Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
A Newsletter to the Church 12 issues each year for $22 Volume 3 Issue 4, April, 2001
Bush kills Kyoto America wins! (For now), continued Reasons not to ratify Kyoto
(Continued from page 1) Product projections Fred Singer, Ph.D.; Science Environment Policy Project
March 18 the country's energy woes — includ- • Harm US competitiveness as cost of produc-
ing shortages and high prices — were caused tion increases due to regulations not suffered Climate science is not “settled;” it is both uncertain and incom-
plete. The available observations do not support the mathemati-
by a failure to build infrastructure, especially by competing developing nations like China, cal models that predict a substantial global warming and form the
in natural gas distribution and generating fa- Mexico, Brazil and others basis for a control policy on greenhouse (GH) gas emissions.
cilities. "We need more refineries, we need • Reduce the average annual household in-
more power plants, we need more pipelines,'' come nearly $2700 at the same time the cost 1) The fate of anthropogenic CO2 in the atmosphere is
he said. This infrastructure simply was not built of products would be sharply increasing uncertain: its uptake into the ocean; the biological pump;
when they should have been. Why? Because • Reduce state tax revenues by $93.1 billion the missing carbon sink. The future growth of atmospheric
of environmental regulations contrived to pre- due to job and output loses CO2 depends crucially on estimates of residence time and
the amount of fossil fuels likely to be used for energy pro-
vent their construction (See Editor's Commen- duction. Some researchers suggest an 8x pre-industrial
tary, next page). Yet, the Kyoto Protocol can- Europe "outraged" over announcement value, while others doubt whether CO2 will even double.
not be met without them being in place. Predictably the press, especially in Europe,
2) The temperature record of the last hundred years is of
The London Electronic Telegraph reported have demonized Bush's decision. "America is poor quality and shows many discrepancies. Surface tempera-
that during a meeting with German Chancellor now confirmed as the unrepentant outlaw, the tures disagree with recent measurements from satellites and
Gerhard Schroder on March 29, Bush said, dirty man of environmental politics," howled balloons. The urban heat island effect may skew the record.
"The idea that somehow we are supposed to The London Guardian Unlimited on March 30 3) General Circulation Models (GCMs) vary by 300%
get enormous amounts of natural gas on line . "Mr Bush, clinging to his 'national interest' in their temperature forecasts, require arbitrary adjust-
immediately to be able to conform to a treaty credo, seems incapable of seeing the big pic- ments, and cannot handle crucial mesoscale and
that our own Senate sent a very overwhelming ture. He does not grasp the basic truth that microscale cloud processes. Their forecasts of substan-
tial warming depend on a positive feedback from atmo-
message against, and that many other countries America's national interest is inextricably in- spheric water vapor (WV).
haven't signed, makes no economic sense. It tertwined with the global interest.... But most
4) GCMs cannot account for past observations: the
makes no common sense." Later in the meet- appalling of all is the message, taken alongside temperature rise between 1920 to 1940, the cooling to
ing Bush said, "I will not accept anything that similarly shortsighted, self-centered actions in 1975, and the absence of warming in the satellite record
will harm our economy and the fields of defence and since 1979. Various explanations need to be explored:
hurt our workers. We have an diplomacy, that this Tali- reduced positive feedback from WV; increase in cloudi-
energy shortage." ban-style act of wanton ness; anthropogenic aerosols; man-made land changes;
destruction sends around increasing air traffic; solar variations influencing climate.
The treaty would cripple the world. Instead of 5) Prehistoric climate fluctuations, on timescales as rapid
America leading the community as a decade, are prevalent – as judged from the data from
of nations, Bush's tree rings, sediments, and ice cores. Such climate events
The US Senate had al- are not explained by existing models, nor can current GCMs
ready voted 95-0 in 1997 on America seems increas- account for El-Nino events, the North Atlantic Oscillation,
a resolution to reject what ingly intent on confront- and other contemporary rapid changes in climate.
later became the Kyoto Pro- ing it." 6) Sea level (SL) rise is a major feared impact of a future
tocol. The Senate said it Other European warming. It seems likely, however, that increased evapora-
would not ratify any treaty pundits point to "se- tion from the ocean may lead to more rapid accumulation
that did not include all na- The US is constantly accused of being the big- vere weather condi- of polar ice and a lowering of sea level. This possibility is
tions contributing to global gest greenhouse gas polluter. However, the best tions around the planet supported by an observed inverse correlation between SL
warming. The Kyoto Proto- scientific evidence shows global warming may — flooding for the sec- rate of rise and tropical sea surface temperature (SST).
col commits 38 industrialized not be occurring, and even if it isCO2 may not be ond consecutive year in 7) Severe storms and hurricanes have diminished in
nations to cut their emissions as important as once thought. Mozambique, drought the past 50 years. A global warming trend is calculated to
reduce the latitudinal temperature gradient and therefore
of the main gases produced by human activi- and famine in the Sudan — and say the U.S. the driving force for storms and severe weather.
ties, which are blamed for climate change. By is substantially to blame," claimed CBS
8) Global agriculture will likely benefit from climate warm-
2012, they would have to cut emissions by an News the evening of March 29. Almost all ing and increased precipitation; increased CO2 leads to
average of 5.2% on their 1990 levels, and the the media also regurgitated the old statistic more rapid plant growth; increased nocturnal and winter
US by 7%. The Senate demanded that devel- that while the US only has about 4-6 per- warming leads to a longer growing season. Farmers can
oping nations also be included since it is a well cent (there seems to be unanimous disagree- and will adjust to climate changes.
known fact that most increases in CO2 output ment over the exact number) of the world's 9) The spread of disease vectors, like malaria-carrying
will come from those sources. population, it produces about 25 percent of mosquitos, is likely to be unimportant in comparison to
• The Senate resolution also said it would not the world's harmful greenhouse gas pollu- human vectors. In addition, medical science and insect
vote for the proposed treaty because it would tion. "This short-termism and this isolation- control technology are sure to progress.
cause economic damage to the US. In 1998 ism is profoundly flawed and misplaced," 10) Historical evidence supports the idea that warmer cli-
the prestigious WEFA international consult- griped British Environment Minister mate intervals are beneficial for human activities, food produc-
tion, and health. Cold periods have had the opposite effect.
ing group analyzed what the treaty would do Michael Meacher. The London Electronic
and found: Telegraph reported that Meacher also de- 11) Mitigation techniques are available that can slow down
the rise of atmospheric GH gases and a possible climate
• It would nearly double energy and electric- scribed global warming as "the most dan- change: energy conservation and increased efficiency often
ity prices gerous and fearful challenge to humanity make economic sense; hydro and nuclear power are avail-
• Cost 2.4 million US jobs and reduce US to- over the next 100 years." He said that it was able now; solar energy may be around the corner; tree plant-
tal output $300 billion (1992$) annually, 3.2 "almost unthinkable" that America should ing and ocean fertilization may be low-cost methods of se-
percent below baseline Gross Domestic Continued on page 8 questering atmospheric CO2.
http://www.discerningtoday.org Discerning the Times Digest
Volume 3 Issue 4, April, 2001 Page 3
Sierra Club/Club of Rome behind California energy crises? Continued What is Bush doing?
populations are continuous from New Mexico notes that in "talking to California business and Over the past few weeks President Bush has
to Greenland; when vast unbroken forests and environmental leaders, one gets the impression done everything possible to bring an avalanche
flowing plains again thrive and support pre- that Californians know a few things the rest of us of criticism upon himself from environmentalists
Columbian populations of plants and animals; don’t. They most certainly do, like how to effec- and globalists in America and around the world.
when humans dwell with respect, harmony and tively shut off significant new building projects He has been called a mass murderer by British
affection for the land; when we come to live in highway, water and energy infrastructure for a Liberal Democrat MP Malcolm Bruce for re-
no longer as strangers and aliens to this conti- decade while adding six million new residents and jecting the Kyoto Protocol (the global warming
nent.” creating a surging high-tech economy (based on treaty) and a warmonger by China, Russia and
In his book, Saviors of the Earth?, editor of electricity). Yes, it takes a special skill to try to the European Union for insisting on building the
Discerning the Times Digest, Dr. Michael Coff- drive a great state into the ground while manag- Antimissile Defense System. He has also come
man, exposed the fact that both Soulé and Noss ing to grow fabulously richer. But you can’t defy under sharp criticism for taking a hard stand
were movers and shakers within the International economic gravity forever." against Russia, North Korea and China, a bully
Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN) "State leaders still refuse to face reality and for bombing Iraq and an isolationist for taking a
and were involved not only in writing the Wild- sacrifice any environmental standards, no mat- hands-off approach with Northern Ireland and Is-
lands Project, but the UN Convention on Bio- ter how unreasonable," claims Hurd, "for enough rael. Is this president inept, or are we witnessing
logical Diversity as well. Coffman, along with cheap, abundant power for the future. And until something else?
three other individuals were able to stop the rati- they do, any manufacturer with an ounce of sense Bush may be many things, but he is certainly
fication of the treaty in in their head would be not what he is being demonized for above. It is
the US Senate when nuts to build here or stay too early to tell yet, but we may be witnessing the
they provided docu- here." That is, of course first real statesman with guts we have seen since
mentation to the Sen- exactly what the Club of Winston Churchill in World War II. He is even
ate proving that the Rome and the Sierra taking a much harder stand for America than
treaty was based on Club had planned for 20 Reagan did during his presidency. Yet, he is be-
The Wildlands years ago. And, now it ing demonized by our allies and bullied by our
Project. is happening. Except enemies--who like British Prime Minister Cham-
But that didn’t nobody sees the real vil- berlain during World War II, insist that their en-
stop Foreman and lain — environmental- emies will just leave them alone if they appease
crew. Immediately ism and the global them.
upon taking office, agenda. Instead, they Even so, Bush knows when to apply diplo-
the Clinton admin- David Foreman, who is now a board member of the Sierra Club, blame deregulation, a macy. On March 23 he met with China’s foreign
istration named helped write the Wildlands Project and promoted even more straw horse that has policy czar Qian Qichen and diplomatically told
Foreman as Under- designations of US parks and monuments as UN Biospheres little to do with the real China there will be no more free ride. The US
Secretary of Inte- and World Heritage Site when he was Under Secretary of Inte- reason people are go- will no longer be a patsy for China, as was the
rior. In this capacity, rior. There are nearly 60 million acres designated now. ing to undergo real suf- case with the Clinton administration. China,
with Interior Secretary Babbitt's blessing, he be- fering in California. stunned, tested Bush’s mettle the following week
gan implementing The Wildlands Project con- Environmental leadership probably repre- when one of their jet fighters collided with the
cept as official government policy through such sent the greatest threat to America today. They US EP-3 spy plane by flying too close. With all
government programs as Ecosystem Manage- should be rated public enemy #1. Yet, because the bluster and indignation they could muster,
ment, The American Heritage Rivers Program, of the relentless support of the one-world glo- China tried to bully Bush into apologizing for their
the UNESCO World Heritage and the Man and balists and the mainstream media, Americans own mistake when they ordered their pilot to fly
the Biosphere Programs, and finally, the mas- have been deluded into truly believing environ- dangerously close to the US plane over interna-
sive declaration of national monuments just be- mentalists are heroes, fighting for environmen- tional waters.
fore president Clinton left office. tal protection for all Americans. In fact, these Bush would have none of it. Other than an
While still serving as Under-Secretary of Inte- leaders want to see the majority of Americans appropriate extension of regret for the loss of the
rior, Foreman was elected as director to the Sierra eliminated from the planet so they can enjoy a Chinese pilot, the Chinese did not get so much as
Club, and the Wildlands Project became a major pristine mother earth while controlling the ev- a hint of an apology. The Chinese will try to play
goal for the Club. In 1999-2000 Brower made a ery activity of the remaining masses. the incident for all its worth, but will not have any
major effort to take over the Sierra Club, and "had America, the world and even the Chris- success in bullying Bush like they did Clinton.
nearly triumphed," according to Elvin. The effort tian church are being led by the pied piper of Bush may have another agenda that will even-
failed "when ill health caused his withdrawal." deceit and delusion, sure they are doing right tually prove us wrong, but he seems to be acting
when in fact they are on a road to self de- like a statesman for America, and makes no apol-
Under a strong delusion struction. Remember Paul's admonition in 2 ogy for it. The rest of the world doesn’t know
The worst is yet to come in California, ac- Corinthians 11:13-15: "For such men are what to do without their US whipping boy to de-
cording to a March 6 CBN analysis. When the false apostles, deceitful workmen, masquer- monize and blame for all the world’s problems.
big heat hits this summer, well-placed sources out ading as apostles of Christ. And no wonder, The big test for Bush will be whether he can keep
here have warned CBN Senior Reporter Dale for Satan himself masquerades as an angel from meddling in the affairs of other sovereign
Hurd that Californians can expect massive "struc- of light. It is not surprising, then, if his ser- nations like an imperialist--something his prede-
tural blackouts." They promise to be much worse vants masquerade as servants of righteous- cessor was incapable of doing. Until he proves
than what occurred in March — even with the 40 ness. Their end will be what their actions his agenda is not honorable, he needs all the sup-
percent plus rate hikes approved in March. Hurd deserve." V mc port we can give him. V mc
http://www.discerningtoday.org Discerning the Times Digest
Volume 3, Issue 4, April, 2001 Page 7