Asignación 3: Comparación de los métodos iterativos más co

Parametros Programados
Bus
Tipo |V| δ V Pgen Qgen
1 Slack 1.025 0 1.025 - -
2 PV - - - 0 0
3 PQ 1.03 - - 3 -

DIAGRAMA DE IMPEDANCIAS
os iterativos más comunes en la solución del problema de flujo de carga
Valores iniciales
Pcarga Qcarga |V| δ V Pgen Qgen Pcarga
0 0 1.025 0 1.025 - - 0
-4 -2 1 0 1 0 0 -4
0 0 1.03 0 1.03 3 0 0

Ybus
-60i 40i 20i
40i -80i 40i
20i 40i -60i

Tolerancia
0.0001
Qcarga
0
-2
0
 Tabla Comparativa
Método
Parámetro Bus (es)
Gauss Seidel Newton-Raphson Newton-Raphson FD

1 1.025 1.025 1.025

Tensión 2 1.0006-0.0367i 1.0006-0.0367i 1.0006-0.0367i

3 1.0297+0.0246i 1.0297+0.0246i 1.0297+0.0246i

1 1.0004 1.0001 1.0000

Potencia
Activa 2 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000
Generada
3 3.0000 3.0000 3.0000

1 0.9040 0.9051 0.9051

Potencia
Reactiva 2 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000
Generada
3 1.3694 1.3694 1.3694

1 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Potencia
Activa 2 -4.0000 -4.0000 -4.0000
Consumida
3 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

1 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Potencia
Reactiva 2 -2.0000 -2.0000 -2.0000
Consumida
3 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

1-2 1.5047+1.0004i 1.5043+1.0016i 1.5043+1.0016i

2-1 -1.5047-0.9227i -1.5043-0.9238i -1.5043-0.9239i
2-3 -2.4962-1.0747i -2.4957-1.0761i -2.4957-1.0761i
Flujo
3-2 2.4962+1.2589i 2.4957+1.2603i 2.4957+1.2603i
3-1 0.5043+0.1089i 0.5042+0.109i 0.5043+0.109i
1-3 -0.5043-0.0964i -0.5042-0.0965i -0.5043-0.0965i
1-2
0.0777i 0.0777i 0.0777i
2-1
2-3
Pérdidas 0.1842i 0.1842i 0.1842i
Pérdidas 0.1842i 0.1842i 0.1842i
3-2
3-1
0.0125i 0.0125i 0.0125i
1-3
 Solución mediante método d
Tabla de Iteraciones
k V2(k) S3(k) Q3(k) vc3(k)
0 1.0025-0.05i 2.06-1.236i 1.236 1.03+0.0152i
1 1.0001-0.0409i 2.6054-1.3671i 1.3671 1.0298+0.0216i
2 1.0004-0.0381i 2.8759-1.3696i 1.3696 1.0297+0.0236i
3 1.0005-0.0372i 2.9589-1.3694i 1.3694 1.0297+0.0243i
4 1.0006-0.0368i 2.9863-1.3694i 1.3694 1.0297+0.0245i
5 1.0006-0.0367i 2.9954-1.3694i 1.3694 1.0297+0.0246i

Resultados Finales
V1 V2 V3
1.025 1.0006-0.0367i 1.0297+0.0246i
|V1| δ1 |V2| δ2 |V3|
1.0250 0.0000 1.0013 -0.0367 1.0300

Flujo y pérdidas en las líneas

Linea Corriente Pérdidas Flujo
1-2 1.468-0.976i 1.5047+1.0004i
0.0777i
2-1 -1.468+0.976i -1.5047-0.9227i
2-3 -2.452+1.164i -2.4962-1.0747i
0.1842i
3-2 2.452-1.164i 2.4962+1.2589i
3-1 0.492-0.094i 0.5043+0.1089i
0.0125i
1-3 -0.492+0.094i -0.5043-0.0964i
olución mediante método de Gauss Seidel
Tabla de Iteraciones
e3(k) v3(k) ΔV2(k) ΔV3(k) Convergencia
1.0299 1.0299+0.0152i 0.0025-0.05i -0.0001+0.0152i NO CONVERGE
1.0298 1.0298+0.0216i -0.0024+0.0091i -0.0001+0.0064i NO CONVERGE
1.0297 1.0297+0.0236i 0.0003+0.0028i 0.002i NO CONVERGE
1.0297 1.0297+0.0243i 0.0001+0.0009i 0.0007i NO CONVERGE
1.0297 1.0297+0.0245i 0.0003i 0.0002i NO CONVERGE
1.0297 1.0297+0.0246i 0.0001i 0.0001i CONVERGE

Resultados Finales
V3 P1gen Q1gen P2gen Q2gen P3gen
1.0297+0.0246i 1.0004 0.9040 0.0000 0.0000 3.0000
δ3 P1carga Q1carga P2carga Q2carga P3carga
0.0239 0 0 -4 -2 0
 Q3gen
1.3694
Q3carga
0
 Solución me
Tabla de Iteracion
k [ δ2 (k); δ3(k); |V2|(k) ] [ ΔP2(k); ΔP3(k); ΔQ2(k) ] [ J (k) ]
0 -4 82.2
0 0 3 -41.2
1 0.2 0
-0.0367 0.0084 82.3079
1 0.0239 -0.0048 -41.2302
1.0026 -0.104 -4.0084
-0.0367 0 82.1991
2 0.0239 0.0001 -41.1757
1.0012 0 -4

V1 V2
1.025 1.0006-0.0367i
|V1| δ1 |V2| δ2
1.0250 0.0000 1.0012 -0.0367

Flujo y pérdidas en las líneas

Linea Corriente Pérdidas Flujo
1-2 1.4676-0.9771i 1.5043+1.0016i
0.0777i
2-1 -1.4676+0.9771i -1.5043-0.9238i
2-3 -2.4515+1.1654i -2.4957-1.0761i
0.1842i
3-2 2.4515-1.1654i 2.4957+1.2603i
3-1 0.4919-0.0941i 0.5042+0.109i
0.0125i
1-3 -0.4919+0.0941i -0.5042-0.0965i
Solución mediante método de Newton-Raphson
Tabla de Iteraciones
[ J (k) ] [ Δδ2 (k); Δδ3(k); Δ|V2|(k) ] [ δ2 (k+1); δ3(k+1); |V2|(k+1) ]
-41.2 0 -0.0367 -0.0367
62.315 0 0.0239 0.0239
0 77.8 0.0026 1.0026
-41.2302 -3.9981 0 -0.0367
62.3391 2.4215 0 0.0239
2.5006 78.2425 -0.0013 1.0012
-41.1757 -3.995 0 -0.0367
62.2847 2.42 0 0.0239
2.4957 78.0266 0 1.0012

Resultados Finales
V3 P1gen Q1gen
1.0297+0.0246i 1.0001 0.9051
|V3| δ3 P1carga Q1carga
1.0300 0.0239 0 0
Convergencia

NO CONVERGE

NO CONVERGE

CONVERGE

P2gen Q2gen P3gen Q3gen

0.0000 0.0000 3.0000 1.3693
P2carga Q2carga P3carga Q3carga
-4 -2 0 0
 [ B' (k) ]
-80 40
40 -60

Tabla
k [ δ2 (k); δ3(k); |V2|(k) ] [ ΔP2(k); ΔP3(k); ΔQ2(k) ]
0 -4
0 0 3
1 0.2
-0.0386 0.1206
1 0.0228 -0.0164
1.0025 -0.1035
-0.0365 -0.0082
2 0.0239 0.0027
1.0012 0.003
-0.0367 0.0004
3 0.0239 -0.0001
1.0012 -0.0003
-0.0367 0
4 0.0239 0
1.0012 0

V1 V2
1.025 1.0006-0.0367i
|V1| δ1 |V2|
1.0250 0.0000 1.0012

Flujo y pérdidas en las líneas

Linea Corriente Pérdidas
1-2 1.4676-0.9772i
0.0777i
2-1 -1.4676+0.9772i
2-3 -2.4515+1.1654i
0.1842i
3-2 2.4515-1.1654i
3-1 0.492-0.0941i
0.0125i
1-3 -0.492+0.0941i
 Solución mediante método de Newton-Raphson Desa
[ B '' (k) ]
-80.0000

Tabla de Iteraciones
[ ΔP2(k)÷|V2|(k) ; ΔP3(k)÷|V3|(k) ; ΔQ2(k)÷|V2|(k) ] [ Δδ2(k) ; Δδ3(k) ; Δ|V2|(k) ]
-4 -0.0386
2.9126 0.0228
0.2 0.0025
0.1203 0.0021
-0.016 0.0011
-0.1032 -0.0013
-0.0082 -0.0001
0.0026 0
0.003 0
0.0004 0
-0.0001 0
-0.0003 0
0 0
0 0
0 0

Resultados Finales
V2 V3
1.0006-0.0367i 1.0297+0.0246i
δ2 |V3|
-0.0367 1.0300

érdidas en las líneas

Flujo
1.5043+1.0016i
-1.5043-0.9239i
-2.4957-1.0761i
2.4957+1.2603i
0.5043+0.109i
-0.5043-0.0965i
de Newton-Raphson Desacoplado Rápido

[ δ2 (k+1); δ3(k+1); |V2|(k+1) ] Convergencia

-0.0386
0.0228 NO CONVERGE
1.0025
-0.0365
0.0239 NO CONVERGE
1.0012
-0.0367
0.0239 NO CONVERGE
1.0012
-0.0367
0.0239 NO CONVERGE
1.0012
-0.0367
0.0239 CONVERGE
1.0012

Resultados Finales
V3 P1gen Q1gen
1.0297+0.0246i 1.0000 0.9051
δ3 P1carga Q1carga
0.0239 0 0
 P2gen Q2gen P3gen Q3gen
0.0000 0.0000 3.0000 1.3694
P2carga Q2carga P3carga Q3carga
-4 -2 0 0
k V2(k) S3(k)
0 1.0025-0.05i 2.06-1.236i
11.0000866924393-0.0409056873236851i
2.60540982805355-1.36711128128555i
21.0003892052186-0.038094099265195i
2.87594224945151-1.3695704060313i
31.00051022279468-0.0371571552949314i
2.95885010176432-1.36942470106126i
41.000550801383-0.0368453356961524i
2.98631038677716-1.36937646057616i
51.0005642750134-0.0367415694598439i
2.99544470045151-1.36936354642678i

S1 P1
1.0004-0.904049999999998i 1.0004

Linea Corriente
1-2 1.468-0.976i
2-1 -1.468+0.976i
2-3 -2.452+1.164i
3-2 2.452-1.164i
3-1 0.492-0.094000000000003i
1-3 -0.492+0.094000000000003i

k [ δ2 (k); δ3(k); |V2|(k) ] [ ΔP2(k); ΔP3(k); ΔQ2(k) ]

0 -4
0 0 3
1 0.2
-0.0366906258 0.0084145283
1 0.0238842368 -0.0048378096
1.0025706941 -0.1039526708
-0.0366536439 4.11294456093003E-06
2 0.023882624 9.42711848752609E-05
1.0012440447 -4.56117347020779E-05

P1 Q1
1.0000983841 0.9050883798

Linea Corriente
1-2 1.46764102733875-0.977138421449996i
2-1 -1.46764102733875+0.977138421449996i
2-3 -2.45151160078804+1.1653891574876i
3-2 2.45151160078804-1.1653891574876i
3-1 0.491935286724648-0.0941253680188004i
 1-3 -0.491935286724648+0.0941253680188004i

Métod

[ B' (k) ]
-80 40
40 -60

k [ δ2 (k); δ3(k); |V2|(k) ] [ ΔP2(k); ΔP3(k); ΔQ2(k) ]

0 -4
0 0 3
1 0.2
-0.038592233 0.1205747968
1 0.022815534 -0.0164394621
1.0025 -0.1034549789
-0.0365366015 -0.0082155855
2 0.0239199443 0.0026737537
1.0012100377 0.0029849173
-0.036658009 0.0003613938
3 0.0238822705 -7.15758687994672E-05
1.001247304 -0.000316757
-0.03665211 -2.50601238480641E-05
4 0.0238850451 8.36937254256043E-06
1.0012433495 8.77339131122312E-06

P1 Q1
0.9999833092 0.9051157747

Linea Corriente
1-2 1.46757861816816-0.977163957206396i
2-1 -1.46757861816816+0.977163957206396i
2-3 -2.45154890962896+1.1654123111424i
3-2 2.45154890962896-1.1654123111424i
3-1 0.491985145730396-0.0941241769680002i
1-3 -0.491985145730396+0.0941241769680002i
 CÁLCULOS

Método de Gauss-Seidel
Q3(k) vc3(k)
1.236 1.03+0.015210355987055i
1.3671112813 1.02979339689436+0.0215946139907857i
1.369570406 1.02973151603576+0.0236015797229448i
1.3694247011 1.02971430184052+0.0242672608518328i
1.3693764606 1.0297088675682+0.0244887141395297i
1.3693635464 1.0297070912449+0.0245624036520658i

Q1
0.9040

Perdidas
0.0776899999999999i
0.0776899999999999i
0.18418i
0.18418i
0.0125449999999999i
0.0125449999999999i
Flujo
1.5047+1.0004i
-1.5047-0.92271i
-2.49619-1.07471i
2.49619+1.25889i
0.5043+0.108895000000003i
-0.5043-0.0963500000000031i

Método de Newton Raphson

[ J (k) ]
82.2 -41.2
-41.2 62.315
5.03536014967443E-15 -2.52380581711176E-15
82.3078870607 -41.2301535846
-41.2301535846 62.3391312736
-4.0084145283 2.5005700969
82.1991253443 -41.1756922263
-41.1756922263 62.2846707285
-4.0000041129 2.4956720599

Q3 V1
1.3693292715 1.025

Perdidas Flujo
0.077719241995047i 1.50433205302222+1.00156688198625i
0.077719241995047i -1.50433205302222-0.923847639991203i
0.1842010254297i -2.49567205992234-1.0761067482739i
0.1842010254297i 2.49567205992234+1.2603077737036i
0.0125429955614766i 0.504233668892764+0.109021497780747i
 0.0125429955614766i -0.504233668892764-0.0964785022192704i

Método de Newton Raphson Desacoplado Rápido

[ B '' (k) ]
-80

[ ΔP2(k) / |V2|(k) ; ΔP3(k) / |V3|(k) ; ΔQ2(k) / |V2|(k) ] [ Δδ2(k) ; Δδ3(k) ; Δ|V2|(k) ]

-4 -0.038592233
2.9126213592 0.022815534
0.2 0.0025
0.1202741115 0.0020556316
-0.0159606428 0.0011044103
-0.1031969865 -0.0012899623
-0.0082056563 -0.0001214076
0.0025958774 -3.767376996257E-05
0.0029813098 3.72663729849416E-05
0.0003609436 5.89905239818697E-06
-6.94911347567643E-05 2.77451601951191E-06
-0.0003163624 -3.95452963746556E-06
-0.000025029 -3.67723770773386E-07
8.12560441025284E-06 -1.0972244034471E-07
8.7624964655144E-06 1.0953120581893E-07

Q3 V1
1.3693612936 1.025

Perdidas Flujo
0.077715909994195i 1.50426808362236+1.00159305613656i
0.077715909994195i -1.50426808362236-0.923877146142365i
0.18420694778163i -2.4957068562538-1.07613162724851i
0.18420694778163i 2.4957068562538+1.26033857503014i
0.0125454372154628i 0.504284774373656+0.109022718607663i
0.0125454372154628i -0.504284774373656-0.0964772813922002i
del
e3(k) v3(k) ΔV2(k)
1.0298876857 1.02988768565837+0.015210355987055i 0.00249999999999995-0.05i
1.0297736026 1.0297736026169+0.0215946139907857i
-0.00241330756070002+0.0090943126763149i
1.0297295594 1.02972955936721+0.0236015797229448i
0.000302512779300157+0.00281158805849011i
1.0297140866 1.02971408655546+0.0242672608518328i
0.000121017576079963+0.000936943970263594i
1.0297088437 1.02970884374166+0.0244887141395297i
0.0000405785883199616+0.000311819598779003i
1.0297070886 1.02970708860667+0.0245624036520658i
0.0000134736304000516+0.000103766236308499i

[ Δδ2 (k); Δδ3(k); Δ|V2|(k) ] [ δ2 (k+1); δ3(k+1); |V2|(k+1) ]

1.48365477889434E-14 -0.0366906258 -0.0366906258
2.45029690981724E-15 0.0238842368 0.0238842368
77.8 0.0025706941 1.0025706941
-3.9981365423 0.000036982 -0.0366536439
2.4215129891 -1.61276277721832E-06 0.023882624
78.2425229106 -0.0013266494 1.0012440447
-3.9950341121 1.18231938052889E-06 -0.0366524616
2.4199720292 2.31841013879981E-06 0.0238849424
78.0265857654 -5.98109519546693E-07 1.0012434465

V2 V3
1.00057153946375-0.036691025681.02970626840094+0.0245967643362324i

6688198625i
7639991203i
067482739i
077737036i
21497780747i
85022192704i

ápido

[ δ2 (k+1); δ3(k+1); |V2|(k+1) ]

-0.038592233
0.022815534
1.0025
-0.0365366015
0.0239199443
1.0012100377
-0.036658009 #REF!
0.0238822705 #REF!
1.001247304 #REF!
-0.03665211 #REF!
0.0238850451 #REF!
1.0012433495 #REF!
-0.0366524777 #REF!
0.0238849353 #REF!
1.001243459 #REF!

V2 V3
1.00057090106984-0.036689465451.0297062088484+0.0245992572865198i

9305613656i
7146142365i
162724851i
857503014i
22718607663i
72813922002i
 ΔV3(k)
.000112314341629949+0.015210355987055i
000114083041470092+0.0063842580037307i
40432496899845e-05+0.0020069657321591i
4728117500724e-05+0.000665681128887992i
4281379998826e-06+0.000221453287696908i
75513499001134e-06+7.36895125360987e-05i