Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Sign In
Modal Verbs
Words
English Grammar
Grammar
English (language)
You'll be speaking a new language in 3 weeks thanks to this app made in Germany by
100+ linguists.
49 Answers
An auxiliary verb is a verb which is used to depict mood or tense of other verbs. Few
other auxiliary verbs are may, shall, can, must etc.
When talking about the past we can use would to express something that has not
happened at the time we are talking about:
We often use would to express the so-called second and third conditionals:
For those unaware, Second conditonal is used to talk about unlikely situations.
Eg. If I had worked harder at school, I would have got better grades.
Using the same conditional structure, we often use would when giving advice:
I wouldn't eat that if I were you.
If I were in your place I would refuse.
If you asked me I would say you should go.
Sometimes the condition is "understood" and there does not have to be an "if" clause:
Someone who liked John would probably love John's father. (If someone liked
John they would probably love John's father.)
You'd (you would) never know it. (for example: If you met him you would never
know that he was rich.)
would for desire or inclination
o I would love to live here.
o Would you like some coffee?
would for polite requests and questions
o Would you open the door, please? (more polite than: Open the door, please.)
o Would you go with me? (more polite than: Will you go with me?
would for opinion or hope
o I would have to agree.
o I would expect him to come.
would for wish
o I wish you would stay. ( meaning - I really want you to stay. I hope you will
stay.)
o They don't like me. I'm sure they wish I'd resign.
Would have and Would have been are the "Second conditional simple" and
"Second conditional Progressive" tenses of the word Would.
English Tenses
Could-
We use could t0 :
We use could to talk about what was possible in the past, what we were able or free to
do:
I could swim when I was 5 years old.
My grandmother could speak seven languages.
When we arrived home, we could not open the door. (...couldn't open the
door.)
Could you understand what he was saying?
Could have and Could have been are the "Second conditional simple" and
"Second conditional Progressive" tenses of the word Could.
Should-
Should have and Should have been are the "Second conditional simple"
and "Second conditional Progressive" tenses of the word Should.
Promote your business on Quora - it's where people look for reliable information about
your industry.
But I'll break it down in layman's terms that aim to help you get it:
could, would and should are a subset of auxiliary verbs called modal verbs (so
are can, will and shall).
They imply a future situation or a potential present one.
could have, would have, should have imply a past potential situation. They are
unchangeable, as the moment has passed.
should have been, could have been & would have been are no different in terms
of my explanation of should have, could have and would have. You just attached
the be verb to those clauses in your question. At that rate you'd have people answering
how should go is different from should have gone, etc.
Should, would and could are modal verbs that fall into one of two
categories, epistemic or deontic. Don't worry about remembering the
words deontic or epistemic.
The context of a situation helps you know if a word is epistemic or deontic. The hard
part is knowing the difference.
"It should rain soon, at least that's what the weather forecast says." (likelihoodbased
on former knowledge)
"You're their father, so you should teach your children some manners."
(obligation based on a belief)
The past tense of these don't change the meaning. I'll just assume you're asking for a
context for them.
"I would have gone out last night, but I didn't have a stitch to wear."
(referring to the past tense likelihood / lack thereof of him going out and confirming
the fact that he didn't go out)
"I could have loaned you some nice clothes to wear, Morrissey."
(referring to the ability the subject had to loan his nice clothes out to his friend
Morrissey, had he mentioned needing clothes)
Note that a should have (verb) _____ sentence is not the same tense as a should
have (noun)____ sentence.
Have is such a versatile verb and in the should have clause it just changes should
from future or present to past tense.
For example, if I say "You should have enough time to make it to the post office, it's
open until 5pm," --that sentence has nothing to do with the past tenseexpression of
likelihood.
The have in the sentence is the operative verb, and it's followed by a noun, in this case
the word time.
So that's why you might see a sentence like "I should have had more time to work on
that project, but the boss was being strict about the deadline."
Isn't that weird? Present tense and past tense of have are right next to each other. That
is where the should have clause can express expectation or belief in the past tense
while also using the verb have.
Believing something is often a continuous act. "I should exercise more," and "I should
have exercised more," are different tenses referring to different times, but
the should part of both of them could be a belief that you just formed presently.
P.S. You will never see the words should, could or would and had next to each other,
as in "should had" --that much is incorrect.
When I was younger, I could run a mile in 7 minutes. Now it takes me 20 minutes!
“Yes, I’ve got a few ideas. I could put advertisements on Facebook and Google.
We could also give out pamphlets in our neighbourhood. Maybe John couldeven
contact local TV stations.”
Should have, Could have & Would have are used to describe lost
opportunities
Should Have: Use should have to say that a different action was
recommended in the past.
“I should have left my house earlier”
Would Have: Use would have to imagine a result (if something had
been different in the past):
“If we had reached earlier, we would have caught the train.”
I would try to explain the difference between could have been, would have been &
should have been using the following examples:
1. “I would have been there for your engagement dinner but I was sick in bed with
the flu.” This shows that you intended to be there but something
came up that prevented you from going.
2. “I could have been graduating next month but I had to drop out of school for a
semester.” So, you were on track to graduate but a circumstances
beyond your control prevented that from actually happening.
3. “I should have paid more attention to my English teacher but I was
daydreaming too much.” This shows that you knew you were supposed
to pay closer attention, but just weren’t focused enough on that
task.
Hope it’s useful!
7.1k Views · View Upvoters · Answer requested by Ashok Choyal, Gavin D'Souza, and 2 more
Sandeep Manudhane, English is a good idea. As peculiar, at times even worse, than the rest.
Answered Jul 13, 2016 · Author has 393 answers and 5.6m answer views
India would be happy to see the Chinese break up their useless all-weather friendship
with Pakistan.
India would have never supported China's permanent seat candidature in UNSC had
we the faintest notion of the way things have turned out.
India's global bargaining position would have been very strong today.
India, given its democratic traditions, should have been helped by the big powers.
But unfortunately, just like all lessons in grammar, India's journey to a peaceful but
feared big power status has become long and tortuous.
1. Would
a. As past of will :
>He said he would be away for a couple of days.
>I tried my best but she just wouldn’t leave.
g. To give advice :
>I wouldn’t drink that if I were you!
>I wouldn’t even give it a second thought if I were in your shoes!
>You would be better off to accept that handsome offer.
h. Making a guess:
>I would imagine they’re at the airport by now.
>I suppose you would find the book boring.
k. Expressing regret :
In the capacity of an expression of regret, would functions synonymous to the
word ‘wish’:
>Would that my brother had lived to witness this proud moment.
>Would I were the captain, I’d have led the team to victory.
2. Could
3. Should
a. to express obligation (things that are good or important for people to do)
Here, should works as a softer form of must.
>Everyone should wear seat belts.
>One should respect one’s parents.
c. with if-clauses
Here should works in the capacity of ‘happen to’
>If you should run into James, tell him he owes me money! = If you happen to run into
James, tell him he owes me money!
> If you should pass a supermarket, do buy some cereal.= If you happen to pass a
supermarket, do buy some cereal.
And now on to the perfect and past conditionals : would have, could have,
should have, would have been, could have been, should have been.
4. would have
Form : would have + past participle (V3)
e.g. would have eaten, would have taken etc.
a. for prediction about an imaginary past situation
(we use would have to imagine the outcome of an imaginary past situation if it were to
actually take place)
>Life in the middle ages was terrible; you would have hated it.
>I’m glad you left him when you had the chance else he would have cheated you.
(Note: It’s important in this last sentence to make a distinction
betweencould have and would have because, “I’m glad you left him when
you had the chance else he could have cheated you”, is also possible.)
The point to appreciate is that while could have is used to express past ability and past
possibility (refer point 4.b below), would have is more concerned with the outcome. In
the sentence the speaker is emphasising the outcome which is “…he would have cheated
you.”
5. could have
Form : could have + past participle (V3)
e.g. could have seen, could have watched etc.
a. unrealised past ability and missed opportunity
We use could have when people feel they had the ability to become someone or
something but they couldn't turn that into a reality.
>I could have become a singer but I had to study law.
Also, if an opportunity has been missed to do something that was possible, we use could
have:
>I could have boarded the train, but I was late to get there.
b. to criticise someone
When someone didn’t do something that was the right or better course of action, we
use could have to present the criticism:
>He could have saved some money but he wasted it on pointless things.
>You could have made something of your life had you studied harder.
>“The Government could have lowered the taxes but no sir it did not!”
6. should have
Form : should have + past participle(V3)
should have come, should have taken etc.
a. if somebody didn't do something that was important
>Jenny should have gone to the doctor but she didn’t.
(Perhaps this was important and could deteriorate her medical condition)
>I should have studied harder at school.
(maybe the present struggle in higher studies or the calling is making this realisation
dawn.)
You may refer to this video of mine wherein I take up the perfect conditionals in detail,
with simple explanation and examples:
>I would have been starving myself for nothing had you not shared such an effective
diet plan. OR
>If you hadn’t shared such an effective diet plan, I would have been starving myself for
nothing.
(Note: Once again, the difference between would have been and could have
been remains that could have been is used when thinking of the past possibility or
ability or lost opportunity. Would have been, on the other hand is used when the
imaginary outcome is more prior in the mind.
>I could've been on the plane if it weren’t for the traffic jam. (thinking of the lost
opportunity)
>I would've been on the plane if it weren’t for the traffic jam. (this time thinking of the
imaginary outcome i.e. sitting on the plane)
Phew! And that’s that! Have tried to be as exhaustive as possible. Apologies upfront for
any slips. Cheers! :)
1.4k Views · View Upvoters
Parul Geete, It's only words, and words are all I have To take your heart away. :P
Answered Feb 24, 2015 · Author has 75 answers and 378.9k answer views
Originally Answered: What is the difference between "would have, could have, should have, and might
have"?
Should have, could have, and might have are sometimes called “modals of lost
opportunity” because they describe situations when we are imagining that the past was
different than present may be good or bad.
Example :
If you arrive late to English class, you can say:
“I should have left my house earlier.”
If you regret an argument, you can say:
“I shouldn't have yelled at you yesterday. I’m sorry.”
You can also use should have / shouldn't have to tell other people that a
different action in the past would have been better.
If your son fails a test, you can say:
“You should have studied. You shouldn't have played video games all
weekend.”
2. Could Have
Use could have to talk about possibilities if something had been different in the past.
Example :
someone who didn't go to college can say:
“If I had gone to college, I could have gotten a better job.”
When talking about a gymnast who didn't win a competition, you can say:
“She could have won the gold medal if she hadn't fallen three times.”
Could have is often used with “if + had + past participle” (If I had gone / if she
hadn't fallen) – these “if” phrases express the imaginary past situation.
However, in some cases you can use could have without the “if” phrase.
Imagine you’re driving with a person who makes a dangerous maneuver on the
road. You can say:
“Are you crazy? We could have gotten into an accident.”
3. Would Have
Use would have to imagine a result (if something had been different in the past)
Example:
If you arrive late at the airport and miss your flight, you can say:
“If we had arrived earlier, we would have caught our flight.”
If you forget your umbrella, and it starts to rain, and you get wet, you can say:
“If I had brought my umbrella, I wouldn't have gotten wet in the rain.”
Would have expresses more certainty about the result than could have:
“If I had worked harder, I could have gotten a promotion.”
(maybe I’d get a promotion… but maybe not)
On a test where you need 70% to pass:
“I got a 68 on the test. If I had gotten two more points, I would havepassed.”
(with the two points, passing the test is CERTAIN)
Could have + past participle - Something was possible in the past, or you
had the ability to do something in the past, but you didn't do it.
I could have stayed up late, but I decided to go to bed early.
Should have + past participle - Something that would have been a good
idea, but you didn't do it or something that we think has already happened, but
we're not certain about it.
I should have gone to bed early.
Ask
Related Questions
How can I determine when to use had, have, had been, etc.?
When should I use "has been", "have been" and "had been"?