Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
net/publication/267155848
CITATIONS READS
3 236
1 author:
Jonathan Wardle
University of Technology Sydney
129 PUBLICATIONS 864 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Examining the interface between complementary medicine and rural primary practice View project
Examining ways to address vaccine hesitancy in health conscious sub-populations View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Jonathan Wardle on 21 October 2014.
Put simply, hydrotherapy, also called hydrothermal One of the first Australian natural medicine texts of
therapy or medical hydrology, is the use of water, in any description was a hydrotherapy text (Hydropathy; or
any of its forms, for the maintenance of health or the the system of effecting cures by means of cold water, a
treatment of disease. Balneotherapy is a branch of this text describing and translating Priessnitz’s work by R.T.
therapy that specifically studies baths and their medical Claridge) originally published in London in 1843 but
uses, with a large focus on the healing aspects of various locally published in Launceston in 1846. By 1861 a water
mineral contents (though this itself used to be a sub- cure sanatorium had been established in Melbourne (La
branch called crenology, which was limited to the science Moile 1861). In 1867 areas around Daylesford and
and use of mineral spring waters). Thalassotherapy is Hepburn Springs were set aside as the Mineral Springs
another branch which refers to the use of seawater and Reserve to protect the health giving properties of the
seascapes for healing. mineral waters from encroaching mining developments,
the first reserve of its type in Australia (Wishart and
History Wishart 1990).
The use of water therapeutically is nearly as old Early Australian naturopathic journals such as Nature
as medicine itself. The Riga Veda describes simple Cure and Medical Freedom (1924-1927), Nature’s Path
hydrotherapy treatments, noting that “water cures the to Health (1930-1950) and Australian Naturopath (1936-
fever’s glow”, and water used for healing was also 1961) extensively covered hydrotherapy treatments.
described in biblical records. Hippocrates extensively Hydrotherapy, like physical medicine and manipulative
described hydrotherapy in his writings and was effusive therapies, was a core part of Australian naturopathic
in his praise, noting that “for the bath soothes the pain education practice until naturopathic scope was
in the side, chest and back; cuts the sputum, promotes compromised by the introduction of the National Health
expectoration, improves the respiration, and allays Training Package which reduced naturopathic training to
lassitude: for it soothes the joints and outer skin, and is herbal and nutritional medicine. This was largely to allow
diuretic, removes the heaviness of the head, and moistens colleges to seek accreditation in the vocational education
the nose” (Hippocrates 1955). Hippocrates viewed the sector which could not accommodate the complexities of
application of water for healing as an essential component broad scope naturopathic practice. This move may have
of his regimen, along with diet, exercise, manipulation been motivated more by the financial gain to colleges
and herbs. Uses of ‘gushes of water’ or ‘water cure’ are of attracting increased student numbers (due to students
documented extensively in Roman, Greek and Arabic at vocationally accredited colleges being eligible for
medicine texts (Boyle and Saine 1988). King Henry’s Austudy payments) than it was by the improvement of
Herbalist Charter also points to the use of water for the the quality or level of naturopathic training (Wardle et al.
treatment of diseases in 16th century England. 2011). In the mid-1990s most, but not all, naturopathic
However no therapeutic discipline has been as training institutions in Australia still taught hydrotherapy
influenced by hydrotherapy as the naturopathic profession. and training was retained in some university programs.
Although naturopathy grew from and inherited the In all nations except Australia, these modalities (physical
traditions of various therapeutic schools (such as the medicine and hydrotherapy) have not been lost but
Eclectics and Thompsonian herbal medicine traditions), remain an essential part of naturopathic practice and are
it was the Nature Cure movement and hydrotherapy recognised as such by the World Health Organization
practice which most influenced early naturopathy and other accreditation authorities (Chaitow 2008; Baer
(Whorton 2004). In Australia too, hydrotherapy had a and Sporn 2009).
strong influence on the nascent naturopathic profession
(Martyr 2002). However the tradition of hydrotherapy Benefits
practice has diminished considerably. The failure of Australian naturopathic practice to
retain hydrotherapy in practice and education has been
Hydrotherapy in Australian naturopathic a great loss as hydrotherapy conveys numerous benefits
practice in treatment. Hydrotherapy abides by the underlying
principles of naturopathic practice far more readily than Hydrotherapy elicits these responses through a
many other therapeutic modalities as, unlike herbal and variety of techniques. These include: application of
nutritional medicines which are considered drugs (albeit water to the body with hands accompanied by light
natural ones), it is completely drugless. It uses only water rubbing (ablutions); application of water in the form of
as a means to support the body’s own healing processes, a gentle pour (affusions); application of falling water
largely through the manipulation of circulation. ‘at some force’ so mechanical pressure effects are also
Additionally, hydrotherapy is a therapy which can offer elicited (douches); ‘mid-range’ falling water application
therapeutic benefit for little financial cost to the patient. (showers); diffused shower (sprays); application of cool
The therapy itself is often free and most patients already to cold wet towelling surrounded by an insulating layer
have the requisite equipment in their homes. After initial (compress or wet packs); application of warm to hot wet
prescription of a therapeutic regime, hydrotherapy is towelling surrounded by insulating layer (compress or
a practice the patient can continue at home without a fomentations); submersion of some part of the body in
practitioner or expensive supplements. water (baths); and exposure of all or part of the body to
As such, hydrotherapy is ideal in instances where steam (steam vapours).
patients may have an affinity for naturopathic treatment Cleansing and detoxification are thought to be
but are limited by available resources or access issues. encouraged via a number of mechanisms. These include:
Such an example is in rural practice where patients often increased kidney clearance via increased water intake;
seek naturopathic treatment but are unable to comply increased removal of blood impurities through the liver
with complex regimes that require ready access to clinics and kidneys by encouraging blood circulation; aiding
and dispensaries (Wardle et al. 2010; Wardle et al. 2012). excretion through sweating (which also occurs when
Similarly, hydrotherapy treatments are ideal for patients underwater); and promotion of detoxification through
who simply may not be able to afford naturopathic chemical mediators in the case of balneotherapy (for
treatments or supplements; it is often these patients example via the effects of various bath salts or minerals)
(Boyle and Saine 1988).
who could benefit most from naturopathic treatment.
Hydrotherapy treatments may therefore provide Thermic application effects
opportunities for new patient groups to experience the
Different types of thermic applications have different
benefits of naturopathic treatment, in addition to offering types of physiological effects. Generally speaking, heat
practitioners an extra tool in their therapeutic toolkit. relaxes and sedates while cold stimulates, invigorates
Mechanism and tonifies (see Table 1). However, prolonged cold can
be depressive and seductive, while high temperatures can
Hydrotherapy and hydrothermal therapy are chiefly
stimulate and also be destructive.
used to tone the body. Most therapeutic benefits result
simply from improved circulation which in turn has
numerous therapeutic benefits. Through this mechanism, Table 1: The effects of different types of
hydrotherapy encourages the body’s innate healing hydrotherapy application (adapted from Blake
mechanisms by encouraging increased nutrition and 2008)
healing precursors via improved blood supply as well as Circulation Metabolism
encouraging elimination of waste. This simple mechanism
has a broad clinical application, with hydrotherapy being Short hot application ↑ ↑
traditionally used to stimulate digestion, circulation Long hot application ↓ ↑
and the immune system, relieve pain, reduce stress,
Short cold application ↑ ↑
rejuvenate the body (through affecting the skin and
muscles), as well as tone the lungs, heart, stomach, and Long cold application ↓ ↓
Principles of ‘blood movement’ in peak popularity in the early 20th century (see Table 2
hydrotherapy for research examples), there has been little further
physiological research into hydrotherapy effects.
To promote healing either locally or systemically,
hydrotherapy treatments aim to maximise circulation Balneotherapy
of well-oxygenated, nutrient-rich blood which also has There is emerging evidence that the mineral content
the effect of carrying away metabolic and other waste of various waters does have specific physiological effects
products. The rate of blood flow and blood volume can which translate into differing effectiveness outcomes
be either increased or decreased through specific organs (see Tables 3 and 4). For example, in a randomised trial
or areas of the body. The major ways in which this is of tap water versus (sulphur containing) mineral water
controlled are listed in Table 2. It should also be noted for low back-pain it was found that mineral containing
that beyond research conducted during hydrotherapy’s waters were more effective, though improvements were
Revulsive Increases blood flow to organ or area. Marked Contrast hydrotherapy (6 mins hot, 4 mins cold
stimulation of local circulation. Ideal for treating (Woodmansey et al. 1938); 4 mins hot, 1 min
conditions primarily presenting as congestion cold (Krusen 1941) x 3 applications)
(e.g. hot/cold compress for sinus congestion)
Derivative Moves blood from one area to another (e.g. Prolonged use of cold or heat to draw blood into
cold compress to the forehead or back of an area (heat) or drive blood out of an area (cold)
neck for congestive headache; hot foot bath to
increase blood flow to feet)
Spinal Cord/Reflex areas Individual reflex areas (e.g. oesophageal Local application to affect distant area
function influenced by irritation of skin over
sternum (Payne and Poulton 1927); externally
applied heat decreases intestinal blood flow as
well as diminishes motility and acid secretion
in stomach, while cold increases (Bing and
Tobiassen 1936)
Collateral circulation Special case of derivative effect – acts on Hot application dilates surface vessels, drawing
superficial arteries to affect deeper branches blood and decreasing flow to deeper branches.
Cold has the opposite effect
Arterial trunk reflex Arterial trunk reflex effect Prolonged cold applied over trunk causes
constriction to AT and distal branches. Heat has
the opposite effect
Table 3: Biological and physiological effects of various water applications (adapted from Karagülle
2006)
Sulphur Water Balneotherapy Thermomineral Balneotherapy Tap Water Hydrotherapy
Immuno-modulatory ++ ? ?
Anti-inflammatory ++ ++ +
Antioxidant + + ?
Release of β endorphin ? + ?
Analgesic +++ ++ +
Muscle relaxant +++ ++ +
Fibromyalgia ↑↑↑ ↑↑ ?↑
Contrast showers basin containing ice water. Wring out the towel from
Contrast showers are traditionally used to stimulate the ice water and place on the back of the neck while
vitality and promote detoxification, as well as treat soaking the feet in the basin of hot tap water. Leave for
generalized areas of pain and soreness. By alternating 20 minutes. If this does not bring relief then soak one
between hot and cold water while showering, the patient towel in the hot water. Place the hot wrung towel on
stimulates their body to heat itself up and cool itself the back of the neck and soak the feet in the basin of
down in order to counteract the external stimulus. This ice water for 20 minutes.
temperature contrast helps strengthen and normalize • Tension headache
the nervous, circulatory, endocrine, musculoskeletal Fill one basin with ice water and one basin with hot
and immune systems (Goedsche et al. 2007) and is water (no more than 46°C). Soak one towel in each
also thought to be excellent for helping the body cope basin. Wring out hot towel and place on the back of
with physiological and psychological stress (Boyle and the neck for 3 minutes. Remove this towel and replace
Saine 1988). One German study of medical students also it with the iced towel for 30 seconds. The hot and cold
demonstrated that regular use of a cold shower alone applications should be repeated three times each.
had a progressively beneficial effect on immune system • Sinus headache
function (Ernst 1990). The same process should be used as for tension
Directions: headache but the wrung towels placed over the sinuses
• After a normal hot shower, gradually turn down the rather than on the back of the neck. This is an example
hot water until the shower is pleasantly cool or cold; of the hot and cold alternating compress.
rinse the whole body under the cooler water for about Colonic hydrotherapy
1 minute. It would be remiss to discuss hydrotherapy without
• If there are localised areas of pain or soreness focus discussing colonic hydrotherapy. Although colonic
the shower stream on these areas. hydrotherapy (also known as colonic irrigation) is
• Next, switch the shower back to hot to rewarm the amongst the most well known hydrotherapy treatments,
body for 3-5 minutes. Repeat the cycle 3-5 times and its modern use as a detoxifying agent and preventive
end with cool water. measure belies its traditional use in naturopathic
• It is important that the hot phase is longer than the cold hydrotherapy. Traditional texts warn that enemas ‘should
and that the process is finished with cool water. not be abused’, that they are ‘remedial, not preventive
• After the final cool rinse, the patient should dry off or strengthening’, and that practitioners should ‘reserve
quickly, rubbing briskly with a cold towel to stimulate their use for well-indicated clinical situations, which
the rewarming process. As a sign of increased are largely limited to constipation, impacted faeces or
peripheral circulation, the skin may turn transiently distension suspected to be caused by faeces’ (Boyle and
pink afterwards. Saine 1988). Similarly, whilst there does appear to be
• It is also important to note that sharper contrasts in some evidence for the use of colonic irrigation in the
temperature between the hot and cold phases increases treatment of defecation disorders (Gosselink et al. 2005;
the therapeutic benefit. As the patient gets used to Koch et al. 2008), there is limited evidence for other
treatment, they can increase the intensity by varying conditions or for preventive use, though some patients do
the speed and degree of the temperature change. report temporary benefit (Tod et al. 2007).
Hydrotherapy for headaches There may also be significant risks with excessive or
Headaches are often caused by muscle tension or unnecessary use of colon hydrotherapy. Injuries caused
temporary changes in blood circulation in the brain. by treatment have resulted in conditions such as life-
The muscle tension that can lead to headaches may threatening perineal gangrene or comparatively benign,
be triggered by stress, joint misalignment in the neck but nonetheless debilitating and unpleasant, abscesses
or jaw, emotional factors, or poor posture. Chemical (Tan and Cheong 1999; Ratnaraja and Raymond 2005).
reactions (including food allergies), poor blood sugar Physiological examination has even suggested that
regulation, hormonal changes, alcohol and fatigue may the process of colonic irrigation may in fact introduce
trigger headaches caused by increased blood flow, as and increase exposure to toxins rather than serving
vasoactive compounds expand cerebral blood vessels. as a detoxifying agent, and, similar to laxative abuse,
Application of hot and cold water to change blood flow excessive use may reduce the ability of patients to perform
and release muscle tension has long been traditionally defecation without assistance (Seow-Choen 2009).
used to relieve headaches of both muscular and vascular Clinicians are free to use their personal judgement in
origin. Materials required consist of two small towels, determining whether colonic irrigation or hydrotherapy
two basins and an ice pack or tray of ice cubes in water. may be suitable for a patient, but they must perform
• Migraine or vascular headache this judgement in the knowledge that use for non-
Fill one basin with ice water and the other with hot acute presentations is neither supported by evidence
water (no more than 46°C). Soak one towel in the nor traditional use. Excessive or unnecessary use of
the therapy also poses significant risks and should only Chaitow L., Ed. 2008. Naturopathic Physical Medicine: Theory
be used when properly indicated. Detoxification and and Practice for Manual Therapists and Naturopaths. Edinburgh,
Churchill Livingstone.
elimination can be encouraged by a number of safer and
Ernst E. 1990. Hydrotherapy. Physiotherapy 76:4;207-210.
less invasive hydrotherapy techniques, in addition to Goedsche K., Förster M, et al. 2007. [Repeated cold water stimulations
other naturopathic treatments. (hydrotherapy according to Kneipp) in patients with COPD]. Forsch
Komplementmed 14:3;15-166.
Other treatments Gosselink M., Darby M, et al. 2005. Long-term follow-up of retrograde
In addition to the beginning treatments outlined, colonic irrigation for defaecation disturbances. Colorectal Dis 7:65-
69.
hydrotherapy texts outline numerous other treatment
Hippocrates 1955. On Regimen in Acute Diseases. Hippocratic Writings
types. The addition of herbs to hydrotherapy treatments [translated by Francis Adams]. Chicago, Encyclopaedia Britannica.
is an obvious example. One of the founding fathers of the Karagülle Z. 2006. Is balneotherapy more effective than hydrotherapy?
hydrotherapy therapeutic movement, Father Sebastian 4th Turkish-Hungarian Balneological Meeting (proceedings). 18-22
Kniepp, caused great consternation amongst his nature January 2006, Balçova, Turkey.
Kniepp S. 1896. My Water Cure. 4th English edition translated from
cure colleagues (who eschewed all drugs, natural and
36th German edition. Kempten, Kosel.
synthetic) when he began using ‘herb cure’ (primarily Koch S., Melenhorst J, et al. 2008. Prospective study of colonic
oat straw baths and herbal teas internally, particularly irrigation for the treatment of defaecation disorders. Br J Surg
nettles) to complement his ‘water cure’. Kniepp believe 95;1273-1279.
that “both cures, the interior and exterior, harmonise and Kräuchi K., Cajochen C, et al. 1999. Warm feet promote the rapid onset
of sleep. Nature 401:6748;36-37.
work together in unity” (Kniepp 1896 p122), though
Kräuchi K., Cajochen C, et al. 2000. Functional link between distal
he did caution that the gentlest application was always vasodilation and sleep-onset latency? Am J Physiol 278: R741-R748.
the best. Modern naturopathic hydrotherapy utilises a Krusen F. 1941. Physical medicine; the employment of physical agents
variety of herbal medicines to complement hydrotherapy for diagnosis and therapy. Philadelphia, WB Saunders.
application. La Moile M. 1861. Victoria water-cure establishment, Malvern hill,
near Toorak, conducted by M. La Moile. Melbourne, Clarson,
Constitutional hydrotherapy, a treatment that uses hot
Shallard &Co.
and cold applications with low-volt electrical sine-wave Martyr P. 2002. Paradise of Quacks: An Alternative History of Medicine
stimulation (Boyle and Saine 1988), was developed by in Australia. Sydney, Macleay Press.
US naturopathic physician Otis Carroll in the first half Payne W. and Poulton E. 1927. Experiments on visceral sensation:
the 20th century. Although commonly used by many Part I. The relation of pain to activity in the oesophagus. J Physiol
63:3;217-41.
naturopathic physicians, particularly in North America,
Ratnaraja N. and Raymond N. 2005. Extensive abscesses following
its therapeutic claims have not been tested. colonic hydrotherapy. Lancet Infect Dis 5:8;527.
Romeijn N., Raymann R, et al. 2012. Sleep, vigilance, and
Discussion thermosensitivity. Pflugers Arch 463:1;169-176.
Although commonly used in most naturopathic Seow-Choen F. 2009. The physiology of colonic hydrotherapy.
traditions, hydrotherapy remains a ‘lost art’ in Australian Colorectal Dis 11:7; 686-8.
naturopathic practice. This is unfortunate as it is a Tan M. and Cheong D. 1999. Life-threatening perineal gangrene from
rectal perforation following colonic hydrotherapy: A case report.
therapeutically valuable addition to any practitioner’s Ann Acad Med Singapore 28:4;583-585.
toolkit. However, the loss of hydrotherapy seems to be Tod A., Stringer E, et al. 2007. Rectal irrigation in the management of
an accidental one due largely to aligning naturopathic functional bowel disorders: A review. Br J Nurs 16;858-864.
education to an inappropriate accreditation model. Given Wardle J., Adams J, et al. 2010. A qualitative study of naturopathy
the reincorporation of naturopathic education into the in rural practice: A focus upon naturopaths’ experiences and
perceptions of rural patients and demands for their services BMC
higher education sector, a model far more accepting of Health Services Research 10;185.
naturopathic philosophy and practice and broader scope Wardle, J., C.-W. Lui, et al. 2012. Complementary and Alternative
of treatment, hydrotherapy is a therapy that could be Medicine in Rural Communities: Current Research and Future
easily re-instated into Australian naturopathic practice. Directions. Journal of Rural Health 28:1; 101-112.
Wardle J., Steel A, et al. 2011. A review of tensions and risks in
References naturopathic education and training in Australia: A need for
regulation. J Altern Comp Med 18:4;363-370.
Baer H. and Sporn S. 2009 Naturopathy around the world: Variations
and political dilemmas of an eclectic heterdox medical system. New Whorton J. 2004. Nature Cures: The History of Alternative Medicine in
York, Nova Science Publishers. America. New York, Oxford University Press.
Balogh Z., Ördögh J, et al. 2005. Effectiveness of balneotherapy Wishart E. and Wishart M. 1990. The spa country: A field guide to 65
in chronic low back pain-a randomized single-blind controlled mineral springs of the Central Highlands, Victoria. Melbourne, Spa
follow-up study. Forschende Komplementarmedizin 12:4;196-201. Publishing.
Bing H. and Tobiassen E. 1936. Viscerocutaneus and cutovisceral Woodmansey A., Collins D, et al. 1938. Vascular reactions to the contrast
abdominal reflexes. Acta Med Scand 78;824-833. bath in health and in rheumatoid arthritis. Lancet 232:6015;1350-
1354.
Blake E. 2008. Naturopathic hydrotherapy. Naturopathic Physical
Medicine: Theory and Practice for Manual Therapists and
Naturopaths. L. Chaitow. Edinburgh, Churchill Livingstone.
Boyle W. and Saine A. 1988. Lectures in naturopathic hydrotherapy.
Sandy, Eclectic Medical Press.