLWRUHDO
1R FDVR GD GRD§£R HQWUHWDQWR D VLWXD§£R DILJXUDVH PDLV GHOLFDGD XPD YH] TXH WUDWDQGRVH GH XP
FRQWUDWRHPJHUDOJUDWXLWRGRD§£RSXUDSRVWRVHPSUHXQLODWHUDOTXDQWRDRVHIHLWRVRUHFRQKHFLPHQWR
GDYDOLGDGHHHILF¡FLDMXUGLFDGDSURPHVVDIDULDFRPTXHRGRQDW¡ULRߚVLPSOHVEHQHILFL¡ULRGRDWRߚ
SXGHVVH LQJUHVVDU FRP D H[HFX§£R HVSHFILFD GR FRQWUDWR IRU§DQGR R GRDGRU D FXPSULU FRP R DWR GH
OLEHUDOLGDGHDTXHVHREULJDUD
2YFLRGHIRUPDVHU¡VDQDGRSHODH[HFX§£RGDSUHVWD§£RSURPHWLGD
1£R KDYHQGR HQWUHWDQWR HP QRVVR 'LUHLWR 3RVLWLYR UHJUD VHPHOKDQWH D GRXWULQD H D MXULVSUXGªQFLD
FRQWURYHUWHPVHDUHVSHLWR
$QDOLVDQGRRSUREOHPD&$,205,2'$6,/9$3(5(,5$SRQGHUD
ߡ7HPDGRXWULQDVHGHEDWLGRVHDGRD§£RSRGHVHUREMHWRGHFRQWUDWRSUHOLPLQDUSDFWXPGHGRQDQGR(DVROX§£RGRXWULQ¡ULDWHPVLGR
LQIHOL] SRU IDOWD GH XPD GLVWLQ§£R HVVHQFLDO HQWUH GRD§£R SXUD H GRD§£R JUDYDGD GH HQFDUJR 3DUWLQGR GD SULPHLUD HVSHFLILFDVH D
SHUJXQWDSRGHDOJX©PREULJDUVHDUHDOL]DUXPDGRD§£RSXUD")RUPDOPHQWHVLPSRUTXHWHQGRRFRQWUDWRSUHOLPLQDUSRUREMHWRXPRXWUR
FRQWUDWRIXWXURHGHILQLWLYRYQVXSUDHVWHQRYRFRQWUDKHUH SRGHULD VHU D GRD§£R FRPR TXDOTXHU RXWUD HVS©FLH $WHQGHQGR D
HVWHDVSHFWRDSHQDVQ£RIDOWDERPDSRLR UHVSRVWDDILUPDWLYDTXHUGRV&³GLJRVTXHUGRVGRXWRUHV$FRQWHFHTXHQ£RVHSRGHGHL[DUGH
HQFDUDURSUREOHPDVRERDVSHFWRRQWRO³JLFRHDVVLPFRQVLGHUDGRDVROX§£RQHJDWLYDLPSµHVHߢ
'HIDWRD ODWHUH D GRD§£R JUDYDGD FRP HQFDUJR ߚ ILJXUD MXUGLFD SHUIHLWDPHQWH FRPSDWYHO FRP D
SURPHVVDSHODVXDRQHURVLGDGHLQWUQVHFDߚDGRD§£RSXUDSRUVHXWXUQRVHDQDOLVDGDLQFOXVLYHHPVHX
DVSHFWRWHOHRO³JLFRQ£RVHFRPSDWLELOL]DULDW£REHPFRPDLGHLDGHXPDH[HFX§£RIRU§DGDSHORVLPSOHV
IDWRGHRSURPLWHQWHGRQDW¡ULRHVWDUFRQVWUDQJHQGRDRXWUDSDUWHSURPLWHQWHGRDGRUDRFXPSULPHQWRGH
XPDWRGHVLPSOHVOLEHUDOLGDGHHPIDFHGRTXDOLQH[LVWLXFRQWUDSDUWLGDSUHVWDFLRQDO
&ODUR HVW¡ HQWUHWDQWR TXH PXLWDV YH]HV R GRDGRU Q£R DWXD VRPHQWH FRP R DQLPXV GRQDQGL PDV
WDPE©P LPSXOVLRQDGR SRU RXWURV VHQWLPHQWRV FRPR DW© PHVPR R GHVHMR GH UHVJDWDU XPD GYLGD GH
KRQUDRXUHFRQKHFHURP©ULWRGRGRQDW¡ULR
1RGL]HUGH/8,6'(=3,&$=2H$1721,2*8//1FLWDGRVSRU$1$35$7$HPPRQXPHQWDO
REUDGR'LUHLWR3RUWXJXªV
ߡD GRD§£R SRGH ID]HUVH SRU JHQHURVLGDGH SRU FDULGDGH SRU YDLGDGH SRU VLPSOHV SRPSD SRU FXOWLYDU R TXH KRMH VH FKDPD XPD
GHWHUPLQDGDLPDJHPSDUDRH[WHULRURXSRUTXDOTXHURXWUDFDXVDߢ
1HVVH GLDSDV£R FRQFOXPRV SHOD LQDGPLVVLELOLGDGH GD H[HFX§£R FRDWLYD GD SURPHVVD GH GRD§£R
PXLWRHPERUDQ£RQHJXHPRVDSRVVLELOLGDGHGHRSURPLWHQWHGRQDW¡ULRSULYDGRGDOHJWLPDH[SHFWDWLYD
GHFRQFUHWL]D§£RGRFRQWUDWRGHILQLWLYRHGHVGHTXHGHPRQVWUDGRRVHXSUHMX]RSRVVDUHVSRQVDELOL]DUR
SURPLWHQWHGRDGRUSHODYLDGDD§£RRUGLQ¡ULDGHSHUGDVHGDQRV
1HVVHVHQWLGR©DFRQFOXV£RGH$1$35$7$
ߡ(OLPLQDQGR GR UHJLPH GD SURPHVVD GH GRD§£R D WXWHOD REULJDFLRQDO GD H[HFX§£R HVSHFILFD HVW¡VH DILQDO D FDUDFWHUL]DU WDO FRQWUDWR
SURPHVVDFRPRLQWHJUDQGRDTXHODFDWHJRULDGHSURPHVVDVSUHF¡ULDVFXMRFXPSULPHQWRVHUHVROYHIRU§RVDPHQWHQDLQGHQL]D§£Rߢ
2XWURQ£R©DOL¡VRSHQVDPHQWRGH6/9,29(126$
ߡ&DVRVHWRUQHLPSRVVYHODHQWUHJDGDFRLVDSRUFXOSDGRSURPLWHQWHGRDGRURRXWRUJDGRWHPD§£RGHLQGHQL]D§£RSRULQDGLPSOHPHQWR
'HVWDUWHDGPLWLGDDWHRULDGRSU©FRQWUDWRQRRUGHQDPHQWRSDUDRVSDFWRVHPJHUDOQ£RH[LVWHHPWHVHREVW¡FXORSDUDDSURPHVVDGH
GRDUߢ
1RWHVHHQWUHWDQWRTXHSDUDH[LVWLUHVWDFRQVHTXHQWHREULJD§£RGHLQGHQL]DUGHYHU£RHVWDUSUHVHQWHV
RVSUHVVXSRVWRVJHUDLVGDUHVSRQVDELOLGDGHFLYLO
(63&,(6'('2$2
$O©P GDV PRGDOLGDGHV HVSHFLDLV M¡ YLVWDV QR GHFRUUHU GHVWH FDSWXOR © PXLWR FRPXP HP GRXWULQD
DSUHVHQWDUGLYHUVDVFODVVLILFD§µHVGRFRQWUDWRGHGRD§£R
$TXLHOHQFDUHPRVDVPDLVFRPXQV
'RD§£RSXUDGRD§£RFRPIDWRUHVHILFDFLDLV
$SULPHLUDPRGDOLGDGH©DGRD§£RSXUDDTXLDOJXPDVYH]HVM¡PHQFLRQDGDTXH©DTXHODTXHVHWUDGX]
VLPSOHVPHQWHHPXPDOLEHUDOLGDGHVHPIL[D§£RGHTXDOTXHUIDWRUHILFDFLDOFRQGL§£RWHUPRRXHQFDUJR
$RODGRGHODSRGHPRVOHPEUDUGHPRGDOLGDGHVGHGRD§£RHPTXHWHQKDVLGRHVWLSXODGRXPGHVVHV
IDWRUHVOLPLWDQGRDSURGX§£RGHVHXVHIHLWRV
RFDVR GDGRD§£R FRQGLFLRQDOH GDGRD§£R D WHUPR FXMDV GHQRPLQD§µHV V£R DXWRH[SOLFDWLYDV 'H
IDWRQRSULPHLURFDVR©HVWLSXODGDXPDFRQGL§£RHYHQWRIXWXURHLQFHUWRDRQHJ³FLRHQRVHJXQGR©
HVWDEHOHFLGR XPWHUPR HYHQWR IXWXUR H FHUWR TXHGHOLPLWD XPSUD]RILQGRR TXDOR GRQDW¡ULR SDVVDD
H[HUFHURGRPQLRVREUHDFRLVDDOLHQDGD
'HQWUR GD LPHQVD JDPD GH VLWXD§µHV HP TXH SRGH VHU HQTXDGUDGD D GRD§£R FRQGLFLRQDO WHPRV D
GRD§£R D HQWLGDGH D VH FRQVWLWXLU HYHQWR IXWXUR H LQFHUWR TXDQWR HIHWLYD RFRUUªQFLD SDUD R TXDO R
&³GLJR &LYLO GH WURX[H GLVFLSOLQD HVSHFILFD HVWDEHOHFHQGR XP SUD]R GHFDGHQFLDO SDUD VXD
FRQVWLWXL§£RVRESHQDGHLQYDOLGDGHGDGRD§£R
DSUHYLV£RGRDUWGR&&TXHSUHFHLWXD
ߡ$UW$GRD§£RDHQWLGDGHIXWXUDFDGXFDU¡VHHPGRLVDQRVHVWDQ£RHVWLYHUFRQVWLWXGDUHJXODUPHQWHߢ
-¡DGRD§£RPRGDORQHURVDRXFRPHQFDUJRFRPRRSU³SULRQRPHLQGLFDWUDWDVHGHGRD§£RJUDYDGD
FRPXP´QXVH[REULJRPHDGRDUOKHXPDID]HQGDLPSRQGROKHRHQFDUJRGHYRFªSDJDUXPDSHQV£R
GHPHLRVDO¡ULRPQLPR PLQKDWLDLGRVD
6XDSUHYLV£R©IHLWDQRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLOGH
ߡ$UW2GRQDW¡ULR©REULJDGRDFXPSULURVHQFDUJRVGDGRD§£RFDVRIRUHPDEHQHIFLRGRGRDGRUGHWHUFHLURRXGRLQWHUHVVHJHUDO
3DU¡JUDIRºQLFR6HGHVWDºOWLPDHVS©FLHIRURHQFDUJRR0LQLVW©ULR3ºEOLFRSRGHU¡H[LJLUVXDH[HFX§£RGHSRLVGDPRUWHGRGRDGRUVH
HVWHQ£RWLYHUIHLWRߢ
SUHFLVRVDOLHQWDUVHPSUHTXHRHQFDUJRQ£R©XPDFRQWUDSUHVWD§£RVHQGRSURSRUFLRQDOPHQWHPXLWR
PHQRV H[WHQVR GR TXH R EHQHIFLR UHFHELGR ,VVR SRUTXH VH R HQFDUJR IRU PXLWR SHVDGR SRGH
GHVFDUDFWHUL]DU D GRD§£R WUDQVIRUPDQGRD SRU H[HPSOR HP XPD FRPSUD H YHQGD GLVIDU§DGD
'HVFXPSULGR R HQFDUJR R VHX EHQHILFL¡ULR SRGHU¡ H[LJLU D VXD H[HFX§£R MXGLFLDO VHQGR TXH VH R
EHQHILFL¡ULR IRUD FROHWLYLGDGH HVW¡R 0LQLVW©ULR 3ºEOLFROHJLWLPDGR D H[LJLU WDOH[HFX§£R5HVVDOWHVH
TXH FRPR YHUHPRV DO©P GHVVD FRQVHTXªQFLD H[HFX§£R FRHUFLWLYD VH KRXYHU GHVFXPSULPHQWR GR
HQFDUJRSRGHU¡RGRDGRUDW©PHVPRUHYRJDUDGRD§£R
'RD§£RFRQWHPSODWLYDGRD§£RUHPXQHUDW³ULD
2XWUDHVS©FLHGHGRD§£RH[SUHVVDPHQWHPHQFLRQDGDWDQWRQDFRGLILFD§£RYLJHQWHTXDQWRQDUHYRJDGD
© D GRD§£RFRQWHPSODWLYD 7UDWDVH GH XPD PRGDOLGDGH HP TXH R GRDGRU GHFOLQD RX LQGLFD DV UD]µHV
PRWLYRV TXH R OHYDUDP D ID]HU D GRD§£R H[ GRDUHL UHDLV D 3HGUR SHOR VHX HVSULWR GH
EHQHILFªQFLDDOWUXVPRHFRPSUHHQV£R(PJHUDO©HVS©FLHGHGRD§£RSXUD
LPSRUWDQWH SHUFHEHU TXH D GRD§£R FRQWHPSODWLYD Q£R VH FRQIXQGH FRP D GHFODUD§£R XQLODWHUDO GH
YRQWDGHXPDYH]TXHDTXHOD©XPDUHOD§£RMXUGLFDQHJRFLDOFRPFRQFXUVRGHYRQWDGHVGRDUHDFHLWDUD
GRD§£R HQTXDQWR HVWD © XPD PDQLIHVWD§£R YROLWLYD XQLODWHUDO TXH REULJD DSHQDV R GHFODUDQWH
FRQVWLWXLQGRVHHPIRQWHGHREULJD§µHV
(TXLSDUDGD GRD§£RFRQWHPSODWLYDSHORPHQRVSDUDRWH[WRFRGLILFDGRHVW¡DGRD§£RUHPXQHUDW³ULD
TXH©DTXHODIHLWDHPUHWULEXL§£RDVHUYL§RVSUHVWDGRVSHORGRQDW¡ULRRFDVRGRP©GLFRGDIDPOLDTXH
VHUYLXDRGRDGRUFRPGHGLFD§£RGXUDQWHWRGDDYLGDVHPFREUDUQDGDSRULVVR&ODURHVW¡HQWUHWDQWR
TXH HVWD GRD§£R Q£R FRQVLVWH WHFQLFDPHQWH HP SDJDPHQWR PDV VLP W£R VRPHQWH HP XP MXVWR
UHFRQKHFLPHQWRGRGRDGRUSHORVIDYRUHVUHFHELGRV
6£RHODVSUHYLVWDVQRDUWGR&&TXHSUHFHLWXDLQYHUELV
ߡ$UW$GRD§£RIHLWDHPFRQWHPSOD§£RGRPHUHFLPHQWRGRGRQDW¡ULRQ£RSHUGHRFDU¡WHUGHOLEHUDOLGDGHFRPRQ£RRSHUGHDGRD§£R
UHPXQHUDW³ULDRXDJUDYDGDQRH[FHGHQWHDRYDORUGRVVHUYL§RVUHPXQHUDGRVRXDRHQFDUJRLPSRVWRߢ
6REUHRWHPDYDOHDOL§£RGH3$8/2/8,=1(772/%2
ߡ$GRD§£RUHPXQHUDW³ULDSUHYLVWDQRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLOFRQMXJDOLEHUDOLGDGHHUHPXQHUD§£RSRUVHUYL§RVSUHVWDGRVSHORGRQDW¡ULR
DR GRDGRU 7HP R SURS³VLWR GH UHFRPSHQVDU VHUYL§RV JUDWXLWRV UHFHELGRV $ UD]£R SU¡WLFD GR UHFXUVR GRD§£R UHPXQHUDW³ULD © D GH
WRUQDULQGLVFXWYHOQRWHPSRDDWULEXL§£RSDWULPRQLDOIXQGDGDQDJUDWLG£R$GRD§£RUHPXQHUDW³ULDQ£RVHFRQIXQGHFRPDGLPSOHPHQWRGH
REULJD§£RQHPFRPGD§£RHPSDJDPHQWRTXH©DVXEVWLWXL§£RGDFRLVDGHYLGDSRURXWUD2SDJDPHQWRRXDGLPSOHPHQWRGHREULJD§£R©
LQFRPSDWYHOFRPDFDXVDGRQDQGLHPRXWUDVSDODYUDVVHK¡QHJ³FLRMXUGLFRQ£RVHSRGHVROYHUDREULJD§£RPHGLDQWHGRD§£R
1DGRD§£RUHPXQHUDW³ULDQ£RK¡GHYHUMXUGLFRH[LJYHOSHORGRQDW¡ULRPDVRGRDGRUVHQWHVHQRGHYHUPRUDOGHUHPXQHU¡ORHPYLUWXGH
GDSUHVWD§£RGHDOJXPVHUYL§RTXHDTXHOHOKHSUHVWRXHSRUDOJXPDUD]£RSHVVRDOUHQXQFLRX UHPXQHUD§£R(QTXDGUDUVHLDQRFRQFHLWR
DPSOR GH REULJD§£R QDWXUDO UHVLGHQWH QD FRQVFLªQFLD LQGLYLGXDO GR GRDGRU TXH R GLUHLWR UHFRQKHFH H WXWHOD 1D VLWXD§£R UHJXODU GH
REULJD§£RQDWXUDORGHYHGRUSDJDHQ£RSRGHUHSHWLU1DGRD§£RUHPXQHUDW³ULDRFUHGRUQ£RGHVHMDUHFHEHUSDJDPHQWRDGPLWHWRGDYLD
UHFHEHUGRD§£RTXHQ£RWHPHVVDQDWXUH]D3RUH[HPSORRDGYRJDGRTXHSUHVWDJUDWXLWDPHQWHVHXVVHUYL§RVSURILVVLRQDLVDXPDPLJRH
HP YLUWXGH GRV OD§RV GH DPL]DGH FRQVWUDQJHVH HP UHFHEHU TXDOTXHU SDJDPHQWR K¡ GRD§£R UHPXQHUDW³ULD QR SUHVHQWH YDOLRVR RX
HVWLPDWLYRTXHRDPLJROKHID]1£RK¡QHPSRGHKDYHUFRUUHVSHFWLYLGDGHRXFRQWUDSUHVWD§£RQRDWRGHGRDUFRP¢QLPRUHPXQHUDW³ULR
&RPDWUDGL§£RGRREMHWRGLVVROYHVHDPRWLYD§£RHRVHIHLWRVGDGRD§£RV£RDVVHPHOKDGRVDRGDGRD§£RSXUDߢ
&DEHQRVPHQFLRQDUDLQGDFRPRXPDVXEHVS©FLHDGRD§£RIHLWDHPFRQWHPSOD§£RDFDVDPHQWRIXWXUR
'LVSRQGRVREUHHVWDHVS©FLHRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLO©H[WUHPDPHQWHFODURHHOXFLGDWLYR
ߡ$UW$GRD§£RIHLWDHPFRQWHPSOD§£RGHFDVDPHQWRIXWXURFRPFHUWDHGHWHUPLQDGDSHVVRDTXHUSHORVQXEHQWHVHQWUHVLTXHUSRU
WHUFHLURDXPGHOHVDDPERVRXDRVILOKRVTXHGHIXWXURKRXYHUHPXPGRRXWURQ£RSRGHVHULPSXJQDGDSRUIDOWDGHDFHLWD§£RHV³
ILFDU¡VHPHIHLWRVHRFDVDPHQWRQ£RVHUHDOL]DUߢ
,QWHUHVVDQWH REVHUYDU QHVVH SDUWLFXODU TXH R QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR VHJXQGR D GLF§£R GHVWH GLVSRVLWLYR
ILFDU¡VHPHIHLWRVHRFDVDPHQWRQ£RVHUHDOL]DU&RQFOXLVHSRUWDQWRHHVVHVHULDXPHUURJUDYHSRVWR
SURY¡YHOLPDJLQDUVHTXHDGRD§£RVHULDQXODQDIDOWDGRFDVDPHQWR7RGDYLDDVVLPQ£R©XPDYH]TXH
VHULDRFDVRGHQHJDWLYDGHHILF¡FLDHQ£RSURSULDPHQWHGHYDOLGDGH
&RP HIHLWR R QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR GD GRD§£R IHLWD HP FRQWHPSOD§£R D FDVDPHQWR IXWXUR © H[LVWHQWH H
Y¡OLGR WHQGR DSHQDV XP IDWRU HILFDFLDO SHQGHQWH TXDO VHMD R UHIHULGR PDWULP´QLR HYHQWR IXWXUR H
LQFHUWR FRPR WRGD FRQGL§£R SRU PDLV TXH RV QRLYRV HVWHMDP DQVLRVRV SDUD FDVDU RX UHFHEHU R EHP
GRDGR
(P WRGDV DV HVS©FLHV DTXL PHQFLRQDGDV RX D PHQFLRQDU R FDU¡WHU GH OLEHUDOLGDGH ID] FRP TXH R
GRDGRUQ£RVHMDREULJDGRDSDJDUMXURVPRUDW³ULRVQHPHVWHMDVXMHLWR VFRQVHTXªQFLDVGDHYLF§£RRXGR
YFLRUHGLELW³ULR FRQIRUPH FRQVWD GD SDUWH LQLFLDO GR DUW GR && 7RGDYLD FRPR FRQVWD QD
SDUWHILQDOGRPHQFLRQDGRGLVSRVLWLYRQDVߡGRD§µHVSDUDFDVDPHQWRFRPFHUWDHGHWHUPLQDGDSHVVRDR
GRDGRUILFDU¡VXMHLWR HYLF§£RVDOYRFRQYHQ§£RHPFRQWU¡ULRߢ
'RD§£RFRQMXQWLYD
'RD§£RFRQMXQWLYDSRUVXDYH]©DTXHODIHLWDDPDLVGHXPDSHVVRDH[YLGRGLVSRVWRQRDUWGR
&³GLJR &LYLO GH ߡ6DOYR GHFODUD§£R HP FRQWU¡ULR D GRD§£R HP FRPXP D PDLV GH XPD SHVVRD
HQWHQGHVHGLVWULEXGDHQWUHHODVSRULJXDOߢ1RWDVHTXHDGLVWULEXL§£RHTXLWDWLYDGDVTXRWDVRXSDUWHVGD
FRLVDGRDGDVRPHQWHRFRUUHU¡FDVRRGRDGRUVHJXQGRDVXDDXWRQRPLDGHYRQWDGHQ£RKRXYHUGLVSRVWR
HPVHQWLGRFRQWU¡ULRH[FDEHU¡D3HGURHD-R£R
(PVHJXLGDRSDU¡JUDIRºQLFRGRPHVPRGLVSRVLWLYRSUHYªTXHߡ6HRVGRQDW¡ULRVHPWDOFDVRIRUHP
PDULGRHPXOKHUVXEVLVWLU¡QDWRWDOLGDGHDGRD§£RSDUDRF´QMXJHVREUHYLYRߢ$VVLPVHRVEHQHILFL¡ULRV
GD GRD§£R IRUHP FDVDGRV HQWUH VL TXDOTXHU TXH VHMD R UHJLPH GH EHQV FRP D PRUWH GH XP GHOHV D
WRWDOLGDGH GD KHUDQ§D WRFDU¡ DR F´QMXJH VREUHYLYR H[FHSFLRQDQGRVH SRUWDQWR TXDOTXHU RXWUD UHJUD
VXFHVV³ULDTXHGHVVHGHVWLQRGLYHUVRDRUHIHULGREHP
(PQRVVRVHQWLUWRGDYLDRFRGLILFDGRUSRGHULDWHULGRPDLVDO©PFRQWHPSODQGRRPHVPREHQHIFLR
FRPSDQKHLUD VREUHYLYHQWH XPD YH] TXH D XQL£R HVW¡YHO HQWHQGLGD FRPR XPD OHJWLPD IRUPD GH
FRQVWLWXL§£RGHIDPOLDWDPE©PMXVWLILFDULDDPHVPDVROX§£R3HUFHEHVHDTXLFRPRHPWRGDVDVGHPDLV
UHJUDV UHIHUHQWHV GRD§£R XPD SULPD]LD GR PDWULP´QLR D TXDO VH SRU XP ODGR © IUXWR GH QRVVD
WUDGL§£RUHOLJLRVD SRURXWURQ£RSRGHULDVLJQLILFDUDPLQLPL]D§£R GD WXWHOD GHRXWUDVIRUPDVGH XQL£R
OLYUHGRWDGDVGDPHVPDGLJQLGDGHFRQVWLWXFLRQDO
$OL¡VFRPREHPREVHUYRX52'5,*2'$&81+$3(5(,5$ߡDSDUWLUGRPRPHQWRHPTXHDIDPOLD
GHL[RXGHVHURQºFOHRHFRQ´PLFRHGHUHSURGX§£RSDUDVHURHVSD§RGRDIHWRHGRDPRUVXUJLUDPQRYDV
HY¡ULDVUHSUHVHQWD§µHVVRFLDLVSDUDHODߢ
'RD§£RFRPFO¡XVXODGHUHYHUV£R
$GRD§£RFRPFO¡XVXODGHUHYHUV£RSRUVXDYH]©XPDLQWHUHVVDQWHILJXUDMXUGLFDHPTXHVHSUHYªR
UHWRUQRGREHPDRGRDGRUQDKLS³WHVHGHSUHPRULªQFLDGRGRQDW¡ULR$FO¡XVXODGHUHYHUV£RSRGHVHU
GHILQLGDFRPRDHVWLSXOD§£RQHJRFLDOSRUPHLRGDTXDORGRDGRUGHWHUPLQDRUHWRUQRGREHPDOLHQDGR
FDVRRGRQDW¡ULRYHQKDDIDOHFHUDQWHVGHOH
7HPVHSRLVLQHTXLYRFDPHQWHXPDGRD§£RJHUDGRUDGHSURSULHGDGHUHVROºYHOGRDGTXLUHQWH1HVVH
VHQWLGRGLVSµHRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLOTXHRߡGRDGRUSRGHHVWLSXODUTXHRVEHQVGRDGRVYROWHPDR
VHXSDWULP´QLRVHVREUHYLYHUDRGRQDW¡ULRߢ
&RPRVHSRGHYHULILFDUDPRUWH©DGPLWLGDSHODOHLFRPRFDXVDGDUHYHUV£RQDGDREVWDQGRSRU©P
TXH VH HVWLSXOH GH RXWUD IRUPD D GRD§£R D WHUPR QR VHQWLGR GH R EHP GRDGR SRGHU UHYHUWHU DR
SDWULP´QLR GR GRDGRU DQWHV PHVPR GD PRUWH GR GRQDW¡ULR 1HVVH VHQWLGR REVHUYD 6/9,2 9(126$
ߡSHUJXQWDVHWDPE©PVHHVVDFO¡XVXODSRGHVHUDSRVWDHVWLSXODQGRUHYHUV£RDQWHVGDPRUWHGRGRQDW¡ULR
$UHVSRVWD©DILUPDWLYD&XLGDVHGHDSOLFDURSULQFSLRJHUDOTXHDGPLWHRVQHJ³FLRVDWHUPRߢ
1HVVHSRQWRWXGRILFDQR¢PELWRGDDXWRQRPLDGDYRQWDGHGDVSDUWHVFRQWUDHQWHV
,QWHUHVVDQWH SRQWR D VHU DERUGDGR GL] UHVSHLWR SRVVLELOLGDGH GH UHQºQFLD GD UHYHUV£R (P RXWUDV
SDODYUDVRGLUHLWR UHYHUV£RSRGHULDVHUUHQXQFLDGRSHORGRDGRU"
1£RWHPRVGºYLGDGHTXHVLP
7UDWDVH SRLV GH XP GLUHLWR SRWHVWDWLYR GLVSRQYHO GR GRDGRU 1HVVD PHVPD OLQKD SRQWLILFD
*8,//(502%25'$ߡ3XHVWRTXHODUHYHUVL³QHVXQGHUHFKRGHFDU¡FWHUSDWULPRQLDOQDGDLPSLGHTXH
VHDUHQXQFLDGRSRUHOGRQDQWHDUW/DUHQXQFLDSXHGHVHUH[SUHVDRW¡FLWDߢ
2XWUR LQVWLJDQWH SUREOHPD GL] UHVSHLWR SRVVLELOLGDGH GH R EHP VHU UHYHUWLGR D WHUFHLUR 2 &³GLJR
DQWHULRU HUD RPLVVR D HVVH UHVSHLWR R TXH OHYDYD SDUWH GD GRXWULQD D DGPLWLU HVVD KLS³WHVH
FDUDFWHUL]DQGR XPD HVS©FLH GH ߡILGHLFRPLVVR LQWHU YLYRV TXH RSHUDULD D WUDQVPLVVLELOLGDGH GR
GRPQLR GH XP EHP GRDGR D XP WHUFHLUR VHP TXH WLYHVVH KDYLGR D PRUWH GR GRDGRU 6XD DFHLWD§£R
VHPSUHIRLSROªPLFDDQWHVGDHGL§£RGR&³GLJR&LYLOGHTXHFXOPLQRXSRUSURLELORFRQVRDQWHVH
GHSUHHQGHGRSDU¡JUDIRºQLFRGRDUWLJRVREFRPHQWRߡ1£RSUHYDOHFHFO¡XVXODGHUHYHUV£RHPIDYRUGH
WHUFHLURߢ
7DOYH] D UD]£R GH WDO SURLEL§£R UHVLGD Q£R DSHQDV QD QDWXUH]D WHVWDPHQW¡ULD GR ILGHLFRPLVVR PDV
HVSHFLDOPHQWH QD QHFHVVLGDGH GH VH SUHVHUYDU R EHP HP SRGHU GH XPD GDV SDUWHV LQFHQWLYDQGRD D
LPSULPLU GHVWLQD§£R HFRQ´PLFD D HOH VHP R ULVFR GH DR ILQDO WHU GH VH VXMHLWDU D XPD VHJXQGD
WUDQVIHUªQFLDHP EHQHIFLRGHWHUFHLUD SHVVRD 5HVJXDUGDVH RXWURVVLP FRP WDO UHVWUL§£R D VHJXUDQ§D
QDVUHOD§µHVMXUGLFDV
'RD§£RPLVWDGRD§µHVPºWXDV
$ GRD§£R PLVWD QHJRWLXP PL[WXP FXP GRQDWLRQH © XP QHJ³FLR MXUGLFR GH FRQWHºGR SUHVWDFLRQDO
KEULGR FRP FDUDFWHUVWLFD GH QHJ³FLR RQHURVR PDV WUD]HQGR HP VHX ERMR WDPE©P XP PDWL] GH
OLEHUDOLGDGH([HPSORFO¡VVLFRSRGHVHULQYRFDGRQRFDVRGHXPVXMHLWRSDJDUOLYUHPHQWHUHDLVSRU
XPEHPTXHYDOHDSHQDV
(PQRVVRVHQWLUSDUDSRGHUGHILQLUHPTXDOFDWHJRULDRFRQWUDWRPHOKRUVHHQTXDGUDULDVHQDFRPSUD
H YHQGD RX GRD§£R WHU¡ R LQW©USUHWH GH LQYHVWLJDU D FDXVD GR QHJ³FLR SDUD FRQFOXLU VH SUHSRQGHUD R
HVSULWR GH OLEHUDOLGDGH RX DSHQDV D HVSHFXOD§£R HFRQ´PLFD ( FRP EDVH QHVVD SUHPLVVD
FRQFRUGDPRV FRP &$5/26 52%(572 *21$/9(6 TXDQGR SUHOHFLRQD ߡ(PERUD VXVWHQWHP DOJXQV
TXHRQHJ³FLRGHYHVHUVHSDUDGRHPGXDVSDUWHVDSOLFDQGRVHDFDGDXPDGHODVDVUHJUDVTXHOKHVV£R
SU³SULDVDPHOKRUVROX§£R©YHULILFDUDSUHSRQGHU¢QFLDGRQHJ³FLRVHRQHURVRRXJUDWXLWROHYDQGRVH
HPFRQWDRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLO ߢ
3RGHVHIDODUDLQGDHPGRD§µHVPºWXDVTXHQ£RVHFRQIXQGHPFRPDGRD§£RPLVWD
2EVHUYHVH TXH QDV ߡGRD§µHV PºWXDVߢ JUDIDPRV SURSRVLWDGDPHQWH D H[SUHVV£R QR SOXUDO SRLV HVWH
QHJ³FLR SUHVVXSµH TXH GXDV SDUWHV UHDOL]HP UHFLSURFDPHQWH DWRV GH OLEHUDOLGDGH EHQHILFLDQGRVH
PXWXDPHQWH HP XP V³ DWR 9DOH GL]HU XPD SDUWH GRD RXWUD H YLFHYHUVD $SUR[LPDVH GD WURFD PDV
FRP HVWD Q£R VH FRQIXQGH SHOD GLIHUHQ§D GH FDXVD D OLEHUDOLGDGH XPD YH] TXH QD GRD§£R H[LVWH XPD
OLEHUDOLGDGHTXHQ£RK¡QDWURFD1HVWDºOWLPDK¡XPDILQDOLGDGHQHJRFLDOWSLFDGHSHUPXWDURTXH©GH
XPSHORTXH©GHRXWUR1DVGRD§µHVPºWXDVK¡DSHQDVRLQWHUHVVHGHEHQHILFLDURRXWURFRQWUDWDQWHVHP
LQWHUHVVHQDUHFLSURFLGDGHHPERUDH[LVWHQWHQRPHVPRDWR
'RD§£RVREIRUPDGHVXEYHQ§£RSHUL³GLFD
$GRD§£RVREIRUPDGHVXEYHQ§£RSHUL³GLFD©SUHYLVWDQRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLOTXHGLVSµH
ߡ$UW$GRD§£RHPIRUPDGHVXEYHQ§£RSHUL³GLFDDREHQHILFLDGRH[WLQJXHVHPRUUHQGRRGRDGRUVDOYRVHHVWHRXWUDFRLVDGLVSXVHU
PDVQ£RSRGHU¡XOWUDSDVVDUDYLGDGRGRQDW¡ULRߢ
(P WDO FDVR WHPVH XP FRQWUDWR FXMDV SUHVWD§µHV GHYLGDV SHOR GRDGRU V£R SDJDV SHULRGLFDPHQWH
QDGDLPSHGLQGRRXWURVVLPTXHRGRDGRUDSOLTXHRFDSLWDOHRGRQDW¡ULRSDVVHDSHUFHEHURVVHXVIUXWRV
VHQGROKHYHGDGRROHYDQWDPHQWRLQWHJUDOGRYDORU&ODURHVW¡TXHRSHURGRGHYLJªQFLDGHVWDGRD§£R
GHSHQGHU¡GRTXDQWRHVWLSXODGROLYUHPHQWHSHORGRDGRUVDOLHQWDQGRTXHDOHLSRVWRDGPLWDREHQHIFLR
SDUD GHSRLV GD PRUWH GR GRDGRU YHGD D SRVVLELOLGDGH GH RV VXFHVVRUHV GR GRQDW¡ULR EHQHILFLDUHPVH
FRPRUHIHULGRUHQGLPHQWR
'RD§£RLQGLUHWDGRD§£RGLVIDU§DGD
3RUILPYDOHWHFHUDOJXPDVFRQVLGHUD§µHVVREUHRWHPDGDGRD§£RLQGLUHWDHGDGRD§£RGLVIDU§DGD
2TXHDGRXWULQDFRQYHQFLRQRXFKDPDUGHߡGRD§£RLQGLUHWDߢQ£RWUDGX]WHFQLFDPHQWHGRD§£RHPERUD
FRQVLVWDHPXPDWRGHYDQWDJHPSDWULPRQLDOSDUDXPDGDVSDUWHV
2 H[HPSOR PDLV OHPEUDGR © R GD UHPLVV£R SHUG£R GH GYLGD $ UHPLVV£R GH GYLGD Q£R © XPD
GRD§£R PDV FRQVWLWXL XP EHQHIFLR M¡ TXH R GHYHGRU WHP XP DFU©VFLPR SDWULPRQLDO FRQVLVWHQWH QD
TXLWD§£RGHVHXSDVVLYR2XWURH[HPSOR©RSDJDPHQWRGHG©ELWRDOKHLRQRWDGDPHQWHTXDQGRVHWUDWDUGH
XPWHUFHLURQ£RMXULGLFDPHQWHLQWHUHVVDGR
$GRD§£RGLVIDU§DGDSRUVXDYH]©DTXHODTXHHQFREUHXPQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRVLPXODGRRXHPIUDXGH
OHL R H[HPSOR GR LQGLYGXR TXH IRUMD XPD GRD§£R TXDQGR QD YHUGDGH HVW¡ YHQGHQGR R EHP SDUD
HYLWDUTXHVHXVFUHGRUHVH[LMDPRSUH§RFRPRJDUDQWLDGHVXDVGYLGDVRXGHDOJX©PTXHID]XPDGRD§£R
SDUDQ£RLQFLGLUHPYHGD§µHVFRQWUDWXDLVGHFRPSUDHYHQGD
(VVD FODVVLILFD§£R © HQFRQWUDGD QD REUD GH &$59$/+2 '( 0(1'21$ TXH H[HPSOLILFD ߡ$V
LQGLUHWDVRSHUDPVHIUHTXHQWHPHQWHDQDVUHQºQFLDVEQDVHVWLSXOD§µHVHPIDYRUGHWHUFHLURVFQDV
UHPLVVµHVGHG©ELWRVߢ2XWURH[HPSORVHULDDSU³SULDGRD§£RPLVWDM¡DQDOLVDGDDFLPD
(FRQFOXLRIHVWHMDGRMXULVWDGLVWLQJXLQGRDVGXDVPRGDOLGDGHV
ߡ WHRULFDPHQWH D GLIHUHQ§D FRQVLVWH QR VHJXLQWH D LQGLUHWD UHVXOWD GH XP DWR TXH Q£R © DSDUHQWH TXH © QD UHDOLGDGH XPD GRD§£R D
GLVIDU§DGD©DRFRQWU¡ULRXPDGRD§£RFRPDSDUªQFLDGHXPDWRMXUGLFRGLYHUVRߢ
(P FRPSOHPHQWR D HVWH LWHP FXLGDUHPRV GH GHVWDFDU HP W³SLFRV SU³SULRV H GLVWLQWRV GDGDV D
LPSRUW¢QFLDHDSURIXQGLGDGHGRVWHPDVDGRD§£RHQWUHFRPSDQKHLURVHFRQFXELQRVHDGRD§£RIHLWDDR
QDVFLWXURHDRHPEUL£R
9DPRVDHODV
(;7,12'2&2175$72'('2$2
1HVWHW³SLFRHQIUHQWDUHPRVRWHPDGDH[WLQ§£RGRFRQWUDWRGHGRD§£RVREGRLVHQIRTXHVGLVWLQWRV
2SULPHLURVHUHIHUH VXDPRGDOLGDGHQDWXUDOFRPDVXDUHJXODUH[HFX§£R
2VHJXQGRSULVPD©MXVWDPHQWHRRXWURODGRGDPRHGDTXDOVHMDDVXDLQH[HFX§£R
9DPRVDHOHV
0HLRQDWXUDOGHH[WLQ§£R
$ IRUPD QDWXUDO GH H[WLQ§£R GR FRQWUDWR GH GRD§£R G¡VH SRU PHLR GH VXD H[HFX§£R YDOH GL]HU QR
PRPHQWRHPTXHRGRDGRUFXPSUHDSUHVWD§£RDTXHVHREULJRXRQHJ³FLRMXUGLFRVHH[DXUH
&DVRHQWUHWDQWRSDGH§DGHDOJXPDLQYDOLGDGHRFRQWUDWRVHU¡H[WLQWRSRUPHLRGHGHFODUD§£RGDVXD
QXOLGDGH RX GD VXD GHVFRQVWLWXL§£R SRU DQXODELOLGDGH QRV WHUPRV GD WHRULD JHUDO GR QHJ³FLR
MXUGLFR
5HYRJD§£RGDGRD§£RLQH[HFX§£RGRHQFDUJRHLQJUDWLG£RGRGRQDW¡ULR
8PDHVSHFLDOIRUPDGHH[WLQ§£RGRFRQWUDWRGHGRD§£RHQWUHWDQWRRSHUDVHSRUPHLRGDGHQRPLQDGD
UHYRJD§£RGRGRDGRU
6XDRULJHPUHPRQWDDR'LUHLWR5RPDQRFRQIRUPHDGRXWULQDGH&$59$/+2'(0(1'21$
ߡ(VVDUHYRJD§£RUHJXODGDSRU-XVWLQLDQRWHYHVXDRULJHPHPXPDGLVSRVL§£RSDUWLFXODU2LPSHUDGRU)LOLSHHVWDWXLXHPXPD&RQVWLWXL§£R
TXH D GRD§£R IHLWD SRU XP SDWURQR DR OLEHUWR VHULD VHPSUH UHYRJ¡YHO YRQWDGH 3HUFHEHVH SRU©P TXH WDO IDFXOGDGH V³ GHYLD VHU
XWLOL]DGDSDUDVXSULPLUDLQJUDWLG£RGROLEHUWR(VVHLQWXLWRGDOHLSRU©PHUDLUUHDOL]¡YHOSRUTXHRSDWURQRHUDDILQDOR¡UELWURºQLFRGD
FRQGXWD GR VHX OLEHUWR H GD UHVXOWDYD D LQFRQVFLªQFLD GD GRD§£R $ LVWR YHLR REYLDU HP RXWUD &RQVWLWXL§£R TXH V³ WROHUDYD D
UHYRJD§£RHPWDOFDVRTXDQGRRGRDGRUIL]HVVHDOLEHUDOLGDGHVHPWHUILOKRVYLQGRPDLVWDUGHDWªORV4XDVHDRPHVPRWHPSRHP
HVWHQGLDVHDRSDLH P£HRGLUHLWRGHUHYRJDUGRD§µHVHPDLVWDUGHHPDWRGRVRVGHVFHQGHQWHVߢ
7UDWDVH SRLV D UHYRJD§£R GR H[HUFFLR GH XP GLUHLWR SRWHVWDWLYR SRU PHLR GR TXDO R GRDGRU
YHULILFDQGR D RFRUUªQFLD GH DOJXPD GDV VLWXD§µHV SUHYLVWDV H[SUHVVDPHQWH HP OHL PDQLIHVWD YRQWDGH
FRQWU¡ULD OLEHUDOLGDGH FRQIHULGD WRUQDQGR VHP HIHLWR R FRQWUDWR FHOHEUDGR H GHVSRMDQGR
FRQVHTXHQWHPHQWHRGRQDW¡ULRGREHPGRDGR
'LIHUHQWHPHQWH GD UHVROX§£R D UHYRJD§£R ߚ DW© PHVPR HP UHVSHLWR DR SULQFSLR GD VHJXUDQ§D QRV
QHJ³FLRVMXUGLFRVߚWHPHILF¡FLDH[QXQFFRQVRDQWHREVHUYD05,2-/,2'($/0(,'$&267$
FLWDGRSRU$5$.(1'($66,6
ߡ$UHYRJD§£RFRQVLVWHQDGHVWUXL§£RGRYQFXORFRQWUDWXDOPHGLDQWHXPDGHFODUD§£RGRVFRQWUDHQWHVRSRVWD SULPLWLYDTXHOKHGHXYLGD
$LQGDTXDQGRVHWUDWHGHUHYRJD§£RXQLODWHUDOGHXPDGDVSDUWHVQ£RVHFRQIXQGHFRPDUHVROX§£RYLVWRTXHRSHUDH[QXQFߢ
7DO SUHUURJDWLYD H[HUFLGD QR ERMR GH XPD D§£R MXGLFLDO FXOPLQD SRU H[FHSFLRQDU R FDU¡WHU GH
SHUSHWXLGDGH GR GLUHLWR GH SURSULHGDGH FRQILJXUDQGRVH SRLV FRPR XPD VLWXD§£R H[FHSFLRQDO H
SHFXOLDU
1HVVHGLDSDV£RFXPSUHQRVPHQFLRQDUTXHR&³GLJR&LYLOEUDVLOHLURDGPLWHDUHYRJD§£RGDGRD§£R
SRUGXDVRUGHQVGHPRWLYRVDUW
DSRULQH[HFX§£RGRHQFDUJRQDGRD§£RPRGDO
ESRULQJUDWLG£RGRGRQDW¡ULR
$SULPHLUDKLS³WHVH©GHLQWHOHF§£RFULVWDOLQD
&DVRRGRQDW¡ULRDTXHPIRUDLPSRVWRRFXPSULPHQWRGHXPHQFDUJRQ£RRUHDOL]HSRGHU¡RGRDGRU
GHVID]HUDOLEHUDOLGDGHUHYRJDQGRD
1DGDLPSHGHRXWURVVLPTXHRSU³SULREHQHILFL¡ULRGRHQFDUJRH[LMDRVHXFXPSULPHQWRDGRWDQGRD
PHGLGDMXGLFLDOFDEYHO6HHQWUHWDQWRREHQHILFL¡ULRIRUDSU³SULDFROHWLYLGDGHLPDJLQHPRVTXHR´QXV
IRVVH D FRQVWUX§£R GH XP SRVWR GH VDºGH R 0LQLVW©ULR 3ºEOLFR SRGHU¡ LQJUHVVDU FRP D UHIHULGD
GHPDQGDFRQIRUPHM¡YLPRVQRDUWGR&&
0DV QRWHVH R GLUHLWR GH UHYRJDU HP SULPHLUR SODQR FDEH DR SU³SULR GRDGRU H Q£R SHVVRD
EHQHILFLDGDSHODHVWLSXOD§£RGRHQFDUJRGHYHQGRVHIULVDUDLQGDTXHRVHXH[HUFFLRQ£RSRGHU¡ILFDUDR
OLYUHDUEWULR GR GLVSRQHQWH H[LJLQGRVH SRLV D FRQILJXUD§£R GH XPD GDV GXDV RUGHQV GH FDXVDV
UHYRFDW³ULDVDFLPDUHIHULGDV
9HULILFDGDDPRUDGRGRQDW¡ULRSRGHU¡RGRDGRUQRWLILF¡ORDVVLQDQGROKHSUD]RSDUDTXHFXPSUDR
HQFDUJRFDVRDLQGDWHQKDLQWHUHVVHFRQVRDQWHGLVSµHRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLO
ߡ$UW$GRD§£RRQHURVDSRGHVHUUHYRJDGDSRULQH[HFX§£RGRHQFDUJRVHRGRQDW¡ULRLQFRUUHUHPPRUD1£RKDYHQGRSUD]RSDUDR
FXPSULPHQWRRGRDGRUSRGHU¡QRWLILFDUMXGLFLDOPHQWHRGRQDW¡ULRDVVLQDQGROKHSUD]RUD]R¡YHOSDUDTXHFXPSUDDREULJD§£RDVVXPLGDߢ
,QWHUHVVDQWH©DUHIHUªQFLDTXHROHJLVODGRUIH]DRߡSUD]RUD]R¡YHOߢH[SUHVV£RGHFRQWHºGRIOXGLFRRX
LQGHWHUPLQDGR Q£R DGPLWLQGR SDU¢PHWURV GRXWULQ¡ULRV RX MXULVSUXGHQFLDLV DSULRUVWLFRV SRU GHSHQGHU
GDVFLUFXQVW¢QFLDVGLWDGDVSHODQDWXUH]DGRHQFDUJRLPSRVWR
4XHVW£RLQWHUHVVDQWHGL]UHVSHLWRDRSUD]RGHFDGHQFLDOSDUDUHYRJDUDGRD§£RSRLVFRQVLGHUDQGRVH
Q£RPDLVH[LVWLUQR&³GLJRGHSUD]RYLQWHQ¡ULRGHSUHVFUL§£RH[WLQWLYD©IRU§RVRFRQYLUTXHHVWH
VHU¡DJRUDGHGH]DQRVH[YLGRGLVSRVWRQRDUWGDYLJHQWHFRGLILFD§£RFLYLO
ߡ$UW$SUHVFUL§£RRFRUUHHPGH]DQRVTXDQGRDOHLQ£ROKHKDMDIL[DGRSUD]RPHQRUߢ
3RVWRLVVRYDPRVHQIUHQWDUQRSU³[LPRW³SLFRRWHPDUHIHUHQWH UHYRJD§£RGDGRD§£RSRULQJUDWLG£R
GRGRQDW¡ULR
+LS³WHVHVGHLQJUDWLG£R
6HPVRPEUDGHGºYLGDXPDGDVSLRUHVTXDOLGDGHVTXHXPKRPHPSRGHFXOWLYDU©DLQJUDWLG£R
6HJXQGR R FO¡VVLFR GLFLRQDULVWD &$/'$6 $8/(7( R LQJUDWR © DTXHOH ߡTXH Q£R PRVWUD
UHFRQKHFLPHQWRߢRXVLPSOHVPHQWHߡTXHVHHVTXHFHXGRVEHQHIFLRVTXHUHFHEHXߢ
1R FDVR GH WDO FRPSRUWDPHQWR SURYLU GR GRQDW¡ULR D VLWXD§£R UHYHVWHVH GH PDLRU JUDYLGDGH QD
PHGLGDHPTXHEHQHILFLDGRSRUXPDWRGHOLEHUDOLGDGHRXDW©PHVPRDOWUXVPRYROWDVHWUDL§RHLUDPHQWH
FRQWUDDTXHOHTXHRDJUDFLRX
3RGHPRVLQFOXVLYHDILUPDUTXHRFRPHWLPHQWRGHTXDOTXHUGRVDWRVGHLQJUDWLG£RFDSLWXODGRVQDOHL
FLYLOWUDGX]TXHEUDGHERDI©REMHWLYDS³VFRQWUDWXDORXVHMDLPSOLFDRFRPHWLPHQWRGHDWRDWHQWDW³ULR
DR GHYHU GH UHVSHLWR H OHDOGDGH REVHUY¡YHO HQWUH DV SU³SULDV SDUWHV PHVPR DS³V D FRQFOXV£R GR
FRQWUDWR
6HJXLQGR HVWH UDFLRFQLR FRQFOXPRV TXH FDVR R GRQDW¡ULR UHDOL]H TXDOTXHU GRV DWRV GH LQJUDWLG£R
HOHQFDGRV QR DUW GR &³GLJR &LYLO HVWDU¡ DWXDQGR HP GHWULPHQWR UHJUD ©WLFD H GH H[LJLELOLGDGH
MXUGLFDGDERDI©REMHWLYDS³VFRQWUDWXDO
ߡ$UW3RGHPVHUUHYRJDGDVSRULQJUDWLG£RDVGRD§µHV
,ߚVHRGRQDW¡ULRDWHQWRXFRQWUDDYLGDGRGRDGRURXFRPHWHXFULPHGHKRPLFGLRGRORVRFRQWUDHOH
,,ߚVHFRPHWHXFRQWUDHOHRIHQVDIVLFD
,,,ߚVHRLQMXULRXJUDYHPHQWHRXRFDOXQLRX
,9ߚVHSRGHQGRPLQLVWU¡ORVUHFXVRXDRGRDGRURVDOLPHQWRVGHTXHHVWHQHFHVVLWDYDߢ
8PGHWDOKHSRU©PVHPRVWUDUHOHYDQWH
1£RK¡OLPLWHVSDUDDLQJUDWLG£RKXPDQD
$VVLP VHQGR D SHUVSHFWLYD GH FDUDFWHUL]D§£R GDV KLS³WHVHV GH LQJUDWLG£R FRPR YLROD§µHV ERDI©
REMHWLYDS³VFRQWUDWXDOID]FRPTXHUHFRQKH§DPRVTXHDRFRQWU¡ULRGRTXHHVWDYDDVVHQWDGRQDYLJªQFLD
GR&³GLJR&LYLOEUDVLOHLURGHRQRYRUROQ£R©PDLVWD[DWLYRDFHLWDQGRHPQRPHGRSULQFSLR
RXWUDVKLS³WHVHVDLQGDTXHGHIRUPDH[FHSFLRQDO
1HVVHVHQWLGRSRVLFLRQDUDPVHRVMXULVWDVGD,-RUQDGDGH'LUHLWR&LYLOTXHDSURYDUDPR(QXQFLDGR
QFRPDVHJXLQWHUHGD§£R
ߡ(181&,$'21ߚ$UWRQRYR&³GLJR&LYLOHVWDEHOHFHXXPQRYRVLVWHPDSDUDDUHYRJD§£RGDGRD§£RSRULQJUDWLG£RSRLVR
UROOHJDOSUHYLVWRQRDUWGHL[RXGHVHUWD[DWLYRDGPLWLQGRH[FHSFLRQDOPHQWHRXWUDVKLS³WHVHVߢ
)HLWDVWDLVFRQVLGHUD§µHVYDPRVHQW£RDQDOLVDUXPDDXPDDVKLS³WHVHVSUHYLVWDVQRYLJHQWH&³GLJR
&LYLOEUDVLOHLUR
D+RPLFGLRGRORVRFRQVXPDGRRXWHQWDGR
&DVR R GRQDW¡ULR FRPHWD FULPH GH KRPLFGLR GRORVR R FXOSRVR HVW¡ IRUD GD SUHYLV£R OHJDO
FRQVXPDGRRXWHQWDGRFRQWUDRGRDGRUSRGHU¡WHUDOLEHUDOLGDGHUHYRJDGD
1RFDVRGDWHQWDWLYDGHPRUWHILFDFODURTXHRSU³SULRGRDGRUGLDQWHGRSLRUGRVDWRVGHLQJUDWLG£RR
DWHQWDGRFRQWUDDVXDSU³SULDYLGDSRGHU¡H[HUFHURVHXGLUHLWRSRWHVWDWLYRUHYRFDW¡ULRGHVFRQVWLWXLQGR
DOLEHUDOLGDGH
7UDWDVH SRLV GH XPD PHGLGD FRP SHUFHSWYHO FRQWHºGR VDQFLRQDW³ULR VHP SUHMX]R GD
UHVSRQVDELOL]D§£RFULPLQDOGRDJHQWHFULPLQRVR
,QWHUHVVDQWH PHQFLRQDU DLQGD D TXHVW£R UHIHUHQWH DR KRPLFGLR GRORVR FRQVXPDGR XPD YH] TXH
FRQVRDQWHM¡UHJLVWUDPRVOLQKDVDFLPDDUHYRJD§£R©XPGLUHLWRSHUVRQDOVVLPRFRQIHULGRDRGRDGRU(P
WDO FDVR HP IDFH GD VXD PRUWH FDXVDGD SRU DWR GR GRQDW¡ULR D TXHP FDEHULD R H[HUFFLR GHVWD
SUHUURJDWLYD"
2&³GLJRGHSRUVXDYH]FXLGRXGHFRQWRUQDUDRPLVV£RGLVSRQGRTXH
ߡ$UW1RFDVRGHKRPLFGLRGRORVRGRGRDGRUDD§£RFDEHU¡DRVVHXVKHUGHLURVH[FHWRVHDTXHOHKRXYHUSHUGRDGRߢ
$SULPHLUDSDUWHGRGLVSRVLWLYR©GHLQWHOHF§£RLPHGLDWD
$ D§£R GH UHYRJD§£R HVWXGDGD FRP PLQºFLD ORJR DEDL[R FDEHU¡ DRV KHUGHLURV GR GRDGRU
OHJLWLPLGDGHDWLYDHPFDVRGHFRPHWLPHQWRGHKRPLFGLRGRORVRFRQVXPDGR1RWHVHTXHHPFDVRGH
WHQWDWLYDDOHJLWLPLGDGHFRQWLQXDU¡VHQGRHPFDU¡WHUSHUVRQDOVVLPRGRGRDGRU
1R HQWDQWR D VHJXQGD SDUWH GD UHJUD OHJDO FDXVDQRV FHUWD SHUSOH[LGDGH ߡD UHYRJD§£R SRGHU¡ VHU
HYLWDGDVHRGRDGRUKRXYHUSHUGRDGRRVHXKRPLFLGDߢ
&RPR HQWHQGHU HVWD UHVVDOYD SDUWLQGR GD SUHPLVVD GH TXH D QRUPD FXLGRX GD SU¡WLFD GH KRPLFGLR
GRORVR"2GRDGRUQ£RHVWDYDPRUWR"&RPRKDYHULDHQW£RGHSHUGRDU"
(P UHVSRVWD D HVWD LQGDJD§£R GHVFDUWDGD D KLS³WHVH GH R OHJLVODGRU KDYHU QR FDVR SUHYLVWR XPD
ߡUHDSDUL§£RHVSLULWXDOGRIDOHFLGRߢWDOYH]VHKRXYHVVHSUHWHQGLGRFRQVLGHUDUTXHQDHYHQWXDOLGDGHGHD
PRUWH Q£R VHU LQVWDQW¢QHD R GRDGRU DLQGD DQWHV GR VHX SDVVDPHQWR WHQKD UHOHYDGR D DJUHVV£R H
SHUGRDGRRGRQDW¡ULR([HPSORRGRQDW¡ULRDWLUDQRGRDGRUHVWH©LQWHUQDGRHQRKRVSLWDOSRXFRDQWHV
GHPRUUHUSHUGRDRVHXDJUHVVRU
2XWUDKLS³WHVH©DYHQWDGDSRU&$5/2652%(572*21$/9(6TXDQGRVXJHUHDSRVVLELOLGDGHGH
VH RSHUDU XPD IRUPD GH SHUG£R W¡FLWR QR FDVR GH R GRDGRU Q£R H[HUFHU R VHX GLUHLWR GH UHYRJD§£R
GHQWURGRSUD]RSUHYLVWRHPOHLTXHHVWXGDUHPRVDEDL[R
ߡ2FLWDGRDUWYHLRVXSULURPLVV£RH[LVWHQWHQRGLSORPDGHVREUHHVVDTXHVW£RDRGHWHUPLQDUDDSOLFD§£RGRFULW©ULRDGRWDGRHP
SDVHVFRPRD)UDQ§DD(VSDQKDD,W¡OLDHWFFXMRVF³GLJRVSHUPLWHPDRVKHUGHLURVSURSRUDUHYRJD§£RGDGRD§£RHPFDVRGHPRUWHGR
GRDGRU SURYRFDGD SHOR GRQDW¡ULR VDOYR VH DTXHOH Q£R WHQGR PRUULGR LQVWDQWDQHDPHQWH WHYH RSRUWXQLGDGH GH SURPRYªOD H Q£R R IH]
SHUGRDQGRWDFLWDPHQWHRLQJUDWRߢ JULIRVQRVVRV
(PQRVVDYLV£RVHJXQGRXPMX]RGHUD]RDELOLGDGHLQWHUSUHWDWLYDFRQVLGHUDPRVDVHJXQGDSDUWHGHVWH
DUWLJRGHUHGD§£RH[WUHPDPHQWHLQIHOL]
(POLQKDGHSULQFSLRHFRPDGHYLGDYªQLDQ£RSHUILOKDPRVDWHVHGRSHUG£RW¡FLWRHVSRVDGDSHOR
JUDQGHFLYLOLVWDHDPLJR&$5/2652%(572*21$/9(6
,VVR SRUTXH HP VH WUDWDQGR GH VLWXD§£R W£R JUDYH KRPLFGLR GRORVR GR GRDGRU DILJXUDUVHQRVLD
H[WUHPDPHQWHSHULJRVRDGPLWLUVHXPDIRUPDW¡FLWDRXLQGLUHWDGHSHUG£RPRUPHQWHHPVHFRQVLGHUDQGR
TXHRGRDGRUWDOYH]Q£RKRXYHVVHSRGLGRLQWHQWDUDUHYRFDW³ULDSRUVHHQFRQWUDULQWHUQDGRQD87,GHXP
KRVSLWDO HP HVWDGR GH FRPD HP YLUWXGH GD DJUHVV£R VRIULGD ( PHVPR TXH WLYHVVH D RSRUWXQLGDGH GH
SHUGRDU GDGD D QDWXUH]D GD DJUHVV£R TXH VRIUHX GHYHULD ID]ªOR H[SUHVVDPHQWH H Q£R VH ILUPDU XPD
VLPSOHV SUHVXQ§£R 9DOH GL]HU HP QRVVR VHQWLU DGPLWLGD SHOR OHJLVODGRU XPD IRUPD GH SHUG£R HVWH
GHYHU¡VHUVHPSUHH[SUHVVRPDQLIHVWRHLQHTXYRFRHQ£RVLPSOHVPHQWHW¡FLWR
$IDVWDGDSRLVHVWDKLS³WHVHUHVWDQRVFRQVLGHUDURSHUG£RH[SUHVVRUHDOL]DGRSHORGRDGRUDQWHVGD
VXDPRUWH
2TXHOHYDULDXPDSHVVRDDSHUGRDUVHXDOJR]VDEHQGRGDVXDPRUWHLPLQHQWH"
3LHGDGHFULVW£GHVHVSHURDOWUXVPRFRHU§£RUHOLJLRVDSRUPHGRGRLQIHUQRHQILPGHYHULDRGLUHLWR
SRVLWLYR FKDQFHODU XP SHUG£R HP WHUPRV WDLV" 3RGHUDPRV FRQVLGHUDU LQWHLUDPHQWH OLYUH D YRQWDGH GD
SHVVRD IHULGD H PRULEXQGD TXH SHUGRD R VHX DJUHVVRU" 6HULD MXVWD HVWD IRUPD GH EHQHILFªQFLD
SDWULPRQLDO" &RPR UHSHUFXWLULD WDO DWR QD VRFLHGDGH" $OLPHQWDULD QR GRQDW¡ULRKRPLFLGD VHQVD§£R GH
LPSXQLGDGHDLQGDTXHQRSODQRFLYLO"
7RGDVHVVDVLQGDJD§µHVFDUROHLWRUSURIXQGDPHQWHLQTXLHWDQWHVOHYDPQRVDQXWULUSURIXQGDDQWLSDWLD
LQWHOHFWXDO SRU HVWD IRUPD HVGUº[XOD GH SHUG£R PXLWR HPERUD UHFRQKH§DPRV ߚ HVSHFLDOPHQWH SRU Q£R
VHUSRVVYHOLQYHVWLJDUFRPSUHFLV£RDYRQWDGHQWLPDGDYWLPDߚTXHVHJXQGRRGLVSRVLWLYRDWXDOPHQWH
YLJHQWH © MXULGLFDPHQWH SRVVYHO TXH R GRDGRU UHOHYH D DJUHVV£R FKDQFHODQGR SRLV D OLEHUDOLGDGH
FRQIHULGD
1DGºYLGDHQWUHWDQWRHGHVGHTXHGHPRQVWUHGLVFHUQLPHQWRDRSHUGRDURTXHSRGHVHUFRPSURYDGR
SRUWHVWHPXQKDVRXDW©PHVPRSRUODXGRP©GLFRGHYHU¡SUHYDOHFHUDYRQWDGHGRGRDGRU
$ILQDOGHFRQWDVVHDLQJUDWLG£R©XPGRVVHQWLPHQWRVPDLVWHUUYHLVTXHSRGHDFRPHWHURVHUKXPDQR
RSHUG£R©DPDLVSHUIHLWDPDQLIHVWD§£RGDGLYLQGDGHHPFDGDXPGHQ³V
$LQGDQHVWHWHPDXPDTXHVW£RLQWHUHVVDQWHQRVIRLVXVFLWDGDHPVDODGHDXODHFRQVLGHUDPRVDGHTXDGR
FRPSDUWLOK¡OD
)LQDOPHQWHREVHUYHVHFRP6,/9,2/8,6)(55(,5$'$52&+$TXHߡ2&³GLJR&LYLOQ£RH[LJHD
SU©YLDFRQGHQD§£RFULPLQDOGRGRQDW¡ULRFRQWHQWDQGRVHFRPRIDWRPDVDVHQWHQ§DFULPLQDODEVROXW³ULD
LPSHGHDUHYRJD§£RGDGRD§£Rߢ
E2IHQVDIVLFD
0HQRVJUDYHGRTXHDVLWXD§£RDQWHULRUSRVWRQ£RPHQRVUHYROWDQWHDGRD§£RSRGHU¡VHUUHYRJDGDVH
R GRQDW¡ULR RIHQGHUILVLFDPHQWH R GRDGRU RX VHMDHP OLQJXDJHP SHQDOPHQWH PDLV DSURSULDGD FRPHWHU
FRQWUD HOH TXDOTXHU FULPH TXH YLROH D VXD LQWHJULGDGH FRUSRUDO RX D VXD VDºGH IVLFD HVSHFLDOPHQWH D
OHV£RFRUSRUDO
1D PHVPD OLQKD GR LQFLVR DQWHULRU GLVSHQVDVH D FRQGHQD§£R FULPLQDO H Q£R VHU¡ FRQVLGHUDGD
LQJUDWLG£RVHDOHV£RIRUFXOSRVDRXSUDWLFDGDHPOHJWLPDGHIHVD 2XWUD Q£R HUD DOL¡V D OL§£R GH
&/9,6%(9,/48$WUDQVFULWDLQWHJUDOPHQWHDEDL[R
ߡD RIIHQVD SK\VLFD WDPE©P Q£R QHFHVVLWD GH VHU UHFRQKHFLGD SRU DF§£R SHQDO H ILFDU¡ GHVFODVVLILFDGD GH HQWUH DV PRGDOLGDGHV GH
LQJUDWLG£RVHUHVXOWDUGHUHSXOVDDXPDDJUHVV£RRXVHQ£RIRULQWHQFLRQDOߢ
$VVLP LPDJLQHPRV TXH WHPSRV GHSRLV GD GRD§£R DV SDUWHV VH HQFRQWUHP GLVFXWDP H R GRQDW¡ULR
GHVILUDXPVRFRQRGRDGRU(PWDOFDVRSRGHU¡DGRD§£RVHUUHYRJDGDLQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWHGRGHVIHFKR
GD D§£R SHQDO YDOHQGR QRWDU TXH DV RIHQVDV GH FXQKR PRUDO RX SVLFRO³JLFR HQTXDGUDPVH QR LQFLVR
VHJXLQWH
F'HOLWRVFRQWUDDKRQUDFDOºQLDLQMºULDHGLIDPD§£R
2EVHUYH R QRVVR DWHQWR OHLWRU TXH SUHIHULPRV XWLOL]DU QD GHVFUL§£R GHVWH WWXOR XPD H[SUHVV£R PDLV
JHQ©ULFD GHOLWRV FRQWUD D KRQUD HP YH] GH VLPSOHVPHQWH PHQFLRQDU ߡD LQMºULD JUDYH H D FDOºQLDߢ
FRQVRDQWHYHPFRQVLJQDGRQRGLVSRVLWLYROHJDOVREDQ¡OLVH
,VVRSRUTXHHQWHQGHPRVTXHRFRGLILFDGRUQDUHGD§£RGHVWHHQXQFLDGRLQFRUUHXQXPHTXYRFRPXLWR
FRPXP HQIUHQWDGR SHORV GRXWULQDGRUHV GHGLFDGRV DR IDQW¡VWLFR HVWXGR GD KHUPHQªXWLFD MXUGLFD GLVVH
PHQRVGRTXHGHYHULD
1HVVHFDVRDUDWLRGDQRUPDLPSRUWDDDSOLFD§£RGDGHQRPLQDGDLQWHUSUHWD§£RH[WHQVLYD PXLWDV
YH]HVQHFHVV¡ULDSDUDIL[DUPRVRH[DWRVHQWLGRGDQRUPDMXUGLFDFRQVRDQWHH[HPSOLILFD25/$1'2'(
$/0(,'$6(&&2
ߡ6HILQDOPHQWHDLQWHUSUHWD§£RGHU OHLXPVHQWLGRPDLVDPSORGRTXHDTXHOHH[SUHVVRSHOROHJLVODGRUQRWH[WRVHU¡HQW£RGHFODUDWLYD
H[WHQVLYD([HPSORTXDQGRQR&³GLJR3HQDODUWVHGHILQHRFULPHGHELJDPLDFRPRFRQWUDLUVHQGRFDVDGRQRYRFDVDPHQWRVH
TXHUSXQLUQ£RV³RGXSORFDVDPHQWRFRPRWDPE©PRWULSORTX¡GUXSORHDVVLPVXFHVVLYDPHQWH$OHLIDODHPߝELJDPLDߞPDVTXHUUHIHULU
VHDGRLVRXPDLVFDVDPHQWRVRTXHHPºOWLPDDQ¡OLVHVHULDDELJDPLDHSROLJDPLDߢ
( DVVLP SHQVDPRV SRLV Q£R KDYHULD O³JLFD QHP FRHUªQFLD HP VH FRQVLGHUDU FDXVDV UHYRFDW³ULDV GD
GRD§£RDSHQDVDLQMºULDHDFDOºQLDFRORFDQGRVHGHODGRDGLIDPD§£R,VVRSRUTXHWUDWDPRVWUªVWLSRV
SHQDLV GH GHOLWRV GR PHVPR JªQHUR YDOH GL]HU GH FULPHV FRQWUD D KRQUD JHUDGRUHV GH ߡGDQR PRUDOߢ
$GHPDLVDGLIDPD§£RSRGHVHUW£RRXPDLVJUDYHGRTXHDLQMºULD
$VWUªVVLWXD§µHVSRUWDQWRSRGHU£RMXVWLILFDUGHSHUVLDUHYRJD§£RGDGRD§£RLQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWHGH
WHUKDYLGRFRQGHQD§£RFULPLQDOQRVPHVPRVWHUPRVHVSRVDGRVOLQKDVDFLPD
2XWURSRQWRLQWHUHVVDQWHDGHVWDFDU©RHPSUHJRGRDGY©UELRPRGDOߡJUDYHPHQWHߢQRLQFLVROHJDOVRE
HVWXGRߡ,,,ߚ6HRLQMXULRXJUDYHPHQWHߢVLF
2 TXH WHULD TXHULGR R OHJLVODGRU GL]HU TXDQGR HPSUHJRX HVWD H[SUHVV£R SDUD FDUDFWHUL]DU D LQMºULD"
3RUDFDVRVHULDDGPLVVYHOXPߡMX]RGHJUDGD§£RߢQRDSUHFLDUDLQMºULD"3RGHULDSRLVVHUOHYHP©GLD
JUDYHDFULW©ULRGRMXOJDGRU"
(PQRVVRVHQWLUSRUUHSXWDUPRVDLQMºULDXPDFRQWHFLPHQWRGHGHILQL§£RFDWHJRULDOW©FQLFDTXDOVHMD
XPFULPHFRQWUDDKRQUDVRPRVIRU§DGRVDFRQYLUTXHDH[SUHVV£RDGYHUELDOXWLOL]DGDUHVVRDXPWDQWR
SOHRQ¡VWLFD SDUD UHIRU§DU XPD QDWXUDO H QVLWD JUDYLGDGH H[LVWHQWH HP WRGR R GHOLWR FRQWUD D KRQUD
HVSHFLDOPHQWHDLQMºULD
1HVVD OLQKD SHQVDPRV TXH XPD YH] UHFRQKHFLGR SHOR PDJLVWUDGR ߚ DLQGD TXH LQFLGHQWDOPHQWH QR
SURFHVVRFLYLOߚDLQMºULDVRIULGDSHORGRDGRUHVWHUHFRQKHFLPHQWRM¡WUD]HPVLDJUDYLGDGHGRIDWR
VLPSOHVPHQWHSRUVHWUDWDUGHXPLOFLWRSHQDOFRQWUDDKRQUD
3RU LVVR DILUPDPRV VHU GHVQHFHVV¡ULD D FRORFD§£R GHVWD H[SUHVV£R QR PHQFLRQDGR GLVSRVLWLYR
UHVWDQGRDRPDJLVWUDGRDSHQDVDGPLWLUDH[LVWªQFLDRXQ£RGDLQMºULDSDUDRHIHLWRGHUHYRJDUDGRD§£R
0DVXPDYH]DWHQGRDGPLWLGRDVXDJUDYLGDGH©LPDQHQWH
3HQVDPHQWR FRQWU¡ULR UHYHVWLUVHLD GH XP LPHQVR H LQMXVWLILF¡YHO VXEMHWLYLVPR DXPHQWDQGR HP
GHPDVLDRSRGHUGLVFULFLRQ¡ULRGRMXOJDGRUTXHDVVXPLULDXPDKHUFºOHDߚVHQ£RLPSRVVYHOߚPLVV£R
GHJUDGXDURXGLPHQVLRQDURHVSHFWURGDQRVRSVLFRO³JLFRGDOHV£RVRIULGD
G5HFXVDGHDOLPHQWRV
$REULJD§£RGHSDJDUDOLPHQWRVHPQRVVRVLVWHPDSRGHU¡GHULYDUGDVVHJXLQWHVFDXVDVGRGLUHLWRGH
IDPOLDFDVDPHQWRSDUHQWHVFRXQL£RHVW¡YHOGRGLUHLWRGDVREULJD§µHVGHFRUUHQWHGRFRPHWLPHQWRGH
DWRLOFLWRFRPFXQKRLQGHQL]DW³ULRRXGRSU³SULRGLUHLWRVXFHVV³ULROHJDGRGHDOLPHQWRV
1R¢PELWRGRGLUHLWRGHIDPOLDRVDOLPHQWRVUDGLFDPVHQRߡSULQFSLRGHVROLGDULHGDGHIDPLOLDUߢTXH
GHYH H[LVWLU HQWUH RV SDUHQWHV F´QMXJHV RX VREUHYLYHQWHV YDOHQGR WUDQVFUHYHU R DUW GR YLJHQWH
&³GLJR&LYLOEUDVLOHLUR
ߡ$UW3RGHPRVSDUHQWHVRVF´QMXJHVRXFRPSDQKHLURVSHGLUXQVDRVRXWURVRVDOLPHQWRVGHTXHQHFHVVLWHPSDUDYLYHUGHPRGR
FRPSDWYHOFRPDVXDFRQGL§£RVRFLDOLQFOXVLYHSDUDDWHQGHU VQHFHVVLGDGHVGHVXDHGXFD§£R
hz2VDOLPHQWRVGHYHPVHUIL[DGRVQDSURSRU§£RGDVQHFHVVLGDGHVGRUHFODPDQWHHGRVUHFXUVRVGDSHVVRDREULJDGD
hz2VDOLPHQWRVVHU£RDSHQDVRVLQGLVSHQV¡YHLV VXEVLVWªQFLDTXDQGRDVLWXD§£RGHQHFHVVLGDGHUHVXOWDUGHFXOSDGHTXHPRVSOHLWHLDߢ
1£R QRV FDEHQGR SRU RUD D DQ¡OLVH GHVVHV GLVSRVLWLYRV VDOLHQWDPRV DSHQDV R WHRU GR VHX FDSXW
TXDQGR QRV LQGLFD DUHFLSURFLGDGH GR GLUHLWR DRVDOLPHQWRV H[DWDPHQWH HP UD]£R GR VXSUDPHQFLRQDGR
ߡSULQFSLRGHVROLGDULHGDGHߢ
3RLVEHP
3UHYLX R OHJLVODGRU D SRVVLELOLGDGH GH R GRDGRU UHYRJDU D GRD§£R QD KLS³WHVH GH R GRQDW¡ULR
SRGHQGRFRQFHGHUDOLPHQWRVDRGRDGRURVKRXYHUQHJDGR'DGDDVLWXD§£RHSHORHVSHFILFRHVSHFWURGH
DWXD§£R GDV QRUPDV LPSRVLWLYDV GD REULJD§£R DOLPHQWDU VRPRV OHYDGRV D FUHU TXH WDO IDFXOGDGH
UHYRFDW³ULD UHVWULQJLUVH¡ REYLDPHQWH V SHVVRDV XQLGDV SRU YQFXOR PDWULPRQLDO FRQFXELQ¡ULR RX
SDUHQWDO,VVRSRUQ£RVHDGPLWLUTXHSHVVRDVHVWUDQKDVYDOHGL]HUVHPWDLVYQFXORVIDPLOLDUHVWHQKDP
HQWUHVLDREULJD§£RGHSUHVWDUDOLPHQWRV
$VVLPHDWWXORH[HPSOLILFDWLYRLPDJLQHPRVTXH-DQLRKRXYHVVHGRDGRXPDYXOWRVDTXDQWLDD%UXQR
VHXLUP£R3RVWHULRUPHQWHDWLQJLGRSRUXPUHY©V-DQLRSDVVDSRUXPDJUDYHFULVHILQDQFHLUDIDOWDQGR
OKH DW© PHVPR R QHFHVV¡ULR SDUD D VXD VXEVLVWªQFLD &KRFDGR YHULILFD DLQGD TXH R VHX ºQLFR LUP£R
%UXQRGRQRGHXPDSU³VSHUDHPSUHVDGHHVSRQMDVGHD§RQHJRXOKHDSUHVWD§£RGHDOLPHQWRV3RGHU¡
SRLVUHYRJDUDGRD§£RFRPIXQGDPHQWRQRGLVSRVLWLYRVREDQ¡OLVH
9DOHPHQFLRQDUHQWUHWDQWRTXHHVWDFDXVDUHYRFDW³ULDSUHVVXSµHDFRQMXJD§£RGHWUªVUHTXLVLWRV
DDSRVVLELOLGDGHGHSDJDPHQWRSRUSDUWHGRGRQDW¡ULRߚSRLVQ£RSRGHU¡VDFULILFDUDVXDIDPOLDRXDVLPHVPR OX]GRSU³SULRSULQFSLR
GDSURSRUFLRQDOLGDGHTXHGHWHUPLQDDREVHUY¢QFLDGDFDSDFLGDGHHFRQ´PLFDGHTXHPSDJDHDQHFHVVLGDGHGHTXHPSHGHSDUDDMXVWD
IL[D§£RGDSHQV£RGHYLGD
EDOHJLWLPLGDGHSDVVLYDGRGRQDW¡ULRߚRXVHMDRGRQDW¡ULRGHYHQDIRUPDGDOHLVHUGHYHGRUGRVDOLPHQWRVVROLFLWDGRV
FD LQMXVWLILFDGD UHFXVDGR GRQDW¡ULR ߚ D VDQ§£R UHYRJD§£R GD GRD§£R SUHVVXSµH D VROLFLWD§£R SRU SDUWH GR GRDGRU H D FRQVHTXHQWH
QHJDWLYDGRGRQDW¡ULR
8PDLPSRUWDQWHREVHUYD§£RHQWUHWDQWRGHYHVHUIHLWD
2 GLUHLWR SRWHVWDWLYR GH UHYRJDU D GRD§£R HP FDVR GD QHJDWLYD LQMXVWLILFDGD GR GRQDW¡ULR Q£R
LPSHGHDH[HFX§£RGRWWXORFRQVWLWXWLYRGDREULJD§£RDOLPHQWDUQHPPXLWRPHQRVDHYHQWXDOGHFUHWD§£R
GDSULV£RFLYLOGRGHYHGRU
(PQRVVRSHQVDUDUHYRJD§£RIXQGDPHQWDVHQDTXHEUDGHOHDOGDGHQDWUDL§£RWUDGX]LGDQRߡYLUDUDV
FRVWDVߢSDUDDTXHODSHVVRDTXHHPGHWHUPLQDGRPRPHQWRGDYLGDGRGRQDW¡ULRFXLGRXGHEHQHILFL¡OR
PRYLGRSRUVLPSOHVOLEHUDOLGDGHRXRXWURQREUHVHQWLPHQWRGHDOWUXVPR3RGHPRVIDODUDTXLSRUFHUWR
HPTXHEUDGHERDI©REMHWLYDS³VFRQWUDWXDO
(QHVVDOLQKDPHVPRTXHRGRQDW¡ULRGHPDQGDGRSDJXHFRPDWUDVRDSUHVWD§£RGHYLGDUHSXWDPRV
SRVVYHO D UHYRJD§£R TXH VHJXQGR D QRUPD OHJDO GHFRUUH GD VLPSOHV UHFXVD GH SDJDPHQWR $GHPDLV
FDVRVHDGPLWDWHVHHPVHQWLGRFRQWU¡ULRSRGHULDRGRQDߓW¡ULRODQ§DUP£RGHPDODEDULVPRVRXFKLFDQDV
SURFHVVXDLVSDUDUHWDUGDURSDJDPHQWRHDSHQDVHIHWX¡ORTXDQGRHVWLYHVVHQDLPLQªQFLDGHVHUSUHVRRX
GHWHUDGRD§£RUHYRJDGD
3RUWXGRLVVRFRQFOXPRVQRVHQWLGRGHTXHDUHYRJD§£R©SRVVYHOGHVGHTXHFRQVXPDGDDQHJDWLYD
GRGRQDW¡ULRHPSUHVWDURVDOLPHQWRVGHYLGRV
H,QJUDWLG£RFRPHWLGDFRQWUDSHVVRDSU³[LPDGRGRDGRU
3UHYª R DUW TXH SRGHU¡ RFRUUHU WDPE©P D UHYRJD§£R TXDQGR R RIHQGLGR QRV FDVRV GR DUWLJR
DQWHULRUIRURF´QMXJHDVFHQGHQWHGHVFHQGHQWHDLQGDTXHDGRWLYRRXLUP£RGRGRDGRU
(PWDLVFDVRVHPERUDRGRDGRUVHMDDYWLPDUHIOH[DGRFRPSRUWDPHQWRGDQRVRHPXPHYLGHQWHGDQR
SRU ULFRFKHWH D DJUHVV£R RX YLROD§£R D GLUHLWR © GLULJLGD D SHVVRD SU³[LPD D VL UD]£R SRU TXH VH
MXVWLILFDVHMDDGRD§£RUHYRJDGD
1£R UHIHULX WRGDYLD R FRGLILFDGRU D KLS³WHVH GH D DJUHVV£R VHU GLULJLGD FRPSDQKHLUD GR GRDGRU
VLWXD§£R LQGLVFXWLYHOPHQWH SRVVYHO H TXH WDPE©P DXWRUL]DULD QXPD LQWHUSUHWD§£R FRQVWLWXFLRQDO R
GHVID]LPHQWRGREHQHIFLR,VVRSRUTXHRIDWRGHDIDPOLDFRQVWLWXGDSHORGRDGRUQ£RHVWDUVRERS¡OLR
ߡUHOLJLRVDPHQWHOHJLWLPDGRUߢGRFDVDPHQWRPDVVLPQR¢PELWRGDXQL£R HVW¡YHOQ£R SRGHU¡ LPSHGLU
VHMDRGRQDW¡ULRLJXDOPHQWHDSHQDGRSHORVHXFRPSRUWDPHQWROHVLYRRXGHVDERQDGRU
)LQDOPHQWHUHJLVWUHVHTXHHPQRVVRVHQWLUDUHIHUªQFLDIHLWDDRGHVFHQGHQWHߡDLQGDTXHDGRWLYRߢ ©
WRWDOPHQWHGHVQHFHVV¡ULDSRUUHSXWDUPRVRDGRWDGRGHVFHQGHQWHSDUDWRGRVRVILQVGHGLUHLWRDW©PHVPR
SRU IRU§D GH UHJUD FRQVWLWXFLRQDO DSHQDV FRPSUHHQGHQGRVH WDO H[FHVVR SHOD SUHRFXSD§£R TXH R
OHJLVODGRUWHYHGHHVFRLPDUTXDOTXHUGºYLGDDUHVSHLWRGDQDWXUH]DHGRVHIHLWRVGDDGR§£R
$§£RUHYRFDW³ULDFDUDFWHUVWLFDV&RQGL§µHV3UD]RV(IHLWRV
2 GLUHLWR GH UHYRJDU D GRD§£R © H[HUFLGR SRU PHLR GH D§£R MXGLFLDO UHYRFDW³ULD FRP SUD]R
GHFDGHQFLDOGHXPDQRDFRQWDUGHTXDQGRFKHJXHDRFRQKHFLPHQWRGRGRDGRURIDWRTXHDDXWRUL]DUHGH
WHUVLGRRGRQDW¡ULRRVHXDXWRUDUWGR&&
1RWHVHSRUWDQWRTXHRWHUPRLQLFLDOSDUDDFRQWDJHPGRUHIHULGRSUD]RQ£RVHU¡RGDFRQVXPD§£RRX
RFRUUªQFLDGRDWRGHLQJUDWLG£RPDVVLPRGDߡFLªQFLDGRIDWRHGHVXDDXWRULDߢ
1HVVDOLQKDFDVRRGRDGRUKRXYHVVHVLGRYWLPDGHXPDWHQWDGRTXHFXOPLQRXFRPRVHXLQWHUQDPHQWR
KRVSLWDODUSRUH[HPSORGXUDQWHGRLVPHVHVDFRQWDJHPGRSUD]RLQLFLDVHDSDUWLUGRPRPHQWRHPTXH
WRPRXFRQKHFLPHQWRGHTXHRGRQDW¡ULRIRUDRDXWRUGRGHOLWR
3RUVHWUDWDUGHSUD]RGHFDGHQFLDORXGHFDGXFLGDGHQ£RVHVXEPHWHDSULRULDFDXVDVLPSHGLWLYDV
VXVSHQVLYDVRXLQWHUUXSWLYDV
2XWUR SRQWR LPSRUWDQWH D VH GHVWDFDU © TXH R GLUHLWR GH UHYRJDU D GRD§£R SRU DWR GH LQJUDWLG£R GR
GRQDW¡ULR©ߡLUUHQXQFL¡YHOߢH[YLGRGLVSRVWRQRDUWGR&³GLJR&LYLO
ߡ$UW1£RVHSRGHUHQXQFLDUDQWHFLSDGDPHQWHRGLUHLWRGHUHYRJDUDOLEHUDOLGDGHSRULQJUDWLG£RGRGRQDW¡ULRߢ
1RWH R QRVVR FDUR OHLWRU TXH D SURLEL§£R OHJDO UHIHUHVH UHQºQFLD DQWHFLSDGD QDGD LPSHGLQGR
SRUWDQWRTXHRGRDGRUSHUPLWDRHVFRDPHQWRGRSUD]RSDUDDSURSRVLWXUDGDGHPDQGDRSHUDQGRVHSRU
FRQVHJXLQWHRVHIHLWRVGHXPDUHQºQFLDW¡FLWD
(LVVRREYLDPHQWHVRPHQWHSRGHRFRUUHUDS³VDFRQVXPD§£RGRUHIHULGRSUD]R
&/9,6%(9,/48$GLVFRUUHQGRDUHVSHLWRGDUHQºQFLDSUHOHFLRQDTXH
ߡ2&³GLJR&LYLOFRPRRXWUDVOHJLVOD§µHVFRQVLGHUDGHRUGHPSºEOLFDRGLUHLWRGHUHYRJDUGRD§µHVSRULQJUDWLG£RGRGRQDW¡ULR1£RSRGH
SRU©P D OHL REULJDU R GRDGRU D H[HUFªOR 3UREH D UHQºQFLD PDV GHL[D DR LQWHUHVVDGR D OLEHUGDGH GH XVDU GR VHX GLUHLWR GH UHYRJDU
TXDQGROKHSDUHFHUFRQYHQLHQWHߢ
1RSRORDWLYRGDD§£RGHUHYRJD§£RILJXUDU¡RGRDGRUGDGRRFDU¡WHULQWXLWXSHUVRQDHGRGLUHLWRVRE
HVWXGRSRGHQGRQRHQWDQWRFRQIRUPHYLPRVOLQKDVDFLPDHPFDU¡WHUH[FHSFLRQDODD§£RVHULQLFLDGD
SHORV KHUGHLURV GR GRDGRU VH HVWH IRL YWLPD GH FULPH GH KRPLFGLR GRORVR FRQVXPDGR DUW GR
&&
1R SROR SDVVLYR SRU VHX WXUQR HVWDU¡ R GRQDW¡ULR DXWRU GR DWR GH LQJUDWLG£R D VHU GHYLGDPHQWH
DSRQWDGRHFRPSURYDGRSHORGHPDQGDQWHQDIRUPDGDOHJLVOD§£RHPYLJRU
2´QXVGDSURYD©GRDXWRUTXHGHYHU¡GHPRQVWUDUFDEDOPHQWHDRFRUUªQFLDGRVIDWRVFDUDFWHUL]DGRUHV
GDLQJUDWLG£R
$GPLWH R OHJLVODGRU DLQGD TXH HP FDVR GH IDOHFLPHQWR GR GRDGRU RX GRQDW¡ULR SRVVDP RV VHXV
KHUGHLURV SURVVHJXLU QD GHPDQGD XPD YH] TXH FRQVLGHUDQGRVH WUDWDU GH SHGLGR FRP UHIOH[RV
SDWULPRQLDLVQRHVS³OLRKDYHU¡LQWHUHVVHGRVPHVPRVQHVWDVXFHVV£RSURFHVVXDO
ߡ$UW2GLUHLWRGHUHYRJDUDGRD§£RQ£RVHWUDQVPLWHDRVKHUGHLURVGRGRDGRUQHPSUHMXGLFDRVGRGRQDW¡ULR0DVDTXHOHVSRGHP
SURVVHJXLUQDD§£RLQLFLDGDSHORGRDGRUFRQWLQXDQGRDFRQWUDRVKHUGHLURVGRGRQDW¡ULRVHHVWHIDOHFHUGHSRLVGHDMXL]DGDDOLGHߢ
)LQDOPHQWHFXPSUHQRVVDOLHQWDUTXHDUHYRJD§£RGDGRD§£RVXUWLU¡HIHLWRVH[QXQF SUHVHUYDQGR
VH SRUWDQWR GLUHLWRV DGTXLULGRV SRU WHUFHLURV DQWHULRUPHQWH DUW k SDUWH VHJXQGR R SULQFSLR
FRQVWLWXFLRQDOTXHUHVJXDUGDRGLUHLWRDGTXLULGR$VVLPLPDJLQHPRVTXHDQWHVGDUHYRJD§£RKRXYHVVHR
GRQDW¡ULRILUPDGRFRQWUDWRGHORFD§£RGDFRLVDGRDGDSRUSUD]RGHPHVHV'HYHU¡SRLVRGRDGRU
UHVSHLWDURGLUHLWRGRLQTXLOLQRWHUFHLURGHERDI©
1HVVDPHVPDOLQKDDWHRUGDkSDUWHGRPHVPRDUWRGRQDW¡ULRQ£RHVWDU¡REULJDGRDUHVWLWXLURV
IUXWRVFROKLGRVRXSHUFHELGRVSURYHQLHQWHVGDFRLVDGRDGDDQWHVGDFLWD§£RY¡OLGDQDD§£RUHYRFDW³ULD
$FLWD§£RQRFDVRIRLRUHIHUHQFLDOXWLOL]DGRSHOROHJLVODGRUSDUDPDUFDURPRPHQWRSURFHVVXDOHP
TXHRGRQDW¡ULRFRQYHUWHVHHPSRVVXLGRUGHP¡I©SRUHVWDUIRUPDOHSURFHVVXDOPHQWHFLHQWHGHTXH
SRGHU¡YLUDSHUGHUDTXLORTXHUHFHEHXGRGRDGRU$S³VHVWHDWRGHFRPXQLFD§£RSURFHVVXDOSRUWDQWR
GHYHU¡ UHVWLWXLU WXGR DTXLOR TXH SHUFHEHU ߚ LQFOXVLYH HP QRVVR VHQWLU RV SURGXWRV SRVWR D OHL VHMD
VLOHQWHDUHVSHLWR ߚHFDVRQ£RSRVVDSURFHGHU UHVWLWXL§£RLQQDWXUDGHYHU¡ID]ªORHPHVS©FLH
LQGHQL]DQGRRGRDGRUVHJXQGRRYDORUP©GLRGDFRLVD
'RD§µHVQ£RVXMHLWDV UHYRJD§£R
$OJXQV WLSRV GH GRD§£R QD IRUPD GR DUW GR &³GLJR &LYLO Q£R SRGHU£R VHU UHYRJDGDV SRU
LQJUDWLG£R
7UDWDVHGHHQXPHUD§£RQXPHUXVFODXVXVTXHHVPLX§DPRVDEDL[R
D GRD§µHV SXUDPHQWH UHPXQHUDW³ULDV ߚ YLPRV OLQKDV DFLPD TXH D GRD§£R SXUDPHQWH UHPXQHUDW³ULD © DTXHOD IHLWD HP UHWULEXL§£R D
VHUYL§RVSUHVWDGRVSHORGRQDW¡ULRRFDVRGRP©GLFRGDIDPOLDTXHVHUYLXDRGRDGRUFRPGHGLFD§£RGXUDQWHWRGDDYLGDVHPFREUDU
QDGDSRULVVR2EVHUYHVHTXHSRUVHWUDWDUGHXPDGRD§£RIHLWDHPUHFRQKHFLPHQWRDRFRPSRUWDPHQWRGRGRQDW¡ULRQ£RSRGHU¡VHU
UHYRJDGDSRUM¡VHFRQVLGHUDURGRDGRUUHFRPSHQVDGR(PDOJXPDVVLWXD§µHVHQWUHWDQWRDQRUPDSDUHFHQRVLQMXVWDFRPRQRH[HPSOR
GHRGRDGRUVHUYWLPDGHWHQWDWLYDGHKRPLFGLRHQ£RSRGHUUHYRJDUDGRD§£RDLQGDTXHWHQKDDPHVPDQDWXUH]DUHPXQHUDW³ULD
EGRD§µHVRQHUDGDVFRPHQFDUJRM¡FXPSULGRߚFXPSULGRRHQFDUJRTXHJUDYDDGRD§£RQ£RSRGHU¡PDLVVHJXQGRDQRUPDOHJDOVRE
DQ¡OLVH R GRDGRU UHYRJDU D GRD§£R SRU FRQVLGHUDU TXH R GRQDW¡ULR M¡ VRIUHX XP GHFU©VFLPR SDWULPRQLDO HP WURFD GR EHQHIFLR
SDWULPRQLDOSUHWHQGLGR0DVVDOLHQWHVHTXHDLUUHYRJDELOLGDGHVRPHQWHRFRUUHU¡VHRHQFDUJRM¡KRXYHUVLGRFXPSULGR
F GRD§µHV IHLWDV HP FXPSULPHQWR D REULJD§£R QDWXUDO ߚ D REULJD§£R QDWXUDO RX LPSHUIHLWD © DTXHOD GH FXQKR PRUDO GHVSURYLGD GH
FRHUFLELOLGDGH RX H[LJLELOLGDGH MXUGLFD H[ GYLGD GH MRJR GYLGD SUHVFULWD 2UD SRU VH WUDWDU GH XPD GYLGD GH KRQUD R OHJLVODGRU
FRQVLGHUDTXHDGRD§£RIHLWDHPVHXFXPSULPHQWRHPERUDQ£RWHQKDWHFQLFDPHQWHDQDWXUH]DGHSDJDPHQWRQ£RSRGHU¡VHUUHYRJDGD
SHORGRDGRUTXHFXPSULXDVXDSDODYUD
G GRD§µHV IHLWDV SDUD GHWHUPLQDGR FDVDPHQWR ߚ D OHL SUREH D UHYRJD§£R GD GRD§£R QHVVD FLUFXQVW¢QFLD SRU FRQVLGHUDU TXH R
GHVID]LPHQWRGRDWRGHOLEHUDOLGDGHSRGHU¡UHSHUFXWLUQDHQWLGDGHIDPLOLDUDWLQJLQGRSHVVRDVLQRFHQWHVTXHQ£RSDUWLFLSDUDPGRDWRGH
LQJUDWLG£R3UHVHUYDDVVLPDSU³SULDERDI©HDHVWDELOLGDGHQDVUHOD§µHVMXUGLFDV
'LVFRUUHQGRDUHVSHLWRGHLGªQWLFDUHJUDGR&³GLJR&LYLODQWHULRU&$59$/+26$1726DUUHPDWD
ߡDUD]£RSHODTXDODVGRD§µHVIHLWDVSDUDGHWHUPLQDGRFDVDPHQWRQ£RSRGHU£RVHUUHYRJDGDVSRULQJUDWLG£RGRGRQDW¡ULR©DVHJXLQWHV³
VHWRUQDQGRHIHWLYDFRPDUHDOL]D§£RGRFDVDPHQWRDUW EHP © GH VH YHU TXH EHQHILFLD Q£R VRPHQWH R F´QMXJH D TXHP ©
IHLWDPDVWDPE©PDRRXWURHDRVILOKRVTXHQDVFHUHPGRFDVDPHQWR$UHYRJD§£RSRUWDQWRLULDSUHMXGLFDUWDPE©PRF´QMXJHLQRFHQWHH
RVILOKRVGRFDVDODUW HPFRQWU¡ULRDRSULQFSLRJHUDOGHTXHDSHQDGHYHVHUSHVVRDOQ£RGHYHQGRDWLQJLUHPVHXVHIHLWRV
VHQ£RRFXOSDGRߢ
'2$2325352&85$2
(QFHUUDQGRHVWHFDSWXORUHSXWDPRVQHFHVV¡ULRREVHUYDUDRQRVVRHVWLPDGROHLWRUTXHDGRXWULQDHD
MXULVSUXGªQFLDWªPDGPLWLGRDGRD§£RSRUSURFXUD§£RGHVGHTXHRGRDGRUFXLGHGHHVSHFLILFDURREMHWR
GDGRD§£RHREHQHILFL¡ULRGRDWRGRQDW¡ULR
7DO VLWXD§£R DOL¡V Q£R SURLELGD SRU OHL M¡ HUD SUHYLVWD QR $QWHSURMHWR GH &³GLJR GH 2EULJD§µHV
HODERUDGRSHORJUDQGH&$,205,2'$6,/9$3(5(,5$
ߡ$UW1£RYDOHDGRD§£RTXHVHID§DSRUSURFXUDGRUVDOYRLQYHVWLGRGHSRGHUHVHVSHFLDLVFRPLQGLFD§£RH[SUHVVDGRGRQDW¡ULRRX
GHXPGHQWUHY¡ULRVTXHRGRDGRUQRPLQDOPHQWHPHQFLRQDUߢ
2&³GLJR&LYLOGHSRU©PVLOHQFLRXVREUHRWHPDSHORTXHHQWHQGHPRVTXHWRPDGDVDVFDXWHODV
QHFHVV¡ULDVHVSHFLILFD§£RGRREMHWRHLQGLYLGXDOL]D§£RGREHQHILFL¡ULR©SRVVYHOVLPWDOPRGDOLGDGH
GHGRD§£R1£RVHULDY¡OLGDSRUWDQWRDSURFXUD§£RJHQ©ULFDSDUDGRDURTXHRSURFXUDGRUFRQVLGHUDVVH
FRQYHQLHQWHSRLVLVVRFRQVLVWLULDHPXPDVLWXD§£RGHFRPSOHWDVXEPLVV£RGRPDQGDQWHDRPDQGDW¡ULR