Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
2
June 2017
Cl inic a l Res ea rc h
Can glycated hemoglobin act as a reliable glycemic indicator in patients with diabetic
chronic kidney disease? evidence from the Northeast of Thailand
Sojib Bin Zaman,1,2,3 Naznin Hossain,4 Ahmed E. Rahman,3 Sheikh M.S. Islam5,6
1
Faculty of Public Health, Khon Kaen University, Khon Kaen, Thailand
2
Institute of Tropical Medicine and International Health, Charité – University Medicine Berlin, Berlin, Germany
3
Maternal and Child Health Division, International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research, Bangladesh (icddr,b), Dhaka, Bangladesh
4
Department of Pharmacology, Dhaka Medical College, Dhaka, Bangladesh
5
Faculty of Medicine, University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia
6
Cardiovascular Division, The George Institute for Global Health, Sydney, Australia
ABSTRAK ABSTRACT
Latar belakang: Penyakit ginjal kronis (PGK) adalah Background: Chronic kidney diseases (CKD) is a common
komplikasi yang sering terjadi pada penyandang diabetes microvascular complication in patients with diabetes
melitus (DM) yang membutuhkan kontrol kadar gula darah mellitus (DM) which requires adequate glycemic control.
(glikemik) yang adekuat. Glycated hemoglobin (HbA1c) Glycated hemoglobin (HbA1c) is a conventional biomarker
adalah penanda biologis konvensional untuk memperkirakan to estimate glycemic status, but its role in diabetic CKD
status glikemik, namun perannya pada pasien PGK akibat DM patients is unclear. Therefore, this study aimed to determine
masih belum jelas. Oleh karena itu, penelitian ini bertujuan whether patients with high HbA1c are associated to develop
untuk mengetahui apakah pasien dengan HbA1c tinggi diabetic CKD.
berhubungan dengan timbulnya PGK.
Methods: Data were obtained from a clinical registry of diabetic
Metode: Data diperoleh dari registri klinis pasien diabetes patients who were treated in a district hospital in the Northeast
yang dirawat di sebuah rumah sakit di sebelah timur laut of Thailand. CKD was defined according to the estimated
Thailand. CKD ditentukan berdasarkan perkiraan laju filtrasi glomerular filtration rate (eGFR<60mL/min/1.73m2).
glomerulus yaitu LFG<60mL/menit/1.73m2. Pengukuran Anthropometric and biochemical measurements of the patient
antropometri dan biokimia pasien diambil dari rekam medis. were taken by review of medical records. Multiple logistic
Analisis regresi logistik multipel digunakan untuk mengetahui regression analysis was used to determine the likelihood of the
kemungkinan hubungan antara HbA1c dan PGK. association between HbA1c and CKD.
Hasil: Dari 4.050 pasien DM, terdapat 1.027 (25,3%) Results: Among 4,050 participants, 1,027 (25.3%) developed
pasien yang memiliki PJK akibat DM. Usia yang lebih tua diabetic CKD. Older age (adjusted odds ratio (AOR): 4.88,
(adjusted odds ratio (AOR): 4,88, (95% CI: 3,71–6,42) p<0,05), 95% confidence interval (CI): 3.71–6.42, p<0.05), female
perempuan (AOR: 1,38, 95% CI: 1,05–1,73, p<0,05), dan (AOR: 1.38, 95% CI: 1.05–1.73, p<0.05), and hypertension
hipertensi (AOR: 1,52, 95% CI: 1,21–1,91, p<0,05) merupakan (AOR: 1.52, 95% CI: 1.21–1.91, p<0.05) were found as the
faktor risiko terjadinya PGK akibat DM. Akan tetapi, pasien risk factors of diabetic CKD. However, patients with high
dengan HbA1c tinggi (>6,5%) berhubungan terbalik dengan HbA1c (>6.5%) were negatively associated with diabetic
PGK akibat DM (AOR: 0,66, 95% CI: 0,51–0,86, p<0,05). CKD (AOR: 0.66, 95% CI: 0.51–0.86, p<0.05).
Kesimpulan: Penelitian ini menemukan pasien dengan Conclusion: This study found patients with higher HbA1c
HbA1c lebih tinggi tidak berkaitan dengan kejadian PGK level were not associated with diabetic CKD. Therefore,
akibat DM. Oleh karena itu, penggunaan nilai batas ambang using the conventional cut-off values of HbA1c in diabetic
HbA1c pada konvensional penderita PGK akibat DM tidak CKD patients may be problematic in the clinical settings.
dapat digunakan di klinis. Peningkatan upaya deteksi status Enhanced detection of glycemic status in patients with
glikemik pada pasien dengan PGK akibat DM perlu diperketat diabetic CKD is warranted to improve the outcome.
untuk meningkatkan luaran.
Copyright @ 2017 Authors. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0
International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and
reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are properly cited.
Chronic kidney disease (CKD) is a frequent the developing countries use HbA1c as a valid
microvascular complication among patients glycemic indicator, and contemporary guidelines
with diabetes mellitus (DM). CKD is considered advocate the same cut-off point of HbA1c to detect
to be the leading cause of renal failure1 with its glycemic status in CKD and non-CKD patients.16
high prevalence in South-East Asia.2 Thailand Therefore, it demands an attention to know
has experienced the epidemiological transition whether HbA1c can detect the accurate glycemic
for the recent years, and non-communicable status in patients with diabetic kidney disease.
diseases have come into the limelight to cause This study aimed to determine whether patients
significant morbidities and mortalities.3 Thailand with high HbA1c are more associated to develop
is also connected to the ‘stone belt’ zone which diabetic kidney disease in compared to patients
normally extends from Central Asia to South Asia.4 with low HbA1c.
Therefore, the rate of kidney disease is high in the
North-eastern Thailand.5 Although all diabetic
METHODS
patients are not at risk to develop CKD, minimal
damage to the kidney is frequent.6 Age, sex, race,
positive family history, and high blood pressure Data sources
are the known risk factors of diabetic CKD. Chronic A hospital-based retrospective data analysis was
hyperglycemia due to uncontrolled DM plays the performed between May 2016 and October 2016.
key role to initiate renal vascular complications.7 The data were collected from the clinical registry
However, a previous study reported that diabetic of diabetic patients which was obtained from a
kidney disease could develop with a relatively district hospital in the northeast of Thailand. This
short duration of diabetes.8 Adequate diabetic hospital is the secondary referral facility with
management and glycemic control are essential a catchment population of about 114,588. The
to prevent diabetic kidney disease and other study data represented one-year sample involving
complications.9 the yearly check-up investigation records of the
patients.
Glycated hemoglobin (HbA1c) is one of the
essential elements of human red blood cells Data collection
which acts like the conventional biomarker to This study has used the clinical registry to
estimate glycemia.10 HbA1c is usually developed collect the records of 4,050 patients who were
by the reduction of glucose with the amino enrolled between 1 January 2015 and 31
contents of beta chains in hemoglobin A. Thus, December 2015. Among the diabetic patients,
HbA1c can reflect glucose status of a person as far the number of CKD and non-CKD patients were
as the viability of erythrocyte remains active in 1,027 (25.3%) and 3,023 (74.7%) respectively.
the blood. One-time determination of high HbA1c Demographic information, biochemical reports,
means that glycemic status of a particular patient and anthropometric measurements were
was not under control for the last three to four extracted from the medical records. Age was
months. categorized into two sub-groups according to the
Thai retirement age.21 Occupation was classified
The prime target of diabetic care is to control as ‘farmer,’ ‘unemployment’ and ‘different jobs’
patient’s high glycemic which reiterates the among the participants. We collected the last
demands of using a valid test to detect accurate recording of HbA1c, LDL-cholesterol, and blood
glycemia in patients with diabetic CKD.11 pressure from laboratory investigation reports.
Traditionally, clinicians use HbA1c to measure Fasting blood samples were used to assess HbA1c
the glycemic status of a diabetic patient, assess and lipid profile levels. Physical measurements
the efficacy of treatment, and recommend the and blood pressure were recorded twice to
appropriate adjustments to lifestyle. Some minimize the observer error. The data entry was
studies have found that HbA1c might not predict done by a group of skilled data operator under the
the exact glycemia in CKD patients under the active supervision of a data management officer.
pathophysiological evidence.12–14 However,
these theoretical arguments have created some Ethical approval
controversies which need to be justified and The Ethical Committee of Khon Kaen University
proved in real life setting as well.15 Most of (KKU) approved this study (approval no.
http://mji.ui.ac.id
Zaman, et al. 105
Glycated hemoglobin in detecting diabetic kidney disease
estimator for the end stage of kidney disease level of parathyroid hormone. On the contrary,
patients.12–14 Based on the pathophysiological activities of hypersplenism can induce the
evidence, HbA1c can lose its credibility to measure process of red blood cell destruction. Therefore,
exact glycemia in diabetic CKD patients.12–14 There patients with an advanced stage of CKD develops
are strong possibilities that CKD creates renal anemia which causes the shorter lifespan of
uremia that modifies the longevity of erythrocytes erythrocyte. Consequently, normal hemoglobin
resulting in alteration of HbA1c component.21 might fail to indicate the exact glycemia.
Moreover, normal erythroid precursor cells fail Moreover, CKD patients receive iron, vitamin
to stimulate erythropoiesis due to the limited B12, blood transfusion, and other medications
response of bone marrow activity with a raised for the purpose of anemia correction. This sort
p value with χ2 test (categorical) or student t-test (continuous). SD= standard deviation; HbA1c= glycated hemmoglobin; BMI=
*
Table 2. Association of different risk factors with diabetic of treatment frequently increases the production
CKD (n=1,027) of immature red cells which subsequently alter
the original hemoglobin structure.22 The above
COR AOR
Characteristics
(95% CI) †
(95% CI)
mentioned multifaceted physiological changes
within the hemoglobin structure can compromise
Age
the accuracy to measure glycemia.20
≤60 years ref ref
>60 years 6.38 4.88 Blood glucose level can fall in a patient with
(5.28–7.70)* (3.71–6.42)* end-stage renal disease due to malnutrition
Sex along with decrease glucose production using
Male ref ref the gluconeogenesis pathway. Therefore,
physiological changes of insulin secretion occur
Female 1.22 1.38
(1.05–1.42)* (1.05–1.73)* for these CKD patients. Such insulin usually might
get extended half-life and destroy relatively more
Occupation
blood glucose in comparison to regular insulin.
Unemployed ref ref Moreover, alterations in insulin metabolism can
Farmer 0.54 0.90 shorten the lifetime of erythrocytes by changing
(0.44–0.67)* (0.65–1.23) the characteristics of the hemoglobin content
Different jobs 0.24 0.74 of red blood cells.22 A few studies also found
(0.15–0.26)* (0.49–1.11) that the survival of RBC usually decreases in
HbA1c patients who were on dialysis. Thus, increased
Optimal control ref ref destruction of erythrocyte might result in
producing low HbA1c values.22 Traditionally,
Poor control 0.67 0.66
(0.55–0.82)* (0.51–0.86)* most of the patients suffering from advanced
stages of CKD are prescribed with erythropoietin
Blood pressure
stimulating agents (ESA) by the clinicians. There
Normotensive ref ref
might be an inverse association of HbA1c with
Hypertensive 2.34 1.52 the introduction of erythropoietin medication.14
(2.00–2.74)* (1.21–1.91)* Application of these external ESA is responsible
LDL- cholesterol for increasing the production of RBC. These RBC
Normal ref ref get insufficient exposure time to go under the
High 1.05 1.14 glycosylation process which consequently might
(0.88–1.24) (0.88–1.47) lower the HbA1c concentration. Thus, the lower
BMI
HbA1c level can give a false impression regarding
the overall glycemic control.21
Normal ref ref
Overweight 0.69 0.73 The risk factors of diabetic CKD vary according
(0.58–0.81)* (0.58–0.93)
to geographical aspect, ethnicity, and racial
Obese 0.49 0.53 consideration.23 In our study, diabetic CKD was
(0.37–0.65)* (0.35–0.81) more prevalent in older ages (above 60 years)
Smoking which was similar to a previous communication.24
Non-smoker ref ref This study found that increased age could be a risk
Current-smoker 0.86 0.50
factor of renal insufficiency which might result due
(0.58–1.28) (0.20–1.24) to degenerative changes in the glomerular tissue.
According to this study, hypertensive diabetic
Alcohol Drinking
patients were 1.5 times more likely to develop
Non-drinker ref ref
CKD which supports a previous communication.
Current-drinker 1.13 2.15 Diabetic patients who were farmer or employed
(0.63–1.13) (0.77–5.97) showed decrease risk of CKD compared to those
who were unemployed. Therefore, patients
*p value <0.05; †= Adjusted for age, sex, occupation, LDL,
BMI, smoking, and alcohol drinking; COR= crude odds ratio; with high HbA1c level were not associated with
AOR= adjusted odds ratio; HbA1c= glycated hemoglobin; diabetic CKD in this study even after adjusted to
BMI= body mass index the risk factors.
http://mji.ui.ac.id
Zaman, et al. 107
Glycated hemoglobin in detecting diabetic kidney disease
diabetes mellitus type 2 and glycated haemoglobin Walker RJ. Assessment of markers of glycaemic control
as clinical reference in rural community primary care in diabetic patients with chronic kidney disease using
settings of a middle income country. BMC Public Health. continuous glucose monitoring. Nephrology (Carlton).
2012;12:349. 2012;17(2):182–8.
17. www.who.int [Internet]. Use of glycated haemoglobin 21. Agarwal R, Light RP. Relationship between
(HbA1c) in diagnosis of diabetes mellitus: abbreviated glycosylated hemoglobin and blood glucose during
report of a WHO consultation. [update 2011; cited progression of chronic kidney disease. Am J Nephrol.
May 2017]. Available form: http://www.who.int/ 2011;34(1):32–41.
cardiovascular_diseases/report-hba1c_2011_edited.pdf 22. Ly J, Marticorena R, Donnelly S. Red blood cell survival in
18. Levey AS, Coresh J, Balk E, Kausz AT, Levin A, Steffes chronic renal failure. Am J Kidney Dis. 2004;44(4):715–9.
MW, et al. National Kidney Foundation practice 23. Zaman SB. Importance of learning the public health
guidelines for chronic kidney disease: evaluation, leadership. Public Health Indones. 2017;3(1):1–3.
classification, and stratification. Ann Inter Med. 24. Srivanichakorn S, Sukpordee N, Yana T, Sachchaisuriya
2003;139(2):137–47. P, Schelp FP. Health status of diabetes type 2 patients
19. Levey AS, Stevens LA, Schmid CH, Zhang YL, Castro AF, in Thailand contradicts their perception and admitted
Feldman HI, et al. A new equation to estimate glomerular compliance. Prim Care Diabetes. 2011;5(3):195–201.
filtration rate. Ann Inter Med. 2009;150(9):604–12. 25. Islam S, Rawal L. Setting HbA1c targets for patients with
20. Vos FE, Schollum JB, Coulter CV, Manning PJ, Duffull SB, type 2 diabetes. J Diabetol. 2015;2:5.
http://mji.ui.ac.id