Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
dialogue
report
STOCKHOLM, SWEDEN
JUNE 12, 2018
Presentations ......................17
ALL CONFERENCE
MATERIALS ARE
AVAILABLE HERE
the dialogue
The Stockholm Dialogue on the
Nexus between Human Rights,
Environmental Sustainability and
Conflict Prevention took place in
Stockholm on 12 June 2018.
A growing body of evidence shows that healthy ecosystems help sustain and
foster peace and security. For example, poor governance leading to land
degradation, deforestation and water shortage, which can be drivers of conflict
and migration. And inequitable sharing of revenues and other benefits from oil,
4
DIALOGUE REPORT
NEXT STEPS
UNDP, the Swedish Environmental Protection Agency, UN Environment, the
Folke Bernadotte Academy, and partners will continue to deliver support to
meet country needs through already existing programmes, initiatives, and
communities of practices to advance integrated approaches to Natural
Resource Management.
5
DIALOGUE REPORT
This session, comprising four panel presentations and four respondents, provided an
overview of challenges and opportunities in applying integrated approaches to
promote sustainability and peace. It focused on examples of how governments, the
private sector, and other actors have contributed to conflict prevention and
sustainable development by integrating human rights, and environmental
sustainability in the governance of the extractive sector.
Panel Presentation 2: Peace and Environment. Jimena Puyana, National Manager for
Sustainable Development, UNDP Colombia; and César Jerez, leader of Rural Peasant
Reserve Zones presented the Colombian “Peace and Environment” programme.
Panel Presentation 3: Weaving SDG 16 and human rights principles into the post-
2020 global biodiversity framework. Presenter: Dr Claudia Ituarte-Lima,
Environmental lawyer, and researcher, Swedbio, Stockholm Resilience Centre.
Tim Scott, Senior Policy Advisor on Environment, UNDP; and Alexander Verbeek, Stockholm Dialogue Facilitator (Left); Massaran
Traoré, Executive Director, International Alert Mali (Center); and Dalia Marquez, Venezuela, UN MCGY as Global Focal Point of
Sustainable Consumption and Production, Latin American and Caribbean Engagement Mechanism of Civil Society (Right).
6
DIALOGUE REPORT
Key messages:
Martin Eriksson, Director of the Swedish Environmental Protection Agency (Left); Kaluki Mutuku, University of Nairobi, Kenya; and
Aumeer Rookayah, Educator, Ministry of Education and Human Resources, Tertiary Education and Scientific Research, Mauritius,
in an interview with Åsa Borssén (Center); Alexander Verbeek, Stockholm Dialogue Facilitator (Right).
7
DIALOGUE REPORT
Panel Presentation 2: Lessons from the oil for development programme: Ingunn
Kroksnes, Senior Adviser with the Norwegian Agency for Development Cooperation
(NORAD) presented Norway’s Oil for Development programme, which aims at
supporting economically, environmentally and socially responsible management of
petroleum resources in 12 countries based on the Norwegian experience.
Panel Presentation 3: Water, Human Rights, and Mining: Chris McCombe of the
International Council on Mining and Metals (ICMM) presented on the topic of water,
human rights and mining from the perspective of the ICMM, a coalition of 27 mining
companies.
8
DIALOGUE REPORT
Key messages:
Panel illustrating key messages from the Stockholm Dialogue by Terese Ellnestam, graphic recorder/facilitator.
High-resolution panel available here.
9
DIALOGUE REPORT
Key messages:
*Carlier, Leon & Xavier, The Third National Conference on Participatory Environmental
Monitoring and Surveillance, Canadian International Resources Development
Institute (CIRDI), 2016. Available at: https://cirdi.ca/wp-
content/uploads/2017/04/Report-of-the-3rd-CMVAP-
conference_Final_Apr_12_2017.pd
10
DIALOGUE REPORT
Key messages:
Reinforcing the rule of law is at the centre of the UN Sustaining Peace Agenda,
and - like human rights-based approaches - is vital to ensuring strong and
accountable institutions that can be an effective pillar in preventing violent
conflict and guaranteeing a fair and equitable distribution of resources.
The self-assessment tool has been developed with a focus on mining sector
performance in government agencies. It is a practical tool that draws directly on
the experiences and insights of the staff of the agency granting environmental
and mining licenses and the users (communities affected by LSM projects such as
smallholders, farmers, re-settled communities as well as mining rights’
holders/small-scale and artisanal mining affected by LSM projects) to outline
recommendations for mining sector reform from a rule of law perspective.
The toolkit complements other toolkits such as the World Bank’s Mining Sector
Diagnostic (MSD) and the Mining Policy Framework (MPF). Where it differs is
mainly on its focus on individual users and their interactions with mining sector
regulatory bodies from a specific rule of law and human rights perspective. Plans
are underway to combine ROLPA-M and MSD for a pilot joint assessment in one or
more countries.
Evidence from research and pilot assessments have shown that although rule of
law principles might be incorporated into laws, they are often not sufficiently put
into practice.
In addition to conflict prevention safeguards, it is critical to address wider
implications of institutional and capacity deficits in the justice and natural
resources sectors; conflict sensitivity is not only dependent on technical assistance
adapted to local context - but also on political engagement.
11
DIALOGUE REPORT
The pilot assessments have shown that key elements of participation - such as
consultation, active engagement, oversight, and accountability - are not included
comprehensively. Participation is mandatory by law, but no penalties are
envisaged. As a result, public hearings have a low impact. Due to various
grievances from communities, referendums to prohibit mining are becoming
popular (e.g. Colombia).
Trust in the effectiveness of complaint mechanisms is low, thus creating a
potential for escalating social grievances and conflict.
Mining formalization is a challenge that requires the state to strengthen its
capacity to respond to the environmental and social needs of some territories (eg.
Colombia).
Possible recommendations for actions deriving from the assessments include:
updating and reforming policies or legislation; improving implementation of
existing policies and laws; building the capacities of agency staff; increasing
accountability mechanisms; and improving outreach and communication with
affected communities. Each of these follow-up actions can also integrate gender-
responsive considerations.
Implementing recommendations requires different approaches (e.g. addressing
structural, institutional or capacity-related challenges). Following up on results,
such as designing action plans with implementation milestones, detailed roles
and responsibilities within each agency unit on the allocation of tasks and clearly
defined and realistic objectives based on available resources are essential.
Creating an enabling environment for leadership and agency staff to engage
more actively can encourage ownership.
The assessment and subsequent action plans can help distinguish between
problems which the agency can address on its own, and problems that require the
involvement of other multi-level stakeholders participating in the self-assessment.
Highlighting difficulties related to regional or national level control and guidance
can strengthen advocacy.
In summary:
There are many policy implementation gaps and what is on paper does often not
reflect what happens in practice.
What do we do when the structures and institutions are not in place, in particular
at local levels?
Core performance issues need to be addressed through dialogue with national
partners and stakeholders.
The ROLPA-M toolkit can help governments to prioritize where to start bridging
these gaps.
Access to basic information is needed to make sure communities are empowered.
The process is as important as the results.
12
DIALOGUE REPORT
13
DIALOGUE REPORT
It is also important for companies and industries to go beyond training their own
staff to also engage in the surrounding communities. International Alert Mali has
done research on CSR policies of endeavor mining in Tabakoto in Mali: oversight of
communities in decision-making regarding resources allocation, opportunities,
and modes of operation.
People are generally open to talk about gender. A more difficult issue relates to
class. Hearing someone from another part of community/society articulating the
“right” priorities is a challenge. Intersectionality is a core concept that needs to be
considered.
The question about power is also at the core of it. Here we need to address power
at different levels. There are multiple layers of power within power that we need to
understand. Local empowerment and the voice of the community is a start. Both
visibility and integration are pivotal.
14
DIALOGUE REPORT
It featured young people’s stories from the field, include a presentation on Youth,
Peace and Security and the role of Youth in SDG implementation, and links to
environmental governance. It aimed to identify relevant youth-friendly and youth-
inclusive knowledge platforms and tools and discuss existing and new entry points
for policy, programming and partnerships.
Key messages:
There are about 1,8 billion young people on the planet. This is not a minority target
group! In some countries, 80 percent of the population is below 30.
Youth are oftentimes seen as a threat, but we need to recognize youth as a
positive force and contributors.
Youth can and do contribute actively to peacebuilding. Young people often see
and understand complex interlinkages as reflected in their lived reality, and have
good communication and ICT skills. Youth contribute to gather and share
information on environmental problems, through apps, GIS mapping, and
hackathons that can contribute to governance processes and early warning
systems.
For example, Venezuelan youth use an app to record public sanitary problems and
pollution to drinking water. Kenyan youth used GIS to share data on waste
littering. There is also a Kenyan GIS mapping tool on coal mines in Africa, that can
be used to better inform communities. In Sweden, there is the annual Hack for
Sweden. The event, organized by SEPA and other government agencies,
incentivizes youth to generate ICT solutions to environmental problems and
support innovation and participation.
It is important to give young people an active role and specific tasks, in the
implementation of Agenda 2030, to use their creativity.
Youth organizations can improve their advocacy efforts by having dedicated
Government contacts, networking across sub-national territories, and
internationally, and with veterans and experts from other fields.
Administrative hurdles to participation in global fora need to be overcome, e.g.
troubles getting visas to participate in international meetings. It is important to
scale up existing university initiatives and to encourage young professions within
universities to share their expertise and contribute to peacebuilding.
15
DIALOGUE REPORT
Involve the youth early, i.e. when making laws, not only when are being
implemented. Also, give youth a specific role.
Create networks for young professionals so that young people can bring about
change.
Make it easier for them to access funding.
Remove barriers in governments in terms of communication channels.
Ensure transparent emission of the ideas young people put forward.
Create a space to engage and include the youth in global dialogues.
Set up more communication channels with the government for young people.
And finally: We have a lot to learn from the youth and youth groups!
16
DIALOGUE REPORT
17